Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 142:12-143:6. Idolatry: Holiday Mead, Bathhouse, Hymnals, Art, Architecture, Shared Wall, Building a Dome, Fee to Church Garden/ Pool, Organ, Renting a Store, Church vs. State Taxes

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 142:12-143:6. Idolatry: Holiday Mead, Bathhouse, Hymnals, Art, Architecture, Shared Wall, Building a Dome, Fee to Church Garden/ Pool, Organ, Renting a Store, Church vs. State Taxes · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:04
  OK, Sean, good morning. We are in Simincliffe and bays
• 0:09
  up to a few bays, Elon Shashomi and Paris of Laos, Maham
• 0:16
  Sheikhar. We should also be on Hagam if
• 0:18
  they have a tree, which again, they used to make Sheikhar out
• 0:22
  of fruit dates or or out of figs and things.
• 0:25
  If they're show me the payrolls to go ahead and to make, you
• 0:28
  know, make alcohol, alcohol, liquor, whatever for, you know,
• 0:34
  their holiday. Be a dua Shahira.
• 0:37
  It tells you this is a SIM in that is an Ashira, you know,
• 0:42
  which I don't. It's not like here nowadays bad.
• 0:43
  So unless maybe you're in the Far East or something, you're in
• 0:46
  Africa or whatever. Alcohol and this is a SIM in
• 0:48
  that that the that the tree itself is what it was.
• 0:51
  Are you Gimel Ilanis rock, Piyush Ilanois and ice in Paris
• 0:59
  right, you know, and the regular trees or whatever she regularly
• 1:03
  leats up his name Lilium that they they plant before Lilium
• 1:06
  low government. No Lilium will also, you know,
• 1:09
  if they just they plant them in front of you know, they have a
• 1:13
  nice they have a nice garden with trees, right, You know with
• 1:16
  the often they even have gardens with the pestle right in the
• 1:19
  middle, you know fancy gardens with the pestle right in the
• 1:21
  middle and stuff like whatever. All those trees are considered
• 1:24
  Noi and and they're also maybe also to to go ahead and to use
• 1:31
  or, or we'll see even we'll see, you know, we'll see about look,
• 1:35
  even, you know, going there, looking at it, things like that.
• 1:37
  We're getting there. You dial it.
• 1:40
  Merhat's she Asia by leeling. If you have a, you know, bath
• 1:44
  house that has a leeling or bathroom, I mean whatever, we'll
• 1:49
  see. You can go ahead and take a, you
• 1:52
  know, go to the bath there and then she he Nazis the shame Noi.
• 1:56
  It's just there to as annoy, not annoy.
• 1:59
  It's not there to be worshipped. It's annoy of the meerkats.
• 2:04
  It's Lola Ofda. It's based on the missionary in
• 2:08
  the vaduzzara that was in the bathhouse for Shame Afridi.
• 2:12
  It's a Mishnah. And so he has a whole discussion
• 2:16
  in there with a philosopher. The whole discussion in the
• 2:20
  Mishnah, he had a discussion with the philosopher and they
• 2:23
  said, so the grass, well, how can you go there?
• 2:25
  So this is because because the, you know, the the pestle of of
• 2:29
  Afriditi was on top of the the bee was on top of the the the
• 2:34
  top of the, you know, the urinals.
• 2:37
  So, so therefore, it's not that it wasn't recovered.
• 2:41
  So therefore, as well as we'll see in a second that's McCoy.
• 2:45
  So it seems the shame noise of the Shenema when they treated it
• 2:52
  as something to be worshipped. They're going zoo.
• 2:56
  She'll met us all a bit right. It's right.
• 2:58
  It's by the drain goes at the sewage, the toilet, right, so.
• 3:08
  Machine this is like Bob or something.
• 3:12
  This is the Voda ulcer. Then then it would be also, but
• 3:16
  otherwise that's not whatever. I remember was in the driving
• 3:21
  through recent few years back from the desert and side of LA,
• 3:26
  you know, and they had this like, you know, rest off or
• 3:27
  whatever. And by the by the, you know, in
• 3:29
  the bathroom there, but they have like little screens, Well,
• 3:32
  so little like screens, so you can play games, whatever while
• 3:36
  you're while you're using that, I guess, you know, they have
• 3:38
  their photos over there also. They keep it in mind the whole
• 3:41
  time. A test of this is a actually an
• 3:45
  important sift. Also the Shamaki shisha Ali Lim.
• 3:48
  It's also to listen to music of Ali Lim, Ali Stakel Benoy Ali
• 3:54
  Lim or to look at the noi of Ali Lim mention about the trees or
• 3:58
  gardens. It's also to look at the Noi or
• 4:00
  you mentioned about going into a fan going into a fancy peeking
• 4:04
  in you go into the church right be a fancy Chapel.
• 4:07
  This whatever y'all you just peek in to see the whatever it's
• 4:11
  utterly stock of annoy Ilili, even Shinena Beria since you are
• 4:16
  Nene Beria, there's a Shmia and Ria was also Raya.
• 4:23
  Also, we think more talks about Raya victorious is also Nana for
• 4:27
  me who dovers A miscavan motor. But if you're walking you you
• 4:31
  know, you're walking down the street and you happen to see a
• 4:34
  beautiful stained glass window and you know, OK, you saw it and
• 4:38
  you realize what it was. So then you move on that we
• 4:41
  can't control everything or but if you, you know, if you walk by
• 4:45
  quickly, but if you stop and gaze at it, you know, whatever
• 4:49
  you try to close your nose, you try to close your ears, whatever
• 4:51
  you can so that that's what that's what you should do.
• 4:57
  So Ramesh has a Chuva saying straight out that listening to
• 5:01
  songs which were based in, in, you know, church songs and
• 5:05
  religious songs and things or whatever are austere to hear.
• 5:11
  So it's posture to sing to hear. He says that I'm shooting Chuva.
• 5:16
  He says anything coming from that Nikuning coming from that,
• 5:19
  you know, is definitely austere. Yeah.
• 5:24
  Like I like for for example, like, you know, my, my my wife
• 5:28
  was once say like different words, like a kids that, you
• 5:31
  know, saying saying singing a song.
• 5:34
  I thought I told her I remember the song.
• 5:35
  Like I remember hearing the real song Glory, glory, whatever.
• 5:38
  If you know what it is, you know, she didn't know.
• 5:40
  I said you Can't Sing that. You can't use that tune.
• 5:42
  You can't even if it's like, you know, I guess if it's Mamish
• 5:44
  Mavazza, Yeah, I don't know if you change the words to Mavazza,
• 5:47
  the vows are maybe I don't know. But you can't use you can't, you
• 5:50
  Can't Sing those tunes even if you're whatever and you know, to
• 5:54
  say here, people don't know to make them a ha.
• 5:57
  Let's say you go to a you go to a Hasna and you hear them
• 6:01
  playing. You know, we hear the people
• 6:04
  saying on a bell here. They heard, you know, playing
• 6:06
  the like, you know, prospect songs.
• 6:09
  So I'll get to I'll get to that. I'll get to that in a second,
• 6:12
  but I'm saying like the real religious ones.
• 6:14
  Let's say so then yeah, like her, you know, to say fine, Tina
• 6:18
  Shanishba to say there, but who wants to be a Tina Shanishba?
• 6:21
  Yeah, it's on. But if you show you maybe you
• 6:23
  could say that. But you know, I think it's
• 6:25
  tonight to to speak up and you know there to swell now
• 6:29
  Craftsman songs like so I was very has to know where they're
• 6:32
  playing Jingle Bells. So so I saw her left.
• 6:36
  I saw true like a letter from his left saying it's just about
• 6:39
  there's nothing religious about it.
• 6:41
  It's just a holiday song. It's bahur Adavar most holiday
• 6:46
  song, right? That's also true.
• 6:48
  It's also true. You know people that you know
• 6:52
  you need Paranasa. What do you want?
• 6:54
  So you know no, so like the hall, the justification about
• 6:57
  winter and and this and whatever, it's All Star.
• 7:00
  It's most adavar. You see that I'm talking about
• 7:03
  isser. This is just, it's very musing,
• 7:05
  you know, whatever, but it's not, it's OK.
• 7:11
  And it's stop and play. It's most another.
• 7:13
  You should tell them, I don't know, whatever.
• 7:14
  So listen. But it's not, you know, but
• 7:17
  it's, you know, it's not, it's not the same, you know, the same
• 7:22
  is Sir. Now the you know, The thing is
• 7:26
  there's a couple other Lucudas here, a couple other Lucudas
• 7:32
  about the the safer conceding. It's not for the safer
• 7:35
  conceding. So the person has to be very
• 7:37
  careful not to sing any of these types of songs like, you know,
• 7:42
  non Jewish songs whatever to their kids.
• 7:44
  And so there's the mouse here. Today's the air of, you know,
• 7:49
  Denon Peres, which law says vomitable down for your kids.
• 7:54
  So, you know, so it says you need to be very careful.
• 7:56
  It says that it says that the Gemara says in the very quick
• 7:59
  Moser, it says that after he used to listen to Ivani's songs,
• 8:05
  he said he says the music has a it's poil to get a little grew
• 8:09
  up singing it and then the Nimshak Ahuriza.
• 8:12
  A person should be careful. So there's like, you know,
• 8:14
  there's a song as a kids song that often people sing.
• 8:17
  It's Ferrer Jacques. It's a French song.
• 8:20
  It's called it means father John, you know, talks about the
• 8:23
  father John get up in the church with a monk or I don't know,
• 8:26
  whatever. You know, I don't know if
• 8:29
  there's anything religious, but you're talking about a gala, you
• 8:31
  know, not you know, I wouldn't sing that song to your kids.
• 8:35
  You know, there's a lot of besides all the violent songs
• 8:38
  that you know, all the you know, you know, if you pay attention
• 8:45
  to a lot of the songs like say, the ring around the ring around
• 8:49
  the Rosie or whatever it is, it was it was a song of the black
• 8:52
  plague. So everyone dying, you know,
• 8:58
  whatever, but acupunting how to go too far off.
• 9:02
  But the in the pistol in the, the brick of the Oasis here
• 9:05
  brings that again. It's it's also, he says clear.
• 9:10
  It's also clear. It's also to go into a church
• 9:13
  about to go ahead and look at the, at the NOI, you know, and
• 9:20
  he and he says, you know, he says that the question is, can
• 9:28
  you look at pictures on the walls?
• 9:30
  But it's all brought in the Shabbos picture is what says
• 9:34
  even Dovin and Golias and it's akumara or tastes, whatever that
• 9:39
  that says what it is. Is there a problem So it brings
• 9:42
  to the Baz, it's a mahogan through Baz says you should be
• 9:46
  you should be. It's Rashi.
• 9:47
  The Rashi interview says that you know the problem is looking
• 9:50
  at the picture. The other other be showing holds
• 9:54
  only if it's actually worshipped.
• 9:55
  It's a problem. Looking at a voter czar is a
• 9:57
  problem. Rashi is not sure.
• 9:59
  Even just looking at the picture, whatever's going to
• 10:01
  draw you away, is, is, is. Usser Rabat says it's glad to be
• 10:06
  Makhmur, even though really, Pasha says a lot.
• 10:08
  It's not like Rashi, you know, But religious painting, yeah.
• 10:14
  Mean if they mean if they're not, it's not pizza stick.
• 10:20
  So, you know, so you shouldn't look at it Last Supper and I
• 10:24
  don't know these things and all that.
• 10:25
  Whatever you shouldn't look at, you shouldn't definitely.
• 10:27
  That's definitely yeah, it's safe.
• 10:30
  It's a Hana looking at no, even though it's they don't worship
• 10:33
  it exactly, but according at least it's for cohesive.
• 10:36
  You know, it's very, very the half mayor even things from from
• 10:43
  no. So Tanakh is really something
• 10:45
  that yeah, so that already is that depends on the interpreter.
• 10:50
  That already is OK, that already could be.
• 10:54
  But something which was definitely is definitely, you
• 10:57
  know, art, which is yeah, you shouldn't right.
• 11:09
  The shark seems to get right OK the shark and it seems to be it
• 11:12
  doesn't say like so it could be the shop is a little more
• 11:18
  medical in a Konami so serious should not so annoy.
• 11:22
  I don't know if it's allowed again to walk The case of the BP
• 11:24
  is to walk is to look into a church and look at a picture
• 11:27
  look at the outside. It could be it's not yeah it's
• 11:30
  varying degrees. You know the outside going into
• 11:32
  a church Yeah he's not going in peeking in a stock of the hand
• 11:36
  There was sewage should not still annoy the lava that maybe
• 11:39
  I don't know if it's looking into a church.
• 11:40
  Maybe it's on the outside. You know, you go to the you go
• 11:43
  to the right. If you go to let's go, you go to
• 11:46
  the Vatican City, right? You go around there and all
• 11:49
  these, you know, they have all these, you know, statues and
• 11:51
  stuff. And I don't know what so could
• 11:55
  be it's referring to that. Not so inside the actual Sistine
• 11:58
  Chapel or, you know, anything like that, whatever.
• 12:04
  But Cliff Van Gimel, Meshaya. But basically someone whose
• 12:09
  house is borders on on like they use the wall they share a wall
• 12:17
  is a Shylock. You have to look into it.
• 12:18
  Someone told me like was the Beethoven Bach?
• 12:21
  I don't know who was made a lot of the music for the trip.
• 12:23
  But it wasn't. It wasn't.
• 12:27
  I don't know. I don't know.
• 12:28
  You'd have to. Yeah.
• 12:30
  Yeah. It's a good Shylock.
• 12:32
  I don't know Misha based on summer club is a Lily Minafal
• 12:37
  ulcer, someone whose house is is to share a wall to the you know,
• 12:42
  to to a church. Let's say you have a townhouse
• 12:44
  with things whatever and they share a wall.
• 12:46
  So also it was enough and that wall fell also lived nicer.
• 12:50
  You can't build the wall. You can't rebuild the wall.
• 12:53
  Kate said, yeah, So what do you do?
• 12:57
  You you even though you lose a bit of property, but you should
• 12:59
  bring it into your property and and build it, but also Revva in
• 13:05
  my local team of so then you put you well, the the Guevara says
• 13:10
  that the the grabbing the Guevara says that they made into
• 13:15
  a bathroom for kids. You know, so whatever you feel
• 13:18
  that the traditional yard can be basically Lillian's and they
• 13:20
  won't expand out if the wall was his, if they were if it was the
• 13:26
  shoot, shoot for him. He don't mess with him, whatever
• 13:32
  it says that wall. So if you want to falls and you
• 13:35
  each get half and so really all same thing over here.
• 13:38
  You get half Shalom motor behind all his bricks or his side.
• 13:42
  He knows which side it is also if you mean a market, but if he
• 13:48
  can't figure out which is which how call also Bahana.
• 13:52
  It's about April. All the dust and all the
• 13:55
  everything I fell is also is also he can sell them his his
• 14:02
  hey, like take the bricks and things, whatever and that would
• 14:04
  be and that would be OK. Why is that over here?
• 14:13
  Once it's a half since like yeah, and that's once once it's
• 14:15
  already you shouldn't sell them stuff, but once it's a it's
• 14:18
  already like they've had a case behind SF.
• 14:22
  You're allowed to you're allowed to like if they they were
• 14:25
  mastered in a if they already touched it, then you're allowed
• 14:28
  to sell it to to not to get a headset.
• 14:31
  Bae's also leave nice emails. Also to keep a you can't build a
• 14:38
  Dome where they put in and if you if you if he you know, if
• 14:45
  you talk of built. But I feel even if he made an
• 14:49
  actual voter Zara scar motor his car is is motor the Shahs try to
• 14:57
  figure it out like the what's Shahs Tamura that it's it's it's
• 15:10
  it's whatever it is a discussion here.
• 15:12
  I think going to the whole discussion about the you know,
• 15:15
  but it seems it's a it's a bit of a it's a bit of a Mahochis.
• 15:21
  It's a that it's a Mahogany's Russian faces, whatever.
• 15:29
  So we pass with the story is you know, so again, it could be once
• 15:33
  it's done already, you can still take Scar because that's not
• 15:35
  Hana, it's not khalifin. Scar is not a Khalifin of the
• 15:39
  money. Once you build it, you didn't do
• 15:41
  it, but you did it. You're allowed to take your
• 15:43
  scar. OK, so and the the woman, you
• 15:55
  know what that whatever in the things in the Khoshi Mishba
• 15:59
  probably about whether things like that, but you're allowed to
• 16:05
  build it. But you're allowed to build like
• 16:11
  the building around it or the, you know, all these things that
• 16:14
  you're allowed to build. It is it is motor.
• 16:22
  You know, the it's technically, it's technically Mutzer.
• 16:32
  Yeah, fine. Gimo Hialeah leading Gino
• 16:35
  Americans. So the the Voto czar has a nice
• 16:38
  garden or bath house. Tova Hiaoitsei Spehan, Hilo
• 16:42
  Kohanim Mutzer Lehano Spehan. And the tova which comes out of
• 16:47
  it is for the Kohanim, it's mutter the Hanos Behan
• 16:52
  Shlobatova, but also the Hanos Mohabbatova.
• 16:55
  So I'll start off this like it's actually tasis and helping down
• 17:00
  that Rashi says the Tova, the virus says the tova.
• 17:03
  The Grashi says the Tova is scar.
• 17:05
  You pay to get in entrance fee. The tasis of you know, Tom says
• 17:10
  no, it's not an entry. That's Bajan saucer.
• 17:12
  He says the Tova over here is your mastic lamb Tova.
• 17:16
  You faith them. They have made such a beautiful
• 17:20
  garden. You you feel good about the fact
• 17:22
  that they beautify the area, things like that.
• 17:25
  That's how mission Omelech explained to that you made a you
• 17:29
  know, you're the you're Max Klantova like you know, like you
• 17:32
  know, good job. So that's that that if if it's
• 17:36
  to the Kohanim. So then Mohabbat seems to go
• 17:40
  like Rashi. So Mohabbat go with Rashi first.
• 17:42
  So you go he the Kohanim. If the money goes straight to
• 17:48
  the to the Klahanim, then you're allowed to go.
• 17:51
  If it's free, then you can then you can go in and you can wander
• 17:56
  and you can walk around and enjoy it.
• 18:01
  You have a suggested donation? Yeah, or make a Poly video call
• 18:06
  more. It's only made it free.
• 18:08
  They do a lot of free things. So you, you know, whatever
• 18:11
  someone else may, you know, make it free.
• 18:13
  So it's also the honest, but it's also even if there's a it's
• 18:24
  still awesome. If the scar, let's say the
• 18:30
  entrance fee doesn't go to, but it doesn't go to the actual
• 18:34
  priest. It goes to the IT doesn't mean
• 18:36
  the workers. It means the other people, the
• 18:39
  other worshippers are goes for the upkeep of the crowns.
• 18:42
  Whatever it is the mutter Lehana sperm, a few little Batova, a
• 18:46
  few little hygiene of America to lead in Nevada.
• 18:48
  Even it's only built for for for that.
• 18:51
  Some say it's not us or if it's this is explanation for the end
• 19:03
  of time that only if they're standing in the actual and
• 19:07
  you're like, you want to give them a oh, thank you so much.
• 19:10
  Of course, I told whatever it is that's that's a problem.
• 19:14
  If it's not standing there, if I'll be shot over, even if
• 19:21
  person feels good about it, you still have it's still as long as
• 19:29
  it's not you're, you're saying, well, you know, person feels,
• 19:32
  you know, I'm happy that there's a that they built this temple
• 19:35
  here because it's beautiful grounds.
• 19:37
  Then, then, then you know, then you'd be also must says you
• 19:43
  could be so much like Hokkil. But obviously with Kokila, you
• 19:46
  should it's it's good. I it's good.
• 19:51
  I mean, Maher, even in that even in that situation, I you asked
• 19:56
  someone asked about the the behind gardens.
• 19:58
  And so I just looked into look quickly what it is.
• 20:00
  It's an offshoot, or some sort of offshoot of Islam.
• 20:04
  It's not an actual voter, Zara. It's some sort of offshoots from
• 20:07
  from from Islam or something. I mean, they're it's not much
• 20:10
  Islam. It's like beyond Islam, whatever
• 20:12
  it is, you know, sort of like, you know, juice for Jake, you
• 20:15
  know, whatever it is, it's it's an offshoot of Islam and they
• 20:19
  don't it's not actual of Azara. They they, they, they, it's just
• 20:23
  they took from Islam and they they they made it weird.
• 20:26
  I don't know yeah, that's true. The whole point of peace and
• 20:31
  whatever. So that's why they don't like
• 20:32
  them. I don't know the funny.
• 20:34
  So so listen, I will say when I say for sure that it's it's a
• 20:40
  good thing to go in. I have no idea, but Lahore, it's
• 20:43
  not awesome. Awesome to go around the gardens
• 20:47
  Lahore, but and also just so I'll just bring up one other
• 20:51
  thing which is important in the in the in just you know, the
• 20:54
  person should think about it is this is the guideline also for
• 20:57
  any you know, Shiloh, the person doesn't want to get hung off
• 21:00
  from something. I get a little Shiloh here.
• 21:02
  I'm getting hung off from places drove on Chavez and things
• 21:04
  whatever. So this would also give you
• 21:06
  guidelines as to what is actually Usurbahana or not.
• 21:10
  You have to know that it's CS in the place and whatever.
• 21:13
  If you're not Usurbahana. I'm saying a person wants to be
• 21:15
  mad by himself, not to get a Nah then or he makes a nether.
• 21:19
  We'll see if he'll listen. Darn, then this would be a
• 21:21
  guideline. Depends where the money goes to
• 21:23
  and not and different things. Dalit Khalilian channel Lilium
• 21:26
  also Lisbo Lisboy Baham Khalilian of Alilium.
• 21:30
  You wanna you know it's also to Lisbo Baham and this is right.
• 21:36
  And so to take their actual Khalilian is also or other
• 21:39
  musical instruments. You want to borrow the church
• 21:41
  organ? I don't know whatever.
• 21:43
  Hey, Hallelujah, shed a Lily. If the the store is a Lily, Liam
• 21:47
  also Lee Scorman. You can't buy anything there.
• 21:50
  So you have some of the Shiloh, you have the Shiloh belts going
• 21:52
  to Korea and they had the lanterns there.
• 21:55
  So if it goes directly to their Votozara, then you can't buy it.
• 22:00
  Yeah, they score whatever. Same idea for Ian Neufeld has
• 22:03
  scarred the Medina. But if the money goes to the, to
• 22:06
  the country behind Conin Sarkheim, Shari goes to a
• 22:10
  central part and the Medina, you know, and you know, they're
• 22:13
  going to go ahead and, and, and support the temples because of
• 22:17
  it. That's still OK.
• 22:18
  If, if there's a middle land involved, like the Medina,
• 22:22
  there's the Medina, there's a city, there's a whatever.
• 22:25
  So that that that's a that's OK. You don't have to be hushish,
• 22:32
  hushish for that. Goodbye Shenaitly Mehsali, the
• 22:37
  ham, if they if they have, if they go around collecting for
• 22:40
  their Zara and they add to tax and they have to give.
• 22:43
  It's also Lita in the ham. I'm not sure to get into that.
• 22:48
  Hagar became the Khan, you know, also again, it's the same thing.
• 22:55
  All of it. The tax goes directly to of
• 22:58
  Azara Atma location. No feel the keys with the
• 23:01
  armadine. If it goes to the religious,
• 23:03
  even though the the country is religious aval bishek coding
• 23:06
  Sarkhevos call him Shari. Even if they're going to buy and
• 23:09
  beautify the temples with it, that's OK.
• 23:12
  It's it's a it's a it's a grandma.
• 23:14
  It's whatever. You know that even if they're
• 23:17
  collecting a tax for temples and churches out of whatever it is,
• 23:22
  but since it's not going directly, so then it's motor.
• 23:25
  It is motor. It is motor to give.