Latest / The Bootstrapped Tech Founder with Fexingo: Profitable Software Companies Without VC / How Bootstrapped Founders Use a Profit Share Pool
Transcript
- Lucas: There's a quiet trend in bootstrapped software companies that I think deserves more attention than it gets, and it's not equity or even traditional bonuses. It's the profit share pool. You set aside a percentage of net profit every quarter, and you split it among the team based on a formula you publish. Luna: So instead of 'here's a bonus based on your individual performance,' it's 'here's a share of what the company actually made.' That feels like it could change how people think about their work. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not new — profit sharing has been around for decades. But the way bootstrapped founders are using it now, with complete transparency and a formula that's easy to understand, feels different. It's less paternalistic and more like a partnership. Luna: Give me a concrete example, because I think listeners will want to know what this actually looks like in dollars. Not just the concept. Lucas: Sure. Let's say you run a small SaaS company with five employees. You decide to put fifteen percent of net profit into a pool each quarter. Last quarter, net profit was eighty thousand dollars. So the pool is twelve thousand dollars. Luna: Okay, twelve grand. How do you split that? Lucas: A common formula is to weight by salary. You take each person's base salary, divide by the total payroll, and that's their percentage of the pool. So if you have one founder making a hundred twenty thousand and four others making sixty thousand each, the founder gets one third of the pool, and each of the four gets one sixth. Luna: So the founder gets four thousand, and each of the four gets two thousand. That's a pretty clean way to think about it. Lucas: It scales naturally with how much you pay people, which is often a proxy for their impact. But the key is that it's formula-driven and published before the quarter starts. No subjective 'you did a great job on this project' — it's just math. Luna: And that transparency is the part that feels like it could build a lot of trust. But I have to ask — what counts as net profit? Is that even well-defined in a bootstrapped company? Lucas: Great question, because that's where most plans trip up. You have to define net profit in the plan. Is it after your own salary? After taxes? After you've set aside a reserve for a future hiring round? Usually, founders define it as earnings before interest and taxes, but after paying all operating expenses, including their own market-rate salary. Luna: So you're not counting the founder's sweat equity. You're saying the founder is paid a normal salary, and then the pool is on top. Lucas: Right. That prevents the pool from being a way for the founder to underpay themselves. And it also makes the pool a real measure of profitability, not a vanity number. Luna: And what about taxes? Are you just handing out cash, or is there a more tax-efficient structure? Lucas: The simplest way is to just treat it as a cash bonus and withhold taxes like you would any other bonus. But some companies use something called a profit-sharing plan under IRS rules, which allows contributions to be made to a retirement account. That's more tax-advantaged, but it comes with compliance headaches and it's less flexible for employees who need cash. Luna: So there's a trade-off between simplicity and tax efficiency. But I want to get back to the behavioral side. You mentioned earlier that it changes how people think about their work. How does that actually play out? Lucas: In a few ways. First, people start asking about the company's numbers. They want to see the profit and loss statement, because their bonus depends on it. That creates a culture of financial literacy. Luna: That's a big shift from the typical 'we don't discuss finances' attitude in most small companies. Lucas: It is. And second, people start thinking about costs. When you know that reducing the hosting bill by five hundred dollars a month increases your bonus, you start caring about that five hundred dollars. Luna: That could be good, but it could also lead to people being too stingy with expenses that are actually important for growth. Like, 'Don't buy that tool, it costs money.' Lucas: That's a real risk. You have to pair the pool with a clear strategy. If the company's goal is growth, you need to communicate that sometimes spending money is the right move, even if it reduces this quarter's pool. Otherwise, you're incentivizing short-termism. Luna: So the pool isn't a silver bullet. It's a tool that needs to be managed. But I love the idea of creating a sense of ownership without giving away equity. Because for bootstrapped founders, equity is precious. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's why I think this is gaining traction. You get the motivational benefits of ownership without diluting your cap table. You can even tie it to retention with a vesting schedule — for example, you only get the full share if you've been with the company for a full quarter. Luna: That makes sense. You don't want someone to join on the last day of the quarter and get a full share. Lucas: Right. A pro-rata approach based on days worked is a common way to handle that. Luna: Before we go deeper into the mechanics, I have to say — if this episode is helping you think about how to compensate your team without giving up equity, and you're finding value in these conversations, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a tiny ask, but it genuinely helps us keep doing what we do. Lucas: Yeah, even a coffee's worth of support makes a difference. We appreciate anyone who takes a moment to do that. But let's get back to the pool — because I want to talk about a common mistake I see founders make when they first set this up. Luna: What's that? Lucas: They set the pool as a percentage of revenue, not profit. That sounds good, but it means you're paying out even when you're losing money. And that's not sustainable for a bootstrapped company. Luna: So the pool should always be tied to actual profit, not just top-line revenue. That's a key distinction. Lucas: Exactly. And the percentage itself matters. You don't want it to be so small that nobody cares, or so big that you can't reinvest in the business. A common range is ten to twenty percent of net profit, but it depends on your margins and your growth stage. Luna: What about companies with a lot of revenue variability? Like, one quarter is amazing, and the next is terrible. How do you handle the emotional rollercoaster? Lucas: That's a real challenge. Some companies set a floor, like 'we only pay out if net profit exceeds fifty thousand dollars.' Others smooth it out by paying out a portion each quarter and holding back a reserve to cover lean quarters. Luna: So you're not just paying out everything you make every quarter. You're building a buffer. Lucas: Right. The goal is to make the pool feel like a predictable bonus, not a lottery ticket. And that requires managing expectations carefully, especially in the first year. Luna: And what about the founder's own participation in the pool? We mentioned the salary-weight approach, but do some founders opt out to make the pool bigger for the team? Lucas: Some do. It's a personal choice. But I'd argue that the founder should participate, because it keeps the incentive aligned. Plus, if the founder is in the pool, it feels less like a paternalistic gesture and more like a shared outcome. Luna: That's a good point. It's more like 'we're all in this together' rather than 'here's your cut from the master's table.' Lucas: Exactly. And I've seen founders use the pool to highlight the collective impact. They publish a short memo each quarter that says, 'Here's the net profit, here's the pool, here's your share, and here's why we made this quarter's decisions.' That memo becomes a communication tool. Luna: That's actually a powerful way to build a culture of transparency. It's not just about the money; it's about the narrative. Lucas: And it reinforces the message that everyone's work contributes to the bottom line. I think that's the real value of a profit share pool — it's not just a compensation mechanism, it's a leadership tool. Luna: So, if a founder is listening to this and thinking, 'I want to try this,' what's the first step they should take? Lucas: Start by defining what net profit means for your company. Write it down. Then decide on a percentage, and a formula for distribution that you feel good about. And most importantly, communicate it clearly to your team before you implement it. Let them ask questions. Make it an open discussion. Luna: And I'd add that you should probably run a few quarters in shadow mode first. Calculate what the pool would have been, but don't actually pay it out. That way you can see the numbers and adjust without committing. Lucas: That's a smart tip. It reduces the risk of a big surprise. And once you're ready to go live, remember that the pool is not a substitute for fair base pay. You still need to pay competitive salaries. The pool is a bonus on top, not a replacement. Luna: Absolutely. Nobody wants to work for a company where they're worried about making rent because the profit pool was thin one quarter. Lucas: Right. So, to sum it up: profit share pools are a flexible, transparent way to share the upside with your team without giving up equity. They work best when the formula is simple, the definition of profit is clear, and the founder is fully on board. Luna: I think this could be a game-changer for a lot of bootstrapped companies. It's not just about the money; it's about creating a sense of shared ownership. Lucas: And that's something you can't put a price on. If you're thinking about implementing this, start small, be transparent, and see how it goes. You might be surprised by the response.