Latest / The So What? / 2024 - Electricity, Once Again!
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans.
- 0:15You can find a written version of this content on JP's website, jplandman.co.za.
- 0:21I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28First of all, happy 2024.
- 0:31Yes indeed, a very, very happy 2024 to all of you.
- 0:34May it be a fulfilling and a healthy and a happy year.
- 0:38Healthy above all.
- 0:41As usual, this podcast goes with a newsletter which you can find on JP's website, which
- 0:46is jplantman.co.za.
- 0:48JP, your title once again, electricity.
- 0:54What happened to make you revisit this topic yet again?
- 0:58Two reasons.
- 0:59One, it is the most important issue confronting the country, particularly the economy and
- 1:04our ability to grow, create jobs and so on.
- 1:08So it will be with us until we've sorted out the electricity issue.
- 1:12It's extremely important.
- 1:13Secondly, we have had a number of important announcements during the holiday period after
- 1:19the country has already gone on leave, so to speak, which impacts quite seriously on
- 1:24the electricity situation.
- 1:27And if I can just briefly refer to what they were, the long awaited IRP, Integrated Resource
- 1:34Plan of 2023, was released just after the end of the year.
- 1:39Secondly, government has announced three different bit windows for new power, 5,000 megawatts
- 1:46for renewable energy, 2,000 megawatts for gas and another 615 megawatts for battery
- 1:54storage.
- 1:55So those three bit windows opened.
- 1:57And thirdly, government also announced during the holidays that in March of this year, it
- 2:03will go to the market with a request for proposals, not for the bit window, but the request for
- 2:08proposals on 1,000 megawatts of nuclear energy.
- 2:12Now we'll have to see what comes out of the request, what the prices will be and so on.
- 2:18I don't think we will have any clarity on that before the end of next year, so we don't
- 2:23have to spend more time on that now.
- 2:25So also it takes time, even if it went through the process tomorrow, it will take 10 to 15
- 2:32years for a nuclear power station to come online.
- 2:34So it's really academic at the moment.
- 2:36Yes, absolutely correct.
- 2:37It is academic in terms of load shedding and what will happen with our energy scene by
- 2:422030, which is the timeframe of the IRP.
- 2:46And the health of ESCOM?
- 2:48The health of ESCOM, we had figures for the year that came out after 52 weeks of data
- 2:54from ESCOM, Chris Yelland, the energy analyst at the work.
- 2:58And what he found was that the energy availability factor, the efficiency of ESCOM or the health
- 3:04of ESCOM has declined from 58% in 2022 to 54.7% in 2023.
- 3:13So there was more than a 3% decline.
- 3:16Now the relevance is not just the decline, the relevance is also that this decline has
- 3:21been fairly consistent now for a number of years.
- 3:25And the fact that it's trending downwards to what 50% makes complete mockery of targets
- 3:32of 65 and 70% energy availability factor, which was said by the previous board and some
- 3:39politicians.
- 3:40It's just not happening.
- 3:41But the major piece of news was IRP23.
- 3:45You call it visionless and without urgency.
- 3:49That's harsh.
- 3:50Yes, it is harsh because I think it's justified.
- 3:53What the IRP foresees is that load sharing will be with us until 2027.
- 3:59Now that in my view for a country which is in the energy crisis is simply not good enough.
- 4:05Common sense dictates that you've got to submit a plan to the nation and to the country, which
- 4:10will take care of this problem and solve it over the next while, not kick the can down
- 4:15the road until 2027.
- 4:19So that is why I call it visionless and not very ambitious.
- 4:24I must just say that the one good thing about the IRP, it works with the energy availability
- 4:30assumption of 49% to 51%.
- 4:33Now given what happened to the energy availability factor in 2023, that's a realistic assumption.
- 4:39There is one scenario in the IRP where load sharing can be sorted before 2027, but then
- 4:45they work with EAF of more than 60%.
- 4:49Now that's not going to happen.
- 4:50So that is just wishful thinking.
- 4:54Where does our hope come from?
- 4:56The bottom line, Rudi, where our hope comes from is that there has got to be new investment
- 5:01in energy.
- 5:02You're not going to get the energy problem sorted by fixing ESCOM.
- 5:05ESCOM I don't think is fixable.
- 5:08You're going to get energy security from new investment in energy.
- 5:12And that's precisely the point where the IRP is not very strong.
- 5:18So let me give you a feel for what is proposed in the IRP.
- 5:21They propose a total of 28,000 megawatts over the period to 2030.
- 5:28That 28,000 megawatts consists of a number of things, which I'll come back to, renewable
- 5:34gas and so on.
- 5:36But you've got to compare that 28,000 with the 50 to 60,000 megawatts, which the Presidential
- 5:43Climate Change Commission has recommended for the next 10 years.
- 5:47Now if you need over the next 10 years 50 to 60,000 and the IRP gives you 28,000, there's
- 5:53a 32,000 megawatt shortfall.
- 5:57And there's no indication in the IRP of how that will be covered.
- 6:01And it sounds as if the two sections of government are not talking to each other.
- 6:06It certainly looks like that if you take the just energy transition plan and you take the
- 6:11IRP next to it.
- 6:12It does look as if they're not talking to one another.
- 6:15Now just to take my criticism of the IRP further, as I've said, in December government released
- 6:24a bid window for 5,000 megawatts of renewables.
- 6:27That is not brought into the plan at all.
- 6:29There's no provision for those 5,000.
- 6:32More inexplicably, the minister still has the authority to issue another bid window,
- 6:38bid window 8, for 5,000 more renewables.
- 6:43So you had one in December, number 7, the ease capacity for number 8, that's 10,000.
- 6:48You can see that that 22,000, 32,000 deficit can be cut down.
- 6:54Just in terms of current plans, yet there is no provision for that in the IRP.
- 6:58It's really inexplicable and it leaves one with the feeling that the IRP was manipulated
- 7:04to force gas into the energy scene.
- 7:08That's the comment.
- 7:09May I ask why you say that?
- 7:11Well because if you brought in these numbers, then we will still need gas.
- 7:15There is room for gas in the South African energy mix, but not for the quantum, which
- 7:21the IRP talks about.
- 7:22The IRP at the moment in theory talks about more than 6,000 megawatts of gas.
- 7:27That's not an overnight project.
- 7:29It will take a long time to develop that capacity and bring it into the country's energy supply.
- 7:36While the short answer, the quicker answer is to go for renewables.
- 7:40Now if you have 5,000 and 5,000 renewables available so to speak, why not use it and
- 7:46reduce the cash load?
- 7:48What does the 28,000 megawatts in the IRP consist of?
- 7:53Good question.
- 7:54Basically, it's 69% renewables, that is wind and solar.
- 7:58It's 21% for gas.
- 8:01It's 5% for dispatchable capacity, simply meaning capacity which can be switched on
- 8:06and off.
- 8:07That can be batteries, it can be pump storage, it can be salt technology.
- 8:13You generate electricity, you store it and you use it when you need it.
- 8:17And then the last 5% is for coal.
- 8:20Now let me just say the provision for coal is really nothing else but the last two units
- 8:25at Madhupi and Kusili which will come onto line in the period of the IRP.
- 8:30One of them this year and the other one next year 2025.
- 8:33So there's no new coal?
- 8:35There's no new coal.
- 8:36I think that's an important point to note.
- 8:38And also important is that in the previous IRP, the one from 2019 which is still current,
- 8:45there was a provision or allotment for two coal fired power stations of 750 megawatts
- 8:53each.
- 8:55The minister has never activated those.
- 8:57So in spite of all the things that he said about coal, he never opened the door for a
- 9:02bit window on those two.
- 9:04And they don't reappear in this new draft.
- 9:07So yes, the only coal are those which are already in process at Madhupi and Kusili.
- 9:13No new coal.
- 9:15Then the gas allocation which is 21% of the 28,000 megawatts consists of three elements.
- 9:24The first one is 1200 megawatts from car powership.
- 9:29Now the funny thing is about two days after the IRP was published, ISCOM announced that
- 9:34they've cancelled the grid capacity which they held in reserve for car powership.
- 9:40Not just for car powership, also for another supplier, people who couldn't reach financial
- 9:45close by 31 December.
- 9:47And ISCOM said that's enough now, giving you enough time to build your plants.
- 9:53You can't reach financial close, so we're cancelling the grid capacity.
- 9:57So that can go to other people.
- 9:59But the 1200 is in the IRP.
- 10:02Then there is another 3000 gas for ISCOM.
- 10:07Now 3000 gas plant will cost in the vicinity of 40 billion rand.
- 10:13There's no ways that ISCOM has got the money to build that.
- 10:16In fact the treasury in the bailout which they gave ISCOM made it a clear condition
- 10:22that there will be no new capital expenditure except that which is necessary for urgent
- 10:28maintenance.
- 10:29So where you're going to get 40 billion to build a new gas plant, you know, is something
- 10:33which the IRP drafters haven't explained.
- 10:36The most realistic one is the last section of gas and that is 2000 megawatts of gas capacity
- 10:44anywhere in the country on any technology.
- 10:46It can be shale gas or imported or whatever for independent power producers.
- 10:52Now that's a realistic thing.
- 10:53I think people will come forward.
- 10:55They will have projects and that could be built and connected to the grid.
- 11:00Then there's last 1000 megawatts which is specifically a marked for the Eastern Cape.
- 11:05But no but window has been opened for that.
- 11:08But it sounds as if the IRP is already outdated.
- 11:13It is.
- 11:14Because realities have come into play which it just does not reflect.
- 11:18No absolutely.
- 11:19There's the car powership one, there's the ISCOM one, there's the but window 7 in December
- 11:245000 megawatts not being accounted for.
- 11:27There's the capacity for 8 but window sometime in the future not being accounted for.
- 11:32And I think the biggest wonder is the contribution from the private sector.
- 11:37Now we heard this week, Narsha announced the National Electricity Regulator announced that
- 11:43in 2023 4500 megawatts from the private sector was installed over the total of 392 projects,
- 11:55392 different private sector projects and combined they generate 4500 megawatts.
- 12:01And that's already online, it has already happened.
- 12:03Well the capacity is being installed.
- 12:05So whether they, I don't think they all came online by December last year but they certainly
- 12:10will come online very soon.
- 12:12Companies invest the money, they want the power, they're not going to muck around.
- 12:16Now in the IRP there's an admission that more capacity will come from the private sector
- 12:23but they put no numbers to it in the IRP which again is an oversight which makes the whole
- 12:29thing a little bit outdated.
- 12:32You call it a missed opportunity to spur re-industrialisation.
- 12:36Why do you say that?
- 12:38The components that we need for renewable energy, a lot of them can be produced locally.
- 12:45So if you take a solar panel for example we don't have the photovoltaic film that goes
- 12:51on top but that film goes on the glass panel and the glass panel fits into a gantry.
- 12:57And the gantry and the glass panel can be manufactured here, the film you'll import
- 13:01from China.
- 13:03That's the kind of example of how we can do re-industrialisation.
- 13:07Likewise for a wind farm, the windmills are not manufactured here but components can be
- 13:13manufactured and you can assemble them here.
- 13:16So it is an opportunity to re-industrialise, the same with transmission lines, the cables,
- 13:23the towers that you need and so on, all these things can be produced locally.
- 13:28So by going with the green revolution or the green power revolution or the renewable power
- 13:34revolution you can actually do a lot to stimulate industrial manufacturing in South Africa.
- 13:41But won't that happen in spite of the IRP?
- 13:42Well the problem is…
- 13:43I mean in spite of the silence of the IRP.
- 13:45I think it will happen but in the ideal world what you would like is not for silence but
- 13:51for a clear statement that says every year we estimate, we budget, we plan to install
- 13:58so many megawatts of solar capacity and then people can do their calculations and say we
- 14:04don't manufacture enough of that here in the country, we'll have to import a lot from
- 14:08China or wherever, let's put up a factory.
- 14:11Now you may recall that in 2016, quite a few years ago, but in 2016 Brian Molefe, who was
- 14:18then the CEO of Eskom, suspended all new renewable contracts and he refused to sign them.
- 14:25As a result of that the renewables program came to a screeching halt.
- 14:29As a result of that, solar plant, plant manufacturing solar panels in KZN had to close down because
- 14:36the demand for the product dried up.
- 14:39So what you want is not number one a low allocation, which is currently the case, what you also
- 14:45want is a fairly consistent allocation over time.
- 14:49Now I give the numbers there in the note but at the moment for 2024 for example, the IRP
- 14:57envisions only 1000 megawatt of solar renewable power and then in 2026 only 1040.
- 15:04Now that's too little, it's too small.
- 15:06Then suddenly in 2025, the year in between, they shoot up to 3000.
- 15:11Now you cannot have industrial, you can't have factories when there is one year of demand
- 15:17for 1000, the next year for 3000, the third year down to 1000 again.
- 15:23Nobody is going to run the risk.
- 15:26This document actually creates uncertainty.
- 15:29It creates uncertainty where it should create certainty and it creates uncertainty where
- 15:34it should put out a vision of where the country is going.
- 15:37Now that leads us to the next question, what now?
- 15:44How relevant is this plan?
- 15:45Is it a completely lost opportunity?
- 15:48Did they lose the opportunity for us or is something else going to happen?
- 15:52Two things must happen.
- 15:55First of all, this is a draft.
- 15:57So the public has been asked to comment and I'm quite sure just as I've now had comments
- 16:01here, many people in the country, much more knowledgeable, will bring strong data to the
- 16:07department and they will have to update draft.
- 16:11That will take quite a while.
- 16:12That will probably take us into the second half of 2024.
- 16:16So yes, it is possible that things could change, but that is in the future.
- 16:22The second thing, which is in a sense much more important, is the changes that President
- 16:28Ramaphosa has made in 2021 and again in 2022 to the regulatory environment.
- 16:34What is essentially done?
- 16:36We've written about this before and talked about it before.
- 16:39He has deregulated or liberated, if you want, the energy market in South Africa.
- 16:45We used to have a very strict state controlled system.
- 16:50Now you've got a complete open free for all system as a result of the changes.
- 16:55What does that mean?
- 16:56It means that private sector people, whether it's a household or a small office or a factory
- 17:02or a mine, anybody can now put up a power plant to service their own needs.
- 17:09It can be renewable technologies.
- 17:11It can be diesel.
- 17:13If they want to go that route, it can be anything.
- 17:16In this list of 392 plants that NASA released this week, there's for example a plant from
- 17:25a big sugar company in KZN.
- 17:28They use extra biomass surplus biomass from sugar to generate power, which they use in
- 17:34their factories.
- 17:36So the space has been opened up and that means private sector people will carry on doing
- 17:43their own thing.
- 17:45We know now that last year 4,500 megawatts, 392 projects.
- 17:50I can guarantee you that'll happen again in 2024 and probably accelerate.
- 17:57Why would it accelerate?
- 17:58Here an important dimension comes in.
- 18:01Load shedding is one reason.
- 18:03People don't want to be exposed to load shedding and if you tell them load shedding will last
- 18:06until 2027, they're going to make a plan.
- 18:10Secondly, more and more companies are moving to renewable energy, not so much for load
- 18:15shedding only, but because they want to become carbon neutral at some point in the future.
- 18:21The world is moving and companies are moving alongside.
- 18:25Take Anglo-American South Africa for example.
- 18:28They have a target that by 2040 they want to be carbon neutral.
- 18:32In order to get there, they must by 2030 install 5,000 megawatts of renewable power and they're
- 18:38busy doing it.
- 18:39Now 5,000 megawatts is big.
- 18:41That's as big as a whole government bid window.
- 18:44That's Anglo-American, but Anglo is not the only one.
- 18:47You get this story from a number of companies who are under pressure from ESG considerations,
- 18:54sustainability and environment considerations who are busy putting money in.
- 19:00And then the third factor I've already sort of touched on, it's reflexivity.
- 19:04George Soros' thing, the thinking that made Soros rich and the thinking basically says
- 19:10whenever you take an action, it's already in that action, the beginning of a counter
- 19:15action.
- 19:17So if you publish the IRP and you say that they'll be loading until 2027, what will people
- 19:22do?
- 19:23We're in a hurry, we can't wait.
- 19:24Let's do our own thing.
- 19:26So for those three reasons, I think the private sector will use more than what they've done
- 19:30so far, the space created by the president and they will put up their own plans and run
- 19:38with them.
- 19:40What about transmission?
- 19:41Because that has been the big problem for more than a year now.
- 19:46Absolutely.
- 19:47Transmission is the big bottleneck and I think there are two data points to consider.
- 19:53The one is it is getting money and number two, it's getting attention, which it has
- 19:57never had before.
- 19:59What is the money?
- 20:00Two agreements have been signed by National Treasury for 300 million euro each with European
- 20:07funders, European and Western funders and that money is allocated for growth expansion
- 20:13or transmission expansion.
- 20:15Is that part of the just economic transition money?
- 20:18Yes, yes.
- 20:19Absolutely.
- 20:20That's the meaning of that, the first money under that plan.
- 20:25So there is money available.
- 20:27Also the minister of electricity, minister Ramajopa, has now been made responsible for
- 20:33transmission.
- 20:34There was previously uncertainty as to where the political responsibility lies.
- 20:39He has now been specifically made responsible for it and in his first news conference of
- 20:44the year he said he's got a mandate, quote unquote, he's got a mandate to look for private
- 20:50sector money to be used in transmission.
- 20:53So there's political attention and there's money and I think between those two we will
- 20:58see substantial progress on transmission.
- 21:01Can I just say the current transmission plan by ESCOM, 10 year plan, provides for 14,000
- 21:09kilometres over 10 years.
- 21:10It's about 1400 kilometres a year.
- 21:14The previous highest point was in the 1960s when South Africa built 1200 kilometres of
- 21:21transmission lines per year.
- 21:23So we're clearly going back to that big expansion we had then.
- 21:28The problem at which is still there at the moment is that most of that 14,000 is towards
- 21:33the second five years of the 10 year plan and not in the first five years.
- 21:39And the manufacturing industry have asked for some of those kilometres to be brought
- 21:45forward into years one, two and three for precisely the same logic as we saw with solar
- 21:50panels.
- 21:51You want to have a consistent demand over time in order to build manufacturing capacity.
- 21:56So I'm fairly happy that the transmission problem will be dealt with.
- 22:02What difference will the new transmission company make?
- 22:06Does it help with ESCOM's CAPEX problem?
- 22:08Yes, it does.
- 22:09Number one, ESCOM can, as I've said, are not allowed to have any CAPEX spending.
- 22:15That doesn't apply to this new company.
- 22:17That's number one.
- 22:18Number two, the new company brings with it focus.
- 22:21If you're responsible for transmission and generation and distribution, I think focus
- 22:26get a bit diffuse.
- 22:29This company will focus only on transmission.
- 22:31That's their sole purpose for existence.
- 22:33Thirdly, they take over from ESCOM, I think some 30 or 40 billion in assets, transmission
- 22:41assets that can now be leveraged.
- 22:43Money can be borrowed from the bank against those assets and you can expand the process
- 22:47faster.
- 22:48So, yes, I think it's a very good development.
- 22:51It's been on the cards since 2019.
- 22:54It's now happened four and a half years later, rather late than never.
- 22:59The economic impact of electricity keeping dragging on.
- 23:04Look, that's why I again started 24 by writing about electricity because it is so important
- 23:09for the economy.
- 23:10As long as we have load shedding, as long as we don't have security of supply, as long
- 23:15as people have to spend money on it, you hold back economic growth.
- 23:19So, what is the bigger picture?
- 23:21The bigger picture is that we've now had 10 years behind us, all the way from 2014 to
- 23:262023.
- 23:2710 years, where per capita incomes stagnated or declined.
- 23:35And I calculate we don't have the numbers yet.
- 23:38At the end of December 23, we were probably about 6 to 7% poorer than what we were at
- 23:45the beginning of 2014.
- 23:47And that poverty comes out in all kinds of ways.
- 23:50Government can't collect the taxes that they want.
- 23:52Companies can't make the profits and reinvest to the extent that they want.
- 23:56Those are not being created to the extent that you need it.
- 23:59You know, there's a price to be paid for getting poorer.
- 24:02For 10 years now, we have been getting poorer.
- 24:05I think the reality is that 2024 will be the 11th year in which we get poorer.
- 24:12The population growth at the moment is 1.8% and nobody expects the economy to grow 1.8%.
- 24:19So it'll give us 11 years of getting poorer.
- 24:23That makes it all the more urgent that we sort electricity out and get back to a growth
- 24:30rate of at least 2.5, maybe 3%.
- 24:35Measure that against population growth of 1.8.
- 24:38Then you start cooking with gas.
- 24:41In a manner of speaking.
- 24:42In a manner of speaking.
- 24:43So in summary, so what?
- 24:46The further decline in ESCOM's electricity availability factor to less than 55% or about
- 24:5455% continues a long term declining trend.
- 25:00And it tells you that the salvation cannot come from ESCOM.
- 25:03ESCOM is not going to survive this crisis in its current format.
- 25:07The salvation must come from somewhere else.
- 25:09The way it is that somewhere else, it is from massive new investment in new energy capacity.
- 25:16And we've got the numbers.
- 25:17The Presidential Climate Change Commission told us 50 to 60,000 megawatts of new renewal
- 25:23capacity and about 3,000 and so of gas.
- 25:28The IRP23 with its 28,000 new capacity falls very far short of 50 to 60,000.
- 25:37You need to plug that gap to get to energy security.
- 25:43The good news is that the President's regulatory reform over the last two years have opened
- 25:48up the electricity market completely.
- 25:50People can now do their own thing, provide their own power and they are doing it as the
- 25:55numbers are showing us.
- 25:57Another interesting development is that we have more and more energy traders and energy
- 26:01exchanges coming into existence.
- 26:04I think NASA has by now licensed three or four traders.
- 26:09Now the big thing about a trader is they can buy from a person with surplus energy and
- 26:13they can sell it to a person who need the energy and you don't need the capex in the
- 26:17middle.
- 26:18It's an essential part of a liberated market and that market is beginning to develop.
- 26:23It will spread supply and demand much, much wider.
- 26:27Look, getting out of the electricity crisis is a huge opportunity for South Africa to
- 26:32industrialize.
- 26:35For that you need a clear line of sight for a couple of years into the future.
- 26:41You need a clear plan.
- 26:43The IOP 23 is not that.
- 26:46What is that is the just economic transition plan, which is much clearer and I think a
- 26:53much better foundation.
- 26:56Therefore going forward, what we will do is to monitor implementation of the jet plan.
- 27:01That is the way that we will see how we're doing with the roadmap.
- 27:05We will talk about that in future.
- 27:07Thank you very much.
- 27:08Thank you.
- 27:11Thank you for listening to the So What podcast.
- 27:14If you enjoy this content, please don't forget to leave a review and a rating and please
- 27:19consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 27:23Also tell your friends.
- 27:25There you can find a written version of all JP's content at JPLandman.co.za