Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Election mania and NZTC penny pinching
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:07the UK energy market. It's almost time to put a cross
- 0:12in the box if you're in Wales or Scotland as general elections
- 0:16are rolling up, and there's quite a lot to be said about
- 0:20that. Also, NZTC up here in Aberdeen
- 0:23made major announcements this week.
- 0:25That's an awful lot to talk about if you're just me.
- 0:27Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, but thankfully this week
- 0:30I'm joined by our crack team of reporters.
- 0:34Up first as Matthew Perry, our news reporter.
- 0:36How are you doing this week, Matt?
- 0:38I'm doing very well. There's something shining and
- 0:40I'm excited to chat all things elections because it's my first
- 0:44holy rood election coming up and I always enjoy, I think most
- 0:49journalists do, sitting down and cracking open a beer and
- 0:53watching all the results come through.
- 0:55Although sadly, I'm not used to doing it on a Thursday.
- 0:58I'm more used to the Saturday elections back home.
- 1:01But let's let's see how it goes next week.
- 1:03Are you still going to have a democracy sausage to to take in
- 1:07the the holiday? I feel like it'd be rude not to,
- 1:09to be honest. Good, Good, good, good.
- 1:11Yeah. I mean, it's it.
- 1:12This is going to be an interesting episode because they
- 1:14always say if you want to make friends, talk about politics and
- 1:18Floyd, you're here to do exactly that in Wales as well.
- 1:20Floyd March, NW, correspondent. How are you doing this?
- 1:23Way. Yeah, I'm all good.
- 1:24And I know you asked the questions normally, but I've got
- 1:27a question. What the hell?
- 1:28Is it a democracy sausage that you just mentioned?
- 1:31Oh well, I mean, I think Matt's better place to describe this
- 1:34than me. It's an Australian tradition and
- 1:35I'll leave him to explain. So essentially in a nutshell,
- 1:38obviously at most, like most elections, all the polling
- 1:42booths are in potentially your local primary school, your local
- 1:45community centre, churches, that sort of thing.
- 1:48And it's a time on a tradition in Australia that when any sort
- 1:50of community event is on, you have a sausage sizzle, you know,
- 1:53it's potentially white bread, a sausage, maybe if you're lucky,
- 1:55some, some onions and some sauce, gold coin, one or $2.00
- 2:00each. And it raises money.
- 2:01And it's become essentially, you know, a time on a tradition that
- 2:06around election time, you will get your democracy sausage while
- 2:10you're lining up to vote because it is compulsory to vote in
- 2:13Australia. So it's almost, I guess a lot of
- 2:16people overseas find it fascinating.
- 2:18They almost think we're being bribed to vote with, with
- 2:20sausages. But yeah, it's quite, I think
- 2:23there's even a map someone's built a website where you can
- 2:26write to your polling station on how democracy sausage was.
- 2:31So you get everything from, you know, the inner suburbs of
- 2:32Melbourne with their, their vegan options to, you know,
- 2:35classic ones in the outer suburbs.
- 2:37So that's democracy sausage in a nutshell.
- 2:40We need to bring that to the Uki think that would definitely
- 2:42boost the voter turn out here, at least in Aberdeen, because I
- 2:46mean, in Scotland in general, we like a, we like a bacon roll or
- 2:50a rolling sausage. So I'm sure that wouldn't be a
- 2:53bad, bad way to boost turn out. But that brings us on to the
- 2:58holy rood elections in a really clumsy, clumsy way.
- 3:01Matt, you've been looking at the runners and riders.
- 3:04What's happening? Do you mind just running us
- 3:06through what you you've been seeing this week and then we can
- 3:09properly get stuck in? Well, I think and, and yeah, one
- 3:13of our columnists, Brian Wilson also did a run through of the
- 3:17the manifestos which is on our website today.
- 3:20But one of the striking things that stood out to me when you
- 3:22sort of look back and it feels like an an absolute eon to go to
- 3:262021 to the last Scottish election and to the the upcoming
- 3:30one in the manifesto is, is the almost complete lack of
- 3:35discussion outside of possibly the the Greens manifesto of
- 3:39climate policy. You know, that was really a big
- 3:42theme of the previous manifestos.
- 3:44And we've seen a real shift in discussions of energy as being
- 3:48less about climate, less about the, you know, transition to
- 3:53renewable energy and more in the context of affordability and
- 3:56economic growth and, and that sort of thing.
- 3:58So we've sort of got, I guess you know, depending on how you
- 4:01want to categorize it, 6 main parties in, in the running.
- 4:06And you know, the net zero is quite a sharp dividing line
- 4:10between them all. You've got, you know, the SNP,
- 4:13Labour, the Lib Dems and Greens all accepting the 2045 net zero
- 4:17target that the Scottish Government has set for itself.
- 4:20The Conservatives did support that in 2021.
- 4:22They now want to scrap it. And then you've got reform who
- 4:25want to abandoned climate targets entirely.
- 4:29And then of course the North Sea is another strong dividing line.
- 4:33You've got the S&P supporting a case by case approach.
- 4:37You know, we're no longer talking about a presumption
- 4:40against. They're trying to straddle a
- 4:42more pragmatic line. You've got Labour and the Lib
- 4:45Dems accepting continued production within a managed
- 4:48transition. This with the language around
- 4:50there, but you know, we've seen Anasawa, the Scottish Labour
- 4:54leader, trying to strike out a different line from his
- 4:58Westminster colleagues on things like the the windfall tax and
- 5:01and North Sea production. But in the in the manifesto, it
- 5:04kind of that that distinction is not really made as as clear.
- 5:11And then of course you've got the Conservatives explicitly
- 5:13backing name projects like Rosebank and and Cambo.
- 5:19And then Reform, of course, who has the shortest manifesto of
- 5:22the whole lot to 7017 pages in in total, compared to the nearly
- 5:26100 pages of most of the other parties backing North Sea and
- 5:30gases, Scotland's primary energy source.
- 5:32So I'm interested to hear your your takes.
- 5:36What, what's the, I guess discussion you've been hearing
- 5:39up in the Northeast, Ryan, around all things the election?
- 5:43Do you know it just mentioning reform and their sort of oil and
- 5:46gas policy and let you know the, the, this has been more from
- 5:49Westminster than it has been from Malcolm Offered per SE.
- 5:53But we've seen, you know, them sort of to be quite hostile
- 5:57towards renewables, which I find quite interesting.
- 5:59And I was speaking somewhat about this last week because the
- 6:02last type, the last and only time I've ever met Lord Offered
- 6:05was up in Aberdeenshire. We were in the middle of the
- 6:09North Sea and we were going to see the Kincardine floating wind
- 6:13farm and he was telling me all about how brilliant offshore
- 6:16wind would be and how great it would be for jobs in Scotland.
- 6:19So it feels, feels like maybe a pivot and his his personal
- 6:23signalling, obviously he was part of the Scotland office at
- 6:25that point. No, not leader reform.
- 6:28But yeah, the sort of the boots on the ground experience, you
- 6:31know, I think there's, there's a lot of people there or there's,
- 6:34I hear this sort of question of why the hell are we talking
- 6:37about oil and gas? Why the hell are we talking
- 6:38about energy? Let's face it, the only thing
- 6:41that you know, there's very little that Holy Rood can do
- 6:44from an energy policy standpoint in terms of, you know, sort of
- 6:49approving new licenses for oil and gas or, you know, sort of
- 6:53they can't deliver CFDS or that type of thing.
- 6:54So what are they doing? And you know, we know our
- 6:58readers will know that when it comes to renewables, well, they
- 7:00have the sign off on on Scottish offshore wind project.
- 7:05And, you know, obviously Crown Estates Scotland is the seabed
- 7:08seabed license license awardee up here as well for offshore
- 7:15wind. But I was thinking about this a
- 7:18little bit more closely and thinking this week, Well, yeah,
- 7:21why is oil and gas specifically such a big debate, but energy
- 7:25more broadly? And I remembered Robert Gordon
- 7:27University and Paul de Lou last year found quite a striking
- 7:34figure across, you know, the number of people that are in
- 7:38energy jobs across the UK, Scotland and then Aberdeen
- 7:44specifically. So I think this is quite a start
- 7:46figure. So across the whole of the UK,
- 7:50one in 220 jobs are directly or indirectly tied to energy.
- 7:57If you narrow that scope to just Scotland, it's one in 30.
- 8:01And then when you narrow it all the way down to just Aberdeen
- 8:04and Aberdeenshire, it's one in six.
- 8:07And I think that really contextualizes why the debate is
- 8:11sort of focusing on energy quite heavily is, yes, they might not
- 8:16be able to approve new licenses or change the windfall tax and
- 8:20so on and so forth, which is something that, you know, even
- 8:23we've sort of criticized the way UK for that being the main
- 8:27staples of their manifesto this year for the Scottish elections.
- 8:32You know, well, Holy Rood can't do anything about that.
- 8:36We've sort of spoken about this more broadly.
- 8:38But at the end of the day, what Holy Rood can do is sort of
- 8:42create a pressure in Westminster to sort of support the jobs that
- 8:46we are seeing lose. They'd be lost in Scotland to
- 8:48cut companies looking to divert investment overseas and so on
- 8:52and so forth. The, I think that's the the sort
- 8:56of key distinction there that I really wanted to sort of touch
- 8:59on. But I guess as this is the last
- 9:01podcast before that will go live before the elections and next
- 9:05Thursday it would be. I thought it was also
- 9:08interesting to run through the polls because the SNP are head
- 9:12and shoulders above everyone else at the moment in terms of
- 9:15all the polling that I'm seeing. You know.
- 9:18Surveation polls across April saw the SNP's share of the vote
- 9:23climb from 35 to 38%. You Gov previously had 41% for
- 9:28SNP and it seems like Labour and Reform are jostling for 2nd
- 9:33place with the latest Survation poll suggesting that Reform the
- 9:372% ahead. Although days before that, that
- 9:41latest Survation poll Find out now said that Labour and Reform
- 9:46were tied at 14% of the vote. So I think there's still a lot
- 9:49to be to be done for the race for 2nd place.
- 9:52So very much like Scottish football, often it comes down to
- 9:55the race for second. Although maybe not this year in
- 9:58the Scottish Premier League, they've decided to go hell for
- 10:01leather on a race for first to allow Holy Rood to do that race
- 10:05for second title instead. So yeah, I don't know, it'll be
- 10:08interesting to see where we are this time next week, you know,
- 10:12will we, will we see a dramatic change?
- 10:14Well, reform would definitely create a a massive shift going
- 10:18from no no seats as far as I wear no seats in Scotland to
- 10:24well, certainly. They won an election because
- 10:26they didn't exist back in in 2021, so.
- 10:29Yeah, well, exactly there. Have been any defectors and you
- 10:32know they they didn't win their seat as a reform candidate?
- 10:35And soon, yes, it would. It would shift quite
- 10:38dramatically going like going from not being on the ballot
- 10:41last time to now being the second largest party
- 10:43potentially. Yeah.
- 10:44And I think one of the main questions, because we are seeing
- 10:46that lead for the SNP in the polling is whether they will
- 10:49walk out of this with an outright majority in their their
- 10:51own right and be able to just, you know, pursue their their
- 10:54policies on things like planning and offshore wind and obviously
- 10:58maintaining that opposition to new nuclear developments in
- 11:02Scotland, Things like the grid and all of that.
- 11:04You know, the skills and just transition fund, you know,
- 11:08essentially the areas that the Scottish Government has direct
- 11:11control over. And also, I guess the areas
- 11:13where, as you mentioned, the collaboration with Wayne
- 11:15Smithster is, is quite important.
- 11:17You know, we've seen that in things, the closure of the
- 11:19Grangemouth oil refinery. Or.
- 11:22You know, whether we see other parties increasing their vote
- 11:26share such as the Greens reform, you know, Labour dropping in in
- 11:31number. So if if it comes out to as a
- 11:34more contested parliamentary situation that the SNP don't
- 11:39have that outright majority to push their own policies directly
- 11:43through without much opposition, then I think that's when it
- 11:46starts to get interesting. You know, who will the SNP work
- 11:49with? They've previously worked with
- 11:50the the Greens. We saw that spectacularly fall
- 11:52apart, you know, and, and, and essentially ending Humza
- 11:57Yousaf's tenure as first minister.
- 12:01So will the S&P be wary of, of collaborating with the Greens?
- 12:06They may not have a choice depending on the type of numbers
- 12:09the Greens pull in. So I just, I think that'll be
- 12:11the interesting thing to watch in the, the wake of the election
- 12:14is, you know, the, the, the numbers that the SNP will be be
- 12:18working with in the in the next. Parliament, no 100% I, I, I have
- 12:22heard some people sort of speaking about a, a rejoining of
- 12:26Green and SNP because at the end of the day, they are the two
- 12:29major parties in Scottish politics that are really
- 12:32backing, you know, independence, which is the SM PS main mandate,
- 12:39you know, at this point in time. So interesting things all
- 12:42around. We could probably speak about
- 12:44this all day, but there is another election that we'll need
- 12:46to get to and we'll be getting to that just after the break.
- 12:51Hello, I'm Ed Reid, the editor of E Forward.
- 12:53E Forward is a membership community that brings together
- 12:56the entire UK energy supply chain, every hub, every sector,
- 13:00every stage. Our aim is to deliver growth to
- 13:03the energy sector, working with industry and policy makers to
- 13:06unlock the UK's opportunities and advantages.
- 13:10This is the movement to secure increased investment, improved
- 13:13policy making and better collaboration by providing our
- 13:16members with visibility, influence and access.
- 13:19Join me Forward today. During the break, you know, I
- 13:27said at the end of the last segment, there's so much to talk
- 13:30about. We could have done this for ages
- 13:31and you'd said it was the exact same for Wales and you
- 13:35threatened to talk at 200 miles an hour.
- 13:37I want to hear that. Tell me what's happening in
- 13:40Wales. Well, absolutely tons.
- 13:42And I'll just, I just want a caveat to start off with that
- 13:46the Welsh elections are always so underrated and they're not
- 13:50always well publicized. And I think one of the main
- 13:53reasons is because it's just consistently Labour.
- 13:56I think it's had 100 year reign in in Wales ever since
- 14:02devolution as well. It's always been like majority,
- 14:06you know, Labour support. But the that, that is all about
- 14:10to change. So, so maybe I'll try and be
- 14:13organizing in what I say and start with like the latest
- 14:16polls. So you know, Labour has has
- 14:19historically been super popular, but they're down in 3rd tied
- 14:23with Conservatives or roughly around 15%.
- 14:27The the neck and neck race now is between played Kumari and
- 14:31reform. I think there's like 13, 2020 8%
- 14:36in. I've probably averaged the the
- 14:38polls to say that. So so yeah, all the way through
- 14:42tracking the election cycle. Like, you know, one day I'll
- 14:44check and reformer just nipping ahead and then a week later
- 14:48played Qumri will be nipping ahead.
- 14:50But they've all got such different energy policies.
- 14:54So I'll start with played Qumri maybe just because they're
- 14:57they're the ones that seem to be in the lead at the moment and
- 15:01they're very much continue businesses as usual in terms of
- 15:07like rolling out the energy transition across Wales.
- 15:10So the Welsh government set out Green Electricity Wales, I'm not
- 15:14going to say in wealth because there's too many WSYS&D's.
- 15:19So I'll say the English translation and basically that's
- 15:23the GB energy for Wales. They've got a mission to develop
- 15:27one GW of renewable energy capacity by 2014.
- 15:31I spoke to Plaid Cymru a few weeks back.
- 15:33They basically said they will keep it as it is, they will push
- 15:37for further roll out of renewables.
- 15:39But what they what they say is that a Welsh Labour just cosy up
- 15:44to central government. So Plaid Cymru basically like
- 15:47your Labour but nationalist version.
- 15:49So I guess quite similar to the SNP in some regards in terms of
- 15:54nationalisation. They basically say that Wales,
- 16:00Wales gets used for all of its resources and all of the
- 16:04positive stuff that comes from that just goes to goes to
- 16:07England and England reap the rewards of basically the Welsh
- 16:11landscape. So I guess similar to what SNP
- 16:15tend to say. Yeah, I mean, that's that's
- 16:17something that we see surface or time and time again, you know, I
- 16:21mean, well, even even this campaign for the SNP, they're
- 16:24going with the it's Scotland's energy sort of a mantra.
- 16:27Whereas, you know, that's kind of a ping a campaign from I
- 16:31believe the 70s and 80s or as it's Scotland's oil.
- 16:34So 100 percent, 100% sort of aligned and sort of their
- 16:38thinking there. So what what about reform?
- 16:41Are they following a similar trajectory to what Matt was
- 16:44describing for Hollywood? Yeah, they are, but but also
- 16:48know at the same time, so they want to basic, they say there's
- 16:53too much onshore and offshore wind, there's too much solar in
- 16:56Wales and it's saturated. That's that's their main stance.
- 17:01So yeah, that's happening to the nimbies out there that don't
- 17:04want anything built near them. But but perhaps strangely,
- 17:10they've gone all in on nuclear. They absolutely love the SMR
- 17:13project in Anglesey and they want more roll out of nuclear
- 17:18across Wales and obviously across England as well.
- 17:21So that's their big sticking point.
- 17:23So, so they're not kind of going on a climate denial route in
- 17:27Wales, but I think in populist fashion, nuclear in Wales is
- 17:31very popular. Wilfa has been a site that's had
- 17:35nuclear kind of like drop off the radar after promises of, you
- 17:40know, new development. So yeah, I think reform, we're
- 17:43just leaning into that populist stance that people in Wales love
- 17:46nuclear. So we love nuclear.
- 17:48People don't like solar, so we don't like solar.
- 17:50That that's very much that tactic outside of energy as well
- 17:54as people can imagine. And that it does seem to be the
- 17:57major dividing line between the Scottish and the Scottish and
- 18:02Welsh elections is nuclear. And in Scotland, nuclear is very
- 18:05much opposed by the the party looking to looking to retain
- 18:10power. Whereas in Wales, as you say,
- 18:12they've already got nuclear capacity.
- 18:14We know they're getting more and that they're quite happy about
- 18:17that. Do you, do you see, do you see
- 18:21any sort of opposition for this, this nuclear project or is it
- 18:25very much everyone goes well, this is creating jobs, it's
- 18:28doing well, bringing investment into the country?
- 18:30Well, funnily enough, the Greens like this should be that their
- 18:33election, right? Like they've been the Greens
- 18:36have been talking about renewable and clean power for
- 18:39decades. Like this is that time energies
- 18:41are really high on the agenda. But but yeah, they don't like
- 18:45nuclear. They want more solar.
- 18:47They want more onshore winds. They just think more, more solar
- 18:51will fix all of the problems. But, but they've also got an
- 18:55internal battle with Nimbyism and environmentalism.
- 18:59So, so whenever they're trying to roll out solar, like they're
- 19:03saying like, oh, well, it can't be on this field, it can't be on
- 19:06that field. So, so they want solar, but they
- 19:08don't really want to build solar.
- 19:09So I think the Greens kind of have themselves tied up, tied up
- 19:12in knots to to be honest, on this election, which which is
- 19:17really strange when energy's so high on the on people's minds.
- 19:20Yeah, I mean it, it, that stance does kind of baffle me a little
- 19:24bit that they have kind of taken that, Yeah, as you say, the
- 19:28NIMBY approach of the although we don't want, yeah, we don't
- 19:32want to see the wind farms. We don't want to see the, the
- 19:34wind there, the solar panels. Because surely that's, you know,
- 19:40like, like any government delivering an infrastructure
- 19:42project, surely you want to be able to pose next to it and go
- 19:45look at this, look at this amazing thing we've done.
- 19:48But maybe with with renewables, we've spoken about this before
- 19:51about how unlike a nuclear power plant or an, you know, new oil
- 19:56and gas installation or, you know, refinery or something like
- 20:00that, they don't create that many jobs in the grand scheme of
- 20:03things. A bit of a sneak peek to what
- 20:05I'll be writing about next week. I was over in the Netherlands.
- 20:09But with Shell last week for their HH one project and we saw
- 20:14this massive site for green hydrogen, it's going to be using
- 20:18a renew offshore wind energy to, to generate hydrogen.
- 20:23And we were asking them, you know, how many, how many people
- 20:27will be working here? And they went, oh, you know, and
- 20:29bearing in mind it took us a good like, you know, for, for
- 20:32the tour, just walking around like where the electrolysis were
- 20:35and the tanks and the pipelines and stuff.
- 20:38You know, it's a, it's a fair size of place.
- 20:40I think they said 8 football fields, something like that, Six
- 20:42football fields, something like that.
- 20:44As in what what our American viewers were called soccer
- 20:48fields. That hurt to say.
- 20:51But the yeah, they were saying, Oh yeah, there'll be about 3
- 20:57shifts of eight to nine people to begin with.
- 20:59And then that can can be reduced over time because that's a bit
- 21:02of a sort of over over commitment just to make sure
- 21:06things run smoothly. We do hear that from like the
- 21:09unions and such about renewables that that aren't the job
- 21:12delivery and sort of operations and maintenance for a wind
- 21:15turbine or solar panel panel. So is that maybe where there
- 21:21were greener struggling, where it's like, well yes, you can
- 21:25deliver this, but you can't then say look at all the jobs we've
- 21:27created on your doorstep? Yeah, exactly.
- 21:29All the jobs are in construction, right, like you
- 21:30say. And then maintenance is like,
- 21:33you know, skeleton crews, but but yeah.
- 21:37And I think just to round up with, with Labour, basically
- 21:40what they're what they're doing is they're just trying to lean
- 21:43on their record wherever they can because they're quite happy
- 21:46with the roll out across Wales. You know, Wilfa's come like the
- 21:50SMR project to come online under their watch and, and under the
- 21:53Labour government. So so they'll be looking to kind
- 21:55of just lean into that a little bit more.
- 21:58So yeah, I think, I think as well, like Miliband for example,
- 22:03I'm going to come out of Wales for for a second and go over to
- 22:06Lincolnshire where I'm originally from.
- 22:08Obviously Miliband used his NC powers for 3000 acre Springfield
- 22:16farm, Spring World Farm. Sorry, in Lincolnshire everyone
- 22:20kicked up a fuss about it. Angela Jenkins, who's the reform
- 22:23mayor of Greater Lincolnshire, said that they'll file a
- 22:26judicial review, like they'll make sure it's not happening.
- 22:29And then now the justice settled, like the department
- 22:33basically said, no, they're not going to file a judicial review
- 22:36anymore. So Welsh Labour will probably
- 22:39lean into that. The fact that there's always
- 22:40opposition when these things get announced, but after like, you
- 22:43know, after a bit of time, when people like see that the wind
- 22:46farm's going to be there, they kind of get over it.
- 22:48So I feel like Welsh Labour kind of delivering the deal with it
- 22:54mantra, which obviously won't go down well with some people, but
- 22:57I think in terms of the energy landscape is probably what's
- 23:00needed to to start getting these projects going.
- 23:04Floyd, if you've seen and I know we're probably running out of
- 23:07time, but whether there's been much discussion in the Welsh
- 23:11election around splitting the the Crown Estate into a separate
- 23:15Welsh. It's similar to how this Crown
- 23:17Estate Scotland, because I have seen Plaid, Camry and you know,
- 23:21I think I'm not sure if other parties are involved, but
- 23:24because there hasn't been from what I can see much discussion
- 23:26around offshore wind, even though there's we've seen in the
- 23:29future, there's some discussions around the Celtic Sea
- 23:32opportunities and then ports in Wales and we've seen the Welsh
- 23:36government talking a lot about that.
- 23:37But doesn't seem to feature as much in the the manifestos from
- 23:40what the quick scan in terms of offshore wind.
- 23:42But have you seen much discussion around the the Crown
- 23:45Estate? Yeah, yeah.
- 23:46So played Cymru massively talking about it.
- 23:49So they're advocating for the, the full devolution of the Crown
- 23:53Estate and they've kind of lent into the nationalist approach of
- 23:57like, it's our like making into an ownership row, essentially
- 24:02saying that like the Crown Estate, like the Welsh people
- 24:06should be able to have more say. And that's what they think
- 24:09devolution will be able to, to deliver.
- 24:12So yeah, they're, they're pushing on with that and that's
- 24:14the key part of their messaging. But I'm not too short on all the
- 24:19other parties, but I know Plaid Cymru are definitely talking the
- 24:22loudest about devolution of, of the Crown Estate.
- 24:25Well. Much like the segment that we
- 24:27kicked off the show with, we can't give a firm, you know,
- 24:33wrap this up in an ice bowl, a firm conclusion to to this.
- 24:36The elections are still to happen at the time of recording.
- 24:39But if you'd like to keep up to date with both of the elections
- 24:42we spoke about, I'm sure Energy Voice will keep you covered and
- 24:44all things energy outcomes from that.
- 24:48And up next, we're going to be speaking about NZTC and they're
- 24:52finding themselves in a bit of hot water.
- 24:55Be the first to hear breaking energy news through the Energy
- 24:59Voice app, available to download for free.
- 25:02You get features like saving the articles you want to return to,
- 25:06access to the Energy Voice supplement.
- 25:09You can read exclusive E Forward content and even listen to the
- 25:13Energy Voice Out Loud podcast. If you work in the UK energy
- 25:17sector. Stay in the loop by saving the
- 25:20Energy Voice app to your home screen.
- 25:22Download the app through the Apple App Store or Google Play
- 25:26for breaking energy news on the go by searching Energy Voice
- 25:30app. So Floyd and Matt have bunked
- 25:34off early this week. So that means that Erica
- 25:37Askeland are fabulous news editors joining me.
- 25:39How are you doing today, Erica? Fabulous.
- 25:41Thank you very much. Erica, you've been you've been
- 25:44around NZTC this week. We've been speaking a little bit
- 25:48about the future of the company. The public funds have dried up
- 25:52£180 million. Job cuts the law.
- 25:55What's happening? You tell me.
- 25:56That's it. So the question is what would
- 25:59you do if you had 180 million / 10 years?
- 26:04Well, the Net 0 Technology Center did that and they are now
- 26:10coming to the end of that and looking towards the post £180
- 26:16million future. So I met up with uh, net 0
- 26:20Technology Centre and said TC, uh, chief executive Mertel Dos
- 26:25and umm. So we reported on Energy Voice
- 26:28that they've, uh, cut about half their staff, umm, and that they
- 26:33are, uh, cutting their cloth accordingly.
- 26:36Umm looking to work with other partners in instead of of having
- 26:43been funded by both the Scottish Government and the UK government
- 26:48through a mechanism called the Aberdeen City Region deal.
- 26:53So that happened 10 years ago. And you know what, I've been
- 26:57around for so long, I remember the excitement and the fanfare,
- 27:01you know, these city region deals were being handed out like
- 27:04sweet teas. And I mean, it was all really,
- 27:07really exciting. And then, but I also kind of
- 27:09remember at the time in 2016 when or 2015 I suppose, when all
- 27:14of the, you know, stuff was being allocated, there was this
- 27:19kind of expectation that this Aberdeen City region deal was
- 27:22going to be, you know, like worth 3 billion.
- 27:25And in fact, it was kind of more in the region of 1 billion and
- 27:29then the bulk of the actual cash that was being handed out
- 27:33because, you know, depending on how people were counting for it,
- 27:37you know, that 180 million of it, which was the bulk of the
- 27:43cash coming from Scottish Government and UK government was
- 27:46being allocated to what was then the Oil and Gas Technology
- 27:51Center 'cause it was 2016. It was before everyone was
- 27:55talking about net zero. So, and funnily enough, the
- 27:58column that Mertel Dots has penned exclusively for Energy
- 28:04Voice Online talks about what those days were like a little
- 28:10bit, you know, she says a decade ago, she remembers that in
- 28:15industry, you know, the words net zero raised eyebrows.
- 28:20And that was also at the time when the North Sea was at the
- 28:27bottom of one of their cycles. I mean, you know, people in
- 28:30Aberdeen were handing back the keys on their flats.
- 28:33You know, there were talks about people showing up to food banks
- 28:36and their Jaguar cars and stuff like that just because, hey, you
- 28:41know, back then Aberdeen was basically a petrostate.
- 28:45But nevertheless, ten years on from now, they changed their
- 28:49name to the Net 0 Technology Center, and they have been
- 28:53developing basically, you know, operate a really successful
- 28:58incubator scheme for energy technologies called Tech X.
- 29:05They have, you know, set up, you know, like AI, don't know, like
- 29:10lots of other things. Oh, what do they say?
- 29:12So 130 startups, £270 million worth of industry funding
- 29:19secured alongside that one AT and so so just.
- 29:24Just go ahead. You know, you know, the, the
- 29:26major criticism I've I've heard since your exclusive report this
- 29:31week about the job cuts, about the, the sort of public funding
- 29:36running out is yeah, but what have they done with that?
- 29:40And, you know, we're, we're hearing, you know, we hear about
- 29:42the, the accelerator program. We hear about, yeah, the
- 29:45incubator and that I think that's all well and good.
- 29:49And, you know, it's, it's great that startups are able to get to
- 29:52market. And I guess the, the question
- 29:56is, you know, who were these startups?
- 29:58I don't think we, we hear who they were, how successful they
- 30:01were after public money was put in.
- 30:03And and then also, you know, I guess the, the real question is,
- 30:08you know, what has the NZTC done in terms of pushing the UK or
- 30:14Scotland or the northeast of Scotland more specifically
- 30:17forward in that energy transition?
- 30:19Is there, is there a technology that, you know, revolutionize
- 30:23the game that's been made-up here in Aberdeen thanks to the
- 30:27NZTC. Have we delivered a
- 30:29revolutionary technology that is going to solve the energy
- 30:33crisis? And no, I don't think so.
- 30:35No, I don't think so. I think we'd report.
- 30:37I know, I know. I could've heard it here on
- 30:39Energy Wise First. Absolutely.
- 30:42No. I mean, I guess maybe some of
- 30:44the highlights referenced, there's Mission 0 has been
- 30:49developing some direct air capture air controls, got some,
- 30:54you know, flying systems and GDI has been working with other MATE
- 31:00Total Energies, I think who's adopted there, you know, digital
- 31:04asset management platform. So these are all kind of like
- 31:06really cool little, you know, kind of startups that have
- 31:09managed to succeed and been bought and sold and all that.
- 31:12And, you know, and for example, there's also a verloom is
- 31:17another graduate, I think of some of these processes and
- 31:21projects. You know, I mean, it's, it's
- 31:23kind of more like an ecosystem. I mean, you know, and if you
- 31:27talk about an ecosystem, you know, say, for example, like
- 31:31Silicon Valley where you get, you know, the likes of, you
- 31:35know, Twitter or X or Facebook or whatever.
- 31:40I mean, like we, we haven't reached those heady heights, you
- 31:43know, in terms of the energy transition.
- 31:45Well, that's, and I, I guess, you know, if, if the, if the
- 31:48intention was always to, to bring, you know, these sort of
- 31:52smaller startups to market and for Loom in particular, they've
- 31:55done very well. We've spoken to them, you know,
- 31:58their former CEO Richard Knox has been on the, the podcast a
- 32:01few times as well. You know, they've done well for
- 32:05themselves. But I guess if I'm seeing these
- 32:07questions after the fact, it, you know, it is that maybe more
- 32:12of a question of was this was the mandate set up inaccurately?
- 32:17Or do you think it was that marketing around it and telling
- 32:21people what they're doing wasn't quite right?
- 32:23Because clearly people don't think that they've done what
- 32:27they set out to do, but they feel like they have to a certain
- 32:29extent. Is this a case of, you know,
- 32:31Life of Brian, what did the Romans ever do for us?
- 32:34Or is this are they right to be upset?
- 32:38Well, you know what I mean. We can probably try to determine
- 32:41who was or was not a very naughty boy with regards to
- 32:45spending the £180 million and you know, kind of what we've got
- 32:50to show for it. The thing now I guess maybe to
- 32:54think about is there is something exciting coming out of
- 32:58it. And I don't know, it's, it's
- 33:00kind of a funny one because like, I think some people are
- 33:03going to be like, yay, cool. And some people are going to be
- 33:05what? Because the next thing that
- 33:08they're planning to do is set up the Weatherford drilling rig up
- 33:14at the Bridge of Don. And that is going to be.
- 33:17So what they're going to be doing in future is testing
- 33:20technologies for companies. And then of course, they also
- 33:24had set up the National Decommissioning Centre and a few
- 33:27other research centres alongside of the universities.
- 33:30So I think they kind of think that, you know, what they are
- 33:33going to be doing in terms of offering a legacy for this £180
- 33:38million is continuing to offer industry the sort of facilities
- 33:43that they require and will continue to pay for to test, you
- 33:48know, what they need to do for decommissioning, geothermal and
- 33:54carbon capture and storage as well.
- 33:58I think they're going to be focusing on, you know, remote
- 34:02drone technology and I guess there's direct air capture.
- 34:05I mean, I'm still kind of waiting for one day to someone
- 34:08come up with a DAC solution that just kind of sucks all the
- 34:10carbon out of the air. And then we can go back to, you
- 34:13know, doing whatever we want. But yeah, so interesting times,
- 34:18though. It always kind of feels like I
- 34:20remember, you know, when they first launched and, you know,
- 34:23they had this kind of swizzy, you know, screens and these big
- 34:25events and, you know, like lots of video content and stuff like
- 34:29that. I kind of wonder if they are
- 34:30doing a lot of like, marketing spend, you know, rather than
- 34:33serious investment. But you know, I mean the
- 34:35industry also needs to communicate what it does, how it
- 34:39does. And I don't know, you know, we
- 34:41are where we are and the Net 0 Technology Center is here still.
- 34:47And I guess we are going to just have to see, you know, what
- 34:52comes out in the next years, 10 years.
- 34:56We'll see. We'll see.
- 34:57I'm optimistic, Ryan, you know what, actually, it's Friday and
- 35:00sunny. I'm feeling optimistic.
- 35:03So I'm looking forward to it. Unlike a.
- 35:05Journalist to be optimistic, but there we go.
- 35:08Right? Well.
- 35:08It's true tell. You what I think that does that
- 35:11is all the time we've got I I'm not entirely convinced yet.
- 35:15I think I still need a bit of evidence.
- 35:17So I'm going to, I'm going to offer this up to our listeners,
- 35:21get in touch with us on LinkedIn and tell us is, is it a case of
- 35:26what did the NZ TC ever do for us or was Myrtle a very naughty
- 35:31boy? Well, you can tell us that over
- 35:33on our social media platforms and we'll see you same time,
- 35:37same place next week. Thank you very much, Erica for
- 35:39joining me.