Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Were Promoted Without One
Transcript
- Lucas: So, Luna, we got a question from a listener named Priya, and it's one of those that makes you pause. She was promoted to team lead three months ago, title change, new responsibilities, managing two people, but her salary didn't move at all. Luna: Oof. That's a tough spot. Did she ask why, or is she just sitting on it? Lucas: She says she didn't push back at the time because she was excited about the title, but now she's starting to feel taken advantage of. And honestly, this is more common than you'd think. A 2024 survey from the Society for Human Resource Management found that about a third of promotions come without a pay increase. Luna: A third? That's surprisingly high. I'd have guessed maybe one in ten. Lucas: Right? And the reasons vary. Sometimes it's budget constraints, sometimes it's a messy internal equity situation, but a lot of the time it's just because the employee didn't ask. Companies often assume you'll accept the title as the reward. Luna: So what's the move? She's past the moment of the offer, so it feels like the window might have closed. Lucas: That's the key—the window isn't closed, it just needs a different approach. You can't go back and say 'actually, I want more money for the title you gave me.' But you can have a conversation framed around performance and market value. And timing matters. Three months in is actually a decent moment because she has some proof of what she's doing in the role. Luna: So it's less about 'I deserve a raise' and more about 'let's review where I am now'? Lucas: Exactly. And she needs to come with data. Not just 'I work hard.' She should look up comparable salaries for team leads in her industry and region. Sites like Glassdoor and Payscale give a range, but the strongest data is actual job postings for similar roles at other companies. If she can find three or four postings that show a range higher than her current salary, that's her anchor. Luna: Would you recommend she talk to HR or her manager first? Lucas: Manager first, always. HR is there to protect the company, not to advocate for her. Her manager is the one who sees her daily contribution and can champion her case in the comp review cycle. So she should set up a one-on-one and say something like: 'I'm really enjoying the team lead role, and I want to make sure I'm being compensated fairly for the scope I'm taking on. Can we review my salary?' Luna: That's a smooth way to phrase it. But what if the manager says 'we don't have budget right now'? That feels like a dead end. Lucas: It's a common objection, but not a dead end. She can ask when the budget cycle opens up, and then hold them to a timeline. Maybe there's a mid-year review in six months. She can also ask for non-monetary compensation in the meantime—like a professional development budget or an extra week of vacation. But the important thing is to get something concrete in writing, even if it's a commitment to revisit the salary at a specific date. Luna: Yeah, that makes sense. You don't want to walk away with just 'we'll see.' Lucas: Right, and there's a psychological angle too. The longer she works at that title without the pay, the more normalized it becomes. Companies start to think they can get the work at the lower rate. So she needs to break that pattern now. Luna: Before we go deeper into the conversation scripts, I just want to say—if this episode is helping you think through your own career moves, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Every little bit keeps this show ad-free, and we really appreciate it. Lucas: Yeah, it genuinely does make a difference. And thanks to those of you who've already chipped in—we see you. Luna: Alright, back to Priya. So what are some actual scripts she could use in that conversation? Lucas: Let's start with the opener. She could say: 'Since my promotion, I've been managing a team and taking on project ownership. I want to make sure my compensation reflects this new level of responsibility. Can we look at market data together?' That's specific and collaborative. Luna: That's good because it's not accusatory. It's like, 'help me understand our system.' Lucas: Exactly. And then if the manager asks for time to look into it, she should set a follow-up meeting right there. 'Great, let's circle back next Thursday.' If they say no, she can ask what would be needed to change that—maybe a performance milestone or a budget approval. That turns a 'no' into a path forward. Luna: What if the manager says something like 'you're new to the role, you need to prove yourself first'? Lucas: That's a common stall tactic, but she has a counter. She can say: 'I understand that, and I'm fully committed to proving my value. However, my responsibilities have already increased, and I'd like my compensation to reflect that from the start, not just after a trial period.' That's a strong, professional pushback. Luna: And if they still refuse? Does she have any options? Lucas: She can consider a few things. First, she could ask for a clear performance plan with measurable goals and a date for salary review. Second, she could look at whether the company has a formal policy on promotions and pay. Some companies have guidelines that say a promotion should come with a 10 percent increase, for example. If that's the case, she can reference it. And third—if nothing moves, she may need to think about whether this company values her fairly, and that could mean updating her resume. Luna: That's a real consequence. But I imagine most managers would rather work with her than lose her, especially if she's a good team lead. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's the leverage she has. A good manager knows that replacing a team lead is expensive—recruiting costs, training time, team disruption. So she shouldn't be afraid to have that unspoken fact in the room. It's not a threat; it's just reality. Luna: So what's the one thing you'd want Priya to take away from this episode? Lucas: That she's not wrong to ask, and that the longer she waits, the harder it gets. She has a window right now to reset her salary trajectory. If she lets it slide another year, she'll be underpaid for two years, and that compounds every time she changes jobs later. Luna: Right. Because her next employer will ask for her current salary as a reference point. Lucas: Exactly. That's why this conversation is so important. It's not just about this year's raise; it's about setting her baseline for the rest of her career. And the good news is, she has a solid case if she brings data and a collaborative tone. Luna: I'd add one thing: she should also document her achievements since the promotion, so she has concrete examples of her impact. Numbers help—like 'reduced turnaround time by 15 percent' or 'brought in three new clients.' Lucas: That's a perfect addition. And she should tie that impact to the company's goals, not just her own work. When she can say 'here's how I've helped the team hit its targets,' that's a convincing argument. Luna: So to recap: she should prepare data, set a formal meeting, use confident but collaborative language, and have a backup plan if they say no. Lucas: That's the framework. And if she does that, she'll at least get a clear answer, which is better than living in ambiguity. And if the answer is no, she knows where she stands and can make an informed decision about her future. Luna: Well said. Priya, if you're listening, you've got this. And for everyone else, we hope this helps you navigate your own promotion conversations. Lucas: And if you have a career question you'd like us to tackle, send it to us—we read every one. Until next time.