Latest / Murder Files Unsealed
The EMT’s Deadly Betrayal: The Murder of Catherine Novak
The episode details the investigation into the murder of Catherine Novak, a mother from Narrowsburg, New York, whose death was initially staged to look like an accidental house fire. While her husband, Paul Novak, originally possessed an ironclad alibi and collected a significant insurance payout, the case went cold until his former mistress, Michelle LeFrance, confessed his involvement years later. Her testimony revealed that Paul, with the help of an accomplice named Scott Sherwood, strangled Catherine and intentionally ignited the residence to hide the crime. Forensic evidence, such as the…
The skinny
The skinny isn't ready yet — notes appear once the transcript is processed.