Latest / NFL Talk | New York Jets / The Wide-Open Path to Super Bowl LXI
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Okay, so let's unpack this. I want you to picture
- 0:03the scene. It's the morning of February tenth, twenty twenty six.
- 0:07We are what less than twenty four hours removed from
- 0:10the final whistle of Super Bowl LX. The confetti is
- 0:13probably still stuck to the turf. The city of Seattle
- 0:16is waking up with just a massive collective hangover. The
- 0:20Seahawks took down the Patriots in what was frankly a
- 0:24wild finale to the season.
- 0:25Speaker 2: This incredible game, it really was.
- 0:27Speaker 1: But here's the thing about the NFL. The machine never
- 0:30ever stops. While the players are booking their vacations, fans
- 0:34are buying T shirts, the sportsbooks in Vegas, they're already
- 0:38back at work. They just released the opening odds for
- 0:40next year Super Bowl LEXI in twenty twenty seven, and
- 0:44I took one look at this data sheet this morning,
- 0:46and I genuinely thought there was like a glitch.
- 0:48Speaker 2: In the algorithm.
- 0:49Speaker 3: It does look like a computer error, doesn't it.
- 0:50Speaker 2: It looks broken.
- 0:51Speaker 1: Usually, the day after the Super Bowl, we have a king,
- 0:54we have a clear hierarchy. We know who the big
- 0:56bad wolf is supposed to be. But today we have
- 0:59a list of teams. That suggests, for maybe the first
- 1:01time in modern history, nobody has a clue who's actually
- 1:04good at football.
- 1:05Speaker 3: That's the perfect way to frame it. The market has
- 1:07effectively just thrown its hands up. We're looking at a
- 1:10set of numbers that really defines a new era of uncertainty.
- 1:14Speaker 1: So that's our mission for this deep dive. We're not
- 1:17just going to read off a list of favorites. We
- 1:19need to unpack why the math looks like this. We're
- 1:22going to look at why the favorites have historically well
- 1:26terrible odds. What this tells us about the idea of
- 1:29a dynasty in twenty twenty six, and where the smart money.
- 1:34You know, the actual sharks are trying to find an
- 1:37edge in a room that is pitch black.
- 1:39Speaker 3: And trust me, the sharks are swimming.
- 1:41Speaker 1: Oh I bet they are. So let's jump right into
- 1:43the deep end. The first thing that just leaps off
- 1:45the page is the team or teams, i should say,
- 1:47at the very top of the board, the favorites. We
- 1:50have a tie the brand new champion Seattle Seahawks and
- 1:53the Los Angeles Rams, both sitting at plus nine to fifty.
- 1:56Speaker 3: Right, plus nine to fifty.
- 1:57Speaker 1: Now for the listener who maybe just throws twenty bucks
- 1:59in the game once a year. Plus nine fifty sounds
- 2:01pretty good, pays out almost ten to one. But for
- 2:03a favorite, I mean, this is weird, right? Can you
- 2:05contextualize that number?
- 2:06Speaker 3: Four?
- 2:06Speaker 2: Us?
- 2:07Speaker 1: How weird is plus nine fifty for the top dog?
- 2:09Speaker 3: Weird doesn't quite cover it.
- 2:10Speaker 1: It is.
- 2:11Speaker 3: It's actually unprecedented in the modern era. We pulled the
- 2:14data from ESPN research going all the way back to
- 2:16nineteen seventy seven, and if these odds hold until kickoff
- 2:20in September, having a preseason favorite at plus nine fifty
- 2:23would be the longest odds for a top ranked team on.
- 2:26Speaker 2: Record since nineteen seventy seven.
- 2:28Speaker 3: Since nineteen seventy seven, that is nearly fifty years of
- 2:31football history. And think about what that implies. In almost
- 2:35every season for the last half century, the market has
- 2:38been able to identify a juggernaut. Usually you have a
- 2:41favorite sitting around what plus four fifty or plus five hundred,
- 2:44you know, think of the forty nine Ers in the eighties,
- 2:47the Patriots in the twenty tens, or the Chiefs just
- 2:50a few years ago.
- 2:51Speaker 1: Usually the bookmakers look at the league and they say Okay,
- 2:53that team is the monster. They have an eighteen or
- 2:55twenty percent chance to win it.
- 2:56Speaker 3: All exactly, But at plus nine fifty, the implied probability
- 3:00is just under ten percent.
- 3:01Speaker 1: Wait, so the team with the absolute best chance to
- 3:03win the Super Bowl only has a nine percent chance
- 3:06to actually win it.
- 3:07Speaker 3: That is correct. And to put that in perspective, since
- 3:09twenty fifteen odds of plus nine fifty would typically lend
- 3:13you fourth or even fifth on the list, you'd be
- 3:15considered a dark horse, fun sleeper pick. This year, plus
- 3:19nine fifty is the ceiling. It is the book makers
- 3:22effectively shrugging their shoulders and saying your guess is as
- 3:25good as ours.
- 3:26Speaker 1: That feels incredibly uncomfortable for a multi billion dollar industry.
- 3:30These guys build skyscrapers in the desert because they know
- 3:33the math. They hate uncertainty. So why is the ceiling
- 3:36so low? Is the league just that competitive or are
- 3:39the book makers terrified of something?
- 3:41Speaker 3: It's fear, absolute fear, And you cannot separate these new
- 3:44odds from the trauma the books just experience. You have
- 3:47to look at the narrative of the twenty twenty five
- 3:49season we just finished because of who ended up playing
- 3:51yesterday precisely. Think back to exactly one year ago February
- 3:55twenty twenty five. Entering the season, both the Seattle Seahawks,
- 3:58who just won the Ring and the New England Patriots,
- 4:00who were the runners up, were listed at plus six thousand.
- 4:03Speaker 1: Plus six thousand. That's we are tanking for a draft
- 4:06pick territory. That's maybe we'll be good in three years territory.
- 4:09Speaker 3: It is lottery ticket territory. And yet those were the
- 4:13two teams left standing. In fact, Seattle is now tied
- 4:16with the two thousand and one Patriots the very beginning
- 4:19of the Tom Brady era, as the second largest preseason
- 4:22long shots to ever be crown champions.
- 4:25Speaker 1: So the predictive models just completely failed last year. They
- 4:28looked at Seattle and New England and saw bottom feeders,
- 4:32and those teams ended up being the best.
- 4:33Speaker 2: In the world.
- 4:34Speaker 3: Catastrophically failed. And when models fail that hard, the market
- 4:38over corrects. John Ewing from BETMGM actually called these new
- 4:42odds a reflex. It's a defensive mechanism. Because two massive
- 4:47long shots made the Super Bowl this year, betters and
- 4:49books are expecting chaos. They are terrified of underpricing a
- 4:53sleeper team.
- 4:54Speaker 2: They don't want to get caught again.
- 4:55Speaker 3: Right, But conversely, they're terrified of overpricing a favorite that
- 4:59might flop. The don't want to expose themselves.
- 5:01Speaker 1: That's almost like they have PTSD. Yeah, they don't want
- 5:03to be the guy who lists the team at plus
- 5:05six thousand that ends up costing the sportsbook millions of dollars.
- 5:08Speaker 3: That is a huge part of it, and Johnny Avello
- 5:10from DraftKings added another layer to this. It's a compression issue.
- 5:14When you don't have a team at the top soaking
- 5:17up all the probability like a dominant team at plus
- 5:20four hundred, that probability has to go somewhere. It gets
- 5:23distributed down the list.
- 5:25Speaker 2: Like spreading peanut butter tooth thin exactly.
- 5:27Speaker 3: Because the ceiling is lower, the floor has to come up.
- 5:31It forces the middle class of the NFL to be
- 5:33priced much lower than usual. The gap between the best
- 5:37and the average shrinks mathematically.
- 5:39Speaker 1: We're going to get to that middle class gym in
- 5:41a second, because that list is honestly where it gets
- 5:44really wild. But I want to stick on the favors
- 5:46for a moment. Yeah, we mentioned Seattle is at the
- 5:48top of plus nine fifty. That makes sense, recency bias.
- 5:51They just won, they had the trophy, but the Rams.
- 5:54Speaker 3: It's an interesting choice, isn't it.
- 5:55Speaker 1: They didn't even make the Super Bowl. They were sitting
- 5:57at home watching it like the rest of us. Yeah,
- 5:59why are they co favorites in all this chaos?
- 6:01Speaker 3: It does seem specific, But this is where you have
- 6:04to look at roster construction and the you know, the
- 6:07smart analysis of what wins in the modern NFL. Joey
- 6:11Feesl from Caesar's Sports Book laid out the case and
- 6:14it's surprisingly solid. It all comes down to stability in
- 6:18an unstable world.
- 6:19Speaker 2: Stability meaning the quarterback.
- 6:21Speaker 3: Partly, Matthew Stafford has quote all but confirmed his return,
- 6:26so you check the QB box you know who's under center.
- 6:29But more importantly, the Rams have minimal expected roster turnover.
- 6:34In an era of free agency where championship teams usually
- 6:37get gutted because they can't afford to pay everyone, keeping
- 6:40your core together is a massive advantage.
- 6:42Speaker 2: That makes sense.
- 6:43Speaker 1: Seattle might lose guys because their price tag just went up.
- 6:46Speaker 2: The Rams are.
- 6:46Speaker 3: Steady, exactly, And there's one more massive factor for Los Angeles.
- 6:51They have two first round draft picks in the upcoming draft.
- 6:53Speaker 2: Oh wow.
- 6:54Speaker 3: Yeah, So you have a team that was already performing
- 6:56at a playoff level. They're keeping their starters and they
- 6:59have the ammunition to add two blue chip prospects or
- 7:02trade those picks for another star.
- 7:04Speaker 1: That is a luxury most contenders just don't have. Usually,
- 7:07by the time you're a favorite, you've traded all your
- 7:10picks away to get there.
- 7:11Speaker 3: Precisely so, in a league of total uncertainty, the Rams
- 7:15look like the safest bet on paper. They have the
- 7:17highest floor, and the market is buying it. The Rams
- 7:20have already taken nearly thirteen percent of the early wagers.
- 7:23People are seeing that roster stability and buying stock early.
- 7:27Speaker 1: Okay, so we have the Seahawks and Rams at plus
- 7:29nine to fifty. But if the shaver Ds are that week,
- 7:33if they're barely ten percent favorites, the teams right behind
- 7:36them must be practically breathing down their necks. Who's in
- 7:39the chasing pack?
- 7:40Speaker 3: It is a traffic jam. Immediately behind them, you have
- 7:42the Buffalo Bills at plus eleven hundred. Then you have
- 7:44a three way tie at plus thirteen hundred. The Philadelphia Eagles,
- 7:48the Baltimore Ravens, and the AFC champion New England Patriots.
- 7:52Speaker 1: I find the Patriots at plus thirteen hundred really interesting.
- 7:55They lose the Super Bowl, their defense got exposed a
- 7:57bit by Seattle yesterday. Drake may have a rough day,
- 8:01Yet the books are respecting them way more than the
- 8:03plus six thousand disrespect they.
- 8:05Speaker 2: Got last year.
- 8:05Speaker 3: They proved the concept you can't list them as a
- 8:07fluke anymore. They went the distance. But here is where
- 8:10the whole parity argument really shows its teeth. We talk
- 8:14about that middle class getting squished together. Look at the
- 8:16group sitting at plus fourteen hundred and plus fifteen hundred.
- 8:20Speaker 1: This is the zone that really confused me when I
- 8:22looked at the sheet. Who is sitting there?
- 8:24Speaker 3: You've got the Detroit Lions and the Green Bay Packers
- 8:27at plus fourteen hundred, then the Los Angeles Chargers at
- 8:30plus fifteen hundred.
- 8:31Speaker 1: Okay, so pause, We have the Lions, Packers and Chargers
- 8:35all effectively within a rounding error of the Super Bowl favorites.
- 8:40Speaker 3: Yes, and when you step back and look at the
- 8:42whole board, here's the stat that just blows my mind.
- 8:45Half of the teams in the NFL are listed at
- 8:47plus twenty eight hundred or shorter half the league sixteen teams.
- 8:51Speaker 1: That is, that's statistically baffing. Usually once you get past
- 8:55the top six or seven teams, you just drop off
- 8:57a cliff. You entered that plus four thousand plus five
- 9:00wasteland of mediocrity where you're betting on miracles. But you're
- 9:03saying the difference between the best team in the NFL
- 9:05and the sixteenth best team is essentially a coin flip.
- 9:08Speaker 3: That is exactly what the odds are implying. The margins
- 9:10are razor thin. It implies that the skill gap between
- 9:14a playoff team and a wild card team has just evaporated.
- 9:17If you are in the top half of the league,
- 9:19you have a legitimate mathematical shot at the title.
- 9:22Speaker 1: Which brings me to the giant elephant in the room,
- 9:25or maybe the giant who is in the room anymore.
- 9:27We have to talk about the Kansas City Chiefs.
- 9:29Speaker 3: Uh yes, the fallen Empire.
- 9:31Speaker 1: For five or six years, the answer to who is
- 9:34winning the Super Bowl was just Patrick Mahomes. It didn't
- 9:38matter who the receivers were, it didn't matter if the
- 9:41defense was banged up. You just bet on Mahomes and
- 9:43you usually won. Where are they in this mess?
- 9:45Speaker 3: They are lost in the sauce. The Chiefs are sitting
- 9:47at plus fifteen.
- 9:48Speaker 1: Hundred plus fifteen hundred, so that puts them behind the Bills, Eagles, Ravens, Patriots,
- 9:53and tied with the Chargers. That feels like a massive
- 9:55overcorrection or is the dynasty actually dead?
- 9:59Speaker 3: The analysis coming out of DraftKings is pretty brutal. They
- 10:02describe the Chief's dynastic ambitions as being in flux. The
- 10:08market perception has shifted fundamentally. They aren't the alpha predator anymore.
- 10:12In previous years, the Chiefs got the benefit of the doubt,
- 10:14even if they looked shaky in the regular season. The
- 10:16books kept their odds short because.
- 10:18Speaker 1: Well, Mahomes, that Moms premium.
- 10:21Speaker 3: Right, and the premium is gone. The market has corrected.
- 10:25Now they are just another team in the crowded middle pack.
- 10:28The market is saying that one player, even the best player,
- 10:31can't overcome the roster deficiencies anymore. It is a huge
- 10:35signal that the era of the super team, where one
- 10:38team just dominates for a decade that might be over.
- 10:41Speaker 1: It's incredible how quickly that narrative shifts. One day you're
- 10:44the King, the next day you're tied with the Chargers.
- 10:47And speaking of teams getting lost in the crowd, what
- 10:49about Denver. The Broncos barely missed the Super Bowl this year.
- 10:52They were right on the doorstep.
- 10:54Speaker 3: They were, and yet they are sitting at plus eighteen hundred.
- 10:58In a normal year, a team that was one play
- 11:00away from the Super Bowl would be top five, maybe
- 11:02plus eight hundred. This year they aren't even getting top
- 11:05tier respect because there are simply too many viable contenders
- 11:08clogging up the board. They're just another face in the crowd.
- 11:11Speaker 1: So we've established that the book makers are confused. They
- 11:14flatten the odds because they are scared of getting burned.
- 11:17But bookmakers' odds are just the opening lines. They move
- 11:20based on where the actual catch goes.
- 11:22Speaker 3: I want to talk about the handles. Who is the
- 11:25public actually betting on with their own wallets right now?
- 11:28Speaker 1: The early returns are fascinating because they show two very
- 11:31different types of betting psychology at work. First, you have
- 11:35what we call the recency bias betters.
- 11:37Speaker 3: The people who only remember what happened yesterday exactly.
- 11:40Speaker 1: The Seattle Seahawks are predictably leading the pack. They have
- 11:45taken twenty one point two percent of the total bets
- 11:48and a whopping thirty three point eight percent of the
- 11:50money so far.
- 11:51Speaker 3: That is over a third of all the money in
- 11:53the futures market. On one team that feels like classic
- 11:56amateur betting. They won yesterday, so they'll win next year.
- 11:59It is likely driven by public sentiment. Yes, the hot
- 12:02hands fallacy is very real, but then look at New England.
- 12:06Despite the loss and frankly, the Seahawks defense really stifled
- 12:10Drake May yesterday, the Patriots are still pulling in about
- 12:13fourteen percent of the money, so the public hasn't abandoned them.
- 12:16They still believe in the runner up.
- 12:18Speaker 1: But there was one team on this list that made
- 12:19me do a double take, a team that feels like
- 12:22a speculative play but is getting serious traction.
- 12:25Speaker 2: The Chicago Bears.
- 12:26Speaker 3: Yes, the Bears. This is the dark horse of the
- 12:29early betting period. They're listed at plus twenty five hundred,
- 12:32so that's.
- 12:32Speaker 2: A mid tier long shot. You put down one hundred,
- 12:34you win.
- 12:35Speaker 3: Two and a half grand, right, But they are attracting
- 12:37over ten percent of the early money. That is a
- 12:40massive share for a team with those odds.
- 12:42Speaker 1: Why Chicago. Is this just the big market Chicago fan
- 12:45base waking up and feeling optimistic, or do people actually
- 12:47see a path?
- 12:48Speaker 3: It feels like a trajectory. Bet Plus twenty five hundred
- 12:52is a price that screams value if you believe their
- 12:55young core is ready to take a leap. It's better
- 12:57as trying to buy low on a stock they think
- 12:59is about to be It's risky, but at plus twenty
- 13:02five hundred, the reward justifies the risk for a lot
- 13:04of people. They are betting on potential, not history.
- 13:07Speaker 1: Now speaking of buying low, yeah, we need to talk
- 13:11about sharp money for the listener.
- 13:14Speaker 3: When we say sharp money, we aren't talking about the
- 13:16number of tickets or the fans at the bar. We're
- 13:18talking about massive single wagers from professional betters that are
- 13:22large enough to force the casino to change the odds.
- 13:26Did we see any of that?
- 13:27Speaker 1: You did? And it was on a team. Nobody is
- 13:28talking about the New York Giants.
- 13:30Speaker 3: The Giants really.
- 13:32Speaker 1: Raftkings reported they took a substantial bet on the Giants
- 13:35very early on, right after the lines opened, enough to
- 13:38move the line immediately. The Giants opened at plus eight thousand.
- 13:42Because of this specific betting action, they dropped to plus
- 13:45seven thousand. Oh, okay, plus seven thousands, still a long shot.
- 13:48That is not exactly a vote of confidence that they're
- 13:50winning the super Bowl. But for a book to move
- 13:53a line purely based on early action, that means they
- 13:58respect whoever plays that bet.
- 13:59Speaker 3: Exactly, if I go in and bet one thousand dollars
- 14:01on the Giants, the line doesn't move. The sports book
- 14:03just says thank you for your donation. But if a
- 14:06syndicate or a whale known for winning drops six figures,
- 14:11the line moves. It means someone with deep pockets thinks
- 14:14the Giants know something the rest of us don't. Maybe
- 14:16a trade is coming, maybe a coaching change, maybe their
- 14:19analytics show the roster is just undervalued.
- 14:22Speaker 1: That is always the most intriguing part to me, the
- 14:24insider trading aspect of the futures market. Someone thinks plus
- 14:28eight thousand is a mispricing and they're willing yet put a.
- 14:30Speaker 2: House on it.
- 14:31Speaker 3: It's the smoke that suggests a fire.
- 14:33Speaker 1: And on the flip side, you have the teams where
- 14:35the books are effectively saying keep your money, do.
- 14:38Speaker 2: Not touch this.
- 14:39Speaker 1: The no hoopers the basement dwellers who are we writing
- 14:42off completely before the season even starts.
- 14:45Speaker 3: Sorry to fans of the Arizona Cardinals and the Miami Dolphins,
- 14:49they are sitting at the absolute bottom of the board
- 14:52two hundred and fifty.
- 14:53Speaker 2: To one odds, two hundred and fifty to one.
- 14:55Speaker 3: It's an implied probability of less than half percent.
- 14:58Speaker 1: Brutal, Although in a world where Seattle wins from plus
- 15:02six thousand, never.
- 15:04Speaker 3: Seen ever, I mean, statistically you should probably say never
- 15:07for those two, But your point stands. The chaos is
- 15:10the theme. If the Seahawks can do it, the dream
- 15:13is alive for almost everyone else.
- 15:15Speaker 1: That really is the headline here. If we zoom out
- 15:18and look at this entire picture, from the plus nine
- 15:21hundred and fifty favorites to this logjam of sixteen teams
- 15:24in the middle, it feels like a fundamental shift in
- 15:27how the NFL operates. It feels different than five years ago.
- 15:30Speaker 3: It is different. We are potentially witnessing the death of
- 15:33the super team era. We used to treat the regular
- 15:36season as a formality. We knew it would be Brady
- 15:38versus Manning, or Mahomes versus Allen, and the conference championships.
- 15:40We were just waiting for the playoffs to start, right.
- 15:42Speaker 1: The regular season was just the preseason for the real
- 15:44teams exactly.
- 15:46Speaker 3: Now the difference between the best team and the average
- 15:49team is thinner than it has ever been. The variance
- 15:52is high.
- 15:53Speaker 1: It sounds great for the product. Honestly, it means more
- 15:55meaningful games. Yeah, if you're a fan of the Chargers
- 15:58or the Lions of the Packers, you genuinely have a
- 16:01mathematical reason to believe this is your year. You aren't
- 16:03deluding yourself.
- 16:04Speaker 3: It makes any given Sunday more than just a cliche.
- 16:08It's now a statistical reality for the entire season. The
- 16:12Lombardi Trophy is sitting there, and legitimately fifteen or sixteen
- 16:15teams have a realistic path to grabbing it.
- 16:18Speaker 1: Which is exciting for us but terrifying if you're a
- 16:21general manager whose job depends on predicting this stuff, how
- 16:25do you build a team when the margins are this.
- 16:27Speaker 3: Thin or better? Trying to pay rent? It's a minefield.
- 16:30Speaker 2: True.
- 16:31Speaker 1: So, as we wrap up this deep dive into the
- 16:33crystal ball of Super Bowl ELEXI, the takeaway is clear.
- 16:37Certainty is dead. The experts are shrugging, the betters are scrambling,
- 16:41and the field is wide open.
- 16:42Speaker 3: It really challenges how we watch the game.
- 16:44Speaker 1: It does, and I want to leave you with a
- 16:46thought to chew on as we head into the off season.
- 16:49We spent this whole time talking about how the bookmakers
- 16:51can't predict a favorite. They're paralyzed by the parody. Right,
- 16:54But here is a provocative question. If the smartest number
- 16:58cruncher is in the world, the people who build the
- 17:01casinos and set the lines are admitting they have no
- 17:05idea who is going to win. Does that mean the
- 17:08skill gap in the NFL have actually disappeared or have
- 17:11we just entered an era of total randomness?
- 17:14Speaker 3: That is the scary thought.
- 17:15Speaker 1: If the margins are this thin, does coaching even matter?
- 17:19Or is building a dynasty now statistically impossible because the
- 17:23ball is just shaped weird and bounce as funny.
- 17:25Speaker 3: That is the multi billion dollar question, and I don't
- 17:28think anyone has the answer yet.
- 17:29Speaker 1: Think about that while you check the waiver wire for
- 17:31your dynasty league. Thanks for listening to the Deep Dive.
- 17:35We'll catch you next time.