Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The New Technology Frontier: Quantum, AI, & National Security
Transcript
- 0:04Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07The New Technology Frontier, Quantum, AI, and
- 0:11National Security. I'm Aulapoli Castro, Director
- 0:14of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:16Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today, I'm
- 0:18delighted to introduce our speakers, Sanjeev
- 0:21Bhaskar and Corey Bieber. Sanjeev is a partner
- 0:24at KNL Gates in the Public Policy and Law Practice
- 0:28Group, advising clients on artificial intelligence,
- 0:31digital assets and payment processing, cybersecurity,
- 0:35government investigations and quantum computing.
- 0:38He previously served as acting general counsel
- 0:40for the White House's Office of National Cyber
- 0:43Director and as a federal prosecutor. An accomplished
- 0:46litigator and emerging technology expert, he
- 0:48has trained government and law enforcement officials
- 0:51in over 40 countries on emerging technology and
- 0:55AML CFT compliance matters. Corey is also a partner
- 0:59at KNL Gates, concentrating his practice in data
- 1:02protection and emerging technologies. He advises
- 1:06clients on compliance and security matters spanning
- 1:09artificial intelligence, virtual reality, biometric
- 1:12systems, blockchain, and conventional software
- 1:15platforms. Drawing on more than 20 years of experience
- 1:18in sophomore development and IT, including a
- 1:21decade as a development and solutions architect
- 1:24in healthcare, he councils universities, game
- 1:26developers, and healthcare systems on data privacy,
- 1:30technology licensing, and software copyright
- 1:33issues. Corey is a certified ethical hacker and
- 1:39a CISSP and CIPP US certified. We're so excited
- 1:44to hear what they have to share with us today.
- 1:45So I'm now gonna turn it over to Sanjeev and
- 1:47Corey. Okay, and let us get our slides in. All
- 1:58right. Thank you so much, Oliver, for hosting
- 2:00us and for the Beverly Hills Bar for making time
- 2:03for us today. We're excited to be here and really
- 2:06dive into what we are calling the new technology
- 2:08frontier, giving us a crash course, a 101, if
- 2:11you will, on quantum, quantum computing, what
- 2:14that is. artificial intelligence, and national
- 2:16security. It's a very fluid time for all of these
- 2:20technologies. And humbly, we are learning still
- 2:23together, but we have developed a practice now
- 2:25where we are engaging with the industry. And
- 2:27part of our commitment to this practice is to
- 2:30engage with you, with the audience, and to share
- 2:32insight, and hopefully come up with ways we can
- 2:34advance forward in the new technology frontier.
- 2:37So I'm excited to be joined with Corey just by
- 2:39background. Again, my name is Sanjeev Bhaskar.
- 2:41I just recently joined K &L Gates. For purposes
- 2:44of this presentation, I'll share with you I most
- 2:46recently worked at the White House for both Presidents
- 2:49Trump and Biden as the Acting General Counsel
- 2:51for Cybersecurity in the Office of the National
- 2:54Cyber Director. Part of the remit and responsibilities
- 2:57there were awareness and adoption of emerging
- 3:00technology, meaning how would we engage with
- 3:03quantum, with artificial intelligence, with cryptocurrency
- 3:06and blockchain, And how do we share that expertise
- 3:09with the industry and government alike as we
- 3:11advance forward in these emerging technology
- 3:14frontier? Recently, I joined the firm. We are
- 3:16working now in our quantum practice group as
- 3:18well as our emerging tech policy group on all
- 3:20the aforementioned areas. And we are excited
- 3:23to be here. And I'm going to defer now to my
- 3:26colleague Corey to introduce himself as well.
- 3:27Thank you. Sure. Hello, my name is Corey Bieber.
- 3:31And as was said in the intro, I'm an intellectual
- 3:33property partner in the K &L Gates Chicago office.
- 3:36My practice focuses on emerging technologies
- 3:39across the IT manufacturing and immersive tech
- 3:42space, including the gaming industry. In fact,
- 3:45I had the firm's gaming and immersive technology
- 3:47industry group. So come check us out. By way
- 3:50of background, as mentioned, I'm a lawyer and
- 3:52a software developer. I worked in a variety of
- 3:54IT roles before I became an attorney. continue
- 3:58to develop software, most recently the firm's
- 4:00litigation analytics platform. On the topic we're
- 4:03discussing today, I'm interested in the gap between
- 4:06what the authorities say on paper and what they
- 4:09actually require someone to build, which I think
- 4:12is going to be a lot of your clients' questions,
- 4:14because all of this eventually lands on an engineering
- 4:17team and they end up having to implement it.
- 4:21That's great. Thanks for us. We're excited to
- 4:23be here. Let's dive right in. So just by way
- 4:26of background and some housekeeping, we are very
- 4:28cognizant that this is a really hot topic and
- 4:31we will get questions. And please feel free to
- 4:33put that in the chat bot and we'll take a look
- 4:35at the end of the presentation. Lord willing,
- 4:37we'll answer your questions as we walk through
- 4:39our slides today. One of the things to remember
- 4:42is these areas are not siloed. Quantum touches
- 4:46AI. AI touches crypto, crypto touches national
- 4:49security, and so on and so on. And what we want
- 4:52to do today at the behest of the Beverly Hills
- 4:55Bar is to sort of give a 101 on how these technologies
- 4:58are functioning, how we are engaging with industry,
- 5:01and how for you, the audience, awareness can
- 5:04create one better visibility of your environment,
- 5:07but ultimately adoption too, and using these
- 5:09technologies in your business practices and in
- 5:12your home lives. So again, by way of introduction,
- 5:14we are going to start with a discussion on quantum
- 5:16quantum computing, what that looks like, what
- 5:18that consists of at a high level, some discussion
- 5:21of quantum advantage, which is in essence using
- 5:24these computers to optimize our business models,
- 5:28whether it's medical research, financial transactions,
- 5:30logistics, so on and so on. We'll spend some
- 5:32time discussing Q Day or Quantum Day, what that
- 5:35actually means. You may have heard of Y2K back
- 5:37in the day. Now we have Q Day circa 2029. A little
- 5:41bit about cryptography and what that means when
- 5:43it comes to business survival and national security
- 5:46mindsets, as well as look at the president's
- 5:49national quantum strategy and what he has in
- 5:52effect articulated in executive orders that came
- 5:55forth this June of 2026. Then we'll spend some
- 5:59time with Corey talking about artificial intelligence,
- 6:00looking at the executive orders. Gold Eagle,
- 6:03you may have heard of the AI clearinghouse that
- 6:06was recently published and released by the White
- 6:08House, what that looks like from a cyber perspective,
- 6:11and how industry can engage with the administration
- 6:14and all the aforementioned areas, and take a
- 6:16look at what we see when it comes to a forecast
- 6:18of artificial intelligence legislation and business
- 6:20models. And we're going to pivot back to national
- 6:23security, focusing on digital assets. The recent
- 6:26Chatri decision of the US Supreme Court regarding
- 6:29digital privacy, location data, and geofence
- 6:32is what that means. If you are an entity that
- 6:34stores privacy data, what should your retention
- 6:37policies be? When should you be engaging with
- 6:40counsel to make sure you are prepared? One, for
- 6:43requests from consumers or customers about if
- 6:46you have their data. And two, what should be
- 6:48your retention and deletion policy given the
- 6:51fact that this law and legal procedures are evolving.
- 6:55And then finally, like always, we'd like to say
- 6:57the dialogue continues. We understand that these
- 7:00topics can be very dense and more so than we
- 7:03can cover here in this brief one -hour period,
- 7:07but we provide you resources, items that you
- 7:09can look at, read, digest. give you opportunities
- 7:12to engage going forth. The goal is for this information
- 7:16to be treated almost as oxygen. You need it to
- 7:18survive. And we want to continue to give it to
- 7:20you in a pace that is acceptable to you. So with
- 7:23that being said, let's go ahead and dive into
- 7:25quantum. So quantum computing at a high level,
- 7:28again, for a 101 type perspective, it's an advanced
- 7:31technology that uses the rules of quantum mechanics
- 7:34to solve complex problems much faster. than classical
- 7:39computers or the normal computers we're using
- 7:41at home today. The computers, the quantum computers,
- 7:44are using qubits instead of classical computer
- 7:47bits that can be engaged or superpositioned at
- 7:51the same time. And by way of example, it's instead
- 7:54of perhaps if you're on your street or on your
- 7:56block looking for a cup of sugar and you knock
- 7:59on one neighbor's door and they don't have it
- 8:01then you have to go to the next neighbor's door
- 8:03you can only be one place at a time correct but
- 8:05imagine being superposition where you can knock
- 8:07on all of the doors on your block at the same
- 8:10point in time ask the same question and efficiently
- 8:14get what you're looking for those are the opportunities
- 8:17that quantum computing brings and when we look
- 8:19at quantum computing in a large scale perspective
- 8:22one We see an entire new industry emerging when
- 8:26it comes to on -premise quantum computers. There
- 8:29are great computers and companies all over the
- 8:31world that are now trying to bring on -site quantum
- 8:34computing to your neighborhood or abroad. Additionally,
- 8:38right now, as we speak today, September 4th,
- 8:412026, you can access a quantum computer through
- 8:44the cloud. You may not know that, but certain
- 8:46companies now afford you the opportunity to rent
- 8:49time or space on their quantum computer. And
- 8:52with that, you can superposition yourself to
- 8:55compete and do compute, excuse me, numerous tasks
- 8:59at the same time. We're going to look at some
- 9:01of that here in a little bit, but just know quantum
- 9:03computing has arrived. This is not a one day
- 9:06maybe we'll have this. It exists. The administration,
- 9:10both the previous, the Biden administration and
- 9:12now the Trump administration, having served under
- 9:14both presidents, have taken the position that
- 9:16we need to engage with this industry, support
- 9:19the development. And that includes many objectives.
- 9:22One, if you are in the quantum industry, grant
- 9:25receipt from Commerce, Department of Energy,
- 9:29NSF, Department of War and DARPA, so on and so
- 9:34on. So there's opportunity for the government
- 9:36to invest into your actual company writ large.
- 9:39But if you're in the private sector, there's
- 9:41also opportunity for you to utilize these computers
- 9:44to optimize your business models. And we'll talk
- 9:46about that here briefly. The other aspect of
- 9:49quantum computing is while we have opportunity,
- 9:52efficiency, and hope with these sophisticated
- 9:55advanced technology machines, it also means a
- 9:59need to update our cryptography and protect our
- 10:02security. Because if the computers get more sophisticated,
- 10:06they may and ultimately will have the ability
- 10:08to defeat some of our current cryptography that
- 10:11exists when it amounts to RSS, RSA, elliptical
- 10:14coding that we have right now in our current
- 10:18infrastructures. We're going to talk about that
- 10:20briefly and give you really a bifurcated view
- 10:24of quantum advantage and innovation, but also
- 10:27updating your cryptography and why that's important
- 10:30because it becomes an existential need and in
- 10:33many ways a national security concern for all
- 10:36of us here. So let's look at this briefly. Now
- 10:39I mentioned as you look at the bottom of the
- 10:41slide, there are many industries now that are
- 10:43trying to engage in quantum computing for the
- 10:46quantum advantage aspect. Manufacturing, pharmaceuticals,
- 10:50great example. God willing, we will come up with
- 10:53a cure for cancer using pharmaceutical research,
- 10:57synthesizing chemicals, medicines, through quantum
- 11:01algorithms and quantum computers. Same with amounts
- 11:05to updating our electrical grid or optimizing
- 11:07financial transactions or working on logistics.
- 11:10These are just a brief tidbit of areas or infrastructure
- 11:16resources or opportunities that can engage with
- 11:19quantum computers to advance business models.
- 11:23We have written aggressively on this and we will
- 11:26share some of our literature with you at the
- 11:27end of the presentation, but just know again
- 11:30these computers exist now. The advanced technology
- 11:34allows us to be super positioned much more optimally
- 11:38than a classical computer would. But now let's
- 11:41look a little bit at the cryptography and the
- 11:44national security concerns. A cryptographically
- 11:48relevant quantum computer is powerful enough
- 11:51at scale to break the current public key encryption
- 11:56that secures our digital infrastructure. And
- 11:59Corey and I are very cognizant that we have a
- 12:00very diverse audience today when it comes to
- 12:02knowledge of these subject matters. So I don't
- 12:04want to get too granular as we discuss public
- 12:06key encryption or quantum key distribution. There
- 12:10will be time for another presentation, God willing,
- 12:12if they invite us back at 2 .01, if you will.
- 12:14But what we need to know is the way the infrastructure
- 12:17currently exists and amounts to data privacy
- 12:19and cryptographic algorithms. When quantum computers
- 12:23exist to scale, and they are powerful enough
- 12:26to scale, they can defeat our cryptography and
- 12:30steal data. And that day, when and if it comes,
- 12:34is being referred to colloquially in the industry
- 12:36and in government as Q Day or Quantum Day. The
- 12:40timing is not certain. We're not sure when it
- 12:42is. The administration said publicly, we believe
- 12:452029, depending who you ask, maybe even sooner,
- 12:48we don't know. But we know the risk is not uncertain.
- 12:52Large scale fault tolerant quantum computing
- 12:55may be years away, but the window to prepare
- 12:57is now. And what does this mean? We discuss often
- 13:01at length. quantum readiness, and we'll spend
- 13:03some time here on the next slide talking about
- 13:05this, but preparing your infrastructure, your
- 13:08company, your communication systems for the day
- 13:11when perhaps a nefarious actor or a nation state
- 13:16that wants to do harm to the United States utilizes
- 13:20this computer to try to steal data, the challenges
- 13:22that provides. Another common phrase that we
- 13:26hear often in the quantum industry right now
- 13:28is HNDL Harvest now decrypt later. What does
- 13:33that mean? Current adversaries, current nation
- 13:37state actors or nefarious parties may already
- 13:40be collecting encrypted data today with hope
- 13:43that once they have a quantum computer, they
- 13:46can later decrypt it. So they are harvesting
- 13:48and taking the data now, understanding that to
- 13:51scale the computers cannot decrypt this information.
- 13:55with hopes of later stealing the data. And we
- 13:59say this not to scare you because we don't want
- 14:00to walk in fear, but more so to educate you on
- 14:03how you can be prepared for this. Now some of
- 14:05the information that can be stolen trade secrets
- 14:07or IP from your company, perhaps a secret recipe,
- 14:10health care records or financial records when
- 14:12it amounts to HIPAA or banking records. or even
- 14:15classified or export control data, depending
- 14:18if you're working in the defense industry, in
- 14:20the military, or in a secure platform that involves
- 14:22national security concerns. Now Corey will speak
- 14:25in a little bit about AI, and I mentioned this
- 14:29at the start of the presentation. These scientific
- 14:32emerging technology areas are not siloed, they
- 14:35do overlap. AI and quantum sit alongside each
- 14:40other, as well as advanced semiconductors as
- 14:42a top -tier national strategic technology and
- 14:46priority. And to further support this, we have
- 14:49seen the administration document this through
- 14:51executive order, through presidential memoranda,
- 14:54and through actions through the executive branch.
- 14:57Okay, so I mentioned a little bit about quantum
- 14:59readiness. In essence, preparing our infrastructures
- 15:03for Q Day. being ready for when and if quantum
- 15:08computing exists to scale, where the computers
- 15:10can be used to create malfeasances or really
- 15:14violate our infrastructure. One of the leaders,
- 15:19or perhaps the leader, when it comes to the US
- 15:21government's efforts to attack and prepare for
- 15:25Q -Day is the Department of Commerce. Department
- 15:28of Commerce, many may know, hosts the National
- 15:30Institute of Standards and Technology, NIST.
- 15:33which, among other things, tasked themselves
- 15:37and others with coming up with certain algorithms
- 15:39that would be resistant to quantum computers.
- 15:44In essence, they developed a new phrase. That
- 15:47phrase is PQC or post quantum cryptography. So
- 15:54by 2029, in theory, which has been the public
- 15:57date discussed by the federal government and
- 15:59others in industry, when quantum computers to
- 16:02scale, have the ability to defeat public key
- 16:06encryption, we must have updated our own encryption
- 16:10to protect us for those attacks. And the label
- 16:15we're using for this is PQC post -quantum photography.
- 16:18Now, in doing this quantum readiness, we are
- 16:22recommending or advising companies to do a review
- 16:25of their data when it comes to most private PII
- 16:31or most consequential information as you make
- 16:33a hierarchy of what you want to go through first
- 16:35to protect and update. Understanding that you
- 16:38must protect that data now and have it stay confidential
- 16:42because there's a risk if it's stolen now it
- 16:45may be decrypted later. So once we have come
- 16:47up on an agreement that Q day is coming and we
- 16:50must update our cryptography, the next question
- 16:53is how do we do it? NIST has published the FIP
- 16:57standards or the federal information processing
- 16:59standards publicly identifying opportunities.
- 17:04In this case, we refer to them as FIPS 203, 204,
- 17:06205 that you see on your computer right here.
- 17:10A variety of algorithms that are approved for
- 17:14protecting against quantum computing, in essence,
- 17:18PQC algorithms. So without going into much detail,
- 17:20you'll see they have different, first off, labels,
- 17:25names, numbers, and purposes, but these are the
- 17:27current three. algorithms that have been approved
- 17:30and published by NIST. Their role right here
- 17:34is they are vetted benchmark algorithms for quantum
- 17:36resistant keys, establishment, and signatures.
- 17:40And when you migrate your current infrastructure
- 17:43to this, it should be risk -based. We understand
- 17:48you can't update everything at once instantaneously.
- 17:50This is not as simple as updating your iPhone.
- 17:53This will take time. And one of the questions
- 17:55we often hear from boards of directors or Sanjeev,
- 17:58Corey, where do we start first? What type of
- 18:01data do we need to update or address first? And
- 18:04we are recommending it should be the most sensitive,
- 18:07those that must remain confidential for the most
- 18:10amount of years. Often that might be the bulk
- 18:12of your data, even better reason for you to be
- 18:15prepared to do this now. And one of the things
- 18:19that we also realize here as presenters is how
- 18:22fluid and new this technology is. So what's helped
- 18:26as we move forward has been the administration,
- 18:28both the Biden and Trump administration to be
- 18:30fair, is their policy towards identifying and
- 18:35understanding need to discuss quantum, but then
- 18:38two, memorializing this through executive order.
- 18:41There were two executive orders that came out
- 18:43this June of 2026. The first one EO14413, ushering
- 18:49the next frontier of quantum innovation, really
- 18:52establishes and articulates an effort to come
- 18:54up with a scientific quantum computer that's
- 18:57based in the federal government, cited with the
- 19:00Department of Energy, that will allow us or the
- 19:03government to expand quantum sensing and networking
- 19:06research and development and ultimately advance
- 19:10quantum research and usage within the federal
- 19:15government, Rich Large. Very, very big deal because
- 19:17a lot of this has opened up opportunities to
- 19:20industry to engage. And that's looks like something
- 19:24like working with the Department of Energy or
- 19:26Department of Commerce on the Genesis mission.
- 19:28There's been a lot of letters of interest where
- 19:31I believe nine companies now have agreed to engage
- 19:33with both commerce and energy, providing stakes
- 19:37in their companies. for over $900 million in
- 19:41investment from the federal government to identify
- 19:42these areas. Also working with the Department
- 19:44of War and DARPA when it comes to research and
- 19:47development in these areas as well. This has
- 19:49all been memorialized through the White House.
- 19:54We'll talk about these guidelines at the bottom
- 19:55here in a second, but the administration's been
- 19:57very clear these are priorities right now when
- 20:00it comes to the nation's quantum strategy. The
- 20:03second executive order, which I will... mentioned
- 20:06briefly here is EO 14412 securing the nation
- 20:09against advanced cryptographic attacks. In essence
- 20:12discusses post quantum cryptography and the importance
- 20:15in the federal government of having individuals
- 20:17tasked with having really accountability to make
- 20:22sure the government is up to date on its PQC
- 20:24algorithms. Now I will say humbly I was blessed
- 20:27at the White House to work with the team. at
- 20:29ONCD and also with the Department of Commerce
- 20:31on this executive order. And many great hands
- 20:34were working on this paper when it amounted to
- 20:37what is the right way, one, to articulate for
- 20:42the executive branch the importance of PQC and
- 20:46of adopting this FIP standards, but two, really
- 20:49creating a template for the public to see this
- 20:51is a real issue. We don't want to wait to 2029.
- 20:54If we do wait, there's a good risk that data
- 20:58will be stolen. Medical records, financial records,
- 21:01we can take the crypto out of cryptocurrency.
- 21:03I'll say one of the things I was fortunate to
- 21:04work on was the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve and
- 21:07the President's Council of Digital Currency Advisors.
- 21:10And while we were establishing the Strategic
- 21:12Bitcoin Reserves, one of the concerns is, and
- 21:14this has been public, what if the cryptography
- 21:17in cryptocurrency, in the case Bitcoin gets defeated
- 21:20and the funds move instantaneously. So these
- 21:22are things we want to be talking about and discussing
- 21:24that the executive order was intended to highlight
- 21:27in addition to addressing the executive branch.
- 21:30It directs the agencies to migrate high value
- 21:31and high impact systems to PQC. Again, as I mentioned,
- 21:35it adopts the NISPIP standards for PQC purposes.
- 21:39In essence, it relies on CISA, which is part
- 21:43of the Department of Homeland Security and NISP,
- 21:45the Department of Commerce, to publish minimum
- 21:48elements for a cryptographic bill of materials.
- 21:50And without getting too granular on this here,
- 21:52because this is more of a one -on -one type discussion,
- 21:54we see a movement now in the National Quantum
- 21:57Strategy led by the administration to say, this
- 22:01is a real deal. We want to engage on quantum
- 22:03advantage. We want to make sure we can be partaking
- 22:06in research and development. We want to encourage
- 22:08business and tech stack growth for all quantum
- 22:11companies, whether you're abroad or domestically
- 22:12to grow here in the US. We want to support that.
- 22:15We want to give benefits for you to do so and
- 22:17grow your footprint. And industry should take
- 22:19heed of that, because that is true when it comes
- 22:21to tax incentives, location, site location and
- 22:24bidding, as well as usage of energy. You have
- 22:28a lot of support right now from the administration.
- 22:30But the second aspect, just as important, the
- 22:32existential national security concern of while
- 22:35computers can be used to do good, in this case,
- 22:37quantum computing, we must be making sure we're
- 22:39updating our algorithms. our cryptography, because
- 22:43this becomes an existential national security
- 22:45issue if your data is stolen. And briefly, before
- 22:48I throw out the query for our next segment, we
- 22:52see a variety of compliance deadlines. Starting
- 22:56back, I believe, on June 22nd or so, 2026, going
- 22:59into 2031 after Q Day, where we have seen the
- 23:03president test the executive branch and making
- 23:06sure the algorithms are in place. people are
- 23:10in place to actually monitor the accountability
- 23:12of this. And finally, the executive branch is
- 23:15required to put together a budget request to
- 23:17go forth and execute this to make sure there
- 23:19is or are sufficient resources to do so. So again,
- 23:23be mindful that quantum is evolving. There's
- 23:25a lot going on right now. Our goal here was a
- 23:27lay of framework for you to see what we're seeing,
- 23:29not only in the administration, but in industry.
- 23:32So with that, let me throw it to my friend and
- 23:34partner, Corey, now to dive into artificial intelligence.
- 23:38Thanks, Sanjeev. So we're going to shift now
- 23:40from quantum, as Sanjeev said, over to artificial
- 23:44intelligence. And I'm going to start with the
- 23:45executive order that sets the federal policy
- 23:48frame for everything else in the section that
- 23:50we're going to discuss. That's executive order
- 23:5314409, promoting advanced artificial intelligence
- 23:57innovation and security. It was signed on June
- 23:592nd of this year and published in the Federal
- 24:01Register three days later at 91 FR. 34565. So
- 24:07here's the framing I'd offer before we get into
- 24:08the individual sections. This is not a comprehensive
- 24:12AI statute. It's a cybersecurity implementation
- 24:15order. It works through existing agency authorities,
- 24:18the Treasury, DHS, NSA, and the Justice Department.
- 24:21And it very deliberately does not create a federal
- 24:25licensing regime for AI models. If you take...
- 24:28one structural point away from the slide we're
- 24:30looking at. It's the order pairs a classified
- 24:34capability assessment with an express disclaimer
- 24:37of license authority. So two things sitting side
- 24:41by side is the entire design Let me take four
- 24:45provisions on the slide and give them the order
- 24:47that I think is gonna matter to your clients
- 24:48Starting with the bottom line items section 3c
- 24:52nothing in section 3 authorizes a mandatory licensing
- 24:56Preclearance or permitting requirement for developing
- 24:59or releasing an AI model. There's no federal
- 25:02permit to build a model There's no registration
- 25:04list. There's no preclearance gate that matters
- 25:08because A lot of the commentary in 2024 and 2025
- 25:12assume we are heading towards something like
- 25:14an FDA -style approval process for frontier models.
- 25:19This order forecloses that at least as a matter
- 25:21of executive action. Want to talk about the limits
- 25:24because this section or this is question I hear
- 25:26from from clients all the time section 3c is
- 25:29Textually limited to what section 3 itself authorizes.
- 25:33It does not say states may not regulate It does
- 25:36not expressly preempt state law. It does not
- 25:39condition federal funds So if a client asks you
- 25:42whether the executive order overrides the California
- 25:45statute or the Colorado statute The answer on
- 25:48the face of this document is no A future federal
- 25:51statute could preempt. A comprehensive federal
- 25:55regulatory scheme could support a conflict preemption
- 25:59argument down the road. This executive order,
- 26:02standing alone, does neither of those. Second,
- 26:05Section 3A, the benchmarking process. The order
- 26:08requires a classified benchmarking process for
- 26:12advanced AI cyber capabilities and a threshold
- 26:15for designating a model. Covered frontier model
- 26:20that was due within 60 days of signing which
- 26:23put the deadline right around August 1st NSA
- 26:26makes that designation What I think's most useful
- 26:30thing you can tell your clients And and it's
- 26:33about the state of public record as of today.
- 26:36There is no publicly available Covered frontier
- 26:39model threshold. We do not know whether the government
- 26:42is using a compute threshold a capability evaluation
- 26:47Or both and we do not know whether a designation
- 26:50attaches to a model or to a developer We don't
- 26:53know whether there is a notice to the developer
- 26:56or a challenge process or any appeal So I want
- 26:59to be careful about the inference because the
- 27:01order requires a classified benchmark Public
- 27:04silence does not tell you the deadline was missed.
- 27:08It may well have been met. We just can't see
- 27:11it. So when you advise a client, the accurate
- 27:14statement is the threshold is not publicly known,
- 27:17not the government blew the deadline or something
- 27:19like that. The contrast with states is instructive.
- 27:22California is SB 53. The Transparency and Frontier
- 27:26Artificial Intelligence Act uses a public bright
- 27:29line definition. More than 10 to the 26th integer
- 27:33or floating point operation. That's a number
- 27:35your client's engineers team can actually measure
- 27:37against. The federal benchmark is classified.
- 27:40So don't assume the California number is the
- 27:42federal number. These are two different regimes
- 27:44with two different definitions. And right now
- 27:46only one of them is legible from the outside.
- 27:49Third, section 3B, the voluntary framework. Under
- 27:543B, a developer may ask the government whether
- 27:56its model is covered and may choose to provide
- 27:59pre -release access for up to 30 days subject
- 28:02to specified safeguards. I want to underline
- 28:04the word may. Nothing in the order compels participation
- 28:08and the order does not describe a consequence
- 28:11for declining. If you have a developer client
- 28:14considering it, This is a real advice question,
- 28:17and I flag six things before anyone assigns anything.
- 28:21One, confidentiality, what protects the weights,
- 28:24the evaluation results, the architecture. Two,
- 28:27insider risk and access controls on the government
- 28:30side. Three, intellectual property and trade
- 28:33secret exposure. Four, exposure -controlled implications
- 28:36of granting access. Five, discovery, assume anything
- 28:41generated in that process is potentially discoverable
- 28:44in later litigation. And six, whether the disclosure
- 28:47interacts with the state law reporting duty you're
- 28:50already carrying. There is no publicly available
- 28:53standard agreement, so my answer to should we
- 28:56volunteer today is not until we see the paper.
- 28:59Fourth, Section 2C. This one directs DHS acting
- 29:04through CISA to expedite cyber defense of federal
- 29:08civilian systems to build out AI -enabled defensive
- 29:11tools and services and to facilitate access to
- 29:14those tools, including covered frontier models
- 29:16where appropriate for federal agencies, state
- 29:18and local authorities, and critical infrastructure
- 29:21operators. The compliance question here is who
- 29:24is actually bound? A CISA binding operational
- 29:28directive binds federal civilian executive branch
- 29:31agencies. It does not by its own force regulate
- 29:33private companies. If your critical infrastructure
- 29:37client ends up with an obligation traceable to
- 29:40this, it will almost always arrive through a
- 29:42contract, a grant, a sector regulator or statute,
- 29:46not through the directive itself. So watch your
- 29:49contract flowdowns. That's where you're going
- 29:52to see this show up. And then section four, the
- 29:55criminal enforcement piece. The order directs
- 29:57the attorney general to prioritize enforcement
- 30:00of existing criminal law against AI enabled unauthorized
- 30:04access, damage and related offenses. Three statutes
- 30:07are named on the slide. We have 18 USC 1028,
- 30:10identity fraud. We have 1030, the CFAA, and 1343,
- 30:15wire fraud. The operative word here is prioritize.
- 30:18Section four does not create a new offense. It
- 30:21does not change an element of any of these statutes.
- 30:24The government still has to prove unauthorized
- 30:26access under 1030. It still has to prove a scheme
- 30:30to defraud and use of wires under 1343. The fact
- 30:35that the defendant used an AI tool does not by
- 30:39itself establish authorization or loss or intent.
- 30:44What I would tell a client is that wire fraud
- 30:46remains the primary workhorse here. If someone
- 30:49clones a CFO's voice and induces a wire transfer,
- 30:53that's a 1343 case with a new fact pattern, not
- 30:56a new crime. And I'd note that for completeness
- 31:00that Congress Has been legislating in the adjacent
- 31:04space deep fake Prosecution Department announced
- 31:07earlier this year was brought under the take
- 31:10it down act not under these three statutes So
- 31:13the enforcement picture is broader than the executive
- 31:16order alone, which brings me to the right hand
- 31:19column here Who should be watching AI developers?
- 31:24They should track Section 3 framework, the threshold,
- 31:27if and when it becomes visible, and any published
- 31:30terms for the voluntary program. Critical infrastructure
- 31:33operators. The value here is on the offer side.
- 31:37CISA is being told to make defensive tooling
- 31:39available to you. If you operate critical infrastructure,
- 31:43that's a resource. And I'd be asking your sector
- 31:45risk management agency what actually is available
- 31:48rather than waiting for it to be announced. Government
- 31:50contractors. In terms of managing expectations,
- 31:54as of today, there is no verified FAR clause,
- 31:57no DFARS clause, no class deviation that expressly
- 32:02implements this executive order. The operative
- 32:04procurement framework for AI is still the 2025
- 32:09OMB memoranda M2521 and M2522 on AI use and acquisition.
- 32:18So the advice is don't assume a flow down obligation
- 32:22that hasn't been written yet and read your solicitations
- 32:25and statement of work carefully because agency
- 32:27specific language is where this will surface
- 32:29first. One last point on this slide, and it's
- 32:32a thing lawyers sometimes forget about in terms
- 32:34of executive orders. Section 5 is the savings
- 32:36clause. It preserves existing agency authority,
- 32:39making implementation subject to appropriations.
- 32:42It disclaims any private right of action. Nobody
- 32:45is suing to enforce this order. It is direction
- 32:48to the executive branch, and its practical force
- 32:50depends entirely on what agencies do with it,
- 32:54which is exactly the right setup for this next
- 32:56slide, because the real operation will roll out
- 32:58under... This order has a name. And we're on
- 33:03the next slide. Okay, Golden Eagle. Golden Eagle
- 33:06is the operational rollout of Section 2D of the
- 33:09order. I just walked through and it was announced
- 33:12by the White House on July 14th. Section 2D directs
- 33:16Treasury in consultation with the National Cyber
- 33:19Director, the Secretary of Defense, acting through
- 33:22the NSA. DHS acting through CESA to establish
- 33:26an AI Cybersecurity clearinghouse gold eagle
- 33:29is that clearinghouse one note on this slide
- 33:32because it matters to how you draft you'll see
- 33:35Department of War executive order 14 for I'm
- 33:39sorry 14347 signed last September, authorizes
- 33:44Department of War and Secretary of War as secondary
- 33:49titles in designated executive branch context.
- 33:52The legal department is still the Department
- 33:54of Defense. If you're citing statutory authority
- 33:56in a brief or contract, cite the Department of
- 33:59Defense. Now, the concepts on this slide is a
- 34:04pipeline. A vulnerability is found. It goes to
- 34:07an AI triage layer. It routes through Vince.
- 34:11Vince is the coordination platform operated by
- 34:13Carnegie Mellon's Software Engineering Institute,
- 34:16or SEI, and it ends in coordinated disclosure.
- 34:21So I'm going to separate what we actually know
- 34:23from what we don't know, because this matters
- 34:25when you're devising on it. What is confirmed,
- 34:28the White House announced the program under Section
- 34:302D with those agencies on that date. That is
- 34:34not publicly available as of this morning. The
- 34:38participation agreement, the enrollment process,
- 34:42the AI triage architecture, the roster of private
- 34:45participants, and the terms of service. Those
- 34:47are not publicly available. There's no published
- 34:49memorandum of understanding. So the flow on this
- 34:51slide is the announced concept. If a client asks
- 34:55what they would actually be signing up for, the
- 34:58accurate answer today is we need to see the program
- 35:00documents. And I would not fill in the technical
- 35:03details from any of the press coverage or something
- 35:05like that. What I can tell you with confidence
- 35:08is what VINCE is, because it has been running
- 35:11since 2020. VINCE stands for Vulnerability Information
- 35:16and Coordination Environment. It's a CERT CC
- 35:18web -based platform for reporting vulnerability
- 35:22and then coordinating privately among the reporter
- 35:25and the affected vendors and other stakeholders
- 35:28before anything goes public. Coordinated Coordinated
- 35:31Vulnerability Disclosure, CVD, is that whole
- 35:34cycle of report, validate, remediate, then disclose.
- 35:37And on the coordination clock, one correction
- 35:39I'd make to a common assumption, there is no
- 35:42single universal deadline. Cert CTC materials
- 35:46describe coordination periods that run 45 days
- 35:49or 90 days, depending on the facts. Those are
- 35:52practices, not statutes. Do not tell a client
- 35:54you have 45 days, as though it were a rule. The
- 35:58FFRDC, point is worth a mention here. A federally
- 36:02funded research and development center brings
- 36:04institutional credibility, technical capacity,
- 36:07and a set of conflict of interest rules. What
- 36:11it does not bring is legal safe harbor. Whether
- 36:14your submission is protected from FOIA, protected
- 36:17from regulatory use, or protected from discovery
- 36:20depends entirely on the precise recipient, the
- 36:24channel, the terms, and the statutory authority
- 36:26under which it's received. We sent it to a trusted
- 36:29coordinator is not a legal conclusion here. Okay,
- 36:33so that brings me to the item on the far right
- 36:36of the slide And I want to start by telling you
- 36:38that the slide is wrong It was accurate when
- 36:41we finalized the deck last week. It stopped being
- 36:44accurate on Wednesday So here's what the slide
- 36:47says the liability and disclosure protections
- 36:49that make cyber threat information sharing workable
- 36:52in this country come from the Cybersecurity Information
- 36:55Sharing Act of 2015 and under 6 USC 1510 a that
- 37:00entire subject chapter on September 30th, 26
- 37:04days from today. Here's what happened this week.
- 37:07On Tuesday, September 1st, the House passed a
- 37:10continuing resolution. The Senate had already
- 37:12approved. The President signed it on Wednesday.
- 37:14The Continuing Appropriations Extensions Act
- 37:17of 2027. 90 to 6 in the Senate. 370 to 48 in
- 37:25the House. It funds the federal government through
- 37:27December 11th, and it carries the Cybersecurity
- 37:29Information Sharing Act along with it. The same
- 37:31package extends to the Federal Cybersecurity
- 37:34Enhancement Act. which authorizes the National
- 37:37Cybersecurity Protection System and the Technology
- 37:40Modernization Fund on the same December 11th
- 37:43date. So the September 30th sunset is off the
- 37:47table. The new date is December 11th, 2026, 98
- 37:51days from today. Now I could stop and tell you
- 37:55that the problem is solved. It isn't. And the
- 37:58reason it isn't is part worth, it's worth discussing.
- 38:04Because CESA's 2020 -2015 protections gets used
- 38:10pretty loosely. The protections are not all in
- 38:13section 1510. Section 1510 is the sunset provision
- 38:17and the savings clause. The operative protections
- 38:19live in sections 1503 through 1505. Section 1503
- 38:25authorizes private entities to monitor their
- 38:28systems, operate defensive measures, and share
- 38:30cyber threat indicators, and it contains an antitrust
- 38:34exemption for qualifying exchanges. Section 1504
- 38:37Does the disclosure work? It preserves privilege
- 38:40and trade seek protections from information shared
- 38:42through the statutory channel. It protects designated
- 38:45information from FOIA and analogous state disclosure
- 38:48laws, and it limits the government's use of what
- 38:51you share, including regulatory use, subject
- 38:53to some significant exceptions for cybersecurity
- 38:56purposes, serious harm, and specific crimes.
- 38:59And Section 1505 is the private entity liability
- 39:03shield, along with the provision confirming there
- 39:06is no duty to share, no duty to warn. no duty
- 39:10to act. Take those and you have a materially
- 39:13different risk calculation behind every information
- 39:17sharing decision your client makes. And it's
- 39:19not a hypothetical exercise either because the
- 39:23sub -chapter has actually lapsed twice. Briefly
- 39:27during last fall's government shutdown and again
- 39:29earlier this year before Congress extended it
- 39:32to September 30th. Each time companies in the
- 39:35middle of active sharing agreements had to go
- 39:37to counsel and ask what was protected, what wasn't,
- 39:40and as of when. If you have any clients in the
- 39:43ISAC or sector sharing program, they have lived
- 39:49through all of this already. The savings clause
- 39:51is what made those lapses survivable. Section
- 39:541510b preserves the sub -chapter's effect on
- 39:58action authorized before the sunset and for information
- 40:02obtained pursuant to an unauthorized action before
- 40:06the sunset. What your client shared in good faith
- 40:10while the authority was live does not lose its
- 40:12protection when the date passes What you should
- 40:15not assume is that a new disclosure made after
- 40:18a lapse gets the statutory authorization The
- 40:21liability shield the antitrust treatment the
- 40:24FOIA protection or the regulatory use limits
- 40:26It does not which means the operative question
- 40:28for your client is not are we covered it is What
- 40:32was the authority live on the day we sent it?
- 40:36That is the date stamping problem. And most clients
- 40:39are not set up to answer it. So why does this
- 40:41keep happening? In 90 day increments, the White
- 40:43House and most of the industry want a long -term
- 40:46clean extension. A 10 -year reauthorization has
- 40:49been the ask. The principal obstacle is the Senate.
- 40:52or in the Senate, is the Senate. In the Senate
- 40:55has been the Homeland Security and Governmental
- 40:58Affairs Chairman, Rand Paul, who has conditioned
- 41:02his support on concerns about the agency's past
- 41:05work on disinformation. That is an issue with
- 41:07essentially nothing to do with liability protections
- 41:10in the statute, but is where the fight sits.
- 41:13Nothing this week resolved it. It'll resurface
- 41:16before December 11th. So where all this connects
- 41:19when industry groups pushed for durable fix this
- 41:23summer. They pointed to two things. One was the
- 41:26operational technology. The operational technology
- 41:28cybersecurity coalition cited tax on water and
- 41:32wastewater system and its position was essentially
- 41:35that the sector cannot keep operating on minor
- 41:37extensions. The other was Golden Eagle. Industry
- 41:40groups warned specifically that letting the statute
- 41:43lapse would put the clearinghouse at risk because
- 41:46a voluntary sharing program is only as attractive
- 41:49as protections attached to what you share. That's
- 41:52the connection I would want you to leave with
- 41:55Golden Eagles. Viability is downstream of a statute
- 41:58that Congress is currently renewing a quarter
- 42:00at a time. If it does not lapse in December,
- 42:02what's left? The contract terms, trade secrets,
- 42:05law. the protected critical infrastructure information
- 42:08program where it's available common interest
- 42:11arrangements ordinary ordinary privilege doctrine
- 42:13those are all real and not one of them replicates
- 42:17the statutory package so practical advice for
- 42:19the client considering golden eagle participation
- 42:21and i give the same advice for any government
- 42:23-facing sharing program get the actual terms
- 42:26before you commit Identify specific legal authority
- 42:29under which information will be received, used,
- 42:32retained, and shared, and whether it is the CISA
- 42:352015 channel or something else entirely. Segregate
- 42:38technical indicators from legal analysis. The
- 42:41indicator can go, your assessment of the company's
- 42:44exposure should not minimize personal data in
- 42:47the submission, mark proprietary material clearly,
- 42:50keep a disclosure log, when it went out, when,
- 42:53to whom, under what authority, and preserve the
- 42:55original artifacts and your investigative work
- 42:58product. Because if this becomes an incident,
- 43:02that log is your record. One more risk I'd put
- 43:05on your radar on AI triage itself. If a model
- 43:07scoring and routing vulnerability reports someone
- 43:10is eventually going to ask about false negatives,
- 43:13the critical finding that got prioritized. Think
- 43:17now about the records that process generation,
- 43:21retention, discovery, privilege, and whatever
- 43:24an AI -generated severity score becomes an exhibit
- 43:27in litigation over a breach that happened afterwards.
- 43:32The takeaway on this slide is three facts held
- 43:35together. Gold Eagle is real. Its terms are not
- 43:38yet public, and the statutory protections that
- 43:41make participation safe now run to December 11th
- 43:44rather than September 30th. The date moved, the
- 43:47structural problem did not. You're advising clients
- 43:49to share sensitive information under a legal
- 43:51framework that Congress is renewing in 90 -day
- 43:54increments that has already lapsed twice and
- 43:57whose long -term fate is tied up in a dispute
- 44:00that has nothing to do with protections themselves.
- 44:02Build that instability into your advice. Date
- 44:05stamp your sharing decisions. Keep your disclosure
- 44:08log, as I mentioned, and put December 11th on
- 44:10your calendar now because we're going to be having
- 44:12this exact conversation again in the first week
- 44:15of December. Next slide. That's great, Corey.
- 44:19We could spend, I think, really the whole session
- 44:22talking about Gold Eagle and AI and what's going
- 44:25on in a very fluid area. And I think great point,
- 44:27too, as CISA 2013 was extended, at least through
- 44:31December. This is very fluid, right? And we want
- 44:34to make sure we get you the information in real
- 44:36time and even more of a reason to engage when
- 44:38you can. So pivot here for a second. It's tough
- 44:41to talk about emerging technology without talking
- 44:43about crypto or blockchain at some level. This
- 44:45is one of the technologies that's been around
- 44:47longer than the others, definitely longer than
- 44:49quantum and at some level longer than artificial
- 44:51intelligence. I was fortunate to work on some
- 44:53of these policies at the White House and at the
- 44:55DOJ, where I served as United States Digital
- 44:57Currency Council. And there's some things here
- 44:59that I just want to flag. that I think will be
- 45:01helpful for us. One is we have a digital asset
- 45:05policy and framework with the administration
- 45:07through executive order. The president established
- 45:09a working group in digital asset markets, which
- 45:11I was fortunate to work on. This is the genesis
- 45:14of the Genius Act, the discussions on clarity,
- 45:18excuse me, the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, which
- 45:21also was memorialized in another executive order.
- 45:24We spoke briefly about this earlier. But the
- 45:27policies here are instead of taking cryptocurrency
- 45:30and cashing them out when the government sees
- 45:33them and turn, uh, seizes them and turn it into
- 45:35us dollars to later be repatriated to law enforcement.
- 45:38Why not keep them in their digital asset form
- 45:41to allow them to appreciate in value, almost
- 45:44like a reserve, like an oil reserve, but in this
- 45:46case crypto and more than just Bitcoin, while
- 45:49it may hold the name of the strategic digital
- 45:52asset stockpile or commonly referred to as a
- 45:55strategic Bitcoin reserve, it involves numerous
- 45:57cryptocurrencies that are still being developed.
- 45:59Sorry about that. The one point I want to make
- 46:02here is the challenge on the national security
- 46:06front and how quantum and AI and crypto are not
- 46:10siloed is if we do not have computer coders that
- 46:13are working the Bitcoin protocol, updating the
- 46:16Bitcoin code, or there's over 10 ,000 cryptocurrencies
- 46:20that exist right now, whatever currencies happen
- 46:22to be in the digital asset stockpile, there's
- 46:26a good chance a nefarious actor thief could take
- 46:30that crypto, which in essence is a software program,
- 46:32and move it from the strategic reserve here in
- 46:36the United States abroad or to some other place
- 46:39and with it remove access for the federal government.
- 46:44For those reasons, in addition to others, it's
- 46:47important that crypto coders update the algorithms
- 46:52the cryptography behind the crypto and cryptocurrency.
- 46:56The Genius Act framework, which has been the
- 46:58most ripe or hottest topic right now, this is
- 47:02the regulatory framework that many software developers,
- 47:05financial institutions, decentralized finance
- 47:09liquidity bridges custodians are interested in.
- 47:12Can we establish a regulatory framework in the
- 47:15US that determines is it the SEC? Or is it the
- 47:19CFTC regulating a specific investment entity
- 47:23currency? We are close. We right now have very
- 47:28clear bipartisan support, and the president's
- 47:29indicated he will sign the bill. However, I think
- 47:34there's a vote for cloture set for September
- 47:3615th. So as we present today, and this is recorded
- 47:39presentation, it's September 4th, 2026. But by
- 47:43September 15, we'll have a vote on cloture. So
- 47:44we'll see if Congress acts and decides to enact
- 47:47this legislation. There's more in the Genius
- 47:50Act framework regarding treatment of decentralized
- 47:52finance, how we deal with stable coin interest,
- 47:56the yield discussion that many of the banking
- 47:57industry has been raising. These are questions
- 48:00that we hear from our clients all the time. We
- 48:01want to engage. in the digital asset framework.
- 48:04We want to go ahead and introduce tokenization
- 48:06or ETFs or real world assets when it comes to
- 48:11securities and bonds, but we're not sure how
- 48:14we're going to be regulated. And the hope is
- 48:16this legislation will bring further clarity,
- 48:18no pun intended. At the same point in time, we
- 48:21do have existing laws, anti -money laundering,
- 48:23bank secrecy act laws that are existed to protect
- 48:26the FISC, the FISC here in the United States,
- 48:28the federal FISC, but also investors and taxpayers.
- 48:32the way those laws effectuate and work are relying
- 48:35on money service businesses or financial institutions
- 48:39that are registering as such with FinCEN, with
- 48:42the Financial Crime Enforcement Network, with
- 48:44Treasury, to have an anti -money laundering program,
- 48:46to have an agent, to do KYC, know your customer
- 48:49due diligence on their customers. And we rely
- 48:51on them heavily to identify nefarious activity.
- 48:54That to say, all this to say, digital assets
- 48:57are here to stay. We have seen A lot of movement
- 49:01in this executive branch, most recently by the
- 49:03GSA, when it comes to how can we do procurement
- 49:06in digital assets. We've seen discussions by
- 49:11major commodity exchanges when it comes to tokenization
- 49:14and settlement on the blockchain. We've also
- 49:17seen companies such as trucking, export, importers.
- 49:23wanting to settle their bills of lading on the
- 49:25blockchain even without digital assets but just
- 49:28having a real -time computer -based ledger look
- 49:31at the movement of funds or money. Some of the
- 49:33challenge with this though is one awareness of
- 49:36the technology, because if you do not understand
- 49:38it, you could be abused by it. But two, making
- 49:40sure we protect it from attack. And some of this
- 49:43is addressed as well through the Genius Act.
- 49:45So I know I want to be cognizant of time. There's
- 49:46a lot to cover here. And there's a lot too we
- 49:49could have added, but we wanted to make sure
- 49:50we at least spent some time talking about digital
- 49:53assets as part of the new technology frontier.
- 49:56And let me throw it to Corey to talk about digital
- 49:58privacy. Sure. Okay. Last slide for me. We're
- 50:05going to move over from cyber to the Fourth Amendment.
- 50:09So on June 29th, the Supreme Court decided Chattery
- 50:13v. U .S. I'd argue it's the most consequential
- 50:17digital privacy decision since Carpenter. It
- 50:21starts with a 2019 credit union robbery outside
- 50:24Richmond. Police had almost nothing to go on,
- 50:27so they got a warrant directed at Google. Asking
- 50:31if or asking to search location history for every
- 50:35device inside 150 meter radius of the credit
- 50:40union during a one -hour window That's not a
- 50:43warrant for a suspect. It's a warrant for a place
- 50:47and a time that identifies the suspect afterward
- 50:51Google's process ran in three stages anonymized
- 50:54data for every device in that zone. Then the
- 50:57police pick a subset and get expanded movement
- 51:01data outside the original time and outside the
- 51:03original geography. Then police narrow again
- 51:07and Google disclosed the names. The government
- 51:09ended up identifying three users. One of them
- 51:12was Mr. Chattery. The court held that acquiring
- 51:15that data is a Fourth Amendment search. Justice
- 51:19Kagan wrote for or wrote for five, Justice Gorsh
- 51:23concurred in the judgment on a proprietary theory,
- 51:27Justice Alito and Barrett dissented, six to three
- 51:30in the judgment. The reasoning extends carpenter.
- 51:34Location history is more precise, more frequent
- 51:38and potentially more revealing than cell site
- 51:41data. And the court rejected the government's
- 51:44best argument that two hours was too short to
- 51:47matter. The question is not the volume ultimately
- 51:50extracted. It's the government's access to a
- 51:53comprehensive, a comprehensive retrospective
- 51:55database. Now the part that matters for, for
- 51:58advice. but the court did not decide. It did
- 52:01not hold that geofence warrants are categorically
- 52:04unconstitutional. It vacated and remanded for
- 52:09probable cause and particularity at each of the
- 52:14three stages. It did not resolve good faith,
- 52:17and it expressly reserved tower dumps, reverse
- 52:20keyword warrants, license plate readers, and
- 52:23purchase broker data. The central operational
- 52:27move is that a process designed by Google is
- 52:31not a constitutional limitation. The warrant
- 52:33itself has to supply the judicial supervision.
- 52:38Objective narrowing criteria at stage two, stated
- 52:42de -anonymization criteria at stage three, and
- 52:45the defense question on every one of these is
- 52:48whether the magistrate made the call or the officer
- 52:52did. So you might be thinking Google moved location
- 52:55history onto the device. So isn't this an academic
- 52:59question? And the answer is no. The migration
- 53:02is real, but the doctrine is not about Google.
- 53:05Location data lives in carrier records, vehicle
- 53:08telematics, in app SDKs, ad tech pipelines, broker
- 53:12and license reader networks. And the biggest
- 53:15open door is purchase. If the government buys
- 53:18the data instead of compelling it, there is no
- 53:21war. No, that's great. I mean, Corey, this is
- 53:25a very consequential decision. We've had argument.
- 53:29I think yesterday was in the Fourth Circuit where
- 53:31they revisited to see how the circuit's going
- 53:33to rule after it was thrown back from the Supreme
- 53:35Court. So stay tuned. This is evolving as well.
- 53:38So as we wrap up here, just a couple of points.
- 53:41First off, thank you for having us. We really
- 53:43appreciate it. Our goal is, as I mentioned, to
- 53:45share this information, to give you counsel.
- 53:48Don't make you understand. We're here with you.
- 53:50We're engaging with you. We're learning with
- 53:52you. The dialogue does continue. And so there
- 53:55are a couple of areas I wanted to highlight for
- 53:56you, Corey, and I both wanted to. One is we have
- 53:59a quantum industry group down at the quantum
- 54:00front. We've written on this topic on Q Day and
- 54:02on quantum innovation and the scientific computers
- 54:04that are being developed now at Energy at the
- 54:07behest of the White House, as well as, to be
- 54:09honest, the funding, the grant work, the LOI
- 54:12at Commerce and Energy. If you want to engage
- 54:15on this, if you're interested in it, we can help
- 54:16you with it. We can walk you through this. On
- 54:18the AI front, we have an entire AI solutions
- 54:21group. Corey and the team wrote a great article
- 54:23on Gold Eagle. I love that title, Gold Eagle
- 54:26takes flight. It's true. It's alive and it's
- 54:28running now. And as we peel back the layers of
- 54:32the onion, we learn more as time progresses because
- 54:34the technology is evolving. But this is an opportunity
- 54:37for you as well as the audience to read, to educate
- 54:40yourself, and to get more granular on this topic.
- 54:43And then finally, on the digital privacy front,
- 54:44which is one of the hotter topics for I think
- 54:47mainstream tech, in addition to the emerging
- 54:49tech, just how we address like a retention of
- 54:52data, what that looks like when it comes to retention
- 54:55policies, because the reality is everything is
- 54:57cyber nowadays and there's digital privacy everywhere.
- 55:01How do we handle that? How should we be consulting
- 55:03if I'm the CISO at my company, if I'm the GC,
- 55:05if I'm the COO? Should I be concerned about quantum?
- 55:08And one of the questions I hear a lot from Chief
- 55:10Information Security Officers are, Sanjeev, we
- 55:12understand quantum, we understand PQC, but can
- 55:15you help us get in front of our boards? Can you
- 55:17help them understand how they need to make a
- 55:19hierarchy of harvest now to Crip later? Can you
- 55:22talk to them more granularly? granularly, excuse
- 55:25me, about public key encryption and decryption.
- 55:28And the answer is yes to all the above. We're
- 55:30here to help. You know, we decided to do this
- 55:32in a CLE platform because in essence, this is
- 55:35legal education for the audience. And we thank
- 55:38you for having us. Corey, I'm going to defer
- 55:39to you, sir, if you have any final words for
- 55:41the group today. No, I mean on the privacy piece
- 55:44again, you know, I'd like to reiterate it's complicated
- 55:46We have over 20 state data protection laws right
- 55:49now. A lot of them say the same thing There are
- 55:51some nuances something we help clients with all
- 55:53the time on artificial intelligence is shine
- 55:57Sanjeev pointed out One of the reasons that we're
- 55:59aware of what's going on is because we as a law
- 56:02firm are dealing with it as well I mean, it's
- 56:04it's complicated for us to deal with things in
- 56:07-house concepts of privilege concepts of privacy
- 56:10data protection security around that all things
- 56:12that we're addressing in real time for our own
- 56:14firm and clients have the benefit of that as
- 56:18well. Perfect. So I'm going to go, we have a
- 56:21couple minutes of the Q &A and I'll just read
- 56:22these questions aloud. We have a couple of comments
- 56:24here. First question is, IBM is an obvious leader
- 56:28in quantum. What other companies are working
- 56:30on quantum and who are the companies lending
- 56:33their quantum computers in the cloud? So that's
- 56:34a great question. There are many computers and
- 56:36companies involved more than I can name and I
- 56:38don't necessarily endorse any specific company,
- 56:40but there are at least nine companies now that
- 56:42were listed in the LOI with energy and commerce.
- 56:44Some of the main companies were Getty, Quantineum,
- 56:48I'm good on the list, D -Wave, IBM, so on and
- 56:53so on. IQM obviously is a player in the market
- 56:55as well and the list goes on and on, IMQ. The
- 56:59reality is, whether or not you are a main company
- 57:01in the LOI, you are definitely given the opportunity
- 57:06to engage writ large with the government, whether
- 57:08it's DOE, Commerce, Energy, Department of War.
- 57:14DARPA, NSF for all those reasons. We've had outreach
- 57:17recently, as of this week, from the Treasury
- 57:19Department to partner with them on the Quantum
- 57:21Readiness Task Force, which is a public -private
- 57:23sector engagement to help them with that. Same
- 57:26from NSF when it comes to driving the public
- 57:28partner engagement. for research funding and
- 57:32development in those areas. So please, please
- 57:34reach out. We'll get you connected and help get
- 57:36you in the right direction. Who are the companies
- 57:38lending quantum to cloud? IBM is doing it. There's
- 57:40a lot of models now. There's still IQM that are
- 57:43giving you cloud -based services, IONQ. It just
- 57:46depends on a specific situation to scale on what
- 57:49you're trying to do. The other question I got
- 57:52here was, are there links to the material? Yes,
- 57:55there are. I will answer it in twofold. One is
- 57:57we will provide our slides to you as part of
- 57:59the CLE. group via Ala and Grace and Suzy with
- 58:05the great Beverly Hills Bar Association, so they
- 58:07will circulate it to the attendees. Additionally,
- 58:10you feel free, please, to go to our website.
- 58:13We gave a couple links here provided, which I
- 58:16think are still showing. Though you might not
- 58:18be able to see the link, but all these are on
- 58:20our client alerts on Candlegate. You can go to
- 58:21Corey's name or my name, or you can just search
- 58:23the firm's website. You could probably even Google
- 58:25them now. That's how much mainstream attention
- 58:27we've been blessed to get on these topics, but
- 58:29they're available. You can look at them. You
- 58:31can discuss them. Happy to share the slides for
- 58:33CLE purposes. I think those are all the questions.
- 58:36Corey, any last words, sir, before we - When
- 58:38we share the slides with the caveat that the
- 58:41September 30th date was extended to December
- 58:4411th, because we had the slides turned in before
- 58:47that happened. So this happens all the time when
- 58:48it comes to emerging fields like this. That's
- 58:51right. Well, we know about Labor Day. So happy
- 58:53Labor Day. You know about Q Day. That's great.
- 58:55Hopefully, it will be another day that we can
- 58:57engage on these topics. We have a lot of appreciation
- 58:59for the bar. Thank you for having us. And credit
- 59:03to you, the audience, for wanting to engage in
- 59:05the new technology frontier. God bless you. Have
- 59:07a great weekend. Thanks a lot, guys.