Latest / Bloomberg Law / Trump's Wild Day on the Witness Stand
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: It's a case that you dismissed immediately. The fraudlers of
- 0:14Speaker 2: the airport, the court. The court was the fraud story
- 0:17Speaker 2: of this case. They made references through assets that were
- 0:23Speaker 2: very valuable, and they said they had no idea, they
- 0:26Speaker 2: had no idea what the numbers were when they said
- 0:28Speaker 2: eighteen million dollars from our autumn, and it's fifty two,
- 0:32Speaker 2: one hundred times.
- 0:32Speaker 3: That amount by any estimation.
- 0:35Speaker 4: It was a wild day in the courtroom as Donald
- 0:38Speaker 4: Trump took the witness stand in the two hundred and
- 0:41Speaker 4: fifty million dollars civil fraud trial over asset valuations at
- 0:45Speaker 4: the Trump organization, the family real estate business at the
- 0:49Speaker 4: heart of his PERSONA less than an hour into his testimony,
- 0:54Speaker 4: Judge Arthur and Goron, who will determine the verdict and
- 0:57Speaker 4: the penalty without a jury, threatened to remove of Trump
- 1:00Speaker 4: from the stand for giving long, rambling answers to yes
- 1:04Speaker 4: or no questions, even after being asked not to do so.
- 1:08Speaker 4: Following Trump's testimony, New York Attorney General Letitia James had
- 1:13Speaker 4: this to say.
- 1:14Speaker 3: He rambled, he hurled insults, but we expected that. At
- 1:21Speaker 3: the end of the day, the documentary evidence demonstrated that,
- 1:26Speaker 3: in fact, he falsely inflated his assets to basically enrich
- 1:30Speaker 3: himself and his family. He continued to persistently engage in fraud.
- 1:35Speaker 3: The numbers don't lie.
- 1:38Speaker 4: Joining me is Bloomberg Legal reporter Patricia Hurtado, who was
- 1:41Speaker 4: in the courtroom. So, pat what was it like in
- 1:45Speaker 4: the courtroom, because reading about the testimony, it seemed so
- 1:50Speaker 4: contentious and.
- 1:53Speaker 1: Just off the rails.
- 1:54Speaker 5: At some point it was basically, you know, we are
- 1:59Speaker 5: all those of US trial reporters are used to the
- 2:01Speaker 5: controlled environment where the lawyer asked questions and the witnesses
- 2:05Speaker 5: under oath, and they're supposed to answer truthfully, and they're
- 2:08Speaker 5: supposed to answer.
- 2:09Speaker 6: To the best of their ability to give honest, truthful answers.
- 2:12Speaker 6: Trump used it as an opportunity, as a soapbox, to
- 2:16Speaker 6: take the stand and basically give the answer and make
- 2:18Speaker 6: the statement and give the spin that he wanted to
- 2:21Speaker 6: give and how he felt about this lawsuit. So he
- 2:24Speaker 6: called it a witch hunt. He would basically add hoc
- 2:27Speaker 6: answers that were not to the exact question. He would
- 2:31Speaker 6: just go off on a diatribe or a long long
- 2:35Speaker 6: comment that the judge said, are we having to listen
- 2:37Speaker 6: to an essay? You know? I mean, at some point
- 2:41Speaker 6: the judge was trying to rain him in, because that's
- 2:43Speaker 6: his job, because the trial was veering off the rails
- 2:48Speaker 6: to not specifically answer what he was supposed to answer.
- 2:52Speaker 6: He was talking about, you know, motives and applying all
- 2:55Speaker 6: kinds of nefarious machinations behind the seat, or why the
- 3:00Speaker 6: led Trump with a lawsuit got brought. He called it fraud.
- 3:04Speaker 6: He said the judge sitting right next to him was biased,
- 3:07Speaker 6: and said the case was crazy. And then the attorney
- 3:11Speaker 6: for the state said done, and then Trump said done.
- 3:16Speaker 6: But then he continued on and used every other question
- 3:20Speaker 6: to use it as a forum to air his grievances
- 3:25Speaker 6: about the feelings about the lawsuit, how great his company was,
- 3:28Speaker 6: how he has a beautiful company with beautiful numbers and
- 3:31Speaker 6: these are amazing, and he's so wealthy, could do whatever
- 3:34Speaker 6: he wanted.
- 3:35Speaker 4: Well, the judge at one point said, you can attack me,
- 3:38Speaker 4: but just answer the question.
- 3:40Speaker 1: Did he lose his temper?
- 3:41Speaker 6: Well, the judge several times stopped and said, can you
- 3:45Speaker 6: please control your client? And he turned to Kaist Christopher Kaist,
- 3:49Speaker 6: who is a lawyer for Trump, and he asked him,
- 3:52Speaker 6: could you please control your client, And he was basically
- 3:54Speaker 6: suggesting that he would dismiss Trump from the witness stand.
- 3:59Speaker 6: And he is allowed in civil law, in the civil
- 4:02Speaker 6: lawsuit to draw what was called an adverse inference, and
- 4:06Speaker 6: he called it a negative I could dismiss mister Trump
- 4:09Speaker 6: from the witness stand. And he didn't say Trump. He
- 4:12Speaker 6: kept saying the witness and I could declare a negative inference.
- 4:17Speaker 6: So you know, basically all bets are off, and I'm
- 4:19Speaker 6: going to vote against mister Trump. Because he didn't think
- 4:22Speaker 6: he was being honest in his answer.
- 4:25Speaker 4: So did Kays at one point argue that Trump had
- 4:29Speaker 4: a right to speak as a presidential candidate.
- 4:33Speaker 6: Yes, he called him the former and seemed to be
- 4:36Speaker 6: chief executive of the United States who understands the rules,
- 4:40Speaker 6: and the judge says, but he doesn't abide by them.
- 4:44Speaker 1: But he was saying that he had the right to
- 4:46Speaker 1: do that on the stand.
- 4:48Speaker 6: Yes, And Kys was basically arguing, he has a right
- 4:51Speaker 6: to do whatever he wants because of this he's running
- 4:54Speaker 6: for president and otherwise, his rights and free speech rights
- 4:57Speaker 6: as a presidential candidate were being impaired.
- 5:00Speaker 4: So what did he say about the financial statements? Did
- 5:03Speaker 4: he make any admissions?
- 5:05Speaker 6: He did acknowledge that he had signed. There were many
- 5:09Speaker 6: times where they showed him guarantees. They gave banks like
- 5:13Speaker 6: Deutsche Bank for loans or loan guarantees, and for the
- 5:18Speaker 6: Darrell Golf Club in Florida as well as for Chicago
- 5:22Speaker 6: Trump Tower in Chicago, that he would guarantee that he
- 5:26Speaker 6: had a certain amount of net worth. So basically he
- 5:29Speaker 6: had guaranteed it. So he was having to admit on
- 5:32Speaker 6: the stand that he had indeed signed and endorsed and
- 5:35Speaker 6: affirmed the accuracy of the financial documents. They're called statements
- 5:39Speaker 6: of financial condition that that Trump Org had submitted attesting
- 5:43Speaker 6: to the value of their properties and how much money
- 5:46Speaker 6: they had on hand, for example, testing that he had
- 5:48Speaker 6: twenty billion dollars in net worth for example, or on cash.
- 5:53Speaker 6: And Trump's like, yeah, it's a beautiful document, you see that.
- 5:56Speaker 6: It's beautiful numbers, beautiful numbers. So in the end, he
- 6:00Speaker 6: could not distance himself from something that he had affirmed
- 6:02Speaker 6: and signed and sworn that was accurate. Because that's a
- 6:05Speaker 6: small victory. I mean, you know, these these things that
- 6:08Speaker 6: are being proven by the Attorney general. It's a case
- 6:11Speaker 6: that's basically built on you want to think about him
- 6:15Speaker 6: as little building blocks, this little element, this element, this element.
- 6:19Speaker 6: He attested that Joeutscha Bank, for example, he said, was
- 6:22Speaker 6: not defrauded. They got great loans and there were worth
- 6:24Speaker 6: a lot of money, and the bank was not a victim.
- 6:26Speaker 6: And so for the lawsuit that Leticia James, the Attorney
- 6:30Speaker 6: generalist brought was basically nonsense and quote unquote crazy. But
- 6:34Speaker 6: you know, Deoetscha Bank has said, have they known the
- 6:37Speaker 6: true value? They may have not agreed to certain terms
- 6:39Speaker 6: that they let Trump have. So you know, this is
- 6:42Speaker 6: now going to be up to the judge. And at
- 6:45Speaker 6: one point the judge interrupted Trump and asked the state lawyer,
- 6:50Speaker 6: are you okay with this because it seems like he's
- 6:53Speaker 6: going off again, and are you all right? And basically
- 6:57Speaker 6: the state lawyer, Kevin Wallace, said, he thinks it's great.
- 7:00Speaker 6: It sounds like what the state is happy about is
- 7:04Speaker 6: Trump did not distance himself. He acknowledged those were his signatures.
- 7:09Speaker 6: He acknowledged he did sign those documents which eventually did
- 7:12Speaker 6: go to the banks. He said it was up to
- 7:14Speaker 6: the banks to do their own due diligence, and that
- 7:17Speaker 6: there's this clause at the very bottom that basically plausible deniability,
- 7:21Speaker 6: that it's up.
- 7:22Speaker 7: To the banks.
- 7:22Speaker 6: You know, it's like an escape clause that Trump claimed
- 7:26Speaker 6: the banks with onus was on them to do their
- 7:28Speaker 6: own due diligence and not rely on the accuracy of
- 7:32Speaker 6: the numbers that Trump Board gave them. So you know,
- 7:35Speaker 6: he's saying it's up to them, and it's the fall
- 7:37Speaker 6: to the banks and the insurers for not doing better
- 7:40Speaker 6: due diligence. But the documents are what they say, so
- 7:43Speaker 6: I can see why the Attorney General may feel that
- 7:46Speaker 6: they've actually gotten a lot out of Trump today, just
- 7:49Speaker 6: basically what they needed.
- 7:51Speaker 4: A lot's been made about the size of his triplex
- 7:54Speaker 4: in Trump Tower. Did he admit that the size was misstated?
- 7:59Speaker 6: Yeah, he is basically saying that, oh, that might have
- 8:02Speaker 6: been a mistake because that wasn't counting to elevator banks,
- 8:06Speaker 6: and that, oh, somebody might have mistakenly tripled it when
- 8:11Speaker 6: it's really only ten thousand and not thirty thousand, and
- 8:14Speaker 6: they got the number wrong. But as soon as it
- 8:17Speaker 6: was discovered incorrect, it was corrected and put out accurately.
- 8:22Speaker 6: But there are many times we have seen throughout this
- 8:24Speaker 6: trial and other documents where they continue to tell lenders
- 8:28Speaker 6: and insurers that this was not accurate.
- 8:31Speaker 4: And also, is he claiming that mar A Lago is
- 8:35Speaker 4: worth like a billion dollars?
- 8:38Speaker 6: Yes, he said it was worth a billion. And this
- 8:42Speaker 6: is a strange answer that's been given by both by
- 8:45Speaker 6: the Trump sons, Don Junior as well as Eric, that
- 8:49Speaker 6: mar A Lago was supposedly had a National Register of
- 8:53Speaker 6: Historic Places preventing it from being developed as anything. But
- 8:57Speaker 6: this historic property, it's beautiful and you know, built by
- 9:01Speaker 6: Merriweather Posts or whatever it's you know, it's a beautiful
- 9:04Speaker 6: as nineteen twenties mansion and it's.
- 9:06Speaker 5: On the water.
- 9:07Speaker 6: And Trump bought it and then claims that he could
- 9:11Speaker 6: develop that. And he did this also for a Scottish
- 9:14Speaker 6: golf club that he wanted to develop. So he claims
- 9:18Speaker 6: these properties he could do whatever he wanted. So if
- 9:21Speaker 6: it was okay for them to overvalue properties like mar
- 9:25Speaker 6: A Lago, because someday in the future it could be
- 9:29Speaker 6: it's a club, but it could also be a residence.
- 9:32Speaker 6: But it cannot be both. But Trump and his sons
- 9:36Speaker 6: Eric and Don Junior have said it's a club and
- 9:39Speaker 6: a home, so he can do whatever he wants, and
- 9:42Speaker 6: he's the owner, and so sometime later it could be changed,
- 9:45Speaker 6: totally ignoring the fact that you know, the National Register
- 9:48Speaker 6: of Much to our Places says you can't change the
- 9:51Speaker 6: construction of the building because it's a store.
- 9:54Speaker 4: Thanks so much, pat, We'll check with you on Wednesday
- 9:57Speaker 4: after Ivanka Drum's testimony. That's Bloomberg legal reporter Patricia Hurtado.
- 10:03Speaker 4: I'm Drewn Grasso, and you're listening to Bloomberg. Kyle Hanagami's
- 10:22Speaker 4: choreography has been used by Justin Bieber, Britney Spears, Ariana Grande,
- 10:27Speaker 4: and he says it's also been used by Epic Games Fortnite,
- 10:31Speaker 4: but without his permission. Hanagami owns a federal copyright registration
- 10:36Speaker 4: covering a full five minute dance routine from his video
- 10:39Speaker 4: to Charlie Poof's song how Long. He's claiming that Fortnite
- 10:44Speaker 4: infringed on his copyright by using his choreography as an
- 10:48Speaker 4: emote in the game. That's a biable dance for a
- 10:51Speaker 4: player's avatar. Other choreographers have not fared well with suits
- 10:56Speaker 4: against Fortnite, but a new ruling by the Ninth Circuit
- 10:59Speaker 4: Court of Appeals puts a new.
- 11:01Speaker 1: Spin on the moves.
- 11:02Speaker 4: Joining me is intellectual property. Attorney Ryan Meyer of Dorsey
- 11:07Speaker 4: and Whitney. Ryan tell us what kind of dance is copyrightable?
- 11:12Speaker 7: So with dance and copyright, there is a spectrum, and
- 11:17Speaker 7: at one end is the copyrightable zone, which is choreography. Unfortunately,
- 11:24Speaker 7: the Copyright Act itself doesn't expressly define choreography, and the
- 11:29Speaker 7: courts haven't well defined it until this decision, But it's
- 11:34Speaker 7: generally something that's a composition and arrangement of a series
- 11:38Speaker 7: of dance movements. By contrast, at the other end of
- 11:41Speaker 7: the spectrum, you have simple dance that are just sequence
- 11:47Speaker 7: of body movements, generally short and simple, often something that's social,
- 11:52Speaker 7: like the waltz or foxtrot step, and that is not copyrightable.
- 11:57Speaker 4: So does it have to be a certain length or
- 12:00Speaker 4: does it have to be complex? Are there any sort
- 12:02Speaker 4: of bright line rules?
- 12:04Speaker 7: There aren't any bright line rules. What there are is
- 12:09Speaker 7: there's a series of non determinative elements, and if any
- 12:13Speaker 7: one of these is present or not present, it doesn't
- 12:19Speaker 7: necessarily affect the outcome. But those elements are whether there
- 12:23Speaker 7: is rhythmic movement in a defined space, the compositional arrangement,
- 12:29Speaker 7: musical or textual accompaniment, dramatic content, presentation before an audience,
- 12:36Speaker 7: and execution by skilled performers. The length doesn't necessarily matter,
- 12:41Speaker 7: although the longer and more complex, the more likely it
- 12:44Speaker 7: is to be protectable.
- 12:46Speaker 4: So how would a choreographer go about getting copyright? I
- 12:49Speaker 4: mean do they write down, you know, explain the moves.
- 12:53Speaker 4: Do they show a clip of dancers doing the moves?
- 12:58Speaker 1: How does the copyright office see what's there?
- 13:01Speaker 7: So there could be more than one way, and both
- 13:04Speaker 7: of the ways that you mentioned might work. They could,
- 13:07Speaker 7: for example, write down and explain in detail the set
- 13:12Speaker 7: of dance moves and cut ways between the dance moves.
- 13:16Speaker 7: Here in this case, there was actually a five minute
- 13:20Speaker 7: video clip that was performed to a song and that's
- 13:24Speaker 7: what was registered with the copyright office.
- 13:27Speaker 4: Tell us about what is an issue here? What was
- 13:29Speaker 4: the dance and the issue with Fortnite using it?
- 13:32Speaker 7: Sure? So the dance is a five minute dance performed
- 13:36Speaker 7: to the song how Long by Charlie coof. It contains
- 13:40Speaker 7: about four hundred and eighty counts of choreography with ninety
- 13:43Speaker 7: six repeated counts, But what was actually allegedly misappropriated are
- 13:49Speaker 7: just four counts of the choreographer's work, which the district
- 13:53Speaker 7: court described as a two second combination of eight bodily
- 13:57Speaker 7: movements set to four beats of music. Now, Fortnite is
- 14:03Speaker 7: a video game published by Epic Games, and what they
- 14:08Speaker 7: did is in that game you have an avatar. And
- 14:12Speaker 7: one of the ways that they make money is in
- 14:15Speaker 7: a marketplace they sell what are called emotes, which are
- 14:18Speaker 7: dance movements or other kinds of movements that you can
- 14:22Speaker 7: buy and have your avatar perform them like a victory
- 14:26Speaker 7: dance er, just for fun. And so here the emote
- 14:31Speaker 7: is called It's complicated, and it's this small portion of
- 14:37Speaker 7: Kyle Hanagami's copyrighted five minute work.
- 14:40Speaker 4: He sued and tell us what happened at the district
- 14:44Speaker 4: court level.
- 14:45Speaker 7: Well, at the district court level, he didn't make it
- 14:48Speaker 7: very far. He filed his complaint, and in response, Epic
- 14:55Speaker 7: Games filed what is called a motion to dismiss for
- 14:58Speaker 7: failure to state acclaim and claiming that the choreographer had
- 15:03Speaker 7: not sufficiently alleged that there was substantial similarity between what
- 15:08Speaker 7: was copied, and the district court agreed and found that
- 15:14Speaker 7: when the dance that was copied is divided up into
- 15:18Speaker 7: a series of poses, those poses are not copyright protectable. Moreover,
- 15:23Speaker 7: the part that was actually copied, it was just a short,
- 15:26Speaker 7: relatively simple part of the overall work, and that short
- 15:31Speaker 7: sequence is a short dance which is not protectable by copyright.
- 15:36Speaker 7: So the court dismissed mister Hanagami's case. That's the choreographer,
- 15:41Speaker 7: and mister Hanagami appealed up to the Ninth Circuit.
- 15:47Speaker 4: You know, I always wonder in these cases when it's
- 15:49Speaker 4: artwork to how the judges have the expertise to figure
- 15:53Speaker 4: this out, And it seems like in dance it's it
- 15:55Speaker 4: would be even harder for a judge.
- 15:58Speaker 7: Yeah, And the truth is typically they don't have the
- 16:02Speaker 7: expertise because most judges aren't experts in dance, or they
- 16:07Speaker 7: aren't necessarily experts in any particular area of copyright. And
- 16:14Speaker 7: that's why copyright the law generally says the copyright cases
- 16:20Speaker 7: shouldn't be shouldn't be dismissed in emotion to dismiss that.
- 16:24Speaker 7: The lad just doesn't favor dismissal at the pleating stage.
- 16:28Speaker 4: Is it easier if you have a traditional form of dance,
- 16:33Speaker 4: for example, ballet or modern dance.
- 16:35Speaker 1: Do you think that makes it easier to get a copyright?
- 16:39Speaker 7: I would say probably not. I would say what is
- 16:43Speaker 7: going to make it easier is the complicatedness and distinctiveness
- 16:50Speaker 7: of the dance, the positions and all the other elements
- 16:55Speaker 7: that go into the dance.
- 16:57Speaker 4: So he took this up to the Ninth Star. First
- 17:00Speaker 4: of all, did the Ninth Circuits rule income as a
- 17:02Speaker 4: surprise a little bit?
- 17:04Speaker 7: I think it did, And there's a couple of reasons
- 17:07Speaker 7: for that. One reason is that this area of the law,
- 17:12Speaker 7: not just in the Ninth Circuit, but in all the US,
- 17:15Speaker 7: is not well defined. There have not been very many
- 17:19Speaker 7: binding cases relating to copyright and choreography, so what was
- 17:25Speaker 7: going to happen was a little bit up in the air.
- 17:27Speaker 7: And another reason why it probably came as a surprise
- 17:31Speaker 7: was because previous cases involving dances and Fortnite epic prevailed
- 17:39Speaker 7: every time. However, in those cases copyright wasn't specifically at issue.
- 17:45Speaker 1: So tell us what the Ninth Circuit decided.
- 17:48Speaker 7: So the Ninth Circuit decided that the Court had essentially
- 17:52Speaker 7: applied the long standard for determining substantial similarity. A copyrighted
- 17:59Speaker 7: were like choreography, when parsed into individual movements, each individual
- 18:05Speaker 7: movement might not be protectable, which is essentially what the
- 18:09Speaker 7: judge with the District Court found and stopped there. But
- 18:13Speaker 7: the combination of them, the selection and the arrangement, the
- 18:15Speaker 7: other elements, the pathways between each movement. When all of
- 18:19Speaker 7: that is combined, the Ninth Circuit found that it could
- 18:23Speaker 7: be a copyrightable work. And the Ninth Circuit also said
- 18:27Speaker 7: it was an air for the court to find that
- 18:30Speaker 7: this particular sequence was too simple and short to be
- 18:33Speaker 7: copyright protectable, because, as the court pointed out, even a
- 18:38Speaker 7: very simple, sorry very short sequence can still be relatively complex.
- 18:44Speaker 7: The court actually compared it to dividing a choreographic work
- 18:49Speaker 7: up into just its individual poses would be like dividing
- 18:54Speaker 7: a musical work just into its individual notes.
- 18:58Speaker 1: So this is the.
- 18:58Speaker 4: First time that a federal appellate court has ruled on
- 19:02Speaker 4: a copyright for choreography.
- 19:04Speaker 7: It's the first time that they've ruled on choreography in
- 19:08Speaker 7: a really substantive way, and especially in the context of
- 19:13Speaker 7: video games, which are using a part of an overall
- 19:17Speaker 7: copyrighted work.
- 19:18Speaker 4: This opinion, then it's good for choreographers. It broadens what
- 19:23Speaker 4: courts and I suppose the Copyright Office can consider.
- 19:28Speaker 7: One of the big things that the Ninth Circuit did
- 19:30Speaker 7: here was it actually gave a definition to choreography. Previously,
- 19:35Speaker 7: the I think I might have said earlier, the statue
- 19:38Speaker 7: doesn't expressly define choreography. However, the compendium of the of
- 19:45Speaker 7: the United States Copyright Office their practices, it does define choreography,
- 19:52Speaker 7: and the Ninth Circuit adopted that definition, which is I
- 19:56Speaker 7: think will make it a lot easier for choreographers people
- 20:00Speaker 7: trying to avoid lawsuits to know the balance of what
- 20:04Speaker 7: they can and can't do.
- 20:05Speaker 1: So you think the Ninth Circuit gave enough guidance.
- 20:08Speaker 7: That remains to be seen. The definition that they adopted
- 20:12Speaker 7: still has It's sort of like every legal definition, it's
- 20:16Speaker 7: open to interpretation. It's the composition and arrangement of a
- 20:20Speaker 7: related series of dance movements and patterns organized into a
- 20:23Speaker 7: coherent whole. And I think you can see that within
- 20:26Speaker 7: that definition there's lots of room for variation. There's lots
- 20:31Speaker 7: of room for questions about how exactly how long this
- 20:34Speaker 7: does it need to be? Exactly, how complex does it
- 20:36Speaker 7: need to be? What is a pattern all these questions?
- 20:40Speaker 7: I think will this case sort of opens the door
- 20:43Speaker 7: for those issues to be further worked out.
- 20:46Speaker 1: So what happens now in the.
- 20:48Speaker 7: Case, so it will return to the district court and
- 20:52Speaker 7: they will proceed into discovery. Right now, it's at the
- 20:56Speaker 7: pleating stage, and I'm sure Hanagami has survived. But surviving
- 21:02Speaker 7: the motion to dismiss is relatively easy compared to actually
- 21:08Speaker 7: marshaling all the evidence, the expert testimony, whatever, he will
- 21:12Speaker 7: need to prove his actual claims, either through later summary
- 21:18Speaker 7: judgment or at trial.
- 21:20Speaker 1: These cases are often settled, but might Fortnite be reluctant
- 21:25Speaker 1: to settle because they don't want to establish a precedent
- 21:27Speaker 1: that every time they use a piece of dance that
- 21:30Speaker 1: they have to pay someone.
- 21:32Speaker 7: That is certainly part of the reason. And then another
- 21:36Speaker 7: reason up to this point might be that they've had
- 21:40Speaker 7: a string of other cases involving dances in Fortnite, and
- 21:45Speaker 7: in all of those they appear to have prevailed. Either
- 21:48Speaker 7: it was the planet's case was dismissed by the court
- 21:51Speaker 7: or the plaintiff voluntarily dismissed for reasons unknown. So clearly
- 21:58Speaker 7: EPIC doesn't necessarily want to to settle if they don't
- 22:01Speaker 7: have to and if it's not advantageous to them. I
- 22:04Speaker 7: would just conclude by saying that anyone who is interested
- 22:08Speaker 7: in copyright and choreography should really keep an eye on
- 22:11Speaker 7: the Honagomi case, since cases in this area have been
- 22:14Speaker 7: relatively rare. However, after the Ninth Circuit revived this case,
- 22:20Speaker 7: we might end up seeing more choreographers using the law
- 22:23Speaker 7: to protect their works and enforce the rights.
- 22:25Speaker 4: We will certainly follow this case. Thanks so much, Ryan.
- 22:28Speaker 4: That's Ryan Meyer of Dorsey and Whitney. Should the government
- 22:32Speaker 4: face lawsuits when it failed to correct false credit reports?
- 22:36Speaker 4: That was the basic issue before the Supreme Court in
- 22:39Speaker 4: a case where incorrect reporting left a Pennsylvania man with
- 22:43Speaker 4: damaged credit. Joining me is Harold Krant, a professor at
- 22:46Speaker 4: the Chicago Kent College of Law. I know you were
- 22:49Speaker 4: in the courtroom today for the oral arguments. Do you
- 22:53Speaker 4: have a prediction right off the top?
- 22:55Speaker 5: No.
- 22:55Speaker 8: I think the argument that their Credit Reporting Act revealed
- 22:59Speaker 8: justices on both sides. My prediction is that the government
- 23:02Speaker 8: will lose. It has a very tough case to show
- 23:06Speaker 8: that it retained sovereign unity under the Reporting Act. But
- 23:10Speaker 8: the justices asked very probing questions to both sides.
- 23:14Speaker 4: Give us some context to you, or how explain what
- 23:16Speaker 4: the case is all about.
- 23:18Speaker 8: So Congress created a Fair Credit Reporting Act to ensure
- 23:21Speaker 8: not only that credit reporting agencies such as TransUnion made
- 23:25Speaker 8: sure to change records when people thought that they were
- 23:28Speaker 8: disadvantaged by incorrect information and reports therefore suffered in terms
- 23:33Speaker 8: of their credit rating, and extended the Act in nineteen
- 23:36Speaker 8: ninety six to require duties of private individuals who had
- 23:41Speaker 8: information about detters and failed to correct the reports to
- 23:46Speaker 8: the credit reporting agencies such as TransUnion. And the word
- 23:50Speaker 8: that they defined in the statute was persons, and they
- 23:54Speaker 8: later defined persons to include not just private individuals and corporations,
- 23:58Speaker 8: but also government. And so the question in this case
- 24:02Speaker 8: is when, by extending this duty to not just the
- 24:05Speaker 8: federal credit reporting agencies but also to private entities and
- 24:10Speaker 8: public entities, whether that is sufficient to waive the sovereign
- 24:13Speaker 8: immunity of the federal government and therefore open it up
- 24:17Speaker 8: to potential damages actions for failure to correct a record.
- 24:21Speaker 8: In this particular case, an individual had taken out a
- 24:24Speaker 8: loan for a rural housing development for housing so that
- 24:30Speaker 8: he could afford, and a subunit of the Department of
- 24:34Speaker 8: Agriculture said that he defaulted on his loan. He contested that,
- 24:38Speaker 8: and he alleged that the Department of Agriculture did not
- 24:42Speaker 8: correct the record, and therefore he sued the department as
- 24:46Speaker 8: well as private entities to recover the damages because what
- 24:50Speaker 8: he said was a false record off his credit status.
- 24:53Speaker 8: And so this is a typical sovereign immunity case about
- 24:56Speaker 8: whether Congress has been clear enough to subject the federal
- 25:01Speaker 8: agencies to suit over their failure to comply with the
- 25:04Speaker 8: Fair Credit Supporting Acts provisions.
- 25:07Speaker 4: Was it mostly reading of the statute and interpretation of that.
- 25:12Speaker 8: Yeah, so everybody agrees that better reading of the statute
- 25:16Speaker 8: is for the private parties. The statute again says that
- 25:23Speaker 8: every person shall be liable and then defines liable in
- 25:26Speaker 8: a different section to include instrumentalities of the federal government.
- 25:30Speaker 8: But there are some problems with that reading, even though
- 25:32Speaker 8: that was the acknowledged better reading of the statute. One
- 25:35Speaker 8: problem was that there was no recognition in the legislative
- 25:39Speaker 8: history the extent that that matters that Congress's decision nineteen
- 25:43Speaker 8: ninety six would open up federal entities to damage's actions.
- 25:48Speaker 8: And another problem was the fact that in other parts
- 25:51Speaker 8: of the statute, any person the word under the statute
- 25:56Speaker 8: can be subject to criminal penalties and punitive damages. And
- 26:00Speaker 8: all the parties agreed that simply couldn't conceive of the
- 26:04Speaker 8: fact that Congress would have wanted to apply puni damages
- 26:08Speaker 8: or criminal penalties to governmental entities as opposed to private parties.
- 26:13Speaker 8: So the issue really boils docut how clear must Congress
- 26:17Speaker 8: be in waving the immunity from a damage's action for
- 26:22Speaker 8: the federal government. And so it's a relatively close case.
- 26:25Speaker 8: But most of the justices, and my view could be wrong.
- 26:28Speaker 8: They were leading to the fact that if you simply
- 26:32Speaker 8: have a statute requiring persons to pay damages, and you
- 26:36Speaker 8: then defined i'll be in a different section persons to
- 26:40Speaker 8: include instrumentality in the federal government. That should be enough.
- 26:44Speaker 4: Justice Britt Kavanaugh said, so, you said at the beginning
- 26:47Speaker 4: that Congress knew what it was doing when it amended
- 26:50Speaker 4: the Act, but I don't think it realized that it
- 26:52Speaker 4: was imposing this liability.
- 26:54Speaker 8: You know, it does mean that it was an inartfully
- 26:57Speaker 8: drafted statute to some extent, but I think that except
- 27:01Speaker 8: for Justice Kavanaugh and maybe one other justice or two,
- 27:05Speaker 8: it was close enough. I mean, certainly, I think if
- 27:09Speaker 8: Congress had to do it over again, it could have
- 27:11Speaker 8: clarify with the more specificity when the government could be
- 27:15Speaker 8: sued for damages, when who could be prosecuted for a
- 27:18Speaker 8: criminal infraction of the Act, And it used the same
- 27:21Speaker 8: term persons in both and hence the confusion. And I
- 27:25Speaker 8: think Justice Kavanaugh had drawn the line and said that
- 27:28Speaker 8: the waves sovereign immunity, Congress must say in creating cause
- 27:32Speaker 8: of action that they mean it to cover not only persons,
- 27:36Speaker 8: but persons comma, including federal instrumentalities. And that is perhaps
- 27:43Speaker 8: a conceivable drafting exercise, But most of the justices didn't
- 27:46Speaker 8: think Congress had to be that specific, and it was
- 27:49Speaker 8: unrealistic to make Congress be that specific in drafting these
- 27:54Speaker 8: kinds of provisions.
- 27:55Speaker 4: Justice Elena Kagan suggested the case could be resolved by
- 27:59Speaker 4: applying statutory interpretation.
- 28:01Speaker 1: One oh one. Was it that simple? Doesn't seem that simple?
- 28:05Speaker 8: Well, you know, it's that fiple on's face, right. If
- 28:07Speaker 8: you just looked at the fact that Congress specified that
- 28:11Speaker 8: all persons would be subject to these civil penalties, and
- 28:13Speaker 8: the civil penalties included federal instrumentalities. That's statory interpretation one
- 28:19Speaker 8: oh one. But when you look and see that the
- 28:21Speaker 8: same construction then allowed for punitive damage and for criminal penalties,
- 28:26Speaker 8: then the question seems to be much more complicated. And
- 28:30Speaker 8: so even though just as Kagan would like this to
- 28:33Speaker 8: be tetritory construction one oh one and may ultimately right
- 28:37Speaker 8: the case that way, certainly Congress wasn't abundantly clear because
- 28:42Speaker 8: of these other provisions that are in the same act itself,
- 28:45Speaker 8: and all parties agreed that you could not subject to
- 28:49Speaker 8: the government to criminal penalties or punitive damages for failure
- 28:53Speaker 8: to follow the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
- 28:55Speaker 1: What are the implications of this decision? I mean, are
- 28:58Speaker 1: there a lot of cases like that?
- 29:01Speaker 8: So, just as Sotomayor noted, at least three statutes that
- 29:05Speaker 8: had very similar constructions, including the Clean Air Act and
- 29:09Speaker 8: some Water Act, and some other statutes as well. So
- 29:12Speaker 8: there are other types of congressional enactments which define the
- 29:19Speaker 8: scope of people to be liable as persons and then
- 29:22Speaker 8: in another section of the statute construe or define persons
- 29:27Speaker 8: to include the federal instrumentalities, and so under these statutes
- 29:31Speaker 8: as well, the question could arise as to whether civil
- 29:35Speaker 8: penalties can be obtainable from federal agencies which you violate
- 29:40Speaker 8: the Safe Drinking Water Act or Clean Water Act and
- 29:44Speaker 8: a couple of others. So there are consequences here, But
- 29:47Speaker 8: more broadly, the issue is to what extent will the
- 29:52Speaker 8: Court demand a clear statement before agreeing that Congresses waived
- 29:57Speaker 8: the sovereign immunity of the United States and therefore exposed
- 30:00Speaker 8: a federal instum mentality to suit. Justice Gorsus asked a
- 30:05Speaker 8: very probing question. I thought that wasn't answered Title litigant,
- 30:09Speaker 8: and he said, is it possible that we would create
- 30:14Speaker 8: a greater specificity of Congress when it waves a state's
- 30:19Speaker 8: sovereign immunity or an Indian tribe sovereign immunity, or a
- 30:23Speaker 8: form instrumentalities community as opposed to that of the federal
- 30:27Speaker 8: government itself? Because Congress keeps the fisk, and so Congress
- 30:32Speaker 8: is always thinking about what is the impact of its
- 30:36Speaker 8: statutory provisions on the fisk where it may not be
- 30:39Speaker 8: as respectful of the immunity of other entities such as
- 30:44Speaker 8: states again or Indian tribes and I thought that was
- 30:47Speaker 8: an interesting way to distinguish other cases and perhaps to
- 30:51Speaker 8: put a new sort of wrinkle on the extent that
- 30:56Speaker 8: sovereign immunity should continue, but neither side really with justice
- 31:01Speaker 8: courses in this question, but that may re emerge in
- 31:05Speaker 8: an opinion or two of the Court.
- 31:07Speaker 4: Thanks so much, Hal. That's Harold Krant, professor at the
- 31:09Speaker 4: Chicago Kent College of Law. And that's it for this
- 31:13Speaker 4: edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always
- 31:15Speaker 4: get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 31:19Speaker 4: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at
- 31:22Speaker 4: www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, and
- 31:27Speaker 4: remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight
- 31:30Speaker 4: at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso, and
- 31:34Speaker 4: you're listening to Bloomberg