Latest / Bloomberg Law / The Strange Dissent of Samuel Alito
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: The legal fight over the abortion pill goes on. We
- 0:13Speaker 2: believe that we were prevailing the courts. We believe that
- 0:16Speaker 2: the law is on our side, and we're going to
- 0:18Speaker 2: continue to fight for millions of women across the country.
- 0:21Speaker 2: That's White House Press Secretary Kareem Jean Pierre.
- 0:24Speaker 3: As.
- 0:24Speaker 2: The controversial case over mifipristone returned to the Fifth Circuit
- 0:29Speaker 2: Court of Appeals after the Supreme Court last Friday blocked
- 0:33Speaker 2: to Texas judges restrictions from taking effect, keeping the drug
- 0:37Speaker 2: fully available while the legal fight moves forward. My guest
- 0:40Speaker 2: is constitutional law expert Stephen Vladik, a professor at the
- 0:44Speaker 2: University of Texas School of Law. Does the Supreme Court's
- 0:47Speaker 2: decision vindicate the Court's majority opinion in Dobbs, saying that
- 0:53Speaker 2: questions about abortion would be left to the political process. Although,
- 0:58Speaker 2: when we'll get to this in a moment, the justice
- 1:00Speaker 2: who wrote that opinion, Samuel Alito, dissented here. Strangely enough, I.
- 1:05Speaker 4: Don't really think that's a great framing. Is only because
- 1:07Speaker 4: I think it reads a lot more into this unsigned,
- 1:10Speaker 4: unexplained order than is reasonable under the circumstances. I think
- 1:13Speaker 4: it'll be easier to say that if the Court ultimately
- 1:16Speaker 4: ends up taking this case on the merits and ends
- 1:19Speaker 4: up reversing Judge Kasmerican siding with the federal government. All
- 1:23Speaker 4: that I m Friday's order really underscores is that there
- 1:27Speaker 4: was a majority of justices who bought sort of the
- 1:30Speaker 4: irreparable harm argument. Who bought that. You know, it really
- 1:33Speaker 4: would cause chaos and disruption if Judge Chasmerics order were
- 1:38Speaker 4: allowed to go into effect while the case works as
- 1:40Speaker 4: way through the court. In that respect, student actually strikes
- 1:43Speaker 4: me as something of an old school emergency intervention from
- 1:46Speaker 4: the justices, where it really is sort of purely about
- 1:48Speaker 4: the equities and not necessarily reflective of you on the merits.
- 1:53Speaker 2: So let's talk about that dissent by Alito. In your newsletter,
- 1:58Speaker 2: you discussed three claims Elito made in his descent. First,
- 2:01Speaker 2: his bitter rant about the shadow docket, where he cachede
- 2:06Speaker 2: on Justices Elena Kaig and Sonya Soto Mayor and Amy
- 2:09Speaker 2: Cony Barrett.
- 2:11Speaker 4: Justice Alito has been very sensitive to criticisms of the
- 2:14Speaker 4: shadow docket. This is not the first time he gave
- 2:17Speaker 4: a whole speech at Notre Dame Law School in September
- 2:19Speaker 4: of twenty twenty one, right in the middle of the
- 2:22Speaker 4: first big public backlash after the Court's ruling in the
- 2:25Speaker 4: Texas six week abortion ban case. You know, I think
- 2:28Speaker 4: he has this sense that those who criticize the Court's
- 2:32Speaker 4: increased use of emergency orders of unsigned, unexplained rulings in
- 2:36Speaker 4: recent years to change the status quo are really objected
- 2:40Speaker 4: to intervention as such, as opposed to a more nuanced
- 2:44Speaker 4: story about when the Court's intervening and why, and so
- 2:47Speaker 4: from his perspective, you know, when justices who have been
- 2:50Speaker 4: critical of prior intervention are nevertheless voting to intervene, as
- 2:56Speaker 4: the majority did on Friday night, you know, to him,
- 2:58Speaker 4: that's hypocrisy. I think that's ironic, and at least two respects. First,
- 3:02Speaker 4: he uses that hypocrisy to justify hypocrisy of his own.
- 3:06Speaker 4: I mean, he expressly says, you know, I didn't agree
- 3:09Speaker 4: with them then, but if they're going to do it,
- 3:10Speaker 4: then I'm going to do what they did. But the
- 3:12Speaker 4: second is I think that just really really sort of
- 3:16Speaker 4: marginalizes what the criticisms of the Shato docket have been,
- 3:20Speaker 4: which is not that the court is ever intervening, right.
- 3:23Speaker 4: I mean, any appellate court is going to have circumstances
- 3:27Speaker 4: where it has to intervene early in the case to
- 3:30Speaker 4: preserve the status quo pending appeal. That's not new, that's
- 3:34Speaker 4: not exceptional. Rather, the criticisms, at least from people like me,
- 3:38Speaker 4: have been that the way the Court has been using
- 3:41Speaker 4: this power in the last five or six years has
- 3:43Speaker 4: been in defiance of historical norms for when the court
- 3:47Speaker 4: should intervene, have been in defiance of the procedural and
- 3:52Speaker 4: jurisdictional rules governing when the court can should intervene, and
- 3:57Speaker 4: worst of all, have been inconsistent in when the Court
- 4:01Speaker 4: has intervened in ways that really don't map on to
- 4:04Speaker 4: any coherent, neutral legal principle so much as it maps
- 4:08Speaker 4: on to the partisan valance of the dispute. That's the criticism. Now,
- 4:12Speaker 4: folks may not agree with that criticism.
- 4:14Speaker 1: That's fine.
- 4:15Speaker 4: But I think what's frustrating about Alito's dissent is that
- 4:19Speaker 4: he's basically knocking down a straw man when he says,
- 4:22Speaker 4: you know, you guys have been opposed to intervention, and
- 4:25Speaker 4: yet you're doing it here like that's not what the
- 4:27Speaker 4: conversation has been.
- 4:29Speaker 2: He also says that the Biden administration has unclean hands,
- 4:33Speaker 2: which is a legal term.
- 4:34Speaker 4: Explain that sort of reinforcing I think the view of
- 4:37Speaker 4: Friday's intervention that this was really about the equities. When
- 4:40Speaker 4: a court is asked to intervene at an early stage
- 4:43Speaker 4: to either grant a stay or list to stay, what
- 4:45Speaker 4: is really supposed to do is balance the equities, which is,
- 4:48Speaker 4: you know, who would be harmed more by the two
- 4:50Speaker 4: competing rules we could hand down and by the two
- 4:53Speaker 4: competing sort of universes we could create while this case
- 4:56Speaker 4: makes its way through the courts, and as an exercise
- 4:58Speaker 4: of equitable power, it is by the idea that like
- 5:02Speaker 4: parties that are acting badly should not be entitled to release.
- 5:05Speaker 4: So one of his arguments for why the FDA should
- 5:08Speaker 4: not have been entitled to his day is because he
- 5:11Speaker 4: believes he maintains that the irreparable harm that the government
- 5:15Speaker 4: said was going to result from allowing Chasmerics ruling to
- 5:18Speaker 4: go into effects was at least to some degree created
- 5:21Speaker 4: by the government through its litigation behavior. In the other
- 5:25Speaker 4: myth Ofpristone case, the one that's pending in the Eastern
- 5:28Speaker 4: District of Washington and Spokane. And you know what's remarkable
- 5:32Speaker 4: about that claim, June is, First, I think there are
- 5:35Speaker 4: any number of ways in which Judge Chasmerics ruling would
- 5:38Speaker 4: have creative chaos all on his own, And he doesn't
- 5:42Speaker 4: dispute that. He just suggests that the government's argument was
- 5:44Speaker 4: about chaos as between the conflict between Chasmartics ruling and
- 5:49Speaker 4: the Spokane ruling. But second, the things he accuses the
- 5:52Speaker 4: government of doing are factually incorrect. He says the government
- 5:56Speaker 4: did not appeal the Spokane ruling. Well, that time hasn't
- 6:01Speaker 4: run yet. The government still has lots of time to appeal,
- 6:03Speaker 4: and I suspective will. He said the government opposed intervention
- 6:07Speaker 4: by seven read states in that case, implying that like
- 6:11Speaker 4: the government tries to prevent them from appealing that decision.
- 6:15Speaker 4: He doesn't tell the reader that actually the intervention request
- 6:18Speaker 4: had nothing to do with an appeal and actually came
- 6:21Speaker 4: even before the injunction was issued in that case. So
- 6:24Speaker 4: it's a remarkable series of claims, Dune, because it's not
- 6:27Speaker 4: just that they are in some respects hypocritical and inconsistent
- 6:31Speaker 4: with his own prior behavior, but he is based in
- 6:33Speaker 4: his arguments on students that are just not true, and
- 6:37Speaker 4: indeed on points that have plenty of receipts that can
- 6:40Speaker 4: be deployed to push back against them.
- 6:43Speaker 2: So what hit me the most when I read this,
- 6:45Speaker 2: What I found astonishing is this sentence. The government has
- 6:49Speaker 2: not dispelled legitimate doubts that it would even obey an
- 6:53Speaker 2: unfavorable order in these cases, much less that it would
- 6:56Speaker 2: choose to take enforcement actions to which it has strong objection.
- 7:00Speaker 2: I don't know where he got that idea that the
- 7:02Speaker 2: Biden administration was not going to obey a court order.
- 7:07Speaker 4: Well, I mean, I fear that he got that from
- 7:09Speaker 4: right wing media. But let's back up the second right.
- 7:11Speaker 4: I mean, so the unclean hands argument is why he
- 7:14Speaker 4: said the FBA was not enteled to emergency release. But
- 7:17Speaker 4: there was another party in this case, Danko Laboratories, one
- 7:21Speaker 4: of the two US sponsors or distributors of mister Pristone.
- 7:24Speaker 4: And Danko said, you know, hey, we're not the government.
- 7:27Speaker 4: We're just a company with the bottom line, and if
- 7:29Speaker 4: you allow Chasmeric's rule and to go into effect, our
- 7:32Speaker 4: bottom line is going to take a huge hit. And
- 7:34Speaker 4: Alito just sort of waves his hands and says, well,
- 7:36Speaker 4: you know, the Biden administration is not going to prosecute
- 7:39Speaker 4: you for basically for violating Judge Chasmeric's order. And you know, dude, first,
- 7:44Speaker 4: that's a remarkable position to take in the abstract that
- 7:47Speaker 4: you know, a company is not harmed because it might
- 7:50Speaker 4: not be prosecuted for breaking the law. Like, hey, company,
- 7:53Speaker 4: break the law, You'll be fine. Even if Danko were
- 7:56Speaker 4: inclined to take such a cavalier approach to the rule
- 7:59Speaker 4: of law. Danko has counter parties, Danko has insurers, Danko
- 8:04Speaker 4: has clients who might not be similarly disposed towards the law.
- 8:09Speaker 4: And so you know, even in the abstract, it's a
- 8:11Speaker 4: remarkable claim. But again, the factual basis for it is
- 8:15Speaker 4: just completely missing. So, you know, let's talk about who
- 8:18Speaker 4: has encouraged the Biden administration to ignore an adverse rule
- 8:22Speaker 4: in this case, Senator Wyden from Oregon, Congresswoman Ocasio Cortes
- 8:26Speaker 4: from New York, Congresswoman Nancy Mace, a Republican, we might add,
- 8:29Speaker 4: members of Congress. There is not only no one in
- 8:32Speaker 4: the executive branch who has even hinted that the Biden
- 8:35Speaker 4: administration would decline to comply. But in response to those
- 8:38Speaker 4: congressional statements, the White House Press secretary specifically said, we
- 8:42Speaker 4: are not listening to them. We are going to comply.
- 8:45Speaker 4: So when Justice Alito just says, you know, the government
- 8:48Speaker 4: has done nothing to dispel legitimate doubts, what else could
- 8:51Speaker 4: the government do and where are those doubts coming from?
- 8:54Speaker 4: And I think you know what's telling about that passage
- 8:57Speaker 4: in the opinion is that he doesn't cite any sources.
- 9:00Speaker 4: There's no authority provided in support of that statement. More fundamentally,
- 9:03Speaker 4: I mean, June, let's just be clear, it has been,
- 9:05Speaker 4: by almost anyone's reckoning, one hundred and sixty two years
- 9:10Speaker 4: since the last time a president the clients to comply
- 9:13Speaker 4: with a federal court order, and that was President Lincoln
- 9:16Speaker 4: in the middle of the Civil War as part of
- 9:18Speaker 4: the fight with Chief Justice Roger Brooks. Tawny, and I
- 9:20Speaker 4: think it's remarkable not only because it was a legally
- 9:24Speaker 4: irrelevant argument for Justice Alitos to make, but because the
- 9:28Speaker 4: only possible factual reason to make that claim is because
- 9:32Speaker 4: you are crediting conspiracy theorists in right wing media more
- 9:37Speaker 4: than your credit in the official spokesperson of the Executive Branch.
- 9:40Speaker 2: The Fifth Circuit is going to hear arguments on May seventeenth,
- 9:44Speaker 2: but it is the most conservative of the circuits, and
- 9:48Speaker 2: is it likely to change its opinion, which it expressed
- 9:51Speaker 2: pretty thoroughly in a forty two page decision.
- 9:55Speaker 4: I think it might. So let's be clear the panel
- 9:57Speaker 4: that only stayed part of the Judge Kasmaric ruler. First
- 10:00Speaker 4: it was divided two to one, and second June, that
- 10:03Speaker 4: won't be the same panel that here's the government and
- 10:05Speaker 4: Danko's appeals on May seventeenth, So you know, first it's
- 10:09Speaker 4: going to be different judges who are going to hear
- 10:11Speaker 4: this appeal. Second, these judges now have the benefit of
- 10:14Speaker 4: knowing that there's a majority of Supreme Court justices who
- 10:17Speaker 4: are not willing to let Judge Kasmeric's order, even as
- 10:20Speaker 4: modified by the Fifth Circuit, go into effect. And third,
- 10:22Speaker 4: as folks have had time to react to Judge Chasmeric's order,
- 10:26Speaker 4: I mean it was keep in mind, is even today
- 10:28Speaker 4: less than three weeks old, and as even conservative commentators
- 10:32Speaker 4: have chanced to weigh in, I think there's been a
- 10:34Speaker 4: developing consensus that there are serious problems with the plaintiffs
- 10:38Speaker 4: in this case is standing. So that whatever folks think
- 10:41Speaker 4: of mifipristone or the FDA or any of the administrative
- 10:46Speaker 4: law arguments that Judge Chasmeric relied upon in his order.
- 10:49Speaker 4: You know, this case has an enormous obstacle in the
- 10:52Speaker 4: form of the planet's lack of stand in. So I
- 10:55Speaker 4: don't think it is by any means a foregone conclusion
- 10:58Speaker 4: that the Fifth Circuit is going to ultimate affirmed Judge Kasmeric.
- 11:01Speaker 4: And if it does, I think all that will do
- 11:03Speaker 4: is kee this up to go back to the Supreme Court.
- 11:05Speaker 4: But if it doesn't, if you get a panel on
- 11:07Speaker 4: the Fifth Circus that said, actually, we don't think these
- 11:09Speaker 4: planets have stand in and so we reverse du Kasmeric
- 11:13Speaker 4: and we dismissed this case. I'm sure the planeffs will
- 11:16Speaker 4: go to the Supreme Court and ask the Supreme Court
- 11:18Speaker 4: to review that decision. I'm not sure the Supreme Court
- 11:20Speaker 4: will agree, and that I think Stuon is where we
- 11:23Speaker 4: might see, you know, more of the point you made
- 11:25Speaker 4: at the top, more of the Court recommitted to the
- 11:28Speaker 4: idea that it really wants to leave the question of
- 11:31Speaker 4: abortion access to the democratic process.
- 11:33Speaker 2: Steve, I want to turn now to another topic. Senator
- 11:36Speaker 2: Dick Durbin, the chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee, had
- 11:40Speaker 2: invited Chief Justice John Roberts to testify before the committee
- 11:43Speaker 2: regarding Supreme Court ethics. That's in light of recent revelations
- 11:48Speaker 2: that Justice Clarence Thomas had gone on luxury vacations paid
- 11:53Speaker 2: for by a billionaire Republican donor for decades, and also
- 11:57Speaker 2: that money changed hands between the two in this sale
- 12:00Speaker 2: of property. The Chief Justice declined the invitation. It was
- 12:04Speaker 2: no surprise that Roberts refused to testify, and he cited
- 12:08Speaker 2: separation of powers concerns and the importance of preserving judicial independence.
- 12:14Speaker 2: Do you think that was the only move for him?
- 12:17Speaker 4: Yes, If I'm Chief Justice Roberts, I am not voluntarily
- 12:21Speaker 4: agreeing to set a precedent wherein the Chief Justice can
- 12:24Speaker 4: be called before Congress anytime you know enough members of
- 12:28Speaker 4: Congress think that a particular justice has acted inappropriately on
- 12:32Speaker 4: the foot side, Right, a sort of an invitation to
- 12:34Speaker 4: testify is about the most milk toast bin that Congress
- 12:38Speaker 4: could have done. Right, there are far more aggressive things
- 12:41Speaker 4: Congress could do going forward, where maybe the Chief Justice
- 12:44Speaker 4: couldn't just politely decline, And I think this is where
- 12:47Speaker 4: I think the story really goes next, which is, you know,
- 12:50Speaker 4: we're not all going to agree on which rules should
- 12:54Speaker 4: bind the Supreme Court's justices. We're not even all going
- 12:57Speaker 4: to agree on whether particular behavior by particular justices violates
- 13:01Speaker 4: those rules. But we all ought to at least have
- 13:04Speaker 4: common cause on the point that there should be some
- 13:07Speaker 4: rules that bind the Supreme Court and that bind the justices,
- 13:11Speaker 4: and that those rules ought to have some meaningful peace
- 13:14Speaker 4: behind them. And this is where I think, you know,
- 13:16Speaker 4: the conversation ought to go next, which is, how do
- 13:19Speaker 4: we create a mechanism where the justices are impelled through
- 13:25Speaker 4: political pressure, through public pressure, through other mechanisms to comply
- 13:29Speaker 4: with the rules as they exist, and not just to
- 13:31Speaker 4: take such applause they approach And to me, I mean,
- 13:33Speaker 4: there's a bill that was introduced this week by Maine
- 13:36Speaker 4: Senator and Gus Kingdon by Alaska Center, at least in Murkowski,
- 13:39Speaker 4: I think this is a pretty good job of actually
- 13:41Speaker 4: splitting the difference. It doesn't dictate a code of conduct.
- 13:44Speaker 4: It says, hey, Supreme Court, you must adopt a formal
- 13:47Speaker 4: code of conduct, and you must create some mechanism for
- 13:52Speaker 4: overseeing compliance with that code of conduct, and whenever there
- 13:56Speaker 4: is a dispute over compliance, you must report back to
- 14:00Speaker 4: us on what the dispute was. That seems to me
- 14:03Speaker 4: not remotely inconsistent with the separation of powers. You know,
- 14:06Speaker 4: Congress can say, hey, we're going to give you ten
- 14:08Speaker 4: million dollars, but we're going to tell you what's spend
- 14:10Speaker 4: it on, and you've got to report back to us
- 14:11Speaker 4: on how you spent it. That's how the budget works.
- 14:14Speaker 4: And then jun then we have the real conversation, which
- 14:16Speaker 4: is whether any of these cases rise to the level
- 14:19Speaker 4: of allowing Congress to exercise the clear constitutional authority it
- 14:23Speaker 4: has to act against justices who misbehave, which is the
- 14:26Speaker 4: impeachment powers. I don't think we're there, but I think
- 14:29Speaker 4: we also ought to be willing to accept that for
- 14:32Speaker 4: the impeachment power to be meaningful, for Congress to have
- 14:34Speaker 4: any real opportunity to wield it as a check on
- 14:38Speaker 4: the justices, there has to be some mechanism by which
- 14:42Speaker 4: Congress can be made aware of violations of whatever the
- 14:45Speaker 4: rules are.
- 14:46Speaker 2: I didn't find Robert's refusal so surprising. What I did
- 14:50Speaker 2: find a little surprising was this statement signed by all
- 14:55Speaker 2: nine Justices vowing to follow foundational ethics, principles and practice,
- 15:00Speaker 2: is because it suggests that everything's fine. They don't have
- 15:04Speaker 2: any need for a formal code of conduct, despite what
- 15:07Speaker 2: we've been hearing about for weeks.
- 15:09Speaker 4: And I think what this goes back to is, I
- 15:11Speaker 4: mean something we talk about a lot in law schools,
- 15:13Speaker 4: the difference between having rules and having an effective means
- 15:17Speaker 4: of enforcing them. Right, you can have the finest rules
- 15:20Speaker 4: that any two humans could devise, and they would be
- 15:23Speaker 4: pretty pointless if nothing happened when they were violated. And
- 15:26Speaker 4: so I think the question is not whether the Supreme
- 15:28Speaker 4: Court should have a code of conduct. Clearly the answer
- 15:31Speaker 4: is yes. The Justices themselves even seem willing to bind
- 15:33Speaker 4: themselves to at least these loose principles that achieve justice,
- 15:37Speaker 4: Roberts attached to his letter. The question is what's going
- 15:39Speaker 4: to happen if and when those principles are violated? And
- 15:42Speaker 4: you know, I think the answer has to be for
- 15:44Speaker 4: the sake of the separation of powers more than nothing.
- 15:48Speaker 4: And I'm on the side that thinks that there would
- 15:52Speaker 4: be separation of powers problems if Congress claims for itself
- 15:56Speaker 4: the power to discipline justices who violate the rules, or
- 16:00Speaker 4: Congress gave someone other than the Supreme Court the power
- 16:03Speaker 4: to oversee compliance with these rules. At the same time,
- 16:07Speaker 4: the Constitution gives Congress the power to impeach judges and
- 16:11Speaker 4: justices entirely for those cases in which those judges and
- 16:14Speaker 4: justices are not engaging in what Article three calls quote
- 16:18Speaker 4: good behavior unquotes, and so it seems like it vindicates
- 16:22Speaker 4: the separation of powers rather than interfering with them, for
- 16:25Speaker 4: Congress to create a mechanism whereby the Court will police itself,
- 16:30Speaker 4: but it will also report to Congress on its efforts.
- 16:33Speaker 2: The Chief Justice also declined to investigate Clarence Thomas's ethical challenges,
- 16:39Speaker 2: shall we say, but he referred to Congress's request for
- 16:43Speaker 2: the investigation to the Judicial Conference of the United States.
- 16:48Speaker 2: Do they do investigations or do they make policy?
- 16:51Speaker 4: I mean a little bit of both. So the Judicial
- 16:53Speaker 4: Conference has at least some authority under a sort of
- 16:57Speaker 4: a nineteen sixties era federal statute, to engage in some
- 17:00Speaker 4: investigative functions, but that's almost always been understood to be
- 17:04Speaker 4: focused at the lower courts that you know, the Judicial
- 17:07Speaker 4: Conference comes in when there's some investigation needed of a
- 17:10Speaker 4: legend misconduct by lower court judges. We're about to see
- 17:13Speaker 4: this in the context of the effort by the Chief
- 17:15Speaker 4: Judge of the Federal Circuit to remove one of her colleagues.
- 17:19Speaker 4: The Judicial Conference is not set up at all to
- 17:22Speaker 4: handle investigations of the court, and that I think is
- 17:25Speaker 4: why the King Murkowski Bill is probably a much better
- 17:29Speaker 4: alternative to what Chief Judge Roberts is proposing, Because the
- 17:32Speaker 4: King Murkowski Bill says, hey, Supreme Court, you know you
- 17:36Speaker 4: you tell us what your rules are, and you create
- 17:39Speaker 4: a mechanism for supervising internally whether your rules are being followed,
- 17:44Speaker 4: and you report to us when they're not right. That,
- 17:48Speaker 4: to me is exactly how you split the difference. So
- 17:50Speaker 4: that in those cases where the rules are not being followed,
- 17:53Speaker 4: we don't expect the courts that discipline itself, but we
- 17:56Speaker 4: do expect the courts to at least identify the problems
- 17:59Speaker 4: so that if Congress, the body that has the conscertorsmal
- 18:02Speaker 4: authority to remove justices who fail to engage in good behavior,
- 18:06Speaker 4: wants to emphacize that power, it has been means to
- 18:08Speaker 4: do so.
- 18:09Speaker 2: It's always so great to have you on the show, Steve,
- 18:11Speaker 2: thanks so much. That's Professor Steven Vladika the University of
- 18:14Speaker 2: Texas School of Law. The Supreme Court justices seemed torn
- 18:20Speaker 2: about whether Congress intended to allow individuals to sue American
- 18:23Speaker 2: Indian tribes in bankruptcy disputes. The Court has long applied
- 18:28Speaker 2: a clear statement rule when Congress means to waive tribal
- 18:31Speaker 2: sovereign immunity. Chief Justice John Roberts noted that Congress has
- 18:35Speaker 2: never waived sovereign immunity without expressly using the term tribe.
- 18:41Speaker 3: Well, but I mean, the biggest hurdle I think you
- 18:43Speaker 3: have to get over is that they everywhere else they
- 18:46Speaker 3: use the word tribe and they didn't hear and they've
- 18:49Speaker 3: got a long list of other type of governmental agencies.
- 18:54Speaker 3: I mean, you don't have to be in the Big
- 18:56Speaker 3: four or Big five because they're I don't know. You
- 18:59Speaker 3: must accounted them like at least a dozen and surely
- 19:02Speaker 3: they're in the top dozen. So this is the only
- 19:05Speaker 3: instance where they haven't used the word tribe or Indian
- 19:08Speaker 3: when they meant to include them.
- 19:09Speaker 2: Right, But the Court has also emphasized that lawmakers don't
- 19:13Speaker 2: have to use specific or magic words to waive tribal
- 19:17Speaker 2: sovereign immunity. Here are Justices Elena Kagan and Amy Cony Barrett,
- 19:22Speaker 2: and I think that the difficulty for you is, aren't
- 19:26Speaker 2: you really making it into a magic or its requirement.
- 19:30Speaker 4: It's hard for me to say how that would be
- 19:32Speaker 4: a hard question for the United States or for a state.
- 19:34Speaker 2: So it sounds to me like you're carving out an
- 19:36Speaker 2: extra special, super super clear weg My guest is Ezra Rasser,
- 19:41Speaker 2: a professor at the American University Washington College of Law.
- 19:45Speaker 2: Ezra tell us about the facts in this case, why
- 19:47Speaker 2: it came to the Supreme Court.
- 19:50Speaker 1: I mean, there's been a series of cases where people
- 19:54Speaker 1: challenging the power of tribes want to undercut tribal sovereign unity.
- 20:00Speaker 1: So this is just another in the theories. I think
- 20:05Speaker 1: the thing that's unique, of course, on this one is
- 20:08Speaker 1: that it got taken preserved, and it got taken so
- 20:12Speaker 1: quickly after the Court had reaffirmed in Bay Mills that
- 20:17Speaker 1: sovereign immunity still exists. And so I think it's less
- 20:21Speaker 1: about the particulars of this case and more about the
- 20:24Speaker 1: fact that the Court continues to take these cases and
- 20:28Speaker 1: threaten to get rid of sovereign immunity.
- 20:30Speaker 2: Do the facts here make the Indian tribe look bad
- 20:32Speaker 2: because it involves payday loans and a man who tried
- 20:35Speaker 2: to commit suicide because he was being pressured.
- 20:38Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean the facts are terrible for sure, and
- 20:41Speaker 1: the way in which tribes have jumped into some of
- 20:44Speaker 1: these what can only be thought of as bad businesses
- 20:48Speaker 1: do look terrible. But as the oral argument made clear,
- 20:52Speaker 1: that isn't the real issue in the case. So, yes,
- 20:55Speaker 1: they're bad facts, but the question is whether there's been
- 20:59Speaker 1: abrogation of tribal sovereign immunity.
- 21:01Speaker 2: Explain what exactly is tribal sovereign immunity.
- 21:06Speaker 1: So the basic idea here is that they're a sovereign
- 21:09Speaker 1: and you can't just sue the sovereign, meaning the government,
- 21:12Speaker 1: unless the government gives you permission to it, and this
- 21:15Speaker 1: is true for all types of government. For a very
- 21:17Speaker 1: long time, the United States government made it hard for
- 21:19Speaker 1: people that were harmed by the United States that sue them,
- 21:22Speaker 1: and so people would do petitions to Congress to get
- 21:25Speaker 1: recourse if the government had harmed them or they'd suffered
- 21:28Speaker 1: some loss, and so tribes have that sovereign immunity as well.
- 21:32Speaker 1: And the question is if Congress, you know, in passing
- 21:35Speaker 1: the Bankruptcy Act, did they abrogate sovereign immunity with regard
- 21:40Speaker 1: to that area of law practice, right, But it is
- 21:43Speaker 1: a standard part of what being a government means is
- 21:46Speaker 1: you have this immunity.
- 21:47Speaker 2: I read that this case is one of the simplest
- 21:50Speaker 2: the justices here this year because it involves no constitutional
- 21:54Speaker 2: questions and the interpretation of a single phrase of a
- 21:58Speaker 2: single statutory provision. It didn't sound that simple.
- 22:02Speaker 1: Yeah, I think the challenge I would actually agree that
- 22:04Speaker 1: it's simple, but for a different reason. So the simple
- 22:08Speaker 1: part about it is that many times the Court has
- 22:11Speaker 1: been asked what counts as waiver of sovereign immunity, and
- 22:14Speaker 1: the answer has always consistently been when Congress is clear,
- 22:19Speaker 1: if there's an express abrogation, then yes, the rights are lost.
- 22:24Speaker 1: But if there's not express abrogation of a tribal sovereign right,
- 22:28Speaker 1: then it continues. And so here there's been no express abrogation,
- 22:33Speaker 1: meaning Congress has not said we are taking away tribes' rights.
- 22:38Speaker 1: Therefore the rights should still exist. So as far as
- 22:40Speaker 1: what the Court has done in the past. It is
- 22:43Speaker 1: a very simple case that should come out very easily
- 22:46Speaker 1: on the pro tribal side, but the fact that they
- 22:49Speaker 1: took certain suggests that it's not going to be that clean.
- 22:52Speaker 2: Also, I mean, some of the justices Amy Cony Barrett
- 22:55Speaker 2: said it seemed that Congress intended to cast a wide
- 22:59Speaker 2: net when described being government and dey susceptible to suits.
- 23:04Speaker 1: Yeah, well, definitely, that's what she said in the oral argument,
- 23:06Speaker 1: and I think for sure that's the argument against the
- 23:10Speaker 1: tribes on this The problem with that argument is that
- 23:13Speaker 1: that argument has been made in many cases in the past,
- 23:16Speaker 1: and consistently the Court has said, no, we mean it
- 23:19Speaker 1: that tribes are sovereign. And I think one of the
- 23:22Speaker 1: things that should be understood by everyone, at least under
- 23:26Speaker 1: federal Indian law that if Congress wants to get rid
- 23:29Speaker 1: of this power of tribes, all they have to do
- 23:32Speaker 1: is pass an act that says tribes don't have it.
- 23:35Speaker 1: But you can't do it by implication. You can't just
- 23:37Speaker 1: sort of infer that they meant to include tribes. And
- 23:40Speaker 1: this case really is about, well, if they use some
- 23:44Speaker 1: words that were not tribes, do those words count? And
- 23:47Speaker 1: traditionally the answer has been easy. No, the fact that
- 23:51Speaker 1: they took certain means that maybe we're going to open
- 23:53Speaker 1: it up to more light abrogation of tribal sovereignty.
- 23:56Speaker 2: Well, just as Elena Kagan said to the tribes attorney,
- 24:01Speaker 2: I think the difficulty for you is, aren't you really
- 24:04Speaker 2: making it into a magic words requirement? And that sort
- 24:07Speaker 2: of went along with what Barrett said. She said it
- 24:10Speaker 2: seemed like the tribe was asking for an extra special,
- 24:13Speaker 2: super super clear rule for Indian tribes.
- 24:16Speaker 1: Yeah, And I had two thoughts when I heard that part,
- 24:18Speaker 1: which one is I don't see what would be wrong
- 24:22Speaker 1: with requiring Congress to actually explicitly be clear that they
- 24:28Speaker 1: want to get rid of this area of sovereignty for tribes. So,
- 24:31Speaker 1: tribes are sovereign entities whose sovereignty pre existed the United States,
- 24:37Speaker 1: and we, meaning the federal government and the United States,
- 24:40Speaker 1: asserts a superior sovereignty over them. We say that we
- 24:43Speaker 1: have plenary power, we can do what we want. But
- 24:46Speaker 1: if we're going to say that we have such power,
- 24:48Speaker 1: we should at least be clear when we exercise it.
- 24:51Speaker 1: And so in that oral argument, I almost wanted them
- 24:54Speaker 1: to agree that yes, that's the point is that if
- 24:58Speaker 1: you're going to take away something, take it away and
- 25:00Speaker 1: be clear you're taking it away. Don't make a general
- 25:03Speaker 1: thing and then later ask the courts to make it larger.
- 25:07Speaker 2: I mean, did you see a split among the justices,
- 25:10Speaker 2: Which did you think were on which side?
- 25:13Speaker 1: Yeah?
- 25:13Speaker 4: I mean.
- 25:13Speaker 1: So the problem is, and this goes back to the
- 25:16Speaker 1: bay Mills case that was the sort of prior case
- 25:20Speaker 1: on the same topic, is that we might have thought
- 25:23Speaker 1: earlier that this case hadn't been dealt with through Bay Mills,
- 25:27Speaker 1: which was decided in twenty fourteen. And in bay Mills,
- 25:30Speaker 1: the court had a similar opportunity to get rid of
- 25:34Speaker 1: sovereign immunity or really weaken it. And despite guesswork that
- 25:38Speaker 1: they would do that, they actually came out on the
- 25:41Speaker 1: tribal side. And so I think this is a very
- 25:43Speaker 1: hard one to predict, because on the one hand, all
- 25:47Speaker 1: the presidents says federal Indian law requires express abrogation, the
- 25:53Speaker 1: tribe should win. On the other hand, you do have parties,
- 25:57Speaker 1: and we saw this at the very beginning of the
- 25:59Speaker 1: oral argument. You have justices who are concerned about Indians
- 26:03Speaker 1: acting in the larger economic space of the country and
- 26:07Speaker 1: are very nervous about sovereign immunity. Now they were in
- 26:10Speaker 1: the descent in prior cases, but the fact that they
- 26:13Speaker 1: keep taking cert suggests some of them think that eventually
- 26:15Speaker 1: they'll win justice.
- 26:16Speaker 2: Neil Gorsuch is often sympathetic to the Indians' rights in
- 26:22Speaker 2: these cases.
- 26:23Speaker 1: Where was he, I don't know, and I think we
- 26:27Speaker 1: have very clear the only one that I was like,
- 26:30Speaker 1: oh my gosh, this is clear where there's two. So
- 26:33Speaker 1: the really clear ones were Thomas I thought at the beginning,
- 26:37Speaker 1: and even the attorney for the tribes that we do
- 26:41Speaker 1: understand that some of the justices are not in agreement
- 26:44Speaker 1: with this right now the acknowledgement of that, and then
- 26:47Speaker 1: Amy Kobi Berrett, I think also was pretty clear that
- 26:50Speaker 1: she saw this, you know, big language used in the
- 26:54Speaker 1: Bankruptcy Act would incorporate all governments on that part. Though
- 26:58Speaker 1: there too, I thought this is weird because not only
- 27:01Speaker 1: have we had precedent on sovereign immunity Kiowa and Bay Mills,
- 27:05Speaker 1: we also have precedents saying tribes are not states, nor
- 27:10Speaker 1: are they foreign governments. And since that's what's listed in
- 27:13Speaker 1: the Bankruptcy Act, there seems to be pretty clear. This
- 27:16Speaker 1: was the first of the Cherokee cases. Pretty clear statements
- 27:21Speaker 1: from the Court when it first considered what Indians were.
- 27:24Speaker 1: They were very clear they are not foreign nations and
- 27:26Speaker 1: they are not states, which would seem to be what
- 27:28Speaker 1: the categories discussed in the statue were.
- 27:31Speaker 2: Tell us about the split in the circuit courts on
- 27:34Speaker 2: this issue.
- 27:35Speaker 1: So to me, that makes sent So one of the
- 27:38Speaker 1: things is that I think that the precedent on this
- 27:40Speaker 1: case is pretty easy. But the ask from tribes to
- 27:47Speaker 1: not Indians who are not familiar with tribal sovereignty, that
- 27:51Speaker 1: are nervous about tribes acting in the larger economy is.
- 27:55Speaker 4: A big one.
- 27:56Speaker 1: And anytime that there's a big ask, and the big
- 27:59Speaker 1: ask here is recognize our sovereignty and when push comes
- 28:03Speaker 1: to sup we can rely on that to protect us
- 28:06Speaker 1: against suit. That's a hard ask to make. And so
- 28:10Speaker 1: the fact that courts are coming out different ways is
- 28:13Speaker 1: somewhat natural. It's not surprising.
- 28:16Speaker 2: So in this case, the first circuit ruled against the
- 28:20Speaker 2: Indian tribes. So isn't it normally that the Supreme Court
- 28:25Speaker 2: takes a case because they want to reverse the lower court.
- 28:30Speaker 1: I think this is one of those that it could
- 28:32Speaker 1: be that way. I just don't know it. This isn't
- 28:34Speaker 1: might be very nervous, and I don't know how to
- 28:36Speaker 1: predict it all. When bay Mills came up, that was
- 28:39Speaker 1: the case that I followed more. And when bay Mills
- 28:41Speaker 1: came up, I, like many of us, were very pessimistic
- 28:44Speaker 1: about what the court was going to do there, and
- 28:46Speaker 1: they didn't go that way. You know, they almost were
- 28:49Speaker 1: apologetic in saying, like, we're doing this because the president
- 28:52Speaker 1: is such that we have no choice. This one seems
- 28:56Speaker 1: so in line with that. And it's not been that
- 28:59Speaker 1: long since they so I don't understand why they would
- 29:03Speaker 1: feel the need except to get rid of it. But
- 29:06Speaker 1: I could be wrong.
- 29:07Speaker 2: You hope you're wrong, right, Yeah, I.
- 29:08Speaker 1: Hope I'm wrong. I mean, clearly, the challenge on this
- 29:12Speaker 1: is that there's got to be a solution to people
- 29:16Speaker 1: that are harmed by what a tribe's doing. But it
- 29:19Speaker 1: doesn't have to be done or it shouldn't be done
- 29:22Speaker 1: by the courts imposing it in the absence of a
- 29:25Speaker 1: clear statement by Congress, and in many ways, tribes themselves
- 29:29Speaker 1: are likely to come up with solutions that would be
- 29:32Speaker 1: all to respect their sovereignty and respect the need for recourse,
- 29:35Speaker 1: like by people harmed by tribal enterprises. So I think
- 29:38Speaker 1: the question is do we impose that downward on tribes
- 29:42Speaker 1: without a clear statement or not.
- 29:43Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Ezra. That's Professor Ezra Rosser of the
- 29:46Speaker 2: American University Washington College of Law. I'm June Grosso, and
- 29:50Speaker 2: you're listening to Bloomberg.