Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP208: The Murder of Lisa Harnum
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a True crime podcast. Hi Tanya, Hi Talia. How are
- 0:38you? I'm John pretty good? How about you? Splendid? Thanks for
- 0:42asking. I hope everybody is doing amazing today. Thank you guys for listening
- 0:48or watching us on True Crime Daily's YouTube. And I have a story today
- 0:55about domestic violence. Before start, though, want me to start I do?
- 1:00I want to ask everybody to subscribe or like us and write nice comments
- 1:06not I hate comments like that, because we will comment on you and our
- 1:11comment on the commoner section. Anyway, this is the Messa violence, which
- 1:17I know can be a trigger for a lot of people. But story needs
- 1:19to be told. Are you ready? Yes? This is a story about
- 1:25Lisa cecil Ya Harnum and she was born in Toronto, Canada, in nineteen
- 1:30eighty one. She basically was raised by her mom and she had a brother
- 1:37she was very close to. His name was Jason. Lisa had a love
- 1:41for dance at a young age ballet. She was one of those girls in
- 1:47high school, beautiful, smart, good at everything she did, the envy
- 1:53of everyone. Yeah, you're that's one of those girls you're so jealous of.
- 1:57Yes, that was her. She was extra outgoing, had a social
- 2:01circle of friends. But just like everybody else, she was prone to feeling
- 2:07bad in your teens. You know how it is. Yeah, you're never
- 2:09perfect. You're not good enough, your hair's not pretty enough, you're not
- 2:14skinny enough, not skinny. Yeah, So Ashley saying that she developed an
- 2:20eating disorder, and she also battled with depression in high school, and at
- 2:24one point she was hospitalized for her eating disorder. I believe it was Bolimia
- 2:31yan anorexia. And then again, she's in ballet and there's probably a lot
- 2:36of pressure on her to be super tiny. Her mother had once stated in
- 2:43the news that it was a very difficult time in Lisa's life. I mean,
- 2:46as you can imagine, going in in a hospital and all that,
- 2:50But she came out stronger, She overcame her issues and she end up graduating
- 2:57doing well. But she didn't really want to stay in Toronto, Canada.
- 3:00She wanted to go someplace where she felt had more sunshine, sunshine, sunshine,
- 3:07and she ended up going at the age of twenty four. And then
- 3:10this is in two thousand and four, she went to Sydney, Australia,
- 3:15and she's there. She's living her life. She has this work visa for
- 3:21twelve months and she likes to do hair. She's a hairdresser. She ends
- 3:27up studying at it's called the Australian Hair and Beauty College in Sydney and working
- 3:34part time to pay her twition. She loved this ribed at this job and
- 3:39she didn't want to leave. She just really liked it there. She also
- 3:44was into fashion makeup and again she's like dropped dead gorgeous, beautiful hair makeup,
- 3:51wearing the bass clothes. It bothered her to be away from her family,
- 3:54but they still talked to her. And her mom Joan and her brother
- 3:59Jason talked every day on the phone and they were really supportive of her despite
- 4:04her being far away. She ended up trying to pursue some citizenship in Australia,
- 4:12But I mean, I do immigration laws, so I'm not sure how
- 4:15she could do it, but I do know that she ended up being able
- 4:18to extend her visa so she's there originally in two thousand and four, and
- 4:24now let's go to two thousand and nine. She's living her best life,
- 4:28even hair, doing makeup, going out looking good. But she needed a
- 4:32new place to live. So she asked one of her friends, Hey,
- 4:35do you know anybody that's looking for a roommate or a place I can stay?
- 4:42And her friend mentions this name, Simon Getney. He was about ten
- 4:46years older than her. He had a place and it was in it's a
- 4:53very nice area of Sydney called Hyde and it was across the street from Hyde
- 4:57Park. His apartment was fifteen stories up and it had like a panoramic view
- 5:02of the park. Oh beautiful, yeah, and all windows Florida ceiling windows.
- 5:10So she talks to Simon and he agrees to let her run a room.
- 5:15It's a little bit background on Simon. Simon worked selling shoes. He
- 5:21was a shoe importer. Oh, shoe importer. I'm guessing these are very
- 5:27high end. They're not the shoes you wear. No, No, definitely
- 5:30not. They're not the shoes I wear. There, Yes, high end,
- 5:34designer, designer footwear. He does it online and a lot of what
- 5:40he got came from the United States. When Lisa talked to her mom Joan
- 5:44about the arrangement, she said it was just going to be temporary and she
- 5:46was going to find some other place to live. But things happened. Okay,
- 5:53Simon's a very good looking guy. She's a good looking girl. They're
- 5:57living together and being clicked. How about that? Things clicked all right?
- 6:03At first, she thought Simon wasn't interested in women, but she found out
- 6:08he was. Definitely, he definitely was, he was. So she moves
- 6:11into this luxury apartment, fifteen floor in the Inner City, the Hide.
- 6:17It was about two months after they were living together that they they started dating,
- 6:21dating, dating, they're dating, their dating, things happen. Eventually
- 6:26it grows serious there and Lisa's not moving out. Remember it was gonna be
- 6:30temporary. Oh yeah, she's she's not moving out. Something strange as Simon
- 6:33would call Lisa byer middle name, Cecilia. Cecilia name it is Lisa is
- 6:40too, Yeah it is, Well, that's what he called her. And
- 6:45he became very infatuated with her. And time goes on, they're starting to
- 6:50fall in love. Twenty eleven comes along. It's Lisa's thirtieth birthday. There's
- 6:56this party and there's a video out there which Simon gets on one knee and
- 7:02he proposes in front of all of her friends. Kind of nerve racking.
- 7:08I think, yeah, I know, because she said, no, I
- 7:11know. She's like, have you seen those videos? Like you that much
- 7:15anymore? She's like, oh, you're taking a chance, yeah, not
- 7:19just videoing it, but in front of everybody. Want to private, but
- 7:26anyway, she starts crying and she's nodding her head. Yes. Yes.
- 7:30She was so shocked, like she couldn't even speak. She's just overwhelmed.
- 7:35So now they're officially engaged. Her mother, Joan, was skeptical about this
- 7:43relationship because Joan had learned a lot of stuff. Cecilia, I mean sorry,
- 7:48Lisa had confided in her about what the past year and a half two
- 7:54years of Button life, and it wasn't his picture perfect suppressed as you would
- 7:58think. The outside, you have this gorgeous couple, right, they're living
- 8:03in a luxury apartment having fun, but there were a lot of things that
- 8:07happened hide and closed doors. Simon became more controlling over Lisa, which is
- 8:16how a lot of the domestic violence cases end up happening, right, that's
- 8:22how they start, and they get control. Next thing, you know,
- 8:24you don't have any friends, any family. Yeah, they isolate you.
- 8:28And so he starts telling her how to dress. She could only wear pants,
- 8:33okay, okay. He told her how to style her hair, which
- 8:39was in a ponytail. They no longer went out to clubs the party have
- 8:43fun, mostly because Simon was really uncomfortable with guys looking at her. Okay,
- 8:50he's insecure. He's extremely insecure. Extremely, he's extremely insecure. A
- 8:56text she wants sad Lisas sent to her mother a red like this. This
- 9:00is a quote. This relationship sure has changed me a lot. Exclamation.
- 9:05I'm much more calm than I was before, domesticated, conservative, dainty.
- 9:11I have nails now too, and they're natural. I have a French manicure.
- 9:15I bought a whole bunch of flat and casual shoes. Oh so she's
- 9:18not even allowed to wear heels. No, no more heels, and she
- 9:22wrote no more cleavage. Jummerfraid. Wow. She wrote, Simon is terrified
- 9:28of summer and the beach. He said, we need to find a burka
- 9:31bathing suit for me to wear. Eh he. Then she wrote, exo
- 9:35he he exo. I'm sure he was not kidding. He rewinded her entirely
- 9:41covered up. I mean she was beautiful to go out. Yeah no,
- 9:45and that's when her mom was this is not a red bright, red flag,
- 9:50red time out. Not okay, what's going on? She would have
- 9:54been even more worried if she knew about Simon's past. Someone tell you it,
- 10:00all right, just briefly. Simon was eighteen years old when he was
- 10:05basically what we would call here but I'm probation. He was given in two
- 10:09year good behavior bond after savagely attacking a deli owner who had confronted him because
- 10:18Simon was harassing a female worker was his ex girlfriend. His ex girlfriend worked
- 10:24at this dally. Yes, and he's harassing her and the owner gets involved,
- 10:26Yes, okay, and he just what the wow? Yeah? Oh.
- 10:33In obviously nineteen ninety three, Simon was caught outside a Era Matra nightclub
- 10:41with a car full of stolen goods, so he's stealing man. He didn't
- 10:45show for court, warrant was issued for his arrest, and then in nineteen
- 10:50ninety four there was this whole string of robberies thefts where he when Stantley was
- 10:56working Oh, he's just coincidentally worked you just started going missing. Yeah,
- 11:01And there was this detective his name was Detective Sergeant Keith Bristow and his partner.
- 11:07They went to Simon's family's home because he lived with his parents. They
- 11:11were wearing regular clothes. The detectives arrive in the doorstep and they have a
- 11:16warrant for his arrest because they believe they have enough evidence to get him for
- 11:22stealing. But when the officers tried to arrest him, all hell broke loose.
- 11:26This is crazy. Sergeant Bristow's partner was struck and not to the ground,
- 11:33just out of nowhere by an old school boombox. What I was like,
- 11:37bam, And it was either by Simon's mom or his sister. Oh
- 11:43that's an unusual item to hit someone with. Really, and why you why
- 11:48you hitting a cop? I know you're not going to get away with this,
- 11:50Like it's not going to just go away if you hit the cap and
- 11:54run off or do whatever. I never understand why people do this. I
- 11:56mean I do understand why people. It wasn't even him right anyway, So
- 12:01if you think that's bad, Sergeant Bristow had a hold of Simon and he
- 12:07was struck, fell onto a bed on top of Simon. So he's on
- 12:11top of Simon on a bad Simon starts biting down on his ear. Oh
- 12:18no, and the sergeant is saying don't, don't stop, stop, but
- 12:22there was no stopping Simon. Simon then bit right through his ear and then
- 12:28spit it out. He did it, Mike Tyson right, Oh no to
- 12:33the police officer, the fuck is this about? What the fuck is this?
- 12:37Come on now? A little cucko. In the end ended up getting
- 12:43kind of a slap on the wrist. He was jailed and after a pre
- 12:48supported Simon's claims that he'd undergone some religious metamoris. He's found God. Simon
- 12:58left Australia into a strict Catholic order at a monastery in Fringance. He every
- 13:05morning he would wake up around five o'clock and he would just pray all day.
- 13:09Good for him, yeah, good for him. Now he had this
- 13:13single bedroom and he was pretty much isolated and he'd have his meals alone.
- 13:18And the priest who had supported all of this claimed to the news channel seven
- 13:24News later that he really believed that Simon had a good heart. Simon really
- 13:28wanted to do better, but he didn't stick with that. How do you
- 13:33know why he's doing a spoiler I mean spoiler alert, No, I mean
- 13:35obvious. That lasted a little over a year and he left the monastery and
- 13:45he basically he couldn't handle a life of celibacy. Yeah wow, So he
- 13:54left. Yeah, and he went back to Sydney and he just kind of
- 13:58picked up we're left off. He was going to nightclubs. One specifically from
- 14:05going from a monastery to a nightclub, right, you know what happened to
- 14:09the devotion, Well, just got devoted to other things exactly. So one
- 14:13of the clubs he liked to go to is called the Ivy Nightclub, and
- 14:18he ended up being arrested in two thousand and one for drug trafficking, drug
- 14:24trafficking fifty two pills ecstasy tablets. Whoa five thousand in cash all in his
- 14:30pants. Wow, they're all mine, I swear. Yeah, I just
- 14:37like to carry. I'm not going to sell it. I'm not going to
- 14:39sell it. Sell it. No, he did, and he ended up
- 14:43pleading guilty to the charges. So now let's fast forward. In December of
- 14:46two thousand and ten, Lisa went back home to Canada to Toronto to visit
- 14:52her family, and she'd been with him for about Simon about a year.
- 14:58Simon didn't end up going on this trip. When Lisa got back home,
- 15:03both her brother and her mom noticed some changes in her. She wore her
- 15:09hair and a ponytail. She didn't wear makeup anymore. She was into makeup,
- 15:15remember, and fashion, and her clothes were dull like black, gray,
- 15:22non revealing clothes, which was really odd because again, she loved fashion.
- 15:26She loved fashion, she loved makeup, she loved being beautiful hair yes,
- 15:31yes, two just like us exactly, not only different. Lisa told
- 15:37her mom she wasn't supposed to see her friends in Canada because Simon didn't want
- 15:43her to go out and he would always check on her. She couldn't visit
- 15:46friends when she went back home, No, because he's controlling or even then,
- 15:50oh man. And eventually Lisa comes back to Sydney and there's an email
- 15:56that her mom sent basically saying that Simon's is no good for you. You
- 16:03need to go. You need to Mom's no best, right, they do?
- 16:06They do unless you ask my kids? Yeah, and I know you're
- 16:08kidding, You're a dip, right, annoying, the most un cool thing
- 16:17that's ever right. My daughter even has me like pull down, like not
- 16:22in front of her school when I let her out. Yeah, because for
- 16:26drop me off on the next black please, I don't want to be nobody.
- 16:30Yeah. She even had me on Facebook put that I wasn't related to
- 16:33her. It's it's humiliating to be to know me. She's fifteen, by
- 16:40the way. Yeah, but mom's always no. They always know. Even
- 16:47when when you were a teenager you didn't want to listen to your mom.
- 16:49I didn't want my mom knew nothing. I knew everything exactly, so everything,
- 16:55but moms always no. The but before I tell you more, quick
- 17:00break. So Lisa ends up telling her mom, don't send me these messages
- 17:06because I think Simon might be reading them. Oh, of course he probably
- 17:11is right, And Simon, of course is Yeah. He's creep and he
- 17:15would have a very explosive personality. Little things can make him go off.
- 17:22For example, if she prepared dinner not right, or she was working out
- 17:29too long, he would just become super angry. She felt like she was
- 17:33tiptoeing around him, and she would do everything possible to not make him upset.
- 17:40You know, try to be perfect, right, becau, it's just
- 17:42not worth the explosion, like the reaction you're going to get. And she
- 17:47probably thinks I am doing things like he can probably guess lighting her, you
- 17:51know. Yeah. Eventually, despite having to pay so Lisa had to pay
- 17:56fifteen hundred in rent a week. A week, Simon convinced Lisa to stop
- 18:03working at the hair and beauty college. No, now she's going to become
- 18:07financially dependent. Hinginging right, the other form of abuse. In early twenty
- 18:15eleven, Lisa told Simon she really wanted a couple days to work. What
- 18:18is she doing? She's got no kids sitting there doing what She's probably not
- 18:23allowed to go anywhere. She's not allowed to hang out with her friends,
- 18:26right, She's probably stuck in that apartment forever, not allowed to go out.
- 18:30Poor thing. He suggested that she volunteer as a compromise, and they
- 18:37got into this big argument that ended up with Lisa leaving. This is in
- 18:42February of two thousand and eleven, and she left for a couple of days,
- 18:45but then they got back together almost out I know. But during the
- 18:49time she was away, she confided in her friend. Her name was Rebecca
- 18:55about the situation being smothered. Basically, right, she's being smothered. Then
- 19:00she gets back with him. With Simon and Lisa's friend, Rebecca gets a
- 19:04message from Simon telling her to stay out of their business and leave Lisa alone.
- 19:11In April of twenty eleven, Simon sent some kind of abusive texts to
- 19:18Lisa. It was because she wore her hair down. Oh no, yeah,
- 19:25there you go again. Yeah, with that attitude, he wrote,
- 19:29Since you got an attitude and you made the comment about me working during the
- 19:33day. There are two bills worth nine hundred dollars, one for electricity and
- 19:37one for elstra. I don't actually know what telstra is, but like gas
- 19:41or something. Yeah, probably I want you to pay for them with your
- 19:45own money. With the with the no job that she has. With the
- 19:48no job, Lisa replied, if I had a job that paid me money
- 19:52instead of something that you're comfortable with, then maybe I could pay something.
- 19:56You are a heartless, heartless person. This pissed Simon off. He's not
- 20:02a heartless person. No, of course not. He's giving her everything,
- 20:06yes, giving her everything. What is her problem? He wrote her back,
- 20:11quote, who the fuck you think you are walking around the house like
- 20:15you own it, or coming and going without my permission. Again, I've
- 20:22waited for you to apologize for your disgusting comment, but you walk around like
- 20:26a peacock with your hair out and too proud to apologize. You lie to
- 20:30me and promised you listen to me at all times. Obviously you're still the
- 20:36proud person and nothing has changed. I was trying to break her. How
- 20:41dare you have your hair out? They're not listening to me? Yeah,
- 20:44and you walk around like you own them the place when I'm paying for everything,
- 20:47is really what he wanted to say. It's wow. Lisa's mom,
- 20:52Joan once told Channel seven News that she overheard an argument between Lisa and Simon
- 20:57and Lisa was going to leave. She went to grab her purse and Simon
- 21:02grabbed it and attempted to pull her purse away. When he did it,
- 21:06he broke her finger. Oh. Now, they'd only been engaged for five
- 21:11days when they got into this massive, heated argument. Simon sent a text
- 21:17to Lisa that said, quote, Cecilia, you're my fiance and I love
- 21:22you, but we both know you have problems. Yeah, it's all her,
- 21:26of course, it's her. All her not fucking hem yes, lighting
- 21:29the fuck out her right. Oh my god, the problems affect the mood
- 21:33of our relationship at times, but you refuse to admit it. Please pray
- 21:37to God so he can help you get rid of these habits. Oh,
- 21:42I'm so angry. It's such a narcissist. So geez, it's all her
- 21:48fault. Like the only thing that can help her is God, right,
- 21:51or listening to him? Yeah, listening to him. She just listened to
- 21:53him. If she just listened, all her problems would be solved. Lisa
- 21:59told him that I love you. I do have faults. It doesn't though
- 22:03obviously Simon, I'm Simon, doesn't. Simon's perfect. Now he's perfect.
- 22:11She said, she has lots of faults, but she was heartbroken when he
- 22:15would yell at her rather than try to help her work through her problems.
- 22:18And this pissed him off because he's always pissed, right, And he told
- 22:22her, basically, you need to fix yourself. Okay, Well, let
- 22:26me where you with her? Then if she's so broken, because he's trying,
- 22:30because she can be a good person, if he sees the potential,
- 22:33if she would just do everything he said, everything things started to change for
- 22:37Lisa. She told her mom she was considering moving to Melvin. I always
- 22:44want to say Melbourne. I always want to say Melbourne, Melvin, Melvin
- 22:48m h into a rental property. She basically what she was stating is that
- 22:53the excitement or of the engagement that was that was over, the reality of
- 22:59the situation was setting in. But Simon stopped that from happening by calling Lisa's
- 23:03friend and being like, don't you even think of letting her rent that place
- 23:08from you? And given all the stress that Lisa was going through, her
- 23:12eating disorder resurfaced and she recognized that she was having issues. She decided to
- 23:22see a personal trainer she was working out, and she told the trainer that
- 23:26she was struggling with an eating disorder and she was trying to get healthier work
- 23:33out. The personal trainer recommended that Lisa speak to a counselor who had experience
- 23:38with eating disorders, and the counselor's name was Michelle Richmond. Lisa called see
- 23:45Michelle and asked her, can we make sure that you don't take any notes
- 23:51of when we meet, because I'm really worried that Simon will somehow get his
- 23:55hands. On these notes, she expressed how she felt very isolated and believed
- 24:03that he was monitoring everything she was doing. She did explain to Michelle how
- 24:07she had a felt a loss of control, couldn't wear what she wanted to
- 24:11wear, couldn't go be with her friends, couldn't do the things that she
- 24:17wanted to do, and she wasn't even allowed to look at guys when they
- 24:21were together. What if she accidentally did, she would get mad. You
- 24:23have to look at the floor all the time. But at that point,
- 24:26she said she wasn't physically abused. But Michelle was very concerned about her safety
- 24:33and recommended that maybe she go to a shelter for abuse women and suggested that
- 24:37she slowly move her belongings to a storage unit, you know, just to
- 24:42get out. But Lisa was she was just too afraid of it. On
- 24:48July twenty eight, twenty eleven, she met with her personal trainer for the
- 24:53last time, and the personal trainer could sense that something was right with Lisa.
- 25:00She seems stressed, nervous. Lisa ended up handing over two pillowcases full
- 25:07of clothes and said she was planning on leaving and she's going to go back
- 25:11to work as a job a hairdresser. She had these two pillowcases and she
- 25:17ended up bringing stuff to a storage unit that she did rent with her own
- 25:21money. I don't know how she had her own money, but she did.
- 25:25Eventually, though, Simon confronted her about this, and you said,
- 25:30well, how would he know because he's been monitoring her calls, for text
- 25:36messages, everything she does. Did she have like spyware on her computer?
- 25:40And spoiler alert? Oh man, yes, so he saw everything. Everything,
- 25:48everything that's tax that was like her part time job. Yeah, what
- 25:52the hell does he You know how much time you have to invest to do
- 25:55something like that. I mean, I'm not you tell me I've never been
- 25:57I mean I've never done it. Geez. Around seven pm, Michelle,
- 26:04the counselor, received a call from Lisa's phone, but no one spoke.
- 26:10Michelle called the number back, called Lisa's number back, and Simon answered and
- 26:14said, Michelle, you fucking bitch, try to contact her or have anything
- 26:19to do with her. I know where you live, and I'll hurt you.
- 26:22What. Yeah, now he's like frightening her. I didn't even give
- 26:26a fuck. No. Then Michelle received a text from Lisa that read quote,
- 26:33leave me alone. You've ruined my relationship. Drop all my stuff off
- 26:37at Concierge no later than tomorrow at ten am. Okay could She had given
- 26:41some stuff to Michelle too. On July twenty ninth, Lisa called her mom
- 26:48in Canada and told her to write down the following information. It was all
- 26:53of Michelle's contact information, and she said Lisa said, quote, if anything
- 26:59happen happens to me, please contact Michelle. Oh that's got to be a
- 27:03asmara. Mom. Yes, a terrifying thing to hear from your daughter if
- 27:08anything happens to me and she's way in Canada on the other side of the
- 27:14world. Yeah, you know, yes, Yeah. I was just so
- 27:17helpless, and basically your mom said you need to come on back right now,
- 27:22get back here immediately, asked to the airport stat So Lisa went online
- 27:26and she tried to book some tickets and work out her visa. Later that
- 27:32day, she called her mom and told her Simon had found out what she
- 27:36was doing, and Lisa found files on the computer that showed all the tracking
- 27:44Simon had been doing with her. Later that night, Misschelle Counselor received a
- 27:51message from Lisa. It said quote, I wish I never met you because
- 27:56you have ruined my life. I've been kids out of the house by Simon.
- 28:00I had everything with Simon, but you brainwashed me Michelle, and now
- 28:06I'm on the streets with nothing. I want the money I paid for you
- 28:11ruining my life as I'm broke and need money. You should be ashamed of
- 28:15yourself. Thank you for this big mess you've created. Wow, of course
- 28:19it wasn't Lisa. It wasn't It wasn't Lisa, it was Simon. Yeah.
- 28:25It's mid morning July thirtieth, twenty eleven. There's this Japanese exchange student
- 28:30and he's walking down to Liverpool Street. I don't know where that is.
- 28:34He's going to catch a bus home with his brother. He's waiting on the
- 28:40Hyde Park side of the street. I remember I told you that they had
- 28:45this panoramic view with all glass that faced the park. So he's waiting there
- 28:51for the bus and he hears something that caused him to look up the fifteenth
- 28:56floor. Then he saw something fall down the side of the building. And
- 29:02where the object that fell from where the fifteenth floor, he could see what
- 29:10looked like a man that was shirtless leaning over the side of the balcony and
- 29:15then this is all happening quick right right, and then bam, he hears
- 29:19something hit the ground. At first he thought it was garbage, and then
- 29:26that someone had thrown out the window, but obviously no, it was Lisa.
- 29:33And then there's this video of Simon trying to get going into an elevator
- 29:38and he had put on a shirt. He's in his pajamas and he's just
- 29:44making weird hand gestures and freaking out and he comes running down in a hysterical
- 29:48state to Lisa's body. Some of the people, because this is an ari
- 29:53it's in Sydney, some of the people they stop and they see Lisa and
- 29:57they try to recess it, try to help her, and it was too
- 30:03late. Yeah, fifteen stories. Fifteen stories is not survival. No,
- 30:08oh my god, I don't want to think about it. That's Selsa's body
- 30:11is or purse which had fallen with her, and this is really weird.
- 30:17In her pocket was this piece of paper and it's probably like this big and
- 30:22it's ripped multiple times this way. On the paper it says there are surveillance
- 30:29cameras inside and outside of the house. Why is it in her pocket.
- 30:33Yeah, and why is it ripped up? I don't know. Someone had
- 30:37installed there was cameras in their apartments and outside their apartment. I don't know
- 30:42exactly where they were in it, but I know he had them outside too.
- 30:48He wanted to track when she's leaving, when she's coming back, what
- 30:52she's doing. CCTV footage showed that only sixty nine seconds before Lisa fell from
- 31:00the building, she can be seen running out of the apartment and Simon's chasing
- 31:07after her, and he grabs her and he ends up putting his hand around
- 31:11her mouth. Neighbors other apartment units, people in the other units, could
- 31:17hear please help me, God help me? That's sixty nine seconds before her
- 31:22body's wow over. As I said, After Lisa falls, Simon is seen
- 31:27on this footage in front of his door, and he's trying to get an
- 31:30elevator, and he's pacing back and forth, waiting, waiting, waiting for
- 31:34the elevator, and then in the elevator as side, he's clearly freaking out,
- 31:40running around like a rat in a cage. All the while, Joan
- 31:45has been texting, oh no, because Lisa was supposed to get the tickets
- 31:48to fly Toronto, So Toronto, and Joan hasn't heard from Lisa now,
- 31:55and she texts Simon, quote, please tell me that Lisa's okay. This
- 32:00is a mother pleading with you, wanting to know she's okay. And it
- 32:04was about two am that Joan got a call from the police stating her daughter
- 32:09was dead. Oh so Simon had his own version of events. Oh yeah,
- 32:15what's he got to say? Yeah, I can't wait hear this.
- 32:17He's got shit to say. He told the police that she fell, she
- 32:22fell from the balcony. Okay, So it's July thirtieth. He woke up
- 32:29to go on his computer and to look at his spyware. Of course he
- 32:34couldn't log in or something happened, so he tells the police he has a
- 32:37spywear. Yeah, he's trying to be forthcoming. Yeah right, he's just
- 32:40being honest. And then he looks at porn Okay after the spywear, and
- 32:45he tells the police's looking at some porn okay for some reason, I guess,
- 32:51he wasn't able to get in the spyware, so he tries to log
- 32:53in again, but he was unable to and he found out that Lisa had
- 32:57changed the password. Oh, she got into it. Wow, I don't
- 33:01know. Oh, they probably set him off. Yes, hello, right,
- 33:06and so he's pissed. They're arguing for a while, and then he
- 33:09went. He says, he went back to bed, and he said he
- 33:13got up a little later and found that Lisa had packed her bags and she's
- 33:19booking a flight. She's leaving, and he challenged her as she grabbed her
- 33:24purse to run out the door. He chased after her. He admitted that
- 33:30he grabbed her and he brought her back into the apartment and wanted to talk.
- 33:34He was gonna make her some tea. Uh huh, make her some
- 33:37time. Uh huh. Sure, gonna make her some tea and they're gonna
- 33:42work things out. But after he brought her back in, she ran out
- 33:46again. I mean they were, they're in the hallway, he's grabbing her,
- 33:50she's it's probably a frantic scene. Come oh, it's bad. Yeah,
- 33:52and we're just gonna come have a calm cup of tea. No,
- 33:57I don't believe this at all. He says. Lisa ran from the couch
- 34:00while he's making tea. She's just making the tea and instead of running out
- 34:06the door, she ran to the balcony. Yeah, that's yes, bullshit
- 34:10bullshit. Why bullshit meter is going off real real high bullshit, Like,
- 34:15why would you run to the balcony? Yeah, why would you run to
- 34:16the balcony instead of running for the door. Again, he tries to get
- 34:20her in time. She's got one leg. Oh, she's gonna jump over
- 34:24the balcony and the balcony so everybody knows, is glass. It's a glass
- 34:30balcony with a little bit of a metal railing. She's got one leg over
- 34:34the balcony, and she's got a purse on her and she's gonna jump with
- 34:38her purse. Okay, that's a good point. Come on now, Yeah,
- 34:43again the bullshit. And she's gonna jump instead of trying to leave.
- 34:45Yes, she tries to get there and she slips, and he says,
- 34:51she's laying on the awning below and grabbing the balcony and then she just looses
- 34:57her grip and she's gone. Fifteen stores. There were no signs of a
- 35:00struggle, no, and so maybe his story could have been something that the
- 35:07police could possibly have believed. But there was more people that witnessed what happened.
- 35:15In particular, there was a guy named Josh Josh Rathmol He was an
- 35:19editor for I think ABC at the time, and he's just walking in the
- 35:23park when he notices something across the road at the Hyde Park apartment complex.
- 35:31He looked up and what he believes he saw was someone without a shirt caring
- 35:37what he thought was a suitcase okay, and it looked to Josh like the
- 35:45person was throwing the suitcase over the balcony. And that ends up being what
- 35:52gets gets Simon. So four days after Lisa's death, he was formally charged
- 35:59with her murder. He's got these murder charges hanging over his head. He's
- 36:04in jail, but he manages to find love still. Really, he's got
- 36:09a new girlfriend. Her name is Rachel. Rachel. She was twenty fourth
- 36:15time of his trial. He's got to be like forty, right, because
- 36:19he was ten years older than yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, Well
- 36:22what they met in two thousand and nine and they claim they were just friends,
- 36:25but people believe, I don't know that perhaps they were more, but
- 36:31maybe he was cheating and Lisa, Yes, well that would explain a lot.
- 36:36I'm not saying it happened. I don't know. I don't know.
- 36:38I wasn't there. I wasn't there. It's a legend, yes, and
- 36:42I close friends. One of the things that really surprised people is how much
- 36:45that Lisa and Rachel looked a lot alike. Really, they both had long,
- 36:51dark hair, slim figures, brown eyes. Later on, Rachel would
- 36:54say that she didn't see any resemblance whatsoever. Well, do you really want
- 36:58to see a resemblance? Right? Right? Right? No? No,
- 37:01no, with your boyfriend's old girlfriend that's dead. Yeah, no, no.
- 37:07Simon ends up instead of having a jury trial, he chooses to have
- 37:12a trial by judge, basically probably because everybody thought it was an asshole.
- 37:15I'm guessing, I'm speculating. I don't know. To me, that would
- 37:19be risky because in a jury trial you have to convince all twelve people.
- 37:23That's true, but I mean there could be just one person, like a
- 37:27holdout, thinking that you're innocent, whereas if you're having a bench trial and
- 37:30the judge is just deciding it's only one person. But a judge is going
- 37:35to look at the law and not be based on emotions. That's true,
- 37:37like, oh you're an asshole, so so you're guilty, right, It
- 37:42is true. My thought but I think I would gamble on a jury trial.
- 37:45Yeah, I think I would. I mean, I think I'm likable
- 37:49enough. I mean I would never, you know, hope to be in
- 37:52that situation. But yeah, I think I would just gamble it. But
- 37:57okay, as lawyers always want a jury trial, Yes, all you gotta
- 38:00do is appear likable, like you said, well maybe, yeah, no
- 38:04he's not. Maybe you know, if I could just charm the jury and
- 38:07that one person, one person, well a least he didn't take the stand.
- 38:12Oh that's too bad, because I would love to see that. And
- 38:15he's not that big of a narcissist. I'm surprised. His trial began October
- 38:19twenty First, the prosecutors painted this picture of Simon jealous, abusive partner,
- 38:24how he alienated Lisa from her friends and family. They brought up all the
- 38:30surveillance and tracking and controlling, and then how coincidentally when she finally has the
- 38:37courage to leave, she's dead. Yeah, but Simon tried to paint it
- 38:43differently. His defense attorney said that she'd had depression in when she she was
- 38:47younger, she had issues, and that she committed suicide. What a crack
- 38:53of shit, I guess it's the only defense he really has. I know,
- 38:58we call it polishing a turd. You have a really bad true crime
- 39:04daily, you know, we do call it polishing a turn. Yeah,
- 39:07when you have a bad professional term, it's a professional terms. That's what
- 39:10his lawyers had to do, was polish a turn. So they tried basically
- 39:15he just that was the gist of it. But then when Josh Wrath Maul
- 39:21testified, that was kind of the nail in the coffin. And then also,
- 39:27by the way, the prosecutors brought up so we have this glass balcony,
- 39:31there's no fingerprints of Lisa's on it, and then it should be filled
- 39:35with fingerprints she's trying to climb over it and struggling and slipping. Yeah,
- 39:40there was none. So they had all the witnesses testified, and the trial
- 39:46actually lasted for four weeks, which seems I mean, it's that's kind of
- 39:51a long time. A long time for this. I don't know, it's
- 39:54not a O. J. Simpson case here, you know, but some
- 39:58serial killer with like up to victims or something. But okay, well,
- 40:01guess what the judge thought. I'm really hoping the judge thought he was guilty.
- 40:06Yes, of course, the judge thinked everybody and then said, quote
- 40:10and many times in his evidence, the accused struck me as a person playing
- 40:15a role, telling a story which fitted neatly with the objective evidence, but
- 40:20which did not more than that. I don't know if that exactly means.
- 40:24Basically, what she's saying is his account often made him probably look better,
- 40:30yes, and it was like didn't match the facts. Yeah, she saw
- 40:34right through his bullshit, Yes she did. She didn't like that they were
- 40:36trying to sabotage for a character. She said, there's no doubt in my
- 40:39mind that he was in a state of rage at that point and he lost
- 40:44control of his temper. That's probably true. Oh yeah, of course too
- 40:46the proposition that he was able to bring himself under control so quickly after the
- 40:52struggle that they saw on the CCTV footage where he's grabbing her by the mouth
- 41:00like behind her, yeah, and pulling her back into the apartment, and
- 41:04then in sixty nine seconds she's not over the balcony. He's calmed down,
- 41:08making tea yeah yeah, and she yeah, climbing is over that. The
- 41:13judge that I cannot know exactly what happened in the apartment in the minute or
- 41:16so following the struggle at the door. But I think it's likely that Lisa
- 41:22Harnum was at some point rendered unconscious. Oh that's her theory. In those
- 41:28sixty nine seconds, I was wondering, like, if she was she wasn't
- 41:30screaming or really like struggling, that would make sense. Yeah, I mean,
- 41:36in sixty nine seconds, you can make some pull someone in and make
- 41:38them at least unconscious. Yeah, I mean I wasn't there. I'm just
- 41:43saying it makes sense. Based on my assessment of all the evidence, I'm
- 41:47satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the accused maintained his rage and in that state carried
- 41:53her to the balcony and unloaded her over the edge. I find the accused
- 41:59guilty of the murder of Lisa Cecilia. That's when Rachel, Rachel screamed,
- 42:06you're wrong, you're wrong. She had to be restrained. She eventually went
- 42:09outside where all the reporters were, took out a cigarette and asked if anybody
- 42:14had a lighter, and she just was filmed in front of everybody, crying
- 42:19hysterically, and Simon's mom had to be taken away by him. I can
- 42:23understand his mom. Yeah, you don't want to think that your child did
- 42:27this. And that's basically the gist. He did end up getting twenty six
- 42:31years Was it twenty six to life? It was twenty six years in jail
- 42:36with the minimum nonparroll of for eighteen years. Okay, Wow, damn,
- 42:43that's a crazy story. Rachel ended up suing the Daily Telegraph because they wrote
- 42:50three stories about our calling her stripper bis gale or a woman of no morals.
- 42:54Oh well, they shouldn't be writing things like that in her defense unless
- 43:00unless she was. I mean, I don't know, I don't know,
- 43:02I don't know, but I guess they settled, so maybe she wasn't.
- 43:07Those tabloids love to just stir ship up. Wow, this is a terrible,
- 43:10terrible story. You know, I hate the miss I mean, I
- 43:13hate I hate all of them. I'm like, I hate domestic violence stories,
- 43:15but I hate everything every story we do. I hate. It's just
- 43:21so sad, Like she was so close, I know, that's a getting
- 43:25thing, like her poor mother, Like she actually got out of the apartment
- 43:30and he dragged her back in. Wow. Well, thanks, you're welcome.
- 43:36Thanks for that and if anybody out there is suffering from domestic violence,
- 43:40please reach out to someone and get help. Yes, definitely you and you
- 43:45may feel like you have no way out or you're alone or something, but
- 43:50there are resources and just get out, Just get out. It could save
- 43:54your life. That's a sort of Lisa. Well, thank you everyone for
- 43:59watching and listening and listening to our episode this week. If you would like
- 44:05to find out more about us or about becoming a Patreon member where you can
- 44:08get additional episodes, you can go to our website Crimesanconsequences dot com, or
- 44:14you can go to Patreon dot com, slash t nt Crimes. You can
- 44:17find us on social media, Facebook and Instagram at Hardcore true Crime. You're
- 44:23so cute right now. You look like to me like you'd be a school
- 44:27team like our Sunday school teacher. And that's all we have for today.
- 44:31Hey you ever today, and thank you again to True Crime Daily and until
- 44:35our next episode, listen and don't kill each other. Bye bye