Latest / Sleepy Facts About History / How Did a Young Artillery Captain Win the Siege of Toulon? - The Strategic Heights and the Recapture of Toulon | Sleepy Facts About History

Transcript

How Did a Young Artillery Captain Win the Siege of Toulon? - The Strategic Heights and the Recapture of Toulon | Sleepy Facts About History · Sleepy Facts About History

0:04
Welcome to Sleepy Facts About History. In late
0:12
1793, the French Republic faced a crisis when
0:16
the vital Mediterranean naval arsenal at Toulon
0:19
opened its gates to the British Royal Navy. Royalist
0:24
rebels had handed the port to an Anglo -Spanish
0:26
fleet, leaving the revolutionary government in
0:29
Paris desperate to recover its southern coast.
0:32
Out of the ensuing military siege emerged a 24
0:36
-year -old artillery captain named Napoleon Bonaparte,
0:39
whose argument to seize the commanding heights
0:42
overlooking the harbor transformed the failed
0:45
operation into a decisive, albeit brutal, republican
0:49
victory. This episode examines the strategic
0:53
geography of Toulon, the political chaos of the
0:56
revolutionary army, and the gruelling physical
0:59
labour required to position heavy siege guns
1:02
on steep, rocky terrain. It also explores the
1:06
violent repression that followed the French recapture,
1:08
a bloody episode later erased from the heroic
1:11
Napoleonic legend. By comparing contemporary
1:15
military records with the memoirs Napoleon dictated
1:18
in exile, the narrative separates the collective
1:21
military achievement from the retrospective myth
1:24
-making. I wanted to understand how a single
1:28
siege could simultaneously produce a horrific
1:31
act of revolutionary vengeance and launch the
1:34
career of the man who would become Emperor of
1:36
the French. Some historical events are remembered
1:40
not for what they were, but for what a powerful
1:43
survivor needed them to be. Join me for a calm
1:47
and clear -eyed look at the gap between the historical
1:50
reality of Toulon and the legend that followed.
1:56
In late 1793, a 24 -year -old artillery captain
2:01
argued that the revolutionary army besieging
2:03
Toulon was fighting on the wrong ground. In doing
2:07
so, he placed himself at the intersection of
2:09
technical competence, political patronage, and
2:13
a revolutionary crisis. That crisis would soon
2:17
allow him to rewrite the story entirely. In late
2:21
August of 1793, The great Mediterranean naval
2:25
arsenal of Toulon did something almost unthinkable
2:28
for a French port. It opened its gates to the
2:31
British Royal Navy. Royalist rebels in the city,
2:35
determined to undo the revolution and restore
2:38
the monarchy, admitted an Anglo -Spanish fleet
2:41
under Admiral Samuel Hood and Admiral Juan de
2:44
Langara. Within days, British and Spanish sailors
2:48
occupied the forts. French royalist émigrés manned
2:52
the walls. The tricolour came down. The message
2:57
to Paris was unmistakable. The Republic had not
3:01
merely lost a battle. It had lost its principal
3:05
southern arsenal to foreign occupation and internal
3:08
counter -revolution. The coalition against it
3:11
grew more formidable by the week. To understand
3:15
what happened next. And why a 24 -year -old artillery
3:19
captain named Napoleon Bonaparte emerged from
3:22
the ensuing siege with a general's rank, we need
3:25
to look carefully at the harbor itself. Picture
3:29
Toulon as a bowl held in the land. The town and
3:34
the inner harbor, the Petit Rady, sit at the
3:37
bottom, close together. Beyond them, separated
3:41
by a narrow channel, stretches the Grande Rade.
3:45
the outer anchorage, where a fleet can shelter
3:47
in deep water. The whole system is commanded
3:51
from the surrounding heights that rise like the
3:53
rim of that bowl. Fort La Malgaie, Fort Balaguir,
3:58
Fort La Guillette and the promontory of Cap Brune
4:01
all overlook the water from their elevated positions.
4:05
Whoever holds those heights holds the harbour.
4:08
Whoever holds the harbour holds the Mediterranean
4:11
coast of France. Holding the town without the
4:15
heights is like holding the floor of a stadium
4:18
while the enemy controls the upper tiers. The
4:22
British understood this immediately when they
4:24
occupied the forts in August. The revolutionary
4:27
army sent to retake the port would have to learn
4:30
it through failure. The political context made
4:34
the military problem desperate. In 1793, the
4:38
French Republic faced what historians call the
4:41
First Coalition. Britain. Austria, Prussia, Spain,
4:46
Sardinia, Naples and the Dutch Republic were
4:50
all arrayed against it. Simultaneously, the Republic
4:54
confronted internal revolt. The Vendée rose in
4:58
the West. Federalist uprisings erupted in Lyon,
5:02
Marseille, Bordeaux and other cities, driven
5:04
by hostility to Jacobin centralization. Toulon's
5:09
revolt was distinct. Their royalist sections
5:13
of the city supported by naval officers loyal
5:16
to the monarchy, had actively invited foreign
5:19
intervention. The Committee of Public Safety
5:22
in Paris, the effective revolutionary government,
5:25
regarded the loss of Toulon as catastrophic.
5:28
The Mediterranean fleet, the naval stores, the
5:33
arsenal itself, all were in enemy hands. Recovery
5:37
became an imperative of revolutionary survival.
5:42
The army sent to besiege Toulon reflected the
5:45
chaos of the moment. General Jean -Francois Cateau
5:48
commanded it. He was a former painter, a man
5:52
of limited military experience, who had risen
5:55
through revolutionary enthusiasm rather than
5:58
professional training. His army was a mixture
6:01
of regular units, volunteers, and raw conscripts,
6:05
variable in quality and uncertain in loyalty.
6:09
The artillery arm, technically the most demanding
6:12
branch of warfare, suffered particular shortages.
6:15
Many aristocratic officers had emigrated, taking
6:19
their expertise with them. Heavy guns, gunners,
6:23
ammunition, and the engineering skills needed
6:26
to position siege batteries, all were scarce.
6:30
Overseeing everything were the representants
6:33
and mission political commissioners sent from
6:35
Paris to ensure revolutionary zeal. report on
6:38
commanders and enforce the will of the convention.
6:42
At Toulon, these included Paul Barras, Louis
6:46
-Marie Stanislas Fréron, Augustine Robespierre
6:49
and Antoine -Christophe Salicetti. They watched
6:53
Carteau with suspicion. They corresponded constantly
6:57
with Paris. They held the power to arrest or
7:01
denounce any officer who seemed insufficiently
7:04
committed to the Republic. Into this situation,
7:08
in september 1793 came napoleon bonaparte he
7:13
arrived almost by accident the artillery commander
7:17
of the besieging army had been wounded saliceti
7:21
a fellow corsican who knew the bonaparte family
7:23
from their shared homeland arranged for napoleon
7:27
to take his place napoleon was not unknown to
7:30
himself as a man of ambition but he was unknown
7:34
to france Born in 1769 in Corsica, trained at
7:39
the military schools at Brienne and the École
7:42
Militaire in Paris, he had served in the artillery
7:45
regiment of La Fere. His family had fled Corsica
7:49
after aligning with the French Republic against
7:52
Pasquale Paoli's pro -British independence movement.
7:55
Now he found himself at a siege that was, by
7:59
most measures, failing. What Napoleon saw at
8:03
Toulon. and what he argued from his first days
8:06
there was that the revolutionary army was fighting
8:09
on the wrong axis. Cato and his predecessors
8:14
had directed their efforts toward the town itself,
8:17
toward the low ground and the direct approaches.
8:21
Napoleon, trained in the technical geography
8:24
of fortification and artillery, recognized immediately
8:28
that the harbor was the key. He also recognized
8:31
that the harbor was controlled from the heights.
8:35
Specifically, the heights of Les Guillettes and
8:38
Balogier on the western shore of the outer anchorage
8:41
offered positions from which French artillery
8:43
could fire directly into the Grande Rade. If
8:48
those heights were taken and fortified, the Allied
8:51
fleet would be exposed to plunging fire. The
8:55
anchorage would become untenable. The fleet would
8:58
have to withdraw. The town, however strongly
9:01
held, would eventually fall. This was not, it
9:05
must be said, a revelation that came to Napoleon
9:08
alone in a flash of solitary genius. The strategic
9:12
importance of the Western Heights was visible
9:15
to other officers who reconnoitered the ground.
9:18
The geography of Toulon was not a secret. What
9:22
Napoleon brought was a combination of technical
9:25
competence, argumentative energy, and the willingness
9:28
to organize the material means to execute the
9:31
plan. He argued persistently with Carteau, with
9:35
the commissioners, with anyone who would listen.
9:38
He requisitioned guns from nearby arsenals. He
9:43
improvised a siege train. He began positioning
9:46
batteries where the revolutionary army had previously
9:49
seen only impassable terrain. The material constraints
9:54
were severe. Siege artillery, the heavy guns,
9:58
mortars and howitzers needed to breach fortifications
10:01
or command anchorages. requires enormous labor
10:05
to move and in place each gun weighs tons the
10:10
roads around toulon were rough the ground was
10:14
rocky and steep guns had to be dragged into position
10:18
by teams of horses and men straining against
10:21
the incline often under allied fire from the
10:24
forts and from british naval guns the work was
10:28
done in the cold and wet of late autumn soldiers
10:32
slept in the open or in rough earthworks that
10:35
offered little protection from wind and rain.
10:38
Once in position, the guns needed protection.
10:42
Earthworks were thrown up by shovel and pick.
10:46
Gabions, wicker baskets filled with earth, were
10:49
stacked to absorb shot. Fascines, bundled brushwood,
10:53
were used to stabilize the muddy ground. Ammunition
10:57
had to be hauled up as well. Powder magazines
11:00
had to be constructed. Gunners had to be trained
11:04
or retrained, for the Revolutionary Army had
11:07
lost many of its technically proficient soldiers.
11:10
The sound of French batteries opening fire would
11:13
be answered by the deeper reports of Allied naval
11:16
guns. The exchange would continue through the
11:20
shortening days as the ring slowly tightened.
11:23
Napoleon threw himself into this work with conspicuous
11:27
energy. Contemporary reports, from de Gaumier
11:30
and from the commissioners, credit him with organizing
11:34
the artillery with a professionalism that had
11:37
been lacking. He named batteries for revolutionary
11:40
symbols. The battery of the convention, the battery
11:44
of the sans -culottes. These were not merely
11:47
gestures of political conformity. They were also
11:51
signals to the commissioners that the artillery
11:53
arm was ideologically reliable. This mattered
11:57
enormously in an army where political suspicion
11:59
could destroy a career or a life. Under his direction,
12:04
the French ring around Toulon gradually tightened.
12:07
Batteries on the western heights began to fire
12:10
into the outer anchorage, making the allied position
12:13
increasingly uncomfortable. The situation changed
12:17
in November 1793 when Carteau was replaced. His
12:22
failures, his conflicts with the commissioners,
12:25
and his inability to produce results had become
12:28
intolerable to Paris. General Jacques -François
12:32
Dugommier took command. He was a different kind
12:36
of officer, experienced in colonial campaigns
12:39
in the Caribbean, professionally competent, and
12:42
willing to listen to technical advice. Dugommier
12:46
endorsed the plan to seize the heights. He organized
12:50
the infantry assault columns. He provided the
12:54
command authority that Napoleon, as a captain
12:57
and then a major, could not exercise. The relationship
13:01
between the two men appears to have been genuinely
13:04
collaborative. Dugamier had the rank and the
13:08
political standing. Napoleon had the technical
13:11
knowledge and the energy. Together they prepared
13:14
the decisive blow. The target was Fort Mulgrave,
13:19
called Little Gibraltar by the British, situated
13:22
on the promontory of Cap Brune. The British commander
13:26
who had strengthened its defences gave it his
13:28
name. The fort was the key to the western heights.
13:33
If it fell, the French could place guns on the
13:36
promontory itself, dominating the entire outer
13:40
anchorage. The Allied Council of War, meeting
13:44
aboard Hood's flagship, understood this perfectly.
13:47
They had reinforced the fort. They had strengthened
13:52
its earthworks. They had garrisoned it with British,
13:56
Spanish and French emigre troops. Its capture
14:00
would require a coordinated assault by multiple
14:02
columns, supported by the heaviest artillery
14:05
fire the Revolutionary Army could muster. The
14:09
attack came on the night of December 1617 -1793.
14:14
The weather was appalling. Rain fell steadily,
14:17
driven by a cold wind off the Mediterranean.
14:20
The ground, already rough and steep, dissolved
14:24
into mud that clung to boots and made every step
14:27
a struggle. Soldiers slipped and fell on the
14:30
wet rock, cursing in the darkness, often losing
14:34
their footing entirely and sliding backward down
14:37
the slope. The French batteries opened fire to
14:40
suppress the fort's defenses. In such conditions,
14:44
artillery support was necessarily imprecise.
14:47
The flashes of the guns were visible through
14:50
the rain. The reports rolled off the hills. The
14:55
fall of shot was impossible to adjust. Multiple
14:59
columns attacked simultaneously from different
15:01
directions, each one struggling to maintain cohesion
15:05
in the chaos. Dugommier commanded the overall
15:08
operation from a position where he could see
15:10
little. Colonel Antoine de la Poipée led one
15:14
column. Other officers, whose names have largely
15:18
disappeared from the later legend, commanded
15:21
others. Napoleon was with the artillery directing
15:25
the fire. He then joined the assault itself.
15:28
Moving through the dark were the same columns
15:30
of exhausted men. The fighting was brutal and
15:35
confused. Night, rain, mud, and the steep terrain
15:39
made any kind of coordinated maneuver nearly
15:42
impossible. Men fought at close quarters with
15:46
bayonets, pikes, and spontoon spears in the trenches
15:49
and on the slopes. They were often unable to
15:52
distinguish friend from enemy until they were
15:55
upon them, the defenders knowing what the fort's
15:58
loss would mean. resisted fiercely. They fired
16:02
down from the earthworks into the mass of struggling
16:05
attackers. Somewhere in this chaos, Napoleon
16:08
was wounded. Contemporary reports confirm a thrust
16:13
to the thigh, probably from a bayonet or spontoon.
16:16
The exact circumstances and severity remain unclear.
16:20
Later accounts, especially those derived from
16:24
his own memoirs, would embellish this wound.
16:28
making it a moment of heroic endurance. What
16:31
we can say with confidence is that he was hurt,
16:35
that he remained in the field and that the fort
16:38
fell after hours of desperate combat. The defenders
16:42
finally gave way as the French columns pressed
16:45
home their advantage through sheer persistence.
16:48
By morning, Fort Mulgrave was in French hands.
16:52
The immediate consequence was not the end of
16:55
the siege. But the transformation of the Allied
16:58
position, with the heights of Cap Brune lost,
17:02
and with French artillery now able to fire directly
17:05
into the Grande Rade, the anchorage had become
17:09
lethal for the fleet. The Allied Council of War
17:12
convened urgently. Hood and Langara, the Spanish
17:16
Admiral, along with the commanders of the various
17:19
land forces, faced a stark choice. They could
17:23
attempt to hold the town and inner harbour without
17:26
the outer anchorage. This would mean accepting
17:29
a naval blockade and eventual strangulation.
17:32
They could attempt to fight their way out past
17:35
the French batteries. This would mean exposing
17:38
the fleet to heavy fire in a confined channel.
17:42
Or they could evacuate, abandoning the town and
17:46
as many of their French loyalist allies as could
17:49
be embarked, and withdraw to Corsica. or other
17:53
Mediterranean bases. They chose evacuation. On
17:58
December 1718, the Allied fleet began to withdraw.
18:02
The withdrawal was not orderly. Ships were overloaded
18:06
with refugees, sitting low in the water, their
18:09
decks crowded with men and women who had thrown
18:12
themselves on the mercy of the departing fleet.
18:16
Stores and equipment were abandoned on the quays.
18:19
Most fatefully, the French ships in the arsenal,
18:23
Ships of the line that could not be sailed away
18:25
were burned or scuttled, along with the powder
18:28
magazines. The destruction was enormous. The
18:33
glow of the burning fleet was visible for miles
18:36
along the coast. A dull orange light reflected
18:40
in the clouds and the water, marking the material
18:43
cost of the victory. For the Republic, this was
18:47
a mixed blessing. The port was recovered, but
18:50
the fleet was largely destroyed and the arsenal
18:53
devastated. For the Allied commanders, it was
18:57
a strategic retreat that preserved their naval
18:59
forces, but abandoned their royalist allies to
19:02
revolutionary vengeance. The Revolutionary Army
19:06
entered Toulon on December 19, 1793. What followed
19:11
must not be minimized or treated as a footnote
19:14
to Napoleon's career. The Representation Barras
19:19
and Feiron, prominent among them, had determined
19:21
to make an example of the city. The convention
19:24
in Paris had decreed punishment for a town that
19:27
had betrayed the Republic to foreign enemies.
19:31
Revolutionary tribunals were established. Firing
19:34
squads worked methodically. The guillotine was
19:38
erected. Hundreds of talones were executed. Estimates
19:44
of the total dead vary from several hundred to
19:47
over a thousand. The exact figures remain uncertain
19:50
because revolutionary records are incomplete
19:53
and later accounts are politically charged. Thousands
19:57
more were imprisoned in makeshift conditions.
20:00
The city itself was renamed Port -le -Monton,
20:04
Mountain Port, in honor of the Jacobin faction
20:06
that dominated the revolutionary government.
20:09
Property was confiscated. Families were separated.
20:14
The harbor that had been recovered was also punished.
20:18
The human cost of the victory was immense. The
20:22
same revolutionary government that would promote
20:25
Napoleon for his competence at Toulon ordered
20:28
this repression. The same commissioners who recommended
20:31
his advancement supervised the executions. The
20:35
victory and the violence were inseparable products
20:37
of the revolutionary crisis. Any honest account
20:41
must hold them together. Napoleon's personal
20:45
trajectory diverged sharply from this destruction.
20:49
On December 22, 1793, he was promoted to Brigadier
20:53
General. He was 24 years old. The promotion came
20:58
on the recommendation of Dugourmier and the political
21:01
commissioners, particularly Salicetti. It reflected
21:05
both his demonstrated competence and his political
21:08
connections. We should not pretend to separate
21:11
these factors cleanly. Revolutionary France was
21:15
a place where technical skill and ideological
21:18
reliability both mattered. It was also a place
21:22
where patronage networks, especially those linking
21:25
Corsicans who had risen in the revolutionary
21:27
service, could accelerate careers dramatically.
21:31
Napoleon had shown that he could organize artillery,
21:35
argue for a plan, and execute it under fire.
21:39
He had also shown that he could navigate the
21:42
political environment of the revolutionary army.
21:45
with its suspicious commissioners and its deadly
21:47
stakes. The gap between what happened at Toulon
21:51
and what was later remembered about Toulon opened
21:54
almost immediately. It opened in part because
21:58
the same revolutionary government that ordered
22:00
the city's punishment also promoted the young
22:03
officer whose later legend would systematically
22:05
erase that punishment from memory. Contemporary
22:09
reports credited Dugommier and the army collectively.
22:13
The victory was understood as a triumph of revolutionary
22:16
arms, of the Republic's ability to overcome internal
22:19
treason and foreign invasion through mass mobilization
22:23
and determined leadership. Napoleon was mentioned
22:27
certainly. His energy was noted. His wound was
22:32
known. But he was one officer among many in a
22:35
collective achievement. This began to change
22:39
as Napoleon himself rose. The Italian campaign
22:43
of 1796 -1997 made him a national hero. The Egyptian
22:50
expedition, the coup of 18 Brumaire, the consulate,
22:53
the empire. Each stage of his ascent recast earlier
22:58
episodes in light of later greatness. By the
23:01
time he dictated his memoirs on Saint Helena,
23:04
exiled and defeated, the siege of Toulon had
23:07
become the first act of the Napoleonic epic.
23:11
In the accounts he gave to Las Casas, to Montelon,
23:15
to Gourgaud, he was the sole author of the plan
23:18
to seize the heights. He had argued against incompetent
23:22
commanders who could not see what he saw. He
23:25
had organized everything. He had led the assault.
23:30
He had been wounded heroically. The victory in
23:34
these retellings was prophetic, the first demonstration
23:37
of the military genius that would transform Europe.
23:41
This was retrospective self -fashioning, and
23:44
we must treat it as such. The memoirs dictated
23:48
on St. Helena were not neutral testimony. They
23:51
were the constructions of a man who had been
23:53
emperor, who had fallen, who was constructing
23:56
a historical justification for his life and reign.
23:59
They systematically inflated his role. They minimized
24:04
or erased the contributions of others. They transformed
24:08
contingent events into the unfolding of inevitable
24:11
genius. Bonapartist historiography in the 19th
24:16
century amplified this narrative. Toulon became,
24:19
in popular memory, the place where a young Napoleon
24:22
arrived, took command, and won his first victory
24:25
through sheer brilliance. Modern scholarship
24:29
has substantially revised this picture. The work
24:32
of historians like Jean Toulard and Patrice Guanaffy
24:37
Drawing on contemporary military correspondence,
24:40
the archives of the Committee of Public Safety,
24:43
British naval records, and the critical comparison
24:48
of multiple sources has restored the collective
24:51
nature of the victory. We can now see that the
24:54
plan to seize the heights emerged from reconnaissance
24:57
and debate, not from solitary inspiration. We
25:01
can see that Dugamier's command was essential.
25:05
The infantry assaults were carried out by multiple
25:08
columns under multiple officers. The political
25:11
commissioners enabled the operation through their
25:14
authority and their correspondence with Paris.
25:17
We can see that the Allied evacuation resulted
25:20
from military necessity, the loss of Fort Mulgrave
25:23
and the untenable anchorage, combined with Allied
25:26
command decisions and internal disagreements.
25:29
It did not result from the actions of any single
25:32
French officer. We can also see... More clearly
25:36
than the legend allowed, what Toulon actually
25:39
gave Napoleon. It gave him visibility, powerful
25:44
men in Paris, Dugomier, Salicetti, eventually
25:49
Brass knew his name. They knew he could organize
25:53
artillery, argue for a plan and execute it. They
25:58
knew he was politically reliable or at least
26:00
politically adept. This visibility combined with
26:04
his genuine technical competence and the extraordinary
26:07
opportunities that revolutionary crisis created
26:09
for rapid advancement, made his subsequent career
26:12
possible. Toulon did not make Napoleon inevitable.
26:17
Nothing made Napoleon inevitable. But Toulon
26:21
was the specific intersection where his skills
26:24
met a specific revolutionary opportunity. It
26:28
was where his name first appeared in the correspondence
26:30
of the powerful. The repression at Toulon, meanwhile.
26:35
dropped out of the Napoleonic narrative almost
26:37
entirely. The memoirs on Saint Helena do not
26:41
dwell on the executions, the renamed city, the
26:45
destroyed lives of the Toulonni. This silence
26:48
is itself significant. The legend required a
26:52
clean origin, a moment of pure military achievement,
26:56
unsullied by political violence. The reality
27:00
was messier, as reality usually is. The same
27:05
revolutionary government that promoted de Paulien
27:07
for his competence at Toulon ordered the repression
27:10
that followed. The same commissioners who recommended
27:14
his advancement supervised the executions. The
27:18
victory and the violence were inseparable products
27:20
of the revolutionary crisis. Any honest account
27:24
must hold them together. What remains uncertain,
27:29
even after careful historical work, is worth
27:32
acknowledging precisely. We do not know the exact
27:35
number of people executed or imprisoned after
27:38
the recapture. Revolutionary records are incomplete.
27:43
Later estimates vary widely according to political
27:46
inclination. We do not know the precise sequence
27:50
of decisions that led to the adoption of the
27:52
plan to seize the Heights. Napoleon's advocacy
27:56
was important, but the surviving correspondence
27:59
does not allow us to attribute the plan solely
28:01
or even primarily to him. We do not know the
28:06
exact nature and severity of his wound. Contemporary
28:09
reports confirm it happened. Later accounts differ
28:13
on the weapon, the circumstances, and the heroism.
28:17
We do not know, finally, the exact balance between
28:20
merit and patronage in his promotion. Both were
28:24
present. Both mattered. Their relative weight
28:28
is probably unknowable. The siege of Toulon,
28:32
then, was not the beginning of Napoleon's genius.
28:36
if by genius we mean some innate and inevitable
28:38
quality that would have manifested regardless
28:41
of circumstances it was the moment when a specific
28:45
technical skill artillery competence in seed
28:48
warfare met a specific revolutionary opportunity
28:51
that opportunity included the desperate need
28:55
to recover a mediterranean arsenal the shortage
28:58
of trained officers the political structures
29:01
that allowed rapid promotion and the patronage
29:05
networks that connected a Corsican captain to
29:08
Parisian commissioners. The victory was collective.
29:12
It was won by Dugommier's command, by the labor
29:16
of anonymous gunners and infantry, by the material
29:19
resources of the revolutionary state, and by
29:22
the mistakes and divisions of the allied occupiers.
29:26
The legend was constructed afterward by the most
29:29
powerful survivor and preserved by a memory culture
29:33
that needed heroic origins. When we look at Toulon
29:37
clearly, we see not a young Gempere in embryo,
29:41
but a young artillery captain who understood
29:44
fortification geography, who worked harder than
29:47
many of his colleagues, who argued for a plan
29:50
that was strategically sound, and who was lucky
29:54
enough to be noticed by men. who could advance
29:56
his career we see a siege that was brutal technically
30:01
demanding and collectively executed we see a
30:04
repression that was equally brutal and that formed
30:07
part of the same revolutionary violence and we
30:11
see in the gap between the event and its later
30:13
narration how quickly collective achievement
30:16
can be condensed into individual legend especially
30:19
when the individual in question becomes for a
30:22
time the most powerful man in europe