Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Archimedes and the Eureka of Electric Efficiency
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to the Deep Dive. I'm your host and I am joined as
- 0:14always by our resident expert. Hello everyone, really looking
- 0:18forward to this. One.
- 0:18Yeah, because today we're doing something a bit different.
- 0:21I want you, the listener, to close your eyes for a second.
- 0:24Assuming you weren't driving, of course.
- 0:25Right. Again, please keep your eyes
- 0:26open if you're driving, but just picture this scene.
- 0:30It is 2026. You are standing in the middle
- 0:33of a pristine white walled car dealership.
- 0:36You know the exact vibe. Polished concrete floors, the
- 0:40smell of espresso and new rubber.
- 0:43That quiet, expensive hum of commerce.
- 0:47Now imagine the automatic glass doors slide open and in walks an
- 0:51elderly man. OK, he is wearing a dusty tunic,
- 0:54he's got a long white beard, he's holding a scroll, and he
- 0:56just looks absolutely exhausted. And presumably the sales staff
- 0:59are frantically calling security right about now.
- 1:01Oh, absolutely. But this isn't a prank.
- 1:05The man is Archimedes of Syracuse, the greatest
- 1:08mathematician of antiquity, right?
- 1:10And we aren't just setting up some kind of, you know, Greek
- 1:12philosopher walks into a bar joke here.
- 1:14No, we actually have a stack of research today, specifically a
- 1:17presentation titled Archimede de Siracusa.
- 1:21And our mission today is to run a serious thought experiment
- 1:25based on that presentation. If this specific genius walked
- 1:29into a dealership today looking for a way to move around, what
- 1:33would he see? It is such a fascinating premise
- 1:36because the easy answer, the obvious 1, is that he'd be
- 1:39terrified of the technology. Right, It's basically magic to
- 1:42him. Exactly.
- 1:43But the source material argues the exact opposite.
- 1:46It posits that Archimedes wouldn't just appreciate a
- 1:49modern electric vehicle, he would actually understand the
- 1:52physics of it better than the salesperson trying to sell it to
- 1:55him. The notes actually suggest he
- 1:56would lose his mind over it and not because of like the heated
- 2:00seeds or the touch screen navigation.
- 2:02No, because of the philosophy. The end of the hood.
- 2:04Right. So today we are exploring this
- 2:06idea that the modern EV is actually the fulfillment of a
- 2:082000 year old quest. We're talking about the
- 2:11philosophy of efficiency, the physics of leverage, and why
- 2:15Archimedes might just be the spiritual father of the electric
- 2:17powertrain. It's a deep dive into pure
- 2:20mechanical advantage. But before we hand in the keys,
- 2:24we should probably ground this a bit, because my memory of high
- 2:27school physics is basically just the guy in the bathtub screaming
- 2:30Eureka. Yeah, the eccentric streaker
- 2:32running through the streets. Is that who we're dealing with?
- 2:34Here. Well, that's the meme version,
- 2:35right? Yeah, but the man behind the
- 2:37myth was much more formidable. He lived in Syracuse, Sicily,
- 2:42from 287 to 212 BC OK. And while he was a
- 2:46mathematician, he wasn't just sitting in an ivory tower
- 2:49contemplating the stars. He was actually a defense
- 2:51contractor. Wait, a defense contract?
- 2:53Effectively, yes, because Syracuse was under siege by the
- 2:57Romans and Archimedes was the guy designing the war machines
- 3:01to keep them out. Oh wow.
- 3:03He built the Claw of Archimedes which was this massive crane
- 3:07like device used to lift enemy ships out of the water and
- 3:10physically capsize them. That is terrifying.
- 3:13He also designed mirror systems to focus sunlight and burn Roman
- 3:16sails, so he was an engineer who was totally obsessed with
- 3:19applied force. OK, so he wasn't just thinking
- 3:23about theoretical numbers, he was thinking about about moving
- 3:26really heavy things. That is the core of his
- 3:28character. He was obsessed with mechanical
- 3:31advantage. You know his most famous quote,
- 3:33right? Give me a place to stand.
- 3:35And I will move the world. Exactly.
- 3:37He meant that literally. He understood that if you have
- 3:40the right lever, the right fulcrum, you can multiply your
- 3:44input force. You can do the impossible with
- 3:46very little effort. Yes, and that brings us to his
- 3:49other defining obsession, which is his absolute hatred of waste.
- 3:53The sources really emphasized this.
- 3:56He despised inefficiency in all its forms.
- 3:58To him, the universe was written in the language of mathematics.
- 4:01It was supposed to be elegant. So if a machine was noisy or hot
- 4:05or required too much sweat to operate, it wasn't just a bad
- 4:09machine, it was almost an offense against nature.
- 4:11He wanted maximum output for minimum input.
- 4:14Pure optimization. OK, so we have a guy who wants
- 4:16to move the world with his pinky finger and he hates waste.
- 4:20Let's teleporting back to that 2026 dealership.
- 4:22Let's do it. Walks past the electric cars for
- 4:25a second and looks out the window at a massive gas guzzling
- 4:29SUV. Or you know better yet, a horse
- 4:31drawn chariot. Which is his actual frame of
- 4:34reference. What goes through his head?
- 4:36He's thinking it's a complete disaster.
- 4:38A disaster. Let's look at the horse first.
- 4:40To Archimedes, a horse is a biological nightmare of
- 4:44inefficiency. I mean, I guess it is.
- 4:46Think about it. It eats grain even when it's not
- 4:49moving. It produces waste manure that
- 4:53has to be manually managed. It has moods.
- 4:56It gets tired. It's high maintenance entropy.
- 4:58Definitely not mathematically elegant.
- 5:00Not at all. And now look at the internal
- 5:02combustion engine. To a physicist like him, a gas
- 5:06engine is just a mechanical horse.
- 5:08How so? Think about the sheer violence
- 5:10of it. You're taking liquid fuel,
- 5:12vaporizing it, and exploding it thousands of times a minute.
- 5:16Right, controlled explosion. Exactly.
- 5:18You're using violent explosions to push a piston, to turn a
- 5:21crank to spin a gear to eventually turn an axle.
- 5:25The thermodynamic losses in that chain are huge.
- 5:28Yeah. What are the numbers on that?
- 5:29A standard gas engine wastes about 70 to 80% of its energy as
- 5:33heat. Wait really?
- 5:34So if I put $100.00 of gas in my tank, only about 20 bucks is
- 5:39actually moving the car down the road.
- 5:40Precisely. The rest is just making the
- 5:43engine hot, and to Archimedes, heat is just energy that is
- 5:47escaping it's failure. Noise is failure.
- 5:50Vibration is failure. So if he stood next to a revving
- 5:53V8 engine, he wouldn't be impressed by the roar.
- 5:56He'd be horrified. He'd look at it and say why are
- 5:58you setting fire to valuable fuel just to create so much
- 6:01waste heat? So he turns away from the gas
- 6:03cars in absolute disgust and he walks over the EV section and
- 6:07the source material actually uses this specific phrase. 0
- 6:11animals. 0 animals, pure force multiplied.
- 6:14I love that this is where the concept of the electric motor
- 6:17perfectly aligns with his lever theory.
- 6:20An electric motor is essentially just magnetism.
- 6:22It's silent. It's highly efficient, but the
- 6:24thing that would really grab his attention is the torque.
- 6:27The instant torque, you always hear that in car reviews when
- 6:30they talk about zero to 60 times, but you're saying
- 6:32Archimedes sees that different. Totally differently.
- 6:35He doesn't care about drag racing a sports car.
- 6:37He cares about the immediacy of the lever.
- 6:39OK, unpack that. Well, in a gas car, you press
- 6:43the pedal, the air intake opens, fuel injects, the transmission
- 6:46downshifts, the RPMS build up, there is a lag.
- 6:50Right, it takes a second to get going.
- 6:51But in an EV, you press the pedal a few millimeters and the
- 6:55magnetic field reacts instantly. It's like his finger on the
- 6:59lever. Exactly.
- 7:00He moves his foot a tiny fraction of an inch and two tons
- 7:03of metal move instantly. That is the ultimate realization
- 7:07of give me a place to stand. The EV powertrain is the fulcrum
- 7:11he was dreaming of 2000 years ago.
- 7:14And what about the silence of the EV?
- 7:15The presentation notes that he would view the silence as pure
- 7:18mathematics in motion. No chaos, no explosions, just
- 7:23vectors and velocity. Now there's one connection in
- 7:25the research that really surprised me.
- 7:28It draws a Direct Line between the Archimedes screw, his
- 7:31ancient invention, and modern regenerative braking.
- 7:34Can you explain that? Because as far as I know, one of
- 7:37those moves water and the other stops a car.
- 7:40This is honestly the aha moment of the whole deep dive.
- 7:43So let's look at the Archimedes screw.
- 7:46It was a device designed to lift water against gravity.
- 7:49You turn a spiral inside a tube and the water travels up.
- 7:53Right, they still use variations of it today.
- 7:54They do. It was a brilliant way to add
- 7:56potential energy to the water, moving it to a higher reservoir
- 8:00for later use. OK, I'm with you so far.
- 8:02Now think about a car moving down the highway at 70 miles an
- 8:05hour. It has massive kinetic energy.
- 8:08In a normal gas car, when you hit the brakes, what happens?
- 8:12You clamp the brake pads onto the wheels.
- 8:13It creates friction and you slow down.
- 8:15And what does that kinetic energy go?
- 8:17It turns into heat, The brakes get super hot.
- 8:20Right. And that heat radiates out into
- 8:22the atmosphere and is gone forever.
- 8:24It's entirely wasted. To Archimedes, that is a
- 8:27tragedy. So how does regenerative braking
- 8:30fix that? When you lift your foot off the
- 8:33accelerator in an EV, the electric motor actually reverses
- 8:36its function. It stops being a motor and
- 8:39becomes a generator. It takes the car's forward
- 8:42momentum and converts it back into electricity to store in the
- 8:46battery. It's.
- 8:47Recycling the momentum. It's a.
- 8:49Closed loop. It is conceptually exactly like
- 8:52the screw. You are taking the forward flow
- 8:55of the car and pumping it back into the reservoir, which is the
- 8:58battery. So Archimedes would look at the
- 9:00energy graph on the dashboard, see that green bar showing
- 9:04energy going back into the pack, and just be floored.
- 9:07He'd say you have tricked nature.
- 9:09You are capturing the motion instead of throwing it away.
- 9:12I feel like he'd totally be that guy on the EV forums arguing
- 9:15about the optimal regeneration settings for different
- 9:17topographers. No, absolutely.
- 9:18He'd be obsessed with one pedal driving because every single
- 9:22time you have to use the friction brakes you are
- 9:25admitting defeat. You are wasting energy.
- 9:27And this obsession with efficiency brings up a whole new
- 9:30metric. The course points out he
- 9:32wouldn't care at all about miles per gallon.
- 9:34He'd care about Watt hours per kilometer.
- 9:36Why Per kilometer? It's the direct measure of how
- 9:39much energy force is required to move a specific mass over a
- 9:43specific distance. So he wouldn't care about
- 9:45horsepower numbers either. Not at all.
- 9:47Horsepower is just marketing to him.
- 9:49He would only want to know the actual work required to move the
- 9:52vehicle. So picture him standing there on
- 9:55the showroom floor, completely ignoring the sales pitch about
- 9:59leather seeds. And he's just doing mental
- 10:01calculus on the drag coefficient.
- 10:03He's looking at the air resistance, he's looking at the
- 10:05curb weight. And based on the presentation
- 10:08sources, there is actually one specific car on the market today
- 10:12that he would buy. All right, drumroll please.
- 10:15The chariot of choice for the greatest ancient geek is.
- 10:18The Lucid Air Pure, specifically the 2025 or 2026 model year.
- 10:23OK, that's interesting. Not a Tesla, not a Porsche
- 10:25Tican. Why the Lucid?
- 10:27It all comes down to the math. The source document calls the
- 10:30Lucid Air Pure, the queen of energy optimization.
- 10:34That is a pretty big title to live up to.
- 10:35It earns it, though. We're talking about a vehicle
- 10:37that achieved something like 146 MPG.
- 10:40That's miles per gallon equivalent.
- 10:42In raw numbers, that means it gets about 5 5 miles of range
- 10:46for every single kWh of battery energy.
- 10:49So for the listener who maybe just drives a standard gas sedan
- 10:52and doesn't know EV stats, is 5 miles per kWh actually that
- 10:57good? It's staggering.
- 10:58Most electric SUV's on the road get maybe 2.5 or three.
- 11:03A decent, highly efficient sedan might get 3.5 or 4.
- 11:08To hit 5 is like breaking the four minute mile in engineering.
- 11:12It implies a level of obsession that is frankly necessary just
- 11:16for getting to the grocery store, but it is absolutely
- 11:19essential for mathematical perfection.
- 11:20So. It's not just the Lucid has a
- 11:22massive battery stuffed into it, it's that it uses a normal
- 11:24amount of energy. Way better.
- 11:26Exactly. The Lucid actually has a
- 11:28smaller, lighter battery than many of its competitors, but it
- 11:32goes further on a charge that is leverage that is doing more with
- 11:36less. I see the connection now.
- 11:38Archimedes would look at something like a Hummer EV,
- 11:40which is this gargantuan battery but is terribly inefficient, and
- 11:43he'd see it as brute force. It's ugly to him.
- 11:47He'd look at the lucid and see intellectual superiority.
- 11:49The notes also mentioned the motors themselves in the Lucid.
- 11:53Yes, volumetric efficiency. The Lucid motors are incredibly
- 11:58compact. You could literally fit one
- 12:01inside a standard carry on suitcase, but they produce
- 12:04massive power. He would want to take the car
- 12:06apart immediately, wouldn't? He oh right there on the
- 12:08showroom floor. He'd want to see the copper
- 12:10windings. He'd want to see how the
- 12:12engineers managed to eliminate all the superfluous weight.
- 12:15I do have to ask about the Cyber Trek though.
- 12:17The notes mentioned it briefly. Visually it looks like a
- 12:19geometry problems, all sharp angles and triangles.
- 12:22Wouldn't a mathematician love that?
- 12:24He might appreciate the low polyesthetic.
- 12:27At first glance, it looks like a platonic solid, but ultimately
- 12:31the Cyber Trek is made of stainless steel.
- 12:34It is incredibly heavy, and it pushes the air out of its way
- 12:37with brute force. The Lucid, on the other hand,
- 12:40cuts through the air. Its drag coefficient is under
- 12:43.20. It's incredibly slippery.
- 12:45And Archimedes did a lot of work with fluid dynamics.
- 12:48Exactly. He's a fluid dynamics guy at
- 12:50heart. He'd always choose the
- 12:51aerodynamic scalpel over the heavy hammer.
- 12:54So he sold. He is signing the papers or I
- 12:58guess scrolling on the iPad, but the source material outlines a
- 13:01specific wish list. Yes.
- 13:04These are the demands he makes of the dealer before he agrees
- 13:06to drive off the lawn. This list is hilarious but also
- 13:09deeply insightful about his character.
- 13:10First up on the wish list, maximum efficiency display.
- 13:14He would demand that the dashboard show him real time
- 13:17consumption down to the decimal point.
- 13:20He'd probably want some kind of vector overlay on the windshield
- 13:23showing wind direction so he could adjust his driving line in
- 13:27real time. That sounds exhausting, but very
- 13:29on brand. Second on the list, perfect
- 13:31transmission ratio. So even though Ev's essentially
- 13:34have one single gear, that reduction ratio is the modern
- 13:38fulcrum. He'd want to know exactly what
- 13:40it is. Is it 9 to 1?
- 13:4112:50 He wants to verify the math.
- 13:43He wants to verify that the engineers found the absolute
- 13:45perfect balance point between low end torque and top speed.
- 13:48And the third one is definitely my favorite open source code.
- 13:51The ancient hacker mentality. You have to remember, Archimedes
- 13:54didn't just use tools, he invented the math behind the
- 13:57tools. He wrote a whole treatise called
- 13:59the Method of Mechanical Theorems.
- 14:01So he wouldn't be satisfied with a black box that just magically
- 14:04works. Never.
- 14:06He wants to root the car's operating system.
- 14:08He wants to see the battery management system algorithms.
- 14:11Oh, he demanded. He'd want to know exactly how
- 14:14the code decides to balance the voltage between individual
- 14:17battery cells. He'd look at the thermal
- 14:19management software and say, you know, if you just tweak this
- 14:22variable right here, you can reduce heat loss by 2%.
- 14:26He'd be the guy voiding his warranty on day one because he
- 14:29rewrote the firmware in ancient Greek.
- 14:31I can just hear the service center argument.
- 14:33Sir, why is your car's center screen displaying geometric
- 14:37proofs instead of the speedometer and he just yells
- 14:40because it is more efficient. And finally, the last item on
- 14:43his wish list. 0 waste. The absolute rejection of the
- 14:48superfluous. If a piece of exterior trim
- 14:51doesn't actively aid aerodynamics, he wants it ripped
- 14:54off. If the back seats are going to
- 14:56be empty most of the time, remove them to save weight.
- 14:59He wants the pure essence of the machine.
- 15:01He creates such a vivid image, Archimedes sitting in his
- 15:05stripped down Lucid Air, gliding completely silently out of the
- 15:09dealership, maybe throwing a peace sign to the confused
- 15:12salesman. It.
- 15:12Really does. And the source document gives us
- 15:15a reimagined quote for this exact moment instead of his
- 15:18famous lever quote. What does he say as he drives
- 15:22away? With this machine I have finally
- 15:24found the perfect fulcrum to move the world without sweat and
- 15:28without horses. It's a funny mental picture but
- 15:30it really shifts your perspective.
- 15:32We usually think of E VS as this hyper futuristic technology,
- 15:36like they strictly belong to the 21st century.
- 15:38But what we're really saying is that the ideals behind them are
- 15:41ancient. That is the big take away for
- 15:43me. The pursuit of the electric car
- 15:45isn't just about modern issues like climate change or saving
- 15:48money on gas. It's the pursuit of mathematical
- 15:51perfection. It's about friction reduction.
- 15:54It's about energy conservation. These are the exact things are
- 15:57committees was screaming about 2200 years ago.
- 15:59We just finally caught up to him.
- 16:01We finally have the materials, the lithium, the silicon, the
- 16:04copper to actually build the machines he could only visualize
- 16:08by drawing in the sand. It honestly makes you look at
- 16:11your own daily commute a little differently.
- 16:13You aren't just driving to work, you're participating in a giant
- 16:16physics equation. And I think it raises a really
- 16:18profound question about how we define progress.
- 16:22We tend to think progress always means more.
- 16:24More features, bigger screens, more size, more horsepower.
- 16:28But through Archimedes eyes, true progress is actually less.
- 16:32Less waste, less heat, less noise, less aerodynamic drag.
- 16:36The elegance of subtraction. Precisely.
- 16:39A perfect machine is 1 where you can't take anything else away
- 16:41without breaking it. You know, we have covered a lot
- 16:44of ground today, all the way from the ancient siege of
- 16:47Syracuse to the drag coefficient of a luxury sedan.
- 16:52But before we wrap up the deep dive, I want to pivot for a
- 16:54second. I want to talk directly to the
- 16:56person listening to this right now.
- 16:58The learner? Yes, you.
- 17:00Because if you are still listening to two people geek out
- 17:03about gear ratios in ancient history, you share something
- 17:06very real. With Archimedes.
- 17:08You have that spark. You aren't satisfied with just
- 17:11pushing a button and having the car go, You want to know why it
- 17:14goes. And that is really the whole
- 17:16mission of these day dives. Whether we are dissecting
- 17:19ancient Roman texts or analyzing modern battery chemistry, it is
- 17:22all about connecting the dots. It's about realizing that the
- 17:26guy drawing circles in the dust of Sicily and the engineer
- 17:30coding software in California today are actually having the
- 17:33exact same conversation across time.
- 17:35They are both just trying to solve the problem of efficiency,
- 17:38so we want to say thank you. Yes, truly.
- 17:41Thank you for taking this specific journey with us today.
- 17:44We know your time is limited, and Archimedes certainly would
- 17:47have calculated its value down to the nanosecond you would
- 17:50have, so we deeply appreciate you choosing to spend that time
- 17:53here, expanding your understanding and how the world
- 17:56works. It really is a privilege to
- 17:58explore these ideas with you. Curiosity is the only thing that
- 18:02doesn't depreciate over time. But before we go, we do want to
- 18:05leave you with one final provocation, something to think
- 18:08about the next time you were sitting in traffic just watching
- 18:11the brake lights turn on and off in front of you.
- 18:14If our comedians were alive today and he looked at our
- 18:17modern world, he wouldn't be impressed by our smartphones.
- 18:20He wouldn't care at all about our social media feeds.
- 18:23Those are just distractions to him.
- 18:25He would look at how we use energy.
- 18:27He'd look at the waste. He'd look at the lights left on
- 18:30in massive, empty office buildings all night.
- 18:32He'd look at the heat escaping from poorly insulated windows.
- 18:36He'd look at the kinetic energy lost into the atmosphere every
- 18:39single time you slam on your friction brakes at a red light.
- 18:43So the question is, would he consider your daily life
- 18:46mathematically elegant, or would he be frantically trying to
- 18:51optimize it? And more importantly, would he
- 18:53let you merge in traffic? Only if you used your momentum
- 18:56efficiently and signaled your vector in advance.
- 18:59Thanks for listening everyone. Keep optimizing.
- 19:02See you in the next deep dive.