Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #31: US Voting Policy Reforms Part 1 - The Voting Process
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:03I'm your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:05Today, we're gonna be talking about voting policy reforms.
- 0:10Voting is, of course, an indelible aspect to the American system of government.
- 0:15However, there is a lot about it that we take for granted.
- 0:19And I'm not just talking about differences in which demographic groups have earned the right
- 0:25to vote over time, Aspects like how and when we vote are sometimes treated as a given these
- 0:33days.
- 0:34But so many of the little things about these aspects of voting that seem so obvious now were
- 0:41not always set in stone.
- 0:43And for all the debates we have about how voting should look and function, there are some
- 0:49truly wild and odd facts looking back at what voting policy used to be in the olden days.
- 0:56And as I was putting notes together for this topic, it became clear that there was just too
- 1:00much info to pack into one episode.
- 1:03So I'm gonna split these up into a series of videos on voting policy reforms in American
- 1:11history.
- 1:11And today's episode is going to focus more on how the process of choosing our elected
- 1:17officials has changed over time, when we vote, who we vote for, and how we vote.
- 1:23So let's begin.
- 1:27First up, changing when we vote.
- 1:29We'll start with the federal level first.
- 1:32Generally speaking, today, general elections for federal offices happen on the first Tuesday
- 1:39after the first Monday in November of even numbered years.
- 1:44So can be from November.
- 1:50Now voting on these days wasn't always so uniform.
- 1:54In the early days of US election, states could hold elections at any point within a thirty
- 2:00four day period before the first Wednesday in December for presidential elections at least.
- 2:06And in 1845, congress passed the presidential election day act setting the first Tuesday
- 2:13after the first Monday in November as election day for president.
- 2:17It was the at the time, it was the most convenient day of the week and time of year for
- 2:22farmers so they could take the time to travel to a polling place, and it was during harvest
- 2:28season.
- 2:30However, that 1845 federal law did not address US house elections, and it did not address the
- 2:37US senate at the time because back then, US senate was not directly elected.
- 2:41More on that in a little bit.
- 2:44But for a time, a few states had some regularly scheduled US house elections in odd numbered
- 2:52years at that point, and they they sometimes still had them in, like, December or October
- 2:58even around the presidential election time.
- 3:03In fact, from at least 1835, possibly earlier until 1875, Connecticut had regularly scheduled
- 3:12odd year elections for US House.
- 3:14Rhode Island also did this for a while, last having having a regularly scheduled odd year
- 3:21election in 1873.
- 3:23So to rectify this, in 1872, congress passed a law that required US house elections to align
- 3:31with the presidential election day, so that took effect starting in 1876.
- 3:38And then in 1914, after US Senators became directly elected, their election dates were
- 3:44then aligned with those who are president and US House.
- 3:49And these days, all federal general elections happen every two years and even numbered years
- 3:56for every state.
- 3:57Now, of course, that does not necessarily apply to special elections, which by default are
- 4:03irregular, and when those guests schedule depends on the state and and when exactly that
- 4:09vacancy happened.
- 4:11But the primary dates for these federal offices still were mostly left up to the states, and
- 4:17those are all over the place.
- 4:18They could be two months, three months, four months, even, like, eight, nine months before
- 4:25the general election for these federal offices.
- 4:29But what about state level offices?
- 4:32When in what ways has when we voted for state level offices changed?
- 4:38So state level election schedules for the most part are left up to the states under the
- 4:43purview of the tenth amendment.
- 4:45All powers not expressly delegated to the federal government belong to the states
- 4:50according to the tenth amendment.
- 4:53Most state elections typically align with federal elections as well for the sake of
- 4:58simplicity, but there are some noticeable differences where states moved to odd year
- 5:03elections for state level offices and that still have them today.
- 5:10Notably, Mississippi did so for 1817 or in 1817.
- 5:15Kentucky did it in 1850, Virginia in 1851, New Jersey in 1947, and Louisiana in 1975.
- 5:24Now not necessarily every state level office in these states that is an elected office or was
- 5:31an elected office moved to these odd numbered years or has stayed that way, but in a lot of
- 5:37cases, they have.
- 5:39State legislative elections in odd years, notably, Louisiana, Mississippi, New Jersey,
- 5:47and Virginia.
- 5:48Kentucky did have them until the mid nineteen eighties.
- 5:52And then gubernatorial elections in those states just mentioned, Louisiana, Mississippi,
- 5:58New Jersey, Virginia, and Kentucky.
- 6:01And most or all other state executive elections in those states are held in odd years as well.
- 6:09One exception at least one exception being, the Louisiana Public Service Commission.
- 6:14For some reason, they are in even numbered years.
- 6:18And there is a unique circumstance where the Wisconsin superintendent of public instruction
- 6:26is not only a state executive office that has elections in odd numbered years, but it has it
- 6:33in a non November month, meaning the general election happens in a non November month.
- 6:37It actually happens in April.
- 6:40I believe April twenty of this year, '20 '20 '5, is the next general election for that
- 6:46office.
- 6:48Not sure if that's always been the case for that office and how long it's it's been an
- 6:55elected office in general, but that's that's a unique situation over there.
- 7:01And then for a lot of local general offices or excuse me, local offices, their general
- 7:08elections are in odd years too.
- 7:10A lot of them.
- 7:11Not all of them, but a lot of them.
- 7:13So things like mayor and city council, and then some of those are even in non November months
- 7:19too.
- 7:20Tampa, Florida, my state, and Chicago are both notable instances of that.
- 7:26I think they're both I wanna say they're both April.
- 7:32Now as for the frequency of state executive elections, that is to say, the term lengths for
- 7:38these offices, that has also changed a lot over time.
- 7:41So that by default or inherently has changed when we vote for those offices too.
- 7:48So, today, every governor is elected for every four years except for New Hampshire and
- 7:55Vermont, which still have two year terms.
- 7:57And that two year term length was a lot more common, but many states changed from this
- 8:03throughout the twentieth century.
- 8:04In fact, 25 states that had two year terms at some point in the twentieth century have since
- 8:12moved to four year terms.
- 8:14And there are even a few states that had one year terms for governor at some point.
- 8:19Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Vermont.
- 8:24And Rhode Island and Maine changed this or changed from one year to two year terms in 1912
- 8:35and 1920, respectively, and then they later on became four year terms.
- 8:41And I believe I wanna say New Jersey actually had three year terms at some point.
- 8:47So very, looking back on it from today's lens, very odd, timing of elections in that regard
- 8:56were or in terms of how often those offices were voted on.
- 9:02And other state executive term lengths and election years have changed over time a lot as
- 9:07well, but it's harder to find comprehensive data on those.
- 9:11So things like attorneys general, lieutenant governor, if that's a considered a separate
- 9:19office to vote on, because some states have governor and lieutenant governor voted together
- 9:24similarly to president and vice president.
- 9:26But for some states, lieutenant governor is a separate election.
- 9:31Things like insurance commissioners, if they those are voted on, labor commissioners, all
- 9:37sorts of these other state executives, but problem is there's not really a lot of comp if
- 9:43any, comprehensive data on these elections, but, undoubtedly, at least some of those have
- 9:49changed over time.
- 9:53Now moving on to changing who we vote for, and, again, we'll start with the federal level
- 9:59first.
- 9:59So at the federal level, we've had two monumental changes in who we vote for, how we
- 10:07choose the vice president, and the fact that we even directly choose US Senators.
- 10:13So vice presidential changes, that came with the twelfth amendment.
- 10:18So initially, presidential voting did not distinguish between presidential and vice
- 10:23presidential candidates.
- 10:24They were all listed on the same ballot, and it was simply first place vote getter becomes
- 10:30president, second place vote getter becomes vice president.
- 10:34Now that's by default led to several instances where the president and the vice president were
- 10:40two different parties.
- 10:42Noticeably, in John Adams is only term in office.
- 10:46He won in 1796, and then Thomas Jefferson became the vice president because he was a
- 10:52second place vote getter.
- 10:54And then when Thomas Jefferson defeated John Adams, Aaron Burr became the vice president.
- 11:01Yes.
- 11:01That Aaron Burr.
- 11:04By following the eighteen hundred election when Jefferson defeated John Adams, the need for
- 11:11change in how these presidential votes were or how presidential voting was handled.
- 11:20The need for that change was recognized, you know, because that was also the first election
- 11:25where an incumbent was defeated because Thomas Jefferson defeated incumbent John Adams.
- 11:31And so the twelfth amendment would be ratified at eighteen o four, making the eighteen o four
- 11:37election the first where the president and vice president were distinct votes, and it paved the
- 11:44way for the presidential vice presidential tickets that we see today.
- 11:50So like with 2024, whereas Kamala Harris and Tim Walz on the Democratic ticket and Donald
- 11:55Trump and JD Vance on the Republican ticket.
- 11:59But, also, the twelfth amendment set the process for what we call contingent elections
- 12:05for president and vice president.
- 12:06And one of my early I think it wasn't really I think it was one of my earliest ones.
- 12:12Podcast episodes covered contingent elections and the electoral college in general.
- 12:18But the contingent election is where no one wins a majority of the electoral college.
- 12:24So if nobody wins a majority of the electoral college for the president, the US House decides
- 12:31from the three presidential candidates that won the most electoral votes, and the US Senate
- 12:39chooses the vice president from the two vice presidential candidates that won the most
- 12:44electoral votes.
- 12:45So for the US house and choosing president, each state delegation gets a vote for
- 12:51president, which means 50 votes, not 435.
- 12:54It is not every single US house rep.
- 12:57So all the reps from California would count as one vote.
- 13:01The lone rep from Wyoming counts as one vote.
- 13:06And then whoever wins a majority of the state delegations votes for president in The U in The
- 13:14in a contingent election would then win the presidency.
- 13:18And then for senate, it's just between two candidates.
- 13:21So simple majority of US senate votes.
- 13:24Each US Senator counts as a vote.
- 13:27Whoever wins the majority there becomes the vice president.
- 13:29So that was another thing that the twelfth amendment changed in terms of who we vote for
- 13:34for president and how we vote for them.
- 13:37And then lastly, on the changing who we vote for for federal elections point, we have the
- 13:44direct election of US Senators from the seventeenth amendment.
- 13:49So originally, US Senators were chosen by state legislatures.
- 13:54The idea the basic idea by the constitution's framers was that the US house would be more a
- 14:01matter of direct democracy because it was directly representative of the people, while
- 14:05the US senate was indirect democracy and representative of the states.
- 14:10In a sense that it was kinda like the electoral college, but within a single state.
- 14:17So for a US Senator, they'd have to win their state legislature's vote.
- 14:22You kinda think of the state legislature as the electoral college in that instance.
- 14:29But the direct election of US Senators was one of many progressive era political reforms at
- 14:35the beginning of the twentieth century.
- 14:39So US Senators go from indirect election to direct election.
- 14:43Seventeenth amendment is ratified in 1913, changing it so that US Senators become directly
- 14:50elected.
- 14:50And it was really the only constitutional amendment to substantially change the structure
- 14:56of Congress, not the only one that affected them, but are the only ones that really affect
- 15:00the structure of Congress substantially.
- 15:02Now as for changes in who we vote for at the state level, at the state level, there are
- 15:09considerable differences across states in which state executives are voted on.
- 15:15Some states might only elect their governor and lieutenant governor, while other states might
- 15:20elect eight, nine, 10 or even more state executives.
- 15:24And of course, there are some States within that range, too.
- 15:27They might have, like, four or five state executives that they vote on.
- 15:30And state executives, just to clarify, are ones like governor, lieutenant governor, attorney
- 15:37general, public service commission, insurance commissioner, labor commissioner, natural
- 15:42resources commissioner, those kinds of offices.
- 15:46Examples of states that only vote on their governor or lieutenant governor, Alaska and New
- 15:51Jersey, and then ones that elect a lot of state executives are ones like Arizona, Michigan,
- 15:57North Carolina.
- 16:00But what's really curious is that there were a few states that once chose their governors
- 16:06through means other than direct election.
- 16:09It's actually kinda similar to how US Senators used to be chosen.
- 16:13So eight states once chose their governors through their state legislature.
- 16:19Delaware did it until 1792, Georgia until 1825, North Carolina, '18 '30 '6, Maryland, '18 '30
- 16:27'8, New Jersey, '18 '40 '4, Louisiana, '18 '40 '5, Virginia, '18 '50 '1, and South Carolina in
- 16:351865.
- 16:37And in 1792 and 1796 in Kentucky, a specially elected body of electors chose the governor.
- 16:46And there were some states that also used to have it where there was a popular vote for
- 16:51governor, but if no if none of the governor candidates no.
- 16:56The gubernatorial candidates received a majority of the popular vote, then the state
- 17:01legislature would decide from that point.
- 17:05So very curious ways that state executives used to be chosen, including for governor.
- 17:11Now there's no comprehensive data, again, on which state executives have shifted between
- 17:16elected and appointed that I know of, but it's happened in various instances before.
- 17:22I can think of a couple of examples.
- 17:24In Florida, my home state, secretary of state and commissioner of education were elected
- 17:31until after the two thousand two election.
- 17:33Now they they still exist, but they are appointed positions now.
- 17:37And other states will have had similar changes as well.
- 17:41And and another change in that regard is there have been different state executives that have
- 17:47been created over time, sort of like how in the presidential cabinet, there have been the 15
- 17:53departments we have.
- 17:55Not all of them have been around since the beginning of The US, but they've been gradually
- 18:04more and more have been made over time.
- 18:06It's a similar thing with certain state executive offices in various states and use
- 18:13Florida as an example since the one I'm most familiar with.
- 18:16The chief financial officer came from a merger of the treasurer and comptroller offices,
- 18:22though those state executives.
- 18:24So you may see similar cases in other states were changed not just from appointed to elected
- 18:34or elected to appointed, but brand new state executive offices have been created at some
- 18:39point.
- 18:40And just like with state executives, it's hard to find comprehensive data on when exactly
- 18:48certain states started electing state level judges because for some states, they elect
- 18:54their state supreme court and intermediate appellate court judges through partisan or
- 18:59nonpartisan elections, but it makes sense to assume that there's been some change in that
- 19:05regard as well.
- 19:06So the who exactly moved toward partisan or nonpartisan elections and who moved away from
- 19:11them is incredibly difficult to pin down.
- 19:15That would take a lot more research to figure out if that information is even available.
- 19:25Now how about changing how we vote?
- 19:29Today, you go to a polling place.
- 19:32You go through the steps to get your ballot.
- 19:34You give them if you're depending on what state it is, you might have to give them a certain
- 19:39ID.
- 19:39You get your ballots.
- 19:40They tell you what exactly you're supposed to do with it.
- 19:43You go to a booth of some sort to vote privately.
- 19:47And once you do that, you take your ballot.
- 19:50You put it in.
- 19:52You feed it into the machine that counts it, and, your vote is counted.
- 20:00But that was not how US elections started off.
- 20:04Not obviously, we didn't have electronics way back then, but there was a lot more that was
- 20:11different about it than you might think.
- 20:13Originally, voting was done by voice vote in a method called viva voce, which is Latin for
- 20:20with the living voice.
- 20:21So you would go to the courthouse where the election is being, or where the polling is
- 20:28being done or wherever the polling is being done, and you would say out loud the candidate
- 20:32you are voting for.
- 20:33Now there are certainly people who go to vote that will let you know who they voted for, not
- 20:40necessarily yelling out loud in the place of polling, but they might wear paraphernalia.
- 20:49Technically, not supposed to in in in polling places, but, they'll certainly let you know at
- 20:55some point.
- 20:56But that was how this this voice voting was, how it was mostly done through the first fifty
- 21:05years of American elections.
- 21:07In fact, Kentucky, for some reason, was very late to the party, and it was the last state to
- 21:12move from voice voting in 1891, but a lot of states had given it up well before then.
- 21:19However, even when paper ballots were starting to replace vote or voice voting earlier in the
- 21:27nineteenth century, there were still significant problems with integrity.
- 21:32First of all, who hands out the ballots?
- 21:35In this or, back then at least.
- 21:37Initially, there was little to no regulation about who could hand out paper ballots.
- 21:43Newspapers printed out blank ballots that readers could tear off and fill in with their
- 21:48choices.
- 21:52More insidious was the fact that the political parties, particularly the party machines in the
- 21:58mid to late nineteenth century, could also print and distribute ballots.
- 22:02Party machines refers to these factions of the parties that controlled really big cities.
- 22:09So Tammany Hall, if you've heard of that, that is probably the most notorious, example of a
- 22:17party machine, but far from the only one.
- 22:20But because these political parties could print out these ballots, sounds insane today, but
- 22:29because they could do that, a lot of times, they conveniently listed only their party's
- 22:34candidates for office, and they make it incredibly easy to vote straight party tickets,
- 22:40meaning you just vote for the one party.
- 22:43And one way that these political machines consolidated powers, they often targeted new
- 22:50immigrants by promising them housing, jobs, all this good stuff as long as these immigrants
- 22:58pledged loyalty.
- 22:59You remember back then, immigrants were of basically, all stripes were treated with at
- 23:06best suspicion, if not outright disdain.
- 23:11But some of these party machines figured out a way to try to bring them in their into their
- 23:16fold.
- 23:16Hey.
- 23:17Welcome to America.
- 23:18You want some you want some food?
- 23:19You want housing?
- 23:20You want a job?
- 23:21All I ask from you is that you consistently vote for my party.
- 23:28And so with the way that a lot of immigrants were treated by other people, it was very easy
- 23:36to bring them into the fold of the party.
- 23:39And boom, you have loyal supporters and you consolidate your power as a political machine
- 23:46or as a party boss, like boss Tweed of Tammany Hall.
- 23:51So, obviously, this causes a lot of problems for election integrity.
- 23:57And so, enter the secret ballot.
- 24:01And sometimes this is called the Australian ballot because that was the country that made
- 24:05the first standardized government printed paper ballot in 1858.
- 24:10It would print the names of all the candidates and hand them hand these papers to voters at
- 24:18the polling place.
- 24:19But it took a while for that to get adopted into The US.
- 24:22In fact, about three decades later, it wasn't adopted until 1888 in Massachusetts and New
- 24:30York.
- 24:31But after that point, election technology started undergoing massive changes from that
- 24:38point on.
- 24:39So in the late nineteen or excuse me, in the late eighteen eighties, the ACME voting machine
- 24:44was invented, And this allowed poll overseers to count exact numbers of ballots compared to
- 24:50registered voters with a tabulator that was activated by lever mechanism that released the
- 24:55ballot in the ballot box.
- 24:58Problem with this was that election officials could, at least reportedly, tear or mark the
- 25:04ballots to make them invalid or just stuff more ballots in the box for additional votes.
- 25:13So that was obviously not gonna work for too much longer.
- 25:18So in 1892, the first lever style voting machine was used, and you would pull a large
- 25:24handle, close the machine's curtains, give you some privacy.
- 25:29The voter would see a board with candidate names, offices, and parties arranged in rows
- 25:34with small levers above them to poll, and it would as soon as you pulled one, it would lock
- 25:39in to prevent duplicate votes.
- 25:43That obviously was better than what came before with the Acme voting machine, but maintenance
- 25:50was very complex for those machines.
- 25:53The machine was inaccessible to those who were physically handicapped, labels were hard to
- 25:58read, and independent records were not recorded.
- 26:01And these independent records were needed to audit and recount an election.
- 26:07So if these independent records of these votes did not exist, made it very difficult to audit
- 26:14and recount elections.
- 26:16You can see the problem there.
- 26:19So it took many, many years later for another major breakthrough, not that there weren't
- 26:26improvements since then, but for the next really major breakthrough was what was called
- 26:32the coil, n c o y l e, which was invented in Ohio by Martin a Coyle, the namesake.
- 26:39It was the first voting machine to turn a punch card into a ballot.
- 26:45And as nifty as it was back then, it was too expensive and heavy.
- 26:50It was something like 33 pounds, which on its own is not a big deal, but when you gotta lug a
- 26:56whole bunch of those machines into a polling place, and then you gotta lug them back out, it
- 27:01becomes quite tedious and not everybody is so capable of lifting something like that.
- 27:08So too expensive, too heavy, and it also did not have a lever for a privacy curtain like
- 27:16those lever style voting machines of yesteryear.
- 27:20So, that created privacy concerns.
- 27:24Well, not too long after the coil was invented, Joseph p Harrison nineteen sixty five develops
- 27:31the Vodomatic punch card system.
- 27:34So a punch card ballot with candidates' names printed on pages of the ballot holder rather
- 27:39than a single card and much cheaper and lighter than the coil.
- 27:45So that became a lot more popular, but this would become the center of controversy in the
- 27:54two thousand presidential election.
- 27:56If you ever heard the term of a hanging chad, back so in the two thousand presidential
- 28:01election in Florida, there was some visual confusion around voter intent because of where
- 28:06exactly they hole punched their cards.
- 28:09Were they voting for Al Gore, or were they voting for George Bush, or were they voting for
- 28:15third party candidate Pat Buchanan?
- 28:18And so that caused a lot of of court fighting and and debates in the greater political
- 28:28culture about these hole punch or these punch card systems.
- 28:33And so these hanging chads in Florida, because of all this ambiguity about where the hole was
- 28:39punched and thus which candidates were being picked by voters, this led to significant
- 28:45reform in 02/2002.
- 28:47The Help America Vote Act is passed, and it sets minimum election administration standards
- 28:55for states.
- 28:56And standards included replacing these punch card systems with newer machines like optical
- 29:02scanners and things called direct recordings electronic systems or DREs for short.
- 29:08DREs are less common, but they're still around.
- 29:10I wanna say I was reading from I think, it was the council of state governments was saying 16
- 29:16states still use those.
- 29:19But Scott optical scanners are likely what you have seen lately when going to go vote.
- 29:26You just fill in the bubble next to your chosen candidate on this long ballot sheet, and you
- 29:30feed it into the machine, and it sucks it up and says your vote is counted, and it reads who
- 29:36exactly you voted for.
- 29:39So for all the debates about election integrity today, it's not nearly as much of an issue as
- 29:47it used to be.
- 29:48And, obviously, not to say that the debates today aren't important, but you look at the
- 29:58twentieth century and especially the nineteenth century, there were all sorts of issues with
- 30:03privacy, with fairness, with integrity.
- 30:09Party and government officials had plenty of opportunity to rig votes, especially with these
- 30:14party machines and these party bosses, in particular with handing out non standardized
- 30:19ballots.
- 30:20Remember, the parties themselves were at one point able to hand ballots with just their pin,
- 30:28party candidates names to people in general, but also immigrants who didn't know anybody who
- 30:36were trying to make a better life for themselves in America, and these party bosses
- 30:43manipulated them into becoming loyal party members, and so these, party machines
- 30:53consolidated their power.
- 30:54Obviously, that causes a lot of issues for integrity and fairness in elections, And it's
- 31:02certainly not perfect today, but we have made significant strides over two hundred and thirty
- 31:09five plus years with when we vote largely standardizing those dates, changing who we vote
- 31:18now, changing who or in terms of who we get to vote for, that's that's something I'm actually
- 31:24gonna cover in a later episode here.
- 31:26Basically, general debates about which elected or which officials that represent us, which of
- 31:33them should be elected versus which one should be appointed.
- 31:40So so I I wanna cover some of those debates more in a later episode.
- 31:46But just to demonstrate how much of what we take for granted today, was once not so
- 31:55obviously, was not considered obvious, not considered what you would think is obvious
- 32:04today was not necessarily considered obvious then.
- 32:07Took a lot of trial and error over time to come up with these reforms to voting policy.
- 32:15So, fascinating stuff, and, thankfully, we've come a long way since then.
- 32:21But, anyways, that is gonna do it for today's episode.
- 32:25As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 32:28I've got my Facebook, Paul Raider, comma, author and speaker.
- 32:32My LinkedIn, you can follow, matchmaker FM profile if you wanna be a guest on this podcast
- 32:37or you want me as a guest on your podcast.
- 32:41My short educational email course, free educational email course about some of the
- 32:48mistakes we make when trying to depolarize politics, why we make those mistakes, and how
- 32:53we can, correct those mistakes, My book, why independents rarely win elections and how they
- 33:01could become more competitive, available on Amazon in ebook and paperback formats, and I
- 33:08think that covers them all.
- 33:10But all that is in the show notes.
- 33:13Please like, comment, and subscribe, and share to, or share this podcast with your networks,
- 33:21your friends, anybody you come across, and that's gonna wrap it up for today.
- 33:27So, again, thank you so much for listening, and until next time, take care.