Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage the Employee Who Overcommits and Underdelivers
Transcript
- Lucas: There's this one employee on every team — the one who nods enthusiastically when you ask for a volunteer, says 'I can handle it,' then comes back with nothing but excuses when the deadline hits. It's the classic overcommitter, and it's surprisingly hard to manage because the problem isn't laziness or incompetence. Luna: Right, it's almost the opposite. They want to please, they want to be the hero. But then reality sets in and they can't deliver. Lucas: Exactly. I was reading a case from a mid-size SaaS company where a senior developer — let's call him Alex — would take on three high-priority features every sprint. His manager was thrilled at first. But after two months, zero features shipped. Alex had worked nights and weekends, but he'd spread himself so thin that nothing was actually finishable. Luna: And the manager probably felt guilty pushing back, because Alex was trying so hard. That's the trap. Lucas: That's exactly the trap. So today I want to talk about why people overcommit, and then a few concrete moves you can make as a manager to turn that energy into actual output. Luna: Let's start with the 'why.' Because if you just tell someone 'stop overcommitting,' it won't stick. Lucas: There are three big drivers I've seen. First is optimism bias — genuinely underestimating how long something takes. Second is the fear of letting the team down, or worse, looking incompetent for saying no. And third is a lack of prioritization skills — they say yes because they can't easily compare the relative value of one task versus another. Luna: I'd add a fourth: sometimes the culture rewards saying yes. If the loudest volunteer gets the most visibility, people learn to raise their hand even when they shouldn't. Lucas: Great point. So step one as a manager: don't reward the yes for its own sake. When an employee raises their hand, your immediate job is to make sure they understand what they're signing up for. Ask: 'What are you deprioritizing to make this happen?' Force the trade-off discussion. Luna: That's a great question. It shifts the frame from 'Can you do this?' to 'What else drops off your plate?' That's more honest. Lucas: Exactly. The second technique is what I call the 'incremental commitment.' Instead of handing over the entire project, break it into small pieces. Ask for a deliverable in three days — a rough outline, a single chart, a prototype. You learn quickly whether they can execute small before they drown in big. Luna: And it's less intimidating for them too. A three-day deadline is concrete; a three-month deadline feels abstract and easy to say yes to. Lucas: Third tactic: teach them to say no in a way that adds value. Coach them to respond with 'I can take this on, but to keep the project on track, I need to hand off X to someone else. Is that okay?' That turns a no into a proposal. Luna: I've seen that work really well. It makes the employee feel more in control and the manager sees they're thinking strategically about capacity. Lucas: Right. Now, if you've tried all that and the overcommitting continues even after clear conversations, you might have a deeper issue. For some people, saying 'I'll do it' is a way to avoid a harder conversation about their actual strengths. They might be in the wrong role. Luna: So you need to ask: is this person overcommitting because they genuinely love too many things, or because they're afraid to admit they're struggling with their core responsibilities? Lucas: That is the critical distinction. If it's the latter, then saying yes to everything is a survival mechanism. And the solution isn't better prioritization — it's a conversation about whether they're in the right seat. Luna: So let's say I have a direct report who's been overcommitting for months. I've tried the trade-off question and the incremental milestones. And I'm starting to suspect it's a fear of failure thing. How do I have that conversation? Lucas: You frame it around growth, not failure. Something like: 'I've noticed you take on a lot, and I really appreciate your enthusiasm. But I'm worried that spreading yourself thin is preventing you from doing the deep work that would really advance your career. Let's look at your top three priorities this quarter and make sure you have room to truly excel at them.' Luna: That's non-threatening. It's about their career, not their performance. Nice. Lucas: And then you need to follow up consistently. The overcommitter is often an optimist who thinks next week will be different. You have to build in regular check-ins where you review the actual workload versus capacity. Use data — how many hours are they tracking per week? How many tasks are they carrying? Luna: If this rings true, honestly, if this episode helped you think about a current team member, it might be worth a coffee. That's the only ask we make — tiny link in the show notes, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, listener support is what keeps this show ad-free and focused on real management problems. So if it helped, we appreciate it. Luna: Okay, back to it. One more strategy I've used: public accountability. When someone says yes to a task in a meeting, I'll say 'Great, can you send an email to the group summarizing what you'll deliver and by when?' That forces them to think twice before committing. Lucas: That's a gentle nudge. They hear themselves making the commitment, and they're less likely to overdo it. Plus, if they do miss, it's visible — which is uncomfortable but it builds ownership. Luna: Right. And for managers who are themselves overcommitters — I think we all have a bit of that — what advice do you have? Lucas: Model the behavior. When you're offered a new project, pause and say 'Let me check my capacity and get back to you tomorrow.' Then actually review your calendar. If you regularly say yes on the spot, your team will too. Luna: That's probably the hardest part. It's easier to coach someone else than to apply it to yourself. Lucas: Absolutely. But if you want your team to stop overcommitting, you have to show them what healthy prioritization looks like. So next time someone asks you for something, try saying 'I want to give this the attention it deserves. Let me scope it out and I'll give you a realistic timeline by Friday.' Luna: I like that. It's respectful and honest. And it sets a standard for the whole team. Lucas: Exactly. So to wrap up: the overcommitter isn't a problem to fix — they're a resource to channel. Use trade-off questions, incremental commitments, and career-focused conversations. And don't forget to model the behavior yourself. Your team will mirror what they see. Luna: Great advice. Thanks Lucas. And thanks everyone for listening to Manager Mondays.