Latest / The Morning Rundown / Spain's Deadly Train Crash, Israel's Vote Count, and a Fed Decision Days Before the Midterms
Transcript
- 0:00[Maya] Okay, I'm on my second cup of tea already, and it's barely
- 0:17[Maya] started working.
- 0:18[Maya] Chamomile was a mistake.
- 0:20[David] Chamomile at this hour?
- 0:22[David] That's a bedtime drink, Maya.
- 0:23[Maya] I know, I know.
- 0:24[Maya] I'm Maya, by the way, and this is the Morning Rundown with
- 0:27[Maya] David, who judges my beverages.
- 0:30[David] Every single morning.
- 0:31[David] So three stories today: a train crash, an election count, and a
- 0:35[David] rate decision.
- 0:36[Maya] Right.
- 0:37[Maya] And a heads-up, some of the numbers we're giving you are still
- 0:40[Maya] moving, the Spain figures and the Israel count especially.
- 0:44[David] Mm.
- 0:44[David] So if something shifts by the time you hear this, that's why.
- 0:48[David] And the crash isn't a place for jokes.
- 0:50[David] We'll keep that one plain and say only what's been reported.
- 0:53[Maya] Agreed.
- 0:54[Maya] Totally.
- 0:55[Maya] Then Israel, where the count still hasn't settled who actually governs.
- 1:00[David] The Fed one, though, has a wrinkle.
- 1:02[David] Days before the midterms and a hold is expected, but a later
- 1:06[David] hike isn't off the table.
- 1:08[Maya] Wait, really?
- 1:09[Maya] We'll get there.
- 1:10[Maya] First, the story that matters most this morning, the train crash in
- 1:13[Maya] Spain.
- 1:15[Maya] Two high-speed trains collided in Spain on Wednesday morning.
- 1:18[Maya] Spain's Prime Minister called it a serious incident, and CNN's live coverage
- 1:22[Maya] has been updating all morning.
- 1:24[David] Serious is the only word we have from the Prime Minister in
- 1:27[David] what we've gathered, so I don't want to put anything more in
- 1:29[David] anyone's mouth.
- 1:30[David] We'll stay with that.
- 1:31[Maya] Right.
- 1:32[Maya] And it's worth saying how we're getting this.
- 1:33[Maya] It's reports from several outlets pulled together, not anything either of us
- 1:37[Maya] have seen firsthand.
- 1:39[David] Here's where the toll stood when we collected this.
- 1:41[David] CNN's live headline said at least 30.
- 1:44[David] That's the early number.
- 1:45[Maya] CBS reported at least 64, with about 80 injured.
- 1:49[David] Then ABC quoted a regional spokesperson saying at least 68, and that
- 1:53[David] the toll is expected to rise.
- 1:55[Maya] So three outlets, three numbers.
- 1:57[David] Right.
- 1:57[David] Not because anyone's wrong.
- 1:59[David] They're snapshots from different hours of the same morning.
- 2:02[David] I wouldn't lock onto any one of them.
- 2:03[Maya] So how should someone reading headlines treat them?
- 2:06[David] As a range, and the direction is up.
- 2:09[David] The lowest is CNN's, the highest is ABC's regional figure, and all
- 2:13[David] three are phrased as at least.
- 2:14[David] That's the honest way to say it right now.
- 2:17[Maya] That's a lot of people on a Wednesday morning commute.
- 2:20[David] It is.
- 2:21[David] And I think what's worth holding onto is that these aren't statistics
- 2:23[David] yet.
- 2:24[David] Every one of those numbers is somebody's family.
- 2:26[Maya] Yeah, that's the part that doesn't fit in a headline.
- 2:29[David] It happened around 8:30 near Erda on the Madrid de Seville line.
- 2:33[Maya] What do we know about how it happened?
- 2:36[David] Only what's been reported.
- 2:37[David] CBS says a high-speed train hit the rear of a stopped train
- 2:40[David] in Toledo Province and two cars derailed.
- 2:43[David] That's a description, not a cause, and nobody should guess at why
- 2:46[David] yet.
- 2:46[Maya] Let me make sure I have it.
- 2:48[Maya] A fast train, a stopped train, and the fast one hit it
- 2:51[Maya] from behind.
- 2:52[David] That's how it's described.
- 2:54[David] Why the one was stopped or how the other came to hit
- 2:56[David] it, we don't have.
- 2:57[David] Nobody should fill that gap tonight.
- 2:59[Maya] And service between Madrid and Andalusia was suspended.
- 3:02[David] Which matters for everybody trying to get anywhere in the south.
- 3:05[Maya] Is there any sense of how long that lasts?
- 3:08[David] Nothing in our reporting says, just that service was suspended, and I'd
- 3:11[David] rather say that than guess.
- 3:13[Maya] Wait, there's a Renfe train and an Iryo train?
- 3:16[David] Yes, one from each operator.
- 3:18[David] ABC calls it Spain's deadliest high-speed rail crash since 2013.
- 3:23[Maya] Since 2013?
- 3:24[Maya] Okay.
- 3:25[David] Which gives you the scale.
- 3:27[David] We don't have much to compare it against tonight, but ABC puts
- 3:29[David] it at the top of that list for more than a decade.
- 3:32[Maya] And that's before you get to the next part.
- 3:34[David] And there's the part that's hard to read past.
- 3:37[David] ABC says it's the second major crash this year on that same
- 3:41[David] line with the same two operators.
- 3:44[Maya] Oh, no.
- 3:44[Maya] The January one?
- 3:46[David] Adamuz.
- 3:47[David] That collision killed 46 people.
- 3:50[David] CBS also notes trains from the same two companies were in a
- 3:53[David] deadly crash in January.
- 3:55[Maya] Same line, same companies, same year.
- 3:58[David] Twice in one year on one corridor.
- 4:01[David] That's the weight of it for anyone who relies on these trains.
- 4:04[Maya] And to be clear, nobody's saying that two crashes are connected.
- 4:07[Maya] We don't know that.
- 4:09[David] I'm gonna say this as a question, not a conclusion.
- 4:11[David] Questions about safety on this line are going to follow.
- 4:14[David] Spaniards will ask them, and they should.
- 4:17[Maya] So what should people keep an eye on today?
- 4:19[David] The toll first, then whether officials say anything about cause and when
- 4:24[David] service on that corridor comes back.
- 4:26[David] Those are the open items, and none of them are ours to
- 4:28[David] answer.
- 4:29[Maya] Totally fair.
- 4:30[Maya] From a story where the numbers keep climbing to one where the
- 4:33[Maya] count still hasn't produced an answer.
- 4:36[Maya] Israel, David.
- 4:37[David] Where a lead is not the same as a majority.
- 4:40[Maya] Okay, Israel.
- 4:41[Maya] The BBC had a snapshot with about 70% of the votes counted,
- 4:45[Maya] and the headline was that Netanyahu's bloc is slightly ahead, but short
- 4:49[Maya] of a majority.
- 4:50[David] Slightly ahead, short of a majority.
- 4:53[David] Both halves of that sentence matter.
- 4:55[Maya] Right?
- 4:56[Maya] And the BBC was careful.
- 4:57[Maya] It said Israeli elections can be decided by a handful of seats.
- 5:02[David] Mm.
- 5:02[Maya] It also said exit polls have been wrong before, and we may
- 5:06[Maya] not know who the next prime minister is for weeks, maybe longer.
- 5:10[David] Weeks?
- 5:11[David] After a vote?
- 5:12[David] That's wild.
- 5:13[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 5:14[Maya] We complain when a count takes two days.
- 5:17[David] Fair.
- 5:18[David] But that 70% snapshot is already old.
- 5:21[David] Ynet has a later count with about 85% counted.
- 5:24[Maya] And?
- 5:25[David] Netanyahu's bloc sits at 53 seats.
- 5:28[David] The magic number is 61, so eight short.
- 5:31[Maya] Eight.
- 5:32[Maya] Okay, that's not a rounding error.
- 5:34[David] No.
- 5:35[David] And Eisenkot's bloc is 48.
- 5:37[David] The Arab party's 19.
- 5:39[Maya] Wait, so who's leading as a single party?
- 5:42[David] Likud with 26 seats.
- 5:44[David] Biggest party in the count.
- 5:46[Maya] So the lead is real.
- 5:48[David] The lead is real, totally.
- 5:49[David] But look at what that means in practice.
- 5:52[David] 53 out of 61 is not a government.
- 5:55[David] You can't govern on a headline.
- 5:57[Maya] Say more, because I think people see ahead and hear one.
- 6:01[David] Right.
- 6:01[David] So in a parliament like this, nobody wins by finishing first.
- 6:05[David] You win by assembling sixty-one votes.
- 6:08[David] A bloc that's ahead but eight short has to find partners it
- 6:12[David] doesn't have yet or hope the numbers move.
- 6:14[Maya] So what does the other side need?
- 6:16[Maya] Because Eisenkot's bloc is at forty-eight, which is further from sixty-one than
- 6:20[Maya] Netanyahu's.
- 6:21[David] Further away, yes.
- 6:23[David] Adding the Arab party's nineteen to forty-eight gets you to sixty-seven on
- 6:27[David] paper, but adding numbers isn't building a coalition.
- 6:30[David] Nothing we have says anyone has agreed to anything.
- 6:33[Maya] And can they move?
- 6:35[Maya] Ynet says double envelope ballots could still shift the result.
- 6:38[Maya] Those are counted late, so the picture isn't frozen.
- 6:41[David] Hmm.
- 6:42[David] So eight seats is a gap, but not necessarily a final one.
- 6:46[David] Eight is a big gap to close with late ballots, honestly.
- 6:49[David] But nobody should call it done, and I'd be skeptical of anyone
- 6:52[David] on either side declaring victory tonight.
- 6:54[Maya] If late ballots even matter if the gap is that big, is
- 6:57[Maya] it just a formality?
- 6:59[David] Not a formality.
- 7:00[David] They're the reason the early picture gets revised, which is why I
- 7:03[David] keep calling every number a snapshot.
- 7:06[David] A small shift in a close count can matter, though I wouldn't
- 7:09[David] promise it closes eight.
- 7:10[Maya] Yeah, the BBC's warning about exit polls sort of hangs over it
- 7:14[Maya] all.
- 7:15[David] It does.
- 7:15[David] Now, if nobody gets to sixty-one, Ynet says a deadlock could leave
- 7:19[David] a caretaker government in place.
- 7:21[Maya] Meaning whoever's running things now just keeps running them?
- 7:24[David] In a caretaker role, yes, that's a reported scenario.
- 7:27[David] Nobody new, nothing decided.
- 7:29[Maya] That sounds like a lot of limbo.
- 7:32[David] It is, and there are reports of possible US pressure for a
- 7:35[David] broader unity government.
- 7:36[David] Reports, though, not confirmed.
- 7:38[Maya] Right.
- 7:39[Maya] I want to flag that.
- 7:40[Maya] Pressure's one thing, a deal is another.
- 7:43[David] Exactly.
- 7:44[David] A unity government would mean rivals sitting at the same table, and
- 7:47[David] nothing in what we have says that's agreed.
- 7:49[Maya] And for a regular person in Israel, what does the limbo look
- 7:53[Maya] like?
- 7:53[Maya] Is somebody actually in charge?
- 7:55[David] In the reported caretaker scenario, the people running things now keep running
- 7:59[David] them, but nothing new gets decided.
- 8:01[David] The count we have doesn't tell us how long that would last,
- 8:03[David] and I'm not gonna guess.
- 8:05[Maya] So for now, a real lead, a real gap, and a count
- 8:09[Maya] that isn't finished.
- 8:11[David] Right, and that's the whole difference between a lead and a majority.
- 8:14[David] The lead tells you who's ahead today, and the sixty-one tells you
- 8:17[David] who governs.
- 8:18[David] Those figures may have moved since the eighty-five percent snapshot, so hold
- 8:21[David] them loosely, and I'd rather be right a day late than first
- 8:24[David] and wrong.
- 8:25[Maya] Speaking of uncertainty in politics, the Fed is set to announce its
- 8:29[Maya] decision today, days before our own midterms.
- 8:32[David] A different kind of waiting then.
- 8:34[David] Let's get into it.
- 8:35[Maya] Okay.
- 8:36[Maya] The Fed.
- 8:37[Maya] And David, I know you've been waiting for this one all morning.
- 8:40[David] I have.
- 8:40[David] Coffee's cold, and I don't care.
- 8:42[Maya] So what's the setup?
- 8:43[Maya] Give me the basics.
- 8:44[David] ABC News says markets expect the Fed to hold rates steady today.
- 8:48[David] The benchmark rate sits at three point seven five to four percent.
- 8:51[Maya] Hold.
- 8:52[Maya] Okay.
- 8:53[David] But here's the part that gets people.
- 8:54[David] The Fed raised rates a quarter point last month.
- 8:57[David] That was its first hike in three years.
- 8:59[Maya] Wait, really?
- 9:00[Maya] Three years?
- 9:01[David] Three years.
- 9:02[David] So a hike last month and now a meeting days before the
- 9:04[David] midterms.
- 9:06[Maya] Nothing says relaxed like a rate decision in election week.
- 9:09[David] ABC points out that the timing adds a political angle.
- 9:12[David] Inflation pressure is high, and everybody's watching.
- 9:14[Maya] Why is a hold the expectation, though?
- 9:16[Maya] If inflation's still high, why not hike again?
- 9:19[David] Fox Business laid it out.
- 9:20[David] September's consumer price data came in hotter than expected, and that sets
- 9:24[David] a high bar for an October hike.
- 9:25[Maya] Hang on.
- 9:26[Maya] Hotter data should mean more hiking, no?
- 9:28[David] You'd think.
- 9:29[David] But a high bar means the Fed wants more evidence before it
- 9:31[David] moves again.
- 9:32[David] Same meeting, different read.
- 9:34[Maya] Mm.
- 9:35[Maya] So hold now.
- 9:36[David] Hold now.
- 9:37[David] And Fox Business also quotes an economist who suggests the Fed could
- 9:40[David] still hike later after waiting for cooler data.
- 9:43[Maya] Waiting for cooler data, like waiting for a cooler summer.
- 9:46[David] Right.
- 9:47[David] I mean, come on.
- 9:48[Maya] So a hold isn't the all clear.
- 9:50[David] Not even close.
- 9:51[David] It's a pause with an asterisk.
- 9:52[Maya] What are the markets doing about it?
- 9:54[David] Fairly calm.
- 9:55[David] CNBC reported S&P five hundred futures inching higher ahead of the decision.
- 9:59[Maya] Inching.
- 10:00[Maya] I like inching.
- 10:01[David] And stocks were broadly higher on Tuesday, fueled by gains among semiconductor
- 10:04[David] companies.
- 10:05[Maya] So Wall Street is relaxed.
- 10:07[Maya] Is Main Street?
- 10:08[David] Uh, that's where I'd slow down.
- 10:09[David] If you're paying for groceries, rent, a car loan, you don't live
- 10:13[David] in futures.
- 10:13[David] You live in prices that keep climbing.
- 10:15[Maya] Right.
- 10:16[Maya] The budget doesn't care about chips.
- 10:17[David] Persistent inflation squeezes a household budget quietly.
- 10:21[David] Every month, the paycheck buys a little less, and people notice it
- 10:23[David] long before any economist updates a chart.
- 10:25[Maya] Okay.
- 10:26[Maya] Bring the rate itself down to kitchen table level.
- 10:29[Maya] Three seventy-five to four percent and a hike last month.
- 10:32[Maya] What does that mean for someone who's not a trader?
- 10:35[David] It means the cost of borrowing is something you can feel.
- 10:38[David] When the benchmark goes up, loans and credit cards tend to get
- 10:40[David] pricier over time, and a first hike in three years is a
- 10:44[David] sign the Fed is worried about prices.
- 10:46[David] I'd be careful not to overstate it, but that's the direction.
- 10:49[Maya] And the Fed's stuck.
- 10:51[David] Kind of.
- 10:52[David] Raise rates and you make borrowing costlier for families already stretched.
- 10:56[David] Hold and you risk letting prices run.
- 10:58[David] Neither option is free.
- 11:00[Maya] Is there a way to read that trade-off without picking a side?
- 11:03[David] Sure.
- 11:04[David] A hold buys time to see if prices cool, and cooler data
- 11:07[David] is exactly what that economist said the Fed might wait for.
- 11:10[David] A hike would say the Fed doesn't trust that September's hot number
- 11:13[David] was a one-off.
- 11:15[David] Each reading has a cost, and which one it chooses will tell
- 11:17[David] us how worried it is.
- 11:19[Maya] Two bad choices.
- 11:20[David] Two bad choices, and somebody has to pick one.
- 11:23[David] I'm not gonna guess which, by the way.
- 11:25[Maya] Smart, because we're recording before the announcement.
- 11:28[David] Yeah.
- 11:28[David] As we prepared this, the decision hadn't come out, so everything we've
- 11:31[David] said is preview, not the result.
- 11:34[Maya] And honestly, what I'll be watching is whether a hold, if it
- 11:38[Maya] comes, calms anyone's budget at all.
- 11:41[David] Probably not by itself.
- 11:43[David] A pause on rates doesn't make groceries cheaper.
- 11:45[David] It just stops one pressure from growing.
- 11:48[David] And if a hike does come later, as that economist suggested it
- 11:50[David] could, borrowing gets costlier for those same families.
- 11:54[David] That's worth remembering when you hear the headline.
- 11:56[Maya] That's the rundown on the big three, so let's wrap it up.
- 12:00[Maya] Okay, so we're out of time, and I'm out of tea, which
- 12:03[Maya] David will be thrilled about.
- 12:05[David] Thrilled isn't the word.
- 12:07[David] Relieved, maybe.
- 12:08[Maya] Spain first, because it's the one that weighs on you.
- 12:11[Maya] At least sixty-eight dead in the latest report we had, and the
- 12:14[Maya] toll was expected to rise.
- 12:16[David] Right.
- 12:17[David] And Israel, a lead that isn't a government yet.
- 12:19[David] Fifty-three seats against the sixty-one it takes.
- 12:22[Maya] And the Fed.
- 12:23[Maya] Hold now, hike maybe later.
- 12:26[David] One caveat, once.
- 12:27[David] The figures we gave were as of when we collected them, and
- 12:30[David] they may have changed since.
- 12:31[David] The Fed is the one to watch.
- 12:33[Maya] Thanks for spending your morning with us.
- 12:35[Maya] Go easy on somebody today.
- 12:36[Maya] You know what I mean?
- 12:37[Maya] And that's the rundown.