Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Workers' Compensation Settlement vs Trial: Strategies, Statutes, and Smart Decisions
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, and welcome to Workers' Compensation Settlement
- 0:06versus Trial, Strategies, Statutes, and Smart
- 0:10Decisions. I'm Michael Falotti, and I'm the chair
- 0:12of the Workers' Compensation Law Section. I'm
- 0:15an attorney at Grayward Kaplan, Vernick & Evans,
- 0:17and a certified specialist in Workers' Comp.
- 0:20Before I introduce today's speaker, I'd like
- 0:22to take a moment to plug the Workers' Comp section.
- 0:25The Workers' Comp section is a new and fast -growing
- 0:27section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:29I encourage all workers comp practitioners as
- 0:32well as practitioners in overlapping practices
- 0:34like personal injury and labor and employment
- 0:36to get involved with the section. For those interested
- 0:39in becoming more involved with the workers comp
- 0:41section, I encourage you to reach out to me or
- 0:43contact the Beverly Hills Bar Association help
- 0:45desk. We'll throw my email and the help desk's
- 0:48email in the chat. And now I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:51our speaker for today, Professor Michael Duff.
- 0:53Professor Duff, a 1995 graduate of Harvard Law
- 0:56School, directs the Weffel Center for Employment
- 0:59Law at the St. Louis University School of Law.
- 1:02Prior to entering into academia in 2006, Professor
- 1:06Duff practiced workers' compensation, personal
- 1:09injury, labor, and employment law in the federal
- 1:12government and with a private firm. He has settled
- 1:15and litigated many cases. Although he has written
- 1:18complex legal texts on theoretical subjects,
- 1:21as he has authored textbooks, law review articles,
- 1:24and bar journal pieces. He is also very well
- 1:27known as a practical lawyer who has resolved
- 1:29many straightforward legal disputes efficiently.
- 1:32And now let's get started. Thank you very much,
- 1:37Mr. Floddy. I appreciate the introduction. Before
- 1:41I even put slides up, let me just say that I
- 1:46learned when I was in my early communications
- 1:49with the Beverly Hills Bar Association, and I
- 1:51want to thank them for inviting me. I learned
- 1:56that my cousin, I have a cousin by marriage who's
- 2:01been affiliated with the Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 2:05Emily Chappelle Edelman. who I understand has
- 2:07been a lawyer in the area for a long time. And
- 2:11so I wanted to mention her name. And I did want
- 2:16to say that the spirit of my presentation was
- 2:22caught very well because I prefer to do what
- 2:30is theoretical and what is practical. And that's
- 2:34how I talk about workers' compensation. That's
- 2:36how I think about workers' compensation. So I'm
- 2:44booting up the slides here. One second. All right,
- 2:53Professor Duff, it looks like we're seeing the
- 2:55other end of the screen. Yeah, I'm trying to
- 2:58get it switched around here. Here we go. Here
- 3:05we go. All right. So I want to say something
- 3:11about myself. because I think it's important
- 3:13when you're talking about a topic to understand
- 3:15who you're talking to. For reasons of bias, emphases,
- 3:23I talk about workers' comp in a very particular
- 3:26kind of way. My grandfather died from black lung.
- 3:31He was a coal miner. He died from disease. I
- 3:34was once a Teamster -represented airline worker.
- 3:38I've been involved in workers' comp cases for
- 3:41a long, long time. But you know, when I first
- 3:43started doing them, I was not, I had not gone
- 3:46to law school. I was not a lawyer. So I was involved
- 3:49in workers' comp cases as a union shop steward.
- 3:52And that was really my introduction to a lot
- 3:55of workers' compensation ideas. concepts and
- 3:59the introduction that I had to Worker's Comp
- 4:02settlement because we were actually involved
- 4:06in Worker's Comp cases before there was even
- 4:09any attorney involvement. I attended Harvard
- 4:12Law School from 1992 to 1995 and it was an interesting
- 4:18experience. I went to school, I won't name drop,
- 4:22but I went to school with a lot of people that
- 4:23I liked and didn't like very much, but I learned
- 4:26a lot. And while I was attending law school,
- 4:30I was a law clerk for the Massachusetts Department
- 4:33of Industrial Accidents. And yeah, I worked full
- 4:37-time in the summer for them, worked part -time
- 4:40during the school years, learned a lot about
- 4:43workers' compensation, learned a lot about things
- 4:46not to say to judges, used to watch judges turn
- 4:50red when lawyers... were making certain kinds
- 4:54of arguments. And I learned more about the pragmatic
- 4:58side of settlement doing that than I ever did
- 5:02in law school. But I was exposed in that environment
- 5:07really deeply to workers' comp and workers' compensation
- 5:13nuance and had a lot of exposure to the mechanics
- 5:21of settlement. which can differ, as I'll discuss,
- 5:25a great deal from state to state. I should also
- 5:29say, and it's funny, I didn't get it on the slide,
- 5:33but when I left workers' comp practice to serve
- 5:39with the federal government at the National Labor
- 5:42Relations Board, I had about 450 cases, about
- 5:4675 of which were active. And so I settled, settled,
- 5:53settled, and I tried, tried, tried, and I was
- 5:55constantly adhering and deposing and settling
- 5:58a lot of cases. And that's when, you know, I
- 6:02learned from a non -theoretical perspective how
- 6:06important it was to have some sense of what was
- 6:09going on in settlement. Now, I'm at a little
- 6:13bit of a disadvantage here because I don't know
- 6:15who my audience is, right? And so I'm going to
- 6:17say some things about settlement. um that may
- 6:20be simplistic to those of you who are who are
- 6:23very experienced um but i because i don't know
- 6:27who's in the room i'm going to say them anyhow
- 6:28and i hope you'll indulge me right um workers
- 6:31comp involves um lots of actors is this true
- 6:36with any law practice. You're constantly dealing
- 6:40with insurance adjusters and lawyers, advocates,
- 6:45others. When I teach my workers comp class, which
- 6:49I have here at St. Louis University School of
- 6:53Law, I spend a lot of time explaining to my students
- 6:57that especially with respect to claimants lawyers,
- 7:01but really with both sides, whether it's claimants
- 7:06lawyers, insurance company lawyers, you spend
- 7:08time talking to, for example, adjusters. And
- 7:13so it's important to be able to communicate,
- 7:17right? It's important to know who everybody is.
- 7:20It's important if you're going to have a settlement
- 7:21discussion to know what the interests of parties
- 7:25are. And those of you who are involved in alternative
- 7:30dispute resolution ADR areas know that this is
- 7:35something that's frequently discussed. I mean,
- 7:37we can talk about nuts and bolts and dollars
- 7:41and cents. and we will, but it's very important
- 7:45to know who everybody is. And I've done a lot
- 7:52of labor law and we talk in labor law about interest
- 7:55-based negotiation. Not everybody has the same
- 7:59interest or is coming from the same place. And
- 8:02we have to try to get to yes, but it can be difficult
- 8:05to get to yes if we don't know what everybody's
- 8:10motivations are. And we need to know going in.
- 8:14And because I'm somebody who's tried a lot of
- 8:16cases, I just want to say that I understand and
- 8:20I'm sure you understand some cases will go to
- 8:24trial. Maybe they have to go to trial. You know,
- 8:27there's an emotional component. There's some
- 8:29kind of a novel issue. Nobody really knows what
- 8:33the outcome of that issue is going to be. That's
- 8:37certainly not most cases. And again, I apologize
- 8:40if I'm stating the obvious, but you know, as
- 8:43in every area of practice, 95 % of cases are
- 8:47gonna settle, right? Settlement is really what
- 8:51we're doing, which is another thing, by the way.
- 8:53We don't say often enough in law school, in my
- 8:56humble opinion. Sometimes everything about a
- 9:02case has to do with cost savings. You have somebody
- 9:05who's permanently, totally disabled, and they're
- 9:10going to be out of work potentially for a very
- 9:12long time. And so from the insurance company's
- 9:16point of view, it's a cost savings issue. Sometimes
- 9:20what we're really talking about is liability
- 9:24avoidance, right? Looking at the potential for
- 9:28the case that's in front of us to serve as precedent
- 9:31for some future dispute or class of disputes.
- 9:35And so we're thinking about avoiding liability
- 9:38into the future. I have represented lots of injured
- 9:44workers who fear. abandonment. I don't think
- 9:47that's too strong a word to use. They're afraid
- 9:50that what's going to happen is that the system
- 9:52will cast them off and they will be left with
- 9:56nothing and they are going to get really unfairly
- 10:02treated. When you have this kind of diversity
- 10:07of emotions at play in the settlement discussions,
- 10:13there's obviously the potential for misunderstanding.
- 10:17for hostility, for really not even being able
- 10:22to get down to the issues because everybody is
- 10:26so at odds with everybody else. It's an important
- 10:30thing, I think, to keep in mind. It's really
- 10:33hard to settle when parties fundamentally distrust
- 10:36each other. Now, when I was representing injured
- 10:40workers, eventually I would be able to explain
- 10:43to the worker, like, listen, this is You know,
- 10:46I understand the feelings, the feelings that
- 10:49are going on here, but what we're talking about
- 10:51is your ability to support yourself and your
- 10:54family, as the case may be, out into the future.
- 10:59So that's something that we talk about in every
- 11:04settlement environment. Now, the next thing,
- 11:07and again, I apologize, this is kind of a big
- 11:10picture idea, but I want to just for a second,
- 11:15I'm interested to hear that the section is new,
- 11:20right? And so maybe I can do a little service
- 11:23for the workers comp section here of the Beverly
- 11:26Hills Bar Association. Workers compensation.
- 11:30I think most folks who are listening to my voice
- 11:34know what workers compensation is, right? It
- 11:37is essentially a substitute for tort, for personal
- 11:44injury. And we often call it, workers' comp is
- 11:48the quid pro quo for releasing tort claims. And
- 11:54it's a system that's been in place. for about
- 11:57a little over a century. I remember 10 years
- 12:00ago, I had the honor of appearing at a number
- 12:04of Workers' Comp century celebrations around
- 12:07the country and speaking. But that's really what
- 12:12we're talking about, right? I tell my students,
- 12:15you know, you can get injured out on the street.
- 12:17or you can get injured in the workplace, as broadly
- 12:20defined. And if you're injured in the workplace,
- 12:22you're not covered by personal injury. You're
- 12:24covered by workers' compensation. And because
- 12:29of that... the stakes can be quite high. If somebody
- 12:33is seriously injured, you've got workers who
- 12:38are either totally or partially disabled. They're
- 12:42not going to be able to work either temporarily
- 12:46or permanently. And so you have workers who are
- 12:52in need of reasonable medical treatment that
- 12:56is related to the work -related injury. And this
- 13:01can be quite complicated. I mean, there are a
- 13:04number of issues that come up, whether the disability
- 13:08that somebody is suffering has been caused by
- 13:11work, as we say, has been sustained, has arisen
- 13:15out of, or has suffered in the course of employment.
- 13:20That sounds, when you first listen to it, like
- 13:23it might be a straightforward inquiry. Often
- 13:25it's not a straightforward inquiry, right? There
- 13:27can be all kinds of issues. about whether somebody's
- 13:30injury, the injury that's there before you has
- 13:33been caused by work. And then the medical treatment
- 13:39itself that's due, oftentimes that can be handled
- 13:44by statute, depending on the state. Usually we
- 13:50don't have to, in individual cases fight about
- 13:53what's reasonable, but that's not always true.
- 13:59Generally speaking, we're not going to get settlement
- 14:02until a worker has reached something called maximum
- 14:06medical improvement or MMI. The worker is as
- 14:11good as they're going to get. The medical evidence
- 14:14shows that they're not going to get better. And
- 14:16when you think about it, this makes sense because
- 14:19we don't know. whether a worker has stabilized
- 14:25enough to kind of take a snapshot of their disability.
- 14:29So we don't know how hurt they are and we don't
- 14:31know what their medical condition is going to
- 14:37be out into the future, right? And there can
- 14:39be disputes over whether a worker has reached
- 14:42maximum medical improvement. There are reasons
- 14:44that a worker may not. uh want to have been want
- 14:48to be found to have reached MMI um there are
- 14:51reasons an insurance company won't want the worker
- 14:54to have reached MMI or there are reasons that
- 14:56um both parties might have to be found at MMI
- 15:00but the point is it can be a complicated issue
- 15:03and it's something that can come up in settlement
- 15:05now typically You can't really even settle a
- 15:09workers' comp case until you know how hurt the
- 15:13worker is. And I'll give you a little bit of
- 15:15trivia here. When workers' comp was initially
- 15:20created in the United States about the beginning
- 15:25of the second decade of the 20th century, one
- 15:29of the things it had to be contended with were
- 15:33workers who waived injury, waived actions, waived
- 15:40compensation before they had even been hurt.
- 15:45And, you know, so, but if you want to get a job.
- 15:48right? Can I have a worker waive their entitlement
- 15:52to workers' comp as a condition of getting the
- 15:55job in the first place? And it would shock nobody
- 15:58in the 21st century that the answer to that is
- 16:01no. But it wasn't so clear in 1909 or 1910. And
- 16:07it's interesting that I'm saying, well, you can't
- 16:11have somebody settle their workers' comp case
- 16:13until they know how hurt they are. I'm saying
- 16:15that there was a time that they would settled
- 16:18cases before they had a case. And suffice to
- 16:22say, the settlements weren't especially good.
- 16:27Universally, this involves calculating a benefit,
- 16:31involves a series of steps. And straightforwardly,
- 16:37you have to figure out what the average wage
- 16:41of the injured worker was at the time they were
- 16:43hurt. I say straightforwardly, like in every
- 16:48other endeavor, this can become complicated given
- 16:51the right set of facts. But what was the person
- 16:54making at the time they were hurt? And in most
- 16:57states in the United States, we have a formula
- 17:00that is, well, roughly two thirds of the average
- 17:04weekly wage capped at or near the state average
- 17:10weekly wage, in other words, the average wage
- 17:13for all workers in a state. So if you're a very
- 17:16high earner and you don't have private medical
- 17:22insurance, and you got hurt on the job, workers
- 17:25comp is going to pretty severely undercompensate
- 17:29you because no matter how hurt you are, you're
- 17:31gonna be capped at some maximum. And I went online
- 17:36a couple of nights ago and learned that the cap
- 17:38right now in California is $1 ,764 a week. And
- 17:43having numbers like that is important because
- 17:47if a claimant comes into your office, and says,
- 17:50I've been hurt and has an idea in his or her
- 17:55mind that they're about to become very wealthy
- 17:59because they've been hurt at work. Maybe I can
- 18:03debate the equities with the client if I have
- 18:05time, but essentially, that's all you're going
- 18:08to get. You're not going to get more than that
- 18:12total amount. The as I've been suggesting and
- 18:18what I've been saying so far settlements have
- 18:22to account for both indemnity and medical payments.
- 18:26Let me expand on that a little bit. An indemnity
- 18:29payment is the cash payment that the injured
- 18:31worker gets. I said it's a maximum of $1 ,764
- 18:36a week right now. So that's one component of
- 18:39workers' compensation. But the other component
- 18:42of workers' compensation involves medical payments,
- 18:45right? And in an era of medical inflation, you
- 18:50know, the medical component of a worker's comp
- 18:53claim can exceed the indemnity portion of the
- 18:57claim, depending on the facts and how long the
- 19:00person's expected to be injured. So both of these
- 19:06things are present in worker's comp claims and
- 19:10complicate the settlement of the claims, because
- 19:13you might be very readily able to determine indemnity
- 19:17with the cash payment. be. That sounds like a
- 19:20relatively simple math problem, but the medical
- 19:22payments can be very difficult even if the worker
- 19:26has reached MMI or maximum medical improvement.
- 19:31And everything that I'm saying here tracks with
- 19:34the California settlement structure. Now, when
- 19:37I was asked by the Bar Association to come in
- 19:41and talk about California, I pointed out immediately,
- 19:44as you would imagine, that, well, I'm not a California
- 19:47lawyer, right? So you can sort of anticipate
- 19:51that what I'm gonna say might be analogous to
- 19:54the kinds of remarks that a judge would make.
- 19:57And you might be thinking as I'm talking, well,
- 19:59that's not the way it works. That's not the way
- 20:01it works. And you may be right, okay? But I'm
- 20:04in a distance, I'm in steamy, humid St. Louis
- 20:07right now, looking at the, statute on Westlaw,
- 20:11and my eyes are relatively good. So I'm looking
- 20:15at the statute. I want to say something about
- 20:20medical considerations. Before I put any text
- 20:23up there on that slide, I want to tell you that
- 20:28Medical is, you know, a huge component of workers'
- 20:32compensation. I've already said it. It's huge
- 20:35for determining things like causation with somebody's,
- 20:40whatever their physical condition is right now,
- 20:42whatever the disability is, was it caused medically
- 20:44by work? So it's important for that reason. But
- 20:48it's also important for benefit calculation depending
- 20:52on where you are. Okay, now there are some states
- 20:56that have incapacity or disability structures
- 21:01that will basically not directly involve medical
- 21:07consideration. So I'll explain what I mean in
- 21:09a minute. But in some states, if you wanted to
- 21:12figure out how partially disabled somebody was,
- 21:16what you would do is figure out, well, how much
- 21:18can they make now? How much did they used to
- 21:20be able to make? let's subtract one number from
- 21:24the other number and then take a percentage like
- 21:2766 and two -thirds of that number and that's
- 21:30your permanent partial disability benefit, right?
- 21:34That seems simple enough, right? A couple of
- 21:37subtraction problems and a percentage problem
- 21:39and boom, there you have it, right? But over
- 21:42a long period of time, And we don't have time
- 21:44to go through the history, but over a long period
- 21:46of time, what happened was many states did away
- 21:51with calculating partial disability in that way.
- 21:56So what they would do is they would say, well,
- 21:58look, if you've got a bad shoulder, let's take
- 22:02the shoulder. There's a certain number of weeks
- 22:05that we're going to arbitrarily say that shoulder
- 22:07is worth in the grand world of workers' compensation.
- 22:12we're gonna simply pay you that number of weeks
- 22:15of workers' compensation. And you know, if you
- 22:16look at it in a statute, I don't care what state
- 22:19you're in, you look at states that have that
- 22:21kind of system, it looks kind of bizarre. It
- 22:22looks like something from out of the Middle Ages,
- 22:25like a shoulder is worth 222 weeks. You know,
- 22:30the tip of your finger is worth a certain number
- 22:33of weeks. You know, your arm is worth a certain
- 22:37number of weeks, right? But basically there is
- 22:39this kind of structure that drives a lot of what
- 22:44goes on in workers' comp, because depending on
- 22:47how, now I'm gonna use a new word, impaired you
- 22:51are, that's gonna affect how much money you're
- 22:55gonna get as somebody who isn't totally disabled.
- 22:58Now, what we're looking at when we do medical
- 23:02evaluations in California, and it's similar in
- 23:06many states, is you first gotta get a medical
- 23:09evaluation. uh that's performed by somebody called
- 23:12a qualified medical examiner right so they're
- 23:16gonna they're gonna look at the workplace injury
- 23:19gonna look at the impact on the worker's ability
- 23:22to perform uh their job and then that examiner
- 23:26is going to assign a percentage that indicates
- 23:29the severity of the disability right so so what
- 23:33i tell my students is um there is this and i
- 23:36mean no disrespect but there is this big bible
- 23:40called the American Medical Association guides
- 23:43to the evaluation of permanent impairment. And
- 23:45what happens is the doctor sees what the worker
- 23:49is or not. Is or is not able to do with say their
- 23:53shoulder or their arm and they go into these
- 23:56books and they determine How hurt the person
- 23:59is according to the rating system set up by these
- 24:03books and by the way You could easily go to a
- 24:07week -long class centered simply on reading these
- 24:11these books I don't even attempt it with my students
- 24:14and I'm not going to attempt it with you, but
- 24:16I will say that when that impairment rate rating
- 24:19is determined. Then there's some adjustment made
- 24:23for age and occupation. So like if somebody you'd
- 24:26say somebody is has a certain impairment where
- 24:29you say, but you know, This person, they only
- 24:32have a high school diploma. They have no college
- 24:34at all. Or they have a GED. They didn't graduate
- 24:37from high school. They have a history of heavy
- 24:40physical labor. That person is not going to be
- 24:45rate the same in terms of the disability, how
- 24:48disabled we're going to find them, as the person
- 24:51who has a PhD in physics and is doing high energy
- 24:56subatomic particle acceleration or something,
- 24:59right? They may not be disabled, even though
- 25:02they're as physically impaired or messed up,
- 25:05right? So there's a lot of fine tuning that goes
- 25:10on here. The impairment rating is converted into
- 25:14a disability rating, and then the zero to 100
- 25:18% higher percentage indicates a more severe disability.
- 25:22Obviously, There is a great deal of resort to
- 25:27medical evidence here. And a lot of what we cover,
- 25:30by the way, in a workers comp class, at least
- 25:33in my class, are disputes between medical opinions.
- 25:38You know, we may wind up with the calculation
- 25:41you're being shown there, which is two thirds
- 25:43of the worker's average weekly earnings. But
- 25:45boy, oh boy, there's going to be an awful lot
- 25:48of conflict that's going to arise in just sort
- 25:51of trying to assess the physical condition of
- 25:55that worker. Now, one of the things that we've
- 26:01sort of, you know, when I was asked, well, What
- 26:05do you think is a good idea to do a CLE on? And
- 26:10the release of claims is a perennial favorite
- 26:14in many places where I've done these types of
- 26:16presentations. And I want to start off by telling
- 26:19you, in California, I think the proper mindset
- 26:27for an attorney in California is to be cautious.
- 26:29Let me explain what I mean before I put another
- 26:32line of text up. um in many states okay the idea
- 26:37is look um if you have a worker who has been
- 26:40injured at work right and they also have a bunch
- 26:44of other uh employment claims you know um they
- 26:47just filed a bunch of claims um uh and um can
- 26:52i just make it all go away by writing a check.
- 26:58I don't want to point my finger at any states,
- 27:02but let's just say there are some states that
- 27:05don't really supervise that kind of thing very
- 27:09vigorously. They have the mindset that any kind
- 27:15of supervision of settlements smacks of paternalism.
- 27:19Now I have some things I could say about that.
- 27:21I won't. I'll behave myself. But California really
- 27:26is not that. And I'm referencing here California
- 27:30Labor Code 2804. And what that is is a very clear
- 27:38section of the California Labor Code that is
- 27:41basically issuing the possibility of simply waiving
- 27:49claims. Right. So there's a jet. Now, this is
- 27:52the overall labor code. This isn't a workers
- 27:55comp provision per se. Right. This is the labor
- 27:58code. Now, what this is communicating, I think,
- 28:01to to everybody is, look, you're not just going
- 28:05to come in and get workers to waive claims. That's
- 28:08not the kind of system we're setting up here.
- 28:10Right. And that's what 2804 is is setting up
- 28:15here. Now, in addition to that, and that's all
- 28:19talk about with a little more granularity in
- 28:21a minute. To settle or release a worker's comp
- 28:25claim, there's a specific form that's needed
- 28:29under the compromise and release agreement structure
- 28:32that requires approval. from the California Department
- 28:36of Industrial Relations or in some context from
- 28:39a judge, from a referee, however styled, there
- 28:43is supervision of workers comp settlements, right?
- 28:49That's an important thing for a lawyer to know.
- 28:51If I had a student who told me I'm going off
- 28:54to California to practice workers comp, what
- 28:57is it that, what general advice can you give
- 28:59me when I got it? So well, Be careful because
- 29:04the communication here is that this is being
- 29:07supervised. In many instances, an employer may
- 29:14want to negotiate an any and all waiver, okay?
- 29:19So like, hey, I'm entering into this agreement
- 29:21and I'm just gonna waive any claim of any kind
- 29:27that I have against you full stop. Well, you
- 29:30have authority in California, and I'm citing
- 29:33here the Arthur Anderson case that was decided
- 29:38in the context of a non -compete, but makes pretty
- 29:42clear when reading the case in its entirety that
- 29:46California frowns on any and all waivers. And
- 29:50I'm sure practitioners may tell me, I do them
- 29:52all the time, and I'm just telling you that's
- 29:56not what the case law looks like. So what we
- 30:04come away with when we think about workers comp
- 30:06settlement is you've got two broad types. You've
- 30:10got a compromise and release claim. So an injured
- 30:15worker under that kind of claim agrees to settle
- 30:18the entire claim, right? I'm gonna settle the
- 30:22entire claim, including a right to seek medical
- 30:26treatment in the future. This ends all litigation,
- 30:31between us. And again, I'm speaking specifically
- 30:34of workers comp settlements, there are actually
- 30:37forms that that apply to the various types of
- 30:41settlements, right? So the no right to get future
- 30:45medical care paid for by workers compensation
- 30:49insurance. So obviously, just to state the obvious,
- 30:53for a minute, the stakes are pretty high. with
- 30:56that kind of settlement, right? Because what
- 30:58you're basically doing is you're signing off
- 31:01your claim. And when I represented injured workers,
- 31:05I was very, very cautious about settlements of
- 31:09this type, because it means that you're not going
- 31:11to be able to come back. And the problem with
- 31:14workers' comp claims, one of the aspects of workers'
- 31:17comp claims, is that in a sense, depending on
- 31:20the body part, they're not over. It's hard to
- 31:23know when they're over. And so that's what makes
- 31:25it a dangerous proposition. Another kind of settlement
- 31:28in California is a stipulation. And that's where
- 31:32an injured worker receives money but maintains
- 31:34the right to seek additional medical care in
- 31:38the future. So the injured worker will receive
- 31:42permanent partial disability benefits according
- 31:45to the disability rating. And then we'll be able
- 31:49to get more medical treatment covered if it's
- 31:52deemed reasonable and necessary. Now, why might
- 31:56a worker want to do this? Well, if it's a very
- 31:58clear injury, we have a very clear prognosis.
- 32:02You know, and as a lawyer, if I know roughly
- 32:07the range of that particular injuries have been
- 32:11settling for in my state, maybe I'm willing to
- 32:17enter into a compromise and release because there's
- 32:20all kinds of things. I can get pretty close to
- 32:22what the value of the claim is. But if I have
- 32:24a condition that might flare up, that might get
- 32:29worse, the prognosis, is uncertain or it's just
- 32:34maybe the prognosis is certain, but it's the
- 32:36nature of the injury that sometimes it gets worse
- 32:39and I'll need additional medical treatment. Well,
- 32:43the problem is that if I haven't accounted for
- 32:46that in my compromise and release, I may run
- 32:49into a problem. I may not have enough money to
- 32:53deal with the medical expense that crops up in
- 32:58the future. Now, the compromise and release is
- 33:09obviously extremely, that's an extremely flexible
- 33:14kind of concept, right? So, in theory, you can
- 33:19negotiate a higher amount of money to cover future
- 33:22medical care. So it's not like that can't be
- 33:26factored in. And that can be very flexible from
- 33:30the point of view of insurance carriers. or employers,
- 33:34self -insured employers, that's great because
- 33:37basically we're done with the case, with the
- 33:40caveat that I just mentioned for the injured
- 33:42worker. Now in California, you have the right
- 33:46to negotiate this type of release. But a workers'
- 33:53comp judge has to approve the agreement. Now,
- 33:56there's tremendous variability throughout the
- 33:58country. as to when this is true or whether this
- 34:01is true. There are many states where even though
- 34:04you have to negotiate a workers' comp settlement
- 34:08standalone, you can't really, you can't mix it
- 34:10with other kinds of claims against the employer.
- 34:17It's completely unregulated after that. As long
- 34:21as we know that you're not trying to sweep additional
- 34:23claims in, there is wide acceptance of those
- 34:27kinds of things. In California, at least, this
- 34:31is under the supervision of judges. In California
- 34:37code, labor code section 5502D1, tells us that
- 34:44this has to be handled by a judge, referee, appeals
- 34:49board. And most claims are settled in that way
- 34:53and you can see why. because it is very, for
- 34:59anybody concerned about ongoing liability, you'd
- 35:02like to be done with the liability. But that's
- 35:05under supervision in California. And there's
- 35:09a lot of flexibility in California for the appropriate
- 35:13officials. to approve those kinds of agreements.
- 35:19And California labor code section 5001 tells
- 35:23us that a compromise and release can be approved
- 35:26during any stage of the legal process, including
- 35:29during a mandatory status conference, a settlement
- 35:34conference or workers compensation trial. So
- 35:37pre -trial or even act trial, the trial opens
- 35:43There's some testimony provided, parties go off
- 35:46the record, they settle the case at that point.
- 35:50Judges have discretion to do that kind of thing
- 35:54under this rule. And a California workers' comp
- 35:58judge can deny. a compromised release settlement
- 36:02deemed unfair to the worker. Now, those of you
- 36:05who are in active practice in this area may tell
- 36:08me, well, that's all well and good, Professor,
- 36:10but that never happens, right? And that may well
- 36:12be the case. Again, I'm looking at what the law
- 36:16provides, looking at a batch of cases, and I'm
- 36:20always at a disadvantage not knowing the actual
- 36:23practice that's going on in your state or even
- 36:26in your city. I've taught cases I've had cases
- 36:31in my textbook. I've written a textbook, Carolina
- 36:36Academic Press, and I have cases where there
- 36:40have been settlement practices in which the parties
- 36:43have engaged apparently for years and nobody
- 36:49ever knew it was all subterranean. It goes, it
- 36:53is litigated because a settlement breaks down
- 36:55and goes to the court. And the court says, what
- 36:58are you talking about? You can't settle the case
- 37:01along these lines and scuttle the entire settlement
- 37:04practice. And I'm thinking of Michigan right
- 37:06now. I'm thinking of a Chrysler case because
- 37:10whatever the parties were doing, it was not allowed
- 37:15under the statute, but they were doing it nonetheless.
- 37:18This is just a graphic. of what we've been talking
- 37:21about, making the distinction between compromise
- 37:24and release and stipulated awards. You can see
- 37:28that the compromise and release is handled by
- 37:33lump sum. It closes the case. There's no future
- 37:36medical care. It's highly negotiable. The stipulated
- 37:40award, on the other hand, typically you're at
- 37:43a bi -weekly pay scheme. Future medical stays
- 37:48open, meaning It can be, you can negotiate for
- 37:52more medical expense later on. It's based on
- 37:55the disability rating, as I've touched on, and
- 37:58it can be reopened. So that's just giving you
- 38:00the same thing that we've already said in graphic
- 38:03form. Now, the mandatory settlement conference
- 38:07is interesting. Many states have mandatory ADR.
- 38:15before a claim can go forward. You know, you're
- 38:19not going to just file a claim and get immediately
- 38:22to the Administrative Fact Finder and 5502. Now,
- 38:28this California Code of Regulations 10759, that's
- 38:33accurate. I checked that last night and it's
- 38:36referring to Labor Code 5502. The judge has the
- 38:39authority to inquire into the adequacy and completeness
- 38:43of a settlement. including provision of lien
- 38:47claims. Now again, I don't know what the experience
- 38:50level of this room is like. There are cases in
- 38:53which a worker is, let's take the case of a worker
- 38:57who's injured by a machine that explodes, okay?
- 39:01The liability with respect to the employer is
- 39:05worker's comp. The most that an employee can
- 39:08get from the employer is worker's comp, period.
- 39:11But in some instances, there may be a third party.
- 39:15The machine blows up. So I want to sue the machine
- 39:19manufacturer in a products liability case, right?
- 39:22Well, what liens are is the worker's comp carrier
- 39:28or employer, if it's a self -employed employer,
- 39:31whoever's paying the worker's comp has a claim
- 39:35on whatever proceeds result from the third party
- 39:40products liability case, right? And there's a
- 39:44way to make sure that that All of that has been
- 39:46done properly. Everybody knows what's going on.
- 39:49That's part of what's going on at the settlement
- 39:51conference, if folks are paying attention and
- 39:55are awake and so forth. And you can get compromise
- 39:58and release agreements that issue at this conference
- 40:02as well, or is based upon stipulations. And the
- 40:08comp judge can adjourn a conference to a different
- 40:12time. issue that parties need to talk about at
- 40:17greater length because there's some confusion
- 40:19about what the terms of a resolution would be.
- 40:23The judge has the authority to continue that
- 40:26conference. Now, you practitioners will be able
- 40:28to tell me. My gut tells me that, you know, there
- 40:33are limitations to the number of times that could
- 40:36happen. But of course, I don't know because I
- 40:39don't practice there. Now, I want to say a word
- 40:42about an arcane area, something called Medicare
- 40:49set -aside agreements. And if I was in a big
- 40:52room where I could see everybody, I would ask,
- 40:55how many people know anything about this? And
- 40:59it's surprising how few people do, even practitioners.
- 41:03I can tell you that the practitioners out here
- 41:06in St. Louis are quite nervous about these things.
- 41:09So let me explain what this is. take a whack
- 41:13at it. Under this federal statutory provision
- 41:18here, you have a secondary payer act is basically
- 41:24what we're talking about. And in that act, you
- 41:28have provision for something called a Medicare
- 41:32set aside agreement. This can also apply in situations
- 41:37where somebody suffers a personal injury, a tort,
- 41:44right? What this is, in essence, is Medicare
- 41:48saying, hey, if some of the medical expense that
- 41:54we're going to be paying comes from a work -related
- 41:59injury, in the case of workers' comp, we think...
- 42:02on on workers comp should in fact pay for some
- 42:06of that right because if it doesn't or if it
- 42:09doesn't pay enough there is cost shifting that's
- 42:13gone on in other words something medicare is
- 42:16supposed to pick up various kinds of medical
- 42:18costs but it is not the argument goes supposed
- 42:22to pick up costs that are related to a work related
- 42:26injury a workers comp injury that kind of injury
- 42:29is supposed to be paid by employers, insurance
- 42:33carriers, workers in the form of lower wages,
- 42:37however you want to think about it. It's supposed
- 42:39to be paid by the industry and borne by the industry,
- 42:43not by the taxpayers. So we have here a statute
- 42:47that goes back a number of years now that says
- 42:51you need to account for work -related medical
- 42:57expense. when you're entering into some kind
- 43:02of a settlement and it's gotten more aggressive
- 43:06because now it's not enough that you should,
- 43:10you have to enter into these agreements. And
- 43:13before I tell you what I mean by have to, let
- 43:16me just say that when is it necessary? Well,
- 43:19you have a claimant who's a Medicare beneficiary
- 43:23right now and the settlement exceeds $25 ,000.
- 43:28or you have a claimant that expects to be eligible
- 43:31for Medicare within 30 months of the settlement
- 43:33and the total settlement amount is anticipated
- 43:37to exceed $250 ,000. Now, I want to tell you,
- 43:42before I put any more text up here, I want to
- 43:44tell you that this provision is terrifying to
- 43:48workers comp lawyers because they may have had
- 43:52limited exposure to this law. Now there's a whole
- 43:54set of workers comp set aside procedures that
- 44:00have been promulgated by the center for Medicare
- 44:03services. And it's a big mess if you don't know
- 44:08what it is. And the reason I'm mentioning it
- 44:11in this context is when we're talking about smart
- 44:13settlements. A smart settlement is one in which
- 44:17the parties are thinking about this issue. right?
- 44:22If you're not thinking about this issue and if
- 44:24the claimant falls into that category, Medicare
- 44:29recipient or expects to be a recipient within
- 44:3530 months of the settlement, you have to account
- 44:43for this. It's very clear that the primary policy
- 44:49behind the Set -Aside Agreement is to protect
- 44:52Medicare from paying for medical expenses. It
- 44:55should be covered by the workers' comp settlement.
- 45:00And there are people who don't know about this.
- 45:05And what the structure is trying to do is to
- 45:09ensure that the funds are being put aside, segregated
- 45:14in advance, so that that segregated amount for
- 45:18the work -related medical expense, that segregated
- 45:23amount is paid down before Medicare ever pays
- 45:27anything. Now, this sounds complicated, and it
- 45:32is complicated. It is complicated, right? Worker
- 45:35has to provide full accounting of the money spent
- 45:37from the set -aside account. And a failure to
- 45:40comply with these requirements can lead to legal
- 45:43action. And I think this is what scares people,
- 45:47because there have been key tom suits, false
- 45:51claim act suits, that have been launched against
- 45:55lawyers. And of course, if you are a workers'
- 46:01comp lawyer and that's what you do, you don't
- 46:05want this to happen. So this is a problem. I'm
- 46:08not gonna explain to you the bounty nature of
- 46:10these key Tom lawsuits, but you can get some
- 46:12aggressive lawyering coming after you. Now, one
- 46:15of the things that's happened is that some specialized
- 46:17firms have emerged that handle these kinds of
- 46:21suits. I'm obviously not gonna say the name of
- 46:23any of them, but they can be found. And there
- 46:26were lots of lawyers that use these firms to
- 46:28make sure they're in compliance with these suits.
- 46:33Okay, I wanna talk about, let me check my time
- 46:35here. Okay, I want to talk about Claims that
- 46:40can't be released right now or to the you know,
- 46:43the advertised portion of the talk and I want
- 46:46to start off by saying in California This has
- 46:51a very different complexion than it would have
- 46:54in some other states because in some states you
- 46:58could package like a workers comp claim with
- 47:02some kind of an FMLA, at least in theory, various
- 47:09types of employment claims, you could theoretically
- 47:11package stuff together, although not really.
- 47:14I'll talk about that in a minute. But the California
- 47:17Labor Code 2804, I just want to keep making sure
- 47:20I've said this section a few times, basically
- 47:23says you can't simply waive claims, and we have
- 47:30that separate workers comp structure that we've
- 47:33talked about. Moreover, in California Labor Code
- 47:37section 206 .5, claims that are indiscutably
- 47:42due, wage claims, overtime claims, and so forth
- 47:47cannot be released. right? So this would be a
- 47:50bad idea to try to include in a workers comp
- 47:53settlement if it's pretty clear that the worker
- 47:56in fact was entitled that minimum wage. Now,
- 47:58if they're disputed, they're disputed. But my
- 48:00point is that if they're not disputed, they can't
- 48:03be released. Sometimes The provision specifically
- 48:09talks about actions for wrongful death and personal
- 48:13injury, right? Those in certain circumstances
- 48:17can't be waived. That should cause your spidey
- 48:21senses to tingle. And then there are various
- 48:24rights where the employer offers its employees
- 48:27medical insurance coverage. And then as part
- 48:29of the settlement, the employer says, well, I
- 48:32no longer want to give you that coverage. That
- 48:34cannot be released under under 2804. Right. So
- 48:40so in California, what I would say is that there
- 48:44are lots of claims that you shouldn't try to
- 48:46release as part of a global settlement agreement.
- 48:50I would be reluctant to do that. Let me also
- 48:54say that there's generally no waiver of federal
- 48:58administrative agency charges. So EEOC, the DEOL,
- 49:04FLSA complaints. And the lead case I think for
- 49:08that is this EEOC V Waffle House. which is a
- 49:122002 US Supreme Court case, which basically protects
- 49:18the jurisdiction of federal enforcement agencies.
- 49:24So the watchword is, I would be very, very careful
- 49:28about broad releases of liability in these situations.
- 49:37Parting word, concluding word, I'll take some
- 49:39questions after this. I've written about resolution
- 49:46of insurance claim disputes before trial. You
- 49:50can get a copy of this at the tort trial and
- 49:52insurance practice section of the ABA. It's a
- 49:55little dated. It's a 2018 book, but really the
- 50:02general tenor of settlements don't change, right?
- 50:07And once you know a little bit about the statutory
- 50:09environment where you're functioning, you know
- 50:12an awful lot about what's going to be permitted
- 50:14and what's not going to be permitted. And in
- 50:17this piece that I have up on the slide here,
- 50:19we kind of go state by state by state and talk
- 50:23about what the workers' comp structure looks
- 50:26like. There are a number of states where you
- 50:28have mandatory mediation and there are sometimes
- 50:32some quite strict procedures regarding how settlement
- 50:39is going to operate in that state. And while
- 50:43they'll change, they will change. I'm a Maine
- 50:46lawyer. I'm actually barred in Maine, and that's
- 50:47where I started practicing workers comp. When
- 50:50I look at the Maine law now, in many respects,
- 50:55it's not much different than it was three decades
- 50:58ago. So I think there's some common common problems
- 51:03that arise from state to state. I'm going to
- 51:06stop there, and if there are any questions, I've
- 51:10been told that those questions will be related.
- 51:13I'm happy to respond to questions. Okay, so I'm
- 51:18just taking a quick look here. In your experience,
- 51:23what are the biggest mistakes attorneys make
- 51:25when valuing future medical care in a compromise
- 51:28and release? So I think I'm not looking at all
- 51:34of the medical opinions right if you're in litigation
- 51:38right obviously the what you want to be doing
- 51:41is emphasizing um your practitioner practitioner
- 51:46for your side right and um and there may be a
- 51:50very different view expressed for purposes of
- 51:53litigation if you're looking at um your expert
- 51:57versus the other side's expert okay but but when
- 52:01you're actually now sitting down and it looks
- 52:03like you could settle the case right and you're
- 52:06trying to get a realistic sense of what future
- 52:09costs may be i think there's no better approach
- 52:13than to review all of the medical opinions in
- 52:16the case to get a full picture of what everybody
- 52:19is saying about the potential for the prognosis
- 52:23for that for that injured worker. All right.
- 52:29And then I have another one. Let's see. Have
- 52:37inflation and increasing medical costs changed
- 52:40how carriers value future medical exposure over
- 52:42the last few years? That's a great question.
- 52:45And the answer is yes. And in fact, let me tell
- 52:48you how intense this gets. Some of you may be
- 52:51aware that back in 2011, Oklahoma basically attempted
- 53:00to make its workers compensation system completely
- 53:04elective, right? Joining Texas, right? Texas
- 53:08has an elective system. Now Texas is an opt -in
- 53:12system. Everybody's out unless they opt in. Oklahoma...
- 53:17purported to set up an opt -out system, right?
- 53:21And what they were going to do is set up ERISA
- 53:24governed alternative benefit plans, which is
- 53:27beyond the scope of this discussion. But what's
- 53:29not beyond the scope of your question is the
- 53:31reason that that was happening was because the
- 53:34rate of medical inflation was crazy. And so you
- 53:41had legislators in Oklahoma that were really
- 53:44attempting to end workers' comp liability. And
- 53:48I would say that it has definitely affected the
- 53:53valuation of claims out into the future. But
- 53:56the problem is, you can account for inflation,
- 54:01but it's very difficult. to account for the rate
- 54:03of inflation, the timing of inflation, right?
- 54:06All of the problems that we have generally when
- 54:08thinking about inflation. So that is the problem.
- 54:12But I would say if there's anything that ultimately
- 54:15long -term threatens the state -based viability
- 54:19of this system, boy, that's a big sentence. I
- 54:22would say that it is the prospect of intense
- 54:25medical inflation that exceeds the ability of
- 54:29some states to be able to pay claims. Have you
- 54:43ever seen employers inadvertently draft releases
- 54:46that jeopardize enforcement because they attempted
- 54:48to waive non -waivable rights? Yes, I've seen
- 54:52it often and I'll tell you the situations where
- 54:56it tends to occur is when an employment lawyer,
- 55:00and this is maybe an apt comment for those of
- 55:04you who are employment lawyers and are only now
- 55:07becoming aware of workers' compensation, and
- 55:09you've got a new section, which I'll say it again.
- 55:12I applaud. Please join it. But employment lawyers
- 55:17who are not sufficiently familiar with the area
- 55:21where they're practicing, they think they can
- 55:23do a certain thing because they did it in a different
- 55:26environment, right? And I think there's two warnings.
- 55:29One is workers' comp is almost always handled
- 55:33differently. So employment lawyers in any state
- 55:36could run into that kind of a problem. But I
- 55:39also think that the sort of, and I haven't had
- 55:43experience with California directly, but I would
- 55:45think the problem in California is maybe not
- 55:48everybody is as aware as I've become of the degree
- 55:52of supervision that California is exerting with
- 55:56respect to settlement. Now, the problem with
- 55:58this is that a practice, and I'll repeat my admonition
- 56:03from earlier, there can be something that everybody
- 56:06does and everybody knows it's okay and it's how
- 56:08they settle, right? And then all of a sudden
- 56:11somebody challenges a practice. And it turns
- 56:16out that that practice was not well grounded
- 56:18in the statute or regulations. That can be a
- 56:22problem. That can get a lawyer into trouble.
- 56:31All right, and let's see. Are there recent appellate
- 56:35decisions or legislative developments that you
- 56:37think practitioners should immediately incorporate
- 56:39into their settlement strategy? Not that I'm
- 56:42aware, but I am not a California expert. So I'm
- 56:46hesitant to say that there's been nothing recent.
- 56:50Obviously, you know, settlement agreements have
- 56:53to conform. to the state of the law, right? And
- 56:58in workers' comp just as in every other area,
- 57:02I think you have to be, you have to stay abreast
- 57:05of what's going on with the law. And there are
- 57:09certain times, historical times when there's
- 57:12been a lot of workers' comp change, right? Now
- 57:15I do know that there are some big changes coming
- 57:18in California workers' comp law. I think next
- 57:21session. I was just recently hearing about it,
- 57:25right? And so that's something that I would want
- 57:28to pay attention to in drafting settlement documents.
- 57:34And given the practical cost and delay associated
- 57:37with WCMSAs, when do you recommend obtaining
- 57:42CMS review even when it is not technically required?
- 57:46Okay, I'm going to be completely evasive. Okay,
- 57:49because that is an area of specialization that
- 57:53I think, let me say this, I think that is an
- 57:57excellent question that should be posed to lawyers
- 58:00that are specializing in this area right now.
- 58:02I know lawyers don't want to hear that. Don't
- 58:04tell me I have to confer with somebody else.
- 58:06But it's really complicated. And I think it's
- 58:09getting worse because there was a new regulatory
- 58:12structure that was put in place in January or
- 58:15February of this year. that really changed the
- 58:18way a lot of this is done. Now, for those of
- 58:20you who have vast free time, let me tell you
- 58:24that I'm not at all clear about the notice and
- 58:28comment procedures that resulted in the establishment
- 58:32of this entire structure. So if anybody wants
- 58:35to write about that, let me know. Right. Let's
- 58:42see. Looks like we have just one question. Let's
- 58:45see. What provisions and employment separation
- 58:49agreements most often create unintended workers
- 58:51compensation issues? Anything having to do with
- 58:56the extent to which a wage amount is reflective
- 59:01of a compromise on the on the workers comp indemnity
- 59:05sides. In other words, If I've calculated an
- 59:09amount of money and I say, okay, this represents,
- 59:12this is a compromise on what we think we owe
- 59:16you. And it's not clear where that monetary amount
- 59:20is coming from. It can create a problem if the
- 59:23monetary amount seems. I don't know, unreasonably
- 59:27low given the extent of disability. Where is
- 59:30the money coming from? So I've seen releases
- 59:34where somebody just comes up with a figure and
- 59:38there's no attempt to idolize in any way. I'm
- 59:42not talking about ultra precise calculations,
- 59:46but just some. understanding that this represents
- 59:49a compromise of indemnity or, you know, this
- 59:53is some kind of an estimate of future medical
- 59:56or whatever it is, right? I would be loath to,
- 1:00:03based on what I've seen of California law, to
- 1:00:06not be in a position to explain to the judge
- 1:00:08where that amount comes from. Now, if you're
- 1:00:11in a real laissez -faire state, where you can
- 1:00:15just write down a figure on a napkin and the
- 1:00:18employee doesn't object and there's minimal supervision,
- 1:00:22then it's not the same kind of problem. But if
- 1:00:24you're in a state that is supervising to a greater
- 1:00:27degree, I have seen settlements where the council
- 1:00:32could not explain how they calculated that figure,
- 1:00:35what it represents at all. All right, looks like
- 1:00:44we are at 1 .30. Professor Duff, it looks like
- 1:00:47we're done with questions. Do you have any other
- 1:00:49closing remarks that you'd like to make for the
- 1:00:50audience today? The only thing I'll say is join
- 1:00:54the workers' compensation section because there's
- 1:00:57always more going on in this area of law than
- 1:01:00practitioners think. I've been able to operate
- 1:01:04a course as a tenured professor, three credit
- 1:01:09course in law school since 2010. And one of the
- 1:01:14reasons I've been able to do that is I can make
- 1:01:16the case to deans that we don't cover this area
- 1:01:20of the law enough and there's a lot going on.
- 1:01:23So I applaud the creation of the section and
- 1:01:25I wish you all well in getting it started. All
- 1:01:29right. This concludes today's presentation. Thank
- 1:01:31you so much Professor Duff for an excellent presentation
- 1:01:34today and thank you so much to our audience for
- 1:01:36joining us. Have a great day everybody. Thank
- 1:01:39you.