Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Media's Facebook Deflection (w/Alex Stamos)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome. Hey everybody.
- 0:14Welcome to this week's episode of dead cat.
- 0:16This is Cam joined as always by Eric and Katie joined this week
- 0:21by our very special, guest Alex Stamos, the director of the
- 0:24Stanford internet Observatory, though, you may all know him for
- 0:27his earlier work as the chief security officer.
- 0:30Assert Facebook, where he oversaw Security on their
- 0:32platforms at a time. That things got a little weird
- 0:36over at Facebook spicen. Yes, by C.
- 0:40So this week, we're going to go deep on Facebook and Russian
- 0:42interference and more specifically if we can get
- 0:44there. How the media reported on this
- 0:47crazy brain breaking time that we probably will never recover
- 0:52from before we get to that though.
- 0:53Quick public congrats to Friend Of The Show.
- 0:55Ken Griffin of Citadel Big Winners this week.
- 0:58Dead cat sponsor chair. Auction to win.
- 1:00Our in-house copy of the US. Constitution can beat out
- 1:04constitutional Dao, better luck next time guys, and congrats to
- 1:08Ken for winning. All right, Alex.
- 1:10So this week we want to dive into a look back on Facebook and
- 1:14Russia and the media. The reason it's interesting now
- 1:17is that there was this recent arrest of I Gordon chanko an
- 1:21analyst who was indicted in an investigation led by the doj
- 1:25that's looking into all the Trump Russia 2016.
- 1:29Ian, what have you? There's actually a great piece
- 1:32about it from Eric when people in Washington Post that we can
- 1:34link to in the show description. But to make this short, which is
- 1:37never easy to do with Russia gate stuff.
- 1:39This indictment essentially led to the collapse of the steel
- 1:42dossier and a number of attractions for media
- 1:45organizations but was never in doubt throughout all of the
- 1:49investigations was that Russia did interfere in the election
- 1:53and continues to interfere in elections as do many, other
- 1:56countries around the world and there's probably no one who
- 2:00Dance, that better than you. Alex, while at Facebook, you
- 2:02were one of the first people, to grasp, really, how Russia use
- 2:06the platform for their interference campaign.
- 2:09And you work directly with the molar investigation to explain
- 2:14that process. And then you got to see a
- 2:16covered by the media. Basically, in real time poorly,
- 2:20what's the score on? How is covered by the media in
- 2:23real-time? I think that's what we're going
- 2:24to discuss. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:26Well, you know, Can you maybe walk us through?
- 2:31What it was? You saw on Facebook's platform.
- 2:34Yeah, we've got to get to check a launching Point here, the
- 2:36weather. Yeah, what exactly did you see
- 2:38while you're at Facebook? And how did you hear going to
- 2:40cut right to the end? You guys gotta let me warm up
- 2:43into the eggs. Like I don't want anybody to
- 2:44actually know what happened. It's a special thing.
- 2:47Nobody knows what happened. And it's all just hot.
- 2:50Takes take first, smart blathers.
- 2:54Yeah, maybe like, yeah, we will sit on the media center enough,
- 2:56Eric, but we got to get a foundation here.
- 2:58You can read all about it. Yeah, in an ugly truth by
- 3:02Katie's colleagues which is soon to be a miniseries which means
- 3:06all of my friends are to eating are texting me with who should
- 3:09play me in the, the adaptation of what have you heard so far?
- 3:12Can we get some casting rumors going?
- 3:13Well, apparently exact Galifianakis is the current
- 3:16leader, making a dramatic turn as a Surefire way to 1 win, an
- 3:19award, but also reinvent your career, so it's it went out
- 3:22every. I think it would be a great move
- 3:23for him from a dramatic perspective.
- 3:24I'm hoping for John Stamos, you know, even though he's like 10
- 3:27years older, I feel like it's the same.
- 3:29This on Stamos could be the name of your podcast.
- 3:32When you talk about the right, I'll have to do a real-time
- 3:35podcast with the episode recapture.
- 3:38I was criticized for making the making this to light.
- 3:41Now you guys are. Okay.
- 3:43Kitty, ask a real question. Okay.
- 3:44Okay. Okay, so tell us what you saw in
- 3:472016 so let's take. So look at the big picture.
- 3:50There's like maybe four different themes of Russian
- 3:54interference in the election, right?
- 3:55And so the first is, when I'm not going to talk about, just to
- 3:58mention is like all of the reach.
- 4:00It's in relationship to the Trump campaign, right?
- 4:02So, you know, all of that stuff of which the Steel dossiers part
- 4:05of it. There's a lot of stuff in the
- 4:06molar report and then the Senate Intel reports.
- 4:10And so, there's the physical stuff right from a propaganda
- 4:12perspective. Another part we won't really
- 4:14talk that much about is, what is called, kind of white or gray
- 4:17propaganda which is the propaganda that can be tied to a
- 4:21government. And so that's like Russia Today,
- 4:22Sputnik that's called White propaganda.
- 4:25And then kind of the two darker more mysterious ways that they
- 4:29influence. The election.
- 4:31The first was the gru activity. So the gru is the main
- 4:34intelligence, directorate of the Russian military.
- 4:37The gru has existed for a long period of time.
- 4:39It's Military Intelligence. They have a hacking side and
- 4:43they have a propaganda side and the hacking and propaganda sides
- 4:45work together. So this is what we see from kind
- 4:47of the really high-end State adversaries is these kinds of
- 4:50hybrid operations, where you have both a offensive computer
- 4:54network intrusion capability, combined, with the propaganda
- 4:57capability. And so, with the gru Was they
- 5:00broke into the dnc's email server.
- 5:02They broke into John, podesta is email, the email thousands of
- 5:04other people. It turns out most of them didn't
- 5:06have much to do with this but the campaign that they uncovered
- 5:10Pizza gate, exactly right. We broke that thing out.
- 5:14Eric's using this to spread disinformation.
- 5:16Fortunately, if you have a whole podcast but this information
- 5:18Spotify will give you a hundred million dollars.
- 5:20So there may be this is the way for you guys to we're working on
- 5:27it and so you have the gru activity T where they breaking
- 5:31all that stuff, they steal all this information and then they
- 5:35release it in a variety of different means, including via
- 5:38Wikileaks, including via personas that they created
- 5:41themselves. Their goal was to change the
- 5:43conversation about Hillary Clinton, so that's the gru
- 5:46activity and then there's the IRA activity.
- 5:49So II RA in this context were talking about the Russian
- 5:51internet research agency. That is a private group.
- 5:55They belong to a guy named Ian vague deeper Goshen.
- 5:58He is an was We considered an oligarch in Russia.
- 6:01He has this troll Farm, which at the time was in this building
- 6:04st. Petersburg, they've actually
- 6:06moved since then, but this famous building in st.
- 6:08Petersburg at which they would build propaganda and spread it
- 6:13on social media, and they did that through the creation of
- 6:16thousands of fake accounts of all of these personas that would
- 6:20pretend to be from the countries where they spread it, and then
- 6:23building up audiences and pushing it, part of that
- 6:25includes advertising. And so, the internet research
- 6:28agency were and about, Thousand dollars in ads on Facebook, the
- 6:32ads were not really for the creation of the propaganda that
- 6:34was for the creation of audiences.
- 6:35So their goal was to use ads to Target groups that might be
- 6:40interested in their content and then pull them into liking pages
- 6:43and then the most of the content was pushed via Facebook pages.
- 6:47So those are the identities for these groups.
- 6:49They would create like a pro-immigration group and
- 6:51anti-immigration group a pro black lives matter, group and
- 6:54anti black lives matter group, stuff like that.
- 6:56Their content in the end with something like 80,000 piece of
- 6:59content. Seen in the end by over 130
- 7:02million Americans. That was the number one topic
- 7:05that they were talking about and you're at Facebook when this is
- 7:08happening or give us where you sort of fit into this time,
- 7:13right? So I was at Facebook, when this
- 7:14happened I joined Facebook in 2015 and as Chief security
- 7:18officer my primary job was keeping people from hacking
- 7:21Facebook, right? So actually feel pretty good
- 7:23about succeed at my piercing, right, right.
- 7:26So we actually did a lot of really good work on security
- 7:28stuff while I was there. And So that's like my primary
- 7:31job. But then I also had a number of
- 7:32groups that worked on the abuse of the platform to cause harm,
- 7:35most specifically there. I had investigators that worked
- 7:38on child. Safety, that worked on
- 7:40counterterrorism. So we had the counterterrorism
- 7:42investigators on my team and then we had to this threat
- 7:44intelligence team. And so the threat intelligence
- 7:46team is mostly X us and then a couple of other from Western,
- 7:51Government intelligence analysts work to NSA, what the CIA in
- 7:54such whose job. It was to track different
- 7:56government's activity, both attacking Facebook.
- 7:59But then also, In Facebook to do bad things.
- 8:01And so kind of a normal work week for them would be, we found
- 8:05four accounts that we can tie to the Islamic revolutionary guard
- 8:08Corps and they are spearfishing, State Department employees to
- 8:13try to get access to their Facebook accounts, from which
- 8:15they can then trick, Iranian dissidents into revealing
- 8:19themselves and then arrest them. So, that's like an actual thing
- 8:21that we found was this big attack by the Iranians because
- 8:24the state department where we had machine learning that
- 8:27detected the kind of activity, we figured it all out.
- 8:29We worked with the state department and the FBI to round
- 8:32that all up in to stop it. And so, that was their normal
- 8:34activity. But we got pulled, we got pulled
- 8:36into this from two different ways.
- 8:37So first, we had a dedicated team working on a PT 28, which
- 8:41is the, the hacking team. That's tied to the Gru.
- 8:44And we saw in the spring of 2016 during the primary process
- 8:49activity by Gru that look like they were interested in people
- 8:52who work for the DN C and D Triple C.
- 8:55If you're an intelligence agent, you've been told I want to hack
- 8:59somebody. Want to hack this organization
- 9:00with the first things you do is you try to figure out all the
- 9:02people that work there and then you learn everything you can
- 9:05about them from their public social media profiles.
- 9:07So, we had a bunch of accounts that we had previously
- 9:09attributed to GRU because their activity.
- 9:11So we saw them doing stuff in the Ukraine and we saw them
- 9:13doing hacks against the world, anti-doping agency, your
- 9:16Facebook, and Linkedin monetize that well or do you make exactly
- 9:21right? Yeah, we get ya LinkedIn.
- 9:23I mean Facebook doesn't sell accounts, but LinkedIn could
- 9:26probably sell some Premium Accounts to the gru.
- 9:29I To most people that reach out to me on LinkedIn are affiliated
- 9:32with some sort of foreign State actor.
- 9:33So, yeah, it's not, it's not a bad Theory.
- 9:36And, and so we saw this activity, we saw them kind of
- 9:38snooping around and so they weren't do any actual attacks on
- 9:40Facebook, but what they were doing reconnaissance, which is
- 9:44the first step in this. The standard operating procedure
- 9:47from that point, was you go and you tell the FBI if they're
- 9:49targeting Americans and the FBI handles it, we now know FBI
- 9:53didn't really do much. Like they had all this
- 9:55information about different kinds of targeting of DNC and
- 9:58there's all this crazy stories. Like I mean, you know, the
- 10:01Hoover building is whatever four blocks from the DNC headquarters
- 10:04or something, and somehow the message didn't make it, but
- 10:06okay. And then later in the year,
- 10:08after the hacks happen, which don't happen on Facebook.
- 10:10They happen on Gmail and then they happen directly against the
- 10:13dnc's infrastructure, which the DNC should never been running
- 10:15their own email server. But that's a different issue.
- 10:18They come back and they create these personas on Facebook
- 10:21called DC leaks. So we'll Wikileaks is kind of a
- 10:24useful idiot to them but they didn't have direct control over
- 10:27Wikileaks. And so, they pretty clearly
- 10:29wanted To have personas to leak information that were under
- 10:32their direct control. And so they create these
- 10:34personas, and then they start reaching out to journalists here
- 10:37are stolen documents. I have, these are the stories
- 10:38you should write, right? And that is effective, it turns
- 10:41out. Now, they also release the data
- 10:42in a bunch of different ways, right?
- 10:44And in the end, they get the stories written that they want.
- 10:47Now, the internet research agency stuff, came after of, you
- 10:51know in the whole discussion of fake news and such that we had a
- 10:53big project to kind of answer the question of all of this fake
- 10:56news content. How much of it came from Russia
- 10:58now in the long term. Just a very small fraction of
- 11:01all that the vast majority of that content is domestically
- 11:04created or family. We suck ourselves that we're
- 11:07just right, right? And or it's created by like
- 11:09financially motivated actors like the apocryphal but real
- 11:13Macedonian teenagers, right? Like things like that.
- 11:16But you know we did obviously found a big chunk of it.
- 11:18We found the internet researching to see activity and
- 11:19then announced that later in 2017, but those are kind of two
- 11:22different things. So, on the gru stuff, we were
- 11:24ahead of the curve on the IRA stuff.
- 11:25We were behind the curve. And you went to the molar team
- 11:29to say, we Found what led to the I re-indictment you reached out
- 11:32to Jeanne re on the team. You know, what was her response?
- 11:35What was that first conversation?
- 11:36Like yeah. So so there's an interesting
- 11:39back and forth between the big tech companies and Department of
- 11:43Justice on all kinds of crimes. In that we have this this is one
- 11:46of the interesting things that we haven't really figured out.
- 11:48Even since 2016 is, how do we want this kind of law
- 11:51enforcement to happen on these companies because the truth is,
- 11:54is that doj and FBI don't have the ability to find the things
- 11:57that the companies can because they can't access.
- 11:59Us petabytes, and petabytes of data without lawful process,
- 12:03they have lots of power to get data on specific individuals,
- 12:06either in a classified or unclassified setting, but they
- 12:08have to know who to grab in the first place.
- 12:11And so, this is actually a pretty common model of the
- 12:15company's notice something bad happening.
- 12:17You go and you send your lawyers to go brief, somebody from the
- 12:20right us attorney's office, you write sign out an Affidavit of
- 12:24this. Facebook employee has witnessed
- 12:25a crime being committed, so it's structurally.
- 12:28This is the kind of conversation that happens all the time.
- 12:29I'm from a political perspective, this was very
- 12:33different right in that, you're not talking about reaching out
- 12:35to like just the normal us, attorney's office in Kansas or
- 12:38whatever because you found a child molester there, you're
- 12:41talking to the special counsel's office, right?
- 12:43And it was interesting, I think in the end, I mean, they were
- 12:45great and they were very thankful.
- 12:47But yeah, we went and privately told them you personally or who
- 12:51is no. No, the lawyers went.
- 12:52So, I was part of preparing all this stuff, but like, in at that
- 12:55kind of level, you're not sending somebody like me in
- 12:58there, all the big tech companies have Of X doj lawyers,
- 13:02who are in-house, who handle law enforcement relationships.
- 13:05So we had a relationship between our threat Intel team and their
- 13:08counterparts and doj. So, for these big groups like
- 13:11apt 28, the FBI actually has coordinator sitting in the
- 13:15Hoover building because, you know, the FBI's like a
- 13:17franchise, right? Just like McDonald's.
- 13:19There's some of them that have, like, great play places and some
- 13:21have the really clean bathrooms. So, like some FBI offices are
- 13:25really good at doing cyber stuff.
- 13:26Some are not so great, so you'll end up with 5 or 6 other Offices
- 13:30looking at a campaign separately.
- 13:32And so the FBI is little have coordinators who sit in the
- 13:34headquarters whose job it is to watch all of this data being
- 13:37gathered and say, oh, these four different hacks, against
- 13:40different steel companies. In four different jurisdictions,
- 13:44are actually the same actor right there.
- 13:46So, we had Direct relationships, those those folks.
- 13:49But when you get to this level in your talking, the special
- 13:50counsel, it's like you're sending the lawyer.
- 13:51So the lawyers go and brief her and them and then we send our
- 13:54people to go talk. After we got lawful process to
- 13:57go, fill them in and to give them all the data that we So
- 14:00this investigation by the special counsel was probably the
- 14:04most watched and reported on Investigation, maybe in my
- 14:08lifetime as your team is speaking to members of molars
- 14:12team. How did you sort of view the way
- 14:14the media covered that? I mean, did you find that there
- 14:17was fairly restrained and reasonable articles written
- 14:20about it? I mean, what's the
- 14:21sensationalism already surrendered?
- 14:23Because we can talk about what happens after the fact because
- 14:25that's when shit really gets crazy but even just in the
- 14:27lead-up to the molar investigation, What was your
- 14:30perspective from where you said right?
- 14:32I mean, I think one, so we published a white paper, I think
- 14:37it was April or something. So in 2017, in Spring of 2017,
- 14:41we publish a paper on what the GRE you did.
- 14:44This is the paper that famously doesn't say it's Russia, but has
- 14:46a footnote that hints that it's Russia and there's almost no
- 14:50coverage of it, right? Like we did media briefings, we
- 14:52did this in that and there's only a couple of stories, right?
- 14:54A hint that it's Russia but not. Not actually have it be Russia.
- 14:57You just say a country and what All-Stars?
- 14:59Backwards or something. So I can pull up the exact
- 15:02footnote. But it says something along the
- 15:03lines of our data is consistent with the attribution provided by
- 15:06the US intelligence agencies in their January memo.
- 15:09So if you remember like, before Obama goes, there's a joint
- 15:12communique from the intelligence agencies, saying it was Russia.
- 15:15Right? Like was clearly the
- 15:16administration getting anywhere. You're worried about getting
- 15:18sued for libel or why the game. No, I mean, so that was a big
- 15:21political fight internally which I'm sure will be an entire
- 15:24episode of this miniseries with Zach Galifianakis being yelled
- 15:27at by by the queen. I was part of Facebook.
- 15:29Except her to not get as much news.
- 15:31So, Facebook, explain any other not the lack of news coverage?
- 15:34I think it's, I mean, there was a bunch of different things, but
- 15:37there's comfy people who did not want Facebook volunteering that
- 15:40bad things. Had happened that Facebook had
- 15:41any part of this, which was clearly not going to work,
- 15:44right? Yeah.
- 15:45Thatís a, and it worked perfectly and no one's blame
- 15:46Facebook since, right? Exactly.
- 15:48And so you have to calm people were pushing that, but then you
- 15:50also have like the d.c. government Affairs.
- 15:52People who don't want to take a side, right?
- 15:55And so, I think that was one of the big things is like, if you
- 15:57say Russia, you know, you got those new Trump Administration,
- 15:59Didn't the right thing to do is to turn this over to the special
- 16:02counsel and eternal all the data over to the people who are
- 16:05investigating. And our job is not to get
- 16:07involved in the public fight, which just happened to coincide
- 16:10with the, like, coms goals of the company.
- 16:12And not yet like involved in anything, right?
- 16:15So, yes, there's a big fight. Like it was a lot, just to get
- 16:18it out. Like the fact that we admitted
- 16:19that anything happened, but everything in there is accurate,
- 16:22just like the whole Rush attribution section was cut out
- 16:25as in one of 85 different versions that went out, but it
- 16:29got very little Coverage. Right?
- 16:30And there's anything we've learned from the whole mother
- 16:32thing. It is that the rollout of stuff
- 16:34matters. Almost more than sort of all the
- 16:37technical footnoted. It's not like, oh, the public
- 16:40eventually consumes it the smartest way as long as it's in
- 16:44there. It's that the the fucking
- 16:46headline is the most important thing and you can say, oh is in
- 16:49there, I don't know. That's that's no.
- 16:51I think you're right. I think you're right and
- 16:53certainly in so it didn't cover the much.
- 16:55I mean, looking back it's not that great.
- 16:58I think like the treatment of Facebook has to Seen in the
- 17:00context of the overall coverage of trump in Russia, which I
- 17:04think, you know, and Smith came up with this term resistance
- 17:07journalism and I think there's a lot of that going on right in
- 17:09that. There's a bit of a moral panic
- 17:12and as long as you say stuff that is about the targets,
- 17:15there's not a lot of pressure from other journalists to get it
- 17:18totally right. And so there's a lot of kind of
- 17:19logical leaping and I think that happened both before and after
- 17:23our announcement September of 2017, obviously after we
- 17:26announce people kind of lose their minds what we'll get to
- 17:28that in a bit because II actually.
- 17:29Yeah. We'll get to that in a bit
- 17:30because I pulled some, some clips from that era which was a
- 17:33great thing. I spent the, I spent like two
- 17:36hours last night, rolling through articles.
- 17:38We'll get to that in a because I definitely want your things.
- 17:40So, so anyway, so you guys work with the council and it is being
- 17:44reported on simultaneously, what will we briefed molar way before
- 17:47the Public Announcement, right? And in fact, when things get
- 17:50complicated, the Public Announcement is that we had a
- 17:52gag order from the molar team, right?
- 17:53So like we go and tell them and then they hit us with a gag to
- 17:57not talk about any of this. And so everything that Facebook
- 17:59Okay, announced had to be negotiated with the special
- 18:01counsel's office, which turns into this whole kind of
- 18:04nightmare when we do the announcement, it doesn't come
- 18:07with any of the data and that was specifically due to this
- 18:10order from Miller's office. So you know and I'm not a lawyer
- 18:13but like these lawyers were having some pretty honest and
- 18:17big arguments both with molars team and then the lawyers in
- 18:21Congress and side like you said, Eric the rollout is what
- 18:24matters. And so you know Facebook ends up
- 18:26putting out this mealy-mouthed blog post with my name on it.
- 18:29That had pretty Much nothing to do with the first draft that I
- 18:31wrote like every single word was changed by a lawyer.
- 18:34A comes first. Before when I say every reporter
- 18:36would tell you you can't let people put stuff on your byline.
- 18:39The you know yes, I learned that too late.
- 18:42Yeah, I should not have let them get my name on it.
- 18:44Really you regret the whole thing?
- 18:46Like I mean isn't it better something than nothing?
- 18:49I don't regret the white paper I think getting the white paper
- 18:51out. So on the white paper side I
- 18:54wish it said Russia. This is the other part.
- 18:56So when you talk about the treatment of the media, you
- 18:58know, again there's two totally different.
- 18:59Campaigns the IRA campaign. Absolutely.
- 19:02The responsibility of Facebook and Twitter, right?
- 19:04It is our responsibility to catch that and we did not my
- 19:06team did not catch that. I did not catch that you didn't
- 19:08stop it. The gru campaign was targeted at
- 19:12the media and that absolutely worked, right?
- 19:15I wrote. There's a there was a story
- 19:17about John podesta as pasta sauce recipe, which one could
- 19:19argue probably wasn't really relevant to the election issues
- 19:22at hand. And yet, there was political ran
- 19:24a live blog at start. We all know we all know that he
- 19:26had risotto recipes, or whatever.
- 19:28Yeah, I mean, yeah, like Luke. I ran a live blog of, like, what
- 19:31embarrassing stuff can we find in these emails?
- 19:33And maybe it's a Russian plot, but doesn't really matter
- 19:35because it's newsworthy. This is where I spent most of my
- 19:37evening yesterday reading through old articles because as
- 19:40Facebook, gets closer to, I guess it was just delivering
- 19:44testimony front of Congress about what you found in your
- 19:47research on the IRA. There's kind of leaks that come
- 19:50out did the day before hand and so just pulling through a
- 19:53sampling of Articles, you know, this one from the New York Times
- 19:56actually October 2nd 2017 headline Facebook's Russia link
- 20:00ads came in many disguises and, you know, has a lead in there.
- 20:04The Russians, who poses Americans on Facebook last year
- 20:07tried on quite an array of disguises.
- 20:09There's an article in CNN from Dylan Byers, September 28th,
- 20:132017 that refers to the IRA as a shadowy agency, which comes up
- 20:18very frequently, describing them as a shadowy agency that's
- 20:21extremely sophisticated in their ways of disseminating.
- 20:25They're not necessary to visit of information things of that
- 20:28nature. There's also So, a column from
- 20:30Margaret Sullivan, I want to get to later.
- 20:32But again, from your perspective, as these articles
- 20:34are coming out in advance of Facebook employees testimony in
- 20:38front of Congress. What's your sense as this is
- 20:40being rolled out? Because it definitely fed a
- 20:42frenzy happening in the public that.
- 20:45Russia fucked everything up. They came in there.
- 20:48They broke American democracy and they did it through to visit
- 20:52Facebook posts. Yeah, I mean, I think so.
- 20:54Facebook obviously takes a huge should take a huge amount of
- 20:57blame on the way that all this information.
- 20:59Was released and framed and the desire to keep everything
- 21:03secret. And then to only allow things to
- 21:04come out drips and drabs really hurt the company.
- 21:07That being said, the overall reaction seemed crazy because it
- 21:10was completely out of touch with the actual quantitative size of
- 21:15this content because something like 80,000 post sounds big
- 21:19Until you realize the denominator on that is in the
- 21:22hundreds of millions, right? And so the vast majority, this
- 21:25content had almost no reach like on the stuff where the Russians
- 21:28posted the content themselves. All right, so II ra, they're
- 21:31making propaganda, they're posting it.
- 21:32So this is like a picture of people at a fence that is an
- 21:36anti-immigration add or it's a pro.
- 21:39Something that looks like it's Pro black lives matter.
- 21:41But made by a fake group, right? For that stuff, its overall
- 21:45reach compared to other, both organic, and paid content was
- 21:49nowhere near, right? There's hundreds of millions of
- 21:52dollars were spent on the election on Facebook and they
- 21:54spent 150,000 dollars, right? Which it's like over the course
- 21:56of two years, which do the math. That's what less than 5.
- 21:59I was in a month. I mean like there are they are
- 22:01like, you know, d2c makeup brands for dogs, that probably
- 22:05spend more on Facebook and Instagram than the IRA did.
- 22:09So the idea that this was a huge spend was was, was always a
- 22:12fallacy and I don't know how many people that, you know, got
- 22:16whipped up into a frenzy, about it, really understood that.
- 22:19Well, because it also got combined completely without any
- 22:22evidence with the Cambridge analytic issues, which is this
- 22:25kind of imaginary world in which Cambridge analytical is this
- 22:28magical Group of bond villains that have mind-control powers
- 22:32based upon, right? Yo, people's likes that they
- 22:35took yo, illegally via an API to be totally clear Cambridge
- 22:39analytical themselves as a scam, right?
- 22:41So they said they had these magical psychographic models of
- 22:43people and there are quantitative metrics as to
- 22:46whether online ads work. There's a whole set of people
- 22:50whose entire job. It is to think about these
- 22:52metrics and I know of those met none of those metrics is came a
- 22:54general like a better than just any other kinds of AD targeting
- 22:58that people do on Facebook, right?
- 22:59And they had nothing to do with Ira to be clear, Kim Joon wook.
- 23:02It had absolutely nothing to do with internet, research to see
- 23:04the research internet research agency did zero data upload
- 23:07custom audiences. So they didn't even do what we
- 23:11consider micro-targeting. They targeted like you know,
- 23:14young men in this ZIP code in Baltimore for pro black lives
- 23:19matter messages, but none of that mattered to the narrative
- 23:22which conflating these things at these Russians have kind of
- 23:25magical mind control powers that they were able to use through a
- 23:28hundred fifty thousand dollars of ads.
- 23:29When Hillary Clinton campaign, spent like a hundred million
- 23:31dollars, right answers? Like the idea that they were a
- 23:34thousand times. But what about this idea that
- 23:36you guys were like hand holding the Trump campaign in a way, you
- 23:39weren't the cloaking campaign. So there's I think totally
- 23:43legitimate arguments on whether Facebook ads had an effect on
- 23:47the campaign. Almost certainly Facebook ads
- 23:49had an effect on the campaign but they were to the
- 23:51quote-unquote legitimate ads paid for by the campaigns and
- 23:55the official committees and such using the money that our country
- 23:58allows people. To give, right?
- 24:00Yo, to two candidates in the parties, for which there are no
- 24:04legal controls, I had nothing to do this.
- 24:05So all of this I know from the investigation afterwards, right?
- 24:08But, my understanding is that both campaigns, just like any of
- 24:11the, if you're a Procter & Gamble, you get a personal, you
- 24:14get a Facebook employee whose entire job it is to help your
- 24:16campaigns run. And so these campaigns are
- 24:19spending tens hundreds millions of dollars.
- 24:21So they got offers of these people will help you do it and
- 24:24the Trump campaign not knowing what they're doing said, yes.
- 24:27And the Clean Campaign was like now we At this and said no.
- 24:31And so it is true and it is quite possible that trumps
- 24:33campaign was way better than Clinton's campaign because of
- 24:36that, we partially don't have this data because the data is
- 24:39kind of Legally locked up and it's never come out and there's
- 24:42never been any changes to the law to allow it to come out.
- 24:44I'm actually think this is where Congress has failed.
- 24:46The most is that there have been zero changes to online
- 24:49advertising law, since 2016. I would like to ban
- 24:52micro-targeting for political ads, because I think it's
- 24:55innately corrupting because it both drives campaigns just All
- 24:59this information but it also drives them to Target message
- 25:03different messages to different audiences.
- 25:05Both political parties. Do this in both political
- 25:06parties, think they're better. So they will make all these
- 25:09noises publicly about how horrible ads are incorrigible
- 25:11lake or river. It's all Bs right?
- 25:13In private, all of these senators and congressmen are
- 25:16being told by their Consultants were getting paid to run
- 25:19political ads. They're being told by their
- 25:20Consultants were better, do not unilaterally disarm, and so they
- 25:24won't pass any laws. Europe.
- 25:25Europe is starting to make some moves here, but in the United
- 25:27States, there's been nothing Kim.
- 25:28Can we take a quick Step back for a second to to the IRA stuff
- 25:32because I mean you sort of brought it up and I have this
- 25:34column here. This is again for that.
- 25:36Same time period in 2017, this is from Margaret Sullivan, who
- 25:39is a great media columnist. This is not a slam on her at
- 25:41all, but I think it looks very interesting in retrospect and
- 25:44really is a good summary of the era.
- 25:47So the headline is collusion, who needs it?
- 25:49When Facebook was allowing Russians to help Trump.
- 25:52This is a key paragraph from this column much of that
- 25:54content. This is the IRAs content was
- 25:56expressly designed to widen the cultural divides, the United
- 25:59States to Of wedges among its citizens and in doing so, to
- 26:02help elect the Russian, government's preferred candidate
- 26:04Donald Trump. It worked.
- 26:07And while those more recent numbers are astonishing, I'm
- 26:09assuming this is the numbers. Unlike reach the reality is
- 26:11probably far worse research from Columbia University's Tau Center
- 26:15suggests that Russian, linked information or disinformation
- 26:18with shared hundreds of millions of times on Facebook.
- 26:20The numbers Boggle, the mind of what here.
- 26:22No, let me, let me read the key paragraph here because this is
- 26:24where I think it really gets to the point.
- 26:26We need to admit the obvious. If there had been no Facebook
- 26:29spreading, Russia propaganda. There might as well be no
- 26:31President Trump. Now looking at this.
- 26:35Now from 2021, I don't want to seem too much smarter now
- 26:38because it's easy to be critical in hindsight.
- 26:40But is that an insane conclusion to reach based on everything
- 26:44that you saw from the IRA? And is the fact that a major
- 26:47newspaper is publishing this, in some way, a failure on the part
- 26:51of the media, or the interaction between the media and these tech
- 26:54companies to accurately, assess the role that the I replayed in
- 26:58the 2016 election. Yes, that's wrong from my
- 27:01perspective, the two kinds of online propaganda that were most
- 27:04effective was one legitimate Facebook ads.
- 27:07The ads that were run by the candidates in, which Trump did a
- 27:10better job than the Clinton headed.
- 27:11Straight up above board, using custom audiences and all the
- 27:14Procter & Gamble shit. Which again, I would like laws
- 27:17to change that but we need laws to change it, right, right.
- 27:19And then the second was the gru activity because the gru
- 27:22activity completely changed the tenor of the coverage of Hillary
- 27:26Clinton, that was incredibly effective because what they used
- 27:29was. Olin emails that allowed them to
- 27:32create stories that were based upon a kernel of Truth.
- 27:35Where the story itself was not accurate and be frank.
- 27:38The US media has never ever ever looked inside of itself of the
- 27:43fact that every major news are, you know, the New York Times The
- 27:45Washington Post, CNN MSNBC, not just Fox, which like, we'll just
- 27:48have to write off Fox of like what we can do about Fox.
- 27:52But for all the, what I considered the legitimate media,
- 27:54every single one of them was played by the gru they wrote
- 27:57exactly the stories of Gru wanted and they Done.
- 28:00No soul-searching on that at all.
- 28:03And so at, yes, we screwed up like I will absolutely admit
- 28:06that we screwed up but the idea that a hundred thousand dollars
- 28:09in ads is as important as the entire legitimate, American
- 28:13Media changing the way it covered Hillary Clinton is just
- 28:17ridiculous. I want to just to say Tom
- 28:21response to your comment and then it was must Alex in a
- 28:23minute. That Margaret sullavan column is
- 28:25so interesting because it kind of erases history, you know,
- 28:29Russia 'He had used propaganda to widen the divisions between
- 28:34Americans before there were very active in the 60s and 70s the
- 28:37United States when the country was going through an
- 28:39extraordinary Civil Rights Movement.
- 28:42This is not the first time that Russia and other countries but
- 28:45especially Russia have used internal divisions in a country
- 28:48to try to destabilise the country itself.
- 28:50So I think that, what is missed in that column is that this is
- 28:53not a new strategy, it's simply a new tool and I think we could
- 28:57debate whether or not the tool is more.
- 28:59Active than any other tool they've had before and that is
- 29:03an interesting debate but certainly this is not new.
- 29:05I mean, if you're a student of history and you've read anything
- 29:08about Russia's efforts to cause the collapse of the United
- 29:13States in the 60s, you know, this isn't new.
- 29:16Yeah. Tom Tom ridge book on this is
- 29:18fantastic right. Active measures like absolutely
- 29:22CIA invented AIDs that whole thing.
- 29:24Yes, I think this is a good because we're now promoted
- 29:26Cecilia and share has book and soon-to-be TV show.
- 29:29Ow. And now, this really great book
- 29:30after measures were really more of kind of like a marketing, a
- 29:34marketing agency owner. Do you guys have a code that
- 29:37unites discount on these books? You need to you need to line
- 29:40that up before this goes. Yeah, but I think that on the
- 29:42question of whether or not newsrooms have really reckoned
- 29:46with this idea of being played by the gru, there were moments
- 29:50where at least Dean baquet at the times, he came out different
- 29:55panels. He was asked about this and he
- 29:56did say that it had led to some soul-searching.
- 29:59I You know, the internally certainly this conversation
- 30:03husband had an is being had and those are really important and
- 30:07ongoing conversations, especially we saw going into the
- 30:102020 election, will see you again going to the 2022.
- 30:15Midterms like this, this is an ongoing conversation.
- 30:18Even if it's not necessarily happening as publicly as it is
- 30:21for Facebook and whether or not that's fair, I think is very is
- 30:24a very good question, really? I mean, there are there are
- 30:28great journalists at All of these organizations who I've had
- 30:30private conversations with where they absolutely recognize all
- 30:33this. And I know that they are part of
- 30:35the internal conversations of. Like, let's not get played again
- 30:37on D McKay, I remember very distinctly a week because I
- 30:40wrote something about this, where Mark Zuckerberg gave his,
- 30:43like, the speech were like, he changes history.
- 30:45That Facebook was invented because of the Iraq War, which
- 30:47is, yeah, yeah. I was not in that Harbor Group
- 30:49which is why I don't own an island, but like, that does not
- 30:52seem accurate to me, but the same week Dean Beck a was on
- 30:56Michael Voris podcast, which I'm a huge fan of the times podcast.
- 30:59And borrow to his credit is like interviewing his boss's boss's
- 31:04boss, and ask them. These really tough questions.
- 31:06And Bouquet says, if it's newsworthy, we will publish it,
- 31:10right? And so I saw both Zach and Decay
- 31:12or kind of actually to me similar figures in that from
- 31:16bekay everything is about newsworthiness right?
- 31:19And even if you're getting played, even if the leaked
- 31:22documents were leaked from hacking from a Russian hacking
- 31:25group, they're going to run. It whereas duck was all about
- 31:28kind of free speech. In the freedom of individuals
- 31:30and I saw them as like in this parallel that both of them are
- 31:32getting played, both of them have like this deep belief in
- 31:35what they're doing. And can't understand how that
- 31:37deep belief is being used against them, so they Facebook,
- 31:39like we at least published I? Yes, I failed to get the company
- 31:43to put Russia into that paper. The New York Times wrote nothing
- 31:47right. The York Times has never ever
- 31:50written anything. About we got played by the
- 31:51Jerry, you were sorry. And so yes, did I fail?
- 31:54Yes, but I, at least will say it.
- 31:56We need to realize, we need to rely on media columnist for
- 31:59that. We need to rely on Margaret
- 32:00Sullivan for those sorts of Articles anymore.
- 32:03But Margaret Sullivan is as subject to the, you know, the
- 32:06whims of the moment. And that means like in general,
- 32:09right? Sure.
- 32:09It's really hard to get the media to write a story saying,
- 32:12we messed up. And I think the red and many
- 32:14moments where various people have said, don't you think that
- 32:18BuzzFeed should apologize for publishing raw unvetted
- 32:23intelligence that completely changed the course of how we
- 32:25think about Donald Trump, that's falling apart.
- 32:27These questions have come up again.
- 32:28And again, Multiple media organizations and I'm not
- 32:31excusing them. I'm just going to agree with you
- 32:33that we haven't seen the equivalent of a white paper
- 32:35where a media organization comes out.
- 32:37And says, this is, this is how we messed up and this is what we
- 32:40want to do better. So I think, because of the way
- 32:42the media works, we are all really dependent on columnist.
- 32:45Whether it's a Margaret sullavan or whether it's a Columbia,
- 32:47journalism review, some sort of outside forcing function to say
- 32:52this is important to recognize for sure.
- 32:55For sure. I mean the handling of like the
- 32:57hunter by knee males Joe His daughters diary.
- 33:00I mean those would seem to be early signs that the media is
- 33:05having a much more command and control approach which is also
- 33:09criticized. Well I mean it is sort of a
- 33:10no-win case where if there's information out there that seems
- 33:14it's absolutely no win and it's no win for both the tech
- 33:18companies in the media. I mean, there's no direct hit
- 33:20both sides screwed up right and sort of the government.
- 33:23So, like you're asking about what is like, so what did it
- 33:26feel? Like for us inside Facebook,
- 33:27what it felt like was there. Three?
- 33:29Three people, there's Mark Zuckerberg in the hoodie,
- 33:31there's, you know, the FBI G-Man in his suit and there's, you
- 33:36know, a New York Times Reporter with like the Press hat on like
- 33:38the little, you know, the Fedora or whatever and both the
- 33:41government guy in the Press car. Like, oh man, that guy in the
- 33:44hoodie screwed up, right? We did nothing wrong, but they
- 33:47really messed up. All these things were in bed,
- 33:49Facebook are accurate and true. And it is the mistakes of the
- 33:52company that need to be fixed, but they are in the context of
- 33:55an overall, failure of American society to deal with this new Of
- 34:00attack by one of our adversaries.
- 34:02And unless you look at the big picture, you can't solve it.
- 34:05And that's like one of my lessons come out of the 2020.
- 34:07Election was the context of propaganda.
- 34:10Mind is completely changed in the vast majority of it.
- 34:12Now comes from verified American voices.
- 34:14Tuna, we know exactly what they are.
- 34:16They're not being Amplified by Russians are not fake accounts
- 34:19and they have the ability to control the media context as
- 34:22well as to get their messages out on social media.
- 34:24And until we kind of deal with the fact that this is a
- 34:27multimedia issue, That that it flows between kind of the
- 34:31traditional media and the online platforms.
- 34:34We're not really gonna be able to do anything.
- 34:35I don't think any of us would make this case.
- 34:37But some you could say that it was in the media's interest to
- 34:40put the blame on Facebook to shift the blame from the media.
- 34:44If the bigger hack was in retrospect about using the media
- 34:48to spread disinformation pointing the finger at Facebook,
- 34:52was in the media, is like Financial corporate interest.
- 34:56I mean, obviously I disagree with that.
- 34:59Really, really the only reason I disagree with that is because
- 35:02you're talking about a period when the media was so beloved
- 35:06that nobody was shifting blame. Well, bye.
- 35:08If you want to Kratz. So loved by the left, if you
- 35:11were walking down the street as a Washington reporter, you went
- 35:16to an airport and somebody recognized in Washington, not
- 35:20just in Washington like all over the country.
- 35:22People were thinking you were getting letters.
- 35:24This. I'm talking about the period
- 35:26right after Trump was elected. Oh, I know what you're talking
- 35:28about. Look my mom.
- 35:29I signed up for a subscription to The Washington Post just to
- 35:31support them. She's like right now.
- 35:32I'm no, I'm not. I'm talking about the Trump, the
- 35:35Trump term of his presidency. I mean, people are wearing
- 35:38democracy dies in darkness shirts, and DC.
- 35:40Yeah, there is no blame to shift who was blaming the media for
- 35:45Trump at that point. Now, people are now might be the
- 35:48time when that thesis would make sense, but literally in the days
- 35:52months after the election, basically, from the time, Donald
- 35:57Trump was elected through the issuance of Of the molar report.
- 36:00They'll nobody was blaming the media for anything, just like
- 36:03nobody is blaming the FBI another group with its hated but
- 36:06suddenly was not hated for like a couple of years.
- 36:09I just want to ask what this social psychological story for
- 36:11the media is if it's not that sort of narrative, like this is
- 36:15a good way to deflect it. Like what is your mental model?
- 36:18Is it just like the media is not top down enough and there isn't
- 36:21enough like command-and-control, it's like sort of that it's an
- 36:24organ or just like do you have a thesis on like where the media
- 36:28fails on this? Stuff.
- 36:30Well, I think Ben Smith was right about resistance
- 36:32journalism, right? Which is like we end up in a
- 36:34situation where as long as you publish something that fits
- 36:38preconceived notions about, who the bad guy is like, if you can
- 36:40tell something in the in the Arc of this is this is the bad guy
- 36:44and they did bad things then getting the details, right?
- 36:47Isn't that important, right? Like, there's not push back and,
- 36:50and we see that with Facebook all the time, we're seeing that
- 36:51now with the Hagen documents, we're about to the media reports
- 36:54about those documents, do not match up to the documents
- 36:57themselves. Once they are released which is
- 36:58one of the reasons. I am quite upset that this is
- 37:01the way. These documents were released is
- 37:02like in a way to create kind of a Feeding Frenzy only for the
- 37:07headlines. There's a bunch of stuff in
- 37:09there. That's going to be super
- 37:10important for academic, study of social media.
- 37:13In the long run. This is going to be great
- 37:14because this is going to kick off, kind of a much more
- 37:17rigorous. Empirical study of the things
- 37:19that happened on line that is going to see a lot of great
- 37:21work. But in the meantime, we have to
- 37:23deal with the headline grabbing of like the Wall Street Journal,
- 37:26writing the story about the Instagram slides that did not
- 37:29match. If the slides once the slides
- 37:30came out, the Washington Post had a headline about Facebook.
- 37:33Uprating, the, you know, the angry Emoji, which was
- 37:37intentionally misleading in that in the story.
- 37:39If you read it, all of the Emojis were upright, all the
- 37:43reactions other than, like, were up ranked and then, and then
- 37:45there is an internal study and that turned out to be causing
- 37:47harm. So they fixed it, which is
- 37:49exactly what you want. People who wrote the read The
- 37:51Washington Post story where, less educated about how faithful
- 37:54camels these issues, than before they read the story.
- 37:57And so that is resistance journalism to me, because Nobody
- 37:59pushed back on them, the Wall Street Journal.
- 38:01The Instagram one is been, I mean we've talked about a lot.
- 38:03What's your case? You just quickly articulate.
- 38:06Now your objection though. So there's a couple things.
- 38:08One, this is like very initial work by an Instagram team to try
- 38:12to ask people how they feel in different circumstances to then
- 38:15lead to more research into your talking about a very small
- 38:17sample size. And this kind of just asking
- 38:20people how they feel is not that great, and it's known.
- 38:23And then the second is, there's Parts where it's much more
- 38:25positive, and it's great makes people really happy, right?
- 38:28When you read this, you know, Okay.
- 38:30It turns out that, yes, there are problems with teenagers and
- 38:32social media and that is something that needs to be
- 38:34studied. And this is the beginning of
- 38:36that. The best part of this was like,
- 38:38there was an article in Wired Magazine, which is owned by
- 38:41condé Nast, who are the people who publish Vogue, which is like
- 38:44to get lectured by condé Nast on, you know, beauty standards
- 38:48for teenage girls is is amazing and just kind of encapsulate.
- 38:52The overall problem here, which is, there is a problem, both in
- 38:54social media, and media, in a bunch of these areas, but only
- 38:57one of those sides ever gets looked at in the media, never
- 38:58looks them. Condé Nast will never ask
- 39:00itself, have generations of our publishing, but they're really
- 39:04obviously doesn't work that way. A reporter at wired isn't even
- 39:07connected, to what the editor-in-chief of wired things.
- 39:09Let alone with somebody it voted but nobody writes it.
- 39:12Nobody will write any of these things in the bigger context.
- 39:14No, but I understand the argument in part, because the
- 39:16media companies themselves aren't doing those studies to.
- 39:19So, we're in an unusual situation, we're probably for
- 39:21the first time. We have studies about how media
- 39:24products. If we want to call, you know,
- 39:26Instagram and meteor product. We want to call copy of Vogue
- 39:30and media product, how they're actually making people feel, you
- 39:32know, Vogue does reader surveys all Publications do reader
- 39:36research but it's really mostly about subscription.
- 39:39How did this convert a subscription or did this not
- 39:42convert a subscription? What are our most loyal readers
- 39:44do? And how do we get more of them?
- 39:47I think to your point about why the Facebook research will
- 39:50continue to be important beyond the stories is that we'd have
- 39:53never seen really this much research done on media products
- 39:57before and I think would be great.
- 39:59More was done. I think it'd be great if the
- 40:02media itself, didn't more of that kind of research.
- 40:04But right now, it does 0 of it. So, right.
- 40:07Well, which is why the big irony series, it's coming out the
- 40:09Wall, Street Journal, a Murdoch property, and the idea of Rupert
- 40:11Murdoch, having like a Civic Integrity team looking at his
- 40:14impact on Democracy is kind of hilarious.
- 40:16I sort of realized that, you know, when Ben wrote that column
- 40:19and by the way, it must be said that.
- 40:20If you want to talk about the various purveyors of resistance
- 40:23journalism, the release of the steel, dossier could easily fall
- 40:26within that category, that was Ben's decision.
- 40:29It's amazing. Yeah it was and look he can
- 40:31defend himself and I'm sure he will on any has several times.
- 40:34So he has, yeah, there's no reason to call him out.
- 40:36He's a friend of the show but it absolutely was friend of my,
- 40:40friend of up, he was a great cast and we like, then it was a
- 40:44great guy love, but I started fighting people Eric, you are
- 40:49more like been than any of the other people on this show.
- 40:52And this is why you can't get all of those Farm on side
- 40:56Channel. My Discord thread.
- 40:57I write, I wrote it like, multi, A screed defending Ben Smith
- 41:01owning shares. I've written on Twitter.
- 41:03I'm I'm the most Ben Smith Toady around.
- 41:05I agree with Ben Smith on the steel dossier.
- 41:08The only reason you're the only reason you're ambivalent is
- 41:10because you guys are the same person.
- 41:12I'm just saying. Yeah.
- 41:13They if you playing the banker is more fun.
- 41:15If he's a friend of me then he's just a blind friend.
- 41:18Yeah. Weirdly Eric was not there that
- 41:19week, we interviewed been. So you make your own decisions
- 41:21on what that? I know I missed out.
- 41:23I've talked to many, many ways. Oh, I just mean you're the same
- 41:25person, but that's not going to make a substitution.
- 41:29Stack joke aren't you supposed to make some tax jokes like
- 41:32every 20 minutes or something? And that required traditional
- 41:35journalists. But no in my mind everything has
- 41:38become resistant journalism, not everything.
- 41:40A lot of things have become resistant journalism now because
- 41:44I think people recognize that as subscriptions have driven, you
- 41:48know, to be the predominant, business model of many things of
- 41:51many of these news organizations, there is real
- 41:53need to serve that audience. Do you think that that has
- 41:56gotten to be more and more the case, you know, post, Teen
- 42:00post-2020. And if you agree with that Alex,
- 42:03what role do you think? The tech companies and Facebook
- 42:06specifically play in in that being the way things are?
- 42:10I mean, yeah. So the Dynamics of like the
- 42:13change way from the advertising model towards subscriptions that
- 42:16is obviously being driven by the tech companies taking up so much
- 42:19revenue and I think, and I've said this probably for I think a
- 42:21huge failure by the tech companies was never to figure
- 42:24out a way to revenue share with legitimate media, whatever you
- 42:27call legitimate media, right? Like a bunch of The stuff has
- 42:29happened and it happened kind of too late.
- 42:31After media was hollowed out, especially local.
- 42:34I saw some stats of like, 10% of people who work in journalism
- 42:37work for the New York Times. Now, it's like four percent of
- 42:39the actual reporters and 10% of people overall.
- 42:43Officially Wonder, like how much support staff in your time,
- 42:45says, I'm skeptical that I would need to see ya insulted Dean
- 42:49McKay, I talk about that your time.
- 42:52This is like the game Katie fire, well, that would get rid
- 42:55of one employee at the, I mean, that, like, consolidation, Is
- 42:59clearly both from advertising being taken up by the companies
- 43:03as well as the decisions of some journalistic Outlets.
- 43:06Plus just the success of the times of building up an audience
- 43:09that is willing to pay all this money but is a smaller smaller
- 43:12audience, right? So that's what sub s
- 43:14demonstrate. I mean, the New York Times thing
- 43:15is the same as the subject demonstration, which is if you
- 43:17have a small number of people who love you, then, that is way
- 43:20more profitable than making it, you know, trying to make it in a
- 43:24per click on an ad basis, right? But our subscription base is
- 43:27growing. It's not a small number of
- 43:29People who are subscribing so it's hardcore.
- 43:32Dedicated you mean compared to like the entire universe of
- 43:34people who use Facebook for TV? What I'm saying is like you have
- 43:38a there's a small number of people who really all of these
- 43:42media outlets and moved to subscription are absolutely
- 43:44motivated to keep their small number of subscribers have.
- 43:46Okay. I think we have more than 8
- 43:47million subscribers. I don't think it's like the
- 43:49tiniest number and I was just trying to be clear.
- 43:52I get the times I'm you know but like I just have to like we're
- 43:55all liberal Elites Coastal Elites, right?
- 43:58And don't you trust At the most, this is what I want to ask.
- 44:00What do you trust like, what if not the times?
- 44:03What, you know, like oh I do trust the times most of the time
- 44:06except like, I'll read the story.
- 44:07I mean, again, there's a difference between like things
- 44:10being factually accurate or not and things being applied in the
- 44:13right context or the amount of coverage they get.
- 44:14Right? Yeah, I understand.
- 44:16I mean, like, this idea of resistance journalism, I'm
- 44:19opposed to it just in practice, just, that's just me.
- 44:23I mean, if you look at most of the things that came out of the
- 44:25Frances Hogan stuff, you can agree or disagree with the
- 44:27conclusions and, and either they, you know, illustrate a
- 44:31completely fucked up company. Or the question is, like, what
- 44:34should they just have released that information publicly?
- 44:36And we could have seen, oh, there were research internally
- 44:39at Facebook, showing that there a percentage of young girls that
- 44:42use Instagram that are unhappy. Obviously, you don't want to put
- 44:45out the internal deliberations at the New York Times, but some
- 44:48sort of public discussion of a decision as to why they chose
- 44:52not to run certain things would sort of benefit people to
- 44:56understand what the process is that, you know, Separates a
- 45:00mainstream news organization from one that has no
- 45:03credibility. I mean, the Facebook side.
- 45:05I think absolutely, they should publish it.
- 45:07We go two directions from this one either.
- 45:09Tech companies start to publish these things because they
- 45:12realize that doing it themselves.
- 45:14Makes it not a scandal like a bunch of these reports are just
- 45:16reports in like there are good things and bad things like the
- 45:18Instagram one. Honestly is both sides and so
- 45:21Facebook, published that it would not be seen as like this
- 45:23huge Scandal for what you need. All these investigations.
- 45:25We actually launched a journal at Stanford which was totally
- 45:27coincidental at the hog and stuff but I It's pretty the
- 45:29Journal of online trust and safety specifically.
- 45:31Because we want to get platforms to published peer-reviewed
- 45:34research in places that they can interact with academics and
- 45:37others. So I think that's a good thing.
- 45:39There's also the possibility from here is that companies just
- 45:41don't do the research because the truth is that Facebook has
- 45:43more people working on this than the rest of the industry
- 45:45combined and is now being punished for that fact.
- 45:47And so there's a possibility that if you're at Tick-Tock,
- 45:50you're like, oh no, never look, never create a document that
- 45:53says anything is bad because eventually if it leaks it
- 45:56becomes a scandal and it's better not to look to go.
- 45:59Also to like kind of the 2016 story.
- 46:01Facebook is not the largest Advertiser on the internet, it
- 46:04turns out, not even by a long shot, and there's another large
- 46:08company. I'm sure smoogle that had lots
- 46:11of stuff going on that quietly found, it never told the public
- 46:15never told molars team never told anybody because they're not
- 46:17legally required to what you think.
- 46:19Google is worse than Facebook and Russian interference in the
- 46:212016 election. I don't I don't know because we
- 46:25don't know anything and And since then their playbook has
- 46:30been to not share anything, right?
- 46:33So like Facebook has crowd tangle which might get killed.
- 46:35So I like crowd angles is fantastic platform.
- 46:39That is super useful and was incredibly key to our 2020 work
- 46:43and all the signs look, like Facebook's going to kill it.
- 46:45But as of right now, Facebook has incredible transparency.
- 46:48Twitter has incredible transparency.
- 46:50YouTube is almost impossible to study as an outside researcher.
- 46:54Tick-Tock is almost impossible to say, he's outside researcher,
- 46:56and so, I think we're going to need to have mandated.
- 46:59Here. Because what's happened so far,
- 47:01is that the companies have opened up.
- 47:02Have had a huge amount of criticism and there's never any
- 47:04criticism the companies that have decided not to open up.
- 47:06And as long as that Dynamic continues to exist, I think
- 47:09we're going to have this lopsided coverage but also the
- 47:11inability to fix some of these problems.
- 47:13So guys, I'm sorry. I have the time out.
- 47:15My daughter, schools about to call her the rubble.
- 47:16So we're about 15 minutes so I can continue this conversation.
- 47:1815 minutes or we've got to wrap it up.
- 47:20I'm so I think we've gone long. Sure I give it like a little
- 47:23goodbye. See ya.
- 47:25Yes thanks so much for having me.
- 47:26All right. We're like what's a concluding
- 47:30Point earlier that's not to say? Well Alex I think we've all
- 47:32agreed that Facebook and the media companies are all the same
- 47:36that we all need to get in the same ship together and and and
- 47:39figure it all out. They're not all the same.
- 47:41I think what we have write my conclusion would be we have
- 47:45fundamental weaknesses in our media environment as well as
- 47:48like the psychology of Americans and we have to look at the big
- 47:51picture if we're going to understand or deal with any of
- 47:52these problems. Thank you so much for having me.
- 47:54I'll send you guys the recording.
- 47:55Sounds good, thank you. Thank you so much Alex.
- 47:57We really appreciate it. Goodbye,
- 48:09goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye,
- 48:12goodbye. Goodbye.