Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When Workers' Comp Meets Civil Court: Crossover Risks That Could Tank Your Case
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome everyone to when workers comp meets civil
- 0:07court crossover risks that could tank your case
- 0:10I'm Michael Falati and I'm the chair of the workers
- 0:12compensation law section I'm an attorney at gray
- 0:15where Kaplan vernic and Evans and I'm a certified
- 0:18specialist in workers compensation law Now before
- 0:21I introduce today's speaker I'd like to take
- 0:23a moment to plug the workers comp section The
- 0:25workers comp section is a new and fast -growing
- 0:27section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 0:30I obviously encourage all workers' comp practitioners
- 0:32to join, but I also highly recommend that other
- 0:35practitioners in overlapping practices like PI
- 0:37and employment join as well. The amount of overlap
- 0:41I see in my own practice demonstrates to me just
- 0:43how much interplay there is between these practice
- 0:45areas. So it's worthwhile and perhaps incumbent
- 0:48upon our practitioners in these practice areas
- 0:51to familiarize themselves with workers' compensation
- 0:53and vice versa, workers' comp attorneys should
- 0:56familiarize themselves with these overlapping
- 0:58practice areas. In fact, today's webinar, which
- 1:02is again about the crossover risks between workers'
- 1:05comp and civil court that could make or break
- 1:08a case, speaks precisely to that point. Should
- 1:11anyone wish to become more involved in the section
- 1:13beyond just webinars and networking events, I
- 1:16also encourage those interested in joining and
- 1:18taking on leadership positions and roles in the
- 1:20section. If you'd like to do so, please reach
- 1:23out to me or contact the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 1:25Help Desk. We'll throw my email and the help
- 1:27desk email in the chat for anyone who wants to
- 1:29join and get more involved. And now I'm delighted
- 1:32to introduce today's speaker for today, Jonathan
- 1:35Robyn. Jonathan Robyn is an LA native and managing
- 1:38attorney at Johnny Law, where he focuses his
- 1:41practice on personal injury, employment, and
- 1:44workers' compensation litigation. He is licensed
- 1:47to practice in both state and federal courts
- 1:49in California and Nevada. A Loyola Law School
- 1:52graduate and Cali Award recipient, He has earned
- 1:55recognition as a super lawyer's rising star and
- 1:58has secured notable appellate victories for his
- 2:00clients, including successful outcomes in age
- 2:03and disability discrimination and workplace harassment
- 2:06cases. Beyond the courtroom, Jonathan serves
- 2:08as president of the Los Angeles Jewish Bar Association
- 2:11and is active in several plaintiff -side legal
- 2:14associations, reflecting his commitment to advocacy
- 2:17both professionally and within the community.
- 2:20And now let's get started. Thank you so much,
- 2:23Michael. Thank you, Suzanne and Grace and the
- 2:27Beverly Hills Bar Association for having me.
- 2:31So today, well, just a little bit about me and
- 2:34why I wanted to give this talk is because it
- 2:39is so prevalent the amount of issues that happen
- 2:45when there are both workers compensation and
- 2:49civil litigation matters at play. And there are
- 2:53so many ways, so many pitfalls that can happen,
- 2:56but not just that, ways to maximize the amount
- 3:01or the recovery on these cases if these tools
- 3:06that I'm going to introduce get utilized. So
- 3:09without further ado, I'm going to share this
- 3:15presentation here. If it decides to share, let's
- 3:32see if this. Is everyone able to see this? It
- 3:37looks like it's actually on the other monitor.
- 3:40There's a way to switch it. There we go. Alright.
- 3:52OK, so this is. Great. Okay, so this is the talk
- 4:02when workers can't meet civil court crossover
- 4:05risk that could tank your case. So got a little
- 4:13bit of a lag on these slides here. Why this matters.
- 4:20I wanna start off with a situation where a hundred
- 4:27dollar release could tank a million dollar employment
- 4:36case. So many times in the workers compensation
- 4:41court system, when the workers comp claims are
- 4:47about to resolve, they sign these agreements
- 4:50called compromises and releases. It's the workers
- 4:54compensation version of a settlement agreement.
- 4:57What they will do is try to incorporate tiny
- 5:02release agreements within those workers compensation
- 5:06settlements. And when there is an unsophisticated
- 5:11or someone who doesn't know how to recognize
- 5:14that kind of language, then that could severely
- 5:18impact a civil case. In terms of other types
- 5:24of cases, like a wrongful termination, or retaliation
- 5:29cases. In order to get the settlement, oftentimes
- 5:34the insurance or the defense will want the applicant,
- 5:39which is the plaintiff in the workers' compensation
- 5:42system, to sign what's called a letter of resignation.
- 5:46I hereby resign from my position as of this date,
- 5:51which can be used as evidence later on in a civil
- 5:56wrongful termination case to say, well, how could
- 5:59they have been terminated when they just signed
- 6:02this letter of resignation? So these are important
- 6:06topics, ones that come up quite often. And let's
- 6:12talk about the reasons why it's important for
- 6:16a civil lawyer to understand the worker's compensation
- 6:20system, at least from the bare minimum so that
- 6:24they could avoid these types of situations. So
- 6:30not only is it important to know about the workers'
- 6:35compensation case because of mitigating those
- 6:38factors, but also to maximize the value of your
- 6:42civil case because there's so much evidence that
- 6:47is available in these workers' compensation cases,
- 6:51such as medical treatment records, where the
- 6:57applicant is going to be sent to various doctors
- 7:01to get their treatments, whether it's going to
- 7:04be potential witness statements, how certain
- 7:07accidents occurred, what was the investigation
- 7:10after the accident. There is potential investigation
- 7:15records and conclusions from those investigations
- 7:17by the company or the place where the person
- 7:21is injured. And there's also QME opinions. A
- 7:25QME, which we'll go into in a little bit, is
- 7:28a qualified medical evaluator. And it goes through
- 7:31a strike process where each side gets a strike
- 7:36from a selection of three panelists. And the
- 7:41remaining one becomes the QME. They're given
- 7:45many records to review, which arguably turns
- 7:49them into a retained expert. and then they render
- 7:53an opinion about the case and about whether the
- 7:59accident caused the injury. This could be important,
- 8:04especially in psychiatric, psychological cases.
- 8:09Second reason that it's important for civil lawyers
- 8:12to understand the workers' compensation system
- 8:14is, one, so that the claim doesn't get destroyed
- 8:20when it gets released on accident. Two, to prevent
- 8:25bad testimony when an applicant gives their deposition
- 8:31in the worker's compensation arena. And three,
- 8:34to prevent a voluntary resignation, which can
- 8:39be disastrous in a termination case. So it's
- 8:44important to think of both of the cases as a
- 8:48single case because the evidence is so intertwined
- 8:52and the attorney that knows how to navigate both
- 8:55of those systems can really use it to their benefit.
- 9:00So the purpose of this talk is really to protect
- 9:06the client's civil claim, just outright, increase
- 9:11in overall recovery in both civil and workers
- 9:14comp, and that the attorneys are able to coordinate
- 9:20a strategy to help each other in those kinds
- 9:24of cases. And so what we're going to do here
- 9:31is first, I just want to emphasize what the crossover
- 9:38is. Second, to see what available options are
- 9:43there for each side helping each other, the workers
- 9:46compensation attorney and the civil attorney,
- 9:49how they can help each other share evidence and
- 9:53coordinate how certain questions are going to
- 9:59be answered without causing damage to another
- 10:03side. Avoiding settlement mistakes or inconsistent
- 10:09testimony, which could also severely damaged
- 10:14either case. We're going to also talk about workers'
- 10:19compensation exclusivity, what it means, and
- 10:23whether a release in a workers' compensation
- 10:26case or the fact that an action may be brought
- 10:30in workers' compensation, does it prevent the
- 10:34person from bringing certain civil claims? And
- 10:38then finally to discuss coordinating. between
- 10:42the attorneys in how to maximize the recoveries
- 10:47for both cases. So I want to start off with talking
- 10:52about two parallel caseloos because the cases
- 10:57will go through timelines and the timelines may
- 11:00or may not intersect. So I have an infographic
- 11:06here on a worker's compensation case on the right
- 11:10in a civil employment case on the left where
- 11:14this is, for example, a disability discrimination
- 11:18case where there's an injury and then the employer
- 11:25gets notified of the injury either through reporting
- 11:30the injury directly to the employer or filling
- 11:34out an initial workers compensation form called
- 11:37a DWC -1 where that gets given to the employer.
- 11:43And from that point, now there is a potential
- 11:48case that is going to start in the civil, whereas
- 11:51the case has started already, and will go usually
- 11:54at a much faster pace in the workers compensation
- 11:57arena. So because it is going so fast, it's important
- 12:06that right when a person An attorney retains
- 12:10a civil case to investigate. Whether a workers
- 12:13compensation case has already started. Which
- 12:16usually it has and to get in touch with that
- 12:19workers compensation attorney right away. To
- 12:22see where they are in the process. In the workers
- 12:27compensation setting. Usually the applicant is
- 12:31already getting treatment. They have already
- 12:35started the. Q and me panel process to see when
- 12:40they are going to get evaluated and what records
- 12:43are going to go to the Q and me for evaluation.
- 12:46And they have already or are about to. Under
- 12:51go a deposition in the workers compensation arena.
- 12:56Depositions. Come very fast when it comes to
- 12:59workers compensation. One because they want to
- 13:04get the transcript. to the QME for evaluation.
- 13:08But two, there's an attorney fee, the labor code
- 13:145710 fees that go to the applicant's attorney
- 13:17for submitting to the deposition, submitting
- 13:20their client to the deposition. So they tend
- 13:22to go pretty quickly. And the issue is that because
- 13:28they go so quickly that there might not be adequate
- 13:33preparation from a civil perspective that could
- 13:38cause significant damage to a civil case. And
- 13:44we're going to go through what those common mistakes
- 13:48or common testimonies are. So that's kind of
- 13:54the timeline that it's important to right away
- 13:58once an employee or a litigant gets retained
- 14:03to see whether there is the workers compensation
- 14:06case going and get in touch with that council
- 14:08to see where it is. So here, this is actually
- 14:12a story from pretty recently where a workers
- 14:18compensation attorney called and asked if I could
- 14:21look at a settlement document for them. And they
- 14:25said, you know, I think they're trying to Get
- 14:29him to sign a release for his civil claims. And
- 14:33we had already started representing this individual.
- 14:37So that's exactly what the. The insurance was
- 14:41trying to do was settle out a claim when they
- 14:44had a pending. A civil claim for 100 dollars
- 14:48and it later settled for well over 100 ,000.
- 14:52So it's. Significant and and they try and do
- 14:57this stuff. So what will come into ways to prevent
- 15:02that? And so the cases will very often collide.
- 15:08Meaning. There's going to be the same documents.
- 15:14That are getting exchanged from the defense.
- 15:17To the applicant or the plaintiff side, it's
- 15:20going to be the same personnel records. you know,
- 15:24maybe some type of difference in between them,
- 15:27but that's going to be important as well to see
- 15:30whether there is something missing in the civil
- 15:34case or something missing in the comp case. And
- 15:38those records might be quite valuable. There's
- 15:42going to be a deposition in both the workers
- 15:45comp and the civil deposition. And, you know,
- 15:49it's very likely that Both depositions will be
- 15:54carefully reviewed prior to trial to see if there's
- 15:58any sort of inconsistent testimonies. There's
- 16:01going to be experts in both sides, both retained
- 16:05and non -retained. Retained meaning that the
- 16:11expert receives records and testimony and conducts
- 16:17an evaluation of the injured. So they give informed
- 16:22opinions and there's going to be settlement negotiations,
- 16:28different types of impairment ratings versus
- 16:31whether they have a disability. So there's a
- 16:34lot of crossover. So I want to go over some of
- 16:52these workers' compensation documents just so
- 16:57we have a fundamental understanding of what they
- 17:01are and how they can affect civil cases and vice
- 17:04versa. So this is called a DWC -1 and it's the
- 17:10initial document that starts the workers' compensation
- 17:14case. And what an employer is supposed to do,
- 17:18they don't do all the time, is give this document
- 17:22to the employee when there is information that
- 17:28the employee has sustained a workplace injury.
- 17:31And so the employee will put basic information,
- 17:35who they are, what their address is, and the
- 17:39date, time, and how the accident occurred that
- 17:43led to their workplace injury. And then the employer
- 17:48is supposed to fill out their information on
- 17:50the bottom indicating who they are and who the
- 17:56insurance is. This is a very important document
- 18:03because oftentimes in the civil case, especially
- 18:08in the employment cases, the employer will claim
- 18:12that they were not aware of certain injuries.
- 18:16But this document will put them specifically
- 18:21on notice of what the injury was, even if there
- 18:26isn't much subsequent documentation directly
- 18:29between the employer and the employee, because
- 18:32after this point it goes to workers' compensation
- 18:34insurance, where many times the employer will
- 18:38claim they don't have knowledge. But this document
- 18:42here is given directly to the employer. And so
- 18:46there was a recent case that came down just a
- 18:50few weeks ago, actually. The husband v. Target
- 18:54case where they said, the court of appeal said
- 18:59that they don't have to, a company doesn't have
- 19:04to engage in an interactive process or accommodate
- 19:07when they don't know whether... the individual
- 19:13has a disability or a suspicion of a disability.
- 19:18But a proper DWC -1 can completely change that
- 19:24argument and thwart any sort of lack of notice
- 19:29or lack of knowledge argument because it says
- 19:33right there on the document what the injuries
- 19:36are and where it occurred and the date and the
- 19:41time, et cetera. And so this is another basic
- 19:47workers' compensation document that is useful
- 19:51in the civil arena. And this is called a PR2.
- 19:55And it is a primary treating physician progress
- 19:59report. And you also have the initial report.
- 20:03But this is the progress report. And specifically
- 20:07on the progress report, this gets transmitted
- 20:11either to the employer or to the insurance company.
- 20:15But importantly, on the second page of the document,
- 20:19it has a work status. And the work status is
- 20:25essentially a request for an accommodation or
- 20:29an invitation to engage in the interactive process.
- 20:35because it states this patient has been instructed
- 20:38to either not work or work on modified duty or
- 20:48work on a certain date, starting on a certain
- 20:50date without limitations or restrictions. And
- 20:54so this is an incredibly important document in
- 20:58civil cases because it shows what the requests
- 21:02for accommodation are and triggering the duty
- 21:07to engage in an interactive process. Meaning
- 21:10the employer now has to talk to the employee
- 21:12to discuss what can we do to accommodate? Can
- 21:16we accommodate? And if not, what are we going
- 21:19to do about it and why can't we accommodate?
- 21:22And this document comes in various forms from
- 21:26different types of treaters. Here's one that
- 21:30was just pulled from online. This is a Kaiser
- 21:34work status report where it's just in a little
- 21:39bit of a different format, but they get sent
- 21:41straight to the employer, or if not to the employer,
- 21:45to the workers' comp insurance company, where
- 21:48adequate discovery could reveal correspondence
- 21:54between the insurance and the employer, where
- 21:57perhaps the employer is not doing what they're
- 21:59supposed to do. meaning they're not engaging
- 22:02in an interactive process or not even evaluating
- 22:05whether they can accommodate. So it's important
- 22:07to get that kind of data. And one of the easier
- 22:13routes to go is when there is regular communication
- 22:17between the civil lawyer and the workers' compensation
- 22:19lawyer. So for both sides, there's many discovery
- 22:25advantages when there is coordination between
- 22:29both attorneys. So let's talk about that briefly.
- 22:35First of all, in a worker's compensation case,
- 22:40there are often times that there is an investigation.
- 22:45There's supposed to be an investigation when
- 22:48there's been a work safety issue, and certainly
- 22:50when there's an insurance claim involved. In
- 22:54an investigation, there's potentially witness
- 22:58statements from the employer. So that could be
- 23:03supervisors, co -workers, individuals that knew
- 23:09what happened, knew what happened subsequently.
- 23:11That could be incredibly valuable to the civil
- 23:15attorney before they take the actual depositions
- 23:18of these individuals and vice versa. From the
- 23:23civil perspective, once they take these witness
- 23:27depositions, that's going to be incredibly valuable
- 23:31for the workers compensation attorney. Perhaps
- 23:34they don't have that witness statement or perhaps
- 23:38the witness statement and the deposition say
- 23:41two completely different things. Another situation,
- 23:47another topic of documents or category is the
- 23:50personnel records like I was talking about briefly
- 23:53before is that there might be significant but
- 23:57important documents missing in a production in
- 24:01a civil case where they were produced in the
- 24:03workers' compensation case. And there could be
- 24:07many reasons for that. It could be a very limited
- 24:11view of looking at a request for production and
- 24:15saying, well, it doesn't respond to this request,
- 24:18but they could be quite significant and It's
- 24:22helpful to have that coordination with the worker's
- 24:26comp attorney to get those documents. There may
- 24:29be different medical records. So, for example,
- 24:32if a person has what's called an accepted case
- 24:36in the worker's compensation arena, then they
- 24:39generally will treat within the insurance company's
- 24:44MPN or medical provider network. However, there
- 24:49may be treatments outside of that that the applicant
- 24:54underwent over on the civil arena. For example,
- 24:58an out -of -network psychologist or psychiatrist
- 25:01that could benefit the worker's compensation
- 25:06attorney, meaning if they have a site claim that
- 25:10is not accepted. So there's many different types
- 25:15of records that are going on. and can help each
- 25:20other out. A big advantage on the workers' compensation
- 25:26side is that subpoenas are not costly for applicants
- 25:35and applicants' attorneys because it's supposed
- 25:37to be a no -cost system for applicants. Whereas
- 25:42in the civil arena, when there's many subpoenas
- 25:45going out to many different providers, the cost
- 25:50of obtaining all these records could easily run
- 25:53into the thousands of dollars, and depending
- 25:55on the budget for each case, that could eat away
- 25:58at a case's budget when they are already available
- 26:04on the worker's compensation side and may have
- 26:08already been retrieved. advantage is when the
- 26:16documents get shared, compared, but each attorney
- 26:23is able to use the data in order to help their
- 26:28clients along the way. And so this we were just
- 26:34talking about briefly is there's different types
- 26:39of documentation. The treating record physician
- 26:42treating physician records. Q and me is an agreed
- 26:48medical evaluated with both sides agree on who
- 26:51is going to conduct the workers compensation.
- 26:54Evaluation to assign certain ratings, which will
- 27:00go into briefly. Witness statements, as we talked
- 27:04about from any investigations and. correspondence
- 27:08regarding any sort of accommodations, what the
- 27:12accommodation requests were, whether they could
- 27:15accommodate, whether they should accommodate,
- 27:17and what the interactive process, the discussion
- 27:21regarding those accommodations looks like. So
- 27:26briefly, I want to talk about depositions in
- 27:31both arenas. So in the workers' compensation
- 27:36arena, the applicant is taking the same oath
- 27:40when testifying that they do in the civil deposition.
- 27:47So anything they say in either one is going to
- 27:51be a potential impeachment evidence. And if they're
- 27:54being asked the same question in each deposition
- 27:58and they're giving two different answers, then
- 28:01that could be very easy impeachment for the for
- 28:08the adversary. So because they are asking relatively
- 28:15related questions, it's important for the civil
- 28:19attorney to get in contact with the workers compensation
- 28:23attorney or vice versa. If the workers comp if
- 28:26the civil deposition occurred first at the workers
- 28:29compensation attorney reaches out to the civil
- 28:32attorney to see if there's a deposition to prevent
- 28:35any sort of inconsistent testimony, because the
- 28:39consumers that we are representing are often
- 28:42not lawyers and have not gone to law school and
- 28:49have not gone through very significant education.
- 28:53And so they might not know the legal implications
- 28:57of answering differently in these scenarios,
- 29:01because in their mind, these are two completely
- 29:06different cases. And they may think that these
- 29:11cases don't have any sort of implication to each
- 29:15other, but too often, they will give one answer
- 29:20in workers' comp to get benefits, to get better
- 29:26benefits, and give a different answer. in a civil
- 29:34deposition to try and preserve that case. But
- 29:38the important fact is, the best way to go about
- 29:43it is to discuss with the applicant and each
- 29:48other and the attorneys on how they are going
- 29:55to strategize and give proper testimony that
- 29:59preserves both cases. So this is common damaging
- 30:06testimony in employment cases. The issue is that
- 30:11there is a conflict between damages and workers'
- 30:17compensation versus employment cases. So if an
- 30:23individual is unable to work in the workers'
- 30:28compensation system, that could be quite beneficial
- 30:31because that means that their disability rating
- 30:34may be higher or they may be entitled to more
- 30:38benefits because they were entered in the workplace.
- 30:42They might be entitled to more EDD since they
- 30:45are quote unable to work. However, that could
- 30:49be catastrophic in the employment case because
- 30:54one of the elements that employment attorneys
- 30:58have to meet is that the employee was able to
- 31:02work with or without reasonable accommodations.
- 31:06So there is a middle ground to meet, which we'll
- 31:11briefly discuss that can preserve both the worker's
- 31:15compensation case and the civil case to maximize
- 31:18the recovery. So these are common examples. I'm
- 31:22on disability because I'm unable to work. I'm
- 31:25not looking for work because I'm hurt. Right.
- 31:30So it's, I can't work because I'm hurt. These
- 31:35may or may not be entirely true. It might just
- 31:41be in their mind, the employee's mind as to how
- 31:46they're supposed to approach the situation. But
- 31:51the better aspect is to figure out the right
- 31:56testimony. the more accurate testimony and specific
- 32:00to give to enhance both cases. And it's not just
- 32:04for employment cases, it's also in personal injury
- 32:07cases. Because workers' compensation is a no
- 32:11fault system, meaning that the employee, the
- 32:14applicant is likely to get compensated anyway,
- 32:18the testimony that they give in workers' compensation
- 32:21cases can be equally catastrophic in civil cases.
- 32:26Meaning they wouldn't have an issue in the workers'
- 32:31compensation arena potentially saying, I should
- 32:36have looked where I was going. I should have
- 32:37been more careful. I knew the bump was there
- 32:42all the time, or I should have watched where
- 32:45I was going when running through the street light,
- 32:49et cetera. And that could destroy negligence
- 32:55cause of action to say this person is entirely
- 33:01at fault or there's too much comparative negligence
- 33:05here. So for PI attorneys, it's also very important
- 33:11to coordinate with the Workers' Compensation
- 33:16Council to see what kind of testimony is coming
- 33:23out. how they're answering questions and perhaps
- 33:27to give more accurate and descriptive answers
- 33:33to questions to preserve both cases. So in the
- 33:36employment case, if a person says, I'm unable
- 33:41to work, that is quite a drastic statement. If
- 33:47they are truly unable to work, then yeah, that's
- 33:50going to be the testimony. if they are unable
- 33:56to work within their restrictions without a reasonable
- 34:01accommodation, that would be one, more accurate
- 34:05testimony, and two, that's going to preserve
- 34:08both cases. Because if the employer cannot accommodate,
- 34:15then that's going to assist the worker's compensation
- 34:18case in maximizing recovery. And if the employer
- 34:23is unwilling to accommodate, that's going to
- 34:26assist the employment litigation aspect. So it's
- 34:32better to give more accurate testimony, meaning
- 34:36that usually when a person says, I can't work,
- 34:41it's usually because it's without a reasonable
- 34:45accommodation, because someone can do something.
- 34:48They could do light duty. They could do desk
- 34:50work. They could do part time work. They could
- 34:55do minimal work. It just depends on what the
- 34:58accommodation is. So it's better to give more
- 35:03accurate descriptive testimony and also in personal
- 35:08injury cases. You know, perhaps they don't say
- 35:13I should have looked where I was going. I should
- 35:15have been more careful like blaming themselves
- 35:17because if they did look. and they were reasonable
- 35:22about the situation, the person might not deserve
- 35:26to have a comparative negligence on them. So
- 35:30they need to give more accurate testimony in
- 35:35terms of these kinds of cases. And that's why
- 35:37it's important to coordinate. When there when
- 35:50there is coordination there needs to be You know
- 35:54phone calls perhaps a joint meeting where the
- 36:00topics that are going to be addressed in the
- 36:03cases and especially in depositions Are going
- 36:09to The the attorneys would go over them and see
- 36:13how they would answer in certain situations I've
- 36:17heard many times Of employees in. Workers compensation
- 36:23cases simply say. I can't work. I'm not looking
- 36:28for work. I don't want to look for work. Which
- 36:31could destroy both. A failure to reasonably accommodate
- 36:38cause of action and also a mitigation of damages.
- 36:42Because the employee, if they've been terminated.
- 36:45They have the obligation to. mitigate their damages
- 36:49usually by looking for work. And they could look
- 36:54for work within their restriction. Even if they
- 36:57get denied the application, they're still looking
- 37:00for work. So it's quite important to have that
- 37:05meeting. And if the meeting isn't had to at least
- 37:10discuss with the client the potential pitfalls
- 37:15and how to answer questions more accurately so
- 37:21that they're less damaging to either case. But
- 37:25the ideal way is to have the discussion with
- 37:29the other council. So many sample deposition
- 37:37questions that can be asked and that are asked
- 37:42in both arenas. What Work, are you unable to
- 37:48perform? Can you perform your job without restrictions?
- 37:52What are you unable to do? Are you totally disabled?
- 37:56Are you disabled? I mean, these are highly significant
- 38:00questions in employment cases, in personal injury
- 38:06cases, and in the workers compensation cases,
- 38:09and they may have completely different implications
- 38:12in each case. So they're important topics to
- 38:18go over. So I want to touch upon the medical
- 38:26evidence that gets created in the workers compensation
- 38:35arena versus the civil arena. And the most important,
- 38:41the most significant crossover I would say would
- 38:43be the psychological psychiatric uh, records
- 38:48because they both have to do with the emotional
- 38:53distress, pain and suffering damages that, uh,
- 38:59give rise to a significant portion of the damages
- 39:03in employment cases, especially in wrongful termination,
- 39:06retaliation cases. And so by an employment attorney
- 39:12getting these records, from the worker's compensation
- 39:17attorney or having that discussion, that could
- 39:22be quite significant in supporting the employment
- 39:26claim for the pain and suffering damages. And
- 39:30what's even more significant is that the QME
- 39:39reports, they show that these are much more neutral
- 39:46reports. So an insurance or a defense would have
- 39:50a difficult time arguing that the attorney has
- 39:55sent the client over to this doctor, meaning
- 39:58the doctor has some sort of bias when it's a
- 40:00QME, because it goes through a strike process.
- 40:03So we once had a, actually this is a fairly common
- 40:09fact pattern. where the employee is reluctant
- 40:13to get treatment or has difficulty getting treatment,
- 40:18they don't have insurance and they might be unreliable
- 40:25or just having difficulty in getting the proper
- 40:30treatments for the civil arena. But even with
- 40:34just a good QME report and deposing the QME,
- 40:39for preparation for a civil trial, that could
- 40:42be quite advantageous for civil cases. And so
- 40:48we had a situation where it was very difficult
- 40:52to get a client into a proper treatment. We just
- 40:57had one report. from a treater, an initial treater
- 41:05and a QME report and it was able to resolve for
- 41:07in the seven figures. So it can be quite significant.
- 41:11So going to briefly touch on some terms that
- 41:17are important to know. So the QME AME reports
- 41:22we spoke about in those reports, there's going
- 41:26to be usually a discussion on whether an applicant
- 41:31or the the worker is what they call temporarily
- 41:35totally disabled which in the workers comp arena
- 41:40means one thing but in the civil arena may mean
- 41:42something totally different uh meaning completely
- 41:45unable to work when that might not be the case
- 41:48just it could mean that they can't work within
- 41:50the restrictions and then there's permanently
- 41:54totally disabled and permanent disability however
- 41:58It's important for a civil attorney not to take
- 42:01these terms at face value, meaning just looking
- 42:04at the term and saying, oh, I think I know what
- 42:06it means, and that doesn't sound good because
- 42:10there could be a significant value in further
- 42:15investigating to seeing whether it is a total
- 42:20disability or whether they are completely unable
- 42:22to perform the essential functions of their duties.
- 42:27One of the reasons why this is, when it's in
- 42:33two different systems, it means completely two
- 42:35different things, is that in the workers' comp
- 42:40arena, they go through a rating system, meaning
- 42:45that there's numbers, letters, and what they
- 42:49call strings to evaluate. what the value of the
- 42:55case is or what the value of the disability is.
- 43:01So when it says permanent disability, that doesn't
- 43:05necessarily mean that a person is permanently
- 43:08disabled. That just means that they have or they
- 43:14may have some sort of impairment. It could be
- 43:18to a foot or a hand or a nervous system or a,
- 43:23you know, a stress system, but it doesn't mean
- 43:27that they're unable to perform their job duties.
- 43:31So these terms are not to be used interchangeably,
- 43:34but when looked further into it, could provide
- 43:38valuable information to enhance both cases. And
- 43:42so here we say permanent disability, it does
- 43:45not mean a FIHA disability, and it does not necessarily
- 43:50mean that a person is disabled. Another portion
- 43:57of the QME or AME reports is that they have a
- 44:03section called apportionment, meaning did the
- 44:07accident cause the injury? And when it comes
- 44:10to emotional distress or pain and suffering damages,
- 44:14non -economic damages in the civil case, this
- 44:18opinion in a QME, in a psychological or psychiatric
- 44:24QME can be quite significant because the QME
- 44:28or AME will likely be looking at alternative
- 44:33stressors, meaning how much stress was from the
- 44:38personnel action versus how much stress was from
- 44:43other pre -existing or post -existing events.
- 44:47So it's quite important to look at the QME opinion
- 44:51to see what they have to say about it and what
- 44:55evidence they relied upon or didn't rely upon.
- 44:59But in many situations, it can be incredibly
- 45:03valuable because a QME may say, I believe that
- 45:1090 or 100 % of their current psychiatric psychological
- 45:17state is due to this bad faith personnel act
- 45:21bad faith personnel event so what when you have
- 45:26a report like that then you can use it as leverage
- 45:30in your civil case and so there's even though
- 45:36there's crossovers there's also evidentiary limitations
- 45:39meaning in the workers comp arena It's acceptable
- 45:45and customary to just walk into court with a
- 45:52medical report and toss it in as an exhibit and
- 45:56the court accepts it as the exhibit. That has
- 46:03many preventions, obstacles in a civil court.
- 46:10The doctor needs to get deposed. The information
- 46:14that they relied upon in order to formulate their
- 46:16opinion might not be admissible evidence. So
- 46:21it's important to understand the differences
- 46:23there, but also where to look for the right evidence.
- 46:28And so. This is probably the most important topic
- 46:33is the settlement landmines and. We're going
- 46:39to talk about the compromise and release. which
- 46:42is the main settlement document in the workers
- 46:45compensation arena. And it has basic information,
- 46:50demographics, who the attorneys are, who the
- 46:54insurance is, how the injury happens, whether
- 47:00certain medical benefits were paid for and what
- 47:05the body parts were. But very importantly, and
- 47:10this is probably the most important sentence
- 47:13in a CNR for a civil attorney is buried at the
- 47:18end of this paragraph which says that execution
- 47:23of this form has no effect on claims that are
- 47:25not within the scope of the workers compensation
- 47:28law or claims that are not subject to the exclusivity
- 47:33provisions of the workers compensation law unless
- 47:36otherwise expressly stated. And so that is the
- 47:40aspect, that's the most important part, is that
- 47:43unless otherwise expressly stated, meaning that
- 47:46a person can and often do waive valuable civil
- 47:53claims in the workers' compensation cases. And
- 47:58this is the signature page. So the seminal case
- 48:04on this topic is called Claxton v. Waters. And
- 48:08so it basically says that the standard compromise
- 48:13and release, the standard form, unless there's
- 48:17something extra to it, it can't be used to waive
- 48:24civil claims. And that's important, meaning an
- 48:29attorney, both civil and workers comp, should
- 48:33look at the CNR to see if there's any hidden
- 48:35language. to try and get rid of the civil claim.
- 48:42So many times there is an addendum to the CNR,
- 48:48addendum A, and that will be just a formal release.
- 48:53Could be extra consideration. On section eight
- 49:03of the CNR, they'll put a lot of language as
- 49:09to the basis of the CNR, and they also may include
- 49:12a tiny little section about any and all claims.
- 49:19And that could damage the civil case, that could
- 49:25release the civil case. And there's also a comment
- 49:29section where they may include the release of
- 49:34civil claims or claims in other jurisdictions.
- 49:39So those are usually the three areas that I've
- 49:43seen release attempts. So there's prevention.
- 49:48There's ways to prevent the attorney from accidentally
- 49:53having their client waive valuable rights without
- 49:58knowing. And one way is discussing with the client,
- 50:06you're going to receive a workers compensation
- 50:10settlement. But I want to take a look at the
- 50:11document to see whether they're trying to release
- 50:18the civil case. A second way is to just put language
- 50:25in there. And I've included language here that
- 50:28I've used many times in the past. essentially
- 50:33saying that this worker's compensation claim
- 50:38has nothing to do with the civil claim. And a
- 50:43third is obviously to look at the CNR and strike
- 50:48out the language where they are trying to release
- 50:53the civil claim. So another settlement landmine
- 51:00or pitfall is the voluntary resignation, which
- 51:05is very common in nearly all workers' compensation
- 51:12cases, that at the end of the case, when they
- 51:16are about to settle it, the insurance wants a
- 51:21letter of resignation from the client, from the
- 51:26worker saying, you know, I hereby resign from
- 51:29my position at the company. That could be destructive
- 51:35to a Bronco termination case where in the civil
- 51:41arena the employee says they fired me and then
- 51:47they get confronted with a document that they
- 51:50signed in the workers compensation system saying
- 51:53that they resigned and that could be quite insignificant.
- 51:59So what do we do? instead of resigning what I've
- 52:06used in many circumstances, pretty much all of
- 52:09them, unless there is no wrongful termination
- 52:11case, is what I call an acknowledgement of separation.
- 52:17Meaning that the employee acknowledges that they
- 52:20are no longer employed with the employer. In
- 52:24that way, it will preserve any civil claim. because
- 52:32all they're saying is that they don't work there
- 52:34anymore. They're not saying what the reasons
- 52:36are. And that usually suffices the employers
- 52:42concerns. And so also on the civil side, when
- 52:50settling civil claims, the defense or the insurance
- 52:56may try to include claims that will harm or pressure
- 53:04applicants in workers compensation cases to settle
- 53:09or dismiss their claims. So for example, there
- 53:13may not be a workers compensation carve out saying
- 53:17that this has nothing to do with workers comp.
- 53:20And so perhaps a defense attorney would try and
- 53:25say, well, look, they settled their civil claim.
- 53:28And so we're entitled to a credit or this has
- 53:33already been resolved because they resolved it
- 53:37for their injuries. If you look at those release
- 53:40paragraphs, there's many, many things listed
- 53:43in there, including physical injuries, mental
- 53:47injuries. If a person is releasing those in the
- 53:52civil arena and it's not supposed to be like
- 53:55that, the workers comp, might try and pressure
- 54:02resolution in that arena. There's also language
- 54:07where an employee will sign that they were not
- 54:11injured in the workplace. Those are minor terms.
- 54:18People may just peruse or not read the settlement
- 54:22agreements carefully, but it's common that a
- 54:27defense attorney will put in the agreement that
- 54:31the employee agrees and acknowledges that they
- 54:33didn't suffer an injury. They could be waiving
- 54:36132A rights, perhaps, and that's the retaliation
- 54:40for the filing of a workers' compensation claim.
- 54:43Perhaps there could be an ongoing claim in the
- 54:45workers' compensation arena that just got waived
- 54:49in the civil arena. And another common term is
- 54:53to request a dismissal of any current claims
- 54:58and that they verify that there are no other
- 55:00pending current claims so it's important for
- 55:03the workers compensation attorney to look at
- 55:05the civil settlement document to make sure that
- 55:08their workers compensation case is not getting
- 55:11adversely affected. So those are the important
- 55:18topics there and then I'm going to briefly touch
- 55:23on exclusivity. What does it mean that an injured
- 55:28worker, when they're injured on the job, then
- 55:32worker's compensation is their only remedy and
- 55:36they can't go after the employer outside of that
- 55:40jurisdiction. That's essentially what the rule
- 55:43says. However, there's exceptions to the rule
- 55:47and the main exception is whether the conduct
- 55:53was outside of the compensation bargain, meaning
- 55:57was it by the wrongful conduct of the employer.
- 56:03And so the main inquiry as to whether it applies,
- 56:08whether the exclusivity rule applies, which is
- 56:12an affirmative defense in almost every answer,
- 56:17especially in disability discrimination cases.
- 56:19is why is the employer being sued? Are they being
- 56:22sued because the employee got hurt? Or are they
- 56:26being sued for the unlawful conduct that ensued,
- 56:31either giving rise to the entry or subsequent
- 56:34to the entry? So if it's because of the injury,
- 56:40then it's usually going to be exclusivity. However,
- 56:45there's many claims that do not fall with an
- 56:51exclusivity. And those are usually the fee had
- 56:54claims and a wrongful termination claim because
- 56:56that is outside the bargain. And also for car
- 57:04accident claims that the two cases can be proceeding
- 57:07at the same time. So even though a person was
- 57:10working and gets injured, Uh, by a third party,
- 57:15technically they were, they were working perhaps
- 57:18they are doing deliveries or purchasing work
- 57:22materials. Still, they have the ability to go
- 57:27to have their third party claim and that would
- 57:29be outside of the bargain. Obviously. And so
- 57:36we're just coming up to the hour and I just want
- 57:39to finish here. So we're going to talk about
- 57:42returning to work. And this is where many of
- 57:45the civil cases get created, where the employee
- 57:53gets injured and there is quite insignificant
- 57:59communications between the employee and the employer
- 58:04to discuss returning to work. Every employer
- 58:09with five or more employees has a duty to engage
- 58:15in the interactive process in California. They
- 58:18have to discuss how are we going to accommodate
- 58:22you? Can we accommodate you? As the employee
- 58:27is discussing that, if they're only represented
- 58:31by workers' compensation counsel that does not
- 58:35have experience in the employment arena, they
- 58:37might not recognize the pitfalls or the creations
- 58:43of civil claims in that discussion. And that's
- 58:50a discussion that takes place in vast majority
- 58:53of workers' compensation claims. And many times,
- 58:57the employer just says, no, we can't accommodate.
- 59:00There hasn't been a timely or good faith inquiry.
- 59:07And so when there is a request and a denial,
- 59:11that's essentially the creation of a civil case
- 59:14or at least a civil inquiry. I'm going to touch
- 59:21upon these ethical considerations is that if
- 59:25an employer is represented in a civil case, then
- 59:31it could be complicated as to how the attorney
- 59:37is going to discuss with the employee, how to
- 59:41discuss with the employer. So that takes looking
- 59:45into and seeing how that goes about. But both
- 59:51parties, including the employee, employee and
- 59:54the employer have to talk to each other. So if
- 59:56the employee goes to get advice, it's not exactly
- 1:00:00the attorney telling the employee what to tell
- 1:00:03the employer, but the advice that the employee
- 1:00:07gets in order to engage in the interactive process
- 1:00:10was since they have a duty to do that. Because
- 1:00:14the liability when it comes to the interactive
- 1:00:17process, it usually falls on the party that causes
- 1:00:23the process to break down. So the employee needs
- 1:00:26to engage and discuss with the employer about
- 1:00:29potential accommodations. And so it's important
- 1:00:32to coordinate with the workers comp who had just
- 1:00:37received this PR2 report and it gets sent to
- 1:00:41the employer and they're trying to see whether
- 1:00:44they can accommodate and they might get a frantic
- 1:00:46phone call from the applicant saying my work
- 1:00:50isn't accommodating me and they said that they
- 1:00:52can't have me work there anymore. What do I do
- 1:00:54now? Which is a common theme in workers compensation.
- 1:01:00And so it's important to make sure you're getting
- 1:01:03all the bits of information, the emails that
- 1:01:06go back and forth, et cetera. So gonna go through
- 1:01:11some best practices in these cases is to communicate,
- 1:01:18communicate early. If you find out that there
- 1:01:22is civil counsel or there is workers compensation
- 1:01:24counsel, introduce yourself. Share major events.
- 1:01:29I'm about to have this deposition of my client
- 1:01:31on this day. Is there anything that you have
- 1:01:35concerns about? Let's talk about the major issues
- 1:01:39in our cases. Exchange documents and before the
- 1:01:44client signs off. On an agreement in either arena
- 1:01:48that the other attorney should should look at
- 1:01:52the agreement to make sure that it's. Clean.
- 1:01:56And so these are the main places to discuss,
- 1:02:01be it the time of the complaint, the intake,
- 1:02:06the discovery, settlement depositions, and trial.
- 1:02:12In the civil side, these are some documents that
- 1:02:18are usually useful and available from the workers'
- 1:02:22compensation side. which will be the claim file,
- 1:02:25the records and AME QME reports, depot transcripts,
- 1:02:29the PR2s and settlement documents, obviously.
- 1:02:34And vice versa, for the workers' compensation
- 1:02:38attorney, there's quite significant documentation,
- 1:02:45which could be the deposition transcripts of
- 1:02:49individuals that they might not have witness
- 1:02:52statements from. The employment discovery answers
- 1:02:57to interrogatories where those might be answered
- 1:02:59differently than what is stated in the evidence
- 1:03:04and other expert reports. Perhaps there's a defense
- 1:03:08expert report, which could be used in the workers'
- 1:03:13compensation arena. Finally, to conclude, I listed
- 1:03:22The top 10 mistakes, not coordinating with the
- 1:03:27council, not preparing for the deposition, not
- 1:03:33looking at the discovery, not reviewing a CNR,
- 1:03:37voluntarily resigning, giving inconsistent answers
- 1:03:41depending on the arena, taking inconsistent positions
- 1:03:46and whether they can work, et cetera. overlooking
- 1:03:49return to work communications, that's the interactive
- 1:03:52process, not understanding whether the actions
- 1:03:57are not to be exclusive within the workers' compensation
- 1:04:02arena, not adequately reviewing the medical opinions
- 1:04:05and treating the cases ultimately as separate
- 1:04:08cases when they both are affecting each other.
- 1:04:13And so, finally, the What I would recommend is
- 1:04:19coordinating early, sharing information, leveraging
- 1:04:24each other's file, preparing for each deposition,
- 1:04:28reviewing the settlement documents to make sure
- 1:04:30you're not waiving your client's claims in the
- 1:04:33other arena, and to not think of it as two cases,
- 1:04:38but as one case just in two different forums.
- 1:04:42And so thank you so much. Just one final tip.
- 1:04:54You can also handle them simultaneously yourself
- 1:04:57if you come to learn both arenas and those can
- 1:05:01be quite significant. I was talking about the
- 1:05:06case earlier where we handle both at the same
- 1:05:11time, make sure all the answers are consistent
- 1:05:15and at least in this situation resulted in seven
- 1:05:20figure resolution. And so these can be quite
- 1:05:24valuable to you. And that's it. Thank you so
- 1:05:30much. So I wanted to open it up for any questions.
- 1:05:36All right, Jonathan, it looks like we have two
- 1:05:37questions for now. One from Judith Coker regarding
- 1:05:41the language that this release does not include
- 1:05:44civil claims. If you add to the document, it
- 1:05:47seems that it would need that to be initialized
- 1:05:51or initialed by all parties, which defendants
- 1:05:53may resist. Do you agree? Yeah, so you can. If
- 1:06:02you are putting into the. CNR that there is that
- 1:06:08that is not going to affect a civil claim. I
- 1:06:10mean, the defense is already going to sign the
- 1:06:13document. And if they are intending to settle
- 1:06:18the civil claim, then that's going to be something
- 1:06:21that needs to be discussed with the with the
- 1:06:26client, because there's really no reason why
- 1:06:30to try and settle a civil claim. or demand that
- 1:06:34kind of language when they're not trying to settle
- 1:06:37the civil claim. And did you say there was one
- 1:06:43other question? Yes. Can you comment on how to
- 1:06:47avoid exclusivity issues where a FIHA client
- 1:06:50seeks emotional distress damages for their harassment
- 1:06:52and or discrimination through workers comp? Yeah,
- 1:06:56so that is a topic that gets brought up quite
- 1:07:00often and the The important factor is to determine
- 1:07:09where the emotional distress arises from. So
- 1:07:12if it arises due to the person having the physical
- 1:07:16injury, then that is going to be subject to the
- 1:07:22exclusivity. But if a person has terminated and
- 1:07:25that is where their emotional distress arises
- 1:07:29from, Then that would not be subject to the exclusivity.
- 1:07:34So it's important when preparing the client for
- 1:07:36depositions. Is to have them adequately discuss.
- 1:07:44You know, from from a civil perspective. How
- 1:07:48the what the pain and suffering symptoms are
- 1:07:52due to the failure to accommodate. You know,
- 1:07:55I thought that my employer was. going to be loyal
- 1:07:59to me because I was loyal to them, or how the
- 1:08:04termination has impacted them emotionally, how
- 1:08:08not having a job due to the wrongful termination
- 1:08:12has impacted them emotionally. And so that is
- 1:08:15what usually preserves a person's ability to
- 1:08:22pursue the civil claim. without getting hit with
- 1:08:26the workers' compensation exclusivity. All right,
- 1:08:31Jonathan, it looks like we actually just got
- 1:08:33two more. Do we have, do you have the time to
- 1:08:36capture these? Sure. All right. All right. So
- 1:08:39one of them, how do I get depositions paid for
- 1:08:42by the insurance carrier in a workers' comp claim
- 1:08:44if it is a non -medical deposition but material
- 1:08:48to acceptance or denial of a workers' comp case?
- 1:08:53Well, if it is the applicant, then you would
- 1:08:57write the letter to the insurance company. But
- 1:09:01if it I believe there's usually a petition that
- 1:09:04can get filed, but that's kind of beyond the
- 1:09:06scope of the of the presentation. But I believe
- 1:09:10there is a there's a petition that needs to get
- 1:09:13filed after a meet and confer effort. And then
- 1:09:16if that isn't able to get resolved, then to file
- 1:09:20the declaration of readiness to proceed to get
- 1:09:23the hearing and go that route. All right. Last
- 1:09:28question. Thank you. One more. How do you obtain
- 1:09:31work comp file if client or PC doesn't have a
- 1:09:36work comp attorney? Yes, you can subpoena the
- 1:09:41insurance company, the workers compensation insurance
- 1:09:43company and ask for relevant data. So that could
- 1:09:49be correspondence between them and your client,
- 1:09:54which is not going to be protected, or them and
- 1:09:59the employer, which may be protected. What the
- 1:10:05investigation was that they conducted, what medical
- 1:10:11records They received what medical records they
- 1:10:14sent off to the employer. There's a list of categories.
- 1:10:17So that that would be. The right way to go about
- 1:10:20it is to just send a subpoena to the workers
- 1:10:23compensation carrier. All right, so it looks
- 1:10:32like we just got 1 more. Shall I. Would you like
- 1:10:35to hear it? Sure. All right, so one more, going
- 1:10:38back to the question regarding exclusivity issues
- 1:10:41in a FIHA matter, would physical manifestations
- 1:10:44of emotional distress, for example, headaches
- 1:10:47fall under exclusivity? I don't believe so. And
- 1:10:55actually, that is... So you have to go to the
- 1:11:00root of the problem, which is... the physical
- 1:11:06manifestations of the stress was the stress from
- 1:11:11the wrongful termination, then all the residual
- 1:11:15effects or the sequelae, as they say in the medical
- 1:11:19world, that points to the wrongful termination.
- 1:11:24So if they didn't have the wrongful termination
- 1:11:26or if they didn't have the violation of the FIA
- 1:11:31statute, then they would not have had the physical
- 1:11:34manifestations. And that would even be more corroborating
- 1:11:41to the pain and suffering damages in the civil
- 1:11:43case. All right, that's it for questions today.
- 1:11:51This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:11:53so much, Jonathan, for taking the time to answer
- 1:11:55questions and for educating our members. And
- 1:11:58thank you so much to our audience for joining
- 1:11:59us today. Have a great day, everybody. Thank
- 1:12:02you.