Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Natalia Grace Documentary Reaction (Chapter 1)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. This episode is an audio version of a number of
- 0:04videos that I posted on YouTube in which I reacted to a documentary about Natalia
- 0:12Grace. If you're familiar with the story and or the documentary, and normally
- 0:18I don't do this, I've been doing this a little bit more lately,
- 0:21but I thought about it, and I thought that you all might actually want
- 0:26to hear this this stuff because it gets into a lot of things that I
- 0:32think are interesting and very psychologically oriented. Of course, you can watch the
- 0:37videos on YouTube if you want, but for some of you you're this you're
- 0:43like me and that you listen while you're commuting or while you're doing chores and
- 0:47you can't really watch something during that time. Plus, I thought it'd be
- 0:52kind of interesting to compile all twenty six videos into three audio episodes because I
- 1:00didn't want to take up the audio feed with a bunch of episodes on this,
- 1:03so I crammed a lot of audio footage into just three episodes. So
- 1:11the episodes for this week will be this, and each episode is going to
- 1:18be long because of that. I think each episode will be a few hours.
- 1:23So if you're into this sort of stuff, then this will be interesting
- 1:26to you, I suppose, But if you're not, then the episodes this
- 1:30week might not be particularly up your alley or you watch the videos. But
- 1:34I can also imagine, even if you saw the videos as they came out,
- 1:38the audio version might be kind of interesting to kind of hear, because
- 1:42it's interesting for me because by the time I get to the end of this
- 1:46documentary, I have gone so many different places, So it's kind of interesting
- 1:49to listen to my thoughts at the very beginning of watching this documentary. So
- 1:55if you're not familiar the story, at least the way it's advertised, as
- 2:00you have Natalia Grace, who is this Ukrainian girl who is adopted into an
- 2:07American family in the United States, and soon after adoption, or at some
- 2:14point after adoption, the parents start to suspect that the child is not indeed
- 2:19a child, is not four years old or five years old, but is
- 2:22in fact a twenty two year old woman who is posing as a child,
- 2:27and then the story gets wilder and interesting or from there. I'm not even
- 2:36joying. If I just heard the tagline, which I don't think I knew
- 2:42at the beginning, I would have been like Okay, you know it's interesting,
- 2:45but there's so many details this and personalities and really just horrible things,
- 2:53honestly, So I thought that I would share this with you, and what
- 3:00you will hear is me watching the video clips and reacting. I imagine that
- 3:07it's not a terrible difference than watching the videos because you know, there's not
- 3:12a lot of visual details that you need to absorb. You know, there's
- 3:16a lot of audio, So I imagine that the audio version actually is pretty
- 3:22pretty close to the videos anyway. So let's get to that. Hey,
- 3:27deserving listeners, a lot of you, and I mean a lot of you
- 3:29have been asking me to react to this documentary on HBO called The Curious Case
- 3:35of Natalie Grace. I have no idea what this documentary is about. It
- 3:40looks like there's a young child involved. I'm not sure. My name is
- 3:45doctor Kirk Honda. I'm a therapist and a professor. Let's watch. They
- 3:47say, Hey, we know you, We've seen your home study. We
- 3:53know that you have a charity for special needs children. You've been doing that
- 3:55for a decade. What do you think you'd be perfect for this little girl
- 4:00that's going to be coming to us she's a little person. She has dwarphism.
- 4:03Now here's the problem. You got twenty four hours to decide. So
- 4:09I've been watching and actually keeping notes. I also noticed at the beginning of
- 4:13the documentary was basically a teaser portion, and I don't like that because it
- 4:18spoils everything. So I just skipped over it. And now I think we're
- 4:21getting to the point where we're going to meet Natalie Grace, who they adopt.
- 4:27And just to keep you up to date on what I have heard from
- 4:30the individuals being interviewed, primarily the adoptive father by the name of Michael Barnett.
- 4:36They apparently, according to him, Michael, they had a picture perfect
- 4:43life, a Norman Rockwell sort of life. They had been married fifteen years,
- 4:46Michael and Christine. They had a huge house, five thousand square feet.
- 4:50They had nice cars, a Lamborghini looked like an old Corvette. Everything
- 4:56was perfect. They had three sons, Jacob, Wesley, and Ethan.
- 4:59The oldest son, Jacob, is on the autism spectrum and he was called
- 5:03a genius. He was on sixty minutes because he was so smart. He
- 5:08I think was skipping grades. And everything was perfect. And then the family
- 5:14also started a charity for special needs kids, and they thought about adopting children
- 5:21seemingly out of the goodness of their own heart. I don't know. And
- 5:25they were looking to adopt. They tried to adopt a child from Haiti and
- 5:30that didn't work. And then this adoption agency reaches out to Michael and Christine
- 5:34to see if they want to adopt this individual, and they have twenty four
- 5:40hours to make a decision. So up until this point, it's all just
- 5:43a normal story of a family that is heading into possibly adopting a child.
- 5:49She's truly frightened and she just doesn't know what she's seeing. What's going on?
- 5:54This is Michael, Michael, look look down. Natalia had full pubic
- 6:00hair, and I don't know what to think. Is that possible? Is
- 6:09that even possible? Okay, Well, that can happen rarely. Also,
- 6:17we have to take their word for it, so huh, Well, I
- 6:23don't know. Wait, so well, I'll keep watching them on me what's
- 6:27going on? I'm'm telling you said that happened, okay. And I can
- 6:34remember her her physicalness at the time, her hands were just out in front
- 6:39of her like this. She said, well, I have a period and
- 6:48I've been hiding it, all right, So I'm going to take a guess
- 6:51and say that she Natalia is not actually six years old. Because the show
- 7:00this documentary, I'm going to take a guess and hope that they would not
- 7:05exploit an actual six year old who had some anomaly biologically that would result in
- 7:12them having those kinds of developments at that young age. We know that she
- 7:17was, or at least they were told that she was adopted from Ukraine.
- 7:20I believe, and I I just don't know what's going on right now.
- 7:30Christina's not possible. Chris found some thock that she had used in her underwear.
- 7:39So another notable thing about the documentary is that Christine, the adoptive mother,
- 7:44is not in the documentary. She's not being interviewed in the documentary.
- 7:46It's only the father, Michael, And I'm wondering why that is. Is
- 7:50it that she doesn't want to participate? Is it that the documentarians are waiting
- 7:55to reveal her later? Do the documentarians not want her involved? She's still
- 8:00alive? Is she in prison or I don't know. We see it suddenly
- 8:03she fills her cheeks with air blows them out a little bit. So the
- 8:07definition in her cheek bones disappears, so that starts to happen. We literally
- 8:16see her head change. It's almost like you got me, okay. So
- 8:26the adoptive father, Michael, he is claiming that Natalia knew how old she
- 8:35was and was actively trying to deceive the parents. And if I heard a
- 8:41client that was referred to me that was doing this, my first hypothesis would
- 8:46be that the child was worried that they were not going to be adopted and
- 8:50were presenting themselves as younger. In fact, I think I might have even
- 8:54ran into that at times, because there are some people who are born in
- 9:00some very chaotic circumstances in which there are no records as to how old they
- 9:05are, whether it's because they come from a region of the world that doesn't
- 9:09keep records, or they come from a region of the world in which there
- 9:13is ongoing war and any documentation of the birth has been destroyed or forgotten or
- 9:18misplaced or something. And there can be times when by the time you adopt
- 9:24a kid, you just don't really know. There's also some cultures around the
- 9:28world that don't really regard birthdays in the way that we do in the United
- 9:33states. They think of birthdays as being like, well, you were born
- 9:39at some point around this year or something. So my first hypothesis would be
- 9:45that she doesn't really know how old she is and or she's terrified that she's
- 9:50going to be rejected. But I'm guessing that isn't this story, because I'm
- 9:56noticing there's a number of episodes in this documentary and the amount of requests that
- 10:01I've received to watch this indicate it can't. So there's got to be something
- 10:07really salacious about the story. So if I was to take a guess,
- 10:11well, it seems like they're heading in a direction where she knows she's older,
- 10:16and she's got to be significantly older, because if she were like thirteen,
- 10:20I guess that would be pretty silacious. But what if she were,
- 10:24I don't know, in her twenties or something, and she was adopted,
- 10:28she conned an adoption agency into believing that she was much younger, and she
- 10:35was an orphan of some sort. I don't know, that would be interesting.
- 10:41Is that what this is about? We thought, how wonderful would it
- 10:43be for you to hear your native language, your native tongue for the first
- 10:48time in a couple of years. The woman from the Ukraine comes in and
- 10:52just immediately starts speaking Ukrainian. I swear in all things whole, Natalia's never
- 11:01heard a word of Ukrainian in her life, all right, So they're seemingly
- 11:05building a case that there's a lot of lies. Now we weren't given and
- 11:11I don't think the parents were given information about the adoption where they told that
- 11:16she was directly from Ukraine, because if not, she could be from Ukraine
- 11:22but was raised in a different country where they didn't speak Ukrainian or it's traumatic
- 11:26for her to remember the language. So just the fact that she didn't respond
- 11:33when she's spoken to a Ukrainian that doesn't really say much necessarily, But I
- 11:37don't know. The documentary seems to be heading in a direction, so maybe
- 11:41that's what they're telling us, is that it's another lie, lack of trust
- 11:48so that you know, compounded, so you lied to so that's what you're
- 11:56going to be in the most trouble for you don't lie. Natalia did have
- 12:03behavioral issues, which okay, so we're going to hear about lying and that.
- 12:07So the way that they're framing this is that Christine, the mother was
- 12:11talking with Natalia about lying about maybe her age and where she's from, and
- 12:18that would not be something I would do. I wouldn't confront a child.
- 12:22There's something going on here because it's not just a child lying about like no,
- 12:26I didn't eat the cookie, it was my brother. Certainly, the
- 12:31adoption process, I'm it must be traumatic. I mean, abandonment issues are
- 12:35a thing, and Natalia was unbandoned multiple times. She was with another family
- 12:43in America before she came with us. Okay, interesting, So she was
- 12:48with another family and it could have been a foster family or an identified temporary
- 12:54family. Natalia was with us four months and that's when we start to witness
- 13:01her dark side. We had two thousand and seven jeep commander. It's three
- 13:07rows of seats, Okay, So it looks like we're heading into a list
- 13:11of allegations or claims by the father, which I just have to say that
- 13:16we don't know if Michael, the adoptive father, is a reliable narrator.
- 13:22There would be potentially, particularly post Hawk, there would be a lot of
- 13:26reasons why an adoptive father would frame things in a certain way or even invent
- 13:31things. But the other thing is is they're not immediately going into talking about
- 13:35the previous parents, So maybe we have to wait for that. But Natalia
- 13:39I could always try to sit next to my youngest, the smallest, my
- 13:43six year old Ethan, and she would do whatever she could to upset him.
- 13:48She would purposely wait until she was next to him in the car,
- 13:52and then she would do her best to urinate on him. She would defecate
- 13:56in the car and put her hand into it and try to smear it on
- 14:00Ethan. Well, so if this is even fifty percent true, yeah,
- 14:05that's obviously very concerning. If you're a parent or a human being, you
- 14:09would be very concerned for that other child. Sibling on sibling abuse is a
- 14:16thing. Kids can be really cruel. Even siblings that love each other could
- 14:20be cruel. So imagine if you had a sibling that was out to get
- 14:24you, right, so we're hearing that. And also just the involvement of
- 14:30feces would raise this question about the potential severe nature of abuse that Natalia had
- 14:37gone through, because you don't see that kind of behavior from people unless it
- 14:45you know, well, I don't know all the research, but if I
- 14:48heard of anybody you doing this kind of thing, I would think that early
- 14:54in life, maybe even during potty training, that there was severe abuse or
- 14:58neglect. Yeah, it was a frequent occurrence for Natalia to soil services that
- 15:05she wasn't supposed to. Okay. So whenever I am hearing people give their
- 15:11account, particularly if it's fairly fantastical as the one that Michael is giving the
- 15:18father, I'm always looking for a corroboration, because if you just have one
- 15:22person saying something, you know it says something, but it says something more
- 15:26if you have corroboration. So we have the son, the oldest kid,
- 15:30who incidentally still lives with the dad, So take that for what it's worth.
- 15:35But you have a third party, an observer who was also claiming that
- 15:41Ittalia would do these things. What were we doing to bother? Ethan?
- 15:46Did you keep doing it while you were in a car with him? That
- 15:50was the life My six year old son had to get into the car was
- 15:54like going through the haunted house. The other thing I noticed as they were
- 15:58telling this story and showing pictures was that of the three sons, only the
- 16:04oldest son's face was non blurred. The other two boys, Wesley and Ethan,
- 16:11I believe they had their faces always blurred out, which makes me think
- 16:15that they're not involved in the documentary. So I don't know, it's just
- 16:21I'm trying to predict what's happening here. Now, what I will say is
- 16:26I have treated people, both children and adults who will present with this behavior
- 16:30of smearing feces on things. It often is a way of protesting for individuals.
- 16:38It can also be some kind of complex around potty training or around their
- 16:45own products, if you will. There's potentially a Freudian thing to it,
- 16:49you know, Freud's theories, of which there are many. This sort of
- 16:56theory seems to maybe hold some water. It's hard to research this kind of
- 17:00thing, but anyway, so for these individuals, the clinical way to look
- 17:06at it is that they are having some troubles emotionally and they're having trouble verbalizing
- 17:11or communicating or feeling safe enough to communicate their protests. So what you try
- 17:18to do with those individuals, even if they're adults, is to help them
- 17:22to feel safe enough to tell you, because usually they're trying to tell you
- 17:26something, they're trying to communicate and they don't believe that anyone will hear it,
- 17:30or they're so hurt that they feel it is justified to take this this
- 17:37extreme action, and they don't have other means to do so. So that's
- 17:42that's what I'm hearing. And now another thing, if we went someplace in
- 17:45public and she made eye contact with somebody, you would climb into the car.
- 17:49She would get into the car, she'd get in her seat, she'd
- 17:52closed the door as soon as I would start to get into my seat,
- 17:56and the car would get in the gear doors open, and she's throwing herself
- 18:00out of the vehicle so people around her can see. Huh. That's interesting.
- 18:07It's interesting the way they're editing this documentary. They are showing a fair
- 18:11amount of real footage that doesn't coincide with the story they're telling. You know,
- 18:18they might be telling a story about her and she is saying, you
- 18:22know, Michael said, and then she said this, and they're showing actual
- 18:26footage of her, which I just hope that the allegations from Michael are at
- 18:32least somewhat believable. Otherwise, you're really leaning on Natalia because if these allegations
- 18:38aren't accurate, or there's reasons to believe they're not accurate, the documentarian should
- 18:42be careful about the sort of associations they're making. But anyway, particularly if
- 18:47we're talking about a child, I assume we're talking about a child. I
- 18:49don't know, but either way, someone who has been through some difficult times
- 18:53at all likelihood. So we're hearing that she would throw herself out of the
- 19:00and try to get sympathy from strangers. So on one hand, you think,
- 19:04in terms of the Michael narrative, is that you have a child who
- 19:10has been abused and has distorted views of authority and parents, and maybe will
- 19:18be defiant in a lot of concerning ways, which incurs a fair amount of
- 19:22discipline or privileges being taken away, and she feels very put upon or something
- 19:27and is trying to get sympathy from others. Is it a manipulation to try
- 19:32to get back to the parents, Or if we were a fly on the
- 19:36wall, would we agree that Ittalia had reasons to try to flee from the
- 19:41family. We're only hearing from the family's perspective, so who knows what was
- 19:45really happening? Right the idea look a poor helpless little girl, and she
- 19:52was trying to get back to poor helpless little girl status. She was doing
- 19:59it as many things as possible to cause hurt or harm or mental distress to
- 20:03the entire family. Okay, so Michael seems to be implying that her whole
- 20:10stick or con is to make everyone feel sorry for her. And if that's
- 20:15where this is headed, that's pretty interesting. And that's the time. My
- 20:19boys are six, nine and eleven. Natalia, would you find things that
- 20:26were important to them, like a hot wheel car, She'd hide them.
- 20:30She'd wait to be crossing the street. She would throw them into the street
- 20:33and make sure the boys saw it. She was baiting my kids to run
- 20:37in the traffic so they'd get run over. Well that's true, My goodness.
- 20:42Again, we can't know my dogs are barking if it's accurate. But
- 20:48yikes, it's one okay, it's horrible to smear your own feces on your
- 20:53brother. It's a whole other thing to try to cause events that would result
- 21:00in the serious injury or death of your sibling, which on rare occasions I
- 21:06have treated kids and adults who have these behaviors. We have ways of framing
- 21:11this personality wise. We'll call them psychopaths, or they suffer from any social
- 21:17personality disorder. There are other conceptualizations as well. But you know, I've
- 21:22treated some individuals that are like this, and it is disturbing to be around
- 21:26them, particularly if they still have a lot of the behaviors. I've helped
- 21:30some people actually with their behaviors such that they don't necessarily develop empathy, but
- 21:37they learn how to account for empathy and stay out of trouble. Because the
- 21:41thing is is if you're suffering from any social and you lack empathy for other
- 21:47people, you lack the awareness of harm to other people, you don't necessarily
- 21:52care about harm to other people. Then as you're behaving in the world,
- 21:56you're going to harm a lot of people, either because you don't think about
- 22:00their feelings or you actually kind of like to harm others. And what will
- 22:04end up happening is what goes around comes around, and there's a lot of
- 22:07consequences to them, and they don't really understand how that whole thing works.
- 22:12So for some of these children, they can be neglected in this way and
- 22:18harm during those critical years and have some very very concerning behavior and lack of
- 22:23empathy. So it's possible that intal But again we're taking Michael's he's the main
- 22:30there are other There have been a few other people that have chimed in,
- 22:33but most of the behavior allegations are from the father. Now, it's also
- 22:36possible that the behaviors were behind closed doors and the parents are really the only
- 22:41Now we haven't talked to the mom. I hope we get to talk to
- 22:44the mom. I can't put in the words the everyday abject horror that we
- 22:51had to go through and live with. And there certainly was like a lot
- 22:56of fear, like what if Natalia it actually harms one of us. Yeah,
- 23:06again, we're taking just a few individuals word for it, But I
- 23:10will say generally speaking that this is a lot more common than I think people
- 23:15realize. I think a lot of times these individuals are narrativized as these devil
- 23:21children right from a horror movie or something, and that's not an accurate way
- 23:27of looking at it. There's a variance to human behavior and personality, particularly
- 23:33when you start involving early childhood attachment disruptions and injury and abuse, and it's
- 23:38more common than people. And there's also a spectrum regarding that behavior. Also,
- 23:44some kids will grow out of it. I have been fortunate enough to
- 23:48work with some kids who were in this direction, maybe not this bad the
- 23:51ones I'm thinking I have worked with kids like this and adults like this and
- 23:55much worse. But of the ones I'm thinking of, I did have the
- 24:00fortune of treating these individuals and families over say, ten fifteen years, and
- 24:06would meet the kid when he was twelve, when the shit really hits the
- 24:11fan, and then I would see the stages of it, and it might
- 24:15get worse as they age into like sixteen, because they start gaining more power
- 24:21in the world and more know how to run away or sell drugs, or
- 24:26they're bigger. They can be physically imposing on the parents, and there's greater
- 24:30consequences. If they commit a crime at that age, it holds with at
- 24:33a greater consequence, and so they can fall into a different crowd pretty particularly
- 24:40concerning crowd of people gangs. I would see all this stuff, and then
- 24:44the child would turn eighteen, thinks would get a little better, nineteen twenty
- 24:48a little better. But time he's twenty five thirty years old, he still
- 24:52has issues, but he's completely you know, ninety eight percent of the problems
- 24:59in terms of behavior have gone away. And so I've seen a lot of
- 25:03futures for kids or adults that will behave this way, particularly when you have
- 25:07enough treatment and a stable you know, because the theory that I come from
- 25:11is that people don't want their lives to be difficult, and they don't want
- 25:17to make other people's lives difficult, unless they're a sayist, and then that's
- 25:19different, or a psychopath who likes to con people, and we might be
- 25:23seeing a situation like that. But again, even psychopaths don't generally want their
- 25:29lives to be horrible, and so if you can teach them to work with
- 25:32the system so that they can get their needs met, then sometimes they'll you
- 25:37know, I wouldn't recommend anyone marry these individuals, but they can participate in
- 25:42society. You could be a friend to someone like this, or you could
- 25:47be a coworker. You might even have friends or coworkers who are on a
- 25:49psychopathic spectrum and they either figured out a way to make it work for them,
- 25:56or they went through enough treatment or something, or they had good enough
- 25:59parents. But anyway, so I just want to say that the other possibility
- 26:04is that all this is exaggeratory and wrong, and a lot of Natalia's behaviors
- 26:10were due to being mistreated, even by the adoptive parents, I don't know.
- 26:17A couple of weeks after that, I came home from work. She
- 26:22had been taking knives out of the kitchen and hiding them in her room,
- 26:25wonder of her bed. I go upstairs, and of course, this whole
- 26:30narrative plays into a trope regarding little people, that they're like some other species
- 26:37of animal and they're scary and they're creepy or something. There's an association with
- 26:47twins that are like this. If you're a twin or you know twins,
- 26:51they will attest to this notion that's in our culture that twins are creepy and
- 26:56they're otherworldly or they're or something, you know, like the twins in the
- 27:03Shining or something. And for little people it's a similar problem, if not
- 27:07worse. And so this depiction, the story, the horror music on,
- 27:12you know, it's edited in. Yeah, it sounds very, very scary
- 27:18if this is true. And I've had clients like this too. I've had
- 27:21kids. An adopted kid would get knives and stand over, the parents threaten
- 27:26them. These things happen, But I'm just kind of worried about the ongoing
- 27:30oppression and misunderstanding and stereotyping of little people. Christine has the knife. There's
- 27:37a big butcher knife. Italia was boarding knives in her room, had intentions
- 27:47to attack us, I asked, So it could be an intention to use
- 27:55the knives. It also could be a safety thing. She might want to
- 28:00protect yourself. I've worked with families who had kids that would do this sort
- 28:04of thing, and they might not be able to articulate why they're hoarding knives
- 28:08or other weapons, or they're too ashamed to reveal that they feel afraid.
- 28:15So that's another hypothesis. It's also, again possible that she actually was hoarding
- 28:18the knives to kill people, but that wouldn't be my first assumption. My
- 28:22first assumption would be that the child is either afraid and is looking for some
- 28:30way to gain some power, some sort of safety, or the child is
- 28:36trying to intimidate by suggesting passively that they're murderous the Italian Italian, did you
- 28:44have this on your bed? Yes? What were you to do with it?
- 28:52I'm going to kill you in your sleep? Well, okay, So
- 28:57assuming that actually did say that, which we can't know, then that's very
- 29:03concerning and should be addressed very thoroughly. I have been in situations like that.
- 29:08It's not only the right thing to do as a clinician and a human
- 29:12being, but it's also one of those areas that as a clinician we can
- 29:17be effectively sued if we don't respond in a reasonable and robust manner. Whatever
- 29:25there's death on the line right whether through homicide or suicide, there are protocols
- 29:30that we have to follow or at least consider to be considered having done a
- 29:36reasonable course of action to address the issue. So I've had situations like this,
- 29:41and there's a protocol of safety, first of trying to get to the
- 29:47heart of the matter, having a lot of procedures for the family about how
- 29:52to react, separating the child from the other kids, or at least making
- 29:56sure that the child is always monitored. Before I was a therapist, I
- 30:00had a child that was kind of in this category, and I was hired
- 30:03as a non clinician to observe this kid twenty for not twenty for seven,
- 30:10but I was one of the people that had to observe him twenty for seven,
- 30:12and this kid was very memorable. It's also possible that if I my
- 30:22so if I heard that a family member said this. You know, they're
- 30:26hoarding knives and when asked, said I'm playing on killing you. I would
- 30:32address it as if it were a real threat, because better safe than sorry.
- 30:37But my assumption would be that it's not actually a real threat, that
- 30:41it's a gesture, some way of manipulating or getting what they want, or
- 30:48they're bored, or it was modeled to them or something like that. Again,
- 30:52I would address it better safe than sorry, but I wouldn't assume that
- 30:57death is around them corner. But we haven't heard from the wife. He
- 31:03referred to the I don't know. I'm trying to predict the future. I
- 31:07should stop. The boys were like, yeah, yeah, this is really
- 31:10happening. Yeah, Natalia is really doing that. This is the time when
- 31:15I backed away from them because I was just in so much shock from hearing
- 31:21this story. I went to Grace and said, you know what, we
- 31:26need to find some new friends to play with. Yeah. I totally understand
- 31:29that it's a very unfortunate thing that happens to families that are going through things
- 31:34like this, whether it's because of legitimate safety concerns for your own children,
- 31:40Grace her child, or stigma or just not understanding the situation. It's a
- 31:45very isolating thing for family and for parents to go through something like this,
- 31:52and I would be with the parents usually after they had been isolated from others.
- 31:57It's really horrible. But you would understand a friend of the family saying,
- 32:02well, I don't know what's happening, and I don't really have any
- 32:06control over what's happening. But until I'm reassured that everything is safe, my
- 32:12kids are not hanging out with your kids at all, and I don't want
- 32:15that kid over here. I'm not going to send my kid over to you.
- 32:17But for the family, it's really rough because this compounds the problem,
- 32:25right because the other kids in the household might be ostracized as well. They
- 32:32suffer, and the parents are already in a difficult spot, and now they
- 32:37have fewer friends, fewer support. You know, it could be very,
- 32:39very hard. And I've been with a lot of families as they've gone through
- 32:44that. Absolutely, we reached out to the adoption agency as we were noticing
- 32:47all of these issues and irregularities. Okay, yeah, that would be the
- 32:52first thing that parents would typically do is reach out to the adoption agency.
- 32:57And this is a message from Michael. My wife has been working the phones
- 33:01between everyone working her something. We are under unspeakable amounts of stress. I've
- 33:07returned a miss something. Christine is doing enough and is under enough stress personally,
- 33:15please you know. Okay, Well, yeah, so we reached out
- 33:19to the adoption agency. They were unhelpful. I was lost. Yeah,
- 33:24I mean, depending on the program, the adoption agency wouldn't necessarily have the
- 33:30resources to help. I was lost. I was getting no help from anybody
- 33:34anywhere. So we went through a few therapists trying to find guidance, trying
- 33:38to figure out the right diagnosis. Okay, so that's good that he and
- 33:45the family went to some therapists, But unless the therapist has some expertise in
- 33:50this area, it's not likely to work because it's a severe, particular kind
- 33:55of situation. Also, he says, I was looking for a diagnosis if
- 34:00we even if we think of her as an adult, but particularly if we
- 34:06think of her as a child. There isn't really a satisfying diagnosis when it
- 34:08comes to stuff like this. And even if we did have a diagnosis,
- 34:14it's not like there's a treatment for these kinds of behaviors. I mean,
- 34:17there's a protocol and we have treatments that we typically will use, but it's
- 34:23not the sort of thing like if someone came to me with PTSD or with
- 34:29borderline personality, or with avoidant attachment, or with OCD or panic disorder,
- 34:37then there's a protocol. There's a lot of research. There's a lot of
- 34:42clients that come to therapy for this, a lot of people have been in
- 34:45research studies, a lot of therapists have been in research site. And I
- 34:49have a very confident approach as well as a lot of other therapists do.
- 34:53I'm not unique in this way to those kinds of issues, but when it
- 34:59comes to this, there's not a lot that my field can do that will
- 35:04instill confidence or optimism in the family. You know, if they came to
- 35:08me, I would say, well, hearing what you're saying, there's a
- 35:12chance that she isn't actually the age that she is. And until we know
- 35:16that, it's hard to take a guess as to what's happening. But if
- 35:21we take a guess and say that she's somewhere in the teen years, then
- 35:25we are looking at potentially diagnoses of conduct disorder or antisocial personality or because psychopathy
- 35:34isn't a diagnosis in a DSM, we wouldn't necessarily use that as the primary
- 35:38diagnosis. There are clinicians and might even myself that will use that construct for
- 35:42sure, because it's a different sort of thing. It's more particular, perhaps
- 35:46more extreme than just antisocial personality. But anyway, so i'd say we could
- 35:53be looking at those kinds of labels. I as a clinician, don't apply
- 35:57those labels unless I have an enough time with someone to justify it. But
- 36:02given what you're saying, there's a possibility that that's what's going on. There's
- 36:07also a possibility that it's temporary and that it's acting out, and that it's
- 36:10a plea, a cry for help, and that once she feels safe enough
- 36:15then she won't exhibit this behavior. Is a possibility. But if we're looking
- 36:20at something more on the level of a pervasive personality issue that isn't likely to
- 36:25respond to treatment, at least very easily, then as a clinician, I
- 36:30have to tell you that there isn't a lot of optimism here. Is there
- 36:35a way forward? Yeah? A lot of that just depends on the resources
- 36:38available to you. What she decides to do, because if she wants to
- 36:45make everyone's lives miserable, then she can do that right, And there's only
- 36:51so much you can do. I mean, you can't chain her up to
- 36:54the radiator and force her to behave That's one of the things that is very
- 37:01disheartening to parents is when you realize that you just don't really have a lot
- 37:06of power over a child's behavior. Ultimately, that's why it's just so important
- 37:09to have a good relationship with your children and to protect your children from traumas
- 37:14so that it's not very difficult to shape a child's behavior. When you have
- 37:20a good relationship with your fourteen year old and you have to go into their
- 37:23room and say, hey, it's time to put down the video games and
- 37:28get to your homework, the reason why that child will tolerate you saying that
- 37:31is because you love each other and you have good will. But if you
- 37:36don't have that, then there's not a lot of influence that you can exert
- 37:39on a child. It's really hard. So for you know, I would
- 37:44tell them this stuff, and I would say the recommendation is to provide you
- 37:51with a lot of resources so that you have respite from the parenting responsibilities of
- 37:58the child, because there's only so much that two people can do to tolerate
- 38:04and handle everything. So I would look into programs where she can be watched,
- 38:10or maybe even a specialized big sister program where the big sister can just
- 38:16take her out and go to the park or a movie or something just as
- 38:20a distraction. It's easier for a single adult with a single child to manage
- 38:25things than when you have your four kids at the home and the neighbors are
- 38:29coming over, so that can help. Also lowering your expectations. Having measures
- 38:37in place that will reduce the risk, like literally not having knives. I've
- 38:40talked with families along these lines that at least in the temporary that they actually
- 38:45get rid of at all sharp objects in their house. You know, whether
- 38:50it's a homicidal issue, or a violent issue, or a suicidal risk,
- 38:57there's measures that you can put in place to reduce the chance of harm where
- 39:01you can sleep a little easier at night. Right getting locks on doors.
- 39:06We got to protect those other kids in the home. We have to start
- 39:09ramping up the monitoring of the child's behavior. We have to do what we
- 39:15can so that the child isn't left on supervised, particularly around other kids,
- 39:20and that will be the first order of business to eliminate the risk of harm
- 39:25to others. And then we're looking at a long term treatment protocol of trying
- 39:31to help her. Well, I guess what I would say is assess the
- 39:36issue, and I might even suggest a specialist beyond myself. I would work
- 39:40with the family and the parents and the kids, but we might find a
- 39:44specialist to work with the child that actually can assess competently whether or not conduct
- 39:52disorder or psychopathy or any social is indeed the constructive choice. So you know,
- 40:00it's not a pretty picture. It's not like if a family brought to
- 40:05me a kid who is suffering from panic disorder, which has happened a number
- 40:09of times in my career. It's a much different story that I tell.
- 40:14I say, okay, well, in X amount of sessions, you know,
- 40:17maybe fifteen, maybe less, if the child participates meaningfully, and you
- 40:22all participate in the family therapy to be helpful to the child, and we
- 40:29correct for whatever sort of issues resulted in the development of the panic, because
- 40:32sometimes panic disorder can result from some sort of trauma or even neglect, early
- 40:38life neglect. You a cold relationship between parents and kids. And I would
- 40:45lay all that out and I would say that, you know, the chance
- 40:47of success, according to researches, is pretty high, and once the panic
- 40:52disorder symptoms have receded, as long as the individual follows up with an ongoing
- 41:00maintenance regimen of self awareness and potentially occasional sessions, then there's a pretty good
- 41:07chance that the panic disorder, if that's all we're looking at, will actually
- 41:12never come back. You know. So that's a much different prognosis to a
- 41:19family than one here. And I find that for parents, initially they think,
- 41:24oh, well, a therapist will be able to fix the problem,
- 41:27right, there's some medication or there's some therapy, because that's the that's the
- 41:34vibe that we give the world as a field and the mental health. We
- 41:37say that therapy is good and therapy can help people. And so when you
- 41:42have something like this, you think, well, okay, there's just got
- 41:44to be some some therapeutic answer to this, but there really isn't, at
- 41:47least a very good one that would work very quickly. You know. I
- 41:52would work with families like this, and I would work with them very intensely
- 41:58for five years, say the it is thirteen and now the child is eighteen,
- 42:04and we would see some changes. But sometimes I wondered if the kid
- 42:07would have just changed naturally anyway because of getting older and maturing a little bit
- 42:12or something. It's just it could be very, very hard work. It's
- 42:15the thing I paid my dues in the beginning of my career. And for
- 42:19those of you that are doing that work, whether you're the foster parents or
- 42:22the adoptive parents, or the therapist or the teachers, you are wonderful,
- 42:29wonderful people. And I thank you for the bottom of my heart for doing
- 42:31that work, because someone has to do it, and thank you. It
- 42:39was really the third or fourth therapist we got to that seem to understand what
- 42:45we're telling them and seem to have an Italian's number. Having Italia's number,
- 42:50that's worrisome because that could indicate some kind of anti child bias on behalf of
- 42:58the therapist. I don't know that, And also he could just be framing
- 43:01it that way. Like I would have parents who would say that about my
- 43:06work with the child. They'd be like, oh, yeah, Kirk really
- 43:07has his number. I'd be no, no, no, that's don't praise
- 43:10it, like that I don't have the don't I'm not against the child,
- 43:15but some parents really after a lot of issues and their own childhood issues of
- 43:20which we don't even know. For Michael I death, they'll go into it
- 43:22and Christine about their own childhood issues. You know who knows. She pulled
- 43:28Christine and I side and said, you're all in extreme danger. At that
- 43:34point in time, we already knew that we had been living that, so
- 43:40we were not stunned at the danger. Yeah. I don't know. Maybe
- 43:44they'll go into the exact assessments. Maybe they'll leave an interview of the therapist
- 43:47somehow I doubt that. But extreme danger. Yeah, even if I barely
- 43:52understood the situation, there's enough information to be very concerned. Out of a
- 43:57concern for the family safety, you would I want to as a therapist,
- 44:00really highlight the risks. Now for myself, if I thought that there was
- 44:07say a three percent chance that Atalia was gonna try to kill them in the
- 44:12middle of the night with a knife, that would be enough for me to
- 44:15say what he is saying, what the therapist said, that you guys are
- 44:19in danger. You need to take action to protect yourself. So to say,
- 44:22oh, my god, you're in danger. That doesn't mean that a
- 44:24therapist necessarily believes you're an imminent danger and she definitely is going to kill you
- 44:30unless you do something to stop her. It could just mean, look,
- 44:35there's enough data here to raise the remote possibility, but we don't want to
- 44:39roll dice when it comes to someone in your family dying right now. It's
- 44:44also possible that the therapist was genuinely thinking that the family was in imminent danger
- 44:52and either had viable reasons to make that assessment or not. But it's possible
- 45:00that the therapist was genuinely severely concerned. But we're stunted to diagnosis. We
- 45:05were expecting a severe mental disorder that was out of her control. We were
- 45:09expecting schizophrenia. Oh okay, right, yeah. I wasn't proposing those constructs
- 45:16and labels because there weren't any other symptoms provided, or any other accounts provided
- 45:22that pointed in any other directions. Without those, you start to hypothesize about
- 45:30any social conduct disorder or psychopathy. I'm guessing that's where he said it.
- 45:35We were expecting something. We were expecting her to say, she hears voices,
- 45:37she's hearing commands. Tell her to do this stuff. So she tells
- 45:43us she's a sociopath. Okay, so sociopath is not a diagnosis. Do
- 45:50therapists and clinicians still use that term, Yeah, but it's rare and in
- 45:57my world and in my cultural pocket with the individuals that do forensic psychology and
- 46:04diagnosing in a rigorous way in psychology, we don't use the word sociopath because
- 46:09it's not formally defined. I've done a whole series of episodes, but one
- 46:15particular episode I broke that you can actually search on my YouTube channel about psychopathy
- 46:20versus any social versus sociopathy, and I go over the literature because it's all
- 46:24consensus. When you talk about what is an apple versus what is an orange?
- 46:30These are scientific facts you have probably DNA involved, that you can look
- 46:35at to identify that's an apple, that's orange, where the morphology of the
- 46:38two fruit are very different. When we're talking about what's the difference between someone
- 46:44with psychopathy or does someone suffer from psychopathy or sociopathy, or what's the definition
- 46:49of sociopathy versus psychopathy or any social we're talking about a bunch of humans that,
- 46:53over the span of one hundred and fifty years are writing in research journals
- 47:00or in their own publications books whatnot, or speaking at conferences, and the
- 47:04people are from all over the world, and everyone is basically free to define
- 47:09these things in the way that they want. Now, with any social personality
- 47:13disorder that has been formalized in terms of criteria from the work of the American
- 47:20Psychiatric Association in the publishing of the various dsms, the diagnostic the diagnostic manuals
- 47:30that we use, psychopathy and sociopathy are are not in here. Psychopathy has
- 47:36been thrown around for a long time, and most people use the hair definition
- 47:42and criteria. There was a psychologist, believes psychologist named hair Hare. I
- 47:47forget his first name, but I have a book of his behind me,
- 47:52and it lays out what most would call a subset of people with antisocial that
- 47:59is particularly a con artist and frequently conning people and frequently committing crimes. Now,
- 48:06sociopathy is sometimes just considered another word for psychopaths, sometimes considered just another
- 48:12word for anti social. Sometimes it's defined as someone who is socialized to act
- 48:17psychopathic, but doesn't have the pervasive foundational personality traits of a psychopath, so
- 48:23they can unlearn their behavior. Like if someone grew up in a war torn
- 48:30country or a part of the city that had a lot of violence, then
- 48:35they might adopt a sociopathic personality to survive, or it's what's been modeled to
- 48:42them or in their families they had to adopt that perspective of lack of empathy,
- 48:46but foundationally they have you know, so there's very different definitions, and
- 48:51you'll hear people on the internet YouTube included just making shit up about the definitions.
- 48:57You know, I would I'm going to take a guess, particularly on
- 49:00TikTok and say that ninety nine percent of the videos in particular of people talking
- 49:05about the differences between psychopathy and sociopathy and any social are talking out of their
- 49:09ass. It's also kind of a hacky thing to say for a clinician to
- 49:15use the words, because we have other words that are more precise. All
- 49:20that is to say that we heard from Michael his account. We don't know
- 49:24the reality that this therapist that seemed to have Natalia's number identified her as being
- 49:31a sociopath or suffering from sociopathic personality disorder or something, and that indicates someone
- 49:39that lacks empathy, someone that doesn't care about other people's feelings. Now,
- 49:45there's a lot of constructs that are associated with what to say, psychopathy or
- 49:52any social that aren't necessarily associated. There's a they're correlated, but they're not
- 49:57the same thing. People will throw a lot of things into this basket,
- 50:00things like Machiavelianism, which is the trait or the tendency to plan ahead to
- 50:07screw people over. You know, it's one thing to react to someone who's
- 50:12like, screw you, right, Like if your brother takes your toy and
- 50:15you, if you're a psychopathic child or a person, then you just smack
- 50:20your brother as hard as you can and you take the toy backtal no remorse,
- 50:24total disregard for other people's feelings. That is one thing that's an impulse
- 50:29and a lack of empathy. It's a whole other thing to plan ahead and
- 50:32say I am going to smack my brother tomorrow and here's how I'm going to
- 50:37do it. And they're making claims along those lines that she would drop the
- 50:42kid's favorite toys on the road so that the kids would run out and be
- 50:45killed. You know, that kind of allegation is pretty unusual. It's possible,
- 50:50especially given the story they're telling us, but that one I would need
- 50:53a lot of corroboration on a lot of evidence to demonstrate that that was a
- 50:58viable interpretation. There's also the construct of sadism, which is different from psychopathy
- 51:04as well, in that sadists will people suffering from what we might call statistic
- 51:08personal disorder, have a desire. They gain a lot of pleasure from harming
- 51:15others or at the very least witnessing other people being harmed, whether it's them
- 51:21being lied to or pushed down or killed. And people suffering from this disorder
- 51:27are very concerning, obviously, and sadism is associated with psychopathy or antisocial or
- 51:34a lack of empathy, but they're not always together. In the same person.
- 51:37You can actually have sadism and foundationally get a lot of desire from seeing
- 51:44other people be harmed or like to harm others in some severe ways. At
- 51:47the same time, you do have empathy for other people. And so I've
- 51:52treated people like this, and I've heard from people like this, and they
- 51:57know not to harm others, but sometimes they can't resist the urge, but
- 52:01they have remorse about it and they regret it. So being a sadist isn't
- 52:07necessarily being a psychopath, and being a psychopath isn't necessarily being a sadist.
- 52:09Now both then you have some very difficult people. If you will people who
- 52:16don't care about your feelings and actually want to harm you, then that's a
- 52:21really and have machiavelianism and plan ahead in advance because when you plan ahead at
- 52:25advance, you can get away with it, whereas if you're impulsive, which
- 52:28is a classic psychopathic thing, then you get in trouble and you get put
- 52:31in jail, which is what happens a lot to these people. And then
- 52:35the other trait is narcissism. By the way, I'm talking about the Dark
- 52:38tetrad have made episodes about this as well. Sometimes we say Dark Triad because
- 52:44we don't include sadism in there. But with narcissism, you know, being
- 52:49very self centered, being a grandiose about your self, your abilities, your
- 52:53achievements. This sort of thing is narcissism in a nutshell. And we're not
- 52:58talking about narciss person, we're talking about a trait. So for people that
- 53:04are psychopathic, meaning they lack empathy and remorse or concern for other people,
- 53:09if they also are sadistic. If they also are machiavelian, if they also
- 53:14are narcissistic, then we have the dark tetrad, and we have particularly if
- 53:19they're moderate to severe in each of these straits, then we have a very
- 53:22very concerning individual, Whereas if you just have one of them, then it's
- 53:28less of a concern. Not that those individuals can't harm people. But I
- 53:30say all this because in the public discourse, and really even among clinicians,
- 53:37they will lump all of these constructs into psychopath or into someone with antisocial So
- 53:44I say all this because you can have an individual. Let's say that with
- 53:47a lot of assessment, we would find that Natalia does in fact lack empathy
- 53:52and remorse and concern for other people's feelings, just fundamentally, not that she's
- 53:58blocked off from her empathy, because that's another thing to think about, as
- 54:00I often will talk about, is someone with narcisstic personality source and now we're
- 54:05talking about a whole other area. They will have impaired empathy, but they
- 54:08have empathy, they have the capacity for empathy, but they're so concerned,
- 54:13they're so worried about losing the race of being the best at everything because when
- 54:22they were young, that was a very dangerous situation for them, or at
- 54:27least a very scary situation, a very lonely situation that they are eclipsed from
- 54:32their own empathy. We all do this if the sort of classic example is
- 54:37you are helping your daughter to learn how to ride her bike. And she's
- 54:42a lovely person, she has empathy like a regular kid. She's eight years
- 54:45old, and you're helping her with the bike and you have your hand on
- 54:49the bike so she doesn't fall over, and you're like, oh, you're
- 54:52doing good, and she says, let go, I think I can do
- 54:54it on my own, and you think you're sure. He's like, yeah,
- 54:57let go, I can do it on my own, Dad, don't
- 54:59let me. And then you let go and she goes forward about a half
- 55:02block and she crashes and she hurts herself and she skins her knee, and
- 55:07you run up to her and you say, oh my god, I'm so
- 55:09sorry. Are you okay? And your daughter screams at you and says,
- 55:15how dare you? I hate you? Dad? Why did you let go?
- 55:19Okay? So, in that moment, if you just take it as
- 55:22at face value, you see a child that is psychopathic. It's a weird
- 55:27word to put to it, but they have disregard for other people's feelings.
- 55:29They're self centered. They're not looking at the situation rationally. But we all
- 55:34understand that because the child is in a very difficult situation, they're in pain,
- 55:37they might be ashamed of themselves, they might be demoralized. It's overwhelming,
- 55:42and so when we are overwhelmed, we are potentially eclipsed from our own
- 55:45empathy, our own concern for other people's feelings, well as the same for
- 55:50people with a narcisstic personality and moderate to severe narcissistic personality, they've been eclipsed
- 55:54since day one. So their empathy is primordial to begin with. So even
- 56:00when they do have access to it, it's not very refined or mature,
- 56:04but they do have the capacity for it. Whereas people with psychopathy seemingly,
- 56:07at least as the way we could sceptualize them, they just fundamentally don't have
- 56:12it for whatever reason developmentally or abuse wise, or they were born that way.
- 56:16They seem to lack that. I saw this because if you had someone
- 56:21in your life that lacked empathy, and it was determined that it was true,
- 56:25psychopathy or any social type of lack of empathy. Then you would potentially
- 56:31be assuming too much by looking to culture and associating that person with machiavelianism,
- 56:38sadism, and narcissism. They might actually just lack empathy for other people.
- 56:44They might have those other things. They're highly correlated, but they're not necessarily
- 56:47together in one person. She knows what she's doing, she's in control of
- 56:52doing it. It's not a diagnosis where she's out of control, and she
- 56:57can really be helped. She's a solopath. How was the first moment from
- 57:02a clinician that we heard, you can't help here. You're twelve years old
- 57:08and you're, you know, just down the hallways as someone who's living with
- 57:13Yeah, so Jacob and the other kids would be particularly traumatized because they have
- 57:19no power because their children. But getting back to what Michael was saying is
- 57:23that the therapist saying that ship has sailed. There's nothing you can do.
- 57:27The child has this condition. You're just going to have to learn to live
- 57:31with it. There's no amount of therapy to change that aspect. You can
- 57:37actually work with people who have psychopathy and lack empathy. There is a road
- 57:42to helping them to function better in society. Also, no respectable clinician would
- 57:50diagnose confidently a young person with sociopathy or psychopathy or any social You just can't
- 57:58know for sure. Now, maybe the therapist did have a lot of time,
- 58:02so who knows. But yeah, I have had that conversation, whether
- 58:07it's about psychopathy and a child or a family member, an adult, or
- 58:13it's some other issue, you know, like a frequent conversation I would have
- 58:16with parents of adopted kids. Now, I want to be clear that plenty
- 58:22of adopted kids develop fine, even kids that are adopted post six months of
- 58:25age, so I don't want to paint that generalization. But I did treat
- 58:30a lot of families that had adopted kids that were adopted post six months,
- 58:35whether it was twelve months or twenty four months or even at the age of
- 58:38five. They had been through a lot of trauma and a lot of attachment
- 58:43jury, and then they're adopted. So I would treat these families. I
- 58:46had a small specialization. I would say five percent of my clients in my
- 58:51first I don't know seven years as a therapist were these kinds of families.
- 58:55And what I would sometimes find myself telling the parents was something along these lines,
- 59:01not that the child is a psychopath. Maybe the kid is, but
- 59:06I wouldn't necessarily know yet until the child develops some ages a little bit.
- 59:10But I would be having this conversation of it looks like your child early in
- 59:15life, due to the circumstances regarding their attachment and their parenting and caregiving from
- 59:22the age of zero to three or whatever, it seems that there's a neurological
- 59:27difference, or a personality or developmental difference, whatever we want to say to
- 59:32this, there's a difference about this child that results in the kind of behavior
- 59:38that you're seeing today. This isn't ADHD, this isn't bipolar, This isn't
- 59:43depression, this isn't anxiety. We're not going to treat this with medication and
- 59:47psychotherapy. This is something about the child that is probably going to be with
- 59:53them forever. And that's a hard pill to swallow because it's very dire.
- 1:00:00Right, it's seemingly hopeless. It's not hopeless though. As the thing,
- 1:00:05there are things that you can do, and the sooner the family could recognize
- 1:00:08this, the sooner we could get to the things that actually might be able
- 1:00:12to quote unquote help. It's not going to take away the problem, but
- 1:00:15it's going to account for it. And the parents who did eventually get there,
- 1:00:22then I was able to start working with them on those other things.
- 1:00:24But prior to them accepting that, they still have this idea that society has
- 1:00:30given them, and a lot of people in my field have given people that
- 1:00:34therapy can help, and that there's medications and there's diets, and there's other
- 1:00:39kinds of programs that will actually turn people around. You know, people on
- 1:00:45Facebook saying I did this program and now my kid's great, or I did
- 1:00:49a boot camp or whatever, now my kid's great. And there's not a
- 1:00:52lot of information out there. It's sort of like what I imagine a lot
- 1:00:55of medical professionals run into when you have someone that is diagnosed with some sort
- 1:01:00of chronic condition like migraine for example, that well, isn't there a medication
- 1:01:07to fix these problems, or isn't there some sort of surgery or back pain
- 1:01:12for example. There's a lot of misinformation or just lack of awareness that well,
- 1:01:19surely there's something you know severe. You know, I don't want surgery
- 1:01:22necessarily, but if nothing else works, surely there's a surgery for you know,
- 1:01:25there's some kind of thing we can do here, and for some conditions
- 1:01:30there isn't, and that's very distressing, and a lot of people will in
- 1:01:34those situations turn to pseudoscientific charlatans who will try to sell you something that's in
- 1:01:39fact, if you want to find out what the frontier of medical and psychological
- 1:01:45science, what the frontiers are, because where the frontiers are, we don't
- 1:01:49know enough yet to help people with these kinds of problems. If you want
- 1:01:53to know where the frontiers are, all you have to do is look at
- 1:01:57all the pseudoscientific charlatans online that are selling things. Because there's not a lot
- 1:02:01of people selling snake oil regarding I don't know, something like cavities, for
- 1:02:07example, tooth decay, because it's pretty well understood, it's not super complicated
- 1:02:13what's happening right, there's enough research in our history and enough knowledge and society
- 1:02:19that I'm sure there are pseudoscientific charlatan's regarding cavities, but I haven't seen any
- 1:02:23whereas there's a lot of charlatan's regarding psychology, regarding ADHD, regarding autism spectrum,
- 1:02:32regarding certain kinds of cancer, regarding energy level and sleep difficulties. It's
- 1:02:39just it's everywhere, and so you know the reason for that is because it's
- 1:02:45hard to accept that there's nothing science can do for you, especially with what
- 1:02:49you're asking for. You're asking to fix this child, and we're not going
- 1:02:53to do that. We're going to do things that might account for things and
- 1:02:58reduce the harm to everyone, particularly your other kids. But this is here
- 1:03:01to say, this is probably an issue that this child and everyone around this
- 1:03:06person is going to have to deal with for the rest of this person's life.
- 1:03:09That's a very difficult thing to accept, and I get it, and
- 1:03:15getting a second opinion would be, of course important, but you know it's
- 1:03:19hard, and so I would have these conversations with parents and it would be
- 1:03:22very hard. You know, this is a thing that happens sometimes and there's
- 1:03:25only so much you can do, and there are definitely some things that are
- 1:03:30not likely to work trying to inject empathy or connect with the child and the
- 1:03:35way that you can connect with it, because that's the other thing. It's
- 1:03:37not just this lack of empathy thing. There's often this lack of connection that's
- 1:03:42even possible with people in this category because they due to this early neglect in
- 1:03:47life, they not only have lack of empathy, but they just don't really
- 1:03:52see the way that I would tell people because I ran into this a lot,
- 1:03:55was that these individuals when their interact with their humans, it's more instrumental.
- 1:04:01Like when I interact with humans, whether it's a cashier at the store
- 1:04:04or my wife, there's a feeling I get of concern or empathy, or
- 1:04:11I feel myself inside of somebody else, you know, like I can feel
- 1:04:15their emotions. I don't know if I know their emotions, but there's a
- 1:04:18concern. Also when I'm interacting with them, I'm highly focused on them,
- 1:04:24because for most humans, we're very focused on other humans. We're very what's
- 1:04:29going on with that human, and I'm very concerned with what they're thinking,
- 1:04:32even the cashier at the store. And as I say this, you might
- 1:04:38think, well, I don't know how concerned I am about the cashier or
- 1:04:41some random stranger. However concerned you are with other random humans strangers. For
- 1:04:45people with this kind of background, where they've been neglected and those neurons have
- 1:04:50not been developed, where they had a lot of interaction with other humans,
- 1:04:54from zero to two. They don't have that innate foundational concern not only just
- 1:05:00for feelings, but just for the whole idea of other humans, And so
- 1:05:05the other humans might as well just be like a computer or a car or
- 1:05:11money. It's only just a means to an end. Because for humans that
- 1:05:15have developed at least somewhat well or at least okay, our needs are met
- 1:05:20often through other humans, and we don't consider humans necessarily to be just instruments
- 1:05:28to get what we want. We actually consider the humans to be what we
- 1:05:30want. Right. Whereas for these individuals, since they didn't have those interactions
- 1:05:36that would lock in that association, there's a critical window that is hypothesized that
- 1:05:43needs to be capitalized on to provide those neurinal connections of associating other humans with
- 1:05:49emotion and needs and attachment. If they don't have that, then other humans
- 1:05:55are just they're just dust in the wind. And if the individual needs something
- 1:06:00that involves other humans, then they'll concern themselves with humans. But as soon
- 1:06:03as that's over, it's over. It can be very very hard for people.
- 1:06:08Now, I don't know what's happening in the story, so let's keep
- 1:06:10watching. Whether you who actively wants to harm you. That's a very scary
- 1:06:15feeling and I definitely didn't feel safe around Italia. I just was scared.
- 1:06:21Yeah, that's something that hasn't been highlighted yet that the individuals and the kids
- 1:06:28in the home, him being a kid back then the amount of fear,
- 1:06:30but the parents too. For myself and the times that I've had to work
- 1:06:34clinically with people that exhibit this kind of behavior, and I can never know
- 1:06:40what's really happening. But when I've been around people like this in my capacity,
- 1:06:45however limited it is because I'm only with them, say an hour or
- 1:06:48two a week, it can be terrifying because so much of our safety,
- 1:06:55our sense of safety is dependent on the assumption that other people at least think
- 1:07:02somewhat the way that we do. And when you have enough knowledge to know
- 1:07:08that they don't think in fundamental ways the way we do, then all bets
- 1:07:13are off. God knows what they're going to do, especially if you have
- 1:07:15someone saying they're going to kill you and they're trying to kill you, they're
- 1:07:19hoarding weapons to kill you. But I do want to honor that. How
- 1:07:24terrifying it would be. Like I said, my capacity. I would be
- 1:07:27with them one or two hours a week, and for some of them it
- 1:07:30would be very, very scary. I wouldn't be able to sleep well at
- 1:07:34night. Potentially I would have these flash images of them coming to my house
- 1:07:42and killing me, even though there was no evidence that they would do that.
- 1:07:45It's really terrifying. I imagine horror movies and other kinds of TV shows
- 1:07:49don't help with this, but I think it's also kind of rational, and
- 1:07:54especially when you have someone that is actively threatening with knives. So yeah,
- 1:07:59and it's it's a special kind of trauma, this fear, because it's one
- 1:08:03thing to have someone like you're in a bank and some people rob the bank
- 1:08:10and they hold you at gunpoint. That can be very traumatic, But it's
- 1:08:13a different kind of trauma when it's every day and your home where that fear
- 1:08:19is present. It might not be spikes of anxiety, or there might be
- 1:08:24occasional but it's just this low grade terror that is happening at all times for
- 1:08:30him being in that house and for the whole family. And I've been with
- 1:08:33families like this, It's hard to think of a lot of things that are
- 1:08:40worse than that. Just that feeling of at any point in time, in
- 1:08:45my safe place of home, where you know, my food is and my
- 1:08:50bathroom is, and my soda and my family and my things, at any
- 1:08:58point, there's this person who could just pop up out of the shadows and
- 1:09:02kill me or someone else, or do something to me or my things.
- 1:09:06It's it's very, very dysregulating, and I feel terrible for everybody if this
- 1:09:13is true. But he doesn't have any reason to lie. Now. I
- 1:09:16guess there's a chance that he's been lied to and he was made to feel
- 1:09:20this way because of lies. But if we take but regardless, even if
- 1:09:26he was lied to, it's still terrified. You just feel bad for him.
- 1:09:30She's standing dead center in the middle of the room, a blank look
- 1:09:33on her face. Natalia, what are you doing? I'm waiting, waiting
- 1:09:45for what for you to go to sleep? Yeah, it's fantastical. It's
- 1:09:56border aligning on too fantastical, but you know, possible for sure, and
- 1:10:01if true. Again, we're not hearing corroboration on this, but it's definitely
- 1:10:06possible. But it's starting, especially with the editing all this stuff, it's
- 1:10:11starting to sound like a legit fantastical, fictional horror story, but again possible.
- 1:10:18I don't know, because I've seen a lot of different things. Okay,
- 1:10:21So I've seen situations where you have a kid who does exhibit some very
- 1:10:27concerning behavior, the parents go to others for support and are denied support or
- 1:10:34help or sympathy, and the parents will start to spin it or lie to
- 1:10:41get sympathy, maybe legitimately, maybe they legitimately deserve sympathy, and just nobody
- 1:10:47really understand situations like this, so they feel like they have to exaggerate in
- 1:10:50order to get people's attention. So I've seen that where you have maybe some
- 1:10:57concern, some moderate concern about a child's behavior, but you have parents that
- 1:11:00have either developed this narrative that's not true, and or they convince themselves of
- 1:11:05things because they want to believe that it's severe so that they can get other
- 1:11:09people to pay attention. Not narcissistically, but they're desperate and they're looking for
- 1:11:15answers. So I've seen that. We've also heard of fantastical stories of just
- 1:11:20parents just fully just making stuff up, Munchausen by proxy kind of thing.
- 1:11:26So I don't know. I don't know why I am so skeptical. I
- 1:11:30just I guess I figure if y'all wanted me to watch this so bad,
- 1:11:34I can't imagine thiss just being a straightforward story, although I don't know,
- 1:11:39maybe it is. Maybe it's just as they're saying, it doesn't really disturbing
- 1:11:42to hear one night sleep in bed, everything's fine, hear a little noise.
- 1:11:51I open my eyes and Italia is standing at the foot of the bed
- 1:11:55with a knife in her hand. What. Yeah, I've said this before,
- 1:12:01but if I were working with a family that told me this, I'd
- 1:12:04take the approach of better safe than sorry, and I would approach this as
- 1:12:08if this is a real threat, get rid of the knives, start having
- 1:12:12monitoring, maybe even having a temporary placement for the child with a twenty four
- 1:12:16to seven monitoring situation, putting locks on the bedroom doors so that she can't
- 1:12:23get in while they're vulnerable and sleeping, and not on Natalia's door, but
- 1:12:26on the doors of everybody else, locking from the inside. I would approach
- 1:12:30it that way, of course, but my clinical assumption of the future would
- 1:12:34not be that the child was actually going to kill anybody, because if the
- 1:12:39child really wanted to kill someone, why would she just stand there with the
- 1:12:43knife, unless she was contemplating it. You know, it's possible, but
- 1:12:46it's more likely that the child is trying to express something. They're trying to
- 1:12:51scare or protest or something. It doesn't make it right. I'm not saying
- 1:12:57it's a viable way of municating your feelings. But you know, given her
- 1:13:01history, that would be my assumption. I wouldn't know. I would have
- 1:13:04to assess further and watch things. But but the way this is all painted
- 1:13:11the documentary, with the sound and the horror music and the lighting everything,
- 1:13:15it's like literally trying to paint her as literally the devil or this demon child.
- 1:13:21What was it, Demion or whatever? Why are you in here?
- 1:13:30I don't know. That's just a blank look there, there's no emotion there.
- 1:13:35There there's no feeling going through her. It's just this blankness. I
- 1:13:40don't know what I'm doing here. Natalia put that down right now, and
- 1:13:45she did, Italian, go to your room right now. Okay. Now,
- 1:13:48we're seeing indications potentially of a sleep disorder of some sort. You know,
- 1:13:56there are versions of sleep walking in which you're kind of awake, so
- 1:14:00there's that also, maybe the development of psychosis or confusion or brain injury or
- 1:14:06something. The way he's presenting it, it's possible that she's confused and is
- 1:14:14maybe even hallu standing who knows. It's also possible that she was legitimately trying
- 1:14:19to terrify them and knew exactly what she was doing, and she did.
- 1:14:26But obviously I sat outside her door for the rest of the night to make
- 1:14:30sure she didn't come out, she didn't emerge, something didn't happen. I'm
- 1:14:35guessing a lot of people would just say, oh, it's a psychopathic sociopathic
- 1:14:40killer. That is just like all the horror movies and all the things we've
- 1:14:44seen, all the Charlie Manson's and the Ted bundies. And it's possible that
- 1:14:47that is true, but that assumption is often unfounded. When I talk about
- 1:14:53all these things, I'm introducing all these possibilities, so like, oh,
- 1:14:56it could be this, could be that, And sometimes I get this pushback
- 1:15:00or slap back of that I'm taking it easy on people, or well,
- 1:15:04you know, so and so doctor Drew said she's psychopath. I don't know
- 1:15:08what you're talking about. And I, as a professor, as a clinicians,
- 1:15:13as a supervisor, I want to promote the idea and the philosophy of
- 1:15:19tentativeness and of acknowledging the humble nature of our field. What I love to
- 1:15:26do is just ask questions. I love to raise question marks. So well,
- 1:15:30could be this, So let's looko into that. Let's watch for data.
- 1:15:33The information given to us, could be biased, could be all lies.
- 1:15:36We don't know. You know, I recognize it can be frustrating.
- 1:15:40But if you embrace what I believe to be the reality, I think it's
- 1:15:44quite liberating. And I think it lends itself to an actual pursuing of so
- 1:15:50called truth or objective reality, because once you recognize that it's not easily found,
- 1:15:57then you can begin the journey of discovery. Christine comes back in Christine
- 1:16:03screets. I come racing downstairs. See a bottle of pledge. I see
- 1:16:11Christine's coffee cup, and Christine tried to drink it and instantly taste and pledge
- 1:16:17leaning supplies that had been poured in the Christine's coffee cup. All right,
- 1:16:21So we don't know if any of this is accurate or distorted, But just
- 1:16:26going off the description, this is an example of what I was talking about
- 1:16:30earlier regarding machiavelianism, maybe sadism definitely on some sort of psychopathic spectrum, in
- 1:16:39that you have a story of an individual, whether it's a child or an
- 1:16:44adult, or someone posing as a child who is an adult. I don't
- 1:16:46know. They haven't revealed that. I don't know if we're looking at a
- 1:16:49teenager posing as a child. I assume that's what it is anyway. So
- 1:16:57regardless of the age, you have an individual who, without any prompting,
- 1:17:01without any immediate reason, takes revenge or tries to harm another person. As
- 1:17:08I was talking about earlier, if you are with a teenager and you take
- 1:17:15away their phone because you are punishing them for getting bad grades or something.
- 1:17:18I'm not recommending this, but let's just say someone it and you take it.
- 1:17:21You say, okay, well you're granted from your phone, and the
- 1:17:25child say tries to grab the phone back or something. No, you know,
- 1:17:29don't take my phone. I need it. So in that moment,
- 1:17:31it's not good that the child is trying to do that, but you understand
- 1:17:34where it's coming from because they have this immediate emotion of like, no,
- 1:17:39you're taking it away from me. Whereas when you have a child who without
- 1:17:45provocation in the immediate seemingly makes a plan. So the full story is the
- 1:17:51individual Natalia goes to the mom and says, I'll help you with the dishes.
- 1:17:57And then I was like, oh wow, okay, so I Tellia's
- 1:18:00kind of coming around, Sure you can help it. She's helping with this
- 1:18:03is Mom leaves, Mom comes back, finds allegedly there to be pine sal
- 1:18:09in the in the coffee, and drinks it andugh and screams. So seemingly,
- 1:18:15what you have as an individual who says, Okay, I want to
- 1:18:18get back or I want to do something to my moment, so I want
- 1:18:20to act calm and I'll get in close to her because I will offer to
- 1:18:27help her with this chore. I'll wait for her to leave, I'll capitalize
- 1:18:30on that moment, and I'll get to realize my plans in the end.
- 1:18:36That's that's different than the kid that just grabs the phone back. Right.
- 1:18:41This is not just your typical defiance. This is a plan. This is
- 1:18:45machiavellian and it's very scary, right because if you have a child that reacts
- 1:18:51impulsively in a way that's defiant, then at least you can only be on
- 1:18:58guard when your child is having a moment or has a reason to have an
- 1:19:00emotion, but when your child is just or when an individual you're living with
- 1:19:04just all the time is just waiting and looking for a reason to get you.
- 1:19:10And I've worked with clients like this. I had one client a long
- 1:19:13time ago who was essentially like this, and I was terrified. And I
- 1:19:20to this day don't know what happened to him. I just can't. I
- 1:19:26mean, it was almost like a compulsion to harm others when he could get
- 1:19:30away with it. It was, you know, it's it's what do I
- 1:19:33say? It's clinically it's a problem to work on, but as a citizen,
- 1:19:38it's utterly terrifying. So we're hearing a story like that. Now it's
- 1:19:44just soap, So presumably that's not going to kill you unless you drink a
- 1:19:47lot of it. So it's possible that the child, if they did this,
- 1:19:54if she did this, wasn't actively trying to kill it. Also could
- 1:19:58just be a mistake, It could be a lie. I don't know.
- 1:20:00Christine is screaming at her natality, why did you do this? And she
- 1:20:09just says plain all straight out, I'm trying to kill you I'm trying to
- 1:20:13poison you. Yeah, I certainly have that instinct. Now, Like,
- 1:20:18if I heard this, I would take it very seriously and would take actions
- 1:20:25to reduce risks by limiting the child's ability to kill or harm people in the
- 1:20:32family. So better say the sorry. But I would assume this wasn't an
- 1:20:36actual homicidal intent, especially given the stories that I've heard. You know,
- 1:20:42she really wanted to kill or poison, there's more effective ways of doing that.
- 1:20:45And if she's older, then they think then she's been told. You
- 1:20:49know, she probably knows how to work the internet and look stuff up.
- 1:20:53Who knows, But standing over or standing at the foot of the bed with
- 1:20:57a knife and waiting for the parents to wake up up, it could be
- 1:21:00a homicidal intent. Could be a child that's like on the fence or something.
- 1:21:04But it also could be an intimidation tactic. Putting pine sal in your
- 1:21:08coffee. Is that a legit attempt to kill the mom? Or is it
- 1:21:14just a way to screw with her? And then she says, I'm trying
- 1:21:17to Is she trying to get kicked out of the home because she wants to
- 1:21:21go back to the other home, or she doesn't like these people, or
- 1:21:25she doesn't like Indiana or you know, there's just a lot of questions.
- 1:21:30I can't really share a drink with someone unless i've yeah, I've seen theirs
- 1:21:36of it the entire time. Well, it's probably rooted in this fear that
- 1:21:45Natalia is coming to like poisonous. Yeah, and that's legit. I don't
- 1:21:53expect the family to have the clinical questions that I do. There's no reason
- 1:21:58to believe that the threats aren't real. So, yeah, it's terrifying if
- 1:22:01you just feel so bad for everybody, but particularly the kids. I guess
- 1:22:05I haven't really figured out a way to reconcile it. I'm being honest,
- 1:22:10I'm still working through it. I think I might need a minute. I'm
- 1:22:15sorry why, it's like what fuck? Okay, So we're skipping forward.
- 1:22:29I think at least a year, maybe a couple of years, and she
- 1:22:32is independently, or she's been instructed to read the Bible to get rid of
- 1:22:38the thoughts of hurting people. Okay. I mean, I don't recommend this
- 1:22:42particular treatment intervention, but as I've been talking about, there are ways of
- 1:22:46trying to help people like this, These behaviors can absolutely be related to trauma.
- 1:22:51Things that can be healed can be a symptom of things, not some
- 1:22:56indication of an inherent foundational personality difference. So maybe this is a part of
- 1:23:00that. I don't know. When Italia was in the state mental hospital,
- 1:23:04she was under twenty four to seven observation and care of ninety doctors, nurses,
- 1:23:11orderly's, therapists, et cetera. While she's there, she admits openly
- 1:23:15and freely that yeah, I'm trying to kill her. And by the way,
- 1:23:20I'm going to tell you doctors, and I'm going to write this in
- 1:23:23my journal, I'm going to kill the boys too. Okay, So there
- 1:23:27was an incident in which they were at some sort of park and the individual,
- 1:23:32Natalia, I want to say child, but I don't know that.
- 1:23:36Natalia, apparently, according to Michael, was trying to electrocute the mother by
- 1:23:42dragging the mother into an electric fence, and the aid car was called or
- 1:23:47an altercation of having some sort of violence or concern, and that prompted the
- 1:23:54authorities or the family to start looking into institutions like a statemental hospital. And
- 1:24:01yeah, given the story, I understand the decision to place around a hospital.
- 1:24:06Do I think it's going to help, you know, maybe it's hard
- 1:24:10to know. I've talked to this before, but just very briefly is there's
- 1:24:15only a small set of things that can be provided to a family, even
- 1:24:20if they're super rich and they have all the money in the world. But
- 1:24:23that's not usually the case. So even people with access and privilege and money,
- 1:24:27there's only so many things available, which can be very distressing for parents
- 1:24:31because I think that there's this notion that is propagated that when push comes to
- 1:24:36shove, if you really wanted, you can always spend more money to solve
- 1:24:43the problem. But we just don't have those services. They don't exist.
- 1:24:48We don't know how to even assess these things, let alone change these things
- 1:24:54in people. We have things to account for it or adjust for it,
- 1:24:58or to reduce harm around and within Natalia's issues. It's a very difficult situation.
- 1:25:05And so anyway, we just have to take a guess and say that
- 1:25:08Natalia has been through a lot of trauma, a lot of difficulty. We
- 1:25:13haven't heard anything about her history, but hard time believing that everything has been
- 1:25:15fine up until adoption. Right, I'm going to drag their bodies out of
- 1:25:19the house and I'm going to put them underneath the deck out back. Natalia
- 1:25:27drew this picture immediately after being admitted to LaRue Carter State Hospital. It says
- 1:25:32bye is in goodbye. It's interesting the bye goodbye included the three sons and
- 1:25:45the mother, but not Michael. I was reading into it just makes you
- 1:25:50wonder, Okay. Due to concerns about their employment, the workers of LaRue
- 1:25:54Carter chose to stay anonymous the people in the mental hospital. According to LaRue
- 1:26:00Carter intake workers, Atalia was transferred to the adult wing upon discovery of her
- 1:26:06pubic hair. She's not a kid. As an adult, she was aggressive,
- 1:26:13she was very manipulous. She could be sneaky. Huh. So this
- 1:26:17is the first time we're hearing corroborating statements from someone not in the family.
- 1:26:24You know. I tend to believe the oldest boy. I don't know,
- 1:26:28but even that he could have been fed information. Sorry to say. I
- 1:26:32remember seeing how mature she was and how busty she was. Her clothing became
- 1:26:44very revealing of her body. In her breast, she talked about six a
- 1:26:51lot. Okay, So I think we're hearing from three different staff members,
- 1:26:57different statements being made by people. Most documentaries have a twist. So I'm
- 1:27:02guessing there's some sort of twist. Maybe it's just her age. I don't
- 1:27:04know, but I keep looking for evidence. I'm not saying that, you
- 1:27:10know, if Michael and the family were actually abused and harmed by Natalia,
- 1:27:16I don't want to just constantly question their story, you know. But so
- 1:27:23if I just heard this story, I would assume that the parents are telling
- 1:27:26the truth. I wouldn't know. I wouldn't put money down on that,
- 1:27:29but I would just think, well, why would someone make that sort of
- 1:27:32thing up? I mean, some people do. But since this is kind
- 1:27:35of a long documentary and I'm sort of in the beginning and you all have
- 1:27:39been asking me to watch this, I just assume, like some some's coming
- 1:27:42down the pie. But so I don't want to give this notion that I'm
- 1:27:46constantly skeptical of everyone's stories of being victimized. I'm not like that typically,
- 1:27:51but I never fully just accept everything that anyone tells me, whether I'm acting
- 1:27:58as a professional or not. You know, I'm always holding out for like,
- 1:28:00well, who knows, maybe there's some exaggeration or some distortion or misperception
- 1:28:04or mis memory or something. So I'm just exhibiting that kind of thinking.
- 1:28:10March comes, Christina and Italia are having the who are you fight? Christine
- 1:28:15wants Natalia to write down people she's lived with, places she's been, tell
- 1:28:21us about people you've known. Okay, so we skipped forward at least a
- 1:28:26year, if not to the mental hospital informed the family that Natalia was propositioning
- 1:28:33and possibly having sexual interactions with other patients, maybe staff members, I'm not
- 1:28:40sure. And they say she can no longer be here. And if you're
- 1:28:45the family, if we take the dad's word for it, you know,
- 1:28:47this is pretty demoralizing because you finally get to a situation where Natalia is in
- 1:28:54a facility, she is presumably safe, there's a lot of monitoring, there
- 1:28:59are dozens of mental health professionals around her to help her, and you've reached
- 1:29:05the promised land. You know, I'm guessing that the service was paid for
- 1:29:11by insurance or some other way of funding, because you know, that could
- 1:29:15be very expensive. I don't know how much money is. I think he
- 1:29:17was saying, well, they had a Lamborghini, so but even that,
- 1:29:19like that sort of service, you know, people will Sometimes clients will propose,
- 1:29:27like maybe my kids should go to a mental health hospital, or maybe
- 1:29:30I should go to mental health hospital, because I think there's this notion that
- 1:29:33that is going to fix it, and sometimes it does. I mean,
- 1:29:36there are legitimate reasons to recommend that that I will engage in. But the
- 1:29:41reality is is that unless you have funding for it, and even if you
- 1:29:45do, sometimes insurance only pays a percentage or something, the expense is so
- 1:29:49astronomically high, and it's temporary. They might have you in the hospital for
- 1:29:56a few days, maybe a week if you're lucky, and that's not going
- 1:29:59to much. You know. The main reason why I would recommend people go
- 1:30:02to the hospital is because people were at imminent risk of dying by suicide,
- 1:30:08and there was enough reason to believe that even if they went home with their
- 1:30:12support system, that they would find a way to die. So they needed
- 1:30:16to go to the hospital to make sure that there was no access to implements,
- 1:30:21there was monitoring, there might be an assessment for changes in medication or
- 1:30:28something. But then I would recommend, and you know, that doesn't solve
- 1:30:31the problem. It just gets them through those days that you know, maybe
- 1:30:34a few days maybe less, maybe longer in which they are not safe to
- 1:30:40be by themselves. But I've even had clients who are still at imminent risk
- 1:30:44but the money runs out or the protocol is such that, well, you
- 1:30:48know, the person has to be released now, or they answer the questions
- 1:30:53in enough of a nuanced way that we're going to discharge the patient. And
- 1:30:57it just isn't the way that it's depicted in society that you know, it's
- 1:31:00kind of weird. It's sort of both right, that the mental health hospitals
- 1:31:03are depicted as these crazy asylums, you know, like Batman, and then
- 1:31:08on the other hand, they're these places that solve all your problems, and
- 1:31:12neither are true. So it's really demoralized that Natalia goes back to the family
- 1:31:16and we're hearing that from Michael anyway, that the mom Christine is playing the
- 1:31:21where are you from? Game, meaning that it was a frequent conflict between
- 1:31:27Christine and Talia about tell me the truth, who are you, where are
- 1:31:30you from? How old you are? That kind of thing, And this
- 1:31:33night, Christine sides that the most effective way to make you tell me who
- 1:31:39you really are is you no longer have a bedroom or a bed, you
- 1:31:44sleep outside, Grab your blanket you're sleeping on the back deck. I have
- 1:31:50heard of parents who will do this. I've had clients who will be told
- 1:31:57to do this by other organizations or books that they've read where the procedure of
- 1:32:01trying to shape behavior or trying to get a kid to comply and the justification
- 1:32:08is reasonable. You are trying to protect your other kids, You're trying to
- 1:32:12help the child not harm themselves. You're trying to set the child up for
- 1:32:15success in the future. You know, there's a lot of legitimate reasons why
- 1:32:19you would want to get a kid to stop this pattern of defiance and aggression.
- 1:32:25So there's a lot of difficulty for parents and situations like this because there
- 1:32:29aren't really answers and they either believe that, well, I just need to
- 1:32:33be harder on the kid, or they're just so resentful of the kid that
- 1:32:36they just have lost all hope and they just want to punish or get rid
- 1:32:41of the kid. Anyway, we hear that the parents, and I've worked
- 1:32:44with families that have been told by organizations that are like self help organizations or
- 1:32:47Facebook groups that will say, look, you have to escalate the discipline if
- 1:32:54they lie once, you do this, If they lie again, you do
- 1:32:57this. You know, it's like with grounding, it's like you're grounded for
- 1:33:00a day, Okay, you do it again, You're grounded for a week.
- 1:33:01Okay, now you're grinded for a month. And yeah, depending it
- 1:33:05might work depending on the situation. It's not the go to way to shape
- 1:33:10a child's behavior. There are much more effective ways, like trying to get
- 1:33:15at the root of them, trying to talk with them, trying to help
- 1:33:17them understand, trying to help them understand how it affects other people, trying
- 1:33:21to be a good role model for them, trying to reward them for behavior
- 1:33:27that you actually are trying to get them to do more of. But you
- 1:33:30know, discipline, it's not necessarily a horrible thing the way that some people
- 1:33:33will paint it. Anyway. I would hear these parents that would tell me
- 1:33:38that they were being told by these other parent organizations that at the you know,
- 1:33:43further up the ladder of discipline is you take away their their room or
- 1:33:47their door. We heard this when we were reviewing the videos and the news
- 1:33:51reporting of Ruby Frankie. She had a video in what she talked about herself
- 1:33:57how she had taken away her her son's bedroom for seven months or something and
- 1:34:02the kid had to sleep in the bedroom on the couch or something. And
- 1:34:06you know, there's a threshold beyond which it's cruel, and obviously that's waybe
- 1:34:12on the threshold making it gets sleep outside. I think most people would agree
- 1:34:15that's that's cruel, regardless of the situation. So not uncovered. So I'm
- 1:34:19guessing maybe the mom had been trying to get some answers and had, you
- 1:34:25know, had given up on therapists and the mental health hospital and was resorting
- 1:34:29to other kinds of influences. I don't know. The Taya's out there crying.
- 1:34:32Finally, like three hours into this, well, I took the scene.
- 1:34:36I can't do this. I get up. I'll let the Italia in.
- 1:34:41I get it back to her room. Plus the transgression that we're being
- 1:34:45told by Michael anyway, is that Natalia just isn't being forthcoming about her history.
- 1:34:49And if I were given a clinical situation like this, my first hypothesis
- 1:34:55would be that she's ashamed of her history, or she's worried if she reveals
- 1:34:59her history that the family will get rid of it. That's kind of the
- 1:35:01weird thing about situations like this is that some kids who have had very difficult
- 1:35:05histories, when they finally get adopted, they have a very conflictual relationship with
- 1:35:12their attachment to their adoptive family. There's a part of them that desperately wants
- 1:35:16acceptance and love and stability and consistency, and deeply appreciates the love and attention
- 1:35:26that they're getting. There's another strong part, maybe a more noticeable part of
- 1:35:29them, that just hates the fact that these people are telling them what to
- 1:35:35do. I mean, how dare you tell me what to do? I've
- 1:35:39been living my own life for a long time. I've had to survive on
- 1:35:44the streets or I've had to survive the abuse that I've been through, And
- 1:35:46what do you do. You're just this suburban group of people, like you
- 1:35:50don't know shit, you don't know what I've been through. Get away from
- 1:35:54me. Or I am so scared of opening myself up vulnerably to these people,
- 1:36:00and that will result in harm like it always does. So one way
- 1:36:05to avoid getting close and vulnerable is to overcompensate by intimidating and being aggressive and
- 1:36:12lying. So that would be my hypothesisis, so why would you have to
- 1:36:17if the child is systematically abusing one of the other kids or yourself or something,
- 1:36:21then I would understand escalating the discipline. I still don't think sleeping outside
- 1:36:27is the answer, obviously, but there at least would be understandable in terms
- 1:36:31of why you would escalate the discipline. But just because the kid isn't being
- 1:36:34forthcoming about their history and the way that they've never been forthcoming, it sounds
- 1:36:40like, given Michael's description, it sounds like the mom is starting to lose
- 1:36:44perspective. One of the neighbors called CPS. So CPS shows up on the
- 1:36:51door Child Protective Services with a detective from the local police department. Okay,
- 1:36:57so one of the neighbors calls Child Protects Services says, I see a child
- 1:37:01to sleeping. Probably the neighbor knows, you know, because they've interviewed other
- 1:37:06neighbors and they probably know what's going on. So who knows what the report
- 1:37:12exactly was. A CPS worker shows up with a police officer and let's see
- 1:37:15what happens. They come in. They've gotten this call and we're neglecting Italian.
- 1:37:21The detective for the Westfield Police department. Now it's possible that the police,
- 1:37:27the law enforcement officer, and the CPS worker globally understand or at least
- 1:37:32had a more nuanced point of view on the big picture and they weren't out
- 1:37:38to get the parents or something. But on the surface, if you just
- 1:37:42look at the behavior, it is child neglect. That's what you would call
- 1:37:46it. To force a child to sleep outside is neglectful. You're not physically
- 1:37:53punching a child. You are denying them a fundamental right or a fundamental aspect
- 1:38:00of safety that you can provide. And there's also no justification. Really,
- 1:38:05she's not telling me the truth, So that's that's the label. So it's
- 1:38:10possible that they saw, well, we understand the bigger picture, but we
- 1:38:14have to ding you for this and get the ball rolling. Now. I
- 1:38:17would be called sometimes by the government after these kinds of determinations were made.
- 1:38:25They would determine that the abuse wasn't severe enough to just take the child away
- 1:38:30completely, and they would say, you know, maybe it would be best
- 1:38:34for the family and the kid if we send a therapist into the home and
- 1:38:39actually help them to change, you know, figure out what's going on.
- 1:38:44And so I would enter the homes in these situations and would be tasked with
- 1:38:50figuring out what's going on and helping. So I wonder if that might happen
- 1:38:56here, a therapist, you know, helping. He's here to protect my
- 1:39:00sons. He knows instantly they're in grave danger, attactical claus He conducts an
- 1:39:06investigation. He comes back and visits us. He's got a picture of Natalia
- 1:39:12when she was naturalized here as a US citizen in two thousand and eight,
- 1:39:15when she first got here from the Ukraine. He's got her naturalization information.
- 1:39:20Okay, interesting. So the police officer takes sympathy on the family and starts
- 1:39:25investigating and finds documentation. I'm going to take notes on this basic vital statistics
- 1:39:30stuff like that. Natalia admitted to Detective Klauds that she was told her new
- 1:39:38birthday at the orphanage in Ukraine, that new birthday being two thousand and three.
- 1:39:45She was told her birthday would be September four, two thousand and three,
- 1:39:48and she was four years old. So it's hard to know the motivation
- 1:39:51on that. I'm guessing they're going to tell us more, but my initial
- 1:39:57assumption, given my experience, would be that the adoption agency had no way
- 1:40:01of determining the age precisely, but had enough reason to believe that she was
- 1:40:06in the ballpark of four, and they just said, let's just pick a
- 1:40:12date, because everyone needs a birthday, and there needs to be some indication
- 1:40:17of when you cross thresholds like turning sixteen where you can get a driver's license,
- 1:40:24and you can't just say, well, you know in the driver's license
- 1:40:26on your documentation. It'd be like, well somewhere around two thousand and three,
- 1:40:29there needs to be a date. I don't know the legality of that,
- 1:40:31but I'm pretty sure that's why that is. Detective Klaus showed her a
- 1:40:35picture of herself from when she entered the country, but she did not recognize
- 1:40:42herself in the picture. He's not one hundred percent convinced a girl in the
- 1:40:45picture is even her. Another interesting things he mentions to us is her height.
- 1:40:51Four years ago when she was naturalized. She hasn't grown a centimeter.
- 1:40:57Wait, is that the twist that he's not even that kid? Because you
- 1:41:01know it was one of the things that they've been saying is that she allegedly
- 1:41:05cannot speak or understand Ukrainian. But we just saw those documentation, that documentation
- 1:41:11that at the age of four or at some age she came to the States,
- 1:41:15And at this point in the story that they're telling us, it's only
- 1:41:18four years after she supposedly emigrated. So now we're hearing that maybe Natalia isn't
- 1:41:26even Atalia. That's somehow, I mean, my god, did she kill
- 1:41:30the kid? And absume though that can't possibly be true. He informs us
- 1:41:34he believes that are Ukrainian birth certificate as all bogus. Here's this business card
- 1:41:40to an attorney. Oh so, what the police officer was hypothesizing is that
- 1:41:46it's not that the kid was replaced. It's just a complete made up set
- 1:41:50of documentation with maybe a picture of some random kid off the Internet or something.
- 1:41:55You need to go to them immediately. You need to correct her age.
- 1:41:59You can't just take a racer to a birth certificate. I had never
- 1:42:01heard of such a thing. I never never even crossed my mind. I
- 1:42:05just thought, we have an adult who's masking as an eight year old,
- 1:42:09and that's what it is, right, It's not usually this inaccurate. Now,
- 1:42:15I will say that I would have clients that, and some clients would
- 1:42:20admit to me that they actually did know their birthday, and the family did
- 1:42:25know precisely when the child was born, but they knew that it would be
- 1:42:30harder for the child if they identified the child's real age, because they would
- 1:42:35enter a grade or an age group that the immigrant child wouldn't be ready for.
- 1:42:43You know, like you have a fifteen year old kid who emigrated to
- 1:42:46the States, and it's predicted by the family, maybe accurately, so that
- 1:42:50if they just are slotted into the rest of the fifteen year olds with the
- 1:42:56classes and the activities and the temptations and the influences, that this fifteen year
- 1:43:01old kid would not thrive as well as if they were allowed to catch up,
- 1:43:09not only academically but culturally. And so they might lie and say the
- 1:43:13kid's twelve, and that's what the official record says, and so the kid
- 1:43:17enters that stream of development. And you know, I've heard I've heard that
- 1:43:23before too, and you know, you could imagine that being a concern.
- 1:43:28But how do they know, I mean, if their questions as to whether
- 1:43:30or not they even know who this individual is, how do you determine the
- 1:43:35age? Right, I guess you just have to take a guess. So
- 1:43:39the only way to protect the entire family, I have to prove she's an
- 1:43:44adult and that she definitely has a fake Ukrainian birth certificate. Christine and I
- 1:43:53again, we reached out to the adoption agency when we ask them, can
- 1:43:56you help give us contact influence. Now I've been hearing primarily from Michael,
- 1:44:01the dad. We haven't heard from the mom at all. For a little
- 1:44:03bit from one of the boys in the family and some of the staff members
- 1:44:08at the mental health hospital, but the bulk of the narrative is from the
- 1:44:12father on this documentary, And if say Natalia is actually Natalia and maybe lied
- 1:44:20on the form of guarding age, but it is Natalia. If you're a
- 1:44:26family that's really struggling with this adoption, it's a convenient narrative to say that
- 1:44:31she's an adult and she's not who she says she is, so we have
- 1:44:36no responsibility. We can literally just kick her out of the house. She's
- 1:44:39a criminal, she's an adult. Legally, no one needs to take care
- 1:44:43of her. She should fend for herself. So that is a convenient narrative
- 1:44:47and would be very convenient if it crops up during a CPS investigation. You
- 1:44:53know, now who knows. Maybe it's all somewhat true, but I just
- 1:44:57throw it out there information for her old family. We have got a find
- 1:45:00out what's going on here. They said, no, we can't. The
- 1:45:03answer is always it is a closed adoption. The other family does not want
- 1:45:09to surrender any information to you. It is not until I'm gonna take a
- 1:45:15guess and say that, Yeah, if it's a closed adoption and there are
- 1:45:19laws and rights that say that the biological family or whoever had Natalia before,
- 1:45:27it sounds like maybe there's another adoptive family before, then yeah. Sure.
- 1:45:31But when you have enough evidence to believe that Natalia isn't who she says she
- 1:45:38is, or isn't the age, then you just imagine that there would be
- 1:45:41some kind of exception to the rule. Really inspect those backpacks. So go
- 1:45:47upstairs in the house, get the backpacks out, start rumminging through it.
- 1:45:54There was a little id tag inside of her bag when we adopted her that
- 1:45:58had the original families inform it. That is weird. I mean, this
- 1:46:02is potentially a year or two later and there's this free floating id tag that
- 1:46:10presumably Natalia wouldn't want them to find, or maybe she would want them to
- 1:46:14find. It's pretty pretty interesting. We know, according to records, Natalia
- 1:46:24starts her early life than an orphanage in Ukraine. Okay, again, we
- 1:46:29don't know if this is the same person that's living with them, But if
- 1:46:32that's true, then that explains some things in that at orphanages, unless they
- 1:46:41pay very close attention to consistent caregiving by a small set, if not one
- 1:46:47individual, one staff member, then you have massive attachment disruption. You might
- 1:46:54be able to provide for the physical needs of the child food and sleep,
- 1:46:59and shelter and safety and you know, clean cleanliness, maybe even activities,
- 1:47:04creative activities, funny, but if the child is denied that strong attachment figure
- 1:47:12that is consistent at least a number of hours every day, then we know
- 1:47:17neurologically there will be effects and behaviorally there will be effects. What's about the
- 1:47:35praises spring? Okay, so according to the biological mother's sister, Natalia,
- 1:47:48what she say, what's about the praises? So she's saying what happened is
- 1:47:58that the mother biological mother abandoned her once and then one family took her then
- 1:48:04threw her away. So yeah, another took her. Presumably this is in
- 1:48:13Ukraine. Another took her and threw her away like trash. So yeah,
- 1:48:17just heartbreaking slot And okay, so identical twins. The mother has an identical
- 1:48:41twin, all right, seventeen years. They are all going here and there
- 1:49:00to be seventeen years. Okay, hard to know if this is accurate,
- 1:49:05but looks like it's strong evidence that Natalia is seventeen, which is a far
- 1:49:13cry from six or by the time they're in this part of the narrative,
- 1:49:16I think Natalia would be eight. This woman, Anagaba, who is supposedly
- 1:49:23in Natalia's biological mother, just said she's been going through this saga for seventeen
- 1:49:30years. Well she said that in twenty twenty. Do the math, Oh,
- 1:49:35in twenty and twenty. So wait, what so how come we're all
- 1:49:42the way out in twenty twenty That maybe I missed that bit. So okay,
- 1:49:47if we do the math, that's seventeen years. That's two thousand and
- 1:49:54seven. That doesn't make any sense or sorry, two thousand and three,
- 1:49:58right my math. But we thought she was born in two thousand and four,
- 1:50:04So because anyway, I'm lost, that means Natalia may really have been
- 1:50:11born in two thousand and three, which is what she has said all along.
- 1:50:15Okay, So this I think that's the lawyer. Okay. So I
- 1:50:19thought she was saying, do the math. She's way older. Okay.
- 1:50:23So according to the mom, I don't know. It's just hard to say
- 1:50:27unless you have some kind of hard evidence than Who knows, but it is
- 1:50:32it is absolutely possible. And like I was saying earlier, given the stress
- 1:50:39of parenting a child with behavior problems, perhaps as a result of the revolving
- 1:50:45door of attachment figures that Natalia had growing up, the parents are grasping for
- 1:50:50any excuse that they don't have to deal with it anymore, and the notion
- 1:50:56that she's a lot older than she actually is an actual adults would give them
- 1:51:00an out. So maybe that's what's been happening. It's possible that they found
- 1:51:05her behavior to be too hard to manage. I don't know, But to
- 1:51:10Sacans, it's clear they wanted to unload her close adoption, giving virtually no
- 1:51:15information about her. They made a mistake, though, they left their identifying
- 1:51:19information on one of the luggage tags. So okay. This seems to be
- 1:51:25suggesting that the first adoptive family might be to blame for this whole thing,
- 1:51:30and that's possible. It's possible that Natalia had limited behavioral problems and then through
- 1:51:38the abandonment of the adoptive family in New Hampshire, her behaviors became ten times
- 1:51:43worse. It's possible, jis within six months of giving her, they were
- 1:51:46taking her to little people conventions and trying to give her away under the name,
- 1:51:50Hey, you're a couple, you don't have a kid, you want
- 1:51:53one. Here Again, it's Michael telling a story. It's hard to know.
- 1:51:59He has I think motivation to exaggerate or just make stuff up. But
- 1:52:03we're hearing that the New Hampshire family would just go to a little person convention
- 1:52:09and just say take this child. I mean, if that's true, my
- 1:52:13god, but that sounds fantastical. We found two different families that they tried
- 1:52:17to give her to. One they gave her to undo the table for four
- 1:52:20months. Mean extortion been a thirty thousand dollars. Okay, well that's specific
- 1:52:25again his account, but let's review those details. They gave her to undo
- 1:52:29the table for four months, mean extortion, Beth, they gave her to
- 1:52:30the family for four months. Give me an extortion amount of thirty thousand.
- 1:52:35Oh my god, the details in this story. It's hard to believe.
- 1:52:43Diane and her husband said, pay the legal fees and you can adopt this
- 1:52:47little girl. If I remember right, she told me that adoption costs from
- 1:52:53the Ukraine were around twenty five thousand, and I find it kind of crazy
- 1:52:58that you would adopt a child and spend twenty five thousand and only spend a
- 1:53:01year with that child. So the New Hampshire family is trying to extort money
- 1:53:08out of the next family twenty five thousand dollars at least. The potential allegation
- 1:53:14is that they're lying about that and just trying to get a bunch of money.
- 1:53:17So the allegation is that there's this family in New Hampshire that either when
- 1:53:25times get tough, they just try to use the adopted kid to gain money,
- 1:53:29or they adopted the child and bad faith to begin with to extort other
- 1:53:34people from money. So I find it odd. I don't know if there
- 1:53:39was a financial scam or not. My husband decided I don't think we can
- 1:53:46do this financially, and I feel like if you're going to adopt, both
- 1:53:50parents have to be totally into it. But it broke my heart. Yeah,
- 1:53:56and just add another tick in the column of a major trauma for this
- 1:54:00young child, even if the kid is older than what the records say,
- 1:54:05which it appears maybe not to be the case. You know, it's just
- 1:54:10really hard on somebody. Think about for yourself. And this is much easier
- 1:54:15to cope with is you start dating and you you know, you fall in
- 1:54:21like with somebody and they dump you, and then you go out with someone
- 1:54:26else and you get the nerve up and you date you know, fifteen other
- 1:54:30people and it's hard and you get your hopes up, and then you finally
- 1:54:32find a person to to lock in with, and then that person, after
- 1:54:36two years, they cheat on you, and then you date again. I'm
- 1:54:40guessing some of you are like, oh my god, you're describing my tender
- 1:54:43life. And then the next person just ghosts you, and the next you
- 1:54:46know, you know, maybe there's a few in there where you break up
- 1:54:49with them as well. But you can imagine after a while just giving up.
- 1:54:55It's not unheard of right to say, at least for a time,
- 1:54:58I am not open. Even if someone comes to me out of the blue
- 1:55:02and seems perfect for me. Why would I open myself up to that.
- 1:55:06I might even be adamantly against entertaining such thoughts because it's so painful. It's
- 1:55:15going to result in me opening up, and then I'll be in pain.
- 1:55:17So what's the point. That's a lot easier to deal with, even though
- 1:55:20that's hard than being zero to five years old and experiencing this kind of getting
- 1:55:28your hopes up that oh my god, finally someone is here for me,
- 1:55:30and now they're no longer here from me. So at least we're hearing an
- 1:55:35account. I think of the mama abandoning the child, then another family in
- 1:55:42Ukraine abandoning a child, then another family in Ukraine abandoning the child. Then
- 1:55:45she goes into an orphanage in Ukraine, which is going to do a number
- 1:55:50on you in all Likelihod because you have a rotating staff of people. Then
- 1:55:55you get shipped away across the world to be adopted into this family in New
- 1:56:00Hampshire. You probably don't speak English at all, right, and like who
- 1:56:03are these people? And it sounds like they're not great people. Who knows?
- 1:56:08And then you're with another family, this family in Indiana, and then
- 1:56:14you're back with the family. You know, it's it's rough, and there's
- 1:56:16so many kids right now that are dealing with some of you might know stories,
- 1:56:21some of you might have actually dealt with a situation like this. There
- 1:56:25are so many people, particularly when you start thinking around the globe, there
- 1:56:29are so many children who are experiencing this revolving door. And that's even in
- 1:56:34situations where a lot of people, adults are well meaning, let alone in
- 1:56:41a situation where it seems like and Talia might be being exploited for money.
- 1:56:45It's you know, so this is a very common story that I've heard a
- 1:56:47lot, and it's heartbreaking, and the effects last a lifetime, you know.
- 1:56:55The the Natalias of the world have a lifetime of healing ahead of them.
- 1:57:01I just want her to be happy. I think when I found out
- 1:57:05what happened to her, I was like, she wasn't happy. That was
- 1:57:12what broke my heart the most, is that she wasn't happy. In my
- 1:57:16heart in Italia is the daughter I never had. At least from the description,
- 1:57:21it seems that this potential adoptive mother doesn't have a lot of negative things
- 1:57:27to say. Now, maybe if she was pressed, she would say,
- 1:57:30well, yeah, there were some issues, and maybe Natalia wasn't there long
- 1:57:32enough to exhibit that behavior. But we're not hearing an account that is in
- 1:57:40line with what Michael is saying as to what Natalia was. Now, again,
- 1:57:45there's a lot of circumstances that that would occur, and Michael's account is
- 1:57:49still accurate. So it's just notable. Appropriate bored Dian, and then you
- 1:57:56asked her what the Ukrainian orphanage was, like, oh, yeah, yeah,
- 1:58:00and she gave an uncoach to answer. It was obvious. Yes,
- 1:58:05she said it sucks. It sucked. And then Diane interrupted her and seemed
- 1:58:10surprised that she said that and said, oh no, it wasn't that bad.
- 1:58:14You were fine. Okay. So now we're learning from another family in
- 1:58:18Austin, Texas who wanted to adopt Natalia from the New Hampshire family. And
- 1:58:26they went to visit the family in New Hampshire and they were asked by the
- 1:58:31New Hampshire family to pay up a bunch of money. They didn't disclose how
- 1:58:36much, and the parents in Austin were saying, no, we're not going
- 1:58:41to pay that money. That's not reasonable, but we're still interested in adopting
- 1:58:45the child. And so they got to New Hampshire, and they are according
- 1:58:49to their judgment, their evaluation. They're guessing or saying that the mom,
- 1:58:58the adoptive mom in New Hampshire, had been previously coaching Natalia about how to
- 1:59:02respond to certain questions. And they're saying that they asked a question, how
- 1:59:08was the orphanage in Ukraine? And Natalia said it sucked? And the mom
- 1:59:14says, no, no, it was fine. And I'm gonna take guests
- 1:59:16and say that the adoptive mom in New Hampshire was not wanting Natalia anymore.
- 1:59:24It could be because of Natalia's behavior. I think people given this narrative that
- 1:59:30they're feeding us right now. They're giving us the narrative that Natalia might have
- 1:59:33been a perfect child in New Hampshire, which is possible but not likely,
- 1:59:38but absolutely possible. There's no way to know really much from what I'm hearing,
- 1:59:44but the New Hampshire so they seem to have some question marks as to
- 1:59:48the treatment of Natalia in New Hampshire. The data given thus far is not
- 1:59:55strong evidence of anything. They just don't really have much data. But any
- 1:59:59parent that would try to capitalize by, you know, if you really want
- 2:00:03to get rid of a kid and you're going to extort money, You're going
- 2:00:10to lie to be able to Now, maybe the mom was in a desperate
- 2:00:13situation money wise. There was medical bills they couldn't pay. I don't know.
- 2:00:16It's just hard to know. Certainly, there are people that will do
- 2:00:19evil things, but it's not common anyway. So what they're saying is,
- 2:00:25we asked a kid Talia to Talia says, yeah, it sucked. At
- 2:00:27the orphanage, the mom steps and I'm guessing the mom was trying to shape
- 2:00:31a story that Natalia was unscathed by trauma, and if Natalia would be coached
- 2:00:40to say a version of her history that everything was fine, then people would
- 2:00:43be more likely to adopt Natalia and might be likely to pay money. At
- 2:00:48this point, though the Austin family says, we're not paying, So it
- 2:00:50seems that the mom is still interested in having someone else adopt Natalia, and
- 2:00:57that's where we're hearing, but we're taking their word for it. It was
- 2:01:00almost like Diane had to give her approval to come out, and then as
- 2:01:05soon as she said, when she was coached to say, she went back
- 2:01:08in. I've never seen another person do that, even in movies, even
- 2:01:14in the actorsist. Oh, okay, I was wondering what he was talking
- 2:01:16about. So he's saying that, according to his observation, that she went
- 2:01:21off script. Natalia by being real and honest and disclosed. Yeah, it
- 2:01:26was really rough at the orphanage, and then when the mom stepped in,
- 2:01:30that's when Natalia shut down and became a different persona almost like a different person,
- 2:01:35that's what he's describing. And he's saying he's never seen anyone do that.
- 2:01:40Yeah, So I don't know. I would be surprised if we were
- 2:01:45like a god and we could see all the factors that led to Natalia's behavior,
- 2:01:50which we still don't even know if it was accurate, but there's reasons
- 2:01:53to believe it is accurate, as you hear from the staff at the mental
- 2:01:56health hospital, that kind of thing. But we hear, well, wait
- 2:01:59a second. So she was observed to have pubic hair at presumably the age
- 2:02:04of six, and was menstruating at the age of six, and was highly
- 2:02:10sexual at maybe the age of seven or eight. Well, that's not unusual
- 2:02:14for people who've been through abuse, sexual abuse and people who haven't, you
- 2:02:17know, it's sometimes an anomaly in terms of behavior. But so I don't
- 2:02:24know. There's a lot more episodes left, so I'm guessing I'm sure you
- 2:02:27know the answer to all these things. I'm just in the dark bay.
- 2:02:30So we're hearing that by this point, Natalia is in this conundrum of lying,
- 2:02:39and then you could see how this could result in someone I would see
- 2:02:42this clinically, and it's not hard to imagine that if you put a child
- 2:02:45in a situation where they're forced to lie, then it creates a habit,
- 2:02:48maybe even a necessity, because in order to avoid being abused, you have
- 2:02:55to lie. And you know, like with Gypsy Rose, with the Munchausen
- 2:02:59by proxy, similar kind of thing. And I saw an interview with her
- 2:03:01and she was talking about how I don't know if this is exactly what she
- 2:03:04was saying, but it sounded like she was saying that she recognizes that she
- 2:03:10lies because her mom made her lie to everyone regarding her medical conditions, and
- 2:03:14she knows she has a problem with it, and she doesn't want to do
- 2:03:16that anymore. She doesn't lie out of psychopathy or lack of empathy or an
- 2:03:21urge to lie. She lies out of habit because she was safer if she
- 2:03:27habitually lied instead of acting normal, And it really screws with a child's mind
- 2:03:34because they are forced to divorce themselves from reality. They're forced to consider what
- 2:03:43they're supposed to be saying rather than just answering the question, and they also
- 2:03:47in all likelihood have to deny their own needs or own emotions just to get
- 2:03:51through the day. So was that purely because of the New Hampshire family.
- 2:03:57Did the New Hampshire family just further that problem or manifest in a certain way,
- 2:04:00because you know, I'd have a hard time believing that Natalia came to
- 2:04:03the New Hampshire family without any kind of trauma that would result in the kind
- 2:04:09of things we're seeing. And I've seen this before where you have a child
- 2:04:14that's adopted into a situation like that at that age. And if the New
- 2:04:17Hampshire family had their shit together or had enough resources or were better people,
- 2:04:23then there would be issues, but it would be mitigated. But then you
- 2:04:27add this further trauma of being potentially abused, at the very least forced to
- 2:04:32lie, maybe further abuse. It seems like they're kind of hinting at that.
- 2:04:36Who knows, there's no facts, but very least abandoned, abandoned by
- 2:04:41another family in Indiana. The Indiana family is not their fault. It's the
- 2:04:45New Hampshire. Now we have another family in Austin. Presumably the family in
- 2:04:47Austin didn't get or other. So you know, you just have these compounding
- 2:04:50issues that you had someone that was starting off in a direction of seeming psychopathy
- 2:04:56or lack of empathy, and then you have further experiences that that lock that
- 2:05:00in. That would be my assumption given what we're being presented here. But
- 2:05:05I'm not going to entertain even saying hello to her. The Barnetts claim that
- 2:05:13Natalia had threatened them, So what even if she did threaten you, you're
- 2:05:17the parent. I'm a teacher. I have six hundred students. Some of
- 2:05:20those are from really rough families. Yeah, I've heard this so many times
- 2:05:25from very well meaning people that are right given their anecdotal experience. Now I'm
- 2:05:30not saying that Christine and Michael are telling the truth, But as a clinician
- 2:05:35that has worked with the extreme cases, of which there are more than you
- 2:05:40would think there are in your community, I can tell you that when I
- 2:05:45hear of a parent that says this child has been threatening to kill me and
- 2:05:49tells me more information that sounds credible. I don't downplay it the way that
- 2:05:55she is doing. You know, what she's saying is, Hey, you
- 2:05:57know, I'm a teacher. I work with a lot of kids, and
- 2:06:00I've received death threats too. And you're the adult. You have to rise
- 2:06:04above it, seek support or find ways of venting about it. But you
- 2:06:10got to return to the table and be a parent. You got to be
- 2:06:13responsible. So you know, if you've never seen it before, there's so
- 2:06:17many things in my professional experience in any therapist would be able to say this
- 2:06:23That really made me realize that a lot of the descriptions that I had heard
- 2:06:29and was skeptical of might have even not been descriptive enough. Now, do
- 2:06:32people lie, do people exaggerate? Yeah? But like one example is with
- 2:06:36ADHD, it was becoming a lot more popular as a concept in the nineties
- 2:06:43when I became a therapist, and I would hear all this debate about it.
- 2:06:46I would hear some people saying that it was overdiagnosed and over medicated.
- 2:06:51You know, Ridlin was really trying to come was really starting to come into
- 2:06:55its own in the nineties, and there was this idea that all these parents
- 2:07:00were working too much and these kids were distressed and at home and they were
- 2:07:04just throwing pills of the kids, and that they were just normal kids and
- 2:07:10sometimes they get rambunctious, you know, boys will be boys, this kind
- 2:07:13of thing. And I would just hear a lot, and I would read
- 2:07:15the criteria in the DSM regarding ADHD, and we would see a vignette or
- 2:07:20something of video, but its usually an actor. You know, we didn't
- 2:07:24have what we have today. You can look on YouTube and actually get accounts
- 2:07:28from people with actual ADHD giving very effective, concise, coherent lectures about what
- 2:07:35it's like to have ADHD. We didn't have that in nineties. So you
- 2:07:38had to read in books, you had to hear stories, you had to
- 2:07:42take a professor's word for it or something. And I just didn't really know.
- 2:07:46Then. I actually had my first client who had a pretty quintessential case
- 2:07:51of ADHD, and long story short, within thirty seconds, I was convinced
- 2:08:00ADHD was a thing. The amount of hyperactivity and confusion and shooting himself in
- 2:08:07the foot and just physical activity. Now it might not have been it might
- 2:08:11not have been ADHD. It might have been something else, but later on
- 2:08:16that seemed to be the likely culprit was something different about the brain that results
- 2:08:22in different processing and different behavior, different impulses, different ability to regulate your
- 2:08:28emotions, different abilities regarding working memory, this kind of thing executive control over
- 2:08:35your impulses and your urges. And I saw it, And until you see
- 2:08:39it, it's hard to believe it because the description, especially when you get
- 2:08:43all these naysayers right. So when you have an individual who works, I
- 2:08:48don't doubt that she has received death threats from her students and that she's very
- 2:08:52good at responding to that. In order to be a teacher, you typically
- 2:08:56are pretty good with that sort of stuff. But there are people, you
- 2:08:58know, there's a bill curve, and you might have experienced ninety nine percent
- 2:09:01of the bill curve, but you haven't experienced that one percent. And there
- 2:09:05are kids who are you know, you present the tagline of the Natalia Gray
- 2:09:13story to a group of people that haven't seen the documentary, most of them
- 2:09:16in my experience, in my circle, in my neck of the woods,
- 2:09:18they'll say, well, there must be something wrong with the parents, they're
- 2:09:22overreacting or something. You know, kids will be kids. What's the big
- 2:09:24deal. But you know it's real. Now, do I know what's going
- 2:09:28on? No, this is documentary. There's usually a twist. Everyone could
- 2:09:33be lying. I don't know. She could be right about it in a
- 2:09:37way. So yeah, just throw that out there, because I've seen so
- 2:09:41many By the time the parents would come to me, or by the time
- 2:09:43I was assigned to the parents, they would have they would have gone to
- 2:09:46the teachers, they would have gone to the neighbors, they would have gone
- 2:09:48to their church, they would have gone to maybe even other therapists, their
- 2:09:52doctor, and everyone would tell them something like this, Ah, you're overreacting.
- 2:09:56You know. Kids would just you know, they might say, just
- 2:10:00be lenient, just love your kid, or you gotta be tougher, you
- 2:10:03gotta you know, here's this discipline program, you gotta read this book,
- 2:10:07you gotta maybe this medication. They're told that by so many And we can
- 2:10:11apply this problem to a lot of scenarios, not just scenarios like this,
- 2:10:16but any scenario in which you have parents who are dealing with a kid that
- 2:10:20has something a little out of the ordinary. Really, and as parents,
- 2:10:24you just get this constant message that there's something wrong with you, even though
- 2:10:30there isn't anything wrong with you, or maybe there's something kind of wrong with
- 2:10:33you, but not that wrong with you that results in that behavior, particularly
- 2:10:37from adopted kid that you didn't raise in the beginning, and it's upsetting,
- 2:10:41it's demoralizing. And so by the time I would come across these people,
- 2:10:46and I didn't have this perspective in the beginning because I didn't know about this
- 2:10:50phenomenon. But over the years, I started getting very defensive about these parents.
- 2:10:54Now I wouldn't automatically believe the parent's point of view and their account,
- 2:10:58but when I would hear people say this, I'd be like, just say,
- 2:11:01you haven't experienced it before. Just say, like, I'm I don't
- 2:11:05know. Maybe the parents are exaggerating, but maybe they're not. You know,
- 2:11:09just just you know, I've been in that situation before and this is
- 2:11:11how I deal with it, and I've dealt with it effectively. But I
- 2:11:15don't know everything because I haven't seen everything, because I'm not a clinician who
- 2:11:18specializes in the worst of the worst. You know, I was a clinician
- 2:11:22who specialized I mean, that's how i'd phrase it. But those are the
- 2:11:26sort of clients that would enter my office or I would be referred and I
- 2:11:31can tell you that those people are out there, and it's really unfortunate.
- 2:11:33Now, I'm sort of gravitating around an hypothesis that the Talia came to the
- 2:11:41family in Indiana, the Barnett's, and Talia came to Christine and Michael with
- 2:11:48significant challenges regarding her personality and her behavior, whether it's fixed and personality based
- 2:11:56or defense based, meaning that it was an adaptation to a difficult situation that
- 2:12:01wasn't locked in either way. I'm gravitating around the hypothesis that if I were
- 2:12:05a fly on the wall and I could observe everything behind the scenes, that
- 2:12:09Natalia was indeed having a lot of challenges that would challenge any parent, even
- 2:12:13her if she did in fact end up adopting her. Now, maybe she
- 2:12:18would have been perfect because she is skilled in this area. But if she
- 2:12:22had adopted her, she say, well, she's definitely the worst I've ever
- 2:12:24seen. But you know, I'm a go getter, and I know I
- 2:12:28have an approach and I have a perspective, and I've had families like that
- 2:12:33before. There was this one foster mother that was like that, that could
- 2:12:37just endure anything you know, she was a quirky person. I just started
- 2:12:41to hypothesize that in order to truly cope with these extreme cases, you had
- 2:12:48to be a little off yourself, not in destructive ways, but just like
- 2:12:52odd ways. But anyway, I'm gravitating around the hypothesis that Natalia, regardless
- 2:12:58of who parented her, there was going to be some major behaviors, maybe
- 2:13:03even close if not more severe than what Natalia presented with the Barnett The Barnett
- 2:13:09family also didn't help the situation. They probably also had some issues in their
- 2:13:15family that exacerbated We're hearing bits and pieces from Michael describing the way Christine at
- 2:13:20least, and again that's Michael saying it, and they're divorced, so maybe
- 2:13:24as Michael, maybe Michael has a reason to throw Christine on their bus.
- 2:13:28You know, making Natalia sleep outside it's not going to help the situation.
- 2:13:31Potentially, it's going to make it a lot worse and really cause a child
- 2:13:35with some abandonment issues and a defense of getting tough to resort to that tough
- 2:13:41persona of threatening and scaring people. I'm not truly scared that that's going to
- 2:13:48happen. That child needs help, so you get that child help. So
- 2:13:54yeah, I find actually being scared of a child when you're a group,
- 2:14:00full size, grown adult a little ridiculous. No. I could see how
- 2:14:05it might seem ridiculous if you've never seen it before, if you've never been
- 2:14:09there before. But I've had kids absolutely terrified me. And I had very
- 2:14:18limited contact with a child. I would see the child in their home or
- 2:14:22in the in my office or an agency office for half an hour or an
- 2:14:26hour, and absolutely I would be afraid and I couldn't imagine living with the
- 2:14:33child. So this idea that all children are harmless and you just have to
- 2:14:39love them is something that really will bog parents down. I would I loved
- 2:14:46that they believed that, but when they would have a kid. The way
- 2:14:50they're describing Italian, I don't know if any of it's accurate, But there
- 2:14:54would be clients that I work with with children that had major issues that were
- 2:14:58abusive and harmful and we're potentially psychopathic, and they believed that if they just
- 2:15:05loved the child more, it would solve the problem. And I wouldn't tell
- 2:15:09them to stop loving the child, but I would say that that has limited
- 2:15:13power, and because I would see the parents blame themselves or say I'm not
- 2:15:18loving them enough, or there's got to be a key to the lock,
- 2:15:20or what am I doing wrong? And it's got to be my spouse.
- 2:15:24They're screwing things up, you know, they just tear their family apart trying
- 2:15:28to find a solution that isn't likely to be found in that way. There's
- 2:15:31a solution of sorts. It's not the solution that they're looking for. The
- 2:15:35solution is a long term plan of lowering expectations and meeting the child where the
- 2:15:43child is. You know, that'd be another way of describing it. I
- 2:15:45would say lower expectations necessarily because parents would have a hard time doing that,
- 2:15:48of course, But I would say, what you're wanting from this child is
- 2:15:54to be like other kids that you know, or maybe even the other kids
- 2:15:58that you have at this age, given the trauma and the abandonment. Neurologically,
- 2:16:03even potentially, we can't expect that. So what we're looking at is
- 2:16:07someone developmentally that is much younger and is still struggling with a lot of difficult
- 2:16:11So you have to meet them where they're at, and what you can expect
- 2:16:15is that they can get better from there right, that they're not going to
- 2:16:20leap frog all the way forward, that maybe instead of threatening you once a
- 2:16:26month, they end up threatening you once every two months or something, so
- 2:16:30we're not trying to get rid of these behaviors. It's a hard sell,
- 2:16:33right, but it's more realistic. Instead of lying to you all the time,
- 2:16:39they only lie to you seventy percent of the time. You know,
- 2:16:43it's a hard pill to swallow for parents because there's this notion that that's giving
- 2:16:48up on a child or it's accepting a child's behavior. But what I'd say
- 2:16:52is change doesn't happen quickly. There's a lot of ground we have to cover.
- 2:16:56So if you want to actually change things, you have to reorient your
- 2:17:01mind to meeting the child where the child is. So I started posting on
- 2:17:07another and secondarily, this is a talk I have with a lot of novice
- 2:17:11therapists that a client will come into their office and the client comes into the
- 2:17:16office with a lot of trauma, a lot of issues, a lot of
- 2:17:20schemas, misunderstandings, a lot of difficulty, and the therapist is trying to
- 2:17:26get that person to do twenty five years of therapy in the span of five
- 2:17:31weeks and the therapist is either beating themselves up or they're blaming the client.
- 2:17:35And so it's a similar conversation. You got to meet the client where they're
- 2:17:39at and you can improve and if you learn how to identify it, you'll
- 2:17:43see improvement in your clients. But they're not going to solve twenty five thirty
- 2:17:48years of trauma overnight. You know, it takes a long time, and
- 2:17:52so there's going to be years of time where you're going to see a lot
- 2:17:54of behavior in the client, will be disclosing to you, a lot of
- 2:17:58concerning behavior as well well, or a lot of difficulty or mood issues or
- 2:18:03relationship problems that that is not going to change overnight. We can hope for
- 2:18:07sure. We don't just give up on people, but to beat yourself up
- 2:18:11or blame the client is it going to help? And so for this family,
- 2:18:15this mother, I believe in Austin to just say, look, you
- 2:18:18just have to you know, why are you threatened? Why are you afraid?
- 2:18:22What's wrong with you? Now? Maybe it is true that the Barnett's
- 2:18:26in Indiana were overreacting lace to see if their names ever appeared, because they
- 2:18:30would have found domestic violence in two thousand and three, years before this home
- 2:18:37study evaluation. They're fighting, Michael's got Christine and a headlock and he's pushedure.
- 2:18:48Okay, So we're reading a police report that there was domestic violence in
- 2:18:54partner violence between Michael and Christine, and it sounds like Michael was the portrayer
- 2:19:01and reading some of these descriptors, it sounds pretty severe. So, yeah,
- 2:19:07that's upsetting. Then Christine would be in the front yard arguing or fighting
- 2:19:13or there was. I never saw anything physical. It was just the yelling
- 2:19:16and the screaming. I felt sorry for Michael because she was degrading him and
- 2:19:22calling him a loser and a jerk, and I just was like that poor
- 2:19:26guy. Okay. So we have a witness, a neighbor saying that she
- 2:19:31would witness them having arguments, not physical, and according to her interpretation or
- 2:19:37her take, the wife Christine was the aggressor verbally and was putting Michael down
- 2:19:46and provoking the neighbor to feel bad for Michael. And the police report,
- 2:19:50I believe we only saw allegations of Michael being physically abusive, so it could
- 2:19:56be a situation where he was the pri Mary perpetrator for not the sole perpetrator,
- 2:20:01and that she would occasionally berate him verbally. You know, those would
- 2:20:07be anomalous behaviors or situations, but the main bulk of the situation was that
- 2:20:16he was being abusive overall. You know, she saw a snippet of it.
- 2:20:18It's also possible that they were both harmful to each other. That does
- 2:20:24happen. It's kind of rare, but it does happen. It's also possible
- 2:20:28that she was the main aggressor overall, and then he would strike back physically
- 2:20:31at times. Not that we would approve of that, but that's not unheard
- 2:20:35of. The way the police report looked, though, it didn't look like
- 2:20:41the sort of thing I would see from someone that I would conceptualize as being
- 2:20:46violent in a defensive manner. It's really hard to determine that based on especially
- 2:20:52descriptions. I doubt anyone saw those violent acts. I'm guessing a lot of
- 2:20:56it was described. You know, it's even possible, I suppose that Christine
- 2:21:00would even lie manipulate to create a police report to control Michael. That's not
- 2:21:05unheard of that an abusive person will make themselves out. In fact, it's
- 2:21:11very common that an abusive person, particularly past a certain threshold, will try
- 2:21:15to get out ahead of allegations or consequences by preempting the victim, by claiming
- 2:21:20that the victim is actually the abuser, because if they can control the narrative
- 2:21:24and get that out there by the time the victim, if the victim ever
- 2:21:28does come forward, then there's question marks and the abusive person wants that.
- 2:21:33All right, Well, let's adjourn there. Tune in next time when I
- 2:21:37continue watching, if you care to, and everyone, please take care of
- 2:21:41yourself because you deserve it, you really really do. Natalia had been trying
- 2:21:48to pull Christine into the electric fence. She'd been screaming out loud. Now
- 2:21:52I was there with the officer. I don't remember any of that being said.
- 2:21:56I don't remember there being any threats about being I'm going to kill you
- 2:22:01or anything like that. I just felt like the situation had kind of been
- 2:22:05overblown and was not really that big of a deal. Okay, So we
- 2:22:11have a worker at the farm or the park or the facility in which earlier
- 2:22:18we were hearing from Michael that Natalia was trying to electrocute Christine, and that's
- 2:22:24when the police are called, and that's when Talia went into the mental health
- 2:22:28hospital. So I'm guessing, so is this documentary just basically a bunch of
- 2:22:33accounts that are edited in a way to keep us flip flopping between the Barnett's
- 2:22:41being evil or Ittalia being evil or everyone's evil or something, because they're laying
- 2:22:46out the data in a way that is I think a result of that.
- 2:22:52And so I have a lot more of this to watch, and I'm guessing
- 2:22:54that it's going to continue to do that. But you know, I guess
- 2:22:56that's effective documentarian. But for me when I present things, it's like,
- 2:23:03just give the data and don't play around with this. But anyway, so
- 2:23:07we're hearing from one of the workers that, according to his account, the
- 2:23:11story is not true, that in fact, it was Christine that was being
- 2:23:18abusive to Natalia, or at the very least Natalia wasn't being violent or threatening
- 2:23:24or anything like that. Way back up there, that Italia's already gone,
- 2:23:28the officer with her has already gone. I don't speak to the officers.
- 2:23:31I speak to my wife. We keep going, We keep going, get
- 2:23:37about forty fifty yards down and I start hearing screaming Okay, so they're catching
- 2:23:41him on an inconsistency. The temptation is to think that it's a volitional lie.
- 2:23:48But this happens when you study I witness accounts and people's memories, people
- 2:23:54will be very confident. That's kind of the problem is that it's not that
- 2:23:58people mistery member, it's how confident they are in their mis memory. So
- 2:24:03it could be just an involuntary thing, you know, like one thing that
- 2:24:09could have happened. And this is just on his side. This is giving
- 2:24:11him charity right now, this is giving him the benefit of doubt. Of
- 2:24:15course, just on the onset, I'll just say it's a possibility that he's
- 2:24:18completely lying, is lying about everything. I have been wondering about that.
- 2:24:22I don't have any big reason to believe he's been lying about everything, but
- 2:24:26you just wonder, and he does have motivation to paint himself in a positive
- 2:24:31light, at least for the documentary. But so there is that possibility he
- 2:24:35is completely lying, and he's been chronically lying about everything. It is possible.
- 2:24:39On the other side, it's possible that he you know, if we
- 2:24:45were there and we could see a recording of it or something that he arrived
- 2:24:48on the scene at the very tail end of things and didn't see much.
- 2:24:54Then later he hears a description from his wife, and since he's partial to
- 2:24:58his wife, he he believes her, especially given his own experience. Maybe
- 2:25:01who knows. And then over time he hears the story enough that he starts
- 2:25:05to believe he was there, and then when he's asked about it, he
- 2:25:09tells a story as if he was there. Then later on, when he's
- 2:25:13asked the question again, he's had time to think or he knows that there's
- 2:25:18some question marks here, maybe he is less partial to his wife or ex
- 2:25:22wife, and he starts to reevaluate that. He's like, well, actually,
- 2:25:26I don't know if I was actually there. In fact, no,
- 2:25:28I actually wasn't there. That happened in an audio episode that I may or
- 2:25:33may not have already published, in which I interviewed my dad on the podcast
- 2:25:37the audio podcast, which when I was talking about this moment in which I
- 2:25:41was bullied by this kid, this bigger kid on the way home from school.
- 2:25:45I walked to and from school, and this bigger kid, like I
- 2:25:48don't know, four or five years older than me, just for whatever reason,
- 2:25:50decided he was going to bully me the entire walk home. It was
- 2:25:54a mile walk, and he just decided he was going to hit me and
- 2:25:58abuse me and put me down, and he just slowly he just because I
- 2:26:03had to walk home, and I'm I don't know, seven years old or
- 2:26:05something, and for whatever reason, my friends weren't there, I don't know,
- 2:26:09but he just walked with me all the way home. I might've even
- 2:26:11been younger. I might have even been like in kindergarten or something, but
- 2:26:15he just walked with me. It was a seventies, a different time.
- 2:26:18Everyone walked to school by themselves, and so he just walked with me and
- 2:26:22abused me the whole time. He didn't like abuse me and leave, and
- 2:26:26so I just was like walking in this trying the whole time, just being
- 2:26:31like, okay, I just got to get home. I just got to
- 2:26:33get home, you know. And I'm small, I can't run away from
- 2:26:35him. And then I told my parents about it, and then they went
- 2:26:39so in my head. Me and my dad went over to the house and
- 2:26:43confronted the family, and I had some details about that wrong. My dad
- 2:26:48said I wasn't there, So it's more likely that I wasn't there because it
- 2:26:52wouldn't be something that my dad would bring me along for. Right, It's
- 2:26:56like he's heard my story. I've had enough drama for the day. He's
- 2:27:00going to walk to the neighbor's house. And then my dad told me the
- 2:27:03story, maybe not directly after, but maybe years later even and I constructed
- 2:27:09in my head a story that I was there. And so it's possible that
- 2:27:13he just had one of those who knows, But it's also possible that he's
- 2:27:18just a chronic liar. We haven't heard anything about his history or his issues.
- 2:27:22You know, some people who are on a mission to save the world
- 2:27:26in a good way, and part of that mission involves adopting kids in need
- 2:27:31in a good way, they sometimes have very difficult pasts and similar pasts to
- 2:27:37the kids they're adopting, and those pasts can result in a lot of issues,
- 2:27:41a lot of fears, defenses, patterns, habits, modeled behavior that
- 2:27:45can result in maybe lying that isn't good. It's not an excuse, but
- 2:27:52I'm just I don't know. I'm just throwing it out there. She helped
- 2:27:54me up, like literally, like I was down and I reached out and
- 2:27:58she helped me up. Fell and it was kind of close, so like
- 2:28:05I was trying to get up and she fell and I fell, and then
- 2:28:09I guess she thought I was trying to put her into the electric fence or
- 2:28:11whatever, because you know, they said don't go by that. Okay,
- 2:28:13we're in an interview that occurs seven years after the incident. I think,
- 2:28:20if I'm looking at my timeline, right, or at least a number of
- 2:28:24years, because this took twenty nineteen with a forensic psychologist or a forensic evaluator
- 2:28:30or so, I'm sorry, I forget. And she's giving her account of
- 2:28:31that story at the creamery, the farm with the electric fence. We're hearing
- 2:28:39from Natalia the story, and she's saying that her feet were hurting and that
- 2:28:43it was just an accident and the mom fell, and then the mom apparently
- 2:28:48just made up that Natalia was trying to kill her by pushing her into the
- 2:28:52fence. What age? But she has not grown in four years. So
- 2:28:58the judge came up with his own little formula, Well, you stop growing
- 2:29:01at eighteen. If she hasn't grown in four years, then she's at least
- 2:29:05eighteen when she entered their lives. And I'm going to add four years he
- 2:29:09said, okay, I find you twenty two. My god. I mean
- 2:29:13if this legal expert, this legal expert seems to not be associated with either
- 2:29:18side or any side. I think it's just an expert that the documentarian's hired.
- 2:29:24So we can maybe trust this person's account a little better better than others.
- 2:29:28I don't know, but she's saying that in court, the judge,
- 2:29:33without any justification, just came up with their own The judge came up with
- 2:29:39his own equations, saying that, well, you stopped growing at eighteen.
- 2:29:43I don't think that's a firm scientific fact. And let's add four years because
- 2:29:48according to you, she stopped growing four years ago, and let's just say
- 2:29:54she's twenty two. Wow, now there's a medical issue here as well that
- 2:30:01would result in growth being different. Now, maybe the judge knew that and
- 2:30:05took that into I don't know, it doesn't sound like it. So I
- 2:30:09grew up thinking that judges and police officers and teachers and therapists were all intelligent
- 2:30:16and wise and fair and right, at least most of the time. I
- 2:30:22have been disabused of that lie throughout my life. Judges included. Most judges
- 2:30:28are fine, but they're human beings, so you're going to have a bell
- 2:30:31curve regardless. And I have learned the hard way that judges sometimes have no
- 2:30:39idea what they're doing, and the problem is they have almost unilateral power,
- 2:30:45particularly when they're dealing with situations in which the people who might push back don't
- 2:30:50have the refund, don't have the funds or the resources to push back effectively.
- 2:30:54And even if they do push back, all the judge has to do
- 2:30:56is just rescind their previous ruling or something. You know, it's a blanket
- 2:31:03statement that I'm saying, but I had almost a very similar situation to this
- 2:31:09regarding age. So early in my career, I was working with a family,
- 2:31:13the mother, the parents were divorced, The mother brings in her three
- 2:31:16kids, and I'm working with the three kids and the mom, and immediately
- 2:31:22I am wanting to meet with the dad, and I get the phone number
- 2:31:26or something and I'm reaching out to the dad or the mom reached out the
- 2:31:28dead and the dad was refusing to come in because, you know, as
- 2:31:33a family therapist, I got to see everybody, and the issues weren't even
- 2:31:37blaming the dad. It was just I think the mom was worried that the
- 2:31:43kids weren't processing the divorce well or something. It wasn't like this custody battle
- 2:31:48or yelling at the dad. It just seemed like a general worry for the
- 2:31:50kids. And so I figured that both parents would want to at least talk
- 2:31:56to me before and during the treatment of three boys. But I reached out
- 2:32:01to dad and he refused, or the mom reached out to and then I
- 2:32:03tried to reach out to the dad and he agreed, and so he came
- 2:32:09in and it was a one off session that he said, you know,
- 2:32:11I'll meet with you one time, and so he met with me one time.
- 2:32:15And then this is This is months into the treatment by this point,
- 2:32:18and I get I can't remember the exact details, but I get notified,
- 2:32:22probably by the mom, maybe via phone. She calls me and says that
- 2:32:28I can no longer work with the family legally speaking, it's illegal. She
- 2:32:33might have said, it's illegal for me to bring my kids in to see
- 2:32:35you. And I said, what why? And she informed me that the
- 2:32:41husband, the ex husband, after meeting me, had felt threatened or something.
- 2:32:46Even though I was very kind, there was I didn't have anything against
- 2:32:50the dad. There was no reason after this, I had a thing against
- 2:32:54the dad, but when I met with him, I wasn't blaming him for
- 2:32:58anything. I was just wanting to work with the family and wanting to talk
- 2:33:01with everybody. But I am informed about this and then I said, why
- 2:33:07is it legal for you to bring the kids? And she says, well,
- 2:33:11because he got a lawyer and went into court and told the judge that
- 2:33:16me Kirk, that I was seventeen years old and not qualified as a therapist,
- 2:33:22that I had no credentials, even though at the time I would have
- 2:33:26been twenty seven maybe older, and definitely had credentials, had a master's degree.
- 2:33:33Was We didn't have licensure back then, but we had certification and I
- 2:33:39was certified to practice as a psychotherapist. I also was hired by an agency
- 2:33:46I was an employee. I wasn't in that wasn't my private practice at the
- 2:33:52time. So because the former husband, the dad went to the judge and
- 2:33:58just claimed that I was seven and I wasn't qualified, the judge just took
- 2:34:03the dad's word for it and wrote some sort of injunction or order or something
- 2:34:09that actually prevented me from seeing the kids. And when I learned about that,
- 2:34:13I said, well, what don't courts of law require evidence, And
- 2:34:20isn't just saying something considered hearsay or at the very least not enough to go
- 2:34:26off of to create havoc in people's lives. You know, It's one thing
- 2:34:31for someone to believe believe someone, it's not a thing to believe and then
- 2:34:33actually act on that right. So that was my early That was one of
- 2:34:37the early experiences I had, among many, in which I realized that judges
- 2:34:43are human beings, and when you let human beings have full control, sometimes
- 2:34:48that results in an abuse of power. And yeah, it was very disappointing.
- 2:34:54I had run ins with police in a similar way. Just to give
- 2:34:58you a small summary, I was working with a family and the older brother
- 2:35:05two brothers, and the older brother was accused of sexually abusing the younger brother,
- 2:35:09and it wasn't strong evidence. I think in the end it was decided
- 2:35:16that it wasn't actually happening, and a police officer got involved, as they
- 2:35:20should and was investigating and had talked to it the family, had talked to
- 2:35:26each of the boys, and when he interrogated the older boy, my client,
- 2:35:31the accused, the police officer said and I heard this all from the
- 2:35:35police officer later, by the way, that he told the older boy that
- 2:35:39he knew that he was sexually abusive of the younger brother. And the older
- 2:35:43brother's like, what are you talking about. I didn't do anything. I
- 2:35:45would no, No, that didn't happen. And the police officer said,
- 2:35:48I know you did it, and you know why. I know. The
- 2:35:50kids like, how do you Why would you know that, and the police
- 2:35:54officer says, because your therapist, Kirkanda told me that you told him that
- 2:35:58you sexually abused your younger brother. Obviously that never happened, or just say
- 2:36:05that never happened. It's not obvious, but that never happened, not even
- 2:36:09anything in the ballpark of that. And so when I was going to work
- 2:36:16with this is in home therapy. So I go to the house and the
- 2:36:18kid, older kid, won't talk to me, big surprise, because he
- 2:36:24believes that I just straight up lied to a police officer to throw him in
- 2:36:28jail. And you know, I'm asking around. The mom says, well,
- 2:36:33you know this happened, and I'm like what. So I call the
- 2:36:37police and I get the supervisor and I tell them the situation, and the
- 2:36:41supervisor is listening, and I lay it all out and I say, so,
- 2:36:46I would like this to be corrected. I would like the police officer
- 2:36:48to tell the kid that I did not say that, and that's not okay.
- 2:36:52You know, I had other questions, like so it's just okay for
- 2:36:54police officers just a straight up lie to anyone, including children, including children's
- 2:37:01therapists, Like you can just make shit up. You can just say like,
- 2:37:03well, your father told me this, or your father abused me or
- 2:37:07whatever, like you can just say whatever you want to in the course of
- 2:37:11trying to extract a confession or something. And apparently that is true at least
- 2:37:16that's what I was told, and or at least there's not a viable way
- 2:37:20of pushing back on that. And the supervisor's like yep, and he's listening,
- 2:37:24and he's being he's listening, and I'm thinking I'm gaining traction, and
- 2:37:28so I say, I want you to do something about it, and the
- 2:37:30plice the supervisor says, well, there's nothing I can do, because that's
- 2:37:35just what it is to investigate these situations. Now, I would kind of
- 2:37:41understand if there was strong evidence that abuse was happening, and you really needed
- 2:37:46to get that confession or some other because it was just he said, he
- 2:37:48said, he said, sort of situation, and you just you have so
- 2:37:52many data points putting in the direction you just really have to nail the perpetrator
- 2:37:56down, and so you fudge the truth to get them to confess or reveal
- 2:37:58something. I guess I would understand that, but this police officer basically had
- 2:38:03nothing to go off of. I remember the evidence being like really circumstantial,
- 2:38:09like a teacher was taking a guess or something like that, and the supervisor
- 2:38:13at the end just said like, well, thanks for telling me, but
- 2:38:16nothing's going to happen. So seeya and I just thought, Wow. You
- 2:38:22know when you give institutions and the people in those institutions complete power without any
- 2:38:30checks and balances, then you get what you get. Are all police officers
- 2:38:33like that? No? Are all judges like that? No? But the
- 2:38:35ones that are bad, who should be fired or at least sanctioned or retrained,
- 2:38:41they just get away with it and they can abuse and harm. And
- 2:38:45so we have a situation where seemingly we have a judge who just made up
- 2:38:50this notion that the child is twenty two, when there's a lot of evidence,
- 2:38:52at least presented to us thus far, that the child was at real
- 2:38:56least not twenty two. We still have the issue. You have the claim
- 2:39:01by Michael. He's the only one who's made this claim, I think.
- 2:39:05Er, Wait, did we know from other people that they also saw the
- 2:39:09pubic hair. Yeah? Right, the mental health hospital said that they saw
- 2:39:13that and the breast development and were speculating that the child was a lot older
- 2:39:22than the stated age. But we haven't heard from a medical professional about the
- 2:39:26possibilities here. We've just seen them do a Google search and that kind of
- 2:39:31stuff. So I'm guessing that at some point we're going to hear from a
- 2:39:35medical professional, and I'm just going to take a guess and say that they
- 2:39:37will claim that it is possible that she is the stated age. We also
- 2:39:41heard from the mom over the phone that the stated age was correct. Who
- 2:39:46knows, I don't know. So if you're ever in court, or you're
- 2:39:50ever having to go to court, like for a divorce or something, and
- 2:39:54your lawyer says, let's try to avoid going to court, trust their opinion.
- 2:40:01Not always, but it's not like it is in the movies. Not
- 2:40:05always. Sometimes it is, but it's not always. We talked about that.
- 2:40:09What crazy I had to I've been going crazy that I had to go
- 2:40:18to the North Community North Hospital LIB and go crazy. Okay, okay,
- 2:40:28So to catch you up. She is living in an apartment now because the
- 2:40:33parents. According to Michael, it was mainly Christine, but the parents wanted
- 2:40:39her out and wanted her to live in her own apartment. So I think
- 2:40:43they might be paying for everything, the parents, and she is living in
- 2:40:46her own place because the judge said she's twenty two. A neighbor said that
- 2:40:52she claimed and Natalia claim that she was twenty six, even though on my
- 2:40:58timeline she would only be twenty three or twenty four, but I don't know.
- 2:41:03And then if we consider that Natalia is not actually that old and is
- 2:41:09still a child, the neighbor called CPS. CPS got involved, and Natalia
- 2:41:16had reported to the CPS worker that the parents were only buying her food every
- 2:41:22couple months or something. The dad was claiming differently. The interactions between the
- 2:41:28dad and Natalia seem I don't know, notable. It's just hard. It's
- 2:41:31hard to watch because someone is stuff. Even if Natalia is lying, which
- 2:41:37is possible, she's not lying because she wakes up in the morning. In
- 2:41:41all likelihood, she's not lying because she wakes up in the morning and says,
- 2:41:45I just want to manipulate everybody. She's lying out of deep trauma and
- 2:41:50confusion and developmental issues related to attachment disruption and injury that can result in chronic
- 2:41:58life pathological lying. So it's hard to watch. Even if I believe the
- 2:42:05dad, which we can't know, then what we see is someone who was
- 2:42:11abandoned and thrown away like trash, like the way the biological mother said on
- 2:42:16the phone. Or was it the ant, the ant that said this,
- 2:42:20yeah, the ant. Anyway, it's hard to watch. But then we
- 2:42:24hear that she went into another hospital, a different hospital, seemingly recently to
- 2:42:31this time span, So twenty thirteen is and I think we're about to read
- 2:42:35something that she wrote while she was in there. She said she went crazy.
- 2:42:39But I could see that looking like a lot of different things. I
- 2:42:43could see the trauma, the abandonment, the frustration. There's also a lot
- 2:42:48of sympathy you have for someone that has trouble walking. She has maybe trouble
- 2:42:52taking care of herself. She certainly isn't old enough to have learned how to
- 2:42:58do those things even if she were in her mid twenties, given her history,
- 2:43:03right to just have the situation where she's abandoned. I am doing this
- 2:43:11because I'm trying to intimidate mom and dad, and I am trying to frame
- 2:43:15them by making my parents look mean. Okay, So it's hard to know
- 2:43:20if this is accurate. It's possible she is being mistreated and she is being
- 2:43:26pressured to write this or just wants to get people off her back. Yeah.
- 2:43:30As a therapist in the early part of my career, I would work
- 2:43:33with people who were both victims of abuse or being mistreated, and they would
- 2:43:39lie sometimes to cover it up. We understand that right that victims will sometimes
- 2:43:45lie because they calculate whether it's accurate or not, that it's better for them
- 2:43:50to just say what the perpetrator wants them to say, so that they'll be
- 2:43:54abuseless or something. So it's hard to know, But it's also completely possible,
- 2:44:00given at least the allegations against Natalia, that she was absolutely lying and
- 2:44:05that something happened in the hospital that helped her to admit this or something this
- 2:44:09handwritten letter. Natalia is recanting all of these things she had said about Christine
- 2:44:16in the past, saying I made them up to make my mom and dad
- 2:44:22look really bad. Is it possible that this is actually dictated by Christine so
- 2:44:28that DCS would get off her back. Oh, so she's claiming that maybe
- 2:44:33Christine dictated it, So the letter was written not when she was in the
- 2:44:37hospital. I don't know anyway. I wonder if there's a popular because there's
- 2:44:39so many twists and turns, And this is what it's like when you work
- 2:44:43for cases like this. You just you gather information, you take guesses,
- 2:44:48and it might seem as though a clinician would need to know the answer to
- 2:44:52this. It'd be nice, but it's not necessary because what I would do,
- 2:44:56and I'm guessing a lot of other therapists would as well, is I
- 2:45:00do what I can to just treat the issues in a diplomatic way, as
- 2:45:05if everyone's telling the truth. Does Natalia lie sometimes? You know, it's
- 2:45:09probable, so I would work on that. I wouldn't just repeat all the
- 2:45:13allegations and say I believe them, but I might even say to someone in
- 2:45:16Natalia shoes, look, you're telling me that you don't lie very often?
- 2:45:20Your parents are saying you lie all the time. I don't know what the
- 2:45:24truth is, and frankly it doesn't really matter. But you know, for
- 2:45:28the sake of this session, how about we just talk about truth and about
- 2:45:33lying and about reasons for lying. Like I'll tell you for me, the
- 2:45:37reasons why I might lie in my past is because of this, this,
- 2:45:41and this. Do you find that you might lie in those situations as well?
- 2:45:46You know, just generally talking about it, because everyone can have a
- 2:45:50conversation like that. And if she did have a problem with lying, then
- 2:45:54I would hope that it would help with the parents. I would say,
- 2:45:58look, you're telling me that you do anything wrong. Other people are saying
- 2:46:01otherwise. So regardless, though, let's just talk about parenting. Let's talk
- 2:46:05about what you've learned about parenting, and I can talk about things that I've
- 2:46:09learned about how to parent difficult children. Now I'm not saying that I know
- 2:46:13that Natalia is difficult. I'm just saying that, yeah, she's not the
- 2:46:18easiest kid to parent, right, that's what you're saying. I don't know
- 2:46:20to what degrees I'm out there. Let's talk about parenting. I might bring
- 2:46:24them all together and say let's talk about how to bond and how to work
- 2:46:28out conflict, even though I don't know who is to blame. Westfield nine
- 2:46:33one one. What's your emergency. I'm stalking one of my neighbors. I
- 2:46:37want to hurt them. I'm afraid of what might happen if someone doesn't help
- 2:46:41me. I'm going to send some help. While living at the Union Street
- 2:46:48apartments, Natalia calls the police on herself. Wow. Okay, So the
- 2:46:56Ockham's razor explanation is that she actually does have a compulsion to harm and either
- 2:47:03has remorse about it or just doesn't want to get in trouble for it,
- 2:47:09and has to call the police on herself to avoid taking action against one of
- 2:47:13her neighbors. They've been interviewing neighbors, a few of them, and they
- 2:47:18all say that she was annoying and a pest and invasive and clingy, and
- 2:47:26some of the neighbors were saying that she was scary. She just gave They
- 2:47:28didn't give any concrete reasons to be afraid of her. So starting to know
- 2:47:33if that's some sort of bias or stereotype, or maybe they were primed to
- 2:47:39worry about her because of things that they had known from other people. I
- 2:47:41don't know, because they didn't really give any huge reason other than that one
- 2:47:46of the neighbors came home and found that Natalia was in her house rifling through
- 2:47:52the fridge. The whole time that the neighbors are describing Natalia, what I
- 2:47:58was thinking was that Natalia is She's like a puppy dog that is desperate for
- 2:48:03attention. People who are neglected will sometimes develop what we call an attachment disorder.
- 2:48:09It's not super related to attachment in the way that I often talk about
- 2:48:15it with preoccupation and dismissive and that kind of thing. It's related, but
- 2:48:18it's not the same thing. And in the DSM, which is right here,
- 2:48:22we have a couple of constructs related to attachment for children, and one
- 2:48:28of them is the observation that you'll have a child that will indiscriminately bond with
- 2:48:33anybody. They don't zero in on one person, even if that person has
- 2:48:39been identified as a stable attachment figure. They will bond with strangers, with
- 2:48:43new people, and they will be very solicitous in trying to bond and trying
- 2:48:50to connect, and it can be very sweet, but it can also be
- 2:48:54very risky. Because you have a child that is willing to just go off
- 2:48:58with anybody. Also be off putting to people because people typically aren't used to
- 2:49:03that we have boundaries. It's like, well, you know, you have
- 2:49:05your family and we're your neighbor where I'm not your mom, why are you
- 2:49:09in my house? And other neighbors were saying as soon as we would get
- 2:49:13or when we would leave to go to a sarga game for one of our
- 2:49:16kids to tell you would call us in Texas and call us in Texas,
- 2:49:18and as soon as we got home, she would rush over to a house
- 2:49:22and she'd be just completely ignoring the fact that we are trying to decompress from
- 2:49:26our trip. And so when I hear that description, I just hear of
- 2:49:30an extremely lonely person who might not have the same sense of boundaries and not
- 2:49:37the same sense of how to build a relationship because it's never been shown to
- 2:49:43her. So we're hearing that, and then she calls on one one saying
- 2:49:48that she's worried she's going to hurt kill. She's saying she's stocking one of
- 2:49:52her neighbors. I don't know, given the allegation that she is lying a
- 2:49:58lot which we can't know for sure. But if we go with that,
- 2:50:01then it's hard to believe anything she says. She could be lying, she
- 2:50:05could be coerced into making this call. I don't know. Maybe we'll get
- 2:50:07some details. She'd been stalking a neighbor and she had thoughts of wanting to
- 2:50:13harm others. What her name, Natalia Barnac. I'm aware that Natalia contacted
- 2:50:20nine to one one a couple of times while she was living in that apartment.
- 2:50:22Okay, according to I believe the police report. I don't know,
- 2:50:26and we're not being told what this copy is, but stated that she is
- 2:50:31stalking several neighbors across the street. She says she wants to hurt them and
- 2:50:35is afraid of what might happen. Okay, so not just one neighbor,
- 2:50:37but several, and told the officers that she was attempting to burn When the
- 2:50:41mother arrived, Christine, daughter was trying to burn things. Nothing is on
- 2:50:46fire. She believes daughter is in a destructive phase and may want to hurt
- 2:50:50self and or others. Yeah, I mean it is possible. There are
- 2:50:56cases that I've worked with in which people will have the set of behaviors symptoms
- 2:51:01if you will, in which they are fascinated with fire. They have a
- 2:51:07semi obsession with harming other people and getting other people, getting back at other
- 2:51:13people. They can be very cold on emotional, psychopathic lack of remorse.
- 2:51:18But it's interesting that she would call nine one one, So that's interesting.
- 2:51:24And she goes, oh, they're afraid of me. I said why.
- 2:51:28She says, because I took a knife to them one night, you know,
- 2:51:31And she just had this strange look in her eye, like it's a
- 2:51:35normal thing, all right. So, again corroborating evidence, we have a
- 2:51:39neighbor who seems credible, who doesn't have a vested interest in lying, seemingly
- 2:51:45who is saying that Natalia admitted to the neighbor that she did threaten the parents
- 2:51:50with a knife. Now, Natalia could have been lying in that moment.
- 2:51:54I don't know. You just feel bad if that's true. It wasn't until
- 2:52:01she started talking to me more in depth about the history with her family and
- 2:52:05she said, well, I tried to kill my mom, and I just
- 2:52:09was asking her more questions, like well what happened? All right? Another
- 2:52:13corroborating witness saying that Italia admitted to her that she tried to kill her mom,
- 2:52:20Well, what happened? How did you try to do that? I
- 2:52:24stood over them with a knife, so they took all the knives away,
- 2:52:26and then I tried to poison them. So I had to live in the
- 2:52:30garage for a while. All right. So we're hearing from a third person,
- 2:52:35and we're hearing about those incidents that Michael talked about, and we're also
- 2:52:39learning that she had to live in the garage for a while. Okay,
- 2:52:43it's upsetting. And he said she got hanging around too close to their chairs,
- 2:52:50rubbing up, you know, leaning on and stuff. It made my
- 2:52:56grandson feel uncomfortable, so he told Nataia get out of here and slam the
- 2:53:03door of her face. Okay. So the neighbors are saying that she seemingly
- 2:53:11was very interested in the young boys and not the girls in the neighborhood.
- 2:53:16And now we're hearing from one of the neighbors saying that, according to her,
- 2:53:20she heard a story from her grandson that we just heard. So what
- 2:53:26does that mean? And then we have a landscaping crew and she would like
- 2:53:33hide behind the bushes then kind of pop out at them and would scare them.
- 2:53:39Okay, another neighbor is claiming that she would hide the bushes and jump
- 2:53:43out at the landscaping crew. We're not hearing from the landscaping crew, so
- 2:53:48who knows. But if we go with the psychopathy hypothesis, the sadistic hypothesis,
- 2:53:54yeah, you could as someone who likes to screw with people. I've
- 2:54:00treated people like this. I'm reminded of some situations. It's not pleasant.
- 2:54:03Obviously, if we go with that hypothesis, then maybe that's what was going
- 2:54:07on. The other angle, which also could be coinciding with the statistic psychopath
- 2:54:13pleasure of it, is that she's lonely and she's never had anyone pay attention
- 2:54:18to her, and she can kind of get two birds with one stone.
- 2:54:24She can have the power and the pleasure of scaring others and invading their space,
- 2:54:31but also she gets to be in other people's space because she's never allowed
- 2:54:35that. She was constantly being abandoned by at least what we know of.
- 2:54:39What we heard of were three families in Ukraine and the orphanage. Even though
- 2:54:43the orphanage wasn't a permanent place, a young child wouldn't know that. And
- 2:54:48then there's the family in New Hampshire. She went to stay with that other
- 2:54:52family in Indiana. The Austin family never took her in, and then we
- 2:54:58have this family, you know, Michael and Christine. She's been abandoned by
- 2:55:01that. You know, there's a lot of loneliness. And the neighbors keep
- 2:55:05talking about how she was really weird and awkward and off putting and bother some.
- 2:55:11And that could be a product of the statistic psychopathy. It could also
- 2:55:16be a product of the fact that she's just so desperate. You know,
- 2:55:18if it's one thing to turn people off, whether it's friends or dating,
- 2:55:22is desperateness, right, and also lack of practice. There's not been a
- 2:55:30venue in which she could learn how to socialize because she might not have ever
- 2:55:33had that, so I don't know. She seemed to hang around all the
- 2:55:39old or real old guys a lot, and she was trying sexual or talking
- 2:55:46sexual things to him. Fred was in there doing his laundry. Okay,
- 2:55:54So according to one of the neighbors, she has heard that older men in
- 2:56:00the neighborhood had told her, the neighbor, that she would proposition them sexually.
- 2:56:07We heard this from the staff at the mental health hospital. So it
- 2:56:13could be the sadistic psychopathy and the pleasure of gaining power over others, making
- 2:56:20other people uncomfortable, maybe even getting sexually turned on by that. It also
- 2:56:24could be an effort to connect with other people. It also could be a
- 2:56:28cry for help. It also could be an effort to recreate something in her
- 2:56:33past, maybe something happened when she was a young child, maybe with Michael.
- 2:56:39Let's hope, not Downey Hill. They were laying Italian him, were
- 2:56:43laying rolling back and forth, and then the next thing I know, she
- 2:56:50was close to the little boy and Natalia reached over it started undoing his pants,
- 2:56:58and I said, Natalia, what are you doing? My god,
- 2:57:01my god. This is treatable with a specialist. There are specialists who work
- 2:57:09with people who have this sort of compulsion, and they are able to reform
- 2:57:13them. Some people are not easily reformed, or seemingly it's impossible to help
- 2:57:20them. But there are plenty of cases that I have personally seen and lots
- 2:57:26of research demonstrating that people who have a compulsion or a history of perpetrating sexual
- 2:57:33predation on children or others can be reformed. They can be changed. He
- 2:57:39said, if you ever touch my son again, you know, he was
- 2:57:43just the dad enraged, and she took off and went up front doing that
- 2:57:48with that little boy in front of us. God knows what she does.
- 2:57:52That is the pattern that by the time you've seen it, the perpetrator has
- 2:57:58become emboldened by my successes in the past. My middle son and my youngest
- 2:58:03son, I've not seen them in over eight years, and they want nothing
- 2:58:07to do with seeing me. We all were abused in that household, and
- 2:58:15Christine was the purveyor of abuse. Okay, So this episode the fourth episode,
- 2:58:22and they're also saying that this is season one, so I'm guessing that
- 2:58:26they're predicting there'll be more developments to the story. I don't know, but
- 2:58:28in this fourth episode, it's just a lot of hearsay and it seems like
- 2:58:33fluff. It seems like reality TV. This episode, they found a police
- 2:58:39officer that would say the right things. They have a lot of speculations being
- 2:58:46said, and I don't really know what to say about that. So I
- 2:58:52wasn't reacting to it on this channel, so I thought I'd catch you up.
- 2:58:56And where we're at now is almost present day, and they got a
- 2:59:01divorced Christine and Michael, and it was not amicable, as he says.
- 2:59:05And he's saying that he hasn't had contact with his two younger sons. He
- 2:59:09lives with the oldest son, So I don't know what that means. Does
- 2:59:13that mean that Michael is a horrible person and the boys are reasonably drawing a
- 2:59:20boundary? Or is Christine the way that Michael is depicting her as this master
- 2:59:26manipulator and abusive person and has manipulated the two boys. We can't really take
- 2:59:33the dad's account at face value. If he has some data, if we
- 2:59:37have corroborating evidence, then we can start to piece together story. But you
- 2:59:41know, a dad that is upset at his ex wife and claiming that she's
- 2:59:46an abusive person, that's not very I don't know compelling. Could be true,
- 2:59:52could be true, we don't know. There's just a lack of data.
- 2:59:56This episode seems to really be trying to paint picture, and I'm resisting
- 3:00:01the pull of the manipulation that they're put. I'm looking for data. I'm
- 3:00:05trying to see past. It's like with reality TV. I can't take what
- 3:00:09is being edited and presented to us at face value. I'm looking for the
- 3:00:13truth, so to speak. And there's just not a lot to go off
- 3:00:16of in this episode, but the facts are, if I'm looking at my
- 3:00:22notes, is that the dad was charged and I think the mom was too,
- 3:00:24with two counts of child and neglect. They moved across the state,
- 3:00:28I believe, to Lafayette, Indiana, and then Natalia connected with someone in
- 3:00:35Lafayette called Cynthia Man. And there's a couple, the man couple, the
- 3:00:41man's Cynthia and someone else. They really connected with Natalia. And then there
- 3:00:50was an interview later on five years later, and Cynthia Man was interviewed and
- 3:00:56said that she still was very connected to Natalia and Natalia had been living with
- 3:01:01them for five years, which I just give it big thumbs up to because
- 3:01:03that actually might be just the thing that Natalia needs. Is maybe Natalia had
- 3:01:09reached a certain level of maturity or maybe the man couple so weird to say
- 3:01:13that, but Cynthia Mann and her partner, maybe they just have what it
- 3:01:18takes to adjust and handle Natalia, sort of roll with the punches and help
- 3:01:24her to feel safe enough so that Natalia doesn't have to act out in those
- 3:01:28ways. Natalia, look at me, look at me, Selia, how
- 3:01:33long have you been on this wall? Thank you? Two minutes? Okay,
- 3:01:41so it's hurting you that bad in two minutes? All right, Well
- 3:01:46you still need to be on your wall. Okay. I don't know what
- 3:01:50I'm seeing right here, At least the way they're playing it, which could
- 3:01:54be an accurate depiction, is that this is Christine being draconian and abusive to
- 3:02:01Natalia. That girl stands there knows in the wall. From ten am to
- 3:02:05noon, Christine makes everybody lunch, gets Natalia's food, puts it right next
- 3:02:11to her. You can eat this when boys and girls, when you sit
- 3:02:16your ass at the table and you write down the names of every person you've
- 3:02:20lived with, and you tell me who you really are. Okay. So
- 3:02:22we've heard from the son who might be in alignment with the father because he
- 3:02:26lives with him and might be lying to not get in trouble with the dad,
- 3:02:31who knows. But we are hearing from two family members that the mom,
- 3:02:37Christine was seemingly very focused on the line of questioning, which I've already
- 3:02:43talked about before, and it was some kind of fixation that the mom had,
- 3:02:50or some kind of power play or anxiety that the mom had, And
- 3:02:54we're hearing an account from the father who has gone through, according to his
- 3:02:58words, a very difficult divorce and they still are at odds with each other.
- 3:03:03And according to him, he's saying that the bomb would frequently grill Natalia
- 3:03:09regarding her history, and that she would have to Natalia would have to sit
- 3:03:15against the wall for hours and would not be allowed to eat. Do we
- 3:03:20believe this account this story? I don't know. Could be? Could be
- 3:03:26that there seems to you know, we have evidence, there's the video of
- 3:03:28we don't know how long those things are happening, but it does add some
- 3:03:33corroboration to his account here, I will say, as he seemingly might be
- 3:03:39exaggerating Christine's behavior. Who knows, he might not be exaggerating, but I
- 3:03:43think it would be easy, at least at this point to have that question
- 3:03:48mark. Then you start wondering, well, was he exaggerating about Natalia too?
- 3:03:54Is he always making himself out to be the victim? Christine says that,
- 3:04:03yeah, she's been standing still, nose on the wall for eight hours
- 3:04:11and she ain't getting out of there until she writes down names. Michael,
- 3:04:16don't you say a word to her, don't you help her? Well,
- 3:04:20so, who knows. But if this is true or he close to the
- 3:04:22truth, Wow, just wow, awful, just awful. Yeah, So
- 3:04:33at this point in time, it's been eight hours Natalia soiled herself. Natalia,
- 3:04:39according to Christine, soiled herself hours ago. Okay, so he's not
- 3:04:45helping himself because if he didn't go to the authorities with its information, he's
- 3:04:50implicated in this. He stood by. I guess he could make the case
- 3:04:54that he was terrified of Christine, but that's going to be a hard sell.
- 3:05:00Why would he say this. He was the dad, he was half
- 3:05:03of the parental system at the very least. Why didn't you tell someone?
- 3:05:09And maybe he did, but it doesn't sound like it. Tell police officers
- 3:05:13this. I can do this. There were multiple times, three that I
- 3:05:22bore witness to, and I'm certain far more than that that Christine beat the
- 3:05:28holy hell out of her. So one day I come home from work.
- 3:05:35Wow, wow, Who knows if it's accurate, but if it is,
- 3:05:41just awful, just awful. Now he's in the middle of telling us the
- 3:05:48story, but it is almost one in the morning and I need to go
- 3:05:54to bed. So that seems weird to stop here. I've been really gripped
- 3:06:01by this documentary. I can see why people would watch this, so tune
- 3:06:07in next time. I watch what he's about to say with the rest of
- 3:06:11the sentence, I don't know why I'm laughing. It's horrible. This is
- 3:06:16just horrible. It's horrible all the way. It's just tragic. It's tragedy.
- 3:06:20It's just tragedy after tragedy for potentially everybody. Just awful, just awful,
- 3:06:26just so sad. Well everyone, please thank you're lucky stars are hopefully
- 3:06:33not in a situation like that, and take care of yourself because you deserve
- 3:06:35it, you really really do.