Latest / Why the Mongol Empire Split Apart So Quickly — Fexingo History / The Mongol Split: Who Really Broke the Empire?
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about how the Mongol Empire held together for a while, and then how it started to crack. But I think it's worth asking: who actually broke it? I mean, there's a moment where it goes from being one empire to four separate khanates, and it's not like there was a single decision. It was a cascade of choices, and a lot of them were personal. Luna: You mean like the infighting between Khubilai and Ariq Böke? Lucas: Exactly. That's the big one, the Toluid Civil War. But it's also the one we've touched on before. I want to look at the details of how that war actually unfolded, because it's so messy. Khubilai was campaigning in southern China when Möngke Khan died in 1259. Ariq Böke, his younger brother, was left in Karakorum, the old capital. And Ariq Böke saw an opportunity. He called a kurultai and had himself declared Great Khan. Lucas: Now, a kurultai was supposed to be a gathering of all the princes and the military leaders, a big assembly that would choose the next khan. But Ariq Böke's kurultai was small, just his supporters. Khubilai, meanwhile, was in Kaiping, which is in modern-day Inner Mongolia, and he called his own kurultai, and he got himself declared Great Khan too. So you have two brothers, each claiming the title, and each thinking the other is the usurper. And the rest of the Mongol world had to pick a side. Luna: So it's like a schism, right at the top. Lucas: Right. And it wasn't just about the title. It was about where the empire was headed. Khubilai was based in China, he was surrounded by Chinese advisors, he was starting to adopt Chinese customs. Ariq Böke was in the steppe, surrounded by traditionalists, the people who wanted to keep the old nomadic ways. So it's a cultural divide as much as a political one. And it's a family feud, because these are brothers, sons of Tolui, grandsons of Chinggis Khan. Lucas: The war itself was brutal. It lasted about four years, from 1260 to 1264. There were battles in Mongolia, in the Tarim Basin, even in the eastern parts of the Chagatai Khanate. Khubilai had the advantage in resources, because he controlled China, the richest part of the empire. But Ariq Böke had the symbolic advantage, because he held Karakorum, the old capital, and he had the support of some powerful princes, including Berke Khan of the Golden Horde, at least at first. Luna: Berke was the one who converted to Islam, right? Lucas: That's him. He was the khan of the Golden Horde, the westernmost part of the empire, and he had his own reasons to support Ariq Böke. He was wary of Khubilai's power, and he had a feud with Hulegu, who was Khubilai's brother and the founder of the Ilkhanate in Persia. So the civil war in the east was tangled up with the feud in the west. It's like a spiderweb of alliances and grudges. Lucas: And the Chagatai Khanate, which was in Central Asia, became a battleground too. Ariq Böke sent his own candidate, Alghu, to take over the Chagatai Khanate, but Alghu ended up switching sides to Khubilai. That made things even messier. So you have all these different factions, each playing their own game, and the empire is fragmenting in real time. Luna: It sounds like the succession crisis just tore everything open. Lucas: It did, but it's also important to remember that the succession problem was baked in from the start. Chinggis Khan himself never set a clear rule for how the next khan would be chosen. The kurultai was supposed to decide, but it was always a forum for negotiation and sometimes for conflict. And after Chinggis, there were always multiple contenders, and the empire was so vast that it was hard for any one person to control it all. Lucas: So when Möngke died, there wasn't a clear successor, and the two most powerful candidates were Khubilai and Ariq Böke. And their war ended in 1264, with Ariq Böke surrendering to Khubilai. But by then, the damage was done. The empire was already split, and it never really came back together. Berke Khan had already established the Golden Horde as an independent state, and Hulegu was building the Ilkhanate in Persia, and the Chagatai Khanate was doing its own thing. So even though Khubilai won the title of Great Khan, he only really ruled over the Yuan dynasty, which was essentially China and Mongolia. Luna: So the empire was already gone, even though Khubilai was still calling himself Great Khan. Lucas: Pretty much. He was the Great Khan of a rump state, and from then on, it was four separate Mongol empires, each with its own khan, its own identity. And they fought each other as much as they fought outside enemies. The Golden Horde and the Ilkhanate clashed over the Caucasus and the Silk Road trade routes. The Chagatai Khanate was in constant conflict with the Yuan dynasty. So the unity that had allowed the Mongols to conquer so much territory was gone, and it was never coming back. Luna: I wonder if there's a point of no return, like a specific moment where you can say, 'This is when it all fell apart.' Lucas: Historians often point to the Toluid Civil War as that moment, and specifically the dual kurultais in 1260. But I think it's even earlier than that. It's the death of Möngke Khan in 1259. Because Möngke was the last khan who had real authority over the entire empire. He could order a campaign in China and also in Persia, and the other khans would follow. After he died, there was no one who could command that kind of loyalty from all the branches. So it's not just a civil war; it's a systemic failure. Lucas: And there's another layer to this, which is the religious angle. Berke Khan had converted to Islam, and he was genuinely outraged when Hulegu sacked Baghdad and killed the Abbasid caliph in 1258. That wasn't just a political move; it was a religious offense. So when the Ilkhanate and the Golden Horde started fighting, it was partly about territory and trade, but also about religion. And that added a ideological dimension to the split that made reconciliation even harder. Luna: So it's not just about who gets the throne, it's about who gets to be the leader of the Muslim world, or the defender of the faith. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the Silk Road trade got caught up in all this. The Mongols had controlled the entire Silk Road, and that was a huge source of revenue and prestige. But once the empire split, different khanates controlled different sections, and they started taxing and restricting trade to hurt each other. There were even instances where one khanate would block caravans from going to another. So the Pax Mongolica, that era of relative peace and safe travel, was really a casualty of the split. Luna: I've also heard that the split made it easier for outsiders to invade, like Timur later on. Lucas: Right. The fragmentation meant that no single Mongol state could project power the way the unified empire had. And by the time Timur rose in the late 14th century, the Chagatai Khanate was a mess, and he was able to carve out his own empire, using Mongol symbols but with his own Turkic-Mongol identity. So the split didn't just end the empire; it set the stage for centuries of conflict and new empires in Central Asia. Lucas: And I think that's something we should reflect on. The Mongol Empire fell apart not because of external pressure, but because of internal divisions. It was a family fight that spiraled out of control, and once it started, there was no turning back. It's a lesson about how fragile empires can be, even ones as powerful as the Mongols. Luna: It's almost tragic, when you think about how much they had achieved together. Lucas: It is. And it's a reminder that the people who built these empires are human, with the same ambitions and flaws as anyone else. But that's what makes history so fascinating, right? It's not just dates and battles; it's about people making choices, and those choices having huge consequences. And I think that's something worth thinking about when we look at the world today, too. Lucas: Before we go, I want to mention something that's been on my mind. We've been making these episodes for a while now, and it's been a real journey. But the thing is, these episodes are only possible because of the support from listeners. A couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going. If you've gotten something out of them, you can help keep them ad-free by going to buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small thing, but it makes a real difference. Luna: Yeah, it really does. And it's easy to do, if you're so inclined. Lucas: Right. And we're not going to belabor it. But thank you for even considering it. Now, back to the Mongols. So we've been talking about how the split happened, but there's another question that's interesting: what did it mean for the people living in the empire? I mean, for the ordinary nomads and merchants, what changed? Luna: Did the split affect them as much as the khans? Lucas: In some ways, yes. When the empire was unified, you could travel from the Black Sea to the Pacific without much trouble, as long as you had the right documents. After the split, you had to deal with different laws, different taxes, and the risk of war at the borders. The Silk Road became more dangerous, and trade declined. So the Pax Mongolica, which had been a real thing, was over. And that had a ripple effect on economies from China to Europe. Lucas: But it's also true that the Mongol states that emerged were still powerful in their own right. The Yuan dynasty in China lasted until 1368. The Golden Horde survived in some form until the 15th century. The Ilkhanate collapsed in the 14th century, but it was succeeded by other Mongol or Turkic states. So it's not like they all just vanished overnight. It was a gradual process of decline and transformation. Luna: So the empire didn't die, it just turned into something else. Lucas: That's a good way to put it. The Mongol Empire, as a single political entity, was gone. But the Mongol peoples, and their culture, and their political traditions, lived on in those successor states. And that's something we can still see in Central Asia today, in the histories of the Kazakhs and the Uzbeks, who trace their roots back to those Mongol khanates. Lucas: So when we ask why the Mongol Empire split apart so quickly, the answer is complex. It's about succession rules, cultural divisions, personal ambitions, and even religion. But it's also about the fundamental challenge of ruling an empire that stretched across so many different peoples and environments. The Mongols managed to do it for a few generations, but it was always going to be hard to hold together. And in the end, the forces of fragmentation won out.