Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Jen St Denis: Did Vancouver Mayor Ken Sim gaslight the public on the Hastings Street decampment?
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. In the decaman process, the City of Vancouver officials were aware
- 0:21that there were not enough shelter beds for folks that were being displaced, and
- 0:25we saw that right like we saw folks that were sleeping in a tent on
- 0:28Hasting Street, then suddenly still on Hasting Street, but now without a tent.
- 0:33Do you have any regrets about that entire process? Yeah, Well,
- 0:37first of all, I want to clarify a couple of things for the record.
- 0:39There always was enough housing or shelter space. Hey folks, my name
- 0:43is Mohameir and this is Van Kuller, British Columbia's bona fide culture and politics
- 0:47TV talk show. Tonight, we'll look at some high profile police action in
- 0:52the City of Vancouver and determine what exactly was accomplished. Let's kick it off
- 0:57by revisiting the City of Vancouver's decision to clear a homeless encampment on East Hastings
- 1:02Street back in April. Thanks to the intrepid reporting of our first guest,
- 1:07we've learned that the entire process cost over half a million dollars. But was
- 1:11it money well spent? Here to discuss, a reporter for the Tayee covering
- 1:15civic issues in Vancouver's downtown east Side. Last year, we moderated a Vancouver
- 1:19mayoral debate together. She is Jen, Saint Dennis Jen. What an honor,
- 1:25what a pleasure to see you. Thanks for being here tonight. Thank
- 1:26you Mooe for inviting me once again. Oh absolutely, so I got to
- 1:30ask you. It took five hundred and forty eight thousand dollars to clear the
- 1:34encampments on Hasting Street and Vancouver's downtown east Side. In the scope of this
- 1:38operation, is this a lot of money? So I didn't actually compare it
- 1:44with other decampment efforts. I did an FOI because you know, as soon
- 1:48as we as reporters went to the scene in April fifth and just saw this
- 1:52massive effort with so many police officers, so many garbage trucks and other trucks
- 1:57and city staff. I think most of the report on the scene were like,
- 2:00Wow, how much is this costing? And the reason I looked at
- 2:04this in isolation is because this decampment was not like other decampments. This was
- 2:08really really unusual for the City of Vancouver. Usually what the city does in
- 2:13partnership with BC Housing and the provincial government is try to, you know,
- 2:16get lease hotels or buy properties, or get some sort of number of shelter
- 2:23and housing spots as they clear. You know, a difficult homeless really entrenched
- 2:27homeless encampment in a city park, for instance. This was different. They
- 2:30did not really have shelter lined up for people. They were just going through
- 2:35and saying this is too dangerous. You guys all need to go, and
- 2:38we'll get into the shelter spaces in a second. But I guess perhaps a
- 2:42more important question is was this money well spent? So I think that depends
- 2:47on your view of this, you know, and I think that you know,
- 2:52the mayor Ken Sam got elected on this promise to restore law and order
- 2:55in the city. This camp, this entrenched homeless camp on Haesting Street was
- 3:00certainly a problem. Like it wasn't safe. There were fires being started.
- 3:05The fire department said there, you know that they would come and people weren't
- 3:07getting out of the way. It was difficult to fight fires. We know,
- 3:08there was a lot of sexual assaults happening, a lot of violence.
- 3:14So there's no one was saying it was safe. But so if you were
- 3:16on that camp and you really wanted the street to be clear, then sure,
- 3:20maybe half a million dollars was the right price to pay. But when
- 3:23you think about you know, we've talked to advocates for homeless people who say,
- 3:28you know, this amount of money being spent to push people along and
- 3:32not ensure that they actually have adequate housing, this could have been spent better.
- 3:37So basically what I'm hearing is, if the goal is out of sight,
- 3:39out of mind, great way to spend money. But if we want
- 3:43to actually connect people to services and have better health outcomes or even better housing
- 3:46outcomes for them, then perhaps this could have been spent better. Yeah,
- 3:51exactly. Okay, Now going to this idea of shelter spaces, Vancouver Mayor
- 3:55Ken sim was on this very program back in June and he said there were
- 4:00plenty and in fact enough shelter spaces and housing for the folks that were being
- 4:03displaced from East Hastings Street. You've looked into it and you saw that there
- 4:10wasn't. Is that correct? Yeah? I mean I think a bunch of
- 4:13us have and Nathan Griffiths at the Vancouver Sun did an FI and found internal
- 4:16mess communication between city staffers, acknowledging that there wasn't enough shelter spaces on that
- 4:21day and the subsequent days. So for instance, they were clearing something like,
- 4:26you know, over fifty people and by the end of the day they
- 4:29knew that there was only like thirteen shelter spaces open. Thirteen Well it was
- 4:34you know, the numbers fluctuated throughout the day as they were more than people
- 4:38being displaced. Definitely, So I think he pretty definitely showed that there was
- 4:43not there was not like a one to one shelter spot for people. We
- 4:46know that shelter operators were caught completely off guard. They did. They told
- 4:50us, They told reporters that they didn't have enough space. They told us
- 4:54that they were scrambling to find mats. You know, people were showing up,
- 4:57like keep in mind it was raining on those few days, right,
- 5:00so they were showing up with all of their belongings soaked. And so we
- 5:02heard those stories from shelter operators. You know. I was also just looking
- 5:05at an FOI from the province where they were giving speaking notes to the minister,
- 5:10and the minister was told to say, you know, we know that
- 5:13some people have had a hard time finding shelter space, but we know the
- 5:15operators are going to if somebody shows up, they're going to work as hard
- 5:18as they can to somehow find a spot for them somewhere. So all of
- 5:21that evidence I'm piling up and saying, like, no, I don't think
- 5:25there was an f Sure are you saying that the Mayor of Vancouver, Ken
- 5:30sim told an untruth, repeated the untruth, including on this program, continue
- 5:34to say that, and has not yet acknowledged that what he said was not
- 5:38true. I mean, some people might call that gaslighting. Not me.
- 5:41I mean, I'm a very serious commentator. I wouldn't say that the Vancouver
- 5:44mayor gas lit the public, but it sounds like some people might say he
- 5:47did. Well, I'm just saying, I'm just showing you like we've we've
- 5:50got we've got the we've got the receipts. I you know, I think
- 5:54it's fair to say like people were struggling to find shelter spots and a lot
- 5:58of you know, it has to be said too, a lot of people
- 6:00do not want to go to a shelter. So even if there had been
- 6:01enough shelter spots, there are legitimate reasons that people don't want to stay in
- 6:05shelters. There's a lot of residential school survivors in the downtown east Side and
- 6:11we hear from them that they have trauma that's triggered from being in a setting
- 6:15like a shelter spot shelter. So we have to take that into consideration too.
- 6:20When people are saying that they don't want to go to shelters, there
- 6:24are legitimate reasons for that. On the topic of shelters, I know that
- 6:27the province is trying to change the definition of quote unquote alternative shelter. How
- 6:32is this going to affect future decampment processes when you have these tents lined up
- 6:36in parks or in city blocks and municipalities end up taking them down, what's
- 6:41the effect going to be here? Yeah, so this was a really basic
- 6:44definition. Basically, they said there's this new definition and it's supposed to come
- 6:47into play when a municipality is trying to get a court injunction to remove a
- 6:53homeless camp. And it's a really basic definition. It's basically like, it's
- 6:57a place where you can stay overnight. You have acts us to a bathroom,
- 7:00access to showers, and some meals, and so it's very very basic.
- 7:04I'm not really sure how it's going to hold up in court because we
- 7:08have seen courts strike down attempts to enforce camp clearing even when they're offering things
- 7:15like sro rooms or shelter spots, because those what courts have said in the
- 7:20past is that they're not people are BC Housing and the city are not taking
- 7:25into account people's specific needs. And we saw that during the Hastings encampment.
- 7:30You know, one of the most vulnerable groups were women being having their shelter
- 7:33taken away, and the downtowny Side Women Centered, which operates shelters in the
- 7:38downtowny Side for women, were like, we're fall we didn't have any extra
- 7:41spots to offer these women. So we'll see how that plays out. I
- 7:46know that the province is putting this definition in place because they're getting a lot
- 7:49of pressure from municipalities who are increasingly dealing with these homeless encampments. And it's
- 7:55all throughout the province. It's great communities, little communities. You know,
- 7:59we are in a new era of homelessness. It's you know, it's sort
- 8:03of like put your mind back to the nineteen thirties when we had they would
- 8:05call them like hobo jungles. Back then, it's it's not the nineteen eighties
- 8:09anymore. It's really a new era where we're seeing very, very widespread homelessness
- 8:13and it feels like governments are sort of it feels like they feel like they're
- 8:20running out of options and they're grasping at these at these sort of more,
- 8:24I guess, more punitive measures just to get rid of the problem. Fascinating.
- 8:28Jen, Thank you so much for your time, right and thank you
- 8:31so much for all your great reporting that you do with the Taie. Thanks
- 8:33well, absolutely, folks, one of Vancouver's best reporters. She is Jen
- 8:37Saint Dennis. Also, if you're in Vancouver on November thirtieth, come join
- 8:41me and Jen at the Rio Theater to celebrate the Taie's twentieth birthday. It's
- 8:46going to be a lot of fun. Visit the Tayee dot ca for more
- 8:50information. Now, after some business, Vancouver Police recently rated a provincially funded
- 8:54activist group that was distributing illicit drugs to members of its Compassion Club. But
- 9:01what exactly did that accomplish? And have we lost the plot on addressing DC's
- 9:05toxic drug crisis. We'll talk about it up next