Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 266. Your Brain Has Too Many Tabs Open: Managing the Voice in Your Head
Transcript
- 0:02Matt Abrahams: Doom loops can be one of the biggest barriers to effective
- 0:06communication, yet we can quiet the chatter and regulate our emotions.
- 0:11My name is Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:15Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:17Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:20Today I'm really excited to speak with Ethan Kross.
- 0:23Ethan is an award-winning professor of management and organizations at the
- 0:27University of Michigan's Ross School of Business, and he is a director
- 0:30of its emotion and self-control lab.
- 0:33He studies emotion regulation and the conscious mind.
- 0:37Ethan has written two bestselling books, Chatter: The Voice in Our Head,
- 0:40Why It Matters, and How to Harness It.
- 0:42And his latest book is Shift: Managing Your Emotions So They Don't Manage You.
- 0:47Welcome Ethan.
- 0:48I'm really excited for our conversation.
- 0:51Ethan Kross: It's a delight and honor to be here, Matt.
- 0:53I've been looking forward to this for a while now, so glad we can make it happen.
- 0:56Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 0:57Shall we get started?
- 0:58Ethan Kross: Yeah, let's do it.
- 1:00Matt Abrahams: So let's start our chat about chatter.
- 1:02Your work on chatter explores our internal self-talk and how
- 1:06it can hijack our performance.
- 1:08Can you explain how this happens?
- 1:10Ethan Kross: Yeah.
- 1:10We should probably start by defining what chatter means.
- 1:13Chatter refers to getting stuck in a negative thought loop, and
- 1:17they're really two kind of telltale signs that you are experiencing it.
- 1:21So one is you've got a legitimate problem that you're facing.
- 1:25Maybe it's a problem at work, maybe it's a problem at home, and you're
- 1:27motivated to work through that problem, to use your glorious, marvelous
- 1:32brain to come up with a solution.
- 1:34The problem is you're not successful, so you keep on trying to work through
- 1:39the problem, but you don't make any progress and you start spinning.
- 1:43Sometimes you call this worry, sometimes we call rumination.
- 1:46The common thread, there's a legitimate problem, but you're not progressing.
- 1:51So that's one sign that you're experiencing this state of chatter.
- 1:53Another is you just berate yourself incessantly.
- 1:56I'm an idiot.
- 1:56Such an idiot.
- 1:57How can I have done this?
- 1:58And you just pile on yourself.
- 2:00How does this undermine performance?
- 2:02One way it does so is by consuming your attention.
- 2:05So let me ask you this question, Matt.
- 2:07Have you ever been in a situation where you sit down to read a few pages in a
- 2:11book, and under oath you would swear to a judge that you've read the information on
- 2:16the page except you get to the end and you do not remember a damn thing you've read.
- 2:20Matt Abrahams: Ethan, that happens so frequently that it is common.
- 2:24Ethan Kross: Well, and it's, in my experience, talking to lots of people
- 2:27about this stuff over the years, this is a universal experience we all have at times.
- 2:32And chatter just promotes this.
- 2:34So how does this work?
- 2:36We have a limited capacity to focus our attention.
- 2:40Our attentional resources are a precious, limited commodity in our
- 2:44brains, and chatter acts like a sponge that consumes that limited capacity.
- 2:50It leaves very little leftover that allows us to do the things
- 2:54that we want or need to do.
- 2:54So that's one way it can undermine our performance.
- 2:57The other thing it can lead to is something that we call analysis paralysis.
- 3:01Here, the idea is you start overthinking things that you can normally do
- 3:05without thinking to the point where the entire performance crumbles.
- 3:11If you watch sports, you see this happening all the time to
- 3:13athletes who choke under pressure.
- 3:15All of a sudden the second baseman, who could historically throw the ball to
- 3:19first base with their eyes closed, now can't get anywhere near the vicinity.
- 3:23That is also a function of chatter, and those are two powerful detriments to our
- 3:27ability to excel in performance context.
- 3:30Matt Abrahams: So chatter sucks up our cognitive bandwidth and it has us
- 3:35doing things more consciously than we might normally do it, and that's what
- 3:39gets in the way of us performing well.
- 3:40I see this play out all the time in the work I do around helping
- 3:43people feel more comfortable and confident in communicating.
- 3:46Anxiety around speaking gets into this chatter loop very easily.
- 3:51But what are some techniques we can use to break this cycle?
- 3:55Ethan Kross: An early experience that I had with analysis paralysis was when I was
- 3:59first public speaking as a grad student.
- 4:01One of the first classes I taught, it went well.
- 4:03I got some feedback though that said that I had forgotten to smile
- 4:06enough, and so in the second time I came back I overcorrected, and like
- 4:12I smiled so widely that it disrupted, I forgot what I wanted to say.
- 4:16Matt Abrahams: And that happens a lot.
- 4:17People get caught up on things like they hear themselves saying or they know
- 4:21what they wanted to say in a certain way, and then they get into these doom
- 4:24loops that prevent them from performing well and how do we get out of that?
- 4:29Ethan Kross: So here's the good news.
- 4:30You can get out of it.
- 4:32More good news, if someone has told you about a tool that worked for them,
- 4:35but it didn't work for you, no problem.
- 4:38Because what we have learned from the science is that different tools work for
- 4:43different people in different situations.
- 4:45There are no one size fits all solutions.
- 4:47I think of managing your chatter a lot like becoming physically fit.
- 4:52So most of us have goals to be physically fit for different reasons.
- 4:56Some of us want bigger muscles.
- 4:57Some of us wanna be able to run longer.
- 4:59Based on who you are and your goals, you're gonna benefit from doing different
- 5:03kinds of exercises and routines.
- 5:06The same is true when it comes to managing your chatter.
- 5:10So what can you do?
- 5:11Well, there are some things you could just do on your own, basic ways of shifting
- 5:15the way you're thinking or behaving that can turn the volume on your chatter down.
- 5:19One category of tools that a lot of people benefit from or call distancing tools.
- 5:24So here the idea is when you find yourself zoomed in very narrowly on
- 5:29a problem and you're ruminating about it, let's find a way to help you step
- 5:33back and look at the circumstance a bit more objectively, almost like
- 5:36you'd be hearing it from a friend.
- 5:38Most of us have had the experience of finding it much easier for
- 5:41us to give great advice to a friend as compared to ourselves.
- 5:45There's a name for this phenomenon.
- 5:47We've studied it in my lab.
- 5:48It's called Solomon's Paradox, named after the Bible's King Solomon.
- 5:52King Solomon was known for being super wise when it came to other people.
- 5:57When it came to himself, he made terrible decisions.
- 6:00This is true of all of us.
- 6:01So how do you step outside yourself?
- 6:04Lots of ways to do it.
- 6:05One tool that I'm fond of is called distanced self-talk.
- 6:09So what this involves is trying to work through a problem
- 6:12using your own name and you.
- 6:14So if I'm really stressed out before a big presentation, I might think
- 6:17to myself, all right, Ethan, how are you gonna manage this situation?
- 6:20How have you managed a situation before?
- 6:22Here's why distanced self-talk helps.
- 6:24It leverages language to shift our perspective.
- 6:29Most of the time that we use the word you or a name, we're using
- 6:33those parts of speech when we think about or refer to someone else.
- 6:38So the link in a person's mind between the word you as an example, and another
- 6:43person is about as strong as you can get.
- 6:45So when you use that part of speech to reference yourself, it's essentially
- 6:49turning on the brain machinery for thinking about someone else.
- 6:52Makes it a lot easier for us to work through our problems objectively.
- 6:55So that's one tool you can use.
- 6:57Another tool is something that I call mental time travel into the future.
- 7:02Super simple.
- 7:03How am I gonna feel about this presentation three hours from now, three
- 7:07days from now, three years from now?
- 7:09All of our emotions they take place on a timeline.
- 7:13So you're living your life, something happens and emotion
- 7:15gets spiked, and as time goes on, the emotion eventually fades.
- 7:20When we're consumed with chatter, we zoom in on the peak of that
- 7:25experience and the awfulness, oh my God, everyone's staring at me.
- 7:28And what if I forget to say what I need to say?
- 7:31What if to go to the bathroom, and blah, blah, blah.
- 7:34It is amazing, I should add, that how creative we can be in coming up with
- 7:38worst case scenarios in those moments.
- 7:41So when you zoom in on the pinnacle of the negative experience, what
- 7:45you lose sight of is something that you know at your core to be true.
- 7:51You know this to be true because you've experienced what I'm about
- 7:54to describe millions of times in your life, which is the emotion has
- 7:58come and has increased, but then as time has gone on, it has faded.
- 8:03So when you jump into the mental time travel vision, you think, hey, how
- 8:06am I gonna feel about this tomorrow?
- 8:07Or next week?
- 8:08It automatically makes accessible this notion that what you're going through,
- 8:14as awful as it is, it's temporary.
- 8:17It will eventually fade.
- 8:18And that does something very powerful to a mind that is racked with chatter.
- 8:22It gives it hope, and that turns the volume down too.
- 8:24So those are just two examples.
- 8:26There are dozens of tools out there.
- 8:27Matt Abrahams: I really appreciate that, the distanced self-talk, putting
- 8:31yourself as the person you're giving advice to, and then asking yourself
- 8:35what this means in the future.
- 8:37I've heard things like writing things down, just recognizing mindfulness
- 8:41teaches us that this is what I'm experiencing in the moment, all of those
- 8:44give us a little bit of space to be able to manage, so thank you for that.
- 8:49Given that a lot of our interactions are mediated, they're virtual, they're
- 8:52through social media, I'm curious if you've found that there are any
- 8:56differences in our self-talk or how we should approach those interactions?
- 9:01Ethan Kross: I think it's really important for us to be mindful
- 9:04of the modality that we are communicating to other people through.
- 9:09Technology has provided us with just enormous opportunities to be more
- 9:14efficient and effective, but there are some trade offs that you get.
- 9:18So here's something I think about often when it comes to chatter and technology.
- 9:23We know from lots of research that when people experience strong emotional
- 9:27reactions of the sort that characterize chatter, they're intensely motivated
- 9:32to share the glory that is streaming through their mind with other people.
- 9:37That is, they wanna talk about it.
- 9:39Now, in the real, in the non-social media, non-technology, quote unquote,
- 9:44real world, there are some obstacles that are embedded into life that prevent
- 9:49you from immediately talking about your chatter in the instant that it
- 9:53has spiked and is perhaps most extreme.
- 9:55Number one, you've gotta find someone to talk to and people
- 10:00aren't like always available.
- 10:02And then once you find them, they may not even be able to listen to you, right?
- 10:05So you've gotta wait some time to find someone.
- 10:08And then what often happens as time passes, some scientists
- 10:12describe time as a component of our psychological immune system.
- 10:17That is, time works to reduce the intensity of our emotional responses.
- 10:22As time goes on, our emotions fade, right?
- 10:26So you're waiting to talk to someone in the real world.
- 10:27You finally, you know, my wife, I finally reconnect with her five hours
- 10:31later, I'm not as upset as I was before.
- 10:34Social media though, gives us access to a network at all times, and when you couple
- 10:39it with smartphones, you whip it out at the very peak, and then you're sharing.
- 10:44And there's one other thing to keep in mind, which is, on social media,
- 10:47I am sharing my inner thoughts and sometimes frustrations into a text box.
- 10:53When I am face-to-face with someone, I'm in the presence of another human
- 10:58being who is sending me all of this rich information back about how what I'm doing
- 11:04and how I'm behaving is affecting them.
- 11:06That is, your face, your body is sending me information about how
- 11:11you are feeling, and that can constrain the way I behave to you.
- 11:16Like sometimes, Matt, I'll be honest, like when I'm pissed off, I mean, it's like
- 11:20a Robert De Niro film in there, right?
- 11:22Like the expletives that are going, if I said some of these things out
- 11:26loud, I would be in big trouble.
- 11:29I would never talk to you that way.
- 11:32I wouldn't talk to any other human being that way.
- 11:34And it's because you are calibrating how I communicate.
- 11:38So I think it's just really important to be mindful of these modality differences,
- 11:43'cause we do see that people are much more likely to share emotional information in
- 11:48an unfiltered way on social media that can sometimes get them in big trouble.
- 11:53Matt Abrahams: Absolutely, and I think it's important to always be thinking
- 11:55about the channel and what that means for how and when, and how specific
- 11:59you can be in your communication.
- 12:01I really like that idea of time being part of the immune system and
- 12:05really helping calm things down.
- 12:07I appreciate that.
- 12:08You've said that a common piece of bad advice is simply get over the
- 12:13negative feelings that people have.
- 12:15I'm curious, why is that such a bad idea, and if it is, what are some
- 12:19communication frameworks or tools you can share with us that we can use to
- 12:24acknowledge others' negative feelings, without just saying, hey, get over it.
- 12:28How can we help them process those feelings?
- 12:31Ethan Kross: Yeah, just get over it doesn't really give people a
- 12:34whole lot of tactical information to help them get over it.
- 12:38I think a lot of people, when they're struggling, they're highly
- 12:41motivated to reduce that struggle.
- 12:43They don't wanna stay in that state, for the most part.
- 12:46And so when you just tell people, just get over it, it's not like
- 12:49they're not trying to do so.
- 12:51In my latest book, I tell this anecdote where my wife and I were driving back
- 12:55from dinner in Detroit with another couple, very close friends of ours,
- 12:59and the husband has been experiencing some real stress at work, and it was
- 13:03the source of some chatter, and he was describing it to us in the car.
- 13:07And his wife says to him, yeah, why don't you just think differently about it?
- 13:11Effectively like, just get over it.
- 13:12And he turns to her and goes, yeah, easier bleeping said, than done.
- 13:17And he did not say bleeping, I'll let you fill in the blanks.
- 13:20And so the idea is, okay, but how?
- 13:22It's equivalent to like, just get in shape, just lose weight.
- 13:25But I've never taught you the exercises and nutritional regimens
- 13:30you need to accomplish those goals.
- 13:32What is the best way of supporting other people when they're struggling
- 13:36with chatter or big emotions?
- 13:37There's a two-step science-based framework that I'm particularly fond of.
- 13:42I'm fond of it because it's grounded in rigorous science.
- 13:45I'm also fond of it because I have personally found enormous value in it.
- 13:49Because before I came in contact with this framework, people would come to me
- 13:53for help and I didn't know what to say.
- 13:55Like, sorry, I feel for you, but now I have a guide.
- 13:58So what is in, what are the steps in this framework?
- 14:00Step one is emotionally connect with the person.
- 14:04Listen to the problem, validate what they're experiencing, show empathy,
- 14:09connect with them, communicate that you are there for them.
- 14:13They have your support.
- 14:14And also learn about the circumstance.
- 14:16You need to wrap your head around it.
- 14:18Once you have a sense that those social and emotional connections have been
- 14:22forged, then you wanna shift to starting to work with that person to help broaden
- 14:28their perspective, help give them actual tools that can benefit them, right?
- 14:34So Matt, you come to me with a problem.
- 14:36I listen, I learn, you know that I'm genuinely here for you.
- 14:39I might throw it back to you and be like, hey, so what would you tell me if
- 14:42I was in your circumstance or I was in that situation a couple of years ago.
- 14:47You know what really benefited me?
- 14:49It was actually doing this mental time travel thing where I went into the future.
- 14:52Maybe you try that.
- 14:54And there are lots of different tools you could slip during
- 14:57that part of the conversation.
- 14:58But the idea is you lay the groundwork, the emotional groundwork for giving
- 15:04those tools at the beginning part of the conversation, and then you come
- 15:07into problem solving mode at the end.
- 15:09That's the formula for both being a good chatter advisor to someone else.
- 15:13It's also a formula for helping you figure out who are the people
- 15:17that you should put on your chatter advisory board, who are the people
- 15:20who do both of these things for me?
- 15:22Because I'll tell you, when I do audits of people's advisory boards with them,
- 15:27there are lots of people that folks go to talk to about their problems,
- 15:30they don't do both of those things.
- 15:31Sometimes they just co-ruminate with the other person in ways that
- 15:35make the situation even worse.
- 15:37Matt Abrahams: I really like this idea of a chatter advisory board and
- 15:40really think about who are the people that help you, and it might be the
- 15:44same person or it might be different people for different situations, but
- 15:48I really like that proactive idea.
- 15:50And then as somebody who is trying to help others, we talk a lot on this show,
- 15:55and with a lot of people and colleagues that you and I have in common, about how
- 15:58we can connect, we can ask questions, we can paraphrase, we can demonstrate
- 16:02our empathy, to really learn about the circumstance before we begin to
- 16:07provide potential advice and guidance.
- 16:09And the examples you used of advice and guidance, I think, I wanna call
- 16:12everybody's attention to, you didn't say you should do this, you said, in
- 16:17my experience, I have found this helped me, which it changes the dynamic.
- 16:22So the tone and manner in which you give the advice, I think is really important.
- 16:25Ethan Kross: Yeah, I couldn't agree more.
- 16:27The you should, you wanna use that very sparingly.
- 16:30Matt Abrahams: I have a friend who says you shouldn't
- 16:32should all over people, right?
- 16:34But saying from your own experience opens up for conversation.
- 16:38Ethan Kross: Yeah.
- 16:38And just to take that a beat further, 'cause I think it's such an incredibly
- 16:42insightful and important point, Matt, is why is it that the kind of softer
- 16:48way in to giving the info is important?
- 16:50It's because all human beings have this fundamental drive towards agency.
- 16:56It's a drive to believe, to use the technical term, that we are
- 17:01capable of handling our own shit.
- 17:04And when you threaten that drive, it elicits a kind of defensive reactance.
- 17:09And so if you could get in there a little bit softer, it makes it all easier.
- 17:13Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 17:14I love the technical term.
- 17:15Thank you.
- 17:16I'd like to shift our conversation away from chatter to your latest book, Shift.
- 17:20You've already alluded to it, but it's all about emotional regulation,
- 17:22and by the way, it's fantastic.
- 17:24You say in there that a key to managing your inner world is to view
- 17:28our emotions not as problems to be suppressed, but as data to be analyzed.
- 17:32So this is a way of reframing it.
- 17:34What does this shift do for us and how can we train ourselves to use this
- 17:38reframe so we can get some of the benefit?
- 17:41Ethan Kross: I think one of the big problems we have in society right now,
- 17:45at least in Western society, is we often, we give people these aspirational goals
- 17:50to live lives free of negative emotions, striving for happiness all the time.
- 17:55Sometimes this leads to what we call toxic positivity.
- 17:59And here's the problem with that.
- 18:01Number one, you're giving people an impossible goal.
- 18:04There's no way you can achieve this goal of never experiencing negative emotions.
- 18:08Number two, it is an undesirable goal because your negative emotions in
- 18:12the right proportions are helpful.
- 18:14Let me give you a couple of examples.
- 18:16Anxiety, when I don't experience any anxiety before an important presentation,
- 18:21the performance I deliver is not as good as when I do experience low anxiety.
- 18:26Why is that?
- 18:27Because the anxiety is information that tells me, hey, dopey, trying to start
- 18:33looking over your slides and making sure it's all top of mind, right?
- 18:37If I don't do that, I just walk in, it doesn't go as well.
- 18:40Anger is what motivates me to intervene when my daughter doesn't put on her
- 18:46helmet when she's riding her bike.
- 18:48So we experience anger when our conception of what is right and
- 18:52wrong is transgressed, and there's an opportunity for you to fix the situation,
- 18:56and you approach, you intervene.
- 18:58In the right proportions those are healthy.
- 19:00The big problem, of course, is we often experience negative
- 19:04emotions out of proportion.
- 19:05That's why it's important to understand how to regulate it, but we really need
- 19:09to understand that we should not be throwing the baby out with the bath water.
- 19:13Just because negative emotions are harmful some of the time doesn't mean that they
- 19:18don't serve a vital role in our lives.
- 19:21Matt Abrahams: Taking that reframe really can help.
- 19:23When I feel my anxiety before giving a speech or my anger with one of my
- 19:27kids because they're driving too fast, when I see that as, hey, this is input
- 19:31for me to then act upon rather than something to bury deep inside or get
- 19:35overwhelmed by, I can really make a difference and I appreciate that.
- 19:39It, again, takes that little bit of distancing to give yourself
- 19:42that space to do that though.
- 19:44Before we end, I always ask people three questions.
- 19:47One I make up just for you and the other two I've been asking people as
- 19:50long as the podcast has been around.
- 19:51Are you up for that?
- 19:52Ethan Kross: Yeah.
- 19:52Let's do it.
- 19:53Matt Abrahams: Question number one.
- 19:54You have studied awe.
- 19:56Can you tell us very quickly what awe is and what have you learned about it?
- 20:00Ethan Kross: Yeah.
- 20:01Awe is an emotion we experience when we're in the presence of
- 20:04something vast and indescribable.
- 20:05Something that just feels bigger than ourselves.
- 20:08And what we've learned is that number one, you can experience awe
- 20:12from lots of different sources.
- 20:13So a lot of people find awe in nature.
- 20:15Beautiful sunset, fall foliage.
- 20:18I'm a science guy and I often am filled with awe when I contemplate the fact
- 20:22that we human beings have cracked the puzzle of interplanetary travel.
- 20:27That is, we have figured out how to blast a vehicle off this planet,
- 20:31and safely land it on planet Mars, and my mind is just can't comprehend
- 20:35how we figured out how to do that.
- 20:37When we experience this emotion of awe, it leads to what we
- 20:39call shrinking of the self.
- 20:41We feel smaller when we're contemplating something vast and indescribable.
- 20:45And when we feel smaller, so do all of the troubles that are weighing us down.
- 20:49And so it's an important reminder of another resource we possess
- 20:52for managing our emotions.
- 20:54Matt Abrahams: Yeah, and awe, I think, also can be experienced internally.
- 20:56You can think about internal things as well, not just external.
- 20:59So again, it's a way of distancing and perspective taking.
- 21:03Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 21:07Ethan Kross: My good friend Angela Duckworth is, I think, just
- 21:11exceptional at clearly talking about science that honors its richness,
- 21:17but still being really impactful.
- 21:19And I think finding that sweet spot between being able to talk
- 21:23with impact, but not diluting the science, is really hard to do.
- 21:29Matt Abrahams: She is an amazing communicator and you and Katy Milkman
- 21:32have both nominated her as a person that is admired, so thank you for that.
- 21:36Our final question, Ethan, what are the first three ingredients that go
- 21:40into a successful communication recipe?
- 21:44Ethan Kross: Clarity, simplifying as much as you can, but not beyond that,
- 21:49and sharing your passion and love of what you're doing and talking about.
- 21:54Matt Abrahams: Clarity, simplicity, and emotion that you feel and experience.
- 21:59Thank you for that recipe and thank you for all the insights you've provided.
- 22:03A lot of us carry around a lot of chatter.
- 22:06It can make it hard for us to regulate our emotions and manage, and you've given us
- 22:09some very specific advice and guidance.
- 22:11The one thing I am certainly taking away as my chatter advisory board,
- 22:15uh, I'm sending out applications to several people to join right away.
- 22:19Thank you, Ethan, for your time.
- 22:20Ethan Kross: Thanks for having me.
- 22:24Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 22:26Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 22:28To learn more about how to manage our internal world and negativity, please
- 22:32listen to episode 179 with Lori Santos.
- 22:36This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 22:41Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 22:43With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 22:46Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 22:49Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 22:51Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 22:54And check out our premium offering at fastersmarter.io/premium.