Latest / DIVEBOMB Formula One Podcast / Episode 11 - Drama In Brazil
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to another episode of the Dive Bomb F1
- 0:02podcast. I'm Maham and I'm joined by my
- 0:05wonderful Co host, Marie and Rohan.
- 0:07Today we'll be doing a Sao Paulo Grand Prix review and just like
- 0:10the last few weeks, I certainly hope that you're comfortable
- 0:12because we have so much to discuss.
- 0:14I'm not going to wait much longer before starting.
- 0:16So let's begin. We're going to start in the same
- 0:18places every week and go back to a name that has repeatedly come
- 0:21up, especially in the last few weeks on this section of the
- 0:24podcast, Lando Norris. Norris, our current championship
- 0:27leader, was effectively flawless this weekend without putting
- 0:30even a foot wrong. I feel like it would be remiss
- 0:33for me not to mention the fact that in every single session in
- 0:35Sao Paulo, with the exception of SQ2, Lando Norris was P1.
- 0:39If you add the competitive sections of the Mexico City
- 0:42Grand Prix weekend into the mix as well, Lando Norris was both
- 0:45on pole and also the winner of that race.
- 0:47So my question to you both to start off with is what else is
- 0:51there left to say about Norris performance this weekend?
- 0:55Truly flawless to me. I don't think there was 1 moment
- 0:58where he slipped up, I just think he's reclaimed that form
- 1:02that he's lost and he's really standing in good stead for the
- 1:05next few rounds. Yeah, I think he's shown so much
- 1:07growth from last year and just his demeanor and his racecraft
- 1:12on the broadcast, they were talking about it a bit.
- 1:14But if you take last year's Brazil, where he didn't really
- 1:17perform quite as well, he was constantly on the radio of
- 1:22where's Max, where's Max, what are we doing, like needing
- 1:25excessive coaching? Whereas this year he really just
- 1:29took off and did his own thing. And I think it's something we've
- 1:34began to see this year and has clearly been working for him
- 1:37really, really well. So yeah, to see him really have
- 1:42a flawless weekend along with Mexico and really just put away
- 1:48all doubts shows why he's leading the championship right
- 1:52now. Yeah, I just want to pick up on
- 1:54what you were saying, Marie. It is genuinely, I think night
- 1:57and day between 12 months ago in Brazil versus right now what
- 2:01we've just seen in Brazil because it's I think it's
- 2:03incredible. He was saying that he just kind
- 2:05of wanted to drive off into the distance as well.
- 2:07And that's exactly what he did. Yes.
- 2:09OK. It wasn't as big a margin as
- 2:10what Mexico was, but he still got the job done.
- 2:13Like he was a decent enough gap ahead of Kimi Antonelli.
- 2:16So he got what he needed to and he got the points that he wanted
- 2:19as well. I also just want to add in very,
- 2:21very quickly, I didn't know this until I looked at the telemetry
- 2:24afterwards, but his lap in Q1 would have been enough for pole
- 2:28position as well. He didn't actually need to do
- 2:30the lap in Q3, it still would have been him on pole.
- 2:34Yeah, the natural pace was, it was definitely there in the
- 2:37qualifying as well as the race that I just don't think you can
- 2:40dispute how he's returned to form and it's just showing why
- 2:44he is or could be the champion, I should say.
- 2:47Yeah, it's great to see, especially because at the start
- 2:50of the season he was especially really struggling with
- 2:52qualifying. Obviously in 2024 he got polled
- 2:56quite often. He was doing really well and
- 2:58then just kind of lost that confidence at the start of the
- 3:01season. So to see him get that back and
- 3:04just get his consistency back is will be really rewarding for
- 3:10him. I think especially because
- 3:12mentality is something that we've spoken about so much just
- 3:14in general, not just the three of us, but in general around
- 3:17this championship battle in 2025.
- 3:19Mentality has always been something that everyone talks
- 3:22about for Oscar Piastre in comparison to Landon Norris.
- 3:24But this weekend especially I think has shown that the scales
- 3:27quite aren't quite as imbalanced as what people are making it out
- 3:30to be. He had, I would say, probably
- 3:34the redemption drive of his career so far in the sense that
- 3:37he put his foot to the floor. He had two clean starts because
- 3:40obviously there were safety cars and virtual safety cars at the
- 3:42beginning. He nailed both of those.
- 3:44He didn't crumble under pressure and he basically did everything
- 3:47that was required of him this weekend.
- 3:50Right. Especially when we think about
- 3:52last year, especially safety car restarts, race restarts.
- 3:56He lost the start going into turn one in Brazil last year and
- 4:00did it quite often last year even if he managed to get it
- 4:04back. So yeah, he's definitely has
- 4:08made an enormous amount of progress from last year and that
- 4:12shows in really every part of his race craft.
- 4:15I think the progress has been made, but I think I don't think
- 4:18it's been so linear across the season.
- 4:21We saw how he had that form dip and then it's come back.
- 4:24So I think in the long term, absolutely.
- 4:27But it has been this, I guess interrupted a part of the season
- 4:32where it matters the most. Absolutely.
- 4:34I completely agree with you. I don't, I think it would be
- 4:36really remiss for anyone to try and imply that this has been
- 4:40super, oh, Lando hit the floor or hit the ground running back
- 4:44in Australia and he won that race and it's just basically
- 4:46been full steam ahead because we've seen the complete opposite
- 4:50happen. He had the lead for four races,
- 4:52then it was basically the Oscar Piastre show in the middle and
- 4:55now he's come back into it. And I think it's perhaps even
- 4:58all the more impressive that it's worked out like this just
- 5:01because it goes to show when the going gets tough, he is able to,
- 5:05perhaps unlike what it was last season, this season he is able
- 5:09to say, right, I'm not. Nothing from the outside is
- 5:12going to concern me or is going to throw me off.
- 5:15I just need to drive. And that's how I'm going to
- 5:17prove that I'm I deserve this championship.
- 5:20And his progress is almost opposite to Oscar Piastry.
- 5:24Obviously at the start of this season Oscar had a rough
- 5:27Australia. And then had a really, really
- 5:31good middle of the season and is now seemingly dropping off.
- 5:36We've talked about it a bit. I don't, I'm not sure if it's
- 5:39just the tracks not suiting him. The car setup isn't suiting him.
- 5:44He himself is kind of worn out from the longevity needed for
- 5:49the season. But when it counts, Lando is
- 5:53showing that he has the form and to have any chance of winning
- 5:59the championship, Oscar will have to get back to his peak
- 6:02form. Because at the moment Lando
- 6:06Norris is showing that his peak form is debatably better than
- 6:11Oscar Piastres is. Obviously Oscar is won by
- 6:15margins before, but he's never won by 30.3 and I feel like when
- 6:21Lando is on his form he has a perfect weekend or a near
- 6:25perfect weekend and he's consistent from the start and
- 6:30hits the ground running in FP1 and really doesn't stop.
- 6:33Whereas Oscar tends to kind of build more throughout the
- 6:36weekend, which does work for him often, but he needs to be doing
- 6:40more of that if he has a chance to win the championship.
- 6:44Yeah, definitely. I wouldn't say the form
- 6:47difference is actually black and white, but with Lana and auras.
- 6:50But when he's on form, it's very obvious and when he's off form
- 6:53it's still quite obvious. So they're not as detrimental to
- 6:57his results. And you both have given me the
- 6:59perfect segue into introducing the next part, which is where I
- 7:02want to discuss Oscar Piastre because unfortunately he wasn't
- 7:05able to replicate the success that he was seeing from the
- 7:07garage next door to him this weekend.
- 7:10I want to start with the Sprint race because Oscar was
- 7:12unfortunately not out on track for the entirety of the 20 lap,
- 7:15a 24 lap dash because he hit the barriers and was forced to
- 7:19retire on lap 6 after qualifying in P3, which has been one of his
- 7:22better qualifying performances as of late.
- 7:25On the back of our discussion of things like mentality and just
- 7:28in general his recent run of performance, what did you make
- 7:32of the Sprint incident? I think for the Sprint instant
- 7:35it was more of an unfortunate error with the water that has
- 7:38settled on the curb. I think he himself and two of
- 7:41the drivers just got caught out by it and it was the
- 7:44unfortunate, costly mistake to me.
- 7:46Yeah, I think he had a little too much confidence going
- 7:50through the curb. Obviously as the track is drying
- 7:53up, you want to try and get that little bit more, a little bit
- 7:55more margin. But with Lando going over that
- 7:59same part of the curb and of course Kami also going over the
- 8:02curb and sloshing up that water, it was it was really just
- 8:06unfortunate. But yeah, I mean, there's
- 8:09nothing much to say. It's not quite his fault.
- 8:11And obviously we've we saw two drivers do it seconds after him
- 8:16so. Moving on to the main Grand Prix
- 8:18performance then I think the main thing to focus on would
- 8:21probably be the incident which got him the 10 second time
- 8:25penalty because I do believe he was showing decent enough pace
- 8:28and he was likely to have finished higher than P5 without
- 8:31that time penalty. In case you missed it, on a
- 8:33restart after a virtual safety car, Piastri tried to move on
- 8:37Kim and Antonelli who was side by side with Charles Leclerc.
- 8:40Going into turn 1. Piastri had a lockup which
- 8:43caused him to make contact with Antonelli, who then went in to
- 8:45declare, who subsequently had to retire from the race because of
- 8:49extensive damage. Now, of course, I'll get on to
- 8:51the stewarding aspect of the situation a little bit later on,
- 8:54but let's talk about the move that Piastry was trying to make.
- 8:57What do you think the rationale behind the move was?
- 8:59Was there a move to even be made there?
- 9:01And do you think that maybe potentially he was trying to
- 9:04prove something after the crash that he had the day before in
- 9:07the Sprint I. Think I think the move was
- 9:10justified but what made it worse is the fact that he obviously
- 9:14locked up into the corner which is causing that domino effect.
- 9:18But you can't. I thought this at the time.
- 9:20You can't go free wide into the first corner.
- 9:23It just lit. It never works.
- 9:25It can work in a lap one situation at the very start of a
- 9:28race but apart from that it never works I don't think.
- 9:31I think it was justified because Antonelli was also having to
- 9:34battle Leclair through the 1st corner who was going around the
- 9:37outside so I think it was just a late move.
- 9:39Then they cause a lock up and it happened.
- 9:41So I would say if anyone was at fault, it was him.
- 9:44I'd say it was absolutely kind of a move of desperation, and I
- 9:48don't fault him for it because you're fighting for a
- 9:51championship. That's what you should be doing.
- 9:53But to me, while it was a racing incident, kind of, Oscar just
- 10:01went into the corner way. Rohan does not agree with me,
- 10:06but Oscar just well it's a kind of racing incident but Oscar
- 10:11just went into the corner way way too hot.
- 10:14Which is. And of course Kimmy could have
- 10:16left him slightly more room but according to the rules he did
- 10:22have the apex. So he did have the corner.
- 10:25But going in too hot is what caused Oscar to break so kind of
- 10:30suddenly causing the lock up causing him to go into Kimmy
- 10:33causing him causing Kimmy to go into Charl.
- 10:35Charles Leclerc in post race did say he wouldn't fault Oscar for
- 10:40all of it, that he thinks Kimmy should have given him more
- 10:42space. And I agree to an extent.
- 10:46I think 10 seconds was too harsh.
- 10:49I could see kind of a 5 second penalty because the ways the
- 10:53rules are written are unfortunate because it can kind
- 10:57of not allow for people to make judgements based on the
- 11:01situation. But because based on the rules,
- 11:04Kimmy had the corner, I think Oscar should have gotten a
- 11:07penalty. But I think 10 seconds was a bit
- 11:10harsh. Yeah, I do agree on that part.
- 11:13I think he was justified to go for the move in the 1st place.
- 11:17Antonelli could have left a bit more space on the right, but he
- 11:20was battling someone else. So I think it was a former
- 11:23penalty, but I think 10 seconds was slightly harsh.
- 11:26I think they only did that peeling in the basis that it
- 11:28wasn't his corner and Leclaire and I don't get DNF ING because
- 11:32of what Piastre End are doing in the 1st place.
- 11:35I think if he'd only got maybe some sort of wing damage it
- 11:38would have been not as harsh. I just want to pick up on a
- 11:41couple of things that you've all said there.
- 11:43For anyone listening who's concerned about whether we're
- 11:45going to revisit this incident for the stewarding section.
- 11:47We are absolutely going to come back to it.
- 11:49So please don't worry about that.
- 11:50I think, yeah, I think the consequence of the contact
- 11:54between Oscar and Kimi, which then meant Kimi went into
- 11:57Charles. I think the fact that Charles
- 11:59had to DNF as a result of, and it wasn't a small amount of
- 12:01damage either, it was quite extensive.
- 12:03I mean his wheel came off and then there was, I believe there
- 12:05was steering damage to his car then as well.
- 12:07So I think the extent of it meant that the stewards turned
- 12:10around and said, okay, we have to deal with this as such.
- 12:13Obviously, naturally Oscar went on the radio immediately
- 12:16afterwards to say Kimmy didn't leave him any space.
- 12:18But even McLaren speaking on broadcast while the race was
- 12:22still happening about the incident itself and then the
- 12:24subsequent penalty said that we can understand why the situation
- 12:28has evolved the way the situation has evolved.
- 12:30So it I think it does make sense.
- 12:32Marie, picking up on the point that you made about it being a
- 12:34move of desperation, I felt that as well looking at it, Yes, he
- 12:38got P2 and he got the track position that he probably
- 12:41wanted. But also at the same time, when
- 12:44the penalty then came into play, it made strategizing everything
- 12:48around Oscar very difficult. And you could hear that between
- 12:51the exchange with Oscar and his race engineer then as well.
- 12:55So it's it's almost like balancing on a knife edge in the
- 12:59sense that, OK, I made the move and I got the position.
- 13:02But then also I now have to factor in this 10 seconds that
- 13:06despite his decent pace, he didn't have the pace to be able
- 13:09to outdrive something like that. So it just, it left him in a
- 13:12really weird spot, I think. I mean, the stewards might
- 13:15revisit this in two weeks time, so we'll have to see.
- 13:17I like the way we keep coming back to the fact that stewards
- 13:20can revisit things to in two weeks time with the three of us
- 13:24aren't going to let that go. Just in case anyone was
- 13:26wondering about that now, it's only right and fair that we
- 13:29discuss the People's Champion this weekend and move on to
- 13:32driver of the Day, Max Verstappen.
- 13:34First, let's just talk about his weekend overall, because if you
- 13:37were told me on Friday that he'd be driving from the pit lane to
- 13:40P3, I probably would have called you crazy, but that car just
- 13:44came alive underneath him during the race.
- 13:47Considering that even GP Max's race engineer was partially in
- 13:50shock when he told Max that he was leading the race on Sunday,
- 13:54what did you make of his weekend and how have the team managed to
- 13:57turn things around him in this, I would say very crucial part of
- 14:01his championship bid? I think that's only something he
- 14:04could pull off. If they told his teammate to do
- 14:08that we wouldn't be in the same boat.
- 14:10Really. I just think it was a magical
- 14:13thing. Maybe not as magical as last
- 14:15year, but it's only something he could pull off when obviously it
- 14:19was a real that he'd be starting from the pit line.
- 14:21It was pit lane. I was like, yeah, and I think it
- 14:24will be more than, you know, AP13 finish or something.
- 14:29It was just great to see as he would just rise up the board and
- 14:32they'd show that in the little screen.
- 14:34That's a bit too small on the timing table, but it was great.
- 14:38I just can't. I can't with this guy.
- 14:39He's too good. He's too good.
- 14:43I don't even know, but it was insane to watch, especially
- 14:47because in the opening laps he went from pit lane to I believe
- 14:51it was P16 or P13, got a puncture head to pit.
- 14:56Of course, it was under a safety car, I believe from Gabrielle
- 15:00Bordeletto's incident. But so he's at the back of the
- 15:03pack again, and then he just rises to the absolute top.
- 15:08And it was just insane to see. Which actually that puncture
- 15:12came very handily for him because he was on hard tires.
- 15:16And as we saw, the hard tires were not the tire to be on.
- 15:20But apart from that, which I would consider pretty minor, I
- 15:24think it's one of the his his race in Brazil last year was
- 15:30insane. It was crazy to watch.
- 15:33To pull off a performance like that was legendary.
- 15:36That being said, he was majorly helped by the red flag, and
- 15:40without that red flag I think it still would have been possible,
- 15:43but it would have been much harder.
- 15:45This was one of the one of the race, one of the first races I
- 15:50can kind of reference where he has that kind of insane
- 15:56performance from pitlane to P3, something that's only been done
- 16:02I believe 8 times in the history of Formula One without really
- 16:06the intervention of a safety car or a red flag or a yellow flag,
- 16:11like whatever it might be. He did it pretty much on his own
- 16:15and on the pace that the car was obviously do it.
- 16:19Whatever they did in that garage really, really, really worked
- 16:23because the car looked great. He looked super comfortable in
- 16:27it and obviously Yuki Sonoda finished P17 which ended up
- 16:32being last with all the DNFS and he got penalty after penalty but
- 16:37just in general looked uncomfortable in the car was
- 16:41just slow period. So great decision by the team.
- 16:46Obviously they had great strategy and Max, as Rohan said,
- 16:51just pulled off something that only Max can.
- 16:53I just want to say in my notes for the race, I've got it down
- 16:57that by lap 7, Max Verstappen was P13 and then obviously
- 17:01subsequently just continued to climb.
- 17:03Marie's holding her head in her hands at the fact that I've just
- 17:06said that because it is just frankly quite unbelievable.
- 17:10But yes, by lap seven, he was P13 and then he continued to
- 17:13climb. And I do want to say, just going
- 17:17off of what you were saying, Maria, as well in terms of
- 17:19setup, I was quite surprised that Red Bull were able to turn
- 17:22it around this weekend because it sounded like based on what
- 17:25Lauren Mckies was saying, because he was, he was on the
- 17:28pit wall with Sky this weekend. So they kept going back and
- 17:30forth to him throughout. They weren't making the setup
- 17:34changes to extract performance or they didn't understand how to
- 17:38make setup changes to extract performance.
- 17:40Apparently they had tried something with Yuki Sonoda's
- 17:43setup that they then replicated on Max Verstappen's car, but it
- 17:47was unsuccessful because they ended up both being eliminated
- 17:50in Q1 for qualifying for the actual race itself.
- 17:53So I guess my question is, is Red Bull now in a position where
- 17:56they basically just have to buy time and claw back points where
- 17:59they can for the sake of the constructors championship?
- 18:03And is that going to be enough for Max Verstappen's own
- 18:05championship bid? Or is it a case of they're going
- 18:08to have to almost put the constructors championship ahead
- 18:11of Max being able to win his fifth title?
- 18:14Unless obviously he can continue to pull performances like this
- 18:17off week in, week out? We'll have to see.
- 18:20I mean, actually on to what you were saying earlier, I think Red
- 18:23Bull will be able to climb back up the constructors.
- 18:27Obviously, we've seen how they capitalize on Ferraris,
- 18:30unfortunately showing it this weekend.
- 18:32So perhaps if they can capitalize on misfortune again
- 18:36or any sort of circumstances, they'll rise further.
- 18:39Obviously the Mercedes are bit further up the road, but it is
- 18:44always possible. They need to focus on Max
- 18:46because Max is really the only one that can show the
- 18:49performance. Yuki is a good driver obviously
- 18:53and can have decent performances, but a decent
- 18:56performance for him is like P8P6.
- 18:59So of course any points help because the title battle is so
- 19:03close, but in the grand scheme of things, it's really Max who's
- 19:08going to be pulling the most points for them and Max who is
- 19:11going to be went wanting to win his fifth title.
- 19:14Obviously at the moment it looks like a pretty distant hope, but
- 19:19it's absolutely so possible and I think he'll still absolutely
- 19:23be wanting to go for it. If I can go back to Max's race,
- 19:27something that really, because it wasn't shocking, but
- 19:30something I didn't quite realize was that before Saturday, Max
- 19:37had never been disqualified or like taken out in Q1 on pace,
- 19:43which was just like, of course he has like obviously Max
- 19:47Verstappen has had this extremely long, extremely, OK,
- 19:50not extremely long, but quite long career in Formula One,
- 19:55raced at Toro Rosso and Red Bull and he's never been out in Q1 on
- 20:00pace. Like of course, who else would
- 20:02we be talking about? There's no superlatives left and
- 20:09I don't even know what to say, but that was.
- 20:12Kind of insane to me to to realize that all other times,
- 20:18mind you, they're very few and far between or an engine failure
- 20:23or a penalty or a whatever it might be.
- 20:26But that was the first time he has been knocked out on pace,
- 20:29which also just shows the kind of limitations of the car at
- 20:32that point. I think Red Bull has gotten
- 20:35really good from going from Friday to Saturday.
- 20:37But of course when we have a Sprint race and we don't have
- 20:40all those pre practice sessions, something they tend to struggle
- 20:45with. So I think they need to find a
- 20:48way to kind of hit the ground running from FP1 and that's the
- 20:51way that they can get higher in the championship, whatever that
- 20:55means or whatever it in whatever championship that is.
- 20:59Yeah, and I mean, in the moment, you know, obviously when he
- 21:02didn't make it through, I was not as shocked.
- 21:04I was just thinking about how he made it 10 years without getting
- 21:07eliminated in but in Q1 and he's been in a Torro Rosso.
- 21:12So I don't know. That's what I was thinking about
- 21:15in the moment. You had it here first.
- 21:17That's got to be some sort of record.
- 21:20I I'm sure that, I mean, the last time he was eliminated in
- 21:23Q1 was Sochi 2021 and he was carrying a penalty then.
- 21:27So he didn't even set a time, which was why he was eliminated.
- 21:31If my research is correct, which I certainly hope it is.
- 21:34But yes folks, you've heard it here. 1st 3F1 podcast hosts have
- 21:37officially run out of words to describe Max Verstappen as a
- 21:40driver because he simply is just that unbelievable.
- 21:44Not even us. I think every single journalist
- 21:46in Formula One has run out. I don't think anybody knows what
- 21:49to say anymore. We need, we need him to start
- 21:52writing what he would like for us to say about him.
- 21:55I think that's the only way to move forward without repeating
- 21:58the same things over and over again.
- 22:00I am glad that we can talk about something happy because now that
- 22:03we've got the winners of the weekend out of the way, it's
- 22:05time to turn towards those who unfortunately had a less than
- 22:08stellar time in South Harbor. And I hate that I always do this
- 22:12and I hate that it always falls on me.
- 22:13But let's start with Ferrari. Let's start where we where we
- 22:17normally start for this section. Before I even get into that
- 22:20weekend breakdown, which seems like a pun I really don't want
- 22:23to make given their performance in the main Grand Prix, I just
- 22:26want to point out that this is their second double DNF this
- 22:29season. Their double DNF before was back
- 22:32in Zanville in August, which means they've effectively just
- 22:35been having a really rough time since the summer break.
- 22:37They didn't get off to the best of starts because they finished
- 22:40P18 and P-19 in the only practice session this weekend,
- 22:43and they qualified P8 and P11 respectively for Saturday's
- 22:47Sprint. They had these decent data
- 22:49collection and they both finished in the points for the
- 22:51Sprint, which looked like they were on for something really
- 22:54good on Sunday. But all that hard work was kind
- 22:56of undone after the early contact between Hamilton and
- 22:59Colapinto, which it eventually led to his retirement from the
- 23:02race. In the meantime, Charles Leclerc
- 23:04was an innocent bystander, as we've already identified in that
- 23:07incident between himself, Kimmy Antonetti, and Oscar Piastri.
- 23:12Now I'm a bit lost for words because it almost feels like I'm
- 23:14a broken record every week when I ask you both where things went
- 23:17wrong for them and what could they have done to have made
- 23:19things better. I imagine that these are the
- 23:21same conversations that they're having as a team as well, but
- 23:24nonetheless, where did things go wrong for them and what could
- 23:27they have done to make this weekend better?
- 23:29What didn't go wrong? I think that's the question we
- 23:31should be asking. I mean, the fact that Shawl was
- 23:35able to get a Ferrari into P3 during qualifying is absolutely
- 23:40beyond me because that car looked absolutely miserable.
- 23:44And I'm at a loss of words really.
- 23:47I don't know how much longer we can do this.
- 23:51We'll say next year's are is there a year?
- 23:54I don't know how much longer we can say this.
- 23:56It's not OK, guys. 2026 will be Cadillac, yeah.
- 24:01I honestly think there's a higher chance of that coming
- 24:04true than 2026 being potentially Ferraris here.
- 24:08Yeah, clearly we're all at a loss of words, but yeah, I mean,
- 24:13the floor damage that Lewis got from that move, which honestly
- 24:19just didn't look like a Lewis Hamilton move, I'm going to be
- 24:22so honest. It kind of just, it was almost
- 24:25reminiscent of Lando and Canada. He just like cooked it in too
- 24:30much and just hit the back of Franco.
- 24:32I was like, what are we doing? I don't know.
- 24:34Yeah. The floor damage was clearly
- 24:36just there was no way back from that after that point.
- 24:40Every single corner, he had immense oversteer.
- 24:43You could hear it on the radio. He he wanted to stick it out for
- 24:47the team, but he also just really wanted to retire because
- 24:50that car was so miserable to drive.
- 24:52And I think shawl too, I believe in post race.
- 24:58He did say of course the incident was unfortunate because
- 25:01he was completely just a bystander, but he didn't seem to
- 25:06believe they could have really gotten anywhere.
- 25:08A podium would have been a miracle really, if he was able
- 25:11to hold on to it. I'd just like to say in case
- 25:15there's any new F1 fans who are listening to the podcast, we are
- 25:18in fact talking about the same Ferrari who are the most
- 25:21successful team in the history of the sport, just just in case
- 25:24that was that escaped anyone's notice.
- 25:26But yeah, unfortunately this is the reality of the situation as
- 25:29it currently stands. And it does feel like, as we've
- 25:32said before, they go one step forward and then they go like 5
- 25:36back and then they go a couple more back and then they make one
- 25:39step forward. So progress for Ferrari this
- 25:41season has been relative and it hasn't been relative to any
- 25:44other team on the grid. It has just been relative to
- 25:47their own kind of standards, which is a shame because like
- 25:51we've said before as well, they have a stellar driver line up.
- 25:54Like they have two drivers who can extract performance out of a
- 25:58car. They've got statistically the
- 25:59greatest driver of all time as part of their team.
- 26:02He's joined on the knowledge or on the assumption that the
- 26:05project that they set out in front of him of being able to
- 26:08win an eighth title is something that they are going to be able
- 26:11to deliver on. And I think this year, like
- 26:14Lewis Hamilton said in his post race interviews, where he said
- 26:16that it's just a bit of a driving has been a bit of a
- 26:19nightmare in general this season, even if joining the team
- 26:22was a dream. It's just unfortunate that it
- 26:25hasn't fallen into place even remotely like what I imagine he
- 26:29thought it was going to be like. Additionally, in every year of
- 26:32Lewis Hamilton's, I don't even know, 18 year, maybe not 18
- 26:36Long, long 18. OK, 18 year career in Formula
- 26:39One, he has gotten 5 podiums in a season.
- 26:42Every single year, at least 5 podiums.
- 26:45There are three races left in the season.
- 26:48He's had maybe a handful of P4 finishes, maybe.
- 26:52I'm not sure of the exact statistic, but it's not much.
- 26:55I'd be surprised if it was 5. I'm going to be completely
- 26:58honest. Yeah, it's not 50.
- 27:00We're struggling, it's bad and I don't even know what to say
- 27:04because it should not have taken a Ferrari as long as it did to
- 27:09overtake an Aston Martin in that Sprint race, because that was
- 27:12embarrassing. I'm going to be honest, I was
- 27:14watching the Sprint race, I was watching Fernando Alonso P5,
- 27:18Charles Clair P6, Lewis Hamilton P7.
- 27:21We only ended Charles Clair P5, Fernando Alonso P6, Lewis
- 27:25Hamilton P7. Why?
- 27:27Why? I don't know.
- 27:28They should have been passed him nearly immediately.
- 27:32However, they're driving a tractor.
- 27:35That's all I have to say. Yeah, it seems Ferrari's natural
- 27:39habitat in 2025 is 6th and 7th place, with the old P4 in a
- 27:44podium for Charles Leclerc. It's quite dire right now.
- 27:47I was holding off a bit of Marie's right?
- 27:50I mean, what didn't go wrong? I'm scratching my head trying to
- 27:53think of it. The weekend was to speak in
- 27:57perfectly serious terms. I think they had like a, I can
- 28:02speak, I'm speaking Ferrari terms, OK, Because if we'd
- 28:05spoken like a whole grid level that they're like kind of
- 28:09falling a bit in standards. So they're like an OK weekend.
- 28:13But then it's unfortunate. I mean, Hamilton obviously got
- 28:17that damage to the T trade, which I think basically ended
- 28:20his when Le Clair's race got ended by the DNF.
- 28:23So I think it's just a black mark they just need to move on
- 28:27from and focus on next race in Las Vegas, really.
- 28:32Right. And then because of that, they
- 28:34dropped to P4 in the Constructors Championship.
- 28:37I mean, they're basically a midfield team at this point.
- 28:40I mean, I don't know what else to say because that seems to be
- 28:44the only true thing. I don't know where we go from
- 28:46here. Yeah, I think that it's, I'm not
- 28:50going to, we'll come on to the constructors championship in a
- 28:52little bit. I'm not going to say it's a
- 28:54foregone conclusion, but I am going to say that it's going to
- 28:57take a mountain. I don't think that that car can
- 28:59drive up to be able to move out of the predicament that they're
- 29:02currently in. Elsewhere on the grid.
- 29:05The stakes were high and I'm going to reel off some facts
- 29:07here really quickly so that we can discuss the ever exciting
- 29:10midfield battle as a whole, which it sounds like Ferrari has
- 29:13now entered even though they probably didn't want to.
- 29:16Yet again Williams, who were looking so incredibly dapper in
- 29:18their new livery, went pointless which although doesn't hurt
- 29:21their championship standings, cannot be a fun experience for
- 29:24either Alex Albon or Carlos Sainz in a season where they've
- 29:26been on top of the world at one point and then down in the dumps
- 29:29as well. For racing bulls who still have
- 29:32no confirmed driver line up next season.
- 29:34It was an impressive haul of points as both Liam Lawson and
- 29:37Isaac Hadja finished in the top ten and enjoyed quite a
- 29:39successful weekend overall with a car that showed very good
- 29:42pace, although Lawson struggled during the spring after an
- 29:45incident with Ollie Berman, which I will have to talk about
- 29:47when we discussed stewarding. The main Grand Prix was a much
- 29:50easier experience for both drivers as they qualified in the
- 29:53top ten as well. It was a decent.
- 29:56It was a weekend of exciting times.
- 29:57Apologies for Alpine as Pierre Gastly scored them their first
- 30:00points for quite a decent span of time I would say, and he even
- 30:04had his first Q3 appearance since Silverstone earlier this
- 30:06year. The car which seemed to come
- 30:08alive for Gatsby had no major upgrades and yet the Frenchman
- 30:12reported being entirely happy with the performance of the car
- 30:15on the reason that no one in the team could explain.
- 30:19So what did you make of the midfield performances that we
- 30:22saw throughout the weekend? I thought they were all good
- 30:25across the board. It was great to see the racing
- 30:27balls challenging for points and etcetera as they usually have
- 30:31been throughout the season. I mean that car has been better
- 30:35than the Red Bull second seat. I think I'm pure pace.
- 30:38I'm going to have to mention so to here as he was basically in
- 30:42the midfield at some parts. I just think if it goes like
- 30:47this for the rest of the season, there's a 0% chance to be on the
- 30:49grid next year. And as it stands, but I, I think
- 30:54it was an interesting midfield battles, although one, although
- 30:58the battle at the end, I think it was from P, is it P7 to P14
- 31:02or there was like a lot of battles they weren't focusing
- 31:05on. They had them on those silly
- 31:06little TV screens on the timetable.
- 31:08I'm sure we'll talk about broadcasting later because boy
- 31:12do I have some things to say, but I thought the midfield was
- 31:16really great. We saw eight different teams in
- 31:19the top 10 for the Grand Prix. Nicole Hulkenberg also got into
- 31:24Q3 for the first time in a Grand Prix format this year, which I
- 31:28was a little shocked to hear. Not entirely, but progress, I
- 31:33guess. Yeah, it was.
- 31:37I was really impressed, especially by Pierre.
- 31:41I don't know where this performance came from, but great
- 31:43for them fortunately if they have no idea how they got that
- 31:48performance the most. Worse than being bad and knowing
- 31:54why because it makes it incredibly hard to replicate it
- 31:58for the races going forward and for next season.
- 32:01So we'll see if they can find an answer to that.
- 32:04Airman also on an incredible run of form at the moment, beating
- 32:08out his teammate in P6. Ollie actually in post race I
- 32:13believe said, oh, it's a shame I got P4 last you can cuz then P6
- 32:18kind of looks like a normal result, but it's really good.
- 32:21We know Ollie, it's OK. Yeah, great result for Hoss and
- 32:26I was really impressed by the racing Bulls.
- 32:28I think it's interesting because they seem to have been through
- 32:31very much of like a roller coaster.
- 32:33Some weekends they're absolutely nowhere and some weekends
- 32:40they're P7 and P8 and do better than Ferrari, so it's on the up
- 32:43hopefully for them. But yeah, overall impressed and
- 32:48it was good to see kind of a lot happening in the midfield.
- 32:52Just very quickly before we move on to discussing the rookies for
- 32:55this weekend, I will just say that I'm not sure whether being
- 32:58better than Ferrari is a good benchmark to have any more.
- 33:00I think we we might have to move past this so now.
- 33:04Yeah, we might have to. Yeah, I, I think it's just time
- 33:07that we just accept that we can't, that can't be the
- 33:10benchmark anymore. I'd like to move to our rookies
- 33:12now because on the whole they had a very impressive showing.
- 33:15And I've said it before and I'll say it again until the end of
- 33:17the season when they're no longer rookies.
- 33:19But this class of 2025 is an absolutely incredible collective
- 33:23and I'm really interested to see where, especially with the new
- 33:26regulations next season, they're going to settle into position
- 33:29next season. For the moment though, I'm just
- 33:31going to reel off some fun and fast facts before I get your
- 33:34thoughts on the rookie at the end of On the rookies.
- 33:36At the end of the Sao Paulo Grand Prix weekend.
- 33:39Antonelli got his best ever race finish in P2 for both the Sprint
- 33:42and the main Grand Prix as well. In the Sprint he certainly gave
- 33:45Lando Norris a run for his money towards the end and defended
- 33:48wonderfully against Verstappen to hold on to that runner up
- 33:50position. In the main Grand Prix there was
- 33:52another solid drive from Ollie Berman who not only scored
- 33:55crucial points for his team but also beat out his experienced
- 33:58teammate who is also a race winner.
- 34:00Yet again, Hajar and Wilson brought home very important
- 34:03points, even if they did get a little bit feisty at the end and
- 34:06made contact with each other, which ultimately resulted in
- 34:08nothing because it was referred to the stewards and then decided
- 34:11not to be investigated. I also just before I want to
- 34:14hand over to you both to discuss the rookies, want to take a
- 34:16moment to just commiserate on Gabrielle Water letters weekend.
- 34:20It was his first home race weekend as an F1 driver for
- 34:25first and foremost, it was incredibly good to see that he
- 34:26was unharmed after his crash in the Sprint race.
- 34:29The impact was incredibly strong and it's a testament to how much
- 34:32safety is improved within the sport.
- 34:34I have no doubt in the career that he's bound to have, whether
- 34:37it's with the team that he's out right now or any other team,
- 34:39he'll have more successful home race weekend.
- 34:41But it was really good to see that he emerged completely
- 34:43unharmed and ready to go in qualifying only a couple of
- 34:46hours later, because I think that that's just incredibly
- 34:49impressive. But yes, your thoughts on the
- 34:51rookies this weekend? I thought all the rookies were
- 34:54quite good, as you said, Bam, and that points tally for him
- 34:58this weekend was very good. Both let's I'd say the crash was
- 35:01like, I don't think I've been that scared of a crash for at
- 35:04least five years. I think it was a good doing
- 35:09thing where he had the DRS flap open at the wrong time and it
- 35:14basically caused him to go into the barrier.
- 35:16I think that was the reason. But generally for the rookies
- 35:19across the market, I think a strong showing from most of.
- 35:22Them, yeah, I mean whatever, whatever book can you whatever
- 35:25set up biography Kimi was reading before the weekend.
- 35:28I think everybody needs to buy a copy if it because he went
- 35:32P2P2P2P2. He was just incredibly
- 35:35consistent and it was amazing to see.
- 35:40Same with Behrman, he did quite well through the whole weekend.
- 35:44It almost looked like he was about to get pull at some point
- 35:48in qualifying, which would have been great, but Lando Norris had
- 35:53to get his perfect weekend. Isaac and Liam obviously did a
- 35:59great job in P7 and P8. And I mean, just echoing what
- 36:04Rohan said, very unfortunate for Porto Leto.
- 36:10And I mean, that crash was insane.
- 36:15I think he had two points of kind of impact.
- 36:19And I think combined it added up to over 90 G of force.
- 36:25And obviously that second impact was 57 GS.
- 36:29So to see him running to the team garage a few minutes later
- 36:35is just a testament to how good safety has gotten because 20
- 36:41years ago, I'd be shocked if someone walked out of that.
- 36:45So while the crash was incredibly scary, it's was great
- 36:53to see that he was completely unharmed pretty much.
- 36:55I mean, I'm sure he has some concussion or something like
- 36:59that just from like the whiplash, but to see him be
- 37:04pretty much OK and like ready to go, it was very great to see.
- 37:08Although he obviously was very it was just very unfortunate
- 37:11that he was hit by Stroll on. Not even it wasn't even that he
- 37:17finished at the back. It was that he didn't even get
- 37:19to race, which was really unfortunate.
- 37:22But as you said, Maham, I'm sure he'll have other weekends with
- 37:27the team going Audi next year. I'm sure they'll have better
- 37:29performances at him his home race, but.
- 37:33Yeah, just adding on the rookies with Antonelli, I've seen an
- 37:36interesting post on social media about when there's a in
- 37:40countries on the calendar where there's some specific food
- 37:43additive. I think.
- 37:44I think, yeah, you've seen this as well.
- 37:47There's like a specific food additive.
- 37:49He always seems to succeed, which I thought was an
- 37:52interesting one. This is a huge aside to what I
- 37:55was planning on talking about next.
- 37:56But yes, this theory I have been seeing basically since the
- 37:59beginning of the season and I thought surely at one point
- 38:03something's going to break this trend and it hasn't so far.
- 38:06We've got three races remaining in the season.
- 38:08So I'm really interested to see whether this is something that
- 38:11is going to continue until the checkered flag flag in Abu Dhabi
- 38:14or whether this is something that obviously is just has been
- 38:17a little bit of fun throughout 2025.
- 38:20But yes, on a more serious note, I'm very interested to see if
- 38:23Kimmy Antonelli can continue this good run of form.
- 38:25He's been locked in effectively since his contract announcement
- 38:30and everything after that. He has just again put his foot
- 38:34to the floor and said, if they're giving me this Mercedes
- 38:36seat, I'm going to prove that I deserve this seat.
- 38:39And I'm going to basically silence all the naysayers who
- 38:42believe that I'm too young or too inexperienced to be at a
- 38:45team of this caliber. And obviously, depending on how
- 38:48Mercedes treat the 2026 regulations or how the 2026
- 38:51regulations treat Mercedes, I'm very interested to see what he
- 38:55could potentially do in a championship contending car.
- 38:59Right. He was the 3rd youngest GP Front
- 39:02row qualifier behind Lance Stroll and Max Verstappen.
- 39:06He has scored more points than Oscar Piastry since Azerbaijan
- 39:11unfortunate for Oscars championship bid and he
- 39:15surpassed Lewis Hamilton and rookie points which correct me
- 39:19if I'm wrong, I believe they had a different point system in
- 39:212008, yes. They did, yes.
- 39:24Yes, they did. Still, to have a rookie season
- 39:29like that, while there's been many ups and downs, is very
- 39:32impressive. Incredibly so.
- 39:35Now the situation has simultaneously changed but also
- 39:38not changed in the World Drivers Championship.
- 39:40And so this is what I'm going to turn to next mathematically, and
- 39:44I do have to say that I didn't work this out myself, so I do
- 39:47apologize if there's any mistakes in this.
- 39:48I do believe that Lando Norris could steal the title as soon as
- 39:52Qatar, which funnily enough would also be the race weekend
- 39:55where he becomes the McLaren driver with the most appearances
- 39:59for the team as well. So my question to you both is,
- 40:02without potentially jinxing anything for Lando and obviously
- 40:04the good run that he's been on so far in terms of performance,
- 40:07is this now just full steam ahead for him in these final
- 40:10three rounds of the season? I mean, it has to be and it has
- 40:13to be for every driver really, no matter where they are in the
- 40:16championship, but especially for him, especially for Oscar
- 40:19Piastre, especially for Max Verstappen.
- 40:22I think at this moment it will be difficult for Oscar to come
- 40:25back. Not impossible by any means, but
- 40:28difficult without any kind of Norris retirement, which we saw
- 40:34it in Las Vegas last year. So it's definitely possible.
- 40:40But I think he said it throughout the weekend.
- 40:44But he really just needs to keep his head down and keep driving
- 40:47as he has been and really just block everything out except for
- 40:52his race engineers and yeah, as you said, full steam ahead.
- 40:57Yeah, we'll have to see. I mean as a very same full steam
- 41:00ahead and I second those words. I do just also want to say in
- 41:03terms of looking at Oscar Piastri's current stance in the
- 41:07championship, and again, I do apologize if my math's incorrect
- 41:10here, but if he's not within 20.25 points of Norris by Qatar,
- 41:14he's actually, I do believe mathematically out of contention
- 41:16for the title, Then obviously there's plenty of opportunities
- 41:19to score those required points and there's a Sprint coming up.
- 41:23There's obviously three races then as well.
- 41:25So there's a lot of opportunity for these points, but it is
- 41:28slowly. Obviously the gap is now 24
- 41:30points. That's almost an entire race
- 41:32win. So you're not only banking on
- 41:34potentially Norris not being able to score points, IE
- 41:36finishing outside of the top 10 or not finishing a race
- 41:39altogether, There also has to be the consideration that that
- 41:41means Oscar has to be on the top step of the podium.
- 41:44He hasn't actually been on the podium since, if my memory
- 41:47serves correctly, since Italy. So it's been, it's been a while.
- 41:51It's been too long. It yeah, it's been, it's been a
- 41:54very, very long time. And I simultaneously understand
- 41:58that it's been a long time. But also when I saw that
- 42:00statistic that it has been since Monza, I was a bit shocked by
- 42:04that. Unless, of course, I'm entirely
- 42:07wrong, in which case I have embarrassed.
- 42:10No, you're absolutely, you're absolutely correct.
- 42:12I no, I had to look it up because it's, it was shocking,
- 42:17really. It's, I mean, that's kind of
- 42:20insane to me. Yeah.
- 42:22I think it's been nearly two months since he scored a podium.
- 42:26So and even that it was AP3, like it wasn't any sort of
- 42:32domination or anything. It was P3, which obviously still
- 42:35podium, but maybe not the result Oscar always wants.
- 42:39Yeah. And I think also, I just want to
- 42:41go back and say, obviously we have spent a lot of time talking
- 42:44about Verstappen swing in the championship standings, him
- 42:47making up. I think it was something like 68
- 42:49or 69 points in the space of like 5 race weekends.
- 42:53Lando Norris did that with I believe it was either 57 or 58
- 42:57points in the course of five race weekends as well.
- 42:59So you've had the change in championship standings, the
- 43:03margins becoming smaller has obviously been contributed
- 43:06towards by a lot of things. It's been really good form on
- 43:09behalf of Verstappen and Norris. And then unfortunately it's also
- 43:11been a loss of form on Piastre's behalf.
- 43:14So I think, like I said when I initially asked the question
- 43:17you, you've simultaneously had a lot of change and also no change
- 43:21at all because on paper it just looks like Oscar and Lando have
- 43:24swapped places. But obviously there's been a lot
- 43:26more that's happened that's contributed to that then as
- 43:29well. Yeah, I mean, the gaps really do
- 43:33change a lot, don't they? I mean, we thought that Max
- 43:35Verstappen was out of the championship and here we are.
- 43:39We'd said obviously before our past episodes.
- 43:42On the topic of championships, I'd like to briefly again go
- 43:44back to the discussion we were having of the battle for 2nd and
- 43:47the Constructors Championship because Ferrari have now been
- 43:51leapfrogged by both Mercedes and Red Bull.
- 43:53It's no doubt that Ferrari, like we were discussing earlier, have
- 43:57had a season of effectively day and night and they haven't even
- 44:00been able to pull anything together to be able to win a
- 44:03race this season, which I think is probably the biggest, I
- 44:06suppose, headline about how bad it has been for them.
- 44:10What are your thoughts on Ferrari being able to match the
- 44:13finishing position in the constructors championship that
- 44:15they had in 2024? Is it a likelihood?
- 44:17And if you don't think that it's going to be them who finish in
- 44:20second, which of Ferrari, which of Mercedes and Red Bull do you
- 44:25see replacing them? I think with Ferrari at this
- 44:28point, you just got to get to the end of the season and what
- 44:30no matter what, you know. But I think if they can have
- 44:35some form and just maintain consistency, I think it is a
- 44:39possibility. Although if they slip up again
- 44:43in this way, whether it's their fault or not, I think it may
- 44:46still their fame with the other teams.
- 44:48It's possible. I mean Red Bull, if they can
- 44:51focus on Max and what he can do then they'll be challenging for
- 44:55the better spot and Mercedes are just need to keep doing what
- 44:58they're doing and they'll be fine.
- 45:00Mercedes, I think, have a strong chance of being P2.
- 45:04Of course, they've been quite strong in Vegas in past years,
- 45:08so that will be promising for them.
- 45:10Qatar, maybe not as much, but they've been terrible in Abu
- 45:14Dhabi from my memory. So I think they have races that
- 45:19they know they can do decent at to keep their kind of
- 45:23championship. And I mean, like last year, Red
- 45:27Bull is essentially A1 car team, unfortunately for Yuki Sonoda
- 45:32and Ferrari. Yeah, I mean, Charles said this
- 45:36too at the end of the weekend. He doesn't really have much hope
- 45:41for the end of this season. He doesn't really see any any
- 45:45big results coming for them. So, as Rohan said, it's just
- 45:49they need to get to the end of the season.
- 45:51Ended the season with two cars intact and hopefully no more
- 45:54entanglements with anyone else. I do think on the topic of
- 45:57Mercedes in Vegas particularly, obviously the Mercedes thrives
- 46:01in colder conditions. Obviously this weekend in Sao
- 46:04Paulo, it was cloudy, it was overcast, which brought track
- 46:07temperature down. So they were able to do really
- 46:09well. Canada earlier this season where
- 46:11George Russell one, obviously, again, very similar conditions.
- 46:14Singapore where George Russell 1 is a bit more of an outlier.
- 46:17But I think there were obviously just different things that were
- 46:19happening that weekend that contributed to that result.
- 46:21Vegas is notorious to be a cold race, so I think it we're on for
- 46:25a good Mercedes showing that which can, depending on what the
- 46:29performance is actually like, really swing the championship in
- 46:32their favour. So we'll have to wait and see
- 46:35for the next race weekend, which will be in Vegas, as much as I
- 46:40could spend another hour discussing both of those races,
- 46:42the Sprint and the main Grand Prix, which probably has to be
- 46:45the most exciting combination of races that we've had so far this
- 46:48season. There's a few headlines in the
- 46:50world around on track action that I'd like to turn to next.
- 46:53Now, I know that we've discussed a lot of incidents throughout
- 46:56the race, even if we couldn't cover them all, but there's a
- 46:58few in particular that were referred to the stewards both in
- 47:01the Sprint and the main Grand Prix.
- 47:03So this is what I'm going to come to next.
- 47:06Of course I am does start with the Sprint and the event between
- 47:10Oddie Berman and Liam Lawson. What was your take on not only
- 47:13the incident, but the penalties that came out of the incident
- 47:16and the order in which they were released in as well?
- 47:19I mean, I don't have a million thoughts about it, but I think
- 47:25IO said it at some point in the weekend that he didn't quite
- 47:32agree with it. And it's another penalty point
- 47:35for Ollie Berman, I believe. So at the moment I believe he's
- 47:39won away from a race ban. So hopefully, really my only
- 47:42hope is that he can pull it out to the end of the season and
- 47:45just stay out of everybody's way.
- 47:49Of course he can't. He shouldn't be driving
- 47:52incredibly defensively because that leads to a whole other host
- 47:55of problems. But.
- 47:58He just seems to be racking up the penalty points,
- 48:00unfortunately. I feels like the new Kevin
- 48:02Magnussen in that sort of way. It's kind of interesting with
- 48:06that sort of history. I mean, as you say, Marie, just
- 48:09stay clean and I think you should be OK.
- 48:12I mean, a lot of these penalty points seem to get dished out
- 48:17spontaneously and not at the time, but we'll have to see.
- 48:22I think that Ollie Berman has now gotten 9 penalty points
- 48:26because some of his were taken off and obviously the limit
- 48:29until you get a race ban I think is 12.
- 48:31Liam Lawson is now on 8 penalty points after having obviously
- 48:35been penalized for this incident.
- 48:37I found it really odd because the directive that came out from
- 48:42the stewards discussing Ollie Berman's penalty, which is
- 48:45obviously what came out first before Liam Lawson's did, very
- 48:49much made it seem like in the stewards view it was Berman who
- 48:53was the cause of the collision and everything.
- 48:55It was a full length document. It was, it was a full page and I
- 48:59got the impression right, this is what the stewards believed.
- 49:01And I was like OK, fine, fair enough.
- 49:03Even if I didn't necessarily understand the decision or I
- 49:06didn't completely agree with it, I understood that OK, they've
- 49:08thoroughly explained it out so I can I can respect this decision.
- 49:13And then not even 15 minutes later you have another directive
- 49:16that comes out from the stewards, which details
- 49:19actually, no Liam Lawson is also equally at fault for the
- 49:22incident, which find fair enough.
- 49:24Sometimes you get incidents like that.
- 49:25But I didn't I could not understand the rationale behind
- 49:29what they had said in the Berman document and then comparing and
- 49:33contrasting that to what they said in the Lawson document and
- 49:35how these two fit together for the same incident.
- 49:39And I think that was my that was perhaps my main gripe with
- 49:43stewarding this round. I mean, I'm going to say the
- 49:47very well known words on this podcast.
- 49:50We need permanent stewards because the consistency is
- 49:55rather lacking and it's, we've noted it over, you know, many
- 50:00races. So I think that's all I've got
- 50:03to say. Yeah, I agree.
- 50:06Although I will say, I was, I do appreciate to a degree that they
- 50:15do rotate them out to kind of block out or attempt to block
- 50:21out bias. So my, my solution to that,
- 50:26here's what we should do. This is just us running the FIA
- 50:29at this point. I think, I think everybody just
- 50:31needs to listen to the podcast and they can just do whatever we
- 50:34say. But I think they should have
- 50:37like three sets of stewards and like mix them all up beach race
- 50:42weekend and like rotate them in and out, you know what I mean?
- 50:46So like we're not having bias, but we're still having like
- 50:49people who know what they're doing and people who all agree,
- 50:53like this incident means this, that incident means that.
- 50:56So we can like, if that makes sense, have like sets of
- 51:00stewards that kind of get rotated in and out to make sure
- 51:05we're not having biases. Biases, but permanent stewards
- 51:11because everybody, I think everybody in Formula One can
- 51:14agree on that, except maybe the FIA president.
- 51:17I don't think we can talk about permanent stewarding anymore on
- 51:20this podcast than we already have to.
- 51:21I think we might have potentially exhausted everything
- 51:24there is to say about why there needs to be permanent stewards.
- 51:27And I think it's plain and simple because you can't, it
- 51:31damages the integrity of the institution and the decisions
- 51:34that said institution come out with.
- 51:36Then if every single time they say something or they try and
- 51:39implement something, there are 50 people who turn around and
- 51:43say, well, actually we just don't understand why you're
- 51:45doing this. Obviously, I'm not saying
- 51:46everyone will unanimously agree if permanent stewards are put in
- 51:50place, but also at the same time I think permanent stewards
- 51:54represent consistency and that is what is missing from the
- 51:57decisions that are coming out of the stewards room for the most
- 52:00part for the entirety of the season so far and not just 2025.
- 52:03You can go back 2020, four, 20/23/2022.
- 52:07I'm not going to talk about 2021 because I think that's a whole
- 52:09other can of worms that we haven't got time for today.
- 52:12But what I'm trying to say is it's a trend, unfortunately,
- 52:16that is developed that no one seems to be doing anything about
- 52:19and it's something that needs to be sorted out because you don't
- 52:22want to. I can't imagine as drivers that
- 52:24they want to get on the grid knowing that all last week a
- 52:27very similar incident or an identical incident happened and
- 52:30they were given such and such penalty and now the same thing
- 52:34has happened and we're almost being treated more harshly.
- 52:36I think it's just not. It's not fair obviously on the
- 52:40drivers and it's not fair for fans who are watching who can't
- 52:43make sense of why things are being done a certain way.
- 52:45Yeah, it's interesting to see how they're done, but.
- 52:49We'll have to see. Now within the race itself, I'm
- 52:51going to turn to something that we have very briefly discussed
- 52:53already, the Piastri Antonelli and declare Tamwan incident.
- 52:56Was Piastri right to get the blame?
- 52:58Interestingly, like Marie said earlier, Charles Leclerc didn't
- 53:01think so, and he was the one to suffer the most as a result of
- 53:03that entanglement. But like I said, I know that we
- 53:06like to be students on this podcast, so I feel like it's
- 53:10only right that we share our thoughts on what we make of the
- 53:13incident. I think, as I said earlier, I
- 53:15think if anybody is it was at fault, it was piastry.
- 53:18I think I and that's the reason why I don't really see it as a
- 53:23racing incident. If nobody had got damaged and
- 53:25someone just gone off track then I would have said it's a racing
- 53:28incident. But the fact that his actions
- 53:31led to someone DNF ING from the race is why I think there should
- 53:33have been a penalty. Anyways, so that's my thoughts
- 53:37on the matter. I agree because you could say
- 53:41and I am partly of the belief that Kimmy should have moved
- 53:44slightly over but I also agree with what's been said previously
- 53:49of he was trying to fight Oscar and trying to fight Charles
- 53:52Claire. Lot was going on.
- 53:54So much easier said than done. I agree.
- 53:57I think if anyone's to blame it's Oscar PS3.
- 54:00I think he kind of cooked it into the corner.
- 54:02Shouldn't have made me gone in as hot, or if he was going to,
- 54:07should have kind of been farther ahead Kimmy before making a move
- 54:12like that. So yeah, I agree.
- 54:16I agree with the penalty, although I do think 10 seconds
- 54:19was slightly too harsh. Yeah, I agree with you both.
- 54:22I think if anyone was to blame, it was Oscar.
- 54:24I think 10 seconds perhaps was a little bit too harsh, but then
- 54:28also taking into consideration that absolutely wrecked
- 54:31Charlotte Claire's race. And to be completely honest,
- 54:34Franco Colapinto was a bit lucky that in the contact with
- 54:37Charlotte Claire, his own car wasn't damaged.
- 54:40I think taking that into consideration, I can kind of
- 54:42understand that where the 10 seconds came from.
- 54:45But yeah, consistency is key. If anyone takes anything away
- 54:49from any of the podcast episodes that they have listened to from
- 54:52the three of us, consistency and stewarding is key.
- 54:54And that's that's the end of it. Now, obviously, a lot of the
- 54:58things that we talk about on this podcast are things that we
- 55:00have seen on the race. So we're going to turn to
- 55:02broadcasting next because I think Marie has a lot of things
- 55:05that she would like to say. So I'm just, I'm going to hand
- 55:07the floor over to Marie. I appreciate it.
- 55:10I cannot. I can't tell you how many times
- 55:14I was yelling at the TV to show me the timing because what do
- 55:19you mean we are in, what, the final five laps of a phenomenal
- 55:24race? I love Brazil, I think we get
- 55:26great racing every single year. I was astonished at how stressed
- 55:30I was at the end of the race. I don't think I've been that
- 55:32stressed at the end of the race for a long time because there
- 55:35were battles up and down the field, yet some bright mind in
- 55:40the broadcasting room decided it would be a phenomenal idea to
- 55:43show us the gap to the leader when the leader was in fact on
- 55:47his own. Why?
- 55:49Why is this an option? I can understand at the start of
- 55:52the race, OK, like show up for like a minute, kind of
- 55:55interesting, you know, periodically, why are we showing
- 55:58how many pit stops people have had for like 3 minutes?
- 56:02I don't care. In fact, I have been keeping
- 56:05track by myself. And if you don't do that, I'm
- 56:08sorry, but it's your fault. So anyways, I I can't even why
- 56:13are we showing I, I don't know if you guys must have
- 56:16experienced this too. At one point they just had the
- 56:19names up there. Yes, for like a solid minute.
- 56:21Yes, it's so nice to know that we are being.
- 56:23I have in fact. Of drivers we've been watching
- 56:26the entire season so far. It's It's so nice to know it's
- 56:30so I love knowing that LEC stands for Leclerc.
- 56:35It's just exactly what I needed to know at the moment that a
- 56:37battle is going on. Hello.
- 56:41No, what it seemed with broadcasting, you know, the
- 56:45start of the start of the season was a little rough and then we
- 56:48got better and then we got worse and then we got better.
- 56:50People listen to our to every the fans feedback.
- 56:53I was like this guy, the guys, this is great awesome job.
- 56:56I don't know what happened today.
- 56:57I don't know who woke up on the the wrong side of the bed.
- 57:00It went downhill. I don't know what to say.
- 57:05I was, I don't even know because why are there 20 battles going
- 57:11on and I don't know the gap in between each driver for any of
- 57:15them. Why?
- 57:18I don't know. I was, I was upset, clearly.
- 57:25So I'm still a little salty about it, clearly.
- 57:28Can we please get better? Please let them listen to
- 57:31everybody's feedback because I'm sure everybody is saying the
- 57:34exact same thing. It needs to get better.
- 57:37Yeah, it does. I think we're all aware of my
- 57:41issue with the little TV screens recovering the sort of center of
- 57:45the action. So we've got London Norris
- 57:47battling someone at the top, or he's, I don't know, God knows
- 57:50where in second. And then there's this really
- 57:52interesting battle that's going on for P10.
- 57:55So the TV people are thinking we've got an interesting battle
- 57:59for a battle for P10 within an RX, many cars.
- 58:02And we've got Lando Norris just driving.
- 58:05Let's just go watch Lando Norris drive his car around the
- 58:08circuit. Do you think it's gotten better?
- 58:10Although I do think I think this race was kind of an outlier in
- 58:14it being bad. I think Mexico is a good example
- 58:16of it being done well. I think with Austin too, if I
- 58:19remember correctly, of showing more of the midfield.
- 58:22And that's definitely been a piece of feedback that the fans
- 58:24have been giving. But today it was just or
- 58:30yesterday it was just bad point blank period.
- 58:35I mean, broadcasting is performing at the same rate of
- 58:38Ferrari right now, so it's not looking good.
- 58:41I was going to make. The people who run that used to
- 58:43do the Monaco broadcasters, the people who do it.
- 58:46And I mean, there's nothing wrong with the cheeky white to
- 58:48Land Stroll doing, I don't know, whatever he's doing.
- 58:52I was just going to say I was going to make a Ferrari joke,
- 58:54but I felt that maybe we just, maybe we just done that too
- 58:57much. So I'm glad Marie did it so that
- 58:58I didn't have to do it. And I also would just like to
- 59:00add on this topic of broadcasting, I didn't actually
- 59:03know that Hajjah and Lawson had made contact until someone on
- 59:07the commentating team had said that they had made contact
- 59:10because they didn't show it on the broadcast.
- 59:12I don't know what they had panned to instead at that point,
- 59:15but it was not the two of them making contact.
- 59:19So yeah, if there's anything to take away from this, if anyone
- 59:22from broadcasting from Sky Sports, F1 TV, any of the
- 59:26numerous providers around the world that showcase F1 globally,
- 59:29if there is anyone that is listening, please, please take
- 59:32this on board about broadcasting.
- 59:33We would like to see the battles.
- 59:35Lando Norris, as much as I think that McLaren is an absolutely
- 59:38wonderful car to take a look at, if he is in the lead by 10
- 59:41seconds, I can trust the fact that he will remain in the lead
- 59:44in case you don't show him on the TV.
- 59:46So it will be fun to see Fernando Alonso and Charlotte
- 59:49declare battling for position for points that will contribute
- 59:52towards the World Constructors Championship, just as a heads up
- 59:55in case anyone is listening. And you know what?
- 59:59If you're that invested in Lando Norris's every move, you can
- 1:00:03watch his onboard. Exactly.
- 1:00:05Exactly. Press the red button.
- 1:00:08If press the red button, we've got Sky ambassadors on the
- 1:00:10podcast today. I had absolutely no idea.
- 1:00:14Just as a final bit from me, in the drivers market we have the
- 1:00:16tiniest bit of movement as well. After a lot of speculation, F1
- 1:00:20fans were finally given confirmation that Franco
- 1:00:22Colapinto would be retaining his seat at Alpine for the 2026
- 1:00:25season and the 2026 season. Only Colapinto, who replaced
- 1:00:29Jack Doing after a very short stint at the team, is yet to
- 1:00:31score a point in 2025. The very decision or one of the
- 1:00:35main reasons why his predecessor was let go.
- 1:00:38What do you make of the decision of the decision?
- 1:00:40Is it financially motivated Perhaps more than anything else,
- 1:00:44and we expect from Franco knowing that he did put in some
- 1:00:46stellar performances at Williams when replacing Logan Sargent.
- 1:00:49Just as a reminder, this will be his first full season in the
- 1:00:52sport, which means it's his first opportunity to have
- 1:00:55preseason testing, something he hasn't had on his two previous
- 1:00:58occasions when being in the sport.
- 1:01:01I do think it was partially financially motivated.
- 1:01:04I mean within the world of motor sport, you always have to
- 1:01:08consider that it's not just about the drivers themselves.
- 1:01:11It's what kind of money and sponsorship do they bring to the
- 1:01:15table? And sometimes that's how these
- 1:01:16things can be decided. Obviously Alpine are a business
- 1:01:20entity as well as a Grand Prix team, so they have to consider
- 1:01:24all the factors. So I think that's part of it.
- 1:01:27But as well perhaps it it's it's investing in the long term for
- 1:01:31him. That's not a term I would often
- 1:01:33use with Flavio Briatore, but maybe there's part of that.
- 1:01:37But perhaps they just want to stick with him for now.
- 1:01:39I don't know not not have a major driver shift again.
- 1:01:44It's possible they're trying to avoid becoming Red Bull 2 point
- 1:01:47O because I do believe that switching a driver in and out
- 1:01:52and in and out is not the way to go racing and not effective.
- 1:01:56I'd be curious if they see anything either on the data or
- 1:01:59on kind of the simulator that proves Franco's performance will
- 1:02:04get better or is better. I think you saw it a lot in 2024
- 1:02:09where Alpine would be pretty much nowhere on a Friday and
- 1:02:14then Jack Doohan would be in the simulator all night, all day,
- 1:02:18all hours you could think of and the team would make a complete
- 1:02:21turn around. So I'm curious what part of that
- 1:02:26they didn't, what either, what didn't translate or what they
- 1:02:31didn't quite value as much as Franco.
- 1:02:33I think it would be naive to say it's not part at least partially
- 1:02:38financially motivated. Of course, the team is really
- 1:02:41struggling at the moment. They're definitely need money.
- 1:02:43They're at the bottom of the constructors championship,
- 1:02:47meaning they'll get the least amount of money from Formula One
- 1:02:51basically at the end of the season.
- 1:02:54So I mean, not even the sponsors, which Franco of course
- 1:02:56does bring a lot, but just the fans and the amount of people
- 1:02:59who are willing to buy his merchandise and support him and
- 1:03:03therefore support Alpine. I mean, Franco has all of
- 1:03:07Argentina going for him and much of of South America and
- 1:03:11obviously beyond people just who absolutely adore him, which is
- 1:03:17something of course Alpine wants to wants to keep.
- 1:03:21And while Jack doing, I would say has a decent fan base, it's,
- 1:03:25I mean, very few drivers, I would say on the grid have a fan
- 1:03:30base as strong as Franco's despite his kind of lack of
- 1:03:35performance. So I think that's something they
- 1:03:37definitely want to keep. And I do think he does have
- 1:03:39potential. I'd be interested to see how he
- 1:03:40does next season with all that testing, with all the
- 1:03:44preparation that's kind of needed.
- 1:03:47I think that's our my at least. My big complaint with Yuki
- 1:03:51Sonoda is that if you were going to replace a driver after two
- 1:03:54races, why did you have him there in the 1st place?
- 1:03:57Like clearly it was not meant to be because I think Yuki would be
- 1:04:01performing a lot better at the moment.
- 1:04:03If he did have the opportunity to do a winner and a pre season
- 1:04:10with Red Bull. I'd also be curious to see maybe
- 1:04:14if he doesn't perform, will they replace him right immediately or
- 1:04:16will they give him another year? But it's kind of a whole other
- 1:04:19discussion. But yeah, I.
- 1:04:20Think it's going to have to be one of those situations that as
- 1:04:222020 and as 2026 unfolds and we obviously see where Alpine falls
- 1:04:28in the ranks with the new regulations, we'll have to see.
- 1:04:31We'll have to try and mine read Flavio Briatore just a little
- 1:04:34bit to see where his head's at, because I don't doubt that he
- 1:04:37has replacement options already in his head.
- 1:04:40Even though it seems almost cruel to have just signed a
- 1:04:42driver or just announced a driver and then already be
- 1:04:44thinking about who could come and take his place.
- 1:04:46But unfortunately, it seems to be that that's the way Alpena's
- 1:04:49choosing to portray themselves, I guess in the media for the
- 1:04:53moment at least. As always for our closing
- 1:04:56remarks, I'd love to get your one word thoughts on this year's
- 1:04:58Sao Paulo Grand Prix. I'll let Marie go first.
- 1:05:01I'm still thinking. This is like my least favorite
- 1:05:06question because I never know what to say, but I will say
- 1:05:10phenomenal. I think we saw some phenomenal
- 1:05:13performances throughout the weekend.
- 1:05:15Personally, I love Interlocos. I think it never fails to just
- 1:05:19produce, I mean, the most beautiful shots, the most
- 1:05:22beautiful racing. So yeah.
- 1:05:26I'll use my favorite word this week.
- 1:05:28I'll use entertaining instead. Wonderful.
- 1:05:31I'm so glad that you're using something different.
- 1:05:32I'm going to go with mind blowing because like Marie, I
- 1:05:35think some of the racing that we saw this week, the on the small
- 1:05:39TV screens in the corner of the screen as opposed to the big
- 1:05:41screen. But again, I digress on that was
- 1:05:43absolutely phenomenal. You had all the teams going all
- 1:05:46out and it's just a track that produces beautiful racing and I
- 1:05:50already can't wait to come back in 2026.
- 1:05:54That's all from us for our Sao Paulo Grand Prix race review.
- 1:05:57On behalf of myself and my wonderful Co host, thank you so
- 1:05:59much for listening and we hope that you enjoyed the episode.
- 1:06:02If you enjoyed this episode and would like to hear more Dive
- 1:06:05Bomb podcast then please do check out the Formula E and
- 1:06:07IndyCar podcasts also hosted by incredible teams.
- 1:06:10Join us next time where we will be hosting another rewind
- 1:06:13episode to discuss the infamous 2016 championship where Lewis
- 1:06:17Hamilton was beaten by Nico Rosberg in equal machinery.
- 1:06:20Thank you so much for listening once again.