Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E212 How Second Life Brought “May It Be” (Lord of the Rings) to Life with Cinematic Machinima (Feb 2026)
Transcript
- Phil Rice 01:00 welcome to and welcome to And now for something completely machinima, the podcast about machinima, virtual production and related technologies. My name is Phil rice. I'm here with my co hosts, Tracy Harwood and Damian Valentine, hello. So this week, we are looking at a film made in Second Life, and it's a gorgeous piece. Tracy, it's your pick for this week. So why don't you tell us about it? Tracy Harwood 01:26 Yeah, absolutely. It's called may it be Lord of the Rings. It's an Enya cover by a young lady called Anna Kurka, Second Life machinima, and it was released in October last year. Anna describes herself as a second life creator, focusing on songs, stories and machinima. She typically covers songs, but also creates original music, which she brings to life with cinematic, virtual storytelling. And there's also an aspiring singer songwriter, and occasionally shares her originally composed works on her own channel as well. And her aim really is that every performance is a visual journey crafted in Second Life, which she describes as a place where imagination needs music. Now this particular short we're focusing on today accompanies one of Anna's classics to Lord of the Rings, maybe where her overall aim is to create a small world to accompany the acoustic cover. So this short, as so many of her works do, shows this kind of beautiful, cinematic quality of the virtual world, and in it, she's covering this really, you know, I mean, you're, you'll be very familiar with this song. I'm certain it's a kind of a real slow, beautiful song. And she does a slow mo fly through of this kind of really ethereal world filled with gothic artifacts and ancient forests and the visuals are really a perfect accompaniment to the song. Turns out, it was filmed in a location called infinite darkness, which is a region in Second Life created by somebody called Gian I found an excellent overview of that region, which, as I said, is, I think, a perfect setting for the song. In the review, it's described as a place where good and evil, water and fire, light and dark are in essence, or are basically its essence, and the majesty of the kind of the Gothic style, the occult symbolism and the dark powers of the Vampires immerse you in a kind of a hellish journey. Well, of course, there aren't any vampires in Lord of the Rings, but it does. Lord of the Rings does refer to similar kind of symbolism as classic Gothic tales such as Stoker's Dracula making this second life region, I think, a particularly excellent symbolic as well as visual choice for situating this particular machinima just just an excellent match. Let me explain a little bit more about that. So, so both Lord of the Rings and Stoker's Dracula deal with darkness, fear and this kind of struggle between good and evil, and in Lord of the Rings, for example, figures like Sauron and the Nazgul are really remnants of an older, fallen age tied to ruined fortresses and a sense that the past still exerts this kind of terrible power of The president. And whereas the settings are often imagined, gloomy castles, nights, night, journeys, mists and forests and this kind of constant sense of threat. I think what's done here is this, in this particular song, it sort of set on the cusp of that as a sort of liminal space between. And you know dark and and Dawn, if you like. You know the dusk and day, so to speak. And that's, I think, really what enya's song is, is trying to portray, which was written for Jackson's 2001 version of Fellowship of the Ring. And she really kind of connects this sort of Gothic elements, and gives this kind of sensual counterpoint to the darkness and fear of the evil forces of of Mordor. Now the tone of the song is really otherworldly. Enya's original version is just the most astonishing thing to listen to with with the harmonies that kind of create this really evocative sense of mourning and distance and the supernatural, similar to the these kind of, you know, what you imagine from these gothic castles and ruins and ghosts and whatnot. And it really does feel like a lament sung on the edge of a sort of a mortal world much, much like the that sort of type of literature used to blur the boundaries, really, between life and death and sort of this feeling of of being the uncanny. And I think what's quite clever about this Machinima is that whilst it's evidently acknowledging that kind of darkness and fear and that kind of long shadow of evil. It doesn't really revel in the terror that we know from that story. Instead, it kind of, it kind of has a more sort of uplifting tone to it. Sort of offers, I suppose, what you'd say, maybe consolation or a kind of faith in Light Beyond the night. So I think the song and the music and its expression takes that sort of atmosphere and reshapes it into a story of probably something more close to spiritual resilience. Now I will give you the link to enya's version of this. But, of course, you know, when you listen to that again, which I'm sure you will, you know, you'll, you'll realize just how astonishing her version of it actually is. I mean, enya's performance is an entirely different quality altogether, and demonstrates, really, how her voice is a very pure instrument, but in this rendition, I do feel Anna has made an excellent job of putting her own stamp on the song. There's a kind of local dialect in it that gives gives it a sense of unique characterization, which she then builds on with showing her avatar, and that's played out, especially, I think, at the end of the machine, which I encourage everyone to take a look at, because it's actually quite a surprising end too. I won't tell you the detail of it. Suffice to say, It's a pity that she didn't take the same approach to presenting the avatar earlier in the film as well. Now, Anna clearly doesn't have the same vocal range as Enya and the and obviously the production quality is is nowhere near the same, but her voice is nonetheless really beautiful, and she captures some of what I would describe as the soundscape for the imagery imaginary space too. You know, the kind of the noise of the forest, the creatures of the of the day and the night, they seem to all be woven into the into the story that she's telling. Really quite an inspirational way. So in this version, I think Anna's captured really well that kind of ethereal nature of the themes portrayed in the original song. But she's done it in only in really what I can only describe as a sort of more human like way, such as being guided by a pillar like rather, and being, you know, somebody being, trying to be faithful to the to the goodness and and all of that kind of stuff. Whereas enya's version of it, you might describe as being from the Elven perspective, you know, coming from a higher plane, so to speak, very different characteristics. I think if you look at it in that way, you'll appreciate this particular version of it as a as a different point of inflection into the into the song, to what the original one gave. Now, I did actually have a chance to ask Anna some questions about this and about her practice, because I was quite impressed with this when I first saw it. It turns out she's actually an amateur singer from Belgium who's never sung in real life. In fact, she's cut out a short which I'll also put a link to, where she's described how she got started and what her inspiration is. And super ironically, it's anime where she where she takes her. A visual inspiration from so I think that's that's all quite kind of fascinating. And I wanted to share this with you because I feel that Anna and her work really deserve a lot more recognition, and once she gains her confidence in the quality of what she's doing, I'm certain there's a real big future for her in doing original song work, as well as in voice acting, because she's got a really unique voice. I think, I think it never really ceases me. Ceases to amaze me, just what kind of talented people there are in Second Life. And I think the biggest challenge folks have is somehow getting themselves away from Second Life and out into a wider world where they, you know, they break away from that sort of, you know, quite narrow community. In some respect, I know it's a large community, but it's still quite a narrow community, because people like Anna really deserve to be heard by a much bigger audience than just a second life community. I'd be really interested to hear what you got to say about this one and see what what your thoughts are about it. Damien Valentine 11:12 That's great. Certainly, I'm actually going to go and see Fellowship of the Ring next Saturday, because my local cinema is doing a releasing them, and that one every Saturday, so fellowships next weekend. So I'm looking forward to that. And this, watching this video has kind of got me excited for it, because obviously, may it be, is a very kind of sad but yet hopeful song at the end of the first film. And I think that's kind of important, because no matter how dark lord of the rings get, whether you reading the book or watching the films, there's always that underlying message of hope at the end. If you know that they're going to win in the end, even though it seems really impossible and Saurons, it's all powerful, and there's no possible way to win. You know they're going to and that's not just because you've seen or read it before. You just know there's got that feel to it that the good guys have to win. And I think the song kind of reflects that. It's like, yeah, things are really bleak at the moment, but you know, there's hope that things are going to get better. So Anna. I think Anna did a really excellent I'm going to talk about the song first. Anna's cover of it is an excellent must. I don't know anything about singing, but I can imagine that, may it be, is a very difficult thing song to sing, and I thought Anna did it rather well. And then, of course, she it's not just about her singing it. She needs to produce the video to go alongside it. So she's found this environment which looks like it belongs in Middle Earth. It's not an actual recreation of anything you've seen in the film or, I think, described in the books. It's just got that Middle Earth vibe to it. So when you're seeing these locations, oh yeah, this fits nicely. And you've got the sunset and the lighting and everything, it just works, and you've got fog and all that. Again, I'm not going to say too much about the ending, because that caught me by surprise too, but I was kind of curious how it was done. And there's a conversation in the comments, saying, Please don't use AI. And then she goes, No, I didn't use AI. And she explains the process, yeah, which, again, I don't want to say too much about that, because it kind of catches you off guard, but I think it's a nice way to do it. So, yeah, this is, it's kind of short and it's well made, but it's kind of hard to figure out how to talk about it a lot, but I really liked it. And again, like I said, it's got me excited to watch the films again. I have to admit, when I first watched this, I didn't know that that screening was happening. It's got me thinking, you know, it's about time to watch them again, because it's been a while, and so watching it again for this recording session today, and talking about now it's got me excited for next weekend. So That's high praise. If you're watching a machinima film and it's based on an existing world, like Lord of the Rings in this case, and it gets you excited for that world. It's, it's a successful piece, I would say. Phil Rice 14:19 So, yeah, you you mentioning Damien about that, that that element of Tolkien, his way of dealing with hope in the face of of darkness, it might be the only thing that all of us on this show agree on, even even Ricky, who he'll be the first to say, he kind of tilts toward more little. He's a little cynical, right? And he's very anti sentimentalism, but he really appreciates Tolkien too, and, yeah, and it's, it's such a. Such a part of the fabric of my life. When I was exposed to the hobbit very early, actually, with the old animated movie of The Hobbit, with the, you know, kind of primitive cartoon and Smaug and all of that, it was just Oh. So then I My mom says, Well, you know, the book is really so I read The Hobbit, and then when I read the Lord of the Rings, in Fellowship of the Ring. Spoiler alert, everyone. But when Gandalf appeared to die, I wept like real tears, like I couldn't I furiously read till the end of the fellowship the ring, thinking, no way they're no way he really, oh my God, he's dead, right? And it wasn't. And then, and then, I think I wept again, real tears when the reveal of Gandalf the White happened, and you realized, oh my gosh, he's still right. I mean, just wonderful, powerful story. So silly side note there. So yeah, my hat's off to Anna Kirke, because it is really a bold endeavor to cover Enya at all. But this song may be in particular. You know, for you, kind of made some comments Tracy that that said that she's maybe kind of lacking a little bit of confidence in her talents. But this choice kind of betrays that maybe she's got a confidence she's not even conscious of, because to even attempt a cover of this is very, very bold, and she and you're I couldn't put it any better than you did. She does. She makes it her own. She's not trying to imitate. She's not trying to do an impression, which, frankly, would probably be foolish for almost anyone you know, because Enya is so supernatural in this song. But Anna Kirkus rendition here is beautiful, and it is. It's her own, own take on it. So I just I loved it, and yeah, you you keyed in on the local dialect. I couldn't, I couldn't come up with the words, but that, that is what makes this a little extra special, I think is, is the way that she, she sings. It's just, it's just wonderful. So, yeah, the visuals are beautiful. I mean, Second Life. I mean, how old is this engine now, you know, and it still is capable of delivering stylized admittedly, but wow factor, you know, it's not photo realistic, but I don't think that's the be all, end all. You know, it is, it's it's stylized realism. It's very gorgeous. The lighting continues to surprise me, the way that the the light worked with this with the sunset, and the glow is a little bit janky, maybe on like the flowers or whatever, but it just seemed to fit with the style of this. And that's just, that's second life. I don't know if other people are, you know, who aren't as exposed to esthetic are put off by that, but I'm not. I like it, and it's very possible to film footage in Second Life and have it not look anywhere near this good. There's real skill involved here in selecting shots and in, you know, machinima has always been about shooting around the as much as you can, shooting around the glitches and the the oddities, right? That's the secret to a great Sims two film, for example, from way back when, is okay, so the character does this weird thing, well, then you just don't film that. You figure out a way to that same technique is is part of Second Life, and it's why that this, there's, there's a there's a skill that's going on in the assembly of this footage that is maybe not apparent if you haven't worked with with the engine before. So it's just, it's just wonderfully done. You guys are both right. It did the whatever this location is. It does evoke exactly the right vibe for the song and for the story that this song is paired with, you know. So I can't believe we're not going to talk about the ending, or we're really not going to talk about it. Damien Valentine 19:45 Go. I'm happy to but Tracy, I'm going to put up, Phil Rice 19:49 I'm going to put up the spoiler alert little graphic thing here. Yeah, right. Spoiler alert, if go see it and then come back and you'll see why this is. Just, but to me, this is like, this is the main thing, right? We have to talk about this. Tracy Harwood 20:06 Yes, go for it. How it's, it's actually, it's a mo cap feature within Second Life. That means you can now do that facial mo cap is brilliant. Phil Rice 20:22 The fidelity is really, really good, excellent, isn't it? It's really good. I think the only, the only place where it it showed a flaw, I think, is the very last syllable, the very last syllable of what she sings, she's doing what's called a diphthong, where you start by singing one vowel and then go to another. So like a Ow, right? Ow starts as an ah, and then your mouth changes shape to an Ooh, and her very last syllable is ah, but the mouth doesn't follow to the Ooh. And that was the only point where the illusion broke for me. And I don't know why that happened, but her mouth stayed in kind of an open ah sound. But up till that point, it's like, man, yeah, this is every bit as good as anything I've ever seen from Accu lips in iClone, which is a top of the line tool for this absolutely top of the line. And I figured that probably the only reason that the one advantage that Accu lips has is that you can go in and modify on a timeline the phonemes, and you could make it exact. It takes time to do it right, but it's so worth it, and it can, you could get it exact. And with this, obviously, there's not any such tool. This is just a, I think it's double capture thing, I guess, just done Tracy Harwood 21:52 with a webcam. Unbelievable. I think she just sang it into a webcam, and it mapped her facial movement, her lip movement, to the avatar quite, quite Phil Rice 22:04 I mean, there's really good, Tracy Harwood 22:06 yeah, there's a video where she just shows you a little bit of what the workflow is and how it's doing it. I don't know whether it means you have to have a very specific type of face on the avatar to do it, I don't know. Phil Rice 22:26 Well, I couldn't have to be if we're talking in terms of traditional models, the face would have to be rigged, yeah, with the right bones to be able to do what it's those movements, and this is the whole face is rigged. How that happens? I don't know. Especially in Second Life, you're not, you're not rigging models. In Second Life, it's not that type of tool. So exactly, I don't know precisely how this works. Model that can do Tracy Harwood 22:53 having a look at Phil, I think it's worth going in. It's, it's having a look at what this Phil Rice 22:58 is, the first time I've been in Second Life in like, Tracy Harwood 23:01 15 years. But if it's got this sort of tool, we're on a different level here, aren't we? Phil Rice 23:05 Yeah, that is something else. It's really, I mean, it helps a lot that the avatar itself is highly detailed. There's this near photo realistic skin on the face, and all the little jewelry and stuff like that that's on it. It's just, and then the hair even is just really nice. So, yeah, that detail helps. But I mean, even eye movement was captured by this thing, yep, eye movement. It looked so natural. And actually, now that makes so much more sense that it's, if it's mocap, well, it was natural, right? That was, that was a performance, so, Tracy Harwood 23:44 yeah, and I think that connects you even more to what she's singing, the fact that she's, you know, done that director, camera, and, you know, and she's looking right at you through that, yes, I mean, that's just, you know, beautiful though. The rest of the video is that is, oh, my god, that's amazing. It was jarring and a good way. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I'm such a surprise. Do you think? Phil Rice 24:10 Do you think it was a good choice to only do that at the end, Tracy Harwood 24:15 I would have done that. Do you? I would have done that too. Do you? Phil Rice 24:20 Yeah? Oh, okay, here's why. I think that it would be impressive to see it lip sync throughout all that, even, you know, even keep all exactly the same shots, but, but you know, have that lip sync be part of the performance, or whatever? It would be impressive to see that, however, some of those shots would be a lot harder, I think, because I assume that she's controlling the camera, she's moving and somehow controlling the camera. But then you'd also have to, in this at that same point, be capturing all that footage with a moving. Camera and performing at the same time. It could just be, logistically, it was difficult to pull off. But let's assume that that's not the case. I think that there would be a lot more opportunities for because I think this tool probably, I mean, mocap, is going to have flaws. It just is, and you have to, I mean, even with iClone Damian knows this better than anybody here. You bring in mocap, it's rarely just good to go. As soon as you import it, you have to clean it, you have to fix little quirks with it, and something didn't read right. And that has to be true for this too, because that's not about Second Life. That's about the nature of mocap, especially, especially video camera mocap, where there's a lot of, I mean, the machine is just doing the best it can and guessing, at least with a suit or with the little contact points, like you see him doing, you know, behind the scenes of Avatar, it's, it's, it's, it's a little more reliable data, much more reliable data, but it still has to be cleaned. Even those guys have to do that, you know. So I think that, if nothing else, practically speaking, it would just be a whole bunch more opportunities for the the the seams to show, if you will, the flaws in the tool that would take away from the impact. So that's part of it. And the other two is just, it's this nice, little, sweet, concentrated morsel that's like a reward at the end. I don't know in terms of, if you can think of it as a narrative of the reveal, it's much more impactful to have saved it and just have one nice little spoonful of sugar at the end, rather than risk that by the end of how long is this video? Three, almost three and a half minutes, that one actually, it's hard to imagine one growing fatigued of that, but it's possible, with our attention spans, to have gone. Okay? It's like the starfield effect we talked about last episode, right? Well, okay, so I've seen this. I've seen it all. So with this, it's someone may tune out of the video before that and miss this, which is a tragedy. But if you do hang in there for this beautiful song, it's like a little present at the end. You know, I think it was a great choice to save it. Now, what the reason for the choice was? I don't know. It. Was it practical or was it calculated? I don't know, but I love it. There's another and it made the whole video for me. Damien Valentine 27:34 Yeah, I can agree with Phil, with your reasons for doing at the end, but there's another two that over my mind as well. Part of it is distraction, like the video isn't about her character and face. She's there singing, but it's right the world and the song great. So you've got that distraction. But the other part is, most of the times when you see her avatar, you're not close enough to actually notice if she's going to have that kind of level of motion capture on her face? Phil Rice 28:02 Yeah, you'd be able to see the movement, but it wouldn't be as impactful as seeing it up close like, yeah, so you're right, so it Damien Valentine 28:08 probably wouldn't have been worth the effort. And yeah, from the practical side as well, if you're capturing, even if you just glance over at second monitor, your motion capture is going to pick that glance up, and you're gonna have to out or that's ruined it. Phil Rice 28:22 That's exactly what I was thinking about, too. Is the logistics of, how do you do this? Right? Yeah, when you're when you're mocap in a face, you got to really be locked in. You can't be thinking about anything else. So I've Damien Valentine 28:33 been figuring that, trying to figure out a good process. At the moment, what I do is I've recorded my phone, and then I've got an iPad, which I hold right there so I can see the scene. But it still doesn't work, because I got to look at the phone camera, and the habit that, the instinct to do that, which, of course, that ruins it, because the camera could only pick up. So I'm trying to just do that, but then I also don't need to, oh, I'm doing that now exactly, yeah, of course, when I'm looking at it on the on the iPad, it sort of is mirrored, because what I'm seeing is the camera is protective, not mine, so the character on the iPad may look over there, so I look over there, but when I really I should be looking over there. So I'm trying to figure all of this out and try and develop a good process. At the moment, the most effective thing to do is render the entire video and then do a horizontal mirror to get that. But then, of course, you've got the time of rendering that, even if you're just doing a basic one, it still takes time and to generate a video and all that. But I'm still trying to figure out a good workflow for that. It is really effective when you do get it right, but it is. It's a lot of work trying to figure out how to get it to work right. Phil Rice 29:55 Ben Tuttle, we reviewed his Bond film in December. He got back. To me privately on some of the feedback that I'd given on that was talking about the eyes and stuff, and he basically, first of all, he responded very positively, by the way, like there was not a trace of upset in him at all. He was, he's just, he's eager to to learn and to improve. He was talking about, he just mentioned real briefly, that he's trying to figure out a good method for getting mocap of even the eyes and stuff like that. And so it's, I don't know, it's weird. It's kind of encouraging to me that someone who's got that level of experience with the tool I use is also having trouble with that. Then, okay, at least I know I'm not just a dummy, right? That it actually is tough to do, right? So yeah, Damien Valentine 30:40 the other thing I found trip shop is wearing glasses, because it blocks part of your face, and so especially here, where you've got muscles that move. And of course, if the camera can't see it, then it can't so it messes things up. I'm short sighted, so if I take my glasses off, I have to have the iPad right in front of my face, because I was a can't see it. Phil Rice 31:01 Yeah, I have to memorize my lines because I can't read them. I have to make notepads font size too big, and then it didn't my eyes are moving like tough stuff. It's fun to figure out, but it's hard. Damien Valentine 31:18 The other one is tricky is beards that can inter interfere with it as well. So yes, if I'm going to do a long face brush, I have to shave all this off, because it's not if you've got a gray beard or a blonde beard, that's pretty okay, because it matches your skin tone. But if you've got pale skin and you got a black beard, like I do, it doesn't work because it doesn't know what to focus on, right. And you have to get the lighting right as well, because if you're like, No, it's not going to work. If half your face is in shadow again, it can't pick it up. You want Phil Rice 31:57 to know what to pick up? Yeah, seem to have any of those problems. Tracy Harwood 32:02 I'm guessing Anna didn't have any of those particularly Phil Rice 32:06 did that whole phrase, and there was just one trailing phoneme at the end that, for some reason, didn't work. I mean, hey, well done. Yeah, well done. Damien Valentine 32:15 So, so Anna, can you give us some advice on how you did it? Tracy Harwood 32:22 Pretty brilliant. Yeah. So there you go. I really enjoyed reviewing that one. Phil Rice 32:27 Yeah, me too. Great pick Tracy. And thank you, Anna, for for making the video, and keep up the good work. Great stuff. I very pleasant voice. And I wish you the very best. I hope, I hope, whatever direction you choose to take it. I hope it goes well for you. So audience, what did you think? Drop us a comment wherever you watch or listen to this, or you can give us an email talk at completely machinima.com is that the right verb? Do you give someone an email? I don't know. Well, I just, I just broke some new ground there. Damien Valentine 32:58 That's also something people come right into us about Phil Rice 33:01 That's right. Just give us an email our English and yeah, that's right. So Well, my name is Phil rice, and on behalf of my co hosts, Damian Valentine and Tracy Harwood, have a great day, and we'll see you next time. Goodbye.