Latest / Wisdom of the Ages Library / 11 - A Confession - Leo Tolstory
Transcript
- 0:00Chapter eleven of a confession by Leo Tolstoy, and remembering how those very beliefs
- 0:04had repelled me, and it seemed meaningless when professed by people whose lives conflicted
- 0:08with them, and how these same beliefs attracted me and seemed reasonable when I
- 0:12saw that people lived in accord with them. I understood why I had then
- 0:15rejected those beliefs and found them meaningless, and yet now accepted them and found
- 0:19them full of meaning. I understood that I had erred, and why I
- 0:22had aired. I had erred not so much because I thought incorrectly, as
- 0:26because I lived badly. I understood that it was not an error in my
- 0:29thought, that it hid the truth from me as much as my life itself
- 0:32and the exceptional conditions of epicurean gratification of desires in which I had passed it.
- 0:37I understood that my question as to what my life is and the answer
- 0:40and Evil, was quite correct. The only mistake was that the answer referred
- 0:44only to my life, while I had referred to it to life in general.
- 0:48I asked myself what my life is and got the reply and evil and
- 0:51an absurdity, And really my life a life of indulgences of desires was senseless
- 0:56and evil, and therefore the reply life is evil and an absurdity referred only
- 1:00to my life, but not to human life in general. I understood the
- 1:03truth, which afterwards I found in the Gospel, that men love darkness rather
- 1:07than light, for their works were evil. For everyone that doth ill hateth
- 1:11the light, and cometh not to the light, lest his work should be
- 1:14reproved. I perceived that to understand the meaning of life, it is necessary
- 1:19first that life should not be meaningless and evil. Then we can apply reason
- 1:22to explain it. I understood why I had so long wandered round so evident
- 1:26a truth, and that if one is to think and speak of the life
- 1:29of mankind, one must think and speak of that life, and not of
- 1:33the life of some of life's parasites. That truth was always as true as
- 1:38that two and two equal four, but I had not yet acknowledged it,
- 1:41because on admitting two and two to before, I had also to admit that
- 1:44I was bad, and to feel myself to be good was for me more
- 1:47important and necessary than for two and two to be four. I came to
- 1:51love good people, hated myself, and confess the truth. Now all became
- 1:55clear to me. What if an executioner passing its whole life and torturing people
- 2:00and cutting off their heads, or a hope was drunkard, or of a
- 2:01mad man settled for life in a dark room which he had followed, and
- 2:06imagines that he would perish if he left. What if he asked himself what
- 2:08is life? Evidently he would be able to provide no other reply to that
- 2:13question than that life is the greatest evil. And the madman's answer would be
- 2:16perfectly correct, but only as it applied to himself. What if I am
- 2:20such a madman? What if all we rich and leisured people are such mad
- 2:23men? And I understood that we really are madmen? I, at any
- 2:28rate, was certainly such. And indeed, a bird is so made that
- 2:31it must fly, collect food, and build a nest. And when I
- 2:35see that a bird does this, I have pleasure in its joy. A
- 2:38goat, a hare, and a wolf are so made that they must feed
- 2:40themselves, and must breed and feed their family. And when they do so,
- 2:44I feel firmly assured that they are happy and that their life is a
- 2:46reasonable one. Then what should a man do? He too, should provide
- 2:51his living as the animals do, but with this difference that he will perish
- 2:54if he does it alone. He must obtain it not for himself, but
- 2:58for all. And when he does that, I have a firm assurance that
- 3:00he is happy and that his life is reasonable. But what had I done
- 3:05during those whole thirty years in my responsible life? Far from producing sustenance for
- 3:08all, I did not even produce it for myself, I lived as a
- 3:13parasite. On asking myself what is the use of my life? I got
- 3:15the reply, no use. If the meaning of human life lies in supporting
- 3:21it, how could I, who for thirty years have been engaged not on
- 3:23supporting life, but on destroying it in myself and in others? How could
- 3:28I obtain any other answer than that my life was senseless and and evil.
- 3:30It was both senseless and and evil. The life of the world endures by
- 3:35someone's will, by the life of the whole world, and by our lives.
- 3:38Someone fulfills his purpose. To hope, to understand the meaning of that
- 3:42will, one must first perform it by doing what is wanted of us.
- 3:45But if I will not do what is wanted of me, I shall never
- 3:47understand what is wanted of me, and still less what is wanted of all
- 3:51of us and of the whole world. If a naked, hungry beggar has
- 3:54been taken to the crossroads, brought into a building belonging to a beautiful establishment,
- 4:00supplied with drink, and obliged to move a handle up and down,
- 4:02evidently before discussing why he was taken, why he should move the handle,
- 4:06and whether the whole establishment is reasonably arranged, the beggar should first of all
- 4:11move the handle. If he moves the handle, he will understand that it
- 4:15works a pump, and that the pump draws water, and that the water
- 4:17irrigates the garden beds. Then he will be taken from the pumping station to
- 4:20another place, where he will gather fruits, and will enter into the joy
- 4:24of his master, and, passing from lower to higher work, will understand
- 4:28more and more of the arrangements of the establishment, and taking part in it,
- 4:31will never think to ask why he is there, and certainly will not
- 4:34reproach the master. So those who do his will, the simple, unlearned,
- 4:39working folk, whom we regard as cattle, do not reproach the master.
- 4:43But we the wise eat the master's food, but do not do what
- 4:46the Master wishes, and instead of doing it, sit in a circle and
- 4:49discuss why should that handle be moved? Isn't it stupid? So we have
- 4:54decided. We have decided that the Master is stupid or does not exist,
- 4:58and that we are wise. Only we feel that we are quite useless,
- 5:00and that we must somehow do away with ourselves. End of chapter eleven.