Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Jealousy (2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07Berto, Have you ever had any experiences with jealousy? Have you ever been
- 0:12jealous of somebody or something? We did something, someone says something about this
- 0:17or something. Well, a patron wants us to talk about it, but
- 0:20I thought I might intro the podcast with some relevant stories from you, the
- 0:25co host. Jealousy and envy. There's a difference, and I heard it
- 0:30defined. Envy is like I want what someone else has. That's where I'm
- 0:35like, Oh, that guy's got a cool Porsche. I envy that Porsche,
- 0:38right Versus jealousy is like I'm afraid to lose something I love because someone
- 0:44else might take it or something that's right all right? Well, I never
- 0:46knew that, like, not never. I've heard that before, but for
- 0:49most of my life the distinction was not clear. Yeah, and I think
- 0:54for a lot of people that use the words sort of interchangeably totally, I'm
- 0:57so jealous of that car over there. Hey, I saw this movie last
- 1:02night, and I'm so jealous. Like, no one says, oh my
- 1:04god, I'm so envious. If that's right, that's right. It doesn't
- 1:07even sound right. Yeah. I had a period of my life when I
- 1:11was in my early twenties where I was very jealous. Yeah, And what
- 1:18did that feel like to you? At the time, It felt like,
- 1:21well, it's funny enough that you we were just talking about the definition,
- 1:25because it actually felt like a threat of losing I had this girlfriend. I
- 1:29was like threatened that I would lose her. Yeah, But it was so
- 1:34ironic about it is. I had had girlfriends before, many of which I
- 1:38should have been concerned about losing, but I never really was this one.
- 1:42I really had no reason to be honestly concerned, but for some reason,
- 1:47and I have my theories, I felt super like concerned, like, and
- 1:51so I would always be like checking on like, well what did you do
- 1:53Friday night? Well, who are you with? And then I would like
- 1:57wouldn't believe her. And then she lived in a dorm that had I think
- 2:04it was each floor had a mix or if it was maybe a floor of
- 2:07women and a floor of men, and I don't quite remember, but either
- 2:10way, there were men close by, and so like I would always be
- 2:14like on high alert. And there was this oh my gosh, uber ridiculous
- 2:17thing where her neighbor from across the dorm, like across the door, like
- 2:23in front of her door, you know, across. They had put up
- 2:25a little rip out from a playgirl magazine or something like that with a dude,
- 2:30a naked dude, and they put a little paper flap over his his
- 2:35little member so that people walking by could lift the flap and you know,
- 2:38get a knifel. I was like, have you lifted the flap? Did
- 2:43you lift the flap? Did you order the code flap? It was ridiculous.
- 2:49I even I remember, I feel so bad about this. I prank
- 2:53called a guy that she was friends with that they really were just friends,
- 2:59like it's but I was so like, oh my god. So I prank
- 3:01called him and and and I think I said this on the podcast before.
- 3:06I pretended that I was running a psychology survey from the University of Washington,
- 3:09and I asked him all these personal questions about his sex life. And then
- 3:15after he'd already divulged quite a bit of information, I started laughing. And
- 3:21it was just a psychopathic thing to do. I mean, it was horrible.
- 3:23Did you feel bad about it afterwards? Not then? Not then,
- 3:30like years later you feel it was not years I might have felt bad about
- 3:34it, like even later that year, but at the time next I did
- 3:38not connect the dots. I don't know why. It's like I didn't even
- 3:42it didn't even occur to me. That was a complete, like anti social,
- 3:46like crazy thing to do. Yeah, did you feel out of control
- 3:51and emotional at the time? Out of control? No, at least I
- 3:55didn't think of myself that way. Emotional yet definitely, Yeah, what kind
- 4:01of emotions? Like I went, oh my god, it's so ridiculous.
- 4:04I went to a play Midsummer Night's Dream. I think it was or something
- 4:12else, but it was something along the lines maybe it was. I saw
- 4:15the prequel. It was early summer midnight, yeah, before sunrise, Summer
- 4:19Night's Dream, and uh and I met my girlfriend there and then I'm like,
- 4:26oh, hey, how did you get here? It's like, oh,
- 4:28I got a ride with with Joy, Bobby and Paul whoever, like
- 4:32three guys. And I'm like, what you were in a car with three
- 4:38dude? Like I'm telling you. It was like it was so childish,
- 4:41so ridiculous, And I had never been like that before. Why do you
- 4:45think you were with this person? I think it. Actually my theories are
- 4:51twofold. One of them is it actually reminded me. There are some aspects
- 4:56of her that reminded me of my mom, not explicitly, but implicitly,
- 5:00and since my mom left me, I feel like that triggered me. Yeah,
- 5:03and I had had although it was two girlfriends before that, I had
- 5:09had one girlfriend break my heart, so I was maybe still kind of reeling
- 5:15from that. I don't know, but I think the biggest thing is I
- 5:18didn't realize it, but I think I felt triggered, like it's my mom
- 5:23and she's going to leave me. Well, today, I want to dive
- 5:27into more of that. Regarding jealousy, a patron wrote in and described a
- 5:31process not too dissimilar to your process. Umbeto, and I want to talk
- 5:39about the research regarding jealousy and my own psychological take on it and how I've
- 5:45treated people in my practice. What do you say, Let's do it.
- 5:47This is the Psychology and SEATA podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkkonda.
- 5:51I am chair of the Couple in Family Therapy program at Antioch University, Seattle,
- 5:57and I'm also a licensed marriage and family therapist. My name is Sumberto
- 6:00Castne. I travel every six months to Russia, where I coach in water
- 6:03sports. This is a email from a patron that's the funniest one you said
- 6:11all year, it's a long year or so far. This is email from
- 6:15a patron, Hi Kirk, I struggle with jealousy. I have episodes that
- 6:18last thirty minutes, and I've had an episode that lasted almost a year.
- 6:23While I am in the midst of an episode of jealousy, I feel like
- 6:27I am utterly out of my mind and out of control. This is a
- 6:30female patron by the Wakay. No other emotion makes me feel so awful.
- 6:35It's like this crazy, amplified mix between all of the negative emotions balled up
- 6:41into one giant, twisting, nasty ball of slithering, biting snakes. Wow.
- 6:46I can become delusional and completely paranoid. I become obsessive, and I
- 6:50do things I normally would never do. For example, I checked the monthly
- 6:55phone bill his monthly phone bill to see if my partner was texting or calling
- 7:00a female friend of his. In my normal state, I would never consider
- 7:04doing anything like that. But in a jealous state, I cannot control my
- 7:08need to control things, or find things out, or control the situation.
- 7:13The worst part is the controlling behavior. Normally I'm not a controlling person,
- 7:17but when I am jealous. I can't help it. Oh Man. I
- 7:21also start pushing away my significant others because I'm constantly getting in a bad mood
- 7:26and interior gating them. And I hate these things about myself. It's even
- 7:30hard to write about it because I hate admitting that I do these things.
- 7:34It's also not just sexual jealousy. I remember when I was younger, I
- 7:38couldn't stand it if my best friends had other friends. I've even dated a
- 7:42guy who had a child and I started to get jealous of his relationship with
- 7:46his child. That's very shameful for me and hard for me to admit.
- 7:51And finally, I want you to talk about how people manage and treat jealousy.
- 7:58I would really love in depth episode on jealousy. Why does it happen?
- 8:03What's the science behind it? Why is it so extreme and drives people
- 8:07to do horrible things? Can it be hereditary? My father was apparently unbeariably
- 8:11jealous, which was part of why my mom left him. Do you treat
- 8:13clients who have come in with severe jealousy? Maybe Umbeto has had any experience
- 8:20with it and he could share it. It would be interesting to hear that
- 8:24I've tried talking with my therapist about this, but she said this mindset was
- 8:31but she sorry. I've tried talking with my therapist about it, but she
- 8:35has this mindset that once we desensitize my childhood trauma, all my problems,
- 8:41including my jealousy, will just go away. But I don't think that's the
- 8:43case, Umbeto, What do you think? This one seems to extend into
- 8:48a lot of different areas. It's not like I felt like mine was very
- 8:52directed, you know, it was like this person specifically and the relationships around
- 8:56her, in my relationship with her, Hmmm, I don't. I don't
- 9:01recall feeling that way throughout my life about other people, including my male friends
- 9:07or other girlfriends or or things like that. But I can certainly relate.
- 9:13I mean, I can relate to the feelings. And she had a really
- 9:16expressive way to describe what she was, you know, what she feels and
- 9:20what she goes through. Uh, And it sounds torturous, you know,
- 9:24like she's aware that it's kind of not healthy maybe or whatever, and it
- 9:30just the way she describes it sounds it sounds really painful for her. Yeah,
- 9:33you know, you think your therapist is on the right track. Well,
- 9:39having been I can only speak from my experience, and there is definitely
- 9:45aspects, many aspects that talking about my childhood and my relationships with my parents
- 9:50and things helped me start to, you know, see some things in a
- 9:56new light. But that was by no means the bulk of my therapy.
- 10:01In fact, I would say I spend maybe only ten percent of my therapy
- 10:05recounting my childhood stuff, and a lot of it was more about kind of
- 10:11dealing with my present moment and how I and and for me, and this
- 10:16might be just be unique to my situation. A lot of my therapy has
- 10:18centered around trying to bring me into present, like being present and being aware
- 10:24of my body and being aware of my relationship with the people I am with
- 10:28and how I'm interacting, rather than you're saying present, present, present,
- 10:33present, present, because there's prescients, oh yeah, not precient, not
- 10:39being precient, not present in Christmas, but being present. But that's one
- 10:43of those Z's accent things that I was trying to point out, present present,
- 10:48present, don't forget it to s it's a Z President present. I
- 10:52need to be present present. Isn't that weird? It is weird, like
- 10:56because because so that's someone that's should be presenting. Okay, so not present.
- 11:03So for the listeners, like a couple of weeks ago, I told
- 11:07Umberto that some of his accent would come out only with his s's and z
- 11:13and I would notice it, and that was one of those examples. So
- 11:16I'm so so, you know, yeah, because because and I wouldn't have
- 11:20pointed it out if I didn't, if I actually wasn't confused with what you're
- 11:26saying, because it sounded like you're saying prescient, like we're prescent, like
- 11:30press present is I don't even know what that is, but presents be one
- 11:35of those because it is a more subtle sound difference that that one slipped through
- 11:39the cracks, right right, Yeah, yeah, So, so your therapy
- 11:46is more around being in the present, and and in fact it so much
- 11:52so that there were times, especially early on, but I'll still have this
- 11:56tendency every now and then where I'm a storyteller or so I'm like, well,
- 12:01let me tell you my story, and then I would start and I
- 12:03would actually kind of get excited about being able to tell all the details about
- 12:07something I remember. And it's not like my therapists wouldn't want to listen or
- 12:09hear that. It's just we started realizing that if I just did that,
- 12:16I was like, I actually took myself out of myself. It was like
- 12:18a third person recounting of my life, and it wasn't really feeling and it
- 12:24wasn't really kind of dealing with like, well, how does that make you
- 12:26feel? And so a lot of my work again has been around rather than
- 12:31like, well, let's recap everything up until now, it's been more about
- 12:35what's going on, what's going on with you right now? How are you
- 12:37feeling? What are you struggling with these days? And then in that we
- 12:41do end up uncovering because I'll naturally say things like, you know, as
- 12:46I'm thinking about it, when my dad did this one thing, this is
- 12:50kind of like this, and I kind of remember that, and so we'll
- 12:54naturally discover pieces like that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Therapy can involve
- 12:58lots of different modes and things, and you're talking about one and it has
- 13:03helped you, which is great. So my take on what you're doing,
- 13:07Patron with your therapist is I actually agree with your therapist. You're saying you're
- 13:13skeptical of whether or not that will actually help your overall jealousy. But I'm
- 13:18saying that I actually think it will help in the end, just by the
- 13:22little I understand. As you heal from your childhood traumas, you will likely
- 13:28feel more securely attached just in general, and you will exhibit more secure attachment
- 13:33in your present relationships and will be much less likely to be triggered to be
- 13:39jealous. Although from your description, I can't tell if your therapist is focusing
- 13:43enough on the relational corrective experiences. I don't clearly you're working on desensitizing childhood
- 13:50trauma, which is a particular brand of trauma work which is wonderful and almost
- 13:58always works, and I've used that, but I don't know if that would
- 14:01necessarily. For instance, with Umbeto, with his childhood difficulties, he was
- 14:07traumatized in some ways, but the issue that seems salient to his jealousy didn't
- 14:13have to do with a trauma meaning like being afraid, being terrorized, or
- 14:18being messed with, so to speak. It was a general neglect and rejection
- 14:24that your mom put you through, which we could say is a broad definition
- 14:28of trauma, but it's more of the effort of and the therapy. Well,
- 14:35so what do you think am I on? No, I think you're
- 14:39right. And in fact, as you were describing to her why you do
- 14:43agree with her therapist, it occurred to me that maybe I was just thinking
- 14:46about that the way to get at that, And then you can decouple those
- 14:50two things, because detraumatizing yourself from your childhood trauma, you can, as
- 14:56you were saying, you could do that in many different ways, and I
- 14:58was saying that in my case, rather than only focusing on the stories of
- 15:03my childhood, we've been focusing a lot on my present and my relationships and
- 15:07then bringing in how that relates to my past as necessary. But in fact,
- 15:13one of the ways that over the last decade or actually or more,
- 15:18I started realizing that, oh, yeah, there's so many things I hang
- 15:22on to about jealousy, for example, that are really residuals of this instability,
- 15:31you know, feeling unstable, feeling like at any time my loved connection
- 15:35might disappear to someone I love, someone who who is my life might go
- 15:39away, and then that that's traumatic. And so did that awareness alone help
- 15:46or did you have to do something else? So for the for the jealousy
- 15:50stuff, it's kind of hard to say because it was, as you know,
- 15:54this wasn't like a one day thing where I was like, oh,
- 15:56it was that, Okay, I'm done. It was that over the first
- 16:00few years of therapy, I started looking at some of my behaviors. And
- 16:07I will say that by the time I started therapy, jealousy was no longer
- 16:11my main like in the say, in the top five of my main issues,
- 16:15but it had been earlier in my twenties because I started like at twenty
- 16:19eight. So if I had been in therapy at twenty two, twenty one,
- 16:23twenty three, do you think that very relevant? Do you think that
- 16:27your stable relationships in your twenties helped to teach you that you could depend on
- 16:34people and therefore now I think that actually probably had a big impact because as
- 16:41an example, with my even just okay, I was gonna say that with
- 16:47that relationship particular, over time, I actually learned that I was kind of
- 16:51banging my head against the wall with no reason. You know, I'm like,
- 16:55this wall is hitting me, and then I just implicitly over time saw
- 16:59that the wall actually wasn't doing anything. So I think I stopped hitting my
- 17:03head against the same wall. But then the other thing that I think helped
- 17:04me is as I as I started developing an adult relationship with my mom.
- 17:11You know, one thing that happened is my mom didn't go away again.
- 17:14Was that in your twenties, starting when I was fifteen and on, and
- 17:18so ten years later she's still there. Yeah, and she's now helped me
- 17:22with college and things. So I think I started implicitly maybe healing a bit
- 17:27from that too. Yeah. Great. So, in summary, what I'll
- 17:32say about your therapy, patron, is it's probably a good idea what you're
- 17:36doing, but it's it's probably also a good idea to explore some of the
- 17:42things that Umberto is talking. Umberto is talking about in terms of general exploration,
- 17:52general healing wounds relationally through actual stable relationships that you can trust, whether
- 17:57that's your therapist or other peace. So, and I realized that that probably
- 18:03doesn't make you feel better because it could be years before you actually see any
- 18:07results of that, of either the PTSD recovery or otherwise. And so,
- 18:14but you know, every little bit helps. I want to get into more
- 18:19regarding the research and maybe some of the specifics in terms of how she experienced
- 18:26your jealousy or description is really quite rich. So I want to go over
- 18:29that, but let's take a break first. What do you say, burtle,
- 18:30Let's break. Okay, we're back. Before moving forward, I want
- 18:40to remind everyone to become a patron. Become a patron of the podcast.
- 18:44You'll get access to the feed that doesn't have any advertisements. And also we
- 18:49have a ton of these patron exclusive episodes that only patrons have access to.
- 18:56Also, if you can tell a friend or colleague about it, because you
- 18:59know, when you spread the word, that increases our popularity, which makes
- 19:03us frankly, make more revenue, which makes us better able to increase our
- 19:08time commitment to this podcast, which makes the podcast presumably more quality. Also
- 19:15rate us on iTunes if you could. If you do that, email us
- 19:19and I'll send you some swag. Also, twenty dollars patrons get mugs.
- 19:25If you live in North America, we have these awesome mugs, coffee mugs,
- 19:30and so if you're a twenty dollars a month there, then you'll get
- 19:32a mug. Also, let's do a sticker raffle. Let's do that after
- 19:37the next break. Okay. Also join the Facebook fan group run by famous
- 19:42patron Linden. Go to Facebook, and it's a there's two. There's a
- 19:45Facebook page for the podcast, and there's also a fan group that is just
- 19:51for the fans that that I don't run. A fan runs. So you
- 19:56know what in Spanish, patron is patron yea and it means boss. Yeah.
- 20:02Yeah, so it's like there are boss they tell us what to talk
- 20:06about. Is it kind of like father? Is it? Is it like?
- 20:11No? But obviously patter is a father rooted in Latin? Yeah,
- 20:15so said four it it's like yeah, okay, So let's let me review
- 20:21how you described your experience of jealousy patron. Uh. You described it as
- 20:27having bouts of jealousy, which is interesting, lasting from thirty minutes to almost
- 20:32a year, so it's episodic. You feel normal and okay most of the
- 20:37time except when your jealousy is triggered, so that's interesting. You also said
- 20:42that no other emotion feels as bad as jealousy does. You say it's a
- 20:47crazy mix of negative emotions. You also said that sometimes you become delusional and
- 20:53paranoid. You didn't go into detail, but I'm guessing what this means if
- 21:00I'm basing it on other people that describe it this way is that you probably
- 21:03become completely convinced that your partner is cheating on you, even though there's almost
- 21:10no evidence of that, you know, like you like with Beto's story,
- 21:17he has three boys dropping her, you know, his girlfriend off at this
- 21:22play, and in your mind, you're just like she had sex with one
- 21:26of them or all of them. It was an orgy. I can't believe
- 21:30it, right, And even though there's no evidence of that, it just
- 21:33becomes this dominant narrative in your head that seems extremely likely when you're having a
- 21:40bout of jealousy. And then once the bout of jealousy is over, you
- 21:42look back and you think, geez, I was I was thinking real delusional
- 21:48and paranoid. I mean, she did walk out naked out of the car,
- 21:51and nine months later she gave birth to triplets and they all look different,
- 21:53right, but other than that, three condoms fill out of that.
- 21:56Well, that doesn't make any sense given to your joke. But anyway,
- 22:00she I'm guessing also experience is given the paranoia delusion, she's completely convinced that
- 22:08someone is about to leave her, you know, like like with the with
- 22:14your example of uh, you're you walk by that one playgirl thing, and
- 22:22there's that penis, and it's this weird route from that to my girlfriend is
- 22:30going to look at that penis like it better and and then look at my
- 22:36penis and not like mine, and then therefore leave me for this guy or
- 22:41another penis or the magazine, right, Because I mean, let's kind of
- 22:45break that down. Like I'm putting thoughts in your head. I'm putting penises
- 22:48in your head, but like, let's really, let's really look at this.
- 22:52So so when you like, what is so, you know, don't
- 22:57think about it in your today, but you're thinking about it. And I'm
- 23:00trying to rewind. Obviously it's a very very long time ago, but I
- 23:06still I remember the hallway. I remember the poster, not exactly, but
- 23:11I remember what they had, the little flap and stuff. It's funny because
- 23:15I switch between two modes. I walk in, and the what i'll call
- 23:19normal beardo mode sees the thing and thinks it's hilarious, you know. I
- 23:25see the poster and they see the flap. I'm like, that's really funny.
- 23:29And then the other part of me engages and starts and it creeps up
- 23:34because at first I'm like it's kind of like, huh, hey, I
- 23:37wonder if my girlfriend saw this, But at first it's not even jealous yet,
- 23:42it's more like curiosity. And then that starts this thread of like,
- 23:48wait, does that mean she's looking at male porn? And what does that
- 23:52mean? And of course I'm not saying these things explicitly in my head,
- 23:56but they all quickly add up to like, wait a minute, I'm mus
- 24:00not be good enough, and and she must be look at this because she
- 24:03wants to leave me and she wants to be with other men. Do you
- 24:06think do you think that's what it was? Does that feel? I mean
- 24:08I must that must be the math that was done in my head, because
- 24:12because then from there I jumped to confronting her and being like, did you
- 24:18lift the flap? Right? It's just such an interesting sequence, right,
- 24:22So, and lifting the flap obviously meant that she had an interest sexually,
- 24:26because you know, I couldn't. I couldn't think of it like, oh,
- 24:30she might find it funny, just like I do know if she lifted
- 24:33that flap, she's sexually interested, not just in this model here, on
- 24:37this, but clearly on everyone else but me. Right, And this is
- 24:41the relationship, right, and then that means she's gonna leave me? Yeah,
- 24:44I mean right? Which, And again I'll clarify that none of those
- 24:48words were literally in my head. The only thing that was literally in my
- 24:52head is I need to ask her if she lifted the flap, right?
- 24:55And that's the compulsion, And that's the compulsion I run into with my clients.
- 24:59There's this, there's a weird sequence of events that happens internally regarding jealousy.
- 25:03And it has to do all with what you articulated, Am I good
- 25:08enough? Is someone going to leave me? But then what comes out of
- 25:12the person's mouth is ninety nine percent of the time it's questions about details,
- 25:18which makes no logical sense to me. Can you make logical sense as to
- 25:22what part of the mind transforms worry of losing someone, worry about not being
- 25:29good enough to interrogating someone about details. Yeah, that's weird, isn't it?
- 25:34Because like the classic that I see in my office with infidelity is questions,
- 25:41very specific questions about exactly what happened during the infidelity. You know,
- 25:47as people recover from infidelity, there will inevitably not everyone, but frequently men
- 25:52and women will say I want to hear every detail. Did you have an
- 25:56orgasm? How many times? What position? How long did you kiss them?
- 26:00How long you know? Where were you are? You know? Are
- 26:03there things bigger or smaller than mine? Did you like it better? You
- 26:07know? It's very specific, and to me it I'm always watching this and
- 26:12just as a side note, I will always slow people down. And what
- 26:17I say is what I say to the asker. To the hurt person,
- 26:21I say, you really want to think about whether or not you want the
- 26:23answers to these questions, because once you hear the answer, you'll never forget
- 26:27it. It'll burn into your brain. If she says, yeah, his
- 26:33penis was bigger than yours, and I actually had more orgasms in one session
- 26:37than I've ever ever felt so good? Is that? What is like?
- 26:41Do you really want that rattling around in your head? Is that? Is
- 26:45that? Is that a box? Pandora's box that you want to open?
- 26:48And the other thing I'll say to the hurt person is there's almost nothing good
- 26:55that comes from learning that information. You know, if you want to know,
- 27:00for instance, how many times or for how for what span of time,
- 27:03you know, I think that's understandable. It's like, what are we
- 27:07dealing with here? But when you start diving into very specific details that are
- 27:11gonna probably traumatize you and burn into your brain, then I say the cheat
- 27:17to the cheater, I say, look, because you're recovering from infidelity,
- 27:22you have to come clean on everything. You can't hide anything. So if
- 27:26if your partner asks you a question, your advice to actually answer it as
- 27:30honestly as possible, because to be shady or to withhold is just to compound
- 27:36the problem. But then I turn back to the hurt person and I say,
- 27:38but be very careful about what you are asking, my friend. But
- 27:45I think that the hurt person, and this extends I think beyond infidelities and
- 27:51think I think that in general, when someone confronts someone else with a whole
- 27:55bunch of specific questions, I think secretly or not even secretly, but in
- 27:59there what they want to hear is the perfect sequence of answers that will put
- 28:04their worst fears to rest. So things like, you know, did you
- 28:08have sex? No? Were you tempted? No? Do you think he's
- 28:12better looking than me? No? In fact, I think he's ugly,
- 28:14And I think you're the best looking person in the world. Do you you
- 28:17know, and like that's ideally I think your brain automatically wants to hear this
- 28:21like sequence that will finally be like okay, right, there's never any problem
- 28:26here, right, which leads me to another thing about being reassured and having
- 28:32a system of reassurance and relationships that I'll get to you later. But anyway,
- 28:36so getting back to your description, so again, you you had bouts,
- 28:40you had you had you know, crazy emotion, your delusional and paranoid,
- 28:44which I commend you for being able to admit that that you get delusional
- 28:48paranoid. A lot of people in your position would be undifferentiated and defensive and
- 28:52would say other kinds of phrases that would indicate immaturity, and you're I just
- 28:59want to commend patron you for exhibiting complete control over your situation here. It
- 29:06really does seem like when you're not jealous, you're mature, differentiated for the
- 29:11most part person, and so I committee for that. You also describe it
- 29:15as you paradoxically push your loved ones away, which is frequently the case when
- 29:21it comes to jealousy. Frequently the case when it comes to jealousy when you
- 29:26don't deal with it. Well, everyone gets jealous, but it's all a
- 29:30matter of how you deal with it. And I'll get more in to that
- 29:33in a second. You also said that you become controlling. You checked your
- 29:37partner's phone records. You don't go into too much detail, but you probably
- 29:41exhibited other classic controlling behaviors. You didn't say this, but maybe things like
- 29:48telling your partner that they can't do things, yelling at your partner in an
- 29:52attempt to get them to alter their behavior so that they stop doing things to
- 29:56make you jealous, accusing your partner, trying to get them to obey your
- 30:00weird set of rules, et cetera. That's all a typical to controlling behavior
- 30:07in the extreme. It's like you can't leave the house, you can't have
- 30:11friends, you can't you can't have a job, you can't talk to people
- 30:15of you know that I'm jealous of blah blah blah. You can't even talk
- 30:18to your family, you can't. You know it, You know, we
- 30:22all know those kinds of extreme situations. You also talk about being extremely shameful,
- 30:29which I just want to put an asterisk on that and say, don't
- 30:33be shameful. It's it's nothing to be ashamed of. It's something that is
- 30:37out of your control. If it was under your control, and you're like,
- 30:40today, I'm gonna I'm gonna be a total dick to my partner,
- 30:44and I'm gonna drum up situations to be jealous of, and I'm I'm going
- 30:48to control him because that's just me. I'm a dick. I like to
- 30:51control him. That's not what's happening. You're being triggered, and you're completely
- 30:56out of control of these feelings and impulses, and you're trying your best to
- 31:03put an end to it. You're writing in to a podcast to talk about
- 31:07it. These are not shameful behaviors. Shameful is doing it and being completely
- 31:12cool with it. Not to blast you, Berto, but if we went
- 31:17back in time to that, you know, the day after you called this
- 31:21guy who just happens to be friends with your girlfriend, and I was to
- 31:26ask you, You're like, oh, yeah, so I totally blame you.
- 31:29And I was like, how do you feel about that? You're yeah,
- 31:30I'm cool with it. Like that's shameful, yeah, Like I think
- 31:33it was hilarious, right, right, that's shameful you you, I mean,
- 31:37think about and we have talked about this before? Did you talk to
- 31:42him again later? I think so? I mean we were acquaintances, I
- 31:51knew him, I'd see him a couple of times. We weren't like friends.
- 31:53But did you ever talk about that event? And I wish I could
- 31:56have? I mean I wish I could have is like apologize, right,
- 32:00which you know, not to blast you, but you know, maybe put
- 32:07that on the agenda because imagine that happening to you. You probably never forget
- 32:13that. And depending on how flexible he is, he could have just been
- 32:16like, you know, what a what a jealous dick that guy is and
- 32:20moved on with his life, or he could have been like shaking with adrenaline
- 32:25and fear about like, wait, so this guy like knows my Like if
- 32:30he's capable of that, what was he watching me? Is he stalking me?
- 32:36Uh? Yeah? I I you know, I'm going to talk to
- 32:38this girl at work. Is her boyfriend gonna start you know it? Who
- 32:44knows? We don't know, but I would imagine the possibility anyway. And
- 32:49so so you patron, anyway, you're better than Burdo, yes, and
- 32:53that you have absolute shame about what you're doing. You shouldn't be a shamed
- 33:00You should be contemplative, and you should be dedicated to change for the betterment
- 33:06of you and everyone around you. But shame is not going to help.
- 33:12Shame implies purposefulness, lack of reflection. Da Dad, I wish I could
- 33:17find him. I don't know his last thing, but maybe I could.
- 33:22Yeah, well, there's this new thing called the Internet. There is yeah,
- 33:25just Google like guy who almost fucked up my You also said that you
- 33:36were jealous of your partner's cheating, but you're also jealous of your friends having
- 33:39other friends, and you are also jealous of your partner's relationships with their children.
- 33:45Okay, so now let's get to your questions. You wanted to know,
- 33:49why does it happen? Is it hereditary? How do I treat jealousy?
- 33:52And how can people manage their jealousy? Well, first off, we
- 33:58have to define jealous and Berto already did that in terms of delineating it between
- 34:04envy and jealousy. So but I will define jealousy in the way that you
- 34:10are patron which is that terrible feeling and desperation you feel when a loved one
- 34:15seems to be pulling away from you or cheating on you. Or something along
- 34:20those lines. That's my definition. It's a terrible feeling. Some people say
- 34:24jealousy isn't an emotion. Into that, I say, that's ridiculous. It's
- 34:30like, have you ever been jealous? Because it's a feeling. I mean,
- 34:32you could break it down into its components, but I think it's worthy
- 34:37of its own category, you know what I mean. That only works if,
- 34:42like, if you could prove to me the neuronal patterns that make distinct
- 34:46emotions, and you could show me that jealousy is the addition of these three
- 34:51very specific ones. But even then, that's like saying that purple doesn't exist,
- 34:53you know. It's like it's like, you know, it's a mixture
- 34:57of other colors, but it's still purple. So the first thing I'll say,
- 35:00as I was saying earlier, is that jealousy is normal. Everyone has
- 35:05this feeling to some degree. Every human being. I'm guessing everyone has even
- 35:08had extreme jealousy at some point in their life, regardless of how well they
- 35:13are raised and regardless of how healthy they are. So to speak, it's
- 35:15natural to get hurt when your partner shows interest in somebody else, particularly when
- 35:20you're younger, and particularly when you've been hurt or you know, recently hurt
- 35:24or something. And people who have not been provided a secure attachment as children,
- 35:30they are much more likely to feel jealous, and they're much more likely
- 35:35to see reasons to get jealous. So it's normal, and it's particularly normal
- 35:39for people who were raised badly essentially, and you don't you don't have to
- 35:45be abused. Abuse can affect future jealousy. But you could just be raised
- 35:51slightly cold. You could be raised in a way that just gives you the
- 35:55sense that you're not good enough, you know, just a little bit of
- 35:59criticism, a little bit of rejection, a little bit of distance. And
- 36:02these things are not things that people typically emerge from childhood saying that they were
- 36:07abused or mistreated. So there's that. All right, let's get to the
- 36:15literature meeting the research. But before that's take a break. What do you
- 36:17say, Burt? Break? All right, we're back, so let's talk
- 36:27about the research now. I want to provide one quote from one of my
- 36:34favorite figures in the history of psychotherapy, Harry Stack Sullivan, an American psychiatrist.
- 36:39Nineteen fifty three, he wrote that jealousy is a great, complex field
- 36:45of interpersonal relations. Harry Stack Sullivan was to some extent you could say,
- 36:51the grandfather of relational therapies including family therapy and relational psychoanalysis and whatnot. And
- 36:59he was. He's a great quotable figure. That makes me so jealous.
- 37:05Yeah. So, and he has got a great name, Harry Stacks Sullivan.
- 37:10Okay, so this is a study twenty fifteen Rodriguez. Jealousy is an
- 37:16emotion that serves to motivate behaviors to protect an individual's relationship from alternative mates.
- 37:23So again, this is how they're defining it based on other literature. Jealousy
- 37:28is an emotion that serves to motivate behaviors to protect an individual's relationship from alternative
- 37:35mates. Pretty good definition, right. Jealousy is interpreted as a sign of
- 37:40caring and concern for one's partner, and research has been shown that it can
- 37:45be positively associated with romantic love. So Rodriguez twenty fifteen is trying to normalize
- 37:53jealousy and also see it as not just a bad thing. It's actually in
- 38:00one way. If you look at it one way, it's an indication that
- 38:01you're actually in love with someone, or that you're you've created a good relationship,
- 38:08there's something to lose, you know, Like if you fall in love
- 38:13with someone and there's an indication that they might be moving away from you and
- 38:17you and towards someone else and you don't feel jealous, then there's something wrong
- 38:23with you or the relationship or or something. So, like many things in
- 38:28life, it's one of those like good things in moderation. Yeah, right,
- 38:32Jealousy can be conceptualized as an emotional response that has positive elements which can
- 38:37motivate behaviors to preserve a relationship. So jealousy isn't all bad. And research
- 38:45demonstrates that jealousy is the most prevalent cause of domestic violence. So so it's
- 38:54it's as that bad element to it. So it's important to note to know
- 39:00is that And we can see how your description and the patron's description taken to
- 39:07a more severe level could absolutely be intimate partner violent related. Okay, like
- 39:15you were saying, like where it develops into control, like you can't leave
- 39:19the house, you can't do this, right, and then if the person
- 39:22on top of that is like violent or something, right, And it's my
- 39:24hypothesis, and I'm always surprised that intimate partner violence. People don't agree with
- 39:32me as wholeheartedly as I think they would. Is that is that intimate partner
- 39:38violence, as it's called now they don't call it domestic violence anymore, is
- 39:43primarily caused by jealousy. It is primarily caused by attachment injury or attachment worries
- 39:50of attachment loss, because you know, we typically look at intimate partner violence
- 39:55perpetrators as these evil, control going, misogynistic assholes. We don't tend to
- 40:05look at them as people who are hurting on the inside, as people who
- 40:08are desperate for an attachment and have been attachment injured as children to the point
- 40:15where they just don't trust people to stay with them, and so they resort
- 40:20to power and control to retain an attachment that they believe they can't attain otherwise.
- 40:28Okay, study by White nineteen eighty one, Berto tell me, is
- 40:31jealousy related? Now your options are negative? Not related or positive related to
- 40:38you know, you know statistics in that way? Okay? Is jealousy related
- 40:43to exclusivity? In other words, like how exclusive a relationship is negative?
- 40:51It's your believe it's negatively a social Well, what I'm let me clarify.
- 40:54What I mean is that I believe that jealousy would manifest its self in uh,
- 41:01polygamous relationships as well. Uh well, okay, So in other words,
- 41:08if if the relationship is non forget about forget about just think about non
- 41:13polyamous relationship. Just think about like monogamous relationships or just typical dating behavior,
- 41:20you know, dominant culture dating behavior. Okay, Well, then I guess
- 41:22yes, positive, because if you start dating someone, you're gonna maybe have
- 41:29more attachment and then maybe more jealousy gets true, that's right, So the
- 41:32more exclusive a relationship becomes, the more people tend to feel jealousy. That
- 41:38the reason I was vacillating is because when we had when we've talked to polyamorous
- 41:43folks before they have, we have talked about the idea that even in polyamorous
- 41:47relationships, jealousy plays a role. Right, we'll get to them in a
- 41:52second. But those are anomalous cultural people and see jealousy in a whole different
- 42:01way and relationships in a whole different way. And so so what we're talking
- 42:06about is the dominant culture, particularly in study nineteen eighty one, Okay,
- 42:08is jealousy related to self esteem? What do you think. And also there
- 42:13some have gender differences. So yeah, more jealousy, less self esteem,
- 42:17so negative relation, right, particularly in men. The more self esteem you
- 42:23have, the less jealous you tend to be, particularly for men. Okay,
- 42:28did you have less self esteem when you were in your early twenties?
- 42:30Well, less self esteem about me not being abandoned by a mother? What
- 42:39about? Is jealousy related to romanticism, meaning the tendency to be romantic,
- 42:46you know, to have romantic ideals about relationships? You know, you would
- 42:51say, man, that guy's he's a romantic so interesting, Oh that's interesting.
- 42:55Is jealousy related to romanticity? Okay? So naively I would initially think,
- 43:00well no, because we usually like, oh, this is a romantic
- 43:02he's so look he's holding the door, he's got the roses and stuff.
- 43:07But now I'm thinking, like, I don't think that. I don't think
- 43:08that's what it's measuring. I think it's more like a desire for romantic love,
- 43:13you know, like that guy he's yeah, he just he loves to
- 43:16have romantic love, and that person could kind of take it or leave it.
- 43:21I don't think positive relationship it's actually not related jealousy has apparently nothing to
- 43:28do with romanticism. Is jealousy related to feelings of inadequacy as a partner,
- 43:34which is probably more of what you were talking about earlier, Yeah, yes,
- 43:37it is positive related. Is jealousy related to sexual traditionalism? So you
- 43:44know, as a man, you're like, I'm a masculine man and I
- 43:46don't wear pink, and I talk like this, and I drive a truck.
- 43:52I'm a girl and I'm very feminine and I only dow addresses. You
- 43:55know, it is jealousy related to sexual traditionalism. Yes, yes, it
- 44:00is, but only in men. So for women they can be jealous whether
- 44:06they're traditionalist, but for men, the more traditional they are as men,
- 44:12the more likely they are to be jealous. And that's an interesting thing for
- 44:15me too, because I grew up in a very traditional society in Colombia and
- 44:21where actually a lot of men that I, well, a lot of the
- 44:24kids I grew up with. As we started having girlfriends and stuff, it
- 44:30seemed like jealousy was just part of the equation. Like everyone questioned, like,
- 44:35you don't dance with someone else's girlfriend you don't like Well, I wonder
- 44:39if that's just part of the age or something that might have been. But
- 44:42remember I left at fifteen, so maybe I didn't finish learning, you know,
- 44:46and then and then that that started evolving, you know, as I
- 44:52as I grew up as well. So what about Is jealousy related to dependence
- 44:57on the relationship? Oh? Yeah, like I really need this? Yes,
- 45:04yes it is, but only for women, only for women? Okay,
- 45:07yeah, that's interesting. Wow. Okay, So Becker at al.
- 45:13Two thousand and four. Participants in this study were presented with hypothetical scenarios involving
- 45:17both a sexual infidelity and an emotional infidelity ok so being cheated on sexually or
- 45:24someone falling in love with someone else. Then they were asked how jealous,
- 45:30angry, hurt, and disgusted they would be, using continuous scales, so
- 45:34not saying yes or no, but having a rating scale. Was there a
- 45:38sex difference between men and women as the binary goes for this study? Yes?
- 45:45There was. Was there a sex difference for anger regarding sexual jealousy versus
- 45:53emotional jealousy? Yes? No? Oh actually sorry I worded that question wrong.
- 46:00Was there a sex difference for either jealous you know process in terms of
- 46:07how angry men would get or how angry women would know they get as just
- 46:10as a right. And actually, I believe the original way I asked the
- 46:15question is the relevant way of asking the question. What about was there a
- 46:22sex difference regarding being hurt about being cheated on or having No, No,
- 46:27there wasn't a sex difference. Is there a sex difference for disgust between men
- 46:31and women regarding sexual or emotional infidelity? Yes? No, Okay, So
- 46:38the lesson here is that men and women tend to get jealous in extremely similar
- 46:45ways. I thought, but it sounds like no. I thought that there
- 46:49was a study or there were some findings that men tended to get more jealous
- 46:52about emotional infidelity versus women got more jealous about sexual infidelity. Right, So
- 46:59that it's the common notion, and it's the one of the major pillars of
- 47:04evolutionary psychology when it comes to sex differences and what shaped our psychologies regarding gender.
- 47:13But that claim, although supported by science, sort of is easily dismantled
- 47:19once you actually ask the question in a different way. For instance, in
- 47:23the studies that Bus and all those other guys point to that prove that there's
- 47:29this huge difference between men women because the whole premise goes that men have a
- 47:32billion billion sperm and therefore don't care if the female has an emotional attachment with
- 47:38another guy, because it doesn't as long as she doesn't have sex with him.
- 47:45I was saying it backwards, but okay, yeah, well that's what
- 47:46the evolutionary psychology. I got it backward. I meant to say that that
- 47:51I thought that guys would give it more upset about the sexual infidelity and that
- 47:54women would get more upset about the emotional infidelity. I thought, that's what
- 47:58you said that that is, unfortunately the the opposite of what I said,
- 48:00But I meant to say that I got it okay, so right, So
- 48:05what the evolutionary psychologists will say is that women don't care if their male mates
- 48:14have sex with someone else because they have billions of sperm, and as long
- 48:15as they have some sperm for her left over, which inevitably he will,
- 48:20then it's fine. But what she really worries about is him having an emotional
- 48:23affair with someone else, because that means that he's not going to be around
- 48:27to take care of the kid once the kid is born. Yeah, and
- 48:29then the opposite is true for men, that they worry that their woman is
- 48:31going to have sex only because if she has sex with someone else, then
- 48:36he might end up having to raise a kid that's not his genetic offspring.
- 48:43And the studies that they point to have to do with asking a question in
- 48:46a particular way, like Ambardo, would you get more upset about being cheated
- 48:53on or an emotional? See? And so answer the question, what would
- 49:00you say? The old Embarrado would say cheated. We'll say now no,
- 49:04I'm emotional. Okay, So you so you pick one and the other one
- 49:07is now gone? Yeah, So it's a binary I see. So if
- 49:10I is to ask you that question, then then you then you you if
- 49:15you're if you're one hundred percent on one and zero percent or the other or
- 49:19fifty one percent and forty nine percent. You don't know the answer that question,
- 49:23right, You just you're forced to choose one. Whereas if I ask
- 49:27you Embardo, on a scale from one to ten, how jealous would you
- 49:30be if your partner cheated on you sexually? What would be your number?
- 49:34Uh? And by cheating I mean behind my back kind of betrayal? Right,
- 49:37well, yeah, like freaking I don't know. Seven? And how
- 49:42upset would you be on a scale from one to ten, if your partner
- 49:45fell in love with someone else, I'd be just broken hearted, so upset,
- 49:50not as upset that well, emotionally bothered. Yeah, fine, seven.
- 49:54Okay, So now that you know the numbers are not as important,
- 50:00but that you see that when you ask a question in the second way,
- 50:04you get a much more nuanced point of view. And when they ask men
- 50:07and women these questions in the second way, they find that men and women
- 50:12are almost identical. But when you ask the first way, you get women
- 50:15tending to say they would worry about their partner if they had to choose one.
- 50:20They'd say, yeah, so you lose the nuance. That makes sense
- 50:23because like when once you average it out when it's just yes or no,
- 50:28then you might say like, oh, thirty versus seventy percent, But when
- 50:30you average it out when it was a scale from one to ten, they
- 50:34might be sixty two, forty nine, fifty one, fifty whatever. And
- 50:37that's what they find. They find that men and women when they when they
- 50:40rate those things, are just like point one off from each other, right
- 50:46or you know, very very close. And so this study also looks at
- 50:52that in terms of this Becker at al. Study points that, you know
- 50:55to the fact that men and women are fairly similar, and I would contend
- 51:01as our society changes the way it looks at gender over the coming decades,
- 51:07that gap will get even smaller. Well, there's also some practical evidence in
- 51:13this sense. If we look at societies nowadays that still support one husband having
- 51:22multiple wives, you could think about it that way, and without if you
- 51:28didn't do a deep research, you would say, well, it seems like
- 51:30those women are fine with him having multiple wives, right, But then if
- 51:35you step back and you look at other factors, you realize that they actually
- 51:37don't have a choice. So it's not like they they are choosing to be
- 51:42okay with that fact. They don't have a choice to not be okay with
- 51:45that fact. And as you look at societies where there is freedom that you
- 51:50know, the woman can the guy can really only have the one wife.
- 51:53But even if you don't look at marriage just in terms of here in the
- 51:57West, like pretty much the guy doesn't just get to have likes and the
- 52:00wife needs to just be fine with it. Well, now, all of
- 52:02a sudden, you see a behavior where women absolutely demand their you know,
- 52:07they are jealous and they demand their guy for themselves. Yeah, and so
- 52:12I think that it's really risky to conclude, and you've pointed this out before,
- 52:16conclude too much without taking into account the influence that the particular society plays
- 52:21in it and the whole right which leads us to our next piece of literature
- 52:23by visser at Out two thousand and seven. This is an article about looking
- 52:28at jealousy, which within culture and jealousy is often talked about, particularly in
- 52:35evolutionary psychology circles, to be hardwired. We evolved to be jealous. But
- 52:39then when you look at polyamorous and swinging couples, they have a completely different
- 52:45approach to jealousy. Although they often will feel a form of jealousy, they
- 52:50will not bar their partner from having sex with other people as long as its
- 52:54particularly in polyamorous circles, as long as they've established rules before. Swingers to
- 53:00the most part as well. So it's jealousy and what it compels is completely
- 53:07cultural, because we have cultural pockets here in Seattle that completely flip jealousy and
- 53:14monogamy and what it means to have sex with someone else on its head.
- 53:17I kind of think about it like you know, we are clearly hard wired
- 53:21to get hungry. You know, but if you think about it right now,
- 53:27depending like if you look at some of the pockets in the US getting
- 53:30hungry, what that translates into is I need some fried chicken and some fries,
- 53:36right, and I need some kale and some right like in solid parts
- 53:40of the world, like I'm hungry, I need to go eat like some
- 53:44corn because that's the only option or whatever. So and then they'll never think
- 53:47of, like I need some ice cream, Like that's not even a consideration,
- 53:51and you cannot deny there's no hardwiring for being hungry for ice cream at
- 53:53all, but being hungry as a thing is so Similarly, the emotions that
- 53:59get they brought up when you describe jealousy, those seem to be neuronal responses
- 54:04to things, right. But what I think what you're getting at is society
- 54:07in one case might make me think, you know, grow up in a
- 54:10certain way of like, Okay, I'm gonna get jealous about these things,
- 54:14right, yeah, because it's a threat to the relationship and or to my
- 54:17manhood or something. And the analogy to take it further that you started would
- 54:24be that in all likelihood. We and I see no problem in this.
- 54:30And it's hard to really demonstrate this with science, but I think you could
- 54:35make a pretty strong case. And it seems very intuitive that we evolved a
- 54:37mechanism to bond with other people and we evolved a mechanism to have sex with
- 54:44other people. You know, we have a sex drive, and we have
- 54:46a bonding drive. We have a desire for secure relationships with friends, family,
- 54:53partners, children, you know, whatever. But how that is configured
- 55:00in terms of whether it's monogamous or otherwise is cultural. Yeah, so,
- 55:06and it makes sense because like if we if we look at just biologically,
- 55:08a single human person, woman or male, even adult, is not well
- 55:14suited at all to surviving in the wild. Like if you know, if
- 55:16you drop the average person in the in the forest, yeah, they're likely
- 55:22to die from any number of things. Well, I mean to be fair,
- 55:24if you dropped you know, twenty seattleites in the middle of the forest,
- 55:29they are all be Yeah, no, if they'd last a little longer
- 55:31because they could eat. But even when they put like survivor man, you
- 55:34know, like an expert in survival, it's still tough, you know.
- 55:37But as a society even a group of seatleites, it's more likely that you
- 55:43can like work something out, work together, and all these kind of things.
- 55:45And so I think that we traded a long long time ago fangs and
- 55:50thick fur and thick skin and all these things for being able to make tools,
- 55:53being able to communicate, being able to have a society. Well,
- 55:57and I think anthropologists would even and go further back before our species, you
- 56:01know, broke off from the branch of chimps or whoever. We evolved along
- 56:06the same lines as we should be evolved from chimps. How come there's still
- 56:08chimps around them? Well, actually we evolved from a similar ancestor as the
- 56:12chimps. But our branch is social. We're a social bonobo's chimps, you
- 56:17know, we're a social branch anyway, So precle at al. This is
- 56:22the last bit of literature I want to talk about twenty fifteen. It has
- 56:24a few interesting tidbits here. Delusional jealousy is also called Othello's syndrome from the
- 56:34I've heard that from the play You Have Yep, really, I've never heard
- 56:37Othellos syndrome. That's interesting sometimes occurs from neurological disorders but obviously can occur without
- 56:44neurological disorders. And just a little bit about the brain for you brain freaks
- 56:49out there. Precl at al. Twenty fifteen observed significant activations during the imagery
- 56:57of sexual infidelity. So they put people in fm UH scanning machines and then
- 57:02they, I guess, put pictures in front of them of their partners cheating
- 57:08on other people, is I guess, or maybe other people cheating people's partner.
- 57:14I mean, the way that fMRI studies work is you either have to
- 57:17talk to them or just put images in front of them as they're being scanned.
- 57:21And so however, they put imagery of sexual sexual infidelity in front of
- 57:24them. As as these people in these fMRI machines were watching this infidelity occur
- 57:30before their eyes, the singulate cortex and the frontal regions of the brain were
- 57:36lighting up quote unquote, but not the amygdala or the hippocampus. That's saying,
- 57:40you know what the singular cortex has to do with No, it has
- 57:44to do with emotion. It's part of the olympic system. So it's your
- 57:47you know, it's your it's your emotional system, which makes sense. You
- 57:52know that you would get emotional upon seeing sexual infidelity. Interestingly, the amygdala
- 57:58no flight or fight response right in this study anyway, Yeah, and no
- 58:01hippocampus, which is also an emotional memory autonomic nervous system center. But that
- 58:08might be okay. I mean, of course it's okay. But what I
- 58:12mean is that I could imagine that in cases where a person starts developing hyper
- 58:17jealousy and then that leads to violence and things like that, there could be
- 58:22this kind of chain reaction where the initial jealousy gives way to some some triggers
- 58:28that actually then get interpreted as a threat to the self, and then the
- 58:35gets triggered as opposed to like kind of your run of the mail, I'm
- 58:37looking at an image, how do I get triggered? Because there is a
- 58:40big difference between I'm looking at an image and an fm TOTAL study to like
- 58:45I just caught my actually, you know totally. I mean, the whole
- 58:47thing about fMRI studies is there's a chance, given new research that's been coming
- 58:53out, that half to ninety nine percent of past fMRI study are completely invalidated
- 59:01by the I won't go to the details, but and people who listened to
- 59:06this podcast know that I'm highly skeptical of fMRI studies anyway, because it's the
- 59:13resolution at which we're looking at the brain is really crude compared to what we'll
- 59:16be able to look at in the future. And two, we're just looking
- 59:21at quote unquote activation, but things can be happening throughout the brain that we're
- 59:25not able to measure. And we don't even know what's happening in the brain.
- 59:29We're it's just looking at a particular marker that's changing in contrast over time.
- 59:35And that's you know, in fifty years, one hundred years, are
- 59:38going to look back and go like, yeah, back in twenty seventeen they
- 59:43looked at fMRI studies, which is just ridiculous that you know, there's no
- 59:47way to find out anything about the brain with that and so and we'll be
- 59:51jealous of how good they are at it. Yeah, And the studies often
- 59:55have ends of like ten, and when they report on their findings, it
- 1:00:01might mean that just like two people coincided on their images and the rest of
- 1:00:07the eight other subjects didn't exhibit it, And that's enough of a signal to
- 1:00:12say that I see, this is what happens to humans when this happens when
- 1:00:15it only happened to two out of the ten. I'm exaggerating a little bit,
- 1:00:19but I think you get the picture. Having said that, you know
- 1:00:22they're they're they're looking at it. All right, let's take a break.
- 1:00:24When we get back, let's get to answering the patron's questions, specifically,
- 1:00:29what do you say, Burdo break out? Okay, we're back, so
- 1:00:37let's get to your questions, patron, why does it happen? Well,
- 1:00:42as I was saying before, we likely evolved to crave relationship security. We
- 1:00:46probably have an attachment drive. Berto. You want to say, where are
- 1:00:52we going to raffle? Uh oh, yeah, let's raffle Otherwise people are
- 1:00:54gonna get envious. Okay, So pick a letter between A and z burto
- 1:01:00uh t. Pick a number seven? Tim, timy Tim, Tim.
- 1:01:07You're gonna you joined in April. We have we have a number of Tim's,
- 1:01:12so it's the Tim that joined in April. You are going to get.
- 1:01:15Now, pick another letter. You're gonna get swag in the mail.
- 1:01:19We're going to send you some stickers, all right, Another letter? Q?
- 1:01:23Is there a Q in the house? Quinn is going there's only one
- 1:01:27Q and Quinn is going to get Quinn medicine. Woman. Quinn just joined
- 1:01:31like a few weeks ago, so he is going to get get some I
- 1:01:37shouldn't assume gender Quinn. We'll just say Quinn is going to get some swag
- 1:01:40in the mail. What's another letter, Ethan Allen? Yeah, we have
- 1:01:47a number of Ethans. You are the Ethan that joined way back in twenty
- 1:01:52fifteen. Actually both Ethans joined in twenty fifteen. You're the first Ethan.
- 1:01:58You you in September. The other Ethan joined in October. So you all
- 1:02:04three are going to get some patron swag. Okay, So your question,
- 1:02:09patron, why does it happen? Why does Jelsey happen? Well, like
- 1:02:12I said, we likely evolved a drive for relationship security, and so combining
- 1:02:19that with culture and your interpretation of the events that are happening before you,
- 1:02:22that engages that system to like that one author said, it's a drive to
- 1:02:30retain the security that you have in your relationships. Well, one thing that's
- 1:02:34not specified in the in the email is that I'd be curious about is what
- 1:02:39were times during this patron's life that she actually had a trust or a relationship
- 1:02:47and it was betrayed. Yeah, right, And I'd be curious about that,
- 1:02:51right. I would assume that given her response to triggers that through throughout
- 1:03:00her life she's been rejected, made to feel not good enough, and been
- 1:03:06traumatized in that way. And I wonder if it now becomes sort of self
- 1:03:10fulfilling in a way, because I know that for me, at the time
- 1:03:15I had I had started down a dark road of basically pushing the person away,
- 1:03:20that would have it would have ended up not well for me. It
- 1:03:24could very well ended up with oh wait, she did cheat on me.
- 1:03:29But it's like because you made her, you know. Yeah, that's one
- 1:03:31of the tragedies of being traumatized and as treated as children is that it creates
- 1:03:38psychic realities and tendencies that tend to create relational realities that repeat the original problem,
- 1:03:46which is, you know, it's like when you're sexually abused as a
- 1:03:52child, over a number of years, the chance that you will grow up
- 1:03:57and be abused again as much high, which is just this double tragedy.
- 1:04:02Okay. Also, you know, Patreon, no one likes to be deceived,
- 1:04:06So why do people get jealous? Well, because no one likes to
- 1:04:10be tricked, particularly by our loved ones. And we all need love and
- 1:04:15trust and security. So it's just it's normal to get upset when someone hurts
- 1:04:18you in that way. Now, why is it worse in some people?
- 1:04:23Like I said, attachment injuries, being neglected, abused, mistreated, traumatized
- 1:04:28as children or as adults. You I've been mainly focusing on childhood trauma,
- 1:04:31but you can be like what Burta was saying, he had just recently been
- 1:04:39in a difficult breakup and so on the tales of that, your jealousy mechanism
- 1:04:44might be easily more easily triggered during that time. Yeah, you also asked,
- 1:04:49patron, is it hereditary? Can can jealousy be hereditary? Well,
- 1:04:55what I'll say is is that there's there's no research that I could find even
- 1:04:59asking that question. It's an extremely difficult question to even research. Whenever you
- 1:05:05talk about personality traits and hereditary and heredity, it's really hard to nail that
- 1:05:13down because it's hard to know if it's learned. You know, you start
- 1:05:15looking at twins and this kind of stuff. But anyway, can't just question
- 1:05:19away five thousand families for fifty years. That's the way you to do it.
- 1:05:25So now what I'll say, it's likely that some personality traits are quote
- 1:05:30unquote hereditary, meaning that you're, all of us are probably born with certain
- 1:05:35tendencies regarding personality, and then combine that with experience and that creates who we
- 1:05:40are. But I would say that when it comes to jealousy and your trigger,
- 1:05:45you know, for you in particular, Patron, my guess is,
- 1:05:47you weren't born this way. My guess is, and you didn't talk about
- 1:05:50this in much detail. I mean, you said that your dad got jealous
- 1:05:54a lot and that's why your parents split up. But that alone, just
- 1:05:59your parents lit up is an attachment injury of sorts for some people. And
- 1:06:05my guess is you had other sorts of attachment injuries as well. And so
- 1:06:11if someone came to me and they talked about having extreme jealousy problems, I
- 1:06:15would assume that they've had bad experiences in their life. I wouldn't. I
- 1:06:18wouldn't. I wouldn't in my mind, I wouldn't be like, oh,
- 1:06:21they were probably born this way. Okay. So, and more specifically to
- 1:06:29your experience, can a jealous parent produce a jealous child? Yes, Jealousy
- 1:06:32implies attachment insecurity in your dad, which leads him to be a bad parent,
- 1:06:39which leads to child attachment insecurity for you, patron, which leads you
- 1:06:43to be jealous later on. Only it might appear hereditary, but not necessarily
- 1:06:47genetically right. It's the same with borderline. It's hard to know whether or
- 1:06:53not that is hereditary or not. There does seem to be some link,
- 1:06:56but jealousy I couldn't find any research on it. Maybe there is, but
- 1:07:00anyway, So how do I treat jealousy? Well, the first thing I
- 1:07:03do is I normalize it. Try to reduce the shame. That's the first
- 1:07:08thing I do with a lot of things. Until people can release themselves from
- 1:07:12the shame, it's hard to address it. So I'll spend a lot of
- 1:07:15time really genuinely trying to get them to stop shaming themselves and to normalize it,
- 1:07:21as I think we did on this podcast. You know, do the
- 1:07:25Rutpric method or not the Ruteprick method. The the in Dirty Rotten Scoundrels where
- 1:07:30he's like dancing with with the gal while while he's in the wheelchair, just
- 1:07:35to get him excited about regaining his Yeah, that was a different care you
- 1:07:41know, I remember that it was it was what was his character's name,
- 1:07:45Colonel something? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Also, how how do I
- 1:07:50treat jealousy? I also, as as as Burrow did with his therapist,
- 1:07:55try to increase awareness. Awareness can do a lot knowing your triggers, knowing
- 1:08:00what jealousy is, being able to sort of categorize it as you're experiencing jealousy.
- 1:08:04If you're completely lost in the jealousy, it's hard to exhibit any control.
- 1:08:10But if in the midst of jealousy, at least part of your consciousness
- 1:08:13can say, oh, I'm jealous right now, that can go a long
- 1:08:16way in terms of not only just helping in that moment, but triggering coping
- 1:08:24skills to be able to mitig mitigate the problems. But the main thing that
- 1:08:30I do for people who have your form of je Patron is attachment oriented therapy,
- 1:08:36relational oriented therapy, corrective emotional experiences. If we can engineer, as
- 1:08:43Birdo did with his mom and with other important figures in his twenties, if
- 1:08:46we can engineer you, patron, to have relationships with people that are stable
- 1:08:51over time, that are proven to you with actual behavior and time that you
- 1:08:58are a lovable person, that you can trust other people that they won't just
- 1:09:02walk away from you or cheat on you, that they're stable people who have
- 1:09:08a caring for you that's independent from you. And that's the thing that's important.
- 1:09:13That's not everyone believes that, you know. And that's kind of the
- 1:09:15crux of jealousy is I don't trust that within that other person is a independent
- 1:09:23from me, a energy that wants to preserve this relationship. I don't think
- 1:09:29I'm worrying this, right, do you know what I'm saying. I do
- 1:09:30know what you're saying. That is that feeling of like left to the other
- 1:09:35person's devices, this is over. So it's all up to me, Like,
- 1:09:41if I don't somehow make a case for this relationship, or if I
- 1:09:44don't somehow prevent this person from having contact with other people, this relationship is
- 1:09:50over. You know. It's sort of like the analogy I always think of
- 1:09:55is the first time I got on a horse, I was like twelve years
- 1:09:58old. It was in the mind Tanna on this thousand acres and there was
- 1:10:02no oversight. It was just like, okay, let's all get on horses.
- 1:10:05And so I got on this horse and it was the most lively horse
- 1:10:10of the bunch, and it just took off running. And we're in the
- 1:10:13wilderness, you know, there's no fences. We're just like, I'm just
- 1:10:15running through this meadow, you know, and there's trees and bushes and stuff.
- 1:10:20And I see this tree stump like right in front of us, and
- 1:10:24I'm like, and I'm giddy. At first, I'm laughing. I'm like,
- 1:10:28oh my god, I'm on a horse. This is this is amazing,
- 1:10:30this is amazing. Oh my god, there's a tree stump like ahead.
- 1:10:33We're heading right toward it. I'm gonna die. I'm dead, like,
- 1:10:38I don't know. No one told me how to turn this thing or
- 1:10:41get it to stop. And the and the horse we're getting closer and closer,
- 1:10:45and then the horse just runs around. Oh the stump. You had
- 1:10:47no faith that if it weren't, if you didn't take some action right,
- 1:10:51the horse on its own would do something right to be served both. I
- 1:10:57didn't realize that the horse was an independ being that likes to be alive and
- 1:11:04doesn't want to run into things. And similar, when you go through enough
- 1:11:10experiences that teach you this, you will look at your partner and see someone
- 1:11:15who independently is desperate to hold on to you and will because really, anyone
- 1:11:23can cheat on anyone pretty easily. I mean, if you wanted to,
- 1:11:27you can even people who are highly controlled or have very busy lives. If
- 1:11:30you wanted to, you could cheat on someone pretty easily. And the fact
- 1:11:36is is that most people at any given time are not cheating on And the
- 1:11:40reason why is because they love their partner and they don't want to hurt that
- 1:11:44person and they don't want to hurt themselves, and they don't want to degrade
- 1:11:47their relationship. But you know, they have all the same desires that you
- 1:11:50do, and so as you have secure relationships, you begin to trust that
- 1:11:55that other person has that and hopefully that other person has that is the thing.
- 1:12:00Okay, your last question, how can people manage their jealousy? Well,
- 1:12:04the first thing is healing from your wounds, which can take years,
- 1:12:08but you know it's a big thing. Also, the main thing is in
- 1:12:13it. You know, in the meantime, get your partner to help you.
- 1:12:15This is I talk with people about this all the time. What people
- 1:12:19often do with jealousy is they ask me, how can I control it?
- 1:12:25How can I stop being jealous, And what I say is it's impossible.
- 1:12:29You're asking the wrong question. It's like saying, how can I stop being
- 1:12:32thirsty? You know, until you heal from your relational wounds, or until
- 1:12:36you have a secure relationship for a long enough time, you're just gonna get
- 1:12:40jealous. That's just how it is. And so the question is not how
- 1:12:45can I stop being jealous? But the question is what do I do when
- 1:12:47I feel jealous? We tend to have very limited options available to us in
- 1:12:51this culture. You know, what are the typical prescribed cultural you know,
- 1:12:58behaviors. And a man gets jealous or a woman gets jealous culturally, okay,
- 1:13:05confront the other person. I guess, yeah, where were you?
- 1:13:09Where were you? Were you with this guy? Did you have sex with
- 1:13:11him? Did you did you pull the flap? Did you did you lift
- 1:13:15the flap? Right? So, now that's just one of thousands of behaviors
- 1:13:20that would make sense given what is happening. For instance, and these are
- 1:13:26my words, but put it into your own words, patron, you would
- 1:13:30say to your partner, and this is prior to feeling jealous. This is
- 1:13:32like in the middle of nowhere, you say, I am so sorry,
- 1:13:38partner of mine that you have to deal with my problem with jealousy. I'm
- 1:13:44so sorry, but it's largely out of my control, and until I heal
- 1:13:48from the ship I went through as a kid, I'm likely to get triggered
- 1:13:54down then, as I have in the past, and you could really,
- 1:13:58really really help me by reducing the likelihood of me being triggered and by helping
- 1:14:03me cope when I do get triggered, because I will get triggered at some
- 1:14:06point, and it's not your fault. Is the point when I get triggered
- 1:14:12my jealousy, when it gets triggered, it is not your fault. When
- 1:14:15you got a ride with those three guys that triggered my jealousy, that is
- 1:14:19not your fault. You were not responsible for that. That's completely on me.
- 1:14:24It's all my fault that I got jealous it is not your fault.
- 1:14:27And if you love me, you will please help me with this. Well,
- 1:14:31she could have taken an uber not back then, then maybe we could
- 1:14:36talk about it now and then. This doesn't mean that you can't have friends.
- 1:14:42It just means I might need some extra reassurance or I might need some
- 1:14:47extra help around this. For instance, you know in your situation, Bruto,
- 1:14:51it would have been like, so, if you have a choice between
- 1:14:57getting a ride with females or male, I'm just telling you it's gonna trigger
- 1:15:02me if you ride with males. Now you are, you are free to
- 1:15:06ride with with males. This is my problem, I understand. So you
- 1:15:12getting a ride with men is totally fine because you're what are you gonna do?
- 1:15:16Have sex? That's ridiculous if you were that close to having sex with
- 1:15:19three random guys. I don't want to be with you anyway, and I
- 1:15:24know you you're not like that. But I get triggered and become delusional,
- 1:15:29and you see how crazy I get. And this is just temporary for now.
- 1:15:33Eventually I'm working hard in therapy, and once I get healed from my
- 1:15:36relational wounds, and once you and I have enough time under our belts where
- 1:15:42I can really feel like I can trust things, then I'm guessing I'm not
- 1:15:45gonna get as jealous in the future, but for now, if I'm just
- 1:15:48I'm begging you to try not to trigger me. The other thing is is
- 1:15:54that I'm gonna need a lot of reassurance, a lot of overt reassurance,
- 1:15:59and I might ask you things. So, for instance, you you know,
- 1:16:03arrive at the play and you say, I got to ride with three
- 1:16:05guys. I'm going to go through a mental circus in my head in that
- 1:16:12moment, and what if I'm following my functional behavior. What I'll do is
- 1:16:17I'll turn to you and I'll say, so, it's not your fault,
- 1:16:21but I'm getting triggered right now by that. It's not your fault. This
- 1:16:26is my problem. You know, fuck my parents for putting me through all
- 1:16:29that shit when I was a kid. Not your fault, but I'm fucking
- 1:16:31losing it right now. Not your fault. If you could reassure me that
- 1:16:39you love me, that you're not leaving me, that you didn't do anything
- 1:16:42with them, that you're not attracted to them, if you could really just
- 1:16:45pour it on thick right now for about thirty seconds. I'm hoping, I'm
- 1:16:50guessing that will help. And then because you've been through this and she's cool,
- 1:16:56then she goes, oh, yeah, I love you. I would
- 1:16:59never leave you those three guys, they're just friends. And even if they
- 1:17:03were attractive, I don't. I'm not looking at other men, you know,
- 1:17:09And you know she might hug you or kiss you and say you're the
- 1:17:13only one I've never cheated on you, I never will cheat on you.
- 1:17:15So what she shouldn't say is those three Oh they were pouring it on thick
- 1:17:19all right. Oh god, well that does it for that episode of psychology
- 1:17:26in Seattle. Thanks for joining us out there. Please take care of yourself
- 1:17:29because you deserve it.