Latest / Where Parents Talk: Evidence-based Expert Advice on Raising Kids Today / A Parent's Guide to AI, Fake News & Digital Independence
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to the Where Parents Talk podcast.
- 0:09We help grow better parents through science, evidence and the lived experience of other parents.
- 0:14Learn how to better navigate the mental and physical health of your tween teen or young adult through proven expert advice.
- 0:22Here's your host, Lianne Castelino.
- 0:28Welcome to Where Parents Talk.
- 0:29My name is Lianne Castelino.
- 0:31Our guest today is Matthew Johnson, Director of education at MediaSmarts, a national charitable organization focused on digital media literacy.
- 0:41MediaSmarts is celebrating its 30th anniversary in 2026.
- 0:46Matthew is also a former classroom teacher and a father of two.
- 0:51He joins us today from Ottawa.
- 0:55Welcome.
- 0:55Hi.
- 0:56Thanks.
- 0:56Thanks, Leanne.
- 0:57Thanks for being here.
- 0:5930 years in this space.
- 1:01If we talk about media smarts and you know, I was thinking about it 1996, right?
- 1:06Like we still had dial up Internet modem stuff.
- 1:10Like, it just seems like so long ago.
- 1:13We're at the point now where we're telling kids not only can they not believe what they read, but they shouldn't trust what they see or hear either when we're talking about the online world.
- 1:25So what has changed then for parents?
- 1:28I think for parents, what really has changed is when it comes to online information, that we need to teach our kids not to decide whether or not to believe or trust something just by looking at it or by
- 1:49focusing closely on it.
- 1:52That when we want to know if something is basically true or basically reliable, what we need is to get external evidence.
- 1:59We need to see where it came from.
- 2:02We need to see whether people who are professional fact checkers or professional journalists have verified it.
- 2:09And for all of us, media literacy has really become, in a lot of cases, a two step process.
- 2:17Where your traditional media literacy is about looking closely what we call close reading media, where you're looking for things like framing, you're looking for word choice, you're looking for how things like camera angle and composition affect us.
- 2:33And that's as important as ever.
- 2:36But now we don't know whether or not something that comes to us is worth that kind of close attention right away.
- 2:45Sometimes it is.
- 2:46If we're reading a newspaper, if we're looking at a news source that we already know is reliable, we can skip straight to that process.
- 2:53Or if it's something where veracity isn't an issue, if it's an ad or a meme or something like that, where it doesn't matter whether it's true or not.
- 3:02Exactly.
- 3:03But anytime something is purporting to be making a claim that is verifiable before we get to that close reading, we need to do a first step of what we call companion reading, it's sometimes called lateral reading.
- 3:20And that is looking at that external evidence because, of course, there's so much content that we encounter today.
- 3:28That's probably the biggest thing that's changed in the 30 years that MediaSmarts has been around, or even the, you know, 18, 19 years that I've been with the organization is we've gone from a world where media was relatively
- 3:43scarce and where a small number of people and organizations had the resources to create and distribute it.
- 3:52And we've gone to a world where creating and distributing media has become the cheapest, easiest thing in the world.
- 3:59And AI has only amplified that because until a couple of years ago, it was easy enough to distribute information thanks to social media, but creating convincing fake information, creating convincing fakes was still difficult.
- 4:16Now it takes very little technology, it takes very little time.
- 4:22And so we, between those two things, between the sheer amount of information that we deal with every day and the difficulty of verifying things just by looking closely at them, we need that first step where we sift out
- 4:42all of those things that we don't have a reason to pay attention to.
- 4:45We just say, I'm not going to give them my attention.
- 4:50Either I can identify that it's not reliable or, or I don't have enough information telling me that it's reliable to waste my time on it.
- 5:01So if we drill down everything you just expressed there, Matthew, it boils down to one thing.
- 5:06It's just become more complex, right?
- 5:08And if you're a parent, as an adult, many of us have trouble distilling, deciphering, figuring out whether this is fake news or not.
- 5:19How do we go about depending on the age of the child, trying to make it easier for them to make that determination?
- 5:29You know, one of the best ways is always to look for teachable moments to start with what they're interested in.
- 5:38It's one of the reasons why parental co viewing is so valuable.
- 5:44And you know, co viewing doesn't necessarily always mean literally viewing or playing or listening to media at the same time as our kids.
- 5:53Now that's really valuable, it's really important.
- 5:57But co viewing can also mean just having an ongoing conversation with our kids about their media lives.
- 6:07One of the benefits, there are a lot of them, but one of the benefits of co viewing is that it gives us little hooks, it gives us little teachable moments.
- 6:14It lets us talk about these issues in a way that is going to first be appropriate to their age.
- 6:22Because we know how well they understand things from what they tell us about what they're seeing.
- 6:27And also that's going to be in a context that is relevant for them.
- 6:33So with my kids, you know, I started talking to them about media very early on about getting.
- 6:41Communicating ideas like that most media exists for a commercial reason.
- 6:45So we'd be in a store and they would say, why is spongebob on the cereal box?
- 6:49And I would say, because that they know that kids like spongebob, so that makes kids ask for that cereal.
- 6:55And when they get older, for instance, my kids, like a lot of kids, went through a phase where they were very, very deeply into Minecraft.
- 7:04And of course, like a lot of kids, they weren't just playing Minecraft.
- 7:07They were, you know, reading about Minecraft.
- 7:09They were watching videos about Minecraft and seeing all kinds of fan theories.
- 7:14You may not know it, a lot of adults don't realize it, but there's a tremendous amount of fan lore about Minecraft, all kinds.
- 7:24There are creepypasta videos about Minecraft, there are conspiracy videos about Minecraft.
- 7:29And so just using those to get in the habit of asking, okay, where did you hear that?
- 7:36So you've heard this claim about Minecraft.
- 7:40Where did you hear that?
- 7:41And why do you think that is reliable?
- 7:45Why do you think that's a source that we should pay attention to?
- 7:48And so how we do that is different at different ages, that with really young kids, it is just introducing them to things like the idea of bounded expertise.
- 7:56So with our lesson for really young kids, for instance, on this topic, we give the example of, well, what does a vet know about animals?
- 8:06And how is that different from what a farmer knows about animals?
- 8:09And how is that different from what a zookeeper knows about animals?
- 8:13And as they get older, we can build on that.
- 8:16Just like all of the other skills we want them to learn, we come back to it, we build on it.
- 8:20We approach it in a way that takes advantage of their growing cognitive development, their emotional development, and as they get older, their moral and social development, so that as they get into their teens, we start to frame it
- 8:37not just as something they do for their own benefit, but as something they do to contribute to the community, which we've seen as a really powerful motivator for teens.
- 8:48So when we talk about that older age group, tweens teens, and in some cases even young adults, we're talking about emerging independence, we're talking about parents who maybe have less of a line of sight into what their kids
- 9:03are doing online.
- 9:05What can you say to parents in terms of what they should know about what their kids are doing online with respect to determining the quality of the information they're exposed to,.
- 9:17Again, it comes down to talking to your kids on a regular basis.
- 9:21And of course, what they're watching or what they're reading or listening to, that's not always going to come out in conversations that are about media specifically.
- 9:32It may come out in conversations about politics, it may come out in conversations about relationships, it may come out in conversations about health.
- 9:41So if you know, you have, if you've booked your flu and Covid shots and you hear when you tell your teenager, okay, I booked us for shots on Sunday, or whatever, if there skeptical about that, or if they
- 9:56have questions or if they're talking about relationships and you hear them saying things about relationships between men and women that, you know, you, you feel are.
- 10:08They're getting bad information, they're getting inaccurate information, they're getting dangerous information.
- 10:13In some cases, it really is important that, you know, we listen, that we give them the chance to speak, we be ready to give additional information, to give them sources, sometimes just to straight up correct them, sometimes that's
- 10:27necessary.
- 10:28And it's always going to be your judgment about essentially how urgent that is, that sometimes it is going to be, well, I hear something I'd like you to take a look at that maybe puts it in a different
- 10:40context.
- 10:41And sometimes you're just going to say, you know, that's wrong and that's dangerous.
- 10:44And here's why.
- 10:46As technology continues to evolve at lightning speed.
- 10:50We talked about AI briefly at the beginning.
- 10:52What does it mean today to be a good digital citizen?
- 10:58I think it's much the same as it has been for the last 15 to 20 years.
- 11:04And that means being a responsible sharer of information.
- 11:09One of the things that did change with the introduction of social media in particular is that now we are all broadcasters, we're all disseminators of information as well as consumers.
- 11:21So as I said earlier, it's not enough just to say that, well, I got the right answer, I wasn't fooled.
- 11:26We need to make sure that we are verifying information before we share it, that we're not sharing things that we aren't sure are true or that we don't have, you know, strong reason to believe are true.
- 11:39And we have a responsibility when we see misinformation to respond to it.
- 11:44And as with everything else, you know, whether we're talking about cyberbullying, whether we're talking about online hate, or any of the other topics where we want kids to be engaged, ethical, digital citizens, it's really important that we give
- 12:02them more than one tool.
- 12:04So when we look at cyberbullying, for instance, we say, here are a whole bunch of different things you can do when you witness cyberbullying.
- 12:12Some will work in some situations, some you'll feel comfortable with in other situations, you don't have to always do the same thing.
- 12:19So it's exactly the same thing when it comes to responding to misinformation.
- 12:24That, of course, sometimes you are going to just correct someone.
- 12:29Sometimes you're going to say, nope, that's not true.
- 12:32Here's the truth.
- 12:34Sometimes you're going to take a little step further and you're going to debunk them.
- 12:37You're going to say, you know, here is how I found out.
- 12:40I looked up, I went to the Health Canada website about this, I looked it up, and you can see that it's not true.
- 12:48But sometimes you're just going to ask a question.
- 12:51Sometimes you're going to say, are you sure that's true?
- 12:54Or where did you hear that?
- 12:55Or what's your source for that?
- 12:57And there's going to be a lot of times when any of us, not just kids, are more comfortable doing that than correcting or debunking.
- 13:06And the evidence shows that it's actually almost as effective.
- 13:10Because what it does is it shows that there isn't a group consensus.
- 13:14If there's even one person who is questioning what's been shared, it shows everybody else that, oh, this isn't settled yet.
- 13:24This is still under debate.
- 13:26And so it's really valuable for anyone, but I think, particularly teens, you know, who are so acutely aware of social pressures to know that they have an option that isn't as necessarily extreme or as out there as directly
- 13:43contradicting somebody.
- 13:46Statistics Canada says that four in five Canadians suspect that they see false information online at least once a month.
- 13:55Frankly, I thought it would be higher.
- 13:57But four in five is a lot.
- 13:58And once a month, certainly what does that say about the entire world at our kids are growing up in currently,.
- 14:07This is something that kids in particular are very much aware of.
- 14:13I would say, you know, when we contrast generations, it's not actually true that one generation is necessarily more likely to be fooled than another.
- 14:25But how they're fooled is different.
- 14:28And what we find in general is, you know, older people are more likely to believe things that are false, and younger people are more likely to dismiss things that are true, because in most cases they've been taught from
- 14:46very early on that they can't trust everything that they see online, but they may not necessarily have been taught how to verify what they see online.
- 14:55And so what happens is they feel it's safer to doubt everything, it's safer to dismiss everything.
- 15:03Or, and this is of course, a natural human tendency, they will say, well, I'll dismiss the things that I don't want to believe, and then I'll trust the things that I do want to believe.
- 15:14They'll apply it, their skepticism based on their emotions or their identity or their beliefs rather than on actual evidence.
- 15:24So it's really important for all of us to approach verifying information, not as a matter of fact debunking, but as a matter of discernment between true and false information.
- 15:38It's one of the reasons why all of our resources, when we teach information verification, we always make sure that at least half the examples are things that maybe seem likely to be false but are actually true.
- 15:50So when we teach about AI, for instance, a lot of the examples we use are things that maybe look hard to believe but are actually real images.
- 16:01So much of what you've just described there really is rooted in critical thinking, right?
- 16:05And if you're a parent, maybe you think, well, you know, I don't see that as my job.
- 16:10That is, critical thinking is what they should be taught in school.
- 16:13What do you say to parents about how they can support their kids at home, especially the older ones in their adolescence, about critical thinking as it relates to what's going on online?
- 16:25I think the number one most important thing that adults can do to encourage critical thinking is to be open with kids about times that we have been wrong about things, and particularly times we've changed our minds, to model
- 16:44the idea that, oh, you know, I thought something and it turned out that that was not true.
- 16:49I got new information or I misunderstood it or something like that.
- 16:53And so I changed, I updated my beliefs, or maybe I heard a convincing argument.
- 16:59But that is the most important thing is what we call intellectual humility.
- 17:04That willingness to reconsider our beliefs, that willingness to change our minds in the face of new evidence.
- 17:13That is what underpins all critical thinking.
- 17:17Because we see there's a lot of research, and you don't have to research it.
- 17:21You can just go online to see this.
- 17:22That conspiracy theorists do kind of a mirror image version of critical thinking.
- 17:30They'll go through the motions of critical thinking and they'll often describe themselves as critical thinkers.
- 17:37And what the research has found is that most people who describe themselves as critical thinkers but haven't had any kind of instruction in critical thinking are more likely to believe conspiracy theories.
- 17:52But people who have received instruction in critical thinking are significantly less likely to believe conspiracy theories.
- 18:00So it is really important that we have that, that underpinning of intellectual humility where we question not just what we're seeing, but we question ourselves and we're open minded.
- 18:16It's the old expression, you don't want to be so open minded that your brain falls out.
- 18:20You're still applying tests of evidence, you're applying tests of reason, you're applying tests to ensure that the sources that you're lear looking at are reliable, but you're still willing to reconsider your views.
- 18:35And so just talking with your kids, being open about, yeah, this, I used to think this and now I think that.
- 18:41And it can be the smallest things, you know, it can be, you know, when I was a kid, I didn't like mushrooms.
- 18:48And you know, I found people made mushrooms in ways that I like better and now I love mushrooms.
- 18:53So it could be something as small as that or it could be something, you know, as big as, you know, what you think about nuclear power or whatever.
- 19:01But it's really important that we model for kids that idea that we change our views when the evidence changes.
- 19:12So building on that point, Matthew, why do we fall for misinformation?
- 19:17You know, it seems like quite easily, even when we know that it exists and that it's out there.
- 19:23I think the number reason, the number one reason that we fall for misinformation is because it will often reinforce what we want to believe.
- 19:33And it's, that's the also the same reason why we sometimes doubt things that are true.
- 19:37Why we, why we are cynical instead of skeptical.
- 19:43It's because we don't want something to be true.
- 19:46As why that, that layer of intellectual humility is so important.
- 19:53And it's why, you know, we recommend before you even start that, that companion reading process, it's really important to reflect on three questions.
- 20:04The first is what do I already think or believe about this?
- 20:08So establish, you know, what is my starting point?
- 20:11And then why do I want to believe or disbelieve this?
- 20:17So if I've just seen a post and I'm like, oh, I really want to find out if that's true or not, it's important to reflect.
- 20:25Why.
- 20:26Why am I pushed to respond to this particular post?
- 20:29Of all the things that I've seen today, why is that the one that I'm, that I'm feeling the urge to debunk or to prove.
- 20:38And the third question is, what would make me change my mind?
- 20:43So you're making yourself accountable.
- 20:45You're saying ahead of time, okay, this is the standard that I will apply.
- 20:49So if I have a mushroom dish that is really delicious, I'll change my mind about mushrooms.
- 20:55So that we're at that point, we've set a standard for ourselves.
- 20:59We're keeping ourselves honest.
- 21:01The other thing I think that makes us fall for misinformation is that it often comes from people who are close to us.
- 21:10It comes from people whom we trust on an emotional level.
- 21:15And that's why it's really important to distinguish between sources that we trust because they have expertise and a good track record and a process for verifying information, and people whom we trust for emotional or identity reasons and to
- 21:36really distinguish between those two.
- 21:40So interesting.
- 21:41So very important questions to ask if we remember to ask them.
- 21:45But, you know, practice certainly would help in that case.
- 21:47Definitely.
- 21:48And I would argue based on what you said, we're at a point where we really don't have a choice if we want to be properly informed about what we're seeing online.
- 21:57So you talked about generations, which I think also factors into this conversation, because there are many parents out there when we talk about AI who perhaps aren't on the AI bus yet that has left the station and is
- 22:11flying down the highway.
- 22:14What age should parents start talking to their kids about AI and misinformation?
- 22:20And I'm talking about parents who may be maybe don't have any knowledge about AI or very little, as well as parents who maybe have a lot.
- 22:28I think it's important to start talking to kids quite early about AI as a companion because we do know that a lot of apps that are made for young kids now use AI chat engines.
- 22:46So they're capable of creating a parasocial relationship, an imaginary relationship with kids in ways that older apps that just had pre programmed chats can't.
- 22:58It's also something, an area where parents often are not aware that their kids are interacting with AI.
- 23:06So if you're, if your child is using Gemini or ChatGPT or something like that, you know they're using AI, but if they're using an app where they're, you know, playing with a, with a doll or something like that
- 23:18on the app, or it's a video, it seems like a video game, you may not realize if you don't look closely at the description of the app, that they're actually interacting with AI.
- 23:29When we talk more broadly about AI generated content and the.
- 23:35The need to, you know, be critical and skeptical of it, I would say you don't necessarily have to talk to them specifically about AI because they've probably heard about it.
- 23:48What really matters is reinforcing the idea.
- 23:53Yes, there is extremely believable fake content out there.
- 23:57Yes, you can't believe everything that you see, but also that you cannot verify it just by looking for extra fingers or anything like that.
- 24:07That what always matters most is whether or not it came from a source that you have a good reason to think is reliable.
- 24:17You talked about the three questions to consider asking.
- 24:20How about habits or tips that you can offer before somebody choose to share?
- 24:28What you want to think about anytime you're going to share is, first of all, how sure am I that this is reliable?
- 24:37And also, what might be the impact if someone believed it and it turned out not to be true in some ways?
- 24:46Sharing any false content obviously is bad for the information ecosystem, but some things absolutely are worse than others.
- 24:55And so if it is something related to politics, if it's something related to health, if it's something related to finance, or if it's going to have a direct impact on someone.
- 25:07So in one of our resources we use the example of, is it going to be a snow day tomorrow?
- 25:12Someone shares false information that it's a snow day and so someone else is late for school.
- 25:20Now, that may not be something on the scope of, of, you know, whether or not you get vaccinated or who you vote for, but it's going to have a direct impact on that person's life.
- 25:31So think about not just how important it is on the macro scale, but how important it is on the personal scale.
- 25:40If someone believes what you're sharing and it turns out not to be true.
- 25:45In your role, what do you see as critical pain points that parents are experiencing right now in terms of the online world and all the things that we have to keep in mind that you've just outlined.
- 25:58But there's always more and it continually evolves.
- 26:02Like, what are some of the real pain points that parents are sharing with you?
- 26:07One of the things that we hear a lot from parents is there's a difference between the things that concern them and the things that cause conflict in the home.
- 26:19So, for instance, when we surveyed parents, misinformation was actually their top concern.
- 26:25But what they said caused the most conflict in the home was screen time and media use.
- 26:32So it's important, I think, first of all to, you know, to take advantage of those topics where you and your kids are on the same page, where you know there is a concern that's also kids we found from
- 26:48our research kids number one concern concern.
- 26:50The number one thing they wanted to learn more about was how to find out if things online were true.
- 26:56So we can use that as an advantage where we're on the same side.
- 27:00But it's also really important not to assume that you're not on the same side, because we also hear from kids that they're concerned, for instance, about the amount of time that they're spending online and that it's their parents
- 27:14who assume that they're not.
- 27:17And in the same way we hear from kids that they would like this is teens too, that they would like to do more media activities with their parents, but they feel their parents don't see media time as family
- 27:33time.
- 27:34So looking for opportunities again that can come back to co viewing, looking for opportunities to make media time, family time to do things.
- 27:44For instance, verifying information or getting news together.
- 27:48For kids, especially teens, news is a really fraught subject because they tell us that they feel the need to be informed.
- 27:59They also tell us they find it incredibly stressful, partly because they're worried about the content that they might see.
- 28:06That following news through social media means that they might, at any given time, you know, unexpectedly see footage of natural disasters or footage of war zones.
- 28:18But again, of course, it is the stress of knowing whether or not to trust what they're seeing.
- 28:23So one great activity that kids and parents can do together is to go through their feeds and curate good quality news sources.
- 28:32Because in fact, one of the best ways of improving your ecosystem is to go out and proactively follow good sources of news to find reliable sources to add them to your feed so that they're going to be ones
- 28:48who are not going to be unexpectedly sharing upsetting content, and they're also going to be ones that you know are reliable.
- 28:59Matthew, what would you say to parents who may listen to or watch this interview and feel quite overwhelmed with what they need to be on top of while they're working and taking care of other kids and all the
- 29:09other things that we're all doing as parents about what they absolutely need to focus on and prioritize when we talk about misinformation and the online world?
- 29:20Well, the first thing is that we need to prioritize that ongoing conversation.
- 29:24What makes it feel overwhelming is the idea that we have to do everything all at once.
- 29:29But when we have that ongoing conversation, we break it into little bits and we find opportunities.
- 29:35You don't have to do it all today, you don't have to do it all this week.
- 29:39If we have that ongoing conversation, those opportunities to talk about these issues.
- 29:44If we wait for our kids sometimes to bring them up or give them opportunities to bring them up, it makes things much more manageable.
- 29:54But as always, you know, the number one rule that we recommend every household has is to make sure your kids always know that if they encounter something online or in any other kind of media that is upsetting, that
- 30:08that frightens them, that they don't know how to deal with, that they should come to you and you're going to listen and you're going to help.
- 30:16And that's true whether it's cyberbullying, whether it is sexual exploitation, or whether it is not knowing how to tell whether or not what they're seeing is true.
- 30:28On the flip side, I'm curious as to what gives you hope about.
- 30:32About, you know, the online world we live in, how it continues to evolve, AI, you know, chat, GPT agents, all of those, and how they can be used as tools and be seen in a positive light if we
- 30:46choose to do that.
- 30:48One of the things that really gives me hope is that the current young generation are probably the people who are most skeptical of AI, and that doesn't mean necessarily rejecting it, because they're not rejecting it, but they are
- 31:03rejecting some uses of it, and they're being very skeptical about its use as a source of information.
- 31:13And I think that is something that we can harness because these are tremendously powerful tools.
- 31:17These are tools that we use at MediaSmarts.
- 31:20They're tools that I use personally, but we have to use them critically.
- 31:25We have to use them responsibly.
- 31:27We need have to know how to use them effectively.
- 31:33Even small things like only using an AI tool that gives you links to its sources can have a huge impact.
- 31:42Of course, you then have to be in the habit of checking up on those links.
- 31:45You do have to make sure that they are what they claim to be and that they really are saying what your AI tool says they are, but just that additional step of making sure that you can follow those
- 31:58sources so that you're not just reading an unsourced summary makes a huge impact in how effective AI is as a tool for finding information or as a tool for verifying information.
- 32:13Any final thoughts in terms of how we go about raising digitally savvy kids today?
- 32:19Matthew?
- 32:20The important thing is to always just encourage them to ask questions, that is, whether they're asking you questions or whether they're asking questions about what they see.
- 32:32Kids have a natural instinct to ask questions.
- 32:35All we have to do is encourage it and teach them how to ask critical questions about the media that they're encountering.
- 32:46You've given us lots to think about.
- 32:47Matthew Johnson, Director of education at MediaSmarts really appreciate your time and your perspective today.
- 32:53Thank you.
- 32:53Thanks for having me.
- 32:56To learn more about today's podcast, guest and topic, as well as other parenting themes, visit whereparentstalk.com.