Latest / Automotive State of The Union / EV Battery Scores, Shady Lease Buyouts, AI-Generated UGC
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Monday, June 22nd. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. That's Kyle Mountzier back from the US win over Australia. We're gonna talk about that.
- 0:11But a lot of EV battery conversations and AI generated UGC. It's a good Monday morning. Kyle, tell us how you felt after going to Seattle, watching the US beat Australia in the World Cup, getting on national TV. Yeah.
- 0:25You had the whole experience. My son and I were on national TV in the preview, pre-game. That was nuts. And then the, the match was absolutely insane.
- 0:34I, I don't know why th- I'm, I'm even okay with this, but at the end of the match, the whole stadium joined in singing Country Roads. [laughs] Like, at the top of our lungs for two minutes.
- 0:46[laughs] And everybody's like, "It's our Wonderwall," which if you know English soccer- [laughs]... you know they, they, they sing Wonderwall after- I didn't know that-... the match...
- 0:53but that does feel like the appropriate song having grown up in the '90s and early 2000s.
- 0:57[laughs] Yeah, so, uh, like, there was something so magical about, "Take me home, country road," you know, and just, like, shouting it at the top of our lungs.
- 1:07You know, there was a Blackhawk flyover at the end of the national anthem. The US Men's National Team look amazing. They are stunning everybody right now.
- 1:15They look creative, and they play great football, and- Wait, wait, wait. Are you, are you saying there's a possibility Jeep might be giving away some Wranglers? Ah, don't get ahead of yourself. Okay. [laughs] Okay? Okay.
- 1:26[laughs] Don't try and get ahead of yourself right now. Tim Howard doesn't think so, I'll say that. Yeah, Tim Howard is always- He came out and said it. [laughs] No, he's a- don't li- don't listen to Tim Howard.
- 1:35[laughs] But, uh, no, listen to Zlatan. Zlatan's like, "These guys are, are legit, and they should be watched." These knees mean nothing to me...
- 1:43Thierry Henry actually back last November said, "Watch out for these guys come next summer," and now they're, now he's, now he's saying the same thing. And those guys are from across the pond, so they know what's up.
- 1:52Um, here- here's the thing. This is what, this is what I wanna get back to.
- 1:56You, you know, and, and s- you might not be able to see, but I have all these soccer scarves, and we do the soccer scarf thing at ASOTU CON every single year. And
- 2:05the th- the reason why we do that is because I was telling you, Paul, very early on, like, why, why soccer scarves exist. Mm-hmm.
- 2:13They are for the fanatics, for the fan that is obsessed with everything that is going on with that football team, and every single year you get refreshed because the energy just, like, builds and builds. And
- 2:28as I, as I was thinking, like, okay, what... Because I knew we were gonna talk about this. Okay. Yeah.
- 2:33The reality is, is when people come to ASOTU CON, when, when they get deep into this industry, when they care deeply about it, when they're passionate about
- 2:42it, it, it requires that level of fandom, that level of celebration. This is w- this is the last thing that's crazy, and, and you didn't know we were gonna say this.
- 2:50But when I go away, sometimes my youngest daughter sneaks in and, you know, fiddles with all the stuff back here- [laughs]... uh, when I, when I'm out on, uh, out of the office.
- 3:00And I landed, uh, I, I got to the office, and I haven't touched these in a while. But these two, uh, cards- Oh, yeah... were sitting next to each other right there on my desk. OG Troublemaker playing cards.
- 3:12And so if you can see, it's- Yeah... it's Troublemaker cards from our, our, like, the very first joint event that you and I stood up. That's when we decided we were gonna make this real.
- 3:19And, and it's Liza Borches and Glenn Lundy, and, uh, and, and these two people celebrate and are fans and fanatics of our industry and making it better- Mm-hmm...
- 3:31for not just the people that work in the industry but the people that do business, uh, with it. And so it was really cool to, like- Oh, what a tie-in...
- 3:38link all of that and then walk in and my daughter, unbeknownst to her, put two people next to each other that deeply care for each other and the whole industry, and so- And are fanatics...
- 3:46uh, there you go What a great way to start a week. Bring it around. Oh, man.
- 3:49We just, uh, don't wanna go too far without saying today's show is brought to you by our friends at Wide Whale, who can show you where dealership stands, your dealership stands on the FTC compliance issues, the ones they're currently scrutinizing.
- 4:01You can watch their webinar they had last week. Super helpful on this. You can go to widewhale.com/ftc and check that out. Um, also have, uh, you know, you didn't get to go.
- 4:14I got to go and hang out with all our people, uh, live in Washington, D.C. We went to the CBT Auto Leadership Summit, and we have a full recap and a lot of episodes that we recorded.
- 4:23Nathan and I were there, recorded a ton of episodes. On the ground, Scott Painter, Kevin Fried, Zach Shefska, John Fitzpatrick, Laura Perata, Sam Weaver, and some more as well.
- 4:33We have them all out, all released, easy for you to get to. Go to autocollabs.com, autocollabs.com. Go and do it. We give a shout-out to our boy Frank Ziti. Look at- Happy Father's Day. Thanks, Ziti Thank you, sir.
- 4:45Thank you, Frank. Look, shameless plug for Frank Ziti's new book, The Lost Art of Not Giving A [squishing] right? [laughs] Very, very well done. That was, that was well done.
- 4:53One of the coolest parts about this book, one of the coolest parts about this book, it came with this little name tag that you, you can't see it. Yes, yes. I love the name tag. "Hi, my name is" blank, "and I give a..."
- 5:03You know. You know. Record scratch. There you go. Record scratch. Sweet. Thanks, Frank. Hope you're having a great Monday too. All right. Let's talk about some news. Let's get to it.
- 5:10Um, this one from another one of our friends releasing a very helpful report. As battery health becomes a bigger factor in used EV valuations, a new LyteFlow, that's the company, L-Y-T-E Flow-...
- 5:21study is raising questions about how some battery scores are generated. The study found that model-based estimates consistently rated batteries as healthier than the direct measurements taken- Whoops...
- 5:33from the vehicles themselves. Lightflow compared battery scores from 150 EVs found, uh, they found that model-based estimates averaged 6.2% points higher than direct measurements from vehicle diagnostic data.
- 5:46The gap grew- Hm... for 2021 in older models, with model-based scores overstating battery health by an average of 9.3 points. In 92%- Whoops...
- 5:55of vehicles studied, the model-based score came in higher than the direct measurement, with the largest difference reaching 18 points difference from a modeled score to the actual score on a 2022 Tesla Model Y.
- 6:08Battery health is increasingly appearing on vehicle detail pages and being used to support appraisal, pricing, merchandising, and consumer-facing battery condition claims. This is, this is kind of a, a big deal.
- 6:18This is an interesting one. There's a, there's a large battle on this. You know, the, the, the reality is, is that it is going to take a long time to get direct, uh, data from a lot of these places. Yes.
- 6:29You know, the plugging into it, the telemetry. Tesla doesn't let you into the APIs of, of their batteries and, and the other manufacturers may not, uh, as well because they're still learning.
- 6:39They're still trying- That's right... to understand what's happening over time here.
- 6:42Uh, but I, I appreciate the team at, at Lightflow, Ryan Austin a good friend, um, kind of putting this out there and, and I think the dealers should be aware and consumers should be aware.
- 6:52And, and part of that awareness is dealers giving that, that ability to be aware to the consumer.
- 6:58I would say if you're not doing something to differentiate an EV's merchandising versus an ICE vehicle's merchandising in your, in your marketing, in your website, uh, then you're doing a disservice to the customer.
- 7:11So, um, at, at minimum, like find a, find, find a partner, find a, a data source that can get you some level of battery health and just some like, some information on how a shopper might be looking at that.
- 7:24M- MPGE, which is kind of the, the interesting miles per gallon electric, uh, measurement. You know, what, what, uh, it might like cost to a customer might be. Mm-hmm.
- 7:34Um, the, these are things that a customer is asking that we need to be giving them the detail on, and you should be considering how you think about measurement and displaying that information 'cause it'll be scrutinized more and more over the next couple years.
- 7:46I mean, I think this highlights, ob- obviously we're talking about some gaps, but in, in, you know, I know it's not the majority, but in an instance where they found an 18-point difference, that is a major deal. Yeah.
- 7:58And that's a major deal if a consumer finds it after they bought the EV from you. Like say you're in the high 80s and then the s- instead you're in actually like in the 60s potentially. Whoops.
- 8:07Even with that, like that's gonna be a major issue. Um, so now that we actually have some, a variety of diagnostic tools out there, I think the conversation is just gonna keep spinning out.
- 8:18Thanks to our friends for putting out report. We always like it when people put out useful reports, right? Get us all thinking, get us all- Yes... solving the right problems. Uh, it's how it moves forward.
- 8:26But speaking about EV residual rates- Hold up. Segway Segway time. [upbeat music] What could be more effective in a battery charge conversation than EV residual rate?
- 8:34Kia offering some EV lessees up to $9,900, almost 10 grand off- Oof... to buy their leased vehicle instead of turning it in.
- 8:44The program is applying to EV6, EV9, and Niro EV leases maturing this month and has some dealers asking what it says about the confidence in an EV's residual value. Wow.
- 8:55Eligible Kia EV lease, lessees can receive between 2,800 and 9,900 towards purchasing their leased vehicle outright. With participating dealers, they would receive $300 for completing the transactions.
- 9:07Customers are identified directly by, uh, Kia, Finance America, and routed back to their originating dealership.
- 9:12Every customer who buys out their lease is one less off-lease EV returning to auction, which pulls obviously a data point out of the market that we would've had, we don't have anymore.
- 9:22Some dealers see the program as a way to reduce that exposure to weak residual values from the finance company. Others view it as a missed opportunity to convert a lease customer into a, another new vehicle sale.
- 9:33As dealer Scott Falcone puts it, quote, "The fewer transactions that occur that indicate the residual was a train wreck, probably the better off the OEM is." Wow, that's a complicated one right there.
- 9:44All right, opportunistic on this side.
- 9:46I, I can't imagine being the OEM dealing with the residuals, what they're expecting, uh, w- from the market pressure of putting these vehicles back into the used car market- I mean, we remember, right?...
- 9:55and then taking a loss. Like, we know. Like you remember when it was like, "How can I lease this vehicle for 179 a month?" Oh, it's insane. This is why. But h- here's, here's, here's the trick for the dealer.
- 10:03Y- you're getting a net, a, a customer that may be net new because, uh, they, they would be coming back to, uh, the, or, or, uh, it's a, it's a, um, sorry, not net new, but it's an opportunity because they're pushing them back to y- the originating dealership to increase your customer lifetime value.
- 10:20You might not have seen them over the last two to three years, uh, just because it was a leased vehicle. And it was an EV- You get the finance opportunity... so it didn't need to come in for anything, right. Right?
- 10:28So you get the 300 bucks on the, on the quote-unquote front end of the vehicle. You get the finance opportunity. You should whip that right into a service opportunity. Treat them with the utmost care.
- 10:37Go get the other car in the garage, right? Like go find a way to increase the depth at which you care for that customer. Uh, this is like, this is like a free gift.
- 10:47You, we, we talk about recalls being a free gift to customer lifetime value and, and, and maintaining loyalty with a customer. This is the same thing. If I'm a Kia dealership, I'm excited about this opportunity.
- 10:57There you go. I love the optimistic spin on a Monday morning, but it's right. Any time a customer is coming back to you, calling, picking up the phone- Yep...
- 11:05let's look at the ha- the half full part of this equation, uh, because it's probably more than half full. Um, oh, I wish- Speaking of too full Of... [laughs] Oh, too full of- Hold up. [laughs] Segway time.
- 11:21Brands are using so much AI-generated influencers and UGC-style content in marketing campaigns, but they are often not disclosing that, uh, that the people featured aren't real.
- 11:32The Guardian found examples of brands using AI-generated people in videos and posts designed to resemble authentic customer reviews and recommendations.
- 11:4070% of people couldn't correctly identify the real or fake videos shown- I believe that...
- 11:44in recent testing, uh, by the customer group, which the rise of AI-generated UGC follows a marketing shift that began several years ago when brands started paying creators to make content that looked like everyday customer experiences rather than traditional advertisements.
- 12:00Supporters argue that the value of UGC has always been its real- liability, not necessarily whether the person on screen was a traditional influencer or content creator.
- 12:10Uh, Clarissa Mansbridge, former celebrity manager and AI creator says, "I'm gonna say about 40 to 60% of the content out there from some of the big brands is actually being made through AI, but a lot of creators are under NDA."
- 12:23Okay. So I, I like when they tie this back to, like, uh, creators that were being paid to generate, uh, UGC, and it came across as actual customer who bought the thing, and then they liked it, right?
- 12:36Like, I think that is- That's so wild... the synthesis for all this.
- 12:38This is why doing it cheaper without all the contracts and the negotiations and the egos and the price points and the professional photo shoot, all of that stuff is being held and put aside.
- 12:48However, if you remember, when a creator does that, it does have to be indicated, right?
- 12:54Promoted posts, and that's why that rule, those rules and regulations, so that you could see #promotedpost or in partnership with right on the post. I think that AI should absolutely have to be flagged right at the top.
- 13:05I don't think it's gonna be long before they do this, um, because it's the- Yeah... it's the same thing.
- 13:10At, at minimum, if there is a recommendation matrix, if, if, if it is impersonating a real user, that's, that's where it gets wild. Like, that's where it, it gets- Mm... important to me.
- 13:20You know, the, I- I think, like, some level of AI, uh, is, is probably okay to not have that in there, but the minute you start turning... And so we probably have to go to the other side.
- 13:31The minute you start turning to like, "Yeah, I bought this product, and I believe in it," you know, that's a, that's a whole different can of worms- I know... on what you can say there.
- 13:39Hey, there's only a matter of time before, if it already hasn't, this hasn't been- Just give me Brian Ortega and, and we're good. You know what I mean? Yeah, I'm in. I'm all in on Bri- more Brian Ortega, please.
- 13:49The real version. AI couldn't copy him if he tr- if they tried. Not being close. Y'all saw what happened when that, you know... Either way, head over to autocollabs.com. Check out the content from last year.
- 13:59We'll see you tomorrow. [upbeat music]