Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Lessons - Tech's Disturbing Gender Gap | Julia Boorstin, CNBC's Senior Media & Tech Correspondent
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Lessons episodes of Success Story, part of the HubSpot podcast network.
- 0:14These lessons episodes will be shorter conversations with past guests, valued members of the success
- 0:21story community, and myself.
- 0:23They'll be focused on teaching you actionable, insightful takeaways that you can use to
- 0:28upscale your personal and professional life.
- 0:31Where are we at in terms of equity?
- 0:33So what is the reality for somebody going into the workforce now and then trying to move
- 0:39up?
- 0:41What are the problems and struggles that perhaps we think are gone but are still there?
- 0:46What do we have to deal with?
- 0:48So what's interesting is that, you know, we've been actually graduating from college in
- 0:53higher numbers than men do.
- 0:54We've been going to more grad school than men do.
- 0:57I think the numbers are pretty close to equal when it comes to business.
- 1:00Well, these numbers change all the time.
- 1:01But there's no, it's not like men are getting more education than women do.
- 1:06But there have been a lot of studies trying to figure out why women may start in jobs
- 1:10at the same numbers as men, but don't end up at the top of companies in the same numbers
- 1:14as men.
- 1:15And one of the key theories, and this was something that was sort of articulated by
- 1:19Alina and McKinsey studies, is this idea of a broken wrong.
- 1:23And it gets promoted at the lower levels, but then there's a sort of a leap to more
- 1:27of a management level where often women just don't get those promotions.
- 1:31And interestingly, it doesn't necessarily seem to have anything to do with performance.
- 1:34It can have to do with how much women are pushing for promotions or maybe they are sort
- 1:39of inadvertently penalized for taking time off from work for maternity leave, et cetera.
- 1:46So there are so many different reasons.
- 1:47But one thing that I really focus on in this book is I look at the tech industry in particular
- 1:52because the tech industry has more of a gap in venture capital funding than in any other
- 1:58industry you'll see in terms of representation.
- 2:01So we all know that tech companies are incredibly powerful.
- 2:03They impact the way we live our lives, the way we travel, the way we order every product
- 2:08to our house or the Amazon.
- 2:09Like there's no tech companies have massive influence over everything.
- 2:14And tech companies are funded by venture capital, whether it's Facebook or Airbnb, Google,
- 2:20all these companies exist because venture capital fueled them and allowed them to grow
- 2:25massively while they were still losing money.
- 2:28So I wanted to look at this sector because this is the sector with the craziest gender
- 2:32gap.
- 2:33Women, on average, female founders have gotten 3% or less of all venture capital funding
- 2:39in the past 10 years.
- 2:41So if you look at billions of dollars in venture capital, like $30 billion last year,
- 2:473% of it actually 2021 was 2%, 3% or so of that money goes to companies with female
- 2:54founders.
- 2:55That's absolutely insane.
- 2:56So that's the reason why it doesn't really make sense.
- 3:00So I really want to focus on that world just because the gap was so crazy that I wanted
- 3:05to understand why that was happening and be how the women who had defined the odds and
- 3:10had managed to get that tiny piece of venture capital funding, how they had done it.
- 3:14I wanted to know there were secrets because I thought these women are by definition exceptional
- 3:19and I really want to learn from them.
- 3:21So so we'll unpack why some women did receive VC funding, but that's a really interesting
- 3:26stat.
- 3:27So I would have actually assumed that in yeah, of course, you think of tech as like,
- 3:32oh, there's all, you know, the tech bros and whatnot and there's this like sort of like
- 3:35a negative connotation with the tech bro SF startup.
- 3:39But the numbers that tech is worse than some other legacy industries is absolutely insane.
- 3:45So if 3% of, it's 3% of female founders are getting VC money, it's very obvious why
- 3:50there's not a lot.
- 3:51And it's actually slightly more complicated, 3% of VC dollars go to companies with female
- 3:56founders, but it's 6% of deals and what's interesting is because you know, each deals
- 4:00like the check that's written, what that means is that women's checks are smaller than
- 4:05the checks that men are getting.
- 4:06If they're getting 6% of deals and only 3% of dollars, it means the checks are on average
- 4:10smaller.
- 4:11So why is that?
- 4:12That's a huge problem to solve for right thing.
- 4:13It's another problem.
- 4:14So there's so much in here and I just want to be clear, I'm not pointing fingers at anyone.
- 4:18I think what's really interesting about this is I don't think there is one group, one
- 4:22person, no, no one group or organizations to blame for any of this.
- 4:26This is layers upon layers of structural historical societal patterns that have established
- 4:33this system and it's very hard to break them.
- 4:36What I was most interested to learn in my research is just this concept of pattern matching
- 4:42is hugely powerful.
- 4:44Pattern matching is this idea that if you're a VC and you want to make an investment in
- 4:49a founder, your instinct and the data would indicate that you should invest in someone
- 4:54who matches a pattern.
- 4:55You should invest in someone whose company is similar to another company you founded.
- 5:00Maybe you have a habit or a pattern of investing in people who were engineers at an Ivy
- 5:05League school and then founded an enterprise software company, which they sold and now
- 5:10you want to invest in these as second time founders.
- 5:13If you're looking at that subset of founder, you're going to be looking mostly at men.
- 5:19So it becomes this feedback loop where people disinvest in more and more of the same types
- 5:23of people.
- 5:24Part of it is that if you're a venture investor, you're making some big bets and you want
- 5:29to control every factor you can control.
- 5:31So if someone reminds you of Mark Zuckerberg, back at Influence you, there are some crazy
- 5:35quotes in my book about VC saying, I'll invest in anyone who reminds me of Mark Zuckerberg.
- 5:40But I think that it's just this instinct to go with the familiar.
- 5:44And also when you're an investor, you're going to be spending a lot of time with these
- 5:49companies you're writing big checks to.
- 5:51And so you want to make sure this is someone you like and don't mind spending hours upon
- 5:55hours with.
- 5:57So there's also this instinct to invest in people who feel like your friends.
- 6:01Maybe they went to your same for turn it, you know, for same college, we're in your
- 6:04same fraternity.
- 6:05So I think a lot of that is this sort of, it's a pattern matching, which is a symptom
- 6:11of unconscious bias.
- 6:13And the more we could just recognize it, the more there's a huge opportunity to break
- 6:17the pattern.
- 6:18And there's financial opportunity in breaking the pattern.
- 6:21There's a VC I interviewed for the book named Josh Cuppelman from First Round Capital.
- 6:26He was a fund in Philadelphia.
- 6:28He had a very successful fund.
- 6:31And after 10 years, he said, let's do a study and let's find out what has been working
- 6:36with our companies.
- 6:37The invested in early stage companies and early stage is when there's the most opportunity
- 6:41for bias because you're not investing in a company based on a five year track record.
- 6:45You're investing in a company based on the idea and the founder.
- 6:49So he went back and looked at the results of his investments over the years and he found
- 6:53that the female founded investments, which weren't, there weren't very many of them.
- 6:57They tended to perform better.
- 6:59And he thought, this is crazy.
- 7:00If the female founders, their companies are doing better, why are we investing in more
- 7:04of them?
- 7:05So he sort of took a step back and realized that there were systems they could put in
- 7:08place to make sure they weren't just, you know, investing in the, in the obvious thing
- 7:14based on the pattern.
- 7:15So they before used to only have investors who had had a successful company that they
- 7:20had invested in.
- 7:21That limited the pool and they said, why do we only have to hire people we've invested
- 7:26in their company?
- 7:27Let's, you know, let's broaden the pool.
- 7:29So they started hiring different kinds of investors, more women and women are choices
- 7:34likely to invest in a female founded startup than men are.
- 7:38So they all the sudden got this different pool of companies who were coming to them with
- 7:42their ideas because they diversified who their, who their venture partners were basically.
- 7:47And then interestingly, they put these systems in place in their meetings to make sure
- 7:52that they were getting rid of bias.
- 7:53They'd hear a pitch.
- 7:54And then instead of just opening, you know, having that founder leave and they'd open
- 7:57the floor of a conversation, this is something that happens in meetings no matter what
- 8:00type of company you're in.
- 8:02They would have a, here a pitch like you could hear a presentation, but they'd have everyone
- 8:07write down what they thought about the company.
- 8:10Then they'd have a conversation.
- 8:12That way you didn't have one very loud, charismatic person railroad everyone else and
- 8:17to listening to their opinion and then everyone would be like, okay, fine, this guy's loud.
- 8:21We should do what he wants to do.
- 8:23This way you could get people who are maybe more introverted, maybe, maybe more women who
- 8:27are less likely to want to go out on a limb in a male dominated room.
- 8:32And you could just let everyone share their opinion without, you know, without it having
- 8:37to be a public performance.
- 8:39And he found that the outcomes of implementing this system were really, really powerful.
- 8:44So I think there's so much upside to recognizing and stripping out the pattern matching in the
- 8:50unconscious bias.