Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Attitude Towards Debt from Howard Marks and Morgan Housel
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever wondered if there's, like, a secret
- 0:02handshake among the world's most successful investors?
- 0:05You know, what if two of the absolute sharpest minds in
- 0:07finance, one this seasoned analyst, the other a masterful
- 0:10storyteller, actually agreed on the most fundamental truths
- 0:15about money, risk and even how to live a really good life?
- 0:20Welcome to the deep dive. Today we're diving into a
- 0:22fascinating sort of intellectual crossroads between two giants of
- 0:25modern finance. Howard Marks, the legendary Co
- 0:28chairman of Oak Tree Capital Management, and Morgan Hassel,
- 0:31the really insightful behavioral philosopher and partner at the
- 0:33Collaborative Fund. Now, their approaches are pretty
- 0:36distinct, but their core principles, well, they
- 0:38remarkably converge in ways that can really transform how you
- 0:40think about your finances and maybe even your life.
- 0:43So our mission for you today is to cut through the the
- 0:45complexity of their thinking, pull out the most important
- 0:47Nuggets of knowledge, and then kind of synthesize it all into a
- 0:49unified framework. We want to help you get better
- 0:51informed, make smarter decisions, and honestly get a
- 0:54shortcut to understanding why these two thinkers are just so
- 0:56resonant. For this deep dive, we've drawn
- 0:58from, well, a pretty rich stack of sources.
- 1:00Marks famous client memos, including the impact of debt,
- 1:03which was actually inspired by households blog post, How I
- 1:05think about debt, their recent joint podcast chat and of
- 1:08course, the big bucks Marks the most important thing and
- 1:10households the psychology of OK, let's let's unpack this,
- 1:15starting with Howard Marks. I mean, his whole career was
- 1:18built in the high stakes world of distressed debt, right?
- 1:20So maybe it's not surprising he puts this almost radical
- 1:22emphasis on price. He argues it's not just the
- 1:24quality of the asset, but the price you actually pay for it.
- 1:26That's what really dictates investment success.
- 1:29Yeah, and the story behind that is really telling.
- 1:31Marks often talks about the Nifty 50 era back in the 70s.
- 1:34You know, these 50 supposedly can't miss companies.
- 1:38Investors bought them at almost any price, thinking how could I
- 1:41lose? But even though the company
- 1:43stayed strong, people lost fortunes.
- 1:45Why? They just paid way too much.
- 1:47It really hammered home that lesson.
- 1:48Great company, bad price equals bad investment.
- 1:51So it really comes down to that margin of safety, doesn't it?
- 1:54Even a fantastic business can be a terrible investment if you get
- 1:57the price wrong. But I mean, how do you know what
- 1:59the right price is, especially when markets are all over the
- 2:01place? Well, that's the $1,000,000
- 2:03question, isn't it? And Marx would say it boils down
- 2:05to a really deep understanding of value, not just spotting
- 2:08quality. And this insight led him to
- 2:11challenge that old chestnut. You know, high risk equals high
- 2:14return. He fundamentally believes the
- 2:16best opportunities are actually where you can get high potential
- 2:19returns for, believe it or not, a low level of risk.
- 2:22Basically when everyone else is just drowning in pessimism.
- 2:25Oak Tree's whole philosophy is kind of built on this.
- 2:27If we avoid the losers, the winners will take care of
- 2:29themselves. It's all about downside
- 2:31protection first. OK.
- 2:33So if price is the bedrock for Marx, what's the actual engine,
- 2:38the thing that lets investors capitalize on those mistakes in
- 2:41pricing? He talks a lot about second
- 2:42level thinking. Can you break that down for us?
- 2:44Sure. I mean think about it, if
- 2:45everyone is the market, how can anyone consistently beat it?
- 2:48You have to think differently, sure, but also better than the
- 2:50average person, than the consensus first level thinking
- 2:53is, well, it's superficial. It's like, hey, that's a great
- 2:55company, let's buy. Or uh oh, the economy looks bad,
- 2:57let's sell. It's the easy, obvious take
- 2:59away. Right.
- 3:00But the real magic, the power of second level thinking, it seems,
- 3:03is that it's often contrarian. It goes deeper.
- 3:05It asks, OK, it's a great company, but everyone knows it's
- 3:07a great company, so it's probably too expensive.
- 3:09Maybe we should sell or flipping that.
- 3:12Yeah, the outlook stinks, but everyone else is freaking out
- 3:14and selling. Is there maybe a bargain hidden
- 3:17in here? Exactly.
- 3:18It means you have to consider the whole range of
- 3:20possibilities, really challenge the story everyone's telling,
- 3:23and understand the psychology that's already reflected in the
- 3:25current price. Being contrarian is necessary,
- 3:29he'd say, but it's not enough on its own.
- 3:31You have to be different and right.
- 3:33And that is incredibly hard because the best investments,
- 3:36the truly great ones, often start when you feel really
- 3:39uncomfortable or when everyone else is running for the exits.
- 3:42Marks also talks a lot about markets not being these, you
- 3:45know, smooth, predictable waves. He's seen decades of it.
- 3:48And his view is it's more about these wild swings, these
- 3:51excesses and corrections that are just driven by raw human
- 3:55emotion. That's absolutely right.
- 3:57And for investors, probably the most important cycle he talks
- 4:00about is the cycle in attitudes toward risk.
- 4:03He paints it as this pendulum swinging back and forth between,
- 4:06you know, just total greed and paralyzing fear.
- 4:09In the up cycle, everyone's optimistic risk feels like your
- 4:12best friend and people pile on the leverage.
- 4:14But paradoxically, that's the most dangerous time.
- 4:17Risk is actually highest when everybody thinks there is no
- 4:20risk. And then boom, the down cycle
- 4:21hits, fear takes the wheel, and all that leverage that felt so
- 4:24good on the way up becomes this, well, this weapon, forcing
- 4:28people to sell, making losses even worse.
- 4:30And that's when the real bargains pop up, but only for
- 4:32those who are disciplined enough to prepare beforehand.
- 4:34Yeah, and it's really important to get this.
- 4:36Marx doesn't believe you can forecast when the cycle turns.
- 4:39Nobody can, really. His whole mantra is you can't
- 4:42predict, but you can prepare. So the goal isn't timing the
- 4:45market peak or bottom. It's about understanding where
- 4:48we are in the cycle roughly so you can adjust your portfolio's
- 4:50risk. Tilt more towards offense when
- 4:52fear is high and more towards defense when greed is rampant.
- 4:55OK. So given Mark's focus on cycles
- 4:57and risk, how does he view something as basic as debt?
- 5:01Does it just pour gasoline on those cycles?
- 5:03For Marx, debt is basically leverage, and leverage is just a
- 5:06powerful amplifier. It makes the good times better,
- 5:09but it makes the bad times much, much worse.
- 5:11He uses that analogy of a Las Vegas pit boss saying, hey, the
- 5:14more you bet, the more you win when you win.
- 5:17But the catch, the part people forget, is you lose way more
- 5:20when you lose, especially if it's borrowed money.
- 5:21That seems like such a critical point, especially when things
- 5:24get choppy. He famously said volatility plus
- 5:27leverage dynamite. It suggests like the amount of
- 5:30leverage you should use is inversely related to how risky
- 5:33the underlying asset is, right? Absolutely.
- 5:35He's argued that a huge part of the 2008 global financial crisis
- 5:38was exactly that misunderstanding.
- 5:40You had institutions using massive leverage on assets that
- 5:42were actually incredibly risky. The goal Marks always stresses
- 5:46should be optimization, finding the right balance of risk and
- 5:48potential return, not just chasing the maximum possible
- 5:51gain. It makes me think of that
- 5:52metaphor, the six foot tall person who drowned crossing a
- 5:55stream that was on average only 5 feet deep.
- 5:58You know you have to survive every point, especially the
- 6:00lowest points, taking on too much debt.
- 6:02It's like loading your backpack with rocks.
- 6:04It might feel OK walking on flat ground, but it drastically
- 6:08increases the chance that one stumble, one dip, becomes fatal.
- 6:11That's a perfect way to put it. Debt doesn't just blow up
- 6:13individual results, it amplifies the market cycles themselves.
- 6:17It turns regular corrections into potential crises.
- 6:20You can really see in Mark's writing how his thinking evolved
- 6:23over time. He started by analyzing the
- 6:25mechanics, the numbers, but eventually realized that
- 6:27understanding human emotion, human psychology, was the
- 6:30ultimate second level insight. OK, let's shift gears now to
- 6:33Morgan Housel. He offers a different
- 6:35perspective, but wow, it's equally profound.
- 6:38His core idea kind of flips finance on its head.
- 6:41His financial success isn't really a hard science full of
- 6:44complex math, but it's more of a soft skill.
- 6:46Yeah, it's fascinating how he makes the case that how you
- 6:49behave with money is way more important than how much you know
- 6:51about finance. He paints this picture where,
- 6:54you know, an ordinary person who just stays calm and thinks long
- 6:57term can actually build more wealth than some financial
- 7:00genius who's constantly getting tripped up by greed and fear.
- 7:04Behavior beats brains, basically.
- 7:06He has this idea no one's crazy, which basically means people's
- 7:10financial choices, even if they look totally irrational to us,
- 7:13make sense to them based on their own unique life
- 7:16experiences. Like he talks about someone,
- 7:17maybe from a tough background, buying lottery tickets.
- 7:20OK, it's not a smart investment, but maybe for them it's the only
- 7:22affordable way to buy a little bit of hope.
- 7:24You know, it's often about what happens at the dinner table, not
- 7:27just on a spreadsheet. Exactly.
- 7:29And if you zoom out from that, Haussel points to social
- 7:32comparison as this huge roadblock to building.
- 7:35Well, he's got the in the car paradox.
- 7:37You see a fancy car, you admire the car, right?
- 7:39You almost never think, wow, look at that driver, he must be
- 7:41amazing. So spending money just to show
- 7:43off or keep up with the Joneses is, in his view, just the
- 7:46fastest way to end up with less money.
- 7:48Getting a handle on that impulse is just critical.
- 7:50So if behavior is households foundation, then compounding is
- 7:54definitely his engine for building wealth.
- 7:56He has that great phrase for it returns to the power of time.
- 7:59Yeah, the key insight there is that everyone gets kind of
- 8:01obsessed with the base number, like what rate of return am I
- 8:04getting? But Household argues the real
- 8:06magic, the exponential power, comes from the exponent, which
- 8:09is just the sheer length of time you can stay invested and let
- 8:11that compounding work its magic without interruption.
- 8:14That is so interesting, it immediately makes you think of
- 8:17Warren Buffett, right? Household points out that
- 8:19something like 99% of Buffett's huge net worth came after his
- 8:2250th birthday day. It just drives home that his
- 8:25secret wasn't just being brilliant, it was time,
- 8:28incredible amounts of time in the market.
- 8:30Right. And it brings up a really
- 8:31important question for all of us.
- 8:33Are you optimizing your financial life for getting rich
- 8:36or for staying rich? Because getting rich might
- 8:38involve taking bigger risks, but staying rich?
- 8:41That requires what household calls a survival mindset, which
- 8:44is really a mix of being frugal and frankly, a little bit
- 8:47paranoid. You have to be, in his words,
- 8:49financially unbreakable, never forced to sell your investments
- 8:53during a downturn because just one forced sale at the wrong
- 8:56time can permanently damage your long term results and break that
- 8:59compounding chain. And for household, money isn't
- 9:02just about piling up more and more stuff.
- 9:03It's real purpose. The ultimate goal is control
- 9:06over your own time. He calls that the highest
- 9:08dividend that exists in finance. Yeah, absolutely.
- 9:11Just the ability to wake up in the morning and say I can do
- 9:12whatever I want today. That, in Hazel's view, is the
- 9:16most valuable thing money can possibly buy, He argues it's a
- 9:19much better predictor of happiness than how much you earn
- 9:21or how big your house is. So what does that mean for how
- 9:25we should even define wealth? Is it just having a lot of
- 9:29money? Hazel draws this really clear
- 9:31line between being rich and being wealthy.
- 9:34Rich is often visible, right? It's the high income being spent
- 9:37on flashy things, status symbols.
- 9:39But wealthy, he says, is often hidden.
- 9:42It's the income you didn't spend.
- 9:43It's the fancy car you didn't buy, the bigger house you didn't
- 9:46need. That unseen wealth is what gives
- 9:48you options, flexibility and genuine freedom.
- 9:51And the key lever for building that hidden wealth, that
- 9:53freedom, isn't necessarily earning more, though that helps.
- 9:56It's your savings rate. It's basically the gap between
- 9:58your ego and your income. Want less?
- 10:00Save more. Simple, but not easy.
- 10:03OK, so how does House's philosophy rooted in freedom and
- 10:05time shape how he looks at debt? He has this definition that's
- 10:09incredibly simple but powerful. Debt is a piece of your future
- 10:12that somebody else owns a claim to.
- 10:14Think about that. And every dollar you save,
- 10:16conversely, is a claim you own on your own future time, your
- 10:19own future options. It just flips the whole script.
- 10:21And he uses that really powerful metaphor, the one that actually
- 10:23got Howard Marks thinking more about it.
- 10:25Debt narrows the range of outcomes you can endure in life.
- 10:28If you have no debt, you can weather storms, job loss,
- 10:31illness, market crashes. But add debt and that band of
- 10:35survivability just shrinks and shrinks.
- 10:37Yeah, and he points to these ancient Japanese businesses, the
- 10:39Chinese, some of which have lasted centuries.
- 10:41How often by holding huge amounts of cash and carrying
- 10:44almost no debt, they prioritize survival above all else.
- 10:47But beyond the numbers, Hazel also stresses the the
- 10:51psychological weight of debt. He quotes Kent Nurburn saying
- 10:54something like debt defines your future, and when your future is
- 10:57defined, hope begins to die. That's heavy.
- 11:00And he lives this, too, right? He talks about paying off his
- 11:02mortgage early, even though, you know, a spreadsheet might say
- 11:05that's a bad financial move because you could maybe earn
- 11:07more investing that money. But for him, that Peace of Mind,
- 11:10that independence, that was worth way more than any
- 11:13potential extra return. Money is a tool for a better
- 11:16life, not just a higher number on a spreadsheet.
- 11:18That's a perfect encapsulation of his thinking, and he even
- 11:21talks about other kinds of debt, like expectations debt.
- 11:24That's when maybe your company's valuation or your own success
- 11:28gets so high it's unsustainable, sustainable.
- 11:30That creates this hidden liability, he says, that
- 11:33eventually gets repaid, usually in disappointment or shame.
- 11:36Howsell really brings this kind of modern stoic vibe to finance,
- 11:40valuing resilience, calm and preparation over just chasing
- 11:43the next big thing. So OK, they have these different
- 11:46angles, the analyst versus the storyteller, but it feels like
- 11:49Marx and House will end up in a very similar place on some
- 11:51really big things. What are the strongest points
- 11:53where they really converge? I think the most powerful common
- 11:55thread is their shared belief in the absolute necessity of
- 11:58survival. For Marx, it's all about
- 12:01structuring investments so you can live through the bad days,
- 12:03the downturns. For Hausel, it's about becoming
- 12:06financially unbreakable personally, so that compounding
- 12:09never gets fatally interrupted. They both get that performing
- 12:12well, on average means nothing if you go bust somewhere along
- 12:15the journey. Survival first.
- 12:17And flowing right out of that is their unified view on debt,
- 12:20isn't it? They both see too much.
- 12:21Debt is like the number one threat to lasting success, Marx
- 12:24warns volatility plus leveraged dynamite, while Housel says debt
- 12:27narrows the range of endurable outcomes.
- 12:30They're really just describing the same danger from slightly
- 12:32different angles. They totally agree.
- 12:33Leverage, especially when it's excessive, is the enemy of
- 12:36endurance. And fundamentally, both of them
- 12:38put human psychology right at the very center of everything in
- 12:41finance. Marx uses his understanding of
- 12:44psychology to find opportunities to exploit the mispricings
- 12:48caused by widespread greed and fear.
- 12:50Hausel focuses more on mastering your own psychology, controlling
- 12:54your own impulses, your own fear, your own desire to keep up
- 12:57with others. They might approach it
- 12:58differently, but they absolutely agree that psychology is
- 13:01probably the most important field to understand and finance
- 13:04maybe more than economics even. That's fascinating.
- 13:07But while their core ideas sync up so well, their practical
- 13:09advice, the application, it does diverge sometimes, right?
- 13:12Which makes sense given their different goals and maybe who
- 13:14they're primarily talking to. Yeah, definitely.
- 13:16Marx's main goal is achieving superior returns adjusted for
- 13:20risk by beating the market. So his philosophy is really
- 13:23geared towards, you know, sophisticated investors, active
- 13:25managers. We're looking for that edge
- 13:27through deep analysis, through exploiting those inefficiencies.
- 13:30It's very much a philosophy of proactive positioning and taking
- 13:34action. Whereas Housel's goal seems much
- 13:36broader. It's about helping pretty much
- 13:38anyone achieve financial independence and just live a
- 13:41better or less stressful life. So his philosophy is really for
- 13:45everybody. It emphasizes things like a high
- 13:47savings rate, staying invested for the long haul, and simple
- 13:49low cost, diversified funds. His method is almost the
- 13:53opposite of Marx in a way. It's more about inaction, about
- 13:55endurance, about, as he puts it, consistently not screwing up.
- 13:59That's a great way to put it. You could almost say Marx looks
- 14:01at the market and sees all these emotional mistakes just waiting
- 14:04to be exploited by someone rational.
- 14:06Housel looks at the market and sees this incredibly powerful
- 14:08long term wealth building machine, but only for those who
- 14:11have the patience and discipline to just let it work.
- 14:14So yeah, for Marx you try to outsmart the market.
- 14:16For Housel, you mostly just try to let the market work for you.
- 14:19OK, so let's try and crystallize this a bit.
- 14:20Just a quick compare and contrast core philosophy.
- 14:24Marx is about exploiting inefficiencies via second level
- 14:27thinking. Housel It's that behavior,
- 14:30psychology and time trump smarts.
- 14:32Right primary view of debt. Marx sees it as a magnifier,
- 14:36something to be carefully optimized based on how volatile
- 14:39the assets are. Hence dynamite.
- 14:41Household sees it fundamentally as a constraint on your
- 14:43endurance, your freedom, narrowing your survivable
- 14:45outcomes. Approach to investing Marx is
- 14:48active bottom up, value guided by cycles, households, more
- 14:51passive long term saving, diversified funds.
- 14:54Let compounding do the heavy lifting.
- 14:56Definition of risk. Marx focuses on permanent
- 14:59capital loss, which is often highest when perceived lowest.
- 15:02Household defines risk more broadly as the risk of ruin
- 15:05anything stopping compounding, including your own bad behavior.
- 15:09Key to success for Marx, it's thinking differently and better
- 15:12than the crowd for household, it's behavioral discipline,
- 15:14saving a lot and having that unbreakable survival mindset
- 15:18and. Finally, their main audience,
- 15:19Marx, is really talking to sophisticated, active investors,
- 15:22The pros Housel's message resonates much more broadly,
- 15:25aiming for any individual who wants to build wealth and live a
- 15:27better life. So after digging into all this,
- 15:29what's the ultimate take away? What's the big lesson from
- 15:31putting marks in Housel side by side?
- 15:33Well, I think the main thing is that their philosophies aren't
- 15:35really contradictory at all. They're actually deeply
- 15:38complementary. They just operate on different,
- 15:40different levels of the whole investment hierarchy.
- 15:43You can think of Housel as providing the absolutely
- 15:45essential foundation that behavioral psychological bedrock
- 15:49you need for any kind of financial success.
- 15:51And then Marx offers the more advanced framework, the
- 15:54superstructure for those who have that foundation solid and
- 15:56want to try and pursue active out performance.
- 15:59OK, so it sounds like a kind of two tiered approach for you, the
- 16:02prudent investor. Listening to this Tier 1 is like
- 16:05the Housel Foundation. Master yourself first.
- 16:07That means really focusing on a high savings rate, living below
- 16:10your means, figuring out what enough actually means for you,
- 16:13fighting that urge for social comparison, avoiding consumer
- 16:16debt like the plague, and really prioritizing your Peace of Mind.
- 16:19Build that financially unbreakable space, maybe using
- 16:22simple low cost index funds. Just guarantee your survival and
- 16:25let compounding start working. Exactly.
- 16:27And then if you have the skill, the temperament, the desire, you
- 16:30can move to Tier 2, the mark superstructure, master the
- 16:33market, build on that solid household foundation, start
- 16:36applying that rigorous second level thinking, look for those
- 16:39genuinely undervalued assets, and maybe start strategically
- 16:42adjusting your portfolio based on where you think we are in the
- 16:44psychological market cycle. This tier offers the potential
- 16:47for better returns. But yeah, it takes immense
- 16:49discipline, hard work, and that truly contrarian mindset.
- 16:52So the big lesson really is that investment mastery, it starts
- 16:55inside. It starts with introspection
- 16:57before you even look at analyzing the market, Trying to
- 16:59jump straight to Marx's sophisticated techniques without
- 17:02nailing down households behavioral truths, It's like,
- 17:05yeah, try to build a skyscraper on sand.
- 17:07It just won't work long term. The truly prudent investor needs
- 17:10both the wisdom of the storyteller and the rigor of the
- 17:13analyst. Wow, we've really journeyed
- 17:15through the minds of two genuine financial Titans today, and it
- 17:19seems the big discovery is that while one focuses on mastering
- 17:22the market and the other on mastering the South, their
- 17:24combined wisdom gives us this incredibly robust path towards
- 17:27not just financial well-being, but maybe a genuinely well lived
- 17:30life too. It really does.
- 17:32It boils down to understanding not just what you should do, but
- 17:35maybe more importantly, how you need to be.
- 17:38So as you think about everything we've discussed today, maybe ask
- 17:40yourself this. What debt?
- 17:43And maybe it's not just financial debt.
- 17:44Maybe it's an unseen expectations debt from chasing
- 17:47things you don't truly value. What debt might you be carrying
- 17:50right now that's unknowingly narrowing your range of adorable
- 17:53outcomes or limiting your future freedom?
- 17:56And maybe flipping around, How could applying some second level
- 17:59thinking help you spot opportunities not just in the
- 18:01stock market, but maybe in your own life choices where just
- 18:04following the crowd might be leading you down the wrong path?
- 18:07Something to chew on.