Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 07/21/26 EPISODE 010: UNCATALOGUED: BANGER OR BUM? - DOC HOLLIDAY 15 YEAR "BUFF-TURKEY"
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Mm-hmm. Welcome back in to the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast for another episode in our series banger or bum. And I chose the bottle that tonight, and I'm not gonna say any details about it. I will just tell you I've never tried this bottle. I have no idea if it's a banger or bum. You've never tried this? Never had it my life. This is a fresh crack for me and for you. I like it. ⁓ and so I'm interested. So I'm gonna get my thoughts on it as well because I have n no clue. Hmm. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. I'm excited for this because you there's a lot of bottles back here. There's there's a few bottles to choose from, and and it's one I've never had, so buckle up. No, I have not done a bottle review on this. I will probably do a bottle review on it in the future, but I've not done one yet. And I've never tasted it anywhere at a bar or anything like that. This is brand new to me. No, no clues. ⁓ nice. I was gonna ask you like if it's your usual. flavor profile, but it's much giving away too much. I'm I mean I hope I like it. I did buy it. I try not to buy bottles that I don't think I'll I'll like. So That's it. This is definitely one that I hope I will like. Not to say that I like every bottle that I purchase, but ⁓ we hope that this one's a good one. So let's dive in, nose, see what we get on it. Okay. I mean, it was funny before we started filming, you did mention it's a it's a little lighter. It is light. Right, John Carlo? Yeah. We've had some twenty year old. Some darker stuff, yeah. It's not super dark. That's true. It's not super dark. ⁓ I would say it's more like an amber on the color. Yeah. ⁓ it's got some viscosity to it, but it's not overly viscous. Yeah, for those just listening. A few little legs. Light legs. Yeah. Actually, but they kinda take a little while to form and then they turn into spider legs down the glass. She's not a thoroughbred, but it's a nice nose though. I like the nose. Sweet nose. Yeah, very sweet nose. I get very sweet. I'm getting apple on the nose as well. My first thing I get is apple. Apple pear, like the ⁓ crispness to it. Yeah. Fresh there's a f yeah, I would say like this freshness. I like the apple. I'd also Maybe go a little bit of cherry, like fresh cherry, not dark cherry. Not dark. Closer to maraschino cherry would be in my mind. There's definitely a like a vanilla creaminess for me. For sure on the vanilla. And I'm getting more of a Man, the more I back away from the nose. Vanilla extract, then I am like a vanilla bean. I like it. As as I s I was sniffing it and then I started backing away a little bit. And I I like the nose. It was a very nice nose. Good. Sweet, fruity. I can see why you purchased it. Well, I was hoping it would be good. Hoping it'd be good. Definitely haven't tasted it. And listen, I've had one recently that I've the nose I absolutely loved. And it is one that people say, Is this bourbon of the year? ⁓ And I are you and I opened it and I'm on the nose, I'm like, this could be bourbon of the year. This is a phenomenal nose. And then I tasted it and I was like, the nose didn't transfer. What is it? Are you gonna say? ⁓ I'll let ⁓ should you I'll let that come out. What's ⁓ the the my my content that I filmed about. All right. Yeah. All right. I'll tell you later. Okay. All right. Yeah. I like it. I don't dislike it. It is just different than what I thought it was. And the palate and the nose are polar opposites. Polar opposites. Okay. Interesting. The yeah. Okay. Yeah. The nose was super like bakery baked goods, toffee, like very sweet. And then the the n the palate was like spicy. Cinnamon, rice spice, very bold spiciness. And I was like That's weird. Not a lot of sweetness, not a lot of fruit. Unlike this one though. Well, we don't know how tastes given me a ton of fruit on the nose. Yeah, it's very I'm going in for a sip. Me too, me too. She's spicy up front. Ooh. I like it. Does have some spice to it. I I'm It does have the sweetness, like that vanilla creaminess is there. The sweetness transfers from the nose. So I got the vanilla creaminess after the subsiding ⁓ spice hot note to it. It's almost like a cinnamon red hot, a little bit in there. On the front end, and then sweetens out a ton on the back end. And but that front was very very hot for me. Yeah. What do you think there, John Carlo? I think the sweetness transfers. Yeah. And I am enjoying it. I get much more vanilla. Like a brulee sugar sweetness. Okay. ⁓ not so much the fruit. On the palate? I get the crispness, but not so much of like the apple or the pear. Okay. Nothing on the palate, yeah. Yeah, something's spicy, a spice note. Maybe cinnamon. This To it's more cinnamon candy versus cinnamon baking spice. Yes. Yeah. Think of like a cinnamon disc or like a red hot's or something like that. I'm torn I'm torn on this. Okay. Yeah. On if you like it or not? Yeah. I am torn if I like this or not. What's good? I like ⁓ I don't dislike it. Yeah. I don't dislike it. ⁓ You just don't know if it's a banger. I just don't know if it's a banger. Fair enough. That's the whole point of the episode, right? Maybe maybe it's literally that the hotness off the front end that's giving Is it still giving you hot on the second, third sip? The second it still did, but I'm getting a little peppery note. I got that. Almost like maybe like a white pepper. Mm-hmm. Mm. Yeah, it's not black pepper. No. No. Like a lightning. Like a sweet white pepper on the back side. I like that descriptor a lot. I do. Because it yeah. It has that peppery, like hot note on it, but not yeah. Yeah, not a black pepper. It's good. I I enjoy it. Okay. So what's your I'll ⁓ let's go with age, how old do you think this is? ⁓ let me try that. Or if are we We do Pager proof. Whichever one. You if you got a proof in mind, let's proof what do you think the proof is? Hundred and twenty four. You think one twenty four. Okay. I see one twenty. You think one twenty? I don't actually recall what it is, so we'll we'll have to look at it when we do I don't I I do think I don't believe it's that hot. You don't think it's hot? I don't think it's I don't think it's in the one twenties. Okay. I'm comparing it to the one seventeen from earlier. Okay. Well, so that's hard. Yeah. I the you know, the age on that I think really mellows that out. Probably you're probably right. Yeah. That's the I think that's why it's hard to compare those two. Speaking of age, what do y'all think of age what do y'all think the age of this I'm thinking? Because it's light? Younger, but the complexity of the flavor for me, I'm thinking nine. Nine years old. Okay. I'm gonna say around twelve actually. Twelve years. I s I if I get the com complexities to it. There it's definitely not one dimensional on it. It's just a little hot up front that's not doing it for me. Okay. But it's not bad. It's not a bum. Okay. Or yeah, it's not a bum for me. So not a bum. I wouldn't I wouldn't call it a banger. Okay. But it is ⁓ middle it's it's good. Don't we have so much. That's fair. So it's really hard to ⁓ categorize these whiskies in general, right? Blind bl and blinding is the the mother of all equalizers. Yeah. Exactly. You could be sipping on Thomas H. Handy or it could be a unicorn. You never know, right? So you're thinking you're saying middle Middle middle of the road. I mean, I'm not saying it's middle of the road. I wouldn't say it's a banger, and I wouldn't say it's a bum. So middle of the road would drain out. I'm leaning towards banger, but not I'm leaning towards it too. I'm on the higher end of the scale. So if you did a one to ten if you yeah, I mean I'm in the seven and a half. Yeah, seven. Seventy five percent or seventy two that's fair, right? Yeah. So we're saying a banger's maybe eight and up and bum is eight and up is a banger for sure. So just shy of a banger. A bum is like a five five down low. Yeah. Yeah. Five down. Five down. Yeah. I think that's so seven and a half, and you're concurring right there? Okay, cool. Awesome. ⁓ do you without looking at it, do you know anything so I know you know what it is. I know what it is. Yeah. But We'll do this a little differently. I I have a little information about this bottle. Okay. That I'm gonna read off. Okay. Before we ⁓ introduce the public gotcha ⁓ to this bottle. All right. So, ⁓ this is let's see here. I 124, you said 120. Yeah. And then I said twelve year. I said nine. Nine. Okay. So I mean, as soon as I start reading, it'll give it away. Well, won't we just not to the proof? Yeah, and age, yeah. Age is 15 years old. Okay. That was way off. 15 years old on the age. Fifteen. Proof on this, I think, is one sixteen and a half. One sixteen and a half. You were closer. Yeah. And to give it away. It's a seventy-five thirteen twelve mash bill. And this is a buff turkey. I yeah, I knew it. This is a buff turkey? This is the Doc Holliday, fifteen year old World of Whiskey, buff turkey. ⁓ Four hundred dollar bottle. so let's read about Doc Holiday, the fifteen-year-old buff turkey. Yeah. So ⁓ so we got the World Whiskey Society. They c they released this fifteen year old quote unquote buff turkey. It's a highly sought after bottle. You know, these buff turkeys are are, you know, hard to find. ⁓ it doesn't ever say buff turkey on the label. Yeah. so you'll never see that if you're trying to shop for one. ⁓ but what is buff turkey? We'll do a little education here, right? Yeah, if don't know, I I think it's super unique. Yeah. Really cool. So in the world of whiskey, buff turkey is a bourbon that was distilled by Buffalo Trace. ⁓ back in twenty nine or excuse me, two thousand nine to two thousand ten. Wild Turkey Distillery was undergoing a massive expansion following an acquisition by Kampari Group. To ensure they would not run out of whiskey while their facilities were undergoing construction, Wild Turkey partnered with Buffalo Trace to distill some bourbon for them. ⁓ and they just said, hey, we want you to distill our mash bill, which is all wild turkey products are 75, 13, 12, or at least their bourbons are right. ⁓ but they did not want to share with Buffalo Trace their their yeast. So Buffalo Trace used Buffalo Trace's own yeast, their grains, and their water, and then they distilled it. So then they barreled it and they shipped those barrels back to Wild Turkey, where Wild Turkey aged them from somewhere between 14 to 16 years. so when they were around 15 year olds and 15 years old, and this might be like a rumor mill, but they I some folks say Wild Turkey started tasting them for their Russell's reserve 15 year old release. I don't know if that's true or not. That's just rumor. ⁓ but they started tasting the barrels and they said it did not taste like wild turkey. And so they made the decision there to kind of liquidate or sell off all those barrels to barrel brokers. And so you'll never see it in a butt wild turkey barrel or a bottle or a buffalo trace bottle, but they've they're out there with all these NDPs and people that purchase this, you know, 14 to 16 year old whiskey. ⁓ this specific bottle ⁓ is the 15-year-old. it is ⁓ 116.5 proof and has an MSRP of 400. It's up there. Most buff turkeys are somewhere 250 to 600 in range there. ⁓ this one was four hundred bucks. And on the nose, here's what the ⁓ The people at the World Whiskey Society say we should be tasting. ⁓ warm and inviting with caramelized apples. Is that the nose? On the nose. Okay. Yep. Sweet marasino cherry, clove, nutmeg, and roasted pecans. Okay. I think I did say maraschino cherry. And I said apple. Yeah, we said the apple and like boom, the crisp. Look at us fruits. Look at us being professionals over here. Rose. On the pal on the palate, ⁓ smooth and velvety mouthfeel, mirroring the nose with the upfront caramelized apples and cherry, deep vanilla sweetness is cut by a savory, buttery roasted pecans richness. And the finish, long and refined, where the baking spices slowly fade out. To leave a lingering dark fruit and toasted nut finish. anyway. Now, World Whiskey Society has also released two 16-year-old buff turkeys. One is just the traditional 16-year-old buff turkey, so a year older, same lot of barrels. ⁓ and then they also released a 16-year-old cigar blend buff turkey. ⁓ Do have that bottle. ⁓ We will have to review that at a later date. ⁓ so I am not a big I bought it because I'm like I I really don't like cigar blends. They don't I don't smoke and and they just feel overly finished to me. But I'm like, it's a buff turkey. Maybe it maybe it's the maybe it's the king of cigar blends. So for those that don't know what a cigar blend, like me, can you explain? So it's usually finished in different type of ⁓ either spirits or wine casks. So ⁓ I think in a few of them, right? Yeah, typically several. ⁓ the only one that I know of that does not finish in other casks or or other spirit casks is still Austin, Tanager. They just do a red corn, blue corn, white and blue white corn blend. ⁓ which is all which is really good. ⁓ yeah, there's ⁓ there's no stipulation of what a cigar blend is. I think there's just what someone thinks would pair well with the cigar. Sure. And that can be whatever they want to I think they're usually trying to get like bolder n flavor notes in the wheel. This one's specific. Smoking Yep. Yeah. So for for the Doc Holiday 16 Year Old Cigar Blend, they finish in Tokai casks, which are which is a Hungarian sweet wine, Armagnac cask, which is a French grape brandy, and then port ⁓ white port wine casks, which brings a bright, crisp, lifting note with citrus and floral notes. Anyway, we'll try that some other time. Yeah. I wish I liked this more. I want I want to I want you to Want you to know. Wish you liked it. I wish I liked it. I think we all do because I'm a big buff turkey guy. Are are you? I th I feel like ⁓ the last time I was here, you you did have a buff turkey at that time. Correct me if I'm wrong. Sealbox fifteen. That was incredible. Yeah. There was I remember that one being lots of tobacco on that, right? Yeah. It didn't get the same on this personally. It's interesting, yeah. I don't know why it's well, these barrels can be wildly different. Yeah, all different barrels. And I I I wanna think that maybe the first folks that went in and s got on this trend snagged all the real good barrels and maybe Sealbox was in there early. ⁓ I honestly think that's the first Sealbox fifteen batch one. I is the first buff turkey I ever heard of. Yeah. Yeah. ⁓ and I found out about it like maybe f ⁓ four months after it became like a thing. And then I was like, What is this buff turkey? And then I went down the rabbit hole. And ⁓ have have purchased quite a few of these. ⁓ Thank you, Ronnie. Appreciate that. Yeah, I've tried that. Thank you for letting me ⁓ try these things. Yeah. They're really good. I mean it it's just such a to me it was like almost like a a time capsule, right? I don't know if you're gonna have these coming out in five years from now. Yeah. ⁓ although I di have heard that Wild Turkey did the same thing ⁓ about eight years ago. ⁓ So there's eight nine year old buff turkey that's out there. Maybe aging. Now I know Ass Pocket released an eight year old buff turkey with their with their inaugural release. But that's the only one that I've heard of that's come out at eight years old. ⁓ I I think the rest of folks are trying to get it up to that fifteen year mark. So stay tuned. What are we at twenty twenty six right now? Twenty thirties, early twenty early twenty thirties, twenty thirty two, twenty thirty three, we might be hitting that buff turkey trend again. and we'll be here for it. Things are Things go in cycles anyway. The thing I'm not here for though is people finishing whiskey in ex buff turkey barrels. That's some bullshit. Like new era. ⁓ I new new era. Literally put a turkey and a buffalo on their label. ⁓ And it's not a buff turkey. It's just finished in a buff turkey barrel. It's Heaven Hill finished in a buff turkey barrel. ⁓ Have you had it? ⁓ I tried it at Trevor's. It's it's okay. Okay. It's not buff turkey. No, I did have this actually. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I I'm pretty sure I had this. It's ⁓ it is it in a new era bottle? I think it's called the Heavenly Blend. ⁓ it's downstairs. I'd I'd have to go dig it out. But yeah, it was it wasn't buff turkey. So be careful. Look for that age statement six fifteen to maybe seventeen years now. And mash bill of seventy five, thirteen, twelve. Yeah, that's the way to know. I wanted to like this more actually. I know, I know, I know. You like what? I would I wanted to like this more after I knew what it was. Well, but I could definitely like taste it. I think blind is so tough. The blind is the equalizer. Blind blind is so tough, right? You can come in, and and so bourbon bingo's been super fun because it's like holy shit, like some there we've been very surprised with not liking things that you know traditionally I think a lot of people like. ⁓ but it's like you're just it's subjective. It's in that day. What did you eat an hour ago before you drank it? Right. So there's a lot of factors. Everyone listening to know what you eat and what you drink affects your palate immensely in when you're drinking ⁓ bourbon and whiskey. Immensely. Yeah. and word of advice, stay away from spicy foods. No Indian food. No Yeah I know and I love Chinese food. I love Indian food too, but I know if I do have it for dinner, I cannot film. ⁓ it just it messes with your palate too much. No marble rays. No hot wings. You're not doing that. None of that. None of that. ⁓ cool. Well, listen, I'm glad you guys gotta try it. I have been sitting on the bottle for a little while, so I was like Yeah, thank you. Let's sneak it in here and ⁓ and ⁓ crack it. So ⁓ I would buy another one. I like it a lot. I I think we need to get it in a ⁓ a buff turkey blind. There is someone out on the in social media land that was like listening to the podcast. They're like, if you ever do an all buff turkey podcast, I need to be on. I think his handle is like Buff Turkey Buddy or something. I d I don't I don't know. I'm gonna say that wrong. I don't remember off the top of my head, but it his his page is only buff turkeys. ⁓ I I run across. ⁓ And so he he was very interested in being a part of the buff turkey ⁓ experience. So maybe we'll do that down the road and just bring down thirteen buff turkeys and try them all together or something. Anyway, we'll see you very soon for another episode of the 323 Bourbon Library podcast. Cheers.