Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 189:13-18. Niddah: Veses, HaChodesh, HaGuf, HaOnes, Based On Month, Action or Physical Sign

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 189:13-18. Niddah: Veses, HaChodesh, HaGuf, HaOnes, Based On Month, Action or Physical Sign · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  OK, good morning. We are continuing with
• 0:03
  Helkhosnida vesit kuf PE tet. OK, today we're continuing with
• 0:08
  Siif Yudalid, but I'm just going to explain better the beginning
• 0:14
  of the Rama in the in Yudgimo. So he has the interesting case
• 0:19
  of she sees on the 1st of the month and the 20th of the month,
• 0:24
  and then according to the remote, it doesn't really matter
• 0:26
  how many more times she sees, she always has to worry about
• 0:29
  this in the next month. Even if she sees again, it
• 0:33
  doesn't necessarily completely uproot the last vestige, she
• 0:38
  still has to worry. Let's say if she sees it on the
• 0:40
  1st and the 20th, no matter what, she's going to have to be
• 0:43
  worried for it on the first of the next month, Rosh Kodesh and
• 0:47
  on the 20th of the next month and on the 9th and on the ninth
• 0:52
  of the next month, she has to worry about every possibility of
• 0:56
  yon of the vesit of the day vesit A Kodesh and the vesit
• 1:01
  haflaga. So just to point out, OK, first
• 1:05
  of all, just to explain what's the rationale behind the Ramaz,
• 1:08
  the post game? You see this in the base Yosef
• 1:10
  and and onward. The issue is when you have A to
• 1:16
  uproot a vesit, even if it's a vesa chena kavua, just to uproot
• 1:21
  the one time vesa, it's not kavua, but just to, you know,
• 1:26
  reestablish your new three times to be Klochechvor or whatever
• 1:30
  you're Klochechvor. It normally we say one time
• 1:34
  uproots a vesa chena kavua. However, the Rama holds again,
• 1:41
  it's unclear exactly who agrees and disagrees, but the Rama
• 1:46
  among the Rishonian. But according to the Rama, it's
• 1:48
  clear if it's gets shorter, if the if the new vessels that the
• 1:56
  next time that she sees is sooner than was a stabbed than
• 2:01
  what was expected from the previous time, then we don't
• 2:06
  automatically assume it's an Akira.
• 2:10
  It's undoing the previous vessels where Hoshish, maybe
• 2:14
  it's an extra bleeding, an extra extra blood and therefore it's
• 2:21
  not necessarily an Akira and might just be extra and
• 2:25
  therefore she has to worry about the previous one and the next
• 2:29
  one. So again, whenever the interval
• 2:32
  or the day is shorter, it's a Mahlocas.
• 2:36
  If it uproots the previous vessel, if it goes from 30 days
• 2:41
  to 35 days and 30 days goes by and the next time is 35, then
• 2:47
  that'll uproot for the next month because that was longer
• 2:51
  than what you were expected. When the time period that was
• 2:54
  expected passes and she doesn't see the blood, then that's a
• 2:57
  proper Akira Lekulioma. OK, who agrees with the Rama?
• 3:02
  So the Taz agrees with the Rama, the Bach and the the Shah
• 3:10
  disagree. I'll just quote a nice line from
• 3:13
  the the taz that he writes Shah Moshe Emes, Viteraso Emes.
• 3:20
  Really. We don't usually refer that to
• 3:22
  Moshe Rabenu, but he uses that the taz to support the Rama
• 3:26
  because it's, that's his name, Rab Moshe Isilis.
• 3:29
  So too we have from the Pasak Derek Mellitza, the Holy Binet
• 3:34
  Israel Yosim Biyad Rama. That's from Azyasha anyway.
• 3:39
  So what's the halacha? So it depends who you ask.
• 3:44
  So first of all, the Araka Shokhan has a middle cheetah or
• 3:50
  whatever he doesn't do it to be. He thinks that's the Amis
• 3:53
  according to the Rama, or at least according to the halacha.
• 3:57
  He says that the Rama lipsaka, the Rama, that a shorter one
• 4:05
  doesn't undo it. He says that's true by a vesit
• 4:09
  khodesh the day of the month, but it's not true by haflaga.
• 4:13
  Whenever it's haflaga, even if it's shorter, it completely
• 4:17
  uproots it. So that's a middle shara
• 4:20
  Anyways, Lamaisa, it depends you ask.
• 4:22
  Some are mahmar like the taz and the Rama.
• 4:25
  Some are Mako all the way to the end.
• 4:27
  Some are Mako only, like the Arakashoghan.
• 4:30
  Some have a they make a difference for the Shana
• 4:33
  rishona. When you get married, they're a
• 4:35
  little more Mako for the first year.
• 4:36
  Anyway, it depends who you ask. And just one last caveat is just
• 4:41
  remember Vestos AR Durabana and the Naf kamina halakhala Maisa
• 4:46
  is not very common anyway. So OK, let's go to where we are.
• 4:52
  Udala kuf peytat udala haita regila lyros Yom esrin.
• 5:00
  The Isla bazerves. It's kabua.
• 5:02
  In other words, the case is she has a vested kabua.
• 5:05
  And the vested kabua is the 20th of the month, always kaf of the
• 5:11
  month, the shinta liyom Yom Sri. Oh wait, maybe it's a flaga.
• 5:18
  Whatever the case is, OK, she has a vesa kavua for the 20th
• 5:23
  and now 20th day or 20th of the month.
• 5:26
  I'm confused but she tell you I'm sloshing and now she goes to
• 5:29
  the 30th day. Zev Azuri.
• 5:32
  So what happens is she has a vesa kavua.
• 5:35
  So since she has a Vesa Kavua for 20, the 20th, 20th day, 20
• 5:39
  day of the month, whatever it is, she always has to worry
• 5:42
  about the 20th until there's an Akira of three times.
• 5:45
  Because again, the scenario is she has a Vesa Kavua 3 times a
• 5:50
  flogger, right? OK, right, OK, good.
• 5:53
  Now when she sees on the 30th day for this one time, right?
• 5:57
  It's how she still has a vessel Kabua of 20.
• 6:00
  Now she sees it once for the 30th Zevizasuri.
• 6:06
  So now you have to worry about both because there was a change.
• 6:09
  So now you have to worry that number one, maybe she still has
• 6:13
  a vesa kavua, so you have to worry about the 20th day.
• 6:16
  Or maybe now it's being changed since there was a change.
• 6:18
  You have to worry. Maybe now it's being changed to
• 6:20
  the 30th day, right? You don't have to worry about
• 6:24
  una benonit because she still does have vesit kavua.
• 6:30
  It wasn't uprooted. But you do have to worry about
• 6:33
  the 30th day, the haflaga. Fine.
• 6:35
  So then let's do that. Inside Zev is asturum kashyyam,
• 6:38
  asturum, the riyat shloshim. So the 20th day, right?
• 6:43
  Vasada fada. But it's the 20th day after the
• 6:46
  last time she saw, which was on the 30th day, right?
• 6:50
  29 days later, whatever asura mishum vasadarisham.
• 6:53
  So 20 days after the 30th, she has to worry about the
• 6:57
  vasadarisham, her vasada kavua vim loads your elbow.
• 7:01
  But if she doesn't see on the 20th, the 20th day still she
• 7:09
  still has to be worried about the 30th, right?
• 7:11
  Because she there was a change and maybe it's going to become a
• 7:15
  permanent change. So that's Sheeta amayim, Liam
• 7:19
  shloshim. And what if she changes 2 times?
• 7:22
  No difference, the same as changing one time.
• 7:25
  Zeviza Assurim, she has to worry about both of them, the 20th and
• 7:29
  the 30th, right? The 20th because that's the best
• 7:32
  of Kabua, the 30th because that's what she just saw the
• 7:35
  last time. This.
• 7:36
  First of all, this is a longer span, so this doesn't address
• 7:40
  the whole Mahlokas we just mentioned of the Rama.
• 7:43
  OK, let's continue. Zeviza Assurim, Shinta Shlosha.
• 7:47
  I mean, now there's three months in a row she doesn't see on day
• 7:51
  20, right? 60 days go by, she doesn't see
• 7:54
  on day 20. Lioma schlossim one second
• 7:57
  shinta shalosh pamelam schlossim.
• 7:59
  She switches 3 times to schlossim puta Yom estrim
• 8:05
  Vanessa Yom schlossim. So OK, so now in this case,
• 8:09
  we're going to see it depends. In this case, it looks like she
• 8:12
  gets a new Shinta 3 times to Yom Schlossim.
• 8:16
  So she gets a brand new vesit kavua and she uprooted her first
• 8:22
  one. So it's important to keep both
• 8:24
  in mind in this case, as as we're reading at this point, she
• 8:28
  uprooted he, she uprooted her vesit kavua because it's three
• 8:32
  times and she established a new vesit kavua because it was done
• 8:36
  three times for the thirty 30th day interval.
• 8:39
  OK, you almost Vanessa Yom Shoshim now Vimla Akasha Shinta
• 8:47
  APA a mine the Yom shlochim RA telesov astrem khazar vessel
• 8:55
  astrem in como vehutar shlochim. So let's say she it was only one
• 9:04
  or two times it was moved. She had a haflaga now of 30
• 9:09
  days, so she still has to worry about the first time vested
• 9:14
  kavua. But if 60 days go by, she's
• 9:18
  going to lose her vested kavua of 20 days.
• 9:22
  But she didn't yet establish right?
• 9:25
  She, she, I think she does because that's 20/20/20.
• 9:32
  We'll keep reading. Let me let me finish and then
• 9:35
  you'll see once she loses anytime a person loses their
• 9:41
  vest we're going to see this insight Well, you want to read
• 9:45
  it inside even more mafurish it's in the Shah in mem Aleph.
• 9:50
  What happens is anytime she loses 3 times, it changes.
• 9:56
  It's no longer the same pattern that she had three times like
• 10:00
  three 20s and that our example three 20s go by.
• 10:03
  She uproots her previous vessels, Kabbalah.
• 10:07
  But let's if she doesn't establish a new Vesit kavua,
• 10:16
  then she has to worry because it's Anna vesit kavua.
• 10:20
  But let me just read over here. Rata lasov astrem khazar vesit
• 10:27
  ESRIM como vehutar sloshim. She didn't get a new vested
• 10:32
  kavua of 30 days in this example 3 * 30.
• 10:36
  So the next time in her life she as long as she never has a new
• 10:41
  vested kavua for the rest of her life, she if she once sees on
• 10:47
  day 20, then she reestablishes her vested kavua and she does
• 10:54
  that's a that's becomes a real vesit kavua and it doesn't get
• 10:58
  uprooted until it's uprooted 3 times and it only takes one time
• 11:05
  to reestablish. See the Shah Namala and read
• 11:08
  Tadwaal Sheen tell Reutel Vilohishwa Otan if she changes
• 11:15
  they, they become different times.
• 11:17
  All right, she's not seeing, she doesn't establish yet with
• 11:20
  30303030 whatever three times intervals, she sees different
• 11:26
  times and she uproots her vesit kabua, the Loishvaotan, right?
• 11:32
  Kangon Shashinta Pam akas Liam Schlossen, right.
• 11:36
  It used to be 20, let's say now it went into 30 Vash Shaini, the
• 11:41
  Lama de base, and then it became Lama de base, Vash Lishi, Lama
• 11:44
  Dalit, and then it became 34 Nekhar vesit harisham.
• 11:51
  So now she uprooted her first vesit, the inla vesit kla, and
• 11:57
  she doesn't have a vesit kavua at all.
• 12:02
  But as the Shah and the Torah Shalamin point out, she still
• 12:07
  has to worry. Since now she doesn't have a
• 12:09
  vesit kavua, she now she has to worry about has to worry about
• 12:12
  the vesit, the possible vesita kodesh, onan, benonite and
• 12:17
  haflaga. And in this case that came up,
• 12:22
  she even has to worry la khumra of vesita diluk.
• 12:26
  But OK, that's al khazara. But the point is here, EIN la
• 12:29
  vesit klao means EIN la vesit kavua.
• 12:32
  Let's keep reading. This is the real point of the
• 12:35
  this the salaha, the IM Khazra Lerod byom ha vesit harisha.
• 12:40
  So she completely uprooted her vesit harisham and now she sees
• 12:46
  one time of the original vesit, the day 21 time Khazar lucviuso
• 12:54
  harisham. She goes back to the vesit kavua
• 12:57
  that she once had long ago, the khosheshit lo tamid.
• 13:01
  And she always has to worry about it.
• 13:04
  Ajiya karmimena shalosh pami until it's uprooted three times.
• 13:09
  As if yeah, I know, I know the Hua din lhabsika lierot shalosh
• 13:17
  onot and here and Hua din, if she stops 3 onot vihar ka khazra
• 13:23
  lierot bayon then havesit Risha khazra lierot bayon havesit
• 13:30
  harisha. So, so too the changes with the
• 13:34
  Ona day and night, and then it goes back to the same day period
• 13:38
  or night period, whatever it was.
• 13:39
  You only need one time to reinstate the vested Kargua.
• 13:48
  Fine, let's go on to Tedzion Coyote.
• 13:58
  I believe so. Tedzion Tedzion Coyote Bezer
• 14:08
  Dinakyard vasit Rasheh Kardashian.
• 14:10
  The same thing for an uprooting Vasila kodesh Keitzag or keitzag
• 14:16
  haita Regila lirad Barasheh Kardashian.
• 14:18
  She always sees on rash Kodesh the Alvar alea rash Kodesh
• 14:23
  valorata. But one rash Kodesh comes like
• 14:26
  all of us, she always sees and then comes, I don't know, ER,
• 14:31
  she doesn't see Valorata Koshesh at the rash Kodesh.
• 14:34
  She has to worry about the next rash Kodesh in Sivan aji abru
• 14:38
  alea shlosha roshe Kardashian. So three months in a row she
• 14:42
  always has to worry about Rosh Kodesh.
• 14:45
  But abru alea shlosha roshe Kardashian velorata 3 months go
• 14:50
  by and she has no riya ina khoshesh Islam.
• 14:54
  She doesn't have to worry about any Rosh Kodesh again in the
• 14:58
  future. However, Kazra Verata verosh
• 15:02
  Kodesh, she sees once on Roche Khodesh because she wasn't, she
• 15:06
  didn't get a new vasit kabua. So then Khazara vasit lincomo,
• 15:10
  she sees it, only has to see it once on a Roche Khodesh, and
• 15:13
  then it turns back into a vasit kavua that needs three more
• 15:18
  times to undo the vasit kavua. But if she actually had a new
• 15:21
  vasit kavua, right, if she wants she has a new vasit kavua, then
• 15:27
  she needs three times to reestablish a vasit kavua.
• 15:32
  Very good. OK, you'd sign.
• 15:34
  Now we're going to enter a little bit of a new topic or a
• 15:37
  subtopic of Vesitaguf. Again, when we talk about
• 15:42
  vesitaguf, there's two different terminologies that are used.
• 15:47
  One is Vesitaguf or Vesitaguf which is comes from a seaman, a
• 15:52
  sign, something in her body is signaling and it's telling you
• 15:58
  like let's say I don't know, strange hiccups, whatever it is
• 16:03
  sneezing, those things are a seaman that it's telling you
• 16:07
  that a vested is coming. That's one category, a vested
• 16:11
  hagoof fine. Another category.
• 16:14
  Some call it vested taunus and some call it vested hagoof, but
• 16:19
  a siba that's A cause like jumping or, I don't know,
• 16:25
  extreme extra or just any kind of exercising that's beyond
• 16:29
  what's normal. And that brings upon the the
• 16:33
  vesit. But they're kind of opposites.
• 16:35
  Just to point out, one is telling you that the vesit is
• 16:39
  coming and one causes the vesit to come.
• 16:42
  So the halakhas are a little bit different.
• 16:44
  OK, so let's start reading with yudzai.
• 16:47
  We'll start today at least beginning with vesit aguf yudzai
• 16:53
  ko vesit shaniqua mahmat onis kagonchikovsa verata.
• 16:58
  So the vessel is established. Anytime she does some kind of an
• 17:02
  it's an onus to her body. She does an act that brings it
• 17:06
  upon and it's, it's like an onus to the vessel that the vessel
• 17:11
  can't hold back. It's, it's caused by this action
• 17:14
  such as jumping or whatever it is.
• 17:17
  It could be carrying any intense movement, I don't know, heavy
• 17:22
  lifting. That's not normal.
• 17:24
  Whatever it is, Afilu ratabo kamapa Amin.
• 17:29
  Even though it happens a few times, imlokava OTA Ana yamin,
• 17:34
  it needs to be set with times inna vesit.
• 17:43
  It's not a vesit MI pene onas. It doesn't become a vesida onas.
• 17:49
  If it's not with particular days, we're going to see this is
• 17:52
  a Mahoka Shokanarathanarama OK rata Nicole Malcolm Koshesha
• 17:59
  Lokomo vessage Ena kavua. So here this is it.
• 18:03
  The Shokanara holds that a this type of vested it.
• 18:08
  If there's no days involved, you do not have to worry about it at
• 18:12
  all. Jumping can only become a vested
• 18:17
  kavua or any that you're Koshisha at all for even like a
• 18:21
  kavua, if it's tied to a particular date, the Rama holds
• 18:26
  that you, even if there's no days involved, if it's the
• 18:30
  action itself, then she has to she does have to worry about it.
• 18:34
  It's not going to be a vest. It's kavua, but she still has to
• 18:36
  worry about it. But you still have to worry
• 18:38
  about the other stuff. The bottom line is, based on her
• 18:42
  pattern, it has to be, you know, abnormal movement that she knows
• 18:45
  it brings it upon and and it becomes it's established.
• 18:51
  Kafta virata. Kafta virata.
• 18:54
  Yeah. If it happens multiple times,
• 18:57
  Kavala vesit liyamim and one second.
• 19:02
  Vesit Liya, one second. How does this go?
• 19:06
  Rata. Yeah, right.
• 19:15
  Because here she saw three times and jumped twice, right?
• 19:20
  I think that's what the case was.
• 19:22
  Rata kafta virata, kafta virata. So kavala vesit liyamim beloch
• 19:29
  feature that she had three times of a day specific same day
• 19:33
  intervals or same day of the month.
• 19:35
  So then she has to worry about the Yamim Kate said.
• 19:39
  Kaftsa. Well, let's see, let's see,
• 19:41
  Let's see his example, whatever it is.
• 19:43
  Kaftsa Beshaba, she jumps on Monday.
• 19:46
  Sunday. Vira TA dah lahar estrem Yong
• 19:50
  Kaftsa the ekhad, the Shabbos. So then 20 days later and
• 19:57
  Kaftsa, it's on Sunday. So it's 21.
• 20:00
  What are you thinking? So OK, then she sees on Sunday,
• 20:04
  she should be fine in 26. OK.
• 20:08
  After. Well, it depends if what month
• 20:10
  it is. No, No.
• 20:12
  Right. OK.
• 20:14
  I hear. Yeah.
• 20:17
  OK, I don't know kaftsa Shabbos Virat tadam.
• 20:21
  So she jumps on Sunday, right? And she sees bleeding ula akhar
• 20:29
  yutet Yom, and then after 19 days Yom kaftsa biyom and
• 20:36
  Shabbos. So then now it's on Shabbos
• 20:38
  where she sees the bleeding Velora tadam and she doesn't see
• 20:42
  bleeding ula akhara Shabbos rata bolokvizza.
• 20:46
  But then after Shabbos on Sunday she sees the bleeding without
• 20:50
  jumping. Hooray Nikba ekhad be Shabbos
• 20:56
  akhar Esri shahre noda shahyom garamla velohakfiza Lukavar and
• 21:04
  Nikba Yomze Shalosh pamim Bahrain called Coyote Baze.
• 21:14
  So in this case the the the the days did not line up 100% with
• 21:19
  the jumping and the pattern was consistent with the days, not
• 21:25
  with the jumping. So therefore the day the jumping
• 21:27
  is not relevant. It's only four days Kafts.
• 21:31
  Let me just read this real quick.
• 21:32
  Your head Kafts abiyom yadu I could go on by Rashkhodesh if
• 21:36
  she jumps on Rashkhodesh OB ekhad bishabis on Sunday Virat
• 21:39
  taboo V irakane bishalosh rasheh Kardashian OB ekhad bishabis 3
• 21:46
  times in a row. The jumping is on the same exact
• 21:49
  interval of the day, whether it's the the dates of the month
• 21:54
  or the day of the week. Kavala vesit.
• 21:58
  So now she has a vesit kavua and so anytime she jumps and has
• 22:06
  that day, she has to worry and write and then it can easily be
• 22:21
  uprooted if it's a change in the day or the the jumping and she
• 22:27
  like she doesn't jump. In other words, if they're tied
• 22:30
  together, then it's it's even easier to uproot it because it's
• 22:34
  only going to continue with that same vessel Kavua if it's always
• 22:37
  with the same jumping but the same time.