Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When Employees Blow the Whistle: Managing Employer Exposure Under the Federal and California False Claims Acts
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07When Employees Blow the Whistle, Managing Employer
- 0:10Exposure Under the Federal and California False
- 0:13Claims Acts. I'm Alapoli Castro, Director of
- 0:16Education and Professional Development at Beverly
- 0:18Hills Bar Association. And today I'm delighted
- 0:21to introduce our speaker, Deidre Kurtman. Deidre
- 0:25is of counsel at Jackson Lewis where she defends
- 0:28employers in employment litigation and has particular
- 0:31expertise representing government contractors
- 0:34facing false claims act allegations related to
- 0:37retaliation claims. She previously served as
- 0:40an assistant United States attorney representing
- 0:43the federal government in employment disputes
- 0:45and received several Department of Justice awards
- 0:47for that work. During her 20 -year career as
- 0:51a litigator, Deidre has appeared in more than
- 0:53100 cases nationwide and served as first and
- 0:56second chair counsel in federal trials. Deidre
- 0:59is enthusiastic and excited to answer your questions
- 1:02today, so please drop them into the Q &A box
- 1:04on the bottom of your screen. And I'm now going
- 1:06to turn it over to her. Thank you so much for
- 1:09that warm introduction. And I appreciate everyone
- 1:12joining. I'm on the East Coast, so I'm about
- 1:14three hours ahead of you. But I think this is
- 1:18a great lunch hour foray into the Federal False
- 1:22Claims Act, as well as its equivalent under state
- 1:25law, which is the California False Claims Act.
- 1:29Just a little bit. This was noted in the introduction,
- 1:33but I come at this from a federal perspective,
- 1:35having worked at the Department of Justice for
- 1:38over 16 years, most recently as an Assistant
- 1:41United States Attorney in the District of Columbia.
- 1:44And I'm sure some of you have the question, well,
- 1:46what does this have to do with employment law,
- 1:48Deidre? Because you have heard that I'm now working
- 1:52in employment law. Believe it or not, under several
- 1:55of the most recent executive orders that came
- 1:59down during the second Trump administration.
- 2:02Title VII became sort of the core intersection
- 2:05of some of the executive acts that have pulled
- 2:09a lot of the Title VII sort of hiring firing
- 2:12promotion connected to DEI practices, DI hiring,
- 2:17front and center with the False Claims Act. So
- 2:20several of my clients in my current practice
- 2:23are dealing with the False Claims Act as it relates
- 2:26to... CIDs, which are civil investigative demands
- 2:30served by the federal government, the US Department
- 2:34of Justice. And those types of inquiries are
- 2:38very similar to what you might find under California
- 2:42law. So I'm here to tell you just a little bit
- 2:45about the Federal False Claims Act. I take it
- 2:48from the perspective of somebody who represents
- 2:51companies and defends companies. So if you are
- 2:54a plaintiff's attorney, I'm sure that I'm giving
- 2:56you a few nuggets as to how I think about these
- 2:58cases, but I'm glad we can all be in the same
- 3:01space together and learn from one another. Next
- 3:04slide, Jose. Just my standard disclaimer, this
- 3:08is not intended to... Represent any legal counsel
- 3:14legal advice. It is information that it was prepared
- 3:19by Jackson Lewis, which is the law firm where
- 3:22I work. for the attendees' reference and connection
- 3:26with an education seminar today by the Beverly
- 3:29Hills Bar Association. I'd advise that you please
- 3:32speak with counsel before you take any actions
- 3:34and not consider these materials as legal advice
- 3:38or anything else in the advice realm. Next slide,
- 3:42Jose. So I wanna start with sort of where we're
- 3:47going to... what we're going to talk about today.
- 3:50But before I do so, if you can use that question
- 3:54and answer box that was alluded to in the opening
- 3:57introduction. And I'd like to hear from you,
- 4:01if you can just put like a simple yes or no,
- 4:04who has dealt with the False Claims Act or has
- 4:07a general working understanding of it? And it
- 4:11can be either in the Federal False Claims Act,
- 4:14or the California space because we're going to
- 4:17talk a little bit about how California basically
- 4:19has the state law equivalent. So Anne, thanks
- 4:24so much. Bernadette, no. Anybody else that's
- 4:29willing to? Thanks so much, Jason. Heather, no.
- 4:35Anybody else willing to share? Just trying to
- 4:40get a lay of the land. Both. Thanks so much,
- 4:43Jack. Really appreciate it. Well, with these
- 4:53answers, it looks like we mostly have a lot of
- 4:56newbies to this, which is great. Like I said,
- 5:00I'm here to sort of lay the groundwork for you
- 5:02as to what the False Claims Act is, both in the
- 5:05federal and state law realms. Please use this
- 5:09question and answer chat to ask questions as
- 5:13we go and I'll field them as we go so we can
- 5:15have kind of a dialogue, so to speak, back and
- 5:19forth about what I'm presenting today in your
- 5:21questions. So this is what we're going to talk
- 5:25about today. These questions that you might have,
- 5:30I'm sorry, internal complaints that might come
- 5:32in to a workplace, an unexpected subpoena that
- 5:36you might receive from the federal government
- 5:38or something called a key TAM complaint, which
- 5:41I'll explain in a little bit, can return, can
- 5:44turn into like very routine business type decisions
- 5:48or. employment work that you would regularly
- 5:52see day in day out into what can be high stakes
- 5:55litigation very, very quickly. And we see this
- 6:01in the workplace employment law area in connection
- 6:05with retaliation complaints, protected whistleblowing.
- 6:08That's kind of the context that we're talking
- 6:10about, which leads into my second bullet point.
- 6:14Whistleblowers are generally employees, current
- 6:18employees, that you would find in a company who
- 6:21make a complaint of some sort, right? So I like
- 6:24to think about whistleblowers under the general
- 6:27umbrella of someone who makes a complaint. Now,
- 6:32whether a person is actually protected under
- 6:34the law is a separate question, and we'll get
- 6:36to that in a little bit. The key thing driving
- 6:41False Claims Act in the federal area as well
- 6:44as the state law is that whistleblowers can recover
- 6:48very large sums of money when it comes down to
- 6:52what the government, whether that be the federal
- 6:54government or state government, ultimately collects.
- 6:57And this is a powerful incentive and drives whistleblowers
- 7:02to work either in conjunction with the federal
- 7:04government or the state government to bring these
- 7:07types of actions. On the employer side, there
- 7:10is considerable exposure. If these cases proceed,
- 7:16there are trouble damages. There are proclaimed
- 7:18penalties, depending on how you calculate them
- 7:21and what constitutes a claim. There are relator's
- 7:24attorney's fees that would need to be paid by
- 7:26the company if they're found liable. And there's
- 7:29potential retaliation claims that I alluded to
- 7:33earlier within the workplace ambit. generally
- 7:38just workplace claims, but also bring their own
- 7:42attendant liability. So today we're going to
- 7:44focus, that's a lot I understand. So today we're
- 7:46going to focus on how they start, how these claims
- 7:48start, how they grow, and how employers can protect
- 7:53yourselves and companies at every stage of through
- 7:58from complaint to potential litigation. Next
- 8:01slide, Jose. So key TAM basically means relater.
- 8:08It's a term used in this space as someone who
- 8:13alerts the government to a potential fraud that
- 8:16could be brought on the government or has been
- 8:18brought on the government. So I'm going to walk
- 8:21you through how these cases work, both under
- 8:23federal law and California law. Jose, next slide.
- 8:28So there are two separate statutes. On the one
- 8:32hand, we have the Federal False Claims Act, and
- 8:35that's what it's called. That provision is 31
- 8:38U .S. Code 3729 and everything that follows.
- 8:42Those are claims that are paid with federal funds.
- 8:46So think about like in the insurance area, a
- 8:51hospital who receives federal Medicare funds
- 8:54or federal Medicaid funds. right? That type of
- 8:58claim would arise for anything that a company
- 9:01would ultimately seek for payment from the government.
- 9:05So the fraudulent part right in a whistleblower
- 9:09could essentially alert the federal government
- 9:12to a false claim. A claim that was made for payment
- 9:16that shouldn't have been made because that it
- 9:19at the under like the underlying sort of claim
- 9:23that the company made is fraudulent, meaning
- 9:26that the company should not have been paid on
- 9:28the claim made. The same exists on the California
- 9:32side, except that this is California code. So
- 9:36this is California code 12650 through 12656.
- 9:41And specifically, these are claims paid with
- 9:43state or political subdivision funds. Political
- 9:47subdivisions include cities, counties, school
- 9:50districts, and other local agencies. So the way
- 9:53I like to think about this is you can potentially,
- 9:56depending on where you sit, where you're doing
- 9:59business, be liable both under the federal FCA
- 10:03as well as the California FCA. Both of these
- 10:07statutes authorize private relators, or the key
- 10:10tam portion of the statute, to sue on the government's
- 10:14behalf. And again, the false claim portion of
- 10:18these types of claims are that a company has
- 10:22presented a claim, be it either to the federal
- 10:25government or the state government, a claim for
- 10:28payment that is fraudulent at base. Both of these
- 10:33statutes, and I have a nice walk through later,
- 10:36a nice graph to show you sort of how these compare.
- 10:39offer and impose trouble damages plus per -claim
- 10:43civil penalties. And when I talk about per -claim,
- 10:47this is generally each sort of each request that
- 10:51a company would make either to the federal government
- 10:54or to the state government for payment. So as
- 10:59you can imagine, these things add up very, very
- 11:01quickly, right? They're many times viewed from
- 11:05a contractual lens. So each request for payment
- 11:08under a contract is a civil penalty in and of
- 11:11itself. I mean, these can be hundreds of thousands
- 11:15of claims in some cases. And I touched on this
- 11:20just briefly, but there could be a scenario under
- 11:24which a single course of conduct, either whether
- 11:26it be Medi -Cal billing that also asks the federal
- 11:32government for Medicaid billing would for any
- 11:37funded contract could trigger parallel federal
- 11:40and state claims in one complaint. So I definitely
- 11:43can see that as a potential scenario and just
- 11:46want you to be aware that when we think about
- 11:48these cases, we're thinking about both potential
- 11:51federal action as well as state action, depending
- 11:54on what the company is billing to for reimbursement.
- 11:59Next slide, Jose. So how do these cases start?
- 12:05Well, first of all, Most key TAM actions, and
- 12:08I want to stop for a minute. Key TAM actions
- 12:12are those cases that are brought by a by a relator,
- 12:15meaning a whistleblower, somebody that is working
- 12:18in conjunction with the government to let the
- 12:20government know that there is possibly fraudulent
- 12:24activity occurring or fraudulent requests for
- 12:26payment on the government. On the federal side,
- 12:30I will note, and it's becoming increasingly like
- 12:33this, that there doesn't always have to be a
- 12:36relator involved, right? So the Department of
- 12:39Justice, the United States Department of Justice,
- 12:40and this is what I did when I was at the Department
- 12:42of Justice, can bring these cases by themselves
- 12:46without any relator available. I will say where
- 12:51a relator is involved, however, they are typically
- 12:55filed under seal. They're filed in camera under
- 12:59seal served on DOJ with written disclosure of
- 13:03material evidence. and not on defendant, so you
- 13:07don't know as a company whether these things
- 13:09even exist until they're actually unsealed. The
- 13:12initial seal is 60 days minimum at the outset,
- 13:16but are routinely extended for good cause, often
- 13:19for years. I have seen cases filed under seal
- 13:22for many years and the government just has to
- 13:25make a showing that they're continuing to investigate
- 13:29and continuing their investigation for that seal
- 13:31to continue. The same exists with respect to
- 13:35the California code. They are also filed under
- 13:38seal where a relator is involved. They're served
- 13:41on the attorney general. And for local funds,
- 13:44the local prosecuting attorney, it's typically
- 13:46a 60 day seal. It's extendable. And the attorney
- 13:51general notifies the affected subdivision if
- 13:54a subdivision is implicated in the investigation.
- 13:59So what's the reality of this? Well, I touched
- 14:02on this previously. An employer may not know
- 14:06that any of this is going on as a defendant,
- 14:10while government lawyers either at the US Department
- 14:13of Justice or the California Department of Justice
- 14:16interviews employees, issues CIDs or subpoenas,
- 14:20in which case the company would know, and analyzes
- 14:24data. And some of the warning signs that you
- 14:27may pick up on if you are actually under investigation
- 14:30is receipt of a civil investigative demand, which
- 14:33is called a CID. That might be one of your first
- 14:36warning signs. And I can tell you that. Anytime
- 14:39a company receives a CID, I think that these
- 14:43vehicles, these civil investigative demands are
- 14:45super important such that you should get counsel,
- 14:49and I would advise to get counsel involved pretty
- 14:51immediately if anything like that should ever
- 14:54hit your desk. Next slide, Jose. So on the government
- 15:02and intervention part, and again, this is just
- 15:04talking with respect to those cases brought where
- 15:08a relator is involved, the government may ultimately
- 15:13intervene if they believe that there is enough
- 15:16sort of to constitute a false claim or enough
- 15:20to give them a belief that there's something
- 15:23to be investigated. And in that situation where
- 15:27the government intervenes, ultimately the seal
- 15:30will be unsealed. The company will learn about
- 15:34the existence of the complaint. The government
- 15:36leads the prosecution and the relator remains
- 15:39the party. If the government should decline,
- 15:44however, then the relator proceeds alone and
- 15:48the government sort of keeps tabs and then later
- 15:51intervenes for good cause or if there's some
- 15:53sort of settlement. Here's the real hook in these
- 15:56cases though. The relator share, meaning the
- 16:00ultimate amount that is established either through
- 16:03settlement or if it should go to trial through
- 16:06trial, the relator gets a sizable amount of the
- 16:10overall money that goes to the government in
- 16:14conjunction with the relator. On the federal
- 16:17side, it's 15 to 25%. It can go up to 30%. And
- 16:22on the California side, it's 15 to 33%. Again,
- 16:27these are very large sums of money, can be very
- 16:29large sums of money because the way a claim is
- 16:33viewed, is typically every time a company would
- 16:36seek payment to the government. So if a relater
- 16:40comes and tells the government that there are
- 16:43a lot of claims, a lot of times that a company
- 16:45has asked the government for money, these things
- 16:48can add up pretty quickly. And then you add on
- 16:51trouble damages. You add on attorney's fees and
- 16:56the relator's share and you have a very gigantic
- 17:00pot of money, which ultimately means that there
- 17:03is a lot of incentive for relators to give information
- 17:07to the government such that the government can
- 17:10investigate potential false claims violations.
- 17:15If the government should dismiss, that is permitted
- 17:18over a relator objection. The case then just
- 17:22continues with just the just the relator. Next
- 17:26slide. Any questions so far? So I'm monitoring
- 17:31the question and answer box. So here's kind of
- 17:37a nice graph that shows the key differences.
- 17:39I will say just at the outset, there's not a
- 17:41lot of key differences. California is one of
- 17:44those states that has a pretty equivalent to
- 17:49the federal statute, False Claims Act provision
- 17:54on the state side. Like I said, I've kind of
- 17:57walked through the funds cover on the federal
- 18:00side. Those are federal funds, including those
- 18:03passed along through contractors, which a lot
- 18:06of my practice involves on the California side.
- 18:09It's state funds as well as political subdivision
- 18:12fund. The key takeaway on the far right hand
- 18:17column for the funds covered is that you should
- 18:20map if you think you have any exposure. you know,
- 18:24it might be that you just map every source of
- 18:27funding that your company is receiving through
- 18:29contracts or otherwise because, you know, multiple
- 18:33funding schemes can basically, you know, mean
- 18:38that there might be potential exposure through
- 18:41both the federal side and the state side. Well,
- 18:46we talked about the seal, typically 60 days initially,
- 18:49but they're always extended. in most cases. The
- 18:54related share intervened and declined are different,
- 18:59right? On the California side, if declined, the
- 19:02related share increases to 50 % from 33. There
- 19:07are self -disclosure credits of double damages
- 19:12that would be credited back to the company if
- 19:14some sort of self -disclosure resulted. The same
- 19:18core remedies exist with respect to retaliation.
- 19:22And I'm going to stop for a minute here and sort
- 19:25of walk you through what a retaliation claim
- 19:27is on a whistleblower complaint. These are a
- 19:31little different because False Claims Act liability
- 19:35is one sort of method of liability in which a
- 19:39company would be liable to a government, right?
- 19:44Whether it's a federal or state. Sometimes we
- 19:47see what's called FCA retaliation liability when
- 19:52an employer suggests that a company was potentially
- 19:56defrauding the government and then took action
- 19:59against an employee when that employee blew the
- 20:03whistle. And so the retaliation complaints are
- 20:08different and separate and apart from potential
- 20:11FCA liability. So that's why I said you have
- 20:15a completely different liability stream there
- 20:18if that should happen. They also have different
- 20:21remedies, right? So if a company were to be found
- 20:25liable under a false claims act retaliation theory
- 20:29of liability, employees can be reinstated. They
- 20:32can be entitled to two times back pay, special
- 20:36damages, fees, as well as front pay. I'll note
- 20:41that on the California side for retaliation claims
- 20:44under the False Claims Act, there is an overlapping
- 20:48labor code provision that establishes the liability
- 20:51on that side, and that's 1102 .5. It's a different
- 20:55burden than you typically see in employment cases
- 20:59that are viewed under the McDonnell Douglas burden
- 21:03-shifting framework and instead are viewed under
- 21:07a clear and convincing burden for employers.
- 21:10Next slide, Jose. So what's some of the risk
- 21:15that arises in these cases with respect to both
- 21:19statutes? Next slide. So generally, if we were
- 21:26to sort of take a macro view here of the federal
- 21:30provision, which is 31 USC 3730, who does it
- 21:35protect? It protects employees, contractors,
- 21:39and agents. It can and I, and again, I'm sorry,
- 21:44I'm sort of. Talking a little bit out of both
- 21:47sides of my mouth here, so I want to be clear.
- 21:50This is the specific anti retaliation provision
- 21:52that I was just talking about in terms of protections
- 21:55that the act gives for. employees who might experience
- 22:00adverse actions because of the fact that they
- 22:03blew the whistle. So just drilling down on what
- 22:06this provision says, this is a provision that
- 22:09is part of the Overall False Claims Act, but
- 22:12is specifically found at 3730 -H. And like I
- 22:16said, it protects employees, contractors, and
- 22:19agents. It protects them from blowing the whistle
- 22:24and then experiencing a host of adverse actions.
- 22:29So discharge, demotion, suspension, threats,
- 22:32harassment, other discrimination. This is, again,
- 22:36still viewed under the adverse action, so it
- 22:38actually has to affect pay. and have an adverse
- 22:43act on, I'm sorry, have an adverse effect on
- 22:46the pay or remuneration they receive in their
- 22:48employment. So the protected activity under 3730
- 22:52is lawful acts and furtherance of an FCA action.
- 22:56And what that means is notifying someone, notifying
- 23:01someone who would have the ability to take action,
- 23:05an adverse action against someone in a job for
- 23:09blowing the whistle on potential fraudulent activity
- 23:13that a company commits against either the federal
- 23:16government or the state government. The actions
- 23:23can either be the act to stop, meaning trying
- 23:28to stop the fraudulent activity from happening
- 23:30or other efforts to stop one or more FCA violations.
- 23:36For FCA retaliation, cases, there is no filed
- 23:40Ketam action, right? So these are internal reports
- 23:44and investigations that you might see in just
- 23:48the day -to -day of employment. And that's why
- 23:52it's really important to sort of drill down on
- 23:54the procedures that you have with respect to
- 23:57investigating complaints, and we'll get to that
- 23:59in a little bit. But we're seeing a lot of these
- 24:02pop up. In fact, in my employment practice here,
- 24:05this is the one area that I've seen expand pretty
- 24:09exponentially. And that's because this provision,
- 24:14which is an employment provision, you know, can
- 24:18protect a lot of different people that may not
- 24:21be otherwise protected under Title VII or other
- 24:25traditional employment anti -discrimination statutes.
- 24:30And that's because it's protecting the activity
- 24:33of blowing the whistle. The key element here
- 24:36is that the employer had knowledge of the protected
- 24:39activity and this is a key defense. It's a frequent
- 24:43battleground in these cases right out of the
- 24:47gate on emotion to dismiss or after discovery
- 24:50in emotion for summary judgment. The remedies,
- 24:54like I said previously, can include reinstatement,
- 24:57two times back pay plus interest, front pay,
- 25:01special damages, fees, attorney's fees and costs.
- 25:05The statute of limitations is three years from
- 25:08the retaliation, the adverse act. And the key
- 25:12takeaway here is, right, retaliation claims often
- 25:16survive when the fraudulent theory, meaning that
- 25:20a false claims act Claim was made on the government
- 25:23fails and that's because these claims survive
- 25:27when employees think that they are blowing the
- 25:30whistle when they are telling a company of protect.
- 25:34Potentially fragile and activity and then the
- 25:36government takes them. I'm sorry then the company
- 25:38takes some sort of adverse action and that's
- 25:40how these claims arise. Next slide so on the
- 25:47California side. We have similar protections,
- 25:53right? So 12653 and the labor code 1102 .5 are
- 25:59the key provisions here. The code at section
- 26:0412653 is very similar to the federal code. It
- 26:07protects employees, contractors, and agents for
- 26:10acts and furtherance of a California False Claims
- 26:13Act action or efforts to stop. The remedies are
- 26:17the same, reinstatement, two times back pay,
- 26:20interest, special damages, fees, in addition
- 26:23to punitive damages where appropriate. And I
- 26:27touched on this on the federal side, but the
- 26:30California Labor Code is similar in that it protects
- 26:32the disclosures of employees who reasonably believe
- 26:36that there have been violations or fraudulent
- 26:38claims made to the California government, to
- 26:41law enforcement, or political subdivisions. There's
- 26:47a separate burden of proof under the Labor Code
- 26:49of California. The employee has to have engaged
- 26:54in protected activity, which was a contributing
- 26:57factor. The employer has to show by a clear and
- 27:02convincing evidence standard that the same decision,
- 27:05the same adverse action, whether that be firing,
- 27:09demotion, suspension of pay would have occurred
- 27:12anyway in the absence of the protected activity.
- 27:17And the key case here is Lawson v PPG architectural
- 27:22finishes. It is not a McDonnell Douglas burden
- 27:26shifting framework. So it is a specific and different
- 27:30burden shifting under the California Labor Code.
- 27:35A few questions here from Jack, and I'm just
- 27:39seeing these. I'm sorry, Jack. His first question
- 27:41is, do federal juries generally get to larger
- 27:43numbers in your experience? Yes. So my experience
- 27:48with juries is that when juries are presented
- 27:52with facts where they think that... somebody
- 27:55needs protection in some way, which whistleblowers
- 27:59kind of fit within that ambit, you can get to
- 28:02very large numbers of potential jury awards and
- 28:06what I would call like, you know, runaway jury
- 28:09verdicts because juries really take to individuals
- 28:13who make complaints on potential fraudulent activity,
- 28:16right? They're seen and viewed by juries very
- 28:19favorably such that you know, as a defense person,
- 28:25I am typically looking for ways out prior to
- 28:27a jury or verdict rendering a potential verdict.
- 28:34Jack, the next question, is this exponentially
- 28:37in federal court or in state court or both? I
- 28:40would say both. I don't have as much experience
- 28:43in state court, but the thing that worries me,
- 28:46you know, just from a practitioner's standpoint
- 28:48on the California side is punitive damages are
- 28:52an available remedy, right? And so especially
- 28:55with these types of cases, where there is found
- 28:59to be willful conduct, which these types of claims
- 29:02kind of fit right within that framework, punitive
- 29:07damages are real and realistic. And that should
- 29:10be something that is assessed very quickly upfront
- 29:14when confronting these cases. Jack, I'm gonna
- 29:18have to get back to you on the corporate veil
- 29:21getting pierced more readily. You know, typically
- 29:26these will proceed against companies that if
- 29:30there are subsidiaries and whatnot, it sort of
- 29:33depends on the corporate structure. But so long
- 29:37as there is somebody that has a connection to
- 29:39the company, who the complaint was made to and
- 29:43who also had the responsibility or could take
- 29:46an adverse action, a corporate entity can potentially
- 29:53be on the hook. Next slide. So, look, thinking
- 30:00about discipline and termination decisions, and
- 30:03I think that this is really where the rubber
- 30:05hits the road. From a practitioner standpoint,
- 30:09I always advise to treat any adverse action against
- 30:14a known reporter as a high risk decision requiring
- 30:18legal review. In fact, this is one of the first
- 30:21questions that I will always ask when advising
- 30:24my own clients, considering a termination or
- 30:27even an adverse action that would result in a
- 30:31suspension of pay, or even for that matter, though
- 30:34technically not adverse administrative leave.
- 30:37And that is whether a client, whether a company
- 30:40knows whether this individual has made a complaint
- 30:43to supervisors, to an internal hotline, to HR.
- 30:51Any of those three things, any internal complaints
- 30:54need to be assessed very carefully in conjunction
- 30:59with potential actions taken against the employee.
- 31:04So after you sort of establish potential discipline
- 31:08and termination and whether there is a known
- 31:11reporter, the next question will be to confirm
- 31:15the decision maker's knowledge and document who
- 31:19knew what and when. If the decision maker actually
- 31:22had knowledge of the complaint, then that becomes
- 31:26a very big problem very quickly. The further
- 31:30that the decision maker is from the person who
- 31:33actually received the complaint, the better because
- 31:35this is a key defense. And that defense is that
- 31:39the decision maker who ultimately makes the decision
- 31:41as to the potentially adverse action has to have
- 31:44knowledge or knew of the protected activity and
- 31:47made the decision anyway. If there is, you know,
- 31:52a complaint, knowledge by decision maker of the
- 31:56protected activity, then my next sort of step
- 31:59in advising any client or potential client would
- 32:03be to anchor any decision making in pre -existing
- 32:07documented performance or contact issues. And
- 32:10this is what I find myself advising a lot, especially
- 32:14when I present, but it's so important to document
- 32:18any decision that you make with respect to an
- 32:21employee, even if it involves a performance issue,
- 32:24a known performance issue, and to establish documentation
- 32:28early and often. Because once these types of
- 32:33complaints arise, you can't go back in time and
- 32:37suddenly start creating the documentation that
- 32:39should have been created in the first instance.
- 32:42So just from a baseline point of advice, I am
- 32:47always advised and will always consistently advise
- 32:50clients to always document and do it often and
- 32:54consistently. Because the first time that any
- 32:57problem arises, my first question as an employment
- 33:00law practitioner will be, is it documented? The
- 33:05fourth point is to apply policies consistently.
- 33:09So you'll want to compare whether anybody else
- 33:11has made a whistleblowing complaint or a complaint
- 33:15period and whether that person is similarly situated
- 33:19to the known reporter. You should, and this is
- 33:23my sort of next big takeaway in addition to documentation,
- 33:27is watch timing carefully, very carefully. So
- 33:32proximity and time to a report or to cover conduct
- 33:37invites an inference of causation, especially
- 33:42under California law. So I can't highlight this
- 33:45enough. Documentation then becomes super, super
- 33:50important, right? Because if you have a situation
- 33:54where timing is in close conjunction, the adverse
- 33:58action is in close conjunction with the known
- 34:01reporter making a complaint and you don't have
- 34:06documentation, then it is going to be very bad
- 34:10from the perspective of potential liability.
- 34:13As sort of a corollary to documentation, to it
- 34:17often and consistently, I would also advise to
- 34:23avoid sudden write -ups, sudden reassignments,
- 34:27exclusion from meetings after a report. You want
- 34:30to be very sensitive to the things that happen
- 34:32after the known reporter makes the complaint.
- 34:37Separation agreements cannot bar reporting to
- 34:40the government or waive a relator's key TAM share.
- 34:43So when you're doing separation agreements, either
- 34:46work with counsel that you've already retained
- 34:48or ensure that there is a provision that does
- 34:51not bar key TAM complaints or complaints to the
- 34:54government. Next slide. So with all of that sort
- 35:01of as like the broad sweep of how to look at
- 35:04these cases, generally as it relates to complaints,
- 35:09I wanted to pivot in this presentation and talk
- 35:12about how you should be handling internal reports.
- 35:17Next slide, Jose. So the key thing is investigation.
- 35:24I, at the first instance, would recommend that
- 35:26everybody take a look at your handbook if you
- 35:28have one. And if you don't, think about getting
- 35:31one in place. And be sure that that handbook
- 35:35outlines how employees can make complaints. There
- 35:40should be an established ability, an established
- 35:43framework for an employee to make a complaint.
- 35:47Outside of that, every complaint that is made
- 35:51needs to be triaged promptly. So I see this often
- 35:57in cases where companies do not investigate promptly.
- 36:01or companies don't acknowledge complaints, and
- 36:05that silence drives employees to file or to file
- 36:09a demand letter or to file a complaint. And in
- 36:14the False Claims Act and California False Claims
- 36:18Act scenario or with respect to retaliation under
- 36:22both statutes, you know, the key factors that
- 36:25you want to think about are the company's use
- 36:28of government funds, potential dollar exposure
- 36:31in those contracts, the seniority of the people
- 36:36implicated, meaning those who are complained
- 36:38about, and even potential criminal conduct. These
- 36:43things can go on to the criminal side, depending
- 36:46on the statutes that are involved. So once a
- 36:50complaint comes in through an established framework,
- 36:53you need to set up the investigation. So engage
- 36:56counsel early. Define the scope of the representation
- 37:00early in writing. Issue a very targeted litigation
- 37:04hold as soon as a complaint comes in. Suspend
- 37:08your auto deletion of IT systems, of emails,
- 37:12of Teams messages, of Slack channels, even potentially
- 37:16the use of AI if you have that in the workplace.
- 37:20And use independent investigators and outside
- 37:23counsel for senior leader allegations, as well
- 37:25as allegations that might be particularly egregious.
- 37:30That's kind of my cutoff line. I certainly understand
- 37:33when companies want to use their own internal
- 37:36investigation teams, and that's perfectly acceptable.
- 37:40I will caution, though, with leadership that
- 37:43involves senior level leader positions or Allegations
- 37:48that seem to be egregious think sexual harassment,
- 37:53sexual assault. I advise that outside counsel
- 37:57or independent investigators be become involved
- 37:59in those situations. In terms of interviewing,
- 38:05you want to consider interviewing the reporter
- 38:08first, reaffirm that your company has a non -retaliation
- 38:13policy, and then close the loop with the complainant
- 38:18after the investigation is completed. You should
- 38:22also evaluate any duties that you have, for example,
- 38:26under the federal acquisition regulations and
- 38:30their mandatory disclosures. The next slide,
- 38:33Jose. One of the key issues or one of the big
- 38:39issues that comes up with investigations and
- 38:43investigating false claims act retaliation claims
- 38:46are privilege issues and work product issues.
- 38:51So sort of the other reason why I typically recommend
- 38:56involving outside counsel is that privilege is
- 39:01more delineated in terms of when you can establish
- 39:04it. So involving outside counsel early helps
- 39:10you preserve privilege with respect to attorney
- 39:13-client privilege as well as work product. This
- 39:18first bullet that talks about structure being
- 39:20counsel directed for the purpose of legal advice,
- 39:23that is a key tenant of the attorney client privilege.
- 39:27And when you involve outside counsel in investigations,
- 39:31that privilege attaches. In the interviews themselves,
- 39:35you should always use up John warnings, meaning
- 39:38that counsel represents the company which controls
- 39:41the privilege and not the employee. which does
- 39:46not control the privilege. Instead, that belongs
- 39:48to the company itself. For third parties, you
- 39:53can retain consultants and forensic accountants
- 39:56through counsel to keep that privilege intact.
- 40:00You should always mark materials as attorney
- 40:04-client privilege, attorney -work product, but
- 40:07those labels themselves do not create the privilege.
- 40:09Rather, it goes to the content of the information
- 40:13included in the materials. You should also plan
- 40:18on any waiver of potential privilege. There may
- 40:21come a point in these investigations where you
- 40:23want to share with the government for cooperation
- 40:26credit purposes, but that will waive the privilege
- 40:30protection as to the government as well as the
- 40:34relator itself. So waiver planning is something
- 40:38that really should be done in conjunction with
- 40:41council. Next slide, Jose. So the other sort
- 40:52of best practices that I offer in this area is,
- 40:56you know, keep business communications factual.
- 41:00Do not talk about labels that are tied to words
- 41:06like fraud, legalistic terms. Do not have non
- 41:11-lawyers draft investigation summaries or legal
- 41:14conclusions. And you should always assume that
- 41:17every email, chat, or text will be an Exhibit
- 41:20A in this type of litigation. And when you're
- 41:24investigating, when you are communicating with
- 41:28a reporter, please do not make accusations of
- 41:31disloyalty. Never ask them to stop digging because
- 41:35that represents that you are trying to stop their
- 41:37efforts to disclose potential fraud. Santa traps,
- 41:46I offer a few here just in terms of when representing
- 41:51a company, you know, a company should always
- 41:54be cognizant that any ignorance or slow walking
- 41:58of responding to. Sorry, responding to a report
- 42:03can establish deliberate ignorance or reckless
- 42:06disregard. So you want to be prompt in responding
- 42:09to complaints and investigation of complaints.
- 42:14And if there is a complaint about billing to
- 42:17the government, if that is the protected potential
- 42:21fraudulent activity, you may want to think about
- 42:26discontinuing billing after receiving notice
- 42:29because that can be strong evidence of continued
- 42:32knowledge and instead you'll want to remediate
- 42:35those, remediate as much as possible promptly
- 42:38after receiving the complaint. Preservation is
- 42:43super important especially in the trial context
- 42:46so please do not destroy, and spoil or obstruct
- 42:51because that will eventually take over the entire
- 42:56case and can potentially invite a finding of
- 43:00a negative inference against the company. Next
- 43:02slide. So the fourth part of today, and I know
- 43:09I'm hitting a lot of different subjects, but
- 43:11I'm hoping that this all sort of gives you some
- 43:15general ideas to think more broadly about these
- 43:18cases. Next slide, Jose. So how should you think
- 43:23about compliance programs? I touched on this
- 43:26briefly earlier, but I think that reporting channels
- 43:30and hotlines are very important. So these are
- 43:34channels and hotlines that should be specifically
- 43:37delineated in your employee handbook. They should
- 43:40be prominently featured on internal websites
- 43:43for employees as to how to report potential fraudulent
- 43:48activity. detected, the more communication and
- 43:53availability to the employee, the better. So
- 43:56this means multiple channels, supervisor, compliance,
- 44:00legal, HR, and an anonymous hotline. As much
- 44:04communication as can be made about noting to
- 44:09employees that they can. raise issues to their
- 44:12supervisor, to compliance to legal, to HR, the
- 44:15better. You want to have multiple channels for
- 44:17these types of communications. You should publicize
- 44:22and memorialize these channels in handbooks,
- 44:25in postings, in annual training, and that retaliation
- 44:29for protected activity is prohibited and that
- 44:33you have an anti -retaliation policy as part
- 44:36of your company or corporate policy. Once the
- 44:40complaints come in, you should also track the
- 44:43every report that with every report made the
- 44:47sort of next step with respect to the investigation.
- 44:51So from intake to investigation resolution and
- 44:55closure, all of those things should be tracked
- 44:57in writing. memo to files are very helpful in
- 45:00this regard. If possible, and it isn't in violation
- 45:04of your company policy, you might also want to
- 45:07think about closing the loop with reporters where
- 45:09possible. And then finally, I would Recommend
- 45:18or this slide recommends routing reports, touching
- 45:21government funds to legal for FCA valuation.
- 45:24So anytime that there is a whistle blowing complaint
- 45:28that you can tie to the potential payment for
- 45:32government funds, that should be legal, should
- 45:36be directed to legal or outside counsel for potential
- 45:39exposure under the false claims act. Next slide.
- 45:47So here's some of the federal training requirements
- 45:51and best practices that I recommend. If you're
- 45:55a federal contractor meeting with the Department
- 45:57of Justice, there are requirements for you to
- 46:00have an ethics program, internal controls, as
- 46:03well as hotline posters. Here's a specific example
- 46:07in the healthcare area. The Department of Health
- 46:10and Human Services and its Office of Internal,
- 46:13I'm sorry, Inspector General has a general compliance
- 46:16program guidance. There it recommends training
- 46:19as a core element. California requires supervisor
- 46:23harassment training. as well as whistleblower
- 46:25posting and hotline. So in addition to some of
- 46:28the things that I noted earlier on the previous
- 46:31slides, there are legal requirements depending
- 46:33on what type of contractor you are and what type
- 46:36of government funds you may be receiving. So
- 46:40in terms of best practices, I recommend teaching
- 46:43managers to recognize, escalate, and respond
- 46:46to protected activity. Managers are some of your
- 46:50frontline people who can detect these things
- 46:52and further insulate the company against potential
- 46:56liability if a whistleblower complaint arises.
- 47:01Next slide. So changing gears here to part five.
- 47:08And this is the final part. So if you have questions,
- 47:11please bring them up in the chat. And this is
- 47:14really sort of like everything that we've talked
- 47:16about before is more advice and counsel, right?
- 47:19Things that you can do as a company to be aligned
- 47:23in a best practice situation to limit potential
- 47:28liability on the flip side if a complaint should
- 47:30be made. I'm going to talk a little bit about
- 47:34litigation and resolution strategy. There are
- 47:37things that you can do on the front end to also
- 47:40help potential exposure should these cases go
- 47:43through litigation. And this involves a lot of
- 47:48law. So I am going to point to a couple of cases
- 47:50in this section. And I hope that you can bear
- 47:53with me with a few citations to cases. I am sorry.
- 48:04Can you go to the next slide, Jose? There we
- 48:09go. And the next slide. So early case assessment
- 48:16is key to determining potential liability and
- 48:22how you're going to think about these cases.
- 48:27You want to do an early case assessment. So identify
- 48:30the funding streams. Is this a federal funding
- 48:33stream? Is it state? Is it local or is a combination
- 48:36of the three? The next thing you're going to
- 48:39want to do is map the person making the complaint.
- 48:43Is he or she an insider? Is he or she a current
- 48:46employee or an outside employee? Because it can
- 48:52be somebody who was ultimately terminated and
- 48:57suggests that they made some sort of complaint
- 48:58before termination. The employer's role in the
- 49:03organization. what type of access the employee
- 49:05had, the potential motive, or any retaliation
- 49:09claim. You're also going to want to evaluate
- 49:12the merits. So I offer a few potential defenses
- 49:16here for your consideration. The first is I want
- 49:22to talk about CNTER. There is a CNTER defense
- 49:26to these cases that is represented in the case
- 49:30called shoot the super value. Actually, Jose,
- 49:35can we go back two slides? So this is the case
- 49:42super value that offers a CNTER defense. And
- 49:46it really rises and falls on knowledge. So if
- 49:51I could just share a little case law. The super
- 49:53value case was a False Claims Act case. That
- 49:57arose on allegations that a pharmacy operator
- 50:02was overcharging and overbilling Medicare and
- 50:05Medicaid programs when seeking reimbursement
- 50:08for prescription drugs. And so. What this case
- 50:13ultimately looked at, the Supreme Court looked
- 50:15at, is the False Claims Act Sienta requirement
- 50:17under Section 37 and 29, and really the operator's
- 50:23knowledge and subjective beliefs as to what the
- 50:29complaint meant to the company when the complaint
- 50:32came in. The center defense is a good one if
- 50:38the complaint when it's made is not understood
- 50:41by the company as being one of suggesting that
- 50:46there is potential fraud on the government. So,
- 50:50you know, a simple compliance complaint may not
- 50:54rise to a false claims act retaliation claim,
- 50:59where it's just the day in day out. compliance
- 51:03complaint that an employee suggests is problematic.
- 51:10So super value is really important with respect
- 51:12to the CNTER requirement because when you're
- 51:16operating a company, you want to document what
- 51:19is specifically compliance and what are compliance
- 51:22interpretations as opposed to potential fraudulent
- 51:27activity on the government, right? Like billing
- 51:29practices, that sort of thing. Because compliance
- 51:32alone in some cases or complaints about compliance
- 51:35alone may not rise to the standard of something
- 51:38that would warrant a retaliation under the False
- 51:43Claims Act. The second sort of defense that fits
- 51:47within the strategy of litigating these cases
- 51:50is government knowledge. The key case here is
- 51:55Escobar. It's a 2016 case, so it predated super
- 51:58value. In an Escobar, the Supreme Court talked
- 52:03or thought about the implied false certification
- 52:06theory and found that, excuse me, a false certification
- 52:11can incur liability under the False Claims Act.
- 52:16And that false certification theory is one in
- 52:20which the claim does not just require payment
- 52:23directly, but makes specific representations
- 52:26about the goods or services provided. And a failure
- 52:31to disclose noncompliance with material statutory,
- 52:35regulatory, or contractual requirements makes
- 52:38those misrepresentations or representations half
- 52:41-truths. And so these are the types of claims
- 52:46that you're seeing or may see or may have some
- 52:49level of familiarity with when the Department
- 52:52of Justice, the Federal Department of Justice
- 52:54is using Title VII now in its sort of strategies
- 52:58under the most recent executive order earlier
- 53:01this year to suggest that companies who have
- 53:04DEI -focused hiring or promotion plans violate
- 53:10Title VII. when they utilize DEI programs. And
- 53:15I'm not saying this is right or wrong. I'm just
- 53:17saying that this is generally the theory that
- 53:18the government is working on, that every time,
- 53:21you know, a government contractor is making a
- 53:25signature on that contract and the certification,
- 53:27if there's a certification, in order to receive
- 53:30funds that it's complying with federal law, this
- 53:33federal government views that as a potential
- 53:36material fraudulent request for payment. We've
- 53:45talked about the retaliation defenses, but the
- 53:49big thing here is if there is performance issues,
- 53:51you need to do any documentation contemporaneous
- 53:55with that performance deficiency and do it for
- 53:58every employee. And in terms of records retention,
- 54:02adopt and follow policies consistently and do
- 54:06risk assessments, especially if you're receiving
- 54:08federal and state funds in your company. Okay,
- 54:12now I think we can go back to slide 24. Thanks,
- 54:18Jose. So what happens if you happen to be a company
- 54:23where one of these civil investigative demands
- 54:26lands in your lap? I'm actually working with
- 54:30a few clients today in this area, and I can tell
- 54:34you that the number one thing that you want to
- 54:36do is to cooperate with the government early
- 54:40and often. So one of the first things that I
- 54:44would recommend is obtaining and engaging outside
- 54:47counsel and having counsel pick up the phone
- 54:51and call DOJ just to acknowledge receipt of the
- 54:55CID and to work towards some sort of resolution
- 54:58or at least initial resolution of how the company
- 55:01is going to respond to the CID. And the same
- 55:04can be true on the California side as well. But
- 55:08you want to respond to the CIDs and subpoenas
- 55:11cooperatively. Obstructionist behavior is typically
- 55:15not viewed favorably by the government. So, you
- 55:20know, even if you have a problem with the scope,
- 55:25That is something that can be negotiated. You
- 55:27can also negotiate rolling productions. CIDs
- 55:31will typically have a 30 -day timeline and deadline
- 55:34for you to collect a huge volume of documents
- 55:38that have likely arrived on your desk by surprise
- 55:44as a request. So that's why it's really important
- 55:47to work with the government immediately when
- 55:50you get these types of requests. Just a simple
- 55:53acknowledgement is a lot, as well as a second
- 55:57call to negotiate the scope and the timing of
- 56:00productions. If you suspect that a relator is
- 56:05involved, you may want to consider requesting
- 56:07a partial lift of the seal so that the company
- 56:10can learn of the underlying allegations. And
- 56:14DOJ and federal courts will often permit the
- 56:18disclosure of the complaint to the defendant
- 56:19to give the defendant a better idea. of what
- 56:23the complaint involves and that will inform your
- 56:26investigation. It will inform your production
- 56:29and it will inform how you move forward in the
- 56:32litigation. The best time to shape any outcome
- 56:38of a government investigation is early. So you
- 56:42want to do that before government intervention
- 56:46before the government makes the decision to intervene
- 56:49in the case. That is when the government can
- 56:51be most helpful in closing these cases and that
- 56:55ties back to my recommendation generally to work
- 56:59in conjunction with the government early and
- 57:01to keep the lines of communication open and frequent.
- 57:08You'll also want to coordinate any federal and
- 57:10local or AG investigations if you know of them.
- 57:15to avoid any inconsistent positions in the federal
- 57:19and state litigation, and generally consider
- 57:24how cooperation under the DOJ's False Claims
- 57:27Act cooperation policy can help you. And that's
- 57:30why my advice on this slide is to obtain and
- 57:35retain outside counsel, work in conjunction with
- 57:38them to make a call, and start working with DOJ
- 57:41where appropriate. And you should also think
- 57:45about managing employees who may be witnesses
- 57:47or even the relator if a current employee without
- 57:50interference or retaliation. It's also super,
- 57:53super important that you issue a litigation hold
- 57:56at the outset. Two minutes, so I wanna go forward
- 58:03to slide 26, Jose. This is kind of everything
- 58:09that wraps today's presentation. And I think
- 58:14puts it in one slide and is sort of your key
- 58:16takeaway for today and potential action items.
- 58:20And that is to spot red flags. So monitor CIDs,
- 58:24monitor audits, any billing anomalies that might
- 58:28result as something that comes out of an audit.
- 58:33And at the same time, monitor employee complaints
- 58:36that touch any government funds. You need to
- 58:40think next about responding carefully to any
- 58:43internal complaints. Triage every report promptly,
- 58:46involve counsel, and preserve privilege from
- 58:49day one. And you do that by involving either
- 58:51internal or outside counsel. Protect reporters.
- 58:56So require legal review of any adverse action
- 58:59against an employee who raised a concern. And
- 59:01this is super, super important. It helps with
- 59:05liability down the line, and it ensures that
- 59:08defenses can remain intact should litigation
- 59:10proceed. Strengthen your program for reporting
- 59:15complaints. So test your hotlines. Tailor your
- 59:19training. Include anti -retaliation provisions
- 59:22in your handbook, in your anti -discrimination
- 59:24annual training, and then document what you believe
- 59:28to be compliance versus whistleblowing. Think
- 59:32dual track. So any time that you may have funds
- 59:37from a contractual standpoint that touch on state
- 59:40and federal, think about potential exposure on
- 59:43both sides and evaluate those potential retaliation
- 59:47claims together because both acts exist on the
- 59:50federal and state sides. And then if you are
- 59:54handed one of these CIDs or face litigation,
- 59:58consider self -disclosure. At the outset, if
- 1:00:01you find it before you receive a CID, consider
- 1:00:04cooperating with the government and the credit
- 1:00:07that you get from that cooperation. And as a
- 1:00:11very, very key takeaway, if a CID should land
- 1:00:14on your desk, please, I would recommend early
- 1:00:17engagement with the government and retention
- 1:00:19of outside counsel. And with that, we're right
- 1:00:22at 430. I will take questions. I'm happy to stay
- 1:00:26on the line. I know that this was a lot of information.
- 1:00:30It was really shaped today, though, to give you
- 1:00:32sort of a taste of key issues that... come up
- 1:00:38in this area and there's a lot. It's a really
- 1:00:40hot area. It's very fruitful in terms of relators
- 1:00:45and potential remedies and huge settlement awards
- 1:00:49that many of these things can be mitigated just
- 1:00:54by the establishment of a very, very good hotline
- 1:00:57reporting system. and consistent audits, especially
- 1:01:01if you're in the area of interacting and utilizing
- 1:01:05government funds, whether it be on the state
- 1:01:07or federal sites. Any questions? Well, with that,
- 1:01:24I want to thank everyone for joining over your
- 1:01:26lunch today. Please feel free to reach out. My
- 1:01:30name, my email can be found on my firm biography.
- 1:01:35It's didra .kurdeman at JacksonLewis .com. And
- 1:01:40I would welcome a call to help out in any way
- 1:01:42as you think about these issues. And Jose, if
- 1:01:46you can go back to slide two, there's my contact
- 1:01:49information should anybody need it. The people
- 1:01:55watching, one second. And it will also be inside
- 1:02:08the materials link that you received. Yeah, so
- 1:02:13there's my email if you need it. Happy to be
- 1:02:16a sounding board if you want to just pick up
- 1:02:19the phone and call me. But with that, thank you
- 1:02:21so much for your time today. I appreciate it
- 1:02:23and wish you all well.