Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Keeps Saying I Need More Feedback
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this paradox that comes up all the time when you're managing someone. The employee who asks for more feedback almost every week. Sometimes every day. And you think, great, they're coachable. But then you realize — no matter how much you give, it never feels like enough. Luna: I've definitely seen that. And it's exhausting. You start to wonder if they're just insecure or if you're doing something wrong. Lucas: Right. And the truth is, it's usually neither. The 'I need more feedback' request is often a symptom of something else. In my experience, it's typically one of three things. Either they lack clarity on what good looks like, they're craving recognition they're not getting, or they're actually asking for more autonomy but can't articulate it. Luna: Hmm. That last one is interesting. How does asking for feedback translate to wanting more autonomy? Lucas: Because if you're constantly checking in with your manager, you never have to take the risk of making a call on your own. You're outsourcing the decision. So the employee who says 'I need more feedback' might be saying 'I'm terrified to make a mistake, so please tell me what to do.' Luna: That makes a lot of sense. And I imagine the fix looks very different depending on which of those three it is. Lucas: Exactly. You can't just throw more feedback at the problem. You have to diagnose first. And there's a really useful framework from a Gallup study a few years back. They found that employees who had weekly check-ins with their managers were three times more likely to be engaged than those who had annual reviews. But the check-ins had to be structured. Not just 'how's it going?' Luna: So what does a structured check-in look like? Because I think a lot of managers default to the 'open door' policy, which sounds good but can turn into a constant stream of unstructured, anxiety-driven questions. Lucas: Yeah, the open door can backfire. The structured check-in has a clear agenda. You're looking at priorities, progress on specific goals, and any blockers. And you're asking the employee to bring their own items to the table. It's a two-way conversation, not a performance review. The manager isn't just dispensing feedback. They're listening. Luna: And that probably helps with the 'clarity' piece. Because if you're meeting weekly, you're constantly realigning on what good looks like. Lucas: Precisely. And it's not just about the frequency. It's about making feedback less event-driven. When you only give feedback at a mid-year review, it feels like a verdict. When it's a weekly rhythm, it becomes just part of the job. It's a conversation, not a judgment. Luna: Right. And I think that's where a lot of managers get stuck. They think 'more feedback' means they have to give more praise or more criticism, but really it's about creating a rhythm where feedback is baked in. Lucas: Yeah. And you know, on that note — this is probably a good moment to mention something about the show itself. We're able to keep making episodes like this because of a small group of listeners who chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's true. No ads, no sponsors. Just listeners who find the show useful and want to keep it going. It makes a real difference. Lucas: And we're grateful for that. But back to the feedback question. Let's talk about a specific case that really illustrates this. I was talking to a product manager at a mid-size SaaS company — let's call her Priya. She had a direct report, a senior designer, who kept saying she needed more feedback on her designs. Luna: What was the setup? Lucas: They were using a project management tool where the designer would post her work and ask for feedback at every stage. And Priya would dutifully comment on every iteration. But the designer kept coming back saying 'that's not enough.' Priya was spending hours a day on feedback, and it was slowing the whole team down. Luna: So what did Priya do? Lucas: She took a step back and asked the designer a few clarifying questions. She asked 'what's the ideal outcome for you when you get feedback?' And the designer said 'I want to know if I'm on the right track.' That was the key. She wasn't asking for design critiques. She was asking for reassurance. Luna: Ah, so it was more about recognition and confidence than actual skill development. Lucas: Exactly. Once Priya realized that, she shifted the conversation. They agreed on a weekly 30-minute design review where they'd look at the week's work together. And outside of that, Priya would only give feedback if something was truly off-track. The designer got her rhythm, and the team got their momentum back. Luna: That's a great example of diagnosing before prescribing. And I bet the designer also felt more empowered because she wasn't being checked on constantly. Lucas: Right. And that's the autonomy piece I mentioned earlier. When the designer realized she wasn't going to get feedback at every step, she started making more of her own decisions. She became more confident. And her design work actually improved because she was taking more ownership. Luna: So how do you know whether your feedback-hungry employee is just anxious or actually needs more guidance? Is there a diagnostic you can run? Lucas: I think the first step is to ask the question I just mentioned: 'What does good feedback look like to you?' Or even better, ask for a specific example. Say 'tell me about a time when feedback really helped you. What was it? What made it useful?' That gives you a window into what they're actually craving. Luna: That's a smart move. And I guess you can also observe whether they only ask for feedback when they're about to make a big decision, or if it's constant across all tasks. Lucas: Yeah, that's a good signal. If it's only before big decisions, it's probably anxiety about risk. If it's about every little thing, it might be a confidence issue or a need for clearer standards. And if they're asking for feedback on work that's already gone well, it's probably recognition. Luna: And recognition is a whole different conversation. That's about making sure praise is specific and timely, not just generic 'good job.' Lucas: Absolutely. And the final piece is setting boundaries. You don't want to create a monster where your employee is dependent on you for every little decision. So you have to be explicit about when feedback will happen and when it won't. You say 'I'll give you feedback at our weekly check-in, and if something is urgent, I'll come to you. But I trust you to make decisions in the meantime.' Luna: That takes a lot of courage, honestly. As a manager, you want to be helpful, so it's easy to fall into the trap of giving feedback on demand. But it's actually better for the employee to build that muscle themselves. Lucas: It is. And I think this ties back to that Gallup finding. The weekly check-in isn't just about giving feedback. It's about creating a safe space where feedback is expected, but it's also a space where the employee is expected to bring their own thoughts. You're building a partnership, not a dependency. Luna: So if someone's listening right now and thinking 'oh no, I have one of these employees,' what's the one thing you'd tell them to do tomorrow? Lucas: I'd say schedule a 30-minute conversation and ask that question: 'What does useful feedback look like to you?' And listen. Don't jump to solutions. Just listen. You'll probably learn that it's not actually about feedback at all. Luna: And if it is about clarity, you can set up a shared document or a checklist for 'what good looks like' for their role. Lucas: Exactly. And if it's about recognition, you can make a habit of calling out their accomplishments in team meetings or in your 1-1s. But the key is to understand the need before you react to the request. Luna: I think that's a really solid takeaway. It's not about giving more feedback. It's about giving the right kind of attention. Lucas: And that's the thing — managing people is never just about the surface ask. It's about what's underneath. So next time someone says 'I need more feedback,' take a breath, get curious, and you might just turn a feedback-hungry employee into a confident, autonomous one. Luna: Well said. Thanks for listening, everyone. We'll catch you next Monday.