Latest / Surrounded / 1 Journalist vs 20 Trump Supporters (ft Glenn Greenwald) | Surrounded
Transcript
- 0:00Hey listeners,
- 0:01just want to remind you,
- 0:02we have episodes of the pod coming out
- 0:04every Sunday,
- 0:04so please consider subscribing
- 0:07wherever you get your podcasts.
- 0:08Thank you for your support.
- 0:10We're in a major war,
- 0:11aren't we,
- 0:11in Iran?
- 0:12I mean,
- 0:12sure,
- 0:13we're in a conflict,
- 0:13but I don't think that this is where you actually got a wrong time.
- 0:15Have you ever thought about going and fighting in this war that you're cheering on?
- 0:19Uh,
- 0:19I mean,
- 0:19I've thought about joining the military before.
- 0:21I don't know about this war specifically.
- 0:22When your adversary races to arms and increases their offensive capabilities,
- 0:26it's going to create a security dilemma.
- 0:27That's a madman mentality.
- 0:29Iran lost any civilians.
- 0:30Uh,
- 0:31yeah,
- 0:31I'm sure that's how a war works.
- 0:33That's how war works.
- 0:33Like on the first day we
- 0:35vaporized 170
- 0:36young Iranian schoolgirls by bombing an elementary school.
- 0:39Is the Trump administration actually America first,
- 0:43or has?
- 0:43morphed into something Trump supporters no longer recognize.
- 0:47I'm John Regalado,
- 0:48and from Jubilee Media this is Surrounded.
- 0:50Today we're diving into Trump's foreign policy record,
- 0:53the conflict with Iran,
- 0:54the United States' relationship with Israel,
- 0:56and much more.
- 0:57I'm here in the center with our featured guest,
- 1:00independent journalist Glenn Greenwald.
- 1:02Welcome to the show.
- 1:03Thank you for having me.
- 1:03Great to be here.
- 1:04Are you ready to jump into these debates?
- 1:06I am ready.
- 1:06Debaters,
- 1:07are you ready?
- 1:10Let's get into it.
- 1:11Hi,
- 1:11I'm Glenn Greenwald.
- 1:12I'm an author and independent journalist,
- 1:14and today I am surrounded by 20 Trump supporters.
- 1:21My first surrounded claim is President Trump is more
- 1:25of a war-making president than a peacemaking president.
- 1:29If you would like to debate this claim,
- 1:30please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:36Hey,
- 1:37nice to meet you,
- 1:37Micah.
- 1:38Good to meet you good to meet you,
- 1:39Glenn.
- 1:39So
- 1:40first I wanna just ask
- 1:42what makes a peacemaking president.
- 1:45A peacemaking president is somebody who in the
- 1:48first place avoids war for their own country,
- 1:51either solves and resolves wars that they inherit,
- 1:53or prevents wars from breaking out that they
- 1:56would get their country involved with.
- 1:57OK,
- 1:57so you agree that prevention is a part of what makes a president
- 2:02a peacemaking president.
- 2:04OK,
- 2:04so then what about Trump's foreign policy is not prevention.
- 2:09Well,
- 2:09the first thing that he did in getting to office basically within 30
- 2:12days was restarted a bombing campaign
- 2:15that President Biden had prosecuted throughout 2024
- 2:18that President Trump during the campaign had heavily criticized.
- 2:20Yet as soon as President Trump got into office,
- 2:23he not only restarted that bombing campaign,
- 2:25but escalated it.
- 2:25That was the one in Yemen against the Houthis.
- 2:28It went on for about 56 weeks or entailed hundreds
- 2:31of people was that not necessary for like global trade.
- 2:35To ensue was was the Houthis not attacking
- 2:39multiple different ships,
- 2:41and no,
- 2:41the Houthis were only attacking Israel at the time that President Trump did that.
- 2:44There was a peace deal that President Trump
- 2:47engineered that ended up being very temporary,
- 2:49and the Houthis said for as long as this peace deal is in place,
- 2:51we won't attack ships.
- 2:53Once the Israelis started violating it,
- 2:54not letting food,
- 2:55they said we're only going to attack Israeli.
- 2:56So here's a question.
- 2:57Here's a question for you,
- 2:58Glenn.
- 2:58Are we
- 2:59still in conflict in Yemen?
- 3:02No,
- 3:02President Trump ended his own war that he started.
- 3:03OK,
- 3:04so then by your definition,
- 3:05did we not prevent further conflict by having this conflict,
- 3:09and would we not free up the trade routes
- 3:12in Yemen
- 3:13from being attacked by the Houthis?
- 3:14It's,
- 3:15it's free,
- 3:16is it not?
- 3:16It's like saying I stabbed myself in the stomach,
- 3:19but then I brought myself to the ER where I had a doctor fix me up,
- 3:22and that proves that I'm really interested in fitness and self-care.
- 3:25President Trump started the war
- 3:27in Yemen.
- 3:28He escalated the war in Yemen.
- 3:29It was stopped at the Houthis attacking people.
- 3:31Or not they were attacking a foreign country called
- 3:33Israel that is not part of the United States.
- 3:35So do these international trade routes not affect America?
- 3:40No,
- 3:40not when it's only Israel whose ships are being attacked.
- 3:42You can say the war is just.
- 3:44The question is,
- 3:45is President Trump making war
- 3:46or making peace?
- 3:48You can say,
- 3:48OK,
- 3:49he made war in Yemen,
- 3:50but I think the war is just.
- 3:50He's still a war-making president.
- 3:52By definition,
- 3:52there was no war when he got in by the result of the conflict that it was a peacemaking,
- 3:58uh,
- 3:59military engagement.
- 4:00We have.
- 4:01How did it end?
- 4:02How did it end?
- 4:03How did it end?
- 4:04It ended by the
- 4:05Houthis saying we will not attack anybody except the Israelis,
- 4:08and as long as they're denying food and water entering into Gaza,
- 4:12and they continue to do so,
- 4:13it achieved nothing.
- 4:14All it did was have the United States deplete
- 4:16our missiles,
- 4:17our
- 4:18military force,
- 4:19our resources.
- 4:20It was a war that didn't exist that Trump created.
- 4:23Yes,
- 4:23congratulations,
- 4:24he ended his own war,
- 4:25but that is an example of a war-making president.
- 4:27That's just one example.
- 4:28There's obviously war in Iran as well.
- 4:30That he
- 4:31inherited
- 4:32a presidency where we were not at war with Iran.
- 4:35We are now at war with Iran.
- 4:36We've twice gone to war with Iran under President Trump.
- 4:38That's another war that he's made.
- 4:40Do you,
- 4:40do you not,
- 4:41do you not agree that Iran
- 4:43is a major threat and destabilizes the Middle East all the time?
- 4:47I don't,
- 4:48but we'll get to whether the war is just.
- 4:50The question now is,
- 4:51does President Trump make more wars?
- 4:52Well,
- 4:53you seem to be acknowledging I want to go back to what you initially agreed to though,
- 4:57is that.
- 4:57Part of what makes a peacemaking president isn't just,
- 5:01oh,
- 5:01we don't start any conflicts,
- 5:03it's actually engaging in conflicts to prevent further so war is peace.
- 5:07Have you,
- 5:07did you read 1984 by George Orwell?
- 5:09No,
- 5:09I'm just,
- 5:10no,
- 5:10but I'm just literally,
- 5:11I'm literally quoting what you said earlier at the beginning of.
- 5:14No,
- 5:14but George Orwell in 1984 described the most
- 5:17extreme kind of propaganda by war-making tyrannies,
- 5:20and one of the things citizens get told is war is peace.
- 5:24Did you not admit
- 5:25that part of what makes a peacemaking president
- 5:29is stepping in and preventing further conflicts?
- 5:32Yes,
- 5:32but you can't prevent conflicts by starting conflicts.
- 5:35Starting conflicts is starting conflicts.
- 5:37Can you not use the wars?
- 5:39Can you gotta pause here,
- 5:40Mike.
- 5:40We gotta pause here.
- 5:41You've been voted out by the majority.
- 5:42Please return.
- 5:43Thank you.
- 5:44So in reference to Trump being a
- 5:46peacemaking president or a war mongering president,
- 5:48let's say for example,
- 5:49let's start with the conflicts that he did.
- 5:51Indeed,
- 5:51stop,
- 5:51right?
- 5:52For example,
- 5:52Pakistan,
- 5:52India,
- 5:53Pakistan nominated Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize.
- 5:55He,
- 5:55they said that he specifically played a
- 5:57big role in preventing that conflict.
- 5:59Well,
- 5:59India disagreed,
- 6:00but Pakistan regardless said that he played a key role in preventing it.
- 6:03Um,
- 6:03we had Thailand versus Cambodia also break out.
- 6:06Cambodia nominated Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize
- 6:07and also said that he prevented that conflict.
- 6:09Um,
- 6:09I'd also say in reference to Venezuela,
- 6:11obviously no one thinks that,
- 6:12uh,
- 6:12Maduro was good there,
- 6:14the tyranny was crazy,
- 6:15um,
- 6:15the,
- 6:15the way that he was leading the government,
- 6:17everyone agrees,
- 6:18but he was able to take Maduro out,
- 6:19and Daisy Rodriguez,
- 6:20who's now the vice president,
- 6:21is very,
- 6:22you could say,
- 6:23subordinate or serval,
- 6:24right?
- 6:2450 million barrels of oil
- 6:26restricting Cuba,
- 6:27so on and so forth.
- 6:28And so I would disagree that he's a
- 6:29warmongering president.
- 6:31OK,
- 6:31the,
- 6:31the point is not he's a war mongering president.
- 6:33The,
- 6:34the formulation is he's more of a war-making president
- 6:37than a war than a peacemaking president.
- 6:39So even in your examples,
- 6:41including in Venezuela,
- 6:42you're not denying that he used military force in a way that
- 6:45is considered an act of war by every country on the planet.
- 6:48You're defending the wars that he's making by saying they lead to good outcomes,
- 6:52which we can debate,
- 6:53but that's a separate question
- 6:54from the proposition.
- 6:56As far as these wars that you're concerned that I know he loves to cite,
- 6:59India was vehement that he had no role to play of
- 7:02any meaningful kind in mediating that conflict between India and Pakistan.
- 7:05That is a war that goes back,
- 7:07that conflict goes back many hundreds of years before conflicts.
- 7:10But even let me,
- 7:11let me ask you these questions,
- 7:12this question about these other conflicts that you've named.
- 7:15Were those part of the 2024 campaign?
- 7:17Did,
- 7:17did anyone ever mention that,
- 7:18right?
- 7:19But you know why?
- 7:19Because they're completely trivial and because the role that
- 7:22the United States plays in them is also.
- 7:24Essentially trivial as well.
- 7:26These are,
- 7:26these,
- 7:26and,
- 7:27and,
- 7:27and a lot we can analyze those,
- 7:29but let's be clear,
- 7:30the,
- 7:30the,
- 7:30the real question is,
- 7:32does President Trump make war
- 7:33for the United States,
- 7:35whether he plays some ancillary role in this,
- 7:37and,
- 7:38well,
- 7:38we're in a major war.
- 7:39We're in a major war now,
- 7:40right?
- 7:40We're in a major war,
- 7:41aren't we,
- 7:42in Iran?
- 7:43I mean,
- 7:43sure,
- 7:43we're in a conflict,
- 7:44but I don't think that this is where you actually got it wrong.
- 7:45Is it a last time?
- 7:46Is it you can call it's a war and a conflict.
- 7:48There's no necessary dis like there's no disagreement there.
- 7:50It's a conflict and a war.
- 7:51It's both,
- 7:52right?
- 7:52But the conflict didn't start recently,
- 7:54right?
- 7:55In 1979,
- 7:56Iran kidnapped 66 Americans and held them hostage for over 400 days,
- 7:59right?
- 8:00So why did that happened?
- 8:01Well,
- 8:01because they're anti-Western,
- 8:02but hold on,
- 8:02just let me finish this.
- 8:03So the conflict with Iran or our issues with Iran
- 8:05in reference to specifically the Islamic Republic started more there
- 8:08in 1982,
- 8:103 years later,
- 8:10specifically,
- 8:11there was the Beirut barracks bombing,
- 8:12which I'm sure you're familiar with,
- 8:14where 242 Americans were killed in Beirut.
- 8:16They were there as a peacekeeping force actually.
- 8:18And guess who specifically,
- 8:19I believe in 2002.
- 8:20A federal judge actually ruled that Iran supplied Hezbollah
- 8:24and gave them intelligence to kill 242 Americans.
- 8:27On top of that,
- 8:28I believe in Venezuela they have the Quds Force as well that is there.
- 8:31They,
- 8:31they fund three main terror groups.
- 8:33According to the FDD.
- 8:34They spent about $16 billion doing so,
- 8:35right?
- 8:36Hezbollah,
- 8:37um,
- 8:37the Houthis in Yemen,
- 8:38and by the way,
- 8:38the last guy,
- 8:39you were also wrong,
- 8:40$200 billion worth of economic damage in reference to the Red Sea,
- 8:43where 1/10 of
- 8:46um trade we at war with Iran when President Trump was inaugurated.
- 8:49No,
- 8:49we weren't directly in,
- 8:50in terms of,
- 8:51right?
- 8:52So I think that I would say,
- 8:53wait,
- 8:53wait,
- 8:53hold on,
- 8:53hold on,
- 8:54hold on,
- 8:54hold on,
- 8:54hold on,
- 8:54stop.
- 8:55I talked a lot.
- 8:56I would say that we're already in a conflict.
- 8:57I would say that yes,
- 8:58generally,
- 8:59not like war in terms of declaring war,
- 9:00um,
- 9:01conspicuously,
- 9:02but yes,
- 9:02we've been in a conflict,
- 9:03a long-standing conflictposition is President Trump is more of a war-making,
- 9:07right?
- 9:08I don't think any of those conflicts were made by Trump.
- 9:10That's where you're wrong.
- 9:11India and Pakistan were in conflict prior to the war that you mentioned,
- 9:14right?
- 9:14They were in conflict with Iran.
- 9:15There are a lot of people who are,
- 9:17there are a lot of,
- 9:17there are a lot.
- 9:18Of countries that are in conflict with one another,
- 9:20they're not all at war.
- 9:21Most of them are not at war.
- 9:23The United States became in a war with Iran when Israel and the United
- 9:27States announced that they were attacking Iran and started a war with Iran.
- 9:31Of course there's conflicts.
- 9:32There's conflicts between Brazil and Argentina.
- 9:33There's conflicts between Peru and Uruguay.
- 9:35There's cont you're being vague.
- 9:37No,
- 9:38no,
- 9:38I'm being very specific.
- 9:39I'm talking about a war.
- 9:40There's a difference between
- 9:41smaller conflicts or like a general conflict that's going on for a long time
- 9:44and like a large scale war and even like,
- 9:46for example.
- 9:47Small military engagements like for example Midnight Hammer,
- 9:49we bombed Natanz Fordo and Isfahan were more smaller engagements,
- 9:53right?
- 9:54And by the way,
- 9:54we pulled out pretty quickly and everything was fine afterwards.
- 9:57If Russia came to the United States and bombed 3 different
- 10:00nuclear facilities in the United States with B-52 bombers of the Russian Cassius,
- 10:05would you say,
- 10:06would you consider that to be an act of war?
- 10:07Yeah,
- 10:08you're saying it would be Cassius Belle?
- 10:09No,
- 10:09I'm,
- 10:09no,
- 10:09I'm not Cassius Bei means means act of war.
- 10:11Yeah,
- 10:11would you,
- 10:12would you,
- 10:12so yeah,
- 10:13it would be,
- 10:13it would be Cassius Belle.
- 10:14That's the answer.
- 10:14OK,
- 10:15congratulations on you.
- 10:16I'm just wanting to,
- 10:17I don't want to necessarily catch your language.
- 10:18I wanna,
- 10:19that would be an act of war,
- 10:20right?
- 10:20Yeah,
- 10:20the same way that,
- 10:21hold on,
- 10:21hold on,
- 10:21the same way that,
- 10:22for example,
- 10:22um,
- 10:23the IRGC,
- 10:23the Pakistani guy that was recently convicted,
- 10:26he admitted that the IRGC paid him
- 10:28and tried to give him intelligence to assassinate
- 10:29Donald Trump around the time where Butler happened.
- 10:32That's also a Cassius Belle.
- 10:33The fact that the IRGC tried to kill our president,
- 10:36were we at war with the elector elected at war is an act of war.
- 10:39So yeah,
- 10:39we've been in conflict and an act of war with Iran for a very long time,
- 10:43and it's funny that you're not mentioning.
- 10:45You're not mentioning the fact that 242 Americans were killed in Beirut in 1982.
- 10:49The United States,
- 10:50the United States has killed countries throughout the Middle,
- 10:53the Middle East.
- 10:53You know what President Reagan did in response to that?
- 10:55He said the reason this happened is because we have
- 10:58a military base in Lebanon where we shouldn't be,
- 11:00and he withdrew those troops.
- 11:01That's because he knew that the reason we were being
- 11:04attacked was because we were interfering in that region.
- 11:06The reason that Iran took over
- 11:08and the embassy was because we had overthrown their
- 11:11democratically elected government in 1953 and imposed a.
- 11:14Savage,
- 11:14brutal tyranny on them that ruled that country
- 11:17from 1953 until the revolution in 1979.
- 11:19But these are all historically,
- 11:21historically interesting points that we could talk about with the justification.
- 11:24No,
- 11:24it's not wrong.
- 11:25The point is,
- 11:26I asked you earlier,
- 11:27was the United States at war with Iran?
- 11:30The answer is yes,
- 11:30but you said no.
- 11:31And it depends on how you're defining war.
- 11:33It depends on how you're defining war and long-term conflict.
- 11:35But let me hold on.
- 11:36The point is we were not at war,
- 11:38as you said the first time when I asked you,
- 11:39with Iran,
- 11:40when President Trump took office,
- 11:41he didn't talk about there being a war.
- 11:43No,
- 11:43he talked about 2011 and we are now in a war because even by NATO20,
- 11:47he continued that Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon.
- 11:49By the way,
- 11:49can you explain to me the reason for 60% enriched uranium?
- 11:52No country that has tried to or even been in
- 11:54talks of trying to get a nuclear weapon has ever,
- 11:56has ever reached 60% and not gotten to 90%,
- 11:59which is President Trump invalidated the agreement where they were only at 3%.
- 12:03President Trump,
- 12:04make this war.
- 12:04No,
- 12:05that's not the answer is no.
- 12:06So we have been a general,
- 12:07we are we have been,
- 12:08we have been at a general,
- 12:09in a general conflict with Iran,
- 12:11or you could say even.
- 12:12War.
- 12:12I am saying for over 47 years and President Trump just forgot to mention that
- 12:16we were at war when he was running for president in 2024 and never said,
- 12:19hey,
- 12:19by the way,
- 12:19we're at,
- 12:20he openly,
- 12:20he openly said,
- 12:21no,
- 12:21no,
- 12:21no,
- 12:21he's been very conspicuous about this.
- 12:23He's been,
- 12:23he's been very clear about the fact that we have a conflict with Iran.
- 12:26We have issues with war,
- 12:27a war like to kill.
- 12:28We do have conflict again.
- 12:29I don't think you understand it.
- 12:30Wars can't also be conflicts.
- 12:32Exactly.
- 12:32But they aren't conflicts aren't necessarily wars.
- 12:35The question is,
- 12:36was there a war with Iran?
- 12:37And if so,
- 12:38why did President Trump bother to mention,
- 12:40hey,
- 12:40by the way.
- 12:41We were at war with Iran in 2024 and he's very conspicuous about it.
- 12:44So what would be the incentive?
- 12:46Just like,
- 12:46hey,
- 12:46we're at war with Iran.
- 12:47Look,
- 12:47everyone understands that we've been at a long understood with Iran was never true.
- 12:52It,
- 12:52we got to pause here.
- 12:53Can we just hear your response and then we got to stop there.
- 12:56There were several wars that President Trump started in Yemen,
- 12:59Venezuela,
- 12:59and Iran.
- 13:00You can say they're just or not,
- 13:01but these wars did not exist.
- 13:02Nobody said they existed during the 2024 campaign,
- 13:06including President Trump.
- 13:07And when he announced them,
- 13:08Yemen,
- 13:08he announced that that as.
- 13:10With the United States in 2024.
- 13:13All right,
- 13:13all right,
- 13:13good to talk to you.
- 13:19Hello,
- 13:20how are you?
- 13:20Good to meet you.
- 13:21Nice to meet you too.
- 13:22OK,
- 13:22so I want to get back to the prompt
- 13:24about
- 13:25peace versus war.
- 13:26So the way I look at it is the first
- 13:28Trump administration was a peaceful administration.
- 13:30There was no new wars that were started,
- 13:32right?
- 13:32We have the Abraham Accords,
- 13:33which
- 13:34Trump should have won a Nobel Peace Prize for because it was historic.
- 13:36Um,
- 13:37and then we had something that was a historic,
- 13:39right?
- 13:39So the Biden administration came in between.
- 13:41It kind of disrupted Trump's foreign policy.
- 13:43And under the Biden administration we
- 13:45saw the disastrous withdrawal from Afghanistan,
- 13:47which was really a green light to our anti-Western
- 13:49adversaries that we didn't really have the strong will
- 13:53to defend US hegemony abroad
- 13:55following that,
- 13:55the invasion of Ukraine by Russia,
- 13:57and then
- 13:58we saw
- 13:59Biden trying to re-engage in JCPOA negotiations
- 14:02as a legacy of the Obama administration.
- 14:04And he unfroze $16 billion in assets to the regime and
- 14:07then also waived sanctions so they could sell over $100 billion.
- 14:10They're theirs,
- 14:10but they're frozen.
- 14:11That's Iran's assets,
- 14:12correct,
- 14:12but that's going against the maximum security,
- 14:15the maximum pressure campaign.
- 14:16So if you don't want war,
- 14:17how do you then deter a belligerent actor if it's not
- 14:20maximum sanctions?
- 14:21What would your solution be then
- 14:22to let them in general,
- 14:24in every other country on the planet except the United States and Israel,
- 14:27war is talked about as a last resort,
- 14:28something that you engage in only if there's a
- 14:31country that's attacking you or attacking your homeland.
- 14:33Or attacking
- 14:34what's that?
- 14:35So the sanctions are a legacy of the Iraq-Iran war in the 1980s.
- 14:38So which war we're talking about the current operation,
- 14:40which is not a war.
- 14:40I'm talking about why we should be at war with Iran at all.
- 14:44And you're saying what is it that we should be doing to Iran?
- 14:46And my point we're talking about the Biden regime or regime,
- 14:48the Biden administration
- 14:50was that they empowered,
- 14:52we could maybe use the regime,
- 14:53they empowered the Iranian regime diplomatically,
- 14:55financially,
- 14:56which then positioned them for October 7th,
- 14:58and also the Houthis.
- 14:59It is true the Houthis blocked off the Suez Canal for 4 to 5 months.
- 15:02We also
- 15:03British military naval ships in the region,
- 15:04US military ships,
- 15:05so they weren't just,
- 15:06uh,
- 15:06attacking Israel,
- 15:07although yes,
- 15:07that was a part of it.
- 15:08Um,
- 15:08so we saw a destabilized Middle East because of the direct empowerment,
- 15:12let me just,
- 15:12it's interesting because I,
- 15:13I,
- 15:14I think there's a very American perspective because we are a country
- 15:17that is constantly at war unlike everybody else on the planet.
- 15:20The last time China fought a war
- 15:21was 1979,
- 15:23and one of the reasons they're displacing the United
- 15:24States and every region in the in the globe,
- 15:26including Latin America and Africa,
- 15:28is because they spend their resources building up
- 15:30their country while we have our country.
- 15:31Deteriorating because
- 15:33we spend so much time and money and effort and resources
- 15:35on foreign wars is that they don't have the conventional capabilities.
- 15:38They have a massive gigantic military.
- 15:40They just don't,
- 15:41they just know that,
- 15:42which is what,
- 15:42by the way,
- 15:43which is what President Trump's primary political appeal was,
- 15:45was that we're constantly fighting these foreign wars.
- 15:47We have to stop fighting foreign wars
- 15:48in the Middle East so that we can focus on our own communities and our own country,
- 15:51and here we are back in another one.
- 15:53But I think the point about Iran is
- 15:55that
- 15:56the
- 15:57idea that we can just go and steal countries' money,
- 15:59as you said,
- 16:00it's Iran's.
- 16:01They have oil in their country.
- 16:02Let me,
- 16:03let me just,
- 16:03let me just finish.
- 16:04They sell their oil to other countries.
- 16:06They receive money for it.
- 16:07We take that money
- 16:08using our dollar as the reserve currency.
- 16:10We steal it and freeze it,
- 16:12and then somehow,
- 16:13I should also say that President,
- 16:15President Trump just lifted sanctions on Iranian oil at sea,
- 16:18enabling them to get huge amounts of money.
- 16:20It was a good faith.
- 16:21No,
- 16:22it was because there was,
- 16:23he needed to do that because we need oil on the global market because of oil,
- 16:26because gas prices are so high,
- 16:28still lower than it was under the Biden.
- 16:30No,
- 16:30I'm saying that we,
- 16:31we,
- 16:32because of this war,
- 16:33President Trump lifted sanctions on Iranian oil at sea.
- 16:36They are now charging money.
- 16:38They are now charging money for the Strait of Hormuz,
- 16:40and the key,
- 16:41and there's no way there will be an end to this war
- 16:43that we're currently negotiating unless the sanctions are lifted on Iran.
- 16:46They're completely wiped out the.
- 16:48Let me just get back to what I was
- 16:49saying about the Biden administration because it's important.
- 16:51So we look at how
- 16:52diplomacy has never worked.
- 16:52The JCPOA completely empowered the regime.
- 16:54Same thing with Biden again.
- 16:55So Trump came into a region that was completely changed also just globally,
- 16:58right?
- 16:59I.
- 16:59The Iranian regime bought 2.5 million acres in Venezuela,
- 17:02which is in our Western Hemisphere.
- 17:03So he came into a world where our anti-Western
- 17:06adversaries had gained strategic holdings
- 17:09that
- 17:10hinder US hegemony abroad.
- 17:11So he went into the region and he said,
- 17:13OK,
- 17:13I'm going to negotiate with the Iranian regime.
- 17:14They didn't come as good faith actors to the negotiation table.
- 17:17Operation Midnight Hammer was a preemptive strike.
- 17:20They still continue to come to the table with Iran.
- 17:22I would say,
- 17:23yeah,
- 17:23he,
- 17:24well,
- 17:24he,
- 17:24it's hard to be at war with the regime that you're funding.
- 17:26So Biden was not at war with Iran.
- 17:28Uh,
- 17:28well,
- 17:29we were at war with Iran via Israel if you look at it as a proxy situation.
- 17:32Biden was fighting a war against and also another thing
- 17:34you keep saying that Trump started wars in Yemen.
- 17:36I'm trying to figure out Lebanon again,
- 17:38but those are proxy wars funded by Iran.
- 17:41Those United States conflicts existed way before President
- 17:42Trump Biden waging a war against Iran.
- 17:45He was funding the regime and empowering them.
- 17:47So the answer is no.
- 17:48It's really hard to wage the war against the regime that you're.
- 17:51So the war in Iran was started by President Trump in the second term.
- 17:53The war in Iran is happening.
- 17:55First off,
- 17:55it's not a war,
- 17:56it's an operation.
- 17:56We have
- 17:57highly.
- 17:57Discriminately taken out as the IRGC,
- 18:00how is it not a war?
- 18:00Well,
- 18:01it's not a war because the Iranian regime can't respond
- 18:02in a way that we're blowing up the bridges.
- 18:04Yes,
- 18:04it's an we're blowing up their,
- 18:05and they've been blowing up the Middle East between a war and.
- 18:08No,
- 18:08I'm just trying to again,
- 18:09the,
- 18:09the,
- 18:10the proposition we're supposed to be discussing,
- 18:12and I realize why you don't want to and others don't want to,
- 18:14is,
- 18:15no demonstrating let me,
- 18:16let me,
- 18:16I have to empowered when you have to let me finish.
- 18:18So it necessitated a response that was different
- 18:21than his first administration when there was President,
- 18:22you have to let me finish.
- 18:23What the,
- 18:24the question we're supposed to be debating is that President Trump.
- 18:27is more of a war-making president than a peacemaking president a situation in
- 18:30the Middle East that was vastly different than the one that he left,
- 18:33I understand.
- 18:34I'm trying to ask about war,
- 18:35which is what is the response?
- 18:37So if it's not high pressure,
- 18:39was President Biden waging a war on Iran?
- 18:41Yes or no?
- 18:42Well,
- 18:42if you're talking about responding to all that,
- 18:44why can't you answer if Iran is considered the Houthis,
- 18:48the Hezbollah,
- 18:48Hamas,
- 18:49then yes,
- 18:49President Biden was waging a war on Iran.
- 18:51I thought you said he was so,
- 18:52so,
- 18:53so favorable to Iran that he was treating Iran so well.
- 18:56Both sides of the conflict,
- 18:57but he empowered the regime.
- 18:58Were we at war not with Iran's proxies,
- 18:59but with Iran itself under Joe Biden?
- 19:01Iran actually broke the status quo of not engaging with Israel,
- 19:03our greatest ally,
- 19:04in Joe,
- 19:05did Joe Biden wage a war on Iran?
- 19:07It's not.
- 19:08First off,
- 19:08again,
- 19:08I can't you just answer?
- 19:09Why can't you just answer said yes,
- 19:11if you're going to consider via proxies,
- 19:12which no,
- 19:12I'm not,
- 19:13I don't mean via proxy.
- 19:14I mean directly with Iran.
- 19:15OK,
- 19:15but this is,
- 19:15you're contradicting yourself because you said Trump started wars.
- 19:17I'm Ye asking and you define it by the proxy asking a question.
- 19:20You can't define war one way for Trump.
- 19:21I'm there.
- 19:22We got to pause there.
- 19:23We're out of time.
- 19:24Please return to your seat.
- 19:26OK.
- 19:29Raise your flag if
- 19:30you would concede that Trump started
- 19:32this current war
- 19:34with Iran.
- 19:38OK,
- 19:38so we got,
- 19:39we got 2 people.
- 19:40Thank you.
- 19:41My next round of claim is President Trump is subservient to the Israel lobby.
- 19:46If you'd like to debate this claim,
- 19:48please get to the chair in 321.
- 19:53Whoa,
- 19:53hey,
- 19:53good to meet you,
- 19:54Ryan.
- 19:54Nice to meet you.
- 19:55Nice to meet you.
- 19:55I it's out.
- 19:58OK,
- 19:58I think,
- 19:58uh,
- 19:59important thing to do with debates is to define our terms.
- 20:01Can you please tell me what subservient is?
- 20:03Yes,
- 20:03uh,
- 20:04serving the interest of someone else,
- 20:06taking orders from somebody else,
- 20:07taking direction from somebody else,
- 20:08not in every case,
- 20:09but as a general posture ethos.
- 20:11OK,
- 20:12so that's already a problem because subservient doesn't mean
- 20:14not sometimes taking the case,
- 20:16sometimes not subservient.
- 20:17It's literally defined as in a subordinate manner you are controlled by.
- 20:20In a very direct way.
- 20:22You want to set it up so that if you can point to one example
- 20:25where President Trump didn't do what Israel wanted,
- 20:28then that means somehow he's not subservient to Israel.
- 20:31You just want creating a binary,
- 20:32a binary framework
- 20:34where as long as you can point to one example,
- 20:36the Israelis wanted something,
- 20:38right?
- 20:38So that's why I'm saying that is not what this proposition means.
- 20:40It doesn't mean that in each and every case,
- 20:42President Trump is fully and absolutely obedient to Israel,
- 20:45that if you want,
- 20:46if you want.
- 20:47Me to concede
- 20:48that there are instances,
- 20:49I will be happy to point to some as well,
- 20:51where President Trump or other presidents,
- 20:53so that's not the,
- 20:53that's not the question.
- 20:54I understand.
- 20:55I'm saying that your claim,
- 20:56it's your claim.
- 20:57I didn't force you to make the claim.
- 20:58Your claim is not there's high influence.
- 21:00Your claim is not any of that.
- 21:01Your claim is he's subservient,
- 21:03and if you're going to say he's subservient,
- 21:05that means something.
- 21:06Now,
- 21:07if we want to change what you're saying and you just want to say he has
- 21:10higher influence from,
- 21:11when you say pro-Israeli,
- 21:12do you just mean Jews?
- 21:13What do you mean by that?
- 21:14No,
- 21:14of course I don't mean Jews.
- 21:15There are huge numbers of Jews who oppose Israel.
- 21:17I'm asking,
- 21:18well,
- 21:18generally when I,
- 21:19when I debate this topic,
- 21:20a lot of people will say like,
- 21:21you know,
- 21:22the Adelsons,
- 21:22right,
- 21:23because they're Jewish,
- 21:23they're Israeli,
- 21:24or do you mean pro-Israel?
- 21:26Like you're talking about AIPAC,
- 21:27you're talking about J Street.
- 21:29People talk about George Soros,
- 21:30but nobody suggests that he's pro-Israel.
- 21:32The reason people talk about the Adelsons is because they
- 21:34gave $300 billion 300 million dollars to Trump's campaigns,
- 21:37and Trump himself said
- 21:39that.
- 21:40Every time the Adelsons came to the White House,
- 21:42they didn't ask about the United States.
- 21:43They asked for things for Israel.
- 21:45Trump went to the Knesset last year and said Miriam Adelson
- 21:48loves Israel more than they love Elon the United States.
- 21:51Is,
- 21:51is Trump subservient to Elon Musk?
- 21:53No,
- 21:53I don't think Trump is subservient.
- 21:54Elon Musk,
- 21:55at least in this last election cycle,
- 21:56gave significantly more than the Adelsons,
- 22:00exactly.
- 22:00One individual gave more than 2 and also the lobbying groups.
- 22:03But that being said,
- 22:04what is it that makes you think he's
- 22:07Controlled in at least a significant way by
- 22:11Whatever you're saying,
- 22:11what President Trump himself said,
- 22:13President Trump said that every single time
- 22:15She
- 22:16Sheldon and Miriam Adelson came to the White House,
- 22:18they asked for things for Israel,
- 22:19and he gave it to them.
- 22:21They didn't ask for things for the United States.
- 22:22He said that Miriam Adelson,
- 22:24he didn't say he gave everything they asked for,
- 22:26he did.
- 22:27He said every,
- 22:27he said every time he said,
- 22:29in fact,
- 22:30in fact,
- 22:31they asked,
- 22:32he gave them even things that they didn't ask for
- 22:34for Israel,
- 22:35not for the United States.
- 22:36He did not tell them times where they had talks where they disagreed.
- 22:39He never talked about that.
- 22:40I know exactly which quote you're talking about.
- 22:42You're adding that in
- 22:43to push your narrative right now.
- 22:45But that being said,
- 22:45we're not here to talk about just the Adelsons.
- 22:47We're here to talk about the pro-Israel lobby.
- 22:49I'm asking you,
- 22:49how do you know that they are controlling Trump,
- 22:52at least in a significant enough way to
- 22:54what I'm saying is that President Trump makes decisions
- 22:57in the interest of the Israeli people and the
- 23:00Israeli government over and above the American people,
- 23:03and it's the only country for which that's true.
- 23:05That is subservience.
- 23:06You can,
- 23:07we can go back to the semantic.
- 23:08Opposition,
- 23:08but that is what I mean.
- 23:09And there's so many instances where President Trump has taken steps,
- 23:13and right now his entire focus is on a country that
- 23:17is Israel's primary adversary that Israel has wanted for decades,
- 23:20the United States,
- 23:20to go in and change the regime.
- 23:22I understand the hyperbole.
- 23:23His entire focus is not on that,
- 23:24but I get it.
- 23:25But my question for you,
- 23:26I would hope it is not,
- 23:27it's a very dangerous war.
- 23:28Your,
- 23:28your argument,
- 23:30you're trying to prove your argument's failing because
- 23:33what you're saying is,
- 23:34is that
- 23:34he is just giving everything they want.
- 23:36As if I didn't say that
- 23:38actually you literally said that you said he gave everything.
- 23:41I said at the start I would rewind the clip.
- 23:43I said at the start,
- 23:44if you want to prove
- 23:45that this,
- 23:46that there are times when the Trump doesn't give everything to Israel,
- 23:49I would concede that it's not a binary absolute framework.
- 23:53I have to,
- 23:53I'm trying to get my question.
- 23:54Remember when I said that?
- 23:55I do remember when he said that,
- 23:56and I remember when you contradicted yourself a few seconds later I contradicted.
- 23:59I already got,
- 24:00I already said this point,
- 24:01but here's the problem when
- 24:03he said that people go in,
- 24:04we.
- 24:05And he's like,
- 24:05uh,
- 24:06I don't really agree with that.
- 24:07It's like,
- 24:07well,
- 24:07we'll give you some more money.
- 24:08He's like,
- 24:08OK,
- 24:08I agree with it now.
- 24:09How do you know Trump doesn't just already align with the same ideology?
- 24:12The reason I know is because President Trump spent a full decade
- 24:16promising people like you
- 24:18and everyone else who voted for him that he was not
- 24:20going to involve the United States in more Middle East wars,
- 24:23in more regime change wars.
- 24:24That is the basis and foundation for Trump's entire political movement.
- 24:28Israel comes to the United States and there's no
- 24:30way to compare Israel to any other country.
- 24:31Netanyahu came 7 times.
- 24:33No other world leader came twice.
- 24:35We give billions and billions of dollars to Israel.
- 24:37I thought I let you talk,
- 24:39and yet
- 24:40you sit there and say,
- 24:40let me talk,
- 24:41let me talk,
- 24:42and then I get 6 words out and you can't control your headline.
- 24:45So there's no comparison.
- 24:46We give infinitely more money to Israel.
- 24:48We deploy our military forces to protect Israel.
- 24:51President Netanyahu,
- 24:52Prime Minister Netanyahu came 7 times,
- 24:54and then when he was done coming,
- 24:56Donald Trump turns around and does exactly what he's
- 24:58been promising for a decade that he wouldn't do,
- 25:00which is he goes to war in the Middle East.
- 25:02A regime change war in the Middle East against
- 25:04Iran's Israel's primary enemy after Netanyahu spent 30 years saying
- 25:08this is what we want the United States to do.
- 25:10That is how I know that President Trump does things that Israel tells him to,
- 25:14even though he doesn't already believe.
- 25:15OK,
- 25:15well,
- 25:15first off,
- 25:16that's actually not proof that he does.
- 25:17That's just an indication that you might be right,
- 25:19but I'm going to correct your quote.
- 25:21Actually,
- 25:21President Trump said
- 25:22multiple times,
- 25:23just off the top of my head,
- 25:24I'm sure I'm missing some,
- 25:25he said multiple times that he doesn't want
- 25:27to go straight to military action with Iran,
- 25:29but he has made it multiple.
- 25:30Very,
- 25:30very clear
- 25:31that if negotiations are exhausted,
- 25:34I will use the military option for regime change.
- 25:36OK,
- 25:36first of all,
- 25:37do you know what the four goals of the war are in Iran?
- 25:40I'm asking you,
- 25:40do you ever know what the four goals of the war are?
- 25:43What are they?
- 25:44Is it regime change?
- 25:44They,
- 25:45they've changed so many times.
- 25:46No,
- 25:47no,
- 25:47no,
- 25:47no,
- 25:48no,
- 25:48no,
- 25:48no,
- 25:48no,
- 25:49no,
- 25:49no,
- 25:49no.
- 25:49There aren't 4 goals.
- 25:50There have been 4 stated goals.
- 25:52You can go on the internet right now to the
- 25:54official government website and you read the 4 of thes.
- 25:56Trump in an interview with The Washington Post said,
- 25:58my main goals.
- 25:59And why I'm attacking Iran is to free the Iranian people.
- 26:02Is that one of the four goals that the,
- 26:03that,
- 26:04that,
- 26:04that President Trump said was his most important
- 26:06objective when going to war with Iran?
- 26:08I'm going to concede something.
- 26:09I agree with you that President Trump speaks in very grandiose measures.
- 26:13He does.
- 26:14I'm not going to.
- 26:15Everything's the biggest thing ever,
- 26:16the most beautiful thing ever.
- 26:17It's the worst thing ever.
- 26:18I'm not going to just stated goal of the war.
- 26:20No,
- 26:20it was not.
- 26:21If you listen to our Department of War,
- 26:24if you listen to our Department of War,
- 26:25and by the way,
- 26:26you can go on the president.
- 26:27That determines the war objective.
- 26:28I understand.
- 26:29It's not the Department of War.
- 26:30It's the that's actually,
- 26:31that's not.
- 26:31I was in the military for 12 years.
- 26:33That's not actually particularly who is your commander in chief,
- 26:35the Secretary of Defense?
- 26:37No,
- 26:37it's not the first,
- 26:38right?
- 26:38No,
- 26:38no,
- 26:38no.
- 26:39First off,
- 26:39that's not how objectives are attained.
- 26:41You,
- 26:41you're right.
- 26:41He agrees with them or disagrees with them.
- 26:43And again,
- 26:43I agree.
- 26:44Trump will go on interviews
- 26:45and he will say stuff who sets war goals for the United States?
- 26:49Well,
- 26:49first off,
- 26:49it's actually a complex measure of how it goes out.
- 26:51Are you asking who agrees with the finalized goals when the,
- 26:54when a war started,
- 26:55who determines what the Goals of the war,
- 26:57it's a very complex measure.
- 26:59Again,
- 26:59if you're saying agree with,
- 27:00he gets briefs,
- 27:01he gets people from the Pentagon who's the final
- 27:03decision maker about the goals of the right question,
- 27:05and that would be the commander in chief.
- 27:06That is true,
- 27:07right?
- 27:07Right.
- 27:07And so if you look at the official memo know what wars are,
- 27:10if you look at the president says,
- 27:12I got it.
- 27:12If you look at the official memo that was signed by him that
- 27:15was pushed out and still on the government website to this very day,
- 27:18you can read the main objectives of the war.
- 27:21Has he said that regime change is one of the goals of the war?
- 27:23I agree that.
- 27:24And
- 27:25he's implied it in interviews he said it explicitly
- 27:28in the official memos where he's our goal is to,
- 27:30let me ask you something.
- 27:31We got to pause there.
- 27:32You got to pause there.
- 27:33You answer my question.
- 27:34Has Donald Trump said that a goal of the war in Iran is
- 27:37to free the Iranian people by changing the regime of that country,
- 27:40a regime change war in the Middle East of the kind he said he wouldn't fight?
- 27:43Did Donald Trump say that was a goal of the war or not?
- 27:46I'm gonna answer you,
- 27:47please,
- 27:47please.
- 27:47I'm going to answer you one word answer or we gotta,
- 27:50we gotta move on.
- 27:50Real quick answer,
- 27:51one word,
- 27:52um.
- 27:53He's said in interviews.
- 27:54Yes,
- 27:54thank you.
- 27:55Thank you.
- 27:57Prior to October 7th,
- 27:59America first,
- 27:59and still,
- 28:00it still means
- 28:02America first is having a strong ally
- 28:05in Israel.
- 28:06I find it very interesting this disproportionate selective outrage with this
- 28:11pseudo-Israel influence AIPAC
- 28:143.8 million
- 28:16compared to the billions of dollars from other foreign
- 28:20adversaries.
- 28:21Um,
- 28:22you're,
- 28:23you're talking about subservient,
- 28:24we have the Chamber of Commerce,
- 28:26we have
- 28:27Big Pharma,
- 28:27we have
- 28:28the Real Estate Association,
- 28:30all
- 28:31massively
- 28:32giving more funds to the lobbying world.
- 28:35The influence of Qatar alone,
- 28:37$1 billion on universities and media.
- 28:41Aren't you more concerned about that?
- 28:43Why do you never speak about the Qatari influence in America?
- 28:47There's no comparing the influence of Qatar in the United States to Israel,
- 28:51and the proof of that is that
- 28:52we don't give $4 billion automatically a minimum every
- 28:56year to Qatar the way we do with Israel.
- 28:58This $3.8 billion that you said,
- 29:00much of which has to be spent at American
- 29:02arms manufacturers like Boeing and Raytheon,
- 29:04is like a gift certificate that the American public gives to Israel and says,
- 29:08Here,
- 29:08go shopping for yourself at our,
- 29:09at our arms dealers.
- 29:10There's no other country that gets that.
- 29:12We've given vastly more sums to Israel over the last several decades than.
- 29:16Any other country by far.
- 29:17We deploy our military for Israel.
- 29:19We don't do that for Qatar.
- 29:20President Trump has been imposing speech codes at
- 29:23universities to protect Israel and not for Qatar.
- 29:25People who demonstrate against Israel are being deported,
- 29:28not for Qatar,
- 29:29and that the amount of money itself,
- 29:30$3.8 million is the,
- 29:31is the minimum,
- 29:32that $3.8 billion is the minimum.
- 29:34We gave over $20 billion under President Biden in 2024 to Israel.
- 29:39You're being honest.
- 29:39These are all facts.
- 29:40No,
- 29:40no,
- 29:41they are facts,
- 29:41but you're not saying the whole story.
- 29:43Yes,
- 29:43Israel is the only country.
- 29:45That actually gives us a return on investment,
- 29:47that 3.8 billion,
- 29:49yes,
- 29:4980% of it is invested right back into America,
- 29:52America jobs,
- 29:53American defense,
- 29:53and guess who tests out all of our military equipment?
- 29:57It's Israel because they are in the front lines of our
- 30:00enemies.
- 30:01They are doing us a favor.
- 30:02We need Israel strategically and we are grateful to have them as a strong ally.
- 30:08The
- 30:09American people have turned against Israel because they're sick
- 30:11of having their resources propaganda that you're perpetuating.
- 30:14Waiting on,
- 30:15we didn't have an issue of this before October,
- 30:17if you look at American communities,
- 30:19they're falling apart.
- 30:20This was what President Trump,
- 30:21this is Israel lobbyists' fault.
- 30:23It's not entirely the Israel lobbyist's fault,
- 30:25but we ought to be focused.
- 30:26We talk about,
- 30:26the $215 billion in Doge.
- 30:30Maybe we should Israeli people have a higher standard of living
- 30:34than tens of millions of people in the United States,
- 30:36and yet they are forced to because Americans are forced to subsidize
- 30:40the Israeli military to send tens of billions of dollars to Israel.
- 30:44To war for Israel tens of billions of dollars.
- 30:46Yeah,
- 30:46I just told you in 2024 alone it was above $20 billion.
- 30:49They were in a war.
- 30:51Every time Israel is at,
- 30:52Israel's always at war.
- 30:53Every time Israel has never asked for boots on the ground,
- 30:55and yes,
- 30:56they were in a war.
- 30:57No,
- 30:57we pay for their wars.
- 30:58We pay for their wars.
- 31:00We pay for those wars because it's an,
- 31:02it's,
- 31:02it's to our
- 31:03interests that there is stability in the Middle East
- 31:05because these are proxies to America as well.
- 31:07Well,
- 31:07the wars that Israel starts create instability,
- 31:10not stability.
- 31:11Sunday.
- 31:11Do not
- 31:12normalize.
- 31:13Terrorism and the Islamic Caliphate.
- 31:16Why are you so hyperfocused on our allies the same way
- 31:18that we started off the first question where people say no,
- 31:20and Trump doesn't make wars,
- 31:21and then,
- 31:22OK,
- 31:22Trump makes them,
- 31:23but they're justified.
- 31:24The point here is we do more for the Israeli lobby than any other country.
- 31:27You started off by saying no,
- 31:28it's Qatar,
- 31:28and now you're saying yes,
- 31:29we do more for Israel,
- 31:30but it's,
- 31:31it's justified.
- 31:32A lot of,
- 31:33of course,
- 31:33they're,
- 31:34they're an ally and they're an enemy.
- 31:35They spy on us.
- 31:36They steal our nuclear secrets.
- 31:38We,
- 31:38they spy selectively.
- 31:40Israel is the number one surveillance.
- 31:43Threat,
- 31:44not the way that Israel spies on the United States.
- 31:45When I did the Snowden reporting,
- 31:46there are documents that say,
- 31:48here are the countries that are the greatest surveillance threat,
- 31:50China,
- 31:50Russia,
- 31:51Iran.
- 31:51Number one on that is Israel because they treat us like an enemy.
- 31:54They take our money.
- 31:55They sponge off our,
- 31:57off our citizenry.
- 31:58They suck money out of our,
- 32:00they suck money out of our
- 32:02country.
- 32:02You want to talk about our actual enemies.
- 32:03You only want to talk about Israel.
- 32:05I think Israel does more damage to the United
- 32:07Statesd out by the majority country on the planet.
- 32:09Please return to your seats.
- 32:11Thank you.
- 32:11Good job.
- 32:13Uh,
- 32:14so here's the thing,
- 32:15I actually do agree with you
- 32:17that Israel does have an outsized influence
- 32:19on our government in general.
- 32:21I think that,
- 32:22uh,
- 32:22it's a policy thing that we have to
- 32:23start putting domestic policy ahead of foreign policy.
- 32:26Uh,
- 32:26what I don't agree with is your,
- 32:28uh,
- 32:29characterization of it as subservient.
- 32:31I think that implies a greater allegiance
- 32:34to a foreign country
- 32:36than what a president actually has,
- 32:38so
- 32:39let me understand.
- 32:40Tell me some of your reasons why you think it goes beyond influence.
- 32:44Sure,
- 32:44um,
- 32:45so
- 32:46for decades in the United States,
- 32:48in
- 32:48both parties when they had the White House,
- 32:50the policy of the United States has been
- 32:53that the worst thing that the United States has to overcome
- 32:56in the Middle East when doing deals in the Middle East,
- 32:58when trying to,
- 32:58uh,
- 32:59advance our interests in the Middle East
- 33:00is the fact that the Palestinians do not have a state
- 33:03and the only way that the United States can ever improve its position in the.
- 33:07In the Middle East is through a two-state solution.
- 33:09That's why going back to the first Bush administration,
- 33:12back to the Reagan administration,
- 33:13they were threatening Israel,
- 33:14they were indignant with the Israelis,
- 33:16that they were expanding settlements in the West Bank
- 33:18because that would forever prevent a two-state solution,
- 33:21would mean that we were seen in the Middle East as suppressing the Palestinians.
- 33:24Israel ignored that.
- 33:25They expanded West Bank settlements.
- 33:27When the Bush first Bush administration tried to stop it,
- 33:29Bill Clinton.
- 33:30Ran in 1992 accusing Bush 41 of being an anti-Semite,
- 33:33and ever since then when that
- 33:35harsh,
- 33:36uh,
- 33:36accusatory framework came down on James Baker
- 33:39and George Bush and Brent Scowcroft as anti-Semite,
- 33:42American presidents,
- 33:42with some exceptions have been petrified of opposing Israel and the Israel lobby.
- 33:47They can remove members of Congress like no other lobby can.
- 33:49They've proven that repeatedly.
- 33:51And so it's not just that there are.
- 33:53Lally and we help them when it's in our interest.
- 33:54We help them even when it's contrary to our
- 33:56interests as we're doing right now with this war.
- 33:58Well,
- 33:58yeah,
- 33:59you,
- 33:59you just kind of danced around it.
- 34:00You didn't actually say what
- 34:02characterizes Trump's behavior as subservient when you,
- 34:05when you,
- 34:05when you,
- 34:05when you take,
- 34:06no,
- 34:06no,
- 34:07let me,
- 34:07let me say,
- 34:08but you wanna know?
- 34:08No,
- 34:08no,
- 34:08but let me say one thing.
- 34:09I actually do relate a lot to what you're saying,
- 34:11being called an anti-Semite.
- 34:12I'm running for Congress in Hollywood,
- 34:14Glendale,
- 34:14Burbank,
- 34:14and Pasadena,
- 34:15and
- 34:16The thing that I got labeled for criticizing Israel,
- 34:18the Israeli lobby,
- 34:20and the government of Israel,
- 34:21to be fair,
- 34:21I got immediately labeled an anti-Semite by my own party,
- 34:25by the Republican Party.
- 34:26But I want to understand
- 34:27what makes Trump subservient,
- 34:29what makes the influence go beyond.
- 34:31Uh,
- 34:32just influence and makes him
- 34:34have a greater allegiance to Israel than America.
- 34:36You haven't answered that.
- 34:36By,
- 34:37by subservience.
- 34:37I mean when you take interests that are in,
- 34:39in the interests of another country over your own and subservient,
- 34:42you can,
- 34:43are you saying why is he subservient?
- 34:44Like what causes that?
- 34:45or what do I mean by subservient what you've described so far is influence,
- 34:49which we all agree there's a foreign influence in our government that's outsized,
- 34:52and it very often drives our politics and our politicians to go
- 34:56beyond the interests of Americans,
- 34:57but that doesn't mean that they have a greater allegiance
- 34:59to a foreign government than they do.
- 35:01To their own people,
- 35:02I'm not saying President Trump has a greater allegiance
- 35:04to Israel than he does to the United States.
- 35:05I'm saying that the lobby that influences him,
- 35:08that he's afraid of,
- 35:09that he takes direction from,
- 35:11their goal is to make sure that American politicians are serving the
- 35:14interest of Israel even above the interest of the United States,
- 35:17even when it undermines or subverts the interests of the United States.
- 35:19That is the point of the Israel lobby is to make sure that Israeli interests,
- 35:23you're talking stay above lobby.
- 35:24All right,
- 35:25we got a pause there.
- 35:25You've been voted out.
- 35:26Good luck in your campaign.
- 35:27Thank you.
- 35:28Hello.
- 35:29Nice to meet you.
- 35:29Nice to meet you as well.
- 35:30I'm Eden.
- 35:32OK,
- 35:32so when you're talking about the Israel lobby,
- 35:34are you referring mostly to AIPAC or,
- 35:36I mean,
- 35:37I'm certainly referring to AIPAC,
- 35:39but there's a gigantic number of other organs and arms of the Israeli lobby,
- 35:42right?
- 35:43And can you give examples where they're going outside of legal bounds?
- 35:47No,
- 35:47I don't.
- 35:47My accusation is not that AIPAC acts illegally.
- 35:50I do think there's a good argument that they ought to be
- 35:52registered under FARA,
- 35:53but under our laws they're not required.
- 35:54So with the FAAA argument,
- 35:56you,
- 35:56you do know that it's American Jewish interests,
- 35:58right,
- 35:59that the lobby AIPAC is for American Jewish,
- 36:01um.
- 36:02Interests.
- 36:03So AIPAC takes direction from the Israeli government.
- 36:05They're over there all the time.
- 36:06I understand the argument that these are Americans,
- 36:08but the fact that a lot of Americans have to register under FAI
- 36:11if they're taking directions from or acting on behalf of a foreign government,
- 36:14which I think AIPAC is,
- 36:15but I'm not arguing that AIPAC is criminal.
- 36:17That's a different debate.
- 36:18We can have that,
- 36:19but that's not the relevant question.
- 36:20I see,
- 36:21I hear this argument a lot,
- 36:22and what I always go back to is America is voting with their dollar.
- 36:26OK,
- 36:27so yeah,
- 36:27there is influence,
- 36:28right?
- 36:28There is.
- 36:29Jewish American
- 36:31influence,
- 36:31but it is because the American people want it.
- 36:34That's why AIPAC is so successful.
- 36:36OK,
- 36:36let me,
- 36:36that,
- 36:36uh,
- 36:36I'm glad you raised that because actually what AIPAC
- 36:38does when they want to remove a member from Congress
- 36:41like they did with Corey Bush or Jamal Bowman in the last cycle,
- 36:43like they've done with tons of them,
- 36:44is they spend
- 36:46insane amounts of money for a congressional district
- 36:48like they're doing with Thomas Massey now.
- 36:49They don't go in and advertise and say this member of Congress
- 36:52isn't sufficiently supportive of Israel or is too anti-Israel because they know.
- 36:56That's a failing issue because Americans don't care about foreign countries.
- 36:59They care about their own country like every other country.
- 37:01What they do is they go in and they deceive people by saying
- 37:04our ads are really about the fact that he doesn't tend to potholes or he has
- 37:07bad constituent services or he doesn't support healthcare
- 37:09or he's doing this or he's do that.
- 37:11Are they lying about it?
- 37:12No,
- 37:12it's just,
- 37:12it's so they're choosing to focus on other issues.
- 37:14It's,
- 37:15it's,
- 37:15it's exactly,
- 37:16it's exactly the opposite of what you said,
- 37:19which is that they go in and the reason why you said the reason why people vote for the,
- 37:22for.
- 37:23AIPAC's candidates is because they want support for Israel.
- 37:25Well,
- 37:25you know,
- 37:26AIPAC doesn't think that AIPAC doesn't,
- 37:28and this candidate says that they're going to,
- 37:29but that's not AIPAC's concern.
- 37:31It's a totally stealth and deceitful campaign money wherever they want.
- 37:34I know I'm not arguing that AIPAC is a criminal organization.
- 37:37I'm not arguing,
- 37:38arguing that they should be imprisoned.
- 37:39I'm arguing that the point of the Israel lobby is to keep,
- 37:42yes,
- 37:42it is nefarious because the point is to in,
- 37:45in the shadows,
- 37:46hide their agenda,
- 37:47which is to keep American politicians.
- 37:50Subservient and captive to the interest so you always have to,
- 37:52you have to always have to revert to the conspiracy idea.
- 37:55It's not a conspiracy.
- 37:56It's done right out in the open.
- 37:57I don't think it's a conspiracy have to go back to the conspiracy.
- 37:59I think it's a conspiracy.
- 38:00You can't deal with the fact that American Jews are voting for this.
- 38:04America,
- 38:05American Jews,
- 38:05do you know what percentage of Americans,
- 38:07do you know what percentage of Americans?
- 38:08Yes,
- 38:09and you're free to do that.
- 38:10You're free to donate to whatever campaign that you want.
- 38:12So am I.
- 38:12There's no argument that we can reform the lobby system.
- 38:15OK,
- 38:15that's fair,
- 38:16but
- 38:17Americans are voting with their dollar.
- 38:18The difference is the way between the pharma lobby and
- 38:21the Wall Street lobby and the Silicon Valley lobby,
- 38:23which are gigantic,
- 38:25is that they're at least American companies.
- 38:27There's no other lobby that represents a foreign country that has
- 38:31even 1/100 of the impact that the Israel lobby has,
- 38:35and that's what makes it so different and so dangerous.
- 38:37An ally.
- 38:38Jewish Americans have a vested interest in Israel,
- 38:40OK?
- 38:41They're also our ally.
- 38:43What do you mean a lot of.
- 38:44Some don't like
- 38:45you,
- 38:45right?
- 38:45You're Jewish,
- 38:46yeah,
- 38:46yeah.
- 38:46So it's like you,
- 38:48so some do,
- 38:48some don't.
- 38:49OK.
- 38:49If some do,
- 38:50they can vote with their dollar.
- 38:51They're already our allies.
- 38:53So a lot of Jews have a vested interest in a foreign country.
- 38:57And how do they?
- 38:57President Trump said about Mary Adelson,
- 38:59for example,
- 38:59who's a citizen of Israel and the United States,
- 39:02that he believes she has a greater loyalty to Israel.
- 39:04She would choose Israel when the two are in conflict.
- 39:06Would that be that's a problem,
- 39:07and I've heard other people say they have different alli.
- 39:10They care more about.
- 39:11Other countries are born in as well,
- 39:13right?
- 39:13But it's kind of a problem that the single richest and most powerful we can put
- 39:15in legislation Israeli American is somebody who's who's
- 39:18who's in the White House all the time.
- 39:20According to President Trump,
- 39:21has more loyalty to a foreign country than she does to the American,
- 39:24to the United States.
- 39:25That's a pretty gigantic problem.
- 39:27She,
- 39:27she kick her out.
- 39:28President Trump has her in the White House every,
- 39:30every other week because of the mass amount of money anything illegal.
- 39:33So what's the problem?
- 39:34You're just,
- 39:34you're,
- 39:35you have a problem with the motivation.
- 39:36OK,
- 39:37so we can't just police everybody's motivation.
- 39:39There,
- 39:39there are a lot of things that aren't illegal that still
- 39:41should be criticized and dragged out into the sunlight and the
- 39:44influence of the whole that I am is this whole AIPAC
- 39:46is this nefarious grand puppet master thing is absolutely debunkable.
- 39:51OK.
- 39:51AIPAC sometimes does not win.
- 39:53I mean,
- 39:53we saw with,
- 39:54um,
- 39:55in 2015,
- 39:55the JCPOA,
- 39:56the situation.
- 39:57Um,
- 39:58I agree,
- 39:58I agree.
- 39:58They don't always get their way.
- 39:59They get their way almost all the time,
- 40:01most of the time,
- 40:01and that is a huge again,
- 40:02America's voting with their do.
- 40:03So,
- 40:04all right,
- 40:04we got to pause there.
- 40:05We are out of time.
- 40:07Please return to your seats.
- 40:11My next round of claim is the Trump administration has been
- 40:15considerably more corrupt than the Biden administration.
- 40:17All right,
- 40:18if you'd like to debate this claim,
- 40:19please get to the chair in 321.
- 40:25Hello
- 40:26hello there.
- 40:27There's so many things I could,
- 40:28I could talk for hours on end,
- 40:31even giving Kamala Harris an appointation of,
- 40:34um,
- 40:34I don't know if that's a word,
- 40:35but appointing her as
- 40:36the next candidate.
- 40:39Because
- 40:40he wasn't able to run,
- 40:42and you're America first,
- 40:43right?
- 40:43That's what you're saying,
- 40:44right?
- 40:44OK,
- 40:45so
- 40:46do you agree that it was corrupt?
- 40:47So I'm somebody who believes that there was a lot of corruption
- 40:50in the Biden administration.
- 40:51My claim is not that the Biden administration was free of meaningful corruption.
- 40:54It was had a lot of corruption.
- 40:56My claim is that the Trump administration
- 40:58has a lot more corruption,
- 40:59and we can talk about what those financial deals are.
- 41:01OK,
- 41:02well,
- 41:02I'll just give you one example.
- 41:03For example,
- 41:04Jared Kushner,
- 41:05who's now running Middle East foreign
- 41:06policy and negotiating Middle East policy for
- 41:09Donald Trump,
- 41:09his son-in-law,
- 41:11right before,
- 41:12right before he was,
- 41:13uh,
- 41:14put into that position just a year or so earlier,
- 41:16he created a hedge fund,
- 41:18and the number one investor were the Saudis
- 41:20who invested $2 billion in Jared Kushner's fund,
- 41:22both as a reward for a job well done for the service
- 41:25that the Trump administration in the first term gave to them.
- 41:27The Saudis and also for making sure that the Saudis' interests are protected.
- 41:31It's basically a bribe directly to the Trump family.
- 41:34The Trump family created
- 41:35a crypto company
- 41:36called the World
- 41:37World Liberty Financial,
- 41:3949% of which is now owned by the United Arab Emirates.
- 41:41We've heard so much here about how important the UAE is,
- 41:44about how Saudi Arabia is,
- 41:46and they're funneling gigantic sums of money directly to the Trump family.
- 41:49OK,
- 41:50but look at,
- 41:50can I,
- 41:50I just want to interject a little bit because.
- 41:52Look at Nancy Pelosi.
- 41:53Look at all the inside trading.
- 41:55It goes way beyond that.
- 41:57So both sides do it.
- 41:58Is it right?
- 41:58No,
- 41:59but,
- 41:59but Biden administration and all of the people on the Democratic side
- 42:03are doing it so much worse on such a larger scale.
- 42:06It's affecting America.
- 42:08I worked a lot on the Hunter Biden,
- 42:09uh,
- 42:10corruption case,
- 42:10principally that he got $50,000 a month from
- 42:13a company in Ukraine called Barria when.
- 42:16President Vice President Biden had immense influence in
- 42:19Ukraine and as more than as Andy McCarthy said,
- 42:22who's a longtime Republican conservative prosecutor,
- 42:24in order to talk about or compare the corruption,
- 42:27similar corruption by the Trump sons and by Jared Kushner,
- 42:29you have to add two zeros to the amounts,
- 42:31and I think that's what the,
- 42:33the concern is.
- 42:34Biden OK,
- 42:34we gotta,
- 42:35we gotta move on.
- 42:36Thank you.
- 42:36You've been voted out.
- 42:37It was fun.
- 42:37Thank you.
- 42:37Yeah,
- 42:38how's it going?
- 42:39Good.
- 42:39How are you?
- 42:39Good,
- 42:40good.
- 42:40Uh,
- 42:41so I think that we can see corruption pretty,
- 42:43you know,
- 42:43well in the Biden administration.
- 42:45You've got Joe Biden's drug addict son
- 42:47that got convicted on gun charges,
- 42:49on,
- 42:50um,
- 42:51you know,
- 42:51tax evasion
- 42:52charges,
- 42:53uh,
- 42:53and Joe Biden used his pardoning power to,
- 42:56you know,
- 42:57erase that completely.
- 42:58But I think that we can see corruption in its finest,
- 43:00uh,
- 43:00when,
- 43:01when you have a senile old man
- 43:03like Joe Biden
- 43:04who is getting propped up and and is basically a puppet for the Democratic Party.
- 43:09So I think when we talk about corruption,
- 43:11we're not talking generally about just bad acts or or or malfeasance in government,
- 43:16we're generally talking about the influence of
- 43:18ill-gotten gains or malicious motives or
- 43:21self-interested motives and government decisions.
- 43:24What made Hunter Biden,
- 43:25the Hunter Biden case corrupt was not his drug addiction or his,
- 43:28uh,
- 43:29tax evasion.
- 43:29Those were personal bad acts on his part.
- 43:33It's a,
- 43:33it's a bad use of the pardoning power for Joe Biden to do that.
- 43:35It shows clear corruption.
- 43:36Yeah,
- 43:37I mean,
- 43:37President Trump has pardoned
- 43:39dozens of people,
- 43:41all of whom are very wealthy,
- 43:42who stole money from
- 43:44investors,
- 43:44who have friends that are very close to the Trump administration.
- 43:47There's a whole pardon industry surrounding the Trump White House
- 43:49where if you have enough money and you can pay
- 43:51a million dollars or $1.5 million or $2 million to close Trump associates,
- 43:55you will get.
- 43:56Pardon,
- 43:56but the problem with the Hunter Biden case,
- 43:59what made that so concerning was that he was monetizing the influence that Joe
- 44:03Biden had in Ukraine in order to get all kinds of money for himself.
- 44:07This is what
- 44:08Donald Trump Jr.
- 44:09is doing.
- 44:09Eric Trump is doing,
- 44:10and especially Jared Kushner is doing in the,
- 44:13in the region of the world
- 44:14that President Trump has been most influential,
- 44:16which is the Persian Gulf,
- 44:17where there's the most amount of money,
- 44:18billions of.
- 44:19Dollars have flowed to the Trump family
- 44:21through properties and entities that they've created,
- 44:24including World Liberty Financial,
- 44:25including Jared Kushner's.
- 44:27Does that not concern you the way it did with Hunter Biden?
- 44:29I don't,
- 44:29I'm not talking about billions of dollars,
- 44:31right?
- 44:31Well,
- 44:31I mean,
- 44:31the HOC did report that the Biden family,
- 44:34uh,
- 44:34received
- 44:35$24 to $27 million.
- 44:37I'm talking about billions.
- 44:38Yeah,
- 44:38we're talking about.
- 44:39So basically you're,
- 44:40you're you're just basically saying that Trump was better at being.
- 44:43No,
- 44:43I'm saying it's,
- 44:44it's great.
- 44:44It's more damaging corruption.
- 44:46So you're criticizing Trump for being
- 44:48more of a businessman,
- 44:49a better businessman than Joe Biden.
- 44:50It's like saying,
- 44:51oh,
- 44:51that guy stole,
- 44:52uh,
- 44:52a Milky Way,
- 44:53and that guy,
- 44:53uh,
- 44:54defrauded billions of dollars from old ladies.
- 44:57So this guy's better than this one at being a crook,
- 44:59at being a corrupt,
- 45:00they're being a corrupt criminal.
- 45:02Yes,
- 45:02I do think Trump's better at that.
- 45:03Yeah,
- 45:03I mean,
- 45:04corruption is similar as far as,
- 45:05you know,
- 45:05how he's monetized.
- 45:06We got pause there.
- 45:07Flags are up.
- 45:07You've been voted out.
- 45:08Thank you.
- 45:09Thanks.
- 45:11How you doing?
- 45:12Good.
- 45:12How are you?
- 45:13Doing well.
- 45:13Um,
- 45:15so you're saying that Trump is more corrupt than Joe Biden.
- 45:19That's what you're saying.
- 45:20I'm saying the Trump administration is more has a
- 45:22lot more corruption than the Biden administration has.
- 45:24OK,
- 45:24by,
- 45:25I'm guessing by what the war or his kids or what?
- 45:28I,
- 45:28I,
- 45:29I think we're focused primarily on financial corruption.
- 45:31I mean you can talk about other kinds of corruption as well,
- 45:33but the,
- 45:33the,
- 45:34the,
- 45:34the.
- 45:34Concerned about Hunter Biden and the money that he made off his father's influence,
- 45:38which I found extremely objectionable and still do,
- 45:40pales in comparison to the extreme fortune that the Trump
- 45:43kids and Jared Kushner are building off of Trump's power.
- 45:47OK,
- 45:47well,
- 45:48Trump,
- 45:48Trump is not corrupted at all.
- 45:50Um,
- 45:51we're not in a war as well.
- 45:52Sorry,
- 45:52there's so many.
- 45:53I wanted to answer you on so many things,
- 45:55but you're not being specific about
- 45:57how it's Trump,
- 45:58his administration corrupted,
- 46:00what exactly,
- 46:01because his kids aren't
- 46:03the administration,
- 46:04it's just Donald Trump.
- 46:05So how is,
- 46:05well,
- 46:05Hunter Biden wasn't the Biden administration,
- 46:07but,
- 46:07uh,
- 46:07it was just the president stumping about Joe Biden.
- 46:09I,
- 46:09I wanna go on,
- 46:10you're saying Trump,
- 46:11OK,
- 46:12Trump administration.
- 46:12How is he more corrupt it's a comparison between the Biden administration,
- 46:15but I'll tell you the most corrupting that Trump has done,
- 46:17I'll tell you,
- 46:17I'll tell.
- 46:18What the,
- 46:19there's a lot of things,
- 46:20but the,
- 46:20the main one is
- 46:21they created a company
- 46:23shortly before Trump's inauguration
- 46:25that's a crypto company called World Financial Liberty.
- 46:27They all,
- 46:28you got,
- 46:28if you want to,
- 46:29if you want me to explain,
- 46:29I can explain it,
- 46:30but you gotta let me explain.
- 46:31So you're saying that he's corrupt that in a way,
- 46:33in,
- 46:33in a way that he can get in trouble just like Hunter Biden got in.
- 46:37There's the World Financial Liberty,
- 46:38which is the,
- 46:39uh,
- 46:39crypto company
- 46:40that the UAE has,
- 46:42uh,
- 46:42invested hundreds of billions of dollars in that has.
- 46:4549% ownership
- 46:47that paid a huge amount of money to enrich President Trump.
- 46:50On top of that,
- 46:50he created this coin,
- 46:51the Trump coin,
- 46:54where any foreign influencers or foreign power can pour as much money
- 46:56as they want into Donald Trump's pocket and have done so.
- 46:59Are you aware that he's doing?
- 47:00Are you aware that Trump doesn't take,
- 47:02he never has took his presidential checks?
- 47:04Are you aware that he's given up all?
- 47:06Yes,
- 47:07that's,
- 47:07that's just $405,000.
- 47:09That's it.
- 47:10OK.
- 47:10Are you aware that he's given up all his Uh,
- 47:13all his everything he owns,
- 47:14the,
- 47:14the,
- 47:15uh,
- 47:15is,
- 47:16uh,
- 47:16Trump is infinitely richer man now
- 47:19than he was when he saw.
- 47:20Are you jealous in 20 or like because he's president?
- 47:22Is that,
- 47:22is that jealousy or something?
- 47:24Are you jealous of that,
- 47:24that he knows what to do with his money and he knows how to do?
- 47:27Were you,
- 47:27did you,
- 47:27were you a critic of Joe Biden?
- 47:29Were you a critic of Joe Biden close to corrupt.
- 47:30And you know what,
- 47:31you wanna know what you're doing right now?
- 47:32You're saying that I,
- 47:34I saw he corrected yourself.
- 47:35You said
- 47:35you were saying Trump to the other people,
- 47:37but now you,
- 47:37you,
- 47:38you're talking to me and you said Trump administration.
- 47:40So no,
- 47:40the,
- 47:41the,
- 47:41the,
- 47:41the formulation is the Trump administration has been
- 47:44significantly more corrupt than the Biden administration.
- 47:46That's what it's been from the start,
- 47:47and you,
- 47:47you were talking to them saying Trump,
- 47:48and now you're saying Trump administration.
- 47:49I'm saying both.
- 47:50I explained to you how Donald Trump was corrupt.
- 47:52OK,
- 47:52so Trump is not the adminis Trump is Trump.
- 47:55So you think he's in control of,
- 47:56of whatever happens on something else,
- 47:58or is the company that received hundreds of billions of dollars from the.
- 48:02UAE is Trump's company.
- 48:03Trump's fault.
- 48:04Trump's company,
- 48:05he created the company with Steve Whitkopf,
- 48:07with Steve Witkoff's kids' fault.
- 48:09Yes,
- 48:09of course it's Trump's fault.
- 48:10He was the one who created the company.
- 48:11How is it Trump's fault because Trump is the one who received
- 48:14all that money and now is in bed with the UAE.
- 48:16It's exactly the kind of quid pro quo that.
- 48:19We pause.
- 48:19No,
- 48:20no,
- 48:20I don't think,
- 48:21I,
- 48:21I think there should be,
- 48:22we got pause there.
- 48:22You've been voted out.
- 48:27Hey,
- 48:27good to see you.
- 48:28Good to see you again.
- 48:28How are you?
- 48:29Good.
- 48:29As I've been listening,
- 48:31I've been writing down
- 48:32all the areas of corruption that I could think of from the Biden administration.
- 48:36And so you,
- 48:37what you have to prove is that what Trump has done is greater than considerably more,
- 48:41right?
- 48:41So you have Biden's autopen where he's just signing legislation
- 48:45without actually not knowing what.
- 48:47It actually is.
- 48:48How do you know what you have,
- 48:49you have OSHA.
- 48:50Well,
- 48:50let me,
- 48:50let me,
- 48:51well,
- 48:51hold on,
- 48:52let me list because you have,
- 48:53you have OSHA where he tried to cram down
- 48:56vaccine mandates on working Americans unconstitutionally.
- 49:00You have
- 49:01$400 billion in COVID fraud during the Biden administration.
- 49:05You have
- 49:06Hunter Biden,
- 49:07I know.
- 49:07You agree with that,
- 49:08so,
- 49:09I don't need to go into that too much.
- 49:10You have
- 49:11millions of illegal immigrants entering in the
- 49:13country and changing the voter base.
- 49:15You have free college,
- 49:17he tried to do that unconstitutionally.
- 49:19You have charisma,
- 49:20um,
- 49:21you,
- 49:21he went after Trump
- 49:23illegally through different court cases,
- 49:25and
- 49:26that,
- 49:26you'll love this one.
- 49:27You know how much,
- 49:28uh,
- 49:29you know who is the greatest senator who has
- 49:31taken the most amount of money from AIPAC?
- 49:34Joe Biden.
- 49:36$4.2 million a fanatical.
- 49:37I know that $4.2 million.
- 49:39No,
- 49:39Trump,
- 49:40Trump has gotten more from the pro-Israel lobby,
- 49:41but,
- 49:42but Joe Biden has spent his entire career in captivity to,
- 49:44to Israel.
- 49:45So,
- 49:45but,
- 49:45so,
- 49:46so your burden is to prove that,
- 49:48let me ask all everything that Trump has done outweighs all those.
- 49:51Have you,
- 49:51I,
- 49:52I think there's an issue with corruption and what that means.
- 49:54That includes and doesn't,
- 49:55but it's not every bad act.
- 49:57But let's just leave that to the side for a minute.
- 49:59You've heard,
- 49:59you've sat here and you've heard me
- 50:01list all of the different ways in which Trump,
- 50:03his sons,
- 50:04and Jared Kushner
- 50:05have built a multi-billion dollar personal fortune by trading on their power.
- 50:10You've heard all those.
- 50:10I'm not saying you agree with them,
- 50:11but you've heard me
- 50:12outline those,
- 50:13correct?
- 50:13I've heard you outline.
- 50:14Do you agree or disagree with the claims that I've made about those?
- 50:17Uh,
- 50:18well,
- 50:19what I,
- 50:19what I want to get to is,
- 50:20no,
- 50:20I know,
- 50:20but we're building up.
- 50:21We're building a comparison.
- 50:23So
- 50:23I heard you.
- 50:24So why don't you go ahead and list all the multiple things,
- 50:27right,
- 50:28because I,
- 50:28because you know,
- 50:29I have,
- 50:29I have,
- 50:30sorry,
- 50:30I'm asking you know the corruption there,
- 50:32right?
- 50:32OK,
- 50:33so then now go ahead and list all the other things.
- 50:35I just,
- 50:36I just got done saying to you
- 50:37that while you were sitting behind me for the last 15 minutes,
- 50:40I've listed 6 or 7 different ways
- 50:43in which Trump,
- 50:44his sons,
- 50:44and Jared Kushner
- 50:46have built a multi-billion dollar personal fortune.
- 50:48By trading on his personal power,
- 50:50I don't think there are things that compare in
- 50:52the Biden administration to the level of personal corruption.
- 50:54And what I'm asking you is whether you think going after your I'm asking you is
- 50:59whether you think you don't think Trump has
- 51:01gone after his political opponents as well.
- 51:03He's tried to indict James Comey.
- 51:05He tried to indict Letitia James,
- 51:07and even the grand jury threw them out.
- 51:08But I'm asking you about the examples that I listed.
- 51:11Do you think I've accurately described the personal corruption
- 51:15I'm,
- 51:15if I grant your.
- 51:15But I want,
- 51:16I don't want you to grant it.
- 51:17I want to know if you think I've accurately described it
- 51:19because we're talking about billions of dollars in personal wealth.
- 51:22And if you think the corruption is worse than the Biden administration,
- 51:25tell me the billions of with all of the examples you named,
- 51:28do you think,
- 51:29do you think to defend the claim that you're?
- 51:31I'm defending it.
- 51:32So
- 51:32Jared Kushner created a vulture capital fund,
- 51:35an investment fund
- 51:37in which the primary investors were the Saudis
- 51:39who invested $2 billion into Jared Kushner's.
- 51:43Personal fund.
- 51:44The Emiratis have invested hundreds of billions,
- 51:46hundreds of millions of dollars as well.
- 51:47Donald Trump,
- 51:48his sons,
- 51:49Steve Witkoff and his sons created a crypto company
- 51:52that the UAE has devoted hundreds of billions of dollars
- 51:55to and then bought a 49% stake share in.
- 51:58The Qataris have done the same.
- 52:00Donald Trump Jr.
- 52:01and Eric Trump just created a new drone company that they're
- 52:04now selling to the Pentagon and getting contracts from the Pentagon
- 52:07that will further personally enrich the Trump family.
- 52:10We're talking about a level billions and billions of dollars in
- 52:13personal wealth that did not exist before Donald Trump entered the presidency
- 52:17that now exists in his family
- 52:18by virtue of these deals with the with the
- 52:20exact countries on which he wields the most influence.
- 52:24There's two points I want to make,
- 52:25OK,
- 52:25so first off,
- 52:27right,
- 52:27even let's say I grant all of that.
- 52:29Let's say I grant all of that.
- 52:30No,
- 52:31no,
- 52:31no,
- 52:31let's say I grant all of that.
- 52:32That still doesn't prove your claim.
- 52:33I brought up a whole list
- 52:35of things that Biden has done that.
- 52:39Biden,
- 52:39Biden his point,
- 52:39but how much can I make my second point?
- 52:40Can I make my second point?
- 52:41OK.
- 52:42Are American citizens not free to pursue
- 52:45business activities outside political office?
- 52:48Can Obama not pursue a Netflix deal?
- 52:51Can Obama not pursue book deals once he's out of office?
- 52:54He can.
- 52:54Once he's out of,
- 52:55once he's served two terms and is out of office.
- 52:57This was Trump in office when this was happening.
- 52:59Yes,
- 52:59the World Financial Liberty Company was created in
- 53:02the transition after he won the election and.
- 53:04Before he was inaugurated,
- 53:044 days before he was inaugurated,
- 53:06he created that crypto company
- 53:08into which hundreds of billions of dollars of foreign money has flowed,
- 53:12enriching the Trump family.
- 53:13I don't think you know about these transactions.
- 53:15I don't think we all,
- 53:16there's things I people I brought up that I don't know about.
- 53:18There's nothing wrong with that.
- 53:19I'm just saying I think you ought to go and look at those transactions.
- 53:21You're just not defending your claim again,
- 53:22even if I would grant you,
- 53:23I'll leave it to the audience to decide if I've defended,
- 53:26even if I grant you all of that,
- 53:27you still will not address anything about Biden.
- 53:29You refuse to do so.
- 53:31Good to meet you.
- 53:32How are you?
- 53:32Good.
- 53:33How are you?
- 53:33Good,
- 53:33thanks.
- 53:34So you mentioned uh,
- 53:35Donald Trump's crypto endeavors.
- 53:36So could you tell me a little bit more about that and how that makes him corrupt?
- 53:39Sure,
- 53:40there's actually a constitutional prohibition on political leaders accepting or
- 53:44receiving gifts from foreign countries because of the obvious and extreme
- 53:47potential to corrupt US foreign policy
- 53:49because foreign governments and foreign leaders
- 53:52can pay money into the pockets of American officials in exchange for favors.
- 53:56So Trump by creating this World Financial liberty crypto
- 53:59Company along with Steve Whitkoff and his kids,
- 54:01made it so that not just it's a potential
- 54:03that foreign governments and foreign leaders can invest huge
- 54:06amounts of money that go into Trump's pocket,
- 54:07but that was what the company was.
- 54:09for and that's exactly what has happened.
- 54:11Mention that,
- 54:11uh,
- 54:11Trump was in violation of some type of federal law that restricted,
- 54:14uh,
- 54:14president,
- 54:14presidents from doing business.
- 54:16It's a constitutional amendment.
- 54:17OK,
- 54:17awesome.
- 54:18OK,
- 54:18so that
- 54:19you did not make that claim.
- 54:20You didn't say Trump was in violation of a constitutional amendment
- 54:22to try to protect the interests of the American people.
- 54:24You said he was corrupt,
- 54:26so you haven't shown any type of reason
- 54:28of why Trump is corrupt.
- 54:30No,
- 54:30the Constitution has a business called.
- 54:32Does Trump own it,
- 54:33or is,
- 54:33did his,
- 54:33does his family own it?
- 54:34He,
- 54:35he,
- 54:35he,
- 54:35he owned it when he founded it and once he was inaugurated president.
- 54:38So he followed the rules.
- 54:40He followed the rules.
- 54:40I'm not saying,
- 54:41I'm not saying,
- 54:41but he followed the rules of the amendment,
- 54:43and also you have no evidence of Joe Biden,
- 54:45Joe Biden also was not convicted for any
- 54:47matters relating to Hunter Biden's business activities,
- 54:49even though most people in this room,
- 54:51as I've heard,
- 54:51and I would agree,
- 54:52think those activities were corrupt.
- 54:54There are lots of political corruption that don't
- 54:56end up crossing the political line of corruption.
- 54:58Corruption is when
- 54:59you do things
- 55:00that look and have the potential to be untoward because
- 55:03the way you're monetizing and exploiting your political power,
- 55:07which is supposed to be in service.
- 55:08To the public
- 55:09for your own personal wealth.
- 55:10How do you have proof that he did this out of interest of the American public?
- 55:13What I,
- 55:13what,
- 55:13what we know,
- 55:14what we also,
- 55:14who should be indicted?
- 55:15What we know,
- 55:16somebody should be indicted,
- 55:16right?
- 55:16If there's corruption,
- 55:17who should,
- 55:17who should it be?
- 55:18Donald Trump Junior.
- 55:19There's a lot,
- 55:20there's a lot,
- 55:20there's a lot of,
- 55:21a lot of corruption.
- 55:22I think it's corrupt when the pharmaceutical lobby goes to
- 55:25members of Congress and says,
- 55:26we'll donate
- 55:27$100,000 to your political campaign or spend $100,000 on your in exchange for this,
- 55:31but it's not criminal.
- 55:32But it's not criminal.
- 55:33It's not criminal to do.
- 55:35And so there's all kinds of corruption,
- 55:37unfortunately in our.
- 55:38In our system that has been legalized.
- 55:39OK,
- 55:40so we both agree Trump didn't break the rules.
- 55:41He gave the,
- 55:42he gave the company,
- 55:43no,
- 55:43I think,
- 55:44I think we need the problem,
- 55:45we need an,
- 55:47we need an investigation to see exactly what happened.
- 55:48But based on what we know in the public,
- 55:49just the mere fact that Trump is creating a company,
- 55:51that Trump is creating a company 4 days before he's in,
- 55:55he's been massively enriched.
- 55:56He's been massively enriched by these transactions during his first presidency.
- 56:00He actually,
- 56:00his net worth actually went lower than when he originally was inaugurated in 2017.
- 56:04It's like about 3 times greater now than it was when he saw.
- 56:07Presidency in 2016,
- 56:09yeah,
- 56:09because the inflation happens,
- 56:10time goes on,
- 56:11and also he was president because he got billions of
- 56:13dollars from the Persian Gulf dictatorships during his presidency,
- 56:17during his term from January 2017 to January 2021,
- 56:20Donald Trump's net worth went down.
- 56:22During the Biden administration,
- 56:23his net worth went up,
- 56:24most likely because of inflation,
- 56:25because the Democrats were rampant
- 56:26with printing money.
- 56:28Serious question.
- 56:28Just imagine a
- 56:30president,
- 56:30a Democratic president that's not Donald Trump.
- 56:33Four days before they're inaugurated as president,
- 56:36they create a new company.
- 56:37And into that company flows hundreds of billions of dollars or billions of dollars,
- 56:41billions of dollars
- 56:42from the very countries that'll be most
- 56:44affected by that president's foreign policy.
- 56:46That wouldn't concern you at all.
- 56:48You don't think there's anything concerning about that a suspicion,
- 56:51but I'm not going to make a claim that he's corrupt,
- 56:52and that's a claim that you're making right now,
- 56:54because everything that Trump has done since
- 56:55then has benefited those very countries that enriched
- 56:58his family so greatly with billions of dollars in personal wealth to his family.
- 57:02And not only that,
- 57:03but the Saudi investment in Jared Kushner's fund,
- 57:06the Saudi.
- 57:07But the Iran war negatively affects the UAE,
- 57:09right?
- 57:09And Donald Trump
- 57:10somewhat Iran is thrilled with the Iran war,
- 57:13as people said earlier,
- 57:14they're having,
- 57:14they're having,
- 57:15they're having shit fall on their cities.
- 57:16UAE.
- 57:17They're having shrapnel fall on the UAE hates Iran.
- 57:20They're encouraging Iran.
- 57:21They're encouraging Trump to continue.
- 57:22They want regime change.
- 57:23They despise Iran.
- 57:24So do the Saudis.
- 57:26This war is done.
- 57:27Trump would never have done this war without
- 57:29those very countries with whom he's closest,
- 57:31which coincidentally has also poured billions of
- 57:34dollars in personal wealth into his family.
- 57:36If that isn't.
- 57:36Corruption.
- 57:37I don't know what it is.
- 57:38And all of you thought that what Hunter Biden did,
- 57:40which was on a much,
- 57:41much smaller scale,
- 57:42you all thought that was corruption.
- 57:44I did too,
- 57:44because I'm actually consistent.
- 57:46I don't change my principles based on which party is in office.
- 57:48It's the same exact transaction only as Andy McCarthy said,
- 57:51the longtime conservative prosecutor.
- 57:52In order to compare Trump's kids and Biden's kids,
- 57:55you have to add two zeros to what Trump's kids are doing.
- 57:58All right,
- 57:58let's pause there.
- 57:59We've run,
- 57:59we've run out of time.
- 58:00Thank you.
- 58:00Good to talk to you.
- 58:01My final surrounding claim is bombing Iran
- 58:04is not in the American people's interests.
- 58:07If you'd like to debate this claim,
- 58:08please get to the chair in 321.
- 58:13Hi Glenn.
- 58:13Hey,
- 58:14how are you?
- 58:14Good to meet you.
- 58:14Good to meet you.
- 58:15So I think in talking about this conflict or war,
- 58:18the things that we have to establish is what each side has lost.
- 58:21So in my estimation,
- 58:22you're welcome to jump in,
- 58:23I think the US has lost about $40 to $50 billion.
- 58:26We've lost about 14 servicemen,
- 58:27which I think is the greatest loss that we've had.
- 58:30And,
- 58:30um,
- 58:31beyond that we haven't lost a lot.
- 58:32What Iran has lost
- 58:34is their entire military,
- 58:35their entire navy.
- 58:36They have lost half their leaders
- 58:38and a lot of money along the way.
- 58:39So in my estimation,
- 58:41we're winning this war,
- 58:42and the reason why we're fighting the war is because 1000
- 58:44Americans have been killed by Iran in the last 50 years.
- 58:47Have they lost?
- 58:48Has Iran,
- 58:48you mentioned the losses.
- 58:49Has Iran lost any civilians?
- 58:52Uh,
- 58:52yeah,
- 58:52I'm sure that's how war works.
- 58:53Like,
- 58:54for example,
- 58:54on the,
- 58:55that's how war works.
- 58:55Like on the first day we
- 58:56vaporized 170
- 58:58young Iranian schoolgirls.
- 58:59I think it's bombing an elementary school.
- 59:01Yeah,
- 59:01I think is that weigh into the calculation at all?
- 59:03I think it's very clear that every single war there are civilian casualties.
- 59:06There's never been a war,
- 59:07but that you have to wait.
- 59:08That that's one reason why we shouldn't fight wars,
- 59:10right?
- 59:10Because innocent people die in them.
- 59:12Life created by God is extinguished.
- 59:14I would say if you're trying to be America first,
- 59:15which is the claim that you made,
- 59:17you should prioritize your own citizens and
- 59:19servicemen over the people of other countries,
- 59:21OK,
- 59:21because I was hearing a lot,
- 59:23probably more than any other argument
- 59:25before the start of the war,
- 59:26that the reason we had to go to war was because the Iranian people were.
- 59:29Massacring their own citizens,
- 59:31and we had to go and protect them and
- 59:32liberate them and bring that freedom and democracy.
- 59:34Is that a goal of the war?
- 59:36How does that weigh in with America first?
- 59:37So absolutely that's part of the war.
- 59:39The reason why Donald Trump chose to take the time that he did to go into Iran
- 59:42is because the fact that the people were ready
- 59:44to stand behind the US government in that.
- 59:47So regime change is part of the war.
- 59:48I think regime change would be the best case scenario of the war.
- 59:51Yes.
- 59:51No,
- 59:51but is it a goal of the war?
- 59:52Like when you start a war,
- 59:53you have goals.
- 59:54Like you said,
- 59:54you gave a reason for the goal,
- 59:56which is that like they've done bad things in the past.
- 59:57I have no problem admitting that it's one of the goals.
- 59:59I've no.
- 59:59No problem admitting that is one of the goals is that war
- 1:00:01has that goal we are currently 5 weeks into the war.
- 1:00:04No,
- 1:00:04I know.
- 1:00:04I'm just,
- 1:00:05I'm asking,
- 1:00:05it has not.
- 1:00:06We're actually in our 6th,
- 1:00:076th full week,
- 1:00:08but has,
- 1:00:09has that weeks?
- 1:00:10No,
- 1:00:10that has not been accomplished yet.
- 1:00:11Do you think that we're on our way to accomplishing the fall of the Iranian
- 1:00:14regime and that the American government considers that
- 1:00:16to be one of the ongoing goals?
- 1:00:18I think it is very possible that that could happen.
- 1:00:20I think it is the least likely goal.
- 1:00:21I still think that the US should pursue that goal,
- 1:00:24but if we end up
- 1:00:26in this war,
- 1:00:26we're currently in a two-week,
- 1:00:28uh,
- 1:00:28ceasefire
- 1:00:29where.
- 1:00:30There is no regime change where the,
- 1:00:32uh,
- 1:00:32current Iranian power structure,
- 1:00:34the Revolutionary Guard,
- 1:00:36everyone else continues to govern Iran.
- 1:00:38Will that have been a successful war goal?
- 1:00:40Absolutely.
- 1:00:41We've lost 14 servicemen,
- 1:00:42bless their hearts,
- 1:00:43but they chose to do that and they,
- 1:00:44they were very brave in doing so.
- 1:00:46We have decimated their military,
- 1:00:47their hypersonic.
- 1:00:49I just want to focus on this,
- 1:00:49this goal
- 1:00:51because I,
- 1:00:51I'm just confused because you were saying there are tiers of,
- 1:00:53there are tiers of goals for sure.
- 1:00:55You were saying if we can achieve 4 or 5,
- 1:00:57fantastic,
- 1:00:57but,
- 1:00:57but I think what you said is so important,
- 1:00:59which is where.
- 1:01:00America first,
- 1:01:00right?
- 1:01:00That's the movement that I thought that
- 1:01:02that Donald Trump was creating that made me interested in the movement.
- 1:01:05And so you began by saying,
- 1:01:06oh,
- 1:01:07it really doesn't matter about these 170 schoolgirls
- 1:01:09because we have to focus on American lives,
- 1:01:10not Iranians.
- 1:01:11No,
- 1:01:11that is what you said.
- 1:01:12No,
- 1:01:12I'm saying that is every single war we do this moral grandstanding where we say,
- 1:01:15oh,
- 1:01:15these civilians died.
- 1:01:16I do think it's horrible that civilians died,
- 1:01:18but I absolutely do.
- 1:01:20But I think it's worse
- 1:01:21for the American government to prioritize anybody outside of America.
- 1:01:24We've had over 1000 people killed by the Iranian regime
- 1:01:27does bringing freedom and democracy to the Iranian people.
- 1:01:29People help the American people who whose interests you say should
- 1:01:32be first because the current regime has killed over 1000 Americans.
- 1:01:35If it's a different regime,
- 1:01:37hopefully that will not be the case.
- 1:01:38But what if they're as tyrannical but pro-American?
- 1:01:40Is that fine?
- 1:01:41What if,
- 1:01:42like we could say,
- 1:01:42what if about no,
- 1:01:43no,
- 1:01:43no,
- 1:01:43because I think that's so,
- 1:01:44because we prop up dictatorships throughout that region.
- 1:01:47We don't care about democracy or bringing freedom to people.
- 1:01:49We prop up the worst,
- 1:01:50most savage dictatorships in Saudi Arabia and Egypt and Bahrain
- 1:01:54because we don't care about liberating people around the world.
- 1:01:56So I just want to get a goal a sense from you for what is your goal?
- 1:01:58Is it a pro-American?
- 1:01:59Dictatorship like we use like we installed previously,
- 1:02:02it's very clear that the goal is if there is a regime change,
- 1:02:04it will be by the Iranian people.
- 1:02:05That's why Trump chose to do it when he did it.
- 1:02:08Is that our goal?
- 1:02:09Is it a war goal?
- 1:02:09That is a goal,
- 1:02:10but there are tiers of goals,
- 1:02:11obviously.
- 1:02:12OK,
- 1:02:12so if we don't end up changing the government,
- 1:02:14will that be a goal that is failed or unfulfilled?
- 1:02:16Yeah,
- 1:02:17I've got no problem saying that.
- 1:02:18OK,
- 1:02:18we got 4 out of 5.
- 1:02:19We got a pause there.
- 1:02:20You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:02:21Good talking to you.
- 1:02:22It talk to you.
- 1:02:23First of all,
- 1:02:24I was flabbergasted to find out you're Jewish.
- 1:02:26Surprise,
- 1:02:27surprise,
- 1:02:28surprise.
- 1:02:29What does Iran need?
- 1:02:29A 60% enriched uranium for Iran never had 60%
- 1:02:33enriched uranium when the Iran deal was in place,
- 1:02:36and there were IAEA inspectors
- 1:02:37all throughout those Iranian facilities.
- 1:02:39When President Trump nullified the deal,
- 1:02:41destroying the obligation of Iran to have inspectors and 24 hour surveillance,
- 1:02:46they decided that they needed protection because now
- 1:02:48they no longer had a deal in place.
- 1:02:49They knew they could be threatened by Israel or the United States at any time.
- 1:02:52And if I were the Iranian leadership,
- 1:02:54I think the one thing the Iranian leadership did that was probably
- 1:02:56their biggest mistake is that they didn't develop a nuclear weapon.
- 1:02:59Because we've created a world in which we tell other countries
- 1:03:03either you get nuclear weapons and we won't mess with you
- 1:03:05like North Korea or Pakistan you're looking for the North Korea
- 1:03:09model.
- 1:03:09That's what we're looking for.
- 1:03:10I'm saying if I were Iran or we tell the world,
- 1:03:13if you don't have nuclear weapons,
- 1:03:14we'll invade you and bomb you at any time.
- 1:03:15Would Iran use a nuclear weapon if they had one?
- 1:03:18No,
- 1:03:18why would they?
- 1:03:19There would be instant and immediate suicide,
- 1:03:21and we're told,
- 1:03:22and we're told that the Iranian,
- 1:03:23it's suicide.
- 1:03:24It's martyrdom.
- 1:03:25To them it's jihad.
- 1:03:26OK,
- 1:03:27then,
- 1:03:27why didn't,
- 1:03:27why aren't they,
- 1:03:28why aren't,
- 1:03:29why aren't they launching?
- 1:03:29All of their,
- 1:03:30I know that.
- 1:03:31Why are they not launching what?
- 1:03:32Why aren't they launching?
- 1:03:33No,
- 1:03:33no,
- 1:03:34no,
- 1:03:34no,
- 1:03:34you got you have to let me talk.
- 1:03:36You said,
- 1:03:36why,
- 1:03:36why aren't they,
- 1:03:37uh,
- 1:03:38why are they,
- 1:03:39uh,
- 1:03:39that they wanted suicide
- 1:03:41every single time that the Israelis and the United
- 1:03:43States have attacked Iran in the past 5 years,
- 1:03:45which is many,
- 1:03:46and even before that
- 1:03:47they have been extremely restrained in their,
- 1:03:49they have been extremely restrained in their,
- 1:03:51OK,
- 1:03:51extremely restrained.
- 1:03:52How many times have you define Iran extremely rested.
- 1:03:55Define who it is
- 1:03:56that is attacking.
- 1:03:57Is it Iran?
- 1:03:58Is it the proxies?
- 1:03:59Are the proxies?
- 1:03:59Iran has an internationally recognized government at the UN
- 1:04:03that's recognized by all countries around the world.
- 1:04:05When I say Iran,
- 1:04:06that's who I mean.
- 1:04:07It's like Israel,
- 1:04:08the United States and Israel have proxies in
- 1:04:10Iran who are trying to overthrow the government,
- 1:04:12who were arming,
- 1:04:13who were training in order to overthrow the government,
- 1:04:15these peaceful protesters,
- 1:04:17a lot of them were actually
- 1:04:18armed and,
- 1:04:19and organized by Israel and,
- 1:04:21and they themselves have been killed.
- 1:04:23But what is the number 30 or 40 or 45?
- 1:04:25Well,
- 1:04:26from what we hear right now is 45,000,
- 1:04:28but here's what I tell you.
- 1:04:30Iran ran out of body bags.
- 1:04:33OK,
- 1:04:33Iran ran out of body bags in those two days,
- 1:04:36and a country of 90 million people usually has around
- 1:04:3930,000 body bags
- 1:04:41in case of emergency.
- 1:04:43So that's what we're looking at right now.
- 1:04:44We have the numbers.
- 1:04:45The numbers vary from all over the place,
- 1:04:47but let me ask you,
- 1:04:47no,
- 1:04:48I wanna ask you.
- 1:04:48I'd like to ask you a question.
- 1:04:49If,
- 1:04:50if we here in the United States,
- 1:04:52we had an insurrectionary movement
- 1:04:54that was armed by China and Russia,
- 1:04:56and they admitted it openly,
- 1:04:57we've armed an insurrectionary movement inside the.
- 1:04:59United States because we want them to overthrow the American government
- 1:05:03and they were going and attacking police officers,
- 1:05:05killing police officers,
- 1:05:06attacking government buildings.
- 1:05:07How do you think we would treat those protesters don't need to give you any kind of,
- 1:05:11of,
- 1:05:12you know,
- 1:05:12pie in the sky because you have Hamas
- 1:05:14and you have Hezbollah and you have this country.
- 1:05:16I'm talking about our country,
- 1:05:17OK.
- 1:05:18Do you,
- 1:05:18do you not believe that these are attacking Americans as well?
- 1:05:22The,
- 1:05:22the United States have been attacked many times.
- 1:05:25Can I answer your question?
- 1:05:26You asked me a question.
- 1:05:26Just let me answer.
- 1:05:27The United States have been attacked
- 1:05:29many times.
- 1:05:29Over the last 30 years with horrific terrorist attacks.
- 1:05:32Do you know how many of them have come from Iranian terrorists or Shia terrorists?
- 1:05:36The answer is 00.
- 1:05:38We have never been attacked on American soil.
- 1:05:41What,
- 1:05:42what,
- 1:05:42what terrorist attack,
- 1:05:44what terrorist attack happened from Iranian and Shia terrorists?
- 1:05:46Which terrorist attack?
- 1:05:48We've had 9/11,
- 1:05:49the Boston Massacre,
- 1:05:50the pole shooting,
- 1:05:51Fort Hood,
- 1:05:52attempted bombing in Times Square.
- 1:05:53These were all Sunni terrorists from the governments that we love,
- 1:05:55like Saudi Arabia,
- 1:05:56and Shiites are,
- 1:05:58are,
- 1:05:58you know,
- 1:05:58you know there's a difference.
- 1:05:59Iran and,
- 1:06:00and,
- 1:06:00and the Arab countries,
- 1:06:01right?
- 1:06:02And so I'm asking about the violence from Iran.
- 1:06:04We're talking about the Iranian threat.
- 1:06:05How many terrorist attacks have come from Iran or from Shia terrorists
- 1:06:09on the United States soil?
- 1:06:10Any on United States?
- 1:06:110,
- 1:06:12right?
- 1:06:12That's not 0.
- 1:06:13No,
- 1:06:13it's not true because the proxies are considered part of Iran.
- 1:06:16Which of,
- 1:06:17which Iranian proxies have attacked the United States homeland?
- 1:06:19How many Americans have died and when you not consider the,
- 1:06:22the barracks over?
- 1:06:23Well,
- 1:06:23we'll get to that.
- 1:06:24I'm talking about the homeland.
- 1:06:25Oh,
- 1:06:25so it has to be in the homeland forever.
- 1:06:27Yeah,
- 1:06:27yeah,
- 1:06:27that,
- 1:06:27that's generally what governments are supposed to.
- 1:06:30You're in.
- 1:06:30So if,
- 1:06:31if Americans are killed abroad,
- 1:06:32about the,
- 1:06:33let's talk about no,
- 1:06:33no,
- 1:06:34no,
- 1:06:34because you said America first,
- 1:06:35right?
- 1:06:35So American lives matter,
- 1:06:37right?
- 1:06:37We shouldn't have the reason we shouldn't have troops over
- 1:06:40protecting Israel is because we put them in harm's way.
- 1:06:42But I'm asking about America,
- 1:06:43the American homeland.
- 1:06:44Has Iran attacked the American homeland through
- 1:06:46symmetric asymmetrical bombing,
- 1:06:48through terrorist attack,
- 1:06:49through guerrilla warfare,
- 1:06:50anything?
- 1:06:50Why can't you just answer that?
- 1:06:52Because the fact that you're blind to,
- 1:06:53can you answer that?
- 1:06:54Just please answer that.
- 1:06:55Yes.
- 1:06:55When,
- 1:06:56when,
- 1:06:56when did that happen?
- 1:06:57I don't have the exact.
- 1:06:58It never happened.
- 1:06:59Anyone has any
- 1:07:01examples of terrorist attacks that came from Iranian or Shia terrorists,
- 1:07:03please come up.
- 1:07:04Iranians control
- 1:07:06the Middle East
- 1:07:08through their proxies,
- 1:07:09through the Houthis,
- 1:07:11through Hezbollah,
- 1:07:12through Hamas,
- 1:07:12and we control the Middle East through our proxy,
- 1:07:14which is Israel.
- 1:07:15So Israel is a proxy of,
- 1:07:17of the US right now?
- 1:07:17Yeah,
- 1:07:18absolutely.
- 1:07:18Oh,
- 1:07:18so,
- 1:07:19so we're not an ally,
- 1:07:19we're a proxy.
- 1:07:20OK,
- 1:07:20we gotta pause there.
- 1:07:21Tell me why.
- 1:07:23Tell me why.
- 1:07:23Tell me why the ceasefire
- 1:07:25needs to include,
- 1:07:26uh,
- 1:07:27you've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:07:28We gotta pause there.
- 1:07:30Thanks.
- 1:07:31Hey,
- 1:07:31how are you?
- 1:07:32Good to meet you.
- 1:07:33Good to meet you too.
- 1:07:34Um,
- 1:07:35I think bombing Iran is absolutely in the American people's
- 1:07:37interest because they've been a problem for 47 years,
- 1:07:40and I think we,
- 1:07:40I think what Trump is doing is he realized an opportune time
- 1:07:43where their economy,
- 1:07:44like the real means absolutely nothing.
- 1:07:46Their
- 1:07:47terror proxies are no longer a deterrent.
- 1:07:49Hezbollah and Hamas have been absolutely decimated since October 7th,
- 1:07:52um,
- 1:07:52and a desperate attempt,
- 1:07:53they murdered 30,000 civilians in the streets,
- 1:07:56and their uranium,
- 1:07:5730,000.
- 1:07:58According to hospital records,
- 1:07:5932,000.
- 1:08:00And 60% uranium enrichment.
- 1:08:02So I think Trump is looking right now and saying
- 1:08:04we don't know what the next administration's going to do.
- 1:08:06We could have Democrats that
- 1:08:07might
- 1:08:08unfreeze their assets again,
- 1:08:09go back into the JCPOA.
- 1:08:11This is an opportune time where they're like the
- 1:08:14weakest they're gonna be in the whole existence,
- 1:08:16so like we should end this now.
- 1:08:18Yeah,
- 1:08:18I think it's,
- 1:08:18uh,
- 1:08:19I wanna talk about that.
- 1:08:19I do,
- 1:08:20I just wanna ask you,
- 1:08:20and I'm not trying to be personal in any way,
- 1:08:22but I do think it's an interesting phenomenon
- 1:08:24that
- 1:08:24for centuries when countries wanted to go to war and people said,
- 1:08:27yeah,
- 1:08:27let's go to war,
- 1:08:28the big test was,
- 1:08:29are you willing to risk your own life
- 1:08:30in the war that you think is so important to defend your country's interests?
- 1:08:33You seem like a young guy to me.
- 1:08:35Have you ever thought about going and fighting in this war that you're cheering on?
- 1:08:38Uh,
- 1:08:38I mean,
- 1:08:39I've thought about joining the military before.
- 1:08:40I don't know about this war.
- 1:08:41Specifically,
- 1:08:42but I,
- 1:08:42that's what makes them heroes.
- 1:08:44They put themselves in dangerous situation.
- 1:08:45I'm asking that because,
- 1:08:46as I said earlier,
- 1:08:47we are a country that constantly fights wars.
- 1:08:50It's extremely aberrational for other countries on the planet,
- 1:08:52including very powerful ones like China,
- 1:08:54as I said before,
- 1:08:55that has grown so significantly
- 1:08:57because they know that war is not a way that you pretend you're,
- 1:09:00you protect your national interests,
- 1:09:01but you undermine them.
- 1:09:02But we are so eager,
- 1:09:04so it's so easy for us to say,
- 1:09:05oh yeah,
- 1:09:06go fight that war,
- 1:09:06go blow blow up these people,
- 1:09:08global superpower,
- 1:09:08of course we're dealing China is a global superpower as well.
- 1:09:11Doing infinitely better than the United States by so
- 1:09:13many metrics because of the they go ask Latin
- 1:09:15American and and and African countries with whom they're
- 1:09:18dealing more and who they prefer to deal with,
- 1:09:20China or the United States,
- 1:09:21and they will tell you that the United States is a bully
- 1:09:23country that runs the world through military force and China isn't.
- 1:09:27That's one of the problems that we have.
- 1:09:28But Iran has not attacked the United States,
- 1:09:31has no ability to attack the United States.
- 1:09:33We're a moral country only goes to war and blows up
- 1:09:35elementary schools if that country is actually attacking the United States.
- 1:09:39It's supposed to be a war of last.
- 1:09:40Resort.
- 1:09:41That is not the case here.
- 1:09:43We're blowing up their country.
- 1:09:44We're killing their people.
- 1:09:45We're threatening civilizational annihilation
- 1:09:48because Iran is not a threat to the United States.
- 1:09:50Death to America.
- 1:09:51Death to Israel.
- 1:09:5260% uranium enrichment.
- 1:09:53There's never been a country ever that for civilian uses of nuclear energy.
- 1:09:57Like when,
- 1:09:57when the Iran deal,
- 1:09:58when the Iran deal was in place,
- 1:10:01to what level did Iran enrich uranium?
- 1:10:03Wanna know the thing about the Iran deal?
- 1:10:04I asked that.
- 1:10:04They kept it low.
- 1:10:05Wanna know why?
- 1:10:06Because that had an expiration date.
- 1:10:07Meanwhile,
- 1:10:07they got to have to reap all the benefits of their own frozen assets.
- 1:10:10And fund their proxies.
- 1:10:12This other thing about,
- 1:10:12there's no limitations on the United States has the right
- 1:10:15to just go around stealing other people's assets like,
- 1:10:18hey,
- 1:10:18uh,
- 1:10:18Indonesia for Indonesia just sold and the United States decides that on their own.
- 1:10:22We,
- 1:10:22that we're in a higher moral ground than Iran.
- 1:10:24This is why we pretend they're the same thing?
- 1:10:26Because I think that's very doubtful.
- 1:10:27I know people in the United States,
- 1:10:28some of them think that,
- 1:10:29but the rest of the world does not think this.
- 1:10:31The rest of the world can cater to the world.
- 1:10:33No,
- 1:10:34we do have to get along in this.
- 1:10:35You've been voted out.
- 1:10:36We do have to be.
- 1:10:37You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:10:38Thank you.
- 1:10:39Thank you.
- 1:10:40OK,
- 1:10:41so I would like to clarify,
- 1:10:42when you say that we are bombing Iran,
- 1:10:44I would like to say we are bombing the IRGC.
- 1:10:46This has been some of the most highly discriminate warfare in US history.
- 1:10:49No civilian infrastructure has been targeted except for one bridge.
- 1:10:52The school that you're talking about,
- 1:10:53there's some credible intel that that was a misfiring from
- 1:10:55the IRGC just like with Al Shifa Hospital in Gaza.
- 1:10:57Nobody thinks of it anymore,
- 1:10:58but go ahead.
- 1:10:59OK,
- 1:10:59so
- 1:10:59even if,
- 1:11:00but what about that bridge?
- 1:11:01What about that?
- 1:11:01So the bridge is used by was,
- 1:11:03it was a bridge built to be used by civilians.
- 1:11:05I'm not going to get hung up on one bridge,
- 1:11:07OK,
- 1:11:07for they were dismantling the.
- 1:11:08to blow up all their power plants now too.
- 1:11:10OK,
- 1:11:11we are trying to get the Iranian regime,
- 1:11:12which is belligerent,
- 1:11:13which is belligerent to the table.
- 1:11:14So this is what I view as in America's interest,
- 1:11:18having an aggressive
- 1:11:19power in the region
- 1:11:21which seeks to export the revolution.
- 1:11:22Someone else already mentioned,
- 1:11:23they are fighting a cosmic war.
- 1:11:25It's really hard to negotiate with
- 1:11:27terrorists
- 1:11:28whose own mortality is a welcome martyrdom.
- 1:11:31So
- 1:11:31the cost-benefit analysis and the negotiation table with
- 1:11:35Shia extremists is going to look a lot.
- 1:11:36Different than any other nation around the world,
- 1:11:38so I view taking them out not only in America's interest,
- 1:11:40but in the interest of our NATO allies in Europe,
- 1:11:42getting rid of the government.
- 1:11:43No,
- 1:11:43taking out the heads of the IRGC.
- 1:11:44I'm not talking about regime change,
- 1:11:45and Trump actually has never stated that as the official objective of this war,
- 1:11:48um,
- 1:11:49and,
- 1:11:49but he did tell the Washington Post that freeing the Iranian
- 1:11:51people was the he said it will be yours to,
- 1:11:53it will be yours to take.
- 1:11:54He said that is a positive externality.
- 1:11:56That is not the war aim.
- 1:11:57There's a difference between a positive externality and a war aim,
- 1:11:59and that is what President Trump stated.
- 1:12:00Do you know the Washington Post interview I'm talking about?
- 1:12:02Are you denying that's something that you hadn't read?
- 1:12:04Glenn,
- 1:12:05I know.
- 1:12:05I just,
- 1:12:06I want to encourage people to go and don't insult my intelligence
- 1:12:08on the point I'm making by myopically focusing on one Washington.
- 1:12:10I think it's,
- 1:12:11I think I take the president seriously when he says this is what my most
- 1:12:14important goal is in going forward with
- 1:12:15Iran take out the IRGC's infrastructure again.
- 1:12:18It's not what IRGC's infrastructure,
- 1:12:19and again,
- 1:12:20he's never said regime change.
- 1:12:21He said it will be for the Iranian people to still in power.
- 1:12:24Uh,
- 1:12:24well then,
- 1:12:24you're acknowledging the great success of this military campaign
- 1:12:27if you're saying that they're not in power.
- 1:12:28So yeah,
- 1:12:29that's why this is a great,
- 1:12:30and,
- 1:12:30and you,
- 1:12:30so you're,
- 1:12:31I,
- 1:12:31I,
- 1:12:31I asked several people now.
- 1:12:32The goal of this war or the goals of this war,
- 1:12:36what do you consider those to be?
- 1:12:37The main objective,
- 1:12:38the primary objective of this war is to take out the IRGC's
- 1:12:43offensive
- 1:12:44military capabilities,
- 1:12:45which is not just a nuclear weapon.
- 1:12:46It could also be ballistic missiles which can reach
- 1:12:48the interior of our NATO allies in Europe,
- 1:12:50which they didn't know before the start of this operation.
- 1:12:52We're currently negotiating with the Iranian are you,
- 1:12:53right?
- 1:12:54What are you waiting for?
- 1:12:54What's the alternative,
- 1:12:55Glenn?
- 1:12:55You want them to hit a NATO ally country and then we're in a larger scale war?
- 1:12:58Is that a positive alternative to you?
- 1:13:00I'm Israel.
- 1:13:01A huge amount of nuclear,
- 1:13:02of a huge nuclear stockpile.
- 1:13:04I'm talking about.
- 1:13:04No,
- 1:13:04I'm,
- 1:13:05I'm,
- 1:13:05and there are tons of countries that have intercontinental,
- 1:13:08but I wanna,
- 1:13:09but I wanna,
- 1:13:11I wanna ask you about this cosmic war.
- 1:13:13I think Israel is fighting a cosmic war.
- 1:13:15They are not.
- 1:13:16They are not fighting a Yes,
- 1:13:17they are.
- 1:13:17Yes,
- 1:13:17they are.
- 1:13:17They're,
- 1:13:18they're religious.
- 1:13:19They're religious freaks.
- 1:13:20The people who run Israel are religious and political fanatics.
- 1:13:23But let me,
- 1:13:24let me ask,
- 1:13:25I need to ask you,
- 1:13:26let me ask you fighting a cosmic war.
- 1:13:28If they were fighting a cosmic.
- 1:13:29You gotta,
- 1:13:29you gotta let me talk.
- 1:13:30Let me ask you a question.
- 1:13:31If the Iranians are these extremely irrational people
- 1:13:34who seek martyrdom and want to die,
- 1:13:36why are we now negotiating an attempt to negotiate an end to this war?
- 1:13:40Why were we able to diplomatically negotiate an Iran deal before?
- 1:13:45But you're saying they want to die.
- 1:13:46They want to die,
- 1:13:48but they want to die.
- 1:13:49Many of them have died.
- 1:13:49But what?
- 1:13:50But you're saying they want that.
- 1:13:51Why would there be Iranian officials currently negotiating into the war
- 1:13:54with the United States when you're saying these are religious fanatics.
- 1:13:57who want to die.
- 1:13:58Why would they want the war to end then?
- 1:14:00Because
- 1:14:00the end of the regime is going to come if they can't get to the negotiation table,
- 1:14:03and that's a certainty.
- 1:14:04So
- 1:14:05let's get back to why this is good for America and Europe.
- 1:14:07They have ballistic missiles that can reach the interior of our NATO allies.
- 1:14:10Um,
- 1:14:11the rest of the Middle East.
- 1:14:12You're so NATO allies,
- 1:14:13you're so myopically focused on Israel when it comes to Iran and the Middle East.
- 1:14:17I'm talking about this entire debate.
- 1:14:19You have the entire Gulf states.
- 1:14:20You have Saudi Arabia,
- 1:14:20you have Kuwait,
- 1:14:21Bahrain,
- 1:14:22the UAE,
- 1:14:22all of these countries also benefit.
- 1:14:24So you're trying to myopically.
- 1:14:25Focus and propagate Israel as a motive for this war.
- 1:14:27I thought we were America first.
- 1:14:28Why so now we're fighting a war for Persian Gulf tyrannies.
- 1:14:31What is your alternative?
- 1:14:32So the,
- 1:14:32the alternative is to,
- 1:14:34because it's their money,
- 1:14:35you don't agree with responding to provocation of the Iranian regime.
- 1:14:37I think the Iran deal worked very well,
- 1:14:38not to get,
- 1:14:39I think the Iran deal worked very well.
- 1:14:41I think you asked me my,
- 1:14:42my solution.
- 1:14:43I can only tell you if you stop talking for like 3 seconds.
- 1:14:45Just breathe a little bit.
- 1:14:47My solution is,
- 1:14:47is that you're,
- 1:14:48you're not,
- 1:14:49you can't stop talking.
- 1:14:50My solution is the,
- 1:14:52the diplomatic solution that we.
- 1:14:54Had from 2015 until 2018 when the Iranians
- 1:14:57were allowing IAA inspectors into every single nuclear facility
- 1:15:00and the IAEA reported 18 times from 2015 to
- 1:15:042018 that the Iranians had not enriched beyond 3.67%.
- 1:15:09The prime minister of the country that you seem to really like,
- 1:15:11which is Israel,
- 1:15:12has said for 30 years is that the Iranians are seconds away,
- 1:15:16minutes away,
- 1:15:16weeks away from getting a nuclear weapon.
- 1:15:18For 30 years,
- 1:15:19the Israelis have,
- 1:15:20have,
- 1:15:20have pulled.
- 1:15:21Americans have have told Americans this,
- 1:15:23and yet they never have.
- 1:15:24Tulsi Gabbard,
- 1:15:25who runs the regime,
- 1:15:26Tulsi Gabbard,
- 1:15:27who's not an Iranian,
- 1:15:28but the American Director of National Intelligence,
- 1:15:30goes to,
- 1:15:31this is what we all,
- 1:15:31I,
- 1:15:32I think you're probably too young to have,
- 1:15:33have lived through the Iraq War,
- 1:15:34but anyone who stood up and opposed the Iraq War,
- 1:15:36the worst disaster in American history of the last 100 years,
- 1:15:39was told,
- 1:15:39you're a propagandist for Saddam Hussein.
- 1:15:41You're rooting for the terrorists in Iraq.
- 1:15:43This tactic doesn't work.
- 1:15:44This is a bullshit tactic.
- 1:15:46I'm an American citizen.
- 1:15:47I care about American interests.
- 1:15:49Monitor not in UN Resolution 1441 to go and inspect their weapons capabilities.
- 1:15:54The Iranian regime has not done that.
- 1:15:55They kicked out the,
- 1:15:56the International Atomic Energy Agency only once
- 1:15:59the deal was invalidated by President Trump.
- 1:16:01good faith actors,
- 1:16:02why wouldn't they just let them stay?
- 1:16:03They,
- 1:16:04they comply with their treaty that Israel refuses to sign,
- 1:16:06which is the Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty.
- 1:16:08Every country in the world except for
- 1:16:10Israel,
- 1:16:11India,
- 1:16:11Pakistan,
- 1:16:11and South Sudan refused to signed that deal.
- 1:16:14And under that nuclear non-proliferation deal,
- 1:16:16the IAEA.
- 1:16:17Inspectors are allowed to go in nuclear and Iran allowed far more,
- 1:16:20far more invasive capability,
- 1:16:23far more IA 101 that when your adversary races
- 1:16:26to arms and increases their offensive cap offensive capabilities,
- 1:16:29it's going to create a security dilemma.
- 1:16:30That's a madman mentality.
- 1:16:32Every country in the world is building arms.
- 1:16:34The idea that we're supposed to go and bomb every country that
- 1:16:36we're in conflict with because they build up their conventional weapons system,
- 1:16:42the difference has that,
- 1:16:42that,
- 1:16:42that you gotta pause.
- 1:16:43You've been voted out.
- 1:16:44Please return to your seat.
- 1:16:47Hello,
- 1:16:47how you doing?
- 1:16:48I'm back.
- 1:16:49So
- 1:16:49we're gonna get into whether or not this is America first.
- 1:16:52I just wanna start with one thing that you've been saying
- 1:16:53is that we fight wars at the behest of Israel,
- 1:16:55which is very important.
- 1:16:56So in Israel,
- 1:16:57you,
- 1:16:58you did,
- 1:16:58you said that we fight wars for Israel or
- 1:17:00we come into Israel's defense in every single war.
- 1:17:02That's what you said.
- 1:17:03But let me respond to that.
- 1:17:04So
- 1:17:05when it comes to this,
- 1:17:06I need to tell you what I said just so you don't
- 1:17:07start arguing against the point that that is what you have said,
- 1:17:10but sure,
- 1:17:10go ahead
- 1:17:11really quickly I'm talking.
- 1:17:12I think this war is for Israel,
- 1:17:13but I also know that every time Israel has wars when they're,
- 1:17:17they're having Iran shoot weapons at them when
- 1:17:19they're stealing them from Syria and Lebanon,
- 1:17:21we deploy military assets to the Middle East,
- 1:17:23put our soldiers in harm's way to protect Israel in those wars.
- 1:17:26OK,
- 1:17:26that's inaccurate.
- 1:17:27I mean,
- 1:17:27the Iron Dome and the arrow system specifically deal with ballistic missiles,
- 1:17:31and we also have bases in Jordan that also intercept them as well.
- 1:17:33We didn't deploy forces.
- 1:17:35No,
- 1:17:35we didn't.
- 1:17:35I no,
- 1:17:36I wanted,
- 1:17:36I wanted to let me.
- 1:17:37Let me get my broader point in really quickly.
- 1:17:39Let's have a broader,
- 1:17:39I have a broader,
- 1:17:40that's fine.
- 1:17:40Hold on,
- 1:17:41I have a broader point,
- 1:17:42but you're so what you said is so false.
- 1:17:44Let me,
- 1:17:44let me,
- 1:17:44let me make this broader point.
- 1:17:45So you've made that general claim that we have been fighting these wars for Israel,
- 1:17:48right?
- 1:17:48You've made the same claim for Iran.
- 1:17:50No,
- 1:17:50I think,
- 1:17:51I think Iran is a war for Israel.
- 1:17:52I don't think other wars are for Israel.
- 1:17:54So only Iran,
- 1:17:55correct?
- 1:17:55That's the only war that we fought we deploy our military forces to
- 1:17:58protect Israel on top of all the money that we do we,
- 1:18:00do we deploy our military forces to protect.
- 1:18:02Protect Bahrain and Qatar and Kuwait where we have
- 1:18:04also military bases there barely ever because they're not,
- 1:18:06they're not fighting wars ever.
- 1:18:08They're not fighting one war.
- 1:18:09They're not fighting wars with their neighbors the #1.
- 1:18:11Israel was the
- 1:18:11#1 country that was hit by Iran
- 1:18:13during like in terms of missiles,
- 1:18:15you mean in the last 3 months since during the conflict,
- 1:18:17during the conflict currently
- 1:18:18they've shot wars at a lot of at number 11 is Qatar.
- 1:18:22Number 1 is Qatar.
- 1:18:23Israel's like number 3.
- 1:18:24OK,
- 1:18:24great.
- 1:18:24And so our assets are there defending those countries as well,
- 1:18:27right?
- 1:18:27Yeah,
- 1:18:28we have military.
- 1:18:28OK,
- 1:18:28great.
- 1:18:29What did,
- 1:18:29what did,
- 1:18:29um,
- 1:18:29bin Salman say in 2018?
- 1:18:32In reference to 2018 is a long time.
- 1:18:33What do you mean?
- 1:18:34Well,
- 1:18:34you were mentioning things from the 1980s and 19990s,
- 1:18:36so I was just saying,
- 1:18:36but the Saudis and the Iranians,
- 1:18:38201,
- 1:18:38the Saudis and Iranians have had,
- 1:18:40I wonder,
- 1:18:40I wonder where that came from.
- 1:18:42But hold on,
- 1:18:42bin Salman bin Salman said that
- 1:18:44the IRGC the last time you were here,
- 1:18:45the last time you were here,
- 1:18:46you gave me,
- 1:18:47no,
- 1:18:47the last time you were here,
- 1:18:48you gave a speech.
- 1:18:49You're trying,
- 1:18:49you're trying to avoid this,
- 1:18:51because you know what he said.
- 1:18:52I'll tell you what he said.
- 1:18:53In 2018,
- 1:18:54bin Salman said the Ayatollah.
- 1:18:55You want me to tell you,
- 1:18:56you have to,
- 1:18:57we gotta,
- 1:18:57we gotta have an exchange,
- 1:18:59Glenn.
- 1:18:59Let's,
- 1:18:59let's,
- 1:19:00let's hear it out.
- 1:19:01Hear from Glenn for a second and then let's get back into a dialogue in 2018.
- 1:19:05Hey Matt,
- 1:19:05we're starting with Glenn.
- 1:19:07You asked me the question,
- 1:19:08what about the situation between Iran and Saudi Arabia.
- 1:19:10Saudi Arabia is a brutal,
- 1:19:12savage dictatorship that the United States
- 1:19:14props up because of religious conflict,
- 1:19:16Sunni versus Sunni versus Shia.
- 1:19:19The Saudis and the Iranians have
- 1:19:21a lot of tension that has been actually decreasing.
- 1:19:23But because the United States uses Saudi Arabia to attack Iran,
- 1:19:27Iran has been shooting missiles at military bases in Saudi Arabiaia's true.
- 1:19:30It really stems from the 2011 Yemeni civil war,
- 1:19:32and I mean we can go to Yemeni history where there's communists in the south
- 1:19:35and the north that was more um pro-Western or more pro-capitalist and so on,
- 1:19:38but specifically the number one funder of the Houthis has been Iran,
- 1:19:42right?
- 1:19:43And the Houthis have,
- 1:19:44have
- 1:19:44obviously trying to,
- 1:19:45they've taken,
- 1:19:46they've taken over the capital,
- 1:19:47um,
- 1:19:47they've been undermining the official government,
- 1:19:49and that's why Saudi had to get involved to protect their own,
- 1:19:51um,
- 1:19:52airspace and their own defenses as well,
- 1:19:53because the Houthis were launching missiles into Saudi Arabia.
- 1:19:55And who funds that?
- 1:19:56The IODC.
- 1:19:56In 2018,
- 1:19:57bin Salman specifically said that who,
- 1:19:59who was the Hitler.
- 1:19:59Of the Middle East in 2018
- 1:20:01or
- 1:20:02even still now you could say the Ayatollah.
- 1:20:03That's what he specifically said that Salman bin Salman is the moral,
- 1:20:07the moral arbiter of the Middle East inahammed bin
- 1:20:09Salman is the worst monster on the planet.
- 1:20:11You can say he's the worst monster on the planet.
- 1:20:13Is he?
- 1:20:13Is he?
- 1:20:14Is he a monster?
- 1:20:14Hold on,
- 1:20:14hold on.
- 1:20:15Is he a monster?
- 1:20:15Oh sure,
- 1:20:15hold on.
- 1:20:16$142 billion arms deal,
- 1:20:18$142 billion arms deal we signed with him,
- 1:20:20um,
- 1:20:20last year.
- 1:20:20I also believe we signed a $1 trillion AI deal.
- 1:20:23So in terms of economic
- 1:20:25benefits that we have in strategic asset benefits,
- 1:20:27yeah,
- 1:20:27it's very good,
- 1:20:28right?
- 1:20:28It's funny,
- 1:20:29it's funny,
- 1:20:29it's funny when you say you love about our assets.
- 1:20:32It's funny,
- 1:20:32it's funny when you talk about our assets because that's really funny.
- 1:20:34What is the point?
- 1:20:35Can you get to the point you've been actually,
- 1:20:37yeah,
- 1:20:37sure,
- 1:20:37I can get to it.
- 1:20:38You keep interrupting me.
- 1:20:38Great,
- 1:20:38I'll,
- 1:20:39I'll get to it.
- 1:20:39Just let me finish.
- 1:20:40Um,
- 1:20:40so in reference to our assets specifically,
- 1:20:43let's talk about South Korea.
- 1:20:44So since 1950,
- 1:20:45we spent about $4 billion annually
- 1:20:47on South Korea.
- 1:20:48So that's what,
- 1:20:4876 years we've been doing that for.
- 1:20:50That's $304 billion.
- 1:20:53You don't talk about that.
- 1:20:53How many,
- 1:20:54where is the number one talk about that.
- 1:20:55Hold on,
- 1:20:56hold on,
- 1:20:56hold on,
- 1:20:56hold on.
- 1:20:56What,
- 1:20:57what is the number one country?
- 1:20:58where we have to do with the war in Iran.
- 1:21:00What is,
- 1:21:01what is the number one the war in Iran because you're,
- 1:21:02because you're acting as if this is an Israel-on thing.
- 1:21:04I have mentioned it.
- 1:21:05We're not talking about Israel.
- 1:21:07No,
- 1:21:07this,
- 1:21:08no,
- 1:21:08you did say this was in reference to Israel.
- 1:21:10Bombing Iran is not in American people's interest.
- 1:21:12You have you've been making about that.
- 1:21:14You've been making this purely about Israel.
- 1:21:16I don't think it's about Israel.
- 1:21:17You do.
- 1:21:17Yes,
- 1:21:17you have.
- 1:21:18Why are you so scared to debate the truth?
- 1:21:20You've been making this about Israel.
- 1:21:22Let me,
- 1:21:22let me ask you a very simple point.
- 1:21:23Are we at the point,
- 1:21:24the point,
- 1:21:25the point that I picked that number 2.
- 1:21:27That I chose
- 1:21:28is President Trump is subservient to the Israel lobby.
- 1:21:31That's I stand here and talked about this for 20 minutes.
- 1:21:34I'm not afraid to talk about Israel.
- 1:21:35There are other reasons why the United States is at war with Iran besides Israel.
- 1:21:39Let me give you a major factor.
- 1:21:40Let me give you.
- 1:21:40OK,
- 1:21:40OK,
- 1:21:41we got to pause there.
- 1:21:42I just want to give Matt one word answer.
- 1:21:44Do you think it's in the United States' best interest?
- 1:21:47I have one question for him.
- 1:21:48I just,
- 1:21:48we,
- 1:21:48we're out of time on this prompt,
- 1:21:49so I just want to hear a one word answer to his prompt.
- 1:21:51Do you think it's in the United States' best interest to bomb Iran?
- 1:21:54Absolutely,
- 1:21:54yes,
- 1:21:55yes,
- 1:21:55OK,
- 1:21:56great.
- 1:21:59I,
- 1:22:00I wanna do a quick,
- 1:22:00quick poll.
- 1:22:01Raise your flag if
- 1:22:03you would support
- 1:22:04if the United States sent ground troops to Iran.
- 1:22:09Raise them high just so we can get a count of flags.
- 1:22:11Raise your flag if you,
- 1:22:13if the Americans sent ground troops to Iran that you would go right
- 1:22:16now and sign up to be part of that ground invading force.
- 1:22:21I did it for 12 years.
- 1:22:23Thank,
- 1:22:23thank you,
- 1:22:25thank you guys.
- 1:22:26So for our last portion,
- 1:22:28I'm gonna ask you to look around the circle and select somebody who
- 1:22:31you want to return to this chair and debate for a final 10 minutes
- 1:22:35based on their claim.
- 1:22:37You're the winner.
- 1:22:37Hi again,
- 1:22:38Glenn.
- 1:22:38Hello.
- 1:22:39My surrounding claim is that Donald Trump is the best president of my lifetime.
- 1:22:44All right,
- 1:22:45so
- 1:22:45I wanna ask you
- 1:22:47what your metrics are.
- 1:22:48Just name the two or three most important metrics.
- 1:22:50OK,
- 1:22:50yeah,
- 1:22:50I would just say America first being prioritizing of the American people.
- 1:22:54I would say the second metric,
- 1:22:55um,
- 1:22:55to me would be,
- 1:22:56frankly,
- 1:22:57the economy,
- 1:22:57which I know that kind of ties into America first,
- 1:22:59but I think the economy
- 1:23:00is the most important thing in opinion polls to Americans.
- 1:23:03And then the third is foreign policy,
- 1:23:04which we've talked about today,
- 1:23:05which is kind of a personal note for me.
- 1:23:07I think he's been the best on foreign policy.
- 1:23:09So let me,
- 1:23:10let's start with the third one just because what we've been talking about,
- 1:23:11but I also have a question about that.
- 1:23:13So as I said earlier,
- 1:23:14what.
- 1:23:15Though I had been long associated with the left
- 1:23:17prior to Trump's emergence on the political scene,
- 1:23:18what interested me
- 1:23:19probably most about his
- 1:23:21political,
- 1:23:22his approach to,
- 1:23:23to this new political movement,
- 1:23:25to this kind of new Republican politics
- 1:23:27was this very aggressive critique of
- 1:23:28prior Republican orthodoxy and foreign policy,
- 1:23:31particularly the Iraq War,
- 1:23:32but other kinds of regime change efforts.
- 1:23:34In the first term.
- 1:23:35I thought he adhered to that because as I said earlier,
- 1:23:37he was the first president in decades not to start a new American war.
- 1:23:40Do you think that there has been a full scale.
- 1:23:42Alignment in the second term,
- 1:23:45even though he focused on Yemen and bombing the Houthis,
- 1:23:47where,
- 1:23:47where,
- 1:23:47which President Biden had done.
- 1:23:49Then he moved to arming and funding Israel and its destruction
- 1:23:52of Gaza and its stealing of land in Syria and Lebanon,
- 1:23:54then on to Venezuela,
- 1:23:55talking about,
- 1:23:56uh,
- 1:23:56overthrowing the government of Cuba,
- 1:23:58putting a new regime change in Cuba,
- 1:23:59and also this war
- 1:24:00in Iran.
- 1:24:00Can you really say with all of that in 14 months that he has focused most on America?
- 1:24:05Yeah,
- 1:24:05absolutely.
- 1:24:06I think that the hallmark of his foreign policy is that he makes conflicts quick.
- 1:24:10And so I don't know if I can say this about the other people in the room,
- 1:24:13but for me,
- 1:24:14if the conflict in Iran doesn't end
- 1:24:16in the next 6 months,
- 1:24:17then I would consider that to be a failure.
- 1:24:19I don't think any of us should look at Donald
- 1:24:20Trump and just think he is my undying loyalty.
- 1:24:22I have full trust in him,
- 1:24:23but the things that you all listed there
- 1:24:25are quick things that have happened,
- 1:24:27and I think that has always been a consistency for Donald Trump.
- 1:24:29For me personally,
- 1:24:30did the,
- 1:24:31did the Yemen bombing accomplish anything?
- 1:24:33I,
- 1:24:33I think anytime that we're taking out terrorists and anti-America people,
- 1:24:36I think that is a pro thing to do for you.
- 1:24:39How do you know we killed terrorists?
- 1:24:41How do you,
- 1:24:41do you know the people who died in Yemen from that bombing?
- 1:24:44Do you know their names?
- 1:24:44I,
- 1:24:45no,
- 1:24:45personally,
- 1:24:45I don't know.
- 1:24:45So how do you know they're terrorists?
- 1:24:47I,
- 1:24:47I think that Donald Trump has credible,
- 1:24:49um,
- 1:24:50intelligence from our intelligence apparatus that tells him these things.
- 1:24:53That's what
- 1:24:54is the finally,
- 1:24:54you just blindly assume that if we kill people they're probably terrorists.
- 1:24:57I assume that I do not know as much as the intelligence apparatus.
- 1:25:00Is that the same assumption when Biden's president,
- 1:25:02when Obama's president,
- 1:25:03go,
- 1:25:03go kill people and we'll just assume they're,
- 1:25:05they're terrorists.
- 1:25:06I think prolonged conflict.
- 1:25:08are an indication that
- 1:25:08that intelligence is not being acted upon.
- 1:25:10So President,
- 1:25:11President,
- 1:25:12uh,
- 1:25:12Obama fought a war in Libya for it lasted about 45 months,
- 1:25:16uh,
- 1:25:17took out the government.
- 1:25:18The,
- 1:25:18the head of,
- 1:25:19uh,
- 1:25:19Libya,
- 1:25:19Muammar Gaddafi,
- 1:25:20who used to be a US ally,
- 1:25:21was,
- 1:25:21uh,
- 1:25:22sodomized and raped to death in the streets.
- 1:25:24I don't think that was a quick war.
- 1:25:25Did you support that war?
- 1:25:26No,
- 1:25:27because that was anti-American.
- 1:25:28When,
- 1:25:28when we're trying to depose regimes or peoples or
- 1:25:31terrorists that are anti-American and we do it quickly,
- 1:25:33fantastic every single time.
- 1:25:34But Gaddafi is a designated.
- 1:25:36Terrorists,
- 1:25:37he was accused of having taken down a plane,
- 1:25:39uh,
- 1:25:40a Pan Am jet that killed 260 people,
- 1:25:42which was one of the reasons why the United States to take out the war.
- 1:25:44I just,
- 1:25:45I get,
- 1:25:45I,
- 1:25:45I totally understand.
- 1:25:46I,
- 1:25:46I think my problem is,
- 1:25:47so you're pointing to all of these things.
- 1:25:48I think at the same time I can point to all these things,
- 1:25:50Venezuela,
- 1:25:51Maduro being taken out that were absolutely fantastic.
- 1:25:53The consistent through all of Trump's presidencies is that it's quick.
- 1:25:56The first,
- 1:25:57the,
- 1:25:57the last part of Trump's,
- 1:25:58uh,
- 1:25:59first term in 2020
- 1:26:00was dominated overwhelmingly by the COVID epidemic
- 1:26:04in which he.
- 1:26:05Ushered in a vaccine that became very controversial
- 1:26:08during that 2020,
- 1:26:09uh,
- 1:26:10year.
- 1:26:10There were all kinds of very severe lockdowns.
- 1:26:13He kept Anthony Fauci in place,
- 1:26:14the COVID infrastructure in place.
- 1:26:16Do you think his management of COVID was good?
- 1:26:18Well,
- 1:26:18I,
- 1:26:19I would not say that his
- 1:26:20management of COVID was perfect,
- 1:26:21but again,
- 1:26:21my claim,
- 1:26:22that was good,
- 1:26:22was it good?
- 1:26:23No,
- 1:26:23I wouldn't say it was even good,
- 1:26:24but my claim was that he is the best president of this century,
- 1:26:27and I think everyone here,
- 1:26:28and I think yourself would agree
- 1:26:30that Biden handled it much worse than Donald Trump did.
- 1:26:32Did you,
- 1:26:32do you agree with that?
- 1:26:34I thought Donald Trump's handling it was terrible,
- 1:26:35and I thought Biden's handling Biden's was much worse.
- 1:26:37I mean,
- 1:26:37Donald Trump would not have prolonged that in the same way.
- 1:26:40Can we agree on that?
- 1:26:41The worst,
- 1:26:41the worst lockdowns happened under President Trump in 2020,
- 1:26:44but that was also right when the virus happened and nobody knew what was happening.
- 1:26:47There were huge numbers.
- 1:26:48There were huge numbers of people throughout 2020 who were
- 1:26:51protesting on the grounds that those lockdowns were extremely repressive.
- 1:26:54We weren't even allowed to go to,
- 1:26:55to,
- 1:26:55to,
- 1:26:56to our relatives' funerals.
- 1:26:57No,
- 1:26:57but that,
- 1:26:58that was a,
- 1:26:58for me,
- 1:26:59that was an extreme extreme.
- 1:27:00Extremely dark mark.
- 1:27:00I totally agree on the first Trump administration.
- 1:27:02I totally agree.
- 1:27:03I do not defend those things that Donald Trump did,
- 1:27:05but Biden was much,
- 1:27:06much worse.
- 1:27:06And mine is,
- 1:27:07Well,
- 1:27:07what did Biden do with the COVID,
- 1:27:09uh,
- 1:27:09the mandate,
- 1:27:10the vax mandate that nothing that Donald Trump did was
- 1:27:13ever pushing a vax mandate on the American people.
- 1:27:15Well,
- 1:27:15I mean,
- 1:27:16there were people,
- 1:27:17including in the military in 2020,
- 1:27:19who were told that they had to get the,
- 1:27:20the COVID mandate,
- 1:27:21who had that they were told they had to get the COVID vaccine or face termination.
- 1:27:24So I disagree on that,
- 1:27:25but Biden.
- 1:27:26Did it to the entire country.
- 1:27:27So again,
- 1:27:27my claim is not that Donald Trump didn't make mistakes.
- 1:27:30My claim is that he is the best president that we have had so far.
- 1:27:33Biden is much worse.
- 1:27:33So my question for you really quick because we're on,
- 1:27:35we're on COVID here.
- 1:27:36Do you think that had Donald Trump been in office longer during COVID,
- 1:27:39that he would have prolonged those bad policies
- 1:27:41like Biden did for literally years after?
- 1:27:43It's really hard to say hypothetically,
- 1:27:45but I know that the,
- 1:27:46he did,
- 1:27:46but I,
- 1:27:46but,
- 1:27:46but he,
- 1:27:47he was out of office.
- 1:27:48But I know that the lockdowns
- 1:27:50and
- 1:27:50the
- 1:27:51empowerment of.
- 1:27:52Fauci
- 1:27:53as the supreme,
- 1:27:54uh,
- 1:27:54authoritarian leader who basically whose
- 1:27:56pronouncements couldn't be questioned,
- 1:27:58that all was done by Donald Trump.
- 1:27:59I know,
- 1:28:00I know we,
- 1:28:00we all want to forget that because
- 1:28:01a lot of us think that,
- 1:28:03that,
- 1:28:03that was very bad.
- 1:28:04I
- 1:28:04I'm not blame that on Joe Biden,
- 1:28:05but Donald Trump was the,
- 1:28:06the,
- 1:28:06the birther,
- 1:28:07the,
- 1:28:07the genesis
- 1:28:08of that COVID regime come out and completely come out against that,
- 1:28:11and Biden has not.
- 1:28:12So here's my question to you.
- 1:28:13There's only 4 presidents who've been president
- 1:28:15this century.
- 1:28:15Who do you think is better than,
- 1:28:17than Donald Trump?
- 1:28:18I actually think that if you judge by
- 1:28:21the
- 1:28:22metrics on which I focus,
- 1:28:23but also on the impact of the country,
- 1:28:24I,
- 1:28:26well,
- 1:28:26definitely,
- 1:28:26I,
- 1:28:27I,
- 1:28:27I would just say
- 1:28:28putting the American people first above
- 1:28:30the establishment,
- 1:28:31above global institutions,
- 1:28:33above the military industrial complex,
- 1:28:34all the things that Trump basically promised to do,
- 1:28:36focus on the working class,
- 1:28:38I think that in a lot of ways.
- 1:28:39In the second term,
- 1:28:40Donald Trump's 2nd term is so different from his first,
- 1:28:42and the 2nd term,
- 1:28:43I think,
- 1:28:43is arguably the worst his first term is the best
- 1:28:46version of the presidency that we've had this century.
- 1:28:48Uh,
- 1:28:48it's just,
- 1:28:49again,
- 1:28:49it's just so,
- 1:28:50such bad competitors,
- 1:28:51but yeah,
- 1:28:51I would,
- 1:28:52I would probably rank his in,
- 1:28:54in this century.
- 1:28:55I would rank his first term
- 1:28:57near the top.
- 1:28:57So we're in agreement.
- 1:28:58Yeah,
- 1:28:58I don't,
- 1:28:59I,
- 1:28:59I told you that.
- 1:29:00I said that from the beginning.
- 1:29:02I said that from the beginning that I was an
- 1:29:03enthusiast for what Trump promised for the Trump movement,
- 1:29:06for the America First movement.
- 1:29:07I actually believed in that.
- 1:29:08That's what I want.
- 1:29:09So here's my question since we have more time,
- 1:29:10Glenn.
- 1:29:11President Trump's presidency,
- 1:29:13his second term,
- 1:29:13we're only about a year and a half in,
- 1:29:15right?
- 1:29:15And so are you willing to change your opinion
- 1:29:18if,
- 1:29:18for instance,
- 1:29:19we talked about Iran earlier?
- 1:29:20Let's say the Iran war
- 1:29:22finishes up here in the next month.
- 1:29:23And there is no regime change,
- 1:29:25but we did completely
- 1:29:26take out their military.
- 1:29:27We did take out half the IRGC.
- 1:29:29We haven't taken,
- 1:29:29we have,
- 1:29:30they have thousands of ballistic missiles.
- 1:29:32Are you willing?
- 1:29:33My main point is,
- 1:29:33are you willing to say you were wrong on Donald Trump and say,
- 1:29:36Oh,
- 1:29:36I was looking at the 1st 18 months of his presidency,
- 1:29:38but the last second term actually turned out pretty good?
- 1:29:40Well,
- 1:29:41I'll ask you the same question.
- 1:29:42If Trump's,
- 1:29:42uh,
- 1:29:42presidency worsens,
- 1:29:43you'll,
- 1:29:44you'll change your mind too.
- 1:29:45Obviously.
- 1:29:45I would change my mind based on whatever happens,
- 1:29:47but the problem is this war is going.
- 1:29:48To have lingering and enduring effects on the economy,
- 1:29:51on gas prices.
- 1:29:52There's the Iranians are not going to give up the,
- 1:29:54the control of the Strait of Hormuz.
- 1:29:55They're going to continue to charge money for that,
- 1:29:57which they didn't do previously.
- 1:29:58Lots,
- 1:29:59and also you have to,
- 1:30:00you have to account the people who,
- 1:30:02who,
- 1:30:02who are dead as well.
- 1:30:04I think that the funding and arming of,
- 1:30:05of the destruction of Gaza,
- 1:30:06which Joe Biden did for 2 years and then Trump did for 8 months,
- 1:30:09is also something that is one of the worst crimes of the century,
- 1:30:12so.
- 1:30:13Yeah,
- 1:30:13I hope it gets better,
- 1:30:14but the problem is,
- 1:30:15and I assume you agree with this,
- 1:30:16it's extremely likely,
- 1:30:17we don't know the future,
- 1:30:18but it's extremely likely Democrats are gonna take over the House at least,
- 1:30:20and not and maybe the Senate,
- 1:30:22and I think a big part of that is Trump's focus,
- 1:30:24not on what he promised it to be on.
- 1:30:26I think that's why Donald Trump is the greatest president of the century,
- 1:30:29is that he's looking at the second term and thinking,
- 1:30:30I'm not thinking
- 1:30:31about the midterms.
- 1:30:32I'm not thinking about the politics at all.
- 1:30:33I'm going to do no,
- 1:30:35absolutely not.
- 1:30:36He,
- 1:30:36as we've talked about today.
- 1:30:38He has talked about this since the 1980s.
- 1:30:39He has always been anti-Iran,
- 1:30:41and he's always made it very clear that Iran,
- 1:30:42why didn't he do it in the first term,
- 1:30:44uh,
- 1:30:44because,
- 1:30:45as I spoke about earlier in our previous section,
- 1:30:47because the Iranian people themselves have come out and are
- 1:30:49finally willing to actually go against the IRGC fight.
- 1:30:51We don't fight wars to liberate people.
- 1:30:53We don't fight wars because the population is it
- 1:30:55completely different when their own people are supporting it.
- 1:30:57My main point is this.
- 1:30:58How do you know?
- 1:30:59Let me ask,
- 1:30:59let me ask that because I,
- 1:31:00I,
- 1:31:00it's so,
- 1:31:01it's so fascinating to me when people say.
- 1:31:02The Iranian people want to be bombed.
- 1:31:04They want to have their bridges blown up.
- 1:31:05They want to have their,
- 1:31:06I'm just saying,
- 1:31:07where,
- 1:31:07how do you know what the Iranian people want?
- 1:31:09There are 96 million of them.
- 1:31:10Have you been there?
- 1:31:11Do you speak the language I've seen the videos of in Tehran,
- 1:31:13Tehran,
- 1:31:14where there are thousands of them cheering in the street.s There are thousands,
- 1:31:17there are thousands of,
- 1:31:18there are thousands of Israelis today in Tel Aviv
- 1:31:21protesting against the war with Iran.
- 1:31:2390% of Israelis support the war,
- 1:31:26and I know,
- 1:31:27but.
- 1:31:27No,
- 1:31:27no,
- 1:31:28no,
- 1:31:28you're right.
- 1:31:28You're taking on 3700 casualties in the civilian population,
- 1:31:32and they support it.
- 1:31:33This is my point though,
- 1:31:34is that you cannot judge what an entire
- 1:31:36population wants by the fact that the streets.
- 1:31:38I don't have to judge it.
- 1:31:38I can see,
- 1:31:39you can see,
- 1:31:40you can see in the streets in the United States huge numbers of
- 1:31:43people marching against Donald Trump and calling him a monarch and a Hitler,
- 1:31:46but you wouldn't say that that means
- 1:31:47that that's representative of American public opinion.
- 1:31:49How do you,
- 1:31:50who never visited Iran,
- 1:31:52who doesn't speak the language,
- 1:31:53who I bet knows very little about Iranian history,
- 1:31:55how do you?
- 1:31:55I know what the majority of 96 million Iranians
- 1:31:58want when it comes to whether we want them.
- 1:32:00They want us bombing their country.
- 1:32:01I know they're,
- 1:32:02so I,
- 1:32:02I,
- 1:32:02we don't have data in the last few weeks,
- 1:32:04but I know there are journalists that have gone there.
- 1:32:05They have,
- 1:32:06they have
- 1:32:07created public opinion polls asking who supports the IRGC and who does not.
- 1:32:11It always overwhelmingly comes out that they do,
- 1:32:12you,
- 1:32:13you were the one who told me that you weren't that
- 1:32:14bothered by the blowing up of that school because we should,
- 1:32:17uh,
- 1:32:17prioritize American lives over Iranian lives,
- 1:32:19weren't you?
- 1:32:20We were talking about the timing of this.
- 1:32:21Now you're like,
- 1:32:21we should go to war because the people,
- 1:32:22we're talking about the timing.
- 1:32:23of why Trump did this,
- 1:32:25and I think the reason why he's done this
- 1:32:26is because the Iranian people will make it easier.
- 1:32:28The same is true for Israel,
- 1:32:29by the way.
- 1:32:29Israel's taken way more casualties than the US,
- 1:32:32and the reason why this is America first is because Donald Trump is able to see
- 1:32:35that Israel and the Iranian people are willing to do
- 1:32:37the work so that we take on less casualties.
- 1:32:39And that's been true.
- 1:32:40Have you seen pro-government?
- 1:32:41Have you seen pro-government protests in Iran?
- 1:32:44No,
- 1:32:44I have not.
- 1:32:45You haven't.
- 1:32:45You should go check because they're gigantic.
- 1:32:48And yes,
- 1:32:49that,
- 1:32:49and that the reason for that is,
- 1:32:50is because
- 1:32:51every.
- 1:32:52Every population unites behind their leaders when
- 1:32:54they're attacked by a foreign country.
- 1:32:56It's a tribal instinct that happens.
- 1:32:58George Bush was a hated president.
- 1:33:00He got elected.
- 1:33:019/11 happened.
- 1:33:02All Democrats,
- 1:33:03liberals,
- 1:33:03people on the left,
- 1:33:04for the most part,
- 1:33:05united behind George Bush.
- 1:33:06It's a tribal instinct that when you're attacked by a foreign power,
- 1:33:08unite.
- 1:33:09I just want to make one more point on the casualties because we talked about that.
- 1:33:11We've taken 14 casualties since the war started.
- 1:33:14Something that Donald Trump did towards the,
- 1:33:16the,
- 1:33:16the first term that you really liked
- 1:33:17was that he brought us out of Afghanistan.
- 1:33:19Um,
- 1:33:20and Biden oversaw the withdrawal,
- 1:33:21but Trump negotiated,
- 1:33:22but he,
- 1:33:23but he started that during that time,
- 1:33:24just during the Trump administration.
- 1:33:25It's just true.
- 1:33:26Biden oversaw the withdrawal of Afghanistan.
- 1:33:28It's fine.
- 1:33:28My,
- 1:33:28my main point is when Donald Trump was,
- 1:33:30when Donald Trump was withdrawing our troops from Afghanistan,
- 1:33:34we took over 200 casualties doing that.
- 1:33:36We've only taken 14 casualties
- 1:33:38doing that.
- 1:33:38And when I say casualties,
- 1:33:39I mean loss of life.
- 1:33:40There's a lot more casualties than 14 loss of life,
- 1:33:42loss of life.
- 1:33:43You're right,
- 1:33:43loss of life.
- 1:33:43We took hundreds when we were taking troops out of Afghanistan.
- 1:33:46What Donald Trump is doing.
- 1:33:47Right now he is making it,
- 1:33:48and I think it's very heroic.
- 1:33:49He's making it so if a future president gets
- 1:33:51involved in Iran and puts boots on the ground,
- 1:33:52that
- 1:33:53that we don't have to lose hundreds of people pulling them out again.
- 1:33:55And so I think what he's doing right now is absolutely heroic.
- 1:33:58What do you,
- 1:33:58what do you heroic?
- 1:33:59You mean heroic.
- 1:34:00What's heroic about sending other people to go fight wars?
- 1:34:03I think it's absolutely heroic to say again,
- 1:34:04we've had 1000 Americans die in the last 50 years because Iran,
- 1:34:08Iran,
- 1:34:08Iranian terrorists and
- 1:34:10proxies have
- 1:34:11killed them said the war is gonna end without a regime change.
- 1:34:14Well,
- 1:34:14I don't know if that's true.
- 1:34:15I don't think anyone does,
- 1:34:17if it does,
- 1:34:17my main,
- 1:34:17but you said if Trump is willing without regime change,
- 1:34:20you're considering that the American people may or
- 1:34:22may not want the Iran conflict to happen,
- 1:34:24but he's willing,
- 1:34:25but he knows what happens when we do go into places like this,
- 1:34:28and he does not want to have to withdraw again.
- 1:34:30So that is why he is attacking the way he is,
- 1:34:32and we've taken far less casualties because of it.
- 1:34:34The problem that he's gotten himself into is he has two options,
- 1:34:37both of which are very bad.
- 1:34:38Either we end the war now,
- 1:34:40we leave the regime,
- 1:34:40we leave.
- 1:34:41The regime in place.
- 1:34:42They have thousands of,
- 1:34:43let me just,
- 1:34:43let me just point,
- 1:34:44they have thousands of ballistic missiles still pointed at Israel,
- 1:34:47still able to reach the,
- 1:34:48the,
- 1:34:48the Gulf states.
- 1:34:49They can have,
- 1:34:50they still have control of the Strait of Hormuz.
- 1:34:52They're still able to,
- 1:34:53uh,
- 1:34:53to,
- 1:34:54to charge for it,
- 1:34:54which wasn't,
- 1:34:55none of that was true
- 1:34:56prior to the war.
- 1:34:57They still have huge drones and drone-making capacities.
- 1:34:59We've sunk a lot of their ships.
- 1:35:00We killed a bunch of their leaders.
- 1:35:02They're still running Iran.
- 1:35:03The Iranian people still don't have,
- 1:35:04so,
- 1:35:05what,
- 1:35:07what is Iranian propaganda?
- 1:35:08The fact that they have complete ballistic missile capabilities,
- 1:35:11that's US intelligence assessments that are
- 1:35:13appearing in every single media outlet.
- 1:35:14So now you support the intelligence like we,
- 1:35:16we got into this.
- 1:35:17No,
- 1:35:17you're,
- 1:35:17you're you're telling.
- 1:35:18Oh,
- 1:35:18so I can't,
- 1:35:19I can't rely.
- 1:35:19So that's that's when,
- 1:35:21when,
- 1:35:22when you are talking
- 1:35:22about how many missiles Iran has or what their military capability has,
- 1:35:26you can't rely on Iranian assessments.
- 1:35:27You can't rely on American intelligence assessment.
- 1:35:29Where do you get your information?
- 1:35:31What are you relying on for,
- 1:35:32for telling me that they've been degraded greatly?
- 1:35:33I'm,
- 1:35:34I'm relying on what's your source.
- 1:35:35I,
- 1:35:35I'm relying on journalists.
- 1:35:36There's been the New York Times and The Washington Post.
- 1:35:38Where do they get that information?
- 1:35:39Yeah,
- 1:35:39it's possible they get it from US intelligence,
- 1:35:41of course they do.
- 1:35:42But you're using the same source.
- 1:35:43I understand.
- 1:35:43I understand.
- 1:35:44But to act like
- 1:35:45the same ballistic missile capabilities exist right now,
- 1:35:48that no,
- 1:35:48they don't.
- 1:35:49They,
- 1:35:49they,
- 1:35:49it's been,
- 1:35:50it's been,
- 1:35:50it's been degraded.
- 1:35:51There's fewer of them,
- 1:35:53but they have thousands of them.
- 1:35:54What is the downside on our side?
- 1:35:56The downside is,
- 1:35:56is that we've,
- 1:35:57uh,
- 1:35:57we've evaporated civilian life,
- 1:36:00including a bunch of young girls,
- 1:36:01and not only them,
- 1:36:02but at least.
- 1:36:02Like thousands of people in Iran,
- 1:36:04many of whom are civilians,
- 1:36:06we've lost our own soldiers.
- 1:36:07We've spent billions and billions of dollars.
- 1:36:09We've made the world infuriating.
- 1:36:10We've driven up,
- 1:36:11we've driven up gas prices for everybody in the world.
- 1:36:13We've destabilized that region.
- 1:36:15We have no idea what's gonna come next.
- 1:36:17These are jihadists that go blow themselves up.
- 1:36:19This is not destabilizing the region about war as some little game that you just,
- 1:36:23no,
- 1:36:23it's not a play,
- 1:36:24and then you just leave it alone as if you're not actually involved in the,
- 1:36:27in the bombs.
- 1:36:28All right,
- 1:36:28great defense.
- 1:36:28Thank you.
- 1:36:29I appreciate it.
- 1:36:31If you are MAGA and you watch this video,
- 1:36:33let us know if you support the United States' actions in Iran.
- 1:36:36Thank you so much for watching.
- 1:36:37Tune in Wednesday for a follow-up podcast,
- 1:36:39and we'll see you next time.
- 1:36:41I was really pleasantly surprised that pretty much universally
- 1:36:43people who were here were very
- 1:36:46connected to,
- 1:36:47engaged by,
- 1:36:48thoughtful of
- 1:36:50the topics we were discussing.
- 1:36:51It made it much more pleasurable and enjoyable for me to do.
- 1:36:54I think Glenn Greenwald is a very good debater.
- 1:36:56Everything he was saying about Qatar and the UAE and
- 1:36:58the financial interests that the Trump administration has with them,
- 1:37:01he's absolutely right.
- 1:37:02Glenn,
- 1:37:02who seems to be anti-corruption on both sides,
- 1:37:04skirts around the Qatar issue again,
- 1:37:06when he talked about
- 1:37:08the Trump family's dealings in the Gulf states,
- 1:37:09there was a $5.5 billion deal that they did in.
- 1:37:12And that's really conveniently left out because they exist within
- 1:37:15the axis of power that aligns with Iran.
- 1:37:18Corruption doesn't get that much attention because people don't
- 1:37:20think that if they vote those people out,
- 1:37:22the other people will
- 1:37:23be less corrupt.
- 1:37:24Trump,
- 1:37:25yes,
- 1:37:25I think he's corrupt like every other politician.
- 1:37:27I just think he's far less corrupt
- 1:37:29than the Biden administration or any other alternative
- 1:37:31that we had going into this election.
- 1:37:33I mean,
- 1:37:33I definitely think there's corruption.
- 1:37:34I don't think it's more than Joe Biden's causally.
- 1:37:36Is it negative for us?
- 1:37:37Like this company funding Trump,
- 1:37:39is Trump doing something that's against American interests as well?
- 1:37:42And the amount of money
- 1:37:43that the Trump family is monetizing and profiting from,
- 1:37:48it,
- 1:37:48it's shocking,
- 1:37:49and I do think when people hear it laid out,
- 1:37:51uh,
- 1:37:52even Trump supporters who,
- 1:37:53who,
- 1:37:54you know,
- 1:37:55are,
- 1:37:55are,
- 1:37:55are willing to be
- 1:37:57critical of him,
- 1:37:58uh,
- 1:37:59trying to take a second look and say wow,
- 1:38:00that does actually bother me.
- 1:38:02Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:38:05your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:38:07And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:38:10subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.