Latest / Podcast Network Insights: Understanding the Business of Podcast "Networks" / The Legal Structure Behind Different Network Models
Transcript
- 0:00Unfortunately, I've seen it often enough that
- 0:02the whole thing, the whole house of cards comes
- 0:04crashing down because they didn't have a contract
- 0:07at the outset or they didn't have a plan for
- 0:09what to do in certain circumstances. So some
- 0:12of my work is about helping develop that plan.
- 0:16I refer to it as a prenup kind of an arrangement.
- 0:19So you know what you get and when you leave.
- 0:26What kind of podcast network are you actually
- 0:28building? And how does that choice set up what
- 0:31you should be doing legally to be set up for
- 0:33success, protect yourself, and the network? Today's
- 0:38guest is a slight variation from my typical guest.
- 0:40The show typically brings on heads of podcast
- 0:43networks. But today, we're bringing on a podcast
- 0:46lawyer to help us understand the legal side of
- 0:49running a podcast network and what hosts need
- 0:53to consider before joining one. Gordon Firemark
- 0:56is an entertainment lawyer who works with podcasters
- 0:59and podcast networks. He started in live theater
- 1:02as a sound and lighting technician and later
- 1:05worked in radio, television, film, and began
- 1:07podcasting in 2009 with Entertainment Law Update.
- 1:11He's now known as the podcast lawyer and we're
- 1:14excited to have him on today's show. I'm Greg
- 1:17Wasserman, host of this amazing show, Podcast
- 1:19Network Insights. I spent 15 years in advertising
- 1:22sales, and since 2021, I've been immersed in
- 1:25the podcast ecosystem. So I believe that life
- 1:28is about time and relationships. You have no
- 1:29clue where one conversation is going to take
- 1:31you. I've had many conversations and built many
- 1:34relationships with different kinds of podcasters,
- 1:36whether they're solo creators just getting started
- 1:38or like the guests of my show, podcast network
- 1:41industry leaders. If you've ever wondered whether
- 1:44joining a network makes sense, how these networks
- 1:47actually run, other networks you could explore
- 1:49joining, advertising with, partnering with, learning
- 1:52from, well then my goal is to make it really
- 1:55simple and give you behind the scenes looks you
- 1:58can confidently navigate, whether you host, produce,
- 2:02sponsor, or run a network. As you listen to today's
- 2:05conversation, ask yourself, are we covered for
- 2:08that? Did we think of that? You may also find
- 2:12yourself saying, whoo, glad we handled that,
- 2:15or we need to take care of that. Either way,
- 2:19this conversation will likely surface a few details
- 2:21to button up, whether you're a host or running
- 2:24a network. And stay tuned after the interview
- 2:27as there's more to this conversation as I share
- 2:29some of my key takeaways. With that said, it's
- 2:32time to learn from Gordon. Well, Gordon, the
- 2:36show is called Podcast Network Insights, so I
- 2:39always like to start with the first question
- 2:41being, when you hear Podcast Network, what does
- 2:43that mean to you? What comes to mind? What comes
- 2:46to mind is a question. What kind of network?
- 2:50You know, there are lots of different kinds There's
- 2:53the I think the ones that we think of in the
- 2:55commercial arena are the ones that are about
- 2:59aggregating programming and aggregating Advertising
- 3:02and doing the ad sales and and then distributing
- 3:05the revenue across the shows that are carrying
- 3:08those ads Uh, but there are the, you know, more
- 3:11social minded ones that are just about a group
- 3:14of podcasters kind of collaborating, I'll call
- 3:16it almost a co -op network. And, uh, there are
- 3:19some networks that are thematically aligned and
- 3:22may not be about the ad sales, but it's a bunch
- 3:25of shows about history or a bunch of shows about
- 3:27science or something like that. So what kind
- 3:30is the, the first question we have to get through?
- 3:33Um, because it does affect some of the business
- 3:36and legal approaches to things. What does it
- 3:39mean to you? I'm not sure I understood the question.
- 3:42What does what mean to me? Oh, podcast network.
- 3:46You pushed it back and said, all right, it depends
- 3:48on what kind, so... Well, it's useful to me in
- 3:54working with networks and representing podcasters
- 3:57to know... What is the goal here? What's the
- 4:01objective? So if it's the commercial style, then
- 4:04I have a pretty good picture of how to deal with
- 4:06that. And it's very similar in a lot of ways
- 4:07to a television network or a streaming company
- 4:10or something like that. But ultimately, it comes
- 4:15down to what's going in the contract, what's
- 4:17going in the agreement between the various podcasts
- 4:20and the network itself. And in those more social
- 4:24oriented networks, it's more of a collaborative.
- 4:28vibe, and in the commercial, I'm going to use
- 4:32that term, the commercial network, it's more
- 4:35of an acquisition of the show by the network,
- 4:39at least for a period of time, and a series of
- 4:42promises back and forth that are going to hold
- 4:44each other accountable. And so this is what I
- 4:46love. In a sense, I asked the question twice
- 4:50in teasing the fact because like, Those that
- 4:53know you, know that you're the podcast lawyer
- 4:55and we're gonna be having a deep conversation
- 4:58on podcast and the legal side of it. And those
- 5:01that don't know you will be like, okay, well,
- 5:04he's asking this question to understand, but
- 5:06then you threw in, it's like, I'm asking this
- 5:08because at the end of the day, it comes down
- 5:10to the legal side of it. And that's what we're
- 5:12gonna be spending most of our time here talking
- 5:14about, which is fun. You know, the fact that...
- 5:19You as a lawyer are always looking, hey, I can
- 5:22write whatever contract we need, but it depends
- 5:25on what are we trying to accomplish here. And
- 5:28part of them guessing your job as a lawyer is
- 5:30to go like, I'm here to protect you. So I'm going
- 5:31to ask a lot of questions so we can make sure
- 5:33we're covering this. So my job is to find out
- 5:37from the questions that I have to ask. Like if
- 5:40I'm starting a podcast network, what should I
- 5:42be thinking about Gordon? Yeah, you know, I left
- 5:45out one other kind of network that's sort of
- 5:48a hybrid. Well, not hybrid, but it's got the
- 5:51advertising commercial side of it, but it's also
- 5:53a production company in a way. And it's actually
- 5:56maybe financing and funding the production, or
- 5:58maybe it's being paid by the podcasts themselves
- 6:01for the production services, and then also sort
- 6:05of bolting on those ad sales and distribution
- 6:08parts of things on the side too. So, yeah, it
- 6:11really comes down to, you know... What kind of
- 6:13network is it? But also why, asking both sides
- 6:16of the equation, why are we doing this? Why are
- 6:19we forming this network? Or for the host, why
- 6:21do I need to be a part of the network? So would
- 6:24it be best to like, let's tackle? I feel like
- 6:27you've been listening to this show by the fact
- 6:29that you're grouping all my guests into the buckets
- 6:33that I'm grouping them into. So let's start with
- 6:35the main one that most of us know. If I'm starting
- 6:38a commercial enterprise as a network, from a
- 6:42podcast monetization standpoint, what should
- 6:46I be doing to protect myself? What should I be
- 6:48even thinking about to protect myself and to
- 6:50make this entity the best possible opportunity
- 6:55I've got as a network? Well, from the network
- 6:59side, the concerns are, what are the rights that
- 7:02we're acquiring to the show? Preferably, it's
- 7:07an exclusive right to carry that show so that
- 7:09it's not anywhere else, nobody else is selling
- 7:11ads against the show, and we don't have confusion
- 7:13in the marketplace by it being distributed multiple
- 7:15ways. Ownership becomes an issue because many
- 7:20times podcasters are very concerned about my
- 7:22intellectual property. And I put that in air
- 7:25quotes for those that are just listening because
- 7:27yes, that's a valid concern, but it's not always
- 7:30that... important because an exclusive right
- 7:32to distribute something forever, but you're not
- 7:35transferring the ownership of the intellectual
- 7:37property. Same difference. The creator still
- 7:40doesn't have any other rights left. So sometimes
- 7:43it's short -sighted to be worried about the intellectual
- 7:46property side. Let's really focus on what are
- 7:48we actually getting out of it. The network wants
- 7:51to have a good long time to distribute that show.
- 7:53They want to have the exclusive right to distribute
- 7:57it and to sell the ad inventory within the show.
- 8:00Sometimes the hosts will have a right to sell
- 8:02their own inventory as well. And then we get
- 8:04into how do we split that revenue versus the
- 8:07traditional advertising revenue. And we get into
- 8:12questions about what happens at the end. Most
- 8:14of the questions in these network deals are actually
- 8:16what happens at the end of the relationship.
- 8:18We've been in this for three or four years and
- 8:20someone's no longer happy. Maybe the network
- 8:22has concluded that... We're just not able to
- 8:25sell enough against the show or it's just not
- 8:27profitable for us. Or maybe the hosts have decided,
- 8:29you know, we could do better on our own or we
- 8:32just don't feel we've been treated well or who
- 8:34knows what. So how do we work the ending of the
- 8:37deal? And for networks, a lot of times the concern
- 8:40is, hey, we built up the show from, say, 5 ,000
- 8:44listens per month or per episode to 50 ,000 or
- 8:48500 ,000. And so we want to hold on to the tail
- 8:52end of that. so that we can realize the fruits
- 8:56of our labor, I guess you could say. And it's
- 8:58a hard one to navigate sometimes. Brand ownership
- 9:03is another one for the title of the show. You
- 9:05know, is the network the exclusive holder of
- 9:07the right to that title? And then if the host
- 9:09decides to go somewhere else, do they have to
- 9:11rebrand the show to reflect that it's no longer
- 9:13on that network? Lots of things like that. I
- 9:18think that's pretty well, oh, and the ownership
- 9:20of the RSS feed, of course, is hugely important
- 9:22because that's the the archive of the show is,
- 9:27well, the content is one side, but the RSS feed
- 9:29is essentially the audience, ownership of the
- 9:31audience. So when I'm talking to podcasters,
- 9:34they're often very concerned about when the relationship
- 9:36ends, do we get our RSS feed back or do we have
- 9:39to start fresh? And that can be a real challenge.
- 9:42Do you see typically the answer to that is yes?
- 9:45I mean, I know looking at most of my guests and
- 9:48I know we're recording this, you know, call episode
- 9:5130ish or so. So I've gotten many more networks
- 9:54to do, but it feels like most of the guests that
- 9:57I'm bringing on, they're like, look, if you don't
- 9:59want to be here, we don't want you and we'll
- 10:01let you go. What is it? Minimum guarantees, which
- 10:06you don't see too much these days, but we still
- 10:08see that occasionally. You're like, all right,
- 10:11here's the minimum guarantee, and once it's done,
- 10:13it's done. But like, to your point, do you see
- 10:16that as an issue? People are like, all right,
- 10:19the end of this contract? No? Like, do you find
- 10:23fights happening, or your job is actually to
- 10:25mitigate that fight to even happen in the first
- 10:27place? I think it's more to mitigate it, although
- 10:29I do encounter situations where the relationship
- 10:32was not clearly defined at the outset, and they've
- 10:35gone forward together for a few years. then someone
- 10:38is either unhappy or sees brighter opportunities
- 10:42on the horizon and they want to break the relationship
- 10:45up. I think what really has to be considered
- 10:49is, well, it's a sliding scale. It's easy for
- 10:52a network to say, well, we don't have that much
- 10:54invested in this show. So yeah, we'll let you
- 10:56have your RSS feedback. But if you're making
- 10:58a big investment on the front end somehow, either
- 11:00you're putting in a lot of production services
- 11:02or marketing and promotion services or who knows
- 11:05what. then you're gonna wanna recoup that investment
- 11:08before you let the RSS feed go, let the show
- 11:11go. And so sometimes there has to be mechanisms
- 11:14for that or payouts, buyouts, buybacks, all kinds
- 11:17of things. And I've seen enough deals go in multiple
- 11:20directions that I can't say there's one perfect
- 11:24solution. All right, so we covered, I don't wanna
- 11:28spend too much time on I guess the standard monetization
- 11:32kind of networks because It feels like at least
- 11:36in this conversation. It's kind of standard boilerplate
- 11:40We just got to figure that out. So but those
- 11:43collectives I mean that becomes an interesting
- 11:46point where all right, we're gonna Come together.
- 11:50I've got you know, I look at some of my guests
- 11:53that are running collectives It's like we're
- 11:54gonna bring everyone under the same hosting platform.
- 11:57So I'm sure is a question of like RSS feed ownership
- 12:00marketing but like that becomes a very different
- 12:06business model because most of them that are
- 12:08running collectives aren't truly running it from
- 12:11the monetization and that's not like their bread
- 12:12and butter. So am I going to spend the money
- 12:16to hire a Gordon and set myself up? Am I opening
- 12:21myself for legal issues if I don't? So I think
- 12:24that's where we should probably spend a little
- 12:27time understanding how those collectives and
- 12:30those communities should be leveraging, you know,
- 12:33Gordon Firemark's legal services. I think it's
- 12:37common in the podcasting industry writ large
- 12:40that folks don't want to spend the money on lawyers
- 12:43and the business side of things until they're
- 12:45very serious about it being a business. And I
- 12:48guess what I would say to those folks that are
- 12:50doing one of these collectives or call it a circle
- 12:52or collab or whatever you want to call it, it's
- 12:55becoming a business whether you like it or not.
- 12:57And what you're doing is going to have legal
- 12:59wrinkles. And the good news I can share with
- 13:01you is it doesn't have to be a very expensive
- 13:03proposition to get me on board to at least give
- 13:06some advice and get you pointed in the right
- 13:08direction. And to write up a contract, assuming
- 13:11it's relatively straightforward, equal sharing,
- 13:15equal chipping in, those kinds of things, that's
- 13:17not all that complicated either. So we're looking
- 13:19at, you know, everybody. putting in maybe a few
- 13:22hundred dollars to make this happen at the outset.
- 13:25And then, you know, as issues come up a little
- 13:27bit here and there, maybe a little bit more once
- 13:30a year or something like that. So hopefully it's
- 13:34not such a big bite to chew. So would you and
- 13:40no, I'm going to have a I'm going to cover the
- 13:42financial side with a different guess because
- 13:44I think that's good. But like. I'll ask the lawyer
- 13:47the financial question, but if I'm charging,
- 13:50I don't know, $5 to $25 a month for someone to
- 13:54join the network, call that $6 to $10 grand.
- 13:58I mean, that's not nothing, but that's not enough
- 14:01to live off of. Is it worth it to invest or charge
- 14:07more to cover the legal fees? Give us a little
- 14:12understanding of how to think about that because,
- 14:15yes, you're 100 % right. Anyone that's listening
- 14:17to this is probably going, probably knows the,
- 14:21yes, I hate those people that aren't willing
- 14:23to pay for podcast hosting. They just want the
- 14:26free, yada, yada. And I'm guilty of it, too.
- 14:29We all are, right? Sure. Yeah. Well, I think,
- 14:34you know, look, it is an investment. And it should
- 14:36be viewed as an investment. It's not just about
- 14:38what you're spending today. It's about what you're
- 14:41spending today to avoid a problem later on and
- 14:44what the potential cost of that problem could
- 14:46be. I'll tell you that a dispute over someone
- 14:49wanting to get out of a network or leaving, if
- 14:51there's any reason for there to be a dispute,
- 14:53sometimes people just get attitudes about things
- 14:55and want to fight, that can be tenfold or a hundredfold
- 14:59more expensive than getting things set up on
- 15:02the front end. And I know that sounds like an
- 15:04ad for legal services, and it is to a certain
- 15:07extent. But unfortunately, I've seen it often
- 15:09enough that, you know, the whole thing, the whole
- 15:14house of cards comes crashing down because they
- 15:17didn't have a contract at the outset or they
- 15:19didn't have a plan for what to do in certain
- 15:22circumstances. So some of my work is about helping
- 15:26develop that plan. I refer to it as a prenup
- 15:29kind of an arrangement. So you know what you're
- 15:31getting when you leave. I can imagine since part
- 15:35of the reason I started the show was around podcasters
- 15:39who are unhappy with their network and going,
- 15:42hey, six months in. So on the legal side, I have
- 15:45to imagine you come across either, how do I help
- 15:49this network mitigate quote unquote, what are
- 15:52the right expectations, you know, air quotes
- 15:55for anyone that's, that's listening because.
- 15:59six months in, I want out of this contract or
- 16:02you aren't filling the promise or the expectations
- 16:06of the growth you promised me, the money you
- 16:08promised me. Would you say like that's a good
- 16:11portion of where either A, you're helping mitigate
- 16:14the contract and that issue or those issues come
- 16:17up and you're like, all right, what do I do here?
- 16:20You know, I'm not sure how I would characterize
- 16:24most of the folks that come to me with a network
- 16:26issue or a network problem from either side.
- 16:29It's usually someone is unhappy, justifiably
- 16:36or not, with how things are going. Oftentimes
- 16:38it's because expectations weren't set very well
- 16:40at the very beginning of things. And I recently
- 16:43gave a presentation where I talked about, you
- 16:45know, there's the pitch and there's the contract.
- 16:48The pitch is going to be very optimistic. It's
- 16:50the, you know, it's the first date presentation
- 16:52of who we are. The contract is the marriage.
- 16:56the relationship and oftentimes it doesn't reflect
- 17:00what was in the pitch. Well, I'm sorry to say
- 17:02that pitch was all marketing and the contract
- 17:05is the actual business deal. Hopefully networks
- 17:09and podcasters are responsible about how they
- 17:13approach that and they don't over promise and
- 17:15then under deliver. In fact, I would say most
- 17:17probably do the opposite. An opportunity comes
- 17:21along to over deliver and most of the networks
- 17:23will jump at it because it's good for everybody.
- 17:25It's profitable. So I guess if I'm asking the
- 17:29questions of like most, I guess I'll turn and
- 17:32ask different questions in terms of like, what
- 17:34are the issues that you tend to when you're working
- 17:37with podcast networks? What are some of the standard
- 17:41boilerplate this constantly comes up? And what
- 17:44are the one -off things that you've seen that
- 17:46anyone that's listening, thinking about running
- 17:48or starting a network should start mitigating
- 17:52themselves for? It's really not all that complicated.
- 17:57It's a question of what are the deliverables
- 17:59on each side, and what are the expectations,
- 18:02and what are the solutions when one party or
- 18:04the other doesn't meet the expectations? Is there
- 18:08an opportunity to fix it, to cure? Or is it,
- 18:10hey, you're in breach of contract and we're going
- 18:12to hold your feet to the fire? That's not productive
- 18:14in most instances, unless it's an ongoing continuing
- 18:17problem. So deliverables. Well, if you're the
- 18:21network, you expect the podcaster to deliver
- 18:24a show of consistent quality on a consistent
- 18:28timeline with consistent duration and consistent
- 18:32inventory for ads, if that's what you're doing,
- 18:34right? And the host expects that the network
- 18:37is going to provide the hosting and selling those
- 18:41ads and actually filling that inventory. And
- 18:43then ultimately where the biggest disputes come
- 18:46from is, I haven't been paid. What gives? And
- 18:51I'll say, I think that one of the biggest problems
- 18:54in the space, and this is an accounting issue,
- 18:56is many of the contracts these days still, even
- 19:00though this is a maturing industry, they still
- 19:02provide that we the network won't pay you the
- 19:05podcaster until we get paid by the sponsor. And
- 19:08one failing I've noticed in many networks is
- 19:11they're real good at selling the ads. They're
- 19:13not so good at collecting the money. Not often
- 19:18I've seen it enough that they didn't even really
- 19:20try to collect the money send out an invoice
- 19:22send out a follow -up invoice Oh gosh, it's 90
- 19:24days now what and they're there again not hiring
- 19:27me or a lawyer to the collection. They're not
- 19:31Chasing it at chasing after it. They're not selling
- 19:33it over to a collection agency They're just sort
- 19:35of letting it go and the podcasters they're sort
- 19:37of holding an empty bag What I would like to
- 19:40see more of is a little better capitalization,
- 19:43at least on the commercial side of the networks,
- 19:46a little better capitalization so they can actually
- 19:49pay for the ads when the ads are delivered. And
- 19:52it's the network's problem to collect the money.
- 19:55I think that if they're the ones holding that
- 19:58empty bag, they're going to be better about collecting
- 20:00it. Right now, that's a recurrent problem I encounter
- 20:05when clients call me up and say, I'm having a
- 20:07problem. It's often about how they got paid.
- 20:11With the more collaborative co -op style networks,
- 20:15it's a bigger issue because whose job is it to
- 20:18do the collection? So in that instance, they
- 20:21should probably be contracting with an ad agency
- 20:25because no one of those podcasters that's joining
- 20:27together in this way is going to be exceptional
- 20:30at selling ads. So get the pros involved in that.
- 20:32Again, you're giving up a piece of the action,
- 20:34but a piece of something is better than all of
- 20:37nothing. So, I mean, I have to laugh having been
- 20:43in the ad industry for the last 20 years or so
- 20:46and going like, all right, I know exactly what
- 20:48it's like to sell it and then try to get my quarterly
- 20:53or yearly commission on what I've sold and go
- 20:55like, Craig, until we collect, which means it's
- 20:58got to go to the agency, the agency, the brand
- 21:01and the trickle down of either a net 30, net
- 21:0360 or if you're a... a very unfortunate net 90.
- 21:08So what I'm gathering here is actually one of
- 21:11those reasons if you're listening in your podcast,
- 21:14you're like, what to think about in terms of
- 21:16if you join a network versus you selling your
- 21:19own stuff as an independent, what your, not only
- 21:22what your take home is going to be, but how quickly
- 21:24you're going to get that take home opportunity
- 21:26because someone else has to get paid before you
- 21:29can get paid. And if they don't get paid, You're
- 21:33not getting paid and it seems in this scenario
- 21:36And it's a problem between networks and ad sales
- 21:39agencies also the same issue the network doesn't
- 21:41get paid until the agency collects And I've seen
- 21:44those agencies You know push push push make a
- 21:47lot of sales get a lot of orders in You know
- 21:50it's when it comes time to actually collect actually
- 21:52seen a couple of network not networks a couple
- 21:54of agencies Kind of fold up shop and go away
- 21:56and just left networks and shows Hanging with
- 22:00no recourse And so that goes to, once again,
- 22:05if anyone's listening to this and you're thinking
- 22:06about joining a network, like joining a new network
- 22:10or joining an established networking and asking
- 22:12those questions in terms of like, this is, you're
- 22:15the first person bringing up, you know, like
- 22:17what's your collection like, you know, how quick
- 22:20you're getting paid, how often you've, or I guess
- 22:24what percentage of your ads are covered by, I
- 22:29actually have no clue what the right question
- 22:30is off the top of my head. You know where I'm
- 22:32going. Yeah. The point is do the due diligence.
- 22:35Ask these questions. And I think it's reasonable
- 22:38to say, what's your collection rate like and
- 22:40what's your timeline from ad insertion to actual
- 22:45podcast or receiving the money? And it makes
- 22:50sense to do some reference checking. Ask some
- 22:52other shows on the network. How's it going? What's
- 22:55the experience been like? And from the network
- 22:58side of it, I think you want to get those numbers
- 23:01together and at least in part on making sure
- 23:05that metric makes sense for everybody involved.
- 23:09Since we're talking about collection, let's think
- 23:12about the scenario where, because it happens,
- 23:16I've got a lot of guests where the podcaster
- 23:21is able to sell their own stuff. The network,
- 23:23of course, is able to sell their stuff. Of course,
- 23:27if the podcaster sells it, there's a different
- 23:28commission rate or a different percentage that
- 23:30they get versus if the network gets it. You're
- 23:33helping write those and thinking about all those
- 23:36different scenarios within the contract in itself,
- 23:40right? And therefore, the network should be thinking
- 23:42about how do we want this to legally operate?
- 23:46Absolutely. The truth is... The sale is just
- 23:51one part of the whole equation because then the
- 23:54network also has to, or the advertising agency
- 23:56or whoever has to serve the service, the deal.
- 24:00And so yes, the commission rate or the percentage
- 24:03that the network keeps should be maybe a little
- 24:06bit different, an adjustment downward if they're
- 24:08not doing the actual sale. If the podcaster brings
- 24:11in the show, yeah, they should get a little more.
- 24:16podcasters often think, well, I should keep it
- 24:17all. Well, no, someone's still got to service
- 24:19that client. So that's something I had to speak
- 24:24frankly with both sides about occasionally. Coming
- 24:28to mind, the scenario I know you've talked about
- 24:31multiple times, a show that never captured the
- 24:38branding on their show name, another show came
- 24:40out. So if that show's under a network, And they're
- 24:45now getting sued because, hey, copyright infringement
- 24:49or whatever the legal terms are, is the network
- 24:53on the hook for this or no? How does that work?
- 24:58Well, I think that's part of the network's due
- 25:01diligence when bringing on shows. They have to
- 25:03know that the show is legally free and clear.
- 25:09In other industries, you refer to it as sort
- 25:11of a chain of title. Do they actually own what
- 25:13they think they own and what they're selling
- 25:14us? The network wants to know that they're not
- 25:17going to be on the hook for something like a
- 25:19trademark infringement because they're carrying
- 25:20a show that that uses another show's brand. They
- 25:24want to make sure that the hosts have signed
- 25:26contracts. And so this is really all plays to
- 25:29from the host side. They need to get their house
- 25:32in order before they go into the network deal.
- 25:35Otherwise they're going to spend the first six
- 25:36months of the network deal doing all that, getting
- 25:39the house in order. And they won't be really
- 25:41in a position to. monetize the show the way they
- 25:44want to until that's all done so I Think that's
- 25:48uh, I think anyone listening. That's a key piece
- 25:50if you're running a network Those are some of
- 25:53the onboarding questions and actually not even
- 25:55onboarding questions pre qualifying questions
- 25:58Forget just the how many downloads do you have?
- 26:02It's it's Tell me about your legal structure
- 26:05so that I can protect myself as a network if
- 26:08I'm bringing you on board, as opposed to the
- 26:11network contract that you're helping set up for
- 26:15them. Right. And when I'm talking to networks,
- 26:19it's important that we remind them that not all
- 26:22shows are alike. A one -person show who produces
- 26:24it, edits it, and delivers it himself, That's
- 26:27easy. It's a contract between the person and
- 26:29the network, and they have to make the promises.
- 26:31And the promises we're talking about, about ownership
- 26:34and rights, free and clear and all that, they're
- 26:36in the contract. They're always in the contract,
- 26:38but oftentimes neither side really pays much
- 26:41attention to that. Oh yeah, it's, yeah, yeah,
- 26:43whatever. So one of the conversations we try
- 26:46to have is, is this really the case? and asking
- 26:51those questions. When you're dealing with a show
- 26:53that has multiple hosts and multiple producers
- 26:55and a team of people and that kind of stuff,
- 26:58now we have to get into what's the legal structure?
- 27:00Is everybody under contract? Is anybody going
- 27:03to leave? And now we've got a different show
- 27:05than what we originally signed to the network.
- 27:08And are there any other outside obligations?
- 27:11And that's when we're looking for usually an
- 27:13LLC or at least some kind of a partnership agreement.
- 27:17Contracts with all the independent contractors
- 27:19that are working on the shows and yeah Do you
- 27:21own the title of your show and how can you prove
- 27:23it if it ever came down to it? I deal every day
- 27:26with Show title disputes where hey they came
- 27:29along and they're using the same title I did
- 27:32and it turns out they were using it first or
- 27:34I was using it first But it was only a few weeks
- 27:37earlier, you know all these kinds of things and
- 27:39so Worth it examining that that's part of the
- 27:43intellectual property that we're laying claim
- 27:45to so And that and the title piece, and if you're
- 27:49saying you're seeing a lot of disputes on that,
- 27:51you think about how many shows that probably
- 27:54have very similar names as a network operator.
- 27:59It's like, should I be doing the due diligence
- 28:01of, okay, let me go figure out this show name.
- 28:05Can I find other shows in it and then go back
- 28:08to them? Or should I, as a network operator,
- 28:10relying on them to have done the due diligence?
- 28:13Like, what level of work should I be doing? Because
- 28:16that sounds like a lot more extra work just to
- 28:19prove, but cover my butt, right? Yeah. I mean,
- 28:22I don't think the network, I don't think it's
- 28:24incumbent upon them to do a deep dive research.
- 28:27I think they have to ask the question, do you
- 28:29own this title and how do you know? If they say
- 28:32I have a trademark, great. What's the number?
- 28:34You know, what's the trademark number? And let's
- 28:36just make sure. The other thing we need to remember
- 28:38is that trademarks are territorial. So having
- 28:41a trademark in one country doesn't necessarily
- 28:43mean you're free and clear in other countries.
- 28:45So it may make sense for, especially for the
- 28:49more descriptive or the more on the nose kinds
- 28:52of titles to do a little dig, a little digging
- 28:55into it and ask this question beyond just the
- 28:58promise from the producer of the show. But ultimately
- 29:02I think it is incumbent on the producer of the
- 29:04show to know. hey, there's six other shows out
- 29:07there with the same or very similar titles, and
- 29:10here's how we distinguish ours. Maybe it's the
- 29:12artwork, maybe it's the name of the host is listed,
- 29:15something like that, and that'll come into play
- 29:17with the artwork and the branding of the show
- 29:19once it's on the network. It isn't necessarily
- 29:21a deal killer that you don't own a registered
- 29:24trademark, even if there are other shows out
- 29:26there. If we can sort of make a reasoned analysis
- 29:29why it doesn't matter that there's no registered
- 29:31trademark, we move forward. I'll take the line
- 29:36here, you're bringing up international podcasting.
- 29:39Defining what a podcast is, right? Media distribution
- 29:42these days, but it's global. So where does the
- 29:47global, where does what you do for mitigation
- 29:50in the global world come in? Because I can imagine
- 29:55the saying, I'm big in Japan, but I'm based here
- 29:59in LA. There's a difference there from a legal
- 30:02standpoint. Yeah, it's a hard question to answer.
- 30:07I mean, I think we focus on the home base for
- 30:10the show. Where's home? It can be multiple homes.
- 30:13Like you said, if you're big in one particular
- 30:14country, even though you don't live there, maybe
- 30:17you want to double down and get the protections
- 30:19there as well. And I do sometimes advise shows
- 30:22or folks to, you know, let's, yeah, let's register
- 30:25it internationally. There are ways to... protect
- 30:28the trademark in multiple places. And once you
- 30:30have it in one place, it's easier for the next
- 30:32and the next, but it's expensive. So it's often
- 30:35a sort of financial triage kind of an analysis
- 30:38that goes into it too. How many, how much audience
- 30:40do you have there? What's the risk and likelihood
- 30:42that someone else is going to come into that
- 30:44market with a similar show and cause confusion
- 30:47that causes problems. And is that going to have
- 30:49an impact on ad sales or distribution? Yeah,
- 30:55exactly. Sometimes it's a nothing burger and
- 30:57we can sort of, hey, we're good here. Most of
- 31:00our listeners are here. We won't worry about
- 31:02it over there. And the U .S. is where most of
- 31:06the litigation happens because we're that kind
- 31:07of country. With the saying, I'll sue you is
- 31:11yeah, you don't hear that in any other country.
- 31:14All right. So before we look at the host and
- 31:17more in depth, what else, if I'm a network operator,
- 31:20what else should I be considering thinking about?
- 31:25What I mean, you've got the floor here. Hey network
- 31:28operators Go for it Well again, it's it's what
- 31:35kind of a deal are we doing? You know, if the
- 31:37network is one of these that is funding the production
- 31:39of the show Then it wants to have the contracts
- 31:43with the artists that I should say the hosts
- 31:45or the the talent Directly rather than through
- 31:48the producer of the show as an intermediary most
- 31:51of the time Because They want to have free course
- 31:56if the host leaves, they don't want to have to
- 31:59wait for the production company or whatever to
- 32:01intervene, for the producer to intervene. So
- 32:04sometimes it's a question of are they an employee
- 32:06of the network? Are they an employee of the production
- 32:09company or are they independent contractors?
- 32:12And this is where it can be tricky and a lot
- 32:14of network owners and operators don't realize
- 32:16that if the person who's working is not categorized,
- 32:22classified correctly, If we say that person's
- 32:26an independent contractor, so we'll just cut
- 32:27them a check and they worry about everything
- 32:28else. And we're wrong that they don't meet the
- 32:31legal definition of an independent contractor.
- 32:33If they look like an employee to the government,
- 32:37both state and federal, then we the employer,
- 32:41whichever entity that may be, can be on the hook
- 32:44for back taxes and penalties and fines and...
- 32:49possibly even criminal liability for trying to
- 32:52defraud the government of tax revenue that it's
- 32:54expecting. And it's hard to reach back to the
- 32:58talent and say, hey, you know, you didn't pay
- 33:00taxes. We need it back from you. You're not getting
- 33:03it back from them. Maybe you dock future pay
- 33:06or something. Again, if the contract allows that.
- 33:09So this question of classifying the talent is
- 33:13an important one that I think is overlooked more
- 33:15often than recognized. And of course, keeping
- 33:21up with your taxes and your insurance and those
- 33:23kinds of things are all big things for networks
- 33:25as well. Are you seeing, I guess to that point,
- 33:28are you seeing networks, and I just think about
- 33:33the guests I've had on the show so far and those
- 33:35that I'm bringing on. Are you seeing, based on
- 33:39where you're at from a legal standpoint, more
- 33:42networks hiring talent as opposed to... No, I
- 33:51think the 1099 is much more common. In fact,
- 33:56if the show is set up as a company, an LLC or
- 33:59a corporation, then it is a contract relationship
- 34:04and the company is responsible for paying whoever's
- 34:07working on the show. But that consequence of
- 34:10not doing it right can trickle up to the network
- 34:12or down to the network, depending on how you
- 34:15look at it. And so it is something we just need
- 34:17to be, again, asking and looking at, are they
- 34:20signed to contracts and what's the structure?
- 34:21That's why these questions are so important at
- 34:23the outset, that due diligence part of the relationship
- 34:29because, you know, it's just about going in with
- 34:32your eyes open and addressing problems before
- 34:35they become real problems. I feel like Gordon's
- 34:38new title after the end of this episode is no
- 34:40longer the podcast lawyer. He's added the podcast
- 34:44lawyer and strategist, because really at the
- 34:46end of the day, your job is asking all the right
- 34:49questions so that you can create the legal side
- 34:52of it. But if you think about most of us that
- 34:55are doing strategy or helping a podcast understand
- 34:59why you're doing it now but with the legal lens
- 35:02behind it. Yeah, I mean, maybe it's professional
- 35:06worrier. At least the part of it and then it's
- 35:10switch hats and become the one who solves the
- 35:11problem. So we don't have to worry anymore. That's
- 35:13really the role. So if we now look at the host,
- 35:17what are the red flags that a podcast who's looking
- 35:21at going to a network should be looking at? Well,
- 35:25if it's a brand new network with no track record,
- 35:27I think there's a lot more conversation that
- 35:29needs to happen. The the accounting terms and
- 35:33payment terms is definitely something we need
- 35:35to be thinking about What is the consequence
- 35:37of if you don't get paid? You know, how do you
- 35:41handle that? I'm trying the other other red flags
- 35:44in network deals for talent or hosts I should
- 35:48say Well a lot of network deals that I've seen
- 35:53when I'm looking at them from a host's point
- 35:56of view is It's really unclear what the network's
- 35:58promising to do, you know Promising to try isn't
- 36:02the same as promising to sell us a fixed number
- 36:04of ads per episode or achieve a certain Revenue
- 36:08threshold. So that's one of the things I'll try
- 36:09to pin them down with is look Understand that
- 36:13it's you're starting out from ground zero with
- 36:15every new show you're gonna have to sell some
- 36:17ads but at some point six months from now and
- 36:20maybe 12 months from now we're gonna take a look
- 36:21and did you meet some some benchmarks and if
- 36:26not, what do we do? Do we change the split? Do
- 36:29we change the? Structure of this or do we allow
- 36:31the parties just go their separate ways? And
- 36:34I think that's a big important one because oftentimes
- 36:36that's where the dissatisfied host is wait a
- 36:39minute I've been on this network for two years
- 36:41and I've made $60 That was an actual situation
- 36:46two years $60 in revenue You know not that podcasting
- 36:51is all about making money, but it ought at least
- 36:53cover the bills yeah, yeah know that that makes
- 36:57a lot of sense because I Don't think I hear too
- 37:01often. Yeah. It's, it's, it's not smoke because
- 37:06it's hard to say like, all right, you've got
- 37:08a $5 ,000 download show. Do the math of, of 50
- 37:13episodes, 52 episodes. This is the money that
- 37:16we think you should be able to make, but that
- 37:18doesn't guarantee that I'm able to get the advertisers.
- 37:21I'm going to be able to collect on that. So you,
- 37:25from your standpoint is making sure the host.
- 37:28hey, let's at least put that number in writing
- 37:30so at least we have that as a benchmark. Yeah,
- 37:33you know, call it a trap door, exit door of some
- 37:36sort where if something isn't going right, if
- 37:38it just for some reason it's not working, let's
- 37:40not blame anybody, let's just, okay, it didn't
- 37:42work, we'll try something else. And oftentimes
- 37:45it's just an option to leave. If it turns out
- 37:49there's a reason why it didn't work... Then the
- 37:52host is gonna look at the situation and say well,
- 37:54okay Let's give it another six months, you know
- 37:56And we shouldn't be afraid to reopen the conversation
- 37:59about the contract if we get to that point and
- 38:02something isn't you know, we haven't met the
- 38:04benchmark but we got close or or the benchmark
- 38:07doesn't make sense given new circumstances, you
- 38:10know, all of these things can come into play
- 38:11so That's that only works if all the parties
- 38:16are willing to get back into it and That means
- 38:19hiring lawyers again, maybe, you know, so it
- 38:21is a hard thing to swallow, but sometimes it's
- 38:25what's necessary and it's better than a rancorous
- 38:29fight over things because it didn't work out.
- 38:33So another thing that's coming to me is, in some
- 38:36regards, the more established networks might
- 38:39be a safer bet in some because they probably
- 38:44have the process down, the collection down. you
- 38:48may not get the large of a percentage split because
- 38:54of the establishment of that network and what
- 38:58the value of them has. That's another reason
- 39:02why I started this show is thinking about how
- 39:06do I help others understand there's other networks
- 39:08out there, but listen to you, it's like, well,
- 39:11There are other networks out there, but something
- 39:13to be said about the larger networks that are
- 39:15Malice Dalish that have this legal backing behind
- 39:18them. You know, common sense might indicate,
- 39:21though, that those bigger networks also are bigger
- 39:24and by bigger I mean more flush with cash really.
- 39:27Yeah. It doesn't matter how many shows, it matters
- 39:29how much revenue they've got. You would think
- 39:32that maybe they would be a little more rigid
- 39:34in their deal making and protective of their
- 39:37bottom line and things like that. But in fact,
- 39:40when they have that I'll call it breathing room.
- 39:43They can afford to be a little flexible if they
- 39:45if they really believe in the show for reasons
- 39:47beyond the Economic they may still support it
- 39:51because they really like what's going on and
- 39:53vice versa If they don't believe in the show
- 39:55doesn't matter how profitable it is They may
- 39:57be willing to say you know what you're better
- 39:59off without us. We're better off without you
- 40:02So it's a little bit of a contradiction sometimes
- 40:07bigger networks can be Really good, but they
- 40:10can you can also be forgotten? Amongst a host
- 40:12of show. I mean I'm you know a sea of shows You're
- 40:16just one little little sailboat bouncing around
- 40:19whatever the waves are doing That's a weird metaphor
- 40:22All right, so from a host standpoint you don't
- 40:28see Not too many red flags if I'm looking to
- 40:31join a network that I should be examining their
- 40:36their contract or asking, hey, why isn't this
- 40:39in this contract? Well, we should be looking
- 40:41for the what's missing. Okay. What do you typically
- 40:45see what's missing that a host should be like,
- 40:47hold on, I need to mitigate myself or why aren't
- 40:51you mitigating this? Like this isn't in the contract.
- 40:54Yeah, usually it's that what happens at the end
- 40:56of the relationship with the RSS feed with the
- 40:58ownership of the episode copyrights and things
- 41:03like that and what happens with You know revenue
- 41:07that comes in after the end of the relationship
- 41:10But it was you know earned in that existed or
- 41:13you know those kinds of things and oftentimes
- 41:15that's just omitted or neglected accounting provisions
- 41:17Is there an option to audit an opportunity to
- 41:20audit the network's books if you're concerned
- 41:22that they're not paying you what they should
- 41:24be paying you Can you can you go in and verify
- 41:27that actually the advertisers haven't paid them
- 41:29yet? Or is that just words? Those kinds of things
- 41:33come up a lot The RSS feed itself. What happens
- 41:36in that? Do I like hire, do I go to Gordon, go
- 41:39Gordon? I think they're holding on on me. This
- 41:42doesn't smell right. So then I go and hire a
- 41:44lawyer to go. I need you to investigate them.
- 41:48Well, you could, it starts with either the lawyer
- 41:51or someone on the host side saying, Hey, can
- 41:54you give us a statement outlining, you know,
- 41:56detailing what's happening with this revenue?
- 41:59In particular, we know this ad, you know, we
- 42:01haven't been paid for these or whatever. You
- 42:03can ask. pointed questions and expect to get
- 42:05real answers if you get the runaround or If it
- 42:09seems to be blowing smoke that's when it's time
- 42:11to maybe bring someone like me or better yet
- 42:13a forensic accountant who can actually Climb
- 42:15in and look at the books if the contract lets
- 42:18you a lot of times it doesn't let you because
- 42:20nobody thought to ask for it Other things that
- 42:25will want to see in a contract that often aren't
- 42:28there are Getting the RSS feedback, what are
- 42:33the mechanism for that? Is it automatic? Is it
- 42:38redirect? Or is it, do I have to jump through
- 42:40some hoops? What about a power of attorney? If
- 42:43the network doesn't sign over the rights back
- 42:44to the host, does the host have a right to do
- 42:48it for them, basically? And that's usually a
- 42:52hard sell, but I've seen it happen a few times.
- 42:56Similar things with the use of the title, what
- 42:59happens with the... Existing body of episodes
- 43:02and and how is that different from what happens
- 43:04with future episodes if the host continues? So
- 43:08I have to imagine when money comes involved That
- 43:12makes it a little more. But if it's just the
- 43:15the collective like hey, we're gonna get together
- 43:17and It's it's community -based. It's supportive.
- 43:22It's educational the legal side there is protect
- 43:27protect the network head from anything going
- 43:31wrong, but at the end of the day, there's not
- 43:34much to stand on because financially, there's
- 43:38not there. You're not tied to financials in that
- 43:41regards? Well, I think that's why you want to
- 43:44have a clear understanding of how this relationship
- 43:48operates when things aren't going super well.
- 43:53You know, if somebody wants to leave the collective
- 43:56network, Maybe that's fine. But what if they
- 43:59want to take the name of the network with them?
- 44:01Who owns the name of the network? What if they
- 44:04want to take other shows with them and form their
- 44:08own new network and stuff like that and there
- 44:10needs to be some Boundaries to how things happen.
- 44:14It's fine if you want to leave but the rest you
- 44:16but you don't get to take anybody with you You
- 44:18don't get to poach the existing Employment, you
- 44:22know, you don't get to hire my editor away from
- 44:24me and or my producer or whatever These non non
- 44:29what's it called? Non -circumvention kinds of
- 44:31language and things can find their way into these
- 44:33agreements, too We're getting into more and more
- 44:35complicated and you know, maybe it is justified
- 44:37Maybe it isn't no we have to talk about too.
- 44:40I mean right now you're talking I want to do
- 44:42Jerry McGuire like who's coming with me who's
- 44:44coming with me because It's quite possibly the
- 44:48the case where it's like all right. I joined
- 44:49this network I don't like how they're operating,
- 44:52but I got five friends and we like what we could
- 44:55do together. So let's go create our own network.
- 44:58And the network head's going like, nope, you
- 45:00can't do that. You guys could leave, but you
- 45:04can't leave and join your own network based on
- 45:06the contract or potentially you're like, oh man,
- 45:09you guys could do that. I can't stop you from
- 45:11doing that because I didn't put in the contract.
- 45:14Yeah. Other language that I worry about, it doesn't
- 45:17matter what kind of network it is, is there's,
- 45:19sometimes there's a right of first refusal if
- 45:21the host is going to do another kind of a show.
- 45:25And maybe it's on point with the, if it's a subject
- 45:28matter oriented network, maybe it is, maybe it
- 45:31isn't consistent with that subject matter. But
- 45:33should that host be restricted from starting
- 45:36a new show and going somewhere else with it?
- 45:38Or should they be required to present it to this
- 45:41network first? Their non -compete language is
- 45:45often a thing and you know How do you define
- 45:47competition when we haven't really got a clear
- 45:49definition of podcast yet? I think we're pretty
- 45:54close to the definition, but there there will
- 45:56be arguments about what is a podcast. Yeah And
- 46:00and so what is competition and also it should
- 46:02be you know noted that there are some places
- 46:04where non -compete agreements are just not legal
- 46:07not enforceable California being the main one
- 46:11And so if you've got hosts there, good luck enforcing
- 46:14a non -compete even if it happens. Trying to
- 46:17think, what else do we worry about? Oh, sometimes
- 46:22we have networks that are sort of asking for
- 46:24a piece of everything the host is doing beyond
- 46:27any other media that they might do. So they have
- 46:29a YouTube channel or they have a very popular
- 46:33social media channel. Can they be required to
- 46:35do certain... Network oriented posts on the social
- 46:39media. There's all kinds of so when you ask about
- 46:41red flags it Everyone is different. Yeah. Yeah.
- 46:46No, that's it. That's a good one because you're
- 46:48seeing that Happen a lot. I want 360 deals. I'm
- 46:51not here just for selling podcast advertising
- 46:54We're looking at how do we do an integration
- 46:57live? I mean I have to imagine because live is
- 47:00becoming a huge thing and subscription revenue.
- 47:03So contracts around well Does the network get
- 47:06access to just the ad revenue? Do they get access
- 47:09to my subscription revenue? Do they get access
- 47:11to all the ticket sales of whatever I do? Things
- 47:14as a host, you should be protecting yourself
- 47:17from. But as the network, it's part of the structure
- 47:20back to your point of like, what kind of network
- 47:22are you creating? Well, I'm creating a network
- 47:24where I want the opportunity to sell the brand
- 47:29and the brand is the show and do whatever we
- 47:32can with it. Another issue that's come up. with
- 47:35some frequency, more in the past than recently,
- 47:38and it's odd because the problem is occurring
- 47:41more recently. It's when the network wants to
- 47:44own a piece of the show if it goes into other
- 47:47media, if it becomes a feature film, if it becomes
- 47:49a television series. IP, okay. That's sort of
- 47:52an IP, I would call it an attachment or a drag
- 47:55-along kind of a thing. I used to really resist
- 48:00that in in deals when I'm when I was representing
- 48:02the creators of a show saying hey No, we made
- 48:05it you you're in the business of selling ads
- 48:07on podcast network. That's great You can do that.
- 48:10But if it becomes a television show we're going
- 48:13and you're not coming with us and you know nowadays
- 48:18what's happening, of course is podcasts are television
- 48:21shows and they are showing up on Amazon and and
- 48:25YouTube is becoming almost a television thing
- 48:27and Netflix is doing podcasts. So those boundaries
- 48:32are sort of irrelevant anymore. I mean, I guess
- 48:37if you turn a podcast into a narrative TV show,
- 48:42scripted show or something, we might still see
- 48:44that issue. So again, everything is negotiable
- 48:50and should be negotiated. It brings up another
- 48:53layer. I can't remember the beginning of our
- 48:55conversation if you brought up this style of
- 48:57network, but I look at a category of network
- 49:01is distribution extension. And so great, I'm
- 49:05going to join this network. But part of the value
- 49:07of joining this network is how they take my show
- 49:10and get the distribution to a fast channel. Because
- 49:13me trying to call up, you know, whatever fast
- 49:15channel or whatever fast platform I want. insert
- 49:20your name of whatever platform it may be, that's
- 49:23a lot harder than a network that's got the connections,
- 49:27got the investment and is able to do that. So
- 49:30I have to imagine, once again, a network that's
- 49:35not even thinking about that two years from now,
- 49:39or I should say didn't think about that two years
- 49:41ago, but that's now a huge opportunity for them.
- 49:45It's either... Did they put that in the contract
- 49:47or they calling up Gordon saying, hey, I need
- 49:49a new contract because I now want to take these
- 49:52shows and help distribute them to other platforms,
- 49:55which therefore creates new revenue streams and
- 49:58yada, yada. Yeah. And that's sort of become part
- 50:00of the 360 deals that we're talking, that you
- 50:02were mentioning earlier. The truth of it is though,
- 50:05if the network, there's two components here.
- 50:08If the network doesn't have any track record
- 50:09in actually selling projects to television or
- 50:12film, then they don't really have any business
- 50:14making that a part of the network deal. Maybe
- 50:16do it as a side letter or something, you know,
- 50:18give it a little try, go shop it around for six
- 50:20months or whatever. But, you know, at the end
- 50:22of the day, if you haven't accomplished anything,
- 50:24we're going to be free agents again. The other
- 50:27thing is that unless the network is also a talent
- 50:31agency, they shouldn't be in the business of
- 50:34finding jobs for the people on the network. That's
- 50:37the role of an agent. And you mentioned Jerry
- 50:40Maguire, sports agent, right? Yeah. His job is
- 50:43to get athletes the job on the team and also
- 50:47book them for sponsorships and endorsements and
- 50:50things like that. I don't exactly want to say
- 50:53it quite as rigidly as stay in your lane, but
- 50:57do what you're really good at and don't try to
- 51:01bolt too much else onto it unless you're also
- 51:04really good at those things, I guess. Because
- 51:07that's a recipe for disappointment. Makes sense.
- 51:11As we think about how much media is evolving
- 51:18and how much collaboration we can have that allows
- 51:24you to go like, you know what, that's not my
- 51:26lane, but I'm going to go partner with someone
- 51:28who does, right? Like we think about a network
- 51:30that partners with a rep firm for advertising.
- 51:35It's like, well, technically I'm outsourcing
- 51:37that to a third party. Here it's like, well,
- 51:40in your contract, do you have the ability to
- 51:42outsource that too? Do me as a network head,
- 51:48do I have to let my host know, hey, you're coming,
- 51:52signing with me, we're going to do ad sales,
- 51:54but technically I'm not doing the quote unquote
- 51:56ad sales. I am outsourcing that to another company,
- 52:00whether it's company A this year or company B
- 52:02next year. I think some transparency there is
- 52:05appropriate. I don't know that it's legally,
- 52:07I mean, I guess the contract could say you're
- 52:08going to keep us informed about who's doing what
- 52:11on our behalf. And if you make subcontract arrangements
- 52:14and things, but the fact of it is a network that's
- 52:16selling ads, they can either have an in -house
- 52:18ad sales staff or outsource it to an agency.
- 52:23And, you know, as long as it doesn't change the
- 52:26equation in terms of the revenue splits, I don't
- 52:30think it matters. Where it becomes troublesome
- 52:32is when the network wants to take an Wants to
- 52:36take their split of the revenue after any outside
- 52:40agency commissions, and they don't tell you what
- 52:42we're gonna outsource at all So then again, that's
- 52:46just another one of those things that I look
- 52:47for is is You know, what's the actual revenue
- 52:51waterfall going to look like when there's revenue?
- 52:54Yeah. Yeah. Well I always I always like to ask
- 52:58these questions We haven't touched on your podcast
- 53:04yet, so Let's give you a plug on what people
- 53:08should be listening to on your podcast. And then
- 53:11the follow up to that is, what's another podcast
- 53:13you think people should be listening to that
- 53:16needs a little more love? Oh, wow. Well, first
- 53:21of all, my long running show is called Entertainment
- 53:24Law Update. We started it in 2009, so that's
- 53:2817 years running. It's a monthly recap and roundup
- 53:31of case law and controversies in the entertainment
- 53:34field. more broadly, film, television, music.
- 53:39We're talking a lot about AI these days. We're
- 53:40talking a lot about digital media these days
- 53:43and copyrights and trademarks and things like
- 53:45that. That's monthly. It's Entertainment Law
- 53:47Update. You can find it on YouTube and as a podcast
- 53:51itself, entertainmentlawupdate .com. My more
- 53:54podcast -oriented show is Legit Podcast Pro,
- 53:57and it is a weekly live stream that I then repurpose
- 54:01as an audio podcast as well. So I do it. live
- 54:04on YouTube Thursdays at 4 p .m. My channel on
- 54:08YouTube is Gfiremark, so pretty easy to find
- 54:10me. And that's a show where I talk about, in
- 54:14sort of a short format, 10 to 15 minute long
- 54:16episodes featuring a tip, a strategy, a concept,
- 54:21and sort of getting into, you know, how to, mostly
- 54:25lately it's been how to be more business -like
- 54:26about your show, even if you're in it as a hobby,
- 54:29just so that you can be. Well protected and well
- 54:34established and then one show besides those two
- 54:37that you think more people should listen to I
- 54:41will tell you that my first listen every time
- 54:44I'm in the car every week when I get in the car
- 54:45is a show from a He's actually a client of mine,
- 54:48but he's also a friend and someone I really respect
- 54:50his name is Colin Boyd and the show is called
- 54:53The expert edge and it's really a business show
- 54:58about how to give better do better speaking engagements
- 55:02and sell from stage and those kind of things.
- 55:04He's a speaking coach, I guess I would describe
- 55:07him. And it's just a fantastic show. He's always
- 55:09got some interesting insights and I love the
- 55:13show. Awesome. As always, we'll have all this
- 55:16stuff in the show notes. So the flip side question
- 55:20to that one is, everyone complains there's too
- 55:23many podcasts. No one complains there's too many
- 55:25books. So then, therefore, I always ask, you
- 55:28know, what's one book you would recommend that
- 55:31people check out? Boy, that's a broad question.
- 55:36It could be anything. We've gotten Kid's book
- 55:39because the guest was deep in motherhood and
- 55:44that's what she was focused on. I've got an autobiography,
- 55:47so you get to choose whichever kind of book you
- 55:50wanted to recommend. Yeah, you know a book that
- 55:52that really made a difference in my life in my
- 55:55business is The Big Leap by Gay Hendrix and it
- 55:59talks about finding your zone of genius and focusing
- 56:02there and and delegating the other stuff and
- 56:05maximizing Productivity that way. I think that's
- 56:09really a good it's worth reading whether you're
- 56:11in business for yourself or or for others Thank
- 56:14You Gordon, you know, I if anyone's watching
- 56:16I've always got One behind me, you know turned
- 56:20on courage by Ryan Berman and since I record
- 56:22on Thursdays his new list newsletter comes on
- 56:25Thursdays It's always something I like recommending
- 56:27Well, I know we jumped straight into our recording
- 56:31and I'm assuming most people are probably listening
- 56:34to this No, but I also know I had a conversation
- 56:37with someone today and they didn't know who you
- 56:38are So give me the quick little backstory on
- 56:42how Gordon Firemark got into being the podcast
- 56:45lawyer well I began my life, I guess you'd say,
- 56:52my adult life, as a sound and lighting technician
- 56:56in live theater. And I moved into radio, TV,
- 56:58and film for a while. And law school came to
- 57:02me as a bit of an afterthought after I'd been
- 57:03practicing a little bit, and I mean, working
- 57:05a little bit in television when the writers and
- 57:08actors went on strike a number of years ago.
- 57:10And so I've been practicing entertainment law
- 57:12since graduating law school in 1992. And when
- 57:17I started... looking at ways to market my own
- 57:20law practice. I started with a print newsletter
- 57:24that became an email newsletter and a blog. And
- 57:27then I discovered this, I found this thing called
- 57:29podcasting when Leo Laporte kind of left his
- 57:32television gig. And I said, oh, I should do that.
- 57:36And fortuitously, someone asked me to be a guest
- 57:38on a show a few times and I got the bug and started
- 57:41my own show. That's Entertainment Law Update
- 57:42since 2009. And in the course of setting up and
- 57:47getting started with that, I went looking for
- 57:50resources and materials on the legal side of
- 57:54podcasting and found that there were none. So
- 57:56I buckled down and did the research and I ended
- 57:58up writing a book called The Podcast Blog and
- 58:01New Media Producers Legal Survival Guide. And
- 58:04no better way to position yourself as an expert
- 58:06than write a book. So here I am. What is it now?
- 58:11Some almost 20 years later as the podcast lawyer.
- 58:15Very proud of that. You niche down in not only
- 58:18your podcast, but also in your legal practice,
- 58:21but covering entertainment. I know you do more
- 58:23than just podcasting, but yeah. There we go.
- 58:26Well, Gordon, it's been a pleasure. Is there
- 58:28anything else that you wanted to cover that we
- 58:30haven't? You know, I will just say something.
- 58:33I don't know if it really belongs in this show
- 58:35or not, but it's on the subject of consistency.
- 58:38I mentioned it in the concept of what are the
- 58:40deliverables? You want a consistent delivery
- 58:42of a show that's consistent quality and so on.
- 58:45I think we often make the mistake of thinking
- 58:47consistency means showing up and making a show
- 58:50every week, publishing on a regular schedule.
- 58:53But I think consistent quality is far, far more
- 58:55important. And audiences will forgive you missing
- 58:58a week, but they won't forgive you turning out
- 58:59a piece of crap. So, food for thought. There
- 59:03you go. On that note, hopefully this hasn't been
- 59:05a piece of crap and it's been a great time talking
- 59:08with you, Gordon. Thank you for joining me and
- 59:10everyone for listening. Thanks for having me,
- 59:12Craig. I appreciate it. Well, you've made it
- 59:14this far, and I really appreciate it. I truly
- 59:16do. But if you give me a few extra minutes, let
- 59:19me share some of my thoughts on my conversation
- 59:21with Gordon. To start, and ultimately during
- 59:24the whole conversation, Gordon made it clear
- 59:27it all depends on what you're trying to achieve,
- 59:30the kind of network you're setting up, and therefore
- 59:32the legal functions you need to cover. As I called
- 59:35out with Gordon, he's pushing to understand your
- 59:39strategy. which sets the table for how you operate
- 59:42and thus get covered legally. Here are a few
- 59:45other things I walked away from this conversation.
- 59:47First, Gordon treated the end of the deal as
- 59:49something to design at the beginning. He talked
- 59:52about what happens to the RSS feed, the existing
- 59:55episodes, the show title, the revenue earned
- 59:57after the relationship ends. Second, Gordon focused
- 1:00:01on the revenue waterfall, not just the commission
- 1:00:04percentage. An ad baby sold by the host, serviced
- 1:00:08by the network, collect it through an agency.
- 1:00:12Each step can affect how money gets arrived,
- 1:00:16how it gets paid, and how much time it happens
- 1:00:18to get all of that. He also pointed out that
- 1:00:21some networks are good at selling ads, but weak
- 1:00:24at collecting them. That changed how you evaluate
- 1:00:26a network. The question isn't only what percentage
- 1:00:29is promised, it's what happens between the ad
- 1:00:32insertion and the payment. Third, and I loved
- 1:00:35how he described this, the pitch and the contract
- 1:00:38is two different things. The pitch is the optimistic
- 1:00:42first date. The contract is the actual relationship.
- 1:00:46He shared how he'd seen a show earn only $60
- 1:00:49after two years. That example makes vague promises
- 1:00:52feel much less harmless. A benchmark, a review
- 1:00:56point, or an exit option can both give sides
- 1:00:59a way to respond when the original plan isn't
- 1:01:02working. Make sure, regardless which side of
- 1:01:05the contract you're on, you're covering yourself
- 1:01:07for these occasions. And fourth, How Gordon questioned
- 1:01:11the idea that every network should automatically
- 1:01:14claim a piece of every part of the pie. He timed
- 1:01:17that back to actual capability. If a network
- 1:01:20has no track record selling projects into television
- 1:01:23or film, should that be part of the deal? At
- 1:01:26the same time, most networks are looking beyond
- 1:01:29podcast advertising and toward the broader media
- 1:01:32opportunities. And that's something they consider
- 1:01:34in the legal structure and the strategy and vision
- 1:01:37as the company expands. There's a lot more to
- 1:01:41sit with in this conversation, and I urge you,
- 1:01:44please reach out, respond, let's have a conversation.
- 1:01:48And once again, thank you for listening to this
- 1:01:50conversation. The show wouldn't be possible without
- 1:01:53some amazing companies and sponsors, so I must
- 1:01:56say thank you. The show is produced by the incredible
- 1:01:59team, stories and strategies. If you don't know
- 1:02:01Doug and Emily, I highly suggest you reach out
- 1:02:04and connect with them. I'm using RSS .com for
- 1:02:08my podcast hosting. This podcast hosting is more
- 1:02:10than just storage and distribution. RSS .com
- 1:02:14provides so many features to ensure a great podcast
- 1:02:17experience. They have a community that I learned
- 1:02:19from. They're easy to use, maximum distribution,
- 1:02:23monetization opportunities, video, and so much
- 1:02:26more. And they have a plan that works great for
- 1:02:29podcast networks, not just individuals like me.
- 1:02:33Systems and processes are key for consistency
- 1:02:35in podcasting, which is why I use Northflow,
- 1:02:38a dedicated project management tool built by
- 1:02:42podcasters for podcasters. Most of us know the
- 1:02:46value of content repurposing, which is why I
- 1:02:48lean on Cast Magic. Cast Magic helps me with
- 1:02:50my scripts, with my posts, my content that I'm
- 1:02:53able to give directly to my guests, and so much
- 1:02:56more. You can check out all the links and all
- 1:02:59the conversations we had here in our show notes.
- 1:03:01To those of you that have rated and reviewed
- 1:03:04on Apple, I thank you. To Frank, who's got the
- 1:03:07great review on great pods, thank you so much.
- 1:03:10Make sure you leave a review. Subscribe on the
- 1:03:13platform of choice. And as I say, life is about
- 1:03:16time and relationships. You have no clue where
- 1:03:18one conversation's gonna take you. This is why
- 1:03:20I'm able to actually have this show and bring
- 1:03:23you these great conversations, which is what
- 1:03:25I love to do is network. And so you have no clue
- 1:03:28where listening to this conversation today will
- 1:03:30take you now. or in the future, but I guarantee
- 1:03:33you, your future self will thank you for tuning
- 1:03:35in today. As I said, I live on LinkedIn. Reach
- 1:03:38out, let's talk. To those of you who've already
- 1:03:40done so, I appreciate you. I love the conversations
- 1:03:44we're already having, and it's showing the value
- 1:03:46of these conversations that we're having on this
- 1:03:47show are worthwhile. I have a newsletter, because
- 1:03:50as I said, podcast discovery is incredibly difficult.
- 1:03:53You'll find that on my LinkedIn as well, as well
- 1:03:55as in the show notes. Subscribe, you'll find
- 1:03:58shows that maybe you've never heard of that need
- 1:04:01to be discovered because there's so many shows
- 1:04:03out there. And of course, subscribe where you
- 1:04:06listen to on whatever platform. New episodes
- 1:04:09of this show comes out every Thursday. Until
- 1:04:11next time, I appreciate you.