Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #209 - Tzeporah Berman
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. This is Van Color. Hey folks, my name is Moomir
- 0:23and this is Van Color, British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show.
- 0:27We're kicking off season three with hot topics here in BC. Michelle Siso
- 0:32will be here to discuss whether or not our political leaders actually want home ownership
- 0:37or even rent to be affordable. Spoiler they don't. But first, coming
- 0:42out of the worst wildfire season on record, an increasingly louder chorus of Canadians
- 0:47want to ax the carbon tax. What good is the carbon tax if our
- 0:51forests are still on fire? To discuss, we're joined by an iconic Canadian
- 0:56environmental activist. It's been thirty years since the War and the Woods, where
- 1:00she was one of the key organizers of the Klackwitt sound logging blockades, a
- 1:04key voice in British Columbia introducing North America's first carbon tax. The international program
- 1:10director for Stand Earth, she is supporta Burman supporta What an honor, What
- 1:15a pleasure to have you on the show. Thanks for having me. So
- 1:18you heard in that intro A lot of Canadians and a lot of conservative politicians
- 1:23are throwing this question out there and saying, why should we be paying a
- 1:26carbon tax when clearly it's not solving climate change and we're still experiencing these worsening
- 1:34extreme climate events. What's the point of this tax? Yeah, it was.
- 1:44It's honestly so frustrating, and I think that it is. I think
- 1:49that it's terrifying in fact, that they're attacking a policy that will reduce future
- 1:57harms, that has lots of scientific and economic evidence that if we if we
- 2:00continue with carbon pricing and carbon and other climate policies, that we will reduce
- 2:07future wildfires, will reduce future deaths and evacuations. That we know that,
- 2:14and they actually know that too, and they're fearful additions being disingenuous. No,
- 2:20but you know, and the carbon tax has been a fascinating example actually
- 2:23because it at the NDP attacked it years ago when the liberals introduced it.
- 2:30Now the Conservatives are attacking it. Everybody before an election likes to attack attacks
- 2:34to appear that they're, you know, for the people. But it's absurd
- 2:38because right now, the public good depends upon us constraining carbon emissions from being
- 2:44trapped in our atmosphere, smothering the earth and causing climate change. There's a
- 2:49lot of evidence to show that the extreme fires that we've been experiencing literally across
- 2:54the country, tens of thousands evacuated, you know, literally millions of hectors
- 3:01of forest for people choking in you know, across the country and even in
- 3:07the US and Europe because of the smoke. That's because of the carbon we
- 3:12put in our atmosphere in the past, right, That's what happens. It
- 3:15gets trapped there, and it comes from three things. It's not rocket science.
- 3:17It comes from oil, gas and coal. Ninety of the carbon emissions
- 3:22trapped in our atmosphere come from oil, gas and coal. So climate policy
- 3:27constrains future emissions, so it reduces the impacts of those fires in the future
- 3:32and support. I understand that on a conceptual level. But when someone is
- 3:37facing, you know, an affordable affordability crisis at home where there is tough
- 3:40to make rent and buy groceries and the cost of everything is going up,
- 3:44and they're literally looking at every single sense that's being spent, how do you
- 3:47convince the general public that like, this is still a good tax. Like,
- 3:53again, on conceptual level, I think people can understand it, but
- 3:55when they're seeing that things are just getting worse, and even climate change preparation
- 4:00or adaptation is not where it needs to be. I can see people kind
- 4:03of throwing up their hands and being like, yeah, why am I paying
- 4:05this tax? So two things here. One, it's kind of like saying,
- 4:14if I eat this piece of k If I don't eat this piece of
- 4:15cake, I'm not going to be skinny tomorrow, so I might as well
- 4:19eat the whole goddamn cake. Well, it doesn't work that way, right,
- 4:25life doesn't work that way. But second of all, the BC carbon
- 4:28tax is a good example of a policy that has been designed in order to
- 4:32support low income families and in fact support all families. We all it depending
- 4:38on your income level, get money back. That's how the BC carbon tax
- 4:43works, and it was actually one of the first ones in the world to
- 4:45do that, to be designed to give a tax credit back to people,
- 4:48and to make sure that it was economy wide, so across all sectors.
- 4:55The problem is there's huge loopholes in the carbon tax NASH, so that the
- 5:00big oil companies are getting a free ride, so they should be paying more
- 5:05of the tax, and they're actually paying less than the average person. So
- 5:11Suncores carbon tax is probably about two dollars a ton should be you know,
- 5:16seventy dollars a ton. And it's not because there's loopholes in the design of
- 5:21the system. Because those companies are the most powerful companies in the country,
- 5:28and they lobby multiple times a day. They spend millions of dollars lobbying,
- 5:30and they get the laws weakened for them, right, And that's what I
- 5:34want to get into. I support this idea of putting a price on pollution
- 5:40or putting a price on carbon. However, where I actually struggle is why
- 5:44are we downloading the responsibility onto individuals while subsidizing oil and gas and fossil fuel
- 5:51expansion throughout the country on you know, we're subsidizing it on a provincial level
- 5:56and a federal level. So how is that fair? Like I can understand,
- 6:00and the opposition then when we were like, okay, on one hand,
- 6:01you're nickel and diming you know, Canadian citizens or Canadians, and then
- 6:05on the other hand, you're given a free ride to big oil and big
- 6:09fossil fuel in the industry. In total, yeah, it's not fair and
- 6:15we should be taking away those subsidies. And in fact, Minister of Gilboa
- 6:18at a federal level has committed to just i think last month, to reduce,
- 6:24dramatically, reduce and eliminate direct fossil fuel subsidies. That's great, by
- 6:29the way, it's not something the Conservatives ever did. So the Conservatives increased
- 6:32fossil fuel subsidies, so so you know, for them to say, you
- 6:36know, attack this government's policies is absurd. They gave more money, sure
- 6:43to the oil and gas industry, but we need to get rid of all
- 6:46subsidies. And it's it's become almost a crisis as the fossil fuel industries see
- 6:53the end of their sector because the dramatic uptake and electric cars, the renewal
- 6:57energy is now cheaper, far cheaper than fossil fuels at scale around the world.
- 7:01So prices have dropped eighty ninety percent for wind, for solar, for
- 7:06battery storage at scale. So now what we're seeing is a dramatic increase in
- 7:12renewable energy and battery storage, a dramatic decrease in the use of oil gas
- 7:15and coal, and investment in oil gas and coal, and we're seeing a
- 7:19huge uptake in electric cars, and so the fossil fuel industry knows their days
- 7:23are numbered, and so they're pushing really hard now to do more, like
- 7:29as much as they can right now, and to get more subsidies. So
- 7:32the IMF just reported that fossil fuel subsidies globally went up two trillion dollars last
- 7:38year, so it's now at seven trillion a year. That means that our
- 7:42governments are giving the most profitable companies on Earth thirteen million dollars a minute.
- 7:46Wow, in public money. It's insane, right, We're literally paying them
- 7:53to pollute and they have known for decades that their products are going to kill
- 7:59us. It's almost as the question, you know, it's almost as if
- 8:01the question should be, with all the subsidies that we are giving the fossil
- 8:05fuel industry, why is the cost of you know, filling up your tank
- 8:09at the gas station, why is that increasing all the time? Right?
- 8:13Like, that's almost the same question on the subolutely be the question. So
- 8:18last year, oil companies doubled their profits. In twenty twenty two, oil
- 8:22companies doubled their profits at the same time as the price skyrocketed at the pumps.
- 8:26Yeah, and we're wondering, no, these companies are gouging us.
- 8:31Yeah, and they're poisoning us. One in five people on the planet will
- 8:35die this year as a result of air pollution just from fossil fuels. One
- 8:41in five. It's the greatest cause of premature death on Earth just from air
- 8:45pollution, let alone the heat waves and the fires. These products are killing
- 8:48us, and these companies are doing everything they can to keep us addicted to
- 8:54them, lobbying governments for subsidies, bearing the science about climate change and about
- 8:58air pollution and desks. They're like tobacco companies were decades ago, but on
- 9:03steroids, because now they're just not polluting you, they're polluting your whole family.
- 9:07Right. We are now in the podcast exclusive part of my chat with
- 9:11the legendary SUPPORTA Burman's SUPPORTA thank you for sticking around. Yeah, no problem.
- 9:16I haven't done one of these long form podcasts in a while, so
- 9:20this is like some old school shit. I'm really excited. There was things
- 9:24that you wanted to mention in the televised portion about the carbon tax. We
- 9:30were we were discussing about, you know, some of the hypocrisies behind it,
- 9:35or you know some of the people like how we can fund the oil
- 9:39and gas industry on one hand, but then on the other hand, you
- 9:41know, expect people to pay the carbon tax, and then because of that
- 9:45we say, oh, the carbon tax isn't working. So I'll let you
- 9:48add on to what we discussed. Well, I was thinking again, you
- 9:50know, but you're comment about the conservatives say that carbon tax isn't working.
- 9:54Look there's the wildfires. Well, they opposed the carbon tax when it first
- 9:58came into play and have ever since. And if they hadn't opposed it so
- 10:03hard, if the oil industry hadn't lobbed so hard, lobbied so hard against
- 10:07it, we would have had it sooner, and we would have had it
- 10:09stronger. And the higher the price on carbon goes, the less fossil fuels
- 10:16people use, and the more that major institutions and companies moved to alternatives.
- 10:22If we moved to renewables, battery storage, electrification quicker than we make less
- 10:26pollution, we have less fires. So in fact, it's the conservatives and
- 10:31the oil and gas industry's fault that we didn't have a stronger carbon tax and
- 10:37that we have the wildfires we have today. And the other point I wanted
- 10:41to make is that the you know, of course how much carbon is trapped
- 10:45in our atmosphere is global. Ye. So if BC or Canada is the
- 10:48only one with a carbon tax, only one with strong climate policy, will
- 10:50still get wild wildfires. But what people forget when they make that argument,
- 10:56you know, it's about what China and India does, they're bigger polluters in
- 10:58Canada. What they forget is that leadership matters. Yes, And if you
- 11:01look throughout history, leadership matters. So when BC put in place our carbon
- 11:07tax and people in two thousand and eight, by two and fifteen, we
- 11:11had lots of data showing that it was working. It was working to reduce
- 11:15emissions, but it wasn't creating economic harm. It wasn't impacting economic prosperity.
- 11:20Interesting, and so that was written up by the World Bank, and a
- 11:24whole bunch of other jurisdictions started putting in place policies like bcs. So it
- 11:28created a domino effect around the world and supporting new carbon pricing in other places
- 11:35of the world. In the same way that when California put in a zero
- 11:37mission vehicle policy saying we're going to ban fossil fuel cars by twenty thirty twenty
- 11:43thirty five, and then other countries including now British Columbia and Canada have done
- 11:46the same and that provides certainty to the market. And that's why we see
- 11:52all these cool electric cars that are now becoming affordable because there were policies put
- 11:56in place where the market had certainty. Okay, let's invest in creating electric
- 12:00cars because now we know there's a policy that will require them. There'll be
- 12:03a market there in the future. Yeah. So it's like that leadership,
- 12:07that's certainty. It really matters, and that's why policy matter. That is
- 12:11such an important point and that's one that I've kind of used as well when
- 12:15people are like, well, even if we reduce our carbon emissions to zero,
- 12:18and it's like, yeah, but there is this idea of global leadership
- 12:20and if we are on the forefront, and you know, other countries can
- 12:24be on the forefront, then it will spread globally ideally, right, And
- 12:28that's all you're really in charge of. Well, yeah, that's all you
- 12:31can do is what you know, your contribution and maybe showing other jurisdictions that
- 12:37hey, this works, that's right, and every ton of carbon matters.
- 12:41So this moment in history, every ton of carbon that we save from going
- 12:46into the atmosphere will save lives. Literally. We know that every ton of
- 12:50carbon that goes into the atmosphere increases the heating. And we now have heat
- 12:56waves just sweeping the planet. Yeah, and they're killing people. I mean,
- 12:58people were incinerated in their cars in Lahnah. Yeah, they had no
- 13:03time because the severity of the of the fires, the heat waves there.
- 13:09There is a person dying in the Horn of Africa right now every thirty six
- 13:13seconds. Wow, it's insane. What's happening to the planet right now.
- 13:18Yeah. And and so to say that it doesn't matter that, you know,
- 13:22while other people aren't doing it, so I'm not going to It's like,
- 13:26it just makes no sense to me, like it this is this used
- 13:31to be an environmental issue. It's not an environmental issue. Now it's the
- 13:35moral issue of our age. It's an economic issue. It's a human rights
- 13:39issue. It's a health issue. You can't I peck analogy was so good
- 13:43though, That's why. But I think, I mean, I do think
- 13:46that there is a segment of the population. I'm not judging them. I'm
- 13:48just saying that with all our overlapping crises, a segment like I let's just
- 13:54say the whole population needs to be met with those with that type of thinking
- 14:00to understand it, because I can understand that if you are having trouble paying
- 14:03your grocery bills, or if you've been pushed out to the suburbs and you
- 14:05need your vehicle, you're dependent on it, you don't have the infrastructure to
- 14:09get around. You know, you might want to scrap the carbon tax,
- 14:11or you might be in favor of that, but I think grounding it in
- 14:13that logic of you know, it's the same thing as a eating a nutritious
- 14:18diet, right where it's like, yeah, this eating eating this piece of
- 14:22cake isn't going to make you fat or skinny. But is that something that
- 14:24you know constantly? Is that how you want to think about your life?
- 14:28But that's why I said that what I think what the conservatives are doing about
- 14:33the carbon tax is fearmongering. And I think that at this moment in history,
- 14:37it's immoral to use the carbon tax or climate policy as a political football
- 14:45to turn the public away and fear climate policy is the detriment of all of
- 14:54us. Right. And so the fact is that the oil gas industry for
- 15:01decades has been trying to make it our fault, an individual's fault, you
- 15:03know, the personal carbon footprint. That whole concept came from BP, and
- 15:09it was popularized by BP. Buy an oil company. And that's why I've
- 15:13been saying for a long time, this isn't just about your light bulbs.
- 15:16It's about laws. It's not about what you buy or what I buy.
- 15:22I mean, of course we should all try, but it's about putting in
- 15:24place laws and policies that make it fair, fast and equitable to decarbonize and
- 15:31move to electrification and cleaner, safer energy systems. That's what this is about.
- 15:35Absolutely, and so it shouldn't good policy shouldn't be a threat to those
- 15:41who you know, have to drive to take their kids to work and can't
- 15:43afford an electric fier. Absolutely not. This is not your fault. This
- 15:48is not it is not on you. It's on your government to protect you.
- 15:52Right. So that means we need climate policy that reduce pollution and put
- 15:56in place systems. Free public transit is something a lot of in in Scandinavia,
- 16:03et cetera. We're seeing way more subsidies to help people buy bikes,
- 16:07by electric bikes, even electric cars. You know, we're seeing some governments
- 16:11even providing heat pumps to get people off gas. Well, what are we
- 16:18seeing here? We still allow the companies to do things like advertise that it's
- 16:22going to be harmful to you to get rid of gas to your host.
- 16:26That's absurd. We now know that fract gas is not only creating climate change,
- 16:33but it's actually polluting your house and causing cancer. So so if you
- 16:38put it a heat pump and you put it an electric stove, you're actually
- 16:41protecting your family. Yeah, we still in Canada allow the oil and gas
- 16:45companies to pedal this these lies, and that's I think be my frustration is
- 16:53even the duality of government policies I kind of touched on in the televised segmented
- 17:00and you're talking about fracking. Fracking takes so much water outside out of the
- 17:03natural water cycle, and so on one hand, we are subsidizing fracking and
- 17:08encouraging you know, that type of economic activity. And on the other hand,
- 17:12you have you know, the government of BC coming on television, you
- 17:15know, begging people to take shorter showers and like turn off the tap when
- 17:19they're brushing their teeth, which is fine, Like that's good. Those are
- 17:22good things to promote, but it just comes off is so disingenuous when you're
- 17:27doing the exact opposite. That's going to completely undercut any collective, individualized effort.
- 17:34Yeah, and it's shortsighted. And the thing that drives me crazy having
- 17:41worked on this now for twenty years, is that there's so many great reports
- 17:45that show that if we move quickly away from fossil fuels, away from fracking,
- 17:51away from l en g, if we put in an oil, we
- 17:53put in the government the policies that are necessary in order to do that,
- 17:57we will have a stronger economy. Yeah, we will have less healthcare problems,
- 18:03we will have people will have more money in their pockets. And instead
- 18:07there's all this fear mongering and politics around the policies as though they're going to
- 18:11hurt you if you use less energy, if your house is more energy efficient,
- 18:17if the public transit is more available to you, then it costs you
- 18:22less. Yeah, and that's what we're seeing. We're seeing in California,
- 18:25we're seeing it in many countries all over the world that are that are further
- 18:27ahead at electrification and implementation of renewable energy and energy efficiency than we are in
- 18:33Canada. So yet we still have this conversation in Canada about how it's it's
- 18:40you know, something that you should be threatened by. Right, I want
- 18:45to shift gears here because I don't want to keep you here forever. It's
- 18:48been thirty years since the war in the woods, the logging blockades and in
- 18:53Clackwood Sound. You were a key organizer. You were in some ways the
- 18:57face of that protest. What is the legacy of those protests in terms of
- 19:03how they change the conversation around forestry in this province? And I guess,
- 19:08you know, how is that informing what we're seeing in Ferry Creek right now?
- 19:12You know, in some ways, before Ferry Creek and before the new
- 19:17satellite mapping that shows just how much logging is still going on in old growth.
- 19:22I would have answered that question differently, Okay, I would have liked
- 19:25to answer that question differently, like, thirty years after Clockwood's owned, we
- 19:30shouldn't be logging an evil growth anymore. It's so rare, and I and
- 19:34I'm and I'm really horrified that today, as we're talking, there are still
- 19:40thousand year old trees coming down in British Columbia and eighty percent, over eighty
- 19:45percent now of the world's old growth intact forest has gone on the planet,
- 19:51and the big areas left Canada, Russia, the Amazon. That's it really
- 19:56and those areas of intact and old forest are what maintained there. We breathe
- 20:03in the water, we drink right ecological systems. So, you know,
- 20:07Clockwood Sound in a lot of way, it was groundbreaking a lot of ways.
- 20:10It was groundbreaking because it was the first time that mass citizens stood up
- 20:14and said, no, hold on, not like this, and we created
- 20:18a conversation about where logging should happen and how logging should happen. It also
- 20:25created a conversation on indigenous rights right that was not happening before Clockwood Sound.
- 20:30The New Channels were the first first nations to get inter measures agreements. And
- 20:34it was in part because Clockwood became so big, so powerful, so famous,
- 20:38the government couldn't ignore it. You know. It was the first time
- 20:42that indigenous nations got the majority decision making. Was part of the final Clockwood
- 20:48decision when they created the Etok Forest a company and they got majority decision making
- 20:55control over their traditional territories. I think it was really the beginning of trying
- 21:00to understand what ecoforestry looks like and well, and of course the intact valleys
- 21:06still stand and it was it set the ground, created a model for the
- 21:11Great Bear Rainforest which came after it. And so I wouldn't say we didn't
- 21:15learn a lot from those protests and from the work that went on by the
- 21:18Central Region chiefs, etc. But I am pretty horrified that today we're still
- 21:25seeing old growth falling and the government has promised to protect our remaining old growth,
- 21:29promised to implement the Science Panel recommendations, and yet last month Stand daughter
- 21:34Earth, the organization that I work with, released Forest Eye, which is
- 21:38a satellite AI mapping tool. So when any company goes in and starts logging
- 21:45or road building in what's left of old forests, endangered old growth forests in
- 21:49British Columbia, we get an automatic alert and it goes into social media.
- 21:55It's so cool, you got to look it up. Stand daughter Earth Forest
- 21:57Eye. Anyone can do first time accountable transfer and it's running. It's running
- 22:03right now end of July. And so what we found out is that since
- 22:10the government made the commitment to defer logging of old growth three thousand hectares of
- 22:15old growth in the deferral areas have already been logged, so there's no monitoring,
- 22:22there's no enforcement. It's like it's either they're lying or they're completely incompetent
- 22:27on this file. I'm not sure how does that happen. We were shocked
- 22:32because what we thought we were going to be doing was showing the areas that
- 22:36they hadn't deferred, that are old growth that should be deferred. And then
- 22:41we realize not only is old growth logging happening in the areas they haven't yet
- 22:44deferred, but even the areas they say are deferred, there's old growth trees.
- 22:48So if there's logging in deferred areas, wouldn't that be criminal? Because
- 22:52it is like, I just don't like, why are they deferred? Then
- 22:56if they're still being logged, I'm very considered. Data came out. We're
- 23:00all very confused that data just came out. The government has responded and asked
- 23:04stand Utter to meet with them about the data we're pulling in all the scientists
- 23:08we've been working with, and you know, in some ways, it's the
- 23:14it's the it's the big moment, because they kept we kept going to them
- 23:17and saying it's not working. You're pilot. You keep saying you're going to
- 23:19protect old growth, but it's not being protected, and getting reports on the
- 23:22ground from this place in this place that old growth is still falling. And
- 23:26then no, no, no, And so now now we have the tools
- 23:29we can We have the satellite mapping tools. It cost a fortune to create.
- 23:33It took us a year to create it. But luckily we had the
- 23:36support of a guy named Dax to Silvas, you know, Dax Age of
- 23:40Union, really cool guy, and he was a kid in clack but two
- 23:42really inspired by it, and he contacted us and and and started a fundraiser,
- 23:49raised one hundred thousand dollars and here we are Forest stand Utter Earth.
- 23:53It's a really cool thing. So well you've just described I think, you
- 23:57know, it should be in any era. But I feel like in a
- 24:00past era particularly would be a scandal, wouldn't it if if the government has
- 24:04deferred, you know, logging on a certain area, but that area is
- 24:07still being logged, Like it just has the makings of either again corruption or
- 24:12incompetence, Like it should be a way bigger scandal than it is. It
- 24:17Really, it's really shocking and So why is that? Because I feel like,
- 24:19and please correct me, I feel like when the War of the Woods,
- 24:22it War in the Woods was happening, it was such a big news
- 24:25story. It kind of captivated the entire province, probably the entire nation in
- 24:29a sense, and I just don't get that same magnitude of attention with Faerry
- 24:34Creek right now. So why are people were arrested in Ferry Creek over the
- 24:38protests than were ever arrested in Clockwood's really okay? Yeah? And then Clackwood
- 24:44ten thousand people came to Clackwood, a little over nine hundred arrested. It
- 24:48was international news. There's I don't know the exact numbers as well, over
- 24:52a thousand arrested in Fairy Creek. Hardly anybody knows about it. It's it's
- 24:56very bizarre to me. And it maybe it's at over time, you know,
- 25:02you get immune to the shock because people are well, I know my
- 25:07own sons who are in their twenties, their cynics. Of course they're saying
- 25:11they're logging it and they're not logging it, and they are logging it.
- 25:14They were all their eyes, you know, they're just they you know,
- 25:15oh mom, we grew up with this, you know, they just I
- 25:18don't know, maybe we get immune to it. I think there is also
- 25:22the issue that there's less media coverage, there's less journalists, there's fewer journalists
- 25:30from back in back in the day, in the nineties, there were huge
- 25:33media rooms. You know, journalists would be on there, out there on
- 25:37the road. There would be you know, they had budget, they were
- 25:38traveling, they were you know, sending out camera crews, et cetera.
- 25:42Yeah, you don't see that now. And there was also a whole number
- 25:48of reporters in this province who were just forestry reporters. That's all they're reporting
- 25:52on. They knew their beat, they understood the issues. Now you talk
- 25:56to a reporter they're covering twenty issues a day. They got five minutes.
- 26:00They don't know any of the background. Well, that's why you're so important,
- 26:03because you help make it accessible for people. It's fascinating. So when
- 26:08we look at when we think about Clockwoods Sound and then we think about Very
- 26:12Creek, has anything in terms of the fundamental issues changed between these two protests
- 26:21or are they? Are they quite identical in terms of at least the core
- 26:26issues. No, I don't think they are. I think we are in
- 26:29a very different place today than we were thirty years ago on issues of indigenous
- 26:34rights and reconciliation. Thank goodness. I certainly have done a lot of learning
- 26:42and unlearning over the last thirty years, you know, we and it's complex,
- 26:51right, and it's unfortunately I think with this government the issue has been
- 26:56a bit used as a as a political football. You know, they said
- 27:00they were going to defer logging, but only in places that First Nations decided
- 27:03they wanted to defer logging. That's an absurd statement considering they never asked First
- 27:10Nations if they wanted logging there in the first place. So then you're going
- 27:14to these resource dependent communities, these indigenous chiefs and saying if you want to
- 27:19stop the old growth, it has to be you to say it. Oh
- 27:22okay, yeah, and there's no money on the table for economic diversification or
- 27:26anything, but you go ahead and tell all those guys you're taking their jobs,
- 27:30right, And so they put they passed the buck basically, So what
- 27:34they are what they should have done is the province should have deferred all the
- 27:38logging in old growth, like the Science Panel said, and then put money
- 27:42on the table for economic diversification and retraining programs and then consulted with Indigenous nations
- 27:49around whether or not they wanted permanent protection or tribal parks, or how they
- 27:52wanted to do it and where they wanted the lines to be. Of course
- 27:56it has to be done nation to nation, but to put all the onus
- 28:00on the indigenous nations to decide to stop blogging was a train wreck. It
- 28:06almost sounds like the province isn't that serious when it comes to saving old growth
- 28:11forests. I think this NDP government is not. Some of them are.
- 28:15There are individuals there who are, but but this is a government that is
- 28:18fighting itself because the NDP comes from a blue collar party. Yeah, there's
- 28:23a lot of people in party who who grew up in the forest industry.
- 28:27And and then there's also a lot of people in the NDP who are very
- 28:30green and you know, a kind of younger NDP who are you know,
- 28:34high tech, clean tech green and they don't want to be known for fracking
- 28:38and logging old growth. And so I think that there is conflict within the
- 28:42party on that vision, and I think the old guard is running the roost
- 28:48on this. On the on the resource stuff. But you know, the
- 28:51other big difference on between now Clackwood and Ferry Street, to be quite frank,
- 28:56is that is I think a little bit immune to the environmental crisis now
- 29:02because it's everywhere and it's all around us. I think it's the opposite of
- 29:04what we need. You know, there's so little old growth left. We
- 29:10are living a biodiversity crisis, a climate crisis, are really kind of shut
- 29:14down the earth systems that support human well being, and so protecting what's left
- 29:21of those old growth systems is even more important. But in some ways I
- 29:25feel like we're not We're not getting that, I think. And so there
- 29:30were a lot of people at Ferry Creek and it was not super organized,
- 29:33and the fact that there when I got there, I was amazed at like
- 29:37hundreds and hundreds of people from all walks of life just flooding there tells you
- 29:41that people care. And the polling shows you that people care. The majority
- 29:44of British Columbians support the protection of all remaining old growth. That's been consistent
- 29:48for years. So the polling shows you that people are there. But the
- 29:53coverage and the response, the lack of urgent response from the government is I
- 29:59think pretty shock. Let's talk about the coverage, and let's talk about some
- 30:03of the tactics that we see the you know, climate change action movement using.
- 30:10And specifically, what I'm talking about is I feel like every few weeks
- 30:14or every month or so, you know, we get this imagery of protesters
- 30:18blocking bridges. They've certainly done that here in Metro Vancouver. We've seen in
- 30:22Europe protesters vandalizing art and museums. Are these forms of protest effective because obviously
- 30:30they're getting coverage and you're sort of you know, putting that in the consciousness
- 30:34of the public, But at the same time, they seem to turn off
- 30:37a lot of regular people. And so in the battle of like trying to
- 30:41get attention back on these issues, you know, how do you see those
- 30:45kind of new tactics that we haven't really seen really at least haven't seen in
- 30:49a while being implemented. Well, Look, I think the bottom line is
- 30:55that if you're not terrified right now, you're not paying attention. And because
- 31:07we're living in a moment where we have only experienced less than a degree of
- 31:15heat rise around the world, Yeah, but we're projected to experience at three
- 31:19degrees and at three degrees, millions of people will die. Millions of people
- 31:26will die. There were parts of the planet this year that were so hot
- 31:32that governments told people they weren't allowed to go outside. Wow, weren't allowed
- 31:38to go outside. And in many of those countries, in parts of China,
- 31:44in parts of the Middle East, even in parts of Europe. During
- 31:47that time, the oldest people and the most vulnerable people died in their houses,
- 31:52they cooked in their apartments. I mean we had that here and well
- 31:56we did with the heat though. We had seven hundred people in Vancouver alone
- 32:00in forty eight hours. So this is only set to increase. And what
- 32:05we're experiencing this year with the wildfires and the heat waves, it's shocking and
- 32:08it's scary, but it was predicted. I could and promptly did say twenty
- 32:17years ago that this is what we would be facing if we didn't reduce fossil
- 32:22fuels, oil, gas, and coal. We've known it, so we
- 32:23know what ten years from now are going to look like. And they're gonna
- 32:27look even worse, and it's going to we're going to be limping from crisis
- 32:30to crisis, and what that means is food prices are going to skyrocket.
- 32:35Food scarcity is going to increase significantly, in water scarcity is going to increase
- 32:39significantly. So that doesn't look good. So these people who are out there
- 32:45blockading bridges and throwing tomato soup on art though it was on a glass covering
- 32:51the art to be clear, doing whatever they can to disrupt daily life,
- 32:57Yeah, good for them. Like I feel like history will look back on
- 33:02them and say thank you, thank you for knocking us out of our complacency.
- 33:07Because we all need to do whatever we can. And that doesn't mean
- 33:12that you you know, oh my gosh, you you can't turn on your
- 33:15heat or you can't drive to work. What I'm saying is call your politician.
- 33:21We have to remember we're not just consumers, we're citizens. Politicians work
- 33:23for us. Call your member of parliament, call your MLA, tell them
- 33:28you care, you want stronger climate policy, you want them to protect you.
- 33:30That's what their job is. And I think what they're trying to do
- 33:35is wake people up, and they're trying to to show and and and bring
- 33:42the stats out on how much we're funding the oil and gas industry and the
- 33:47science that our governments have signed off on. By the way, in the
- 33:51inter Governmental Panel and Climate Change says no new projects can fit in a livable
- 33:57climate. We need to stop approve moving new oil and gas projects and start
- 34:01ramping them down. Our government here in BC, in Canada they're proving new
- 34:07projects. So it's the UK government. So those folks in the UK or
- 34:10in Canada who are doing this, they're saying, look, no new projects,
- 34:14this is what the science says to keep us safe. Stop listening to
- 34:16the oil companies, start listening to us. And so yeah, and you
- 34:20can see how your kids are cynical, right, because it's like, oh
- 34:22yeah, the government will say, oh, yeah, no, you're right,
- 34:24like, well, we'll sign off on this, but at the same
- 34:25time do the complete opposite right and interests. Yeah, but there are moments
- 34:30in history where governments are unduly influenced by those who stand to benefit from the
- 34:36status quo. And at those moments in history, that's when we stand up.
- 34:39Yeah, so I say, dust off your placard, join them on
- 34:43the bridge, march, disrupt, do whatever you can, because this is
- 34:47one of those moments where we have to wake up our governments to protect us
- 34:52and not just to protect us from the flooding, which they should to put
- 34:57in place cooling centers so the next heat wave we have where to go.
- 35:00All that adaptation, absolutely, but they need to stop making the problem bigger.
- 35:05They need to stop allowing fossil fuel emissions and fossil fuel projects to increase.
- 35:09And you know, one more thing about the protests I want to say
- 35:14is that you know, I've heard a lot of people say, but you
- 35:16know, they block a bridge and it's really disruptive to normal life. Droughts
- 35:22and heat waves and fire tornadoes, those are disruptive to daily life. I
- 35:28didn't know fire tornadoes were a thing until this year, But as a whole
- 35:34point, that's what's terrified. Yeah, I feel like on a policy level,
- 35:39it does feel like cutting carbon commission, cutting carbon emissions is less of
- 35:45a priority or less of a discussion than it was. And again I'm talking
- 35:49about government policy, like they seem to be focused more on climate adaptation because
- 35:55people are losing their homes, because people are running from the floods and the
- 36:00fires and the and the heat. We need to adapt to a change in
- 36:04climate. We do. Sorry, well, I guess my point is are
- 36:07we are we beyond the point of our return Now, in a sense,
- 36:13every ton of carbon matters. That's the bottom line. Every ton of carbon
- 36:15that we saved from going into the atmosphere will will will save lives. It's
- 36:21we haven't hit a point of no return three degrees, four degrees probably no
- 36:28return that's right now, that'll be somewhere around twenty one hundred. What we
- 36:32do today will decide what our kids, what our grandkids, what future generations,
- 36:37what world they live and will it be mad Max and will they be
- 36:39limping from crisis to crisis and trying to find a safe place when the world
- 36:45is so hot that you can literally can't survive for more than five minutes outside.
- 36:52There's no safe place, right and and so that's what we're trying to
- 36:57avoid. Can we still avoid it? Yeah, we haven't hit you know,
- 37:00the tipping point moments where there's no way that we can we can avoid
- 37:05it. We can still And you know what, it's a it's a responsibility,
- 37:13especially for those of us who have privilege, who live in wealthy economies,
- 37:19who have the ability to make changes. I spent a lot of time
- 37:22this year in the South Pacific in Venawatu after two cyclones. I'm working with
- 37:25the governments in the South Pacific on a new global treaty to start to reduce
- 37:30fossil fuels, and they said to me, we don't have a choice.
- 37:36We're drowning here. We have we have no choice. We despair is not
- 37:39an option for us, So we're asking it to not be an option for
- 37:45you. Huh, despair is not an option. It's interesting because I feel
- 37:49like there might be listeners of this podcast after hearing you, you know,
- 37:54being informed, but then also being full of despair and being like, well,
- 37:59it doesn't like we're pointed in the right direction at all. So give
- 38:01me some hope, Give me some hope to end this chattel good because in
- 38:05fact, this year and last year, the world spent more money for the
- 38:10production of electricity on renewable energy, on wind, on solar, on batteries
- 38:16than we did on oil, coal, fossil fuels and nuclear combined. We
- 38:21are buying more electric cars than anyone ever thought. It's tipping the balance now
- 38:27if you look at those stats. We are living a moment where we are
- 38:30changing industrial society and it will happen. It is actually happening. The question
- 38:37is how quickly will it happen? And how do we make it happen quicker?
- 38:43But we are actually living an incredibly exciting moment and some of the statistics
- 38:49are amazing. But hope. Hope isn't something you can just have. Hope
- 38:54is something we have to create. We have to put it on every day
- 38:58and just say I think of it. I think of it like a jacket.
- 39:00I'm going to put on hope this morning, and I'm going to say,
- 39:02Okay, this is what I'm going to do. Hope is a responsibility.
- 39:07So regardless of what your job is or what you do, we should
- 39:12all be thinking, Okay, what can I do today? What can I
- 39:15do today to wake one more person up to the climate crisis, to put
- 39:20a little bit more pressure on our on my politicians, even just to have
- 39:22a hard conversation with other members of my family about how can we get involved
- 39:28or create something. Sure, because that we owe it to future generations,
- 39:34but also we owe it to ourselves. We we have to we have to
- 39:38see the beauty in life and we have to and honestly, experiencing doing something
- 39:45together with other people that makes a difference that you know is going to make
- 39:50a difference, that's really hopeful and it's really fun, and that's why I
- 39:53love where I work with the Fossil Fuel Treaty. People can find at Fossil
- 39:58Fuel Treaty dot org and also stand Daughter Earth, and we're running a bunch
- 40:00of campaigns and and we're making a difference supporta I don't want to go any
- 40:07further because I feel like that's a good way to end the podcast on a
- 40:10hopeful note, but also a bit of a call to action. I like
- 40:14this idea of hope is something that you have to put on every day.
- 40:16It's not just something that's within you. It is work in a lot of
- 40:20ways. So I appreciate that. I appreciate your honesty. I do hope
- 40:24people who you know, maybe are feeling full of despair or they're feeling cynical,
- 40:30hopefully they have a little bit of hope or hopefully they feel motivated after
- 40:34listening to you, because I think, obviously these issues are very important,
- 40:37and they are as much as much as they are globally, they are very
- 40:40local issues, right, So I appreciate your time. You got to come
- 40:46back at some point, you gotta do this again. I really loved it,
- 40:49but thank you so much, great, thank you so much folks,
- 40:52a local legend, one of the most influential activists INBC in Canada, the
- 40:57international program director for Stand Daughter supporta Burman, and of course I am Mohamir
- 41:01telling you that in a city where you can be anything, be colorful, peace,