Latest / Indie Film Hustle® - A Filmmaking Podcast / IFH 716: How Master Storytellers Keep the Audience Engaged with Richard Walter
Transcript
- 0:03You are listening to the IFH podcast Network. For more amazing filmmaking and screenwriting
- 0:08podcasts, just go to IFH podcast network dot com. Welcome to the Indie
- 0:13Filmhustle Podcast, Episode number seven sixteen, Except no one's definition of your life,
- 0:19Define it yourself. Harvey Fiersty broadcasting from the back alley in Hollywood.
- 0:26It's the Indie Film Hustle Podcast, where we show you how to survive and
- 0:30thrive as an indie filmmaker in the jungles of the film biz. And here's
- 0:34your host, Alex Ferrari. Welcome, Welcome to another episode of the Indie
- 0:39Film Hustle Podcast. I am your humble host, Alex Ferrari. Today's show
- 0:43is sponsored by Rise of the Film Entrepreneur How to turn your independent film into
- 0:47a profitable business. It's harder today than ever before for independent filmmakers to make
- 0:52money with their films from predatory film distributors ripping them off to huckster film aggregators
- 0:57who prey upon them. The odds are stacked against the indie filmmaker. The
- 1:00old distribution model of making money with your film is broken, and there needs
- 1:06to be a change. The future of independent filmmaking is the entrepreneurial filmmaker or
- 1:11the film entrepreneur. In Rise of the Film Entrepreneur, I break down how
- 1:15to actually make money with your film projects and show you how to turn your
- 1:19indie film into a profitable business. With case studies examining successes and failures.
- 1:25This book shows you the step by step method to turn your passion into a
- 1:29profitable career. If you're making a feature film, series, or any other
- 1:33kind of video content, the Film Entrepreneur method will set you up for success.
- 1:38The book is available in paperback, ebook, and of course audiobook.
- 1:42If you want to order it, just head over to www dot film bizbook
- 1:47dot com. That's film bizbook dot com. Enjoy today's episode with guest host
- 1:55Dave Bullis. This concluding academic year lie first is the new academic year.
- 2:01Of course, this is the concluding thirty eighth year. So I've seen a
- 2:08lot, but I'm recalling years and years ago, and one of the things
- 2:13I've seen is, oh, about twenty five years ago, actually probably a
- 2:15little longer than that. The arts at UCLA all across the campus were reconfigured
- 2:23and the Film School, which was part of the Theater Arts department was turned
- 2:29into a long was turned into a separate two separate departments, the Film,
- 2:35TV, Digital Media. On one hand, that's my department and our assistant
- 2:39apartment, the theater department, and we aren't together in the School of Theater,
- 2:44Film and Television. And years ago when we were still the Theater Department,
- 2:47there was a retreat up to Lake Garrowhead. There's a very beautiful,
- 2:53upscale, gorgeous conference center up in the mountains, just about an hour hour
- 3:00and a half from the campus. And the whole subject that was discussed up
- 3:06there for the weekends was the spelling of the word theater. There were some
- 3:12people who wanted to change it from the ear to the r e. It's
- 3:17terribly unimportant, but I am on the side of the er people. Well
- 3:23though it was after two days of robust and vigorous and eager discussion, it
- 3:31was decided without any equivocation, without any hesitancy to discuss this further out another
- 3:40retreat. Yeah. I mean, it's like it's been said of the universities,
- 3:46that university it's just like a corporation, except that there's no bottom line
- 3:49and there's no calendar. Now both of those things are completely untrue today.
- 3:53You know, they're universities, especially here in California, but all across the
- 3:59country are very much in touch with the notion of the bottom line, as
- 4:02you know, support for public education, retreats, and not only at the
- 4:08university level, but much more grievously I think at the K through through twelve
- 4:14level, and calendar is very much attached to budget issues and so on.
- 4:18So fascinating any place to spend the life. That said, there's no escaping
- 4:25the you know, these bureaucratic issues, they're not you may unique to public
- 4:31universities or private universities, but all institutions, corporations, non profits, governmental
- 4:36agencies. You know, nothing ever runs real smoothly, and people should stop
- 4:41explaining it to you know, and and trying to make do because what else
- 4:45can you do. So in any event, there I am very sympathetic with
- 4:49what you're saying. The organizing principle of my life has always been no meetings.
- 4:58I don't do like as much as I can avoid it for exam,
- 5:01and yesterday I was at an awards lunch and I had to be there.
- 5:03I am also the associate dean now of the School of Theater, Film,
- 5:09and television, and I have to be there for the awards, the ceremony,
- 5:14you know, they give out scholarships and stuff like that and celebrate the
- 5:16students. But I'm reminded of a line in one of my favorite lines in
- 5:20olive movies, in Oliver Stone's Wall Street, there's a line. There's a
- 5:27moment where Gecko, you know, Michael Douglas. I'm sure you've seen that.
- 5:30I expect you've seen the movie. He's on the he's fielding like eleven
- 5:34phone calls at the same time. At one point he says, lunch.
- 5:40You know, clearly somebody's invited him to lunch and it's his lunch, and
- 5:45he scouses his lunch is for whimps, and he hangs up, you know,
- 5:48and I say, lunch is for whimps, I believe, you know,
- 5:51my first obligation to the university as professor in a research institution like the
- 5:57University of California, the first set second obligation is teaching. The first obligation
- 6:02is what they call in the traditional disciplines research, and in the arts they
- 6:09call the creative activity. But that's the first obligation that I have, and
- 6:13I can't do that, and that all the faculty have, but we can't
- 6:16do that if we don't have the time to do that. So one does
- 6:18need to be a warrior for one's writing time. If you follow what I'm
- 6:21saying, and I'm just responding to your talking, all these meetings are previous.
- 6:28Chair she had a sign. I loved her because because she had a
- 6:32sign on her desk on a little table at her in her office that said
- 6:41this meeting is costing. And then there was a blank you know, fill
- 6:45in the number, you know, next to a dollar sign. So I'm
- 6:47always sympathetic with what you're talking about. You know, there was a book
- 6:51I was just reading, Richard. It was called The Power of No,
- 6:56and basically it's that one word you could use just sort of the crux of
- 7:00the book is if you say the word yes, you inherit all that person's
- 7:04problem. So like if Richard, what would you like to go to lunch?
- 7:08And you say yes, well, well, you know it's it's funny
- 7:12because there's a self help guru who died I think last years, very well
- 7:19known, Stephen Covey, who wrote a book that is translated into like one
- 7:26hundred and sixty seven languages. You know, several of which are not even
- 7:29identifiable. I mean, he sold millions of millions of copies of this book,
- 7:32and it's called something like those Seven Habits of Highly Effective People or something
- 7:38like that. And in that book he says at one point he has a
- 7:46he has something he calls six words for serenity, and he there are own
- 7:51less, do less, say no. And that's what you're talking about.
- 7:58I have had to learn how to say no. Uh. You know,
- 8:03it's a necessary condition when I'm asked to do things that I just can't do,
- 8:11rather than sort of play along, go along and so on. You
- 8:15know, there's all kinds of ways to say. It's a student. I
- 8:16just got a request, for example, for the summer, a student,
- 8:20and you know there. I love the greatest thing about UCLA and the greatest
- 8:26thing about teaching is the students. Uh. And I love our I love
- 8:30our students. But there is among young people and and maybe college students in
- 8:33particular, maybe especially prestige students in glamor programs like UCLA. I mean,
- 8:39it is the you know, those major film schools like my own, Alma,
- 8:43modern USC, like NYU, like like certainly like UCLA. We are
- 8:48the glamour corner of higher and learning. So the people who do get in,
- 8:52it's very competitive. They maybe, you know, they they're very gifted
- 8:56and they used to get getting their own way, and I think maybe they're
- 8:58unique entitled, you know, they have a sense of unique entitlement. Say,
- 9:03somebody just announced to me, and this is somebody I really have a
- 9:07fond of and a very fine writer, a student in a program that he's
- 9:11decided to take an independent study with me this summer. I don't get paid
- 9:16for that, by the way. He will, and of course I have
- 9:20to consent to it. He can't just announce it, although he felt that
- 9:24he could. That he's just entitled to it, and he's going to if
- 9:28he has his way. Uh, you know, meet with me this summer
- 9:31and discuss his outline for a screenplay after I look it over, and then
- 9:35we'll meet several times. I'll review the pages and give them notes and so
- 9:39on. All I do that, you know, for eight writers every quarter.
- 9:43We're on the quarter system at UCLA routinely. But I'm not going to
- 9:50do that this summer. You know, I'm working on my own stuff.
- 9:54I have all kinds of things planned. We'll be right back a word from
- 10:00our sponsor, and now back to the show. But rather than just say
- 10:09no, what I told him was that I wished I could do that,
- 10:11which is only partly true, and however, that I would not be able
- 10:18to give him and his screenplay the time and the attention and the consideration that
- 10:24they both merit. So that's a polite way to say no. But you
- 10:28do need to learn how to say no. And I've also said in Hollywood
- 10:33dealing in the movie business, you're a hard no. No. This is
- 10:39not for us. As painful as that is, it's not as painful as
- 10:43what one usually hears when one submits a project, either to potential representatives or
- 10:48to a production company. One usually hears is this you know what I mean?
- 10:58The silence is definitely yeah, very shrill, very shrill silence. So
- 11:03I'm sympathetically what you're you're talking about. You do need to I mean,
- 11:07I consider it actually part of my my my pedagog if I could call it
- 11:11that, My teaching philosophy is to teach students. We are a professional program,
- 11:20a graduate program. We offer the Master Fine Arts. I trying to
- 11:24teach them by example how they need to be even warriors for their own writing
- 11:30time. I once had a definition I used to climb around about a definition
- 11:35of a writer. A writer is somebody who's always available to pick up relatives
- 11:39at the airport. And I've preached to writers that if they when they complain,
- 11:48oh, you know, I can't get any done them, the family
- 11:50wants me to you know, they think I'm available to pick up people over
- 11:54there. I said, well, you are available. I mean you did
- 11:54get picked them up. I didn't you, So why you know, if
- 11:58you don't get it, you're going to get it. You know. It's
- 12:01one of my principles, which is if you want to be treated as a
- 12:05professional writer, you have to treat yourself as a professional. And the fact
- 12:11is people who are going to pick up relatives at the equot but they don't
- 12:15realize is they're actually glad to do that because it allows them to avoid doing
- 12:18what every writer wants to avoid doing, and that is writing. And not
- 12:22only that I get to do to feel virtuous about it, and to get
- 12:26the gripe and catch and carp and complain about everybody intinging on their time,
- 12:31when in fact they're terrified to sit a loan in front of that word processor,
- 12:35you know, and the relatives coming in from out of town has given
- 12:39them the excuse not to do that. If you follow me, yeah,
- 12:43I absolutely follow you. Because there's a book that I read, The War
- 12:48of Art, by Stephen Pressfield. He's a genius. Press Field, He's
- 12:52just I love that book. Yeah absolutely, And you know I was fortunate
- 12:56enough to be able to speak with him briefly and I old him you know,
- 13:00reading that book was an epiphany for me. Oh absolutely, I just
- 13:05love the book. In fact, I was just quoting and somebody. I
- 13:09do a lot of consulting off campus. I give notes to writers who have
- 13:16deals at studios. You know, it's becoming more and more routine in Hollywood
- 13:18now, even when you have a deal, you know, typical writing assignment
- 13:24is what they call, and it's whatever is negotiable, you know, as
- 13:28long as the guild minimums are being observed. The typical assignment is what they
- 13:35call a draft and a set. A draft is a draft of a screenplay,
- 13:39and a set usually consists of what somebody will call a rewrite and somebody
- 13:43else, and then it'll be followed by what somebody calls a polish. But
- 13:46of course the guy uh doing the polish and the guy doing the rewrite have
- 13:50different views of you know, what what it should be let should be called.
- 13:54But often between such stages, UH, smart writers will go to somebody
- 14:03like me, a script doctor of script consultants, and say, listen,
- 14:07they owe me, you know, I owe I owe them this trapt before
- 14:09I handed in. Ask me. You know, I want you to ask
- 14:11me the hard questions because the studio asks them and and and so on.
- 14:18So I was talking to But I also work with writers who, you know,
- 14:24who are independent and who can afford my very very high fees to give
- 14:28those kinds of notes. You know, It's easier for a writer who's getting
- 14:30a quarter of any them a fee from Paramount Pictures to do that happen than
- 14:33somebody out of out of their own pocket. But I do work with writers
- 14:39off campus. As I say, who can have Again, if I'm attracted
- 14:41to the script, I think it's something that I want to you know,
- 14:45if you feel merits encouragement, and then of course it costs a lot of
- 14:50money. So I was working with somebody. I'm working with a particular writer.
- 14:56It was in the Midwest, and sheet I just sent her back a
- 15:00a second raft of notes. Oh, it's about a fifteen page document,
- 15:05going through her script and talking about it in general, but also going through
- 15:07the page is not page for page, and indicating where there are certain issues
- 15:11that are around, some of them as trivial as typos, and some of
- 15:15them, uh, you know, fundamental issues about character and story structure and
- 15:18whatever. And she complained to me that she was really disappointed that there's more
- 15:26work to do, that she thought she had the whole thing set up,
- 15:30and that she's kind of sorry that things aren't proceeding, you know, according
- 15:33to schedule, you know, in the way that she predicted. And I
- 15:39immediately thought of press Field, who I know what he would say. Stephen
- 15:43would say that her only amateurs and dilettants think that it goes, you know,
- 15:48in a steady, predictable, reliable way. That it's not herkey,
- 15:50jerky and frustrating every inch of the way. You know. Press Field would
- 15:56say, stop trying to feel good about it, you know, feel good
- 15:58about having done it, but don't feel good about doing it. Nobody does,
- 16:03No writer does it. One of my first principles is all writers hate
- 16:07to write. We love having written, but actually sitting down and addressing the
- 16:14pages. That's what press Field goals. Resistance. There's always resistance sitting there.
- 16:21And I have a lot of experience as a writer over my years.
- 16:26I've been writing professionally for more than forty years. But my own experience is
- 16:32leveraged by the experience I've had with other writers, working very very closely,
- 16:37very intimately with writers on campus and off campus, and so you know,
- 16:41I have the experience also of all of those writers. And that's the way
- 16:45it is for everybody, for everybody, including the highest handed, you know,
- 16:52highest minded, most successful, richest practitioners. It's always that way,
- 16:56and people have to, you know, stop trying to feel good about it.
- 17:03You know. It's like Steven said one time, he said, uh,
- 17:06you know, if you can beat resistance inch by inch and you can
- 17:08actually get something made, and you can actually you know, you sit there
- 17:11and there's a polished manuscript, and he says, congratulations. Now move on
- 17:15to the next one. Exactly. I quote a student of mind. He
- 17:22wrote two scripts in class that became gigantically successful films. They became franchise as
- 17:30one as Highlander maybe they they called it The Highlander, and the other one
- 17:36is Backdraft. I mean, Backdraft became an amusement park ride, you know,
- 17:42I mean, it's gigantic success. And so here was this twenty six
- 17:45year old writer, multi millionaire. Already I was reading an interview with him
- 17:52in the press. This is some years ago, and he was again just
- 17:56like writers, complaining and you think he'd beat something for joy and you know,
- 18:00whistling a happy tune. No, he was talking about how they had
- 18:04betrayed him at Fox, how they had dissed him at NBC, and burned
- 18:10him at Warner Brothers and lied to him at Paramount and on and on.
- 18:14You know, all of these dramas, and you know, acts of these
- 18:19crimes that had been visited upon him, This poor poor guy, this poor
- 18:25multimillionaire, twenty six year old screenwriter. And then he pauses in the interview,
- 18:30and I swear if you held the interview this is a press you know,
- 18:32a print piece, if you held the news page close to your face,
- 18:37you could have felt the waft of his sigh. If you know what
- 18:41I'm saying, He felt a breeze on his cheek. It was that palpable
- 18:44in the context of what he was saying was quoting me, he was saying,
- 18:48Ah, but I can just hear. After he's griping and complaining,
- 18:51he says, oh, but I can just hear. My professor Richard Walter
- 18:52of Mucila say mcgreg don't you know it's the privilege in Hollywood, even merely
- 18:56to be mistreated this way? Again, what Hollywood will do to you the
- 19:00worst than Hollywood will do to he is not mistreat you, but ignore you.
- 19:07I have an experience I met with Rest his soul, Julius Epstein.
- 19:15He's He and his brother and another writer wrote Casablanca and among many other things
- 19:22that Julius was involved in. He lived, he was working well into his
- 19:26eighties. He passed a few years ago. Now, rest his soul.
- 19:32He uh. When I first time I met him, I said, oh,
- 19:34mister Epstein, I'm so excited to meet you. The only you know
- 19:37all I hope, all of all I or any of my film phony palels,
- 19:41all we hope for is his wants in our lives. We should touch
- 19:45something as you did with Casablanca. It's timeless, that's eternal. That is
- 19:51going to you know, touch the hearts and minds of generation. Something like
- 19:55that. We'll be right back after a word from our sponsor, and now
- 20:03back to the show. Yeah, it wouldn't be nice affected report to you
- 20:08that. He said, Oh, thanks very much, kind of you to
- 20:11say so. I mean, that would be courtesy one oh one. You
- 20:15know, Uh, he's a writer. You gotta understand. He grew up
- 20:19in Brooklyn, but he spent seventy years in la but he never lost the
- 20:25Brooklyn drawl that he had. And his reply to me was, cassi blankish
- 20:30Messiblanca. They fucked that up. You know what a part where Floyd Rayne
- 20:34says such and such a day. But oh no, they wanted with my
- 20:37brother Philip. I mean we had a thing with it. And here he
- 20:40is complaining, you know, more than a half century later, like sixty
- 20:45seventy years later, about how they messed up his movie, what movie Casablanca?
- 20:52And all I could think is, my god, I wish somebody would
- 20:55mess up my movie like they messed up Casablanca. So, you know,
- 20:59again, only amateurs and dilettants think you're just settled in eagerly in front of
- 21:03the word processor, and you know, you take a deep breath and you
- 21:07kind of just get into your creative zone and it just kind of flowes out
- 21:12of your magically, you know, just ain't that way? Ain't that way?
- 21:18And the other thing is people and never you can't get no satisfaction.
- 21:22If I may quote the Rolling Stones, it's never as good as people think
- 21:27that it should as the writer herself or himself thinks it ought to be.
- 21:33It's always better in the mind, you know, when it's not an actual
- 21:37tangible old in your hand, it's always more perfect than when it's a real
- 21:41thing. You know. So there is a quality of frustration and disappointment that
- 21:47walks hand in hand with creativity. And professionals know that they accept that,
- 21:52they tolerant, that they endure it, they don't like it, and amateurs
- 21:56deny it. It's amazing that the screen mode of Casa Blanca actually, you
- 22:03know, had of problems with it because you know, that's the movie,
- 22:08that's the go to movie that you know, almost every screenwriting professor I've ever
- 22:14had, or you know book I've ever you know read, that's one of
- 22:15the two movies that they use as a paradigm for this is this is what
- 22:19a great movie or sorry, this is what an excellent movie is. You
- 22:22know, yes, well it's what a great screenplay is, and it is
- 22:26a great movement, and it's beautifully acted and beautifully directed. I quite agree
- 22:32with you. And yet the actual writer of that, you know, thinks
- 22:34say so so. But then there is also a trend kind of that I've
- 22:38detected among writers where if you talk to a really successful writer and you asking
- 22:44what's the favorite thing that you wrote, They're going to pick their most obscure,
- 22:47least successful project, you know, almost to make up for the disappointment
- 22:53that they experienced when it was was released. As I say, one praise
- 23:00for disappointment when something because you'll never be disappointed if something isn't released, you
- 23:06know what I mean. So again I tell my writers, and I tell
- 23:11my colleagues around the table from at the time at UCLA on the faculty,
- 23:15that fantasy is for your screenplay, for your life reality. So you know,
- 23:22as we we talked about, you know, just you know about writing,
- 23:26and you know some disappointments you know in your classes. What I wanted
- 23:30to ask, you know, it was when whenever a student comes to you,
- 23:33you know, how do you know what's a good concept and what's not?
- 23:38Well, you don't, you don't you never know what's a good concept.
- 23:41You never I'm going to tell you two concepts right now that are the
- 23:45stupidest concepts for movies. You will never hear a stupider concept for a movie
- 23:52than uh than either of these. Ready, I mean, let me let
- 23:59me let me before I say that, let me let me mention Blake Snyder
- 24:03and Save the Cat. He argues that if you're a writer and you have
- 24:11a concept, you should run that concept past some some other people. He
- 24:15actually says you should stop people in the street, and especially young people,
- 24:18and telling hey, can I talk to you for a minute. I'm a
- 24:22writer, and I have a notion for and I you know, for a
- 24:25screenplay of a concept, and I'm wondering I'd love to, you know,
- 24:27talk you through it for a minute or two and see what you think of
- 24:32it, whether you think I'm like you know, it be a mistake to
- 24:36move forward or resist the worthy. And now, imagine you were walking down
- 24:37the street and somebody comes up to you and wants to run a concept past
- 24:41you, and you and you're generous enough most people probably would say, well,
- 24:45all right, all right, you know, let's hear it. Because
- 24:48and you did that, and the guy gave you the following concept. You're
- 24:52ready, I'm ready. A man stutters, but he has to give a
- 24:56speech, so he hires a speech there this, and they work on the
- 25:00speech, and then he gives the speech. What if somebody's what if you
- 25:07said to like, well, I gotta tell you, honestly, you know,
- 25:08you seem like a really good guy. And but you know that sounds
- 25:11just oh let's I mean, who could possibly care about what you just described?
- 25:17What if he then said he will, all, well, you know,
- 25:19thanks, just the same. But respectfully, let me tell you that
- 25:22I happen to think this this. When it's all done, it's going to
- 25:26win the screenplay, you know, best Screenplay, Oscar and best movie.
- 25:32You'd figure crank up the lithium on this guy's drip. It's madness, you
- 25:37know. And yet I don't have to tell you what movie that is.
- 25:38I'm sure. Oh how about this? Somebody comes up and says, I
- 25:44want to do I have an idea for a cable series. I think it's
- 25:47going to be sixty two hours. It's going to run for you know,
- 25:49five seasons or six season. It's gonna be sixty two hours of programming.
- 25:55And here's the idea A here's the concept. A high school chemistry teacher gets
- 26:00a cancer diagnosis and he say, he decides, in order to provide for
- 26:08his family, to partner with a former incorrigible student and go into the meth
- 26:15trade to manufacture and cell methodphetamine. One of these well, Ida, that's
- 26:22how that doesn't sounding much of a concept that would work one of these all.
- 26:26I think it's going to turn into sixty two hours of unparalleled genius.
- 26:30I don't mind telling you I am one of those people who regards Breaking Bad
- 26:34as one of the greatest achievements in the history of civilization. In fact,
- 26:38last Saturday I was at just a week ago today, I was at the
- 26:41pitch Fest in Burbank, big screen ranking festival have every year, and I've
- 26:47actually met Tom Snaw's and Peter Goulds, who are the forces behind Better called
- 26:53Saul, which of course grew out of Breaking Bad, and I just trem
- 27:00to meet them. You know, I have to shake their hands that wrote
- 27:03those all of those uh beautiful Breaking Bad episodes. They were prominent writers,
- 27:07producers and occasionally I think directed some of the Breaking Bad episodes. So it's
- 27:12not about ideas it's not about concepts. It's about story. The story is
- 27:18all. It's about stories everything, and that's what we preach at UCLA.
- 27:25And you know, if the proof is in the tasting we've we've you know,
- 27:29there's a lot of evidence that we're we're not wrong about that. Yeah,
- 27:33I you know, I sawd the some of the accomplishments you know,
- 27:37uh they some of your students have done, and that that is just phenomenal.
- 27:41And you know that's why, you know, you were the guy that
- 27:44I wanted to talk to if you were you know, when I was in
- 27:45the early stage of this podcast, you were one of the of the people
- 27:48that I actually marked down to talk to. And I'm so happy that we
- 27:52actually got to talk. Now we'll get too and I'm flattered by what you're
- 27:56saying. I thank you kindly. Oh, completely my pleasure. And just
- 28:00you know, to to continue talking about your class. You know you mentioned
- 28:03before an outline, So do you have your students actually you know sort of
- 28:07uh fusht fush out their stories through an outline? And how if so,
- 28:12how detailed do they have to go with that outline? Well, the first
- 28:15answer is yes, I do have them do an outline, but I also
- 28:18tell them to throw away the outline once I get started writing. It's not
- 28:23terribly detailed when we have our each quarter. We have three ten week quarters
- 28:30at UCLA, where most institutions have two semesters, you know, fifteen week
- 28:36semesters, and at the Big I work each quarter. I've taught the course
- 28:41now over one hundred times with students, eight students around the table writing a
- 28:48you know, feature length screenplay, and each one has to We meet once
- 28:52a week for three hours, the whole group. But oh I do meet
- 28:53with them multiple times during the quarter, independently individually to two really one on
- 29:00one where we review the pages together. You know, I read the pages.
- 29:06Having read the pages, I meet and give them my notes I have.
- 29:11Everybody has to bring the second week of that class. They have to
- 29:14bring in a maximum two page kind of a beat sheet, sort of a
- 29:18scene list. It's not really an outline, but it's a sort of a
- 29:22document that helps the writer have a general direction that the script is going.
- 29:30But then I tell everybody to stay open to the surprises. The last thing
- 29:34you want to do is drag something back to, you know, an earlier
- 29:40notion that you had if it's working better in a new fashion. You know,
- 29:45I never knew a writer who wasn't surprised by lines of dialogue that our
- 29:51characters spoke. You don't seem to invent by themselves. We'll be right back
- 29:56after a word from our sponsor, and now back to the show. You
- 30:04know, by twists and turns in the story that they didn't they weren't even
- 30:10aware of, even though they are creating the whole thing. There is a
- 30:14kind of a magic to it. I had Neil Simon come to class to
- 30:22talk about comedy. Imagine being in a writing class and having, you know,
- 30:27Neil Simon comedy. It's like being in seminary. And you know,
- 30:32he was announcing at two o'clock in room nine, the Lord will be doing
- 30:36a Q and A, you know. And I asked mister Simon, I
- 30:41said, do you laugh at your own jokes? And he said, sure,
- 30:45I do the first time I hear them. And I think that's a
- 30:48great line. It's as if his jokes are not made up by him,
- 30:52but cold to him, by the characters that he creates. I don't know
- 30:56any writer who hasn't had that experience. So yes, I do think you
- 31:00have to have an outline, but I think you have to then sort of
- 31:03throw away the outline and expect the script to unfold in a way that will
- 31:08surprise not only people who read it but the person who wrote it, you
- 31:14know. Very true. And there was a book and I can't remember the
- 31:15name it off top of my head. I think it may be in the
- 31:18artist way, but the author of that book, Julia Cameron, Yes,
- 31:22I yes. And one of the methods that she describes in that book was
- 31:26basically, you know, just sort of starting and just going and don't worry
- 31:32about, you know, having a plan, you know, meaning like you
- 31:34know what a detailed outline means. Well, there's something. There's something to
- 31:37be said for that. El Doctor Rao, who's not a screenwriter to my
- 31:41knowledge, but a very very successful novelist who's some substantial number of his novels
- 31:47have been made into movies. He's probably best known for Ragtime. He says
- 31:52driving he compares writing to driving at night. You can only see as far
- 31:59as the headlights reveal. But that's long enough, that's far enough to drive,
- 32:05you know, the whole journey. He also describes Ragtime how he came
- 32:10up with Ragtime, which is that he was in his He lived in New
- 32:15Rochelle, I think he still does. New Rochelle, which is in Westchester
- 32:19County. It's a suburb of New York City. And he lives in a
- 32:22home, kind of a early twenty century home. And he was just stuck.
- 32:31He was in his writing room and he just didn't know what to write
- 32:35about. And he was in deep, deep dark depression and despair, the
- 32:39way writers get. And he finally just wandered around his study and could think
- 32:45of nothing to write about. Say, he put his head against the wall.
- 32:49He started to like bang his head literally bang his head against the wall.
- 32:54And finally he decided, well, the hell with it, He's just
- 32:57going to write about the wall. And he thought about the wall that he
- 33:00was, you know, pushing his forehead up against, and when it went
- 33:05up, and when the house was built, and that happened to be around,
- 33:07you know, in the period that Ragtime is built, and what was
- 33:08going on in New Rochelle at that time, and there was a parade and
- 33:12this one fraternal order of something and ratherand and suddenly out of out of banging
- 33:17his head against the wall and ran about comes Ragtime, which is a gigantic
- 33:22number one you New York Times bestseller uh and a sensationally successful film directed by
- 33:28Millish Foreman. Uh. And all of this came back by you know,
- 33:30banging his head against the wall. So so again the you you were asking
- 33:38about, oh, yes, about getting started. There's a writer. Do
- 33:40you know the name Anne LaMotte, Yeah, Annie Lamotch. He's best known.
- 33:45She's a wonderful novelist, but she's probably best known for the books she's
- 33:49written about writing. The best known is called Bird by Bird and she Annie
- 33:55preaches that every writer should allow themselves, which she calls a shitty first draft.
- 34:04You got to get it down on the page and stop, you know,
- 34:07being disappointed that it's not genius. Yet. There's another book I think
- 34:13is very interesting. It wasn't written about writing. About thirty years ago,
- 34:20there was a best seller by a writer named Mark McCormick. Mark McCormick actually
- 34:25was a sports He invented modern day sports management. He really started in golf
- 34:31and he's the guy who you know, got multimillion dollar contracts for ball players
- 34:37and really went along way towards getting rights for ball players at they you know,
- 34:42used to not have I remember, almost a half a century ago,
- 34:45I was working on a Jerry Lewis picture. I was the dialogue director on
- 34:50a Jerry Lewis picture of Warner Brothers, and on the Jerry liked to slum
- 34:53with ball players, and so he had the star of the Dodgers at that
- 34:55time, Willie Davis, on the movie. And Willie was a hold out
- 35:01that winter. You know, it was pre free agency. I don't know
- 35:07what you could do is refuse to play. So he had held out for
- 35:08this contraent front. Driving over the studio one day we were shooting in December.
- 35:13In January, you know, off season for baseball, I heard on
- 35:16the radio that Willie had signed his contract. So I asked him when I
- 35:20got to the studio. I had no right to ask him, but I
- 35:22asked him how much? So what do you think he got for the nineteen
- 35:25seventy season. He was twenty nine years old, he had hit almost four
- 35:30hundred the previous season. He was in his prime. He was one of
- 35:34the best players in baseball. What do you think was his salary for the
- 35:37nineteen seventy season. Take a guess. I'm going to take a guess.
- 35:42At thirty thousand for the year. That's a really good guess. It was
- 35:46not as bad as that. It was actually fifty thousand. People will guess,
- 35:51oh, you know, quarter of a million, a half a million,
- 35:52you know, million dollars and so on. Why do I mention this?
- 35:55I had to do with Oh yeah, Mark McCormick writing about sports management.
- 36:00He wrote a book called He went to the Harvard Business School and he
- 36:02wrote a book called What they Don't Teach You in the Harvard Business School.
- 36:07And it was kind of a street savvy, you know, wisdom for MBAs
- 36:13and CEOs, you know, and cefos and CEOs and CEOs and whatever,
- 36:20you know, major executives. And we was saying. One of his rules
- 36:24is it's quite wonderful, uh, I believe, And it works very well
- 36:31for people in the arts and including writers, and here it is, don't
- 36:36let excellent stand in the way of good. He got something that sort of
- 36:40works. Go with it, you know, at least for the time being,
- 36:45and then you'll come back and rewrite. But I think that's what slows
- 36:50people down sometimes they and stops them cold, you know, is it's not
- 36:55excellent every inch of the way as they go. It's merely good, and
- 37:00I'm saying, if you can be nearly good, thanks to God and move
- 37:06on. You mentioned Bird by Bird. It's funny you mentioned that because I
- 37:12was actually talking to people about, you know, books on writing and I
- 37:15and you know, usually the book if we just talked about writing as a
- 37:19whole. The number one book I always hear about is Stephen King's on writing.
- 37:22That is my favorite book by Stephen. It's a brilliant book. And
- 37:27by the way, you'll recall what he has to say about ideas. He
- 37:30launched his whole career with Carrie. That was his big success, his breakthrough.
- 37:37And by the way, you may remember from the book that he'd gotten
- 37:42some distance into it and then he despaired of it and he threw it away
- 37:45and Tabitha, his wife, Tabitha King, found it in the garbage and
- 37:51took it out and read it, said what's this? And she said,
- 37:53what's this? Friend of the Gum And she said, ah, it's just
- 37:55now we're going to have them in the band name. She said, well,
- 37:58you mean, it's just great. You should keep going. And that's
- 38:00how Carrie came about. But do you remember how it started. Stephen was
- 38:07living in Maine, where he still lives. And he was a high school
- 38:10teacher, and he always wondered what he knew what the boys room and the
- 38:15boys lockers looked like, but he was curious what the girls bathrooms and the
- 38:21girls lockers looked like. So one day when the after school hours, when
- 38:27when school was closed, but some of the teachers were still there and the
- 38:30lockers in the bathrooms were deserted, he went into the women's you know,
- 38:36the girls bathroom and the girls the lockers, and he discovered, guess what,
- 38:39they just exactly like the boys lockers, except for two differences. One
- 38:44is that in the showers, the boys lockers had gang showers, you know,
- 38:51just a great big room with nozzls you know, on the wall,
- 38:54and the girls had curtains. They had, you know, modesty curtains.
- 38:59They were there were tracks on the ceiling of the shower room and that provided
- 39:06for curtains so that they had, you know, a more modest experience when
- 39:10they showered. The other difference was that in the girls locker rooms and meth
- 39:16rooms there were these little vending machines, if you know what I mean.
- 39:22And look at Carrie. It's all about this girl who comes into menstruation and
- 39:29doesn't know what it is, is mocked and ridiculed by the other girls who
- 39:34see her in the shower, and they can see blood running under the curtain.
- 39:37If you saw the movie, if you remembered, or if you read
- 39:38the book, just looking in the locker room leads to a thing which he
- 39:43sold back then, forty years ago for four hundred thousand dollars, adjusted for
- 39:49inflation, would be about three million dollars today. And it all came about
- 39:52from curtains and tampons. We'll be right back after a word from our sponsor,
- 40:04and now back to the show. Amazing, amazing. Yeah, I
- 40:10remember the opening of that movie, and it did heavily involve that. And
- 40:14you know, and you know, even the remake, which I remember pieces
- 40:19of I don't remember as much as the original, but uh, you know
- 40:22that had I think that's a similar, a similar beginning, similar open.
- 40:25Yeah. Well, I don't see the remake, but I remember Sassy Spacic
- 40:29in the beginning. She's very beginning of the hour. She's you know the
- 40:32movie, She's in the shower at school and there were other girls in the
- 40:37showers, and suddenly blood is running and she clearly does not know what this
- 40:42is about. He's never been taught by her parents or anybody else about menstruation.
- 40:45And she thinks there's something horribly wrong with her, that you know,
- 40:49she's evil, and and and then the other girls, uh see the blood
- 40:53and they see that she's upset about it, and you know, there's this
- 40:57terrible bullying uh attitude that emerges among adolescents, men and women, and they
- 41:05start to attack her. And so I mean, that's what drives the whole
- 41:08movie in this movie about revenge, isn't it. And she ultimately, you
- 41:13know, avenges them at the end of the movie. But it all derives
- 41:17from from that very very simple premise. And if you describe that to somebody
- 41:22superficially, they would think it's pretty hopeless. So again, I think that
- 41:25one of the biggest mistakes that writers make is to assign too much value,
- 41:32too much credit to the idea. I like to tell writers when you have
- 41:37a great idea, if you have a really great idea for a movie,
- 41:42that's all you got. I mean, what remains after that the you know,
- 41:49the incidents, the anecdotes, the events, the characters, the dialogues
- 41:53that describe I mean everything remains After that, the idea is really rather useless.
- 42:00What has value is the story. And think about it. You can
- 42:02tell the idea for a movie in a you know, a minute is about
- 42:07forty seconds more than you need to tell an idea, But to tell the
- 42:12story takes you, you know, as long as the movie. For example,
- 42:15I was talking. I was saying to somebody the other day what I
- 42:16had just said to you a little while ago about talking about the King's speech.
- 42:21I was describing, as I did to you, man man stutters,
- 42:25he has to give a speech. He how's a speech therapist and gives a
- 42:28speech. So somebody said, yeah, well you left out that the man
- 42:32who stutters is the King of England. And then it's the nineteen thirties and
- 42:37war clouds are gathering in, you know, on the continent, and that
- 42:40he's having a romance with Wallace Simpson, you know, an American commoner,
- 42:46and so on and sofa. Well, that's the story. That isn't that
- 42:52the story. That's not the idea any longer. It's the story, and
- 42:54that's where the value is. Yeah, you know, somebody wants told me
- 43:00that, you know, ideas are a dime a dozen but at that at
- 43:05that point, you're overpaying for the idea. It's yeah, well, I'll
- 43:07tell you something. I have a sideline I have. You know I am.
- 43:13If you ask me what I do, I would I am a writer,
- 43:15if you know, if I were an elevator and time to respond,
- 43:20you know. But the truth is, I also am an educator, pretty
- 43:24well known educator. But that's not the end of it. That's just the
- 43:28beginning. But I'm also a consultant and I consult in you don't know,
- 43:32a public speaker, and I'm a media commentator. I do a lot of
- 43:37appearances on talk shows, television, radio, and as a consultant, I
- 43:45do two kinds of consulting. One is I've already told you about where I
- 43:49work with writers. I consult with writers as a script doctor. I give
- 43:52them support in working out there their scripts. And the other kind of consult
- 44:00things that I do is in the court. I am a court authorized expert
- 44:05in intellectual property law, particularly copyright infringement in plasiarism. Who wrote the movie
- 44:10and I have testified. I've been an expert witness in oh between thirty and
- 44:16forty court cases over the years where there's litigation over you know who wrote the
- 44:23movie. Somebody thinks the movie was stolen from them. And over the years,
- 44:27I've on occasion been retained as a witness by plaintiffs but also by defendants.
- 44:32I was a witness, for example, in the very legendary case at
- 44:37Paramount involving Art Buckwalt, the famous humorist and the Paramount the producer of the
- 44:44movie Coming to America and Eddie Movie, Eddie Murphy movie and Eddie Movie Murphy,
- 44:52where buck Walt suit claiming they'd stolen it from him and so on.
- 44:55I testified that the you know, they didn't steal the from him, that
- 45:00it was a different movie. But I only mentioned it because it is the
- 45:06miss appropriation of value regarding ideas that has if I could put it this way,
- 45:13put orfodanche on my children's teeth and paid for their fancy ass nose bleed
- 45:17costly private school education. My wife and I looked a lot of kids have
- 45:24grown up now, God blessing, But we used to joke that we saved
- 45:28up enough money to send our kids to college, but we spent it all
- 45:30on high school. You know. And what I mean by one of that
- 45:35is people attach too much value to the idea. They had an idea for
- 45:42a movie, they see another movie that has a similar idea, and they
- 45:45think it must have been stolen from them, when they don't get that it's
- 45:51just an idea. Ideas are not protectable. It's the expression of the idea
- 45:57over the length and breadth of a narrative, where the where the value is.
- 46:00You know, you have to show what the courts called substantial and ideally
- 46:06strikingly similar examples from one to the other, you know, not just that
- 46:13the boy and a girl fall in love, they break up, and then
- 46:15they get back together again. You know. So so this misunderstanding of ideas
- 46:19has put a lot of money in my pocket. You know. It's it's
- 46:22you know, funny you mentioned that because about maybe two summers ago, I
- 46:27actually met a professor who teaches at Yale and he actually also does you know,
- 46:34uh does copyright and things like that, and he was actually involved in
- 46:37the Avatar case because some some writers came and said James Cameron stole their idea
- 46:42for Avatar, and they wanted to you know, they wanted a you know,
- 46:45a couple of millions, actually, you know, more than a couple
- 46:46of million. Dollars. But uh, and he was involved in that whole
- 46:50litigation. Interesting, I don't mind bragging that it's a student of ours and
- 46:54named Leita Kinda gritas very successful writer. She wrote much of Avatar. Jim
- 47:04gives her credit, not as writer, but she does have a producer credit
- 47:07and it's her own card. Her name stands all alone on the screen.
- 47:14But the fact of the matter is she really wrote a lot of that movie.
- 47:15She's not suing her complaining, You understand, she idolizes Jim Cameron,
- 47:20and I think he's I know him too. He's been very good to us
- 47:22and our students in our program. And uh, you know, Leda was
- 47:30paid millions and millions of dollars for her work on Avatar. And she's she's
- 47:35not not complaining. But yeah, I believe that any any big movie.
- 47:39You know, a lot of people know about the the buck Wald case.
- 47:44It was covered, you know, the Coming to America case that I mentioned
- 47:47earlier. It was covered Gavel to Gavel. It was held live Gabble to
- 47:52Gavel on the trial on CNN. I remember, And a lot of people
- 47:58don't know that there that particular litigation was one among seven or eight cases where
- 48:05people had claimed, you know, other people had claimed they'd written the movie,
- 48:07you know, independently. There's an expression that every success has many parents,
- 48:16but failure is an orphan. In other words, if a movie makes
- 48:21no money, nobody hears about it, no one will sue. But if
- 48:22you have a great, big hit like Avatar, there's going to be bunches
- 48:27of lawsuits. I know that my old classmate, George Lucas from usc film
- 48:30school. We were film school students together all those years ago. You know,
- 48:37there have been multiple suits. Star Wars was sold from him, you
- 48:39know, from them. I I remember that he went up to Canada to
- 48:45it would have been easier for him to just settle, which is what they
- 48:49usually do. But he's a very funky, feisty guy, George, and
- 48:52nobody's going to say that. You know, he's not going to going to
- 48:55consent to anybody. Uh you know, Uh, he's never going to agree
- 49:00in any that he ever ripped anybody off. And so he actually went to
- 49:06the trial and somebody had uh claimed that he the plaintiff, had had invented
- 49:13the whookie and George has stolen that from him, you know, So you
- 49:17know, suck when my son was little, if he couldn't find his baseball,
- 49:21maybe he'd say, who stole my glove? You know, it couldn't
- 49:22be that he misplaced it, you know what. You know what I'm saying.
- 49:27So people always think that there's something similar. It must have been stolen
- 49:30from from them. Uh. Occasionally it happens, but it's most exceptional.
- 49:35And when you mistake the exception for the rule, ya fall on your face
- 49:37every time. Very true. Uh, you know. And and the more
- 49:42I hear about, you know, cases like that, you know, Richard,
- 49:45And the more I hear that it is either you know, a hey,
- 49:47you know what, two people, you know, great minds think alike,
- 49:50as they say, So you know, it is possible if you know
- 49:52two people that living, you know, maybe the opposite ends of the earth
- 49:55came up with a similar idea. You know. We'll be right back after
- 50:00a word from our sponsor, and now back to the show. I mean,
- 50:10I mean, you know, you and I could go to the video
- 50:12store. You know, well, if their video stores are still around,
- 50:14you and I could go to Netflix and we could see there are there's all
- 50:16there's a plethora of movies that maybe share maybe the same scene or maybe share
- 50:22like the same you know, plot points, or maybe share the same you
- 50:25know character character attributes something similars on those lines. Again, the only thing
- 50:31I totally I totally agree theme many movies of the same theme Jaws, I
- 50:38happen to know. And now I'm blanket card Nottley who who wrote Jaws,
- 50:45of course he was adapting to Peter Benchley book. Was was telling me that
- 50:52the h you know, he had conversations with Bentley. Jaws is based on
- 50:58a play by the great Norwegian player at Enrick Ibsen, and the play is
- 51:07called an Enemy of the People. It's a very well known, you know,
- 51:08sort of a classic play. I guess it's a one hundred and fifty
- 51:13years old or something. And it's set in a health resort, health spa
- 51:20that's famous for its waters, that there are healing water as people come from
- 51:24you know, a thousand miles you know, to have their their maladies healed
- 51:30in the waters, the magical waters of this particular health spa. And the
- 51:37protagonist in the movie is doctor Stockman. He's the medical director of the baths.
- 51:44Now this doesn't sound at all like Jaws, but consider this, at
- 51:47the beginning of the movie, he discovers, the doctor does that the waters
- 51:51are actually polluted and that they're making people ill. And this is a really
- 51:57important discovery. When he announced, is it, he thinks people will honor
- 52:01him because he's saving a lot of people a lot of illness and even death,
- 52:07you know, because they'll stay out of that bad water. And it
- 52:09will also get the resort to do whatever needs to do if it can be
- 52:14done to you know, repair that right. So that doesn't sound terribly like
- 52:19Joe's, and yet it is because the reaction of the of the health spa
- 52:23and the community around it that lives off the income brought in from tourists coming
- 52:28into be guests at the spa, they instead of honoring him, they they
- 52:35you know, degrade him, They deride him, and they declare him an
- 52:37enemy of the people. And that's exactly the deal with Richard dreyfuss In as
- 52:44the sheriff and Jaws and John's if you remember that he realizes it's the start
- 52:49of the season, it's a beach town and suddenly there's a dangerous shark.
- 52:53Uh And if word gets out that there's all of that danger and people aren't
- 52:59supposed to use the each well, they're not gonna do a beach vacation,
- 53:01at least not there, you know. So instead of honoring him for making
- 53:06this really important life saving discovery, they degrade him, they humiliate him,
- 53:12they scorn him, they mock him, they loathe him. And so the
- 53:15theme is history hates a truth teller, something like that. And that's the
- 53:22same theme for Jaws and for the Enemy of the People, even though they
- 53:28so what's the difference between them. The difference is the story totally different story,
- 53:32the setting, the dialogue, the characters, everything is different, though
- 53:37they have the same theme. Quite quite true. So you're going to see
- 53:42movies that have similar themes. But you can't protect a theme. All you
- 53:45can protect this a story, and it has to be substantive. This happens,
- 53:50that happens, this happens, that happens, the same stuff happens in
- 53:53both. And then you're starting to get onto a uh, you know,
- 53:59and enterprise that is protectable. It's just a very, very crazy arena.
- 54:09The truth of the matter is studios, producers, production companies, networks,
- 54:15cable companies. They have no selfish interest in stealing material. They don't want
- 54:21to risk the tens of millions of dollars that it takes to put together a
- 54:25series or a movie. Indeed, Avador have a billion dollars. Nobody's going
- 54:36to make that kind of investment and try to cut somebody out of one tenth
- 54:39of one percent of that, which would be you know, hundreds and hundreds
- 54:43of thousands of dollars or even millions of dollars for the script, and put
- 54:47the whole rest of the project into jeopardy just trying to shave off a point
- 54:52or even two from the budget by stealing the script. You follow what I'm
- 54:55saying, Oh, yeah, it just you know, there's a ah,
- 55:00I'm not a lawyer, though I've spent a lot of time around lawyers doing
- 55:05this kind of kind of working. There's a there's a Latin phrase, I
- 55:09forget what it is, something like queen bone. Oh, you know who
- 55:13benefits from this? If you look at a legal case and you want to
- 55:17say, well, who's in you know, you suddenly discover for somebody dies
- 55:21and you suddenly discover that they had a huge insurance policy and it all goes
- 55:25to this particular beneficiary. Well, that beneficiary had a substantial steak and a
- 55:30great reward in this person dying, maybe maybe she or he killed him.
- 55:35Right, So movie companies have a steak in not stealing material. Nobody benefits
- 55:45by that, and indeed they suffered greatly. So I think it does happen,
- 55:51but I believe it's vastly, vastly exaggerated. You know, you mentioned
- 55:57you know your classmate was George Lucas. Do you have any other, you
- 56:00know, interesting stories or any other funny stories about you and George. Well,
- 56:05you know, I am the uncredited writer of the first two drafts of
- 56:08American Graffiti. There's no controversy about it. George doesn't tell it any differently.
- 56:16There's nothing unusual in Hollywood about a substantial number of writers being paid for
- 56:23their services on a particular picture and not all of them getting credit credit as
- 56:29a a judgment that is rendered by the writers Guild. So I yeah,
- 56:36I worked there. I knew George pretty well. We weren't very close friends
- 56:38in film school, but we knew each other, and we were at parties
- 56:43together, we were in classes together. I was in awe of his achievements
- 56:46as a film student, as we all are back then at USC. His
- 56:52legendary student film THHX one eight four eb which became a feature length film,
- 56:59ultimately not as good as the shorter version, but it was his first movie.
- 57:04It was done at Warner Brothers with Francis Ford Coppola producing. I was
- 57:10this, you know, in awe of his talent as a graphic artist as
- 57:15a filmmaker when I was in film school. When we worked together on Graffiti,
- 57:20I didn't really work closely with him. He had he was out of
- 57:24the country, actually had the long version of sex we called it sex THHX.
- 57:34He was bringing that to Can the festival. I was traveling with his
- 57:37then wife Marcia. They were backpacking around Europe and they were going to end
- 57:40up at can and they needed a draft of Graffiti in a hurry, and
- 57:46I was asked to write it in a couple of weeks, which I did
- 57:51on that first draft, and it did not He was not pleased with it.
- 57:57For he complimented it for it and he had over the years complimented for
- 58:01its professionalism and all of that. But he was bothered by two aspects of
- 58:07it. One was the sex in it. You know, I saw it
- 58:09as a tale of you know, adolescents coming of age and all of that,
- 58:15and that's a time of sexual awakening. And you know, if you
- 58:17look at George's films that kind of like clinical surrand rapped. As far as
- 58:22sexuality is concerned, there's sort of isn't any you know, the h and
- 58:29I'm a sexual pervert, not really a kidding, but but I think that,
- 58:35you know, in my own I've written at length about adolescent My first
- 58:37novel was a coming of age in New York City, and there's a lot
- 58:43of you know, sexuality in its young people flirting and and and more.
- 58:49And George didn't like that. He's kind of uptight about those sorts of things.
- 58:52And the other thing you didn't like was that it wasn't close enough his
- 58:54own experience, you know, growing up in the desk. So hey,
- 58:58I'm you know, I'm a New York kid. I'm up in the Queen's
- 59:00and went to school, went high school in Manhattan, you know, and
- 59:02I didn't know any of about cars and stuff like that. So we never
- 59:07really worked together on and except after the first draft. It was a two
- 59:10draft deal we did. We didn't meet at my house and then we met.
- 59:16I remember we had another meeting at a restaurant in Hollywood, and we
- 59:21spoke at length on the phone after the you know, during the process of
- 59:24writing the second draft and and so on. I was well paid for the
- 59:30work that I did, and I'm not complaining. You know, again,
- 59:35the credit decision is something that is rendered by the writer's guild and uh,
- 59:42the so it's really their judgment, not the studio's judgment, not George's judgment,
- 59:46and so on. He's a powerhouse. You know, he's a kind
- 59:52of a rough, nerdy, scratchy voice, little guy. But I mean
- 59:58he's suggested great genius I've ever known. We'll be right back after a word
- 1:00:04from our sponsor, and now back to the show. I mean, the
- 1:00:12impact of that his work has had across I mean, who on the world,
- 1:00:16you know, who around the world doesn't know some aspect of the of
- 1:00:20the Star Wars franchise hasn't been touched by some aspect of it, right,
- 1:00:24I mean, you know, don't you think it's realistic to suggest that billions
- 1:00:28of people have heard of it? At least? Who do you know in
- 1:00:30all of human history who touched so many people, got into the consciousness and
- 1:00:35the awareness of so many people all around across the globe in so little time.
- 1:00:42As George did. I also believe that the influence that he's had the
- 1:00:45influence of Star Wars. I'm not really crazy about the movies. John Neaius
- 1:00:50our film school. Look An, you know, a fellow alumnus, alumnus
- 1:00:58you know, calls them pap. I watch all of them. I've seen
- 1:01:02the first one, which is I guess the fourth one by a certain measurement,
- 1:01:07part of the second one, and so on. But the lesson that
- 1:01:10they put out there, I think is a really really affirmative, healing,
- 1:01:16positive message across the world, a very Judeo Christian message, which is that
- 1:01:23the power of love is greater than the power of hate, the power of
- 1:01:28God is stronger than the power of Satan, the power of construction is bigger
- 1:01:34than the power of destruction. I mean, you know, you have a
- 1:01:37fairy tale. And again again going back to the ideas we were talking before,
- 1:01:40what's the idea behind Star Wars. I'll tell you what it is,
- 1:01:45and you already know what it is. It's a fairy tale in space.
- 1:01:50The bad guys abduct the princess and you know, the good guys rescue her.
- 1:01:54That's Star Wars, isn't it. Yeah, That's what makes I was
- 1:02:00special in the answer is the frame by frame, moment by moment scene by
- 1:02:04seeing action in it, and the dialogue that the characters speak and and so
- 1:02:10on. So, you know, George is a very h you know,
- 1:02:16he's not a very available kind of a guy. I don't think a lot
- 1:02:20of it. People would describe him as warm and cuddly. But when I
- 1:02:29worked with him, both on campus and off campus, that was certainly a
- 1:02:34professional arrangement and agreement. And you know, whatever disagreements that that were had
- 1:02:39were you know, we're experienced, were not unusual among artists working on a
- 1:02:46movie together. Yeah, very It's very understandable. And I was actually his
- 1:02:52house guest. I remember my wife and I in the August of nineteen sixty
- 1:02:57nine. He had already left LA he was living up in marin And I'd
- 1:03:04love to say that my class at USC we were the first to move on.
- 1:03:07You know, when we came to film school, there was no tradition
- 1:03:09of moving from film school into the professional community. In fact, I have
- 1:03:13an article right now it's just come out like yesterday or the day before,
- 1:03:17in the current issue, the most recent issue which has just come out excuse
- 1:03:23me of written by which is the Writer's Guild monthly journal, and it's called
- 1:03:30film school haven or hoax, and I'm arguing that, you know in it.
- 1:03:35I'm arguing, of course, I have a vested interest in it,
- 1:03:37but I still believe it's observably, verifiably empirically true. The film schools not
- 1:03:42a hoax, you know, but very very helpful in in getting you know,
- 1:03:49people into the movie business. I cite in the article eleven eleven titles
- 1:03:54of movies written, I'm sorry, directed or produce and or produced by Steven
- 1:04:00Spielberg that were written by at least in part by UCLA trained writers who have
- 1:04:05on screen credits for those movies. Eleven of them. Jurassic Park won too,
- 1:04:10three, Indiana Jones two and three. That's five right there, the
- 1:04:15terminal Munich Lincoln, War of the World's Eagle Eye. Eagle Eye was produced
- 1:04:23by Stephen Travis. Wright was the writer our student a few years ago when
- 1:04:28am I leaving out, oh the TV series Amazing Stories. Our students in
- 1:04:34the last six or seven years of at five just in the last six or
- 1:04:39seven years, five Academy Award Best Screenplay nominations and have won three Oscars for
- 1:04:46Best Screenplay in the last so script between now and then now being today and
- 1:04:53then being with time now almost half century ago that I was going to film
- 1:04:57school in classes with George Lucas. The big diff prances that film school has
- 1:05:01gone from being a dead end professionally to being the single most advantageous way to
- 1:05:10enter the film industry. So I like to say that our class at USC
- 1:05:15we were the first ones to go on to own Hollywood, except for Georgia
- 1:05:19Olms Marin County. So in any event, my wife and I in nineteen
- 1:05:25sixty nine, in August, we took a motor trip, just a vacation,
- 1:05:30a holiday up the West coast, and we drove all the way up
- 1:05:32ultimately to the Oregon border, the California Argon border, the quad Dunes.
- 1:05:39There are some beautiful sand dunes along the northern California southern Oregon coast, just
- 1:05:47exquisite. We camped along Brenson but on the way we stopped at San Francisco,
- 1:05:51and I remember I had we had brunch one Sunday morning in Sauce Elite
- 1:06:00with some old film schools pals, including George and Marsha. Also John Nelius,
- 1:06:06if you know that name, I referred to him earlier. John,
- 1:06:10you know, invented Schwarzenegger. You know, he did con Conan and bunches
- 1:06:15of other movies he wrote. John probably best known for his script of Apocalypse.
- 1:06:19Apocalypse now. So it was my wife and I and George and Marsha
- 1:06:25and Melius. Also Caleb Deschanel, who's probably famous now being the father of
- 1:06:30very famous actors daughters. But the Caleb is of course himself a multi nominated
- 1:06:36cinematography he's one of the most respected, the most successful cameraman in the history
- 1:06:43of the industry. And there were some other people. There was Walter Murch
- 1:06:47who's very famous. Walter actually won two Oscars for sound design and something else
- 1:06:53in the same years. In Officer one he got to come of twice to
- 1:06:58the stage to pick up as oscars. He was there with his wife Aggie,
- 1:07:02a British woman. And then was also Caleb, as I mentioned,
- 1:07:05and a producer now a well known producer, David Lester, who produced all
- 1:07:14around Shelton's films In a Bull Durham and on and on and on, and
- 1:07:17I remember Marsha invited us to to be there. Their house guests, and
- 1:07:25we said, well, we're moving on up the coast tonight, you know,
- 1:07:29I mean right after this meal, we're driving north. She said,
- 1:07:32but on the way down, if you want to stay with us, feel
- 1:07:34free. So we did. We were actually the house guests overnight when he
- 1:07:38was living in Mill Valley in Marina. Was before his gigantic success with Graffiti.
- 1:07:45Graffiti wouldn't come out yet for about three years. I think it was
- 1:07:48in seventy two seventy one or seventy two seventy three. It came out.
- 1:07:55It was released in seventy three. So we were all, you know,
- 1:08:00well, film school pals. When I look back, you know, at
- 1:08:02the time, we weren't really aware of it. You've got to look back
- 1:08:06to see it to talk about right place, right time. You know,
- 1:08:09I had come out. I thought to California for three weeks from New York,
- 1:08:15and at the last moment I just fell into film school. That sc
- 1:08:17kind of a whim and you know, somebody turned around. It was ten
- 1:08:23years later. You know, I had never really planned to settle in California.
- 1:08:30It's much less to become a screenwriter, much much much less to be
- 1:08:35a paniard professor you know, and legal expert and so on. If here
- 1:08:41has a great example of staying open to the surprise is in a life narrative.
- 1:08:45I think you know, I'm always sowing writers in your dramatic narrative,
- 1:08:48in your life narrative, stay open to the surprises that all of the people
- 1:08:53I know who are enjoying what they're doing are also surprised by what they're doing,
- 1:09:00doing what they planned to do. People who do what they planned to
- 1:09:03do are people. I know a lot of such people, and they offer
- 1:09:08the most what doctors. I grew up in New York City and the big
- 1:09:11thing to be was a doctor. So I know a lot of medical professionals,
- 1:09:15and they're very successful. They're you know, they're well paid and so
- 1:09:19on, but not all of Some of them are very happy, but not
- 1:09:21all of them. Many of them are unhappy. This one wishes he was
- 1:09:26an oceanographer. That one wishes he was an anthropologist, and all of them
- 1:09:30seem to wish they were also screenwriters. Sometimes it seems like. And the
- 1:09:35point is that you know, there's a Chinese curse me or dreams come true
- 1:09:42curse. It's a little scary when when you accomplish what you said out to
- 1:09:46accomplish, and it doesn't really feel right. I have a friend who's just
- 1:09:49retired from medicine. He's done very very well, he's respected, he's made
- 1:09:56a good living, but he's always been lukewarm at asked about about his career.
- 1:10:02We'll be right back after a word from our sponsor, and now back
- 1:10:10to the show. Never really enjoyed it. On the other hand, I
- 1:10:15know another doctor, a friend of mine who went to film who went to
- 1:10:18medical school but just didn't like practicing medicine. What he liked was computers,
- 1:10:24and very early in the computer revolution, he got into the the writing of
- 1:10:31software for computerizing pathology laps. He was a pathologist whose specialty was pathology,
- 1:10:40and that branched on out to general medical medical record keeping in general. They
- 1:10:47were computerizing all of that. You know, previously a doctor would see a
- 1:10:50symptom and would sort of think about it. Now you can, you know,
- 1:10:53really search the databases. And this is a result of not just inconvenience,
- 1:10:58but in the savings of countless lives if you think about it. So,
- 1:11:03my friend is we were visiting with him. He lives in Seattle.
- 1:11:11We were visiting with him and his wifele ar Old Pounds of laws some months
- 1:11:15ago. And his house is on Lake Washington. There's a duck behind it,
- 1:11:21and on one side of his power boat and on the other side of
- 1:11:25his sailboat across the lake, and a little to the south the Bill Gates
- 1:11:31compound. I mean, this guy has done real well, my friend,
- 1:11:34and he loves his work. And he didn't jettison his medical education. He
- 1:11:41very much exploited it. And that's not a dirty word. It just means
- 1:11:43make the most of it. He integrated into his career, his very successful
- 1:11:46career, a career that he loves that he just enjoys enormously. My point
- 1:11:54is he's not doing what he expected to do and he's loving it. And
- 1:12:00that's what I'm what. The point that I'm making is that it's possible to
- 1:12:04overplan, kind of outsmart yourself in life and else. And you mentioned Richard,
- 1:12:11you know sometimes it wants to be a screenwriter. You know, it's
- 1:12:15kind of like everyone. I think it was. Joe Esterhouse, the screenwriter
- 1:12:18of Basic Instinct, once said, uh, you know, it used to
- 1:12:21be if it wants to write the great American novel. Now it's the great
- 1:12:24American screenplay. Yeah. No, Joe is a friend of mine. I
- 1:12:30know him well over a number of number of years, and I'm aware aware
- 1:12:33that he said that it seems to be true. Uh, it seems to
- 1:12:40be true. People people want to Uh. You know, there are more
- 1:12:43people who years ago would have been writing novels than are writting screenplays. I
- 1:12:47do both. I've just finished the novel and I've had modest success in both
- 1:12:56areas. And it's interesting that guy was just lecturing on this this is my
- 1:12:59subject. A week ago at the pitch Fest, we were talking about how
- 1:13:04it's funny. Let me put it this way. There's a there's a political
- 1:13:10figure you've heard of, Governor Christie from New Jersey. He's running for president,
- 1:13:15and he was I saw him sometime last week. Earlier in the week,
- 1:13:20he was bitterly denying that he was what somebody had accused him of.
- 1:13:26Somebody had accused him and called him to characterized him as a particular word,
- 1:13:30a very very evil word, the most evil word that you can you know,
- 1:13:34used to characterize a political figure that these days in this country. Can
- 1:13:39you guess what the word was, I'll tell you. Somebody called him a
- 1:13:44moderate they said that he was moderate. Imagine that used to be like a
- 1:13:50compliment, you know, he was denying these a moderate. Now why do
- 1:13:56I bother you about that? Because there's a word in Hollywood that Hollywood seems
- 1:14:00to have come to hate. Are you ready? Original? They don't want
- 1:14:05to do anything original. In fact, the disappointing release of Tomorrowland is that
- 1:14:12what it's called Rowland? Yeah, with Clooney? What kind of disappointed?
- 1:14:17They say that they're not going to do any more original movies, you know,
- 1:14:20because if Tomorrowland is original movie, they only want to do tinfoles,
- 1:14:25remakes, reboots, prequels and sequels, adaptations of material from other media.
- 1:14:32They don't want to do original screenplays. And I think that's a real pity
- 1:14:36because, uh, you know, what they're trying to do is play it
- 1:14:42safe, and playing it safe is the most hazardous course you can follow in
- 1:14:46an arc. You have to take the risks, you have to embrace the
- 1:14:51risks. Invites, solicit and courage the risks, it seems to me.
- 1:14:58And nevertheless, it as if you're a writer and you have an original screenplay,
- 1:15:03what are you gonna do with that? Nobody's making original screenplays or certainly
- 1:15:05these studios are not. They are not buying spec scripts and turning them into
- 1:15:11movies. They're developing projects inside. I had a writer who wants to he's
- 1:15:15a huge fan of Batman, and he wanted the Batman franchise, and he
- 1:15:18wanted to pay me a substantial sum to give him notes on a Batman script.
- 1:15:24Day right, I said, but you can't do anything with a script
- 1:15:28Warner Brothers on the right, you know Batman, Because he said, well,
- 1:15:33I'll show what the Warner Brothers. But Warner Brothers isn't gonna look at
- 1:15:38a Batman's script. They're not going to buy it speculated Batman script. They're
- 1:15:43going to develop it with writers they know who work with producers. They know.
- 1:15:46Those writers may very well be former students of mind mind you, and
- 1:15:49I'm happy to brag about that. But they are not going to do this
- 1:15:53guy's script. Not only are they gonna make it, they aren't even gonna
- 1:15:56read it. And they're gonna make a point not to read it for a
- 1:15:59reason. To go back to what we were talking about earlier, having to
- 1:16:00do with litigation, If it's Batman, it's certainly going to be similar.
- 1:16:04It's going to have certain similarities to the doesn't Batman have franchise? Don't you
- 1:16:10think? And then they'll be they'll be their lawyers at Warner Brothers will be
- 1:16:13telling you you mustn't look at this and you must notify you must send this
- 1:16:16back to him and tell him we haven't looked at it. We don't accept
- 1:16:18the the symterial. And so because he's going to claim when the new Batman
- 1:16:21games out that we that we really used it, and we didn't, you
- 1:16:27know, uh, we just we stole it from so uh. So we're
- 1:16:33talking about originality. So how do you get around that as a writer?
- 1:16:38Uh? And the answer is, and I've had modest success with this repeatedly
- 1:16:42in my career. I don't consider myself to be any kind of superstar.
- 1:16:46But the uh, the Wall Street Journal calls me. They what did they
- 1:16:53say about me? They said, Oh, I am a writer of substantial
- 1:16:57professional experience. You know, there's no literary laundry I haven't taken. And
- 1:17:01I've written feature assignments, feature length movie assignments for all of the studios,
- 1:17:08almost every studio, and I've told material to all three major broadcast networks.
- 1:17:15And I have had almost half a dozen books published by by all of them
- 1:17:18by major New York publishers. I've had best sellers in non fiction, my
- 1:17:25screenwriting books in print, you know, over thirty years. My last novel
- 1:17:31made the Times List best seller lists only for a week and only at number
- 1:17:36thirteen. But think you know the Times List. It's not a small thing.
- 1:17:41And the reason I mentioned it to you is that my very first novel
- 1:17:47I had written as a screenplay and I just couldn't. It's been said Hollywood
- 1:17:56is the one place on earth where you could die of encouragement. I had
- 1:17:59some encouragement over that script when I never had was a nickel for it.
- 1:18:03And finally there was a strike and you couldn't market to Hollywood anyway, And
- 1:18:09so naively I turned it into I used it as an outline for a novel,
- 1:18:12and I wrote a novel. I was naive about how cruel the fiction
- 1:18:15market is, especially the first fiction market, and that naive pay served me
- 1:18:19very well because I sold a thing right away. And you know, had
- 1:18:24I been more stavvy about the business, maybe I wouldn't have you invested the
- 1:18:30time and effort it would take to turn down into a novel. Knowing how
- 1:18:32grim the chances were. So you understand how ignorance is your friend, naive
- 1:18:38pay is your pal. Now, as soon as it was sold as a
- 1:18:43novel, it was sold as a movie. A Warner Brothers, a studio
- 1:18:48that had turned it down when it was a screenplay, bought the same screenplay
- 1:18:51as soon as it had been published as a novel because it was no longer
- 1:18:55original, it was now an adaptation. It had been tested in another market.
- 1:19:00The executives. If every every day in Hollywood that an executive doesn't have
- 1:19:04to make a decision about anything as a victory for her. She hasn't put
- 1:19:10her neck out, she hasn't risked and he you know, if you don't
- 1:19:13do anything, you'll never do anything wrong. Right. So, and every
- 1:19:17movie that does get made starts with the anticipation by the executives who are responsible
- 1:19:23for spending the money to produce it. It starts with their expectation that it
- 1:19:28will fail. And they're trying to figure out how to explain away the anticipated
- 1:19:32failure of the movie. I don't see how that can do anything other than
- 1:19:36to suppress creativity and imagination and so on. But you understand how somebody could
- 1:19:43say if the movie comes out and it bombs, for example, Bonfire the
- 1:19:48Vanities, which is reduced by a friend of mine and a colleague of mine.
- 1:19:53He's also a professor at UCLA. Peter Goober very successful producer. He
- 1:19:57was We'll be right back award from our sponsor and now back to the show.
- 1:20:06Had a Warner Brothers. He was at a Columbia. He's produced a
- 1:20:10lot of major, major movies. Well, one of the movies that he
- 1:20:14produced, it was a Terrible mom there's even a book written about about it
- 1:20:19was Bonfire the Vanities. And when people say to him, Peter, how
- 1:20:25could you invest so much money in this turkey? He can. I mean,
- 1:20:30you must be some lousy executive. We should get rid of you.
- 1:20:31He has a defense, and the defense is, wait a minute. This
- 1:20:35was a best selling novel by Tom Wolfe. I also had Bruce Willis and
- 1:20:42Tom Hanks in the movie. The screenplay was adapted by Michael Christopher, a
- 1:20:48very very distinguished, respected writer. The director was Brian the Pond. It's
- 1:20:54not my fault. It's not my fault. You understand what I'm saying.
- 1:20:56So suddenly, because with my own novel when it was sold as a movie,
- 1:21:01the producer who bought it could say, if anybody asked him, how
- 1:21:04I think you'd buy this? Because say, what, don't mean Mortar Books
- 1:21:08published this? You know, major publisher New York published this. So I'm
- 1:21:12not the only one crazy enough to think that there's merit in this. So
- 1:21:15I've been recommending to writers that they contemplate me write a screenplay, but instead
- 1:21:21of showing the screenplay, write an original screenplay. Certainly you don't want to
- 1:21:27do an adaptation of material that you don't own. I mean, they're lie
- 1:21:34dragons. What are you gonna do with something if you don't have the underlying
- 1:21:38rights. So what I'm recommending is they write an original screenplay, but then
- 1:21:44instead of marketing the screenplay at first, they use it as an elaborate outline
- 1:21:49for their novel and write it as a novel, and then try to sell
- 1:21:54the work as a novel, and once it sold as a novel, they
- 1:21:59can get action as a screenplay. I've done that multiple times now, and
- 1:22:02right now I'm working on I've just finished a novel that's based on a screenplay.
- 1:22:08I wrote the screen the last summer, and now I'm finished the draft
- 1:22:12of the novel. It's just the draft. I still have to do a
- 1:22:14bunch of work on it. But once you've got the screenplay, most of
- 1:22:16the heavy lifting has been done. I regard it just like we were talking
- 1:22:20earlier about the most valuable part of the equation is the story. Once you've
- 1:22:26got the story will work. Now you've got the characters, the dialogue.
- 1:22:30I mean, most of that's there in the screenplay, isn't it. To
- 1:22:32turn that into a novel is relatively easy? Underscore relatives, you know,
- 1:22:40relatively there's not a you know, no writing is easy. But for me,
- 1:22:45the hardest part of writing is the heavy lifting. Isn't in devising creating
- 1:22:49the plot, because the plot, the story really involves everybody else. The
- 1:22:54story is character, story is dialogue, story is description, It's every thing.
- 1:23:00I mean, who's the richest character? I mean, imagine somebody said,
- 1:23:03well we're in a minute, richie, what about character? Isn't that
- 1:23:05important? But who's the greatest character in all of English language dramatic literature?
- 1:23:11Isn't it a Hamlet? Certainly Hamlet would be a good candidate, don't you
- 1:23:16think? So? What's the description? Have you ever read Hamlet? Do
- 1:23:24you remember the playwrights description of Hamlet here it is, it's three words prints
- 1:23:30of Denmark. That's it. There's nothing about melancholy. So where does this
- 1:23:36Hamlet come from? And the answer is from the story, the stuff he
- 1:23:40does and the stuff he says inside the context of the story. So it's
- 1:23:45really really all about all about story. So once the story has worked out,
- 1:23:51you have the opportunity to retell that story as a novel. And it's
- 1:23:56just easier to write a novel. It's easier because you're not stuck with this
- 1:24:00sight and sound like you are in a movie. You're not. You know.
- 1:24:06We mentioned George Cluney a moment ago. I read a screenplay called The
- 1:24:11American. I didn't see the movie. It's a dreadful screenplay. Cluney was
- 1:24:15in it. I think the only reason George was in it because it was
- 1:24:18shot in here where he lives in northern Italy, and I lives Lake Como
- 1:24:24at the edge of the Swiss border up there, and they was shot it
- 1:24:26up there. So I think that's the only reason I can imagine that George
- 1:24:30would have been, you know, had anything to do with this movie,
- 1:24:32would be because it was convenient. Was in the neighborhood, so so it's
- 1:24:38been at There's a scene in the movie where the main character is sitting is
- 1:24:44at a cafe ordering a bottle of wine. He's with a girl, and
- 1:24:48the waiter comes up and offers him, you know, taste of the wine,
- 1:24:51and he samples the wine, and it actually says in the script that
- 1:24:54he takes a ship of the wine. It takes slightly flinty, with notes
- 1:24:59of chess, nuts and cinnamon. Wait a minute, well, how does
- 1:25:05me? Well, how does anybody knows sitting in a movie theater watching them
- 1:25:09on screen with what something tastes like? You follow what I'm saying? Yeah,
- 1:25:13I knew exactly what you mean. This guy, this writer, doesn't
- 1:25:16understand the most fundamental aspect of screen running, which is you stuck with sitan
- 1:25:20sound. It's just sitan sound. It's easier to write a novel because you're
- 1:25:27not stuck with You can say with somebody remembers what they think, how they
- 1:25:31feel. You know. The greatest compliment that's ever been paid me is that
- 1:25:39final draft. The software. I'm sure you know of it, the screenwriting
- 1:25:44software has actually created. I don't know if it's available yet. We are
- 1:25:48creating they are creating for me in consultation with me, that Richard Walter template.
- 1:25:55You know, like if you want to write a if you want to
- 1:26:00write a Simpsons script, for example, you can you can punch up Simpsons.
- 1:26:06You know, there's a pull down window in Final Draft and you can
- 1:26:10go to Simpsons and you click that and it will immediately give you the formatting
- 1:26:15for the uh uh. You know the Simpsons likes that the Simpsons uses.
- 1:26:20And I don't mind telling you that a colleague of mine has won several Emmys
- 1:26:25for the Simpsons, and a bunch of us students have written for the Simpsons,
- 1:26:29and oh, one of them. This makes me sad because he died
- 1:26:33young in his forties. A wonderful writer and wonderful guy, very successful in
- 1:26:41not just in TV, but also in features. He wrote four he wrote
- 1:26:45the super Girl. Very very fine writer. He uh. He was a
- 1:26:55the the oh producer what are they quote? Exact producer of the Simpsons and
- 1:27:00a writer for the Simpsons. So Final Draft has a Simpsons template. They
- 1:27:04now have a Richard Walter template. If you if you punch up me,
- 1:27:10you'll get format that conforms to my particular desires. For example, I don't
- 1:27:15when if you write x E x T for exterior, you know, it's
- 1:27:21like extort. I was taught that you don't put and I preach it,
- 1:27:26you should not put a period after that. And in final draft, if
- 1:27:31you go to the Richard Walter template, it'll get rid of the theory that
- 1:27:33comes after that. Somebody might say, Kee, that seems like a pretty
- 1:27:36petty point, but actually I think it's the most important, the most profound
- 1:27:41point in all of creative expression. And the point is simply this. There
- 1:27:44shouldn't be anything in the script that doesn't serve the script. That is to
- 1:27:47say, it doesn't move the story forward. And if you learn, if
- 1:27:53you get into the kind of mindset that leaves out even the period after exterior,
- 1:27:56then you'll leave out lines of dialogue that you don't need. You leave
- 1:27:59that whole paracrasy they don't lead, You leave that whole scenes that you don't
- 1:28:02need, if you follow what I'm what I'm saying so in anyway, the
- 1:28:08only reason I'm telling about this is that in the Richard Walter template for final
- 1:28:13draft, they are now having we're tweaking it. And in the wide margin
- 1:28:16description, if a word like realizes feels, remembers, thinks, appears,
- 1:28:24It's going to get highlighted a little zig zaggy line underneath if some attention will
- 1:28:28be called to it, to ask the writer, do you really want to
- 1:28:31say this? Is this something that the audience can see or hear? Because
- 1:28:36if it's an internal, interior mental thing, it has no place in a
- 1:28:41movie. But in a novel, I mean everything in it that's interior mental
- 1:28:44and movie has to come out of sight and sound. You know, the
- 1:28:48Mariland's eyes widen in what can only be the realization that Harry left the gun
- 1:28:55in the nightstand at the motel. You understand what I'm saying. It's going
- 1:28:58to be told from a visual standpoint. Answering the question, never mind the
- 1:29:02reader of the spink on the page, I want to know how the viewer
- 1:29:06in the movie theater watching it on the screen is going to know this information.
- 1:29:13And but in a novel you can just spill it out. And you
- 1:29:15can also write in the past tense or in the future tense. I wrote
- 1:29:19a novel, and that's said in the past, in the present of the
- 1:29:23future, and in the past. I tell it in the past and in
- 1:29:27the future I tell it in the future tense and in the present. I
- 1:29:30tell it in the in the present tense. He goes to the door,
- 1:29:33she opens it, He stands there. You know what I'm saying. So
- 1:29:38you don't have to worry about that. In a novel, you can you
- 1:29:41can do anything you want. Also, novels are longer, and it's easier
- 1:29:45to write longer then shorter. Not everybody gets that. There's a it's like
- 1:29:51it's easier to ride a bike fast and slow. You know what I'm saying.
- 1:29:57It's very true. You're absolutely right. We'll be right back after a
- 1:30:01word from our sponsor, and now back to the show. There's a letter
- 1:30:12from Hemingway. There's a very famous letter from Ernest Hemingway. He was in
- 1:30:15Cuba, I think he was working on The Old Man in the Sea,
- 1:30:21and he wrote a letter to his legendary editor, Maxwell Perkins. It was
- 1:30:28nine pages long, on and on and on and on and on about this
- 1:30:30and that and the other thing in aspects of the script of the manuscript,
- 1:30:32the type script for Old Man of the Sea, and this and that and
- 1:30:36the other thing. Finally, halfway down the middle of page nine, he
- 1:30:40says, well that's about it for now, Max. He says, please
- 1:30:44forgive me for writing such a long letter. I didn't have the time to
- 1:30:45write a short one. It takes longer to be quick and to the point
- 1:30:53and to call and select and do the things that artists have to do.
- 1:30:57So I think there's really something to be said for writers taking another tech,
- 1:31:04trying their script out as a novel, trying to get some tractions there,
- 1:31:09and if they do, suddenly it becomes viable as a movie project because it's
- 1:31:15no longer original. They've taken the quote curse quotes quote off of it by
- 1:31:21removing its originality and making an adaptation. So you know, there's some thoughts.
- 1:31:28There's some thoughts. You know. It's funny you mentioned that, Richard,
- 1:31:30because I'm actually a Final Draft not only affiliate, but I also am
- 1:31:35part of their their program where we like beta testing. I'm sorry whose program
- 1:31:40I missed? Oh, I'm sorry. I'm actually a part of Final drafts.
- 1:31:44Final Draft. Yeah, not only their affiliate program, but also they're
- 1:31:47beta testing, so like I get the new stuff before anybody else, you
- 1:31:50know, and get feedback. I haven't got a chance to actually check that
- 1:31:55template out but one, but I'm gonna keep my eye out because yeah,
- 1:31:58you know, I've been working with all one hundreds Arry who's one of the
- 1:32:00guys, a great guy, And I don't know if it's available or not
- 1:32:04yet. I think it's it's an you know, like you can sort of
- 1:32:09upload it depending what you know, what version you have and so on.
- 1:32:14Yeah, and uh, because right now, the latest thing that I've been
- 1:32:16beta testing is, uh, they have a new app out for the iPhone
- 1:32:23and that's what I've been beta testing a lot of just you know, giving
- 1:32:26them feedback and you know, hey, I like to see this feature,
- 1:32:29I wouldn't like to see this feature, you know, stuff like that.
- 1:32:30And I'm gonna keep an eye for for that template. I'm gonna actually because
- 1:32:34if it's it's available, I will definitely upload that. Well, thank you,
- 1:32:39I'm honored that you would. It's it's not radically different, but I
- 1:32:44am a big believer in the less is more, no continued, absolutely nothing.
- 1:32:50I've argued for years and years and years that if you can embrace this
- 1:32:59very very fundamental precept, which is what we were just saying earlier, then
- 1:33:03it's just site and sound and if you can add to that just one thing,
- 1:33:09and that is that every site and every sound must move the story forward
- 1:33:12some palpable way, some identifiable way. That doesn't matter what you're right,
- 1:33:17That doesn't matter what this so called genre is. It doesn't matter what happens.
- 1:33:21People will be drawn to it. You can even have nothing happen.
- 1:33:26And if somehow nothing happening can move the story forward, people will pay very,
- 1:33:32very rapt attention to nothing happening. And I'll give you an example of
- 1:33:36that, and a student of mine, God blessing me, blurbs my book
- 1:33:42very prominently. Alexander Payne in one of his best movies, I think about
- 1:33:50Schmidt, starring Jack Nicholson. I think it's Nicholson's best work. The movie
- 1:33:56opens with Jack just sitting alone. He's an insurance salesman. It's just clearly
- 1:33:59his last moment, literally his last minute on the job before he retires,
- 1:34:03and he just sits at the desk and absolutely nothing happens. But the camera
- 1:34:08kind of wanders around the room and you can see the only motion in the
- 1:34:10room is the sweep second hand of the wall clock, and it's ticking off
- 1:34:17the seconds. It's like forty seconds before five o'clock, and when it hits
- 1:34:20five, he gets up and he leaves. You know, that's the scene.
- 1:34:25But it tells you so much about that man and how punctual he is,
- 1:34:29and how afraid he is, and how this he is, and how
- 1:34:31that he is and so on, that you get it. You get really
- 1:34:34really drawn into that. So that's why my template, if you can get
- 1:34:39into it, if you can find it, you'll see that it really preaches
- 1:34:42minimalism, that you should keep everything off the page that you can keep off
- 1:34:46the page. You know, if you look at my books, you see
- 1:34:48the front page of a screenplay. I have a model of a front play
- 1:34:53of screenland, and I have a model of what not to do, and
- 1:34:57the model of the what you should do is just the ti A little of
- 1:35:00the script, the name of the writer. It shouldn't stay written by or
- 1:35:05even merely by, much less an original screenplay written by In case you think
- 1:35:11you're worried, somebody might think it's the chicken salmath sandwich or a bowling ball
- 1:35:15or something. Well, what if it just says by, written written by?
- 1:35:20What does that tell you? It tells you nothing if it simply says
- 1:35:26bottom dollar, you know, Sam Smith, people are gonna say you this
- 1:35:31script is called bottom Dollar and this guy Sam Smith probably wrote it, you
- 1:35:34know. And then on the only other thing you should have on that page
- 1:35:39is a phone number and an email address, you know, contact info.
- 1:35:44Now, if you have an agent, she's going to be sending out on
- 1:35:47her own. You know, she's not going to want potential buyers to contact
- 1:35:53the clients. She's going to want them to contact her. And by the
- 1:35:55way, the author should not want to be contacted directly. Be suspicious of
- 1:35:58anybody contact if you have a representative, if they are legitimate, if the
- 1:36:03producer legitimate, should be willing to and eager to call the producer, you
- 1:36:09know what I'm saying. So it's different if the thing is sold. But
- 1:36:13if it's a speculative script, if you just have the name of the script,
- 1:36:18the title of the script, in the name of the writer. And
- 1:36:20as I say, a phone number, one phone number, only one phone
- 1:36:25number. I have a bunch of phone numbers. I have my UCLA number,
- 1:36:28I have my home number, I have a cell number, I have
- 1:36:31his best number in my home office. They don't want all of that.
- 1:36:34They don't want my mother's number, they don't want my lawyers. I'm you
- 1:36:39know, just one number and one email. Is this so that you can
- 1:36:43be found if people people are interested. And as I say, if it
- 1:36:46even simply says by somebody who puts that on the script on the front page,
- 1:36:51doesn't get it. That right on the cover of the script is information
- 1:36:57that serves no purpose at all. What is the likelihood that somebody's going to
- 1:37:02miss that? But get character and story and dialogue and all of the sophisticated
- 1:37:08and heady and provocative precepts and principles that apply to the autonocraft in the business
- 1:37:15of screenwriting. You know, it's you know, not encouraging. So again
- 1:37:24that's what you'll see is very very minimal. Anything that can be lost,
- 1:37:29you should lose. And if you're in doubt about something, you sort of
- 1:37:30feel, well, maybe you need this. Maybe then you lose it.
- 1:37:34If you're in doubt, throw it out. Just have stuff that absolutely must
- 1:37:39be there. And it's so easy to figure out what must be there.
- 1:37:45You just ask yourself, what if it weren't there, does it still make
- 1:37:49sense? If it makes sense without it being then it wasn't needed. If
- 1:37:56the whole thing falls apart without you know, when it's not there, then
- 1:38:00it was needed. You follow what I'm saying. It's like there's a there's
- 1:38:03a joke. A guy goes into a library and he steps up to the
- 1:38:11desk and he says, to the library, and I'll have a hot dog
- 1:38:14and a coke and French fries please, And the librarian system sir, this
- 1:38:23is a library. He says, Oh, I'm sorry, I have a
- 1:38:27himp. I'll have a hot dog. Whisper. Is it? You get
- 1:38:31the joke. It's like, you're not supposed to talk loud in the library.
- 1:38:34He thinks that she's reprimanding him. It's talking too loudly, rather than
- 1:38:39for ordering food at a library desk. You follow the joke. Yeah,
- 1:38:43absolutely, So the reason I tell you that joke is you can imagine if
- 1:38:45that were a screenplay, a portion of a screenplay. You absolutely have to
- 1:38:50have the parenthetical direction and whispers sir, this is a library, carry whispering
- 1:38:59and the line again you with me if if if you don't have it,
- 1:39:04the the person who's going isn't going to whisper, and the whole joke is
- 1:39:08lost. So you needed the parents edicle. But that's the exception. One
- 1:39:13of my great battles is against parents edicles. It's a sure sign of amateurism
- 1:39:21where there are a lot of parents edicles. Riley Rolly angrily smiling. You
- 1:39:30know, sadly Shakespeare got through thirty six or thirty seven plays not a single
- 1:39:36parents edicle, you know, Hamlet, Melane College never. So you want
- 1:39:41the least, and you can figure out what the least is by asking yourself,
- 1:39:46what if this weren't here, does it still make sense? Then we
- 1:39:51didn't need it. We'll be right back after a word from our sponsor,
- 1:40:00and now back to the show. So that answers the question that every artist
- 1:40:05is confronted with, which is what needs to be in the work and what
- 1:40:09doesn't and why doesn't everybody do that? And the answer is it takes time
- 1:40:15to do that, and that's what people won't give it. They just won't
- 1:40:18give it the time that it takes. You know. One of my one
- 1:40:24of my mentors, Bill boyle Uh, he actually wrote a book called The
- 1:40:27Visual Mindscape of the screen Play, and he goes into that in depth,
- 1:40:30that you have to take out anything that is not you know, it's always
- 1:40:35about what's on the screen, all the good and it always and he's that
- 1:40:41way, uh because he says he always would see people hanging in screenplays and
- 1:40:45they would say things that like, you know what someone is thinking in a
- 1:40:48screenplay? And he's like, how can we show that stuff exactly exactly?
- 1:40:55You know, Evelyn remembers that the she left the car our idling. Well,
- 1:41:00what does that look like on the screen? Somebody remembering something? You
- 1:41:03know? And how you're gonna know? Uh, Let's say the actor looks
- 1:41:09up remembering and acting for dummies, if there is such a thing, and
- 1:41:14is able to put on the remembering face. If there is such a thing,
- 1:41:16then how do we know what they remembering? You know? Again,
- 1:41:20it's so simple. It's it's really very simple, very simple to know what
- 1:41:27to do to succeed. Why it isn't everybody to see because it's hard to
- 1:41:30do it. It's easy to know what you do. It's like I don't
- 1:41:33know exactly what to do to hit a home run. I'm sitting here about
- 1:41:39two months from Dodger Stadium, and I know exactly what you have to do.
- 1:41:44You have to get to bat around in the right place at the right
- 1:41:45time. The difference between me and you know, Babe Ruth is that he
- 1:41:50could do it. He didn't merely know how to do it, but actually
- 1:41:54could do it. I know how to do but I can't do it.
- 1:41:57I don't have an equipment to do it. So it's really you know that,
- 1:42:04that's really all there is too And again the reason people don't do it
- 1:42:10is they in too much of a hurry. Had a writer just tell me
- 1:42:15it's already, this is already a third draft. Well, come on,
- 1:42:17David Kepp, I bet you know the name Koepp, a former student of
- 1:42:24mine, a writer director. He wrote you know, Mission Impossible, Jurassic
- 1:42:31Park one and two. Right now he's writing the second chapter of the Ron
- 1:42:40Howard of the Da Vinci Code. I mean, he's a gigantic successful writer,
- 1:42:44also a very very sweet man. He says the secret of his success
- 1:42:46is seventeen drafts. He knows he can get through seventeen drafts. He says,
- 1:42:51that take seventeen drafts to hear somebody complaining to me about their third draft,
- 1:42:57you know, and they don't like hearing me telling them. You're just
- 1:43:00getting started. You know, you gotta If you could get one more draft
- 1:43:03out of this, then you'll only need about thirteen more after that, you
- 1:43:06know. And that stops a lot of people. They just don't have the
- 1:43:15what some people call z it's flesh, uh, you know, the ability
- 1:43:19to sit there. The flesh would tolerate just sitting there reworking it, reworking
- 1:43:27it, reworking it. You know, in my own experience, you know,
- 1:43:30Richard, I wrote a It was a comedy horror movie and it was
- 1:43:34about at a at a summer camp. And summer camp, uh, it's
- 1:43:40a made up summer camp I had, uh huh. And the the I'm
- 1:43:45about seven or eight drafts in now, and some people feel that these drafts.
- 1:43:51Some people have said, who write it? They said, listen,
- 1:43:54these drafts are better. Some are saying, you're starting to get maybe a
- 1:43:58little too far away from the original concept. And you know, and now,
- 1:44:01you know, I sort of judge for myself. I sort of have
- 1:44:04to say, you know, who's writing a situation? Well, you know,
- 1:44:08and I sort of go back and and there was at one point,
- 1:44:11I'm gonna be honest with you, I was so burned out from rewriting this
- 1:44:14thing. I was like, I was fearing opening up final draft and looking
- 1:44:17at this thing again. Well, that's every writer has that experience. It's
- 1:44:23actually a good sign, but do go on. And at that point I
- 1:44:28actually, uh, you know, I printed it out. And one of
- 1:44:30my favorite things to do is actually just printed out and I make marks with
- 1:44:33just a pen, you know, sort of I cut myself off from all
- 1:44:35technology, just me and a you know, a ninety or excellent, excellent
- 1:44:43thing to do. I also think, uh, it really makes a lot
- 1:44:46of sense to write something else, put it aside, work on something else,
- 1:44:50and then you'll be able to come back to it with fresh eyes.
- 1:44:56You know. Over the last number of years, I've become a a fanatic
- 1:45:00crossword puzzle guy. I do it the New York Times Sunday Crossword Puzzle every
- 1:45:03Sunday. And one thing that I learned doing crossword puzzles is you, you
- 1:45:09know, you go through, you get what you can get, and then
- 1:45:12the stuff you just can't get. And funnily, you're just reading all the
- 1:45:15clues and you fill them maybe a little less than half the thing, and
- 1:45:17you just still you can't get another freaking thing. You just can't, and
- 1:45:23you feel defeated and stupid, and so you put it aside, just go
- 1:45:27up and do something else, come back to it later. You sit down
- 1:45:29and suddenly wam wa wa wa. When this thing, gap thing, this
- 1:45:31thing, it all leaps, you know, into relief that you can write
- 1:45:36in and almost run your hand over and feel it like a freeze on a
- 1:45:40temple, you know, a carved marble freeze. And it teaches me that
- 1:45:47just like the body gets tired, the muscles get tired, the mind gets
- 1:45:51tired. And when you rest the muscles and they recover, so also can
- 1:45:56you rest the mind and it recovers. And you look away from something,
- 1:46:00you look at something too careful, you really can't see it. You kind
- 1:46:03of look away, and then you look back and there it suddenly. As
- 1:46:05I'm reminded of when I was an undergraduate student in Binghamton, New York,
- 1:46:10as a you know, history major in college. Binghamton is in Broome County,
- 1:46:16New York, and I remember going through some original letters that had to
- 1:46:21do with Broom County history, and they've been written in like the early eighteen
- 1:46:26hundreds, and there was a you know, they were concluded in some state
- 1:46:30archives, some kind of the archive or something like that. They were contained
- 1:46:33there, they were housed there, and they're written in this ancient kind of
- 1:46:39script, you know, handwriting and sometimes I just can't read what it says.
- 1:46:44I remember my teacher telling me, you're looking at it too hard,
- 1:46:47look away from it, and then kind of sneak up on it, and
- 1:46:50suddenhow suddenly in context it all leaps out. You know. So if you
- 1:46:56take time away from you, you really step in your script to let your
- 1:47:00eighth draft. And when I say you, I mean any writer, what
- 1:47:03about put it aside for a while and work on something else and then come
- 1:47:06back to it. And as far as you're getting too far away from your
- 1:47:10original concept, maybe there's something better than your original concept. Maybe you've taken
- 1:47:14it to a place that's even better for it to be. One more thing
- 1:47:18on this subject, and it goes back to David Tepp in the seventeen draft.
- 1:47:21He says, very often the latest drafts mimic the earliest draft. You
- 1:47:28sort of get back to the beginning of it, and you get back to
- 1:47:31that context, that original concept that you had, And that might seem like
- 1:47:38a ferocious waste of time, but it wasn't. You needed to go through
- 1:47:42all of that to see that this is the way it really ought to be.
- 1:47:46I was talking to writer only the other week a few weeks ago.
- 1:47:49Who was I ran and I haven't seen him in a long time, A
- 1:47:51guy I know pretty well, but I don't seen a long time any now.
- 1:47:54And he says, well, much better now. I said, what
- 1:47:56do you mean? He said, Well, I was stuck for ten months
- 1:47:58this year. I was struggling with this script and I just pumpfort and hesitated
- 1:48:04and stumbled and just couldn't make any pregress with it at all, and it
- 1:48:10haunted me and it tortured me. And then finally two weeks ago, I
- 1:48:15just settled in and said, screw this, I'm going to do this.
- 1:48:18And I remember right through it and I got it and you know, and
- 1:48:21nailed it and it's just great, you know. And that's why I'm upset.
- 1:48:28I said, I don't understand. Why, Why Why is that a
- 1:48:31setting? It sounds like like a nice thing. He said, Well,
- 1:48:34I struggled with this thing for the nine or ten months. Why don't I
- 1:48:39just do this ten months ago? You know? And I wouldn't have had
- 1:48:41all of the darkness and all of the pain that I had. And I
- 1:48:44said to him, you couldn't have done this ten months ago. You needed
- 1:48:47to struggle and suffer and have all of this pain and live all of this
- 1:48:51life of the last nine to ten months to become the person that you are
- 1:48:56that could have you know, who's also the person that could finish this script,
- 1:48:59you know, right, this script. So that's where it goes.
- 1:49:02You know, nothing new about writers beating up on themselves. So I mean
- 1:49:09what I ended up doing was I ended up Actually I did work on something
- 1:49:12else. I just at that point I said, you know what, I
- 1:49:15think I should just take a break from this, and I'm thinking about coming
- 1:49:19back to it very soon. And because it's been about probably a month or
- 1:49:23may month, I him and I think now it's probably better you can come
- 1:49:27around full circle now and and just again start draft nine and see where that
- 1:49:30takes me. Look, my first novel was I told you about it earlier.
- 1:49:39I had written it as a screenplay and couldn't get any action. I
- 1:49:42wrote as a novel, and it's what it is, a screenplay years later,
- 1:49:50and by the way, it taught me a lot of work. You
- 1:49:53know, it was an adolescent coming of age story. We'll be right back
- 1:49:59after word from our sponsor and now back to the show. And given that
- 1:50:11on my drafts of Merdan graffiti, which is, uh, you know,
- 1:50:14an adolescent loss of innocence, right of passage, coming of age story.
- 1:50:17I was able to get a lot of work. I was kind of the
- 1:50:18go to guy for adolescent kind of age stories, loss of innocence stories in
- 1:50:24Hollywood. That novel after I saw and it's a kind of a I grew
- 1:50:31up in New York City and I sang do op in the streets with friends
- 1:50:34of mine and so and so. It's about this do op group that never
- 1:50:38really succeeds, but they learned that if you're singing harmony, you'll live in
- 1:50:42harmony, you know. And after I saw it, I started thinking about
- 1:50:45it as a stage play. You know, it's a musical, but I
- 1:50:53needed a songwriter. And then after I saw Jersey Boys, I was seeing
- 1:50:57it several times on Broadway, I realized, no, it could be a
- 1:51:00jukebox musical, and so I rewrote it as I adapted it for the musical
- 1:51:06theater using existing tunes, you know, just like the Carol King Show and
- 1:51:11the Motown Musical you know, and Jersey Boys, you know, are just
- 1:51:17examples. There are a lot of them. Now am not using original music,
- 1:51:21but that's why they called jukebox musicals because they use existing tunes. I
- 1:51:27suddenly realized I could do it as a jukebox musical, so I rewrote it
- 1:51:30as a jukebox musical. Two years ago it was workshop at UCLA. There
- 1:51:38was a humble read through sing through directed by one of the professors in the
- 1:51:45musical theater program in our sister department Theater. It was the most satisfying,
- 1:51:51fulfilling creative experience I've ever had in my career, this humble little read through.
- 1:51:57Now there's a somebody eagerly show the play around trying to get a production
- 1:52:02for it. Probably nothing will come of it, but but my you know,
- 1:52:08the craziest things have happened. But the point is, and the reason
- 1:52:10I bother you with it telling you about it is, Look how long I
- 1:52:13have there even business with this thing. It goes back over forty years before,
- 1:52:18you know, between the time that I first started outlining what became the
- 1:52:23screenplay, which ultimately became the novel, and so on. My most recent
- 1:52:28novel, which which I bragged to you, made the Times List, I
- 1:52:31also wrote originally as a screenplay. And I'm talking about over thirty years ago,
- 1:52:42probably thirty one of thirty two years ago. I wrote it as a
- 1:52:45screenplay. It was optioned and dropped, an optioned and dropped. I made
- 1:52:48some money on it. It was optioned by you know, an Oscar winning
- 1:52:53multi Oscar winning independent company of air prestigious companies. I made some money on
- 1:52:59it, but I never got anywhere with it. It never got produced.
- 1:53:03So eventually a student of mine at UCLA I was talking about the project.
- 1:53:11He said he'd love to read it. So it convinced me to let him
- 1:53:13read it, and he came to me and he said, you should use
- 1:53:15this as an outline for a novel, a comic novel. So I did,
- 1:53:21and when that was done, I showed it around to the publishing business
- 1:53:28and I couldn't get any interest in it at all. All I had with
- 1:53:31it was frustration and heartache and as I say, disappointment then, I mean
- 1:53:38I'd made some money on it, you know, in the early days when
- 1:53:41it was a film script and I got those options, but generally it had
- 1:53:43been a pretty big disappointment. Then I met an editor, and I'm sorry,
- 1:53:46I met a very powerful agent. I have been so privileged in my
- 1:53:49life to do the things that I've done. One of them is for five
- 1:53:56summers. I would take the whole family to Maui for the writer's conference late
- 1:53:59in the summer. And if it had been in a Motel six, that'd
- 1:54:01be okay, it's Maui. But it wasn't in the motel six. It
- 1:54:04was in the ground while I lay a five diamond luxury spa hotel resort,
- 1:54:10you know, just an incredible place. And there I would meet all of
- 1:54:14these heavyweights from both literature and film. We mentioned Stephen King earlier. Stephen
- 1:54:20was there, you know. I mean, they had world class writers,
- 1:54:26both in the movie business and in the literature business. And I remember I
- 1:54:30met an agent there and she said to me, a very powerful New York
- 1:54:36agent, and she agreed to I pitched the project to her, and she
- 1:54:41agreed to read it on the mainland when she got back to the mainland.
- 1:54:44So I sent it to her in New York and she called me up and
- 1:54:46she said, and this is like twenty This is twenty years after I had
- 1:54:53first written, and about fifteen years ago. If you're with me, she
- 1:55:00said, I have to tell you. I read your tape script and I
- 1:55:04think it's great and I want to represent it and I'll represent it exactly as
- 1:55:09it is if you want me to, I'll send it out exactly as you've
- 1:55:12written it. However, I have an editor here in the office that I
- 1:55:15work with, and I think you should get notes from Miriam. And if
- 1:55:23you don't like the notes, you know, then the hell of it off,
- 1:55:28you know, drum away. I'll show the book as this. But
- 1:55:30I have to tell you, Richard. She said to me that when my
- 1:55:34office work with Miriam, I sew this stuff right away. Now I charge
- 1:55:38thousands and thousands and thousands of dollars for notes, and they're not charging me
- 1:55:42a nickel for this, you understand now. I wanted to say to them,
- 1:55:45please, I'm not interested in rewrite. I had nothing but grief from
- 1:55:48this project, and I'm depressed and lost at the moment, this moment in
- 1:55:56my life, and I hardly feel like going into some old thing that's been
- 1:56:00nothing but discipline all the way. And you've already said you show it as
- 1:56:03this, Just show it as it is. I didn't say this, mind
- 1:56:05you, David, I just was. This was my thinking, you understand.
- 1:56:12So I said to myself, don't tell her how much you hate the
- 1:56:15notes until you see the notes. In other words, wait for the notes
- 1:56:17and then tell them that, yeah, you know, you really appreciate Miriam
- 1:56:23doing what she did, but no, you want to stick with what you
- 1:56:26had in the hell with us, you don't have to do any more work,
- 1:56:27right And by the way, who the fuck is this Miriam? Some
- 1:56:33twenty three year old who just got out of you know, creative writing major
- 1:56:38from Suave Moore or Brin Moore or one of them. More's you know,
- 1:56:42don't they know who I am? And on and on, you know,
- 1:56:45that kind of insulated view of self the writer can get and become his own
- 1:56:49worst enemy. Of course I said none of that. Well that was my
- 1:56:53thinking. So finally the notes come from Miriam. By the way, it's
- 1:56:59Miriam go to she's now a partner in the agency. It's Thistle go to
- 1:57:03its now. And I read Miriam's notes, and you know what, David,
- 1:57:08the notes. My heart sinks like a stone when I read these notes,
- 1:57:11because they have such good notes, and I know I'm looking at my
- 1:57:15worst enemy. And when I brush my teeth, when I shave, if
- 1:57:18you follow me, if I don't get my button a chair, my hands
- 1:57:23on the keys and find the old files and get get back into it right.
- 1:57:28So I certainly didn't want to do that, but I did. And
- 1:57:30by the way, the moment I started, i'd written two three sentences.
- 1:57:34I suddenly was born again. The fog lifted, the depression was gone.
- 1:57:39I was sealed by the wonderful nurturing juices the photo through the system when you
- 1:57:46when you, you know, get involved in creative expression. And it took
- 1:57:51me a couple of months, you know, to get the script attended to
- 1:57:56in the way that had been recommended, and then I out of back to
- 1:58:00the agency and bingo, they sold it right away. As I've told you,
- 1:58:03it made the Times List best seller. You know, it's a Times
- 1:58:08best seller, and there was a lot of movie action around it, but
- 1:58:15nothing ever came of it as a movie. Now all that ever comes of
- 1:58:17it as it was a best selling novel. That's such a bad thing,
- 1:58:19isn't. But guess what, I'm going to London. I'm going to be
- 1:58:24at the London Screenwriters Festival in October. And a British producer called me.
- 1:58:32He said that he's he's actually American producer, but he's British based. He's
- 1:58:35London based, and he said he has. This was a few years ago,
- 1:58:43this was three or four years ago. He'd come upon the novel and
- 1:58:46he thought it'd make a great movie and he wanted to option the rights to
- 1:58:50it. Well, nothing ever came of that, more frustration and disappointment.
- 1:58:54Now suddenly he calls me, just coincidentally, I'm going to be in London
- 1:58:58in the fall, and he says, guess when he made a movie with
- 1:59:02a He produced a movie that was directed by a new director, a short
- 1:59:09film, and on the strength of that short film, that director has been
- 1:59:14signed by a very very prominent agency and they have asked him to bring projects
- 1:59:20to them that he would like to do. So he asked this producer,
- 1:59:24and producer called me and said, is your novel still available? And it
- 1:59:28is so right now as we're talking, it's being shown not by me,
- 1:59:32but by an artist who's been signed by a major agency who have asked him
- 1:59:40to show them stuff that he wants to do. Do you understand how much
- 1:59:43better that is for the material to be exposed to them that way than for
- 1:59:45me, the author to call their attention to it. You follow what I'm
- 1:59:48saying, Yeah, oh yeah, absolutely. And on top of that,
- 1:59:53it's conceivable that they will be showing it to producers and production companies. We'll
- 2:00:01be right back after a word from our sponsor, and now back to the
- 2:00:09show. I would rather be represented, if anything comes of it, by
- 2:00:15a lawyer rather than an agent. But if they want to go out with
- 2:00:18this thing, and they approach me and they want to want me to let
- 2:00:21them represent them on it, I'll do that in a heartbeat. It's better
- 2:00:26for me to have them motivated, you know, extra motivated. Follow my
- 2:00:30reasoning there, If they can represent me as well as the director, they're
- 2:00:34going to be that much more motivated to sell the thing. So the likely
- 2:00:40there's nothing that will come of it. But here we are. We're talking
- 2:00:42in twenty fifteen, midway through the year just about, and I'm still in
- 2:00:46business on this thing that I started writing in like nineteen eighty. So you
- 2:00:53see what a mistake it is for writers to do what they often do,
- 2:00:56which is a writer script that doesn't sell. That's the end of it.
- 2:00:58They think it was a failure. Mistake, mistake, mistake, mistake,
- 2:01:01mistake. Yeah, and you know that that's, you know, very true.
- 2:01:05I have a friend of mine also who he's you know, in his
- 2:01:12forties or fifties, but he wrote a screenplay, you know, in his
- 2:01:14twenties and then suddenly, you know, that's becoming a light again and you
- 2:01:16know, uh, you know again, like you were saying, you know,
- 2:01:20it's it's amazing how these things get new life. You know, years
- 2:01:25David webbed people's you know, he won the Oscar for Unforgiven. It was
- 2:01:29also the best best movie that year. Clint hung onto that script for twenty
- 2:01:33years, and Clint made another movie that was very successful, didn't win the
- 2:01:38Oscar, but it was very successful about the the Secret Service guy takes the
- 2:01:42bullet for the President in the line of Fire. And that's another script that
- 2:01:45was hanging around for fifteen sixty years. The writer and that strip was packing
- 2:01:49his trunk of his car and getting ready to you know, go back and
- 2:01:54defeat with this tale between his legs back to New Hampshire when the film rings
- 2:01:59a small puss Oaklin's company and you know, they want to know that,
- 2:02:02they want him to know that they wanted to come in for some meetings about
- 2:02:05brushing up the script. There they now have a schedule they're going to go
- 2:02:10ahead and you know, produce it. For eighty eight million dollars something like
- 2:02:14that. You just never know. People don't understand that when a script doesn't
- 2:02:17sell, it's not the end. If it's the beginning, that script might
- 2:02:20sell eventually. But even if it doesn't, it's a sample of your craft.
- 2:02:27It could lead to representation. It could lead to a development deal on
- 2:02:32another notion that you have in mind. It could lead to a rewrite assignment.
- 2:02:39I've seen all of these things happen. They've happened to me, they've
- 2:02:44happened to writers that I know, And that is why it is a terrible
- 2:02:50self defeating mistake to imagine that a script that doesn't sell that's the end of
- 2:02:58it. It's a failure. The very script I ever wrote, I wrote
- 2:03:00in a class at USC. It was in the legendary The instructor was the
- 2:03:06legendary Irwin ar Blacker, who was George's teacher and John Melius's teacher, and
- 2:03:12on and on. That script never sold, but I got top flight representation
- 2:03:21as a result of it. I got a onto staff at Universal. And
- 2:03:28here I was a young kid. I wasn't you know. I was in
- 2:03:30my twenties and I had an office at Universal with my name on the door
- 2:03:33a parking place next to Paul Newman's parking place. I noticed a ridiculously generous
- 2:03:42salary, at least it seemed that way at the time. Actually adjust different
- 2:03:45inflation was pretty generous. And it all came to that from a script that
- 2:03:49hasn't sold, you know, to this day. So to consider that script
- 2:03:54to be a failure is lacy and very buious business. The business is hard
- 2:04:01enough on writers. Writers don't need to be hard on themselves, is the
- 2:04:04point that I'm making. And yeah, and that that's an excellent point,
- 2:04:09and that that sort of leads me into you know, one of my last
- 2:04:12questions. I know we've been talking about two hours. I know I've been
- 2:04:15taken up a lot of you delight. It is that we don't want to
- 2:04:15make sure we do cover I do talk a little bit about the uh,
- 2:04:19the summer session, that class that I offer, So go ahead and ask
- 2:04:23me a question and then I'll talk a little bit about that. That's actually
- 2:04:25the question I was going to ask you was, you know, I know
- 2:04:28you have a you know, upcoming summer session and this is the only time
- 2:04:30of the year where non UCLA students can sign up and I wondered if you
- 2:04:35could just you know, talk a little bit about the class and you know,
- 2:04:38for anyone listening, who's you know, interested in signing up. Well,
- 2:04:42the first thing I'll say is just that the housekeeping. If you want
- 2:04:44to find out official information about it, h you can do that by simply
- 2:04:49going to my website Richard Walter dot com. There is no asset the end
- 2:04:53of my name Richard Walter dot com. And I think the very first thing
- 2:04:57on the side is a link that will take it to the use cla site
- 2:05:00that describes enrollment procedures and tells me a little bit of the class. It
- 2:05:03also tells me something wrong about the class, which is that there are certain
- 2:05:09prerequisites for the summer session. All prerequisites are waived and the class is open
- 2:05:15to the classes especially designed for the summer session. I've taught it for thirty
- 2:05:19over thirty years now. It meets starting on June twenty second, Monday,
- 2:05:25June twenty second, Monday afternoon and for the next five that is a total
- 2:05:30of six Monday afternoon sessions. It's not electric course, it's hands on writing
- 2:05:34course where you get The main activity of the class is the in class examination
- 2:05:43of in progress scripts being written by students in the class, so you get
- 2:05:45not only the support of the teacher and the teaching assistants, but also your
- 2:05:54fellow writers around the table. And one thing that has touched me very deeply
- 2:05:58all these years is how generous everyone is. All the writers are with everybody
- 2:06:00else, how much support that the writers give each other. I feel like
- 2:06:05I've learned much more than I've ever taught, you know, being at UCLA,
- 2:06:10and my students are my teachers. So you get all of that alive.
- 2:06:14It's not online, it's alive in a classroom. And it is a
- 2:06:18rare course in that it's very difficult to get into it. Even if you're
- 2:06:25a registered matriculated UCLA student. It's very hard to get into an advanced film
- 2:06:30class with senior faculty like me. So this is an opportunity to do that,
- 2:06:35not only for UCLA students, but even for students who are not enrolled
- 2:06:39at UCLA. And by the way, everybody gets eight credits for it.
- 2:06:43Those credits are useful at anybody, you know, for anybody at any University
- 2:06:48California campus. But also they're transferable depending upon the attitude of the institution.
- 2:06:54They're transferable to other institutions, though I would say most people take the class
- 2:07:00really aren't interested in the credits. They're interested in getting the attention and consideration
- 2:07:03that you know, our regular students get when they write their their screenplays.
- 2:07:09So it's a really upbeat six weeks together. And uh, it's limited enrollment.
- 2:07:18It's almost sold out, but there is still some room for some people.
- 2:07:23I want you to know that I don't get paid per student. I
- 2:07:26don't get paid on a per student fee. Rather I get a flat fee.
- 2:07:30And the only is I tell you that is that I'm not trying to
- 2:07:31self act grand buys here. I'm not against self promotion and I'm not against
- 2:07:35making money, but I'm not I don't get any extra money if you know,
- 2:07:41extra students enroll or anything like I just want anything like that. I
- 2:07:45just want your readers and listeners, the people that you reach, I want
- 2:07:51them to know that this is a rare opportunity. It's not that widely known,
- 2:07:56it is available to them. And we crank up two weeks from Monday.
- 2:08:03It's not too late to register people commute. By the way, it's
- 2:08:07obviously most convenient for people in the southern California region, but there are people
- 2:08:11who commute from all across the country. I had somebody last summer commuting from
- 2:08:16Illinois. The previous summer, I had a couple I were, a doctor
- 2:08:20and his wife coming commuting every Monday. They would fly in to La from
- 2:08:28El Paso and take the class and then fly back, you know, either
- 2:08:31late that night or the following morning. That's how motivated people ought to take
- 2:08:37the class. And I would commend it to you know, all of the
- 2:08:41people that you reach. And you know, I've actually I've known people who've
- 2:08:46actually taken the course, and you know, I'll probably I'll mention their names
- 2:08:50when we get affchered ox. You probably know, you probably remember a few
- 2:08:52of them. And they spoke very very highly of the course. Oh thank
- 2:08:56you, and uh, you know, and again I mean to work with
- 2:09:01someone who's actually been in the fields, but in the trenches, it's just,
- 2:09:03you know, it's unbelievable. And you know, I again, I
- 2:09:07will link to your your upcoming class in the show notes. You know,
- 2:09:11and everyone. I also recommended to check out Richard's book Essentials of Screenwriting.
- 2:09:16I have a copy behind me. I swear rich Or you can't see it,
- 2:09:18but it's on the massive bookshelf behind me. But Richard, you know
- 2:09:24I've taken up so much of your time today. I want to say thank
- 2:09:26you very much. It's like flick. I enjoy channing. I really truly
- 2:09:30did. David. Oh, and I would love to have you back on
- 2:09:31if you ever wanted to. Absolutely, you know how to reach carefully.
- 2:09:35She kind of handles my calendar and I'd love to come back. Be a
- 2:09:41pleasure to do that. Excellent, because there's a ton of questions that we
- 2:09:43never got a chance that I never got a chance to ask you because I
- 2:09:46mean there's so many and there's so many things we could talk about. Well,
- 2:09:48one thing I've learned about the questions and answers, and that is really
- 2:09:52good. Answers just lead lead to more questions, you know, so,
- 2:09:56and there's nothing wrong with that. That is the nature of learning. Absolutely,
- 2:10:00uh you know everyone you can check Richard at Richard Walter dot com and
- 2:10:05yes, rich exactly right. And Richard, I want to say one more
- 2:10:07time, thank you again for coming on, and I well, thanks for
- 2:10:09having me David. Thank you. Oh, it's my pleasure. I'm so
- 2:10:13afford to chatting with you. Again we will do it for sure. Amazing
- 2:10:18Again everyone, thanks again for listening, and Richard, I wish you would
- 2:10:20have a great day and uh you know, best of luck with all your
- 2:10:22projects. Back to you and thank you so kindly. Thank you care now,
- 2:10:26bye bye bye bye. I want to thank Dave so much for doing
- 2:10:31such a great job on this episode. If you want to get links to
- 2:10:33anything we spoke about in this episode, head over to the show notes at
- 2:10:37any film muscle dot com forward slash seven sixteen and if you haven't already,
- 2:10:41please head over to Filmmaking podcast dot com. Subscribe and leave a good review
- 2:10:48for the show. It really helps us out a lot, guys. Thank
- 2:10:50you again so much for listening. Guys, as always, keep that hustle
- 2:10:52going, keep that dream alive, stay safe out there, and I'll talk
- 2:10:56too soon. Thanks for listening to the Indie Film Hustle pun Cast at Indie
- 2:11:01film huscle dot com. That's I N D I E F I L M
- 2:11:05h U S T L E dot com.