Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline for Thursday, August 17, 2023
Transcript
- 0:22Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network. Decision.
- 0:27You are surrounded West Room, were Million, Virginy. Welcome your radio
- 0:34turned on. From the studios of w VRC Media and the Metro News Radio
- 0:40Network, the voice of West Virginia comes the most powerful radio show in West
- 0:45Virginia. This this he is Metro News Talk Live with Hobby kirchiv activated switch
- 0:53NETWA can chill from Charles kund stand by you, Hoppy. You're on Metro
- 1:00Who's talk Line with Hobby kirchiblas brought to you. Buy in COVID Insurance and
- 1:03circling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting coovid dot
- 1:07com to learn. Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on Metro News from
- 1:11the Cove Insurance studios in the Dale Miller Building. Full number one hundred seven
- 1:15six five eight two five five Text me three oh four Talk three oh four.
- 1:19So, as you know, WWU is making major cutbacks because of a
- 1:25budget deficit that's totaling forty five million dollars. They've already eliminated half of that
- 1:30deficit through other cuts have been made, and now they're proposing cutting one hundred
- 1:34and sixty nine faculty members, also eliminating thirty two programs to try to save
- 1:40the rest part of the conversation has been okay, So the state government has
- 1:46a significant or had a significant surplus of over four hundred million dollars. They
- 1:51gave forty five the legislature, the governor gave forty five million to Marshall for
- 1:55their cybersecurity unit. They gave twenty five million to the Pierpont Community Technical College
- 2:00for their aeronautics program. They gave fifty million to the WU Cancer Center.
- 2:05Some have raised this question, why wasn't some of that surplus money used to
- 2:08help WVU so they didn't have to cut back or lay off. Let's go
- 2:13to the chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, Senator Eric tar Republican from Putner
- 2:19County, sen A. Good morning, how are you, sir? Good
- 2:21morning, hoppy to an excellent How are you today? I'm well, thank
- 2:23you, thank you for coming on. Why didn't the legislature and or the
- 2:27governor. You can't speak for the governor, but why didn't the state bailout
- 2:30WVU? You know there's one This isn't a bill out position, So you're
- 2:35looking at a ten percent reduction in their their overall spend reltan what their budget
- 2:39comes through. And one of the things we've been doing in the legislature for
- 2:44several years now, everybody's heard us talk about holding four years of the flat
- 2:46budget and what that does a couple of things. One is it starts to
- 2:52decrease the spending that normally would increase conflation over a few years, and that
- 2:57squeezes government agencies. And in this respect, I think you could look at
- 3:01W as one of those government agencies as you go through that that three percent
- 3:06year that would increase in spending. As you do, that squeezes out efficiency
- 3:09that otherwise agencies have no incentive to find. And so with W, this
- 3:15is W is a part of a much larger picture that's happening nationally, and
- 3:22that higher education economy is changing, and it's changing such that student enrollment is
- 3:27dropping all across the country. Higher education has known this all across the country.
- 3:31There was just just a couple of days ago there was a Wall Street
- 3:35Journal article that came out that said that you know, land grant, not
- 3:39land grant, it was flagship universities have been spending like crazy, and now
- 3:45there's a reckoning. And so what's happening is is that you have taxpayer dollars
- 3:50that go into these universities, and you have student tuition that goes into it,
- 3:53and have grant funding that comes in, offer research grants and things they
- 3:54do, as well as any benefactors that they may have with their endowments.
- 4:00And so what's if here's the scenario is that you have these programs that have
- 4:05been continued to be propped up, they are not producing such that they're either
- 4:11not drawing students or they could be swallowed up by some other educational peace within
- 4:15university. And what happens is either you can ask the taxpayer to pay more
- 4:21for an underperforming college or program, or you can ask the students to pay
- 4:28more, which is the parents or whoever is paying that as well to pay
- 4:31more intuition, or the university can go in and right size so that you
- 4:36don't throw that money unnecessarily back on the taxpayer or back on student student tuition
- 4:42hikes, so that those the options. Do you go to taxpayer, you
- 4:44go to students, or do you right size your university? And I think
- 4:46what they're doing is right moves. So okay, So your opinion that this
- 4:50is an appropriate reckoning at WVU. Correct. Absolutely. Did you have any
- 4:57conversations with WVU President Gordon Gey about all of this and did get at any
- 5:00point hits you up for more money? You know, we had conversations a
- 5:03very public manner that we had both Gordon Gee and we had Brad Smith for
- 5:10the first time I'm ever aware of come in and testify in front of Finance
- 5:14Committee over the past two years when we would do budget hearings about tell us
- 5:18what's happening at the university and why the money that the legislature appropriates is necessary.
- 5:25And both of the both Gordon and Brad when they came in and testified
- 5:30to the Senate Finance Committee, said that in the next ten years, it's
- 5:32forecasted that about fifty percent of the universities across the country will close, and
- 5:40the reason is because of the declining student enrollment. Was it was significant,
- 5:45especially as we have an aging population and less of an emphasis on higher education
- 5:48from parents and who guardians or whoever toward towards their students because the expensive higher
- 5:55ed has grown so much that the valued return on the dollar for them to
- 6:00go into hire ed versus just going straight to work, isn't there Now there
- 6:03are things that do that, but there's also a lot of things like puppetry
- 6:08programs and as you saw the foreign language programs, that you have to consider
- 6:13what the job market looks like when you're going to programs, and that's not
- 6:15been happening, and they've been building programs without the universities considering what the job
- 6:18market is. So now they have to, and I think that once they
- 6:23get through this, we're going to have a much better West Virginia University.
- 6:27So we had those discussions publicly with both Gordon and Brad and then beyond that,
- 6:30I read a book that Gordon wrote back in It was published in twenty
- 6:34one. I'm not sure how long it took to wrote it write it,
- 6:38but it had to. It said what's public about public higher it? And
- 6:42not only did Gordon outline the problem that was coming down the pike to where
- 6:46the universities across the country we're going to have to address this in our Senate
- 6:50Finance committee, but he wrote about it in a published book along with another
- 6:55university PhD out of o High State. So they this isn't something that has
- 7:00just suddenly surprised everybody this has been coming. They know it, they've been
- 7:04they've been telling us it's coming. And so I just don't think that we
- 7:08should be paying for empty rooms or asking taxpayers, Hey, take more money
- 7:12out of your pay so we can feel empty rooms with professors at West Virgina
- 7:15University, because that's what's happening. Senor Eric Tarz with his chairman of Senate
- 7:19Finance Committee. Senor in the article in the Chronicle of Higher Education, this
- 7:25is what was part of this. It said from twenty thirteen to twenty twenty
- 7:29four fiscal years, state appropriations to WVU declined by twenty four percent, or
- 7:33one hundred forty six million dollars when adjusted for inflation, according to an analysis
- 7:40by the West Virginia Center on Budget and Policy of Public Public Policy organization.
- 7:45So has the legislature, has the has the state been tightening the grip on
- 7:53higher ed by when adjusted for inflation, reducing the financial commitment to hire it,
- 8:01You'll have tightened the grip that I would absolutely say we've tightened the grip,
- 8:03and that goes back to forcing those efficiencies. But beyond that, what
- 8:07we've also done in partnership with the Higher Education Policy Commission and university presidents across
- 8:13the state. A year before last, the legislature came out and worked with
- 8:16them to develop a higher education funding formula. And believe it or not,
- 8:20there's not been anything objective that says how we fund higher education up until two
- 8:26years ago. It's what the method has been is how strong is the university's
- 8:31lobby and what did we fund them last year? That has been how higher
- 8:35education has been funded for decades. And so we pulled the university presidents together
- 8:41and a GPC and said, you know, we need to go through and
- 8:45put a formula together for funding higher education that's based on results of those those
- 8:48institutions, and so what do we value What should a westerning at taxpayer value
- 8:54from those institutions when they're sending their children there. So now we have an
- 8:58objective measure for what programs are offered, what degrees are offered, and then
- 9:03what those results are and what their student retention is within those programs as they
- 9:07move forward, that will indicate what their funding share is amongst any university within
- 9:13the state. So we passed that law two years ago. This year the
- 9:18rules go through and so now funding for a higher education institution happens that way.
- 9:22Well, I want to go back to what you said about this Center
- 9:26for Budget and Policy, which is which is a left waning think tank in
- 9:31West Virginia. Yeah, you might as well just go out and ask the
- 9:35most left you know, congress person in the world what they think about it,
- 9:37and you're gonna get that from Center from Budget Policy. But what it
- 9:41will tell you is there has been a really good study a reference to the
- 9:45Wall Street Journal came out, adjusted for inflation, across the country, the
- 9:50flagship universities for every state. So in flagship men are usually the oldest university
- 9:54and state and they're usually your land gray institutions. Is for folks in twenty
- 10:01twelve to present the for ever reduction in state support to those universities adjusted for
- 10:07inflation. For every dollar of reduction, universities have increased their student tuition by
- 10:13two dollars and forty cents. They've spent like there's no tomorrow across the country
- 10:18and ignored what is happening within the higher education economy. W do that?
- 10:22W you do that? Well? I mean they bonded out thirty million dollars
- 10:28over the past couple of years for doing things, and and they have programs
- 10:31that are propped up that have little to know students in them, but we're
- 10:35still paying professors to teach them. So you know, I think I think
- 10:41there's some logic that that has happened there. But also have heard President Gee
- 10:46exclaiming for years now, at least since twenty twenty one, if not before,
- 10:50that this is going to be a problem and it's got to be fixed.
- 10:52But a president alone can't fix that. I got to give him props
- 10:56for what he's doing. So you give him props with what he's doing.
- 10:58He's taken a lot of heat, the administration has taken a lot of heat,
- 11:01but you, as a as a legislative leader, you believe that he
- 11:07and the university are doing the right thing. Absolutely. And I'll answer your
- 11:09question. Did Gordon ask us for money? He did not. And in
- 11:13fact I had a conversation with and he said, I know not to ask
- 11:16you for money because you can kick my butt all the way back to Mortontown.
- 11:18And that's what what happens is that because that would be the most irresponsible
- 11:24thing we could do, is to enable a program that's been developing for decades
- 11:30or a problem that's been developing for decades, States finds Committee Chairman Eric tar
- 11:33Republican Putnam County Senator. Always good to have you on. I appreciate your
- 11:37insights. You've answered some key questions about this situation. WVU. I appreciate
- 11:43you coming on today. I absolutely happen to be on any time. Hobby,
- 11:46Thank you very much. Talklient continues. We'll be right back staying with
- 11:48us. Are you tired of joint pain or muscle injuries holding you back?
- 11:52Trust the experts at CMC Orthopedics and c AMC Orthopedic Trauma for personalized treatment options
- 11:58tailored to your needs. CMC offers comprehensive orthopedic treatment for all types of pain
- 12:03and injuries. Our specialists provide tailored options from diagnosis to rehab with state of
- 12:09the art facilities for top quality care. Visit CMC dot org slash Orthopedics to
- 12:15learn more. Metro News Talk Line with Hobby Kirchibill is brought to you by
- 12:31in Coca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what do you care about
- 12:35most? Visiting coopad dot com to learn more. Talk one from Me and
- 12:37COVI Insurance Studios jackpots in the MIGI intern West Virginia. Who doesn't want to
- 12:41be a millionaire? Get in the Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays.
- 12:46The megameens drawings Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big winner?
- 12:48Play today? The Powerball jackpot is two hundred and sixty four million dollars.
- 12:52The Megames jackpot is twenty million dollars. Please welcome Brad maclan he via Skype.
- 12:58Good morning, brand Hey, come. What stood out to me about
- 13:01that interview with center Erictar and Tar is always extremely candid. Is that that,
- 13:07and I think he represents a sentiment of many of the Republicans and legislature,
- 13:11is that it the belief that WVU and or higher ed needed to right
- 13:16size and there simply was not going to be more money additional money for the
- 13:22schools. Your take. WU officials have assessed that as a practical reality that
- 13:31a couple of things. WVU has received state support fifty million dollars for the
- 13:37WU Cancer Institute, for example, also money to go toward longstanding capital improvements,
- 13:43additional dollars out of the most recent budget. But what Rob Alsop,
- 13:48the Vice president for Strategic initiatives at WVU has said is the reality is we
- 13:52have fewer students than we used to have, so it's a hard ask for
- 13:56more general revenue funding. So that it's been the reality the WV officials know
- 14:03that they can't ask for. You know, it wouldn't be a bailout,
- 14:07but it would be additional public support while WV goes through this difficult time.
- 14:11Yeah, maybe bailout's not the best term, but ww is not going to
- 14:13be able to as no other institutions going to be able to say, our
- 14:16enrollment is declining and we need more money. That's just not going to fly.
- 14:20You can agree or disagree or believe it's the wrong decision by the legislature,
- 14:26but that's the reality that the legislature simply is not of a mind to
- 14:30do that, especially with the corresponding belief that these schools need to right size.
- 14:33That is their view on this. Okay, Governor justiceys and bill signings
- 14:37today this morning as we speak. What's going on? Yeah, one is
- 14:41going on right now and it is a worthy program. It's twenty five million
- 14:46dollars in funding for Pierpont Community and Technical College. That money is going to
- 14:52be used twenty five million dollars to construct a new seventy thousand square foot hanger
- 14:58and classroom. The will house the college's popular aviation maintenance training program that is
- 15:05physically at the north Central West Virginia Airport. That's going to give Pierpont's program
- 15:11enough space to add seventy more students to that program. Now, again,
- 15:15a worthy program, sounds like it's quite popular adding more students. But from
- 15:20the big picture, when when you look at it, like we just talked
- 15:22about it, wvu's gap is forty five million dollars. People in that area
- 15:26may see twenty five million dollars going to an aviation program at Pierpont Community and
- 15:31Technical College, and they may think, well, why do we need to
- 15:35get rid of our language program? Why do we need to get rid of
- 15:37our math program. So, I mean, the state makes choices, and
- 15:41this is one. Yeah, that is one. And I don't want to
- 15:45speak for the legislature, but we've heard them make comments that, well,
- 15:50this is a program, the aviation program at Pierpont, which is expanding.
- 15:56This is a program that is more students are intera in studying. This is
- 16:00a program that where as soon as students get out of school, they immediately
- 16:03have jobs, sometimes into six figures. And the same said about the cybersecurity
- 16:08program at Marshall, where there's tremendous demand for those students. So that's where
- 16:14the legislature at least is more interest in. A governor is more interested in
- 16:18putting money into higher education programs that they believe there is a greater return.
- 16:22Again, you can agree or disagree, but that is the thinking along those
- 16:26lines. What about the announcement yesterday speaking of state investments, the state's putting
- 16:30up a huge chunk of money for an investment in Mason County. What do
- 16:33we know about that? Not enough? Sixty two and a half million dollars
- 16:37and it is going toward a company called Fidelis. And this is a project
- 16:42that's going to try to do a lot of things. That's gonna turn West
- 16:45Virginia natural gas at this Mason County property into what they're calling clean hydrogen so
- 16:52energy. That's one aspect. The second aspect is that it's intended to be
- 16:57cleaned by pumping carbon dioxide down into the ground, and that's going to happen
- 17:03apparently at West Virginia wildlife areas that question is one that's going to get a
- 17:07lot of attention. Well, what would the effect be? How would you
- 17:11pump carbon dioxide under the ground. If you're a conservationist, are you now
- 17:15worried about how to transport the natural gas to these wildlife areas? Does it
- 17:22are there? Well pads? Do you actually pump it into the ground?
- 17:26What's this going to be like? Not many of those answers are available yet.
- 17:30The third thing that this property is going to try to do is be
- 17:33one or more data centers. So it's a project trying to do a lot
- 17:37of thing with significant public dollars. And also Brad and I root for all
- 17:44of these projects. But has this even been done commercially successfully to store carbon
- 17:48dioxide underground? No, So that's another great question. There are, of
- 17:53course, as we said yesterday, big incentives through the Inflation Reduction Act to
- 17:59do this kind of carbon capture in sequestration. Is it is promising science that
- 18:06has been studied for years, but the economics of it have just not been
- 18:10there. Maybe they will be at scale, but if this project were to
- 18:14succeed, it would be groundbreaking. Indeed. Yeah, and again I don't
- 18:18want to throw water on these kinds of announcements, but everybody's happy when the
- 18:22announcement is made. There are great forecasts about what it's going to be,
- 18:25and it may well be that. I would hope it would be that.
- 18:27But I tell you, there is so much money, just billions and billions
- 18:33and billions of federal money and also a lot of state money that's available,
- 18:37and a lot of these projects, these green energy type projects are just getting
- 18:41favorable. You know, they're in a good position to get a lot of
- 18:45this federal money. And they again I'm not speaking specifically about this one,
- 18:48but they cannot all be successful. They can't all work out. I mean,
- 18:52the math just isn't there. So we need to keep an eye on
- 18:56this and see what it looks like five years from now. Quite frankly,
- 19:00one other thing, Brad, and that is the governor did in fact sign
- 19:03the property tax fix on the personal property tax on vehicles. So I don't
- 19:08know if I should mind numbingly go through that again, but I can.
- 19:12I will tell you this that the West Virginia Tax Division has the information on
- 19:17its website. The short version is that the tax reduction approved by the legislature
- 19:25includes a refund a credit on your personal property tax on your vehicles. It
- 19:30starts in twenty twenty four. However, when you get your personal property tax
- 19:36bill now on your vehicles, if you pay it in its entire team now,
- 19:41if you pay it in its entire team now, you will be able
- 19:44to get a credit for the half that was due in twenty twenty four.
- 19:47How's that? Do you understand? You follow it? I actually lost sound
- 19:53for just a second, so as a technical matter, I literally couldn't follow
- 19:57it, did you? But it doesn't mean your explanation wasn't good. No,
- 20:02I think you too, me out on purpose. I think you too,
- 20:04Brad mcclinny, Thank you, Brad. I think Brad heard me mention
- 20:07the personal property tax on vehicles and said I don't want to hear that again,
- 20:12so I won't go through it yet again. I'll just say that if
- 20:17you go to the West Virginia Tax Division website, there's a one page there
- 20:22that has a really good explanation and that will save the listeners ears from me
- 20:26having to talk about that yet again. We'll take a break and come back.
- 20:30When we come back. Former Charleston Mayor Danny Jones in the house.
- 20:33Danny always has some provocative thoughts. That's when talk Line continues on Metro News,
- 20:38the Voice of West Virginia. Talk Line on Metro News from being COVID
- 20:55Insurance Studios. Please welcome in our Charleston studios. Former Charleston mayor, video
- 20:59talk show host, restaurants tour, former legislator. Now kind of gadfly.
- 21:06I think he's bored. Part of the time is Danny Jones? Are you
- 21:08you get bored? Yeah? I do in the afternoons and I hate Sundays.
- 21:11I'll be glad when football seasons comes back. But I I I now,
- 21:17I drilled down on stuff all day, all day, all day that
- 21:19I've been curious about. Like what now you you said you're curious about viewing
- 21:26and listening habits. Okay, the last night that O'Reilly Bill O'Reilly was on
- 21:32Fox, and I don't know how many years it's been, maybe eight out
- 21:34of something like that, he had four millions. He had four million viewers,
- 21:40and I used to watch it. I like to watch in that show
- 21:42and he had four million viewers. Now that the highest rated show on talk
- 21:49television is now the Five that comes up every day at five o'clock. And
- 21:56uh, but the the venues that are holding is this one and podcasts and
- 22:03that. But your show is big, and I think it's because people want
- 22:08to be curious, are curious enough to get some depth and to learn things.
- 22:15I learned things when I listen to talk radio and listen to podcast and
- 22:18but I study history of organized crime. I study a lot of black history.
- 22:25And now that I've got time, I mean, well, good,
- 22:29well good, I'm glad you do. I mean, you text me early
- 22:32in the morning, you text me late at night about stuff you're reading,
- 22:33and well and not send you an email with stuff that I'm trying to get
- 22:38on your show. But no, I know, I like having you on.
- 22:41But I think that I try to tell like, I see a lot
- 22:44of stuff that I think you might be interested. As far as topics come
- 22:48for your show, well here's I think with television, and certainly you can
- 22:52record and watch on television, but I would say, without giving it,
- 22:57I do a lot of research that there's a couple of things there. One
- 23:00is that podcast. They're growing popular to the podcast is I want to listen
- 23:03to it when I want to listen to it, or watch it when I
- 23:06want to watch it. Because people want the convenience in the conveniences there and
- 23:08then also in the in the nighttime slots. I mean O'Riley was a major
- 23:12talent. And you know Tucker Carlson, where you liked him or didn't like
- 23:17him, was a major talent. So do you have an absence of significant
- 23:22talent was at that level? Now? I watched a hit YouTube because I'm
- 23:29not crazy about Tucker Carlson, but he had a he had a podcast I
- 23:33guess he puts or a video cast he put on YouTube where he was interviewing
- 23:37ice Cube and it was fascinating, was it? Oh gosh, he talked.
- 23:42He said, why are you talking to me? And ice Cube said,
- 23:45because I think people should talk to each other. Okay, that's remarkable.
- 23:49I mean, I think that's so profound. I like ice Cube.
- 23:52I don't get into rep music, but I thought the movie Barber Shop was
- 23:56was precious. It was a great movie. I mean it was fun.
- 24:00Danny Jones is with is. What do you think of the latest Trump indictment.
- 24:03I think she's way out over Skis. I don't know why in the
- 24:07world you would want to bring a state Rico case. First thing, I
- 24:12don't think she has a jurisdiction what she could have done. In other words,
- 24:17Mark Meadows has already made a move to go into federal court, and
- 24:19I think a bunch of them will. And there was a case in New
- 24:25Jersey in nineteen eighty seven eighty eight, and they made a movie about it
- 24:30called Find Me Guilty, And it was a mafia trial with twenty twenty one
- 24:36defendant at the last twenty one months and they found them all not guilty.
- 24:40And it has the potential to turn into a circus. Well, ones,
- 24:44here's an on the Rico charge, And I know that there's a lot of
- 24:48speculation like this is very significant because it's rico and if convicted, you have
- 24:52a mandatory minimum five years in prison. And I get all that, But
- 24:56you know what, Danny and a lot of re you'll usually hear about with
- 25:00organized crime, you know that, you know the deal about organized crime,
- 25:03it's actually organized, okay, meaning that there is an organization to the crime
- 25:11that is committed in this instance, In these instances, I wonder if I
- 25:15don't get a sense it was that highly organized as much as it was the
- 25:19gang that couldn't shoot straight. Just like Willy Nilly, Trump says something today
- 25:23and somebody goes out and tries it, somebody else tries something else, somebody
- 25:27else's spit bawling. Giuliani's down there just you know, wild accusations. I
- 25:32mean, is that organized, an organized effort or just like just that she's
- 25:37trying to turn it into an enterprise. And I don't think it's a good
- 25:41idea of what she should have done. And I'm not a lawyer, folks,
- 25:44if I get it, but what she should have done. You picked
- 25:47the two top guys, you picked Trump and Juliani, and you make witnesses
- 25:51out of the rest of them, and all you have to do to do
- 25:52that is bring him in front of the grand jury. She proved she can
- 25:56do that when when she had Lindsay Graham's appointed, and you make them all
- 26:00take community so they can't take the fifth and that's where her witnesses could come
- 26:03from. That's not used very often, but that's what could be done.
- 26:08It was just I don't get it. This case will there's no way this
- 26:12case will be hurt before the election, and what started with a phone call
- 26:17of the Secretary of State the president. Trump has some grievance here because this
- 26:22case could have been wrong about a long time ago. So you're question the
- 26:27timeliness of it. I do. And now I text you last night I
- 26:32think they may bring a case in Arizona. And Katie Hobbs, who's who's
- 26:37the governor out there is is pushing it. And you know in the Washington
- 26:41Post there's a lady that right, I can't remember. Her last name is
- 26:45Marcus, and she said, look are we getting is this a little bit
- 26:51too much? I think it is? For me? The case is the
- 26:55one in DC. That's the case for me. I mean, that's the
- 26:57one if they convict him of it. At that's almost edition. Are you
- 27:00following the WU stuff? Are you following that at all? I am.
- 27:04I followed from you. And I think that's one of the treasures that you
- 27:07give us to edge because I'm not a college boy. And uh and well
- 27:14yeah, you know why because you were overserving. You were serving Vietnam.
- 27:17You were serving the country in Vietnam. So well, we just the guys
- 27:21that I was friends with, We worked on cars. I raced a car
- 27:25the summer sixty nine, won six trophies. And when the summer is over,
- 27:27I got drafted and I went to Beckley and they said, you're going
- 27:32in the Marine Corps. I said, oh, no, I'm not.
- 27:33Oh yes you are, And I did. And it was one of the
- 27:37greatest experiences in my life. I look back on. I can't believe they
- 27:41paid me, even though it wasn't very much. But but what ranked did
- 27:45you achieve? E three? I was in there lance corporal. Okay.
- 27:49They offered for me to ship and ship for three years and make corporal and
- 27:56then I wound up probably driving to general or but or I could have gone
- 28:00into food service, which I was thinking about doing. Anyway, were in
- 28:03Vietnam five months. I was on Okla No War for five months. I
- 28:08was in Vietnam for five months. We came on early. We came home
- 28:11too early for me to get an early out, so I spent the summer
- 28:15in California and which I suffered through that, And I drove a school bus,
- 28:18which was very difficult. They can use that they need school bus drivers.
- 28:22Now, well, i'd drive you help out, No, I don't.
- 28:26I don't think. I I think I'd rather study than do that.
- 28:30One One more thing that the state you had, Senator tarl And I'm going
- 28:36to go back and listen to it because I couldn't hear it, but they
- 28:40need to be careful about passing on these jail fees these cities. Remember,
- 28:45cities are political subdivisions of the state. And if one of them files Chapter
- 28:51nine. I've told the last three mayors of Huntington. Police don't get mad
- 28:53at me, Steve, but Steve Williams that they ought a file Chapter nine
- 28:57because this fully will stop. But it does. Do municipalities not bear some
- 29:03responsibility if if the city police arrest somebody in the city for a crime in
- 29:08the city, and then and then the individual has to be taken to a
- 29:11regional jail. And why does the city have no financial responsibility for them?
- 29:15Because they take them in front they are agents of the state and they take
- 29:19them in front of a magistrate. And which is with the counties and the
- 29:25sheriffs have always been keepers of the jail. Which is all county and the
- 29:30county can raise taxes and the we talked about the sales tax. I think
- 29:36the counties. The counties can't impose a sales tax. They can impose a
- 29:40higher property tax. Higher property tax, yes, but the city can add
- 29:42on a sales tax, add on to a sales tax. But we have
- 29:45to. We did that, and half of it went to pay the pensions,
- 29:48and half of it went to pay for the new Civic Center, the
- 29:52Danny Jones Convention Center and it and but it won't. You can't just do
- 30:00it and not take off another tact. It's very complicated. The Republicans are
- 30:06not pro pro municipal, their per rural and this doesn't work well for the
- 30:11cities. All right, Former Charleston Mayor Danny Jones, I look forward to
- 30:15your text at eleven tonight or whatever you're enthused about. Thanks for not smoking.
- 30:19Okay, let's see talk line continues. We'll return in just a moment's
- 30:23day with Metro News. Talk Line with Hobby Kirchiblas brought to you by in
- 30:40COVID Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most.
- 30:45Visiting coovid dot com to learn more Talk line from me and COVID Insurance studios.
- 30:48Are you ready to hire as a business owner? Finding qualified employees can
- 30:52be a struggle, sorting through endless resumes, interviewing candidates that don't fit the
- 30:56bill. It's time consuming, it's constantly work force. West Virginia is your
- 31:00partner in funding qualified talent through virtual job fairs and tabword recruitment strategies. Workforce
- 31:07West Virginia provides a reliable pipeline of talented individuals ready to contribute your company's growth
- 31:11and success. So when you're ready to start hiring, start with Workforce West
- 31:15Virginia. Visit Workforce wv dot org to learn more. This outreach campaign is
- 31:22one finance by federal funds. So for years, computers were just thought of
- 31:26as really fast but dumb tools. Now, with artificial intelligence, computers are
- 31:33for lack of a better term, thinking. And I'm trying to decide as
- 31:36I read and study about this, whether this is fascinating or whether this is
- 31:41frightening. Joining us on Metro News talk Line is Amy Seifert. She's a
- 31:44lecture at the w College of Walls who she studies this and she recently gave
- 31:48her presentation on artificial intelligence ethics and its implications for communications. She joins us
- 31:53on Metro News talk line, Amy, good morning. Should we be frightened
- 31:56or should we be fascinated? Well? Good learning, hoppy? I guess
- 32:00can we be both? Yes? We can, yes, we might we
- 32:04might need to be both. I talk all the time hoppy about both the
- 32:07promise and the peril. Start with the promise, Start with the promise.
- 32:09Well, the promise is incredible. Some of these tools, especially these sort
- 32:14of new generation artificial intelligence tools that are fueled by deep learning and machine learning
- 32:21and are amazing. They can do things that really can help us. They
- 32:23can they can screen melanoma from a picture of a patience, and they can
- 32:30screen it at a better, more reliable, you know, rate than than
- 32:35a doctor might even be able to and they can give us early detection.
- 32:38When COVID was out, some of these AI tools could help us predict the
- 32:42next wave of COVID and help us know where to deploy resources. That's amazing
- 32:45and that's something we should invest in and be excited about and we should lean
- 32:50into. Okay, there's there's a lot of peril too, Okay, p
- 32:53well it. You know, there's there's a different peril for different tools.
- 32:57But the thing that we all need to understand about artificial intel lugence is it
- 33:00as our creation and it often reflects back our own biases, our own you
- 33:07know, inability to always be able to get things right. And it's also
- 33:12prone to something we call AI hallucination. Well, these new these new generative
- 33:16AI tools, things that people have heard of like chat GPT. These aren't
- 33:21research tools. These aren't you know, news databases, and these are just
- 33:25tools that have been designed to talk like humans, to predict based on their
- 33:30data, training set, the way we would talk if we were talking about
- 33:32a topic. But they make things up, and they make things up with
- 33:37really amazing confidence. Since some lawyers have recently gotten into trouble because they use
- 33:43chat GPT to help them draft illegal brief and that the tool gave them some
- 33:47cases that were really great for them, really supported their client's position. How
- 33:52wonderful they turn that into the judge. Opposing council says, uh, here,
- 33:55honor, we can't find these cases that have cited. Could you ask
- 34:00opposing counsel to give us copies? And of course, hoppy, that's that's
- 34:04pretty rare that you wouldn't be able to find a case. Well, it
- 34:07turns out CHATCHYPT just made them up. It made really this entirely guess and
- 34:10when the lawyer said these are real cases, right, CHATCHYPT said sure.
- 34:15So the lawyers this was up in New York, you know, Unfortunately they
- 34:17had to. They had to face professional discipline and a whole lot of embarrassment
- 34:22because it was all over the news. Why would why would why would the
- 34:25AI? Why would it make it up? Look? The first thing,
- 34:29the first thing we need to remember, Hoppy, is these tools they aren't
- 34:31capable of having human concepts like lying. They all they are programmed to do
- 34:38is to say, based on my data training, if somebody were going to
- 34:42write a legal brief about this, these are the types of words they would
- 34:45use. And so they know that lawyer site cases, and so the tool
- 34:50says, great, here's a case, and if it said this, wouldn't
- 34:52it be wonderful. They aren't research tools, and they aren't intentionally trying to
- 34:58mislead us because they can't intention and only try anything. There You are you
- 35:00sure? Are you sure? I mean that's and that's whatever. That's kind
- 35:04of the paranoia that it does get to the point where, like you say,
- 35:07right now, it's it's creating, but it's it doesn't have a conscience,
- 35:13right, I mean, it's not consciously making something up right, That's
- 35:16that's right. I don't think we've we've reached any kind of level yet where
- 35:20we actually have you know, true general artificial intelligence or anything like that.
- 35:24You're right, they don't have a conscience, and that's important to remember,
- 35:29Hoppy, because these tools can sound so convincingly human. A lot of times
- 35:34people are more likely to believe misinformation when it's been provided by an AI tool
- 35:37than if it's been provided by another human. We can't distinguish anymore what is
- 35:43written by AI from what is written by humans. So they sound like us,
- 35:46but they are not us. We take, for example, like look
- 35:50at I think one of the first applications of misuse, there's got to be
- 35:52in politics where you could one could take AI and create image of a politician
- 36:01saying something and it sounds exactly like their voice. It looks like that individual,
- 36:06It looks for all intensive purposes real, but it's not. It's such
- 36:12a great point, Hoppy, and that's the kind of stuff that keeps me
- 36:15up at night. What you're talking about. We describe it in technology as
- 36:19a deep fake, and the idea is that we are now able to convince
- 36:22very realistic looking videos, sound bites, other things. Hoppy, you would
- 36:27be really actually at great risk for having your voice put into a deep fake,
- 36:31because we have hours and hours and hours of you speaking, and the
- 36:36more recording we have for the database, the more the better A tool that
- 36:39was trying to spoof Hoppy kirchible could be. So it would actually not be
- 36:44terribly hard for somebody to train an algorithm on the hours of your voice and
- 36:47then program that algorithm to say whatever they wanted to in the sound of your
- 36:52voice. Tell me, tell me this. Let's go to law enforcement for
- 36:54a minute. And this made me think of the movie Minority Report. Frankly,
- 36:59but it could you are their algorithms? Could an algorithm be created through
- 37:02AI that says an individual and here's everything we know about this individual, and
- 37:07they're coming, they're in jail, they're up for parole, and then you
- 37:13use AI to determine whether this individual is likely or unlikely to commit a crime.
- 37:17Again, what about that application, oh, Hoppy, Not only could
- 37:21they do, it's already get use. It's at us across the country.
- 37:23Really talking about is called a recidivism prediction tool. Maxie wrote a law of
- 37:28your article about this because these tools scare me a lot. Like you said,
- 37:30Minority Report, that's what we all think of. So essentially, we
- 37:35have tools that use machine learning algorithms or other types of algorithms in our court
- 37:39system, and they say this person is more or less likely to reoffend.
- 37:44That's what we call, you know, just committing another crime. And it
- 37:46shouldn't surprise you to hear that. There have been a lot of researchers who
- 37:50have been able to show that these tools they produce biased outputs. And the
- 37:54reason is not because the people who designed them intentionally made them that way or
- 37:59because of something sinister like that. The reason is because they're trained on historical
- 38:04criminal data. And we know that our criminal justice system has faced issues with
- 38:07bias and other problems for decades, and so we really can't be surprised when
- 38:12a tool that has been trained on something that had biased data produces a biased
- 38:16output. You know, in computer science they call it garbage in, garbage
- 38:20out. In this context, we call it bias in, bias out.
- 38:23But yep, they're already at use. They're at use across the country.
- 38:27Hey, this is fascinating. I'd like to like to speak with you further,
- 38:31and i'd like maybe for to get together sometime and have you show me
- 38:36some things because I'm trying to educate myself on this front. Do you think
- 38:38we could work that out? Absolutely? It'd be an honor. All right,
- 38:42thank you, Amy. Good to talk to Amy Seifert on lecture at
- 38:45the w College of Law. Just very very scratching the surface on AI.
- 38:49It's fascinating. I need to learn more about it. I look forward to
- 38:52doing that. Talk on from mean Cove Insurance Studios, text Copy Bureau of
- 39:07Labor Statistics in the FAA project a ten thousand commercial pilot shortage in five years.
- 39:12These programs like the one that Pierpont Community Technical College currently have one hundred
- 39:17percent placement one hundred percent. Two point four percent of incoming workforce in twenty
- 39:22thirty are projected to be in US drone industry, flying servicing, maintaining,
- 39:28loading, etc. Our state should rightly invest where the market dictates, says
- 39:32the texture, and that is the ongoing yin and yang of this. What
- 39:37is the role of a higher education institution now Pierponds Community Technical College, But
- 39:40is it to provide an individual with a broad liberal arts education or is it
- 39:45to train someone to be in the workforce where the demand exists? Back in
- 39:52six minutes, this is talk line on Metro News. Metro News is the
- 39:54Voice of West Virginia. Welcome back out number two talk line on the Metro
- 40:17News readio network all across the great state of West Virginia. Happy kirchiville with
- 40:22you. I have so many questions for my next guest. It's Tom Barkin.
- 40:25Tom Barkin as president and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond.
- 40:30West Virginia is in that district that Tom represents, and he's coming to West
- 40:35Virginia later this month. By the way, we'll talk more about that and
- 40:37he joins us on Metro and his talk on Tom. Good to have you
- 40:38back. How are you, hey, Hoppy, Thanks for having me back,
- 40:42Thanks for coming on. Let's I got a lot of things to cover
- 40:45here. Let's start with inflation. A isn't inflation still too high? And
- 40:50what's the fair going to do about that? If anything? Well, if
- 40:53you look at the twelve months numbers, is definitely too high, but I
- 40:57think the last couple of months have been encouraging. If you look at the
- 41:00three month average, you're actually at target. And so I don't think our
- 41:04job is done yet, but it's definitely headed in the right direction. And
- 41:07you can see some of these supply chain issues that hit us during COVID being
- 41:12largely in the rear view mirror. You can see some of the energy things
- 41:15that hit us right after the Ukrainian invasion that seemed more in the rear view
- 41:21mirror. And so now we're getting the economy we've got, which is still
- 41:23growing, and inflation is still a bit too high, and hopefully that'll settle
- 41:29in the coming months. Will there be another rate increase, Well, we'll
- 41:32have to see what the data says. I think looking at inflation is the
- 41:37right place to look, though, because our objective isn't to increase rates.
- 41:40Our objective is to get inflation under control and correctly if I'm wrong, But
- 41:45when when inflation is measured, always read and says well, except for the
- 41:50volatile commodities of fuel and food, to which I always say, wow,
- 41:55guess what everybody's doing today. They're buying fuel and food. So to me,
- 42:00there's a disconnect of Okay, yes, inflation is coming down, it's
- 42:02not nine percent, it's three it's three something now. But when you go
- 42:06to the grocery store and you start buying hamburger or cereal or whatever, it
- 42:10still seems pretty high. And you go to the gas, well, gas
- 42:14prices are going back up. So do you see the disconnect there? Yoh
- 42:19yeah. And I think you know a reminder for everybody listening, our target
- 42:22isn't on core. Our targets on total inflation, which includes gas and food
- 42:27and shelter and everything else that matters to people, and so we are very
- 42:31focused on that. When people talk about core, they're really talking about predicting
- 42:37the future, not talking about the present. So our target is the full
- 42:40number. But when we're trying to figure out how close are we to hitting
- 42:44that number, you're trying to figure out, if you strip out the volatle
- 42:46stuff, are we headed in the right direction. So I look at the
- 42:49total number, I look at the core number, and until both of them
- 42:52are where you want them to be, I don't think we'll have inflation under
- 42:54control. But Tom Barkin is with us, and he is the Presidency Reserve
- 43:00Bank of Richmond's going to be in West Virginia d this month. We'll talk
- 43:01more about that. So you know the old saying time that economists have predicted
- 43:06ten of the last five recessions, and so we never had a recession,
- 43:09right, So what happened? And I'm glad we didn't, But I mean,
- 43:12what happened or is one still pending? I know the stock markets way
- 43:15down this week, but what's going on? Well? I keep saying,
- 43:17if you keep predicting a recession, eventually, you're going to be right.
- 43:21I mean, nobody, nobody ever canceled the business cycle. So we'll have
- 43:24one in time, I'm sure. A reminder that most recessions, you know,
- 43:29don't come gradually. They come suddenly. If you think about the pandemic,
- 43:32you think about the global financial crisis, you think about the one after
- 43:35nine to eleven, some outside force comes in, and so I think predicting
- 43:38a recession is a difficult business, a dangerous business. The way I think
- 43:43about it is this, which is the American economy is amazingly vibrus. And
- 43:49that's true when you compare it across the world, and that's you know,
- 43:52what we've done to build this country. I'd say, in addition to that,
- 43:57there's a bunch of these pandemic era forces that are still with us.
- 44:00You know, people who got stimulus and are still spending. At the stock
- 44:04markets up, that's supporting spending. In addition, unemployments very low. People
- 44:08have jobs and in a lot of sectors. Wages are up, which means
- 44:13people have money to spend in all that supporting the economy. On the other
- 44:17side, we're raising rates, and so again we're you know, our objective
- 44:22isn't to create a recession. Our objective is to get inflation under control.
- 44:24And so think of it as leaning against the wind. You've got all this
- 44:29spending going on. We're raising rates as an effort to sort of tamp it
- 44:32down, not to hurt the economy, but to keep inflation under control.
- 44:37And we'll see how much you know, a tailwin or headwin we have as
- 44:42we get through the fall and into next year. Are you worried about the
- 44:45debt national debt? Just some numbers. In two thousand and nineteen forty six,
- 44:54after World War Two, our debt was one hundred and six percent of
- 44:58GDP. Our parents and our grandparents paid that down over the next sixty years.
- 45:04By two thousand and seven it was thirty eight percent of GDP. Now
- 45:07it's up to one hundred and six percent again. And there's no one number
- 45:10that's you know, means that some things fall off the table, but you
- 45:15know, trees don't grow to the sky, and there will be some point
- 45:17somewhere if we keep growing the debt where our creditors will say, you know,
- 45:22I don't just don't like that credit anymore, right, and that will
- 45:25mean interest rates will go up, and they'll go up, you know,
- 45:28in the same way that people don't like it when we raise our interest rates,
- 45:30that'll raise interest rates across the curve. So that's not a place you
- 45:34want to be. So that would be that would result in those who buy
- 45:37our debt being more reluctant to buy our debt. Therefore we'd have to give
- 45:43a higher interest rate on that so they get more return. Therefore we have
- 45:45even less money. I mean, is there is there a death spiral here?
- 45:51Well, that's not That's not how you wanted to go. What you
- 45:53wanted to go is to you want to either grow faster so that you know
- 45:59you can therefore taking more revenue and have smaller deficits, or you want to
- 46:05have spending less and excess of your revenues. That's how you avoid that scenario.
- 46:09Tom Barkin is with its president CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond.
- 46:14You're going to be in West Virginia this lay of this month. What
- 46:15are you going to be doing. I'm in Logan and Boone Counties for a
- 46:20couple of days doing what we usually do, trying to try and talk to
- 46:22local businesses and understand how they're experience in the economy, trying to understand economic
- 46:28revitalization efforts and what's being successful and what the challenges are. And then there
- 46:31are always issues in the small towns where in housing is what I'm hearing a
- 46:36lot about these days, and trying to figure out how people are managing to
- 46:38cope with those issues you talked about inflation. I'm always trying to understand how
- 46:44people are experiencing that day to day, trying to understand labor markets, what's
- 46:47working, what's not working, what it takes to get more people off the
- 46:51sidelines. I'd like to say, we have a beautiful twenty fourth story building
- 46:54in Richmond right on five. It's quite literally in Ivory Tower, and I
- 46:59just don't think you can understand the economy from the building. So I'm out
- 47:02every week in the markets that we serve doing my best to understand, you
- 47:07know, what the economy is do in real time. Well, I really
- 47:10appreciate the fact that you're coming and coming to that part of West Virginia,
- 47:14and you probably already know. I'll give you heads up on a few things.
- 47:16One is that those are typically those are economically depressed regions. The codustry,
- 47:22of course, not nearly what it was. They try to they try
- 47:25to fight back, but it's difficult to attract new businesses there. There's a
- 47:29workforce issue of when there are new businesses, of attracting and retaining a workforce.
- 47:36There's an opioid drug crisis, there's an access issue. You want me
- 47:42to keep going. I mean, they're just there's just a lot of head
- 47:45winds in these communities right now. And I appreciate that, and that's I
- 47:49think we've got a round table. Everything you mentioned I think is on our
- 47:52on our list, and I don't think I'm not so arrogantist to think we
- 47:54can solve those things. But I do think it's important as we try to
- 48:00do our best to steer the economy, to understand how people on the ground
- 48:02are experience in it and and for a lot of folks in West Virginia.
- 48:06I don't mean to be lecturing you, and you're the fed guy, but
- 48:08I mean that it's just the day to day of gas prices, grocery prices,
- 48:15the car broke down, repairing the vehicle, you know, mortgage,
- 48:20roof leak. I mean that kind of stuff. I mean, that's everyday
- 48:22stuff that that we face here in West Virginia that as you stay, is
- 48:24outside of the ou retire. And I'm not again, don't get me wrong,
- 48:28I'm not lecturing you. I'm just telling you that's what's happening. I
- 48:31appreciate that, and that's the kind of stuff that makes me even more committed
- 48:35on the inflation side, because a lot of stuff you talked about, gas
- 48:37prices, grocery prices, the cost of home repair, the challenge of buying
- 48:42a house, all that is prices. And if there's one thing we've relearned
- 48:45over the last couple of years is that we actually just hate inflation. It
- 48:50feels unfair. You know, you might get a raise and then you've got
- 48:52to spend it at the gas bump, and frankly, it's just exhausting.
- 48:55It's hard to shop around for higher prices. It's just a pain to deal
- 49:00with somebody who's trying to raise your prices, shop around for lower prices,
- 49:04or deal with someone who's trying to raise your prices, So I think it
- 49:07just makes the case why you've got to get inflation under control. Here's a
- 49:10loaded question you may want to dodge, but I appreciate your candor if you
- 49:14choose to be did the Inflation Reduction Act reduce inflation? Well? I think
- 49:22the way to think about it is that it's our job to take care of
- 49:25inflation, and the federal government does a set of things that help and a
- 49:30set of things that hurt. And if you if the federal government runs bigger
- 49:35deficits, that doesn't help. On the other hand, if the federal government
- 49:37can build some supply work the supply side, whether that be on the labor
- 49:43side or on the manufacturing side, that helps. And I don't spend a
- 49:46lot of time just to not answer your loaded question trying to do the puts
- 49:51in the takes on any particular bill. I take the world as it comes
- 49:53and we try to do what we can on inflation. Are you concerning the
- 49:59overall well being of the country's economy in the micro, in the macro,
- 50:07competing globally in the micro? What's happening in Logan County? Are you an
- 50:09optimist? Well, I'm an optimist about the US. If you look at
- 50:15every country in the world has experienced the set of horses that where we've experienced
- 50:20coming in and out of the pandemic and with the Ukrainian conflict in the like,
- 50:23and it's hard to find an economy that's growing the way our economy is
- 50:28growing. Look at China, for example, which looks like it's plummeting and
- 50:32in deflation. And then well, our inflation isn't where we want it to
- 50:36be. You know, we're a lot happier than if we're in Europe.
- 50:38We're inflation significantly higher, so you know, again, we have more to
- 50:43do. I don't think we're anywhere close to a full victory, but we're
- 50:49in a lot better shape than any other country you can think of in the
- 50:52world. Tom bark And, President CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond,
- 50:55coming to West Virginia later this month, going to southern West Virginia.
- 50:59I think you're also going to the meeting it's gonna be taking place. Yeah,
- 51:01well, listen, it's good to talk to you again. And I
- 51:05appreciate the fact that you're coming to West Virginia, and I think that's great.
- 51:07I think that's great. So I'm glad you're gonna be here. It's
- 51:09good to talk to you again. Thanksp. We appreciate what you do every
- 51:13day. Thank you very much, appreciate it. Talk line continues, We'll
- 51:15be right back. Stay with US Metro News. Talk Line with Hobby Kirchibile
- 51:30is brought to you by in Covid Insurance and circling you with coverage to protect
- 51:34what do you care about most? Visit incovid dot com to learn more talk
- 51:37line from me and COVID Insurance Studios. Network security is serious business, and
- 51:42city net is serious about protecting your business and your employees from today's constant barrage
- 51:47of cybersecurity threats. Let's city Neet be your cybersecurity hero. Learn more citynet
- 51:52dot net. Let me do some texts Hobby. University needs to tighten its
- 51:58belt. Audit every department. Did the university pay for the BLM stickers on
- 52:02the helmets or does that money come from the athletic director's budget? Who pays
- 52:07for things like that? Okay, first, the repositioning that WV is doing
- 52:16is based on the based on audits by the consulting firm that they hired.
- 52:22So there are audits so that the university can make the argument that, well,
- 52:30this department has declining enrollment but still has these high faculty costs, so
- 52:35you got to give that some scrutiny. So there is an audit or review,
- 52:38whatever you want to call it. And the BLM stickers, I don't
- 52:42know what they cost. A couple hundred bucks. Yeah, not the problem,
- 52:46I'll be I'm no expert on finances, but the university is going broken,
- 52:50students can't pay loans. Looks like another hit to the taxpayer coming soon.
- 52:53If well, the university can pay its bills. The university is paying
- 52:58its bills, and it's take these steps so it can continue to pay its
- 53:01bills. And isn't another Alderson broadness. Also that the interview with Center Eric
- 53:08Tarr indicated that there's not more money coming. There may be, I mean,
- 53:15I think the Republican legislature is interested and willing to invest in projects where
- 53:22they think there's a return, like the cancer center, like the cybersecurity Center
- 53:28at Marshall, like Pure Pond as we've talked about many, many times.
- 53:30But when it comes to just providing more money to meet a budget when enrollment
- 53:37is declining, that's a hard no that you can hear from lawmakers, and
- 53:43it's not just Derek Tarr that is a hard no. Let's see Hobby the
- 53:50Cancer Institute of a partnership between w and WV Medicine. W Medicine is not
- 53:53a not for profit health system. This is different than giving funding just to
- 53:58a universe. The text three or four Talk three or four Happy two coaches
- 54:02eight million dollars plus shut down Potomac State and WVU Tech. Again, the
- 54:08coaches salaries are paid for by Athletic Department revenue and they are not taxpayer dollars.
- 54:20Also, I don't know when it was, but I think there's been
- 54:22I think there's been a couple of years or a year where the WU Athletic
- 54:27Department gave additional money to the university part to the academic field. Maybe they
- 54:32do it every year, I'm not sure. I mean, they paid the
- 54:36school for the scholarships, they paid the academic side for the scholarships. I
- 54:38know that there might have been some years where they gave them more money.
- 54:45Happy the Hydrogen Plant is trying to strong arm their neighbors for their lands so
- 54:49it can be used for carbon storage, using the Economic Development Office to push
- 54:53it. Do some checking, you'll find out the game they are playing,
- 54:58says the texture. Three oh four talk three oh four Hoppy Center Tar is
- 55:07following the exact playbook of the Cardinal Institute, demand the closure of several state
- 55:12colleges, the elimination of all collegiate athletic programs outside of WVU, and Marshall
- 55:17says the texture Let's see. I don't know, okay, I don't know
- 55:27what that isp. Why didn't Governor Justice mention in his speech yesterday that the
- 55:34energy company locating here is because of the Inflation Reduction Act. I don't want
- 55:38to speak for Governor Justice, but I'll tell you this is that if you
- 55:45ask West Virginians, I'm going to speak in generalizations here. You ask West
- 55:51Virginians, what do you think of the Inflation Reduction Act? Oh, I'm
- 55:55against it, not everyone, but a majority because it's a Joe Biden,
- 56:01Joe Mansion thing. It's the Joes that got that through. So that's why
- 56:07there would be a lot of opposition to the Inflation Reduction Act. However,
- 56:14who wants to go to groundbreaking, Everybody who wants to go to the ribbon
- 56:17cutting? Everybody, Hoppy, here's a typical segment on a nightly cable show,
- 56:25the problem in the Middle East? How would you solve it? You
- 56:28have thirty seconds go. I think about how ridiculous that is, says the
- 56:32texture tomorrow night on cable news. What's the one true religion? Tech Stoppy?
- 56:40Why haven't CenTra tar and other legislative leaders taken on the obvious overbuilt post
- 56:46secondary institutional structure. It was Virginia and closed some public institutions, a problem
- 56:52that's been neglected for years. Otherwise mediocracy for all? Well, if I
- 57:00know that's been talked about a lot over the years. There are too many
- 57:04colleges and universities in West Virginia. Maybe there are, especially since the demographics
- 57:09show that the state's population is not growing and the number of college age students
- 57:15in West Virginia is either not growing or declining. So it is very tough
- 57:21right now for these colleges and universities. Does West Virginia have too many?
- 57:24Probably? But who's gonna who wants to make that call? That takes a
- 57:30lot of political will Abe pretty much just did it to itself, just died
- 57:35on the vine. But boy, you try to close another one or others
- 57:42going to be a heck of a fight, Hoppy. I hope Sandrew Tarn
- 57:49remembers that these programs he thinks are superfluous are commonly known as humanities, and
- 57:53part of what makes us human. Puppetry is one of the most ancient art
- 57:58forms. Millions have been educated to entertained by puppets over the ears. Maybe
- 58:02muppets ring a bell says the texture. I get it. Like many I
- 58:08love puppets. But if you're talking about having to make tough decisions, and
- 58:19you look at the puppetry program and you see a declining number of students,
- 58:24what should you do? It would be pretty to think that you could have
- 58:29all of these things. I wish they could. I think everybody wishes they
- 58:32could. But can you can you continue to afford to do that, especially
- 58:39when you face the democratic demographic cliff, especially when the message is clear from
- 58:46the legislature You're not going to get any more money just to sustain your budget.
- 58:53Not going to happen, but not going to happen. All right,
- 59:00We'll take a break and come back. We'll come back on Metro News talk
- 59:02Line and continuing in our series of companies in West Virginia that export this is
- 59:07talk line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia, lots of worlds.
- 59:23He's my trouble man talk line from me and COVA Insurance Studios. Jackpots
- 59:30in the millions here in West Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a millionaire?
- 59:32Getting the powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays and the Mega Millions drawings
- 59:37on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big winter Plate? Today?
- 59:39The powerball jackpot is two hundred and sixty four million dollars. The Megamillis
- 59:44jackpot is twenty million dollars. Tech three or four talks three or four hoppy
- 59:47as crazy as Trump sometimes is, so it's the texture. It really does
- 59:53appear the swamp people are piling on to make one percent sure. He's smeared
- 59:59and tied up in court so much he has no chance of competing against Grandpa
- 1:00:02Biden. Yeah. Look, I've said many many times I think that Trump
- 1:00:07is disqualified from ever holding office again for a variety of reasons. But yeah,
- 1:00:13it does have a feel like really again another one, I mean,
- 1:00:16it has a if you don't look at these very very closely, just you
- 1:00:22observe them overall, it does have a piling on field to it. Certainly,
- 1:00:31I'll be be that AI is for the birds. I'll be almost all
- 1:00:37shows, all news outlets turned to turn into podcasts, and you can listen
- 1:00:42to them and speed them up and skip the commercials. Don't skip the commercials.
- 1:00:49I'll be artificial intelligence. It's been around for a long time. It's
- 1:00:51called the media. At least we're rated as intelligent. I'll be The charade
- 1:00:58the Democrats are putting on with all these indictments of Trump and his associates is
- 1:01:01going to come back and bite them on the buttocks. They're demonstrating exactly what
- 1:01:06Trump accused them of doing. Election interference. Election interference hoppy like Star Walt
- 1:01:14Danny Jones is always entertaining, but he's wrong on Rico. The name is
- 1:01:17corrupt organizations, not competent. Nothing Trump did was competent, but it was
- 1:01:22absolutely corrupt. The well again, is that you have You would have to
- 1:01:30show that this was a conspiracy among the actors, among all these people to
- 1:01:37overturn the result of the election in Georgia. And was it a true conspiracy?
- 1:01:44Were all these people working together, conspiring together in a particular way,
- 1:01:49to change the outcome? Or was it? And it would to me,
- 1:01:52there's no question. There's no question that these actors, starting with the president,
- 1:01:57were directly involved in trying to change the outcome of the election, even
- 1:02:00when they were presented with information that the allegations they were making were not true.
- 1:02:05However, was it a coherent conspiracy or was it? Was it just
- 1:02:08guys and women? Was it just individuals who support Trump in there? Just
- 1:02:15shotgun blasting the thing, trying to find something or anything tech copy? Did
- 1:02:24you just make a date with with who? A lot of people I have
- 1:02:31and I like, I mean, I really like talking the Federal Reserve when
- 1:02:37I had Tom Barkin on. I've been doing this for a long time and
- 1:02:43I don't ever remember until Tom Barkin came to the Federal Reserve in Richmond,
- 1:02:46ever even talking did the head of the Federal Reserve in Richmond, which covers
- 1:02:51West Virginia. So and they've been they reach out to me and say,
- 1:02:54listen, can we come on the show. We're going to be in West
- 1:02:57Virginia. Yeah, sure, come on. And and the fact that here
- 1:03:00is the head of the Federal Reserve in Richmond, the Federal Reserve which covers
- 1:03:04West Virginia, Virginia, I think North Carolina, Maryland, and he's coming
- 1:03:07to Logan County. That's awesome. That's awesome, and he said it himself.
- 1:03:13Get out of the Ivory Tower on ninety five and come and see what's
- 1:03:15happening in your district. Good for him. Happy, Our country of liberals
- 1:03:23has destroyed the moral values of working hard to better oneself. Everyone gets a
- 1:03:28trophy regardless of how hard you work, says the texture Hoppy. How much
- 1:03:34does China or do Chinese proxies own of West Virginia Land? Answer? I
- 1:03:39don't know. Happy, AI is coming just in time for your retirement instead
- 1:03:45of two thousand and one space Odyssey. How it's going to be called hop
- 1:03:50highly opinionated political computer? Well aie. The one of the areas that AI
- 1:03:54is making tremendous inroads is in media. Is in media and in news stories.
- 1:04:00I mean, now there are news stories that are put together by AI.
- 1:04:02I think it started primarily with sports, but there are news stories that
- 1:04:05are done by AI. Happy the WU president makes eight hundred thousand dollars a
- 1:04:12year. I know where the cuts should be and it shouldn't be a tuition
- 1:04:15increase. All right, you can cut GE's salary by four hundred thousand dollars.
- 1:04:17And by the way, I do know that, and you can.
- 1:04:20There's a legitimate discussion, a legitimate debate when you are cutting positions as to
- 1:04:26whether the president of the university is overpaid. I would argue that he's not.
- 1:04:32I mean, I think that West Virginia is fortunate of Gordon Ge,
- 1:04:35and I think he's done a really good job. I know what he's doing
- 1:04:39now is very, very controversial, but it needs to be done. Did
- 1:04:42make g made a critical mistake in twenty fourteen and maybe he was just too
- 1:04:47aspirational when he said that we're gonna have forty thousand students and that not only
- 1:04:53did that not happen, but they lost enrollment. So that was that was
- 1:05:00a wrong direction, clearly by g. I also know that g returns a
- 1:05:04portion. I'm not sure what it is, but I know there's a portion
- 1:05:06he returns to the university in donations. Let's see insert how voice from two
- 1:05:15thousand and one. Sorry, Hoppy, I cannot allow you to bring fourth
- 1:05:17facts to the people, says the texture Hoppy. It sounds like some questions
- 1:05:24should have been answered before money invested. You're talking about the thing in Mason
- 1:05:29County, Hoppy, did you see with the W elementary education departments being downsized
- 1:05:35right as Daily tells you, they are expecting they have seven thousands, not
- 1:05:39seven seventeen hundred teacher vacancies. Yeah, And I checked on that, and
- 1:05:43I think, I think I'll have to check on this, but I don't
- 1:05:46have to do more on this, But I think that the department or the
- 1:05:51curriculum that W is proposing downsizing or getting rid of, is not where teachers
- 1:05:59are now educated. It's not where future teachers are educated. And I may
- 1:06:02have that not exactly right, but there's there's something there that that teachers they're
- 1:06:11still educating teachers. They're not going to educate a fewer teachers. It's just
- 1:06:14they're being educated differently, and they're not in this particular course or something like
- 1:06:17that. There's something I do believe, or I've been told that there's some
- 1:06:20logical explanation for that, speaking of which I'm glad you mentioned that because I
- 1:06:26wanted to reference something I read the other day in the Gazette mail. Because
- 1:06:30remember when we talked to day A Lee, and we've talked about this before
- 1:06:34about about discipline in the classroom and how teachers and administrators get just burned out
- 1:06:41on the lack of discipline or if a kid misbehaving, you can't do anything
- 1:06:45with them. It disrupts the whole classroom. There's that and also, and
- 1:06:48this is one of the great it's not an untold story. Sister's not allowed
- 1:06:51to focus on it. And that is absenteeism. You can't teach children who
- 1:06:56are not there. And chronic absenteeism is getting worse across the country. There's
- 1:07:00a new study out about that, about chronic absenteeism and kids missing. You
- 1:07:05know when you went to school, I mean kids, not the kids missing
- 1:07:09twelve days, I mean kids missing one hundred days. Right. But there
- 1:07:13was a piece by Joe Lambert Blackwood in the Gazette Mail and Joe Lambert Blackwood
- 1:07:18is a retired teacher from Kanaal County, and she talked about the discipline issue.
- 1:07:25Now here's somebody who's been on the front lines. She said, this
- 1:07:30is about chronic this is about chronic absent this is about chronic absenteeism. And
- 1:07:33she said, when I called their homes the students homes, when I called
- 1:07:36their homes. Sometimes parents would say their child wasn't feeling well, or they
- 1:07:40had a doctor's appointment or a therapy session. She writes, I do understand
- 1:07:44medical needs, but when this student is absent more than they are present without
- 1:07:46a medical reason, I tend to believe the responsibility belongs to the parents and
- 1:07:50the guardians. She said. In a few cases, students would check out
- 1:07:56early and regularly missed the last period. One student and I saw it a
- 1:08:00football game, said he left early to get a haircut. The next semester
- 1:08:03of the same student said he was absent because he needed to get new shoes.
- 1:08:06I know. The sophomore said he had a babysitting job that started at
- 1:08:10two thirty, right before a class period began. Since parents are required to
- 1:08:15come inside the building to check a student out during the school day, they
- 1:08:17might want to reconsider their scheduling priorities. So this is I just thought that
- 1:08:23was a good anecdotal report from somebody who's been on the front lines about the
- 1:08:27absenteeism and the chronic absenteeism, and the criticism is frequently of public educators.
- 1:08:33Well, look this, you gotta teach the kids. It's your job to
- 1:08:35teach the kids, and that is true, but you can't teach them if
- 1:08:40they're not there. And then Monday, the kids there and you're trying to
- 1:08:44help the kid learn how to read. Okay, they're making some progress.
- 1:08:46Then they're not there Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, they come back
- 1:08:48Monday, they're behind. Take a breaking me back. Talk line continues after
- 1:08:54this, Yeah, that, of course is uh. Philip Bowen from West
- 1:09:09Virginia on America's Got Talent. He has advanced and in fact, he is
- 1:09:13in the semifinals. He's gonna be on the next time he's gonna be on,
- 1:09:15it's gonna be September five on NBC. He's got a new album coming
- 1:09:19out. I think there's still calling albums coming out tomorrow. He joins us
- 1:09:24on Metro and news talk client. What are you doing, Philip? How
- 1:09:26are you hoppy? I'm doing I'm doing great. I'm trying to respond to
- 1:09:30all these like text messages and so forth. Yeah about all of this,
- 1:09:34but I'm I'm doing. I'm doing great. It's hard to complain. Good
- 1:09:38for you. September five, is that right? September fifth is the date
- 1:09:42on the UH the Peacock Network NBC. All right, and can you what
- 1:09:46can you say about it? I know you have a lot of constraints about
- 1:09:49what you can and cannot say. Can you say anything else about it?
- 1:09:51What you're gonna play? You need or you need to surprise the judges.
- 1:09:55I mean, what are you gonna do? Or can you say? Yeah?
- 1:09:57Yeah, so I can. I can tell you that you're right.
- 1:10:00September fifth, I'm going back out to California. It's going to be in
- 1:10:02Pasadena at the Pasadena Civic Auditorium. I'm down to my last couple of choices
- 1:10:09for sure about what I'll play, but I'm gonna probably make the final decision
- 1:10:13the week before. I'll be out there about a week before for rehearsals and
- 1:10:15stuff like that, so you know, I'll play around with it, play
- 1:10:17with the band, and we'll make a final decision. So the bonus with
- 1:10:20us? Will it be anything off of your new album which comes out tomorrow,
- 1:10:25which is entitled Old Canal? Yeah, and I love it. You
- 1:10:29get the pronounciation right, of course because you're from there. But I had
- 1:10:33somebody from New York say, what is a cannon? Wat? Yeah?
- 1:10:36Exactly slightly off there, but no, I wait and see on the performance
- 1:10:42part of it is a lot to say, but it'll be good. I
- 1:10:45promise you that. Well that's good. That's good. Tell me about the
- 1:10:47new album. I mean, what did you I'm looking to I just got
- 1:10:50it. Thank you for sending it to me. I'm intrigued to hear the
- 1:10:53song Vampire and Appalachia. I'm really intrigued to hear that. Yeah, you
- 1:10:59know, the album is special to me, obviously, you know. But
- 1:11:01the best part about that is that, even though I had offers and opportunities
- 1:11:05to record the whole thing in Nashville, I made the decision to do it
- 1:11:10all in West Virginia at a West Virginia studio. And then every piece of
- 1:11:14design work, illustration that you see on that record is from the West Virginia
- 1:11:18small business. So Kinship Goods and Charleston did the design work, base camp
- 1:11:23printing and Charleston did the posters. So I did as much assumingly possible of
- 1:11:28this album. Uh, locally, you know, in the in Appalachia Charleston
- 1:11:31area. Well, what's it like when you're in there? I mean,
- 1:11:33when you're in your student you don't you don't know, go in and play?
- 1:11:35I mean how much of of just working with other musicians, of changing
- 1:11:41of rearranging of a producer's input. What's that like, Yeah, it's it's
- 1:11:45a really awesome experience to do it, you know, with a bunch of
- 1:11:48other professionals that like all they do, for example, is play the electric
- 1:11:51guitar, or all they do is play the bass. So you kind of
- 1:11:55have to find that balance of your vision of what you're wanting the song to
- 1:11:58v but also letting these they're great creative people express themselves through the music.
- 1:12:02So once you kind of get in that groove, it's a really it's a
- 1:12:05really special thing. You're kind of capturing a moment in time. How much
- 1:12:10creative tension is there where you go like, that's not what I want to
- 1:12:13do. I want to do this, and I don't want to do that.
- 1:12:15I mean, yeah, a little bit. But that's also why you
- 1:12:20need a good producer because obviously, you know, I'm playing the fiddle on
- 1:12:24the record too, and so sometimes I get a little carried away and I
- 1:12:27just play play a play and so like, hey man, that might be
- 1:12:29like I'll take it easy. It's like a little bit much right there,
- 1:12:31let's live it back. So it definitely goes both ways, and you kind
- 1:12:34of have to have I don't know, that good relationship where you can,
- 1:12:38you know, check each other and be like, I don't know if that
- 1:12:39really fits man, you know. And then I get back to the drawing
- 1:12:42board. So the producer hits his talk back key and says, Philip,
- 1:12:46that was really special, but we want to try maybe bring it back a
- 1:12:49little bit, maybe roll it back a little bit, doone, but maybe
- 1:12:53take a drink of water and sing that again one more time, a little
- 1:12:56stray. That's that's the kind of stuff you gotta do. You're you're really,
- 1:13:00really, really busy, aren't you. I am very busy, yeah,
- 1:13:03you know, plus I have I have a three young kids who are
- 1:13:06about to start school, and you know, the Abbey album and then America's
- 1:13:12got talent. So yeah, I'm a little busy, a little busy.
- 1:13:15Are you doing any other like between now and then? Are you doing other
- 1:13:18shows? Okay, so this is pretty banana. So I have had this
- 1:13:25a private event booked a couple of years ago that they're word if I was
- 1:13:29going to show up. It's actually a wedding. I think it's the very
- 1:13:30last private wedding I'll do for a while, but they booked it two years
- 1:13:34ago. But it's a Texas not that if you if I said I'll be
- 1:13:38there, I'll be there. So I'm gonna fly to Texas next Friday.
- 1:13:41You do this wedding, fly to California for America's Got Talent, and I'll
- 1:13:44be there for a couple of weeks and then I have a gig in Vancouver
- 1:13:47a couple of days later. So a little bit of a frequent flyer miles
- 1:13:50going to get out of here at the end of this monthing. Oh my
- 1:13:53gosh, Oh my gosh. What do you do for your shows? Do
- 1:13:56you have a band or you gather a local musician? What do you do
- 1:13:59when you do shows? Yeah, I'm still figuring out a little bit.
- 1:14:01So a lot of the shows I do are kind of solo style, and
- 1:14:05then sometimes I'll have a full band, Like I've did a concert up in
- 1:14:09Morgantown for the WVU Spring Game, for example, and I had a full
- 1:14:12band with me. So it just depends on, you know, kind of
- 1:14:15the venue and what's going on. If I have the full band, if
- 1:14:17it's just me. Phil Bowen is with his West Virginia native, of course,
- 1:14:21and he is in the semifinals of NBC's America's Got Talent. His next
- 1:14:27appearance will be September fifth, and each show features eleven semifinalists. So what
- 1:14:32do you think your chances are I'm going Do you think about that or you
- 1:14:34just think I'm gonna do I'm gonna do my thing and see what happens.
- 1:14:38Yeah, I'm honestly, I'm just excited about doing it again and getting that
- 1:14:42good exposure. Like I was joking with the music producer I worked up on
- 1:14:45the show, and he was saying, man, you know, it's not
- 1:14:47about time to be on national television rights this album is coming out, so
- 1:14:51you know, I will just take that the exposure, and I like my
- 1:14:55odds. You know, two out of eleven. That's okay. I can,
- 1:14:58I can. I can work with that, so I can do it.
- 1:15:00I can do that. Do you have songs like on the new album
- 1:15:03on Old Kana, Do you have songs that you that you like better than
- 1:15:08others and something like okay, I you know this is okay, I just
- 1:15:11don't like it as much. Do you have those or do you like all
- 1:15:13of them are different? You like all of them. You like all your
- 1:15:15kids, Yeah, you like all your kids. Yeah, yeah. They
- 1:15:16all have their own they all have their own special personality traits, you know.
- 1:15:21So I there are a couple that are very sentimental to me, and
- 1:15:26which ones you know, which ones? Like Old is probably my favorite that
- 1:15:30I had written and played. And of course I like Vampire for a different
- 1:15:33reason. And I debuted both of those back in January when I got to
- 1:15:38do Mountain Stage and so to do those there and that way like that was
- 1:15:42a really cool thing for me as a as a West Virginia native. But
- 1:15:45I like both those for different reasons. You are very a very entertaining guy,
- 1:15:49and we we can't wait to see if we wish you much much good
- 1:15:53luck. The new album comes out tomorrow, although I, as an influential
- 1:15:56member of the media, have an advanced copy your Flexi Influencer exactly Old Cana
- 1:16:04So of Philip bo and Philip it's good to reconnect with you. I know
- 1:16:06you're super super busy. Thanks for coming on. We will watch with great
- 1:16:11joy when you perform on September five on NBC U King Well, thank you
- 1:16:15anytime, and maybe we can shout again when I'm out there in California.
- 1:16:18All you know how to is all on the West coast. Would have loved
- 1:16:20that. Thanks Philip, all right, thank you. Sorry, I appreciate
- 1:16:23it. Take care, Bye bye. Talk line continues. WU Medicine Dermatology
- 1:16:34offers conference of services for adults and children. Board certified dermatologists treat a variety
- 1:16:40of skin conditions, from acne to complicated skin cancers. Self schedule and evaluation
- 1:16:45at my WVU chart dot com or called eight five five w VU care Gotta
- 1:16:49run. See tomorrow. Talk line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia,