Latest / No Way Out / Primal Intelligence: Story, the Real OODA Loop, and Why AI Can't Reframe | Angus Fletcher
Transcript
- 0:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right, we'll start this one a little bit different.
- 0:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're here with Goofy, uh Moose and Punch.
- 0:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we got three characters on our show.
- 0:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do want to start off uh the way we previously started off, but uh not everybody here on the show knows that.
- 0:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that is uh what's the simplest way to explain John Boyd's oodloop to your kids?
- 0:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, well, I don't know how to do that.
- 0:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh I'll tell you how I'm I'm talking about it now.
- 0:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The purpose of it, starting with the what, is really to uh for an agent to take some kind of action on the environment and and the the how, how they do that is we go through this whirl of reorientation um where we build off of our genetics, our culture, and our previous experience, so our priors, if you will, and update those through something.
- 0:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh another way to think about this is uh if you're if you're leaning towards the neuroscience application, towards AI, there's something known as a uh partially observable Markov decision process.
- 1:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can think of it this way that the agent doesn't have complete access to the external world.
- 1:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we have to come up with a way to understand what's going on in the external world.
- 1:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So why do we do this?
- 1:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, that's why we named the podcast No Way Out.
- 1:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It really connects to the never-ending threat of entropic erosion.
- 1:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: As agents, we have to go through this role of reorientation to avoid death.
- 1:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So one thing uh that's very important in this uh aspect and something we haven't talked much about on the show, is the power of story or and or narrative.
- 1:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so our guest today knows a lot about the brain, knows a lot about uh story, uh, Professor Agus Fletcher from Ohio State University.
- 1:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Welcome to the show.
- 1:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm totally thrilled to be here.
- 1:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks for inviting me.
- 1:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh thanks for doing this.
- 1:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I I I asked you earlier in a conversation: is there a relationship too between you and a movie called S-E-R-E?
- 2:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Between Sear?
- 2:02Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 2:02Angus Fletcher: So back a long time ago, we did do a movie called Sear as a kind of like fun thing.
- 2:07Angus Fletcher: But that was kind of the beginning of this journey that I had where I got to go work in Hollywood, uh sort of work with a bunch of big name actors, a bunch of big name studios.
- 2:16Angus Fletcher: And that was just kind of my own process of learning about how story works from the professionals.
- 2:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I'm just curious.
- 2:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You picked Sear, so survival escape, uh, help me out again.
- 2:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I went through SEER school up in Maine.
- 2:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Resist, evade.
- 2:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Evade, thanks.
- 2:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 2:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So things that we're trained to do, um, you know, what at Moose, did you go through SEER at all?
- 2:33Mark McGrath: No.
- 2:33Mark McGrath: I I was a field artillery officer in the Marine Corps, so I we we were taking prisoners, not becoming prisoners.
- 2:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 2:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so on our end, yeah, all aviators and special operators, I believe, have to go through SEER training.
- 2:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's uh it's intense.
- 2:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's pretty uh you learn a lot of great things in there and like how to resist.
- 2:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, I think that's the most important thing.
- 2:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So how do you not punish yourself in an environment where people are trying to punish you?
- 2:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But anyway, um uh interesting connection that I came across recently was your work on that movie.
- 3:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then again, uh your recent work with um you get to work with our special operators, um, maybe some Delta, maybe some Devagrew, maybe some 160th, is that right?
- 3:12Angus Fletcher: Yeah, well, uh, for the record, there is no Delta, but uh hypothetically I do work with the United States Army's two JSOC units, for those who know what that is.
- 3:19Angus Fletcher: And I also work quite extensively with the Green Berets.
- 3:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So why would uh that the military want somebody with your background in neuroscience and storytelling to come in uh and help them out?
- 3:28Angus Fletcher: Yeah, because basically for years I was kind of a rogue neuroscientist.
- 3:32Angus Fletcher: So, what do most neuroscientists think?
- 3:33Angus Fletcher: Most neuroscientists think that the brain is a computer.
- 3:37Angus Fletcher: And they think that the way the computers work is they're giant sense-making machines that take on all this data and crunch that data to arrive at probabilities and predictions and so on and so forth.
- 3:46Angus Fletcher: But here's the secret about the human brain: the human brain can be really smart with limited information.
- 3:51Angus Fletcher: And that's something that a computer cannot do.
- 3:54Angus Fletcher: And so the question is, how is that happening?
- 3:57Angus Fletcher: And so basically what we did at my lab for years is we said, well, actually, what's unique about the human brain is its ability to initiate new actions, to do something that has never been done before, and to do it without input.
- 4:07Angus Fletcher: And if you're a special operator or anyone else in the military, you know what that is.
- 4:10Angus Fletcher: You go somewhere, the plan breaks, your radio is down, comms are down, you've got to initiate action.
- 4:16Angus Fletcher: You gotta do something.
- 4:17Angus Fletcher: You know, where does that come from?
- 4:18Angus Fletcher: It comes from within.
- 4:19Angus Fletcher: And the human brain, right down to the level of the individual neuron, what every single neuron in your brain is doing right now is initiating action.
- 4:26Angus Fletcher: It's not taking inputs, it's initiating action from nowhere.
- 4:29Angus Fletcher: It's the same thing that happens in a democratic society, which is like a collection of little individuals initiating action.
- 4:35Angus Fletcher: And for a long time, people have been scared of that because they think, oh, it's gonna lead to chaos, so on and so forth.
- 4:40Angus Fletcher: But actually, if you understand how actions that are initiated can be chained together, what is a series of actions that are chained together?
- 4:47Angus Fletcher: That's a narrative.
- 4:48Angus Fletcher: And another nerd, another word for narrative is a plot, is a plan.
- 4:53Angus Fletcher: So essentially your brain is a giant story-making machine.
- 4:56Angus Fletcher: And the purpose of those stories is to invent the future faster than your adversary.
- 4:59Angus Fletcher: And so talking about the ODA loop, essentially what's happening in the OODA loop is your enemy's got a story and he's trying to make that story happen.
- 5:06Angus Fletcher: You know, he's got a narrative that he wants to impose on you.
- 5:08Angus Fletcher: And what do you do?
- 5:09Angus Fletcher: You break his story.
- 5:10Angus Fletcher: You break his plan, and then out of the fragments of that collision, you create a new plan faster than he can, and you kill him.
- 5:18Angus Fletcher: And so that's essentially the way in which human beings can survive in chaos.
- 5:23Angus Fletcher: That's why we can do things that AI cannot do.
- 5:25Angus Fletcher: And that's why, as we see ourselves walking to this world increasingly of volatility in markets, in politics, in everything, humans are gonna have the edge over computers.
- 5:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're saying that we just don't simply go through the observe, orient, decide, act stage.
- 5:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We actually have a plan or maybe some intuition as well.
- 5:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So break, break, surprise, surprise.
- 5:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what we talk about on here is we we use the four Ps.
- 5:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not gonna go through them today, perception, planning, and uh perception.
- 5:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh hopefully I got that all right, and then uh flow, uh being the third or the fourth P with the PHLOW, uh, which is actually just intuition again.
- 6:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, what plan does is it's internal to the system, um, and that action realizes that plan.
- 6:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, uh what we're trying to do with a plan is reduce risk or minimize risk uh based off the information we have.
- 6:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And more importantly, and I think you you cover this in your book a little bit, and that is um when we talk about planning, when we talk about planning, Moose and I talk about planning.
- 6:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Planning is continuous, it's it's always updating with the information we have from the external environment.
- 6:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't set a strategy and just let it run, you know, hey, here's a strategy that McKenzie gave to a company and let it go.
- 6:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's a bad way to plan, by the way.
- 6:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So um the way we talk about planning, and Moose, um can you bring your color into this as well as to how you explain strategy?
- 6:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But we always talk about building a good map of the external world, and we know that all maps are wrong.
- 6:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right?
- 6:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Moose, do you add some more to that?
- 6:51Mark McGrath: Yeah, I mean, that's why the way we approach teaching Boyd in Oodaloop is so different because we're trying to follow what he authentically prescribed and taught, you know, that we're the Oodaloop sketch is merely an illustrative abstraction of how the orientation functions inside of you know complex nonlinear environments, which is the universe.
- 7:14Mark McGrath: And therefore, strategy also is not linear.
- 7:20Mark McGrath: So that there's that illustrative abstraction, but then strategy also becomes instead of a plan or a mission statement or whatever, it's a the way he defines it is a mental tapestry of changing intentions to achieve uh to achieve an objective.
- 7:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm gonna add this to this, uh to that, Moose.
- 7:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, in within the Oodaloop, when we talk about the OODA loop, we also talk about counterfactuals as far as a connection to plan, um, right, and stories.
- 7:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I believe stories would connect to that as well.
- 7:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Story plot, plan, uh, solid connection, what-if scenarios, counterfactuals, um, co-selection.
- 7:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so we're always going through that process.
- 7:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And those that do I hate to say planning better, but plan better.
- 8:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, and again, it's not about developing a plan, it's about the process of planning.
- 8:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The higher quality planning you do, the more Yeah, the orienting, reorienting.
- 8:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, all the time.
- 8:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh Angus, is there is there is that connect to how you you you looked at this as uh with your Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 8:15Angus Fletcher: So by the way, what we talk about a lot, and I gotta so first, just full disclosure, I got thrown out of the Marine Corps when I was 18 years old.
- 8:21Angus Fletcher: And that's one of the reasons why we made that movie Sear, is I went through OCS and they were like, You're a loser, man.
- 8:26Angus Fletcher: We don't want you here in the Marine Corps.
- 8:28Angus Fletcher: And then Army Special Operations picked me up and were like, we want to work with you.
- 8:31Angus Fletcher: So that gives you some indication, I think, of the relative quality zones of the Marines and Army Special Operations.
- 8:37Angus Fletcher: But what we talk about in Army Special Operations is what we talk about is plan or not the plan.
- 8:43Angus Fletcher: And so what we say is you gotta plan like a madman.
- 8:45Angus Fletcher: You gotta plan out every single counterfactual.
- 8:47Angus Fletcher: You gotta go into this situation and say, what if my enemy does this?
- 8:50Angus Fletcher: What if my enemy does this?
- 8:51Angus Fletcher: What if my enemy does this?
- 8:52Angus Fletcher: And you got to have counter plan, counterplan, counterplan.
- 8:54Angus Fletcher: You gotta get that all done in advance, and then you gotta plan for catastrophic success.
- 8:57Angus Fletcher: You gotta say, what if I destroy my enemy so totally?
- 8:59Angus Fletcher: What do I do now?
- 9:00Angus Fletcher: What's my next move?
- 9:00Angus Fletcher: I can't hesitate in the moment of victory.
- 9:02Angus Fletcher: So you plan, plan, plan, plan, plan, plan, plan.
- 9:05Angus Fletcher: And then the moment that reality hits, all those plans break.
- 9:07Angus Fletcher: But it doesn't matter because by planning, you have trained the planner.
- 9:11Angus Fletcher: Right.
- 9:12Angus Fletcher: You have increased the muscle in your brain.
- 9:14Angus Fletcher: And we see this again and again and again.
- 9:16Angus Fletcher: You get faster and faster and faster at doing uh, you know, um, whatever the situation requires if you've gone through a whole variety of those different situations.
- 9:23Angus Fletcher: And why is that?
- 9:24Angus Fletcher: Well, because you're basically practicing all these story mechanics in the brain.
- 9:28Angus Fletcher: And that certainly maps over the oodle loop.
- 9:30Angus Fletcher: These are just kind of different languages.
- 9:31Angus Fletcher: We're talking about essentially the same mechanical process, which is what do you do in a violent environment when you're when you have an adversary who's trying to impose their reality on your reality?
- 9:41Angus Fletcher: Um, and to that extent, planning isn't just about decreasing your risk, it's also about increasing your adversary's risk.
- 9:47Angus Fletcher: Right.
- 9:47Angus Fletcher: You're saying, what can I do to move risk into his domain so that all of a sudden that's starting to disrupt him?
- 9:52Angus Fletcher: And I'm getting inside his head and he's getting inside his head.
- 9:55Angus Fletcher: And so this is all basically, I think, out of the same tree.
- 9:58Angus Fletcher: It's just sort of different languages and uh kind of vernaculars.
- 10:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 10:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So how do we increase their entropy their entropy while decreasing ours?
- 10:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 10:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's that's the same.
- 10:06Mark McGrath: So let's go back to destruction.
- 10:07Mark McGrath: Yeah, it's destruction and creation.
- 10:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 10:10Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 10:10Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 10:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh let's go back to story a little bit more and understand uh why, as living systems, and in particular as humans, we use story.
- 10:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um so let's build this up into two phases if we can.
- 10:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Genetically, uh, I think as humans, we're predisposed to tell stories and use them for something.
- 10:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um question to you, do animals do the same thing?
- 10:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then what about culture?
- 10:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you kind of expand that a little bit?
- 10:34Angus Fletcher: So, first of all, story is not primarily for telling, it's for thinking.
- 10:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 10:39Angus Fletcher: And we know this because animals do have narratives.
- 10:42Angus Fletcher: They just don't communicate in narratives.
- 10:44Angus Fletcher: Sort of a simple example is how we know that that animals have narratives, is because crows, birds, can use tools.
- 10:50Angus Fletcher: Tool use is an indication of narrative because you're basically saying if I do this, then this other thing is going to happen.
- 10:55Angus Fletcher: So they're telling a little story in their brain that they're able to play over and over again.
- 10:58Angus Fletcher: If you go back to the common ancestor of the crow, the Caledonian crow in humans, that goes back before the trans source wrecks.
- 11:05Angus Fletcher: So narrative exists basically in the brain of any single animal that you pick.
- 11:09Angus Fletcher: Um, that animal is essentially thinking to themselves a story of their life.
- 11:15Angus Fletcher: Like, I want to do this, I want to do this.
- 11:16Angus Fletcher: When that happened in the past, this thing happened, cause and effect, that's all story.
- 11:20Angus Fletcher: So, why does culture exist?
- 11:22Angus Fletcher: Your other question.
- 11:23Angus Fletcher: Well, culture exists both as a repository of stories, because it's useful for us to trade stories as humans, for me to say, hey, when this thing occurred, that other thing followed.
- 11:30Angus Fletcher: And I can give that to you, and you can say, Oh, okay, I'll store that story in my mind because I could use it later.
- 11:34Angus Fletcher: But also, more profoundly, culture makes us better at story.
- 11:39Angus Fletcher: So there are certain stories when you listen to them, you don't just remember the story.
- 11:43Angus Fletcher: They actually activate your brain's power to tell stories better.
- 11:46Angus Fletcher: The classic example of this in Western culture is Shakespeare.
- 11:49Angus Fletcher: So millions of people have, you know, read, listened to Shakespeare, and gotten better at storytelling.
- 11:53Angus Fletcher: But you know, if you do near uh term sci-fi, this is something we do a lot with the operators, is we do these kinds of sci-fi stories that are set 10, 15 years in the future.
- 12:01Angus Fletcher: The more time you spend consuming those stories, the more it makes you able to imagine things that might happen to you in the next 15 minutes because those stories are boosting your brain's deep storything ability.
- 12:12Angus Fletcher: So animals can do story, culture exists to amplify that natural ability.
- 12:17Angus Fletcher: Story, as we talked about earlier, is essentially just your ability to make plans to tell a story of the future faster than your adversaries and make it happen.
- 12:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Really cool.
- 12:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, in your book, you you write a little bit about um we call it complex facilitation.
- 12:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We use a uh an approach called the future backwards.
- 12:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So starting somewhere in the in the future and working backwards from that.
- 12:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk a little bit about why force, you know, forcing folks, or I hate to say forcing folks, but using that constraint to allow creativity to flow.
- 12:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why does that work?
- 12:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're reverse engineering.
- 12:47Angus Fletcher: You're reverse engineering, you're going backwards from an effect to a cause.
- 12:50Angus Fletcher: So basically, the way that narratives work in real time is they go from causes to effects.
- 12:55Angus Fletcher: The simplest story is a cause to an effect.
- 12:58Angus Fletcher: So it's a beginning to an end, essentially.
- 12:59Angus Fletcher: But what you're doing when you go backwards from effect to cause is you're reversing that natural relationship and you're falling, you're forcing the brain to pause and identify the mechanic beneath it.
- 13:13Angus Fletcher: And there's a lot of different ways that we do this.
- 13:15Angus Fletcher: Um, you know, so a simple way that we do this all the time with operators is say, oh, you've got this model.
- 13:19Angus Fletcher: Well, based on this model, this thing should have happened, but it didn't.
- 14:20Angus Fletcher: Why didn't it happen?
- 14:21Angus Fletcher: And that's because your model is essentially over-predictive, you know?
- 14:24Angus Fletcher: And so these are all different ways you have of playing things forward, playing them backwards, and sort of always tightening and tightening and tightening that model, not because that model is going to last, but because you have to practice the process of tightening faster and faster.
- 14:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, so a rigid predictive model probably is um not anti-fragile, right?
- 14:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's exactly right.
- 14:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 14:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right.
- 14:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what we're asking folks to do when we talk about orientation, so orientation inside Boyd Zoodaloop, you can think of it as a world model or a generative model, right?
- 14:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh genetics, culture, and experience, and all the things that are connected to that.
- 14:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the more rigid it is, um, uh, if you want to look at like the default mode network or the way we operate or see the world, that acts as a filtering system.
- 15:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what it does is it prevents you from seeing new evidence or new information of what the world actually is, right?
- 15:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or what we think it actually is.
- 15:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um so what we want to do is we want to relax that to um allow you to see the world or more information to update that orientation as we go.
- 15:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And story, if I understand it correctly, is a great way to do that.
- 15:26Angus Fletcher: That's right.
- 15:26Angus Fletcher: Okay, so first of all, um that what you're talking about there is sort of breaking your world model, whatever we want to call that world model.
- 15:33Angus Fletcher: What that happens according to the army is through the detection of something known as exceptional information.
- 15:37Angus Fletcher: So exceptional information is basically any exception to a rule that you have in your brain.
- 15:42Angus Fletcher: And why is it that you become interested in a story?
- 15:45Angus Fletcher: It's because there's some interesting character or some interesting world, something that's breaking your preconceptions of what can happen, opening a new possibility.
- 15:53Angus Fletcher: Stories, by their very nature, are not boring, right?
- 15:56Angus Fletcher: I mean, at least stories that work are not boring.
- 15:58Angus Fletcher: So at the very elemental level of creating a story, you've got to figure out what's a piece of exceptional information to give my audience?
- 16:05Angus Fletcher: What's something that would surprise them and hook them and pull them out of the tedium of their day-to-day?
- 16:09Angus Fletcher: This is why people who are good storytellers are very good at identifying stuff that's weird and then very rapidly tying it back to relevance.
- 16:15Angus Fletcher: And that process of seeing the weird and realizing how it can be connected to actually kind of the ongoing flow or mechanism of life.
- 16:23Angus Fletcher: That's also a power we see in special operators and in most kind of effective military commanders, is they're able to rapidly see, okay, that's weird.
- 16:29Angus Fletcher: Okay, now how do I connect that to my existing plan?
- 16:32Angus Fletcher: Okay, now that allows me to see opportunities on the battlefield that I hadn't seen before.
- 16:36Angus Fletcher: So story helps you practice that.
- 16:39Angus Fletcher: That's why typically when you're walking soldiers through kind of tactical or strategic training, you tell them a story of a battle.
- 16:46Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 16:46Angus Fletcher: Yep.
- 16:47Angus Fletcher: And you release information a piece at a time.
- 16:49Angus Fletcher: And the point of each piece of information is to cause hesitation because all of a sudden it conflicts, right?
- 16:54Angus Fletcher: Because what you notice with with kind of like, I would say, sort of young or inexperienced kind of commanders or tacticians, is they very rapidly grip onto a strategy that they want to use in a particular battle.
- 17:04Angus Fletcher: You know?
- 17:05Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 17:05Angus Fletcher: And what you've got to do constantly through these role-playing exercises is start to disrupt them and see do they actually just get stuck on this plan, no matter how much information I give them?
- 17:15Angus Fletcher: Or the alternative is if they don't get stuck, a lot of them just freeze like deer in the headlight.
- 17:19Angus Fletcher: There's like there's too much happening.
- 17:20Angus Fletcher: And so, you know, the what a good storyteller is able to do is disperse information at the right speed so that the audience never gets confused and never gets aggressive.
- 17:28Angus Fletcher: And that process of exercising those muscles, those are the same muscles that help you kind of develop a plan, right?
- 17:33Angus Fletcher: If they help you develop a story.
- 17:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But this is not just about uh special operators, it's about everybody.
- 17:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, so you you bring up commander's intent and make a connection to Hamlet and Shakespeare.
- 17:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and and can you talk a little bit about how important storytelling is in the concept of commander's intent?
- 17:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we call it there's another level there.
- 17:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We call it mission command, right?
- 17:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we have mission command, commander's intent.
- 17:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We call it leader's intent as well.
- 17:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But what what is a connection that uh business leaders can take away from this conversation and connection to Hamlet?
- 18:01Angus Fletcher: Yeah, first of all, I just want to say that everybody's a special operator.
- 18:03Angus Fletcher: If I can be a special operator, you can be a special operator, right?
- 18:05Angus Fletcher: I mean, that's like the whole point of the Green Berets is to force multiplies to take everybody, every regular person, and turn them into a green beret.
- 18:12Angus Fletcher: To your question about commander's intent, what's happening there is you're telling people the end of the story.
- 18:17Angus Fletcher: You're saying this is where the story has to end.
- 18:20Angus Fletcher: The story has to end with this outcome.
- 18:21Angus Fletcher: Now I'm giving you, the person who I've given my intent, the ability to write the rest of the story.
- 18:27Angus Fletcher: You're at your beginning.
- 18:29Angus Fletcher: I've given you the end, create the middle.
- 18:32Angus Fletcher: And that process of storytelling is both incredibly powerful for organizations because it unleashes the creativity, the autonomy of your teams, but also because it allows them to be flexible.
- 18:44Angus Fletcher: They're on the ground in the way that you're not.
- 18:45Angus Fletcher: And when I see bad organizations, what they're trying to do is they're trying to tell not just commander's intent, but also the middle of the story.
- 18:52Angus Fletcher: So they're trying to say, here's where you're going and here's how you're gonna get there.
- 18:55Angus Fletcher: The moment you say, here's where you're going and here's how you've got to get there, you've just turned your human into a robot.
- 19:00Angus Fletcher: It's eliminated their ability to think autonomously.
- 19:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So agency is removed the moment you start telling them.
- 19:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is very important, too.
- 19:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and Moose, um, I I know you're you're you got some ideas in your head, I could see it.
- 19:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um Moose, can you bring us back to the loot loop on this and Boyd?
- 19:18Mark McGrath: Well we're biased, right?
- 19:22Mark McGrath: So we've been in the Boyd archives, and we know that the Army stole a lot from Boyd and and called it other stuff and didn't credit it.
- 19:35Speaker 2: Come on.
- 19:35Mark McGrath: Wait a minute.
- 19:36Mark McGrath: Okay.
- 19:36Mark McGrath: So box box fourteen of the Boyd Archives.
- 19:39Mark McGrath: I've been there, I've seen it with my own eyes.
- 19:41Angus Fletcher: As a as a um uh as a flunky from the Marine Corps, uh let me just point out to you that actually Boyd, I believe, was part of the Army Air Force originally, right?
- 19:50Angus Fletcher: Because you know the Army invented the Air Force.
- 19:52Angus Fletcher: So really all this stuff goes back to the Army.
- 19:54Angus Fletcher: The Army's the granddaddy of the Trevor Burrus, No, no, no, no.
- 19:57Mark McGrath: The Army's the granddaddy of the Space Force.
- 19:59Mark McGrath: They're the daddy of the Air Force and the granddaddy of the Space Force.
- 20:04Angus Fletcher: Um That's an unfortunate result that maybe the Army, you know, isn't it?
- 20:09Mark McGrath: Well no, just for context, though.
- 20:11Mark McGrath: So you you were Green Beret.
- 20:13Mark McGrath: No, I'm not a Green Beret.
- 20:15Mark McGrath: I'm a professor at Ohio State.
- 20:16Mark McGrath: No, I know that.
- 20:17Mark McGrath: But you I work with the Green Berets.
- 20:19Mark McGrath: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 20:20Mark McGrath: So so what I heard you say when you say like exceptional information, I mean that's what we would call a mismatch.
- 20:27Mark McGrath: So when you're scanning your environment and you encounter a mismatch, you you either have to interact with it in order to isolate it or you're gonna get isolated by it because you didn't interact with it.
- 20:36Mark McGrath: Um well, also too, I think another thing that really resonates with me, it's no secret, by the way, you know, because maybe another episode, but the we had Bing West on, and the Green Berets and the Marine Corps combined action program were the two forces in Vietnam that really tapped really tapped into this.
- 20:57Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 20:58Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 20:58Mark McGrath: That totally uh were highly successful.
- 21:01Mark McGrath: But back to the Air Force, the arm, you know, the institutional army, the institutional air force, institutional navy, the the idea of aligning inside of villages and aligning with tribes and aligning with culture, culture disseminated, and working from within to push out, that was a To you know dumping tonnage on things to get to get body counts, right?
- 21:23Mark McGrath: That's right.
- 21:24Mark McGrath: So so the Green Berets in the Marine Corps, I think, have uh an akin to thinking that Boyd himself uh tapped into because it was Andrew Krapinovich, who we'd love to have on the show, still around, uh, whose book The Army in Vietnam, Boyd talked, he talked about this exact thing, but Boyd would mention that book and discussing powers of conflict.
- 21:44Mark McGrath: And I would think that a lot of what you're speaking about, Angus, is that when when you have a cultural officer uh or a program like CAP or the Green Berets or others that are assimilating into, say, guerrilla forces or uh like a Lawrence of Arabia, you have to understand stories and you have to understand tribes because tribes are wired for stories and stories are are are how tribes uh how tribes communicate, and it's even how Boyd communicated.
- 22:11Mark McGrath: He didn't publish books and he didn't, you know, he he did it all through oral briefing culture.
- 22:16Mark McGrath: Um and and it and it changed every time.
- 22:18Mark McGrath: Um so I think the the resonance is pretty is pretty clear.
- 22:23Angus Fletcher: Yeah, yeah.
- 22:24Angus Fletcher: And to be clear, I think Boyd's a genius.
- 22:25Angus Fletcher: I think so what you're talking about there when you're going to another culture is first of all, every culture has its own narratives.
- 22:30Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 22:30Angus Fletcher: And that's kind of what you got on the list.
- 22:31Angus Fletcher: But also every individual within that culture has their own way of spinning those narratives and has their own narrative capacities.
- 22:37Angus Fletcher: And so a big part of what you have to do as a Green Beret, or you got to do as a Marine when you're when you're engaged in these exercises, you've got to get inside the head of your ally and think like them, or you've got to get inside the head of your adversary and think like that.
- 22:49Mark McGrath: I mean, there there's the there's the million-dollar point is that you it's all in the cognitive space.
- 22:56Mark McGrath: The war is always, always, always in the cognitive space.
- 22:59Mark McGrath: The ultimate weapon.
- 23:00Angus Fletcher: This is the ultimate weapon.
- 23:02Mark McGrath: Well, I'm glad.
- 23:02Mark McGrath: So I you know, I know your PhD is in English literature, so I know I'm I'm not the only liberal arts guy here today, but it that that exact frame of thinking that you have to have of interdisciplinary perspective, uh is exactly what you need to thrive in chaotic, nonlinear environments to get out of that uh sort of typeset mindset.
- 23:26Mark McGrath: You know, we start from the left, we go to the right, we start from the left, we go to the right.
- 23:29Mark McGrath: 100%.
- 23:30Mark McGrath: Um we haven't brought his we haven't brought his name up, but I think one of the things where we've broken a lot of ground on was compounding uh John Boyd with Marshall McLuhan.
- 23:40Mark McGrath: Because a lot of the things that you've been saying, it makes me think of it makes me think of Marshall McLuhan talking about how even things like the phonetic alphabet, even things like the written language and the printing press and all those things, those those media have a direct effect on how we interact with our our environment, how we interact.
- 23:56Mark McGrath: It shapes us as it shapes us as humans.
- 23:59Angus Fletcher: The media is the medium.
- 24:00Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 24:00Angus Fletcher: The medium is yeah, the medium is the same.
- 24:02Mark McGrath: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 24:03Mark McGrath: Yeah, yeah.
- 24:04Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 24:04Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 24:05Angus Fletcher: So um 100% agree with all these things.
- 24:09Angus Fletcher: And I think the question is is like, well, how do we help people get better at this?
- 24:12Angus Fletcher: Because the thing about what we what we see, uh, you know, this is my opinion anyway, what we see is that, you know, these are natural processes.
- 24:18Angus Fletcher: You know, anyone, you know, is born to a degree with a certain capacity to imagine like other people or learn stories or things like that.
- 24:24Angus Fletcher: But we see that certain groups are better at it, and we also see that certain groups are better at training it.
- 24:29Angus Fletcher: And you know, I think Army Special Operations has an incredible training pipeline.
- 24:33Angus Fletcher: I also think the Marines, to be honest, probably has an even better training pipeline because the Marines doesn't have the same selection sort of process, right?
- 24:39Angus Fletcher: So they just take everybody and train them to be a Marine, right?
- 24:41Angus Fletcher: Whereas Army Special Operations, you know, it's a little more than that.
- 24:44Mark McGrath: Well, there's a little there's some nuance behind that.
- 24:47Mark McGrath: I mean, I would say that um I would say that, well, officers are selected.
- 24:53Mark McGrath: Marine Marine officers are selected by Marine enlisted that train us.
- 24:57Mark McGrath: Um Marines have to go through a transformation process of 90 days at Marine Corps Recruit Depot, where you take a kid off the street, you break them down, you build them up, and 90 days you have a Marine.
- 25:09Mark McGrath: What General Gray with warfighting tried to get the point across, and Boyd was there for all of this, was that being a Marine is not a thing per se.
- 25:19Mark McGrath: It's a state of mind, it's a cognitive operating system, it's an orientation.
- 25:24Mark McGrath: And that's that's the distinguisher, I think, between that and looking at a lot of other things.
- 25:29Mark McGrath: They don't think of the, they think of the Marines Corps, Marine Corps in technical terms, not the Marine Corps in in cognitive terms, because that's really what it is.
- 25:37Mark McGrath: It's a way of thinking.
- 25:38Angus Fletcher: Well, I can tell you just based on my own limited experience at OCS, one of the gifts that I got from the Marine Corps is the Marine Corps puts you in these threat situations.
- 25:46Angus Fletcher: And so you go into a fight or flight response, and the Marine Corps teaches you when you're in fight or flight to fight.
- 25:52Angus Fletcher: And it's really effective at doing that again and again and again and again and again.
- 25:56Angus Fletcher: And I think that's a kind of training that we could benefit from giving a lot of young people because I think a lot of young people, when they go into a threat response, are more likely to quit nowadays than they were 10 years ago, 20 years ago, 30 years ago.
- 26:06Angus Fletcher: Whereas to go through uh basic training for the Marines is to start to understand your threat response and start to shift over to fight.
- 26:12Angus Fletcher: And I one of the things that I really loved about my you know brief contact with the Marines is to a certain extent, the Marines don't even care what you're fighting for.
- 26:20Angus Fletcher: You know, they just want you to fight.
- 26:22Angus Fletcher: Like that's kind of the basic training, you know, and and and and you know, they they allow a great deal of autonomy within that, right?
- 26:28Angus Fletcher: Because it's it's an American institution, right?
- 26:30Angus Fletcher: It's not like a conditioning system.
- 26:32Angus Fletcher: But that's the basis, really, of your autonomy is when you get into a situation when you're really scared, you don't give up.
- 26:39Angus Fletcher: Instead, you say, you know what, I have this other option, which is to struggle.
- 26:42Angus Fletcher: And even if I don't know exactly where I'm going, I'm just not gonna give up.
- 26:45Angus Fletcher: I'm gonna struggle, I'm gonna struggle.
- 26:46Angus Fletcher: And I don't think anyone is better at teaching that than the Marines.
- 26:48Mark McGrath: Just like how not to quit when you get in a situation where And there's way, well, the SEALs would be on par, I think, but and there's uh um there's ways to do it where you've never you don't even have to have you can learn fight or flight response with uh with breath work.
- 27:04Mark McGrath: And you can learn you can learn how to do it without having any any any time in the in the Marine Corps at all, but it teaches your body and your central nervous system that same response that you're uh that you're talking about.
- 27:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I think I think this is an opportunity to really give away some secrets here on building that adaptive capacity to understanding the environment, right?
- 27:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think that's what you're talking about, both of you, and that's intuit to me, that's intuition or process or adaptive capacity.
- 27:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, we've had folks come on from ecological dynamics, talk about the uh perception action loop and constraints-led approach inside of sports, which we think is fantastic, perceptual control theory.
- 27:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Earlier we we talked a little bit about hey, we don't want to take an engineering approach towards humans and say that we're computers.
- 27:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't want to take the same idea, but we are seeing natural intelligence go back into AI or what we think uh the way the brain works through things like the free energy principle, active inference, and high product perceptual control theory as well.
- 27:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So can you help us understand how we develop that intuition or what John Boyd called finger spliting of fuel?
- 28:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, yeah.
- 28:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So how do we do that?
- 28:03Angus Fletcher: You gotta be prepared, however, is that I'm a I spent 10 years working in AI and I think it's largely a hoax.
- 28:08Angus Fletcher: Same.
- 28:08Angus Fletcher: I think I think okay.
- 28:10Angus Fletcher: So and I think that I think that the reason that humans are smart is because we do things that AI can't do.
- 28:14Angus Fletcher: And so I think we've got to think of so let me give you a quick question.
- 28:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, let's build, let's build on that first.
- 28:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Boyd brought up people, ideas, and things, right?
- 28:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Always in that order.
- 28:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So things are AI.
- 28:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, we're not gonna take an engineering approach and apply it to a human system.
- 28:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We don't want to do that.
- 28:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But we I think what is better is taking a natural intelligence approach, what we think we know about how the brain processes, the living things process, and try to create AI off of that.
- 28:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So large language models are really just the closed oodaloop, the the linear basic approach to what everybody gets wrong about John Boyd's work.
- 28:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so we're with you 100% um with on this thought.
- 28:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I don't think the military, the department of war is.
- 28:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think a lot of folks in there don't understand that these engineering approaches are not how we're going to win war.
- 28:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to put that in there.
- 28:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's how the Chinese fight.
- 29:00Angus Fletcher: The Chinese are all in on AI because they're communists, and communism is a top-down system which is based on statistical inference.
- 29:07Angus Fletcher: Yes, exactly.
- 29:09Mark McGrath: Well, also, also, too, what we were talking about earlier, uh the the just the difference between Green Berets and marine combined action in Vietnam versus the the institutional military that was all about body count and technology and metrics uh and whiz kids and all that happy horse shit.
- 29:28Mark McGrath: That's right, rock back and arrow.
- 29:30Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 29:30Angus Fletcher: So okay, so let me give you a quick kind of just example of the difference between human intuition and computer intuition.
- 29:36Angus Fletcher: So if you go back and you, you know, you if you read your Daniel Kahneman or you look at any computer science textbook, they'll tell you what intuition is, is that it's a pattern match.
- 29:43Angus Fletcher: They'll tell you that.
- 29:44Angus Fletcher: And there's a problem with this, which is that computers crush at pattern matching.
- 29:50Angus Fletcher: You won't find any human that can pattern match like a computer can, but computers are terrible at intuition.
- 29:55Angus Fletcher: They're unable to see the leading edge of the future.
- 29:57Angus Fletcher: Meanwhile, children have pretty high intuition.
- 29:59Angus Fletcher: Children are able to spot.
- 30:01Angus Fletcher: I mean, this is why young kids are always spotting the next action trend faster than adults, right?
- 30:04Angus Fletcher: So, you know, there's a certain kind of prime area where you see kind of in your teens, where you're sort of like maxing out your intuition, your ability to kind of anticipate the future.
- 30:12Angus Fletcher: That's why entrepreneurs are typically younger, yada yada yada, right?
- 30:15Angus Fletcher: That's why people who get Nobel Prizes are typically younger.
- 30:17Angus Fletcher: All this, or you know, they discover the Nobel Prize from there because you have this intuition, which is not actually data-driven.
- 30:23Angus Fletcher: What's actually happening there?
- 30:24Angus Fletcher: Well, human intuition is the ability to spot exceptional information, which is the ability to spot an exception.
- 30:29Angus Fletcher: So actually, intuition is your ability to see something that does not fit, not your ability to detect a pattern.
- 30:35Angus Fletcher: It's the opposite of that.
- 30:37Angus Fletcher: How do you train that up?
- 30:38Angus Fletcher: There's lots of different ways to train it up.
- 30:39Angus Fletcher: The simple and most basic way to train it up, which every green beret does, is just to travel.
- 30:43Angus Fletcher: And by traveling, I don't mean, you know, like going to a resort and eating McDonald's, you know, in another country.
- 30:50Angus Fletcher: I mean literally living in someone else's house, getting yourself immersed in other culture.
- 30:54Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 30:55Mark McGrath: Why is I have to tell I have to tell you, so that actually came up at this event that I was here here in Manhattan last night, um, where one of the exercises that uh Dr.
- 31:05Mark McGrath: Anna Yusome, who's a psychiatrist at Yale, um who has been a guest on our show, and she's talking about spirituality and consciousness and these sorts of things.
- 31:14Mark McGrath: And she had us go through three exercises, and and one of one of them was, you know, like what is it about you that makes you you, makes you, you know, different or distinguished versus others?
- 31:26Mark McGrath: And the thing that I brought up was growing up the son of a career army officer that went to West Point, that we lived all over the world, and both of my parents had had itinerant lifestyles growing up.
- 31:38Mark McGrath: My my grandfather was an executive uh with Exxon, so they moved around a little bit and lived in other countries.
- 31:44Mark McGrath: And then my mother, uh her dad, who's also a Yaley like you, um they he was a uh he was an Episcopalian priest and they, you know, moved around from place to place.
- 31:54Mark McGrath: And then having that military experience as a kid, you were constantly in immersion, re-immersion, immersion, re-immersion.
- 32:02Mark McGrath: So you were learning different cultures, different languages, going to different countries, meeting.
- 32:05Mark McGrath: Now I interacted with a lot of kids whose moms were from Vietnam because their dads that had fought in the Vietnam War, they brought back a wife from Vietnam or their moms were Korean.
- 32:15Mark McGrath: So you're constantly exposed to like other cultures and and other perspectives such that it's not like, oh, I was born here and I lived here my entire life, and that's my that's my uh that's my worldview.
- 32:28Angus Fletcher: And so neurologically, what does that do?
- 32:30Angus Fletcher: It does a couple things.
- 32:31Angus Fletcher: So, like, um uh first of all, the reason that children are so good at spotting exceptions is because they're born into a world where everything to them is exceptional.
- 32:41Angus Fletcher: So you're essentially putting yourself back in your kind of like child state of mind, where you're constantly being immersed in a place where everything is exception to you, exceptional to you.
- 32:49Angus Fletcher: And all those kinds of parts of your narrative hardware and your brain are starting to pop in that situation.
- 32:54Angus Fletcher: The other thing is you're discouraging what is the adult response to exceptions.
- 32:58Angus Fletcher: So, what's the adult response to exceptions?
- 33:00Angus Fletcher: The adult response to exceptions is to do what a computer does and regress them to the mean, or to skip over them as an exception.
- 33:06Angus Fletcher: This is what computers do.
- 33:07Angus Fletcher: So they basically discount exceptions.
- 33:09Angus Fletcher: They say, oh, that's an inefficiency.
- 33:10Angus Fletcher: You know, I need to I need to not pay attention to that because every second you're spending focusing on an exception is a second you're getting away from your core mechanism, your core productivity.
- 33:19Angus Fletcher: So when we look at top executives, they spot tailorism, right?
- 33:23Angus Fletcher: Tailorism, yes.
- 33:24Angus Fletcher: Oh my gosh, that's right.
- 33:25Angus Fletcher: Yeah, yeah.
- 33:26Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 33:26Angus Fletcher: I'm I'm I'm uh definitely not a tailorist when I go to foreign countries.
- 33:30Angus Fletcher: So don't don't be tailored.
- 33:31Angus Fletcher: But a lot of the institutional thinkers are.
- 33:34Angus Fletcher: Are they the foundation of Harvard Business School?
- 33:37Angus Fletcher: And you know, and I by the way, I have, thanks to Army Special Operations, one of the most popular articles in HBR last year, a big feature article on how to become a leader based on special operations.
- 33:46Angus Fletcher: But I will tell you that 99% of the world gets their business training from Harvard Business Review Online, and it's all tailorism.
- 33:52Angus Fletcher: And we would do a lot better to send some of those folks into some military training or just get them to travel more.
- 33:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So yeah, so can you say that again?
- 34:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you can you say that all again?
- 34:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Because uh please, that's what we're trying to explain to folks is get away from Harvard and learn from Yeah, yeah.
- 34:08Angus Fletcher: Yeah, so so Harvard is great.
- 34:09Angus Fletcher: So, like as I said, you can you can look this up.
- 34:11Angus Fletcher: I have um I have a big feature.
- 34:13Angus Fletcher: So they publish only a few features a year.
- 34:14Angus Fletcher: I have a huge feature.
- 34:15Angus Fletcher: It's called uh, you know, lessons on leadership from U.S.
- 34:17Angus Fletcher: Army Special Operations.
- 34:18Angus Fletcher: I talk about kind of all this brain science and all this kind of stuff.
- 34:21Angus Fletcher: So, you know, I love Harvard, love the editors there.
- 34:22Angus Fletcher: But I will tell you, based on my experience with Harvard Business Review, is that 99% of what they publish is a version of Taylorism or organizational psychology or all these things that grow out of tailorism, design thinking, all these things.
- 34:34Angus Fletcher: These are totally fine in stable environments, which is to say they're fine for managers, which is to say they're fine for being inside a company which is data rich and its processes are not changing.
- 34:43Angus Fletcher: The moment that you are confronted with anything new, you need to shift from management into leadership.
- 34:48Angus Fletcher: You need to have initiative, you need to have imagination, you need to have common sense, which is something that Taylorism does not teach you.
- 34:54Angus Fletcher: These are all things that you learn automatically almost your first day on the job uh in the military because the first thing, because what's the basis of the military?
- 35:03Angus Fletcher: It's it's something called inherited problems.
- 35:04Angus Fletcher: What are inherited problems?
- 35:06Angus Fletcher: They're problems you didn't make.
- 35:07Angus Fletcher: United States uh people made a problem for you, right?
- 35:10Angus Fletcher: Welcome, you're welcome, military.
- 35:12Angus Fletcher: Take this problem and solve it.
- 35:13Angus Fletcher: And you're like, I don't have any training in solving this problem.
- 35:15Angus Fletcher: It doesn't matter.
- 35:16Angus Fletcher: You better solve it because now all of a sudden it's your job.
- 35:18Angus Fletcher: And so you've got to get very, very quick at learning.
- 35:22Angus Fletcher: You've got to get very, very quick at opening yourself to your environment.
- 35:25Angus Fletcher: You've got to very, very quick because you also have inherited talents, right?
- 35:29Angus Fletcher: Which is a kind of nice way of saying you're stuck with the people who happen to be on your squad.
- 35:33Angus Fletcher: You've got to get very, very good at identifying what their strengths are.
- 35:36Angus Fletcher: And one of the things that I love about the military is the military almost never throws anybody away.
- 35:40Angus Fletcher: Now, occasionally you get some people, right?
- 35:42Angus Fletcher: They just keep transferring them around and hoping that they stick somewhere.
- 35:45Angus Fletcher: But for most good leaders in the military are able to look at individuals who haven't been activated yet, who nobody else has been able to figure out, and they're able to find out what makes them work.
- 35:55Angus Fletcher: That's totally different from business where you just fire people immediately.
- 35:58Angus Fletcher: So the entire purpose of the military is to identify what's exceptional in your environment, to identify what's exceptional in the members of your team.
- 36:04Angus Fletcher: That's what powers leadership, that's what's different from management because that's what allows you to have an edge in a changing world which prioritizes innovation and initiative as opposed to optimization, efficiency, and just kind of squeezing a couple more numbers out of the system.
- 36:19Mark McGrath: So you do were you familiar with uh One Tribe at a Time?
- 36:23Mark McGrath: Yes.
- 36:24Mark McGrath: And and James Gant?
- 36:25Mark McGrath: So why didn't that catch on then?
- 36:28Mark McGrath: Like why didn't that work?
- 36:30Mark McGrath: In in the in the business community you mean?
- 36:33Mark McGrath: Or well, let's start with the army, but you know, you know, again, you could take the same concepts to the business community, which which which Ponch and I have talked a lot about and and tried to demonstrate.
- 36:43Mark McGrath: But like why why did something that seemingly a thing it seems like there was a thinker that was doing what you say and was pretty good at storytelling and pretty good at uh at interacting and and and pretty good at dealing with exceptional information and the model was working, but why how did it not?
- 37:03Angus Fletcher: But but the system didn't accept it.
- 37:05Angus Fletcher: So here's the thing.
- 37:05Angus Fletcher: So I don't want to get in trouble from the army for saying this, but this is true.
- 37:09Angus Fletcher: Is when I praise the army, I praise the people in the army.
- 37:12Angus Fletcher: I do not praise the system of the army.
- 37:15Angus Fletcher: There we go.
- 37:15Angus Fletcher: And I've spent an enormous amount of time watching all the work that we've done get thrown out of the system.
- 37:20Angus Fletcher: So I've spent like the last couple of years with the army getting these like just really, you know, these phone calls from people who are like, oh my God, you know, they just threw out this thing that we did, they just threw out this other thing that we did, and so on and so forth.
- 37:29Angus Fletcher: And so I can't explain the army.
- 37:32Angus Fletcher: It's the largest bureaucracy in the entire world.
- 37:33Angus Fletcher: It's totally dysfunctional like any bureaucracy.
- 37:35Angus Fletcher: But what I do know is that those ideas stick around in individuals.
- 37:39Angus Fletcher: And when individuals hit a crisis, they pull that book off the shelf and they learn from it.
- 37:43Angus Fletcher: And that's my sense of how the military generally works is it's unable to systematize these insights, but they kind of stick around long enough in the culture that when people need them, they get them from word of mouth to somebody else.
- 37:54Mark McGrath: So do you think then that the reason that like that idea which General Purchase has told everybody to integrate this and operationalize this, so it was the system, because we, you know, Punch and I aren't aren't going to disagree with that.
- 38:08Mark McGrath: Like we know that systems drive behaviors, but so that so the system didn't allow that kind of thing to flourish.
- 38:15Angus Fletcher: Systems exist to perpetuate themselves.
- 38:18Angus Fletcher: Yep.
- 38:18Angus Fletcher: And what perpetuates a system is stasis.
- 38:21Angus Fletcher: And so, you know, the thing that I think has always been the amazing thing about the military is that it's always managed to win despite being a system.
- 38:30Angus Fletcher: It's not the system that helps it win.
- 38:32Angus Fletcher: And you see this again and again in the military.
- 38:34Angus Fletcher: I mean, the the smart folks that that that you know in the military always figure out ways to like bend the rules, break the rules.
- 38:40Angus Fletcher: Everybody figures out how to kind of get it done.
- 38:42Angus Fletcher: And you know, the military has this culture, which is per, I think, you know, maintained by the sort of senior NCOs, which, you know, when the system is helpful, and sometimes the system can be helpful in peacetime in terms of getting you your funding.
- 38:53Angus Fletcher: I mean, there are ways to play the system, to work the system, you know, and certainly good NCOs know exactly how to do that.
- 38:58Angus Fletcher: But the moment you get into a conflict space and the system is working against you, you just see everybody just kind of pushes it aside.
- 39:04Angus Fletcher: And, you know, that relies again on common sense.
- 39:08Angus Fletcher: Because if people push the system aside and just go totally rogue, you end up with like anarchic, violent, destructive behavior, right?
- 39:14Angus Fletcher: You know, you end up with vigilante behavior.
- 39:16Angus Fletcher: I mean, and there are instances of that obviously happening in special operations.
- 39:20Angus Fletcher: But for the most part, there's a culture of special operations which is essentially the good outlaw.
- 39:24Angus Fletcher: You know, you you've probably heard this term before, you know.
- 39:26Angus Fletcher: And basically it's like, you know, we go outside the rules to kind of respect the rules in a way, right?
- 39:31Angus Fletcher: You know, we we we we we we break the law in order to make the law, essentially.
- 39:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the a lot of the constraints or rules are designed for a complicated domain.
- 39:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think you you it sounds to me like you're very familiar with complexity theory and you use a lot of unknown and unknowns and things like that.
- 39:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So yeah, neuroscience, complexity theory, and storytelling.
- 39:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, the connection to AI, what I'm hearing from you is hey, these things are really good in the complicated domain.
- 39:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Humans are fantastic in the complex domain.
- 39:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, relationship between cause and effect is only known in retrospect.
- 39:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, and therefore, um not just only not just intuition, but common sense allows us to navigate that complex domain.
- 40:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is is that ring true with you?
- 40:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and do you have any more?
- 40:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That was an amazing synopsis.
- 40:12Angus Fletcher: You didn't need me on this podcast.
- 40:13Angus Fletcher: You could have just said those words, you know.
- 40:15Angus Fletcher: Um No, we need you on this podcast.
- 40:17Angus Fletcher: No, no, we really do.
- 40:18Angus Fletcher: Uh what interests me is how you train common sense.
- 40:20Angus Fletcher: And this is another thing because like I went through so special operations actually has a common sense course.
- 40:26Angus Fletcher: They have a course for common sense, and they essentially put me through it and I scored a negative.
- 40:30Angus Fletcher: I scored a negative on common sense.
- 40:33Angus Fletcher: And they were like, whoa, they're like, we we get people in here all the time.
- 40:35Angus Fletcher: Because I think a lot of young people go into the course that essentially score zero, but scoring a negative is is is is amazing.
- 40:40Angus Fletcher: Well, congratulations on that.
- 40:42Angus Fletcher: That's amazing.
- 40:42Angus Fletcher: I have negative common sense.
- 40:43Angus Fletcher: And you know, of course, it's because I spend all my time in front of a computer or in a classroom.
- 40:47Angus Fletcher: You know what I mean?
- 40:48Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 40:48Angus Fletcher: So I don't have the ability to make intelligent decisions when I don't have a lot of information, which is what common sense is.
- 40:53Angus Fletcher: It's like, how do you make the right call?
- 40:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's put a pin in that for a second.
- 40:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you saying that people that spend a lot of time in front of their computers that don't go outside and engage with the external world probably don't have a lot of common sense?
- 41:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm telling you they probably have negative common sense like I do.
- 41:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's take it a step further.
- 41:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I've been told that you know every village has an idiot, but the internet brings them together.
- 41:11Angus Fletcher: So are we is that is I think that's mostly accurate, except I think it would be more accurate to say the internet makes them.
- 41:18unknown: Ah.
- 41:19Mark McGrath: Okay.
- 41:19Mark McGrath: Angus, so here's my question then.
- 41:22Mark McGrath: So we're we're talking about dealing with complexity and we're talking about how um you know the the m the Green Berets and the and the USMC cap and the in the complexities of Vietnam with a you know a a different you know in an Asian culture, an Eastern country, an Eastern language, an Eastern way of thinking, how they were able to thrive in that and and yet their dependence on what the on on what it was that was empowering to thrive was not technical, was not computers, was not munitions, was it was something else that engineers don't learn the way liberal arts people do, the way linguists do, the way psychologists do, historians, et cetera, philosophers, et cetera, et cetera.
- 42:09Angus Fletcher: Aaron Powell That's certainly right.
- 42:10Angus Fletcher: And it and I will say, however, that over the last 20 years, kids who are getting a liberal arts education are learning less of it than kids who got a liberal arts education, you know, 40 years ago or 60 years ago.
- 42:19Angus Fletcher: There's been a real narrowing of this.
- 42:21Angus Fletcher: The main reason for that is what does school teach you?
- 42:24Angus Fletcher: School teaches you that there's a right answer and the teacher has it.
- 42:27Angus Fletcher: And even in liberal arts.
- 42:29Angus Fletcher: Well, increasingly now in liberal arts.
- 42:31Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 42:31Angus Fletcher: You know, it used to be the case that you would kind of, you know, you take a class in philosophy and then you go over to literature and the two classes would be different.
- 42:37Angus Fletcher: And so it'd be like going from one world to another.
- 42:39Angus Fletcher: I mean, that's the basic idea.
- 42:40Angus Fletcher: Is that you're constantly exploring all these different cultures.
- 42:43Angus Fletcher: But increasingly, the humanities has narrowed in on a smaller and smaller set of truisms.
- 42:48Angus Fletcher: Why?
- 42:48Angus Fletcher: Because the humanities is detached from reality.
- 42:50Angus Fletcher: And so you get this artificial culture that's essentially starting to replicate itself like any system that needs, I think, to kind of be disrupted.
- 42:57Angus Fletcher: And people are trying to disrupt that now by adding this kind of, you know, these, you know, you know, right-wing ideologies into it.
- 43:01Angus Fletcher: The problem is much more fundamental than that.
- 43:03Angus Fletcher: The problem, the problem is that it's ideological at all, really, right?
- 43:06Angus Fletcher: I mean, you know, I mean, the humanities should be a place where you explore different perspectives in a in a democratic way.
- 43:12Mark McGrath: Do you think that so disclosure, I'm I'm of the Jesuit system, so liberal arts, and my my BA was in history.
- 43:20Mark McGrath: So do you think that when open inquiry in a worldly view, exposing people to all those sorts of things, that when we've shied away from that or moved away from that, that actually hurts us in complexity, not helps us?
- 43:35Angus Fletcher: Yeah, absolutely.
- 43:36Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 43:37Angus Fletcher: Yeah, no, 100%.
- 43:37Angus Fletcher: Because you you've got to understand that that other people think differently than you.
- 43:42Angus Fletcher: That's it.
- 43:42Angus Fletcher: And why do other people think differently than you?
- 43:44Angus Fletcher: Well, it's a biological thing.
- 43:46Angus Fletcher: Every brain is different.
- 43:47Angus Fletcher: And beyond that, biological success comes from the ability to surprise your adversaries.
- 43:52Angus Fletcher: So the human brain evolved to think differently because that's its edge.
- 43:55Angus Fletcher: So anytime a human is going into an environment, it's like, what can I do differently than other people?
- 43:59Angus Fletcher: That's like your basic thought, you know?
- 44:01Angus Fletcher: And and so, you know, repressive regimes try and suppress that by programming everybody and making them think the same.
- 44:07Angus Fletcher: Whereas democratic environments say, let's use that.
- 44:09Angus Fletcher: Let's use the fact that we're all thinking differently and figure out a way to have conversations.
- 44:13Angus Fletcher: So a big part of a classroom, the idea there is you have conversations with other people who think differently than you.
- 44:17Angus Fletcher: And the classroom is going to nurture those differences of perspective, not try and gain consensus, but actually allow you to understand somebody else at the same time as you remain yourself.
- 44:25Angus Fletcher: And what that's doing is the same thing that, you know, the Marines or, you know, uh Mac V.
- 44:30Angus Fletcher: Sog or whatever were doing in Vietnam when they were going in and and and and you know, building across cultures.
- 44:35Angus Fletcher: They weren't creating Americans, they were allowing that culture to remain distinct while at the same time they were having a conversation.
- 44:41Mark McGrath: Ooh, absolutely.
- 44:42Mark McGrath: So what do you think we've given up then?
- 44:44Mark McGrath: Do you think it's our educational system that's that's emphasized more STEM and pulled people away from those things that allow for creativity and imagination?
- 44:54Angus Fletcher: It's standardized testing, which is infected high schools.
- 44:56Angus Fletcher: It's basically what I would call kind of careerism, which is the idea that college exists to give you a stamp, a rubber stamp.
- 45:02Angus Fletcher: So people aren't interested in learning anymore.
- 45:04Angus Fletcher: They're just interested in getting the stamp.
- 45:06Angus Fletcher: And also it's about the kind of ideological consolidation of the humanities.
- 45:10Angus Fletcher: Um, you know, and there was a period of time, I would say kind of a sweet spot in the 90s, where you had the kind of older, more conservative humanists and you had the newer, kind of more progressive humanists, and they were just like fighting like cats and dogs inside departments.
- 45:22Angus Fletcher: But that was great for students because you could go back and forth between like your 70-year-old professor who was like, Let me tell you the great books and the great classics, and you could have your new professor who's like, I'm gonna use some radical ideas.
- 45:31Angus Fletcher: Now all those radical professors are the old guard, and there's no new radicals.
- 45:35Angus Fletcher: And so as a result, we just basically have this ideological conformity, and that's the death of any system.
- 45:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm curious about this.
- 45:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, you in within the army, I'm sure you are aware of University of Foreign Military Cultural Studies, UFMCS, and and their now defunct red teaming school, which was created by Colonel Rodkoff.
- 45:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So why did it why did the military army get rid of that?
- 45:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you're insane.
- 45:59Angus Fletcher: Steve, Steve.
- 46:00Angus Fletcher: Because they're insane.
- 46:01Angus Fletcher: Yeah, no, I mean, this is first of all, I mean, I I don't know the individual decision makers, and I'm sure the folks that I've talked to about this have all expressed heartbreak over it.
- 46:09Angus Fletcher: So I know it's not like, you know, but I mean, getting rid of red teaming is nuts.
- 46:13Angus Fletcher: Absolutely nuts.
- 46:15Angus Fletcher: And I think everybody knows it.
- 46:16Angus Fletcher: I mean, if you go into any sports team in America, any professional sports team, they spend all of their time red teaming.
- 46:21Angus Fletcher: Right.
- 46:21Angus Fletcher: That's why they're good, right?
- 46:22Angus Fletcher: You know, you're always trying to kind of, you know, bring your adversary into the building to break you down.
- 46:28Angus Fletcher: And the moment you stop doing that, and I think, you know, there's been this whole shift, and I don't know exactly why it is, but this shift towards optimization.
- 46:35Angus Fletcher: The problem with optimization is it gives you this idea that there's a right way to win everything.
- 46:39Angus Fletcher: And if we somehow just get that right way to win, then we're okay, you know?
- 46:43Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 46:43Angus Fletcher: Optimization biologically leads to extreme fragility.
- 46:46Angus Fletcher: Any organism, any organism that's optimized to its environment is the first organism that goes extinct.
- 46:51Angus Fletcher: Yep.
- 46:51Angus Fletcher: You know, the human hand, not optimized, right?
- 46:54Angus Fletcher: Totally not optimized, right?
- 46:56Angus Fletcher: But good at a million things, right?
- 46:57Angus Fletcher: It's adequacy, it has maximum adequacy.
- 47:00Angus Fletcher: And so I think, you know, there is a culture of optimization, of efficiency.
- 47:03Angus Fletcher: These things tend to take over.
- 47:04Angus Fletcher: Over specialization.
- 47:05Angus Fletcher: Over specialization, all these things, right?
- 47:07Angus Fletcher: You know, and they're they're not good in militaries, and they're really, really bad for kids, which to go back to our earlier part of the conversation is what's the problem with schools.
- 47:15Angus Fletcher: And they're also disasters for businesses.
- 47:17Angus Fletcher: I mean, you're seeing now with businesses, there's this loss of growth, there's this loss of productivity.
- 47:22Angus Fletcher: There's something called the productivity paradox, which I'm sure everybody who's a business person knows about, which is that we keep dumping technology into companies that doesn't increase their productivity because we're not accessing the human potential inside companies, and humans are becoming widgets.
- 47:34Mark McGrath: And all isn't that the isn't that the Vietnam example?
- 47:37Mark McGrath: We'll just keep throwing more money and tech and sensors at all the problems.
- 47:41Mark McGrath: That's right.
- 47:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, let me ask you that.
- 47:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This now is is that happening now in the DRW uh in the US?
- 47:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are we are we becoming more dependent on more tech or people?
- 47:52Angus Fletcher: I mean, you know, again, I I don't want to speak out of turn and I speak for myself, not for the Department of War.
- 47:56Angus Fletcher: Right.
- 47:56Angus Fletcher: But I mean, all I see everywhere is how special operations is going to suddenly get into cyber and how this is the future.
- 48:02Angus Fletcher: And there's no question that cyber is a great tool.
- 48:04Angus Fletcher: But the moment you start thinking that all of these battles are gonna be fought in this kind of technological zone of IT and the rest of it, right?
- 48:11Angus Fletcher: You're taking away the human edge.
- 48:14Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 48:14Angus Fletcher: You're taking away the fact that if you drop, and there's a uh a buddy of mine who's a uh um who just recently retired from special operations.
- 48:21Angus Fletcher: His name is uh Colonel Gaines, Tom Gaines.
- 48:23Angus Fletcher: He just wrote a great uh novel called Quantum Dagger.
- 48:25Angus Fletcher: So I'm just gonna promote that here on your podcast.
- 48:27Angus Fletcher: Go read Quantum Dagger.
- 48:29Angus Fletcher: It's basically about a bunch of green berets who have to go up against the Chinese AI.
- 48:32Angus Fletcher: And it's basically a story about how the AI is like winning and winning and winning and winning until all of a sudden catastrophic, right?
- 48:38Angus Fletcher: Problems.
- 48:39Angus Fletcher: And so, and and and this is the thing, is we're losing what made America America and what made it prosperous and what made it succeed, which is this ability to be different uh in a positive way, you know?
- 48:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We just had uh Fred Stein on the show.
- 48:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's the co-author of Network Centric Warfare.
- 48:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He worked with Admiral Zabrowski years ago.
- 48:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the bottom line was in 1999, early 2000, we were trying to figure out um how to use information, information for the external environment.
- 49:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do we improve organizational and individual performance?
- 49:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That got lost into hey, we need better systems, better technology, and and so we're this isn't changing.
- 49:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what I'm getting at, is no matter how much we push people, ideas, and things, um, the systems can be driven towards things, technology.
- 49:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's the systems want the things.
- 49:26Angus Fletcher: And there's no question that intelligence is really important.
- 49:28Angus Fletcher: So if you if you get great surveillance on your adversary, that's incredible, right?
- 49:31Angus Fletcher: If you can get eyes inside, that's incredible.
- 49:34Angus Fletcher: But the problem is increasingly, the more we've shifted to tech, the more we've lost human intelligence, which is way more valuable than surveillance intelligence.
- 49:41Angus Fletcher: You know, I mean, if you look at this operation that just happened in Venezuela, that was essentially a single human on the inside, which gave us all of that information.
- 49:49Angus Fletcher: And you couldn't replicate that with a billion satellites spying and spying and spying.
- 49:54Mark McGrath: What do you think of like say 9-11, where 19 guys with box cutters, they defeated the system with all the sensors, all the satellites, every all the tech, all the security, everything.
- 50:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Humans are always going to beat systems.
- 50:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and then that led to a more rigid system now, right?
- 50:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean Right.
- 50:10Angus Fletcher: And now we all have to do this insane thing at the airport.
- 50:12Angus Fletcher: We all take our shoes off for no reason.
- 50:14Angus Fletcher: Like there's no one putting a bomb in their shoes.
- 50:16Angus Fletcher: And yet, I guarantee you, over a billion shoes have been removed and scanned for no reason whatsoever because the system has decided this is how to keep people safe.
- 50:24Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 50:24Mark McGrath: Unless you have TSA Pre.
- 50:26Mark McGrath: Right.
- 50:27Angus Fletcher: Well, that's a way for the system to extract money from from you for its stupidity, right?
- 50:32Mark McGrath: Right, for its own survival, as you say.
- 50:34Mark McGrath: So, so you you don't then foresee, I don't know, I doesn't sound like it.
- 50:40Mark McGrath: I mean, guerrilla warfare will still work.
- 50:44Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 50:44Angus Fletcher: Of course, yeah.
- 50:45Angus Fletcher: And you know, when you're fighting a conventional army, you're gonna use conventional uh, you know, response to some extent, right?
- 50:53Angus Fletcher: Because that's how you balance and pause it.
- 50:55Angus Fletcher: But then the guerrilla warfare is what allows you to get inside and disrupt and create chaos inside.
- 51:00Angus Fletcher: So in any conflict, there's gonna be guerrilla warfare.
- 51:03Angus Fletcher: It's just a question of how much.
- 51:04Angus Fletcher: And you do need some conventional response.
- 51:06Angus Fletcher: I mean, if China shows up uh with you know, thousands and thousands of warships and planes, we need some way to knock those down.
- 51:13Angus Fletcher: We can't just all of a sudden be running around.
- 51:15Angus Fletcher: You know, we you got to balance your enemy to some extent, you know, but you can't rely on that to create victory.
- 51:20Angus Fletcher: Um, that's just gonna get us back to World War I and the stalemate and this kind of you know, um, two giants just basically engaging in a war of attrition.
- 51:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and and that's a disaster.
- 51:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to get your thoughts on this.
- 51:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We talk a lot about being in World War III now.
- 51:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a cognitive war.
- 51:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's happening, you know, the battlefield is our mind.
- 51:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So fifth generation warfare um, you know, PsyOps.
- 51:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How does your work tie into that?
- 51:44Angus Fletcher: Yeah, well, I did in fact work quite a lot with PSYOPS units inside special operations as as you might imagine.
- 51:50Angus Fletcher: And, you know, to your point, essentially, what you're trying to do there is you're sort of trying to win the narrative.
- 51:55Angus Fletcher: You're trying to figure out how to win the story.
- 51:57Angus Fletcher: And if you can win the narrative, you can win the story, then you get people on board without fighting because they realize that they've already lost and they realize that you've already won.
- 52:04Angus Fletcher: And I think for a long time and that's Sun Tzu.
- 52:06Angus Fletcher: That's boy.
- 52:07Angus Fletcher: Exactly.
- 52:08Angus Fletcher: Sun Tzu.
- 52:08Angus Fletcher: No, I totally agree.
- 52:09Angus Fletcher: Yeah, yeah.
- 52:09Angus Fletcher: And now that but the problem is that people don't understand what a winning story is anymore.
- 52:14Mark McGrath: Why do they so you're saying that they always want to see a trigger pulled or a bomb fly?
- 52:19Mark McGrath: They they don't realize that you could, you know, like we're seeing some of the ex posts now.
- 52:25Mark McGrath: It looks like there's going to be a deal on whatever, but there didn't have to be a shot fired.
- 52:29Mark McGrath: There didn't have to be a a life taken.
- 52:32Angus Fletcher: Well, what I think it is, is I think the military in most cases would prefer not to pull a trigger, but I think that they don't know how to make the stories effectively.
- 52:38Angus Fletcher: And I think that they always default back to what doing what they do well, which is pulling a trigger, because it's easier to pull a trigger.
- 52:43Angus Fletcher: I mean, it's easier to send in Delta Force, hypothetically, if they exist, than it is to come up with a, you know, a counter-narrative that shifts South America onto our side.
- 52:52Angus Fletcher: And the reason for that is because, you know, when you look at how people use narratives nowadays, they don't engage with their audience.
- 52:59Angus Fletcher: So they're just telling a story of how I, the storyteller, want it to be, as opposed to engaging with my audience and figuring out how to connect with them.
- 53:06Angus Fletcher: The reason that in the, you know, after the Second World War, the reason we were successful at rebuilding Germany, rebuilding Japan is we were able to find narratives that work for those countries.
- 53:14Angus Fletcher: And as a result, they became huge economic engines, which then boosted the city.
- 53:17Mark McGrath: Oh, what a great point.
- 53:18Mark McGrath: So, so when so we've had, we're Punch and I were just talking about this in our little gap there, about Charlie Pratzman that was talking about how uh MacArthur brought over all these statisticians and whatnot to really reinvent the Japanese economy.
- 53:34Mark McGrath: But what it was was is a fusion of respecting their culture with sort of the greatest hits of of Western culture.
- 53:41Mark McGrath: Whereas when I heard you just now say, it's a lot of time we're going around to enforce our culture or our template on something where it can't, it can't even flourish anyway, and all it does is create more conflict.
- 53:56Angus Fletcher: I mean, we all know this is the story of Iraq.
- 53:58Angus Fletcher: We went in there, we then ripped out their entire operating system and tried to replace it with our kind of operating system, and then the result was ISIS and chaos.
- 54:06Angus Fletcher: And what you got to do is you gotta go in there and say, what story is being told here?
- 54:10Angus Fletcher: How do we make that story better?
- 54:12Angus Fletcher: Because we're America, we make everything better.
- 54:13Angus Fletcher: We have Hollywood, right?
- 54:14Angus Fletcher: You give us your story, we make it better.
- 54:16Angus Fletcher: That's what we do, you know?
- 54:17Angus Fletcher: And we could do that again and again and again.
- 54:19Angus Fletcher: And when people see a story that's not only better, but also possible.
- 54:23Angus Fletcher: Because, you know, a lot of what happens with, you know, I would say bad stories, you know, the stories like emanating out of Russia or whatever, is they're lies.
- 54:30Angus Fletcher: So, you know, they they say, oh, things will be better, but they're not possible or they're not gonna happen.
- 54:34Angus Fletcher: Whereas America creates better stories that can work.
- 54:37Angus Fletcher: Like that's the key.
- 54:38Angus Fletcher: Another name for that, right, is a plan, is a strategy.
- 54:40Angus Fletcher: You know you've got a good commander when they give you something that's ambitious, an ambitious narrative, but you know it can work if everybody just gets on board.
- 54:47Angus Fletcher: And that's what motivates people to try hard.
- 54:49Angus Fletcher: And we've gotten out of the business of doing that.
- 54:50Angus Fletcher: Instead, we're trying to sell quick fixes and big fantasies.
- 54:54Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 54:54Angus Fletcher: And if we go back to this narrative project, like you're talking about, as you're calling World War III, if we go back to this project and say, all right, what can we actually do to get on the same page as everybody in South America?
- 55:05Angus Fletcher: How can we build a story of what it looks like to have an America, right?
- 55:09Angus Fletcher: What would that look like?
- 55:09Angus Fletcher: How would we all gain from that?
- 55:11Angus Fletcher: What are the steps we've got to take?
- 55:13Angus Fletcher: You know, um, that's uh a future which can happen.
- 55:17Angus Fletcher: Whereas, you know, whereas, you know, um what we're doing now is we're is is is is is we're not putting in that kind of like deeper psychological work and we're just trying to drop systems on top of things and act as those systems can fix it.
- 55:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Angus, how familiar are you with uh Dave Snowden's work on complexity theory and Kinevin and narrative?
- 55:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you briefing?
- 55:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm relatively convinced.
- 55:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, okay.
- 55:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the the so we've worked with them in the past, and and the idea is to amplify the stories that you want and dampen the ones you don't, right?
- 55:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So as leaders in a complex environment, we want to collect those narratives, the stories that people are telling uh each other at a water cooler or what have you.
- 55:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this is fundamental.
- 55:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What you're telling us is consistent with what we've heard from others.
- 55:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's consistent with what we understand um on how the brain works from both neuroscience and cognitive science.
- 56:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's very consistent with uh sports, too, right?
- 56:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You don't want to go in and and impose your your your approach onto the context.
- 56:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You want to understand the context first, understand where you are, right?
- 56:13Angus Fletcher: Why are the Seahawks doing so well this year?
- 56:15Angus Fletcher: Because they had a coach come in and activate these latent narratives inside all those players.
- 56:19Angus Fletcher: You know, the the players are basically the same, you know?
- 56:21Angus Fletcher: Um, the coach just kind of helped them find that bigger story.
- 56:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's that's the role of a leader or a coach, and a coach is a leader, to do that.
- 56:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, so I I I I don't know anything about the Seattle story.
- 56:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you go a little bit more?
- 56:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Like now that we're gonna be coming up on Super Bowl or Championship weekend?
- 56:35Angus Fletcher: I I just mean that they have a relatively young coach who does not have amazing new schemes, does not have anything particularly special, but just went in there and, you know, rebooted what Pete Carroll had there before and was able to find a way to get everybody to buy in collectively, particularly on the defense, the idea if we just do this, this is gonna work.
- 56:53Angus Fletcher: I'm gonna tell you a narrative of the future.
- 56:55Angus Fletcher: And any good and effective coach is gonna come in there and say, Here's your story.
- 57:00Angus Fletcher: And I'm gonna tell you your story to you so well that I teach you things about yourself that you didn't know, but that you realize them as yours, right?
- 57:06Angus Fletcher: That's what a good coach does is they unlock something about you that's true, and you're like, okay, this guy knows me.
- 57:10Angus Fletcher: And then he says, now I'm gonna do it like Shakespeare did.
- 57:12Angus Fletcher: I'm gonna take all these different characters and I'm gonna put them together in one play.
- 57:15Angus Fletcher: We now have one play, and that one play is gonna connect us all, and it's gonna be better than the other guy's play because all of us are gonna be connected into this one play, whereas the other guy, he's got half the guys on board on their play, right?
- 57:27Angus Fletcher: And he's telling the other half he's trying to force them to conform to the play.
- 57:30Angus Fletcher: And so good leaders elicit the narratives, the stories, the lives of the people in their organizations, combine them into a larger narrative that's going the direction the leader wants.
- 57:42Angus Fletcher: And that kind of organic process is what leads to victory.
- 57:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, you ready for this?
- 57:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to switch it up a little bit and talk about the market because we we fall a lot on the market in here and we know that there's always a narrative as to why the market went up or down, right?
- 57:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um the day we're recording this as 21 January, 20th of January, we had a pretty big down day in the market.
- 57:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the narrative was um, I think Greenland and everybody forgot about what was going on in Japan with the yen and everything going on there.
- 58:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So why, why, why are narratives so important in the market and why are they always wrong?
- 58:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll give you that thesis.
- 58:14Angus Fletcher: Well, okay, so um we've already talked about broadly why narratives are so important generally.
- 58:18Angus Fletcher: I mean, a narrative is making you think that you can see the future, is essentially what it's saying.
- 58:21Angus Fletcher: It's saying, like, here's the effect of this cause.
- 58:23Angus Fletcher: And so uh the moment you lock in on a narrative and say that this narrative is true, then you know, and if that narrative's negative, you're like sell, sell, sell.
- 58:31Angus Fletcher: That narrative narrative is positive, bye, bye, bye.
- 58:34Angus Fletcher: This is fundamentally misunderstanding how narrative is supposed to work in the brain.
- 58:38Angus Fletcher: The purpose of narrative is not to tell you what's true or even what's probable.
- 58:41Angus Fletcher: The purpose of a narrative is to multiply possibilities, it's to increase the action space.
- 58:47Angus Fletcher: And so, really, as a successful investor, you want to go into the market with five different possible narratives of things that could happen.
- 58:54Angus Fletcher: And then you want to be able to kind of rapidly shift between them, or because you've got those narratives, you want to be able to be more able to come up with a sixth or seventh or an eighth, right?
- 59:01Angus Fletcher: Once you've got those initial five.
- 59:02Angus Fletcher: And so I think the problem is that most investors don't understand how narratives work, and so they get caught in them.
- 59:07Angus Fletcher: But if you're losing money, somebody else is probably making money.
- 59:11Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 59:12Angus Fletcher: So even if the market is going down, there's probably still somebody out there who's making money off that downturn.
- 59:17Angus Fletcher: And that person is the person who's able to see more narratives than you.
- 59:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, I try this.
- 59:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If the systems drive behaviors, then it's um probably a good thing for those that are making money off you losing money to tell you a narrative.
- 59:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so, right?
- 59:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're talking heads.
- 59:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Totally agree.
- 59:31Angus Fletcher: Yeah, no, and that's what systems do.
- 59:32Angus Fletcher: Systems try and create narratives and they try and make it seem like those narratives are faded or predetermined because that shifts all the power into the system and it takes all the power out of you because then you can't make your own story.
- 59:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's let's get a little bit uglier here, if we if we don't mind.
- 59:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that is get back to the cognitive war, the AI space, the um access to more information, information flow.
- 59:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I want to include in that the um our attention spans and maybe memes.
- 59:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do they all work in this cognitive war that we're that that we claim we're in right now?
- 1:00:02Angus Fletcher: What they're doing is they're disrupting our ability to make our own narratives.
- 1:00:05Angus Fletcher: So computers cannot think in narrative.
- 1:00:08Angus Fletcher: This is a mechanical fact, and they will never think in narrative.
- 1:00:11Angus Fletcher: I can explain this to you in technical detail, but basically, computers think in equations, and equations cannot be narrative.
- 1:00:16Angus Fletcher: Um, so because computers think in equations, they also think in associations.
- 1:00:20Angus Fletcher: That's why when you go in your note, your news feed on your phone, it's always just like flashing you a whole bunch of stuff, you know, that it associates, you know, this word, this keyword makes it think of this article, makes it think of that article.
- 1:00:29Angus Fletcher: The more time you spend interacting with computers, the more time your brain starts to respond like they think.
- 1:00:35Angus Fletcher: And so you lose your narrative capacity and start thinking associationally, which is to say you're thinking in this space of constant distraction and things that are just tangentially connected because they have a word or an image in common, you know?
- 1:00:47Angus Fletcher: And that destroys your common sense.
- 1:00:49Angus Fletcher: It destroys your ability to maintain and sustain an action over time.
- 1:00:52Angus Fletcher: So what we're seeing, particularly with young people, is they're spending so much time on technology, they can't make plans for their own lives.
- 1:00:58Angus Fletcher: And if you can't make a plan for your own life, you go into a threat response faster, you panic faster.
- 1:01:02Angus Fletcher: When you panic, you look to somebody else to give you a plan.
- 1:01:04Angus Fletcher: And so that's why young people are becoming more and more deferential.
- 1:01:07Angus Fletcher: Same thing if you're spending too much time on your computer staring at the market, you know, you're seeing all these lights go off, you know, that's decreasing your ability to make long term plans.
- 1:01:15Angus Fletcher: The good investors that I know usually make two or three.
- 1:01:18Angus Fletcher: Major investments a year.
- 1:01:19Angus Fletcher: So I know a lot of investors who are have values in the billions.
- 1:01:23Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:01:23Angus Fletcher: And they usually do not go on and make 45 trades in a day.
- 1:01:27Angus Fletcher: They usually will make a few trades over the course of a year because they're building that long-term plan.
- 1:01:32Angus Fletcher: And then when they see that moment for high leverage, they go all in.
- 1:01:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Trend followers.
- 1:01:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:01:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What about tribalism?
- 1:01:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So is that is this um you said when children are can't think for themselves, they're looking for somebody to think for them, right?
- 1:01:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that is that partially explained.
- 1:01:49Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:01:49Angus Fletcher: So let's talk about why this is a normal behavior in children and why it becomes, you know, bad in adults.
- 1:01:54Angus Fletcher: So what you want from a child is you want someone who is aggressively exploring their environment, you know, who takes a lot of initiative and is constantly pushing the boundaries.
- 1:02:02Angus Fletcher: But the moment they get into danger, you want them to immediately listen to you.
- 1:02:06Angus Fletcher: And so the way the children work is they're constantly happy, going around, going around, going around.
- 1:02:11Angus Fletcher: But the moment that they get scared, or the moment you say, you know, you yell at them, they immediately go into a threat response, a fight of a flight response, which makes them susceptible to doing exactly what you tell them to do.
- 1:02:21Angus Fletcher: So you see children become submissive very quickly the moment they get scared.
- 1:02:24Angus Fletcher: The reason that that happens is because the brain has a bias to action.
- 1:02:28Angus Fletcher: You know, the brain always wants to be acting.
- 1:02:30Angus Fletcher: It always either wants to be generating its own actions when that's okay, or taking on an action that works in the outside world.
- 1:02:35Angus Fletcher: Now, what happens when people form into tribes, essentially, where they all share the same narrative, and that tribe that gets divorced from reality is because they're all essentially in a state of group fear.
- 1:02:47Angus Fletcher: It's another way of saying that is herd behavior.
- 1:02:49Angus Fletcher: Why does herd behavior happen?
- 1:02:51Angus Fletcher: Well, because a shock occurs to the system, people have been living inside the system for so long they can't think outside the system, therefore they can't come up with plans for themselves, therefore they just take the plan from the next person.
- 1:03:01Angus Fletcher: And then they all take the plan from the next person, then before you know it, they're all acting the same way and they're a herd or they're a tribe.
- 1:03:06Angus Fletcher: So that's where that comes from.
- 1:03:07Angus Fletcher: And the moment you see a group of people just acting the same way, you know that on some level they're in a state of shock.
- 1:03:13Angus Fletcher: Or they're subject to a psyop.
- 1:03:16Angus Fletcher: Yes.
- 1:03:16Angus Fletcher: Whether you well, psy-op exists to create shock, right?
- 1:03:19Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:03:20Angus Fletcher: I mean, the way that a psyop is effective.
- 1:03:22Angus Fletcher: Now, I will say the most effective psy-ops actually tell the truth.
- 1:03:25Angus Fletcher: And there's a small number of really effective psyops that go into it.
- 1:03:28Angus Fletcher: Tell us more about that.
- 1:03:30Angus Fletcher: Well, what I mean by this is I'm so so I've been going on and talking a lot about why I love America on this podcast.
- 1:03:36Angus Fletcher: And to just to be clear, I'm an immigrant.
- 1:03:38Angus Fletcher: I'm a naturalized citizen.
- 1:03:40Angus Fletcher: And so when I say America, I mean that I chose to become an American.
- 1:03:44Angus Fletcher: You know, I'm one of those people that gave up my own citizenship to become an American.
- 1:03:47Angus Fletcher: And I think when you talk to, you know, if you talk to people who are, you know, refugees from, you know, the former Soviet Union, Soviet blocks, whatever, you you discover a certain kind of person who really, really likes America.
- 1:03:58Angus Fletcher: And, you know, the reason we really like America is because America gives us the chance to tell our own stories.
- 1:04:06Angus Fletcher: And so the most effective psyops, I've always believed, is to go out to the rest of the world and be like, here's why America's actually better.
- 1:04:14Angus Fletcher: Like, we're not actually engaging in propaganda here.
- 1:04:17Angus Fletcher: It's actually better.
- 1:04:18Angus Fletcher: Like the food here is actually better, right?
- 1:04:20Angus Fletcher: The opportunities here are actually better.
- 1:04:22Angus Fletcher: Like we're not saying that there's unlimited opportunities or it's magic or the streets are made of gold, but we are saying it's better.
- 1:04:28Angus Fletcher: And so the most effective psyops has always been we are better.
- 1:04:33Angus Fletcher: And that's why I think when you look at Germany and Japan after the Second World War, we were able to convince them of that.
- 1:04:38Angus Fletcher: We were able to show, look, you know, we are actually what we're doing is actually better.
- 1:04:41Angus Fletcher: Get on board the democracy train.
- 1:04:44Angus Fletcher: Get out of the, you know, the fascist systems that you're in, get in the democracy train.
- 1:04:49Angus Fletcher: So the most effective psy-ops always lean into that.
- 1:04:51Angus Fletcher: Now, I've seen a tendency in psyops to lean into fear, because if you can get people to be scared, as we've talked about, you can get them to kind of do what you want in the short term.
- 1:05:00Angus Fletcher: So there's a tendency in psy-ops to not lean into America is better and instead lean into, you know, if you don't do what we tell you, you're gonna die.
- 1:05:06Angus Fletcher: You know, your commanders are gonna murder you.
- 1:05:08Angus Fletcher: You know, I've seen a lot of kind of like anti-ISIS kind of psy-ops, which is all about how, you know, terrible things are gonna happen to you if you stay in ISIS.
- 1:05:14Angus Fletcher: But the most effective psy-ups is always here's the true story of what will happen if you become an American.
- 1:05:20Angus Fletcher: Your life will get better.
- 1:05:22Angus Fletcher: Your children's lives will be better.
- 1:05:24Angus Fletcher: And the only thing that that requires us to do as Americans is live up to the American dream and keep making America better.
- 1:05:29Angus Fletcher: You know, and I think at the moment we're sort of in a we're in a rocky batch here, you know?
- 1:05:34Angus Fletcher: And it's unclear whether the next generation of Americans is going to be better off than the current generation.
- 1:05:38Mark McGrath: It's interesting.
- 1:05:39Mark McGrath: Uh the remark about PSY-OPS being about truth, it's interesting to me.
- 1:05:44Mark McGrath: I I I would always thought it like a PSY-op would be about influence.
- 1:05:47Angus Fletcher: Well, yeah, but what's more influential than the truth?
- 1:05:50Angus Fletcher: Like if I come on here and tell you that so like there must have been moments in your life when someone sat you down and told you the truth and it prompted a conversion experience in you.
- 1:05:59Angus Fletcher: They're like, whoa, because you realize, like, I I mean the first time you read Marshall McLuhan, maybe, or whatever, right?
- 1:06:03Angus Fletcher: Or the first time you read about the Oodaloop, right?
- 1:06:05Angus Fletcher: I mean, the most profound and sustained moments of influence come from somebody revealing the actual nature of reality to you.
- 1:06:12Mark McGrath: Um What what do you think then when you see I mean, I I I would say like social media is a really good example here in the United States, particularly when there is uh a chasm between two sides that seem to be heavily influenced, but saying the opposite thing.
- 1:06:31Mark McGrath: So then how would you how would you how would you square for that?
- 1:06:35Mark McGrath: Because, you know, it it as I look at it, it's I don't know if I call it a PSY-op, but it's certainly an influence operation that you could get people to look alike, think alike, dye their hair the same color, put it in the same septum rings, sit on the other side, have the same hats, have the same American whatever.
- 1:06:52Mark McGrath: Like, I totally agree.
- 1:06:53Angus Fletcher: I totally agree.
- 1:06:54Angus Fletcher: But what we're talking about there is again that these are individuals who are caught in a state of shock and purposelessness and despair.
- 1:07:00Angus Fletcher: I mean, if you're spending all your time doom scrolling, it's pretty easy to get influenced.
- 1:07:03Angus Fletcher: And what I'm talking about here is first of all, let's start to influence the people who really matter, right?
- 1:07:09Angus Fletcher: You know, the people who are not doom scrolling all the time.
- 1:07:11Angus Fletcher: And second of all, if you can start to influence the doom scrollers in a positive way, then they stop doom scrolling because they're not going to be on social media anymore because they're gonna have found a deeper truth.
- 1:07:21Angus Fletcher: And, you know, there's different versions of that deeper truth.
- 1:07:24Angus Fletcher: I believe in science, I believe in democracy, you know, I believe in America, I believe in these kinds of things.
- 1:07:28Angus Fletcher: These are the things I think we should be bringing to people.
- 1:07:29Angus Fletcher: I believe in the OODA loop, you know, I believe in these kinds of, and I believe that the more that people find these durable narratives that are true, and when I say they're true, what I mean by that is that they actually work in reality.
- 1:07:39Angus Fletcher: You know, um they make your life better, they help explain the nature of reality more effectively.
- 1:07:44Angus Fletcher: They give you more power to do accomplish things you want to accomplish.
- 1:07:47Angus Fletcher: I mean, that's what, you know, uh an effective narrative is.
- 1:07:49Angus Fletcher: And I think what you see in social media is a lot of people who are lost because they're spending so much time on social media that they've lost their own momentum.
- 1:07:57Mark McGrath: Do you think it's complex more complex though?
- 1:07:59Mark McGrath: Like where there's certainly mental health is certainly an issue.
- 1:08:04Mark McGrath: So uh SSRIs, you know, um diet.
- 1:08:10Mark McGrath: I don't know.
- 1:08:11Mark McGrath: I mean, the is it more nuanced?
- 1:08:14Angus Fletcher: Yeah, okay.
- 1:08:14Angus Fletcher: So to your point, yes, there's a lot of factors that are contributing to the rise of behavior.
- 1:08:20Angus Fletcher: But I do think that just in general, the more you use social media, the more it pushes you in that direction that you're already going.
- 1:08:25Angus Fletcher: Um it would be better if people ate better.
- 1:08:26Angus Fletcher: It would be better if people exercised more.
- 1:08:29Angus Fletcher: These are all important things.
- 1:08:30Angus Fletcher: I don't disagree.
- 1:08:32Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:08:32Mark McGrath: Let me ask you.
- 1:08:32Mark McGrath: All media are an extension of some human function.
- 1:08:40Mark McGrath: So here we find the electronic media, social media is an extension of the human human nervous system.
- 1:08:45Mark McGrath: And the suggestion would be that if you when you look at it and get a sampling, the human nervous system doesn't look like it's in very good shape.
- 1:08:53Speaker 1: I would definitely agree with that with that assessment, yeah.
- 1:08:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Aaron Ross Powell I've got a question about podcasting now.
- 1:08:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is kind of interesting.
- 1:08:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In the last few months, uh Moose and I have noticed that uh people are watching more of our YouTube videos, more they're watching more of the conversation, they are listening to it.
- 1:09:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if that makes sense.
- 1:09:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um so uh my hypothesis is that they are looking for connection.
- 1:09:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um that that in the here in the near future, if if uh we do see the growth of AI and uh people become less human, if you want to go call it that, that they'll be looking for more connection.
- 1:09:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, how do podcasts fit into the world of storytelling and narrative?
- 1:09:30Angus Fletcher: What I think is really great about podcasts is you get individuals talking honestly from a range of experiences.
- 1:09:37Angus Fletcher: You can have pretty niche podcasts that allows them to be honest, candid, explore things that that they're experts in.
- 1:09:43Angus Fletcher: And, you know, the problem increasingly with the way that big media is, is it it is it has to appeal to a broad segment of people, which means it can't do anything actually interesting.
- 1:09:53Angus Fletcher: And as a result of being unable to do anything interesting, you're not gonna actually change anybody's mind.
- 1:09:57Angus Fletcher: And you're not gonna be able to connect with anybody on a deep level.
- 1:10:01Angus Fletcher: I mean, when I first started working with special operators, the first thing I did was I started listening to tons and tons of military podcasts.
- 1:10:07Angus Fletcher: And those podcasts changed my life because all these folks would come on and start talking about their real experience in the military.
- 1:10:13Angus Fletcher: And it completely, I was someone who before I started when the Army first called me, I was like, I'm not working with the Army, I'm not working with a bunch of killers.
- 1:10:19Angus Fletcher: What are you talking about?
- 1:10:19Angus Fletcher: You know, I'm a professor, you know, we don't like the army, we don't like the military.
- 1:10:22Angus Fletcher: And then the more I started listening to these podcasts, the more I started to realize, no, I've completely got the military backwards.
- 1:10:27Angus Fletcher: Like I don't understand any of this.
- 1:10:29Angus Fletcher: And I do think that podcasts provide people with that opportunity to explore, to discover, to find things that are different, that are interesting.
- 1:10:36Angus Fletcher: I mean, I'm really glad that you guys are doing the work that you're doing because I mean, if you'd asked me in a million years if there would be a podcast dedicated to the Oodaloop, that would never occur to me.
- 1:10:44Angus Fletcher: But I mean, I think it's genius that you guys are doing it.
- 1:10:46Angus Fletcher: So that's what I think.
- 1:10:47Angus Fletcher: I think it's a place for people to come together and learn from experts in an authentic way.
- 1:10:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Aaron Powell The great thing is we'll never run out of content because the OODA loop is it to us, it really represents how living systems interact with the environment, not the not a decision-making process.
- 1:11:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think um a reason we we want you on the show is to make sure that military leaders understand that the way they look at the oodaloop, and I'll give you the example.
- 1:11:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: NATO NATO just put out a document a couple weeks ago on cognitive warfare and then used the linear approach to the oodaloop, even though they had the correct sketch in there, a really good version of it.
- 1:11:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But what they're saying is, hey, this nonlinear thing that we're talking about in cognitive warfare, it it disrupts this linear thing called the OOD loop.
- 1:11:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we're like, no, no, they're there, you're actually you're doing this wrong.
- 1:11:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you need to use the nonlinear approach to oodloop, and that'll open you up to understanding peak performance flow strategy, the Toyota production system, AI, uh, large language models, which are, again, the linear oodaloop, and then the next generation of AI, which looks like it's active inference or something connected to uh three or four dimensions, um, which is really what the oodaloop is.
- 1:11:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's there's so many aspects I think military military leaders get wrong uh about this thing they claim they know so much about.
- 1:12:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and you can see it on every news channel, they'll come out and say, we got to disrupt their OODA loop, and and sometimes they'll they'll get the acronyms wrong too.
- 1:12:12Angus Fletcher: Well, you know, what I'd like to say there is probably our military is just kind of doing a little bit of a dodge there.
- 1:12:17Angus Fletcher: You know, they don't want to put the real truth out there uh in public because, you know, backdoors, they've got to, you know, keep the OODA loop to themselves.
- 1:12:23Angus Fletcher: That's what I'd like to think.
- 1:12:24Angus Fletcher: But you mean look, I mean, the moment I went into special operations, everyone's like, oh, you gotta read Klauswitz.
- 1:12:29Angus Fletcher: Nobody has special operations for these Klauswitz.
- 1:12:31Angus Fletcher: Klauswitz is brilliant.
- 1:12:32Angus Fletcher: Everybody should read Klauswitz, but nobody does.
- 1:12:34Angus Fletcher: So I mean, to a certain extent, there's always a small group keeping the torch alive.
- 1:12:39Angus Fletcher: That's just always how it's gonna be, I think, in these in these environments.
- 1:12:42Mark McGrath: And that's we call we call them uh when they've written a lot, you can see it on the Substack, uh, the guardians of decay.
- 1:12:50Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 1:12:50Mark McGrath: That they make sure that the uh the entropy is well well in place.
- 1:12:56Mark McGrath: Like, but but it's almost like in you know, in markets, it's it's the uh the whole Keynes versus Hayek.
- 1:13:06Mark McGrath: Well, Hayek was right, but he lost.
- 1:13:07Mark McGrath: Why?
- 1:13:07Mark McGrath: Keynes was more influential.
- 1:13:08Mark McGrath: It's the same thing, you know, uh Clauswitz say versus Sun Tzu.
- 1:13:11Mark McGrath: I mean, Boyd eviscerated Clawswitz, he he debunked it, the the the entire the entire thing.
- 1:13:17Mark McGrath: Yet still it's the canon.
- 1:13:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:13:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I think uh Keynes read Shakespeare, is that correct?
- 1:13:23Angus Fletcher: Keynes read Shakespeare?
- 1:13:24Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:13:24Angus Fletcher: I mean, everybody, you know, everybody who has an idea has read Shakespeare, whether it's a good idea or a bad idea.
- 1:13:29Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:13:30Mark McGrath: Do you find so you're a professor of, you know, in the English department, um, and as I mentioned, you know, being a liberal arts guy, uh my almost officially minored in British literature.
- 1:13:41Mark McGrath: I don't are people gravitating towards the English department, the history department, the philosophy department in state universities?
- 1:13:49Mark McGrath: Aaron Powell No, no.
- 1:13:50Angus Fletcher: We're so just uh like a quick thing here.
- 1:13:52Angus Fletcher: First of all, I love English departments and I could only exist inside the English department, even though I'm not really an English professor, right?
- 1:13:57Angus Fletcher: I'm like this crazy neuroscientist.
- 1:13:59Angus Fletcher: And so I think we should put all the money in the world into English departments.
- 1:14:03Angus Fletcher: But no, in my department, we basically have the same number of majors as we have professors practically.
- 1:14:08Angus Fletcher: You know?
- 1:14:09Angus Fletcher: Um and and that's that contraction has happened over the last 10 years.
- 1:14:13Angus Fletcher: Like we've totally imploded.
- 1:14:14Angus Fletcher: We've lost almost all.
- 1:14:16Angus Fletcher: And I'm being essentially moved over to the business school.
- 1:14:19Mark McGrath: I mean business school.
- 1:14:20Mark McGrath: I I think that maybe you probably have more uh situational awareness on us than I do, but was it that in state universities, like the bottom major was mine, history.
- 1:14:31Mark McGrath: Um that then, you know, then philosophy, literature, linguistics, whatever, but like number one in state universities was exercise science.
- 1:14:43Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 1:14:44Angus Fletcher: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:14:45Angus Fletcher: Well, I mean, we had for a while like the biggest major here was like communications, which is kind of a little bit of a pseudoscience, to be totally honest.
- 1:14:53Angus Fletcher: Um, and I think in general, you know, the the challenge, as we've talked about before, is that people don't really come to university to learn anymore.
- 1:15:02Angus Fletcher: They come to get a certificate.
- 1:15:03Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:15:04Angus Fletcher: And if you're gonna learn, you got to go into a classroom where you don't know anything and you're prepared to get a C.
- 1:15:08Angus Fletcher: I mean, that's really the only way to learn.
- 1:15:10Angus Fletcher: And if you don't have that, then what you get is this kind of slide towards students going into classes where they know they're gonna get an A and then they're not being challenged too much, and then everything just kind of homogenizes.
- 1:15:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You sound like most executives in organizations is they don't want to learn anything new.
- 1:15:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They just want to be told what they already know.
- 1:15:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's exactly right.
- 1:15:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's why they're so successful, obviously.
- 1:15:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 1:15:28Angus Fletcher: And that's why what else do they have to know?
- 1:15:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the consultants that you do that are no longer useful because AI can, you know, a large language model can tell a leader what they already know.
- 1:15:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's exactly what I think.
- 1:15:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I love that, by the way.
- 1:15:39Mark McGrath: Do you think that universities, I mean, really, I mean, because you hear this all the time, that they're that it's less of an education or open inquiry or learning, it's more of an indoctrination.
- 1:15:49Angus Fletcher: I don't think it's really an indoctrination in the sense that I don't I think everyone's pretty skeptical about what happens inside universities, but I think it's an indoctrination in the sense that everybody realizes that they kind of have to go along with the ritual, you know, and and pretend like they learned something.
- 1:16:01Angus Fletcher: And I think to that extent there's a kind of like giant kabuki theater thing happening.
- 1:16:05Angus Fletcher: It's the university.
- 1:16:07Angus Fletcher: Um, what I would say is I think universities are gonna come back.
- 1:16:11Angus Fletcher: I think people have had enough.
- 1:16:12Angus Fletcher: How so?
- 1:16:13Angus Fletcher: Well, what I mean, so I'm the fact that they moved me over to the business school, basically what the business school is saying is they're basically saying we realize that AI has basically replaced most of the instruction that we've been doing here for the last few years.
- 1:16:26Angus Fletcher: We've got to figure out something new.
- 1:16:27Angus Fletcher: And what did the business school, which is the most successful unit at Ohio State, decide is new?
- 1:16:32Angus Fletcher: They decided what's new is what I'm doing, which is basically the humanities.
- 1:16:35Angus Fletcher: And they're like, we want to basically bring in someone who's gonna teach our students to think smart in low information environments, to be able to tell effective stories, you know, to role play, all these kinds of things which are really based at the humanities.
- 1:16:46Angus Fletcher: So my sense is that there's going to be a bounce back because I think people have started to have enough.
- 1:16:50Angus Fletcher: I mean, you know, from our moment, it just seems like, oh my goodness, where can we go?
- 1:16:54Angus Fletcher: But there have been plenty of periods in history where there have been these kinds of blips and weird things that happened.
- 1:16:58Angus Fletcher: Do you do you think so?
- 1:17:00Mark McGrath: I mean, this is what I wonder.
- 1:17:02Mark McGrath: I mean, the I mean, I could take right now, my master's is in economics.
- 1:17:08Mark McGrath: I could I could take right now and create a full-length graduate course on Google Notebook LM using using publicly available PDFs of things that I read.
- 1:17:17Mark McGrath: I mean, is the is the university in that sense is it is it proving that it's it's uh to your point about more of a certification or a rite of passage versus uh actual authentic learning because you can get everything online for free right now.
- 1:17:34Angus Fletcher: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:17:34Angus Fletcher: So this again goes back to what I really took out of the special operations pipeline.
- 1:17:39Angus Fletcher: Because basically the whole thing about the special operations pipeline is like 5% is instruction and 95% is experiential learning.
- 1:17:45Angus Fletcher: Like once we give you the instruction, we're then gonna force you through these exercises again and again and again.
- 1:17:51Angus Fletcher: And that's what we're trying to do at the business school.
- 1:17:52Angus Fletcher: And I think that's where you're gonna see colleges start to come back, is you need to have an experienced essentially trainer in the room.
- 1:17:58Angus Fletcher: And, you know, I'm gonna give you the, you know, the slide from the econ deck or whatever, and then I'm gonna say, okay, you've got your company started and your investors have just walked away because this thing just happened.
- 1:18:07Angus Fletcher: What do you do?
- 1:18:07Angus Fletcher: You know, and then you're like, oh, well, I do this.
- 1:18:09Angus Fletcher: I'm like, well, you know what?
- 1:18:10Angus Fletcher: Your stocks just doubled.
- 1:18:11Angus Fletcher: Now you have all this extra cash.
- 1:18:13Angus Fletcher: What are you doing with that cash, right?
- 1:18:14Angus Fletcher: You know, and we start to basically role-play these scenarios and put the economics into an actual simulation environment that allows them to practice before they get to the real world.
- 1:18:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It sounds to me like your business school recognizes that non-technical skills are more important in this environment than anything else.
- 1:18:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you're gonna want to look at the interactions, which includes leaders' intent, telling the story, understanding um how to leverage cognitive diversity through those techniques such as red teaming, right?
- 1:18:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes.
- 1:18:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so where I'm going with this is everything that a at this age of AI is doing to us is forcing us to go back to becoming more human.
- 1:18:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that right?
- 1:18:46Angus Fletcher: That's right.
- 1:18:47Angus Fletcher: That's exactly right.
- 1:18:48Angus Fletcher: I mean, that's always kind of the way that history works, you know, is we kind of go in one direction and then we're like, okay, yeah.
- 1:18:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you need some experienced trainers and people that may have lived in special operations or in a world of uh low information who have experienced things like teaming, uh red teaming, uh, who understand flow, who understand the oodle loop.
- 1:19:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'm just kind of throwing this out there as you know, understand sacrifice, suffering.
- 1:19:10Mark McGrath: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:19:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, exactly.
- 1:19:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:19:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it's best to learn from those people who have experienced that.
- 1:19:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it sounds to me like it's it it's a good thing to learn from those that come from the military that have that background in teaming, in distributed leadership, and understanding complex adaptive systems, right?
- 1:19:27Angus Fletcher: That's exactly right.
- 1:19:28Angus Fletcher: And we're we we have a bunch of special ops and military instructors that we use.
- 1:19:31Angus Fletcher: And you know, the only thing I would say to someone who's in there in the military who's thinking about trying to, you know, you know, get into business or something like that is business is gonna attempt to socialize you into thinking like a business person.
- 1:19:41Angus Fletcher: I see this happen all the time with folks when they transition out of the military, is they get this moment of like fear and they're like, oh, I've got to like do what the you know the civilians are doing.
- 1:19:49Angus Fletcher: I'm gonna like figure out how to fit into the system.
- 1:19:51Angus Fletcher: And when you do that, you lose your edge.
- 1:19:53Angus Fletcher: Yes.
- 1:19:53Angus Fletcher: And, you know, the folks that I've seen be the most successful in their transitions out of the military, a lot of them, what they do is they start their own businesses, they have this kind of you know entrepreneurial thing, or they're able to be brought into a business where they're actually listened to and you know, their experience is respected.
- 1:20:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm gonna I'm gonna add to that.
- 1:20:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sometimes we see folks come from the military, they jump out of the cockpit and they say, I know how to do this flawlessly.
- 1:20:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They use effects-based operations, they use things that are um have bounded applicability and say this is how it works everywhere.
- 1:20:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're saying that's not true, right?
- 1:20:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's what Moose and I have have done with the show and what we've done with Substack is that, hey, look, these things have context.
- 1:20:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think you talk about um uh maybe let's go back to the uh Kinevin framework.
- 1:20:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So in the in the center there, you have confusion, uh, which has I think you wrote about this in your book, not necessarily these words, but when you know you're confused, that's a good thing.
- 1:20:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and what we call that is aporetic or aporia, and and that's actually saying I am not applying the wrong method in the wrong context.
- 1:20:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just saying I'm pausing right now because I don't know where I am.
- 1:20:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that true?
- 1:20:55Angus Fletcher: Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:20:55Angus Fletcher: I mean, you know, now you've got to, I would say, once you get into a state where you realize you're dealing with unknown unknowns, which I would call is kind of the ultimate form of confusion, you know, when your anxiety is kind of off the charts and you're sort of like, there's so much happening here in my environment that I don't know.
- 1:21:09Angus Fletcher: What you got to do in that moment is you do got to take a pause and say, is there someone else in my immediate environment who I trust who knows the way?
- 1:21:15Angus Fletcher: In which case, absolutely learn from them.
- 1:21:17Angus Fletcher: But if you look around, To right and left, and there's nobody, then you know, run ahead.
- 1:21:22Angus Fletcher: And I think that, you know, my experience with military individuals is they're far more emotionally comfortable with that experience than most business people.
- 1:21:30Angus Fletcher: Business people freeze.
- 1:21:31Mark McGrath: I did actually, um, so I go around and unpack that more because I think that's a very incisive point.
- 1:21:37Angus Fletcher: Well, I just did a training the other day at a very large company that will remain nameless.
- 1:21:41Angus Fletcher: And so a lot of what I get asked to do now is is go around and kind of you know talk about these kinds of special operation mindsets.
- 1:21:47Angus Fletcher: And I'd gotten three words into the talk and I was interrupted and they were like, please don't use negative words.
- 1:21:51Angus Fletcher: And I was like, What do you mean?
- 1:21:53Angus Fletcher: They're like, you use the word failure.
- 1:21:54Angus Fletcher: Like, please don't use that word here.
- 1:21:55Angus Fletcher: And I was like, why, why, why would that?
- 1:21:57Angus Fletcher: It's like, well, because negative words create negative thinking and then negative thinking creates negative outcomes.
- 1:22:01Angus Fletcher: I was like, no, it's the opposite.
- 1:22:03Angus Fletcher: First of all, if something is bad and you say that it's bad, that's called reality.
- 1:22:07Angus Fletcher: You know, like, you know, and so what I think actually, when I experience what happens in a lot of businesses, is they practice things that I would call dissociative.
- 1:22:15Angus Fletcher: So they basically, you know, when something bad happens, they just pretend like it didn't happen.
- 1:22:19Angus Fletcher: You know, we're not gonna have a hard conversation right now because we're gonna pretend like that thing just didn't happen.
- 1:22:23Angus Fletcher: This is endemic in in you.
- 1:22:25Angus Fletcher: I actually have to teach classes on how to have hard conversations in businesses because people won't do it.
- 1:22:30Angus Fletcher: Whereas if you go into any military environment, they're like, what do you mean hard conversation?
- 1:22:33Angus Fletcher: I just yelled at that guy, he yelled back at me, then we hugged it out, and we went on, and then we yelled at each other some more, you know, and and so all of those level, what I'm talking about in terms of the level of emotional comfort.
- 1:22:43Angus Fletcher: What I mean is that you've been in the situations, not just hypothetically, but you've been in the situations.
- 1:22:48Angus Fletcher: And you understand that you have a capacity when you're confused to continue to act.
- 1:22:52Angus Fletcher: You understand that you have a capacity, even when you hate the guy next to you, to talk it out and then bond tighter over that and then become brothers.
- 1:23:00Angus Fletcher: You know, you understand that emotionally.
- 1:23:02Angus Fletcher: It's not just a conceptual thing, but it's something that you've lived.
- 1:23:05Angus Fletcher: And I think, you know, when you start to bring that, which I would call wisdom, I would call lived knowledge wisdom.
- 1:23:10Angus Fletcher: When you start to bring that wisdom into businesses, it does tend to make people nervous because people at businesses actually have not experienced very much of the world.
- 1:23:19Angus Fletcher: And they spend a lot of their time being concerned they're just gonna get fired or made redundant, you know?
- 1:23:23Angus Fletcher: Um, and so the idea of acting with initiative is is is is is very low on the kind of order of emotional comfort.
- 1:23:29Mark McGrath: I was in asset management for 15 years after the military, and I once got told I I used to basically drive my business by teaching how to integrate John Boyd's thinking into you know building your business and your markets, things like that.
- 1:23:44Mark McGrath: I'll never forget this one portfolio manager who told me, he says, if this was important, it wouldn't have been taught in the military.
- 1:23:50Mark McGrath: I would have learned it at Harvard.
- 1:23:52Mark McGrath: So don't waste my time.
- 1:23:53Mark McGrath: I'd be like Yeah.
- 1:23:56unknown: Cool.
- 1:23:57Angus Fletcher: By the way, I mean something about elite institutions, which I think anyone who's been at an elite institution can understand is they're very self-regarding, just like they're very vulnerable.
- 1:24:07Angus Fletcher: When you're self-regarding, you're very inward-looking.
- 1:24:09Angus Fletcher: When you're very inward-looking, you don't learn.
- 1:24:12Angus Fletcher: And you essentially just become very conformist.
- 1:24:14Angus Fletcher: Yeah, they're closed systems.
- 1:24:15Angus Fletcher: There's a closed system.
- 1:24:16Angus Fletcher: And so actually, you know, when you're at Harvard, the safest assumption to make at Harvard is that you're actually not learning very much.
- 1:24:22Angus Fletcher: Now you're getting a great badge and you're surrounded by a lot of other folks who probably have a lot of money and so on and so forth.
- 1:24:28Angus Fletcher: But the more you're in those institutions, the less you're probably learning.
- 1:24:32Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:24:32Mark McGrath: Do you think that those I mean, it I think again, as t as tech just gets better and better and AI just gets better and better, I I mean, I really think that a lot of those sort of uh old timey institutions that don't adapt, that they're a lot more vulnerable than they realize.
- 1:24:47Mark McGrath: Oh yeah.
- 1:24:48Angus Fletcher: And I think that some of them are starting to realize it, actually.
- 1:24:50Angus Fletcher: I think I think there's this thing, but again, it's the we don't know what to do.
- 1:24:54Angus Fletcher: And when you don't know what to do when there's a problem, you just pretend like it doesn't exist.
- 1:24:58Mark McGrath: They just double or double down.
- 1:24:59Angus Fletcher: Or you double down on what you're doing, yeah.
- 1:25:01Angus Fletcher: But I think I think basically what you're seeing is a kind of creeping fear and anxiety that's infusing these places, and it's so intense they can't even acknowledge it.
- 1:25:09Mark McGrath: Whereas, you know, you're Angus, when I hear you say that, I I I remind that of Boyd, you know, he he k he uh well empowers the conflict and in organic design.
- 1:25:19Mark McGrath: He says that, you know, basically the the the way it's always been is like we just put a fresh coat of paint and a new name on what we've always done, and we'll just tell everybody we're doing something different, but we're not really.
- 1:25:32Mark McGrath: We're not.
- 1:25:33Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:25:33Mark McGrath: So I I wonder in earnest if if those institutions are are actually making the right changes.
- 1:25:42Mark McGrath: You know, I I I look, yeah, I haven't looked at the military academies in a while, but I know that I remember reading that a lot of the humanities were getting purged out in f in in in favor of STEM type topics, and I thought that, well, how how are you gonna lead people?
- 1:25:55Mark McGrath: And how are you gonna how are you gonna interact with people by getting rid of humanities?
- 1:26:00Angus Fletcher: Yeah, I agree with you on that.
- 1:26:01Angus Fletcher: I would say that the military academy has they they have a certain kind of you know like horse sense about them.
- 1:26:06Angus Fletcher: And once they realize that that they need kind of more people leaders, they're gonna put the humanities back in.
- 1:26:11Angus Fletcher: With these other institutions like, you know, you know, Harvard or or wherever, what I would say is I spend a fair amount of time across the pond, you know, uh, you know, I'm I'm I was born there uh in England and uh and you know, Cambridge, Oxford, those institutions are on the verge of collapse, but they're actually on the verge of financial collapse.
- 1:26:30Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:26:31Angus Fletcher: I mean, it is really bad over there, really, really bad over there.
- 1:26:35Angus Fletcher: And so I don't think we're that far away from some of the same problems starting to hit American institutions.
- 1:26:41Angus Fletcher: I think that really the only thing keeping most of them alive is the goodwill of their alums.
- 1:26:45Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:26:46Angus Fletcher: And, you know, it's not there.
- 1:26:48Angus Fletcher: I mean, if you if you took away the alums and you tried to sell most of these colleges to students, most of them wouldn't go.
- 1:26:54Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:26:54Angus Fletcher: Um, so I think you know, we are at a moment where there's gonna need to be a change.
- 1:26:59Angus Fletcher: And to your point, yeah, the humanities.
- 1:27:01Angus Fletcher: I mean, philosophy, literature makes you smarter.
- 1:27:06Mark McGrath: Well, so I mean, I ask that because when I when I think of the the old curriculum at West Point, again, I'm biased to West Point only because my father went there and I was raised to be that, and and I was the black sheep going into the Marine Corps and a naval ROTC scholarship.
- 1:27:20Mark McGrath: Um that they, you know, in the old days, being a cultured officer was like a hallmark of an officer.
- 1:27:29Mark McGrath: So that you had to learn French, you had to take art classes, you had to learn Shakespeare.
- 1:27:33Mark McGrath: Um, in fact, the Shakespeare book that I have, the complete works, is my father's from West Point.
- 1:27:37Mark McGrath: I that I have his actual complete, uh, complete works.
- 1:27:41Mark McGrath: That was his textbook there.
- 1:27:43Mark McGrath: So I mean, it was a it was a thing.
- 1:27:45Mark McGrath: And it seems to me that for it, it's always like, oh, for practical purposes or for measurement or for metrics, we're we're getting a we're getting rid of that stuff and we're gonna be doing something else.
- 1:27:55Angus Fletcher: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:27:56Angus Fletcher: Well, let me just give you an example from you know my own cultural background, which is Winston Churchill.
- 1:27:59Angus Fletcher: Winston Churchill essentially invented special operations.
- 1:28:02Angus Fletcher: You know, he was the guy who basically invented the commandos and that we sort of kind of got on board with that.
- 1:28:07Angus Fletcher: And Winston Churchill, I think, is also generally acknowledged to be a pretty good leader and someone, you know.
- 1:28:12Angus Fletcher: Well, his mom was from America.
- 1:28:15Angus Fletcher: Let me his mom was from right here in New York City.
- 1:28:18Angus Fletcher: So go ahead.
- 1:28:19Angus Fletcher: So my point being is that who's his favorite author?
- 1:28:22Angus Fletcher: Shakespeare.
- 1:28:23Angus Fletcher: And you know, and the reason that Shakespeare is good is not because Shakespeare is amazing, but because Shakespeare includes the richest diversity of characters.
- 1:28:29Angus Fletcher: That's the whole point about Shakespeare.
- 1:28:30Angus Fletcher: I think people get Shakespeare wrong when they think, oh, I've got to like memorize and understand him.
- 1:28:33Angus Fletcher: No, the point is just that no one has a variety of individuals like Shakespeare.
- 1:28:37Angus Fletcher: So the more you read Shakespeare, the more you're just exposed to different ways that different people can think.
- 1:28:41Mark McGrath: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 1:28:41Mark McGrath: Well, stay on your topic there.
- 1:28:43Mark McGrath: So that book uh you've I'm sure you've read it about the uh the was it the ungentlemanly conduct or whatever was that the Churchill's gentlemanly, like like his commit like his uh special operator book.
- 1:28:56Mark McGrath: It's something called like uh his tribe of ungentlemanly men or something like that.
- 1:29:00Mark McGrath: Sounds about right.
- 1:29:01Mark McGrath: I don't know the title.
- 1:29:02Mark McGrath: I'll look it up before we go.
- 1:29:03Mark McGrath: But yeah, yeah.
- 1:29:04Mark McGrath: But basically the the point of the matter is that to your to your point, these guys that were in the intelligence world, the special operations world, the commando world, the uh OSS world, these were high cultured men that Ian Fleming based James Bond after, right?
- 1:29:20Mark McGrath: I mean, these only if you wrote about this in your book.
- 1:29:22Mark McGrath: But but these were not necessarily pure technicians.
- 1:29:26Mark McGrath: These were these were cultured men.
- 1:29:29Mark McGrath: One quote I saw something like, yeah, he could be he could be sabotaging a, you know, disarming a bomb in the morning and and dancing with a double-agent female at the at Monte Carlo at night, you know, like like they had this range, but how do you get that range without liberal arts?
- 1:29:46Mark McGrath: I don't I don't know.
- 1:29:47Mark McGrath: I don't know how you do it.
- 1:29:48Angus Fletcher: You know, no, I mean, because the point is that increases your imagination while also increasing your common sense.
- 1:29:53Angus Fletcher: That's the duality that's really important.
- 1:29:55Angus Fletcher: It gives you a broader sense of what can happen, right?
- 1:29:57Angus Fletcher: You just start to see life is full of a lot of possibilities that I didn't learn about in math class, right?
- 1:30:02Angus Fletcher: There's all because I mean all of special operations really is just going outside the existing channels, going outside the box, you know, just saying, what can you know?
- 1:30:09Angus Fletcher: I'm just gonna move beyond the system.
- 1:30:11Angus Fletcher: So there's that, but then also the common sense thing.
- 1:30:13Angus Fletcher: I mean, you know, when you when you read Shakespeare at the end of the day, you've got to figure out how to make it work.
- 1:30:17Angus Fletcher: I mean, that's the thing about Shakespeare.
- 1:30:18Angus Fletcher: Like, how do I actually make this work?
- 1:30:19Angus Fletcher: I gotta stage this, you know?
- 1:30:22Mark McGrath: The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare.
- 1:30:24Mark McGrath: That's it's a great title.
- 1:30:25Mark McGrath: Oh, and it's gonna be a movie coming out.
- 1:30:27Mark McGrath: And how about that?
- 1:30:28Mark McGrath: I can't wait.
- 1:30:29Angus Fletcher: Um But yeah, you get those things from books, essentially, from reading books and having conversations about those books with smart people, um, not from math.
- 1:30:39Angus Fletcher: Math is great.
- 1:30:40Angus Fletcher: I don't have any problem with math, but you gotta develop the other side of your brain.
- 1:30:43Mark McGrath: How many of those guys, too, like that were Oxford Dons, like like Tolkien and C.S.
- 1:30:49Mark McGrath: Lewis were, I mean, weren't they they were also war fighters too?
- 1:30:52Angus Fletcher: Like they they had been in the Yeah, Tolkien was in World War I, actually.
- 1:30:55Angus Fletcher: And we think, I mean, so actually the first screenplay that I ever sold in Hollywood was on Tolkien in World War I.
- 1:31:00Angus Fletcher: I sold it to Bob Shea, the guy who did Lord of the Rings.
- 1:31:02Angus Fletcher: Okay.
- 1:31:02Angus Fletcher: Um, yeah.
- 1:31:05Angus Fletcher: So um, so yes, to your point, yes, the there there's a there's a long history of that.
- 1:31:11Angus Fletcher: Now, I don't want to make it seem like somehow if you read Shakespeare, it automatically makes you a great officer.
- 1:31:15Angus Fletcher: There's plenty of bad officers who've read Shakespeare, but the point is it helps because it does help stimulate that ability to realize that there are just different ways of seeing the world, different people.
- 1:31:23Angus Fletcher: Shakespeare, one of the most famous things that he did is he didn't just write comedies and he didn't just write tragedies, he wrote both.
- 1:31:29Angus Fletcher: Prior to that point in history, he wrote history plays, of course.
- 1:31:32Angus Fletcher: He wrote romances, relations, sonnets.
- 1:31:34Angus Fletcher: Up to that point in history, he was thought, no, you've got to specialize in one kind of story.
- 1:31:38Angus Fletcher: And he's like, No, I can tell lots of kinds of stories.
- 1:31:39Angus Fletcher: And again, that's what it is to be an operator, so be like, I can tell lots of kinds of stories.
- 1:31:43Mark McGrath: Did did you have um uh there was oh I just I just blanked.
- 1:31:49Mark McGrath: We were talking about Shakespeare.
- 1:31:50Mark McGrath: There was something else I wanted to say about reading.
- 1:31:52Mark McGrath: I was gonna add, oh, um uh Norman Dixon's this uh psycho the psychology of military incompetence.
- 1:32:01Angus Fletcher: Oh, right, yes.
- 1:32:02Angus Fletcher: I actually did read that book very quickly.
- 1:32:04Angus Fletcher: Um that now that book is a little bit outdated.
- 1:32:07Angus Fletcher: It's got I I forget exactly, it's got like a very narrow sort of like psychological explanation for everything.
- 1:32:12Mark McGrath: Well, no, he was a psychologist that fought in the British Army in World War II.
- 1:32:16Mark McGrath: And so, but then he was a trained psychologist.
- 1:32:18Mark McGrath: So a lot of it was his inquiry, like why were these incompetent guys in in command of us as we were all getting slaughtered on the beaches or whatever it was.
- 1:32:26Mark McGrath: And it's 50, you know, it's it it's the same year as me uh and and destruction creation, John Boyd, 1976.
- 1:32:34Mark McGrath: So it's 50 years old now, but the but the book is two parts.
- 1:32:37Mark McGrath: It would and it's all it's all uh British military escapades that he puts in it.
- 1:32:41Mark McGrath: Um but you could cross out military incompetence and you could put university incompetence or you could put neuroscience incompetence because the the concepts seem to hold across disciplines.
- 1:32:53Mark McGrath: So I don't know if you'd ever looked at that.
- 1:32:56Angus Fletcher: Yeah, well, there's no question that the failure of almost any individual is a failure of imagination or a failure of common sense or failure of intuition, you know, or a failure to understand your own emotions or the emotions of others.
- 1:33:05Angus Fletcher: I mean, these are the basic problems, you know, and and they do recur across organizations, and they certainly occur in the military.
- 1:33:12Mark McGrath: Aaron Powell Do you find that with a a doctorate in literature, do you find, and now that you're in the business school, do you find that leaders are even reading authentic good literature, even if it's, you know, I mean, some so much of literature, I guess, over time is you know, various degrees of of politics.
- 1:33:29Mark McGrath: But do you do you find that people are even reading Hemingway or Kerouac or What I find is the most successful leaders generally are.
- 1:33:38Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 1:33:39Angus Fletcher: But in general, MBAs are not.
- 1:33:41Angus Fletcher: And so there's a kind of interesting thing there happening that we're I feel like we're we're essentially training a management class as opposed to a group of leaders.
- 1:33:49Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:33:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm wondering if you can bring this on for us today.
- 1:33:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh thank you for your time.
- 1:33:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But can you tell us a story about um what a future leader who is looking back at the failure of the organization six, nine months, twelve months down the road, uh, what they should be taking away from, uh, why they failed and what they could take away from the things we just talked about?
- 1:34:09Angus Fletcher: I would say the main thing is learn from the military and run an AAR, run an after-action review.
- 1:34:14Angus Fletcher: Get everybody in and tell the honest story of what actually happened.
- 1:34:19Angus Fletcher: Because the reason that most people do not learn from failure is they tell themselves the wrong story.
- 1:34:23Angus Fletcher: They tell themselves the story that makes them feel good about themselves, that pushes blame away from themselves.
- 1:34:29Angus Fletcher: Tell the true story of why you failed.
- 1:34:31Angus Fletcher: Get everybody in the room together to tell the true story of why you collectively failed, have that honest moment, and you will develop true wisdom, which is what the military does every day.
- 1:34:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I can't uh think of a better way to wrap this one up because we're strong advocates of effective debriefing, retrospective AARs, understanding what happened from multiple perspectives.
- 1:34:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what John Boyd would say too.
- 1:34:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, you because everybody has a perspective on what happened.
- 1:34:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Nobody really understands the true reality.
- 1:35:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, therefore, we can understand the what, the how, and the why.
- 1:35:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that why gives us the first principles.
- 1:35:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's uh what makes your uh your book, Primal Intelligence, and your book on creativity and other writings so powerful.
- 1:35:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, Angus Fletcher, thank you so much for being here today.
- 1:35:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're gonna stop recording.
- 1:35:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, and before we do, where can our uh listeners find you on the web and what's coming up next for you?
- 1:35:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm pretty much the only Angus in Ohio, so you can just Google that.
- 1:35:23Mark McGrath: Yeah, you can uh Except all the cows.
- 1:35:25Angus Fletcher: Except cows.
- 1:35:27Angus Fletcher: Yeah.
- 1:35:27Angus Fletcher: Um just uh just look at my book, Primal Intelligence.
- 1:35:31Angus Fletcher: It's now a national bestseller and it's published in like about 20 different languages.
- 1:35:34Angus Fletcher: So if you don't read it, you'll be missing out.
- 1:35:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thank you very much.
- 1:35:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'll keep you on here for a few moments.