Latest / The Counter Momentum of Spin, with Dr. Franco Musio / The mindset and strategy of Putin are misunderstood by US and Europe
Transcript
- 0:12Good day.
- 0:12Welcome to the Midday Report on the America Allow News Talk Radio Network, the counter-momentum of SPIN.
- 0:20I'm your host, Dr.
- 0:21Franco Musio, to our friends listening in the U.S.
- 0:24and around the world today.
- 0:26Today's topic is front and center in global news with almost daily twists and turns, the ongoing saga of the Russia-Ukraine war.
- 0:36I'm thrilled to introduce a leading expert in this topic, Ambassador Kenneth Yalowitz.
- 0:41Ambassador Yalowitz was a career foreign service officer from 1966 to 2001 and served twice as U.S.
- 0:50ambassador to the Republic of Belarus from 1994 to 1997 and to the country of Georgia from 1998 to 2001.
- 0:59Other overseas assignments included Moscow twice, and very importantly in 1991 at the time of the breakup of the Soviet Union, he was actively on the ground, so to speak.
- 1:09So there's no better expert on this topic than him.
- 1:13Since his retirement from the State Department in 2001, Ambassador Yalowitz has remained very active academically teaching at the School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University.
- 1:23I was my alma mater.
- 1:25I'm very proud of that.
- 1:32His accomplishments, honors, interviews, articles written would fill up our whole program.
- 1:37So he he does not want that.
- 1:38I know that.
- 1:39So Ambassador, thank you so much for joining us and being willing to share your experience, your insights on this war, which is certainly becoming more and more complex.
- 1:50Well, it's my pleasure, Dr.
- 1:52Musio.
- 1:57And I'm ready to go.
- 2:01Okay.
- 2:01So let me start with uh just a brief introduction, and I'll certainly defer to the ambassador to fill in the blanks.
- 2:09The initial incursion of Russia into Ukraine was in February 2014.
- 2:14Most people don't realize that, uh, with disguised Russian troops who invaded and annexed the Ukrainian Ukrainian peninsula of Crimea.
- 2:24This was followed by conflict in the Donbass region beginning in April 2000, April, not February, but afterwards, after a number of months, April 2014, which escalated into a full-scale invasion, February 24th, 2022 in Kiev, which was labeled very uh uh nicely by the Russians as a special, special military operation by the Russians.
- 2:49So if you look at I was just looking up the sources, and it it's it's just disgusting and and very painful of the amount of deaths, the casualties.
- 2:59Now, they're very skewed.
- 3:00If you look at CSIS, I I gather that's the Center for Strategic and International Studies.
- 3:06Um, if you their thought or their um their reporting of Russian casualties approaching one million total casualties and approximately 250,000 killed, whereas Ukrainian casualties killed and wound wounded 400,000, they're stating 60 to 100,000 killed of the Ukrainians.
- 3:29Uh the UK estimate for the Russians, 1.1 million killed and wounded.
- 3:35Now, if you look at what Ukraine says, and the right, especially the Russians, Russians are stating officially fewer than 6,000 killed.
- 3:43Okay, give me a break among their own people.
- 3:46And and then approximately one million killed and wounded among the Ukrainians.
- 3:51So and then the Ukrainians are not as bad, but in terms of skewing the data, but but they're kind of bad too.
- 3:58So approximately 750,000 losses, they're calling among the Russians.
- 4:04So that's kind of closer, and then 43,000 killed, uh, or more than 43,000 killed among themselves.
- 4:10So I I'd like to talk about, and and the ambassador is so well versed in this.
- 4:17Putin's mindset, his strategy.
- 4:19So I'm going to stop talking, but what I've learned over the course of years that he's more into Russian imperialism and a denial of Ukrainian statehood and uh a conviction, and this is the ambassador taught me earlier, you know, uh Russia's historical sphere of influence and challenge.
- 4:38Challenge to Western security um must be restored.
- 4:43So what do you think?
- 4:46Well, you've given an excellent uh introduction.
- 4:49Um I myself use that figure of approximately one million uh killed and wounded.
- 4:56Uh what if it's slightly above or slightly below uh whatever it is.
- 5:02This is a tremendous loss, you know, of human life on the part of the Russians.
- 5:08The Ukrainian losses, you know, are less, obviously, because the population is less.
- 5:14But uh, you know, the Russians, you know, have basically tried during the course of this war to break the will of the Ukrainian people.
- 5:23And I mean that what they've done is they've bombed infrastructure, schools, hospitals, roads, heating, electrification, uh, anything, you know, to you know, to try to break the will to fight of the Ukrainians, and they have not.
- 5:40But let me just uh say a few things just to fill in a little bit more.
- 5:45Sure.
- 5:45Um uh Putin's mindset basically, you know, is that of a great Russian, and that is, you know, that Ukraine is an intrinsic part of Russia, you know, that Ukraine is not a separate nationality, that Ukraine state that exists today was only because of mistakes, you know, that were made by Lenin and Stalin, you know, years and years ago, and that it was exacerbated uh by the breakup of the Soviet Union.
- 6:20But in their mindset, you know, Ukraine is the word in Russian is Nash, you know, is ours.
- 6:27And uh Putin has said repeatedly that the breakup of the Soviet Union in 1991 was the greatest tragedy, you know, in modern history.
- 6:37So his mindset, it's not to re-recreate the Soviet Union, but what he wants to do is to uh posture Russia as a great power in the world of up against the United States.
- 6:52This is his mindset.
- 6:54And to do that, he has to have Ukraine.
- 6:58Uh he denies Ukrainian statehood.
- 7:01This has gone on for hundreds of years.
- 7:04The Russians, you know, argue that the Ukrainian language is just a stilted form of Russian, and that you know, the the Ukrainians are sort of the little brother of Russia, you know, if you will.
- 7:16And you're correct.
- 7:18What a way, what a way of what a way of uh framing that.
- 7:21But I I guess they I guess do think that, but notwithstanding bombing and killing.
- 7:26Yeah, you don't bomb and kill your little brother.
- 7:28They do.
- 7:29Yeah, this is this is the crazy thing about this.
- 7:32Their narrative is so steeped in lies and you know, miscalculations.
- 7:39Uh, and you know, the the facts, I mean, just you know, fall right into their face.
- 7:45You know, if the Ukrainians are their little brothers who are longing to be part of Russia, why are they bombing the way that they are?
- 7:53Why do they have to use the military invasion?
- 7:56Well, their their logic, the Russians, was that this was not a true government.
- 8:02This was a government of fascists, of Nazis, you know, and they were basically colonizing the Ukrainian people.
- 8:10And when those Russian soldiers went in in 22, February of 22, they were told that they were going to be greetered, uh, you know, like long-lost cousins and relatives, that there would be flowers thrown at them.
- 8:25And what happened, of course, was they had the line of tanks, and the tanks were destroyed, you know, by the Ukrainians.
- 8:34This was not exactly a love fest.
- 8:37And the Ukrainians, to their enormous credit, you know, have fought back.
- 8:42We'll talk a little bit later, you know, about the nature of the warfare.
- 8:47Yes.
- 8:47But the Ukrainians have been much more subtle, much more flexible, uh, much more pragmatic, you know, in terms of how to fight the war and how to sort of balance the uh battlefield because the Russians, you know, have more people, more equipment, and the Ukrainians basically have used their heads.
- 9:08Yes.
- 9:08And they're also fighting, you know, for their own land.
- 9:12So they have done very, very well.
- 9:14But the problem right now with Putin, let me know to finish with this, is that he is dead set on continuing this.
- 9:21You know, he's ignored President Trump, you know, on negotiating a ceasefire.
- 9:27And basically, there's three reasons, you know, why this is going on the way, you know, that he is just dead set on continuing.
- 9:35One is, you know, is the ideological, and that's what I've talked about, this idea of Russia as a great power, you know, and that Ukraine is part of Russia, and that you know, the Ukrainian people are all part and parcel of the great Slavic Brotherhood.
- 9:51That is a very powerful emotive force, even in Russia today, because they still uh feel the breakup of the
- 10:00Soviet Union.
- 10:01You know, Russia is a powerful state, but it is not the power, you know, of the Soviet Union.
- 10:07And Putin hearkens back to those days.
- 10:10He's always talking about the glory of World War II.
- 10:14So that is one very important factor.
- 10:17A second is territory.
- 10:20He clearly, you know, has laid out the ambition of getting four regions, you know, of Ukraine, including the Donbass.
- 10:29And that is sort of his uh minimal goal.
- 10:34The maximum goal is to basically neuter Ukraine, you know, to uh get rid of the Zelensky government and probably Zelensky to install a puppet government and to ensure that the Ukraine that ensues is neutral, not a member of NATO, does not have the defense forces, you know, to defend itself.
- 10:57That is, you know, that is a point number two.
- 11:00You you saw that starting to interrupt.
- 11:05Did you not?
- 11:06Oh, yeah.
- 11:06Uh with uh what's his name?
- 11:08Lushenko.
- 11:09Uh with Lukashenko.
- 11:10Lukashenko.
- 11:11But just the third, yeah, the third reason very quickly, and then we'll go we'll go to Belarus.
- 11:16Oh, no problem.
- 11:17Um, with uh the third reason is for Putin, this is a war, this is an existential war.
- 11:24He knows that if they lose badly, uh that he will probably be ousted.
- 11:30Uh so as long as this war goes on, he is relying on the patriotic momentum.
- 11:36You know, great Russia, you know, Russia fulfilling its destiny.
- 11:40Uh we have to fight these, you know, these horrible people in Ukraine who are supported by the United States and NATO and the West.
- 11:48They are the real enemy.
- 11:50They're the ones who provoked this war.
- 11:52So that is the narrative, you know, that he has used now for three years.
- 11:57I think it's beginning to wear thin, but those are the reasons he is doing.
- 12:02Yeah, those are the reasons he's doing.
- 12:05You know, I think Belarus, you're absolutely right.
- 12:08You were there.
- 12:09You were probably I was there.
- 12:11You were meeting with him, I'm I suspect.
- 12:14Oh, yes.
- 12:14I I I I saw Lukashenko uh implant the authoritarian dictatorship in Belarus.
- 12:22I am very, very sensitive uh to movements away from a semi-democratic state, uh, you know, to an authoritarian dictatorship.
- 12:32So did you tell him did you tell him what what the hell are you doing?
- 12:36Or um I did.
- 12:38I I rem I rem yeah I remember very well the last meeting I had with them when I left on the other end of my assignment, and I said to him, Mr.
- 12:48President, I said, you have two choices.
- 12:52One, you can continue to preside over a living museum of the former Soviet Union, or you can be the father of independence of your country and move it to a more open, more democratic, uh freer type of system.
- 13:10And he just glared at me.
- 13:12He just looked at you.
- 13:13I remember he just looked at you.
- 13:16So he didn't even respond.
- 13:18So I I gather I gather Putin, he was just had Putin on his mind, right?
- 13:24The whole time, uh, or the or the Soviet uh Russia, and if I if I do that, well, he'll he'll take care of me.
- 13:32He'll he'll kill me.
- 13:35Do you think that's what was going on?
- 13:37Oh, yeah.
- 13:38Well, this uh when Lukashenko came into power, uh Yeltsin was still the boss.
- 13:43Oh, yeah, that's right.
- 13:44That's right.
- 13:45Maybe not as bad.
- 13:46Yes.
- 13:46The key point with Lukashenko in Belarus uh is the year 2020, and that was the year that uh Lukashenko had a presidential election, which was fixed, you know, totally corrupt.
- 13:59Uh, and millions, literally millions of Belarusians, you know, poured onto the streets.
- 14:06Uh, and he that was the closest that he has come to being ousted.
- 14:10I mean, he was on his last legs.
- 14:12Who saved him?
- 14:14Putin.
- 14:15Uh, and that in effect is you know, he sold his soul to the devil.
- 14:20Uh, he is now, you know, in the pocket of the uh, you know, of the Russians.
- 14:26But very, very recently, we are trying a little bit of effort to extract him a little bit.
- 14:32I'm not sure it's gonna work.
- 14:33I I've seen Lukashenko the way he operates.
- 14:36He takes a bunch of political prisoners, and then when he wants to make an opening to the West, he releases some of them.
- 14:43Very clever.
- 14:44But he's been doing this for 20 years already.
- 14:47It's the same thing, and it's going on right now.
- 14:5020 years.
- 14:51So he's been re-elected and re-elected just like Putin by over 96, 97% of the population.
- 14:58Yeah.
- 14:59Yeah.
- 14:59You know, it's a joke.
- 15:01It's a joke.
- 15:02I wonder, I I'm just thinking out loud right now that um Stalin and Lenin and just kind of copying that playbook or or that DNA, if you will.
- 15:14Uh it's not really DNA, but uh you think of nature versus nurture, certainly nurture in terms of for Putin, and and the other leaders in maybe Georgia a little bit later, you can address that.
- 15:26But um, in in terms of killing their own people, killing other people for this uh this ego, this this humongous ego, even surpassing the Arabs in terms of, or the Middle Easterners, in terms of the importance of an ego.
- 15:43Um, but but at the expense of so many deaths.
- 15:48Uh again, Stalin, Lenin, um uh Marx.
- 15:52Um so Putin, I guess Putin wants to be one of the fourth, I guess.
- 15:56I I don't know, but he doesn't care that he kills so many people.
- 16:00So in my opinion, he has his place in hell waiting for him.
- 16:04Uh uh I agree.
- 16:06I agree completely.
- 16:08Um, uh it's interesting because when he first came to power when Yeltsin sort of turned over the reins of power to him.
- 16:16We're talking, you know, uh, you know, roughly 20, 25 years ago.
- 16:21Uh he was making noises, uh, you know, like he wanted to have Russia, you know, sort of part of the West, part of NATO, part of, you know, the European Union.
- 16:32Uh that did not last, you know, very long.
- 16:35And uh, you know, in the last, you know, 20 years now, 18 or so, you know, he has blamed the United States in particular, uh, you know, for rubbing their noses, you know, into the dirt at the end of the Cold War, you know, for expanding NATO right up to the Russian, you know, border, uh, you know, for being wanting to be the policeman of the world, you know, uh refusing to let Russia, you know, be a great power again.
- 17:02Well, let me interrupt the list of resentments, yeah.
- 17:05Do we have did we have a choice?
- 17:08And and you know, as it goes up to now in terms of geopolitics.
- 17:12Did we have a choice then?
- 17:13I don't think so if we wanted to prevent a World War III shortly after World War II, but he clearly did not interpret it that way.
- 17:22In terms of NATO strengthening NATO.
- 17:25Yeah.
- 17:26He basically said, you know, that the uh that the expansion of NATO was done, you know, to threaten Russia, uh, and that you know, that we do not respect Russia, that we're trying to get Russia's, you know, minerals and things like you know that are up in the Arctic.
- 17:42But he has a whole litany, you know, of complaints against the United States and Western Europe.
- 17:49And uh and this is where you know his his um uh closeness with the Chinese comes in.
- 17:55That this is the basis of their very close ties these days, and that is you know, an antagonism to the United States, wanting to push the United States off of its quote unquote pedestal, uh, you know, the superpower of the world.
- 18:11And that is really the fundamental reason that the Chinese and the Russians, you know, are getting along so well right now.
- 18:19They do not agree.
- 18:20I don't think the Chinese like to see what the Russians are doing in Ukraine.
- 18:25Uh the Chinese are very big on territorial integrity on you know the uh sacrosanct borders, uh, and they are not happy, I believe, you know, with what Putin is doing.
- 18:36But the more important thing is is that you know, is that um you know the West is engaged, you know, in Ukraine, uh, and that uh you know, and that uh you know that that Putin and that that the Chinese see certain benefits, you know, in the West bleeding itself, you know, in you know, in in Ukraine.
- 18:55And also, I think Russia to a certain extent.
- 18:57Oh, yeah.
- 18:58Well, we're gonna talk about that.
- 18:59They have a history of competition.
- 19:01We're gonna talk about that.
- 19:02So hold that thought, Ambassador.
- 19:04Uh, and when we come back, when we come back, we're gonna continue this uh this stimulating discussion.
- 19:10Tired of harsh chemical toothpaste that do more harm than good.
- 19:14Upgrade your oral health with smile.
- 19:16The doctor formulated toothpaste for the wellness company.
- 19:18SMILE uses powerful peptides, remineralizers and probiotics to rebuild gum tissue, strengthen enamel, and keep harmful bacteria away.
- 19:26And also leaves your mouth feeling fresh with a clean mint flavor.
- 19:29No fluoride, no toxins, just real science-backed results.
- 19:33Go to TWC dot health forward slash out loud and use code out loud for 20% off your first order.
- 19:42But our diet and the way we eat has creating an environment in your mouth for bacteria to wreck havoc on your teeth and gums for better oral health.
- 19:51Get spray, dental defense, an oral care line designed to combat acid creating bacteria.
- 19:58The toothpaste mouthwash mints.
- 20:00And gum all contain xylitol and natural ingredients shown to dramatically improve oral health.
- 20:06Sprite can be found online and at all fine natural retailers.
- 20:10Is your gut a mess?
- 20:11Two-thirds of Americans suffer because of gastrointestinal issues, and I was one of them.
- 20:16That is why we created a three-step doctor formulated completely natural gut reboot system that you can do at home in just minutes a day.
- 20:25Go to Chemicalfree Body dot com forward slash out loud today.
- 20:29Get the Malcolm Healthy Gut bundle, reboot your gut and your energy, and save 20% on your first order.
- 20:37Have you been looking for a healthy snack for on the go?
- 20:39But all the energy and protein bars are just too sweet and full of sugar preservatives and mystery ingredients.
- 20:44Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary.
- 20:47Bear bars are a crunchy savory bar made from just six simple natural ingredients made with veggies, nuts, and seeds.
- 20:53Bear bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free, contain six grams of protein, and are low temp dried for a unique crunch.
- 21:00To learn more, just visit bearbar.com forward slash out loud and get the exclusive discount just for America Out Loud Listeners.
- 21:07That's B E A R B A R dot com forward slash out loud.
- 21:12The smartest food on the planet doesn't come from a lab or in a package.
- 21:16It grows in a glass jar.
- 21:19I'm Doug Evans, author of the national bestseller, the spout book.
- 21:23Sprouts deliver up to a hundred times the antioxidants of mature vegetables.
- 21:29They grow in just three to five days for under a dollar serving.
- 21:33Get your sprouting kit at the sprouting company.com slash out loud.
- 21:39Use the code out loud for an exclusive offer.
- 21:42Grow smarter.
- 21:43Hi, I'm Dr.
- 21:44James Bragman, board certified DO in internal in geriatric medicine.
- 21:48Whether you're flying on a cruise, driving or exploring, use COFEXRX nasal cleanse daily to help protect yourself from viruses, bacteria, and allergens.
- 21:56COFEX RX is easy to use, safe and effective.
- 21:59If it's perfectly in your pocket or purse, travel with confidence and stay healthy with Kofix RX nasal cleanse.
- 22:05Click on the COFEX RX banner ad in the American Outlawed Shop for 20% off your next order of Kofix RX.
- 22:14Well, did you see Google quietly updated its AI principles removing its pledge not to use AI for weapons or surveillance?
- 22:24A promise they agreed to in 2018.
- 22:26Well the American people have seen Google's track record.
- 22:31Is Google an untrustworthy player in the AI race?
- 22:39Now is our time, my fellow America outmaw.
- 22:45Liberty and justice for all.
- 22:51And we are back.
- 22:52Welcome back.
- 22:54The last side we were talking about Putin's mindset and strategy.
- 22:59But I want to ask Ambassador this.
- 23:10So quote on the history on the historical unity of Russians and Ukrainians.
- 23:14And in that, it was kind of a revisionist narrative, historical narrative.
- 23:19And that what you were talking about kind of served to justify, not kind of did, uh, his invasion and uh uh kind of erasure uh uh removing the Ukrainian identity, the the national identity of Ukraine with that essay.
- 23:35So it was kind of a springboard for his attack.
- 23:38Or am I wrong?
- 23:40You are absolutely correct, because along with that, you know, they were mobilizing troops, you know, along the border, you know, with uh, you know, with Ukraine, and uh they were playing a double game.
- 23:52You know, they were saying, oh no, these are just maneuvers, you know, we don't have you know, um, you know, hostile intent, but that was clearly a lie.
- 24:00Uh we offered to negotiate with him, and he just you know just turned a blind eye.
- 24:06They just went ahead and attacked, you know, at the end of February.
- 24:10And let me just say a couple of words about why I think he did that full-scale attack, you know, when he did that.
- 24:17This was unleashed the largest land war in Europe, you know, since the end of World War II.
- 24:23Yes.
- 24:24He was a victim of his own sort of ego and uh uh the fact that he was surrounded by a small circle of advisors thinking the same things.
- 24:35They thought that the Ukrainian army would, you know, would just fold up and you know and disappear.
- 24:41Um they thought that the West would be disunited, would not, you know, react in a united way.
- 24:48Uh they saw, you know, President Biden in office, and they thought that the example of Afghanistan and the difficult, you know, uh end of the war in Afghanistan for us was going to tie, you know, Biden's hands.
- 25:03What about what about themselves?
- 25:04That they were in there for over 10 years, were they not in Afghanistan?
- 25:08So didn't they learn something from that too?
- 25:12Yeah, but they they they saw the most recent event.
- 25:14You know, it looked like Biden had been weakened.
- 25:18Yes.
- 25:19Um, and then also they felt that their flank with China was protected, you know, that they had good relationships with the Chinese.
- 25:27And at that time, the Russian economy was doing pretty well.
- 25:31Uh, you know, there were lots of exports of oil and gas.
- 25:35Uh, you know, the economy was, you know, that was you know moving along well.
- 25:39And yeah, that, you know, the the special military operation was a very clever attempt at a very clever ruse in the sense that they thought this was going to be over with.
- 25:52You know, they were going to send all these tanks and troops in the government in Kiev was going to fall.
- 25:58Zelensky was going to get killed, and they were going to be you know treated like you know, well, like uh uh you know, like a uh welcome with flowers.
- 26:06Yes.
- 26:07None of that happened.
- 26:09But but what uh Putin did though after that was very clever.
- 26:13Um by trying to shield the mass of the Russian population, you know, basically saying this is a special military operation, we're doing very, very well.
- 26:24Uh we're gonna win this thing very quickly.
- 26:27What he was trying to do was to keep the Russian population happy.
- 26:32He basically said, go about your lives, we're not going to disturb you.
- 26:37Let us fight the war, we'll win it, and then everything is gonna be great.
- 26:40Well, Ken, and then does he care what he did?
- 26:43Did he care?
- 26:44Does he care about what the Russian population thinks?
- 26:48Yeah, I think I think they have to in certain ways.
- 26:52Uh going back to the war in Afghanistan, you know, which they lost years earlier.
- 26:57Uh one of the things that did them in uh was uh the large number of casualties that they were incurring.
- 27:06And the bodies that were coming back in sealed, you know, metal caskets, and mothers and grandmothers were outraged, you know, that they could not see their children, you know, before they were buried.
- 27:20And that was one of the reasons that they ended up leaving Afghanistan.
- 27:24And I think that kind of thing he was afraid of again, uh, that that possibly, you know, could happen.
- 27:32Yes.
- 27:32And they are aware, you know, that they are aware of sort of what's going on.
- 27:37But what he was doing was while to to minimize the threat of that happening, they were uh uh organizing far more repressive activities.
- 27:47They were arresting anti-war demonstrators, they were jailing people for 10 years, they were beating them up, they were basically doing Lukashenka's type thing, you know, beat demonstrators into submission.
- 28:00And that's what they were the the two things were going on at the same time.
- 28:04He was basically trying to shield much of the population.
- 28:08They were not using, you know, drafted boys that were using contract, you know, military and they avoid calling up people for yeah.
- 28:17Well, they avoided calling up, you know, uh uh enlistees or young, you know, young men uh until I think the following September.
- 28:26And what happened is that there was such a strong negative reaction to that.
- 28:31That's when hundreds of thousands of young people fled Russia, you know, to go overseas.
- 28:37And they are aware of these things.
- 28:39They are aware that these so he has tried, you know, to shield the population as much as possible from the war.
- 28:46And that goes to your point about mercenaries.
- 28:49Uh, you know, they're trying to do everything.
- 28:51They've they emptied the jails, you know, and and put they were looking for basically cannon fodder and and and the other thing I would mention on that.
- 29:00Castro Castro used to do that.
- 29:02Fidel Castro.
- 29:03Yeah, empty dishes.
- 29:04A lot of it, yeah.
- 29:05A lot of the uh cannon fodder came from Muslim areas of the North Caucus of Southern Russia.
- 29:13And they did that purposefully because you know, these are not, you know, hotbeds of intellectualism, they're not hotbeds of insurrection against Moscow.
- 29:23Uh they are these are people who are very, very poor.
- 29:26And the fact is that what the Russians have done is they paid very large bonuses, you know, to people to join the army, and even more importantly, they paid even larger bonuses to men who are killed.
- 29:40And for some of these poor peasant types, you know, uh a 20,000 dollar, if you will, bonus to their parents uh for them getting killed is worth, you know, is worth it.
- 29:52So those are things in there, as I said, they're using mercenaries now, they're doing everything they can.
- 29:57That's what they're doing now.
- 29:58Ambassador, you're you're
- 30:00I'm not getting confused, but this is dovetailing both the Afghanistan experience and now the Ukrainian experience per the population of Russia, because in terms of the caskets coming back, the steel caskets, they couldn't open them and et cetera, et cetera.
- 30:17That was Afghanistan.
- 30:19But but they're reliving this, or at least objectively, what's happening is the same thing right now.
- 30:28Except that a lot of these boys that are being brought back, the corpses are going to places in Dagestan and Chechnya, where there, you know, isn't a free press.
- 30:40Uh there are no opposition political parties.
- 30:43There are no NGOs that you know stand up and say, what the heck is going on?
- 30:49They know what they're doing, you know, in terms of trying to keep the lid on domestically.
- 30:54I think uh uh perhaps uh a weaker point is going to be the economy.
- 30:59Uh as I said, the economy was doing well until this war began.
- 31:04And what they have done is turn the economy into what I would call you know a wartime economy.
- 31:10Right.
- 31:11Their budget, all their expenditures are now very skewed towards the military industrial complex.
- 31:18And that really gave the economy a bump upward over the last couple of years because they were pouring money and money and money into armaments and tanks and vehicles and everything else.
- 31:30And they have a labor shortage.
- 31:31Uh the Russians have a um demographic problem.
- 31:35Uh they're losing population or it's not being replaced.
- 31:39Of course.
- 31:40As quickly as they're using hundreds of thousands of of young men.
- 31:45Yes.
- 31:45Yep.
- 31:46Even before that, even before that, they were having demographic problems, which means labor shortages.
- 31:52Uh and that has meant that their uh, you know, their uh costs of production have gone up.
- 31:58Uh there are lots of things that are bedeviling that economy, and the sanctions are hurting them.
- 32:04Uh they have not yet forced Putin to be serious in negotiations, but they are hurting.
- 32:11And now, you know, Trump finally put a couple of sanctions on uh on two of the major oil and gas producers, and that has the potential of really hurting them.
- 32:24Whether the question now is, is it going to be enough, you know, to force Putin to negotiate, you know, seriously?
- 32:31And the other side of that equation is Trump, you know, finally did some um you know serious sanctions.
- 32:39Is he going to provide Ukraine with enough weaponry uh you know to allow Ukraine to, you know, to ambassador force the Russians to negotiate.
- 32:49Ambassador, he has no choice.
- 32:51Trump has no choice.
- 32:52He really does not.
- 32:53I mean, he's making the we'll talk about that in the next segment, but uh in terms of the geop geopolitics.
- 32:59I I don't think Trump uh nor Europe separately or in tandem with the United States uh have have a uh have a choice.
- 33:07Um so you're telling me in in a nutshell, kind of.
- 33:11Uh it it's not only about territory, but but that's a a part of it, a big part of it.
- 33:16But but it's it's having political control over Ukraine.
- 33:19And and again, I I guess the land is just a means to an end of everything you were talking about before, about um, you know, uh uh the cold war is preceding all of this and and the breakup of Russia preceding all of this and Russian primacy over its neighbors, and and and it it's as much a political slash psychological issue uh as a territorial issue, which we don't understand, uh meaning our foreign policy doesn't understand.
- 33:51And I apologize because I wanted to talk about that.
- 33:54But am I right that this is as mental and psychological as uh as again, for example, the Middle Easterns uh in in different different subjects, Middle Easterners, different Middle Eastern countries.
- 34:07Um ego is huge.
- 34:09And that's why I was asking about the DNA from Stalin, uh Lenin, you know, kill at all costs.
- 34:16We need to um politically slash psychologically slash uh you know, ourselves feel this supremacy that is key.
- 34:29Oh, and show ourselves to the rest of the world, of course.
- 34:33So it's hinging Russia you can go back further um, you know, into Russian history, and there's a strong streak of Russian messianism, you know, a strong streak that says that Russia, you know, is is uh you know it idiosyncratic, is different, it's not a Western country, uh, and that it has its own rhythms, its own spirit, uh its own well-being.
- 35:01And a lot of that is messianism in the sense that you know, spreading Russianism, you know, uh everywhere.
- 35:08Uh that was one of the reasons why they were so adaptable to uh adopting uh communism, Marxism Leninism.
- 35:17Because Marxism Leninism is sort of a totalitarian, it is a totalitarian ideology.
- 35:23And that you know, sunk with the Russians, you know, who sort of had that mentality, you know, if you will.
- 35:30And um uh yeah, uh now the going back to us, because I really would like to talk about us, you know, a little bit here.
- 35:38Sure.
- 35:38Uh Joe Biden, I think, you know, has been wrongly criticized in a lot of ways, but I think he got Ukraine right in the sense that uh you know, he was the one that succeeded in and crafting, you know, the alliance with all of our allies, you know, to provide uh equipment uh and uh military equipment uh and financial aid, you know, to Ukraine.
- 36:02I think he recognized you know the the three elements you know that I talked about, which you are telling um you know, Ukraine.
- 36:12And Donald Trump, you know, uh uh his people, uh, there are a lot of them who who basically believe Ukraine is not important to the United States, that China uh is really important to the United States, and now increasingly internal enemies as they're talking about, you know, are most important.
- 36:34And so when he came into office, I think what he was uh after, and it was a laudatory uh objective, you know, is to get some kind of a peace settlement, you know, in Ukraine.
- 36:46But I think he went at it the wrong way.
- 36:48I think he, you know, he he was blaming uh Ukraine for starting the war, which was completely false.
- 36:55Right, right.
- 36:56Um he seemed to be siding more and more with the Russians.
- 37:00But as time has gone on, I think he has learned the lesson.
- 37:04Sure.
- 37:05Uh, you know, he's had now that summit with uh Putin when uh you know uh they hit they met him in the day afterward, uh it didn't work, you know, at the summit, and the day afterward, Putin had the biggest bombing against Ukraine of all.
- 37:19Yes.
- 37:19I mean, what what more lessons you need?
- 37:22And you know, recently, as I said, he's put sanctions on two major uh oil and gas exporters to I think you know a lot of us hope that that means you know he has recognized you know that Putin, this is more than a real estate deal, which I think he was trying to negotiate.
- 37:39Yeah.
- 37:40You know, he was trying to give Putin real estate and then that wasn't enough for Putin.
- 37:45He wants war.
- 37:46So I'm hoping, you know, that uh he understands that.
- 37:50I I now I think so.
- 37:52Now I think so.
- 37:53And and I'm I hope so.
- 37:55I I because there's no other, yeah, Putin has made that critically clear, uh uh painfully clear.
- 38:02So I I want to touch on just a couple things.
- 38:05Do you think Russia is falling at this point?
- 38:08So for example, um their lack of access to to Western technology.
- 38:13So in the banking industry, the banking network, the SWIFT banking network, it's it's it has a long name, but society worldwide interbank financial telecommunications.
- 38:22So they're out of that.
- 38:23And you know, the Russian I re uh I saw a picture or a video the other day um uh filmed in downtown Russia, downtown Moscow.
- 38:34And the question was, what do you see here that bothers you?
- 38:38And guess what?
- 38:39It was pretty obvious.
- 38:41There were all women, all women of all of all ages, you know, starting with little well, well, starting with um adolescents or above adolescence, you know, late teenage years, and and throw all women, maybe one or two men, and that was it.
- 38:56So that that has to resonate with the population if you're telling me that oh they they really do, Putin really does look at that, and and his reports may be inaccurate as well, by the way.
- 39:10His intelligence, I don't know what you think about that, that that he's not really um in the know, uh, or or maybe he is uh of exactly what's happening, or is is Russia is there a possibility, which we all hope, maybe I do secretly, uh, that Russia's gonna fragment into separate pieces, separate parts.
- 39:30Uh uh uh I guess he would have to be assassinated first if that were to occur.
- 39:35But uh it is is Russia is there a downfall and is that gonna happen?
- 39:40Um we're gonna talk on the other side about China propping them up and so forth.
- 39:44But do you see that happening?
- 39:47I I do not over the near term.
- 39:50Um what I do see happening is the following.
- 39:54I think there are questions about Putin's health, uh, you know, uh the remedy
- 40:00The Russians, as I said, have a demographic crisis.
- 40:03And the average age lifespan of a Russian male, I mean, he's probably exceeded at, you know, now.
- 40:11So uh I I don't think he has bad habits from what I've seen, and I've never seen him smoke all Russians drink.
- 40:18Right.
- 40:19Uh but you know, whether he has some incurable disease, I don't know.
- 40:24But that is to me, point number one uh is his longevity.
- 40:29Uh I don't think the chances are good of him being overthrown.
- 40:34Uh, you know, he's got military forces, you know, that are loyal to him.
- 40:40And uh there is no opposition, you know, out there.
- 40:43There's no in Navalny after that very famous uh, you know, uh critic critique of Putin was died or killed uh in prison camp.
- 40:53Yes.
- 40:54There isn't really anyone.
- 40:55I would argue.
- 40:56Oh, he was killed.
- 40:57Yeah.
- 40:57Yeah.
- 40:58There isn't anyone, you know, to sort of uh mobilize the population.
- 41:03No.
- 41:03I mean, they they just squash any opposition they squash, you know, there's no free press.
- 41:10No, they can squash things, you know, pretty well.
- 41:13What's going to happen though is over the medium to longer term.
- 41:17Yeah their economy is gonna grind down further and further.
- 41:21It's for the reasons that you were mentioning before.
- 41:24Ambassador falling behind tech yeah, they're falling behind technologically.
- 41:28Yeah.
- 41:29Yeah.
- 41:29Hold that thought.
- 41:30We're gonna continue this discussion on the other side.
- 41:33Okay, but thank you.
- 41:35Boy, you're you're such a wealth of knowledge, it's impossible almost to stop you.
- 41:38But I have to.
- 41:40So we will see everyone uh after this commercial break.
- 41:44Thank you.
- 41:46All right, welcome back, everybody.
- 41:48So Ambassador, you and I were talking about partly geopolitical implications, but uh but I want to go full force into the geopolitics here.
- 41:57Um and I was also mentioning about Putin miscalculating he was given being given inaccurate information by his own uh CIA type, I gather his own generals.
- 42:10But um tell me what what you thought about that.
- 42:13Inaccurate information and and as I recall a number of his generals were were killed as well because of that inaccuracy, or at least fired, but well, uh first of all, there is a lot of corruption in the Russian military.
- 42:30Um it is uh in many ways, it's been reformed in many ways, but it is still retained some very old archaic structures.
- 42:40Uh and one of the worst is that uh, you know, that they it's sort of centralized command.
- 42:46Uh our military forces, you know, they devolve responsibility and decision making, you know, uh to a considerable extent, you know, down to the lieutenants and the sergeants, you know, who are in in the front lines.
- 42:59The Russians, you know, want everything centrally directed.
- 43:03Uh they don't have the NCO, you know, abilities that we do.
- 43:07But anyway, um uh the points I wanted to make are are simply the following.
- 43:12Uh I think he did not go outside his own small circle of advisors before he made the decision.
- 43:18Uh he kept everybody in the dark.
- 43:21Um uh the soldiers were told that they were going to be on maneuvers.
- 43:25Uh his generals were not informed.
- 43:28They really told nobody up until the very uh unleashing of the attack, you know, what was going to happen.
- 43:36And that is not a way to, you know, to run an efficient operation.
- 43:40No.
- 43:40Um their communications were poor, and as I said, I remember that long line of tanks, you know, that was on its way to Kiev, and they were sitting ducks.
- 43:50You know, the Ukrainians just destroyed that whole line.
- 43:53So that was that was mistake, you know, number one.
- 43:57On NATO, um he has now uh uh miscalculated uh by now having NATO stronger than it was before.
- 44:06You um uh Finland and Sweden are members of NATO, which means the border between NATO and Russia is now I think about a thousand miles longer, yeah, than it was before.
- 44:19Yes.
- 44:20A very serious mistake, you know, on his part.
- 44:23Number three, uh he thought the Europeans would be cowed and that they would not move away from their dependence on Russian oil and gas.
- 44:33We are seeing now slowly that that you know is beginning to happen.
- 44:38Right for the Americans, Biden were decisive.
- 44:42Um, you know, we stepped up and we did a great deal.
- 44:45The mistake I think that Biden made with this war is that uh he was supplying enough equipment to be sure that Ukraine would not lose, but not enough to be able to really on the Russians.
- 44:59Right.
- 44:59Yeah.
- 45:00And that we're left with that same issue, you know, you know, today.
- 45:04Yes and I think Putin, you know, who regards himself, you know, as a genius, you know, these miscalculations have really been bad.
- 45:12But let me just quickly say on the battlefield today, the Russians have learned, uh I think their their casualties are still enormous, but they have learned how to fight better.
- 45:24You know, they are they are doing they're using uh drones, they're using, you know, missiles, uh, they're doing all kinds of things better on the battlefield.
- 45:34And the other thing that I wanted to mention about that is they are conducting a silent war, you know, in Europe right now.
- 45:41Uh Poland, yesterday there was a railroad that was bombed and it was clearly sabotage.
- 45:47Uh they have been doing this in various places all across Europe.
- 45:52Yes.
- 45:52Uh, you know, spreading propaganda.
- 45:54So covert financing, yeah.
- 45:56Maybe not so much covert, but uh that was over it over.
- 46:00And uh they they don't like to leave traces, or maybe it's it's by assumption by assumption that it that it's up to them, or or they've paid somebody to do that.
- 46:11They paid their mercenaries.
- 46:12I don't know, other countries or or what have you to do that's pretty clear.
- 46:18There are there are many Western leaders now in Europe, you know, who are basically saying, you know, Russia has really declared war against us now.
- 46:27And the the again, again, Putin's miscalculations, what that has done is to drive the Europeans to be more determined in opposing Russia.
- 46:38Uh they are increasing defense spending.
- 46:41Um and that, you know, when you look at Europe right now, you can see countries like Slovakia, you know, and Hungary, you know, which are led by uh basically Putin almost allies.
- 46:55Uh you got those guys, and then you've got a lot of other countries in Europe, you know, which are led by people who are Britain, France, you know, who are you know committed in Germany, you know, to really standing up to Putin.
- 47:09But that is another thing that Putin is looking at.
- 47:12Uh he is looking at this and saying, you know, are things gonna go my way?
- 47:16Are other countries gonna go the way of Hungary and Slovakia?
- 47:20I think that they will.
- 47:22That's the oh you think they will be able to do it.
- 47:24You think they will go his own.
- 47:25Oh, no, no, no.
- 47:26He he he no, he he thinks they will.
- 47:28Oh, he thinks, of course.
- 47:29No, I'm saying he's but but objectively absolutely not.
- 47:35Uh hopefully that'll be the case.
- 47:36No, we don't know.
- 47:38What what Putin is doing in many ways is using the tactics that the Soviets use after World War II when they took over Eastern Europe.
- 47:47Um a lot of the things that they're doing, you know, to just try to, you know, to uh destroy democratic political parties, you know, to support uh after the war it was left wing people, now it's more right wing people.
- 48:01Uh they're doing whatever they can, you know, to uh split European public opinion, you know, to drive they they're trying to do to Europe what we're doing to ourselves here, you know, split ourselves, uh destroy the middle, you know, if you will.
- 48:16Um that's what he you know, he is still a KGB thinker.
- 48:21And what he is doing in many ways reflects it just reflects KGB tactics.
- 48:27That's what he's doing.
- 48:28I remember I was in 1985, I was in Ethiopia in um Addis Ababa and Ubaba.
- 48:35And uh I remember just watching everywhere there were there were these uh posters of Marx Lenin Stalin.
- 48:46And read everywhere throughout Ethiopia.
- 48:49And and then to the side you would see Comrade Mengustu, you would see him.
- 48:53Uh and I don't know if you you you had dealings with Ethiopia or not.
- 48:58But but it was rather I I was young and naive, and I'm glad I was because there were Eastern European and Russian tanks and trucks everywhere.
- 49:07And there were just seas of Russians there in Ethiopia.
- 49:12And uh, you know, so so what in God's name did he want in Ethiopia?
- 49:16But but they were there.
- 49:18They were there, and I'm sure other places as well.
- 49:20Yeah.
- 49:21Um I'm sure you're I'm sure you're exactly right.
- 49:24Yeah.
- 49:24No, but as I said, the uh one one thing though, uh, you know, that has happen excuse me.
- 49:31Um we tried to isolate, you know, Putin diplomatically internationally.
- 49:38And we did a very, very good job of it.
- 49:41Uh he was branded a war criminal by the International Court of Justice.
- 49:45Yes.
- 49:46You know, he he was unable to travel to a lot of places.
- 49:50Um and uh but one of the um problems I think we've had is there's also been a north south divide, you know.
- 50:00We've talked about East West.
- 50:01And by that I mean the countries of the North, Europe, the United States, etc., etc., all have a you know pretty similar view on what's going on and the need to oppose Ukraine, uh need to oppose Russia in Ukraine, and that Russia, you know, has invaded Ukraine.
- 50:20If you go to Africa, Latin America, and a couple of other places, maybe they say, look at you know what the United States and Israel have done in the Middle East, and you're not doing anything about that.
- 50:37Yeah, yeah.
- 50:38And I think that yeah, that so as I say, there is a north-south divide.
- 50:43And in addition to that, uh, I hate to be, you know, critical of U.S.
- 50:47foreign policy, but I I think it was a uh a mistake, you know, to basically try to bring Putin in out of the cold, you know, by having the summit meeting, you know, in uh Alaska, putting out a red carpet for him, uh, you know, the limousine, all of these things, you know, where the president was trying to feel that, well, if I'm nice to this guy, maybe we can cut a deal.
- 51:10Right.
- 51:10No way, no way, no way.
- 51:13No way.
- 51:14I mean that wishful thinking, but uh no, we learned pretty clearly that uh yeah, is there even going to be an end to this?
- 51:22I want to talk about China.
- 51:23Uh but strong tie.
- 51:25He still has strong strong ties.
- 51:26We talked about Belarus, but but Iran, uh behind the scenes, North Korea, of course, Venezuela.
- 51:33I suspect Venezuela and Cuba, and I was mentioning India.
- 51:37So there are a number of countries that are supporting them.
- 51:40Now, China.
- 51:42That that's a big uh uh you call it an elephant elephant in the room or not.
- 51:47Yes, um Xi Jinping and uh Trump met.
- 51:53And then um shortly thereafter, or even this month, uh, China and Russia have been having relationships, you know, talks and such.
- 52:03And the the language, the verbiage coming out of that is kind of incredible, and it makes you laugh, but maybe not so much.
- 52:11So early November, Xi Jinping met with the the Prime Minister, the Russian Prime Minister.
- 52:16We haven't heard much about him, uh Mishuston.
- 52:19And they reaffirmed a technocrat.
- 52:22Okay.
- 52:22So quote, comprehensive strategy, strategic partnership of coordination, and commitment to deeper cooperation.
- 52:29So we've heard a lot of this kind of wording.
- 52:32It makes you laugh, but but maybe not maybe not really.
- 52:36And you know, these statements of cooperation and but but that's uh so what's all that about that Ji Jinping.
- 52:44Are they playing both cards?
- 52:46Are they playing both sides, the the Chinese with the United States and with Russia?
- 52:52I think they they clearly are.
- 52:55What do you think?
- 52:57I would have to say one thing about our relationship with China.
- 53:01Uh, you know, the president has uh used tariffs very, very freely, and uh uh, you know, announcing them and then you know having to pull back, you know, on several of them.
- 53:14Yes.
- 53:15Uh the recent summit meeting between Xi Jinping and the president basically ended up in a draw and basically went created the um went back to the situation that existed, you know, before uh all of these uh tariffs were announced.
- 53:34Yes.
- 53:35The calculation I think that we or miscalculation, I think that we may is we neglected to think about two things.
- 53:43You know, one is that uh China was withholding, you know, buy buying soybeans, and that's a huge market for U.S.
- 53:51farmers.
- 53:52Yes.
- 53:52And the second thing is that we are dependent on the Chinese for these rare earths, these the exotic minerals.
- 53:59Um, and basically, uh, you know, what we what we held over the Chinese, you know, was our tariffs and our technology, you know, the Nvidia, uh, you know, um uh various products, you know, uh uh of theirs.
- 54:14And it ended up as a draw, you know, in this meeting, whereas I think the president thought we were going in with an advantage.
- 54:22And uh I think you know, the China relationship is still absolutely critical, and um we're just gonna have to see, you know, what happens now, you know, in this year, you know, that they've declared uh truce.
- 54:35But China has been critical, you know, to uh Russia.
- 54:39Yes.
- 54:39Uh the Chinese have picked up buying, you know, Russian oil and gas when you know the Europeans are you know turning away from it.
- 54:47Um, let me interrupt you, Ambassador, Ambassador.
- 54:50Because of the sanctions, now did not some of the um companies, uh Chinese companies, uh stop buying uh stop buying Russian gasoline, although I know that there's a natural pipeline, a natural gas pipeline that they're proposing between Russia and China.
- 55:08So didn't it have some effect, or is that just glossing it over and the sanctions really are sanctions against the Russians?
- 55:16It's a very it's it's a very, very good question.
- 55:19There already is you know a major you know gas pipeline, and they're talking about building a second one.
- 55:25Um but what you what you're mentioning now is uh you know, this is the sanctions that we put on these two major uh you know Russian oil and gas producers, yes, yes, they're also secondary sanctions.
- 55:39Uh in other words, we are going to sanction companies that buy you know Russian oil and gas despite our sanctions.
- 55:47And that, you know, that could hurt.
- 55:50You know, it's very possible, you know, that the Chinese are cutting back some, but I believe the Indians are coming back as well, because they do not want the secondary sanctions, you know, on their companies.
- 56:02Um but the major the countries that have been really buying a lot of oil, Russian oil and gas, you know, uh they're China, uh Iran, uh, and um uh Turkey have Turkey has Turkey.
- 56:16India.
- 56:16In India in India and Turkey, yeah.
- 56:19Those are the countries.
- 56:20And uh everyone that I've talked to about these latest sanctions on these two major oil exporters and gas exporters, is how tough the Trump administration is going to be on companies from India or you know, from Turkey, you know, countries that we have good relations with, how much we're gonna crack down on them, you know, if they continue to buy uh Russian oil.
- 56:44Yes, yes, yes.
- 56:46Other area, the other area where we can cut down cut hurt them is what they call the shadow fleet.
- 56:53Uh the Russians have uh gathered together a hundred or two hundred old tankers and you know, sh ships that were being scrapped and have put together a fleet, you know, God knows who owns these ships, but they're using those ships, you know, to ship you know, oil and gas.
- 57:10And again, if we can crack down on that, we can we can hurt them.
- 57:14I I could guarantee you someone's making money off of that as to who owns those ships.
- 57:19Ambassador Yalowitz, it's been a pleasure speaking with you and having you share your valuable insights.
- 57:25Thank you so much.
- 57:26My pleasure, Dr.
- 57:27Thank you.
- 57:28My pleasure, Dr.
- 57:29Musiya.
- 57:29I'll look forward to doing this again.
- 57:31Absolutely.
- 57:32So thank you so much for listening.
- 57:34I the whole uh everyone listening, I enthusiastically look forward to being with you weekly on the counter momentum of spin.
- 57:42Please note that this show and all the shows on America Out Loud Talk Radio.
- 57:47Go to your favorite podcast networks within 24 36 hours.
- 57:51So Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora.
- 57:54Tune in, Amazon, iHeartRadio, and among others.
- 57:57Have a great day.
- 57:58God bless you.