Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / The First Federal Home Loan Bank Oversight Hearing in 15 Years with Ryan Donovan CEO of the Council of Federal Home Loan Banks
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Hey, everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited to be here today with Ryan Donovan, the CEO of the
- 0:08Council of Federal Home Loan Banks.
- 0:10Ryan, how you doing this morning?
- 0:12Ryan Donovan: Hey.
- 0:12I'm doing great, Mark.
- 0:12Thanks for having me.
- 0:13Mark Treichel: You got it.
- 0:14Yeah, we've had you on a couple times.
- 0:15We go back to the CUNA days before America's Credit Unions when
- 0:19you were at the, the top of the organization over there, and I
- 0:22always enjoy chatting with you.
- 0:24But I thought it'd be good to just say, hey, what's going on with the Federal
- 0:27Home Loan Banks, particularly since last week, the day before the Bank Act turned
- 0:3494, they had the first oversight hearing in 15 years and you were able to get the
- 0:38good thoughts out of the organization.
- 0:40So how did that go?
- 0:41Ryan Donovan: Listen I thought it went great.
- 0:43When I was at CUNA, I prepared probably 60 different people to
- 0:46testify before Congress over 15 years, and it is certainly a much different
- 0:51experience when you're the, when you're the person behind the table.
- 0:55But we had the opportunity, as you said, it was Federal Home Loan Bank
- 0:58Week, 94th anniversary of the Federal Home Loan Bank Act, and the House
- 1:03Financial Services Committee gave us the opportunity to participate in an
- 1:08oversight hearing and really tell the story about the home loan banks and
- 1:11how we're fulfilling our mission today.
- 1:14And it's a great story to tell.
- 1:16We've got 11 banks that are serving 6,300 members, credit unions,
- 1:21banks, insurance companies, CDFIs.
- 1:24We're providing liqui- liquidity to them so that they can serve their members,
- 1:29customers, and communities, and we're supporting housing affordability.
- 1:33I- We're not a well-known system, right?
- 1:34You mentioned it was the first oversight hearing in 15 years.
- 1:38So we had a lot of education to do with the members on the subcommittee and
- 1:41that's where we started in the testimony.
- 1:44Mark Treichel: And you triggered something.
- 1:46So y- all the different players that you can have belong to the Federal Home Loan
- 1:51Banks, I think last time we chatted, I went back and looked at some of the notes,
- 1:55cre- the growth of credit unions was bigger than some of the other players.
- 1:59How has that played out over the last year?
- 2:01Credit unions still growing robustly?
- 2:02Ryan Donovan: Yeah it's continuing.
- 2:03I think that credit union membership has grown.
- 2:06We've got a substantial portion of the credit union assets.
- 2:09If you look at it by asset size there's a substantial portion.
- 2:12If you look about it member size, there's still opportunity to
- 2:14grow among the smaller members.
- 2:17But I think across the country and all the various districts credit
- 2:20union membership is re- is robust.
- 2:23Mark Treichel: That's great.
- 2:23That's good to hear.
- 2:24A- and, when I'm talking to credit unions it's always a tool in their tool-
- 2:28generally a toolbox that, especially the bigger ones, just like you say.
- 2:31So it's good to see everybody's embraced it for all it can do for credit unions.
- 2:35Ab-
- 2:36Ryan Donovan: absolutely.
- 2:37Mark Treichel: If I, if my research was right GAO came out in December
- 2:42and said that the, the Federal Home Loan Banks are a reliable funding
- 2:45source for institutions of all sizes.
- 2:47Getting an independent scorekeeper like that to give you the Good
- 2:50Housekeeping Seal of Approval what did that do for business?
- 2:54Ryan Donovan: I told I, I told the bank presidents and our system
- 2:57leaders, this was actually the second report GAO's done in recent years.
- 3:01I said, "No one in the history of GAO reports has ever said, 'Man, I cannot
- 3:06wait for that GAO report to come out.'"
- 3:07We might be the first.
- 3:09Because GAO does call balls and strikes.
- 3:11They're a fair arbiter.
- 3:13And, again, we hadn't been telling our story until the last four or five years.
- 3:18But when we told it to GAO and they validated it what they came back with
- 3:22was a lot of statements that , we would use in our advocacy material and
- 3:27now we can say, "According to GAO."
- 3:29And they did talk about the the role we play as a reliable liquidity
- 3:33provider, how we help increase lending and particularly mortgage lending the
- 3:38role that we play in times of stress.
- 3:41And we also had a lot of that validated by the Urban Institute that did three
- 3:46reports on us late last year coming to many of the same conclusions.
- 3:50So when you've got multiple groups and multiple sets of researchers
- 3:55asking similar questions and getting the same answer I think there's a l-
- 3:59there's a lot of validation in that.
- 4:01Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 4:01That's amazing.
- 4:02Yeah.
- 4:02Y- you get, getting a good GAO report,
- 4:04Ryan Donovan: Yeah
- 4:05⦠Mark Treichel: is rare.
- 4:06Ryan Donovan: No, absolutely.
- 4:07And I think that we're in a position right now where we're in, we're l- continuing
- 4:13to launch a research pipeline to ask interesting questions about the system.
- 4:18So hopefully, i- in the months and years ahead, we'll continue to
- 4:22get that type of very positive and informative research and analysis.
- 4:28Mark Treichel: Yeah, that's exciting.
- 4:29That's exciting.
- 4:30So one of the stats I wrote down here it's gonna, it's gonna mean more
- 4:33to you when I say it than the, the cryptic way I wrote it down here, but
- 4:37so there's 11 Federal Home Loan Banks.
- 4:40I have a note here about 73,000 families being helped.
- 4:45Does that ring any bells from the testimony?
- 4:47Just different projects where the banks are particularlyâ¦
- 4:50'Cause credit unions have anecdotal stories, right?
- 4:53When they go to- Yeah ⦠Congress and they say, "We have this small little
- 4:56credit union we have and they got turned down by banks and this is how we're
- 4:59able to help them start their business."
- 5:01Ryan Donovan: Yeah.
- 5:01And the- A-
- 5:02Mark Treichel: anecdotal stories of Federal Home Loan Bank helping
- 5:04people housing-wise or however.
- 5:06Ryan Donovan: Yeah.
- 5:07No I, the, the 73,000 is probably a, a y- units affordable housing units-
- 5:12Okay ⦠supported in a year or perhaps even just by a particular bank.
- 5:17One- Yeah, it was
- 5:17Mark Treichel: last year.
- 5:17That's right.
- 5:18Yep.
- 5:18Ryan Donovan: Yeah.
- 5:19One of the things that we are required by law to do is set aside 10% of our previous
- 5:26year's net earnings and put it into what's called the Affordable Housing Program.
- 5:32It's a government program that's run by the banks it's
- 5:35got a very descriptive name.
- 5:37It does, it's exactly what it says it is.
- 5:38Afford- it helps affordable housing.
- 5:40For the last couple of years, the banks have contributed, 50% more
- 5:46than what's required by law to, broadly speaking, affordable housing
- 5:50community development projects.
- 5:52It could be more money into the government AHP program or to voluntary programs.
- 5:57Now here's the, here's where I'm getting to, to some numbers for you, Mark.
- 6:01Each of the last two years, that has resulted in more than $1 billion each
- 6:06year going to affordable housing.
- 6:08Now, before we made that commitment to do the extra 50%, we were already
- 6:13the nation's largest source of private capital support for affordable housing.
- 6:18And now we're doing even more clearly in recognition of the severe crisis we have.
- 6:24But that, that gives us the impact to to support projects across the country.
- 6:29And when we work with our members, with credit unions and other members at a local
- 6:34level, and our affordable housing advisory councils, we can target that support
- 6:41where it's needed the most or will have the most impact in each of the districts.
- 6:45So we're real proud of that effort and our ability to do that extra contribution.
- 6:50Mark Treichel: And so the voluntary program versus the, the AHP, I think
- 6:56in your testimony you may have pointed out some of the challenges of the AHP.
- 7:00Some-- Maybe there's some regulatory pieces that could be enhanced.
- 7:04Ryan Donovan: Yeah.
- 7:04The AHP is a government program.
- 7:07It's created by Congress.
- 7:08It's regulated by FHFA.
- 7:11It's very well-intentioned, but as with many similar efforts, what starts
- 7:17in statute ends up in regulation, ends up in regulatory burden on
- 7:21the folks that have to- Right
- 7:23ultimately implement it.
- 7:24AHP is touched by 13 different regulations from FHFA, six
- 7:29different advisory bulletins.
- 7:31What does this mean?
- 7:32It means it's complicated to apply for, which is problematic because,
- 7:37you have to you have to, qualify and, be the one-- among the best
- 7:42applicants to get the money.
- 7:43So that's complicated.
- 7:44We-- we're often the last part of a large capital stack we're a
- 7:51s- we're a small part of it but critical to getting jobs done.
- 7:54But we're all often, In that capital stack, you'll have other sources of
- 7:58federal or state funding that has its own due diligence requirements.
- 8:03So we're adding on another layer of due diligence there.
- 8:07It could be a lot simpler.
- 8:09And to FHFA's credit, and under Director Pulte's leadership, the agency is taking
- 8:15steps to overhaul the AHP program.
- 8:19That will make it- A little bit easier, I think, to apply for, win, be
- 8:25awarded, easier for the banks to get the money out the door and provi- and
- 8:29perform the oversight than it is today.
- 8:32What's cool about the voluntary programs is banks create them based on the feedback
- 8:37they get from their members and their affordable housing advisory councils.
- 8:42They can put them into place relatively quickly and get the
- 8:47money out the door immediately.
- 8:49So one of the things, and you may have an appreciation for this, when
- 8:52we talk about the funding, sometimes we get tripped up because with AHP,
- 8:57it's the amount that we've committed that will go out the door someday-
- 9:01Mark Treichel: Right
- 9:02Ryan Donovan: after all the boxes are checked, versus with voluntary programs,
- 9:06it's the amount that we contributed, which is money that's been out the door that's
- 9:09having an impact in local communities.
- 9:12That flexibility I think is really critical, and one of the points that
- 9:14I made in my testimony is that if Congress is gonna talk about or think
- 9:18about adjusting that 10% statutory floor you can't crowd out the voluntary
- 9:25programs because those are the ones that are having a localized impact.
- 9:30So it's, I know that was a lot, but- No, that's,
- 9:33That's explanatory ⦠understanding the distinction between those
- 9:35programs and what we're trying to accomplish, I think is really critical.
- 9:39Mark Treichel: A- and am I interpreting it right, so the 10% is mandated, that
- 9:42has to go through- Yeah ⦠the AHP?
- 9:44Is- That's right
- 9:45And then anything on top of that is the voluntary, but also- And y- ⦠the
- 9:49one that's more flexible that you can get- Right ⦠moving quicker.
- 9:52Ryan Donovan: Yeah.
- 9:52And voluntary could go through the AHP, but it doesn't have to.
- 9:55And what we've seen is, over the last three or four years, the banks
- 9:58have created more than three dozen different programs again, based
- 10:02on their needs in, in local areas.
- 10:05Mark Treichel: I know that I, I've got some, some friends and relatives in
- 10:08the rental property business, and I just- ⦠remember having discussions with
- 10:12them, and I think it's still the case.
- 10:14There's more houses and homes going out of being available than
- 10:19there are being built new, right?
- 10:20So they're the places- Yeah ⦠that are dilapidated and need to be torn down.
- 10:24Is that still, is that still- Yeah ⦠the battle we're fighting?
- 10:27Ryan Donovan: Yeah.
- 10:27I think it is in many areas.
- 10:28And, that's why, one of the things that voluntary program money can be used for
- 10:33is rehabilitation of of those units.
- 10:36And, again, another example of why it's critical to have some flexibility.
- 10:40Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 10:40Makes sense.
- 10:41That makes sense.
- 10:42I noticed a reference to the Federal Home Loan Bank interoperat- interoperability.
- 10:47Interoperability.
- 10:47Ryan Donovan: Interopera-
- 10:49Mark Treichel: boy, try and say that without enough coffee.
- 10:51Ryan Donovan: What I learned was at some of these hearings, there are these games
- 10:54on, what word is gonna be used- Right
- 10:57or how many times will it be said.
- 10:59For, for us, it was countercyc- cyclical and interoperability.
- 11:03Hard words to say, but things that are really important to what we do.
- 11:05You,
- 11:05Mark Treichel: you got it down.
- 11:06I could tell you practiced that a lot last week.
- 11:08So that committee was it Jefferson and Bauman from both sides- Yeah
- 11:12of the aisle could set that up.
- 11:13Howâ¦
- 11:14Has that improved things?
- 11:15Ryan Donovan: Yeah.
- 11:15R- this work really comes out of the lessons learned from March 2023, right?
- 11:21Where we had the Silicon bag Silicon Valley bank failure,
- 11:24Signature Bank failure.
- 11:26And I think there were a number of lessons learned, but for the Fed and the home loan
- 11:30bank system, it was really a lesson of, hey, let's-- we're already coordinating
- 11:35but we need to do a little bit more.
- 11:36So for the home loan banks, what we've done is we've encouraged each of the
- 11:40banks has encouraged their members to develop a relationship with the discount
- 11:44window and test those lines periodically.
- 11:46That's a, a good best practice.
- 11:48We've also had discussions with the Fed on a number of work streams improving
- 11:53communication, making sure that the personnel in critical positions at
- 11:58the home loan bank and at the Fed know how to get the, get ahold of
- 12:01each other, at 6:00 on a Friday.
- 12:04We've been working with them on, master subordination agreements so that in a
- 12:09time of crisis we can pull a document off the shelf and move collateral faster.
- 12:14W- we've also proposed, the home loan banks have proposed what if
- 12:18the Fed accepted a letter of credit from the home loan bank on behalf
- 12:23of one of our members in stress?
- 12:24We can do that very quickly, we can do that 24/7.
- 12:28Take that letter of credit, it will buy some time, maybe bridge from,
- 12:33the market closing on a Friday to market opening on Monday so that it
- 12:37gives the regulators a little bit more time to to work things out.
- 12:42Again, all of this is making sure that we've got the right tools in
- 12:45the toolbox in times of stress, and we know how to use them.
- 12:49And the good news is that the conversations with the
- 12:52Fed have been very positive.
- 12:54Vice Chair Jefferson and Vice Chair Bowman have been integral,
- 12:58I think, into that leadership.
- 13:00But the, the thing that I have learned about both the home loan
- 13:03bank system and the Federal Reserve system in the last several years is
- 13:06that neither are a monolith, right?
- 13:09So there are multiple levels and multiple groups at the Fed, and there
- 13:14are the, the same thing happens in the home loan bank system, maybe
- 13:17to a a little different extent.
- 13:19But it's really important that we're all pulling in the same direction,
- 13:23and I think we're starting to do that.
- 13:24Mark Treichel: And, two things that resonate, testing the system
- 13:27so that if something goes wrong you're ready to rock and roll and
- 13:31you know that the system works.
- 13:32But as you're talking about, making the contacts and all that, all I could
- 13:36think about was, NCUA had buyouts and lost about- 27% of their staff.
- 13:41Federal Home Loan Banks have turnover, the Fed has turnover- ⦠FDIC.
- 13:46And you think about those call trees that you have where you pull
- 13:48out all the people's names- you try and call someone at NCUA right
- 13:52now, 27% of them are gone, right?
- 13:54So you better know who it is that you're supposed to call in the event
- 13:56of a Friday emergency for liquidity
- 13:58Ryan Donovan: Yeah, there there's no question about that, that, you wanna make
- 14:00sure that, when the alarm bells ring and, the, the trucks are ahead of the fire.
- 14:05Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 14:05Yep, that's for sure.
- 14:07Ryan Donovan: So o- one, one thing, Mark, if I could just go a little bit further
- 14:10on the discount window and, o- one of the things that we also have, have tried
- 14:14to make clear with our members and in our testimony was that, borrowing from
- 14:18the Fed and borrowing from the Home Loan Bank i- very different, right?
- 14:21The Fed's got very limited lending authority, right?
- 14:25They lend overnight.
- 14:27There's limits on the number of consecutive days and the number
- 14:30of days within, a, a 100 and day, 120-day period that that a depository
- 14:36can, can borrow from the Fed.
- 14:38A- whereas the Home Loan Bank is a, we're a daily liquidity provider
- 14:42to support the needs of the credit union to make sure that they can
- 14:45continue to serve their members.
- 14:47And for us, where our nexus to housing is, it's really in the collateral that
- 14:52credit unions bring to to the system.
- 14:55So it's mortgage-related collateral, either mortgages that they've
- 14:57originated or bought or mortgage-backed securities that they've invested in.
- 15:01That's our nexus to colla- nexus to housing.
- 15:04And our, and it gives us the ability to be a reliable lender
- 15:09to our members every day.
- 15:11Mark Treichel: Yeah, it makes total sense.
- 15:12And again, going back to the Signature and SVB and how you were
- 15:17able to help on a Friday to prevent, you know- Contagion ⦠contagion.
- 15:21Yeah, exactly.
- 15:22Contagion.
- 15:23And then a note from the testimony, I believe regulators treating
- 15:27advances like ordinary wholesale funding a- how could thingsâ¦
- 15:32things are going well, but how could things get even better in that
- 15:35Ryan Donovan: regard?
- 15:35So this, what this really gets at is- The Home Loan Bank System has demonstrated,
- 15:41certainly in the last several decades, but I hope, but probably throughout its
- 15:45history, that we are reliable, affordable quick and safe form of liquidity.
- 15:52That you, that a member can count on the Home Loan Bank System
- 15:56to get the liquidity they need.
- 15:57So what we're starting to talk to the regulators about, we've had a
- 16:01conversation at F- FDIC we'll have some conversations with the other regulators,
- 16:06including the the new incoming chair of NCUA is when you're looking at the
- 16:11liquidity coverage ratio and other other measures and y- you're taking into
- 16:16consideration home loan bank advances that those should be treated as as,
- 16:21as core liquidity for those purposes.
- 16:24Just reflective of the, the reliability that we've seen
- 16:28throughout the history of the system.
- 16:30Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 16:30No, that makes sense.
- 16:31And you mentioned the incoming NCUA chairman.
- 16:33Rumor has it that's gonna happen next Monday or Tuesday.
- 16:38The episode we're recording will come out the following Monday or Tuesday.
- 16:41Yeah.
- 16:41Again, that's rumor.
- 16:42I'm not sure if it's- Which rumor?
- 16:44Yeah ⦠I'm not sure if it's a good rumor or a bad rumor, but it is rumor.
- 16:47Ryan Donovan: I've heard the same and, I, I- there's reason to have confidence,
- 16:51Mark Treichel: there is reason there's reason to have confidence.
- 16:54That's right.
- 16:54And and so then what happens then, it's August, right?
- 16:57The, the NCUA doesn't have a board meeting every, every month.
- 17:00They used to just not have them in August, but they definitely
- 17:02don't have them in August.
- 17:03But that's gonna gear up you and and your crew getting over there to meet
- 17:07the new chair and all that, and making sure they understand all the good
- 17:10things that that the FLBAs do, right?
- 17:13Ryan Donovan: Yep.
- 17:13No, we're we're, eager to to connect.
- 17:16We had as, as part of our advocacy, we try to go to the top of the house
- 17:20at all of the member regulators and and certainly getting to know Mr.
- 17:25Cruz as he as he takes office will will be important.
- 17:28Mark Treichel: Yep very much yeah, he's gonna be drink- he's a smart
- 17:30guy, you can tell that, and he knows a lot about the, the industry.
- 17:33But it's g- they got their budget coming up and all that, so he's ⦠It's good
- 17:37they got him in, hopefully in August so he can get up to speed before all
- 17:40that hits him, Absolutely ⦠with drinking water from a fire hose, let's
- 17:43see, Chicago, Boston, and Cincinnati all run subsidized programs for CDFIs.
- 17:48How does that ⦠credit unions can take advantage of that as well, I presume.
- 17:52Ryan Donovan: Yeah, absolutely.
- 17:53The CDFI membership is one of the, one of the smaller segments of our membership.
- 17:58Setting, set aside the depository CDFIs, right?
- 18:01Yep.
- 18:01When we think about CDFIs as a membership class, we're really thinking
- 18:05about the non-depository CDFIs.
- 18:07And, and- Yeah ⦠they face some obstacles that other members may not face.
- 18:13And one of them is the fact that their, the non-depositories don't
- 18:16have a prudential regulator, and the collateral that they bring,
- 18:21particularly the LIHTC collateral that they bring is hard to value.
- 18:25And it's a shame that it's hard to value because LIHTC collateral
- 18:29is pretty reliable collateral because no one sells it, right?
- 18:33So it's ⦠The issue is it's hard to value.
- 18:35They ⦠So as a result, the haircuts that are often applied to CDFIs are a little
- 18:40bit steeper than to to other members, which is why these programs are important
- 18:46to try to provide a m- more access on a more parity basis for for CDFIs.
- 18:52Mark Treichel: A- and LIHTC, could you describe that?
- 18:55Ryan Donovan: Yeah, low income housing tax credit.
- 18:57It's,
- 18:58Mark Treichel: Okay
- 18:58⦠Ryan Donovan: the provision of the of the tax code that really incentivizes
- 19:02investment into to- ⦠affordable housing in low in- low-income areas.
- 19:06Mark Treichel: Got it.
- 19:06Got it.
- 19:07HR 7647,
- 19:10Ryan Donovan: The MENSA Act
- 19:12⦠Mark Treichel: yeah, so that would add credit unions to the community financial-
- 19:15Ryan Donovan: Oh, that, no, yeah, the, the credit unions to the CFI definition.
- 19:19Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 19:19Ryan Donovan: Listen, this is an area in we're, we are required, by law to treat
- 19:24all of our members pretty much the same.
- 19:26This is an, a, an area where Congress has created sort of an exception to that
- 19:31for community financial institutions.
- 19:34And when they did that they defined a community financial institution as
- 19:38a community bank under, I think at the time it was a billion dollars.
- 19:42What the, what the legislation would do, I think, is it would add credit
- 19:45unions to that to that definition.
- 19:48Our view on these matters has always been that is a, that's a
- 19:52decision for Congress to make.
- 19:53Absolutely.
- 19:54And that, if they're gonna, make a change y- they should also consider increasing
- 19:59the threshold to, to 10 billion.
- 20:01But ultimately we're gonna, we're gonna follow whatever law that Congress allows.
- 20:06The playbook
- 20:07Mark Treichel: Congress gives you is who you will
- 20:08Ryan Donovan: serve.
- 20:08Yeah.
- 20:09Yeah.
- 20:09I think it's not much different than a credit union, right?
- 20:10Yeah.
- 20:10This is the really, the, the wonderful thing that I've really enjoyed over
- 20:15the last four years is that there isn't much difference between a federal
- 20:18home loan bank and a credit union.
- 20:20Both federally chartered.
- 20:21They operate with limited powers limited field of membership, who
- 20:24they can serve, what they can do.
- 20:26The, Congress has really set up a box, and the responsibility, I think, for
- 20:31both is to how can you have the biggest impact operating within that box, right?
- 20:36Sure.
- 20:37And that's what we try to do.
- 20:38Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 20:38No, that makes perfect sense.
- 20:40Any other takeaways from the hearing that, that you wanna highlight?
- 20:44Ryan Donovan: I, I-- there were several moments in the
- 20:46hearing that stand out to me.
- 20:48I had a, I think, a pretty positive exchange with Representative Pressley from
- 20:53Massachusetts, and it is-- it's, it stuck in my head because of a statistic that
- 20:59she shared, which was in her district, which includes, many of the prestigious
- 21:05universities in Boston, including MIT.
- 21:08If you go just three miles away from MIT, the life expec-expectancy drops 30 years.
- 21:15Mark Treichel: Wow.
- 21:16Ryan Donovan: And that just, that blew me away in the hearing.
- 21:19And her question really got to what can we do to get CDFIs more in the
- 21:26game and leveraging the home loan bank membership to a greater extent.
- 21:32We've explored a couple of solutions to this.
- 21:34You mentioned three three programs that banks are running.
- 21:37In the last administration, we suggested using the CDFI Bond Guarantee
- 21:42Fund to help guarantee advances to C- to CDFIs as one solution.
- 21:46They didn't take us up on that.
- 21:48We'd like to work more closely with F- FHFA to get better supervisory guidance on
- 21:54LIHTC valuation, so we can do more there.
- 21:57There-- the home loan banks are committed to serving their CDFI
- 22:01members to address issues like the ones that were raised at the hearing.
- 22:05But there are some things that the government needs to do,
- 22:07I think to facilitate that.
- 22:09And that, and we work with the CDFI community on that You know, the other
- 22:13moment that that stands out really has to do with the a class of our
- 22:18membership that some people might think why are they involved in this?"
- 22:22The insurance companies.
- 22:23And the, the hearing gave us the opportunity to reinforce that,
- 22:27listen, every member that's coming to the Home Loan Bank for advances
- 22:32is bringing with them housing related assets, whether whole mortgages or
- 22:37mortgage-backed securities that they either originated or bought or invest in.
- 22:42And and that's the nexus to collateral.
- 22:44And for insurance companies, they're some of the largest purchasers of whole
- 22:49loans at MBS in, in the country, and they help keep those markets liquid.
- 22:54And that's important because that provides scale, not just to the home loan banking
- 22:58system, but also to, to those markets in general which is helpful 'cause it, scale
- 23:04helps bring the cost down for everybody.
- 23:06So being able to reinforce that was really critical as well.
- 23:10That's great ⦠no, it was a great opportunity.
- 23:12The, the joke at the end of the hearing was, "We'll see you in 15 years."
- 23:16I hope it's not that long.
- 23:17We need to keep an understanding of home loan banks front and center.
- 23:20And I- that's why I appreciate being on your podcast to, to elevate
- 23:25this to credit unions' attention.
- 23:26Mark Treichel: You got it.
- 23:27Yeah, I always enjoy touching base with you, see what's going on.
- 23:30And as always, I you, I learned a few things, and the timing is great
- 23:33because, 'cause you just had to cram for that big test last week.
- 23:36That's right.
- 23:36And, I
- 23:37Ryan Donovan: got it all in here, I just have to get it out
- 23:38⦠Mark Treichel: yeah exactly.
- 23:39Ryan, I wanna thank you.
- 23:41If someone wants to reach out to you, your organization, what's
- 23:44the best way for them to do that?
- 23:46Ryan Donovan: So both the council and I are both very active on LinkedIn.
- 23:50Council of Federal Home Loan Banks and Ryan Donovan on LinkedIn.
- 23:54And that's a great way to get in touch with us.
- 23:56That, that's probably the, the easiest way.
- 23:58You'll get all of the information that we're putting out, and
- 24:00it's a good way to connect.
- 24:01Mark Treichel: Awesome.
- 24:02All right.
- 24:02Thanks so much, Ryan.
- 24:03And listeners, watchers thanks for listening or watching.
- 24:06I hope you'll do the same again soon.
- 24:08This is Mark Trakel signing off with Flying Colors.