Latest / Blast Radius / Defrost Mode
Transcript
- 0:01It's just past one in the morning, on the second of November,
- 0:06and somewhere in Belgium the technicians of a refrigeration installer are doing the one thing nobody in their trade ever wants to do.
- 0:17They are pulling their own installations off the network, one by one,
- 0:23as fast as their hands will go.
- 0:26Next store.
- 0:27Take it offline.
- 0:29Don't wait for the readings, just cut it off.
- 0:32Far to the north, in a supermarket in Sweden, the freezers have been told it's time to defrost,
- 0:40and the temperature setting reads plus fifty degrees.
- 0:45Set it back.
- 0:47It won't take it.
- 0:49It just won't take it.
- 0:51Nobody has opened a door, and nobody has touched a fridge, but in one store the cooling system has started to make heat.
- 1:03By four, store managers in Belgium are reading warnings by text message,
- 1:08and some of them are calling in refrigerated trucks to save what's left.
- 1:14And the part this whole case turns on is that none of it is new.
- 1:19It has happened before, three weeks ago, in France.
- 1:25I'm Nora Whitfield.
- 1:27Before we begin...
- 1:28one honest disclosure.
- 1:30Everything in this story is real.
- 1:33The company, the timeline, the numbers.
- 1:36All of it happened, and all of it comes from the public record.
- 1:40The voice about to tell it to you...
- 1:42is not real.
- 1:44Neither is mine.
- 1:45We are synthetic...
- 1:47generated with AI.
- 1:49The facts are human.
- 1:51The reconstruction is ours.
- 1:53I'm Julian Ashcroft, and I'm your narrator.
- 1:57This is Blast Radius...
- 2:00stories from the nights our systems failed...
- 2:04and the people who brought them back.
- 2:07This is a true story.
- 2:10Tonight there's no single company in the dock.
- 2:14The victims are supermarket chains across Europe, from Leclerc,
- 2:18Intermarché and Coopérative U in France to Carrefour, Spar and Coop in Belgium and Sweden,
- 2:27and the system is the small box on the wall of a plant room that runs their fridges and freezers.
- 2:32It's a refrigeration controller, and many of these, from makers like Danfoss,
- 2:38Copeland and Dixell, came with a web page so a technician could check the temperatures from anywhere.
- 2:46Anywhere turned out to include the open internet.
- 2:50On the night of the eleventh of October, someone reached those web pages and told the freezers in French stores to defrost,
- 2:58with their setpoints near fifty degrees.
- 3:01Early reports said a few hundred stores were hit, and the French government later put it at about seven hundred sites,
- 3:09with at least fifteen fires.
- 3:12Three weeks later it happened again, this time in Belgium, Luxembourg,
- 3:16Sweden, Ireland and Estonia at least.
- 3:20France says it knows who was behind the first night.
- 3:23So far, nobody has said who was behind the second.
- 3:28Incident declared.
- 3:31Start the clock.
- 3:34Let's go back to an ordinary day, before either night, and start with the box on the wall.
- 3:41In the back of a supermarket, behind the aisles, there's a plant room full of compressors and pipework,
- 3:48and a controller that decides how cold every display case and every freezer should be.
- 3:55It holds the setpoints, the alarms and the defrost schedule,
- 4:00and in a big store it watches dozens of units at once.
- 4:04Defrost is the most ordinary thing it does.
- 4:08Ice builds up on the coils inside a freezer, so every so often the controller warms them for a while to clear it,
- 4:16and then the cold comes back.
- 4:18It's maintenance, built in, and it runs on its own without anyone thinking about it.
- 4:25Frozen aisle's holding.
- 4:27Dairy's fine.
- 4:30Defrost cycles look normal.
- 4:33Nothing to drive out for tonight.
- 4:36That's the convenience the web page was built for.
- 4:40The people who look after these systems, at installers and at service providers that manage refrigeration for whole chains,
- 4:47can check a store from a laptop instead of a van.
- 4:52Some stores sit inside a chain's central network, and others are run by independent operators with refrigeration systems of their own.
- 5:01When Sweden's ICA later described the stores it lost, its press officer put it this way.
- 5:08Affecting a small number of ICA stores operating outside ICA's central network.
- 5:15Now here's the fault, and it has been sitting in plain sight for years.
- 5:20Many of those web pages didn't only answer the technician.
- 5:25They answered anyone on the open internet who went looking.
- 5:29Many of the controllers ran older versions of their software,
- 5:33and some were past the end of their life, with no more updates coming at all.
- 5:39France's computer emergency team would later say it plainly in its alert:
- 5:43in general, exposing a management interface on the internet goes against good practice.
- 5:50And it wasn't a handful of boxes.
- 5:53The day after the first night, a security researcher counted two thousand seven hundred and fifty-two Danfoss systems exposed online,
- 6:02fifteen hundred and ninety of them in France, and the Shodan search engine was tracking more than forty-five hundred Danfoss devices reachable from anywhere.
- 6:14Sweden's national cybersecurity centre would say it had already flagged a lot of exposed operational equipment in the country,
- 6:23equipment that needed updating or patching.
- 6:26So the warning existed, and the boxes were still there, humming in plant rooms across Europe.
- 6:34And on every one of those web pages, among the alarms and the temperatures,
- 6:40sat the setting that would become the weapon, and it was the most ordinary one on the page.
- 6:48It was the switch that tells a freezer it's time to defrost.
- 6:54The first night was a Sunday, the eleventh of October, in France.
- 6:59Overnight, someone reached refrigeration controllers in supermarkets that were running older versions of Danfoss control software,
- 7:09and they didn't need to break anything at all.
- 7:11They used the units' own built-in defrost and set the targets near fifty degrees.
- 7:19Temperature alarm, frozen aisle.
- 7:22And the dairy case.
- 7:24They're all in defrost.
- 7:27All of them at once?
- 7:29That's not a schedule.
- 7:31Who changed the setpoints?
- 7:33Nobody here.
- 7:36The controller says fifty, and it's climbing.
- 7:41By Monday morning some of the biggest names in French retail were confirming the damage,
- 7:47and France would later list Casino, Leclerc, Coopérative U, Metro,
- 7:52Carrefour and Intermarché among the victims.
- 7:56Intermarché's spokesperson gave the first account of how the attack got in.
- 8:01Following a cyberattack reportedly affecting a service provider that manages refrigeration systems in stores,
- 8:08some fresh and frozen food display units are out of service.
- 8:13Intermarché and Netto pulled the products from those units as fast as they could.
- 8:19The president of Coopérative U confirmed that since the night before,
- 8:23an attack had been hitting refrigeration in several of the group's stores,
- 8:28and he described the response like this.
- 8:31Our teams are fully mobilized, working alongside refrigeration specialists,
- 8:36to resolve the situation as quickly as possible.
- 8:39Then he said what the whole trade was thinking.
- 8:44Targeting equipment essential for preserving fresh produce and supplying food to the French people is an extremely serious matter and is unprecedented.
- 8:54It is unacceptable.
- 8:56That same Monday, France's computer emergency team, CERT-FR,
- 9:01published its alert.
- 9:03It said it knew of numerous compromises of remote controllers for refrigeration installations,
- 9:10naming the Danfoss AK-SM and AK-SC series and Copeland and Dixell xweb.
- 9:17Its advice was blunt: cut them off the internet, check the whole configuration,
- 9:23especially the defrost schedules, and bring access back only through a secure VPN or a protected network.
- 9:32The Paris prosecutor's office opened an investigation, and it told the news agency AFP what that investigation was for.
- 9:42Identify the victims and establish the link with the damage they reported in terms of foodstuff losses and the outbreak of fires.
- 9:51Fires, from a fridge.
- 9:54France would later count at least fifteen of them.
- 9:58On the thirteenth, CERT-FR added more targeted equipment to its alert,
- 10:04and on the sixteenth it updated its advice again.
- 10:08Two lines in that update read like a forecast.
- 10:12Attack campaigns against these controllers, it warned, were probably still under way,
- 10:18and for end-of-life units left on the open internet a factory reset alone wasn't enough,
- 10:25because the equipment would stay vulnerable and would almost certainly be compromised again.
- 10:31So we wipe it clean, and it's wide open again the next morning.
- 10:36Three weeks later, on the night of the first of November, the forecast came true.
- 10:44So who did the trade suspect first?
- 10:47On any normal night, a warm freezer means a tired compressor or a stuck valve.
- 10:54But one store failing is a breakdown, and hundreds failing on the same night is something else entirely.
- 11:03The next suspect was a supplier.
- 11:05Intermarché said the attack had reportedly hit a service provider that manages refrigeration in its stores.
- 11:15But in the second wave, the Colruyt Group described the Spar shops it lost like this.
- 11:23These stores are operated by independent entrepreneurs who have their own refrigeration systems.
- 11:29Sweden's ICA said much the same about its own stores, the ones running outside its central network,
- 11:36so a single provider couldn't explain it all.
- 11:41As for Ahold Delhaize, it had taken some systems offline after an incident of its own back in October,
- 11:48and its page said there was no evidence yet of any link to France.
- 11:54And it wasn't anyone on shift.
- 11:57Nobody here touched a setpoint.
- 12:00And yes, before you ask.
- 12:03Was it DNS?
- 12:06It was not DNS.
- 12:09The second night didn't stay in one country.
- 12:13Before dawn on the second of November, the reports came in from Belgium,
- 12:17Luxembourg, Sweden, Ireland and Estonia at least, and the count of stores differed from one outlet to the next.
- 12:27In Belgium and Luxembourg, dozens of Ahold Delhaize stores saw their temperatures climb overnight,
- 12:34and a refrigeration company said the evaporators had been switched to defrost.
- 12:40I've reset this one twice.
- 12:42It goes straight back into defrost.
- 12:46Then stop resetting it.
- 12:48Pull it off the network.
- 12:51That was the wrong fix the trade kept learning the hard way.
- 12:55CERT-FR had already warned that a reset wouldn't hold on an exposed,
- 13:00end-of-life unit, and the director of a Belgian installer said a software update alone couldn't protect these boxes either,
- 13:08because they needed physical changes too.
- 13:12In Ireland, SuperValu took chilled and frozen products off the shelves in thirteen stores.
- 13:18In Sweden, freezers at an Axfood distribution centre near Gothenburg were hit,
- 13:24and at one ICA store the setting sat at plus fifty and would not change back,
- 13:30so the frozen food was thrown away.
- 13:33Carrefour in Belgium counted fifteen stores hit, and kept every one of them open.
- 13:40The EU's agriculture and food commissioner put the cost in plain words.
- 13:47Europe's food supply chain must be prepared for new and evolving threats.
- 13:52The repeated cyber-attacks on supermarkets are deeply concerning,
- 13:56causing economic losses for retailers and empty shelves for consumers.
- 14:02And Belgium's cybersecurity centre said the thing nobody on shift wanted to hear,
- 14:08that the attackers may never be identified.
- 14:13So who's next?
- 14:16So far, nobody could say.
- 14:19Here's the root cause, and it was never the freezer.
- 14:23It was the web page.
- 14:25A box built to keep food cold was answering anyone on the open internet who went looking,
- 14:33and many of those boxes ran older software, some of them past the end of their life,
- 14:38with no more updates coming.
- 14:41Nobody needed to break anything.
- 14:44Whoever reached those pages used the most ordinary setting on them,
- 14:48the defrost the controller runs on its own every day, and gave it a target near fifty degrees.
- 14:55At one store in Sweden the setting sat at plus fifty and would not change back.
- 15:02That's why the resets kept failing.
- 15:05Wipe an exposed, end-of-life unit clean and it's still sitting on the internet,
- 15:10still vulnerable, and, as CERT-FR warned, almost certainly compromised again.
- 15:17The only fix that held was the one those technicians in Belgium were doing at one in the morning:
- 15:23take the box off the open internet, and let people back in only through a secure VPN or a protected network.
- 15:31So the freezers never broke down.
- 15:34They did exactly what they were told.
- 15:37What failed was who they would take orders from.
- 15:42By sunrise on the second of November, the recovery looked less like engineering and more like housekeeping.
- 15:52Spoiled food went into the bins, refrigerated trucks stood behind the stores,
- 15:58and the boxes the technicians had cut off the network stayed off it.
- 16:03Across the trade, the fix that held wasn't a clever patch.
- 16:08It was a connection taken away.
- 16:12In Belgium, the director of a refrigeration company told the broadcaster RTL that a software update alone couldn't protect these units,
- 16:22and that most of his clients had already moved to a secure connection after the French attacks.
- 16:28He put the lesson in one line.
- 16:32The simplest solution is to manage the refrigerators via a secure internet connection.
- 16:39Then the authorities caught up.
- 16:41On the third of November, the European Commission held emergency meetings with ENISA and Europol,
- 16:49and a controller maker confirmed that some of its web controllers had been targeted.
- 16:54Britain's cybersecurity centre said it knew of a couple of cases in its own food supply chain and had alerted the companies that might be affected.
- 17:04In the United States, the FBI and CISA warned of attacks on refrigeration and cold-chain systems worldwide.
- 17:12On the ninth of November, France said who it blames for its night.
- 17:19According to France, the October wave was the work of a unit linked to Iran's Revolutionary Guards.
- 17:27It says the same infrastructure was used to scout industrial equipment at small energy and water plants,
- 17:34and that its investigators found traces of Farsi in it.
- 17:39The foreign ministry said it would summon Iran's ambassador and propose new EU sanctions,
- 17:45and it described the campaign like this.
- 17:48This is an unprecedented campaign in terms of its scale and level of aggressiveness,
- 17:54thus constituting the first cyber offensive campaign carried out purely for the purpose of sabotage on national territory.
- 18:03That is France's accusation, and it covers October only.
- 18:09So far, nobody has said who was behind the second night.
- 18:15But this show doesn't sentence people, it sentences systems,
- 18:20and the action items hardly depend on whose hands were on the keys.
- 18:24Take every management page off the open internet, and bring access back only through a secure VPN or a protected network.
- 18:32Check the whole configuration, not just the temperatures, and above all the defrost schedules,
- 18:38because a schedule someone else wrote will run on its own.
- 18:43Treat an end-of-life controller as a box with no future, since CERT-FR warned that a reset only puts it back in front of the same open door.
- 18:52And plan for the night the cold stops, because the Commission said it would look at exactly that:
- 18:58retailers' contingency plans and their ability to respond.
- 19:03So nobody on shift goes in the report.
- 19:07Nobody does.
- 19:09The report names a web page that should never have faced the open internet,
- 19:14and the most ordinary setting on it, which nobody ever thought of as dangerous.
- 19:20It wasn't the freezers, which did exactly what they were told.
- 19:25It wasn't the technicians, who spent the small hours pulling their own installations off the network.
- 19:31And it wasn't some exotic trick, because nobody needed to break anything:
- 19:36they used the defrost the controller already had.
- 19:41It was a management page that answered anyone on the open internet,
- 19:46on boxes running older software, some of them past the end of their life,
- 19:51with the most ordinary setting in the trade sitting on it like a loaded switch.
- 19:57So here's the one thing to take back to your own shift.
- 20:02Somewhere in the systems you look after, there's a box that went online for convenience and that nobody has looked at in years,
- 20:11a camera, a badge reader, a controller in a plant room.
- 20:16Find it before someone else does, take it off the open internet,
- 20:21and let people back in only through a secure VPN or a protected network.
- 20:27And when it misbehaves, don't trust a reset to save you, because a box wiped clean behind an open door is still sitting behind that door.
- 20:37So.
- 20:39The verdict.
- 20:41Incident resolved.
- 20:43Stop the clock.
- 20:45...
- 20:46Sleep with your pager on...
- 20:49This story was built from the public record: CERT-FR's alert on the refrigeration controllers,
- 20:55statements from the retailers and from France's foreign ministry,
- 21:00and reporting from BleepingComputer, The Register, Reuters, Al Jazeera,
- 21:05AFP, Cybersecurity Dive and the trade paper Cooling Post.
- 21:10Links, timestamps, and sources are in the show notes.
- 21:14It's a story that's still moving.
- 21:18Our sources run to the tenth of November, so when you heard "so far" tonight,
- 21:24we meant exactly that.
- 21:27Some of the numbers, from how many stores were hit to how many countries,
- 21:32still differ from one account to the next.
- 21:36Tonight's voices were Nora Whitfield and me, Julian Ashcroft,
- 21:41both synthetic, reading a reconstruction of real events.
- 21:46We named no engineer, technician or store worker, because the culprit was the system,
- 21:53not the people who spent the night saving what they could.
- 21:58Blast Radius is an AllTuner Originals production.