Latest / Advancing Health / Workforce Burnout: Embedding an Organizational Culture of Wellness
Transcript
- 0:00Even 15 years ago, you
- 0:02often would have searched in vain
- 0:03for a title
- 0:04like Chief Wellness Officer
- 0:06on the payroll of most employers.
- 0:08Today, the job is increasingly common
- 0:10as employers have taken note
- 0:11of the high levels of stress and burnout
- 0:13reported by their employees.
- 0:15This is especially true in health care,
- 0:17where burnout is rampant and costly.
- 0:20Not only is burnout associated
- 0:22with more errors on the job,
- 0:24but a physician
- 0:24who chooses to leave costs on average
- 0:27at least a half a million dollars
- 0:28to replace.
- 0:30This is where a robust wellness program
- 0:32can make a huge difference.
- 0:48Welcome to Advancing
- 0:49Health, a podcast
- 0:50from the American Hospital Association.
- 0:52I'm Tom Haederle with AHA Communications.
- 0:55In this podcast, Elisa Arespacochaga.
- 0:57AHA’s vice president
- 0:59for clinical affairs
- 1:00and workforce,
- 1:01speaks with an expert on developing
- 1:03organizationally wide
- 1:04wellness and well-being programs
- 1:06that are making a difference.
- 1:08As Dr.
- 1:09Kristine Olson,
- 1:10chief wellness officer
- 1:11for Yale-New Haven Hospital, says,
- 1:13it's not possible to have reliable access
- 1:15to cost effective,
- 1:16safe, high quality, patient centered care
- 1:19without high performing
- 1:20professionals and health care workers.
- 1:23Let's join them.
- 1:24Thanks, Tom.
- 1:25I’m Elisa Arespacochaga AHA,
- 1:27vice president of Clinical Affairs
- 1:28and Workforce.
- 1:28And I'm joined today by Dr.
- 1:30Kristine Olson, chief wellness officer
- 1:32for Yale New
- 1:32Haven Hospital
- 1:33and director of Work Life, Wellbeing
- 1:35Analytics, a Yale
- 1:36New Haven health system.
- 1:37And today
- 1:37we're really talking about her journey
- 1:39in developing and leading
- 1:40organizational wide wellness programs,
- 1:42what she's learned
- 1:43and what advice she has for others.
- 1:45So to get started, Kristine
- 1:46tell us a little bit about yourself
- 1:48and your role
- 1:48and how you got to where you are. Sure.
- 1:50Thank you for having me.
- 1:52It's great to be here
- 1:52and it's great to see you
- 1:53at the American Hospital
- 1:54Association is doing
- 1:56and making this a priority.
- 1:57My journey is
- 1:59I'm currently the chief
- 2:00wellness officer
- 2:01and I do the data analytics,
- 2:02as you mentioned, that's started.
- 2:05Maybe I'll do it chronologically.
- 2:06I had a grandmother
- 2:07who was very influential,
- 2:08who always helped to make life
- 2:11good for people
- 2:12outside of her family
- 2:13and was civic minded
- 2:14who encouraged my education.
- 2:16I went to the Peace Corps
- 2:17because when you have,
- 2:18you are expected to give back. There
- 2:20I learned a lot
- 2:21about what it means
- 2:22for government
- 2:23and policies
- 2:24to create the environment
- 2:26in which we thrive.
- 2:28And then I came back
- 2:29and I did medical school
- 2:31at University of Minnesota,
- 2:32where I started to look
- 2:33at the health care system.
- 2:34I’m...a system minded person.
- 2:37And I started to be curious
- 2:39and started studying that
- 2:40for the last 25 years.
- 2:42And then when health care reform
- 2:44was becoming evident
- 2:46that that was going to happen,
- 2:47I should say the internal medicine
- 2:49and pediatrics
- 2:50training at Yale-New
- 2:51Haven Hospital first.
- 2:52And then when
- 2:53health care reform was underway,
- 2:55I went to fellowship at Cornell
- 2:57for Health Services,
- 2:58Research and Epidemiology
- 2:59in 2010 to study
- 3:02the to create models of health care
- 3:04so that we could use
- 3:05professional satisfaction
- 3:07as a compass
- 3:08to tell us
- 3:09the adverse effects from health policies
- 3:11and to find
- 3:13how it was affecting
- 3:13organizational performance
- 3:15as a health care system.
- 3:16And so we could identify things
- 3:18that we could correct before
- 3:19they had adverse effects.
- 3:21So that's how I got started in that.
- 3:23And that that took me to 2015
- 3:25where I got to meet one of my mentors,
- 3:27Mark Linzer, who invited me in to a group
- 3:31that was with the early group
- 3:33of Mayo, Stanford and the AMA,
- 3:34where we were the steering committee
- 3:36for the Joy and Medicine Initiative,
- 3:39and then created the three
- 3:41domain model
- 3:42called the Stanford Model
- 3:43of Culture Climate,
- 3:45a practice efficiency and resiliency
- 3:47and the first
- 3:48recommendations for a research agenda.
- 3:51That group went to see
- 3:53the National Academy of Medicine,
- 3:55the American Conference
- 3:56of Physician Health
- 3:57and the UEC,
- 3:59the Professional Wellness
- 4:00Academic Consortium,
- 4:02of which we were early adopter.
- 4:05And that takes me into my current role,
- 4:08I should say,
- 4:08maybe how
- 4:09we socialize that at Yale as well.
- 4:11So in 2016,
- 4:13we did our first burnout assessment
- 4:16to show
- 4:17that we too
- 4:18had burnout
- 4:19similar to the national level.
- 4:21So we were seeing that
- 4:22xenophobia showing
- 4:23in the triennial surveys.
- 4:25We also couple that with a path forward
- 4:27that we had to start to work on
- 4:29and the organizational strategies
- 4:31that we put in the first step
- 4:32forward module
- 4:33at the AMA for the joy in medicine.
- 4:36So that showed that it was something
- 4:39that was dynamic in health care.
- 4:40It was temporally related
- 4:42to people entering health care,
- 4:44it was dose
- 4:44related to their FTE,
- 4:46whereas otherwise static
- 4:47in the general population.
- 4:48So we knew that it was something
- 4:50that we had to correct as an industry,
- 4:52that it was our responsibility
- 4:54and we adopted that
- 4:55through the School of Medicine
- 4:56and through the Yale-New
- 4:57Haven health system.
- 4:59And then we consolidated them
- 5:01and we're moving forward
- 5:02with that agenda.
- 5:03So you've spent a while doing this work,
- 5:05and you certainly have come about.
- 5:07I really love the idea
- 5:08that you started with this sense of
- 5:10how do you build thriving
- 5:11more broadly,
- 5:12not just in your community,
- 5:14not just among your fellow physicians,
- 5:15but really
- 5:16how do you build that
- 5:17as a community,
- 5:18as a government, as an organization?
- 5:20How do you put those structures in place?
- 5:22So you had all of that
- 5:24supporting your knowledge.
- 5:26What helped
- 5:27you refine the strategy, the messaging,
- 5:30the conversations
- 5:31specific to your health system, where
- 5:33obviously you're facing
- 5:34challenges of
- 5:36the focus areas around
- 5:37quality, around patient safety,
- 5:39around the financial pressures
- 5:41that hospitals are under.
- 5:42How did you get that
- 5:43messaging refined
- 5:44to be able to go to your colleagues
- 5:46and your leadership to say
- 5:48this is a problem
- 5:49that we have to address? It is ours too.
- 5:53One was showing that
- 5:55the numbers were consistent
- 5:56with the national numbers
- 5:58and that we had a problem
- 6:00at the organizational level.
- 6:01It wasn't something that belonged
- 6:02to individuals themselves to fix.
- 6:05We also know that the interventions
- 6:06at an organizational level
- 6:08are more effective than those
- 6:09at an individual level
- 6:10from different systematic reviews.
- 6:13A meta analysis that had been done.
- 6:16So that was a galvanizing event
- 6:18and to be able
- 6:19to put together the strategy.
- 6:21But the
- 6:22burning platform of
- 6:24not only the prevalence of the problem,
- 6:26but the fact that
- 6:28health care is dependent
- 6:29on its health care professionals
- 6:30and health care workers,
- 6:31those caregivers.
- 6:33And it's not passive role
- 6:34to have reliable access
- 6:36for the population
- 6:37that reliable access
- 6:38to cost effective quality,
- 6:40safe, high quality, patient centered care
- 6:43without high performing professionals
- 6:46and health care workers.
- 6:48So we knew that
- 6:48there was plenty of evidence
- 6:49showing that burnout is associated
- 6:52with errors
- 6:53burned out
- 6:53physicians may be present,
- 6:55but they their patients know
- 6:57that they're burned out
- 6:57and don't have
- 6:58the same kind of reciprocity
- 6:59in adherence to the recommendations
- 7:01as likely
- 7:02to follow up,
- 7:03show up and follow those recommendations.
- 7:06We knew that it was related
- 7:08to people's perception of quality,
- 7:09the idea of moral injury,
- 7:11if they weren't able
- 7:12to live up to their standards
- 7:14and we knew that
- 7:15it had a very high return on investment
- 7:17for physicians, for example,
- 7:18just the turnover costs
- 7:19alone is half
- 7:21million to $1.8 million in turnover costs
- 7:24that was in the literature
- 7:25and we validated that
- 7:26that was true at our organization
- 7:28as it was in the literature.
- 7:29So that made it a business case for it
- 7:32as well as you can't
- 7:34carry out the mission
- 7:35and you have to adopt the quadruple aim
- 7:37to include professional
- 7:38well-being and workforce well-being.
- 7:40Absolutely. Absolutely.
- 7:42We cannot care for others
- 7:43if we're not well ourselves.
- 7:44And I know that's easier said than done.
- 7:46So in addition
- 7:47to the chief science officer,
- 7:49I mentioned that you also do
- 7:50the data and analytics
- 7:52for the well-being program
- 7:53for the system.
- 7:54And I'd like you to talk a little bit
- 7:56about how you approach that work
- 7:58and some of the lessons
- 7:59that you've learned.
- 8:00Because what I've found over time
- 8:02is that this is a very hard
- 8:03subject to measure.
- 8:05It's not as easy as you did
- 8:06an intervention,
- 8:07and therefore you've seen this results.
- 8:09The indicators are very lagging.
- 8:11There's a lot of challenge
- 8:12in pinning down
- 8:13what use of help,
- 8:14what is not of help,
- 8:16and really building that evidence
- 8:18in that business case.
- 8:19So can you talk a little bit about
- 8:20what are the ways
- 8:21that you thought about those analytics
- 8:23and how have you refine that
- 8:24as you've gone forward?
- 8:25Yeah, I think first and foremost
- 8:27is always thinking of our mission.
- 8:28We assume good
- 8:29intent of everyone
- 8:31who shows up to deliver
- 8:32health care every day
- 8:33and all of the stakeholders.
- 8:34We assume that
- 8:36all of them are mission driven
- 8:37to make sure
- 8:38that people have access
- 8:39to cost effective, safe, high
- 8:40quality, patient centered care.
- 8:42So that's the number one thing
- 8:43that we're trying to accomplish.
- 8:44So those are always
- 8:45my outcomes
- 8:46that I'm thinking of as most important.
- 8:48But then to make sure that we have people
- 8:51that are engaged
- 8:52and able
- 8:52to carry out
- 8:53some of the outcomes
- 8:54that we're looking at,
- 8:55are looking at burnout.
- 8:56Let me talk about how we think
- 8:58about those outcomes of burnout.
- 8:59So there's the job demand resource theory
- 9:01that we often talk about where the
- 9:04job demands
- 9:05and the resources and latitude of control
- 9:07that you have to meet your demands.
- 9:10There may be a mismatch
- 9:11and the conservation
- 9:12of resource theory
- 9:13being that
- 9:14if you have hindering obstacles
- 9:17that prohibits you
- 9:18from being masterful in your mission,
- 9:20that you
- 9:21that makes you feel proud and inspired,
- 9:24that you are going to feel depleted
- 9:26by those obstacles
- 9:27and you're going to withdraw yourself.
- 9:29So burnout
- 9:29is a sense of a lack of accomplishment,
- 9:32and then you're feeling emotionally
- 9:33exhausted and checked out.
- 9:35Moral injury would be that you feel like
- 9:38you can't live up to your own values
- 9:40for something you did or didn't do.
- 9:42You Didn't you?
- 9:44It was a compromise of your own values
- 9:46or the compassion fatigue
- 9:47that is required to move a patient
- 9:49through a congested system
- 9:52that may have obstacles.
- 9:54So when we think about measuring
- 9:56burnout of professional fulfillment,
- 9:57we're looking to identify
- 9:58those hindering obstacles
- 10:00so we can remove those
- 10:01so that they can engage themselves
- 10:03in the challenges
- 10:04that make them satisfied
- 10:06in which they're absorbed.
- 10:07And that is the care for the patient
- 10:09And the challenge of doing that.
- 10:11The diagnose
- 10:11is the treatment, the education and care.
- 10:16So we try to find those obstacles.
- 10:19So we look for those obstacles.
- 10:20We look for the outcomes of trying
- 10:22to make sure that people
- 10:23are not burned out,
- 10:24that they're professionally fulfilled,
- 10:26that they don't intend to leave, that
- 10:27they're likely to promote the practice,
- 10:29that they
- 10:30promote, the quality of care
- 10:32that we deliver there.
- 10:34And then we look for the system,
- 10:36how the system works
- 10:37to try to identify those drivers.
- 10:39So those system elements are
- 10:42how are we as a culture
- 10:43that supports wellness?
- 10:45So if you think about the
- 10:46attitude of control,
- 10:47the professionals and people at work,
- 10:49they all want a sense of agency,
- 10:51They want voice and agency
- 10:52because they are aligned with you in
- 10:54what is to be accomplished,
- 10:56and they just want to be able
- 10:57to accomplish that.
- 10:58So if they have voice and agency,
- 11:00they are able to get the job done
- 11:03and feel good about it.
- 11:04And so you want to find a way
- 11:05to communicate with them,
- 11:07to hear from them
- 11:08so that you can identify those things
- 11:10and that
- 11:11and then take care of those obstacles.
- 11:14So what we do is we look in our culture
- 11:16to find out our leader,
- 11:18our type of wellness
- 11:19informed leadership,
- 11:21often transformational servant style
- 11:22leadership, distributive collaborative
- 11:25that brings out the voices
- 11:26and input from people that we get, input
- 11:28we seek by,
- 11:29and especially from our high stakes
- 11:31complex decision makers.
- 11:32So leadership,
- 11:33teamwork, how we work as a team
- 11:35not only in the culture of teamwork,
- 11:38but also in the way
- 11:40we share the care together,
- 11:42in the way
- 11:42we support each other as colleagues,
- 11:44and the
- 11:45sense of belonging that you fit in
- 11:47and you have that voice and agency you're
- 11:49seeing, heard, valued,
- 11:50supported and developed.
- 11:51So that's a culture.
- 11:52And then we look at the practice
- 11:54efficiency.
- 11:54Nursing might call it
- 11:56care plans
- 11:56and we might call practice efficiency.
- 11:58But our ability,
- 11:59our workload flow pace
- 12:02and our latitude of control to live up
- 12:05to our professional standards
- 12:07and do a good job for our patients.
- 12:09And then when you think
- 12:10about personal resiliency,
- 12:11you're often thinking of your ability
- 12:13to maintain work life integration
- 12:15so that you're able
- 12:16to maintain your relationships
- 12:18and your self-care and come back rested
- 12:20and recharged and ready to go.
- 12:22So we look at this environment
- 12:25to see how well people are able
- 12:27to do their jobs masterfully
- 12:29and what leads
- 12:30to their professional fulfillment
- 12:32and how those affect the outcomes
- 12:33and the mission
- 12:34that we're trying to accomplish.
- 12:36I like the idea that you really balance
- 12:38this between the individual responsible
- 12:41to come prepared
- 12:42to address those solutions,
- 12:44create those solutions, identify
- 12:46where there might be solutions
- 12:47and the system responsiveness
- 12:49to really put those into place.
- 12:50I think that that marriage
- 12:52is really essential to this work.
- 12:54So let me ask you,
- 12:55it hasn't all been sunshine and roses.
- 12:57You've obviously
- 12:58certainly faced some challenges,
- 12:59as we all have
- 13:00when we try to implement a new thing.
- 13:02We all love the idea of change
- 13:04just right up
- 13:05until it lands at our doorstep.
- 13:06So what's one of the biggest hurdles
- 13:09you face in moving forward in your role?
- 13:11And was it something that you said?
- 13:12Yeah, I know going in.
- 13:13I know this
- 13:14this department, this challenge,
- 13:16this area is going to be a problem.
- 13:18And how did you prepare for it
- 13:20if you expected it or would you do
- 13:22if it came out of the blue at you?
- 13:23Yeah,
- 13:24I think the greatest challenge has been
- 13:27what's happening around the country
- 13:28with the disruption.
- 13:29So much change in leadership.
- 13:31So as I mentioned, how we socialized on
- 13:34both the school
- 13:34medicine side and the health system side
- 13:36and then came together with the consensus
- 13:38that was just the fall of 2019
- 13:41and then 2020, the pandemic hit
- 13:44and we continued to hold the wellness
- 13:47agenda and advance it
- 13:48and move it forward,
- 13:49especially supporting psychological
- 13:52first aid and peer support
- 13:54and really focusing on that
- 13:56through the pandemic.
- 13:57Our earlier preparations
- 13:59created the Care
- 14:00for the Caregiver website
- 14:01and allowed us to be prepared
- 14:02with a safety net
- 14:03because we knew
- 14:04we had to have a safety net first
- 14:06to do the work of removing
- 14:08these obstacles that improved efficiency.
- 14:11So in 2022, today
- 14:14we've had a lot of changes
- 14:15in leadership on both sides of
- 14:18the street.
- 14:19And I think
- 14:20we're seeing that around the country
- 14:21and re socializing the agenda
- 14:24and being able to create that platform
- 14:27that then moves forward as
- 14:30things are shifting all the time.
- 14:32So I think that has been a challenge
- 14:35because you have to do it every day
- 14:37and you have to keep socializing it.
- 14:39The other thing is communications.
- 14:41I wish that I had a dedicated
- 14:43communications officer
- 14:44because there are stakeholders
- 14:47across the organization
- 14:49that are doing things
- 14:50and in
- 14:51keeping our professional fulfillment
- 14:53or health care worker well-being in mind
- 14:55in everything that they do.
- 14:57And they may see another initiative
- 14:59that's been implemented,
- 15:01but they don't see how much work
- 15:02goes behind the scenes
- 15:03to make sure
- 15:04that we implement
- 15:06this mandate as easily
- 15:08and as possible without disruption.
- 15:10So I think some of the things
- 15:11that they don't see,
- 15:12that's a challenge too,
- 15:14because you want them to see
- 15:16how much work is going into
- 15:17everything we do on their behalf,
- 15:20as you mentioned, how
- 15:21we use
- 15:21also the assessments
- 15:23to mobilize the whole health care system.
- 15:25And that is
- 15:26when we get these assessments,
- 15:28we will get them by every department
- 15:30and section for every hospital
- 15:31and delivery network,
- 15:33for every type of practice model,
- 15:35whether it's private practice,
- 15:36academic or employed.
- 15:38We will get them at every level,
- 15:39whether you're a physician, advanced
- 15:41practice clinician
- 15:42or trainee, for example,
- 15:45we will look at them
- 15:46in every way that we can
- 15:49for every hospital, every delivery
- 15:50network, every practice model,
- 15:52so that we can find
- 15:53where the positive deviants are,
- 15:55so that we can see what we can scale up
- 15:57and we can see the health
- 15:58of our delivery of health care services
- 16:02so we can see if there's a threat
- 16:03somewhere that needs to be addressed.
- 16:05And also we order all of those scores
- 16:07so that they go to our stakeholders
- 16:09so that we use that data
- 16:11driven approach
- 16:12to make policy or governance decisions
- 16:15to find out where
- 16:16service lines or services
- 16:18may be threatened,
- 16:20to find out
- 16:21which stakeholders
- 16:22can take a piece
- 16:23of that
- 16:24puzzle and implement it into their work
- 16:27as a priority.
- 16:28And then at the department
- 16:30in section level
- 16:31and then at the individual level.
- 16:33So people feel empowered for themselves.
- 16:35I mentioned that after I mentioned
- 16:36the communications person,
- 16:38because I don't think that each level
- 16:41that we implement
- 16:43vertically and horizontally,
- 16:44I don't think they all know
- 16:46how much
- 16:46the other people
- 16:47are also taking a piece of that puzzle
- 16:50so that they feel like if we all move
- 16:53and we all take a piece of this,
- 16:55that we're going to move
- 16:55our organization faster
- 16:57to make this the professional home,
- 17:00the place to be.
- 17:01Faster,
- 17:02you know, it's always a challenge
- 17:03to make sure everyone understands
- 17:05the nuances of what's being done
- 17:06and how it's being done
- 17:07and how people can help.
- 17:09And sometimes it's
- 17:10just those conversations of,
- 17:12Oh, hey, did you know about this?
- 17:13And it it can make such a difference.
- 17:15But sometimes you think
- 17:17this should happen better.
- 17:18It more routinely more standardized,
- 17:20and sometimes it's just impossible
- 17:22to get to that level of communication.
- 17:25So my last question for you
- 17:26is, you mentioned
- 17:27you've been doing this for quite a while.
- 17:28This is certainly been
- 17:29a passion for a long time.
- 17:31But how do you maintain your enthusiasm
- 17:33for this work?
- 17:33I mean, you're looking at
- 17:35something that has often been
- 17:37a side of the desk activity.
- 17:38It's not always
- 17:40had the focus and attention.
- 17:41I think it has more now, but
- 17:44how do you keep up engagement to say
- 17:46not only are
- 17:47we aiming for absence of burnout,
- 17:48but we're really aiming
- 17:49for a thriving community.
- 17:51I think that's the reason itself.
- 17:53I think being a system thinker
- 17:55and just loving the puzzles
- 17:56of this work,
- 17:57of putting systems
- 17:58together, seeing how they work
- 17:59and wanting to fix them
- 18:01so that they're more efficient
- 18:02and better.
- 18:03I also think that having done
- 18:05a lot of International Health
- 18:07and Peace Corps
- 18:08in the United States,
- 18:09we take for granted
- 18:10that we have
- 18:11a reliable health
- 18:12care system
- 18:12and I don't want anything
- 18:14to happen to that.
- 18:15I really want to
- 18:17make sure that we as a country
- 18:19have the best, most reliable
- 18:22health care in the world
- 18:23and to keep moving toward that.
- 18:25We still have a lot of work to do,
- 18:26but to keep moving toward that
- 18:27because it should be
- 18:29a real point of pride for us.
- 18:31And as it has been, as it should be.
- 18:34And I want to make sure that my parents
- 18:37in a different state
- 18:37than me have access to reliable, the best
- 18:42health care
- 18:42and my family
- 18:44and my sisters,
- 18:44my loved ones, my friends.
- 18:46I want to make sure wherever they are
- 18:47that there is a reliable health
- 18:49care system in this country.
- 18:52So how do I keep mission driven?
- 18:54I keep that in mind
- 18:55when I have obstacles.
- 18:57I remember that
- 18:58this is just a piece of the puzzle
- 19:00to keep moving
- 19:00in the direction of my calling,
- 19:02my mission.
- 19:03I use gratitude
- 19:05for having a such a problem
- 19:07to deal with these obstacles.
- 19:08I'm very grateful
- 19:09to be in a position
- 19:10now that I think of growth mindset.
- 19:13What can I
- 19:13how can they grow and learn
- 19:14from every situation that I have?
- 19:16Every difficulty?
- 19:17Grit to be persistent
- 19:19and grace to give myself grace
- 19:21and to know that I'm doing the best
- 19:23that I can with the resources that I have
- 19:25and I will keep at it.
- 19:26It sounds like you're very much
- 19:28living the mission
- 19:28of being a wellbeing officer
- 19:30and really driving
- 19:31wellness in your system.
- 19:32Thank you so much for joining me
- 19:33and for sharing your story. Thank you.