Latest / Bloomberg Intelligence / Tesla’s EV Sales Miss Expectations Again in Deepening Slump

Transcript

Tesla’s EV Sales Miss Expectations Again in Deepening Slump · Bloomberg Intelligence

0:02
Speaker 1: Bloomberg Audio Studios, Podcasts, radio news. You're listening to the
0:10
Speaker 1: Bloomberg Intelligence Podcast. Catch us live weekdays at ten am
0:14
Speaker 1: Eastern on Apple, Cocklay and Android Auto with the Bloomberg
0:17
Speaker 1: Business App. Listen on demand wherever you get your podcasts,
0:21
Speaker 1: or watch us live on YouTube.
0:23
Speaker 2: Getting back to Earth here, but we're still talking to
0:26
Speaker 2: elon Musk. Tesla had some numbers come out that were,
0:30
Speaker 2: in terms of deliveries a little bit disappointing. But I
0:34
Speaker 2: guess I'm like a lot of people like, are.
0:36
Speaker 3: They really a car company or is there something else.
0:38
Speaker 2: That's exactly right? So let's go to a car person.
0:41
Speaker 2: That would be David Welchi's a Detroit Burrough chief for
0:45
Speaker 2: Bloomberg News. He's based in Detroit. Hey, David, talk to
0:48
Speaker 2: us about Tesla's delivery numbers here. What did you see
0:51
Speaker 2: and what's the company saying.
0:54
Speaker 4: Look, it was a disappointing quarter no matter how you located.
0:58
Speaker 4: Even though it was up over last year. There's some
1:00
Speaker 4: complete there's some complexities there. So they were they greatly disappointed.
1:05
Speaker 4: What analysts and investors expected them to sell. It was
1:10
Speaker 4: up over last year, So how does that happen? Last year?
1:14
Speaker 4: This time there was a backlash against Elon Musk over
1:18
Speaker 4: Doge and everything he was doing with the Trump administration,
1:21
Speaker 4: so sales had really pulled back from that. If you
1:24
Speaker 4: look at this first quarter versus previous years, not twenty
1:29
Speaker 4: twenty five, but twenty twenty four, twenty three, it's down
1:32
Speaker 4: significantly from there. So Tesla's overall sales globally have just
1:36
Speaker 4: been sliding here for quite a while. EV sales are
1:41
Speaker 4: down all over the globe. I mean not in every market,
1:45
Speaker 4: but the Chinese have pulled back on some of the
1:48
Speaker 4: incentives there. Even Bid has seen a couple of tough
1:50
Speaker 4: months in terms of sales with some of those government
1:53
Speaker 4: based incentives going away. Trump administration got rid of them here.
1:56
Speaker 4: That's hurting EV sales here, and that's all they sell.
1:59
Speaker 4: They getting rid of the Model S and the Model X.
2:01
Speaker 4: And you know, they're the companies trying to pivot toward
2:05
Speaker 4: robotics and automated driving, both of which are very big
2:09
Speaker 4: challenges to beat in the next few years. It's just
2:13
Speaker 4: very difficult to get cars to drive themselves. And the
2:16
Speaker 4: methodology Tesla is using is different from everybody's. They're relying
2:20
Speaker 4: on their data, So look it's it's going to be
2:23
Speaker 4: a tough road ahead, I think for Tesla to really
2:25
Speaker 4: turn investor sentiment around, because they're not selling vehicles like
2:29
Speaker 4: they used to, and there's there a lot of big
2:31
Speaker 4: question marks on the new strategy and the big pivot
2:34
Speaker 4: that Elon Musk is making with this company, all right, and.
2:36
Speaker 5: That's kind of been the story with Tessa for a
2:38
Speaker 5: while now that you know, even though it does still
2:40
Speaker 5: sell cars, that that trajectory has gone down, and with
2:45
Speaker 5: ev sales slowing overall, what's interesting is with the oil
2:48
Speaker 5: prices now elevated, there is more interest among consumers at
2:52
Speaker 5: least into looking into examining the prospect of buying an
2:56
Speaker 5: evy to save on gas costs. There's another story out today,
2:59
Speaker 5: David about Stillantis in talks.
3:01
Speaker 3: To make Chinese evs in Canada.
3:04
Speaker 5: I thought that the US car makers were staying far
3:07
Speaker 5: far away from the Chinese ev makers.
3:11
Speaker 4: They are, But then against Dealants is really a European
3:13
Speaker 4: company with a big US harm, isn't it? But look
3:17
Speaker 4: at Canada relies on the US companies and Toyota largely
3:21
Speaker 4: for its auto industry. That's that's you know, it's for
3:24
Speaker 4: GMS de Lantis and Toyota UH to a degree, Honda
3:27
Speaker 4: that are making a lot of vehicles up there. That's
3:30
Speaker 4: where they get you know, they're there their domestic supply
3:33
Speaker 4: of cars that aren't imported and facing tariffs now and
3:38
Speaker 4: also for employment. And if you're going to have this
3:41
Speaker 4: trade tension between the US and Canada UH, which which
3:45
Speaker 4: we have had for a while now, and and we're
3:48
Speaker 4: unsure of what's going to happen with US mc A.
3:50
Speaker 4: There's a lot of talk that you know, maybe Trump
3:53
Speaker 4: will cut separate deals with Canada and Mexico, and he's
3:56
Speaker 4: been very annoyed with Canada these days. Then Canada has
3:59
Speaker 4: to look elsewhere for companies that are going to invest
4:01
Speaker 4: in their industrial base and make vehicles there that aren't
4:05
Speaker 4: going to be subject to different trade issues. And they're
4:08
Speaker 4: increasingly looking to the Chinese, and I think they would
4:11
Speaker 4: welcome that. Stoantis's partner, Wheat Motor, I'm sure they'd love
4:17
Speaker 4: to get into the Western hemisphere with the hopes that
4:20
Speaker 4: one day, if trade tensions between the US and Canada subside,
4:24
Speaker 4: they could actually send some of those vehicles into the
4:26
Speaker 4: US market And it's not a bad place. These would
4:29
Speaker 4: be small plants, but it's not a bad place for
4:31
Speaker 4: the Chinese companies to get in, even if they need
4:35
Speaker 4: a partner to do it.
4:37
Speaker 3: Stay with us. More from Bloomberg Intelligence coming up after this.
4:43
Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Intelligence podcast. Catch us live
4:47
Speaker 1: weekdays at ten am Eastern on Apple, Coarclay, and Android
4:50
Speaker 1: Auto with the Bloomberg Business App. Listen on demand wherever
4:53
Speaker 1: you get your podcasts, or watch us live on YouTube.
4:58
Speaker 5: When it comes to the drivers in the market, in
5:00
Speaker 5: particular the tech part of the market, it's all about
5:03
Speaker 5: the hyperscalers and how much.
5:05
Speaker 3: Money they plan to spend this year going.
5:08
Speaker 5: Forward on AI infrastructure and hyperscalers. We're talking about Alphabet,
5:13
Speaker 5: We're talking about Microsoft, We're talking about Meta. Microsoft was
5:16
Speaker 5: one of the originals the ogs when it comes to
5:19
Speaker 5: building out its AI infrastructure. Brody Ford is one of
5:22
Speaker 5: our reporters here at Bloomberg. He covers the technology sector.
5:26
Speaker 5: He covers software among other parts of tech, and he
5:29
Speaker 5: has a Bloomberg Big Take story on how Microsoft's CFO
5:33
Speaker 5: has some AI ambitions that are running up against the
5:35
Speaker 5: tech bubble fears and Brody, you kind of write and
5:39
Speaker 5: let's take you inside what's going on at Microsoft and
5:43
Speaker 5: understand how the CFO amy Hood has made these decisions
5:46
Speaker 5: on when to spend, when not to spend, when to
5:49
Speaker 5: pull back. You didn't get a chance to speak with
5:50
Speaker 5: her because she doesn't talk a lot to the public,
5:54
Speaker 5: but you talked, You did a lot of reporting around
5:57
Speaker 5: Microsoft with her team.
5:59
Speaker 3: What did you learn.
6:02
Speaker 6: So why this story is so interesting is Microsoft, as
6:05
Speaker 6: you said, is kind of one of the original hyperscalers
6:08
Speaker 6: and they're sitting on really a nation state size investment pool.
6:13
Speaker 6: And the big question the economy right now is are
6:16
Speaker 6: all these data centers going to pay off? Are all
6:19
Speaker 6: these tens and hundreds of billions of dollars actually going
6:22
Speaker 6: to result in businesses that make margins that are worthwhile?
6:27
Speaker 6: And at Microsoft, amy Hood has effectively become all powerful. Right,
6:31
Speaker 6: you have a CFO who is making decisions about allocation
6:35
Speaker 6: of resources and data centers and who.
6:37
Speaker 7: Gets GPUs and where.
6:39
Speaker 6: And what we largely found is that she took a
6:42
Speaker 6: bit of a skeptical tone over the years. She took
6:45
Speaker 6: a bit of an anxious tone, even that there were
6:48
Speaker 6: moments where she said, man, we really might be overspending here.
6:53
Speaker 2: So she decided to dial back some of that spending.
6:57
Speaker 2: Was that a mistake in hindsight, A lot.
6:59
Speaker 7: Of peop people would say it was. It was maybe
7:02
Speaker 7: about a year year and a half ago.
7:03
Speaker 6: She looked at the numbers that folks were giving her
7:05
Speaker 6: and she said, Man, I don't believe this demand. I
7:09
Speaker 6: questioned this demand, and you know, it's time to hit
7:12
Speaker 6: pause on a lot of these data center projects. And
7:14
Speaker 6: I don't know if you remember, but when this played
7:15
Speaker 6: out in public, it rattled the markets. Everybody saw this as,
7:19
Speaker 6: you know, a sign that Microsoft was getting cold feet.
7:23
Speaker 6: And you know, we're able today to say that that
7:26
Speaker 6: that is what that indicated at that time. Of course,
7:29
Speaker 6: today Microsoft is in the position of finding that, golly,
7:33
Speaker 6: we can't find enough data center capacity and our business
7:37
Speaker 6: is being held back by it. And so it seems
7:40
Speaker 6: clear that they undershot their demand projections. And you know,
7:44
Speaker 6: we're in a moment right now where industry consensuses spend
7:48
Speaker 6: as much as you can, as quick as you can
7:50
Speaker 6: on data centers, and I'm sure in six to twelve
7:52
Speaker 6: months we'll talk again and the consensus will flip once again.
7:56
Speaker 5: And because Microsoft is one of the og hyperscalers. When
8:00
Speaker 5: Amy Hood decided to pull back a bit on spending.
8:03
Speaker 5: That not only caused questions in the market, but it
8:06
Speaker 5: caused other hyperscalers to kind of rethink they're spending as well,
8:09
Speaker 5: didn't it.
8:11
Speaker 6: Well, I think it actually created an opening in many
8:15
Speaker 6: cases a lot of the sites that Microsoft walked away from,
8:18
Speaker 6: some of the younger rivals, think the core Weave, the Nebius,
8:22
Speaker 6: the n scale.
8:23
Speaker 7: They kind of.
8:23
Speaker 6: Swooped in and said, Man, we're ready to buy some
8:26
Speaker 6: data center capacity here. And I think all this kind
8:30
Speaker 6: of shows just how difficult it is right now for
8:34
Speaker 6: the big hyperscalers. I mean, you know, they for a
8:38
Speaker 6: long time had a business model based around no assets
8:41
Speaker 6: around software that hey, if you want to change your plans,
8:44
Speaker 6: you really just kind of have to reallocate some coding teams,
8:47
Speaker 6: and you know, you don't have these long term fixed
8:51
Speaker 6: assets that depreciate over ten fifteen years. And now they're
8:55
Speaker 6: in the position of trying to act almost more like
8:57
Speaker 6: a Boeing or a ge these kind of old in
8:59
Speaker 6: dust real giants, and you know, forecast out demand for
9:03
Speaker 6: a technology that's still emerging. It's it's a really tough
9:07
Speaker 6: balancing act. And I'd argue that there's nobody out there
9:10
Speaker 6: who has more directly on their plate in this than
9:14
Speaker 6: Amy Hood.
9:14
Speaker 3: Does I like the way you put that.
9:16
Speaker 5: They kind of went from it feels like asset light
9:18
Speaker 5: to very asset heavy because they now own and oversee
9:23
Speaker 5: these big, these big data centers. Does that mean that
9:27
Speaker 5: investors eventually will kind of re rate these companies as
9:31
Speaker 5: well given what they have on their on their balance sheet.
9:36
Speaker 6: I sort of think we're seeing it happen already. I
9:38
Speaker 6: mean Microsoft is down, you know, about a loss about
9:41
Speaker 6: a quarter of its value over the last year, and
9:43
Speaker 6: I think a big part of that is the margin
9:45
Speaker 6: story that you know, their margins have been pretty steady,
9:49
Speaker 6: but that's only because they've really been cutting in a
9:51
Speaker 6: lot of the other parts of the business. Right, we
9:54
Speaker 6: write in the story that you know, their cash cow businesses,
9:57
Speaker 6: let's call it like a windows, have had had a
10:00
Speaker 6: lot of cuts in them because this new AI business
10:04
Speaker 6: the margins are so much lower, right, And so you
10:07
Speaker 6: had a company that was printing some of the craziest
10:10
Speaker 6: margins in the world now renting out servers at a
10:13
Speaker 6: much lower margin and having all this, you know, tens
10:17
Speaker 6: of billions of dollars of chips on their balance seat.
10:20
Speaker 6: It does paint a different picture of a company right
10:24
Speaker 6: and the question is are they going to keep spending
10:26
Speaker 6: this way in perpetuity?
10:28
Speaker 7: Are we in a phase?
10:30
Speaker 6: I think that leaders like Amy Hood are really charting
10:33
Speaker 6: in new territory and answering all this in real time.
10:37
Speaker 2: The stock is down twenty five percent year to date.
10:39
Speaker 2: Is Amy Hood feeling any pressure for some of her
10:43
Speaker 2: maybe decisions as it released to AI spending.
10:47
Speaker 6: Our understanding is a lot of folks in the company
10:50
Speaker 6: were not happy with her around the pause last year.
10:53
Speaker 6: That said, it wasn't our indicator that you know, hey,
10:56
Speaker 6: she's going to get the boot over this or something.
10:59
Speaker 7: All that said, she's been in the seat for thirteen years.
11:02
Speaker 6: That's a long time for any CFO, and it's our
11:04
Speaker 6: understanding that there are starting to be succession conversations. We
11:09
Speaker 6: heard some names that were interesting. Chris the CFO over
11:13
Speaker 6: at VISA, well regarded figure over there. You know, he's
11:16
Speaker 6: a name that comes up a lot because he used
11:18
Speaker 6: to be at Microsoft. He knows the business he left
11:21
Speaker 6: and kind of gained skills and could be primed for
11:23
Speaker 6: a return. There's somebody named Matt McBride, who's kind of
11:27
Speaker 6: her internal air apparent, right. I mean, his name will
11:29
Speaker 6: certainly be in the ring here, and so I wouldn't
11:32
Speaker 6: be surprised if in the next year or two we're
11:34
Speaker 6: talking about, you know, the great Microsoft CFO search. But
11:38
Speaker 6: at the same time, I don't think it's that, you know,
11:41
Speaker 6: she screwed up a decision and now she's getting the.
11:43
Speaker 7: Can That's That's not what's happening. Stay with us.
11:46
Speaker 3: More from Bloomberg Intelligence coming up after this.
11:53
Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Intelligence podcast. Catch us live
11:56
Speaker 1: weekdays at ten am Eastern on Apple, Cocklay and Android
12:00
Speaker 1: with the Bloomberg Business app. Listen on demand wherever you
12:03
Speaker 1: get your podcasts, or watch us live on YouTube.
12:07
Speaker 2: Let's stay with the tech theme a little bit, but
12:09
Speaker 2: we'll go to the credit side of the equation. Why
12:11
Speaker 2: because these companies are issuing debt handover fist, which is
12:14
Speaker 2: something we haven't really been used to, but that is
12:16
Speaker 2: something that is a big theme I think across the
12:20
Speaker 2: tech space is kind of how they're funding some of
12:22
Speaker 2: this AI. And the best name for us to chat
12:26
Speaker 2: with on that story is Robert Schiffman. He is tech
12:28
Speaker 2: credit analysts for Bloomberg Intelligence. Let's start with Intel, Rob.
12:31
Speaker 2: I mean, I'm just looking at the stock and the
12:33
Speaker 2: stock's really turned around, really working from a credit perspective.
12:36
Speaker 2: What's the view of Intel, because there we're some concerns.
12:39
Speaker 8: Sure, first, happy holidays to all. Unlike Ira, I will
12:42
Speaker 8: not be working tomorrow. I will be eating through one
12:44
Speaker 8: of our hundreds of boxes of matza.
12:46
Speaker 2: Okay, so we have on the six floor.
12:48
Speaker 8: God bless our our rates chief of staff. Yeah, listen,
12:53
Speaker 8: it's nice to be talking about a name that actually
12:56
Speaker 8: people like in the technology space. Now, stock is up
13:00
Speaker 8: thirty odd percent this year. The S and P five
13:02
Speaker 8: hundred Tech index is down almost ten percent. Spreads or
13:06
Speaker 8: fifty basis points tighter over the past six months. I
13:10
Speaker 8: actually think they they're the original poster child for AI.
13:14
Speaker 8: They announced that they're going to be spending tens of
13:16
Speaker 8: billions of dollars building foundries, not data centers, and free
13:20
Speaker 8: cash went negative. They barred a lot, stock sold off,
13:24
Speaker 8: bond sold off, and lo and behold. You know, they're
13:26
Speaker 8: in the midst of a pretty major turnaround. I think
13:28
Speaker 8: it's a plan others can can potentially follow over the
13:31
Speaker 8: next couple of years.
13:32
Speaker 5: But what makes Intel different, Why was it able to
13:34
Speaker 5: pull it off? And how will other companies who might
13:37
Speaker 5: want to follow in its footsteps be able to you know,
13:41
Speaker 5: follow this blueprint and also succeed.
13:43
Speaker 8: Yeah, well, there's a lot of benefits of having big,
13:46
Speaker 8: powerful friends. So first, you know, the government converted some
13:50
Speaker 8: of their grants into a ten percent equity state that
13:52
Speaker 8: was over eight billion dollars, and Video wrote them a
13:54
Speaker 8: five billion dollar check, and SoftBank wrote a couple of
13:57
Speaker 8: billion dollar check. On top of that, they sold assets,
14:01
Speaker 8: so they gained almost another ten billion dollars in assets
14:04
Speaker 8: sales for non core businesses. So unlike others that have
14:08
Speaker 8: been doing nothing but been borrowing and adding leverage, this
14:11
Speaker 8: company has been on a de leveraging push. On top
14:15
Speaker 8: of that, they're fundamentally their core business is starting to improve,
14:19
Speaker 8: so a better balance sheet, a top line that we're
14:22
Speaker 8: looking to see grow this year after falling five straight
14:25
Speaker 8: years in a row. So they are doing things that
14:27
Speaker 8: are different and they're getting paid for it all right.
14:29
Speaker 2: So on the Bloomberg terminal, if you want to see
14:32
Speaker 2: who the shareholders are of any particular company, you just
14:34
Speaker 2: type in HDS for holders number one for Intel, black Rock, okay,
14:40
Speaker 2: Number two Vanguard got it. Number three United States of America,
14:44
Speaker 2: you don't see that every day, and number four Nvidia.
14:48
Speaker 2: So those are the partners for Intel here. How about
14:53
Speaker 2: the free cash flow story, because I was just looking
14:55
Speaker 2: back at the FA function and as you said, negative
14:57
Speaker 2: free cash because they're spending so much on capex. You're
15:00
Speaker 2: a bond guy, you like free cash flow. How's that
15:03
Speaker 2: story developing.
15:04
Speaker 8: Yeah, we haven't had a lot of free cash flow
15:07
Speaker 8: the last few months to talk about, and we haven't
15:09
Speaker 8: been worried about it. Listen, Intel has been bleeding cash.
15:12
Speaker 8: It looks like they're probably going to be around flatish
15:14
Speaker 8: this year. That being said, though, with all these transactions
15:17
Speaker 8: that they've done, they've built a pretty big base of
15:20
Speaker 8: thirty seven and a half billion dollars of cash on
15:24
Speaker 8: the books. They're using some of it to buy back
15:27
Speaker 8: Apollo stake in one of their jps. It's a phenomenal move.
15:31
Speaker 8: You know, we wrote yesterday that it was a sign
15:33
Speaker 8: of strength. What this company had to do is some
15:36
Speaker 8: creative financing, like you know we've seen with AI. We've
15:38
Speaker 8: seen some of these off balance sheet SPVs to raise
15:41
Speaker 8: money so it doesn't lever the companies. Intel was sort
15:44
Speaker 8: of the first to do this, but they did it
15:46
Speaker 8: with a variety of foundriies. They did a deal with Apollo,
15:48
Speaker 8: and they did a deal with Brookfield. What they're doing
15:51
Speaker 8: now is they're unwinding one of those and it's showing
15:53
Speaker 8: that they now have the financial firepower to go into
15:57
Speaker 8: this build on their own. They don't need partners anymore.
16:01
Speaker 8: So they're using some of that cash that they've got
16:04
Speaker 8: from their equity friends and they're using it now to
16:07
Speaker 8: take a bigger stake in what will be upside in
16:10
Speaker 8: terms of cash flow and EPs from this foundry business.
16:14
Speaker 8: So it's a real sign of strength. It's not just
16:17
Speaker 8: from US. SMP came out right away yesterday and said
16:19
Speaker 8: thought it was credit neutral. Moodies came out and said
16:21
Speaker 8: they thought it was credit positive because it was going
16:24
Speaker 8: to enable quicker deleveraging over a shorter period of time.
16:28
Speaker 8: So it's a real sign of strength, and it's one
16:30
Speaker 8: of the few names that put the equity and the
16:32
Speaker 8: bomb Mark's really love.
16:33
Speaker 3: And very quickly, Robert, do we give all the credit
16:35
Speaker 3: to Boomtown.
16:37
Speaker 8: Let me tell you something. You bring in a new
16:39
Speaker 8: CEO and you make the type of changes that he's made.
16:42
Speaker 8: I think every technology firm would love to have a
16:46
Speaker 8: CEO like that, so yeah, I'll credit kudos to him.
16:50
Speaker 1: This is the Bloomberg Intelligence Podcast, available on Apple, Spotify,
16:55
Speaker 1: and anywhere else you get your podcasts. Listen live each
16:58
Speaker 1: weekday ten am to newn Eastern on Bloomberg dot com,
17:02
Speaker 1: the iHeartRadio app, tune In, and the Bloomberg Business app.
17:06
Speaker 1: You can also watch us live every weekday on YouTube
17:09
Speaker 1: and always on the Bloomberg terminal