Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Liberal Christianity (2020 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. A lot of you have been sending me emails about
- 0:03your stories and your questions about religion, and it's something that isn't talked about
- 0:10enough, especially in psychology and psychotherapy circles, and so I've done my part
- 0:16to talk about it a little bit. To further the conversation, I thought
- 0:20I would play an interview that I was on another podcast. They interviewed me,
- 0:24and I thought I would play that. This is a podcast called the
- 0:28You Have Permission Podcast. You Have Permission. It's a progressive Christian podcast and
- 0:36they talk about psychology and beyond. And it's hosted by Dan Koch. So
- 0:41let's just get to that interview, Doctor Kirk Conda, Thank you so much
- 0:45man for joining me today. I am a fairly recent convert to your podcast,
- 0:50even though you are like a OG podcaster twelve years now, I think,
- 0:55right, Yeah, twelve years, over one thousand episodes, so many
- 0:59hours of me yammering into a microphone. Yeah, exactly. This show is
- 1:03called Psychology in Seattle. I love the show. I love how many diverse
- 1:07topics you tackle. And as I move closer and closer to myself being a
- 1:12clinician, I know it's going to be even more and more helpful. But
- 1:17most recently, in the episode on evangelicals and conspiracy theories and stuff like that,
- 1:22I pulled directly from your episode on conspiracy theories and what makes people likely
- 1:26to believe in them, so people might remember your name from that episode.
- 1:32This is the guy you guys, This is that guy in the flesh.
- 1:36But we're not talking about conspiracy theories today. We are talking about really faith
- 1:41and clinical practice and treatment and trauma and sort of where religion and spirituality overlap
- 1:48with your work as both a clinician with your own clients, but you're also
- 1:52a professor besides being a podcast you teach it Antioch University, one of the
- 1:56programs here in Seattle. So I know that you for for various reasons,
- 2:00professional reasons, you don't talk about your specific religious beliefs today. But in
- 2:07an episode that I really enjoyed, you did talk about the way you were
- 2:10raised, and I think that that can be helpful to give us some background.
- 2:15So can you give us a thirty thousand foot view on your religious upbringing?
- 2:19Yeah, I was born in nineteen seventy and we moved to Issaqui.
- 2:23If you're a local you know where that is. And it was a very
- 2:27small town, kind of rural at the time, and there were very few
- 2:30churches at the time, and so my parents joined the local church, Issaquah
- 2:36Christian Church. And at the time it was in a tiny little trailer next
- 2:40to the fish hatchery if you're familiar, and it was a bunch of you
- 2:46know, semi hippie people that had young kids in nineteen seventy and the brand
- 2:53of Christianity that it was was called non denominational, meaning that at least this
- 2:59non noma national church was focused on the sort of common factors if you will,
- 3:06across not only Christianity and all its various sex, but also across other
- 3:09religions, meaning that love is the answer, forgiveness is the answer, community
- 3:16is the answer. And I don't remember hearing anything about politics. I don't
- 3:21remember hearing anything about the sort of things you hear from evangelicals today, and
- 3:27I just felt I went to day camp. I went. You know,
- 3:30I have three siblings. The six of us would go to church together.
- 3:34It was a total event every Sunday, and my parents were quite devout,
- 3:39and me and my siblings were quite devout. I was baptized by my father
- 3:45in Lake Samamish because that's how our church would do it. It was very
- 3:49non hierarchical, if you know what I mean, as a church, very
- 3:53community, sort of grassroots, and I loved that upbringing and I have almost
- 4:00no negative memories of going to church and being in the youth group as a
- 4:05young teenager was a huge part of my development in terms of my self esteem
- 4:11and really leading me to become a therapist. Being psychologically minded. I mean
- 4:15in youth group, we would sit around in a circle and talk about our
- 4:18feelings and talk about our angers and our hurts and our aspirations. And the
- 4:26youth minister was probably twenty three at the time, but he was seeming so
- 4:30old to me, and there were older kids who were a few years older.
- 4:33I really looked up to them, and yeah, I just have so
- 4:36many wonderful memories about my experience. And the thing that has carried with me
- 4:42into being a professional is compassion and love. I explicitly talk about love as
- 4:47a therapist and as a professor. I think that our profession in psychology and
- 4:55in mental health is primarily a profession of love and compassion, and we should
- 5:00be explicit about that we can be professionals, and we could be ethical,
- 5:03and we could have professional boundaries. But at the core is what I believe
- 5:10to be ninety five percent true for people when I talk about this is at
- 5:13the core the reason why we enter this field is because we want to love
- 5:15other people. We want to have compassion. We have compassion, and we
- 5:18want to help, and we believe in the goodness of other people, and
- 5:24all of that I believe had a big part of you know, all my
- 5:29upbringing in church and the community had a huge impact on me in that way,
- 5:33and I'm really quite grateful for that. Having said that, Isakuah Christian
- 5:38Church has become more political. So if you just google their website, I
- 5:44don't know if it says anymore, but a few years ago, last time
- 5:46I checked, it literally says on one page that they do not support gay
- 5:49people and that they're against legalizing gay marriage and all these kinds of things.
- 5:55And there's the non denominational evangelicalism that I recognize, right, right, So
- 6:00in the seventies and eighties, for various reasons, right, I could speculate
- 6:03that just wasn't a concern, you know, the non denominational Christians weren't politicized.
- 6:11I don't remember anything. I remember a couple of things, as you
- 6:14might have heard in the episode that I talked about. I remember at a
- 6:16camp that we went to. I remember a teacher that wasn't from my church
- 6:20talking about how John Denver was evil because he talked about sunshine on my shoulders
- 6:26makes me high. And I remember, at the age of eight thinking that
- 6:30person was stupid because John Denver is an American treasurer. I knew that at
- 6:33the age of eight, So it was very occasional. And I worry about
- 6:39people today, you know, I worry about the state of mainstream Christianity today.
- 6:46Really. I think there's so much that Christianity can give us that I
- 6:48think is lost to people because of the political differences. Yeah, that's in
- 6:54a bad way, and it will reap the whirlwind to use some scriptural language,
- 6:58and it already is the exodus of young people, especially out of evangelicalism.
- 7:02It's only with all the politicization of this next election baked in, and
- 7:08then of course the fallout baked in whichever way it falls, it's just going
- 7:12to be a demographic bloodbath. That's something that we talk about a lot on
- 7:15the show, and kind of mentally preparing myself and some of the listeners for
- 7:20one thing. I just want to say I never say this, but I
- 7:23had a great youth group experience as well. I think it was really one
- 7:26of the places where I came into young adulthood. And compared to, for
- 7:31instance, my non denominational Christian high school, which I also really enjoyed,
- 7:36I had a good high school experience junior high high school. But most of
- 7:41the damaging teaching that I got did not come from my church or youth group.
- 7:46Purity culture came from all sides. This was the nineties and it was
- 7:49completely saturated with true love weights, conferences and rings and all that shit.
- 7:55But besides that, most of all the shitty stuff I got from school not
- 7:59from youth group and so, and in fact, I'm still very close friends
- 8:03with many people from youth group, you know, twenty years later. I
- 8:05just wanted to say that you mentioning the loving thing. My dad has been
- 8:09a therapist for forty years and one of his lifelong best friends and colleagues has
- 8:16one time said to me, my job is to professionally love people. And
- 8:20I didn't really know what that meant. When he told me this was before
- 8:22I was in a program. I think it was in fact, when I
- 8:26was calling him to kind of help discern whether or not I would start the
- 8:28program. But now having read a little bit about different modalities and like Carl
- 8:35Rogers and the clients centered approach and this idea that a lot of what therapy
- 8:39is is just making an alliance with another person, giving them unconditional positive regard
- 8:46so they feel safe and heard, and then just like helping them get shit
- 8:50out of the way as they try and progress, and that for the most
- 8:54part, people's progress will be actual. Like people want real progress, They
- 8:58want to be truly healthier, They want to love their loved ones better.
- 9:03Unless they are sociopathic or have certain kinds of personality disorders, most people,
- 9:09if you remove impediments, will become better, will become more loving themselves.
- 9:13And so it's been interesting to kind of get a little bit of theoretical language
- 9:16around that more colloquial way that he had told me in that conversation. Yeah,
- 9:22I'm glad that you're inspired by that, and that you see that it's
- 9:26kind of a rare thing. And given that you're just starting in the profession.
- 9:31That's even more pronounced because a lot of novice therapists feel this need to
- 9:37appear ultra clinical and dry and science based. You know, quote unquote,
- 9:45of course love is science bace. I just want to point that out,
- 9:46And Carl Rogers is one of the most science based therapies there is. It's
- 9:50often not characterized that way by people who are trying to grasp for resources.
- 9:56But I'm curious, did you grow up in the area. No. I
- 9:58grew up in the in California, so, you know, kind of culturally
- 10:03similar West Coast religious but not And I have some questions I want to get
- 10:07to sort of like the unchurched aspect of Seattle. Yeah, but no,
- 10:13I grew up in California. Let's start with some definitions here, just as
- 10:16a clinician and as a professor, what are your definitions of the terms religion
- 10:24and spirituality. Well, I'm not an expert on this area, so bear
- 10:28with me as I probably muddle my way through this thinking off the top of
- 10:31my head. But religion is a set of things to people, and it
- 10:35means a lot of different things a lot of different people. Right, But
- 10:39when I think of religion, I think of an organized group of people with
- 10:45a text that they follow or mole over, if you will. Every religion
- 10:52has its own text that they follow, literal texts and also ancillary texts,
- 10:58if you will, And there are certain principles that they follow, and certain
- 11:01rituals and ceremonies, and there's meaning and community. So that's what I would
- 11:07say is in religion obviously as history, and that's a big part of the
- 11:11meaning of people in the current times. So that's what I would say religion
- 11:16is, and religion, you could say, obviously with that definition, could
- 11:20extend into scientology, it could extend into other kinds of belief systems, if
- 11:26you will, that aren't always considered to be religion. But according to the
- 11:31broad definition, you know, it's a religion and the way that you've described
- 11:33it could exist without God as well, right, without even particular beliefs about
- 11:39God, right, and you know, locally, and I don't know how
- 11:43prevalent it is in San Franscot. I'm guessing it's similar the Universalists Unitarians well,
- 11:48from my observation, except Congregants who are atheists, right, you know,
- 11:54So they are a religion that proposes the idea of like, well,
- 11:58it's there is no God, and you can participate still in the humanist notions
- 12:05and celebration in our congregation. So that's my definite definition of religion. Spirituality
- 12:13when I think of that word and I think about the social construction in our
- 12:18society in Seattle and maybe the West Coast, is the more broader concept of
- 12:24a personal vibe or feeling or belief system that there's something greater, something greater
- 12:31than the physical world, a metaphysical existence of some kind. And it can
- 12:37range obviously from hard and fast religion, Catholicism, this sort of thing too,
- 12:43just a general sense of a greater meaning of You could argue that it's
- 12:48spiritual to say that the universe it appears to cycle itself, that it there's
- 12:56the big bang, and then there's the expansion, and then the the great
- 13:01you know, energy death, and then eventually there's another big bang and your
- 13:05awe and your sense of that we're all star dust. And even though that's
- 13:09hyper rational practical science, you could argue that, you know, it felt
- 13:15in a certain way, expresses in a certain way, it could absolutely be
- 13:18spiritual. Oh yeah, so that's my definition of those two things. Yeah,
- 13:22that's that works pretty well with Doug Shirley, who's a professor at Seattle
- 13:26School of Theology and Psychology, and when I interviewed him about a year ago,
- 13:31his kind of simple breakdown is spirituality is related to kind of the spark
- 13:35the desire for transcendence that basically all human beings have, and religion is the
- 13:41way that that gets codified in certain groups. And then of course that's relates
- 13:46to texts and rituals and behaviors and teachings and all that stuff and gatherings and
- 13:52whatnot, which I think is that's pretty good. So as a I'm curious
- 14:01what kinds of questions your students tend to bring up around the overlap of psychology
- 14:07and religion and spirituality. It's a great question. So you're at the Seattle
- 14:11School, I'm guessing you're I'm actually at Northwest Yeah. Oh, okay,
- 14:15I just know people at all the programs. Okay, I'm guessing people at
- 14:20Seattle School and SPU and these other more overtly religious graduate But if you're not
- 14:24aware and you're listening to this, in Seattle, we have a number of
- 14:28different graduate programs that teach mental health clinicians and most of them are actually Christian
- 14:33based. Yeah, it's weird. And Seattle school I was talking to one
- 14:37of our administrators and she said they actually produced the highest number of therapists of
- 14:41any of the schools in Seattle, which is a quite non religious city.
- 14:46So there is something very it's very odd that that's the case. I would
- 14:50question that figure, honestly, because Antioch is gigantic and I used to be
- 14:54a program director and I used to monitor all those marketing numbers. Of course
- 14:58I don't them from me now, but that might be true. But regardless
- 15:03of that, there's a large percentage of Seattle graduates who are graduating from the
- 15:07verious different even for example PLU it's a Lutheran university. And then we have
- 15:13Antioch, which is often confused with being a religious organization because Antioch is associated
- 15:20with because there's a lot of churches called Antioch. It's a New Testament somewhere,
- 15:26right. It's a great question. And what I'll say at Antioch is
- 15:31that I get no questions about religion or spirituality as a professor, and so
- 15:35I have to bring it up. And when I do bring it up,
- 15:39there's a lot of tension in the room, because the dominant discourse is that
- 15:46religion is bad and that it harms people and that it doesn't have a place
- 15:52in mental health discussions. Now I'm exaggerating, but sure, if you pulled
- 15:58like twenty people and just ask them at Antioch like what their position is,
- 16:03I would guess that of the different categories of responses, a pretty dominant response
- 16:07would be that. And of course there's a silent group of people who are
- 16:12either overtly Christian in their lives now or at least friendly to it and are
- 16:18afraid to bring it up because of worries that it's going to be stomped on.
- 16:25Now, it varies from professor to professor. There was a professor who
- 16:27taught at Antioch for thirty years and she was overtly Christian and had a cross
- 16:33that she would wear, a jewlry cross that she would wear when she would
- 16:37teach, and so she probably got you know, other sorts of responses.
- 16:41But I insert it into the discussions because for most people, they are religious,
- 16:48and for most people or at least spiritual spiritual, and for these people
- 16:55at least a good chunk of their lives is seeing through that lens, through
- 17:00that reality. And processed through that meaning system, and for you not to
- 17:07bring it up as a therapist is like not asking them how they feel.
- 17:11In my opinion, yeah, that particular position which I have not encountered.
- 17:15But again, I am at an overtly religious institution, although it's worth noting
- 17:21that the undergraduate institution of Northwest University is quite like standard evangelical. We do
- 17:26not have to like go to chapel and do all that like we're you know,
- 17:30we're related. But I could not go if I had to engage in
- 17:33that the kind of undergraduate stuff. But like, the research does not bear
- 17:38out that view that religion is harmful, at least not in a clinical setting.
- 17:42I mean, I've been doing research towards my dissertation recently and it's like,
- 17:47you see the articles that pop up are like religious people are happier,
- 17:51but why right, So it's not like they it's agreed they are happier.
- 17:56It clearly can be a help in people's from grief, from trauma, whatever.
- 18:02I don't know how much psychopathology you teach, but I'm sure you're aware
- 18:06of these culture bound syndromes that only occur in certain cultural environments, and they
- 18:11often recommend you bring the priest or the shaman or the whatever in because it
- 18:17actually helps people heal. It's like clinically backed up. So I'm a little
- 18:22bit shocked that people would have sort of that unnuanced of a view about religion
- 18:26if they are attempting to be steeped in the clinical research, right, the
- 18:30academic research. The other thing that I'll say is I find myself sort of
- 18:36in between what's going on in your classes and then what I get a lot
- 18:40at Northwest because a lot of the faculty are kind of evangelical, you know,
- 18:45their baby boomers are just below that and a little bit younger, you
- 18:49know, And I am like, it ends up being tense when religion comes
- 18:53up in my classes because I'm pushing back on the simplistic, sort of evangelical
- 19:00notions of how we might combine religion and mental health and psychology and in various
- 19:06theological concepts, and I'm kind of always like, actually, it's theologically more
- 19:10complex than that. And there are liberals and they think this, and so
- 19:12it's funny that the tension comes. I would say, like a third or
- 19:15half of my cohort is non religious, so it's not like all all Evangelicals,
- 19:21and we have a couple Mormons, like sort of pseudo practicing Mormons,
- 19:23and it's we have the whole gamut. But it's just funny that the tension
- 19:29is quite different there. Yeah. Yeah, And I commend you for speaking
- 19:37that side of things, because that's a scary place to be as a student
- 19:41to say, hey, well there's more nuance there. And I'm sure your
- 19:45fellow classmates are like, you know, I hope Dan says something because I'm
- 19:51thinking it, you know what I mean. Yeah, I don't know.
- 19:52Maybe, yeah, I don't get too scared in situations like that. Maybe
- 19:56I should be more deferential or whatever. No, no, no, I
- 20:00mean I don't know about your professors, but that worry. I've often heard
- 20:04from students that somehow they're going to be they're going to experience retribution grade downs,
- 20:11you know, downgrading at the end of the quarter. And I've I've
- 20:14literally never seen that in a professor. Professors are not petty third graders.
- 20:18But the other thing that I'll say, you know, getting back to what
- 20:22you said about the research, is yeah, I've experienced that a lot.
- 20:25And I don't know how much of the podcast you listened to. Beyond what
- 20:29you've listened to. But I have a co host that I've been with for
- 20:32twelve years. I'm Bardo Castanetta, and he grew up in Columbia, and
- 20:37I don't know exactly his exact upbringing, but he is he has one hundred
- 20:41and ten percent negative view about religion. And you know, he grew up
- 20:45in a Catholic country and experienced a lot of bad things apparently, And he
- 20:49actually has in his DNA history he found out that he's part Spanish, which
- 20:56means that under the Christian you know, cross his his peace, committed terrible
- 21:02atrocities over centuries throughout the Americas. And that's what he thinks of when he
- 21:07thinks of any religion or any spirituality for that matter. And so when I
- 21:12bring up any kind of research over the past twelve years, when I when
- 21:15I you know, research that you're pointing out that religion is a protective factor
- 21:19for a lot of things, protective factor for suicide, protective factor for various
- 21:23different mental conditions. Now, you know, what do we do with that
- 21:27information? Do we take an atheist and try to convert them? Right now,
- 21:32that's now, that's not what we're saying, but What we're saying is
- 21:34that there is health potential in meaning making, in community, in comfort of
- 21:44a God that may or may not exist, in believing that something is bigger
- 21:49than yourself, all those various different things that are common across different religious traditions,
- 21:56or you know, literally God exists and when you believe in him,
- 22:00he helps you out. There's no way to scientifically prove or disprove that hypothesis.
- 22:04But these are things that when I say it to I'mbardo and other people,
- 22:11they'll be like, well, you know, they can't just accept the
- 22:15data, right because of the traumas that they've been through and the traumas they've
- 22:19observed in other people. It is just an impossible pill to swallow for them.
- 22:26And I will often try to loosen people up, not because I'm trying
- 22:33to convert, because I'm not at all at all, but just to be
- 22:37open, you know, to the positive and negatives that religion can provide.
- 22:47Yeah, I'm going to come back to trauma there, spiritual trauma, because
- 22:52that is the focus of my own eventual dissertation, but also one of the
- 22:56ways that I try to not fall into the opposite trap, right, which
- 22:59is like, oh, look, the research just shows religion's good. So
- 23:03Christianity is true. Like a kind of a stupid, poorly thought out move
- 23:07is I try to be very honest about what the research shows that is negative
- 23:11about religion in people's lives. And the biggest takeaway, it seems to me,
- 23:15is that religion makes us groupish, right, So that has some short
- 23:21term benefits, and maybe happiness is one of those. And perhaps the more
- 23:25groupish you get, you take your wedding vows more seriously, you get divorced
- 23:29less often, you might whatever you have all this meaning as being a part
- 23:33of a group. But they show over and over again that there are negative
- 23:37outgroup consequences. Right, So people who are more religious will tend to get
- 23:44higher scores on xenophobia, they will do worse in terms of how they think
- 23:48about people who are not in their in group on various measures, right.
- 23:52And so for liberal Christians like myself, the sort of quest is, how
- 23:57do we maintain the good stuff without that negative byproduct? And I might be
- 24:04a little cynical, but I think that probably some of that negative byproduct is
- 24:07baked into the cake from the beginning to some extent, as you feel part
- 24:12of a group, you will feel less part of an out group. But
- 24:17I comfort myself in that Christ seems to constantly be pushing the boundaries of the
- 24:22in group. Somebody asks him what shall do to be saved? And then
- 24:26he says, how does the Tora read to you? And he says,
- 24:29love the Lord God with all your heart, love your neighbors, yourself.
- 24:32Jesus says, that's right, do this and you shall live. Another guy
- 24:34pipes up and says, well, who is my neighbor? And that's when
- 24:37Jesus tells the good Samaritan. So like the good Samaritan, which in our
- 24:41day could be like the good illegal immigrant or something like that. Right,
- 24:45it's like this person that you think is not a Jew, is not part
- 24:49of your group. That is the person who really loves the way that God
- 24:52loves. And so that's always the tension. And we've got to be careful
- 24:56not just selectively choosing the research that supports being religious and ignoring the stuff that
- 25:03says and then here are the sort of drawbacks of it. Yeah, I
- 25:06really love that. I mean, that's really a message that I see some
- 25:11Christians promote. Obviously, it needs to be, you know, greater promoted
- 25:18and in my opinion, it comes down to leadership. So if you're a
- 25:22leader of a religious community and you have racist ideas or you're not very enlightened
- 25:30yourself, then that's going to trickle down. Whereas if you are enlightened and
- 25:34you do spend the time and you aren't afraid to sacrifice some of your popularity.
- 25:41You know, the problem right now is that politics and the news and
- 25:45the echo chamber and religion is so intertwined that religious leaders, from my perspective,
- 25:55in order to stay solvent. I mean, these are people trying to
- 25:56start a business. I mean, that's what it is. And to say
- 26:00that it's not is to completely ignore the reality. You know, God doesn't
- 26:07send money to so that the you know, ministers and the staff people can
- 26:11pay their bills. It's the it's the congregants. The congregants give money too,
- 26:17and that that's how it happens. Well, if you say unpopular things
- 26:19politically, then you go out of business, and then you have no church.
- 26:25And even if you are enlightened, well no one's going to be listening
- 26:29to you. And so it's a vicious cycle. And that's the problem is
- 26:33that it's economic as all problems stem from, Yeah, it's the buck stops
- 26:41with the average congregant news viewer, et cetera. And the way that I
- 26:45think about it is, as Christians, we might hope that our discipleship of
- 26:52Christ would be the thing that primarily forms us, forms our character, forms
- 26:57our behavior, our rituals, our practices, our decisions. And sometimes that's
- 27:04true, But increasingly I interpret Jesus's thing about the narrow road and the wide
- 27:11road as having nothing to do with Heaven and Hell and everything to do with
- 27:14this question that actually, most people who live their lives under the banner of
- 27:18Christianity are not formed by that as much as they are formed by other things.
- 27:22And what happens to be true today and maybe wasn't true forty years ago,
- 27:27is that our socio political identity is the primary forming agent of all Americans
- 27:33right now. And if it's not for you, then you are the exception.
- 27:37And so people, you know, the simplest answer to the question why
- 27:42are all my evangelical parents and their friends voting for Trump, The shortest answer
- 27:47is they are formed by Fox News other conservative media. Their socio political identity,
- 27:53which has been trending this direction since the mid seventies, and you know,
- 27:59their frogs in the world in some sense, unless they are one of
- 28:02the few who has gone, oh, hold on, this isn't working for
- 28:04me. I need to be formed by something else. Then of those people,
- 28:08a big chunk are conversely formed by their new socio political left identity.
- 28:14And that is the shortest answer for why they opposed Trump. And only some
- 28:18percentage of each side oppose or support Trump for like sort of what we might
- 28:23call genuine reasons. They've really thought about it, They've really done the work,
- 28:27and they have concluded this thing. And for me and I talk about
- 28:32all the time at nauseum, but Jonathan Height's Righteous Mind has been the single
- 28:36most helpful kind of book and rubric for thinking about these things. Anymore to
- 28:41add on that topic before we move to spiritual trauma, No, I really
- 28:45like that. That makes a lot of sense. And the thing that I
- 28:48thought of was my mom. My mom is a devout Christian, and I
- 28:52remember early in the nineties we were talking about gay rights and she just simply
- 29:03said, and you know, she doesn't go to graduate school. And this
- 29:06is before any Internet or anything, and I just remember her saying, you
- 29:10know, I've heard some Christians say that gay people are wrong, but that
- 29:15just doesn't make any sense to me, because they're good people and that's how
- 29:22God made them. So that's the end of that. And I just and
- 29:27you know, I had all these political kinds of angles to take with it,
- 29:32and my mom she just simply she just looked at it and said,
- 29:36that doesn't just just doesn't make sense to me. Just another side note about
- 29:40my mom. In high school in Spokane, Washington, fell in love with
- 29:42my dad. My mom's white, white, blonde hair, and my dad
- 29:47is Japanese and at the time, it was literally illegal for my parents to
- 29:52date or get married across the United States. It was various different states.
- 29:56It was illegal for my parents to get married. And I asked him.
- 29:59I was like, how did you you get over that? She's just like,
- 30:00well, the racism just didn't make sense to me, so I wasn't
- 30:04going to go along with it. And so it's just a simple evaluation of
- 30:11reality or as a common sense thing for her. Yeah, it's kind of
- 30:15following her heart. There's good examples of people following in their hearts and then
- 30:18there's bad examples. Right, if she's following love, then there are basically,
- 30:22no bad examples of people following love, but there are bad examples of
- 30:26people following their unreflected intuitions for sure. Right, that's people can get And
- 30:34of course I don't mean to I'm not criticizing your mom, of course,
- 30:44but let's talk about spiritual trauma, because this is something that not only are
- 30:48a lot of listeners interested in, but as I said, this is what
- 30:51I plan to focus on in my own work. You mentioned the sort of
- 30:53spiritual trauma of your friend and co host Umberto, But I'm wondering about clients.
- 30:59So obviously, keeping everybody confidential, what are some examples of stuff that
- 31:06you know Seattle? I find anecdotally there's a lot of religious trauma in this
- 31:10city. People move here often from the Midwest or the South or other parts
- 31:14of the country that are more conservative. Where As one might my recurring guest,
- 31:21Terry Shoemaker, who's a sociologist, puts it, spiritual humidity or religious
- 31:25humidity is higher. It exerts more gravitational pressure on people than it does here
- 31:30on the West Coast. So I just imagine it must come up in your
- 31:34office. So I'm curious. Yeah, I don't know if there's any commonality,
- 31:38And I don't know if any of the stories that I would reference would
- 31:41be that surprising, but obviously being literally sexually traumatized by a leader or an
- 31:49extension of the church and then subsequently told to be quiet about it or something.
- 31:56We've all known those stories, and I've heard those stories, but I
- 31:59think were commonly it's a sense of family breakdown where you as a kid just
- 32:07wasn't that into it, and your parents were or one of your parents were
- 32:13very into it, and it created this rift in the family where you were
- 32:17identified as the bad kid, and it fueled and already dysfunctional system problem that
- 32:27led to even more distance and more neglect and more feeling as though you don't
- 32:31matter, you know, for a child to feel like your parents are choosing
- 32:37their religion over you over you yeah, yeah, which some religions will overtly
- 32:43say, oh yeah, I mean Jehovah's witness for instance, like active shunning.
- 32:46You know, if you if you're out, you are sucking out.
- 32:50Yeah, and the yeah, and their loyalty is more important. Yeah yeah.
- 32:52And there's a fair amount of Jehovah witnesses that are in Seattle, and
- 32:58I've treated a lot of them active and not active. Other things that I've
- 33:01heard are women who are in a marriage and they want a divorce, but
- 33:08their religion and their community is saying that that is just not an option and
- 33:14if you do, you're going to be essentially excommunicated and sent to Hell,
- 33:17and so they're in this totally tough position to be in. I've talked with
- 33:22people about that, but I think mainly what I hear is what I said
- 33:25in the middle. There is family difficulty being exacerbated by people taking sides about
- 33:32what religion it's supposed to be in the family. Well, that's interesting because
- 33:37I am not one of the kids who didn't take it seriously. And almost
- 33:42nobody who listens to this podcast was one of those kids, or else they
- 33:45would not listen to this podcast. They'd be listening to Bill Simmons or Fresh
- 33:49Air or whatever else. You know, Joe Rogan, because the whole point
- 33:53of this show is like you could say, like, Okay, so you
- 33:57care deeply about faith, but you have these problems. So that would be
- 34:00like that's the one liner intro. You know, I could give to somebody
- 34:04like the elevator pitch for you have permission but once I do this work clinically,
- 34:09I will get a lot of those clients that will just be I'm just
- 34:13kind of flagging that for myself as something interesting to think about. You know,
- 34:16the level of how serious one takes it, and if it's when it's
- 34:21the family member that takes it seriously and it's not you, how that looks
- 34:23from the outside, and that's that's really interesting. But you also mentioned hell,
- 34:29and I'm curious. Fear of Hell is one of those topics that I
- 34:32am just so interested in because on the one hand, it is so absolute,
- 34:37it is literally the worst possible thing you could ever tell anybody what happened
- 34:44to them. And on the other hand, there appear to be really kind
- 34:47of hard psychic limits for most people about what they can really believe about.
- 34:52Like, for instance, there's research that shows that almost nobody who believes that
- 34:57hell is concrete, eternal people going there believes that they're going there right Like,
- 35:01it's like two percent or less than one percent or something, because you
- 35:06can't believe that right like, you have to basically be in incredibly self loathing
- 35:10or something like that to believe that you're going to experience that thing. My
- 35:15question for you. That's a big lead up I apologize, is what do
- 35:19you notice about your client's actual beliefs about hell, Like do they believe it?
- 35:25Like what's your professional opinion of their sort of cognitive state, or do
- 35:30they repeat things that they've heard the way that they've been said, or you
- 35:35know what I'm saying. You see what I'm getting at. Yeah, Well,
- 35:37the broader answer I'll say is, on average, most of the clients
- 35:43when we get into this topic, which I don't always with every client,
- 35:45there's a lot of amorphous agnostics in Seattle who have a general belief that there
- 35:52is something greater and they might have kind of pseudo Christian or if they grew
- 35:59up Jewish, like pseudo Jewish or pseudo Mormon ideas that they don't really identify
- 36:05as Christian, you know, like karma is an idea that people will often
- 36:08go to that isn't from the East, it's from the West. That idea
- 36:13actually comes from the Christian and the Jewish Bible. So but anyway, so
- 36:19most of the people that I guess, on average I talked to would probably
- 36:23say, now, they don't really believe in a hell, and they might
- 36:30believe in a nice afterlife. I feel I feel like there's a I don't
- 36:34know just the people I run into, but I feel like there's a lot
- 36:36of people who personally and professionally, and when I ask them this question,
- 36:39because I'm actually curious as a person who thinks about this a lot, I
- 36:43find that people's ideas are fairly unformed. They have ideas, but when I
- 36:49ask them, because they'll give me sort of an amorphous answer, and then
- 36:52I'll say, well, do you believe in an afterlife? Because that's one
- 36:54of the questions that I actually ask a lot of my clients when they've lost
- 36:58someone close to them it's relevant. Yeah, They'll say, like, well,
- 37:02you know, and they'll kind of give a long answer as if this
- 37:07is the first time they've really spoke out loud about it. Right now.
- 37:09Obviously, if you're a Christian you go to church every Sunday, you're probably
- 37:14going to have an answer to that. But a lot of people in Seattle
- 37:16don't, as you say, like the unchurched, right, even churched people
- 37:21have you know, ambiguity about yes, they don't necessarily buy the party line
- 37:25right. So consequently, I anecdotally would say most people don't even consider hell
- 37:30to be like a viable possibility. Otherwise I think they would do something about
- 37:37it. You know, if you if you even kind of believe in hell.
- 37:43This is one of my favorite arguments to make, is like nobody does.
- 37:46The only people who act like they do, we think are have mental
- 37:51disorders. Basically, you know, like the person screaming at you at the
- 37:53baseball game is the only person acting like they really believe in hell, and
- 37:58most of us think probably something up with that guy, right, So there
- 38:01is a funny disconnect there, and I try to promote that idea. I
- 38:06try to tell people because so many people in my circle look at sort of
- 38:12fundamentalist religious people is totally wacko. And what I try to impart on them
- 38:17is what I grew up actually believing. That was a big part of my
- 38:21upbringing was Hell. I remember there was not a lot of talk about it,
- 38:24but there was there was some overt talk about it. And what I
- 38:28try to tell people is like, look, if we all understand that there's
- 38:30religion, right, and there's religious people, and if you're in that camp,
- 38:36of which there are many, and you believe in Hell, then it
- 38:38is imperative that you try to save people from going there, and you're the
- 38:44most moral person on the planet to be standing on the corner and trying to
- 38:47alert people to the fact that they might be suffering and going they're not.
- 38:51These people aren't a holes. These are like this comes from love. Now,
- 38:55you could be annoyed with it, and you could be bothered by it,
- 38:58but don't look at that person and think they're some kind of jerk face
- 39:01for doing it. Like from where they come, this is a wonderful thing
- 39:05that they are doing it. It's they are loving you in the way that
- 39:07they want to love you. You could be annoyed, but don't look at
- 39:12it like they're evil. Right, Yeah, I would tend to think of
- 39:15them as being misled and maybe dealing with some mental health issues like religious scrupulosity
- 39:22or something where they feel like if they don't perform really perfectly, God will
- 39:27hate. I mean, there could be quite a bit of dark shit under
- 39:30the surface, or they could just be like fairly straightforward simple people, not
- 39:37in the sense of simple minded, but just like this is what I believe,
- 39:39and this is I think the best way to spend my day or whatever,
- 39:44and I'm doing it because I care about these people. And you know,
- 39:46I think they're wrong, but they're not a jerk for it, right,
- 39:50right. I always think about this one metaphor that a minister, not
- 39:53the minister at my church, but I went to a friend's church in Bellevue
- 39:58and it was actually Ken Hutchinson. I think his name was an ex He
- 40:01was an ex Seahawks player, okay, and very popular, and I loved
- 40:07his church because all the Seahawks went to that church. Kenny easily these kind
- 40:12of people. Anyway, he gave this one metaphor this one time he said,
- 40:15Okay, what we are in this room, this is what we are
- 40:20like. We are like people who are driving in a car and we're going
- 40:23to a bridge and we see that the bridge is out and there's a cliff
- 40:28into certain death, and we slam on the brakes. But there's fog.
- 40:32I remember, you know, there's it's hard to see. You don't have
- 40:35very good visuality. Yeah, And so you get out of the car and
- 40:38you see cars coming down the road and you're waving your arms saying, don't
- 40:43go down this road because there's certain death and destruction and terribleness. And we
- 40:50are the people on the side of the road. Screaming, you know,
- 40:52and waving our arms. I still remember that to this day. It applies
- 40:57to a lot of situations, I think. But when I think of those
- 41:00people on the corner, or the people who come to my door, and
- 41:04even Jevah Witnesses for that matter, I think that's where they're coming from,
- 41:08and that's what they're trying to do. Whether or not I'm on board with
- 41:12that, I know where that comes from. Yeah. I used to use
- 41:15that metaphor as well, and it described my understanding of what I was doing
- 41:20when I was much more overtly evangelistic in my efforts. And I've just come
- 41:24to believe over time, not least because of Jonathan Height's work, that like
- 41:29it doesn't work, that's not how people's minds are changed, first of all,
- 41:32and then second of all, of course I don't believe in that kind
- 41:36of eternal punishment anymore. So what's the cliff I'm saving them from. It's
- 41:39probably more like themselves than it is hell or something. And if you're saving
- 41:44people from themselves, then that's even more nuanced and complex, and you really
- 41:47realize you just got to lean into loving people basically, which even as a
- 41:52clinician as you brought up, I wanted to ask you a little bit more
- 41:55about the kind of research that you end up. I know you're not an
- 42:00expert in the religion and spirituality research, but you do know some stuff and
- 42:04you've been practicing with clients for a long time. So when you're in a
- 42:08session with the client and something comes up around religion and spirituality, what do
- 42:15you tend to call to mind or use with them, or what's sort of
- 42:20the strongest, most empirically backed stuff that you feel most confident in using to
- 42:27respond to these sort of religious spiritual concerns or problems. Well, I don't
- 42:31typically get spiritual or religious concerns directly, but there's two main things that I
- 42:37have to bring up, and I tell them all my trainees this as well,
- 42:40because I want them to consider it. The first one is what I
- 42:45mentioned earlier, is that when someone dies in their life, I always ask
- 42:47do you believe it in afterlife? Because even if you're not religious, you
- 42:51might believe that they You know, people will say I just feel like their
- 42:54presence is still with me. And that's an important detail to know about your
- 43:00clients in terms of how they process loss. And you need to know that
- 43:04as a clinician. Now, if they just believe their lights are turned off
- 43:07and they're gone, then that's you also need to know that as well.
- 43:09But if they believe that they're present or they literally believe that they can directly
- 43:15commune with that person, Okay, so that's one question that Yeah, that's
- 43:19one question that I feel like is if you don't ask, why are you
- 43:22not asking a question? That's a pretty important question to ask people who have
- 43:25lost someone, and frequently people come with therapy having lost them. The other
- 43:30question I ask is more prompted when I see people struggling with the meaning of
- 43:35their life, which is frequent because even just depression, I think is often
- 43:39a crisis of lack of purpose. I will ask, one, do you
- 43:44believe in God? And two what does God want for you? Or what
- 43:49is your purpose? What purpose does God want you to have on this planet?
- 43:52Or if you believe in reincarnation, what does the universe have you know
- 43:58for your purpose? There's a reason and why you're on this planet or do
- 44:01you believe that there's a reason you know? And so most people do most
- 44:06people believe that a lot of people believe that either there is a God,
- 44:09or a universe that has ideas about humans or even us in particular, and
- 44:17contemplating that question and coming to your own answer, I think is an antidote
- 44:23to a lot of problems that people come to therap before. Yeah, that's
- 44:27good. What about like mindfulness or some of the some of the research around
- 44:32prayer and more in the abstract, not necessarily the like those studies they tried
- 44:37to do with intercessory prayer where they're trying to prove if it works or not,
- 44:42which I had a client who told a really funny story of her son
- 44:45reading about those and telling her his mom, Mom, I just invalidated all
- 44:50those studies because I went and prayed for all those people. Right, It's
- 44:53like those ones are silly. But the sort of the internal effects of prayer,
- 44:59right, the brain functions and stuff like that. Do you do mindfulness
- 45:04stuff with your clients? Do you consider that to be similar to prayer?
- 45:07Is that something other therapists do more than you. I'm just curious about any
- 45:09of that stuff. Yeah, I know a lot of people who use mindfulness.
- 45:13I don't. I like mindfulness, It's just not really my style.
- 45:16And I have a much more relational, interpersonal direct way of working with people,
- 45:23and that's more homeworky to me, especially if they're not doing it.
- 45:28Yeah, but I totally value that and one hundred percent understand the research that
- 45:32supports mindfulness as a thing. How it relates to prayer, And I guess
- 45:37you other question of it's probably clear that I don't recommend prayer, you know,
- 45:42I don't suggest it to you don't. Yeah, yeah, exactly,
- 45:45But if it does come up and people they like in that, you know,
- 45:50I could see a scenario and I can remember a handful of where someone's
- 45:53struggling with the purpose of their life, and I'll and I might ask the
- 45:55question, you know, what does God or the universe want from you?
- 45:59And then I might say, well, they and they might be confused.
- 46:02I mean like, I don't know, I don't know what the purpose of
- 46:06my life is, and yeah, you know, I don't know what God's
- 46:08wants for me. Then I'll be like, well, do you talk to
- 46:10God? Do you ask when you ask God? What does God say?
- 46:14Or are there signs? When you think right now about God in the room
- 46:20with us right now, what do you think he would tell you? Can
- 46:22you hear God? Obviously not in the hallucination sense, but you know,
- 46:27in the sense that most personal spirituality people have. And that's the way I
- 46:30grew up. That was the version of Christianity I grew up with, was
- 46:35that everyone has a personal relationship with God and no one else can comment on
- 46:38that. And so I'll definitely ask that question. I guess that relates to
- 46:43prayer, and I certainly recognize the data pointing in the direction that prayer provides
- 46:50a lot of things that in positive psychology that we point out of gratitude.
- 46:54So a lot of prayer traditions grace for your meal. You're expressing gratitude for
- 47:00the meal that has been shown to have tremendous positive effects on average for people.
- 47:07Having a sense that there's an all knowing, all loving presence that is
- 47:12looking out for you obviously would have a lot of benefits to that. Processing
- 47:17your thoughts quietly or communally obviously has a lot of benefits as well as well.
- 47:23Having positive thoughts about another person and saying I pray for this person or
- 47:30this group of people can have a lot of positive outcomes as well. So
- 47:35I don't know if that answers your question. Well, it's good, it
- 47:37sort of does, and it leads me in a couple little directions for their
- 47:40last few minutes here. I was just listening to this fantastic interview that Ezra
- 47:44Kleine did. I forget. That guy's name is Cyrus Habib. He is
- 47:50a blind he's the lieutenant governor of the state of Washington, and he is
- 47:53not running for reelection. A lot of people thought he would become governor,
- 47:58especially if Biden wins and Inns becomes Secretary of environment or whatever that is called
- 48:05the environmental cabinet position, that this guy might have become governor. And he's
- 48:09becoming a Jesuit. He left politics, he's taken a vow of abstinence,
- 48:15poverty, and obedience, and he's becoming a Jesuit. And he had been
- 48:20in conversation with Ezra Klein, who's an atheist, and Ezra had been doing
- 48:23the examine, which is like the primary Jesuit prayer that you do at the
- 48:27end of the day, and you can do it in a non religious kind
- 48:30of a way. But one of the things the first thing you do is
- 48:34you searched back through your day with gratefulness, and you find the stuff and
- 48:38you sort of meditate on in that soft sense. You know, the good
- 48:43things in your day and where you found meaning, and then you also look
- 48:46for the stuff that you didn't do with the way you'd want to do it,
- 48:49and you know all of that. So it just reminded me of that.
- 48:51And when you said gratitude has been shown to be helpful, I'm really
- 48:54interested in this kind of in the positive psychology stuff and the relationship between classic
- 49:00conversations about virtues, you know, gratitude, humility, forbearance, stuff like
- 49:06that. You also mentioned the sense of having someone looking out for you or
- 49:09whatever, and I've been thinking about this a lot, So this will be
- 49:13my last question. But we have a six month old and we have started
- 49:16reading books to him. We've had to be quite careful which Christian books we
- 49:22are happy with, given our modified set of beliefs and our desire to avoid
- 49:29harming him with vengeful God stuff like that. But we've started to read these
- 49:34books that are like God Loves You. And that's the thing that I believe
- 49:37is true. I cognitively believe it, and I also experientially believe it based
- 49:43on my prayer practice, And of course I can't prove it. I can't
- 49:46prove it to myself, much less prove it to sore in my six month
- 49:50old. But I have been thinking about it, and I just I wanted
- 49:53to pick your brain. So, coming from you know, pretty clinical,
- 49:57non religious angle here, what is that benefit of having that sort of belief
- 50:04that, yeah, there is a benevolent force looking out for me in some
- 50:07sense. I don't happen to believe that God is like supernaturally removing obstacles for
- 50:12me and like favoring me over other people or anything like that. I don't
- 50:15believe that, and I will not teach Soren to believe that to the extent
- 50:19that I can. But I do believe that God loves me and cares me,
- 50:22and that that kind of love is at the center of creation, big
- 50:25bang whatever, the universe existing, and my ability to be a sentient being
- 50:30in that universe and experience the insane gracious gift that is life. Okay,
- 50:36that was preachy, but you can not respond to that just the straight question
- 50:40of what is the benefit, Like if Sorin can grow up with that sense
- 50:45firmly as opposed to not having that sense, what benefit does that confer?
- 50:49Well, tremendous benefit And data shows this that when one has a sense that
- 50:55life has meaning one and that you have meaning, and that meaning does transcend
- 51:02atoms and quarks in this kind of thing. Then it feels good, you
- 51:07know, for me, whether it's by God or the universe or my humanistic
- 51:15leanings my mission in life. My purpose in life is to try to make
- 51:19the world a better place. And I don't know if I ever succeed,
- 51:22but that that's what I try to do. And I could die at any
- 51:28point and say, well, I know I was in line with my purpose,
- 51:31and I'm satisfied with what I did with my time overall. So there's
- 51:37that benefit. The other benefit is, like we've been saying, the comfort
- 51:42of two things. One that an all powerful, all knowing creature or presence
- 51:49is looking out for me. That is a wonderful feeling that Sorein probably has
- 51:53anyway, because you and you know your family is looking over Soorin, we
- 52:00will hopefully have quite secure attachment, right, well, you just will.
- 52:05The thing I tell parents is limit your damage so that he only needs five
- 52:09years of therapy when he's an adult, exactly. Yeah, that's the best
- 52:12you can hope for, honestly. So that's a tremendous benefit. So yet
- 52:16another presence besides you in his life that is there for him. And when
- 52:22he is eight years old, fifteen years old and he doesn't feel like he
- 52:27could talk to you or he's alone, and he stares into the darkness and
- 52:32he sees a loving God, that is a tremendous comfort. And we live
- 52:39in a world now that we need more of that. We're more isolated,
- 52:45there's more threats to our well being and safety and threats to connection that to
- 52:52have that presence, whether rational or not, has so many benefits to it.
- 53:00Now, as you talk, I don't think I've ever answered a question
- 53:02like this before. And as we talk about it, it's like, obviously,
- 53:07there's other ways to do it. Aside from talking about a god,
- 53:10right, you could talk about meaning in general. You could talk about ancestors.
- 53:15You could talk about doing the right thing for your own ego to observe
- 53:21yourself having done something that would you know, like you're your best judge and
- 53:24jury. At the end of the day, can you look at yourself and
- 53:29see that you did what you needed to do. You know, there's a
- 53:30lot of different angles atheist and religious, you know, combined, but focusing
- 53:37on that and having some way of imparting that on your children, I think
- 53:40is a wonderful thing. It's just it's it's wonderful. Doctor Honda, Thank
- 53:45you so much, man for your time, great conversation, and thank you
- 53:49for inviting me on. I love talking about this as I think as evident,
- 53:52and no one ever asked me about this because we live in an unchurched
- 53:55Seattle. All right, Well that was my inner with Dan Koch from the
- 54:01You Have Permission podcast. Check it out if you're interested and let me know
- 54:07what you think comment below, email us, go to our website, contact
- 54:10us, and let us know your own experiences. I'm guessing that this at
- 54:15least provoked some thoughts in your own stories, and you know, let me
- 54:21know what you think. I think we should be talking about this more often
- 54:25because for a lot of reasons. One is, it's an important part of
- 54:30most people's lives. And also I find that when it comes to religion,
- 54:36only certain types of voices get propagated through our society, which I don't think
- 54:40is a good idea. That does it for that episode of psychology and Seattle,
- 54:44thanks for joining us out there. Please take care of yourself because you
- 54:46deserve it. You really really do a paper were in