Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #87🎙️ |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 4th Aug Lighting Day 2 |
Transcript
- 0:05Spill, glare, glow-sounds like the line from a future poem that
- 0:09could be rattling around in my brain. Alas, instead, it's a
- 0:13testament to the last two days, and in an odd way, it could
- 0:16represent the enclosure of our final commons. More about this
- 0:20later. The day opened with submissions of a document called
- 0:24Guidance for the Implementation of the Water Framework Directive
- 0:30during the permitting of new projects and existing
- 0:33activities, with a particular focus on the mining sector by
- 0:37the applicant. Yes, I know our topic is about lighting, and
- 0:42that there is also supposed to be no new evidence submitted to
- 0:45the Commission, except in the case where it did not exist
- 0:49before the start of the public inquiry. This document was
- 0:53published in May 2026. It is a new piece of European Commission
- 1:00guidance on how the Water Framework Directive should be
- 1:03applied to mining projects. It doesn't actually change the law;
- 1:09it is only guidance, but it does seem to signal a shift in
- 1:13emphasis. The Water Framework Directive has been one of the
- 1:18strongest legal protections for rivers and groundwater available
- 1:24to communities facing mining proposals. So anything that
- 1:28appears to make the permitting process simpler or more
- 1:32predictable for the mining industry is something earth
- 1:35protectors will read very carefully indeed. Whether this
- 1:40proves to be a subtle change in guidance, or the beginning of a
- 1:44much bigger change in direction, remains to be seen. You might
- 1:50wonder why it has been presented now. Well, the topic of water is
- 1:54in September, and I guess they wanted to give the commission
- 1:57plenty of time to peruse it before then. I will be doing a
- 2:02separate podcast about this document over the next couple of
- 2:05weeks, when we all have had a little time to read and absorb
- 2:11it. After some back and forth conversation, there was no
- 2:15objection to the submission, and the document has been admitted
- 2:19by the commission. The commission then moved on this
- 2:22morning onto mitigation, which, to remind the listener, refers
- 2:27to legally required measures implemented during the planning
- 2:31process to avoid, reduce, or offset significant adverse
- 2:36environmental and community impacts of a proposed
- 2:40Development from conversations had yesterday on day one of
- 2:45lighting and subsequent revelations remodelling this
- 2:49morning, Mary Brawley, solicitor for Saversburns, summed up the
- 2:54third party's unease and lack of confidence in the proposed
- 2:58mitigation measures, saying because of gaps and
- 3:01deficiencies, and what appears to be unreliable modelling,
- 3:05along with no baseline surveys, save our sperms have a lack of
- 3:09confidence in any mitigation measures taken. This was further
- 3:13corroborated by Sean Tracy, who raised the point about the
- 3:16absence of what's known as native files. These are the
- 3:21original computer files used to create maps, models, and
- 3:25technical assessments, not just PDFs or printed versions.
- 3:30Without those original files, independent experts can't
- 3:34properly interrogate the data, check assumptions, or test
- 3:38whether conclusions really stack up. His question was a
- 3:43straightforward one: How can the commission discuss mitigation if
- 3:47the underlying native files haven't been provided for
- 3:50scrutiny? The rest of the day was spent on debating
- 3:55hypothetical conditions, which, again, to remind the listeners,
- 3:59are rules or restrictions added by a local council or department
- 4:03for infrastructure when granting planning permission. The day
- 4:09finished early, and as all topics have been covered in
- 4:13relation to lighting, tomorrow is now a null day, and the
- 4:17inquiry resumes again on september 1. And as I listened
- 4:21to the evidence about lighting today, I was mulling around in
- 4:24my head about who gets to decide what a landscape becomes, a huge
- 4:30subject, particularly here in Northern Ireland. And before you
- 4:33start worrying, let me reassure you, I'm neither historian,
- 4:37philosopher, nor a political commentator, so fear not, this
- 4:41isn't about to become a treatise on the rights and wrongs of our
- 4:44recent history, but every now and again it's worth stepping
- 4:47back from the daily evidence and looking at the bigger picture,
- 4:51because underneath it all this is a story about
- 4:54self-determination and about who gets to shape the land and the
- 4:58lives of the people who call it home.
- 5:01Here in Ireland, in common with most inhabited places on Earth,
- 5:05our landscapes have been shaped by human history, by people
- 5:09making decisions, and here, particularly in Ireland, because
- 5:13of our colonial past, very often those decisions weren't made by
- 5:18the people who actually lived on the land, or anywhere, or
- 5:21anywhere near it, for that matter. Over centuries, people
- 5:25were pushed further and further onto the mountainy uplands,
- 5:29forced to scratch a living from ground that was never meant to
- 5:32be farmed. They persevered and stayed because it gave them a
- 5:37measure of independence, a place to belong, a place to call their
- 5:41own. It gave them self-determination. Those
- 5:44choices, or perhaps more accurately, the choices that
- 5:48were taken away from people, still shape our landscape that
- 5:52we see today. And I can't help wondering whether today we're
- 5:55seeing a modern version of something we've lived through
- 5:59before. Terms like extractivism and corporate colonialism are
- 6:04used to describe situations where decisions about a place
- 6:08are driven by interests far removed from the communities who
- 6:13live there. Whether or not those terms resonate with you, they
- 6:18lead us back to the same fundamental question: Who gets
- 6:21to decide? Is it the people who have loved and cared for a place
- 6:26for generations, or is it an organisations whose connection
- 6:31to that place lasts only as long as the project does? The other
- 6:37thought that stayed with me today was this idea of the
- 6:40commons, there are some things that don't really belong to any
- 6:44one person: clean air, the sound of birdsong, a river flowing
- 6:50through a valley, the stars overhead, a truly dark night.
- 6:55They are part of our shared inheritance. We don't own them
- 7:00in the way we now own a house or a field, we simply hold them in
- 7:04stewardship for a while before passing them on to the next
- 7:07generation. And that is not to say that at one point in time
- 7:12land itself was never enclosed; it too belonged to the commons
- 7:16of the people. Of course, history has a habit of turning
- 7:21the commons into commodities, and water is probably the best
- 7:25example. Something that, for most of human history, people
- 7:29simply drew from a well, a spring, or a river, is now
- 7:33bottled, branded, and sold back to us, neatly demonstrating how
- 7:38our relationship with the commons can change. It reminds
- 7:42me of that old saying: "The law locks up the man who steals the
- 7:46goose from off the common, but leaves the greater villain loose
- 7:50who steals the common from the goose. It was written about the
- 7:54enclosures of common land centuries ago, but it poses a
- 7:58timeless question: when something belongs to everyone.
- 8:02Who gets to decide that it no longer does? How long will it be
- 8:06before someone figures out how to commodify darkness? Will we
- 8:11one day have a premium darkness experience? Come and enjoy three
- 8:15hours of authentic, uninterrupted darkness booking
- 8:19essential. Sounds ridiculous until you remember that in many
- 8:24places, people already have to travel miles and pay for the
- 8:27privilege of seeing a truly dark sky. Perhaps darkness is one of
- 8:32the last commons; it belongs to no one, and therefore to all of
- 8:37us. The question is whether we're quietly enclosing that
- 8:41too, not with fences this time, but with floodlights, spill,
- 8:47glare, glow. If something belongs to all of us, who has
- 8:52the right to change it? And perhaps more importantly, who
- 8:57gets to make that decision? Today's discussion about
- 9:01lighting opens the possibility of altering something that has
- 9:05quietly belonged to everyone since the dawn of time. And to
- 9:10finish, a poem sent in by a listener on the back of last
- 9:15night's darkness podcast. It's from Rayner Maria Rilke. Your
- 9:21darkness that I come from. Your darkness that I come from. I
- 9:27love you more than all the fires that fence in the world, for the
- 9:31fire makes a circle for everyone, and then no one
- 9:34outside learns of you, but the darkness pulls in everything,
- 9:39shapes and fires, animals and myself-how easily it gathers
- 9:44them, powers and people-and it is possible a great energy is
- 9:50moving near me.
- 9:54Our next podcast will go out on Saturday, 15th of August.
- 9:58Returning to the Saturday we. Schedule until the PI starts
- 10:02again on september 1, and as always, this podcast is intended
- 10:08to help people understand what happens at the inquiry by
- 10:11bringing together the week's evidence in plain English. If
- 10:15you find these updates useful, please consider joining the
- 10:18Sperns Community Campaign newsletter, and the link is in
- 10:22the show notes below. And we'll see you all soon.