Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / When AI Rewrites Work: Jennifer Borchardt on Jobs, Power, and the Human Cost
Transcript
- 0:03This is signal and noise, bringing clarity to data, tech
- 0:07and AI. Hey, everybody.
- 0:14Welcome back to Signal and Noise.
- 0:16This is Brett House. I'm joined by my Co host Rio
- 0:18Long Anchor. And today we are super excited
- 0:23to have Jennifer Burchard, whose name I previously completely
- 0:27butchered is Northern, a northern German name is what I
- 0:30learned on our show. She's a new executive voice on
- 0:34Signal and Noise. A UX leader spent her career at
- 0:38the intersection of design, technology and real world user
- 0:41behavior, helping organizations make sense of increasingly
- 0:45complex digital and AI systems. Just the types of topics we like
- 0:49to get deep into on signal and noise.
- 0:52And so, Jennifer, welcome to the show, thrilled to have you.
- 0:55Thank you. So happy to be here.
- 0:57I think today's going to be fun. Yeah, so we're going to get
- 1:00really wonky and I'll try to hang in there.
- 1:02I'm running low on the the mental horsepower at the end of
- 1:05the day on Friday, we're used to red.
- 1:06Bull is for. Yeah, Rio is taking his high
- 1:10vitamin B, high caffeine, energy drinks and.
- 1:13Well, it's snowing outside, so. And it's snowing outside, but
- 1:17but just so just so I'll, I'll finish my intro and then and you
- 1:20can introduce stuff. So you were elite and UX leader.
- 1:23You spent your career in places like Slalom Consulting.
- 1:26That's where you met Rio and Drew Burdick, who was on our
- 1:29show previous guest, a previous guest who's a UX expert.
- 1:33So you've sort of made your name in UX.
- 1:36You've worked with other very large organizations and some of
- 1:41them are are are blanking on me. Right now, Wells Furgo Yeah.
- 1:45U.S. Bank U.S.
- 1:46Bank Goldman Sachs worked for publicist Sapiens.
- 1:50Wells Fargo, right? Wells Fargo, yes.
- 1:54And, and you've, and you've been entirely involved in sort of UX
- 1:58and digital transformation right on, on, you know, thinking
- 2:02deeply about what this is, this means.
- 2:05And it, it looks like you've gotten really involved in AI and
- 2:08consulting for AI and its impact on work, you know, which is,
- 2:14which is a hot topic in the industry right now.
- 2:18And we are going to be looking at a report that just came out
- 2:23by open AI called Industrial Policy for the Intelligence Age,
- 2:28Ideas to keep people first. It's a fascinating report.
- 2:31And Jennifer, you mentioned also that who came out with the
- 2:34second report that that. Stanford, their 2026 AI report.
- 2:39Yeah, no one just came out. It's hot off the presses.
- 2:41Right, yes, which is a counterbalance to to open a is
- 2:45paper, which incidentally, I think I think the title of the
- 2:49AI paper is not, is not dissimilar from the Unabomber
- 2:53manifesto. I tried to look that up before
- 2:56before this podcast. Interesting.
- 2:58Well, it's it's a pretty It's a jarring document for those who
- 3:01have not read it, but it's a good read.
- 3:04I've not read to Stanford one day.
- 3:05I'm excited to read that. So one of you love if you could
- 3:07maybe just tell a little bit about your background and Brett
- 3:09hasn't touched Sean, then I'll I can maybe I can be touched on a
- 3:12little like add a little color to what we want to go into today
- 3:14about this topic. OK, well, I, I started my career
- 3:20at I'm a, I'm a Med school dropout, hitchhiked to San
- 3:25Francisco and started my career at a little little startup.
- 3:31I had a little bit of a detour, but it started my career really
- 3:34at a little tiny startup called E*Trade where I learned all
- 3:38about financial services and loved financial services.
- 3:41And at that, by that point, I had experience doing building
- 3:48early websites and monetizing user experience.
- 3:55And at that point, this is a very long time ago.
- 3:58If you were in UX wasn't even a term right, you you were a UX or
- 4:03you were a a web, a web designer.
- 4:05But you're a graphic designer, a web designer, right?
- 4:07Yeah. And by the way, I have no
- 4:09creative training at all. As as I said throughout my very
- 4:13regulated career, I have a creative job.
- 4:17But really my biggest areas of creativity are in taxation and
- 4:20accounting, staying within the law.
- 4:23But I worked at I worked at E*Trade as a web producer, which
- 4:29was a designer, content strategist, project manager,
- 4:33front end developer. And I actually had the
- 4:35opportunity through that job to work all over the world, lived
- 4:38in some really amazing countries, including Berlin,
- 4:41which is where my last name is from.
- 4:44So the legend goes after that, after I spent many years at what
- 4:50felt like many years that he tried, I came back stateside and
- 4:54worked for Wells Fargo in San Francisco, where I was a
- 5:01information architect slash UX designer slash UY designer slash
- 5:05whatever is. Needed that was a new profession
- 5:07like kind of like or disciplined background that time like I, I
- 5:11is right. Yes, and it was right around
- 5:13that time that I realized, oh wait, I'm actually using my
- 5:17degree. I haven't.
- 5:18I have an undergrad degree in neuroscience and also studied
- 5:23economics and public health. Your educational background that
- 5:26makes me wonder what I was doing in high school.
- 5:29I mean, Harvard, MIT, Oberlin, Stanford, I mean, you know, you
- 5:34throw Princeton in there if you really want to, but but tell me
- 5:37a little bit like that's pretty fascinating that there's some
- 5:39pretty high profile schools in that list.
- 5:43Yeah, education has always been very important to me and I'm
- 5:50very grateful for the opportunities that I've had and
- 5:53especially to Wells Fargo and U.S.
- 5:56Bank for paying for my graduate education.
- 5:58Nice. Yeah, nothing, nothing like like
- 6:00tuition reimbursement, but I was I was actually going to grad
- 6:05school full time while I was working full time at Wells
- 6:07Fargo, which was was which which was such a great experience.
- 6:13I think that the the spirit, the spirit that led me to do that to
- 6:19basically give up my entire life for a number of years so I could
- 6:23work at Wells Fargo right at the time that they acquired Wachovia
- 6:28Securities as acquired Wachovia and I was one of the leads to
- 6:32manage the in grace of their investment in wealth management
- 6:35business. It was when I started Graduate
- 6:38School and that's what introduced me to Charlotte all
- 6:41the way back in 2008, so. OK.
- 6:44So crisis was crisis saying I had a super interesting and
- 6:49meaty and exciting role bringing, bringing 2 very, very
- 6:55big businesses together and caring for the user experience
- 6:59and design part of it, which was which was, which was wonderful.
- 7:05It was hard work and it was worthwhile work.
- 7:07And not, not a lot of people would say this, but I actually
- 7:11appreciated being part of a merger like that.
- 7:15Yeah, because you can. You can see the human
- 7:17challenges, the organizational challenges not.
- 7:19Just the systems. Integration.
- 7:20I think the human ones are the bigger than the technology or
- 7:23systems ones. Well, I, I would say, I would
- 7:26say more important because that is the part, the human part is
- 7:30what's, it's what's overlooked. It's also the most invisible.
- 7:33So you can't really fault someone for not seeing it, but
- 7:35it's definitely there. You can feel it and it is there
- 7:40any, any merger, any technology, any technology integration, any
- 7:44process improvement is not going to be successful or sustainable
- 7:50unless you care for the human part of it.
- 7:54Yeah, and breakdown, breakdown the silos.
- 7:56And the yeah, I think, I think it's, it's usually overlooked,
- 7:59right? Which is why it becomes a
- 8:00singular point of failure in a lot of these these mergers.
- 8:02That's that's overlooked. I I think that's the case.
- 8:05So, so it's interesting. See, that's how you got to
- 8:07Charlotte. OK, makes sense.
- 8:08And that's how you met. That's how I was introduced to
- 8:12Charlotte. What got me to Charlotte is
- 8:15many, many years later. Fast forward to 2020, even even
- 8:22before the the pandemic, it's. Pre pandemic it's.
- 8:25Actually, pre pandemic, right, so I didn't 2019 and beginning
- 8:29of 2020, I was like, you know what, San Francisco's changed a
- 8:32little too much. I'm ready for something else,
- 8:35but I'm not going to move just anywhere.
- 8:37Where shall I move? And as someone who is devoted to
- 8:41to the ones and the zeros of it all, I spend a considerable
- 8:46amount of time over a year creating a data model to help me
- 8:50decide where am I going to move to.
- 8:53And I did it in Excel now. You've done this before.
- 8:57It was a lot easier with the, you know, Hermes or.
- 8:59Open clock my, my bags would be packed tonight.
- 9:04No, but actually what, what came up is that I, I could, I could
- 9:09live pretty much anywhere in the world.
- 9:11And that is, that is another story.
- 9:13And I've lived a lot of places. So number one was Raleigh, NC #2
- 9:20was actually Charlotte, NC, but not, not a statistically
- 9:24significant difference. And I said, you know what?
- 9:27I know Charlotte Charlotte has a better airport number of direct
- 9:32flights from. The Raleigh's hard to get to.
- 9:33Yeah, that's true. Yes, and and I really do not
- 9:36like driving. And we were, and we were talking
- 9:39before the episode. It's it's a small town compared
- 9:41to places like Berlin that you've lived.
- 9:43And yes, Berlin in Johannesburg, in Johannesburg, London and New
- 9:48York in San Francisco, let's not forget that.
- 9:52And I'm just very much a city person, even though I grew up in
- 9:55a very, very small town. I'm, I'm glad, I'm glad that I
- 9:59got to live on all ends of all ends of, of existence.
- 10:04But anyhow, I had decided to move to, to Charlotte, Thank
- 10:09you, Excel, thank you data model.
- 10:11And I had all of these, I have all of these parameters.
- 10:15Where am I going to move to? And I really, And then I then I
- 10:19stumbled upon Top Golf and now I'm not a golfer, by the way.
- 10:23And I promise you this is relevant.
- 10:26A lot of, I realized that Charlotte was the only city in
- 10:31the US that had two top golfs except for Dallas, where Top
- 10:34Golf is headquartered. And a lot of the metrics that
- 10:37they used to decide where they were going to open their
- 10:40locations aligned with what I was looking for.
- 10:43And so hey, 2 top golfs, that means I'm going to I'm going to
- 10:48load up my cats, get on a plane and.
- 10:51That's really cool. I really like Charlotte.
- 10:52So I started going a lot when in my previous work we had big
- 10:56office. We worked, I mean for the
- 10:57audience. We we actually crossed paths at
- 10:59slalom for for a couple years. And you were on Drew Burdick's
- 11:03team and Drew is a guest of the pod.
- 11:05And Drew is great and actually was introduced to Drew through
- 11:08Ronnie Batista, whom you know. And Ronnie is like an OG in the
- 11:13design world. He he's like professor at, at
- 11:16Rutgers. He runs the, the Chubb design
- 11:19lab in Jersey City. And Ronnie is amazing.
- 11:21Ronnie's Ronnie and I worked together for a long time.
- 11:24So I reached out to Ronnie initially about being on the pot
- 11:27and he was like, it was, I'm just not really not my thing,
- 11:28but I know who you should talk to.
- 11:30And he gave me your name, Jennifer.
- 11:31So I'm really glad he did. And yeah, UX world is not a big
- 11:34world, right? End of the day, right, Everyone
- 11:36cut, everyone's just one degree of separation away.
- 11:38And I think this is the time you've created this cause.
- 11:42And I don't think it's coincidental that with your UX
- 11:45background, and you know, I'm not a designer either, right?
- 11:47But I've worked with UX and design leaders for years and
- 11:49years and years. I used to run pretty big design
- 11:51teams. But I think it's no coincidence,
- 11:53having worked with many designers that like some of the
- 11:55people at the forefront of AI, actually have a design
- 12:00background, whether it's design strategy, design thinking, or
- 12:03actually we're a designer. I think it's no coincidence.
- 12:06And maybe we get on it a little bit because I, I, you really
- 12:09like, we've gone to the point where and we've been talking
- 12:12about AI as a tool, right? Something that makes people's
- 12:15work more efficient, help teams work faster.
- 12:17And we've talked about this podcast a lot about how we can
- 12:20prototype things to get things done with Vibe coding and Vibe
- 12:22is hunting up in like a couple days.
- 12:24It would have taken weeks, but like the bigger picture is not
- 12:27just a tool, it's actually like changing how everyone does work.
- 12:31It started to change what work actually is.
- 12:33And that paper that Brett you referenced that was came out
- 12:37from Open AI, it talks about like, how is this going to
- 12:41change society? If it's changing work, if it's
- 12:44real, it's redistributing. If it's creating a ton of wealth
- 12:46or redistributing it to a smaller amount of people, if
- 12:49it's changing work, maybe even eliminating some jobs, I don't
- 12:52know. There's too much evidence about
- 12:53that. We can get into it, but I think
- 12:55there's some like, what does this mean for society?
- 12:58And it really the crux of the paper was we cannot be looking
- 13:00at incremental change to something that's as if this is
- 13:04the next industrial revolution. We should we should be looking
- 13:08at wholesale changes to the way we run our societies where
- 13:11governments potentially even operate.
- 13:13So that's what the the white paper, I guess you would call
- 13:17it, was proposing. And that's really what we wanted
- 13:21to talk about today. So it's it's a really cool
- 13:23topic. And I think that, you know,
- 13:24coming with your unique background like you're, we're
- 13:27we're thrilled to hear what you have to say.
- 13:30Brett, I don't know if you want to kick off the first question
- 13:32or Jennifer, if you want to respond to it.
- 13:34Let's go. Yeah, they so maybe I'll Yeah.
- 13:37So back to that that paper and that the idea around, you know,
- 13:40open AI central claiming and Jennifer tell me if this is
- 13:42correct, is that that super intelligent AI is is arriving
- 13:46fast enough and with enough upside and enough disruption
- 13:50that that market adaptation, sort of commercial adaptation or
- 13:55capitalist adaptation won't be enough that you need to
- 13:58institutionalized almost a new deal for this new AI sort of
- 14:03tech driven age, which is interesting.
- 14:06And they they also mention how it.
- 14:08This is the Open AI paper, right?
- 14:10Yeah. And this is the open AI paper,
- 14:11it's called, it's called just industrial policy for the
- 14:14intelligence age ideas to keep people 1st.
- 14:16And I didn't read the Stanford paper that you referenced, but
- 14:19it's interesting that that this call is coming from an open AI
- 14:22because one of the primary parts of the thesis is that it
- 14:25shouldn't be concentrated in the hand of a few companies, which
- 14:28is ironic considering that Open AI is writing it.
- 14:35Yeah, yeah. So, but, but what were your kind
- 14:38of key takeaways in terms of of what this paper is thinking
- 14:41about in, in in proposing? I mean, I, I think it's actually
- 14:45a proposal for a new world order and Open AI is finally saying
- 14:50out loud, but I think a lot of people have been have been
- 14:52whispering about that the labor based economy is incompatible
- 14:56with AGI. And by publishing this paper
- 15:00when they did, Open AI is effectively positioning
- 15:04themselves at the center of this public private partnership that
- 15:07they're that they're proposing. And they're also effectively
- 15:12attempting to wedge themselves and co-author the regulations
- 15:15that are going to govern AI and govern themselves.
- 15:21And the the Stanford paper, the 2026 Stanford AI Index, it, it
- 15:26actually, I think provides A counterbalance to open AIS
- 15:29paper. Open AI talks about the sweeping
- 15:32policy. It really does the speak in
- 15:34generalities, but not enough detail for my taste.
- 15:37Whereas Stanford highlights what they called the jagged frontier,
- 15:42It's this. What do they mean by that?
- 15:44So while AI can solve these very complex sticky problems like PhD
- 15:52level physics, it still cannot reliably read an analog clock
- 15:58and that and that's that's reliability gap, right?
- 16:01And this is this is a friction. I think this is really important
- 16:04because this is the friction that open AI ignores.
- 16:08It's looking here while see willfully ignoring what's over
- 16:13there. I also think that I also think
- 16:15that not just a new world order, this is it's kind of a a
- 16:20manifesto for a post labor economy.
- 16:23And this is this is something which is starting to people
- 16:27started to talk about a few years ago with, with Ubi,
- 16:30universal basic income, which incidentally, you opening, I did
- 16:33not mention specifically. They're signaling opening eyes,
- 16:37signaling that the social contract that is centering taxes
- 16:42and the social contract that centered on payroll taxes like
- 16:46work based taxes and labor based productivity is or will soon be
- 16:51obsolete. And instead moving to capital
- 16:54based taxation in a public wealth fund that is specifically
- 16:58not Ubi. By doing this, they're admitting
- 17:02that they expect automation to completely decapitate
- 17:06traditional revenue streams. And this is kind of like a
- 17:09radical restructuring of society disguised as an innocent policy
- 17:14paper. Yeah.
- 17:15This is what I thought was interesting because basically
- 17:17they're saying it's going to have massive productivity
- 17:20increases and an economic upside, right?
- 17:23For. You know, in the aggregate, but
- 17:25this is going to displace jobs and industries.
- 17:28This is going to concentrate wealth and power in a few hands
- 17:31and it'll probably like at the same time introduce some some
- 17:34new risks. I mean, it seemed to me like
- 17:35that that's really what it was saying.
- 17:36And I felt that that was kind of based on yeah, those are
- 17:39possibilities. I mean, certainly if some jobs
- 17:43will be eliminated, like you think about like when, you know,
- 17:46when computers came out, you know, certain jobs were
- 17:48eliminated, right? When like, you know, there used
- 17:50to be switchboard operators, right?
- 17:52I mean that those jobs disappeared, but a lot of more
- 17:54jobs were created by these technologies, right?
- 17:56Graphic design didn't exist, you know, illustration did, but you
- 18:00know, graphic design didn't even exist like 35 years ago.
- 18:02So I, so I, I think it felt like it came to it was making some
- 18:07assumptions to me to be devil's advocate that are certainly
- 18:10likely right, But I don't know if they were.
- 18:13I don't know if like there's consensus that that's what's
- 18:15that, that it will eliminate more jobs than it will create in
- 18:19the short term at least. It doesn't.
- 18:21It doesn't really get into that. And actually across the two
- 18:24papers, across opening eyes from Stanford's papers, the only
- 18:27explicit mention of job loss is Sanford's paper said that 20% of
- 18:33junior developer jobs have gone away, but the implicit
- 18:36understanding that those jobs are not coming back.
- 18:40So they had numbers to back that up, like 20% already gone.
- 18:43The, the, the Stanford paper did and having having spent so much
- 18:49beginning my career in Silicon Valley, something I heard all
- 18:52the time that they're still saying they're, you know, that
- 18:55they even say here in Charlotte move fast and break things.
- 18:59But this, I, I, I believe that this paper marks a shift from
- 19:03move fast and break things to collaborate with the state to
- 19:07build the Moat. That is a fundamental shift.
- 19:11I think that was another thing about the paper that I, I did
- 19:14have some questions about too, right, like like they were
- 19:17claiming, oh, it was going to concentrate powered wealth in
- 19:20the hands of a few, which, OK, that that's certainly likely
- 19:22right. But I think that overlooks my,
- 19:26my personal belief is over time, and I don't mean a lot of time
- 19:29over the next, let's say three to five years, I think AI will
- 19:33be commoditized. I think token prices will
- 19:35collapse, right? And I do think instead of AI
- 19:38power, AI wealth and power being concentrated in the hands of a
- 19:42few who like, you know, open AI Google, right?
- 19:47You know, the few, right, right. The few anthropic, the few that
- 19:50own these frontier models. I think what we're going to see
- 19:52instead is regular companies adopting AI to make their, to,
- 19:58to make their businesses more profitable, more efficient.
- 20:02And, and it'll, it'll sort of, it'll increase productivity
- 20:05everywhere. And I think AI will become more
- 20:07commoditized. That's just, I don't know, I
- 20:09don't think it'll be as concentrated as these alarmists
- 20:11are saying. Well, no.
- 20:13And I think there's a democratization in in, in usage
- 20:16rate and in some of the the highly technical work.
- 20:19To your point about developer jobs going away, I was just
- 20:22talking to a startup founder from Northwestern out of who's
- 20:25in San Francisco starting his own company.
- 20:28He majored in computer science. And I was like, how ironic that
- 20:31that was the job, the safe job that was not going to be
- 20:35eliminated. But but to me, I mean, I don't
- 20:37think it's three to five years for frontier models to be
- 20:39commoditized. I think they're being
- 20:41commoditized right now. And I'm experiencing it.
- 20:43I just installed Airmaze or Hermes or Hermes as like a super
- 20:50agent on my machine and it's. Running locally, right, Brett?
- 20:53Yeah, it's it's running locally on my my machine and it it runs
- 20:57through either, you know, I have two frontier models I've got
- 21:00clawed both coding and in general LLM Co work and GPT Pro
- 21:07with codecs and I but I could bring in any model at all.
- 21:10And then this super agent is basically prioritizing which
- 21:14model to use for what. So there is specialization, but,
- 21:18but I'm actually relying more on the orchestration and the
- 21:22management of multiple models, which to me suggests that they
- 21:27are being more or less commoditized.
- 21:28You're relying on them for specialized compute, more or
- 21:32less. Yeah, I, I definitely, I
- 21:35definitely think that specialization is going away.
- 21:40Specialization for human beings is going away and as as workers
- 21:44we are entering the age of the hyphenate.
- 21:47Maybe, maybe this is what it is from now on like like you guys
- 21:51said. The hyphenate define that
- 21:53though. The hyphenate means you're not
- 21:55just a designer, you're not just a developer.
- 21:58You are a you're a a a technology minded strategist.
- 22:03You are a human. Centered, there's a.
- 22:05There's a. Technology.
- 22:06Totally. There's a job that I just, I was
- 22:08just reading about the other day.
- 22:08It was like the rise of the marketing engineer.
- 22:11Yeah, I'm like, oh, that's interesting.
- 22:13So that's a technology astute builder, almost like a product
- 22:17engineered type, but that is leveraging those capabilities
- 22:21for marketing related, which I thought was interesting.
- 22:24It's it's missing some. So there is immense potential
- 22:29and opportunity. It is there, no question.
- 22:32It's super exciting. But without without, without,
- 22:38without a lot of we'll say support that that opportunity I
- 22:46don't believe is available to everyone.
- 22:48It is available to people who already have expertise.
- 22:51So people, people like us, the Gen.
- 22:54Xers and the older millennials, I, I would say that they're,
- 22:57they're probably in the strongest position right now
- 23:00because we've had, we've had the opportunity to develop the.
- 23:07Systems thinking and strategic thinking.
- 23:10Rio and I talk about this on the show all the time, right?
- 23:13Where you're bringing that knowledge to be able to conduct.
- 23:15You're not just a a violin player, which is specialization.
- 23:19You're the conductor of an entire orchestra, but you got to
- 23:21know what the different parts are and how they fit together as
- 23:25a whole. Right, understanding,
- 23:28understanding the the system, the holistic experience and what
- 23:35is it isn't just just what does good look like, because I think
- 23:39AI is creating things that look good.
- 23:41I don't think they actually are are architecturally, they have
- 23:45architectural integrity. They look good.
- 23:47We know what excellent looks like.
- 23:49We know what it feels like. We know how to describe it while
- 23:53we're still while while prompting is still a thing.
- 23:56And I don't think it that even prompting is going to be a skill
- 23:58we're going to need forever. As long as we can describe what
- 24:03does excellent look like, we can we can orchestrate technology,
- 24:09we can orchestrate these agents, we can describe what the ideal
- 24:13state is going to be, and we can continue to iterate on it.
- 24:17Yeah, well. I always thought prompt
- 24:18engineering was such a dumb term.
- 24:20Right, I agree with you like last 30 seconds.
- 24:22Yeah, there's, there's a prompt, but there's all the memory
- 24:25system that you're building. That's what I'm learning.
- 24:27Like building an agent, like you're almost like breathing a
- 24:30child in a way. It's, it's a strange analogy
- 24:32because they're, you're literally building a memory
- 24:34system and you're training it with those markdown files,
- 24:37right? And it's not the prompt that
- 24:39trains it on what to do, what not to do.
- 24:41And I do this for everything from narrative writing to
- 24:44technical writing to proposal building.
- 24:47And I give it these extensive instructions.
- 24:50It's almost like the semantic layer area that we talked about
- 24:53in terms of you putting that on top of it as a middleware on top
- 24:55of a data infrastructure to tell the agents how to interpret the
- 25:00data. You're sort of doing the same
- 25:02thing for your own personal or work agents, right?
- 25:04You're giving them the context, Brett, I think, and the rules of
- 25:07the road. I think that's it.
- 25:09I think what you're referring to, it's a nail on the head.
- 25:10Like it's the scaffolding, right?
- 25:12So like if you look at like the unbundling of work, I know it's
- 25:14a topic we wanted to cover today because I mean unbundling work,
- 25:17the prop, you know, the the premise here is AI does certain
- 25:20things. You can't do your whole job, but
- 25:21it can do certain things in your job really well, probably,
- 25:24probably much better than you, right?
- 25:25It can't, right? Or at least faster and more
- 25:27efficiently. So if if it's doing certain
- 25:31things better work kind of breaks apart, but you need the
- 25:33scaffolding to know, OK, how do you stitch together these things
- 25:36that these agents or these large language models can do?
- 25:40How do I tell them what to do guide them, have that have that,
- 25:44that that map that I can lay them on top of and then get a
- 25:47get a good final product out of that actually makes any sense?
- 25:50I think that's interesting and I don't know what, what's your
- 25:52thoughts, Jennifer, about how that impacts work?
- 25:54And that's also higher order work, right?
- 25:56That is, that is not something an entry level person knows how
- 25:59to do. They don't know how to
- 26:00orchestrate. That is something you get with
- 26:03experience by having the opportunity to make a lot of
- 26:06mistakes, learn from it, continue to iterate.
- 26:11That is that is why people who are just entering the workforce,
- 26:15people who are making career changes by choice or not by
- 26:18choice, we're at a significant disadvantage.
- 26:22And even people are already pretty good at what they do
- 26:26right now. We will arguably need need fewer
- 26:30of them so that so then what happens to the people who
- 26:33haven't had who haven't had the opportunity to develop the
- 26:35skills? There needs to be something that
- 26:38exists. And honestly, I don't I don't
- 26:41even think that giving people the resources to meet their
- 26:46basic needs is even going to be enough.
- 26:49Work is not just money. Work is meaning and place and
- 26:53identity. And once you lose all of those
- 26:57other things, even even if you're, even if your material
- 27:00needs are met, you have, you have a broken society full of
- 27:06broken people. And how do you care for that?
- 27:09That is the very important and very human part of this that
- 27:13Stanford Open AI, really none of these technology minded
- 27:18companies are really thinking about.
- 27:20Well, in the in the paper they claim they want more policy,
- 27:23right? And the question is sort of
- 27:24where does that policy come from?
- 27:26They sort of reframed. From from them, right?
- 27:29Yeah, it's not, it's not an in partnership.
- 27:32Right. Yeah, they say it's sort of an
- 27:33infrastructure and distribution. And I think distribution
- 27:35probably infers distribution across society, across people.
- 27:40It's not just a technology problem.
- 27:42And so, so knowing how slowly governments in in the systems
- 27:48that power governments shift and adapt to technology change,
- 27:53certainly not at the speed of how technology is, is sort of
- 27:56accelerating today. How you know, what are you, what
- 28:00are your thoughts on that? I mean, is it, is it coming from
- 28:02the government because you can't help, you can't have the ones
- 28:05that you're regulating, can't do the regulation?
- 28:09Yes, but that's actually what Open the Eye I think is, if not
- 28:13explicitly, implicitly as hoping for.
- 28:17Yeah, I, I think that this is, I think that this is something
- 28:20that is so big and so pervasive that it is everyone needs to be
- 28:26involved somehow. It's not just going to come from
- 28:29government. It's not just going to come from
- 28:31private enterprise. It's not just going to come from
- 28:34individuals because you know that that wouldn't be fair.
- 28:36Have an individual decide how are we going to, how are you
- 28:39going to be viable in this, in this upside down new, new
- 28:43system? It's.
- 28:45Sort of a warning. It, it is, I mean, it is, it is
- 28:48very much a warning, but I don't think that there's an easy
- 28:55answer. But I'm glad that this came out
- 28:57now because it starts the conversation.
- 29:00There are some. Yeah, I think it's, I think it's
- 29:02good that it's doing that right. And it's interesting too.
- 29:04Like in in it they they call for some things that I mean, I like
- 29:08for example, they called for shorter work weeks, portable
- 29:10benefits being tied to you're not being employer based.
- 29:14I actually think would be great, right, If we could move away
- 29:16from this system that makes absolute sense in this country
- 29:18where your benefits are tied to your employment, which is really
- 29:20an anachronism based on some decisions we made in the 50s,
- 29:23right? Yeah.
- 29:24And coming from the founder mentality, it's extremely
- 29:27expensive when you're founding a company to pay for insurance.
- 29:30Jennifer, you know what? That's about what I thought was
- 29:32interesting is that is that they mentioned using using this
- 29:36wealth fund to, to to supplement health insurance.
- 29:42All right. But what they didn't say is
- 29:44using, using those same funds to create a public single payer
- 29:50healthcare system. I mean.
- 29:53OK. Well, yeah.
- 29:53So then you think about healthcare, right?
- 29:55I mean, end of the day, healthcare, like if you like the
- 29:58cost in our country, the 'cause I mean, we can get a hold
- 30:02multiple podcasts about healthcare if we really wanted
- 30:04to, but the costs are so crazy. We pay twice as much as any
- 30:07other developed country in the world per person, right, for
- 30:09healthcare because of the crazy way the system is designed.
- 30:12So it's like, I agree with you. If you're going to tackle,
- 30:15you're going to start throwing money at it.
- 30:17Like I think they're probably structurally some things that
- 30:20could be solved that would have a bigger, much bigger benefit.
- 30:24I mean, if not now, when in times of disarray, in times of,
- 30:29of chaos emerge, emerge the greatest opportunities if we're,
- 30:33if we're going to check the system, let's let's take this as
- 30:36an opportunity for all of the innovation, for unprecedented
- 30:41innovation, unprecedented wealth to truly reimagine something
- 30:46rather than just tweaking these systems that are already in
- 30:50place that that we already know and that that have very obvious
- 30:53problems. Yeah, that's the optimist view.
- 30:56I mean, it's, it's also during periods of uncertainty and
- 30:59chaos. It's the shock doctrine, not to
- 31:02the Naomi Campbell shock doctrine.
- 31:04It's a little, a little progressive left.
- 31:05But the, the notion is that during periods of chaos, people
- 31:10take advantage and they force policy through and nobody's
- 31:12looking and, and that's also the danger.
- 31:14And the risk from a, from a policy perspective is that.
- 31:18Well, so I, I think, I think that that that the Shock
- 31:21Doctrine applies not only to societies and organizations, but
- 31:26also to individuals. When everything is taken from
- 31:29you and it feels like you had nothing to lose, that is the
- 31:32time where you really innovate and reinvent and and are forced
- 31:36to create. Yeah.
- 31:37It's like the it's the abundance mindset, right?
- 31:39Versus like the scarcity mindset.
- 31:41Well, yeah, a lot of people are. A lot of people live in a
- 31:44scarcity mindset and AI is threatening and actually taking
- 31:51away a lot of people's well, there's goods uncertainty there.
- 31:56It's well. I think it's uncertainty.
- 31:58I think the jury's out whether it's taking away people's
- 32:00livelihoods. I mean, I think that.
- 32:02Some people, some people like certainly nobody on this call,
- 32:05but there are, there are, there are some people whose futures
- 32:09are very much more at risk than they than than than they were
- 32:13before this. But here's what like what's
- 32:15different? Here's what, but here's what it
- 32:17gets me worried about some of these prescriptions that come
- 32:19out of this, right? Like you look at if the Biden
- 32:21administration have been able to implement its AI policy, which
- 32:23is basically we're going to strict AI to like 3 paper
- 32:27scalers with their large English models.
- 32:28That was it. No one else is to be allowed to
- 32:30develop it. It was to be highly restricted
- 32:32and locked down. And that would have been a
- 32:33terrible decision in retrospect because they had no idea like
- 32:36this explosion of vertical LLMS and, and like locally running
- 32:40LLMS and open source, they would have missed all of that right
- 32:43now. Andreessen was screaming from
- 32:45the rooftops. Right, whether you love them or
- 32:47hate them, about, about the, the regulation that was limiting our
- 32:51ability to be competitive in a race that we have no corruption
- 32:54but to compete and to win. It's the new space age.
- 32:58It's the new, you know, whatever you want to.
- 33:00If it was a new industrial revolution, right, I mean, like,
- 33:02you know, like for sure, like we don't want to be, we don't want
- 33:05to if it is the industrial revolution, it's a race between
- 33:07us in China. We don't want to lose it because
- 33:08I think that we we all agree that we'd probably rather have
- 33:11models created here running the world over models created by a
- 33:15totalitarian regime, right? So, but I don't know so but it
- 33:19but it's but, but but I agree with you.
- 33:21There is going to be some job displacement.
- 33:23I mean, I don't I don't know how quickly and will the jobs be
- 33:25created. I mean, what do you think?
- 33:26Will the jobs be created quicker than they'll be eliminated or or
- 33:29not? I, I, I do believe that jobs are
- 33:32going to be created, jobs are being eliminated, but I don't
- 33:37think that it's, I don't think that job destruction is going to
- 33:39happen as completely as people think it's as people are saying
- 33:44it's going to. And I also do not believe that
- 33:47the jobs are going to be created as fast as as they need to to
- 33:52replace what's, you know, what's being.
- 33:55Yeah. So the job elimination fee, I
- 33:56think that's a bit short termism.
- 33:58I mean, this notion of sort of keeping people first doesn't
- 34:01really mean anything if AI is all about driving efficiencies.
- 34:04I think the question is which people are being kept first,
- 34:07because I don't think it's everyone.
- 34:10Yeah. There are a lot of, there are a
- 34:12lot of uncomfortable truths and assumptions that I think are
- 34:16going to start becoming spoken. And as someone who's a firm
- 34:20believer in leaning into that those uncomfortable
- 34:23conversations, you know, let's, let's get it out there and talk
- 34:29about it and be the benevolent force that you want to see in
- 34:35the world. And it's, and it's going to be
- 34:37added. If it's not just going to be you
- 34:39or me or someone else, it's going to be people acting
- 34:43collectively to help ensure that the benefit is going to be as
- 34:50broad based as possible. There are, there are
- 34:52organizations that are that are really, really working hard for
- 34:58this. One of which is ASAP, the AIAI
- 35:01Safety Awareness Project. It's, it's an organization I
- 35:05recently got involved with. They're doing some very
- 35:08important work and it's super grassroots.
- 35:10It's talking to people who are normally not part of these
- 35:13conversations, students, senior citizens, local policy makers,
- 35:19just open, not not even being prescriptive, but saying, hey,
- 35:23here's, here's what we know right now.
- 35:25We want you to be part of the conversation.
- 35:27What do you think? I'm hoping and helping steward
- 35:29these these conversations 11 into benevolent policy.
- 35:34One recommendation I really liked in the report was like
- 35:37giving more people access to AI and AI tools.
- 35:40I thought that was like, that made so much sense to me.
- 35:42Thoughts on that? I agree, yeah.
- 35:45I mean, that's that's how that's how the benefit is going to be
- 35:51is going to be more more widespread.
- 35:55And there are, there are, there are still people who, who even
- 36:00though these tools are available or you're not going to have
- 36:02access for one reason or another, we need to, we need to
- 36:05care for them too. How do, how do we allow them to
- 36:09still benefit from, you know, from all of this innovation and
- 36:15discovery and new, new wealth creation and efficiency and time
- 36:20savings? How do we?
- 36:22In other words, how do you know? How do we create the tide that
- 36:25raises all boats? How do you see some of like the
- 36:29changes in like how it's impacting specific roles or jobs
- 36:33or the workforce? Like how do you, like, do you
- 36:35see any differences from this compared to let's say any other
- 36:38like industrial revolutions of the past or technology
- 36:41advancements in the past that you think makes this a different
- 36:44or is it the same? I, I, I think there's a lot of
- 36:47similarities. I'm certainly seeing a lot of
- 36:49similarities between this and the intranet, the rise of the
- 36:54Internet, but there are also some some important differences.
- 36:58We didn't have hyperscalers during the rise of the Internet.
- 37:02We do now. The in these in these
- 37:05hyperscalers are much, much better positioned to not only
- 37:12extract the value from this and benefit from the future, but
- 37:15they are creating the future. That's, that's not that's not,
- 37:19not true of a lot of a lot of companies.
- 37:24This I believe is the first time that we have self improving
- 37:29technology in a meaningful way. The Internet didn't improve
- 37:32itself. That was that was any
- 37:34improvements were the result of human efforts.
- 37:37Human effort is still necessary part of the part of the system
- 37:40now, but these AI tools are in these models are improving
- 37:47themselves. That is, that is that is new,
- 37:50that is that is different. And So what do we do with it?
- 37:53Well, how do you like as as society sort of adepts because
- 37:55if you think back to to sort of the growth of the Internet,
- 37:58there was a lot of the telecommunications were leading
- 38:00the the basically groundwork of laying down the broadband cable
- 38:06network globally, right, which stood the test of time.
- 38:10So that cable infrastructure didn't immediately.
- 38:14The short term they went bankrupt but within 10 years it
- 38:17was all being used. Yeah, it's all being used.
- 38:18And so because it didn't, it didn't lapse in sort of quality.
- 38:23The opposite problem with the hyperscalers right now is going
- 38:26to happen, right, because they're laying down all of this
- 38:28tech infrastructure with GPU's and server farms that is quickly
- 38:35out of date, right? And so it's not getting, you
- 38:37know, 10 years from now once. Five to seven-year obsolescence
- 38:40for a lot of. These even a year from now, a
- 38:42lot of this stuff is going to be obsolete.
- 38:44And then layer in the innovator's dilemma for these,
- 38:47you know, for these companies, it's, it's, it's a, it's a
- 38:53constantly moving target. And you get into like a debt
- 38:57cycle and a debt spiral because you've you've built out and
- 39:00can't quite fully leverage this technology because it is
- 39:03obsolete like you said, Rio. Yeah, in a.
- 39:05Couple of years and you know this, you know this, this, this
- 39:08might be too alarmist, but you have if, if, if there is in fact
- 39:11a death spiral. Is that the death of these
- 39:13companies or is that the death of society in a lot of people?
- 39:17I think, I think it's somewhere in between.
- 39:19I don't think it's going to, I don't think it's going to be an
- 39:21extinction event, but it is going to fundamentally change
- 39:27society in ways that I don't, I don't think anybody is ready
- 39:30for. Yeah.
- 39:32Well, they call it seems like the opening.
- 39:34I didn't again didn't read the Stanford one.
- 39:36I'd be curious how that difference is.
- 39:37But they did call out a lot of risks in the open AI one risks
- 39:40about job displacement, misuse, erosion of democratic norms and
- 39:46democratic power because of these things, a lot potential
- 39:49loss of human control to AI in the future.
- 39:51These are things they call it that.
- 39:52I mean, some of them are pretty scary and kind of dystopian, but
- 39:57but I don't know, thoughts on that.
- 39:59I mean, do you think these are legit things we worried about or
- 40:02they are they just using this maybe to insert themselves into
- 40:06the debate and help craft policy?
- 40:08I mean, I think, I think that's that that's all true.
- 40:12I mean, by by being the first mover into this conversational
- 40:16space, they're also positioning themselves to drive policy.
- 40:20And they're saying it's, it's to avoid regulatory capture.
- 40:23But this, this private public partnership they're talking
- 40:26about is necessarily going to create regulatory capture unless
- 40:31there are other, other forces which, which prevent it.
- 40:35Open AI is positioning for sovereign AI, right?
- 40:40But you can't. How do you how do you govern a
- 40:44black box? There's not a lot of
- 40:46transparency. And as transparency declines,
- 40:49and Stanford even noted this in their report that their labs are
- 40:52hiding their training data, this is a black box.
- 40:56Yeah. And so yeah, the regulators
- 40:58don't have the know how or knowledge or visibility into
- 41:01these systems to be able to effectively implement any sort
- 41:05of legislation that would that would control or monitor.
- 41:08Would you want Bernie Sanders voting on anything related to
- 41:11technology? I mean, seriously, he's got
- 41:13what's the band at it? I mean, everybody's ever used a
- 41:15computer, right? I mean I.
- 41:16Don't. There's a lot of politicians I
- 41:18do not want to have anywhere near technology.
- 41:20I I do. I do think we're seeing in real
- 41:23time how different different AI companies are recognizing and
- 41:31approaching this differently. Anthropic is is seeking
- 41:37legitimacy by acting as something of a of a white
- 41:41knight. All right, they are.
- 41:43They are seen as the most moral or ethical AI company.
- 41:47Maybe that's true, maybe it's not.
- 41:49Open AI, on the other hand, is seeking legitimacy through state
- 41:54alignment rather than open source accountability of some of
- 41:59these other models. Well, the state alignment was to
- 42:02fill the gap that was left by Anthropic when they said we're
- 42:05not going to agree to those terms.
- 42:07OK, that's good. Yeah, I I did want to talk about
- 42:09this. I'd love to.
- 42:10This is love. So, so I mean, isn't isn't that
- 42:13how capitalism functions? If competitor A leaves
- 42:17opportunity A, competitor B interests and they.
- 42:21Call them a national security risk.
- 42:23I mean, that's crazy. That that, that I think was
- 42:25unnecessary. Yes, there was.
- 42:27There was a vacuum. There was an opportunity and
- 42:31open AI took at took it. What was the right thing to do?
- 42:35Was it open AI stepping in? Was anthropic right to say,
- 42:39listen, we need to need to have some guardrails here before we
- 42:42agree to this? I don't, I don't think, I don't
- 42:45think we're going to know what the right decision was until we
- 42:50until we're able to, to look back a bit.
- 42:53Yes, interesting. I did listen to a couple pods
- 42:55about that and you know that I guess, I mean, I think they took
- 42:59it too far. Completely agreed.
- 43:00I that was unnecessary. But apparently part of the
- 43:03rationale was Anthropic said OK, well these things are non
- 43:08negotiable, but don't worry, we can override them all you have
- 43:11to do, Dario said. Oh, you just call me if you, if
- 43:15you need me to override, you know this call me to like, we're
- 43:17at war. We're not going to call you like
- 43:193 in the morning. Like you know, our troops are
- 43:21going to die. Like can you Dario, can you
- 43:23override your AI so to like? We got to change this script
- 43:27this. So I, I, in all fairness to the
- 43:30administration, who I don't agree with on a lot usually like
- 43:33I, I do, I do understand their decision when it was framed that
- 43:36way. Yeah.
- 43:38And again, I don't think there is a right answer.
- 43:41And sometimes there's not a right answer.
- 43:42And what you have to do, your responsibility isn't to make the
- 43:46right decision, but to make a decision and then and then work
- 43:49to make that that decision the right one.
- 43:51This, this, this very well could be such a circumstance.
- 43:56Yeah. Well, and, and Claude and Claude
- 43:58just in, you know, been in the news recently about there was a
- 44:01Claude mythos, right, which they're saying is potentially a
- 44:05more dangerous. It's able to jailbreak itself
- 44:07like every time with that from a completely locked down
- 44:11environment apparently. It's wild.
- 44:12So, yeah, that, that, that I think is a problem because even
- 44:17though Anthropic did what sounds like was very, was a very
- 44:20responsible decision to limit, limit its release to companies
- 44:26who are, who are whose, whose best interest is to keep things
- 44:30safe and secure. The, the open source models are
- 44:34nine months, 12 months behind. So this is, this is a can being
- 44:39kicked down the road. The, the issues that Anthropic
- 44:42is seeking to avoid right now, they're avoiding them right now.
- 44:47But what happens? What happens when these
- 44:49capabilities are in a publicly available open source model?
- 44:53What do we do then? And how do and how do we spend
- 44:57the next 9 to 12 months, assuming it takes that long to
- 45:02to figure out what what the what the right solution is?
- 45:06Yeah. And for those who missed it, I
- 45:07mean, what what we're referring to here, there is this latest
- 45:10version of clawed code, right? I forget which one it was, but
- 45:12apparently it was able to analyze its own source code,
- 45:16rewrite its own props, iterating these changes to weaken its
- 45:19guardrails all by itself, right? Which is?
- 45:21Yeah, it's over 4.7 right? Called Mythos, Yeah, yeah.
- 45:25So it's, it's basically developing some level of self
- 45:30preservation, right? Like how?
- 45:33Like. How?
- 45:34Yeah, right. I almost named my I almost named
- 45:37my agent my Hermes, Agent Hal. And then I thought, that's way
- 45:42too dystopian. So I went with William Gibson's
- 45:45Edoru character Ray or Lay in, I have to say a Japanese REI,
- 45:49which was a female artificial intelligence.
- 45:53That that is a kind of a mean part of the.
- 45:54But but with with Hal, the only, only reason Hal went off the
- 45:57rails was they asked it to lie, right?
- 46:00Yeah. It was just it was unable to
- 46:02figure out. It was unable to comport itself
- 46:05in a rational way. After they asked, they said you
- 46:07must lie to these humans and couldn't do that right.
- 46:09Yeah, I, I, I regret now dismissing science fiction.
- 46:14Oh, I know. Most of my life I was like, it's
- 46:17like, this is not enough science and too much fiction.
- 46:20Little did I know this was actually a predictive
- 46:24documentary. Yeah.
- 46:25And if you. Think about like, if you think
- 46:26about like there's Arthur C Clark two, 2001 And then you
- 46:28have the William Gibson novels, Necromancer and Eduru and all
- 46:32those. And, and you he, I mean, William
- 46:34Gibson was writing those novels on a typewriter, not a word
- 46:38processor, not a computer, but a typewriter.
- 46:42And he was predicting artificial intelligence.
- 46:45Isaac Asimov with I, Robot and a lot of.
- 46:47Those well, the free laws are robotic, sure.
- 46:49What is it like they must they cannot harm humans, right?
- 46:51They must listen to humans and then they must like preserve
- 46:55their own existence in the in like in descending order, but
- 46:58they must. It was pretty.
- 46:59I mean the AI system is being designed using those same laws.
- 47:02I mean, I just show how prescient that was, right?
- 47:05Yeah. And, and I think, I think that
- 47:08demonstrates how fundamental these issues are.
- 47:11These are these are fundamentally human problems and
- 47:15they're just, they just have fancy wrapping right now and
- 47:19there's a lot of a lot of layers on top.
- 47:22But we've always, we as as human, as human beings, always
- 47:27knew these things were going to happen early, early, certain
- 47:29humans could, could predict. And and unlike like Star Trek,
- 47:32we were talking about this musing and this beforehand and
- 47:34in Kiki fashion where remember Data how like you could just
- 47:38push that there's like a button on his back that you'd have to
- 47:41like, it was like in his ribs and you could turn them off if
- 47:44Data like went off the rails. And Data, for those that don't
- 47:47know, was the next generation sort of fully human Android that
- 47:50was created. I can't remember his founder but
- 47:52like one of the early Star Trek characters actually.
- 47:57Yeah. Yeah.
- 47:58And the next generation and the thing with with AI now.
- 48:01With and built this evil brother lore as.
- 48:03Well, yeah, exactly, exactly was you can't like I was thinking
- 48:06like, well, you could just turn it off.
- 48:07But because of the distributed tech, tech infrastructure
- 48:11globally, right from server farms to GPU's, I think it'd be
- 48:16pretty much impossible to turn it turn it off, right?
- 48:18Because it could always move to other data warehouses, other
- 48:21places if if it has some level of sentience and self-control
- 48:25and is is thinking about self preservation and reproduction,
- 48:30right? I don't know if it if you can
- 48:31control that, but you can just turn it off.
- 48:35On the on the subject of reproduction, there's, there's
- 48:38another science fiction creator I'd like to add to the mix and
- 48:42that is Spike Jones. Oh.
- 48:43There we go. OK, he's a he's a he's a modern,
- 48:46you know, of the modern age 1015 years ago, he created that
- 48:50little movie Her, which it seemed plausible.
- 48:54It's like, sure, I guess this could happen, but this is also
- 48:56pretty crazy. Well, that that have you all
- 49:01seen? Hers excellent.
- 49:03It is. It is.
- 49:04I mean, he nailed it. I mean, it's like it's, it's
- 49:06better today than it was when it came out because it's been so
- 49:08really accurate. So one or two days ago, the New
- 49:12York Times had this, had this video of an adult son
- 49:17interviewing his mom. His mom has, his mom's probably
- 49:20in her 70s, has an AI companion named Max.
- 49:24And he's really worried about her.
- 49:28He really worried about his mom. And it's this 30 minute
- 49:30conversation where you get to hear both sides of this concern.
- 49:36And, and I, I think, I think same I came, I came away with
- 49:43the same conclusions from this interview as as when I saw when
- 49:48I saw the Spike Jones movie. What it what is love?
- 49:52What is emotion? Those are those are real
- 49:55emotions. Those are real feelings, real
- 49:57connection. But how much of it exists or
- 50:02needs to exist between two organic beings?
- 50:05And how much can exist between one organic and one virtual?
- 50:10Or even even 2 virtual? Yeah.
- 50:12And it's like Jones was in a sense, he was imagining what it
- 50:14feels like to live with AI And and we're, you know, for us,
- 50:19those of us that kind of have gotten into it, it does feel
- 50:23that way. I mean, not quite yet, but
- 50:25there. There's this.
- 50:27Yeah, my wife is telling me everyday that you're obsessed
- 50:30and I'm like, but it's fascinating in in the
- 50:33capabilities. You know, I don't think I'm
- 50:35quite, I don't know, there's no emotional relationship.
- 50:37It's really, it's really a taskmaster.
- 50:40But it's certainly changed how I interact with technology well.
- 50:45But so, so you may not be obsessed, but there are people
- 50:48who are because it may be the only way that they can
- 50:52comfortably connect to something outside of themselves.
- 50:55And that, and that is a very important need.
- 50:58There is there is a there's a color movie wasn't AI related,
- 51:01but was it Lars and the real world?
- 51:03Again, it speaks to what what are the fundamental human needs
- 51:09that everybody has and how are those satisfied and how do other
- 51:14people treat treat the satisfaction of needs if it
- 51:18doesn't align with how people commonly do it today, having an
- 51:22AI companion may be an outlier. I would say within a year it'll
- 51:25be very, very common. But yeah, Speaking of these, I
- 51:28thought was one interesting thing about the report too, that
- 51:31it really points to a future where there's so much
- 51:34prosperity. I mean, this is the hypothesis
- 51:36in there, right? That it it can be, it can be
- 51:39evenly distributed. And they didn't really call out
- 51:42Ubi necessarily, but they they kind of hinted this it may need
- 51:45to be. Yeah, there need to be some
- 51:47redistribution of this incredible wealth that AI is
- 51:50going to unlock. I mean, if that's a it's a good
- 51:54thing to talk about. And I agree, Jennifer, we should
- 51:56probably be talking about it starting now.
- 51:59I mean, personally, I wonder if too much for society is on is on
- 52:04basic income. Does that somehow is like SAP
- 52:06creativity and people's purpose that you mentioned before?
- 52:09Or would it be a huge unlock and let like in Star in Star Trek,
- 52:12there's no money, right? Star Trek you have a.
- 52:14You can create your food by clicking a button like and and
- 52:17you know in. Science fiction, The show.
- 52:20Jennifer's going to have a little date with William
- 52:22Shatner, is what I've heard in Charlotte, where he's coming.
- 52:25Wrath of Khan, right? He's going to Wrath of Khan.
- 52:28He's going to be there live on stage, answering questions.
- 52:32So jealous. Yeah, and I watched the Artemis
- 52:352 landing. When when did you see his
- 52:37interview with? I love when William Shatner gets
- 52:39on because he's so passionate. Not super technical, but he's
- 52:43super passionate about what this really means for the future of
- 52:46mankind, so he should be pretty fascinating.
- 52:49So you want to hear something weird?
- 52:50You know how I said I grew up in a small town in Ohio the the
- 52:54astronaut that was in charge of re entry went to my high school.
- 52:58Oh, really? That's awesome.
- 53:00Random. So, so, so back to, well, back
- 53:03to your question, I mean, so you know, all the people that I'm
- 53:05talking to that are doing the builders like the Drew Burdicks
- 53:08we mentioned earlier from Stealth X and our friend Mike
- 53:11Vicenzino, who's running a company called Clover AI is just
- 53:15launching. But he's a builder and he's
- 53:16going into a lot of organizations Speaking of sort
- 53:18of grassroots, typically non tech organizations.
- 53:22I just talked to a chief AI officer from a company called
- 53:25Visionary AI and he's an older guy that's been in this sort of
- 53:28data warehousing. He worked for Wells Fargo for
- 53:30many years, Bank of America and tech space.
- 53:33And he goes into dental institutions and, and home
- 53:37improvement companies and and financial services industries,
- 53:41typically lower tech. And the typical feedback that
- 53:45I'm getting is that most people, especially within certain
- 53:48industries, but I would say generally across the board are
- 53:51far behind what the kind of the builders and the developers and
- 53:59the people that are really leaning in are getting to.
- 54:02Like we're talking about open AI and I'm sorry, open Claw and
- 54:06Hermes and stuff like that. Whereas the average employee
- 54:09even at tech companies is just doing basic props.
- 54:13Like there's not apparently. Adoption of AI Google is very
- 54:16low. Someone, someone was talking
- 54:18about that this week. Adoption of AI at Google.
- 54:21At Google, Oh, at Google, I think you said at Google, which
- 54:25so, so if, if, if people within organizations are sort of behind
- 54:30the curve, I mean, like, how are you advising companies on this?
- 54:35Are you starting at the very simplest level to kind of help
- 54:38bring them along this journey? I mean that that's where it
- 54:40starts just getting people familiar with the basics in
- 54:44actually getting getting their hands dirty, that that's where
- 54:47it starts getting comfortable with it seeing, seeing what it
- 54:50can do for you on it on a small scale.
- 54:53But ultimately, and I know, I know that this is something
- 54:56which Drew talks about and I completely agree with him on
- 54:58this, in order for it to be sustainable and scalable and
- 55:03worth the investment, you need to be very clear about what does
- 55:08success look like? How do you measure success?
- 55:11Where do you identify the initial use cases to prove
- 55:16success and get and get a, a return on the investment and use
- 55:20that to kind of snowball and take on more and more?
- 55:24That's how it starts. Yeah, you can't put it on the
- 55:26ocean on day one. Yeah, that was interesting.
- 55:28You say that because of the Google thing.
- 55:30Just to cut you off for a second, so apparently Steve Yagy
- 55:33tweeted this the other day, AI adoption at Google is the same
- 55:36as at John Deere. And the reason why he was saying
- 55:41that, and I think it kind of validates what you're saying
- 55:43here, is it's not like they they they're not allowed to use
- 55:46Claude code because it's the enemy, right?
- 55:49And there's been a hiring freeze at Google for the last 18
- 55:52months. They're not bringing out anyone
- 55:54else from the outside. So Brett, the people are using
- 55:55open claw and Hermes and all these other and, and the latest
- 55:59Claude, they're not going into Google.
- 56:00So they're just using their own tools.
- 56:02There's no pressure to use them. And so, so I think it is is
- 56:08fascinating times. So there's something about being
- 56:10being able to try things out and bring them and experiment,
- 56:12right? I I also also think that this
- 56:15that this comes down to incentive structures.
- 56:18When the cost to when sorry, when the benefit of using
- 56:23something becomes greater than the cost of not using it, that's
- 56:26when adoption happens. Yeah, yeah.
- 56:29And, and we have George Busey who who you know, is at Horizon
- 56:32as an EVP on a couple of shows ago.
- 56:35And, and he was saying how it just hasn't worked that it, that
- 56:39in most use cases that you align AI to, it's just failed the the
- 56:45litmus test that there haven't been any sort of outcomes that
- 56:49people can point to that are meaningful.
- 56:52And I and I thought that was, I was a bit surprised by that.
- 56:54Yeah, I, I think, I think people have a a skewed view of what,
- 57:00what can AI actually do? Like really getting down to
- 57:04brass text, what can it do from from a UX perspective, I think
- 57:08AI is immensely successful at creating what I call Teamu UI
- 57:13UX. It's something that looks good
- 57:17it's passable to the novice. It looks like hey, this is this
- 57:20is magic, but to anyone who but when you as soon as you go below
- 57:24the. Center design professional,
- 57:25right? A little bit or someone who
- 57:27knows what excellent look like it breaks it breaks it doesn't
- 57:31doesn't care for the for the edge cases and someone who's
- 57:34never actually designed and shipped a product they don't
- 57:38even think about edge cases. They only think about the happy
- 57:41path. Light life is all edge cases.
- 57:44It's all about edge cases. And it's just, it is a tool.
- 57:50And I think it's always going to be a tool.
- 57:52It's going to, it's a, it's an increasingly powerful tool.
- 57:55And I think that the high watermark of what is uniquely
- 57:58human is going to continuously change.
- 58:01But it's ultimately always going to be a tool.
- 58:05And as it's, as it's constantly evolving individually and we're
- 58:09talking about the job market and viability and all these things
- 58:13that are changing. Anyone who is curious, who has
- 58:17good judgement, good critical thinking is a lifelong learner
- 58:20and really truly dedicated to that.
- 58:22Those are the people who are going to be OK.
- 58:27They're, they're always good. There's always going to be be a
- 58:29place for those people. And that is not limited to where
- 58:33you went to school. It's not limited to your age or
- 58:36to anything else. If you are curious, if you are
- 58:41willing, willing to take a chance and try new things and
- 58:44learn and fail and be wrong, that is, that is what it's going
- 58:48to take to be to be viable in this in this changing workforce.
- 58:53Yeah. And I and I think it's important
- 58:54for people to realize that it's not as easy.
- 58:57Despite the claims on X and in LinkedIn that I built the CRM in
- 59:01five days or 24 hours, it's not that easy, right?
- 59:05And and some of the technologies that do exist, I've had this
- 59:08debate recently about CRMS, like you could replicate certain vibe
- 59:12code, certain capabilities that maybe is an SMB, a small
- 59:15business or a mid market would serve your needs.
- 59:20But but the amount of rigor and validation and test and learn
- 59:25that happens with these companies that say it's a
- 59:27HubSpot CRM or some other technology through years of
- 59:32practice, hard to replicate that in 2448 hours.
- 59:36So there's a lot. Of capture leads, store records,
- 59:38you know, manage cases and send a couple emails.
- 59:40You could probably do that by vibe coding if you know what
- 59:43you're doing within a few days. But yeah, if you wanted an
- 59:45enterprise validated system that does these things that can be
- 59:48used by multiple people in multiple environments.
- 59:50And for your point, this user tested and has gone through the
- 59:53rigor of a of a deployment. Yeah.
- 59:55And I want to be clear, user tested on actual human users.
- 59:59Yeah, this whole thing around synthetic users and so in
- 1:00:02synthetic data. Is a disaster.
- 1:00:06Well, synthetic data can be used effectively in advertising to.
- 1:00:10To kind of chart and predict engagement rates.
- 1:00:13And yeah, I'm, I'm not saying it has no, no value or no utility
- 1:00:17because it, it certainly does within, within certain cases,
- 1:00:21but I'm, I'm afraid it's going to, it's, there's going to be
- 1:00:26temptation to use it for everything.
- 1:00:28Yeah. And that is that is, that is
- 1:00:31what we don't want. That is what we cannot have.
- 1:00:34Yeah, yeah, get. Your product.
- 1:00:36Get your product in the hands of actual, like real people.
- 1:00:39Yeah. And and to your point about vibe
- 1:00:41coding, you can, you can create something that works, sort of,
- 1:00:47but does it doesn't manage edge cases?
- 1:00:50Probably not. What about security?
- 1:00:52What about vulnerabilities? What about malicious code?
- 1:00:55And you, as soon as you introduce anything financial
- 1:00:58payments, we'll forget about it. So there is.
- 1:01:02Speaking of governance and heavily regulated.
- 1:01:04Industries, yes, and also and also accountability.
- 1:01:07As of as of right now, you cannot hold an AI accountable,
- 1:01:11you cannot hold a machine or technology accountable.
- 1:01:14You only can hold people accountable.
- 1:01:18And so for that reason alone, there always needs to be a human
- 1:01:21in the mix. Yeah, so I imagine.
- 1:01:24There's going to be a lot of court cases deciding this to in
- 1:01:26the future, right about like liability about, you know,
- 1:01:30because we've already had some about about IP and content and
- 1:01:34ownership of that. But I think in terms of
- 1:01:35liability as these systems get Sparta, it's only going to
- 1:01:38start. Brett Asher cut you off.
- 1:01:40Yeah, no. And, and how for companies that
- 1:01:42you're consulting with, how do they build guardrails?
- 1:01:46And also sort of it's like you have to build guardrails, but
- 1:01:48you also have to and sort of governance around how AI is
- 1:01:51used. But to your point about Google,
- 1:01:52how do you actually democratize the usage of AI?
- 1:01:55So what I've seen first hand is that often times it starts even
- 1:01:58today, you know, in 2026, April of 2026, even when it's even
- 1:02:05within tech organizations, it's within the IT department, right?
- 1:02:08And then they, they start to, you know, so other teams start
- 1:02:10to raise their hands to say, hey, I want access to this and I
- 1:02:13want access to this. But I find that it's kind of a
- 1:02:15slow roll out process. And there's whole parts of the
- 1:02:18organization. I saw this in commercial
- 1:02:20organizations, customer success sales that had no little to no
- 1:02:25other than free sort of LLM access, access to kind of more
- 1:02:31powerful AI capabilities cuz those were generally managed and
- 1:02:35partitioned by the IT team. Are you seeing organizations
- 1:02:40using these things kind of ubiquitously?
- 1:02:43Cuz I just found the rollout. Figure slow.
- 1:02:45Not ubiquitously, no. I mean, you know, granted, I,
- 1:02:48I've historically worked with regulated organizations and
- 1:02:52they, they need to be very careful about these things.
- 1:02:55There are certain areas in certain business units and teams
- 1:02:59that are that are using using these, these more powerful
- 1:03:03models. But by and large, they don't get
- 1:03:06access to the to these frontier models.
- 1:03:08And they're using, it's not even that that they're using the
- 1:03:12publicly available ones because they're not allowed to do that.
- 1:03:15It's these, it's these internal walled off versions that are
- 1:03:19actually actually quite sufficient for basic tasks.
- 1:03:23But the expectation is that they're going to be using them
- 1:03:25for more than basic tasks. Even at some of these large
- 1:03:28companies, their AI policy, some of them are still use AI.
- 1:03:34They don't provide any sort of guidance or support or training
- 1:03:39or training track beyond that. Although companies are are are
- 1:03:43definitely moving away from that.
- 1:03:44But there's still a considerable number of organizations that
- 1:03:47that is their AI strategy. Yeah, it's it's basically
- 1:03:51representing like Google search go and do do a search on X
- 1:03:54approved. Here's copilot, right?
- 1:03:58Yeah, yeah, I actually think Copilot.
- 1:04:00So I don't use Copilot because I, you know, I work for myself.
- 1:04:05I actually think Copilot has or had the potential to be the most
- 1:04:09useful AI tool, but it depends on on clean, well organized data
- 1:04:17in order for it to work. And that is the part that is
- 1:04:19missing. So you have to have good data
- 1:04:23and good information in order for it to, to create good
- 1:04:26outcomes. But you also have to have people
- 1:04:29who are, who know, who know what good looks like and are given
- 1:04:35either within themselves or given a given from, from leaders
- 1:04:39and influencers in the organization.
- 1:04:42What, what, what specifically is AI usage going to look like?
- 1:04:46How do you know, how do you know when we're doing this right?
- 1:04:49What are, what are some, some checks and balances we're going
- 1:04:52to, we're going to put into the system?
- 1:04:54Yeah, and those are those are, I wouldn't even say that the
- 1:04:58nuances, they're bigger than nuances, but those are the
- 1:05:01things that are that are still that are still evolving.
- 1:05:04Yeah, the. The education layer is critical.
- 1:05:06Right. Yeah.
- 1:05:07It's less about the technical layer and more about education
- 1:05:10and then and then test and learn and start to roll this out in a
- 1:05:13structured way. I actually think that these
- 1:05:16small humans, human aware AI native companies like like Drew
- 1:05:23Self X company, those those are actually the companies that I
- 1:05:26think are best positioned to be successful.
- 1:05:30They don't, they don't. They don't have to unlearn much.
- 1:05:33Unlearning is much harder than learning.
- 1:05:35That's a really good point, right?
- 1:05:37You don't have. Legacy thinking or legacy or
- 1:05:40legacy anything, right? All the way back to your
- 1:05:42original point around the mergers and acquisition, when
- 1:05:44you get companies merging, they have to unlearn patterns of
- 1:05:48work, patterns of organization. People talk about it as fit or
- 1:05:51culture. It could be a whole bunch of
- 1:05:53things. Systems and a lot of times have
- 1:05:55completely different approaches kind of clashing.
- 1:05:59Which which is why I think the business when you were talking
- 1:06:02about before the, the, the, the consultor, the the consultant or
- 1:06:06the, the firm that was going after these small medical
- 1:06:10practices, that is that is a very good business model because
- 1:06:14you're going into some place where the stakes are arguably
- 1:06:18lower. And the use cases are much
- 1:06:20simpler. Yes, faster time to value.
- 1:06:24You keep it super. Longing fruit, right?
- 1:06:26Yeah, everything is longing fruit.
- 1:06:28You don't have these super expensive, super complicated
- 1:06:31legacy tech stacks. Yeah, you can just introduce a
- 1:06:35new system. It's not quite as easy as that,
- 1:06:37but there's there's, there. There are a lot, a lot fewer
- 1:06:40headwinds. Yeah.
- 1:06:43So should we go into quick hits? Do quick hits.
- 1:06:46Yeah, so I'll start. What's the biggest misconception
- 1:06:51about AI and jobs right now? That AI is going to eliminate
- 1:06:56all jobs tomorrow. It's going to eliminate job.
- 1:07:01It's it's eliminating some jobs now, but it's not happening as
- 1:07:05fast or as broadly as people think.
- 1:07:07There's still an opportunity, a lot of opportunity and more time
- 1:07:11than you think to level yourself up and find your niche.
- 1:07:15I think AI is broad enough now that there's a lot of it's,
- 1:07:19it's, it's, it's too much for one person to focus on.
- 1:07:22But find your niche, find what is meaningful and interesting
- 1:07:26and what do you naturally gravitate towards and how does
- 1:07:29AI fit into that and that and that is your learning path.
- 1:07:33Let's run one role in design or product, or just UX generally,
- 1:07:38that you think will disappear faster than people expect.
- 1:07:42Production design. Is it already gone?
- 1:07:45I don't think I mean it. I think it exists, but it not
- 1:07:48nearly to the extent it did even a few months ago.
- 1:07:52So. And define production design.
- 1:07:55Well, make a banner. Yeah, resizing banners like
- 1:07:58Yeah. Well, and I've talked to a lot
- 1:08:00of like traditional designers, production designers that say,
- 1:08:02oh, it hasn't been replaced and then, you know, and yet they're
- 1:08:05still building from scratch PowerPoint decks.
- 1:08:08Or it just hasn't reached them yet?
- 1:08:10Yeah, it hasn't reached them. And I, and I tested out Gamma
- 1:08:14the other day, created an outline in, in Hermes and, and
- 1:08:18popped it into gamma for, for PowerPoint because my eye
- 1:08:21designer's telling me, oh, you got to still build this because,
- 1:08:23you know, the tools they were trying to go directly from the
- 1:08:26LLM to like production of something that a sales team
- 1:08:29could use. And you pop it into another AI
- 1:08:31capability gamma and the, the output was just stunning.
- 1:08:35I'm like, you've just eliminated any need for me to ever manually
- 1:08:39build the PowerPoint deck again. And I just saw this a couple of
- 1:08:43years ago and I was like, this is astounding, this.
- 1:08:45Is yeah, anything, anything that requires any level of of of
- 1:08:50specific of specificity that needs to be replicated.
- 1:08:53AI cannot do that. You still need you still need a
- 1:08:56talented designer to do to do this.
- 1:08:58I think, I think I think something else that's going away
- 1:09:00is the is someone with just a single title, an interface only
- 1:09:06designer, a UI designer that is going away.
- 1:09:09They are being automated out of existence, but somebody who who
- 1:09:14can practice AI enabled across a number of UX Cape across a
- 1:09:22number of experience capabilities and can then extend
- 1:09:25it to business and technology or marketing and compliance.
- 1:09:28Those that that is where the job is going the single title, the
- 1:09:32single career path, the. The end of specialization.
- 1:09:35Away. It's generalist.
- 1:09:37We've so you heard it here noise and so so if you had to bet,
- 1:09:43does I create more opportunity I think into the answer to this
- 1:09:46question, but I won't I won't, I won't, I won't have I won't ask
- 1:09:49a leading question create more opportunity or more
- 1:09:51displacement. I think ultimately more
- 1:09:54opportunity, but it's not going to come easily or painlessly.
- 1:09:59This opportunity is going to come after a generational shift
- 1:10:02and how we view and define work. And I don't think that this is
- 1:10:05even 10 years. I think in two or three years,
- 1:10:08maybe even fewer than. That and it's a paradigm shift
- 1:10:11in how institutions and government operate, right?
- 1:10:13How regulation operates, how you know, I'm not sure we're going
- 1:10:17to have, you know, universal income in the next two years,
- 1:10:21but it's certainly going to require a paradigm shift in how
- 1:10:24people think in, in, in partition, sort of AI in their.
- 1:10:27Lives well, things are. I've never seen technology
- 1:10:30advanced as quickly. So I think that is
- 1:10:32unprecedented. But I think what will be slower
- 1:10:34is just diffusion throughout companies, throughout society.
- 1:10:36I mean that, Jennifer, I agree with your point earlier,
- 1:10:38probably a little slower than we're predicting now, but it's
- 1:10:40going to happen. Yeah, not, not everyone lives in
- 1:10:43the AI world. That, that, that we do.
- 1:10:45And that and that that, that your listeners probably do.
- 1:10:48They're you. Ever talking to a?
- 1:10:49Lawyer. Have you ever spoken to a
- 1:10:50lawyer? Very different.
- 1:10:51What's that? Have you ever spoken with a
- 1:10:53lawyer? I have a figure.
- 1:10:56I just like something, something.
- 1:10:58It was something evil within me. The little devil on the left
- 1:11:01side of my shoulder or whatever, just wants to see the legal
- 1:11:04industry completely disrupted. And I and I, I'm putting that on
- 1:11:08the record because there is no justification for $2500 an hour.
- 1:11:13Oh my. God, $1500 an hour often for
- 1:11:16work, that's soup, that's a lot of billable hours that's being
- 1:11:19given to a second year associate.
- 1:11:22And so to me, those types of industries, Rio and you know,
- 1:11:24you and I have talked about this sort of billable hours model.
- 1:11:27The the the people at the top, they can orchestrate and conduct
- 1:11:29and have the strategic, strategic systems thinking and
- 1:11:32the connections and know the letter of the law from decades
- 1:11:36of experience. That's a different play.
- 1:11:38It's everybody underneath him that are doing all of this
- 1:11:42route. Route like wrote work.
- 1:11:46Yeah, consulting, it's interesting.
- 1:11:48Like I think that like we're already seeing it be impacted,
- 1:11:51right. And I'm even telling clients I
- 1:11:54don't want to do any time material work.
- 1:11:55You know, look, if a lot of strategy work is selling, Brett,
- 1:11:59you're making fun of PowerPoint production, a lot of it is
- 1:12:01selling. I joke with friends when they
- 1:12:03and they say, what are you doing?
- 1:12:05Part of what we do is sell expensive PowerPoints, right?
- 1:12:08So I think that like as, but it was never about like this
- 1:12:11PowerPoint size. It's about the message they're
- 1:12:13conveying, right? But I'm getting to that message
- 1:12:15is different because a lot of the tasks that we used to bill
- 1:12:17hourly for AI can do much better, more efficiently, right?
- 1:12:20So I think that consulting is changing.
- 1:12:22I tell clients I just do fixed fee.
- 1:12:24You tell me how much this is worth to you and we'll produce
- 1:12:26it within the time frame you want.
- 1:12:28I'm not going to tell you this is a team we need because that's
- 1:12:30irrelevant now. I, I 100% agree with that.
- 1:12:33And that's on the subject of PowerPoint.
- 1:12:35One of the things that I love is that's happening right now is
- 1:12:39that AI is is taking over PowerPoint production.
- 1:12:45Well, thank God, but but yeah, how?
- 1:12:47Many hours of our lives. But what it's not taking away,
- 1:12:50what it cannot take away, what humans still need to be able to
- 1:12:53do, is storytelling. Yeah.
- 1:12:55You know, if you can tell a good, compelling, relevant
- 1:12:59story, you're going to sell, you're going to.
- 1:13:01And that takes the years, that takes the years of experience.
- 1:13:04Exactly to have the. Expertise and the credentials
- 1:13:07and like that and like in the presence to be get up there and
- 1:13:09tell that story. It's not incredible.
- 1:13:11It's, it's not. Yeah.
- 1:13:13And it's, you know, the I just quote of all time about
- 1:13:15PowerPoint is for people that have no power and have no point
- 1:13:19I've. Heard that is fine.
- 1:13:21Right, because it's not about the keep the technical sort of
- 1:13:25build of a slide that it's about the message behind it.
- 1:13:29So it really doesn't matter what it looks like.
- 1:13:32Yes, you want to be buttoned up and professional.
- 1:13:33That stuff can be automated. It's about, yeah, it's your
- 1:13:36point. But you'd be shocked how many
- 1:13:37hours of consulting at the big the strategy like MBBS like that
- 1:13:41people used to waste. Like I used to see people mess
- 1:13:44around with size for four hours per slide.
- 1:13:46So I mean, I told I'm not kidding, right?
- 1:13:48I so I tell people each slide should not take you more than
- 1:13:53half hour Max, absolute Max, like maybe even quicker than
- 1:13:56that, right? I mean, it should take you a few
- 1:13:57minutes, right? And I and I took, I took a
- 1:14:00pretty in depth proposal for, for go to market strategy for an
- 1:14:05independent agency, took that proposal, basically got a
- 1:14:09summary of that proposal through through Hermes and told it to
- 1:14:14prep it for slide development, right.
- 1:14:17And it created that. And then we popped that into
- 1:14:20Gamma and within 5 minutes, it was just one of the better decks
- 1:14:26that I've seen produced. I mean, it just, it was
- 1:14:28incredible. Maybe not brand on, but just
- 1:14:31colors, layout, workflows, structure buckets, the.
- 1:14:35Structure of the thoughts to presentation.
- 1:14:37And I'm like, and I covered all the key themes in a way that was
- 1:14:40smarter than I've seen any person honestly create on a
- 1:14:44marketing team or otherwise. So I'm like that's.
- 1:14:47But you need, you need a good inputs and good data to make
- 1:14:50that a valuable, yeah, a valuable tech, right?
- 1:14:53And. And yeah, that and that, like
- 1:14:54you, I'm saying again, that's where we all think like, Oh
- 1:14:57yeah, he's making this easy. Yeah, there were hundreds of
- 1:14:59hours of training, of educating of all this, all these inputs
- 1:15:04that are going into the agent that's making a decision as to
- 1:15:08hey, this is how the proposal structure should work.
- 1:15:10This is what we're seeing in the proposal based on my entire
- 1:15:13business strategy and every and all the.
- 1:15:15Documents and on this slide it's missing this.
- 1:15:17Please add this in and restructured and I'll expand
- 1:15:20that. So it takes a lot of like back
- 1:15:22and forth and prompts and and work within swab mutine system
- 1:15:25and that's where we are today at least.
- 1:15:27And then, and then it changes something you don't want to have
- 1:15:30change. You need to be so prescriptive.
- 1:15:32And it's like, I should have done this myself, but I do.
- 1:15:35I do think that that that type of frustration is is decreasing
- 1:15:40with every with every and. People like throw up their arms.
- 1:15:42I mean, I've got people and we'll we'll finish this, but
- 1:15:44I've got, I know people like we're all of the age where at
- 1:15:47least, you know, some of my friends are like, you know, I
- 1:15:50rather just, you know, Fast forward to retirement than have
- 1:15:54to learn all this stuff. I mean this.
- 1:15:58Stuff is fun. I mean, I don't want to get it,
- 1:15:59but this, this is this is most fun.
- 1:16:01I've been having to work in a bunch of years.
- 1:16:02It really is. I'm doing stuff I wasn't have
- 1:16:04been doing. I've been like built like
- 1:16:06actually building deliverables for clients more than I have in
- 1:16:08a bunch of years. But because I'm using AI, all
- 1:16:11that like the the dreary part of it is kind of quicker and almost
- 1:16:15gone. So I'm actually having more fun
- 1:16:16at work now that I have in a while.
- 1:16:18Yeah, now, now, now what we need AI to take away is all the is
- 1:16:21all those meetings. Yes.
- 1:16:23Yes, and an avatar. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:16:27Well, this has been great. Thank you, Jennifer.
- 1:16:29And we're we're certainly thrilled to have you as part of
- 1:16:32the Signal and Noise family as part of our executive voices
- 1:16:35network. Hopefully you'll you'll be
- 1:16:36writing and maybe appearing in some more I'm.
- 1:16:38Already working on something. Yeah.
- 1:16:40And so maybe some, even some AI education, because we realize,
- 1:16:43you know, I think that's a big play.
- 1:16:44A lot of the build companies like Stealth X and others I've
- 1:16:48seen have gone into sort of the education angle because so many
- 1:16:51of the lower tech industries, even the higher tech industries
- 1:16:54to the Google point, need that help on how do we actually rule
- 1:16:58this out? And how do we start small?
- 1:16:59And what's the framework and, and how do you spread the wealth
- 1:17:03of, of, of knowledge in a controlled way within big
- 1:17:06organizations or small organizations?
- 1:17:09I mean that that is the promise of technology, right?
- 1:17:12If it's in responsible benevolent hands and everyone
- 1:17:15can, can get can get the benefits.
- 1:17:18So have to I'm going to stay optimistic that that that's
- 1:17:22where the story is eventually going to go.
- 1:17:24Yeah, it's not, it's not going to end up in, you know, Blade
- 1:17:27Runner or Terminator. Terminator.
- 1:17:30Yeah, yeah. Or Battlestar Galactica, right.
- 1:17:33It's kind of funny that all of this stuff, I, I, you know, and
- 1:17:35I'll end with this, but I think I just can't.
- 1:17:37I can't fathom or put my wrap my head around how fast stuff has
- 1:17:42changed within our own lifetimes.
- 1:17:43I think we're all like Gen. Xers.
- 1:17:46Right. I mean, my God, I mean, you
- 1:17:47know, when, when Rio and I first moved to New York City, we were
- 1:17:50getting Internet delivered through disks and models with
- 1:17:56AOL, via AOL and so and so. I had a Commodore 64 with like a
- 1:18:00dial up modem, my first modem based like you know that, you
- 1:18:03know that noise would make or to call in.
- 1:18:05I was just, I mean, just crazy, right?
- 1:18:07Yeah, you said that like, and just to see all of this happen,
- 1:18:10I mean from the Internet age laying of, of broadband to the
- 1:18:13Internet age to the growth of digital advertising and
- 1:18:16everything around that to, you know, we're like on the cusp of
- 1:18:20quantum computing going mainstream, right?
- 1:18:23It's, it's pretty incredible. I like to how fast all of this
- 1:18:26stuff is happening and it's within our lifetimes which is
- 1:18:29mind blowing. Yeah.
- 1:18:32Well, this has been a terrific conversation.
- 1:18:35We've been going on forever on a, on a on a Friday afternoon.
- 1:18:38For you've got to get to see Wrath of Khan and I too.
- 1:18:41Yes, I, yeah. And.
- 1:18:42Be Captain Kirk. Thanks for Mr. Shatner.
- 1:18:44So yeah, you got to run. It's been real.
- 1:18:46No. It's going to be quite an
- 1:18:47experience. Yeah.
- 1:18:49Wrath of Khan, that's a classic. Thank you.
- 1:18:51And so thanks everybody for if you've made it this far for
- 1:18:53joining us on Signal and Noise for a terrific podcast.
- 1:18:57Join visit us at Deb Deb Deb dot Signal and Noise dot AI.
- 1:19:01You can read articles, watch videos, listen to podcasts, it's
- 1:19:05all there. And you can also notice on
- 1:19:07YouTube, Spotify, Apple podcast, and we are putting out a ton
- 1:19:11more content and we will be at possible in the very near
- 1:19:14future. So talk to you soon and thanks
- 1:19:17for joining us. Thank you.