Latest / Her Moment: Female perspectives on life, culture & society / Why You Stay Silent in Meetings (And How to Break the Spell) | Her Moment
Transcript
- You know the answer. It’s sitting right there on your tongue, sharp and certain, but when the room turns to you, your throat closes up like a fist. Let’s talk about why that happens, because it has nothing to do with competence and everything to do with the invisible weight we carry into every conference room. I want you to picture a scene from last Tuesday. Or maybe Monday. Maybe it was yesterday. You’re in a meeting, or perhaps it’s a Zoom call where you can see everyone else’s faces frozen in little squares. Someone asks a question. A simple one. Something you’ve been thinking about all week. In fact, you’ve probably drafted three different ways to answer it while making your coffee this morning. But then, silence falls over the table. And in that silence, something shifts inside you. You feel a sudden, heavy pull backward. You think, 'Who am I to say this?' or 'What if they don’t like my idea?' or worse, 'What if I’m wrong?' So you swallow the words. You let someone else speak, usually someone louder, someone who doesn’t hesitate. And afterward, you sit there, fuming quietly at yourself, wondering why you didn’t just say what you knew to be true. Here’s the thing: this isn’t just you. This is a phenomenon so common, so deeply embedded in how we’re socialized as women, that it feels like gravity. We aren’t born afraid of speaking up. We learn it. We are taught, through years of subtle corrections, that our voices are optional, that our opinions are suggestions, and that our certainty is somehow arrogant. So we hold back. We wait for permission that never comes. Let’s unpack that feeling of hesitation. It often masquerades as humility, but really, it’s fear wearing a polite mask. When you stay silent in a meeting despite knowing the answer, you’re not being modest. You’re engaging in a kind of self-erasure. You’re trading your truth for safety. And I get it. Safety feels good. It feels warm. It feels like avoiding conflict. But what is the cost? The cost is that you begin to doubt your own voice. Every time you choose silence over speech, you send a message to your brain: 'My thoughts aren’t important enough to risk rejection.' Over time, this builds a wall. Not between you and your colleagues, but between you and yourself. You start to believe that you don’t actually have the answers, even though you do. This is the imposter syndrome whispering in your ear, telling you that you’re an fraud, that if you spoke up, everyone would see you for who you really are. But here’s the secret they don’t tell you: everyone else is doing it too. They’re all terrified. They’re all second-guessing. The only difference is that some people have learned to act before the fear fully sets in. They’ve trained themselves to trust their gut faster than their anxiety can interrupt. And you can too. But first, you have to recognize that the fear is lying to you. There’s a cultural script that many of us are reading from without even realizing it. From a young age, girls are praised for being quiet, helpful, agreeable. Boys are praised for being bold, assertive, leading. When we enter professional spaces, those early lessons don’t vanish. They follow us into the boardroom. If a woman speaks up too much, she’s labeled aggressive. If she speaks up too little, she’s labeled disengaged. It’s a lose-lose scenario designed to keep us small. And so we modulate our tone. We soften our statements with phrases like 'I might be wrong, but...' or 'This is just a thought...' We pre-apologize for taking up space. But when you know the answer, you don’t need to hedge. You don’t need to dress your truth in layers of uncertainty. Think about the last time you heard a colleague present an idea with absolute confidence. Did you respect them less because they were direct? Probably not. You likely respected them more. Confidence is magnetic. Uncertainty is draining. When you withhold your insight out of fear, you’re denying the team your best work. You’re keeping the solution locked inside you because you’re worried about how it will be received. But consider this: the room needs your perspective. Not the watered-down version. The real one. The one that makes you nervous to share. That nervousness is a signal, not a stop sign. It means you’re onto something valuable. Have you ever noticed how your body reacts when you decide to stay silent? Your shoulders might tense. Your breath might catch. There’s a physical heaviness in your chest, like you’re holding your breath waiting for a blow that never comes. That tension is energy trapped. It’s the energy of the words you didn’t say. And it doesn’t disappear. It stays with you. It leaks out later in the day as irritability, as fatigue, as a sense of resentment toward the person who finally said what you wanted to say. I remember a specific meeting early in my career where I had the solution to a problem that had stumped the entire department for weeks. I sat there, watching my male counterpart struggle to piece it together. He was charming, confident, and completely off base. I could have fixed it in ten seconds. Instead, I stayed quiet. I told myself I was being a good listener. But in reality, I was afraid of being seen as competitive. After the meeting, he took credit for the direction he suggested, which was wrong. And I sat there, burning with frustration, unable to correct him without seeming difficult. That night, I couldn’t sleep. The regret was sharper than any criticism I could have faced. Had I spoken up, even if I’d been shut down, I would have felt honest. I would have felt aligned with myself. Silence left me feeling fractured. It’s important to realize that your voice is not just a tool for communication; it’s a tool for integrity. When you use it, you align your outer world with your inner truth. So, how do we break the spell? How do we move from paralysis to participation? It doesn’t require you to become a different person overnight. You don’t need to shout over others or dominate the conversation. Start small. Pick one meeting this week where you plan to speak. Just once. Choose a topic you know well. Prepare two sentences beforehand. Write them down if you need to. Keep them in your pocket. When the moment comes, say them. Even if your voice shakes. Especially if your voice shakes. Because the shaking proves you’re alive, you’re engaged, you’re risking something. And notice what happens. Usually, nothing bad happens. People listen. Sometimes they nod. Sometimes they ask follow-up questions. Rarely do they reject you for having an opinion. The worst-case scenario you’ve imagined in your head rarely comes to pass. In fact, the opposite is often true. When you speak up, you give others permission to do the same. You create a ripple effect. Your courage becomes contagious. And slowly, the walls around your voice begin to crumble. You’ll find that each time you speak, the next time is easier. The fear doesn’t vanish, but it shrinks. It becomes background noise rather than the main event. Tell me more about how that felt? Does the idea of preparing two sentences feel manageable? Or does it still feel like climbing a mountain? Whatever it feels like, it’s worth it. As we close this reflection, I want you to think about the legacy of your voice. What do you want it to stand for? Do you want it to stand for caution? For avoidance? Or do you want it to stand for contribution? For connection? For the unique value only you can bring? You have answers. You have insights. You have experiences that matter. Don’t hoard them. Share them. The world doesn’t need more perfection; it needs more authenticity. And authenticity requires voice. It requires the willingness to be seen, to be judged, to be misunderstood, and to keep going anyway. This isn’t about becoming the loudest person in the room. It’s about becoming the most honest. And honesty is rare. Honesty is powerful. So next time you’re in a meeting, and you know the answer, take a breath. Feel the fear. And then speak. Not because you’re sure they’ll like it, but because you owe it to yourself to be heard. You deserve to take up space. You deserve to be part of the conversation. And most importantly, you deserve to hear your own voice echo back at you, strong and clear. Let’s make a pact, right here, right now. Next time you have the answer, don’t swallow it. Offer it. Give it away. See what happens when you stop hiding your light. I’ll be thinking of you. And I’ll be listening. Thank you for letting me into your space today. Be gentle with yourself. You are doing better than you think. Until next time, keep speaking your truth. I’m Heidi Ashman, and this has been Her Moment.